Restoration of the Bolivian Amazon

With experience as an investor and entrepreneur in diverse industries, Ursula Pero wants to help restore the Bolivian Amazon. To raise awareness about biodiversity, she founded a non-profit. To scale soil and forest restoration, she started a company. Biodiversity Allies aims to protect and restore plant and fungal biodiversity through community resiliency, food security, and natural resource conservation. The organization develops networks, facilitates knowledge exchange, and builds biodiversity databases. As a startup venture, Land for Good is consolidating land portfolios in Bolivia and Paraguay, transitioning soy monocultures to agroforestry, and reversing desertification across over 100,000 hectares. What would it take to fully restore the Bolivian Amazon? What is the status of land tenure in Bolivia? What mix of nitrogen-fixing plant species, mycorrhizal fungi, and fruit trees will be commercially viable? Join us to meet Ursula, learn the answers to these questions, and more. References: The Land Foundation (land tenure), PROBIOMA (environment), and CEDIB (human rights).

Recorded March 7, 2022

References:

CEDIB webinar on GMOs

Bolivian Environmental Defense League (Publisher of Habitat Magazine)

Habitat Magazine – Issue 90

Solon Foundation: Articles on Fires and deforestation

The impact of cattle ranching in Bolivia

Land Foundation: Transnational interests in the agricultural supplies market

Land Foundation: Dispossession of community lands by Bolivian agribusiness

WATCH:

  • Unidentified presenter
  • Ursula Pero
  • Andrea
  • Danielle Rappaport
  • William
  • Jacqueline
  • France
  • Martin
  • Viviana
  • Maria Duran
  • Unidentified participant

Unidentified participant:

Thank you.

Unidentified presenter:

And so, welcome everybody. This is our 78th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition and this is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing forest friendly economic development across the Amazon region of South America. And we are supported by Nexus, the global governance philanthropy network and a coalition of other organizations as well. And so this is an exciting call for us because this is the first time that we are featuring a Bolivian Amazon region focused work. So today we are featuring the work of Ursula Pero and she will be our speaker and she is the founder of Biodiversity Allies and Land for Good.

So welcome Ursula. Excited to have you.

Ursula Pero:

Thank you. Thank you. Nice to see you all. I’m going to be very fast. There’s a lot of numbers. So, please be patient with me. Thank you.

Unidentified presenter:

And no need to rush, but welcome to put your presentation on if you have the ability to share the screen and then Ursula if you don’t mind giving us a little background about who you are your story and then you can go ahead and jump into your presentation.

Ursula Pero:

Yes. My name is Ursula Pero as I she mentioned. I was born in Bolivia. I grew up in Bolivia. I did my college degree here. During my while I was growing up, I lived in three different cities. One is La Pass, another Santa Cruz, and another Coachaba. Give me a little second. There you go. Well let’s start. I’m introducing a presentation about the land use and deforestation of Bolivia. Most of the work is was made by Probioma and other foundations for the people that are aware of Bolivian situation. Bolivia is the 12th most of biodiverse countries and that is surprisingly because is also a landlock country.

On the list is the only land landlord country with the most biodiversity. Bolivia is also a very low populated we only have 11 million people. The forest cover is very large. It’s about 58 million ectares. This is the Amazon basin is you if you see Bolivia is in the core of South America and most of Bolivian territory is Amazon is probably near 50%. The forestation hit us hard the last years especially here we are here is Bolivia and if you can see here is Brazil is almost the same region about why we have the forestation in Bolivia the first reason is mechanized agriculture the second cattle rancher and the last very small scale agriculture the changes in agriculture uses you can see them here.

During the years we changed from cereals wheat to mostly soybean. Here you have most of the food we eat also has been reduced because of the focus on oil. And as you can see most people think that cocoa leaves are important part of the forestation. Actually it’s not that much. The red line on the bottom is cocoa leaves. Bolivia now is importing food. That is very sad because we are losing our food sovereignty. As you can see the changes are huge. Here you have a chart for all the years and total imports has been increasing yearby year.

We now are importing more than $800 million in food. Now who are the soy who are who are the players of soy ago business? The biggest with the big properties mostly are Brazilian, Japanese, u Amish, menitan is Amish and Bolivians is just one/ird with the small scale agriculture it’s almost the same on nationals Bolivians is just one/ird and then Amish is the other two3. We used to have a conventional seeds for soybean GMO seed started 2005 as you can see we used to have 80% or more of conventional seed and now we have almost nothing.

It’s very little what we have of everything is GMO soy. In contrast you can see the performance per ectar on the bottom. It hasn’t changed that much. Before I mentioned that GMO soybean has been introduced on 2004 2005. If you can see we even had a better performance year with the conventional soybean. What has changed is the import of agrochemicals per ectar. And it’s it increased exponentially during the years. So now Bolivia has copy exactly what’s happening with Argentina and Brazil. Mostly is GM GMO seeds. Big trucks, chemicals. We depend on the Chicago trade for the for the prices.

