Sustainability, Markets, and Nature: Introducing the Rainforest Alliance
Founded in 1987, the Rainforest Alliance (RA) works to create a more sustainable world by using social and market forces to protect nature and improve the lives of farmers and forest communities. Working with over 5000 companies, the organization offers a seal that certifies products and ingredients that are produced according to select social, economic, and environmental sustainability metrics. How does RA convene agricultural industry stakeholders to understand risks and develop landscape-wide systemic solutions? How do they work with local communities? Join us to discuss these questions, hear about cocoa farmers in the Colombian Amazon, and learn about two international RA programs. Based on 30 years of experience, RA’s Forest Allies program helps local communities to secure land rights, develop product lines, access markets, and more. At the other end of the supply chain, RA supports Landscale, an assessment tool that helps organizations to generate landscape-level insights to make decisions about sustainability at scale. Join to meet RA Corporate Partnerships Lead, Pamela den Hartog, and learn.
Recorded July 25, 2022
References:
Cocoa for Life + Forest in the Amazon
What Does “Rainforest Alliance Certified” Mean?
How have 30 years of logging saved the rainforest in Guatemala?
Integrated Forest Community Management Position Paper
1000 Landscapes for 1 Billion People
Rainforest Alliance 2021 Annual Report
WATCH:
Participants
- Jonah Wittkamper
- Pamela den Hartog
- Nicolas
- Lena
- Mache
- Santiago
- Gustavo
- Hassan
- Amy
- Art Krebs
- Kristen
- Marcella
- Pacho
- Unidentified participant
Transcript
Unidentified participant:
This meeting is being recorded. Hey. Hey Pamela. Can you hear me? Hello. Hi. Yes. Can you hear me? Hey. Yes, I can. Good to see you. Sorry for the delay in getting some of those questions to you. Sorry about your in-laws. Yeah, really scary situation. Oh, hello. Hello. No one’s hurt, fortunately. Hello, Pacho. How are you? How are you today? Good.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Good. Doing very good. Just so everybody knows how this works, for the first five minutes, we allow the audience to introduce themselves. I usually call on people. And then close to four or five minutes after the top of the hour, I introduce Pamela. And Pamela, I think you’ll have 15 minute presentation. Does that sound about right? And then I’ll have a few questions and then the goal is at the 30 minute mark we switch over to questions from the audience.
Unidentified participant:
Do you before we get started do you have any questions for me? No, sounds good.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. Yeah. No. Okay, great. So I’m just going to go ahead and call on people to introduce themselves. Patcha, would you like to introduce yourself?
Pacho:
Yeah. Can you hear me? All right. Yeah. And I’m here at the farmhouse connect. I’m going to put the camera for a bit then I’ll turn it off because maybe signal comes on and off. So I’m Pu. Nice to meet you everybody. Nice to talk. I am the president of Gamas and I imagine you’ve heard a little bit about Gay Mason already. Great to be in touch with you and well hopefully that with today’s meeting we can get the final details up and running. We have a board meeting now in Friday with the rest of the North Amazon Alliance.
So, it’s great to have everybody on board. I won’t take much of your time. Thanks.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Okay. Po. Ju just so you know, this is the weekly call of the AIC podcast. Is that Oh, are you in the right place? It’s.
Unidentified participant:
Possible you showed up at the wrong meeting. All right. Let me see if I’m I am in the right place. Wait one second. Am I with Andy Gibson’s team? No, I think you clicked on the wrong calendar link.
Pacho:
Oh, okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. So then let me just send the WhatsApp and then do we have a podcast today. I was not aware. It seemed that I jumped on it seems very lucky that I jumped in the right meeting at the right time without.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Knowing. So this is where we are. Hey, th this is a presentation of the Rainforest Alliance to the to the network of the Amazon Investor Coalition. So, the North Amalian Alliance is certainly welcome to listen in, but it’s you guys aren’t the featured presenter today, just so you know. I’m going to go ahead and call others.
Pacho:
Yes, please. What the Give me one minute. Yeah, thanks.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Nicholas Mendonsa, would you like to introduce yourself?
Nicolas:
Yes. Hello everyone. I am Nicholas based in Bogotaa, Colombia. I work in Rainforest Alliance in sustainable landscapes and communities. We are implementing very exciting projects in the Colombian Amazon region, the Kokqua for life and Forest Allies projects.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Okay, great. We’ll be hearing more about your program. Hey Marian Adney, would you like to introduce yourself? If you’re there. No worries if not. Lena, would you like to introduce yourself?
Lena:
Sure. Hi, I’m Lena calling in from New York out on the beach and I am a deep lover of the wisdom of the of the rainforest and how we can protect and serve and uplift the mission of First Nations people and you know restoring the sacredness of the rainforest and the temples of nature is kind of why I’m here.
Jonah Wittkamper:
So great, thanks so much for joining us. Machi Kwalsski, would you like to introduce yourself?
Mache:
Hi everyone. My name is Mache. I come from financial and private equity background but woke up and started to build a new next generation financial system is inspired by nature but basically looks at finding ways to connect profit and sustainability.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. Thanks so much for joining us. Santiago, would you like to introduce yourself?
