Responsible Artisanal Gold Mining in the Amazon
Susan Keane: There is an epidemic of artisanal gold mining in the Amazon. It pollutes the river with mercury and poisons indigenous communities. The Minimata Convention is an international treaty signed in 2013 to protect people and the environment from mercury pollution. Because of this treaty, today, planetGOLD works to make small-scale gold mining safer, cleaner, and more profitable around the world, with programs across the Amazon. Susan Keane joins us to tell the story.
Recorded October 12, 2020
WATCH:
Participants
- Susan Keane
- Unidentified speakers
Transcript
Unidentified speaker:
Hello everybody. This is the 15th call of the Amazon investor coalition. Again, this is a program of the global governance philanthropy network and a partnership platform for the UN 75 global governance forum. Uh this week we’re going to be featuring the uh amazing work of Susan Keen and Planet Gold followed by Gabriel Labate. I’m sorry Gabriel if I’m mispronouncing your name and his work from both the UN REDD program and the future UN decade on ecosystem restoration. Uh Susan I give the floor to you. Feel free to uh ask a couple of people to introduce themselves etc. but you’ve got a half hour. Go for it.
Great. Okay, thanks so much Jonah and hello everyone. Uh thanks for joining on a on a holiday for those who who are celebrating. Um I am now going to try to share my screen because I have a hopefully relatively short presentation um that you can ask questions and um we can have a little bit of a dialogue. So can everyone see that okay? Yeah. Okay, great. So um thanks again Jonah and and everyone for inviting me um to talk about the Planet Gold program. Um my name again is Susan Keen. Um my official title is senior director of global strategies in the international program of the Natural Resources Defense Council.
Some of you may be familiar with NRDC. We’re a US-based environmental group um but in this capacity I’m the global coordinator um of the Planet Gold program which is a global initiative to phase mercury out of small-scale gold mining. Um it’s funded by the Global Environment Facility which is um a collaborative entity between governments, UN agencies, development banks, and others uh to address global environmental problems for those of you not familiar with the Jeff. So, I’m just going to give you hopefully a fairly brief overview of a the purpose of the program and what we’re doing, and then hope we can have a chance to talk.
Um so, for those of you who were on the call a couple of weeks ago um and also maybe been following in the New York Times and Washington Post and a lot of you who are of course interested in the Amazon and its deforestation issues have seen these pictures. Um this is a picture of um the devastation wrought by uncontrolled illegal small-scale gold mining. Um in this particular picture, this is Peru. Um and you know, this is what happens without any controls. Um uh lots of miners come in and inefficiently work the land leaving a basically an unreclaimed wasteland uh with really devastating impacts um on the landscape.
Um but, it’s worth noting that these activities also pose really um great health and safety risks to the miners themselves. So, this isn’t just an environmental issue. Sorry? Is everyone can everyone still hear me? Yeah, that was background. I’m going to go ahead and put everyone on mute. Go ahead.
Unidentified speaker:
Okay. No problem. Um so, this is uh yeah, just to note that we think of this as a big environmental problem, which of course it is. Um but, this is uh a big risk to human health as well. Um but, what you may be less aware of is that small-scale gold mining is not unique to the Amazon. It is a global phenomenon. Um it’s practiced in at least 80 countries. Uh there are estimates of up to 20 million miners directly involved, of whom about 4 million are women and children. Um and it’s an extremely important source of livelihoods in many rural areas around the world.
But, of course, it’s also associated with these not always, but sometimes associated with negative social and environmental impacts, um including not for deforestation, of course, but also mercury pollution. And in fact, um artisanal and small-scale gold mining, you’ll see it abbreviated as ASGM, um is the largest source of mercury pollution in the world. Uh people often hear about coal-fired power plants, and those are a big source, but um small-scale gold mining uh contributes more mercury to the global atmosphere. And this map um shows the estimated tons of mercury released to the atmosphere by country. And of course, you can see uh you know, quite a lot of red in the Amazon region.
Um and in fact, um South America and mainly those Amazon countries um represent about 40% of global total mercury emissions from small-scale gold mining. I just one uh caution, these are old numbers, these are from 2012, even though it’s a 2018 report, and there are current activities um to gather newer data. Uh so these these numbers might change. But just to give you a sense of the magnitude of the problem and and the contribution that the Amazon region um plays uh in the mercury problem. So fortunately, I guess, um the international community um has recognized a threat from mercury pollution, not only from this sector, but from lots of other sources.
