The Amazon Bio-Economy Impact Investing of Althelia/Mirova Capital

Alan Batista: Today we learn about Amazon bio-economy investing by Mirova Natural Capital (formerly the Althelia Biodiversity Fund Brazil). Mirova is a leading investor in bio-economy entrepreneurship of the Amazon region with investments in agroforestry, sustainable beef, and more. Originally founded as Althelia Ecosphere, receiving support from the European Investment Bank and subsequent support from the USAID Development Credit Authority, their biodiversity fund was later acquired by Mirova. As a reference for private and public sector blended finance, the fund has learned a lot and refined their investment thesis along the way, adapting to the special needs of the Amazon region. Join us to learn about their journey with Alan Batista.

Recorded March 1, 2021

References:

Press Release: Mirova has finalized its acquisition of Mirova Natural Capital

2019 First Closing of Althelia Biodiversity Fund Brazil

2020 Fund of the Year – Multi-asset/other: Althelia Biodiversity Fund Brazil

2019 Impact Report

2020 Impact Report

2017 Presentation

WATCH:

  • Jonah (moderator)
  • Alan Batista
  • Marina
  • Rafael (Conexsus Fund)
  • Maria Duran (World Bank)
  • Alan (audience participant)
  • Lars (Rainforest Foundation Norway)
  • Marita

Jonah:

Hello everybody. This is the 34th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series featuring different Amazon innovators. It’s a project of the Global Governance Philanthropy Network and the Amazon Investor Coalition supported by Nexus and many other partners. This week we are featuring the work of Mirova Natural Capital formerly known as Alia Ecosphere and the Althelia Biodiversity Fund Brazil. Our featured presenter is Alan Batista from Mirova Natural Capital. And we’re going to conduct this session as an interview. Alan, thank you so much for joining us.

Tell us a little bit about yourself. Tell us who you are and some of the things you were up to before you joined Mirova.

Alan Batista:

Thanks Jonah for the introduction. It’s a it’s a pleasure to be here. I’m actually quite surprised to hear that this is the 34th meeting that you that you have. That’s quite interesting. So for me it’s actually my first but I know my colleagues have been in these previous calls. So I’m a I’m a Brazilian. I’m based here in S. Paulo with our newly launched subsidiary from Mirova Natural Capital here in Brazil. I joined the team last year in March. So it has been one year I’ve been working here as an investment analyst for the Althelia biodiversity fund.

Before joining Mirova Natural Capital I was working with so world resources institute also based in Brazil. So I was working previously also with you know valuation of ecosystem services restoration projects agroforestry regenerative agriculture so been working on that space for the last four years with before that I worked in the forestry sector so I’m actually a forester by training so I started with my career in forestry pulp and paper sector here in Brazil and then I kind of dived a little bit more into finance with my masters in forest and economics.

So this is just a bit about me very pleased to be here with you all.

Jonah:

Great. Thank you so much. So let’s get into Althelia. Where did it come from and what was the role of the European Investment Bank?

Alan Batista:

Oh, good question. So, we started back eight years ago pretty much with the launch of the Alilia climate fund. So we can say that was the first let’s say large enough with scale of capital resources to invest in climate solutions in the world. So it was a raise of pretty much 100 million euros back at that time in 2012. So it has a term of eight years that fund and the strategy was to really invest in climate solutions related to natural capital so soil agroforestry nature conservation and carbon played a really important role there.

So all the solutions all the financial instruments we used on that fund it’s based on carbon credit. So it was the first it was the first big fund we had. So everything actually it’s really inspired there and of course the European investment bank had an important role on the on the derisking mechanism. So that’s really how we are able always to attract private capital. So pretty much all funds across Bureau of Natural Capital now you have all the risking mechanism. So to increase the appetite of the private sector as you know this is a this is a very these are very new ventures usually early growth businesses that if you have some sort of the risking mechanism you can really keep capital at scale.

I was just caught up on the on the on the conversation you were having before and just a small comment on that. So if you see like mainstream let’s say private equity or venture capital investments in Brazil. So I was just looking at this latest data month ago from the 2020 until 2020 closing year. If take mainstream private capital, venture capital in Brazil, usually you’re you’re going to look at 0.3% of the GDP, you know, goes to these sorts of investment industry. If you take a look at the US, it’s about 1.5% of the US GDP, it’s allocated to private equity, venture capital funds.