Santiago:
Yes, sorry. Hi, my name is Antio. I’m from the DN Alliance for Sustainable Development and we work within the Amazonian basin. We have a coffee project in Peru. So, nice to meet you all and of course all the guests and everyone.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Okay, great. That puts us at just about five minutes after the top of the hour. So I’m going to go ahead and start the regularly scheduled programming and I’m going to go ahead and paste in a lot of the links about PA and the Rainforest Alliance and references. So hold on one second. Hello everybody. Welcome to the 93rd call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing forest friendly economic development, the rule of law across the Amazon region in South America. This week we are featuring the work of the Rainforest Alliance, one of the oldest organizations bringing together the global capital markets and industry in service of sustainability.
And this week we are hearing from Pamela den Hartog who is responsible for corporate partnerships. Pamela tell us a little bit about yourself and then we can move into the presentation. But we’d love to know what you did before RA and your role now. Was there a life before or.
Pamela den Hartog:
Thank you very much for having me today and for giving us the opportunity to present ourselves. I’m Pamela den Hartog. I grew up in Venezuela and I’m but I’m Dutch and I live in the Netherlands. I’ve been working for the Rainforest Alliance for over seven years now. Before that I did a PhD in evolutionary ecology and I’ve been working at the intersection of natural resources and how we use them for a while. So I worked in fisheries, biotechnology and palm at the Rainforest Alliance recently and now I’m in charge of corporate partnerships with which includes our forests work as well which is really exciting and I’ll tell you a little more about it.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. Feel free to go ahead and give the presentation. I think that the screen should be free for sharing.
Pamela den Hartog:
Yep. Let me just do that. Can you see my screen? Let me put it in presentation mode. Yeah, great. Once again, thank you very much. We’re very excited to be able to share who we are and some of our work with you today. I’ll go into some parts of our work a little bit more high level and I’ll go into more detail in some other areas, but feel free to ask questions or we can link later for more detailed conversations. So the Rainforest Alliance, our vision is a world in which people and people in nature thrive in harmony.
And that sounds amazing. But it’s as you probably all know, it’s harder to achieve. So the way we do that is by using social and market forces that Jonah already alluded to in the in the introduction to protect nature and improve the lives of farmers and forest communities. So at the heart of our intervention in the middle of this schematic here are farmers and forest communities. We work with those directly as you can see from the bottom Rainforest Alliance we have interventions and resources that go directly into landscapes and supporting farmers and forest communities.
But we also have more supply chain focused interventions which is which you see a little bit more on the left here which is our certification program. And there we support farmers to get certified. We support companies to get certified and then a supply chain of certified goods is created which in turn creates revenue and resources back to the farmers to be able to sustain their sustainable practices. And this is also stimulated by consumer demand and then that stimulates corporate and brand demand and that’s how farmers and forest communities are then supported and then their lives are improved and nature are is protected.
But we also do this through supporting and influencing civil society and donors and governments which then create the enabling environment for landscapes to become more sustainable or for farmers to become more sustainable and for us to be able to push that sustainability agenda. So there’s various ways. So we do supply chain oriented interventions which are mostly through our sustainability projects but then we also do direct work in landscapes and communities. And then there’s also the influencing, the advocacy, the ensuring that we get resources to the right place at the right time.
Our alliance is about changing the way the world produces, sources and consumes. Our key priority areas are or sectors are cocoa, coffee, tea, bananas, horse products and palm oil. And we work in some of those with various interventions. For some of them, we have our certification program. For some we work more on traceability or supply chain mapping and for some we work directly for example with forest communities. We’re a global movement. We have 4 million farmers and workers on this the certified farms that are certified with Rainforest Alliance. We have 5,000 company partners.
1.7 million social media followers, over 140,000 newsletter subscribers. We have both individual donors over 10,000 of them and we also have institutional donors almost 50 and we also have coalitions that we’re part of and platforms that we that we are in and those are over 50 as well. We also advocate alongside and work together with NOS’s and CSOS both globally but also locally in the areas where we have presence on the ground. So as part of our global interventions, we have that sustainability program that we’re very well known for. But we also have for example LandScale which is more of a landscape tool or framework that we that we use to promote landscape sustainability.
So LandScale is a way to measure performance of a landscape and that measuring of that performance allows us to then see what the landscape needs are and to continue pushing for that those improvements on the on that performance in the landscape. So it’s a very practical and robust system to assess but also to be able to communicate how the landscape is performance in term in performing in terms of sustainability. So it allows us to identify risks and opportunities in the landscape that can inform decision- making to be able to drive positive impact.
It also convenes stakeholders diverse stakeholders across a landscape that can then identify shared goals catalyze cross- sectoral action in a landscape and they use a common language to do that. So with that data and with that robust framework of measuring the performance, it allows to have that common language for setting goals and trying to achieve those together. It also allows for connecting to incentives because policy, market and financial mechanisms often require that hard and robust data to understand what’s what’s happening and also credible insights on progress made. So that along with our certification program is kind of like the some of the global tools and frameworks that we have to advance sustainability at different levels.
And one intervention I wanted to share a little bit in more detail with you today is our Forest Allies intervention. Forest Alice is focused on restoring, managing, protect and protecting forests preserving the biodiversity within those forests and reducing the carbon footprint caused by deforestation. The fundamental thing about Forest Allies is that forest communities are front and center of this intervention. And they play an essential role in being able to manage those forests sustainably because then we empower them to do so. But also we empower them further because they’re actually already know quite well.
