What is the Global Forest Bond?

Protecting and restoring native biomes is paramount for sustainable development. But how can we finance the process? Global Forest Bond (video) is a Brazilian greentech/fintech startup that builds innovative financial instruments for the protection and recovery of ecosystems. The company unites the legal certainty of agribusiness bonds with the environmental sector through Green Rural Product Notes (CPR Verde), coupled with a state-of-the-art forest audit platform developed in partnership with KPMG to improve transparency and reduce issuance costs. Join us to meet GFB founder Artur Villela Ferreira to discuss new financial instruments that protect biomes in Brazil and around the world.

Recorded August 1, 2022

References:

The Green Finance Market Emerging in Brazil

ESG and Sustainable Business Report: How does the Green CPR work as an economic incentive for environmental preservation?

Agribusiness Receivables Certificates – Green CRAs: Encouraging more responsible practices in commodity production in Brazil

Green CRA Tech receives certification from the Climate Bonds Initiative as the first collective Green CRA issuance in the world

Partnership between Global Forest Bond and Banco BV

Global Forest Bond is a finalist of MIT’s innovation competition

Partnership between Brasil Biofuels and Global Forest Bond

The Federal Decree that Regulates the Issuance of CPR Verde 

CRA Verde.Tech

Forest Bonds – Climate Bonds Initiative

WATCH:

  • Pedro
  • Artur Villela Ferreira
  • Jonah Wittkamper
  • Jason
  • Leonardo
  • Ali
  • John Bruno
  • Marcelo Salazar
  • Alana
  • William
  • John
  • Sarah
  • Andrea
  • Danielle Rappaport
  • Federico
  • Unidentified participant

Pedro:

Our yes thank you Janna. So to start our meeting I would like to start with a first introduction from each one from ourselves. So Jason Petrada could you start?

Jason:

Sure. So Jason Petrillia, I’m a technologist. I’m a Nexus member. I’m building financial pl platforms and tools to help reduce carbon emissions and I’m super excited to be here.

Pedro:

Great. Thank you. Leonardo Gava.

Leonardo:

Yeah. Hi guys. My first time here. Pleasure. I’m the Brazil agriculture transition manager for Climate Bonds Initiative. I’m based in Brazil. I’m an aronomist and I’m responsible for leading the agri food program in Brazil.

Pedro:

Great. Thank you. Ali Rose.

Ali:

Yeah. Hi everyone. I work with Jason at Anthropogenic and I my background is in environmental impact measurement and management. And I’m excited to be here. Thanks.

Pedro:

Great. Thank you, John Bruno. Hello.

John Bruno:

Hi. I’m the executive director of the International Ecoourism Society and I was actually at the very first AIC call which I’m very proud and very happy to be back and watching these amazing sessions. Thank you.

Pedro:

Great. Marcelo, I phoned you, Marcelo.

Marcelo Salazar:

Yes. Oh, hello. Good to be here with you guys. I’m Marcelo Salazar from Brazil, Alameira in the banks of Shingu River and I work for Health and Harmony in Brazil. NGO in the planetary health and I am in a startup a food tech on with Amazon rainforest ingredients as well. Great pleasure to be here.

Pedro:

Welcome. Elena Mils, are you there? Hi. Yes, nice to say hi to everyone. I am Alana. I live in Brazil, but right now I’m in Portugal for a few months in the UK. And I co-ounded Epioneers, which is a climate crypto bank. Basically, we’re launching before the end of the year from Brazil.

Pedro:

Okay, great. William Faler,.

William:

Hi. I’m actually here with Jason who at least in my window is also over here. I’m one of the co-founders of Anthropogenic. We’re creating a couple things. One of them is an API for making Earth science data more accessible. Oh actually look there’s all kinds of team members popping on. I see Ally too. That’s all right. Oh, Jonah is over here. That’s okay. This is they’re people are everywhere. This is lovely. Any I think I’m the first one to introduce us. But essentially we’re creating a near realtime API for Earth science data and then on top of that creating new systems to help with bonds and regulatory markets as they begin to emerge and support greater use of climate data.

Pedro:

Great. So thank you for this introduction for some of us that are here. So now I would like to welcome you again to the our 98 94th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is our weekly call and podcast series. We work to advance force friendly economic development and the rule of law across the Amazon region of South America. So this week we will feature the work of Artur Valella and the Global Forest Bond. So Artur is here with us and welcome Artur and thank you Pedro and thank you everyone who is here with us.

So I think you can start like maybe talking a little bit about Global Forest Bond and also if you want to share your screen with us to present Global Forest Bond.