But the thing is if you have if you cut that across regions in Brazil or across let’s say the north region which you have the Amazon nothing of those of those investments are going to the Amazon. So pretty much 95% of those investments stay in the south and southeast of Brazil for example. So, so this is why it’s so important to have these t- risking mechanisms in place so you can actually attract capital to places where it’s not being deployed like that. So, it’s very important.

Jonah:

Nice. So, an eight-year legacy. You guys, you’ve got some stories. Tell us what happened just a few years ago when the US aid development credit authority came along and the Alia Biodiversity Fund Brazil was born. Tell us about that.

Alan Batista:

Yeah. So the idea was to based on our learning of the of the of the ACF so that of the climate fund. We wanted to develop a new fund where we could really focus on the Amazon biome under different pillars because we had as you probably know I think you even we even have discussed this before you know our largest investment it’s on PEXA and we can maybe we can discuss a little bit about that later on the ACF climate fund and then we really wanted to approach the ABF fund where we could have different investment pillars.

So basically our mandate it’s to have it’s to have investments in different pillars. So for example one it’s community and livelihoods. So to support you know co-ops, communities non-timber forest products. So very specific mandate on that we have a second pillar which the investment it’s based on the on opportunities on agroforestry. So small holder farming so agroforestry restoration. We have a third pillar of mandate investing there based on regenerative agriculture. So a little bit of more large scale but still focusing on more large scale where you can actually really sequester carbon in the soil.

And we have a fourth pillar which is kind of new to us which we are we’re very focused on innovation technology financial services because if you think of the other three pillars which are very focused on land use on farming on forestry you need to have some sort of smart infrastructure behind to deliver those impacts. So, so that’s why it’s very important for us this pillar four. So which is focused let’s say on remote sensing MRV traceability access to finance like I said you see okay you have we have a large capital base for PE for VC but it’s not reaching the Amazon so that’s why we have this is how it differs from the other funds and the role of the US a very important so the investment of US a seat so the center for international tropical agriculture which is really we have a double lock de-risking mechanism where you have a first loss guarantee and we have a guarantee on 50% of the portfolio of debt in the in the ABF portfolio.

So they are junior shares so with our first closing we have a shares B shares and we are fundraising again with the ABF to our second closing. So we’re just be about to begin our next fundraising the second close of the ABF. So today the fund is denominated in Brazilian highs. So we have 62 million Brazilian highs up to date for the first closing and we’re aiming to 300 million in the second fundraising. And anyways I can talk a little bit about of the how this how this strategy actually goes with our you know venture window early growth windows because if you see for if you see of the projects we screen in the Amazon it’s actually a very large capital base so we have different strategies to deploy that.

Jonah:

Great we’ll get that we’ll get there in a second. Mhm. Tell us a little bit about Mova, Mova Natural Capital, where it came from, who owns it, and why did it acquire Alia?

Alan Batista:

Yeah. So, Mirova is actually an asset management firm based in France and it’s a part of the NIX’s investment manager. So Natics is it’s a it’s a bank also based in France and within MOVA asset management there is Mirova natural capital so which basically folks on natural capital investment so basically we are talking about three big parts here we’re talking about forest so conservation reforestation for example oceans so there’s the sustainable ocean fund for example that came in with MROA natural capital and investing in soil as well. So up to date we have about 500 million US dollars of assets under management in within Eurova Natural Capital and seven mandates.

So seven investment funds we talked about two of them here. So Alilia climate fund, the Atheilia biodiversity fund and of course you have the sustainable ocean fund, you have the lender neutrality fund, the LDN agri fund, L’Oreal anyways I mean there’s a good cross-section of investment funds under Bureau of Natural Capital. So the objective it’s really we see how to add value and impact on the natural capital space. So we really see that more and more we can get traction deploy capital make our impact and report returns to investors.

Jonah:

So you guys are organizing a lot of other folks money. We’ve heard about the European Investment Bank and US Aid. Tell us about some of the other and you told us about CIAT. Tell or through us a te tell us about some of the other investors that you guys have been able to bring on board to invest in the fund as it relates to the Amazon.

Alan Batista:

Yeah. So you for example the agri 3 fund you have partnership with rabo bank for example so usually so the investment instrument in this case is usually long-term debt and guarantees. So it’s really about to reach that the last mile you know of the investment. So usually commercial loans for farmers to turn from conventional agriculture let’s say to lowcarbon agriculture you usually have a little bit longer tenure. You need more mature instruments and you usually don’t find in commercial banks that last year last couple of years. So for example, this fund is a partnership with a with a bank with a bank which is very well known in the agri business space to really reach that last mile and really implement you know for example lowcarbon agriculture practice let’s say no till practices integrated live crop forest systems for example.