And so far, 124 countries have ratified the Minamata Convention on Mercury, uh which seeks to control mercury pollution uh globally from all the major sources. So coal-fired power plants, small-scale mining, uh you know, uh uses in thermometers and other products, etc. The negotiators of this convention uh recognized, uh when thinking about the small-scale mining sector, they recognized that banning mining per se, or banning mercury use in mining, um historically has not been a successful strategy, uh by different countries who have tried it. Um in the long run. There’ve been short-term gains, you know, with heavy military interventions, etc. Uh but in the very long run, what tends to happen is the mining uh activities start to creep up again as soon as your guard is down, essentially.
Um and those off or those miners just go off into other areas and um cause havoc elsewhere. So, um recognizing this, the convention really looks at it as a transition. Um there needs to be a transition over time, um with assistance, away from um mercury use and other informal activities of the sector, transforming it into a formal uh sector that contributes to livelihoods while minimizing impacts on the environment. And the convention has mechanisms for financial assistance to countries who want who want to make this transition. And that’s where we come in. Um we are the planet gold program. Um gold, the acronym, are you ready for this?
It stands for global opportunities for long-term development in the artisanal uh gold mining and small-scale gold mining sector. So, that’s a really long mouthful, but it’s really meant to remind us that the goal of the program is to realize the economic positive economic benefits of small-scale mining, which are substantial in a lot of rural areas, but while eliminating mercury use and other um ill effects of the informality of the sector, where feasible. And as I mentioned at the beginning of the discussion, the program is funded by the global environment facility. Again, if you weren’t familiar with the GEF, it was established in 1992 after Rio, um as a mechanism for governments and and UN entities, etc.
to get together and fund projects on globally important environmental issues. In this case, um this particular project is led by the UN Environment Program in partnership with the United Nations Industrial Development Organization, United Nations Development Program, and Conservation International. We’re all working together. Um and we, NRDC, are what’s called an executing agency. We’re working directly with the United Nations Environment Program as uh a collaborator to implement the program. So, the mission of the program is uh we’re working to make small-scale gold mining safer, cleaner, and more profitable. Um and for the miners themselves, which creates their incentive to stick with it. Um and the vision of our program is at the end of it, we should have a clean global supply of gold um from artisanal and small-scale gold miners.
So, right now um in the gold-colored countries, uh we are working in not we’re actively working in nine countries, but you can see um four of those uh touch on the Amazon region. So, we have Colombia, Ecuador, Peru, and Guyana currently. And we’re adding Bolivia and Suriname to that mix, uh plus a number of other countries in Asia and in Africa. Um and there is, as I mentioned, a global component uh for which I am the coordinator. And the point of the global component is to really coordinate all of those different country activities, make sure they’re sharing communicating each other with each other, sharing information, exchanging experience, etc.
So, we don’t have nine separate, you know, one-off projects all working in silos, but instead really, really try to learn from each other and create an overall movement uh to transition this sector to be a better sector. Um one notable absence from the map in the Amazon region is Brazil. Um and I all I can say about that is that um, as a government, you know, sort of oriented entity, the Jeff is country driven. It needs to be asked by the countries um, who who want assistance. Um, so absent that, there’s only not much we can do about that. Except as the global component, we can certainly share information and work across partners across all different countries.
We’re not really limited. So, as an example, currently we’re uh in conversations with the center for mineral technology or CETEM uh in Brazil, which is a sort of a quasi-governmental research institute in Brazil with a long standing history of working with the small-scale mining sector. Uh that’s planning a project on training of small-scale miners on um mercury-free techniques. So, that’s just an example of how we can have a broader reach um than just these countries noted. Um, so that’s a lot of blah blah country program talk. Very formal. What you know, what do we really want to do here? What is the our hope? And as we said in the vision, you know, the vision is really to trans- transform these kinds of scenes, the one you’re looking at right now, um, which is from our uh Guyana, one of our country projects, uh into you know, more sustainable practices.
So, that could mean on a very small scale with an artisanal miner. So, this particular photo is Americo, who is an artisanal miner from a traditional Afro-Colombian community. Um, he’s posing in front of his well-managed mercury completely mercury-free site. Uh so, that you know, we can work with those kinds of miners. Or we can we can scale up, um, and work with, you know, bigger operations that are, you know, more much more mechanized but are nonetheless still considered small-scale when compared to large-scale mining. And um, you know, that this I for those of you who aren’t familiar, you know, with the look of mining, this probably looks like a hot mess to you.
Um and it kind of is, but it it nonetheless what it really represents is a series of highly efficient uh gravity-based methods of very efficiently separating gold um from the other materials. And what you see kind of, you know, splashing out at the end, which is by the way not going into a river but going into a holding pond, um is completely chemical and mercury-free. Um uh and mer- of course mercury’s a chemical, but and other chemicals as well are not present there. So So this represents, you know, a technology that can be applied um in, you know, those kinds of sites that you were seeing uh where there’s, you know, the moonscape.