But we also support them in setting up businesses and in making a good sustainable living from that forest and that helps maintain this sustainability of those forests and that the integrity over time. So forest was formed in 2020. It’s a datadriven initiative. So we make sure that we have we have a monitoring evaluation framework. We measure the progress across those key indicators which I will discuss in a little bit. And it’s a method that has proven results. So we’ve applied it already in the Maya Biosphere Reserve for example in Guatemala where we’ve been for over 30 years.
And we’ve seen that deforestation rates using this model have reduced to close to zero and they have been near zero for a long time. So we’ve taken that model of that community forestry and re tweaked it a little bit to make it scalable and to be able to apply it across the globe in other areas. Another interesting thing about force allies is that it’s a community of practice. So companies are members of force allies thereby investing into a project portfolio for force allies and in the community of practice they have the opportunity to directly interact with some of the communities and to really address key challenges that they’re facing or find innovative ways to do things.
So the proven intervention method goes across four pillars and those are at the same time the four pillars that we measure impact across. So these are governance and social organization, tenure and landscape planning, forest management and enterprise development and all of them are key and they’re four pillars of the integrated community forest management pathway. So the governance in organization is that multistakeholder institutional arrangements are made force governance mechanisms are in place there’s participation there’s accountability tenure and landscape planning is about rights to the land access to the land who landscape planning land use planning and also development plans for the landscape.
The MA forest management piece is about having a good inventory of the forest resources, having good planning to manage the forest resources and have those interventions to conserve the forest and at the same time assess that impact. And a key pillar is the enterprise development. So really supporting the communities to be able to market and have access to those markets of some of the products from the forest include timber but also non-timber forest products that are sustainably harvested. And we support them in doing that market analysis, finding that those partners, doing the business planning and also make sure that they have a diversified income to make sure they are resilient to any changes in those supply chains.
And across all of this, we have advocacy, participatory methods, social inclus inclusion including gender and youth and monitoring, evaluation and learning which I already mentioned. We have a tool that has done we’ve done baseline assessments across the projects and then now we can start tracking their project the progress against these measures. And obviously the enabling environment supporting this is access to markets, access to alliances and access to finance to make sure that this integrated model works. Trying to change there we go. So currently the project portfolio has six projects in critical landscapes across the globe.
And they contribute to outcomes in over 330,000 hectares and 7,400 livelihoods. So we have we’re testing productive re restoration in Guatemala for example in Colombia we have in the Tirete National Park buffer zone. We’re working on restoration and also setting up lieloids or enterprises. In Peru, we have the Indigenous Economist Project, which I’ll go to into a later. In Cameroon, we’re supporting communities to market non-tech forests projects products. And in Indonesia, we have two projects. One that focuses on small wood timber harvesting and one that focuses more on rubber, which is the Indonesia archipelago project.
So just to zoom in more specifically on one of the projects and also very relevant for the conversation today because it’s in Peru and it’s in the Peruvian Amazon. There in Peru native communities have legal autonomy of 14 of the 70 million hectares of tropical forest land and with funding from force allies we’ve started to work with 11 native communities in the province of Lamas in the summer region. And the objective is to have estab have them support them with establishing forest based enterprises to be able to harvest and sell sustainable forest products and this at the same time enabling them to protect and restore the natural ecosystem.
Pictures are always help. So this is the area where you see the gorgea with a forested kind of mountains and hilly landscape. And what we’re doing is strengthening the producer capacities to implement sustainable forest management. Articulating the market and sources of finance for them. So support them to understand what the market requirements are, what’s responsible management is and how these products can be timber and non-timber products can be harvested from the forest. And we’re also supporting them in restoring the landscape to help them strengthen their resilience and facing deforestation and degradation threats and helping them take the full landscape into consideration as a as a production area and a and a diverse production area.
So this is a schematic representation of the landscape. And here it’s nice to see that all our interventions come together as it were. So the cordier scaler is the mountainous bit with the trees in the middle. That’s where we have our interventions to with the indigenous communities to support the forest. But at the same time LandScale has been applied here to pilot measurement of how the landscape is doing in terms of sustainability. There’s multistakeholder agreements in place. There’s private businesses that are that are engaged and we’re working on certification for coffee and cocoa in the landscape at the same time.
So ultimately it all kind of comes together here and we’re fostering resilient communities, improving farmer livelihoods and facilitating the sustainable management of the landscape. And now I’d like to pivot a little bit to the Colombian Amazon which is where we have our Coco for life program. If my colleague Nicolas can answer specific questions on that and he works in that area. So in Colombia we see that deforestation is still high and in the three districts or departments here shown with a yellow circle which are Kaketa, Guavier and Kumayu the deforestation rates are over 44%.
So what we’ve done here is that we’re developing a resilient deforestation free cocoa business model to support the livelihoods of cocoa farmers which is already good in itself but the interesting key thing here is that this is an area where before there was cocoa u plantation so these farmers were and it was a very insecure area because of the drug trading and the kaka for life program is helping these farmers and their families come back into a social a more normalized and safe and peaceful social system in which they can make a good living and good livelihood off of a good crop like cocoa to helping them transition back into a safe and more normalized social system.
So it’s protecting the forests and improving the livelihoods of these families in the Colombian Amazon region. It’s also promoting the collaboration between those three departments which was which wasn’t the case before this and fostering collaboration across farmers in those departments so they can become a bigger group and a bigger cooperative to market their products in a better way. Yeah so this is some more information on that project. So there’s a monitoring reporting and verification system. We’re designing a deforestation free business model. There’s traceability in the cocoa value chain which is obviously very important on the market side of the supply chain.