So this is just one example of how we talked a little bit about you know d-risking mechanism with u let’s say with the development agencies but you also have this space with commercial banks for example institutional investors they’re they’re also there as cornerstone investors on those on those funds of Moba natural capital as well.

Jonah / Alan Batista — boundary unclear:

Are there some family offices involved?

Alan Batista:

Yes and in fact we see a lot of space to grow with family offices. And for example specifically on our Amazon fund since is Brazilian denominated so local currency denominated. Yeah. You really avoid a lot of the you know the transaction risk of you know having hard currency. Then you have for example at this period of this very large crisis of COVID where you have big movements a lot of volatility on exchange rates. So this you really remove a very a very large layer of risk that you usually get caught up on those transactions really.

So we see a lot of space to grow with family offices as well.

Jonah:

What is the percentage of public money versus private money?

Alan Batista:

It really it really depends Jonah. For example, it depends on the closing of the fund. Usually you start with a much more share of public money, right? So and you end up after the fund raise after you finish all the fundraisings until you close the fund, you get the private capital. So usually start more with public funding, so development agency funding and as you go through the fundraising process, you have more private capital than the public money. That’s the whole idea of leveraging, right? I mean, when we talk about leverage in this case, it’s about okay, so for every dollar that the you the development agency invested, we’re going to bring another four, five or six, for example.

So, it’s a it’s a bit of a it’s a bit of a process, but the but the objective is always to have more private investors attended at the closing of the fund than public funding.

Jonah:

From you mentioned PEXA earlier from what I understand what they were one of your first investments. Tell us a little bit about them, their business model, why you guys chose them.

Alan Batista:

Yeah. Well I mean when we talk about Amazon and get it scale impact and avoid deforestation increase carbon secretation there’s always the challenge of beef production livestock. Of course everybody knows this if you if you go into the news that’s pretty much a lot of the problem behind of the sustainability of the Amazon. So when we first saw this opportunity was really trying to you know can we make it this at scale. Can we can we make you know can we can we have regenerative livestock production in the Amazon. So PEXA actually started before we entered PEX about in 2016 between 2015 2016 and before that it was run by an NGO ICV here in Brazil and this was actually a spin-off from them.

So we usually work with partners. We engage a lot with partners. I mean if you go to the Amazon it’s you cannot do anything alone and it’s actually a big reason to fail. So not only PEXA but many other projects we have like the I dare project probably some of you know in Peru as well with you know avoided deforestation and cocoa producing agroforestry. We always do with partner with technical assistant for TA for implementing. So this is how actually PEXA started and then we got in to bring capital at scale and really bring to scale the production.

So today they have about u 25,000 heads in production. They have a lot of partnerships. They have you know regenerated 10,000 hectares of p pasture and we are going into a phase of closing now right so the ASF it’s coming to an end so we have the business who are in restructuring business that fail and business that are actually doing very good so more than 50% of the net asset value of the fund has already been realized so there’s always the next step. So, we got this early growth capital for PEXA and now they’re going to an X phase to the next phase to really growth.

I mean from 10,000 hex to 30,000 50,000 100,000. So they have a very a very bold strategic plan for developing the business and the and the model which is really about bringing together all of these stakeholders because when we talk about you know businesses that really relates let’s say with other cattle ranchers for example it’s really about having someone who understands the reality understands the business and bring together this operation. It’s never easy to work with many with many stakeholders in place and have commercial transactions with them. So it was a hard learning we had a good learning process with PEXA especially for the other businesses that we are developing where you have for example like I mentioned pillar one of our ADF investment fund where we’re working with co-ops and communities and non- timber forest products.

It’s really about having someone who can operate these many dozens hundreds of people of families that can really bring together value to all of them.

Jonah:

From what I understand there was also an investment in a macaúba palm oil venture. Could you tell us about that?

Alan Batista:

Yeah, this is this is this is very interesting. This is actually we are advisors with IDB lab. So the investments actually made from IDB and we are advisers on that. So it’s a very interesting venture as well. It has already completed 1,000 hectares of planting Makuba and integrated system. So livestock it’s really about integrating. So livestock production. So they have many partners in the mineriz states in Brazil. So it’s more focused on sahadu makuba palm oil. It’s actually native from the Brazilian sahadu. So also you can find in transition between sahadu and the Amazon biome.