Is exactly the copy. What are the impacts of agri business in Bolivia? Besides pollution, water pollution and the rest, the most important is the forestation. This is a picture of 1975 the lowlands and then you can see how it increased during the years. This is the last ones and the last picture on your right is how is now. We don’t even have wine breaks. It’s just completely chopped forest just soybean. Is what some Argentinas called green deserts. So every year the deforestation has been increasing espec es especially for the for the soil there’s not enough data lately the last one was 6 million etories u for 2010 only in one year this is also a picture of soil erosion and degradation you can see all the upper level and this level is the Amazon we have a lot of deforestation also fires and also a lot of concessions in the forestry.

Now the problem in Bolivia is mostly illegal deforestation and that happened 3 million were deforested illegally from 1996 to 2009. After that the government gave a peronaso that’s what is called in Spanish. So they legalize all the forest the deforestation. Approximately 81% of the forestation is caused by the soy industry and cattle grazing. These are two of the indigenous territories. One is in north of the Amazon. These are the tribes. What they requested is in two thou 2 million eto and what they got is 1 million eto. You can see that there is only 9,000 people living in one near 2 million eto.

Then this is the Amazon south. It’s similar. They received 1,500 acres titled and there’s only 17 people living there. Now why Bolivia needs a change in this soybean agri business agriculture? First of all environmental impact that’s impacting not only us it’s impacting all the world. It lower unemployment rates. Now we don’t have because of everything is mechanized. People from the from the country are leaving to go to the urban cities. As you saw before we have less food. So soybean has not contributed to the soy security and also it is contributing agri business is contributing to the global greenhouse gas emissions.

Now what we propose with land for good is to restore the longlands what you saw to restore that with agroforestry and agroecology. Why both? Because only agroforestry could be tempting to do the same as before and do monocultures. That is what we witnessed with asai with pome oil and everything else. We need to have a mixed system that also contributes o to the people you know socially and also to the environment. Now what we need is investors that look in the medium-term and the long term. What we have now is a very shortterm site of investments.

Brazilians usually, Brazilians and Argentinas that are in Bolivia, sometimes they just rent the land for one, one season and then, they move to another place. And that’s what is going on. That’s why the u deforestation is increasing because the lands be become tired. You have some type of they don’t produce as much. Now why Bolivia? Bolivia is the last country in South America with affordable land. Prices for right now from $300 you can maybe 10,000. It depends on where the land is located. There’s a lot of investment especially in cattle ranching and other places that’s why the price increases u there is a lot of land available compared to United States or even Europe it’s very hard to find land here there is a lot of land available you can go to any real estate company and you will find u lot of lots of land there is at least what the information I received is at least 1 million etos but very easily you can increase that to 6 million ectors.

The low the labor is still low. We’re talking about maybe two 230 $250 a month. That’s a minimum wage. There is a lot of water availability. The area of the Amazon is huge. The aquifers are very low. Sometimes 60 m meters, 100 meters, you find water. Besides the rain obviously, the taxes for agriculture are low compared to other countries. And then if the focus with the with the land is to produce super foods that is a mix of tropical fruits, there is not any problem with the there’s no restriction to export.

Bolivia does have restrictions to ex exports in terms of sugar sometimes rice corn so there are some restrictions of some commodities. Now, land portfolios, I’m thinking about a minimum of 100,000 etories. That is mostly for to scale. And, the land I saw it’s 3,000 or more. Some properties are even 12,000 or more ectares. All the properties I saw I are in Santa Cruz and Benny. I only search for those areas. The land I’m talking about is just agri business. The kind of property you saw before. There’s no forest. It’s already developed.

So we are not touching at all indigenous or community land. I already built a team with environmental non forprofits working in Bolivia. One of them is one of it is a probioma. And I’ve been working with data and other information. It’s important to have a real estate brokers and intermediaries because the you have to be very careful with land ownership and titles. So you need someone to review everything. We need or I’m planning that all the produce could be has to be organic certified. So we have organic certified consultants. We have food processing.

I’m not going only my idea is not just producing you also need the to process the food but added value to the food and also I have environmental consulting companies some agroforestry professionals ag organic producers and also obviously fundraising consultants post acquisition ition. The first stage is the acquisition, postacquisition. We will do a climate assessment with all the team I mentioned soil assessment and obviously we have to evaluate case by case depending on the soil test and climate assessment what plants will go there. It is it was the rainforest. So it could be u anything that similar to what was before palms big trees etc.