And we’re improving the skills and providing tools to the farmers and cooperatives in that area to really be able to make a good living whilst protecting the forest where they adjacent to them and where they live off. That was it for me for now. Happy to answer any questions.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. So we’ll have a few questions from me and then we’ll open up to the larger community. First question I have is what a sophisticated program. What would it take to bring Forest Allies to a new country such as Brazil?
Pamela den Hartog:
The quick answer is money. So yeah, so we’re ready. We’ve had discussions with companies and others and there’s obviously a big footprint in Brazil, right, in terms of deforestation. So, it’s definitely a company a country that we’ve had on our radar. And I think we have we’re building kind of the capacity there in our teams and we have good partnerships locally which we could which we could leverage to bring Forest Allies to Brazil. But indeed we’d need new members or some sort of help with those investments to get to get that up and running.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Indeed. Okay. I’ve got one question about the Cocoa for Life program. I am familiar with some cocoa agroforestry in the Amazon region and the fungus witches broom being a big problem. I’m wondering if you guys have found a variety of cocoa that is able to overcome it or you have some other way to counteract the problem.
Pamela den Hartog:
I’d like to pass that one to Nicolas if he can answer because he probably knows. Yes. Well, we don’t have we don’t do research here in this project. So in order to find the best genetic materials to fight against the witch’s broom, we work together with Fed Cacao, which is the National Federation of Cacao Cocoa Growers. They do the research and they have different clones and varieties with different levels of resistance to which is broom. However, the worst problem here is not that one is the other one called monilia which is a another fungus which is really having an economic impact in the cocoa plantations throughout the country.
So that is the way to approach that challenge is with a integrated MIP integrated pest management system. So we work with the agricultural practices not only with the genetic resistance but also with picking up the parts of the plant that are affected by the disease. So that’s the best way to control.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. I have a question about the seal the frog they say. I remember your page on the website says find the frog. How does a new company become certified? I realize that you can make an hour presentation on just that. So just.
Pamela den Hartog:
Briefly, I suppose you mean a supply chain.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Company or Yeah. Yeah. How does the supply chain of new company X get certified as RA compliant?
Pamela den Hartog:
So actually they would get in touch with a certification body that’s accredited to audit our against our standard and they and or at the same time get in touch with us. We could provide them all kinds of materials of like what are what is the things that we will be checking on? What are the important things you need to make sure you have in place to pass the requirements of the audit? And then basically they need to make sure they have their processes in place all the requirements from the standard and then an auditor comes and that visit is planned and then they make sure that everything’s in place.
Checks and then if they don’t have any what we call nonconformities which means that they don’t have any issues where in which they don’t adhere to the standard then they auditor passes them and requests a license I think to in our systems to be certified I think it goes there’s a risk assessment previous as well to see how risky a company is depending on what their processes are what their products are etc.
Jonah Wittkamper:
I realize it’s a very complex process probably. I’m just wondering if you have any estimation of costs. Sometimes cost for certification is an obstacle for some small producers especially.
Pamela den Hartog:
Yeah, for small producers that can indeed be a challenge. I wouldn’t know exact numbers at this point because it’s very dependent on where you are in the supply chain, where you are geographically, how many auditors there are, etc. So that’s a.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Little hard to estimate. I just realized we’re still on full screen. If you could pull it off, people.
Unidentified participant:
Will be able to see us speaking. Sorry. It’s okay. So another question.
Jonah Wittkamper:
For me. Could I if I’m a small producer in Peru that is participating in the Forest Allies program, can you walk us through a little bit more concretely what support you’re able to provide with market intelligence and access?
Pamela den Hartog:
Yeah. So we actually so usually it’s like it’s communities that we work with and then they have access rights to the land. We actually have colleagues both in kind of more markets countries like the US but also in on the ground in the countries where in Peru for example which would actually help them do an inventory of like these are the products these this is what you can market these are the markets where it would go into these are prices so we actually very specifically with technical capacity support them on making a business plan on understanding what the opportunities are and Actually, we also help them with getting potential corporate partners.
So, if they have honey, we help them find a tea or another brand that’s interested in or food company that’s interested in using the honey for as an ingredient or with wood. We support them with some of the brands that might be interested in a specific type of wood for a specific purpose. So we actually very specifically have that technical capacity and then and apply it to help these communities.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. Just two more questions for me and then we’ll bring it over to the audience. I would like to ask about LandScale. Super impressive program. Can you give us an idea of some of the either ministerial level or global corporate level planning that has become possible because of LandScale that was not possible previously?
Pamela den Hartog:
I would actually not know those details. I did invite my colleagues to this call. I was just scrolling through the names but I don’t see them here. So, that’s actually an answer that I would have that I owe you then and would have to get back to you.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Okay. Has do you know if anyone has been talking about using it to create ecosystem bonds or e ecosystem.
Unidentified participant:
Service bonds or anything like that? Not sure. Not sure. Okay. Yeah. Okay. No worries. And the last.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Question I had related to LandScale is are governments participating or is it mostly just a private sector effort?