Artur Villela Ferreira:

Thank you. Thank you Pedro. Well I will try to have a brief overview of what we are doing so we have more time to trade and discuss with the with most people who are here. I would also like to have some feedback and some exchange on what you guys think of what we are doing and how we can collaborate with all these wonderful initiatives here. So we are a Brazilian startup that develops financial solutions for the forest preservation of forests. So we are working on development developing solutions for the payment for environmental services.

And we have a very the core of our thesis is trying to bring what already works in the agri business sector in Brazil but to finance the preservations of forests. We also have a technological side. We have a digital platform developed together with KPMG to audit forests and gather field data. And I will share more of about them with you. But this is the gist of the problem. We are dividing the land in the world nowadays as productive or improductive. So here in Brazil we call twothirds of the of the area of the country as unpro improductive land.

Which is a pity. You have an ectctor or acre of beautiful Amazon rainforest and people look at it and say oh this is unproductive land. This is dirty land. It has to be stripped down and we have to have cattle on there. Which is a pity and it’s one of the main drivers of climate change across the globe and especially in Latin America and in Brazil it’s like two three4s of our emissions are a fullu emissions agriculture forest and land use so if we treat preserved lands as having no economic value there is no in influx of cash to invest in preservation activities.

You cannot you cannot have like professional firefighters and land protections. This activity is not pro is not done in a professional way. Well and the these areas with native biomes are completely ex excluded from the economical and financial systems. So forests are not are not accepted as collateral. There’s no insurance for native forests. So we are basically excluding in the case of Brazil two twothirds of the area of the country from the from the economy. Given this tragic scenario what we are trying to build as solutions or bring to the table as solutions to the problem.

We say we act in two main roads we have to improve to in this payment for environmental services. There is the financial in instruments side of things which can also be sea seen as the institutional side of things. We need to improve legal certainty reduce the transaction costs of all these financial instruments and allow access to a broad range of people and companies in these environmental markets and we also have a technology branch of things. So we need to reduce the cost of issuances of and improve the transparency of any bonds being carbon credits, payment for environmental services and any other bonds that aim at in the end of the day preserving native biomes and especially forests.

So on the institutional side of things we understand that Brazil is a is a powerhouse in the agri business sector and that happens in part because of natur natural characteristics. It’s a very large country. It has tropical sunlight and all this helps Brazil have high output, high yield output in most in most agricultural cultures, soybeans, meat and many others. But there is also a number of institutional reasons for the success of Brazil’s agro business because there the agri business instrument sector in Brazil has very good contracts very high legal certainty and very good financial instruments.

So we aim at GFP to bring those instruments to the preservation and environmental markets. So we use what is called a rural product note which in Brazil it’s called a CPR to trade environmental services. These have been long used as the most used financial instruments to trade commodities in Brazil. And we are we are enveloping the conservation or restoration of forests as an environmental product that can be in delivered through the financial markets. So investors can buy a promise of forest preservation or a promise of forest recovery through the financial markets by a rural product note.

This is how was our thesis when we started the company in 2019. Since we started our company this vision of ours has been turned into law. So in 2020 there was the this law 13986 that institutionalized the possibility of using rural product notes as a as a means to trade environmental services and this was later there was a later decree last year that formalized all this the legal certainty of the of the site. So this gives us a very powerful tool in the Brazilian toolbox to have new more rigorous contracts, greater legal certainty and have having all those instruments registered and in the in Brazil central bank and regulated in the financial markets regulators in Brazil the CVM which would be something like the FCC in the United States.

Well, with this we can have preserved areas we can that are providing ecosystem services like carbon, water and biodiversity. We have a we have a prefield analysis document satellite images and whatnot. We go to a field collection of information and this I will tell you some more about what this platform. We register this instrument that is bought by anyone wanting to do any kind of environmental offset that being a person or and or companies can buy those instruments in the in the financial markets in Brazil’s stocks exchange. And we also understood that alongside the institutional improvements that had to be made to the to the environmental sector, we all also had to bring in lots of technologies.

And we found out that the KPMG auditing big four company they had a software to audit the issuance of the rural product notes for soybeans here in Brazil. So we had a few conversations with them and we decided to have a strategic partnership to adapt this platform they were using for the soybeans product notes but to use for our green product notes. So we kept the backbone of their auditing infrastructure and we plugged in our knowledge of environmental services and ecosystem services. So we told them all to measure a forest we can we need to measure diameter and height of trees.