Now we have to look the demand there’s a lot of demand you only have to go to Amazon.com and other eBay and search for the demand and there’s demand for everything. There’s demand for acerola. There’s demand for acai, papaya, banana. There’s a lot of fruits that are in high demand. And surprisingly, there’s a lot of demand of medicinal plants and trees. You can find cats glow. You can find a lot of tropical and Amazonian medicinal plants in United States. So the final products I’m thinking it’s a fruit power dry fruit let fruit extract tinctures oils that could be harvested from the from the new companies.

Now the planning of the products it has to be but what’s the best we have to look for niche markets. There is a lot of competition especially Thailand and all those tropical countries so that the that planet has to be very careful also Bolivia is a langlo country so we have to consider the transportation costs and as I mentioned part an important part of the project is to have ba basic processing produce some plans of freeze drying, cold press and that kind of stuff. The planning is a five to 10 year plan with obviously you have diverse crops.

Some of the products I’ve seen that we can produce medicinal plants, some powders that are now on demand. What is the key to success is the transformation of the output. It’s impossible to think about selling the produce as it is. Bolivia is very small as I mentioned is just 11 million people. We are not able to consume everything. So we need to add value and export. I suggest mimicking to grow and mimic the agro business model. The soy model provides everything from start to finish. They give money to the farms at the beginning for seeds and everything.

They provide a seos and then also process and export. I’m thinking a mini agri business model but for agroforestry we have to think on the consu final consumer what they want and what they want is not rare. They want products without pesticides and superfoods. That’s what the consumer wants and we have to reduce the risk with diver diversification and actually that’s exactly what agroforestry gives us we need to have in one property different trees different crops and the same is the is our market. The plan obviously depends on the demand and what we can we can do in the in the properties.

Some crops are stational just three months. It could be peanut it could be even soybean is if it’s organic and the goal is to do intercropping. So now well I finished. I would love suggestions maybe fundraising ideas possible partners and well thank you.

Unidentified presenter:

Thank you. So if you have specific questions for Ursula, please put it in the chat or raise your hand. Ursula, I got a couple of questions for you and then we’ll open it up to the audience. So I do want to dive into Land for Good and what you’re working on. I would love to know a little bit about the background of what got you there. So how did you end up here at this point and what was a little bit of your background?

Ursula Pero:

Yes. Well my background is mostly in business but my family had a had a farm 10,00 farm. We used to have all that thing soybean and the rest. So I know how it is how the system works. I was working mostly in finance but environment was always in my soul. So what I did I did a master’s degree in non forprofit and then I haven’t finished but I started a master’s degree in agricology. So, what I really like to do is do something, for what’s happening, with the planet. That’s my in my core.

Unidentified presenter:

And, and so, you’re also involved in Biodiversity Allies. Is there is that tied to what you’re doing with the work for land for good or what’s the connection there?

Ursula Pero:

Yes. Biodiversity Allies is a nonprofit I started that in New York. It’s a New York non forprofit. The goal of the nonforprofit mission is to preserve plants and funer is related. Our first goal is to build an allies and an ally could be a small farmer that preserves 150 v varieties of tomato. It could be a drive taking care of 50 medicinal plants. So what we are doing is building the network and after we build the network allow the communication within between members of the network. We’re will our goal with biodiversity is to allow the allies to exchange seeds to exchange knowledge because that’s what we need.

We need to continue doing what the human beings have been doing forever. That is changing their best plans and obviously that’s what we’ve been doing. That’s our goal. So if someone knows an ally that could be part of the network, please I would love to know it.

Unidentified presenter:

So then the major part in terms of the development for land for good right now is building up the team and building up the network. You mentioned you had a couple of nonprofits that you were working with in land for good. Where are you in terms of the current status for the project?

Ursula Pero:

We started six months ago. It’s very recent. What I did with was leverage what was happening with the land how much land is available knowing if the owners now are willing to sell it and they are willing to sell it. That is rare because usually in other parts of the world they are it’s very hard to find land. So that’s good news for the project. So now I built a small team of people especially with realtors and also some agroforestry professionals and also did some research regarding what are we going to how are we going to export the goods and some products that we could start producing after the first stage.

Unidentified presenter:

Okay. And you mentioned Santa Cruz and Bise as one of the areas to start with first. Is that because of demand of owners wanting to sell? How are you sourcing the owners that you’re.

Ursula Pero:

Santa Cruz is the most deforested department in Bolivia. That’s what I picked Santa Cruz. It’s very sad. Benny they are starting to the foresa benny not really it’s not as bad as Santa Cruz. So the goal of the project is restoration and reforestation. The second goal is obviously get a profit with the products that are going to be produced. But the first goal is reforestation and restoration.

Unidentified presenter:

And how are you sourcing the owners?

Ursula Pero:

The owners. Believe me, there’s a lot. I grew up here, so I have a lot of friends of friends. I already contacted realtors. We have Century 21 here. We have a big companies very organized. So there is plenty of land and there’s plenty of sellers.