And since we wanted to do partnerships the best way was to do integrated systems. So we usually have you have planting a fewer number of macaka compared to let’s say a pure plantation. So you can have pasture production with the macakuba plants and they have been reaching they have reached 1,000 hectares and we’re going to plant in the next phase another thousand. So the first goal of this investment was really to deploy a very let’s say a very good scale in terms of pilots. So two 2,000 hectares in four years and develop as many in partnership as possible and not only that especially to really test with the market how much they have appetite really to have the macakauba oil to substitute the palm oil the regular palm oil.

So because it’s all about that we think it’s the key here it’s really about the idea of substituting the regular palm oil by the macob oil which is you know it’s a native species of our biomes and it can goes grows really well together with other systems. So you can have agroforestry they have been testing in agroforest system with other crops and also with livestock. So we see a lot of potential on that because the market can be really huge. You can you can reach cosmetics can you can reach cooking industry so food and beverage industry.

So that’s basically the focus because you can aggregate more value to the product. So that’s a bit of the of the rationale of the inocus project.

Jonah:

Great. I want to talk a little bit about scale. So many Amazon producers are still small scale. And if your minimum investment size is let’s say a million dollars and up, it can be really hard to find enough qualified projects. I’m wondering what is your minimum investment size and have you guys had to adapt, so to speak, to the needs of the Amazon along the way?

Alan Batista:

That’s a very good question actually, Jonah. Yeah so the first thing is that the so the fund being denominated in Brazilian high is not in US dollar that’s already bring us a lot of you know let me put this way it brings us more flexibility on not only on the ticket size but like I mentioned before on the risk management side we don’t have to you know if you have a US dollar denominated debt in your balance sheet that be a huge problem in let’s say eight years, 10 years when the fund is closing.

So you have two good things with that. So I don’t the minimum ticket size let’s say it’s not a million dollars it’s a million high so it’s like five times less a bit more than five times less than what would it be if it was in US dollars. So the thing is we understand that a lot of these business are very small. So we have smaller ticket sizes for the for this first let’s say venture window. But of course we plan follow on as business grows. So for example you invest in a business now that it’s very small but in within three years five years we always have for example follow on option.

When this business is much larger, you have a larger valuation. So you don’t dilute founders that much. So you can really you really able to align interest when you do that. So it’s we never have majority stake at those businesses. So this kind of helps for example if I have like a convertible notes now I don’t really to worry that much about valuation today. We can go back to this like in one or two years and then have like a after we have you know gone through a lot of the milestones proposed in the business model we can sit down together again with founders and okay so let’s convert into equity let’s bring more capital let’s make this business grow beyond the venture phase to an early growth phase for example so we have these strategies in place not only not only for ticket size but many things I mean really to align interest so have skin in the game from both sides right so you don’t dilute founders so much that’s usually a big problem as well and we have very flexible mandate as well I mean we can do we can use all sorts of instruments from common equity to playing vanilla debt so this was that’s something that’s always the issue with the Amazon So that’s something we wanted to make sure in this fund we don’t get stuck with this.

Jonah:

A last question from me and then I want to invite others to go ahead and indicate their interest. We already have one question from Marina Compa. So last one for me. There are a lot of businesses even those at scale that operate in an informal way. They might not necessarily have an audited financial statement or a clear business plan, but they can be they can have a high revenue. I’m just my question is how much support do you give the a candidate company’s team? When you’re evaluating them for investment for the first time, do they do they need to have all the financials ironed out in house or is there because you guys are sort of a more virtuous and philanthropically minded fund with you know government subsidy do you give the entrepreneurs a little bit more support?

Alan Batista:

That’s a good question John. Yes like the your previous question we also know that this is a big problem for small enterprises in the Amazon. So we do give them a lot of support. We usually build financial statements together. Usually they are they’re not limited liability companies in Brazil. They are they’re likememes really so they don’t have audited financial statements for example. But we build this together. We go through we talk to the with the accountants we talk to the to the to the if they have a financial manager for example.

So we really on the investment process we really want to see an impact in a business proposition. That’s what we want to see. If we see value on that we carry on. So we go to the first so that’s the first phase. So that’s the first step on the process to see if they have good impact story and usually it’s much harder to build this impact story because usually that’s not in place of course even if the financial statements for example are not really well developed the impact the impact is this is also true for the impact story.