Um it’s it’s not um it’s still mining. You know, it is. Uh we’re not all, you know, enviro- as environmentalists, we’re not big fans of mining, but as the convention recognized, you know, these these mining activities have have been going on a long time. They’re going to continue. A lot of the government efforts to date haven’t really been effective at exterminating them, even in very uh sensitive areas. So the approach is, you know, here we’re really trying to make it as efficient and clean and um sustainable as we possibly can. Um and to date I’ve been talking about methods that are really uh geared toward alluvial mining, which is the kind of mining where that involves a lot of deforestation.
But in the Amazon, there’s also a lot of hard rock mining, believe it or not. Um not as much as alluvial, but it still does occur. And so we also have uh solutions that are oriented toward hard rock mining, which may not cause as much deforestation, but certainly has a bigger mercury footprint, generally speaking, than alluvial mining. So this photo shows processing a a processing site with efficient ore milling and gravity separation. Again, completely uh uh chemical-free and mercury-free and very very efficient. Um so uh you know, you can tell that so far my my talk has been really focused on these mercury-free technologies, but really that’s just one part of the planet gold picture.
Because the transition to mercury-free technology and responsible production requires a very holistic approach. Um of course, as a you know, as a child of the Minamata Convention, uh we have an ambitious mercury reduction target as our main objective. But to have uptake of mercury-free gold extraction methods, we need to remove the barriers to formal financing and create access to formal supply chains. Uh you saw some of that equipment. That that’s not uh inexpensive equipment, right? That takes some financing. But if we have formal financing and access to downstream formal markets instead of smugglers, um this will actually encourage miners to adopt these mercury-free methods and in turn improve uh their livelihoods because those methods are more efficient and give them more gold.
And then one of the key barriers, of course, to finance and to access to formal markets is the fact that these miners are operating informally and at worst illegally. And so, of course, part of our program is focused on actually formalizing these miners and making them legal and providing other kinds of formal assistance to bring them into the formal economy. So, all of these elements have to work in concert. We can’t just go and hand people mercury-free technology, uh dust off our hands, and walk away. This is um if it’s going to stick, it has to be a really holistic approach that offers um economic incentive to the miners while also uh creating a a more environmentally friendly um environment.
So, just one more example of to illustrate, you know, really practically of this holistic approach. Um, I wanted to start with this picture from um, Peru. I think this is from Madre de Dios region. And it’s a good illustration. Uh, I like this pic I don’t like this picture. I hate this picture. It’s horrible. But it’s a good I like it because it’s a good illustration of um, how the land is broken up by mining. Uh, and the reason is they have very inefficient mining techniques. So, there the miners are hopping, you know, from one pit, mine, mine, mine, dig, dig, dig, get what they can from that inefficient method, hop over to the next one, dig, dig, dig, and so on until you have these huge moonscapes.
And um, that is uh, very inefficient, very destructive. So, one solution that’s been proposed is to create these mining corridors um, that keep the mining into a more restricted given location. But for that to work, you have to have very efficient mining technology so that the miners can get all of the gold um, from a given location. That requires finance and formality, etc., etc., and so on. So, it’s all a big circle. And that’s why we really need these holistic approaches. Uh, just wanted to mention Planet Gold is uh, not only about mercury um, but and um, reducing the impacts on the environment, but of course we’re also focused on um, making sure the program participants comply with other kinds of social safeguards for responsible production, including observing human rights and rights of indigenous community, labor rights, etc.
So, all of the Planet Gold what we call Planet Gold criteria that our participants have to adhere to are also observe the typical environmental and social safeguards of any responsible mineral sourcing standard. Um, adding on Minamata requirements as well as as well as Jeff requirements. And on that note, um, you know, I did want to point out that uh, some researchers have really begun to formally study the link between transitioning informal small-scale mining to formal small-scale mining. So, this recent study uh by the University of Delaware and a group called Pact uh did that study and you can see in this summary, you know, the transition between negative impacts, which are shown in red arrows on the left, to largely positive impacts on most of the SDGs um in in the right-hand uh picture.
And just to drill down on that a little, uh there’s Yep. I’m I’m on the almost last slide. So, the um I just wanted to point out to those of you who are interested in impact investing that those SDGs can be translated into measurable impacts. Um so, good health and well-being can be measured in terms of the actual mercury exposure reductions and other improvements in the safety and health of workers in the mining uh communities. Uh of course, decent work and economic growth to improve productivity and responsible consumption and production. Uh as more and more responsible mercury uh sorry, mercury-free gold uh flows to jewelers and other downstream um buyers.