We have to know what’s the species to see how biodiverse is that area. We can have we need to have soil collect soil samples and what and they plugged in those data collections in their auditing platform. So when we go to a to a field work which will be the basis of issuance of any bond we can make sure that the professional there was that biologist or that forest engineer he was inside the area that’s being surveyed during the day that we said it would be surveyed. He takes a picture of a tree.

He cannot be at his office in another place or it’s impossible to take a picture of a tree and put that into five or six different projects. So this gives a very high level of certainty of what’s being measured. This whole process can be accompanied. So a company that buys this off offset tools or offset instruments can even have an access to a QR code they put on their products and the final customer be that in a big city in Brazil or even abroad can scan that QR code and have access to all the trees that were measured individually and even to the diameter and height of that and redo our carbon accountings if that company that customer wants to or even a regulator or NGO.

We also think technology is a key to lowering issuance costs. So we’ve already put in this zap a number of technologies to a number of tools to improve the efficiency of the field work. So we have an automatic tree height measuring using the inclination of the tablet. We have an a API of that plantet neuronet network so that our biologists can the tool identifies a large number if not most of the plants in field so that the biologists and tree forestry engineers can focus on the few rare species we found on that specific field.

So all this aiming at lowering the issuance costs while improving transparency. So we can later have talk a little bit more of the capabilities but it’s asynchronous it’s st it’s very stable and very scalable. It’s based on this technology that KPMG is already using for a decade all over Brazil. It has lots of information modules that we based on IPBS’s environmental services platform. And it’s it grants a unique user login. It has automatic metadata collection for all this information and it’s all this is kept on a KPMG server with very good encryption for the communication be that on the upload side of things be that on the access side of things so that customers are really sure they are looking at 30 field data.

And all this work we have been doing is to reverse that tendency we saw on the first part of my presentation is we aim at having native biomes or preserved areas as revenue generating areas. So that this revenue can be spent in protective measures so that those areas can be better integrated in the whole economic system. Be that as collateral for investments can be protected in the financial markets via secures and with that how do you see this becoming business or business opportunities? We are seeing a push over companies to improve their business models to towards a more sustainable business models.

We see increase in the demand of sustain sustainable sustainably market marketing products. And this all.

Unidentified participant:

I think he’s paralyzed. Yes. Let’s wait for she comes back.

Jonah Wittkamper:

I’ve been messaging some people in the chat. For those of you who are new to this call series, feel free to send me an email or a message. Just give me your email address for future invites. If you got a chat, it may be for me.

Pedro:

Yes. And also if you want to like maybe put some given that we have this break if you want to add some questions that you might have on the on the chat also. So we can as soon as our touring comes back, we can start to answer your questions. Let me just check if he’s coming. Just one minute.

Jonah Wittkamper:

While we’re waiting, I believe that we have a representative of the climate bonds initiative on the call. Would you like to come on and introduce yourself just because it’s super relevant? And tell us about the CBI in just a couple minutes.

Leonardo:

Yeah, sure. That would be me. It’s a pleasure being here. It’s my first time here. Lisa was the one that has given me all the direction to be here and well I am responsible for the agri food transition program in Brazil. Actually CBI today we have a taxonomy and criteria to actually assess and evaluate transactions and whether they could or not receive the label of green. In other words, green means that all the proceeds are being directed to a project that has some sort of good environmental impact. But we see that when it comes to agriculture and agri food systems, not everyone is green.

We have a lot of farmers that are not still green. But if money is somehow directed to them, perhaps in the future they could become green. So this is the work I’m developing in Brazil. We are trying to define a consensus, a narrative of about what it means transition in the agri food sector. So what we need to change in the sector, what we need to finance to fund in the sector so it becomes green in the future. So this is the work we are focus focusing now in Brazil. But of course we have our other agendas being developed as well.

We still have that big green project looking at agriculture. So looking at farmers and growers that want to fund their production systems with green financial instruments like green bonds or green loans. So this is back those are main works in Brazil right now.

Pedro:

Thanks. Thanks. Welcome back our tour.

Artur Villela Ferreira:

Thank you Lunardo. Thank you Lonardo and Pedro. Pedro what slide have you.

Unidentified participant:

This one? This one. Okay. Yeah. So, I’ll get back. So, as I was saying, there is also this these pressures coming from.

Artur Villela Ferreira:

Market already start showing up in investors and how investors are looking at companies. So u that we are seeing lots of ways of using those agricultural product green product notes in Brazil. The first one is selling them together with agricultural commodities. So since investors are already buying rural product notes of any commodity and there are private lands there are private preservation quotas in private lands. Why not selling those two things together like for each pack of meat you are also buying one he actor of reserved Amazon or something like that.