So, so if we think there’s a impact story behind a business proposition behind, we go through our first investment committee and then we start screening and within the screening process which is this second step we really dig into the operations. We interview the managers the employees. We build the business plan together, the financial statements together. We go through on the possible investment structures investment instruments that are possible to be in place. So for example funders are not over let’s say overleveraged. You don’t you don’t want to see a company that cannot pay that later on or funders that are too diluted at the beginning because they’re going to need to fund raise for the next round and they’re going to get diluted over time.

And then and then we present this to the and this is the most important phase where we present then to the investment committee and the in the expert board and then if it’s approved and then we dig even more into it and we start the due diligence process of course so you have lawyers and then we do a an accounting diligence as well. So it’s not that every everything needs to be in place. We build that together and some of the things even after the screening process you can have in place instruments that okay within our after our investment in three months you need to bring you know a business plan or a number of clients for example because these are usually very small enterprises where the founder it’s the it’s the management it’s in the management team and it’s doing the business plan, the fundraising, it’s doing everything.

So, we really understand that and we really sit with them and work across all these all these important matters. We don’t believe we’re going to find any enterprise really that it’s that ready to raise capital because if they are that ready, they probably going to have other sources of capital out there that they might that they might reach. So, so this is a very this is a very important part of the process and it’s kind of a interesting challenge for us. We are very small team here in Brazil. We are only three.

So you probably know my colleagues Nick Nicks and Rosanna. So we kind of kind of go through we do everything from day to day and it’s it has been quite fun the last year. Very good.

Jonah:

Okay. We have our first question. Marina,.

Marina:

Hi Alan. Thank you so much for your presentation. It was really interesting for me to hear more about the Mirova and Alidia funds. So my question to you is if you could elaborate and tell us a little bit more about what kind of impacts do you monitor and how do you monitor them? I would appreciate. Thank you.

Alan Batista:

Oh yeah. No, no, no problem. Thanks for your question. So they we build a framework on impacts and ESG. So we have my colleague Rosanna, she’s the specialist here in Brazil on impacts. We also have people based in the London office who assist us. So it’s really about understanding the business and building an impact framework that they’re going to need to you know to fill in across the years of implementation of our investment. So like I said none of the companies they have like an impact assessment framework in place that’s something we discuss with them and we go through among the investment process.

So for example there are many things that are not negotiable for us. So for example deforestation even if it’s legal u we don’t accept that. So we build impact framework where we can monitor and we don’t for example also have any leakage where your supplier might cause for example deforestation so an indirect impact. So we have so we start building all these impacts. So for example let’s say living wage. So how if your if your suppliers they have like a minimum living wage to have a decent life who are supplying you.

If all your workers are we say here in Brazil or CLT. So if they are you know keeping with the legal labor regulation. So all this we put an impact framework and we assess that over and over. Of course there’s a carbon piece depending on the project. This is more important and you’re going to have like for example MV ver verification gold standard schemes. For some companies this is not as important. So, so it’s really I mean we don’t it’s hard to have like a ready a tailored like we need to do tailor made for every different company.

It’s hard to have like a okay so this is our impact framework and this we implement in every company. It’s so I think it’s a very that’s what makes so special this assessment and we work very closely with the companies to develop that because we also don’t want to do anything that’s not reasonable they’re not going to reach or if it’s going to be so overwhelming that they’re not going to have enough let’s say enough dedicated people to keep up with the monitoring for example right so it’s very small enterprises they don’t have a sustainability ility team for example.

So, so it’s always this balance and then everything it’s everything afterwards it’s disclosed on our on our u reports although the impact assessment so it’s really about being transparent as well it’s very important on the impact assessment to be transparent.

Marina:

Thank you Alan. If I can just do a followup that Jonah said I could. So I was just wondering if you could explain a little bit I mean all the organizations especially small businesses in the Amazon it would be really costly for them to create like a baseline monitor got all this data be able to report and monitor either for them or for the NGO if they have any other partners on the ground and most donors unfortunately they require and request monitoring and evidence that investment is having some potential results but very rarely they fund that monitoring process.

So do how do you deal with that and do you guys are open to this to funding for all the structure and the team that is necessary to do the monitoring or do you guys do yourselves?

Alan Batista:

Yeah, we so that’s the good thing about being a larger company now, right? So we are all like Nurova Natural Capital now. So we have a team that takes care of so impact assessment and ESG sorry and ESG issues. So we have our own assessment tools of course we follow all the methods IFC for example standards and everything. And we never we have already understood this. You cannot like it cannot be costly. I mean for example, if I have a 1 million Brazilian high ticket, how I’m going to do like a baseline monitoring and all of that?