Pamela den Hartog:
No, I think from my understanding that multi- those multistakeholder agreements and those established kind of multistakeholder bodies do can include government rep government representatives depend like at whatever level is relevant at that at that landscape.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Okay, great. Okay. I’m now going to hand it over to those in the audience. Luis from Moss Earth. I’d like to invite you to introduce yourself and to sort of make your request. If you’re still there, I think he’s not there. Okay. Maybe he had to get off. Are there others who have questions for Pamela or other members of the Rainforest Alliance team? Well, that was a great call. No, just kidding. Go ahead, Gustavo. Okay, Gustavo and then Mache.
Gustavo:
Hi, Pamela. Congratulations on your work. U Force Alliance is very inspiring for many of us. It’s great to see all the impact you are bringing on the ground and also the connections with the market. I’d like to know like have more like your opinion on some things like on a little of a political perspective as we are going to have elections in Brazil. H how do you see like Brazil positioning like in comparison with the other Latin American countries? I see Rainforest Alliance has is much more present in the Spanish than in the Portuguese or loafos parts of America.
Could you give us a glimpsey of your perspective on what’s the role of Brazil and versus or in partnership with the other Latin American countries?
Pamela den Hartog:
Yeah, that’s a that’s a good question. So, we are present in Brazil actually. So, we do have an office there and we do have a staff and we’re actually looking to expand that a little bit. So it’s definitely a country that we find important especially from a rainforest u protection perspective of course which is obvious. I think it’s more I don’t think it has necessarily been a conscious decision to not engage in Brazil. I think it’s more a historical way that the Rainforest Alliance has grown with a lot of the focus of the work in Central America and then it expanded more into Spanish speaking Latin America if you will and also with the merger with UTZ.
I think those kind of countries in which both organizations had good footing remained and the Brazil is definitely one of them and I think as I said for Forest Allies it’s key to look into what we can do in Brazil and for a certification program Brazil is also very important in some of those key products that we certify in the supply chain. I think it’s just a matter of time and that we’ll be there and yeah, I hope to be able to that we can proceed with that impactful work as well in Brazil and thank you very much for your compliments on that.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. Next up, Mache. Yeah, I wanted to ask if you use any technology kind of to facilitate your business especially to facilitate the connecting throughout the supply chain you know between farmers and customers and your you know your.
Pamela den Hartog:
Okay, good question. Yeah. No, definitely for our certification program. It’s really important and also part of our assurance system to make sure that ultimately the product the especially for certified products the certified products that are carrying the seal in the marketplace that we actually know that they came from certified producers. So yeah we do have an intricate traceability system where everybody has to register and where volumes are given to producers and those volumes are passed along in the supply chain. So that’s for certification. And then for some of the crops outside of certification, we also provide services in supply chain mapping and helping companies understand where their non-certified supply comes from to help them improve their practices and address risks in those supply chains.
Palm is an example of that. And we also for example for palm provide the traceability platform for RSPO the round table and sustainable palm oil. So in that sense the traceability systems and that tech technology side of it is very core to the work that we do. Yeah.
Mache:
And in terms of let’s say community building and communication have you considered you know creating some sort of marketplaces? Have you thought about this area where you could kind of like automate a bit you know the relationships?
Pamela den Hartog:
Yeah, that’s a good a question. So we’ve used an in so for it’s an example but for example for RSPO where they have the credit I don’t know if you’re familiar with RSPO the credit trading mechanism. It’s a functionality that allows producers to directly sell credits to and buyers in supply chain. So we do have that and sometimes we think of how we could use that maybe in other ways. We are brokering in different projects kind of how companies can invest into landscapes or how companies can invest into projects. But that’s a good question.
I don’t think for the community work we’ve actually h we don’t have a way to broker kind of their products to find buyers. So that’s an interesting perspective to take with me.
Mache:
Yeah. And maybe last question. Do you see like a common synchronizing factor that you know synchron it’s like a common synchronizing factor between you know all of your stakeholders? Do you see something that is like you know common denominator if you like? Between all of your stakeholders. Yes.
Pamela den Hartog:
Yeah I think that’s a good question. I think for the corporate side for sure it’s really that shift that we’re seeing right to having to meet targets on sustainability no deforestation etc. I think for the more the farms stakeholders it’s indeed also a question of yeah be having a good livelihood and be able to sustain that over time. I think and as that goes kind of hand inhand with some of that the environmental components I think that’s kind of the common denominator but across all of them I think would be hardification.
Unidentified participant:
Right thank you great Hassan.
Hassan:
Hi thank you and thanks for the presentation and actually the part of my question was around technology. So I’m glad it was it was pretty much that half of it was answered. But the other part also had to do with specific to you mentioned how you provide is it market data, market intelligence, right? And I was just wondering like so are you where are you getting that from? Are you how are you how are you getting that? Are you and how are you then in what way are you like is there again you use providing it through a tech platform I just wondering just a little more about that so I can understand is there any analytics or how do you do that an analysis.
Pamela den Hartog:
Yeah so I think what I was mentioning was more for the communities to help them market the products they have so that’s more of market scans and like locally like what’s the potential to sell it that’s just basically research done on the ground with like trying to understand who buyers could be what bringing potential buyers in that kind of thing. I think organizationwide we do have platforms where we get our market data from and but a key thing actually for us is really to have our own impact data actually being able to translate that to our market partners.