We are structuring some deals on this on this way that the private land owners, the farmers can receive for both the product the rural the commodity product that comes out of their lands as well as the preservation of that land. We are looking at voluntary markets. So we are seeing this rural product note as a very efficient way of selling the preservation of forest in voluntary markets. We are also seeing the increase of regulated markets. We bring here the example of civil course corsia the civil aviation but there is an increased pressure for regulated markets and also international trade as we point out the conservation of forest is Brazil’s most is the commodity that’s easily most easily exported from Brazil in a country that suffers from poor infrastructures and roads and delayed imports.

If we can export forest conservation through financial markets, it’s it would be a very good thing for many for many populations that contribute to the preservations. Well, this was the my introduction of what we are building. I would like now to open to questions and to have a discussion with such an interesting group.

Pedro:

Great. Sure. Thank you once again. I think I see that Marcelo had already added a question for the debate. So Marcelo, do you want to bring for us?

Marcelo Salazar:

Oh yes. No, regarding Thank you. First of all, thank you very much for the amazing presentation. I’m very interested in this topic and trying to stud from different angles. I have two questions to start the debate. One regarding to the last quote is how much do you guys think there are in the Amazon rank forest of land owners producing in a very good way that has more than 80% of the forests preserve it like in this way I see they can sell the meat and some environmental bonds otherwise they have a debit it to recover the area to do the reforestation and so on.

And the second question is if you see opportunities for indigenous lands and conservation units mainly his the conservation units with traditional communities in the Amazon rainforest like 40% of the forest in the Amazon are in the in the hands of indigenous people and rubber tappers for example in average.

Artur Villela Ferreira:

Marcelo, thank you. Thank you very much. I think those are both very interesting points. I will start with the second one. The main challenge we are facing is the regulation over the CPRs the rural product notes. When we are looking at indigenous or traditional territories is who is allowed to issue the CPR? Do the communities themselves are the communities themselves allowed to issue those or there needs to be any participation of Brazilian government like any public federal instance like the fun or bill in these issuances. I have a meeting with some representatives of indigenous communities on the not on next Monday to discuss this point I can keep in touch with you and also how we are advancing on that point we see as very important one because as you said it’s a very large part especially in the Amazon biome maybe in the other biomes not as much so in the Amazon.

Yes. And the indigenous communities have been doing a extraordinary job in the protection of forest. When you compare the protection of indigenous lands with non-indigenous lands in the past like decade or two decades. But there is this which is not a small one but there is this technical point the this legal certainty side of things the instrument as I said it was made for the financing of rural production so it’s easier to issue on private lands we are already doing some issuance in private lands and it’s more clear on that side about the number of areas that are well that have over 80% which are which is the minimum legal requirement.

Our stance Marcelo is to try to how can I put that we are trying to value each plot of land according to their contributions. So we believe that even areas that are that have legal obligation should be preserved should also receive for the for the preservation. This price although will not be the same if you are talking about areas that there are exceeding legal requirements there in those areas there are two things being sold. The preservation and the right well there is also you are also giving up a right of deforesting.

Whereas if you have only the legal the minimum amount you are only preserving an area and should be paid for that. Okay.

Pedro:

It’s a great point your we have discussed about a lot about this right me and you and so this I think this is a great way to tackle this issue to that the areas that are surplus in regarding to the legal to the legal reserve would have like a plus in the price or something like this. It makes sense. Does anyone has want to make a question? I see that John is cool. Do you want to bring from for us John?

John:

Well sure. This is a simple financial question. Typically bonds deliver a financial return on investment. Are these investment instruments that return monetary? Is there liquidity available?

Artur Villela Ferreira:

John there can be well the question about liquidity it’s a market question there is we have some we have a few issuances and we have no public ones we have we have only taken private ones. So we believe we will reach a market of p publicity of these kinds of instruments but we are not there yet. Regarding if there is return on investment there can be if we have a future promise of delivery of environmental services we are structuring for instance red projects or reforestation projects where investors put on the money we issue the CPR which is a pro promise of delivering a forest in 30 years or something like that.

So if we can sell the carbon capture on this forest investor can have a return on investment. But you were quick to see that there are two types of CPRs of there is the physical CPR which is deliverance of a product and there is the financial CPR which is there is a return on investment. The physical CPR is mainly used as a means of transaction those environmental services. So there would be no return on investment on that case. We are just using it as a tool for a company to buy one year of preserve forest or carbon capture or other environmental services.

John.

Pedro:

Okay, great. Do you want to add something, John, about this?

John:

No, I have a sec I have a second question, but I see that Sarah has several, too. So, I’ll go after her.