Unidentified presenter:

And so how are then are you evaluating the products? So there’s a couple of different avenues that you mentioned in terms of areas of superfoods and trees. How are you evaluating which ones work for the land?

Ursula Pero:

That will be done in a second stage. But in general in general we have it was a rainforest all this area. It’s tropical land. And whatever you imagine obviously we do have the native plants here for example kusi is one palm then you have other plants as well but we can use moringa for example we can use papaya is not native from here but you can do papaya you can do acerola you can do and it has to be a mix but you have to think about also the demand because otherwise we won’t have success if we want to build just you have to sell you have to sell you have to emulate what is happening now.

Unidentified presenter:

Yeah. So then with that being said is it possible to be able to do this with indigenous land if how do you work with indigenous communities if that’s the case?

Ursula Pero:

Indigenous communities are very hard very hard to work with them in terms of a project like this one indigenous communities first of all you need to map the area unfortunately we don’t have the areas of the TCOS mapped yet I’m saying like how many how part is the first step how part is as far what part you need to have a an assessment of the land and also the soil. Some of the it’s very politicized some of the organization some of the tribes so it’s very hard to reach them and also because of past problems they dustrust they don’t trust especially an outsiders so you have to be very careful I think that with the with the indigenous communities is better to work with non forprofits and help them first know what they are what they want, what are they needs and then maybe in a small scale work with some parts that they might have deforested, they might have some fires or and then you can work a project like this but in general it’s very difficult.

Unidentified presenter:

Sure. So that makes sense. So, do you see partnering with nonprofit that are working with them? Is that one of the goals as well?

Ursula Pero:

That would be great. You know, I could be the link even with the not for profofit in New York to help the tribes. As I mentioned, we need to assess the land. Some part has issues. They have they have issues all the time. They have illegal loggers come coming to their territories. So they need an assessment. If we can help them perform an assessment and then even some training to care for the forest. There is a project that an a foundation in La Pass has to control with GPS but it’s a they are just writing the grants and everything else.

Unidentified presenter:

Got it. And so thank you and I’m going to open up to the rest of the audience if you guys have questions. Andrea, I see a question from you. How is the indigenous land titling in Bolivia? And if you want to just answer that andre if you have another question go ahead.

Ursula Pero:

Yeah, they indigenous communities they own the land. There’s like two types of title. One that allows them they cannot sell the land that I cannot get a loan with the land. They can just occupy and harvest the products. They might have the but they don’t have the tractors, they don’t have anything. So they cannot use the land in any mechanized way. But it’s most mostly because of lack of funds.

Andrea:

Thank you. I was wondering if the if the indigenous community they have more most of the land is titled to them if it is the case if there is any gap in conserv in conserve those lands or if they need titling of some areas more like this.

Ursula Pero:

It’s the tail is very recent and if you see well I’m going to share the PowerPoint. The area they requested is almost double and what they received is like half the land and obviously the land that is they stolen from them. That’s the that’s the reality was given to other people especially agri business or maybe communities other communities that are not natives. So what they need is help to preserve their land. They want to do it but they don’t have the resources. They don’t have the knowledge. They don’t have the resources.

They don’t have most of them they don’t even have cars. So how can they do it? It’s impossible. So that’s the help they need to help. I don’t think there’s as bad as what’s happening in Brazil. But here they don’t have the resources to protect their land.

Andrea:

And just another last question. As soon as this area is like tightly to the indigenous communities, they it can be any exploitation in the area like such as mining. It’s or not?

Ursula Pero:

Unfortunately, yes. There are some not in the Amazon north or south but I’ve seen other TCOs that they have let’s say that the land given is 200,000 hectares but 10,000 eto is for an oil company or maybe 5,000 it’s for mining that’s happening.

Andrea:

So the subsurface is still it’s in the hands of the state the subsurface.

Ursula Pero:

In some way. Obviously, if they could have a legal aid, an attorney or someone some envir environment groups that could help them test the water and everything else, you could have some kind of control on the territory, but not now.

Unidentified presenter:

Okay. Thank you. And I’m just going to invite the next person. If you have a question, you can unmute yourself. Just introduce yourself quickly and go ahead and ask your question.

Danielle Rappaport:

I’m next. Hi Ursula, Danielle Raport here. I’m with the Amazon Investor Coalition. Hearing your story completely charged me up. Thank you. So your knowledge and your vision is really inspiring and spoton. I my question is have you had any conversations with buyers to set up long-term purchase contracts that can help of catalyze this transition that you’re kind of setting out for us here.

Ursula Pero:

Like yeah I had informal conversations and what I realized because I used to sell gold in New York so that was my job for seven years. I used to be a precious metal dealer, completely different of what I’m doing now. The type of investor that could be attracted to this project, it has to be a medium or large. Small investors get frightened about the news with Bolivia. They don’t have space or maneuver or enough money to lose. They are afraid. If you see the data a lot of for most of the land is in hands of foreigners.