That’s like a really core element of what we do. So that certified companies can say okay so I’m certified with you but what’s the actual impact that we’re achieving together by this certification program and that’s I think the key where we’re I’m really focusing our energy on and our platforms are geared more and more to be able to provide that very specific data on specific supply chains and so that’s kind of the inverse of what you were asking I think but that’s more where we where we are focusing at the.
Hassan:
Moment just one it’s more of like a comment. I’d love to just say that I think you should connect offline because I work with an AI tech company and I’d love to see how if we can help you to in any way. Yeah, just that’ be that would be great.
Pamela den Hartog:
Sure. Yeah. Always welcome. Happy to. Yeah.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Pamela, you mentioned one thing earlier that really caught my attention and that is the merger between UTZ and the Rainforest Alliance. This is something that’s super rare in the nonprofit universe, super common in the corporate universe. Could you tell us a little bit about that story?
Pamela den Hartog:
Yeah. So the ultimate I so what we were seeing and I think everyone was seeing right is that there’s a lot of labels out there, a lot of sustainability standards etc. And at some point some farms were being certified against different ones to be able to access different markets. And ultimately what we were asking ourselves is that really what we’re you know what we’re trying to achieve and we figured the less if all these standards are doing very similar things how nice would it be if we can join two of them with a pretty large reach and then actually be able to scale that impact and have bigger impact together rather than be trying to get pieces of the market away from each other or whatever we where we’re trying to achieve the same thing.
So that’s where that came from and Rainforest Alliance and UTZ were actually quite complimentary organizations. So it was a very nice coming together of these complimentary qualities that we now see within the new unified organization. So I think yeah, that worked out quite well quite well.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. I’ve got a long list of questions, but I don’t want to use up all the oxygen in the room. So, do others have questions? So, another question I have is the arrival of the task force on nature related financial disclosures and sort of the equivalent task force on biodiversity. There’s a more and more corporate demand for nature-based solutions. You guys are one of the few organizations with a real global footprint with advice. Could you tell us a little bit about how you guys institutionally get swept up in that planning process?
Pamela den Hartog:
Yeah, so we talk to a lot of companies on naturebased solutions. What we do see is companies are a lot of times struggling with like all the frameworks they have to adhere to and all the things they need to report and then ultimately they you know there’s solutions within their supply chain but then there’s also solutions outside supply chains force allies for example is one that’s outside supply chains and then they sometimes wonder well you know should I be investing outside of my supply chain what is that bringing me so I think there’s a big struggle going on there I think ourselves We are gearing ourselves up to be able to support companies more widely in these solutions.
We’re also looking at carbon for example to include that in some of our projects and to have those measures and to make it more appealing and interesting and easy for companies to be able to join some of these projects. Yeah, I think Amy is on the call. I’m not sure if she has more to say on this piece on spotting.
Amy:
I actually was answering a question from previous in the notes. So, sorry. But I think that no, I mean our global programs also actually interact and feed into a lot of the different global processes. For example, I know our team on the accountability framework initiative has been really feeding into the European Union draft language that for the new requirements that will be coming out. So I think we enter into different spaces at different like different teams also at different levels. Yeah, so it’s sometimes hard to track who’s talking to who about what.
But I also wanted to follow up on a question about the creating a marketplace because we are in discussion with the donor now about funding that we hope to we’re getting close to receive for creating a marketplace for companies in the Amazon. And we think Joan, I don’t know if you remember Adriana mentioning that, you know, that’s probably a couple years out because there’s still a lot of capacity building that needs to be done with the companies before we can even bring them kind of connect them with buyers. But that is something that we definitely are hoping to receive funding for and invest in the next.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Year. There are some people on this call who are involved in developing supply chains in the Amazon region. Wondering if any of you guys would like to introduce yourselves and maybe a you know opportunity for global and local to meet.
Santiago:
Sure. Hi, my name is Santiago. As I talked before, we work with a coffee project in Peru. And, I wanted to ask a little bit more in depth about the this idea of the carbon market, you know, as a as a another income like an extra income for farmers and what’s the viability that you have to study and if it’s good and it’s actually something that provides an important income for farmers in terms of their livelihood. And but also yeah I wanted to say that these types of like marketplaces and everything shorten the supply chain which in the case of coffee it’s also a very complicated and sometimes very long supply chain so I think it’s a really good idea.
Pamela den Hartog:
Yeah I think for carbon actually we’re exploring that at the moment like what that what that could look like and what role we could play in that space as well like what does our certification program bring in terms of benefits in carbon emission reductions etc. And also the same for our Forest Allies and some of those interventions. So from there we can then start seeing like okay can we measure these changes and then what can we do like is this robust enough to be able to look at credits or other ways of marketing this.
So I think for sure there is an opportunity there. I don’t think we’re there yet in terms of researching what if that’s viable or not.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Oh, go ahead Machi. Yeah. So I can connect you with some let’s say blockchain related technologies that already figure out the way to use data to like build carbon you know credit kind of product. So you know I don’t know how far you are so you know it’s really hard to understand you know through this like short call but I send you a LinkedIn invite so we can connect that way I can connect you with a couple of company in my kind of like parimeter that probably can help you with that and yeah so yeah I think I think it’s a lot that’s why I ask about synchronization and those parameters that synchronize because there’s a lot of like s you know small activities here and there and there is a really lack of synchronization so I’m kind of like you know in my thinking trying to find those you know common denominators somehow to connect that makes people yeah.
Unidentified participant:
Thanks no that would be great thank you.