That’s not possible. We know that. So, so I mean we were able to discuss with our investors and donors to come into a place where we know how far we can go with this and how we can actually be efficient on monitoring our impacts. So it’s like I said it’s from case to case. I mean, if it’s a carbon financing project, of course, I’m going to it’s actually a big chunk of the of the investment is going to be it’s going to go to that. So, right. So, to build the baseline to the assessment to the monitoring and everything.

So, like I said, it’s a bit of case by case, but I think we are in a very good terms with the investors on that on that matter specifically.

Jonah:

Thank you. Raphael, you’re up next. Could you please introduce yourself as well when you ask your question?

Rafael (Conexsus Fund):

Hi, my name is Rafael Hiber. I am the manager of Conexsus Fund in Brazil. Alan, thank you very much for your presentation with valuable insights for us as well. So my question is in terms of deployment, you mentioned that many times in your talks. I was a little confused about your investment strategy. If you focus on equity investments and large ones rather than smallcale social u ventures the community led and that are more based on that financing. And how do you manage with three staff with three people with this very detailed the diligence as you were describing?

H how can you manage to deploy this the size of the fund which is impressive for investments in the Amazon. As we know that the region has many obstacles in terms of smallcale business development.

Alan Batista:

Thanks Rafael. Very good question actually. So we so we have a very broad mandate in terms of instrument. So like you asked about equity or debt. So we do actually we pref we prefer some instruments that are actually in between like common equity or debt. So we could have like for example preferred equity. We have revenuebased loan profit share loans convertible nodes carbonbacked loans. I mean we have a very this is very interesting about the fund. We have a very broad mandate. So I mean when you’re discussing transaction you can always find a new interesting instrument that you can really align interest between the fund and the and the founders of the company we are we are looking at.

And more specific to the to the point. So to the point of you know u larger companies or like more specific smaller communities actually we want to do more on pillar one which is specifically with co-ops and communities. So usually forest management of non-timber forest products I mean some supply chains that we believe it’s interesting like cast or asai I think we have a lot of potential there but then it’s a bit more complicated to structure so it gets really more of the challenge of working with Amazon so you have usually many stakeholders together you have to plan really well how that’s going to be operated in the ground because a lot of times the problem is operation right so how you going to operate a very large scale operation with 300 families for example it’s not it’s not very simple issue so we want to we want to do more of that and we are in a very interesting phase of the fund where we are looking at those of those projects where we can you have like smaller ticket sizes and as they grow their operations, we can come back, you know, with follow on investments for example on those and really reach the scale and the impact that we are we’re aiming for.

But I agree with you. I mean to be to be very honest common equity for example it’s not the most common instrument because we are we are in the investment phase but we always have to remember that in 10 years I have to divest I have to you know the fund it’s a closed ended fund so if I do equity I that means I have to usually to sell someone so it’s not so it’s not so simple so we always have to find an instrument that it aligns the interest now between fund and company and then I have to think that in 10 years I have to do a divestment so it’s really about that and yeah and we are have been working a lot I mean the three of us yes but it’s fun we like it.

Jonah:

Great next step is Durang please introduce off as well.

Maria Duran:

Hello, good afternoon. Thank you very much for your presentation. My name is Maria Duran and I work with the Amazon sustainable landscape program within the World Bank. My question was well after your excellent presentation I wanted to know what is your main framework for working as only the private sector or have you approach it approached to governments or public sector? If so, do you help with a report to international environmental conventions such as CBD or UNF C? Thank you.

Alan Batista:

Thanks. Yeah, I mean at the at the company level I mean we are we use a lot of the those proposed methodologies for reporting. I mean of course we don’t we don’t want to do something that only Mirova does for example. So at the at that level we do and like I said I mean we are we are very few people here. So we’re really focused let’s say on the on the investment phase now we really have to build our track record regarding the fund. We have to we have to bring this impact story to life because if we don’t have if we don’t have investments we don’t have an impact story to tell or even to measure right I mean to you know to report back to those conventions for example so but we do maybe I’m not the best person in terms of you know impact hect assessment.

I’m more into the into the business side of the of the fund. But in fact I think my colleague Rosanna later can help as well. Are there other questions?

Jonah:

Go ahead Alan.

Alan (audience participant):

Thanks Jonah. Hi Alan. Thanks for your great presentation. I really like the work that you guys have done in pioneering carbon and I’m curious to see whether first of all how the carbon markets in Brazil are coming along right now and if you see any development around broader ecosystem services you know for example around water around biodiversity and things like that. Th.