So there’s not a real problem here in terms of investments or issues. But obviously we have a bad reputation in the world. That’s the reality. We have to see the reality. But in terms of environment if you find an investor that is looking in a win-win term in terms of environment that is the key investor someone that’s what I the minimum I think that h it’s 100,000 ectares because you know you don’t it’s not just land you just implemented a system is the land and you also have the little factories that accompany the land and the exportation it we are emulating exactly agri business but for good that’s what the project is land for good.

Danielle Rappaport:

I just have one follow- on question thank you Ursula how does fire and what’s happening what we’re seeing because of climate this combined force of climate change and deforestation how is that affecting your forecast for this agroecology project and the risk involved.

Ursula Pero:

Yes, I was here last year. I arrived last year to Bolivia. Fire in Bolivia is mostly provoked. It’s not like you what you see in California. It’s different. It’s very humid. All Santa Cruz and Benny is very humid. So when you saw the 2010 we had huge fires we also had huge fires to 2018 every most of that is provoked and the reason is because they want that land it’s fiscal land that people set fire and then the government legalize the fires given that land. So that’s what happened. I think that it we need to have some pressure also from organizations for investors to the government to stop this because we need to stop the firstation stop the fiscal land it must be respected we don’t have that issue with indigenous land not that much but with fiscal land yes.

Unidentified presenter:

All right William, you’re next. Reintroduce yourself quickly.

William:

Hi, Ursula. Thank you very much. I’m William Lana from a small impact investing portfolio that’s attached to the Full Circle Foundation. Really love the idea of taking some degraded land and using agroforestry to breathe life into it. I’m based in Tottess in the UK, so my neighbor is Martin Crawford, so agroforestry just runs through this town. So that’s really good to hear and really exciting. I love the proposal will have a third party element. So you’re talking about organics for example. So it’s not just you saying look I’m doing these wonderful products and very low impact and increasing biodiversity but there’s also someone else saying that as well.

And I think consumers increasingly they’ve got to be careful with greenwashing and so they really like to see that third party in inspection. So thanks and nice to see that included. I guess what I’m interested in is the time scales that you expect because to take degraded land and of course there are different levels of degradation but it’s got to be in pretty bad shape looking at those pictures and to produce some you know fantastic superfruit crops using agroforestry it might take 10 to 15 years. So I’m wondering how you how you what your thinking is around that and excited to hear a much better answer than 10 to 15 years.

Thank you.

Ursula Pero:

Yes. Well, you have short-term crops. It could be peanuts. It could be even organic or conventional soybean. And then the trees obviously you have you need three years or more maybe papaya less. I’m also a gardener. I garden myself and I gu I used to have a small property here is Pylon is called the area very close to that plot that I saw you last it was surprisingly in eight years in only 10 20 eto we had more than 4,000 trees moringa papaya then you have passion fruit. Passion fruit is very shortterm crop.

And obviously that’s the that’s what you need the assessment. It depends on the property because some you have some parts that are inundated, some parts that are higher. Then you the higher parts that you need a drier land you will plant pahaya. Then there’s a lot of there’s a variety you can have there. Aceterola you can start producing the third year. It’s very and you buy nurseries have now nurseries in Bolivia have plants that are three years old that are already producing. So you can in very short I’m not going to say three years three years for probably the first harvest but then you can have peanuts it’s and also all the pulses it’s just one season and you improve the soil fertility lentils it has to be a mix.

William:

Great. Super. Thank you very much.

Unidentified presenter:

Yeah, Jacqueline, you’re up. Introduce yourself.

Jacqueline:

Hi, Ursula. How’s it going? My name is Jacqueline. I’m actually based in New York at the moment, so you’re missing glorious New York day. I’m actually one of the senior associates here at Capital for Climate. I was just really interested in what are what are the kinds of returns you’re you’re expecting you know from implementing these agroforestry projects and also how much does restoration cost per hector compared you know in the in the Bolivian Amazon compared to Brazil. I know I think I spoke to a couple of people in for restoration in the Brazilian Amazon and they were actually quoting something ridiculous like 15 to 25k per hectare reis sorry so it’s about 3 about 3,000 to about I think about 5,000 he per hectare for restoration so you know I mean it’s a pretty hefty effort especially you know when you’re looking at you know what were you looking at 10,000 hectares of restoration or so.

So I was just very interested in that. And also like in terms of like implementing a lot of these agroforestry systems, I know it’s pretty complex depending on how you know how many plants you’re actually putting in. And one of the huge barriers that many people were talking about in terms of like scale is actually the technical assistance that you need, right? So h how is that implemented in into this project as well?