Pedro:

Okay. Thank you. So, Sarah, do you want to bring to us your question?

Sarah:

Yeah, I had a couple questions. Thanks, Artha, for the presentation. I’ve been trying to learn about bonds. So, this was really useful as an overview. Some of my questions may reveal some of my general lack of knowledge, so apologies for that. But I had questions on a couple of the cases that you mentioned. So, first on the cases related to the voluntary and compliance carbon markets, just sort of generally wanted to ask how you were dealing with I mean you may have just answered it when you mentioned it could be like protection of a forest for just one year, but how do you like sort of deal with issues of like permanence and leakage and how does that sort of compare when you’re selling this versus some of the more traditional project standards like VCS and gold standard?

And then the second question I had was about the case you mentioned with sort of integrating these into supply chains. Are there any initial cases of companies or supply chains that you’ve explored that with that you could sort of just give a concrete example about?

Artur Villela Ferreira:

Yes. Thank you. I think it would be easier to explain dividing into three groups. Let’s see. We can talk about financial instruments. We can talk about technology and we can talk about the product that is being sold. So when we talk about project this the product this would be something like a vera certified carbon credit or just payment for environmental services or voluntary forest protection any kind of this all those products Sarah can be integrated into can be traded or invested through a green CPR and we are working with all of them.

So when we have customers that want to enter or want or have to enter high standard carbon credits verified carbon credits market or regulated markets there are the limitations on what can be how we can sell those products like if you’re talking about a red product project we are talking about 30 over years and have bases and what and we can we are also developing this supply chain product products that may not need this kind of verifications because what is being sold is not avoid deforestation it’s just forest protection we have entered a public bid by BNDS to develop financial instruments so we are doing let’s see if we have the BN BNDS grant.

If not we will do it will we will make it work with only private money but it’s having a investment fund Sarah that goes into land owners and buys the receivables for the two sides of the of that land the soybean and the forest from the same land and packs together to sell. So this is one such project. We are working together with Brazil Bofuels to develop some payment for environmental services in their areas. As Marcelo s they have most their areas are mostly under or on the legal limit. So we are not talking about avoid deforestation on those projects.

We are doing something like if you buy one barrel of biodiesel you are taking together 10 hectares of forest preservations.

Unidentified participant:

Sarah great thank you very much. Hey Ter let me see I think there is a.

Pedro:

Question from seat oh there’s John also if you want to yeah John go ahead to.

John:

So yeah Arthur you mentioned this notion of possibly packaging an acre of protected land when you buy a pound of meat or something and I think that’s a really interesting idea because I think the consumers might like that, especially given that these days if they had the coordinates of their acre, they could look at them every so often on a satellite and do some monitoring while taking some pride in what they’re doing. Is that just an idea or is that an available scenario?

Artur Villela Ferreira:

John, that’s an available scenario. As I said that’s exactly what we proposed on this BNDS publicing to go well I wouldn’t say we are working on the each acre we are more like this the this farm sold I don’t know 300 tons of meat and it has a thousand acres of protected areas. So there would be like each package of meat would be responsible for something like but we could we could yes work on individualizing this and having it divided via blockchain or something to have an individual square acre that would be that would be something that is doable.

But what we want is when we can talk more about the technology side of things with our platform we’ve in integrated the possibility of then looking at each tree that we measured and the sound of the birds on that forest the day we were there and listen to the sound of the birds and it’s something that it has value on the sci science of conservation side of things identifying species and but also value on the marketing side of things. Oh, that’s my tree. I’m paying to protect that tree over there and th those birds singing are the birds that are being protected by the my Sunday barbecue.

John:

My intuition is that individuals might well be interested in owning or gifting those but that the concretess and the accountability of saying this is my tree or this is my acre. I don’t own it but I’m a careo stakeholder caretaker of it could be very valuable. If you know how I can do that please let me know directly. Okay. Okay.

Pedro:

Great. John, I think this is a good way to good possible way to work on these two. Andrea, do you want to share with us your question?

Andrea:

Really important one. Sure. Hi. Hi all. Nice to meet you. So, my question is regarding this financing mechanism. It only applies for private owners or should be applied for community land as it is the majority inside the Amazonian beyond biome. Is that a possibility?

Artur Villela Ferreira:

I’m sorry and community lands you mean indigenous lands kilola lands and traditional.

Andrea:

Yeah.

Artur Villela Ferreira:

Well, when we are talking about indigenous and traditional land, there is that point I was discussing with Marcelo that it’s not yet clear on the regulatory side of things if the those indigenous tribes can issue the bonds themselves or there if there still has to be any involvement with public offices.