Alan Batista:

Thanks. Thanks Alan. Yeah, I mean so far up to now you we have I mean what’s in place now, right? So it’s voluntary markets, right? So but what’s coming up? I think that’s the question you kind of raised. There’s a lot of discussions on policy frameworks and Rosanna my colleague she’s very deeply involved in this the discussion with the ministry of environment here in Brazil it’s a bit of an if right so there’s what’s going to happen so if we’re going to have like a regulated market here or not we continue with the with the voluntary market but we See we see some momentum going on in this great discussion but it’s always hard to bet on what government’s going to do next especially now right I mean we are in a very u I mean strange situation regarding you know what governments are doing especially here in Brazil so it’s hard to bet everything on that but even with the with the voluntary markets So we are managing to close the our deals on payment for environmental services.

There’s also discussion on a federal level but at state level at municipal level you already have some of those schemes in place especially for water. So you do have like u I think the oldest one is actually 10 years old in a watershed close here to St. Paul. It’s very interesting. There is also in the state of spirit sanu here in Brazil also envir payment for environmental service but still on biodiversity there’s a lot of discussion but I haven’t seen any really a lot of development on that side. So I think still carbon and water are going to be the ones for the next for the next years I would say.

Jonah:

Great. Thanks Lars.

Lars:

Hello. I’m Lars from Rainforest Foundation Norway. I really like the tone of your presentation. So my question is you are going to provide social and economic benefits at the local level in the Amazon. You are going to provide returns on investment. And I imagine that it’s easier with sort of large scale land owners or sort of few local partners but the challenge is to provide those benefits to you know to local communities and you mentioned like you know families and do you have any concrete example where you feel that you have actually succeeded in both providing local social and economic benefits and At least you see that there can be a return on investment as well.

Thank thanks I think it’s a very honest question and really like okay so where it is right so the ABF fund it’s very it was recently launched we are just closing our two first deals I think soon we’re going to publicly announce those but if you but what we really.

Alan Batista:

Have as a track record on that it’s the ACF so the ACF fund we have the impact performance on the on the fund and that’s where you can actually see if we if actually we could lock in a return to the investors and of course the social impact that we actually designed when it was first actually built right so the ACF fund invested in 11 enterprises across Africa, Southeast Asia and Latin America. And you do have all those actually those two perspectives you brought you do find there. So I would say for example PEXA it’s a bit on the larger land owners.

So you have because it’s livestock so it’s a bit of be since you don’t have so much aggregated value so you need more scale and you have for example the tumbleata project with the IDEAR project where you have small farmers they on average they own three hectares of agroforestry cocoa. So I think I think we have some interesting stories to tell. Already more than 50% of the of the return of the ACF fund has been realized meaning that we were able to divest eight businesses are performing well two needed to be restructured and pretty much one failed so which is actually a pretty good ratio if you think 70% performed well and up to 90% it’s alive I mean because two needed to be restructured which is I mean for the first fund we are we are quite happy with that and then we have all the social and the impact story like the carbon that has been sequestrated the avoided deforestation there’s all sorts of indicators that so I would say that we I think we were able to find a balance between investment returns and social impact on the ACF.

Jonah:

I have two questions. And then we’re getting near the top of the hour and I haven’t seen any questions from others. So others please feel free to wave your hands and indicate interest. My two questions how many businesses did you guys evaluate compared to the number that you’ve invested in? Let’s go ahead and take that one first.

Alan Batista:

Specifically for the ABF fund, the Ailia Bodiversity University fund or the ACF.

Jonah:

Anything that has to do with Amazon?

Alan Batista:

Okay. No, I mean I can speak better for the for the ABF fund because I work in the ADF fun.

Jonah:

Okay.

Alan Batista:

Yeah. No, I mean we have we have analyzed pretty much 150 u business opportunities. We went for out of those 150 let’s say 12 did a first pass u to you know to continue like that I briefly mentioned that process which is pretty much the ratio we see across funds and not other asset managers impact investors so tw so 12 are still in what we call in an active pipeline time. So, we’re in conversations with these 12 businesses going back and forth with them. And we have two executed deals. We just closed the contract last week and like I said, we’re going to we’re going to public announce this very soon.

So, so it’s yeah, it’s not it’s a lot that comes to us and we screen and for different reasons. There’s many reasons why we it doesn’t do the first pass. A lot of them we do some we give some advice so they can come back to us in a more a little bit more mature phase after six months or a year. One year for an early stage business is a lot. I mean you can grow your operation you can prove your pilot. I mean it’s so it’s not the first not best doesn’t mean that it’s dead.