Ursula Pero:

Yes, the technical assistant is accompanying the product from the start to finish ongoing. That’s why it’s important to it’s a business. That’s what the key s of success of this project is because it’s a business otherwise if we are going to rely on donations it’s not sustainable and that’s exactly what we are trying to do. Regarding the prices it depends on the on the property. As you mentioned it could cost anything from 600 1,000 per ectar to 10,000. And also that is also a key decision making at the at the beginning.

If you have a lot of properties, obviously you’re going to purchase the ones that require less investment compared to the ones that are u more in a awful state of the certifi the certification. In general terms, the land is still producing two three tons per of soybean per hectar. So it’s not bad. That’s the amazing nature we have here. We have we still have rain. We have the soil is really good. Certain parts are really compacted of the land but that it’s solved very easily. When you do the crop rotation as I mentioned pulses some I hydroxen fixation crops and then you next year you plant the trees but anyway it’s not cheap.

Let’s just think it’s it will cost at least one thousand dollars per acre at least. Yeah. Now, regarding the return on investment, the approximate amounts that in India they’ve been developing the this already they are comparing the normal crops besides agroforestry and the inputs the results from agroforestry it’s three times three times. So, it’s a good business. It’s a win-win situation for everybody.

Unidentified presenter:

And France, I know you didn’t have a question. It was a statement, but if there’s anything else you’d like to add, go ahead.

France:

Thank you. How are you going to decide which products are you going to produce? Because, there are some mixes that are better than others. So as you said it’s a it’s a matter of the market as well. I’ve been working with value chains in Colombia and I know that export exporting this type of goods they have through a very difficult process. So there’s no almost any guarantee that the produce that you have will go through will be approved. So there are a lot of things that one has to take into account.

So what are the type of products that you’ve been thinking on the first stage?

Ursula Pero:

All the products are going to be processed products powders, fruit powders, fruit leather, fruit dry fruit. That’s nowadays like a staple for the for the citizen of United States, Canada, Europe, everybody’s eating dry mango in the subway and everywhere. It’s not like before. What I noticed that in terms of like 15 or years, the citizens everywhere embraced new products very easily. When I was growing up there was no chia, there was no a lot of products that we eat normally now. Even quinoa it’s a boom. Who knew that quinoa will be selling that much.

It’s not something that we grew up but people embrace the products. If you see, it has to be a the system also besides the trees the crops that are cultivated just by the season. In Bolivia, usually we have two seasons. Sometimes you can even do three because of the nice weather. So, you can adjust very easily from one season to the other. That’s what they do. One year agro business cultivate soybean, the next the next one will be sorghum and the next one will be sunflower. So that’s what they do.

They adjust and also they plan they can in consideration the prices, what is the most attractive, what is your niche market. You have to it’s a business. You have to look for niche markets also to take advantage of the pricing. You have to you need to have a pricing strategy and also on the planting it has to be joined.

Unidentified presenter:

All right. And Martin, you’re up next and reintroduce yourself.

Martin:

Okay. Hello. I’m a geographer based in Bolivia. I have actually left Switzerland for year and a half years ago to work for the Amazon and also I have a million points to discuss with you which I will not share because it’s just too large. But let me say one thing we’re working with high intensity agroforestry systems mainly in small communities and in indigenous communities. What’s interesting that is that we have people have reached $2,500 net profit per year per hectare. So if you compare this with soybean h evidently it’s just way better and so this is a point that we should take keep in mind I think there is a availability of experiences in smallcale agriculture but we lack experiences in large farming environments so there is actually there’s a very interesting topic of scaling up and if you talk about large farming at adequate machinery which is not available, which has to be developed.

And why not think about integrated systems along the value chains that can integrate large scale producers and smallcale projects because it’s all the same. It’s in environmental terms, it’s the same the same issue. We have to rebuild land. We have to protect forests. We have to create sustainable systems that are highly productive so we don’t have to cut into the forests anymore. And this is highly questionable because I think it’s we have not been talking about government policy so far. This is completely contradictory because Bolivia has a constitution that honors mother earth and in actually in actual politics there’s large scale untitling of public lands which is a cause from for the for the forest fires and there’s a large scale reassignment of public lands to ag agro business and the goal is all seed.

So we have a very all seed friendly public policy and we are building an alternative to this. So let me finish with a question. How do you relate to these government policies that actually favor all crops and how can you create a niche for your kind of projects?

Ursula Pero:

I think the government point of view well what they want is to be able to export. That’s the their main issue. That’s why they favor agro business. The small farmer is not producing enough for exports and they need they need the export money you know. I think that if we if we develop an agri a larger scale agree business that as you mentioned will increase the income of the farmer three threefold and also we’ll be exporting other products not only soybean because it’s silly to export soybean. It’s not just it’s just a commodity.