Jonah Wittkamper:
One of the global corporate philanthropies that I have been talking to has been looking for ways to help band smaller producers together so that they can qualify for you know these large purchase contracts that the Fortune 500 companies have and things like that. I’m wondering if you have seen that happening in the supply chain space. If a small holder farmer doesn’t have enough money to hire an auditing company, can they start a cooperative and join up with others in order to go through that auditing process so that they get verified?
Have you seen that happening?
Pamela den Hartog:
Yeah, actually we usually for small holders we actually advise it that they have a cooperative because then it helps them have that kind of internal management system, have that internal checks to make sure that they’re all there’s a manager supporting them and make sure that everybody can adhere to the standard etc. Like really doing that at the individual level is indeed very tough. Also costwise, but also cooperative helps them be able to market their products better, have a stronger negotiation position, all these kind of things. So I think from various points of view that’s we definitely stimulate that and make that it’s usually cooperatives that are that are the certification unit so to speak.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Yeah. I have another Brazil related question. I flora has been an active supply chain certifier. I’m wondering if the presence in a large company like Brazil of an existing supply chain certifier may be part of the reason why you guys have less market penetration to date.
Pamela den Hartog:
Not sure. I don’t I’m not that well versed into the supply chain, but as to my understanding, I think they’re actually good a good organization that we work with. So, I’m not sure how that relationship is, but I think we have some good relationships in Brazil. I my understanding is that enough is one of them. I’d have to get back to the colleagues on that.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. I see some ecoourism expertise on the line. Could you tell us a little bit about your ecoourism work.
Unidentified participant:
That would be for RA? Yeah. Right for I think as we say pre.
Unidentified participant:
Merger Rainforest Alliance historically did ecoourism work. I think that’s now been is that still online?
Unidentified participant:
Not clear on where that is. I thought that was one of our partners that was proceeding with that preferred by nature which used to be Nepcon. Okay, that may be the case.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Yeah. Do others have questions? I have a couple more sort of industry related stuff, but I’m just wondering if some people on the call who would like to introduce themselves. So one thing that we have seen an opportunity for Oh go ahead Art.
Art Krebs:
Hello Jonah. Thank you very much for your presentation. I think this is very instructive and I want to introduce myself. My name is Art Krebs. I’ve been attending as many sessions as I can. Sometimes I’m not able to but I think that in this case it kind of is closer to what we are focusing on. I did hear a lot about the Amazon and projects in Peru. We’re currently doing some development on ecoourism and also in conservation and reforestation in the Amazon in this areas around Peru. So, it’d be great to collaborate in any way that we can.
And I don’t I’m not certain if we need to get certified because we’re not necessarily producers, but more of developers trying to create that collaboration with different entities to the same goal. But I’ll be more than happy to contact you separately and talk a little further. Appreciate it.
Pamela den Hartog:
Sure. Yeah, of course. Always open to that. And I can ultimately link you to our colleagues in Peru which might make more sense for you. But yeah, more than happy to.
Unidentified participant:
That’d be great. Thank you very much.
Jonah Wittkamper:
One question I have, we have seen an opportunity to accelerate the process by which some of the Amazonian superfoods come to market. I, you know, 20 years ago, 30 years ago, few people outside of the Amazon region were familiar with acai. Now, it’s a billion-dollar industry. That’s probably going to happen with a lot of other superfoods from the region. I’m wondering if you guys either partner with or are involved in the process of R&D about individual rainforest products and helping them, you know, be import export compliant with a country where you guys come up in that process of sort of product development.
Pamela den Hartog:
Yeah, we’re happy to partner actually. So, we don’t do that ourselves, but like if there’s a market, usually the market actors know quite well like how that process works. So if they are looking for an ingredient for their products that’s specific from the rainforest or close to it they will know they will have R&D processes in place either their own R&D facilities or external partners that can do like the checking on quality and properties etc. And we’re happy to partner and provide support from the country specific and like some of the rules that are associated with the products in country and then how they can be exported and how they can go through that samples sent over etc.
So, we, play more a supporting role there. But we’re happy to, to partner with organizations that do that, especially, yeah, what comes to mind for me immediately is for some of these communities that could be, a very good source of income, right? So, but these are long trajectories that, but we’re there for a long time, so we’re happy to support them.
Jonah Wittkamper:
I have another question related to brand development. Do you believe that the Rainforest Alliance brand, the frog, do you think that it’s power is equal in its sort of B2B relationship to help large certifiers just ensure a safe supply chain, but also motivate consumers to choose, you know, one sustainable product over another. And, you know, where does that power exist and how do you push and pull it and grow it?
Pamela den Hartog:
Yeah, I think in general it’s more in the in the consumers in the consumer market, but I think B2B it obviously definitely helps because it’s usually the client asking for certification and that kind of gets cascaded down the supply chain. But I think ultimately the brand or the seal is more is more of a consumerf facing power. And we work on consumer campaigns. We also work on campaigns to put companies in the spotlight that are doing really well or that are have you know like our follow the frog campaigns in which we highlight companies that are certified with us and that and what their journey has been and like the positive impact they’re achieving.
So we definitely do that on our different channels to really promote the SEO but also the good work the organization does more broadly.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Do you guys get involved in site visits for philanthropy education?
Pamela den Hartog:
That would be a good one for Amy. Yeah, I mean I think actually I’ve only.