Andrea:

Okay. So in case of like most of many of them are associated with like KA or other huge indigenous organization like as a NGO not as a as not at a governmental level but as a NGO representing them could this be a possibility.

Artur Villela Ferreira:

No the point Andrea is at the governmental level because it is a matter of land ownership it’s a matter of ownership of the and who is able to promise the preservation of the land because that’s the main the main point of theization which is not yet clear. We are studying on how to work together with those communities and how we can best provide them with the tools for the issuance if they are the in the end of the day the issuer or if how can we work together with Incra and Nibio if they need the approval of those public entities to issue such bonds.

Andrea:

Even if they have the legal rights over the land like if it’s a already titled territory it’s over them like sorry I’m just putting this just to be more clear because we are trying to support those organization through the land titling and one of their questions are exactly they are financial mechanism how could they be more independent without been asking the government to give them their own way to finance and have their forest standing, right?

Artur Villela Ferreira:

Yeah. No, the I believe th those green CPRs would be a very strong tool for the for those communities. I’m not yet sure on the and I’m a business administrator, an economist. So we can keep in touch and I can put you in touch with our legal team to see how to better work together with those communities. We but we are we are doing our best to put this to their availability.

Andrea:

It would be great. I will put my email here. We really would be great because this is a common question that come to us. Okay. So it would be great. Thank you.

Pedro:

Sure. We are we are going to organize those ones that are asking for more information to help our tour also with the with feedbacks and more information. Do you want to say something Marcel about this?

Marcelo Salazar:

Oh yeah no just a small contribution on this discussion very interesting. Thank you Andrea and our tour to holding it. But we are here in the Shingu River. We are doing some pilots exactly on this issue with the strate reserve strate a contract with the government the real right of the use of the land and there are some understandings inside the same view that the money can go 100% to the units and we are working to in a juredic I don’t know the word in English u so we need to do it there are some experience in indigenous territory as well but I don’t know exactly with this instrument that our tour presented so this is something that really concern us because when you go to farm farmers it’s easy in one side because if the guy has the documents of the land oh he’s the owner it’s easy to make the contract and so on but who works in the Amazon rainforest knows that it’s a very messy situation the land regulations here and the real rights over the land so many cases of apparently legal documents are land grabbings and so on.

So something that seems like trustable in the beginning can be a very a very a land grabbing of the land and the concern we have is how can you prevent the leaking of the money? If you give the money for a farmer that ensure that we’ll protect the area or reforestate the area, they can get this money and invest in another deforestation in the in the other name of in Amazon rainforest we call langas. Yeah, the orange gotcha that kind of things. So it’s a big discussion like u and Arur if you want to follow this I’m very interesting to have a conversation about yeah I just took your contact that we should we should talk more about this as we said I said like it’s a common question to us and we are even more supporting land rights and one of those is the financial mechanism if it goes straight to the community.

It’s the ideal word.

Pedro:

Yeah, I think this is really important because from my understanding the initial idea of this CPR, the green CPR is that it was developed by for no private lands, you know, initially. But in order to bring to this more like common lands and indigenous for traditional communities, we have to bring more minds and see how it works together, right?

Artur Villela Ferreira:

Yes, Pedro, there is this but it’s mostly on this land ownership side of things, but we have to understand that CPRs also have a wide range of uses in agriculture in Brazil and lots of problems that are particular that we think are particular to forest protection or forest recovery have been dealt with by farmers. Like the possibility of issuance of one CPR by a number of land owners. If you have lots of small holders, we can have one issuance and make them have access to financial markets. This was developed by small land owners who want to produce soybeans together or finance soybeans togethers or meat together or anything else.

But we can appropriate that to the conservation and have one issuance of giving access to many small holders. Also there is the question of performance. If you if you if you want if you promise to protect a forest or promise to recover a degraded area with a forest what happens if you can’t deliver that? And this is also something that already was solved for the on the rural side of things. There is there is how do you say that you can have a securitization of that and there are companies and banks specialized on having assurance of those insurance of those agricultural deliverables.

We need to also bring that expertise to the conservation and have insurance of forest protections or insurance of future carbon credits.

Pedro:

Great. I think this is a great way to try to think about think more about this common benefits for this common communities common lands. John Bruno do you want you to bring your question for us?

John Bruno:

Sure. Artur, thank you for the presentation. It’s really powerful and I think you know from us in the world of sustainable development it’s amazing to see the kind of innovation that is going on to appropriately create the financial structures for conservation. But what I think I you know I it’s amazing to and I know you have so little time and how much you can say in 40 minutes but the one thing that I urge you know as someone from United States you know packaging bonds you know anybody who’s been around for a while remembers that you know whenever you’ve got assets under assets under assets and especially with self-reporting you there have been a few incidents in the past.