There’s not added value. So if we do that the government will comply with and also will favor the system. I don’t think the government will try to object or oppose if it’s a private project they won’t I had conversations even with what another thing we can do is to produce seeds there’s not enough non-GMO corn seed in the world that’s why they can change we can produce non-GMO soybean. There’s at least 15 or 20 varieties that are needed everywhere because this shift is not only Bolivia. Everybody realized that we need to change the way we do a agriculture.

It’s not good for the planet and but there’s not enough seeds. So part of the project could be a producing seats. And well I would love to talk to you more about your experience and everything else.

Unidentified participant:

Coordinates.

Ursula Pero:

Yes.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. Yeah.

Unidentified presenter:

Perfect timing. We’re right at the top of the hour, but Ursula, if you have more time to hang around if anyone.

Ursula Pero:

Yes, of course.

Unidentified presenter:

Questions. This is the official hour is over, but we can hop on and take on additional questions. And Ursa, do you mind if we share your email if there’s anyone?

Ursula Pero:

Yes, please. My email, my phone.

Unidentified presenter:

We are putting the email in the chat. And then, if anyone has any questions, introduce yourself and ask away. Hi.

Unidentified participant:

Oh.

Unidentified presenter:

Oh, sorry. Go ahead. Go right ahead.

Viviana:

Thank you. Hi, Osula. My name is Vivana Ses and I’m a researcher at the University of Maryland. I’m also from Bolivia. I wanted to ask you know, one of the issues with so precisely is the fact that you need really vast amounts of land in order to produce this commodity, right? And high value crops such as the ones that you are referring to require much smaller amounts of land. And so you know how do you see the production of these goods really being in you know to what extent can they be a solution to the issue of large scale deforestation for soy production because we don’t really need such huge amounts of you know the products that you’re mentioning whereas soy is something that is in really vast great demand and so you know that this it just wondering about the distinction between the forms of production of these two different kinds of goods that you’re mentioning.

Ursula Pero:

Yeah. Viviana the what I how I see the issue and not only a Bolivian issue is the world issue is what do we want to produce? We want to produce food for humans or food for animals. That’s the key. The issue we have now with soybean in Bolivia, it’s really nonsense because the it’s different comparing Argentina and Brazil that they are not landlock countries. We have to produce the soybean in Bolivia and then transport it to the to the to the sea. Bolivian soybean is bought by Colombia, Peru and it’s just animal food.

So what the proposal here is to change and produce food for humans, not for animals. And I think the human being of the future is going to reduce the meat intake. That’s for sure because there’s it’s not healthy to eat that much meat the amount we are eating. Not healthy for ourselves, not healthy for the planet. And that’s an issue we have to touch. And if you see the statistics meat consumption is diminish diminishing. So there’s a lot of demand of food. Even if you do if you harvest non-GMO soybean, there is a high demand.

Non-GMO corn, there’s a high demand. And then you have other products as well that you just go to Whole Foods and you realize quinoa noodles, lentil noodles, there’s a lot of products. So is just, one product that unfortunately just wreck havoc in our forest. It shouldn’t be like that but it happened because of the right conditions poor government lack of policies it’s a mix of the situation because other countries look at India they produce a diverse products you just have to go to foods and see how much diverse is the Indian product products and Bolivia has an opportunity even with the native products, we have a special beans.

There’s a little white bean that probably I don’t remember it’s choo miy something like that. It’s a super special being that we can produce and that’s just an example.

Viviana:

Yes. I understand and agree that there’s definitely a lot a lot to be done in terms of switching from food production for humans versus for animals. The other the other question is related and perhaps it’s a bit outside the scope of your project but one of the of course the question is like we still have a lot of deforestation right now happening for conversion to soy and you know the idea here is to reforest some of the stuff that’s already been deforested but to what extent or I guess a broader question you know the focus on stopping deforestation that is currently happening instead of starting to focus on of course both things can be done at the same time.

It’s not a zero- sum game, but the it really seems that the focus on stopping what’s happening is really important and something we should all be working towards.

Ursula Pero:

Yes. Definitely we need to stop deforestation. And it’s I think as a well we couldn’t do anything with this government. It’s very hard. The problem is that citizens they participate very small in very small numbers. Bolivians you know what’s happening here in Bolivia. The grassroot movements we have it’s about non GMO we have like 16,000 people on it’s a yonoid transos in Bolivia we’ve been fighting the deforestation and GMO for long I’m also I also talked about GMO soybean but we have GMO everything we have corn everywhere and it’s a it’s forbidden by law.

So in some way we need to protest. That’s the only way the government bolivian government hears and we also need to control more our INRA that is the government the governmental department of that of land. We need do to do a better control citizens, you know, citizens and also non forprofits.

Unidentified presenter:

Any other questions or anything else anyone would like to share?