Amy:
Been here nine months, so I’m not entirely sure that we haven’t had them since I’ve been here and I think they’ve if we were having them they definitely tailed off with COVID. So it might be something that we bring up again once the you know the countries and communities where we most work are feeling safe and that they can entertain that.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Understood. Yeah. CO was a big disruptor. H have you guys been involved in organizing investors internationally? Do you know putting together new financial products, forestry bonds or things like that?
Unidentified participant:
Not that I know of, Paul. I don’t know if in your experience. I think we were exploring some actually, but I don’t know where that where that’s at and if that’s communicable or what the stage is. Actually,.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Part of our niche as an organization is serving as this convening point and crossplatform learning for investors and donors and corporate procurement. You guys are obviously a real special long-term partner. You guys have been going at this for decades longer than many others have active in the space. So, some of these following questions sort of come from that perspective. 10,000 donors, that’s a super impressive number. I’m wondering what fraction of your annual budget comes from the donors versus the institutional the individual donors versus the institutional donors. Do you know?
Amy:
I yes I think our institutional donors well I don’t know the fraction of the budget I can say that certification is our largest kind of revenue generator and then following that is the institutional donors with a very kind of pretty small portion of that from individual donors maybe kind of like a threeish to fiveish million for individuals versus 30 for institutions.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Okay. And are those institutions generally governments or corporations or private grant making foundations or an equal spread?
Amy:
It’s a mix. Yeah, it’s a mix. Corporate philanthropy, private foundations, bilateral, multilateral donors.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Part of the story of Nexus and the Amazon Investor Coalition has been starting first of its kind conversations about philanthropy with young people from the country’s top industrial families somewhere in the global south. I imagine that you guys play a similar role. You bring the narrative of commercializing rainforest opportunities to areas where has never existed before. I’m wondering if you guys have countries where you know you have your best success story in the previous country X had nothing in this space. You guys intervened you know now things are so sustainable.
What might those countries be? Might some of those top success stories be?
Unidentified participant:
Pamela, do you have an answer to that? Well, I always I have a Guatemala biosphere reserve in.
Pamela den Hartog:
Guatemala. So, that’s a very important both historically, right? From a community and people’s rights point of view as from a natural forest point of view. So that’s definitely one where we’ve been for a long time. So we and it’s it deforestation rates are close to zero and the communities are doing are doing very well. It’s taught us a few things. It takes a long time. You need to stick around for a long time and really have that holistic approach to that force protection both from a environmental as from a community’s perspective.
So and that’s now what we’re trying to scale to other places. I’m sure there are more examples but that one’s the one that comes to mind to me.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Was Guatemala the very first country that you guys started working with.
Pamela den Hartog:
I think so. I know that has its roots for example in Guatemala and I think Rainforest Alliance might actually as well. So that I think those connections with Guatemala go far.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Yeah. Great. Questions from others really wonderful comprehensive presentation. Anyone else? Yeah, someone was.
Amy:
Oh, Jonah, I was just it was just me. I was going to say to your question about investment products, financial products. We are actually this year undergoing a new strategic plan. Our strategic plan ended last year into this year. So I think part of that process is we’re looking at these different mechanis funding mechanisms and how we can expand beyond the certification and donor model too. So that’s on the horizon probably more at the end of this year that we could share about that.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Right before we get off I’d just love a couple of people who are important future allies to introduce themselves. Kristen Reberger would you like to introduce yourself if you’re there?
Unidentified participant:
You’re on mute. I’m here. How are you? Good. Good to see you.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great to see you. Do you just want to tell us a little bit about yourself and your work?
Unidentified participant:
I’m sorry. Could you tell us a little bit about yourself and your work?
Kristen:
Oh, sure. Dynamic planet has been working for the last decade on regenerative seascapes and landscapes and how to value ecosystems on a holistic geog geographic scale. We mostly work in the ocean space off of highly protected areas especially with national geographics pristine seas. So you know the ocean can regenerate miraculously if you leave it alone. So we work on tourism models inside the reserve, sustainable fisheries outside, carbon, and then we look at things that could erode that value. In the case of coastlines is often sewage and waste management and nutrient runoff and things like that.
So and listening hard on your nature and commodities management and always trying to look at what land models might help also influence our sea models. Maybe land scale can be adapted for.
Unidentified participant:
Ocean scale. For sure. Well, I think we can go both ways here. Yeah, for sure.
Jonah Wittkamper:
I wonder if Marcela Bashim from Tasin Paku, would you like to introduce.
Marcella:
Yourself? Sorry, Jonah. I’m with the baby here.
Unidentified participant:
Okay, no worries. Crying. Okay, so I’m moving I’m moving rooms. Sorry.
Marcella:
Hello. My name is Marcella. I am a Brazilian consultant. I work with social entrepreneur and in Amazonia I’m working with the gender and inclusion agenda and I’m working to with Mercado Liy developing small business to get in touch with the digital platform and sales. Great. Thank you for the opportunity. Sorry not to open the mic before the baby was super crying.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Okay, that brings us to the top of the hour. Thank you so much Pamela, Amy, everybody for joining us. Great conversation. I’m going to stay on after in case anyone has other questions, but.
Unidentified participant:
I think Pamela probably has to go and others. Thank you so much. Yeah, thank you very much for having us. It was our pleasure. Bye. Have a good day. Thank you. Kill him.