So you know, but I think it’s amazing what you’re doing and the way that you’re trying to give transparency into those bonds, but how are you focusing on the people that we’re supposed to be helping? I know that it’s not a lack of intent on your part. But if you could, you know, maybe for 30 seconds tell us the way that all of this that we’re doing in all of this thinking and theorizing and packaging and financial instruments comes down to preserving, conserving and at the same time allowing agency so that these people can determine for themselves the kind of sustainable lifestyle that they want to lead.

Thank you.

Artur Villela Ferreira:

Thank you, John. We are we are pretty aware of what too much finance can do and the limits of the financial markets. And the there is something that we all always discuss and keep in mind. We are trying to develop as we are we are discussing here the best tools for the people or peoples who are in areas protected areas to report and report the environmental positive environmental impact they have and to seek compensation for the for the for this for this which today are being treated as positive externalities that need to be internalized into the economic system.

That said Joan that this is not our only our only worries with those communities. We also believe that having a very transparent and powerful tool of forest inventory and whatnot. We are also changing the core of the trust mechanism in this environmental markets which nowadays is based mostly on unscalable certifications. And we are flying certifiers all over the world to measure trees in Brazil or we believe that with our tool and giving our transparency we can also create more jobs locally related to the certification of forest and bioeconomy and whatnot and the conservations because we don’t need to have that guy that anyone trusts to go everywhere and measure the trees.

We are giving the people on the field a tool for them to go there, measure the trees and issue a bond backed by that. We had an issuance last it’s been a couple of months our first pilot project was acquired by a bank in Brazil. It’s called Bank BV, former Vtorin Bank. I think it’s the fifth or sixth largest bank in Brazil. It’s a very wellrespected institution and the bond was issued in a private preserved area in the Micera forest. And there were two main field professional professionals one biologist from the municipality of Cruso which was where we issued and another from the University of Compinas which is nearby.

So we had people from the city that where that area is preserved working on that on that certification. And we are also doing the same on scale in Amazon or Pantanana wetlands. So we can provide those communities with revenue for the preservation and also creating jobs on those areas related to forest preservation John thank you.

Pedro:

Okay so thank you thank you John we are going to like to get into the hour that we finish our eating. But those that can stay and a few more minutes I can stay a little bit more. Jonah, I see that you haz your hazed your hand. Do you want to make qu make a question or just.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Yeah. Yeah. I have one quick question. This is actually for our friend on the call from Natura. Feder Rico, I’m wondering if Nata has issued a bond for wild harvesting and I’m wondering if you guys have I’m wondering if that could be combined with this idea.

Federico:

Hi J, thanks for I was not expecting to be answering those sort of questions. Well, we are exploring different options. Yes, that’s why I’m I am here not precisely on this aair because I understood it as a sort of aggra business instrument right which is a guarantee instrument to the bank not related to the collateral but sort of the same idea linked to the to traditional communities would work I.

Unidentified participant:

Think okay worth for future exploration that’s all thank you Jedi.

Pedro:

There is one question from Danielle from our team at AIC. Danielle, are you there?

Danielle Rappaport:

Yeah, I’m here. I’ll keep it real quick. So I’m a I’m a forest remote sensing scientist, so I can’t help but ask about errors and uncertainties. And you know, our estimate of the carbon stored in a tree is based on assumptions of the density of that tree. If we’re only looking at tree height density and the alometric equations that we use and so forth. So how are you guys considering and kind of propagating your understanding of error and uncertainty when pricing these assets?

Artur Villela Ferreira:

There thank you for your question. Yes we are we are still using the same kind of methodology of measuring tree diameter or in height. And this has an inherent error. We what our investment is on the technology side of things is we can we have to do what’s being done better, more transparent and quicker and cheaper and help build the next steps. I would love to have like satellite imaging and how do you say LiDAR imaging with drones and this give me more accurate carbon estimate for preserved areas. This is the reality for planted forests and but it’s not the reality for native rainforest areas.

So much what’s been doing I’ve seen people from Canada from Ireland can see well if you fly a drone over the forest you can count the trees. I was like okay that may work in Canada but that does not work in the Amazon or in the Atlantic rainforest. So there is lacking data Danielle on the on this sector and we hope to build the next technologies based on having putting together an instrument that works and we can gather data because much of the data that exists forest inventories and whatnot is has been gathered by hand and it’s not m machine readable.