I mean, you know, I mean, we always come back to them.

Jonah:

Last question from me. Instead of a hundred million dollar fund, if you guys were a billion dollar fund and you had a team that was 10 times as large, do you guys think that you would be investing at the same rate and have made only the same number of investments or do you have a guesstimate about how much how much more money would be going out the door and how many more projects you guys would be analyzing?

Alan Batista:

Yeah, I mean I think yeah that’s an interesting question because the point is if I have a let’s say a billion dollar fund, I will need a very different strategy of investment. I would not be able to deploy such amount of capital in a venture phase of those companies. So I would probably only provide that amount of capital let’s say to a late growth phase of those companies. So but you can say okay so today you have let’s say $15 million in three years $100 million in seven years eight years $1 billion.

I mean you could do that. I mean that would be would be possible because you would get all the business that you that you put in a venture and then on an early growth to a later growth. That would be that would be definitely possible and we can aim for that.

Jonah:

Great. Well, we hope to make that scenario possible bringing in this these 30 people who are all your cheerleaders. Does anybody else have any, following messages for Alan?

Unidentified participant:

You’re our north star, Alan.

Alan Batista:

Well, I really I really enjoy I think was great energy from everyone and thanks for keeping up until now with me. It was a pleasure. I learned a lot with you as well. And yeah, I mean you can give my email across everyone. So if you have further questions or anything, I will be happy to come back to you.

Jonah:

Great. I’m going to go ahead and paste his email below. Anyone else who wants to share their email addresses or their websites, please do so. We’re now at the top of the hour. So this is the moment where we convert. Class dismiss. Most people leave, but I leave the chat room open and so people can copy the links and we usually people have unstructured conversations with each other now.

Alan Batista:

Nice. Okay. Thank you all. It was a great to be with you.

Jonah:

Thank you so much for joining us, Alan.

Alan Batista:

Okay. Take care. Bye-bye.

Jonah:

Marita, we could continue our conversation about bioprospecting. Although there’s still some really amazing people on the call. Hey, Keith, do you want to introduce yourself? To us. I see you’re still there. We have a couple of people who are new to our call. Or Hinata, you want to introduce yourself? Oh, I think she just went.

Marita:

Okay. Joe and I as you know we are we are really sort of coming alive on the rainforest business school out of my house and also parallel webbased online Amazon business school and to observe this case that was presented by Alan Batista but also others over time would be fantastic material for the business Amazon business students u you know I don’t know whether there is a possibility for you to ask eventually around some of the people who have been making presentations whether they would be willing to you know be part of a sort of case study experience, life experience.

Jonah:

Yeah, I think a lot of them would. I’m happy to turn all of them.

Marita:

Yeah, because you know that’s the learning we are all doing. I mean, some do it for a living, but we want to do the learning as teaching materials and what works, what doesn’t work. He was citing tonight that there 150 cases they reviewed and then they just picked a handful. So what were the other cases? And you know if some of this material without too much ado u would be made available to the rainforest social business school in man would be great.

Jonah:

Has the business school opened up for business yet? Yeah, I mean it’s.

Marita:

Formally established since November 5.

Jonah:

Oh, great.

Marita:

The first course, of course, was ideally to begin now in March live, but they’re doing it online. So there’s a curriculum of 430 hours sort of 18 months graduate course and you know part of that is case studies and then also on the parallel related Amazon business school online which we are building up out of USPI in S. Paulo together with Manau, we also have part of our site dedicated to case studies. GIZ, the German organization, they’re already doing five case studies which will be which will be finished by the end of March.

But the real idea here is to make it as real as possible and to learn from experience and not just age-old experience but ongoing experiences would be very interesting. So maybe at some point you could you could just check who would be who would be interested to participate in this.

Jonah:

That would be great. I yeah I have a running list of Amazon businesses and investors. Another question about the business school. Are the students already all signed up? C can people sign up who are overseas?

Marita:

Yeah. The first course because it is all funded by the state of Amazonas is only open to students from the state of Amazonas. But the Amazon rainforest business school online which will go online we hope in April is open generally. So people can sign up from abroad. And of course the idea is that the next courses in Manau will also be open to students from anywhere.

Jonah:

Great. I’m gonna I realize we’ve been recording. I’m going to stop the recording now and ask you a couple of things that might not be appropriate for the recording.