Unidentified participant:

I just wanted to make reference to the small comment I wrote at the very end of the our discussion. We had a similar kind of talk maybe it was a month ago or so with a company called Terara Formation and they’re obviously focused on reforestation and their main focus is actually on creating seed banks and on the exchange of seeds. So if you’re currently looking at that then you should go and reach out to him. I don’t have his first name up off the top of my head, but if somebody could bring his first name up, that would that would be great.

But anyway, it’s terraformation. I’m pretty sure it’s terraformation.com. And anyway,.

Unidentified presenter:

Yeah, we said we were going to make you.

Unidentified participant:

And then separately going back to the comment which I had made there are lots of great ways to kind of fund you know your sorts of projects and it’s very exciting actually because I mean I have a project finance background and given that you used to trade in gold it’s not the same thing but you know gold projects every Everyone uses a project finance structures to fund such projects. So given that you’re kind of trading in it, you probably do know these kind of finance structures. And so recently there was a project finance deal which came out led by Ben Pepe Pariba and it’s you know funding rubber financing rubber and so the kind of the kind of early construction phase was the kind of planting phase which you know takes a few years and you were saying some of your plants take about four years and then afterwards is the harvesting phase and then Michelang was the main offtaker.

You know. So actually it’s it was very exciting because it’s very similar to what you would want to do.

Danielle Rappaport:

Yeah. And Robert, as you mentioned, was part of the Bolivian Amazon.

Unidentified participant:

There you go.

Unidentified participant:

Yes. So you absolutely you should check out those two links because actually it’s I mean it’s exciting in the sense that it’s kind of in the relatively new asset class. Well relatively new relatively new asset class for a kind of more classic funders like Benpe and so forth. But the structure is not new. It’s a very classic project finance structure. The only difference is you have DFIs involved. But that’s not that different. I mean the World Bank and the IDB, they have been doing such project finance deals for decades. So it actually has been tried and true.

So anyway, I’m just very excited. I just wanted to tell you thank you for kind of giving me those links, Danielle, earlier.

Danielle Rappaport:

Yeah, absolutely. Ursula, do you have can you remind me what the footprint of the land that you’re trying to restore is? And do you have a deck that you can send that we can send around and about your project?

Ursula Pero:

Of course. I’m planning the first the it’s 100,000 ectares. The total land in Bolivia it’s over three u million etoies. What is already deforested? It’s huge. So if we can do maybe one portfolio 100,000 it’s one portfolio maybe we can reach in 10 years 10 portfolios that will be 1 million extra it will be very tiny part of the Amazon but I think that what the best is what we’ll do for the rest because if another farmer is looking oh my god this they are with this project they are earning three times more I’m going to do it as well.

So I’m trying to build something organically but lead by example something like that.

Unidentified participant:

Yes. The network effect.

Unidentified presenter:

Yes. Does anyone else have any last question? Last shameless plug before we let Ursula go. Someone Maria raise your hand.

Maria Duran:

Thank you. Hello everyone and I’m sorry I joined a little late through the conversation. My name is Maria Duran and I work for the Amazon Sustainable Landscape Program that is implemented by the World Bank and financed by the GF. This is a regional project that includes se seven of the eight Amazon countries and in the second phase of course we’re including Bolivia as a ally and with a national project. I it was just a quick question. Do you have do you maybe have and could share a link for the land for good work and what you are doing Ursula because I found very interesting to learn a little bit more and to maybe explore some work that we could do together since our regional project is going to work in some of the value change and bioeconomy as we said it in Latin America, it’s a very used terminology.

And see how we could work together in order to of course include not only Bolivia and the work that you’ve been doing there, but also to include the other countries that we work with right now. Of course, our counterparts within the countries are the governments, the ministers of environment. So, yeah, I would really appreciate that if you could share with.

Ursula Pero:

Sure. Sure, Maria. Thanks for telling me.

Unidentified presenter:

I Yeah, go ahead. I was just going to say, Maria, if you can add your email to the chat so she can share it with you directly.

Unidentified participant:

Great.

Ursula Pero:

Yes.

Unidentified presenter:

Go ahead, Ursula.

Ursula Pero:

Yeah. Maria, I talked with some of the majors of the indigenous towns here and they all are willing to have some project with the a bigger project of the reforestation or food produce. There’s a lot to do here because pretty much Bolivian government they are not doing anything. So there’s a there’s a very fertile area to work directly in with local majors a lot of small towns with a with a small project.

Maria Duran:

Great. Great. Thank you so much for the information.

Unidentified presenter:

Any last thoughts, Ursula? Thank you so much.

Ursula Pero:

Thank you, Naana.

Unidentified presenter:

Wonderful.

Ursula Pero:

And thank you all.

Unidentified presenter:

And I will follow up with you as well.

Ursula Pero:

Yes.

Unidentified presenter:

And hopefully see you guys on the next Monday call. And have a great rest of your day.

Ursula Pero:

Thank you. Have a great day.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you.