It is stored on drawers on universities. So we also hope that’s another there’s another positive impact that we hope to have on the research of the conservation is to have public access to the inventories that are being made using our technologies and eventually as I said each place we go to have a field collection we also fly a drone over take images and LiDAR data and maybe someday hoping to train an algorithm in the future that would allow us to decrease all those all those errors that exist today. But we have built a tool that can do what is being done today which is measure diameter and height of trees with the inherent challenges that th those methodologies have.

But we think our position is we need to have an instrument or a set of financial instruments that are based on this so that we can give next.

Unidentified participant:

Steps on the technological side of things. Thanks Arto.

Federico:

Hi guys. Thank thanks for your presentation. And I might have missed the first part. So I just a question of understanding. So basically you’re trying to pick an instrument that already exists. No se and then adding a forest component to it. Right? Which is a sort of collateral for a land holder to go to the bank. No to have access to credit. Right? So this is the first part of your idea. Then the second part of your idea is to measure or to guarantee that the or to find cheaper ways or cheaper technology to measure the amount of forest that is available on that proper property.

So if I understand correctly you have two angles right adding add having adding a forestier component to access to finance and then bringing technology to measure and to make it accountable. Am I correct?

Artur Villela Ferreira:

Yeah, that’s some of it. But Fedrico, I think the I don’t know if you have seen the regulation of the sep the green CPR which it’s not only they it cannot only be used to improve traditional CPRs. Is another instrument in which is backed by forest preservation or forest recovery. I can I can share you some documents on that.

Federico:

Okay. So it would be innovative financial instruments plus a new way of monitoring, right?

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. Yeah. On that second point, new way of monitoring, how do you distinguish yourselves from current.

Federico:

Public systems and for instance some states like paras state, they’re investing on the car 2.0 and all these ways to develop no public and massive no monitoring systems. What’s the point of having a private monitoring system?

Artur Villela Ferreira:

Frederrico, thank you. We use all that’s publicly available. So we use the MapBiomas initiative. We also plug in every time we do an issuance we plug it the we plug the car in the MapBiomas Alerta which is the for those who do not know it’s a it’s a NGO sponsored initiative to how do you say to monitor areas. So we are using those large public datas data sets but our tool the focus of our tool FICO is the collection of the field data because as you we have accompanied discussions about the VA methodology for carbon credits there is still need using only satellite data there is limit there is limits on what we can say about the area with current technology.

We can have average carbon stocks for Amazon rainforest but that does not mean that anyone will buy a carbon credited issued based only on this on a satellite image and n national average or even state average. So we are we are focus we understand that they are very good public tools and we are using them for the remote sensing side of things. We are also talking with private developers of such tools satellite imaging and drone imaging but our focus is to reduce the costs of field sensing and with that we developed that platform together with KPMG.

So we which is what they are using to monitor the to monitor soybean plantations in Brazil. So we believe the there is a value added with that we can have KPMG’s name brand on the and security of data and our reduction of cost on this field. We should be comparing ourselves to people getting into forest with pieces of paper and pencils which is how is being done in most projects today. Even large carbon credits.

Unidentified participant:

Issuance today’s are doing by p pencil and paper. Okay. Thanks guys.

Pedro:

Okay. So, I think is there anyone that wants to make another question? I can I can stay for a little bit more minutes. But if we don’t have it. Yeah, I saw sorry I just saw a question from Jeremy. I don’t know if it’s he’s still online, but he said he asked how is the field data verified? And maybe it’s like a final question.

Artur Villela Ferreira:

Well, Pedro, we have we have assurance by KPMG of the of the how do you say the veracity of that data. When a professional like takes a picture of a tree, their software grants that the metadata is captured like where the where it was by GPS, what day it was, who was logged in on the platform. So this is the level of assurance we have on the on the quality of the data.

Pedro:

Yeah, I think this is was a great way to answer this question. So want to thank you Wur for your great presentation for us. Great to know more about this new financial mechanism kind of new right CPR green CPR over here in Brazil. I will there is some I think I was thinking maybe some way that I can send maybe some more materials or maybe some there is the link that we send already on the invitation that talks about CPR and the initiative some Global Forest Bond but also you can get in touch with her through LinkedIn and also there is I think there is a on our invitation but if you don’t have it you can share with us over here Drew.

Artur Villela Ferreira:

Yeah I think I put here in the message but I will I will put it again to everyone. So.

Unidentified participant:

Yes the last message. Yes. Great. So thank you all. Thank you.

Pedro:

Thank you for your questions and hope you enjoy it and see you next week.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you. Bye. Thank you all. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. See you. Bye-bye. Thank you, Marcelo. Bye-bye.