So, all those can be turned into um metrics that can be measured and can really show impacts of um finance in the sector. Visit our website planetgold.org for more details on any of this uh information. And thanks for your attention. Really appreciate the opportunity. Uh great. Uh Maite, uh please go ahead and share your question. Thank you so much for your presentation. And we all know that anyone who works in the Amazon or globally knows that that uh illegal mining and small-scale mining is something that happens everywhere. So, I appreciate the fact that you guys are having a program that is inclusive and as as you said, is dealing with a lot of issues.
But, to be honest with you, at least the reality I know best, which is Brazil, most of the illegal mining is occurring in places that actually there is no way to legalize because it’s invasion of indigenous lands. It’s invasion of other lands. So, I don’t see how you can do What I’m afraid is that by bringing techniques that improve people’s uh livelihoods, which is all very important, that diminishes the use of mercury, all this environmental impact, but in a way which is very similar to what Juliana posted, you’re stimulating an industry that is actually being very detrimental to other rights in the region. So, this is one question I had to you.
And another question I had is Is it I heard at some point ago, and I’m not familiar with gold, how traceable is gold? Can you Can you trace to its source? Uh and then my other point is that I saw that I thought it was a little bit missing in your overall systematic approach is the awareness of consumption of gold. I think most of people are unaware that the gold that they consume can be coming illegally from the Amazon and other places. Anyway, that’s just
Unidentified speaker:
Yeah. the things I wanted to. But, thank you for your work. Sure. Yeah. Um Juliana, should I go ahead and respond to that now? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So, so on your first point about indigenous peoples, yeah, for sure. And as I said in the last next to the last slide about we have environmental social safeguards. One of those is free and prior informed consent. So, we wouldn’t be working with groups that are invasive of indigenous areas. The idea is that the you know, let me be clear. We’re not certainly not supporting, you know, ongoing illegal activities. But, the point that we’re trying to recognize is that that’s not all small-scale mining.
Right? There are There are certainly lots of illegal and nefarious characters in the sector, but there’s also a lot of people who are just escaping poverty. And we’re really trying to make the distinction between those, follow the normal guidelines including F pick and others to to recognize those who are trying to do it right. Um, and so of course we’re support efforts to enforce against um invasion and and all those illegal activities. Um, so but but really at the same time um recognize that this is a as I said it’s a global sector and the notion that it’s like encouraging the development of a sector um I don’t agree with because it’s actually just recognizing the existence of a sector that’s already flourishing.
Um, and so you you know that’s that’s the reality um in in the Amazon and everywhere in the world really. So the notion is to try to focus on the good guys and support enforcement efforts against the bad guys. Um, in terms of tracing um yes there uh it it it is diff- it’s more difficult because it’s it’s a not a um discrete entity like diamonds. It can be melted down. But there are innumerable efforts globally quite quite a number um to do tracing of um responsibly produced gold and we will be engaging in some of those using blockchain and other methods. Um, but it all kind of fundamentally comes down to whether you first of all actually have clean production uh to then trace, right?
So um we’re really focusing first on making sure the production is you know again supporting those guys who are doing it right. Um, and then uh working with various technologies and methods and downstream buyers uh to develop um tracing programs. And in fact the final point about awareness I sorry I just did I just had limited time. We have a fairly substantial communications um effort um both in each country as well as as global component. Um, all kinds of different methods of media, um newspaper, video, social media, etc. efforts to really educate about the dangers of mercury and about the you know, the downsides and the dangers of this of these practices, but also emphasizing and supporting and uplifting, you know, those who are aiming and striving to do it in a much more responsible and a uh much more responsible way.
So, that’s a big component of our program. Great. Thank you. So, did anyone else have a subsequent question? Go ahead, Matt. Jonna Tolsa, I’d like Oh, go for it. Um So, yeah, thanks so much. We we recently had a great conversation, Susan and team about this. So, um yeah, I’ve been thinking a lot about the goals of the clean gold campaign. Um one I guess the the several questions and observations. One is around um the banning of mercury itself, the limit and control and enforcement and global banning of mercury production. You know, just kind of get Where are we in terms of global cooperation around that?
Um obviously, the demand for gold is driving this and the demand for gold is, you know, is something that is consumer jewelry, of course, but also the speculative market of gold. So, you know, in terms of I feel like, you know, partly what we haven’t seen enough of and maybe this is the beginning is our campaigns that target the financial um the financiers behind the gold and the consumers in the markets and using that as leverage uh to limit clandestine gold mining. But obviously, we are um you know, there are impacts like have been already mentioned, around mining and I I realize we’re not trying to, you know, we’re dealing with the facts as they are.
Uh but really looking at systemic changes, how do we mobilize markets? How do we target financiers? How do we encourage research and exposing of the illegal um mafia rings and the clandestine activities and demand more enforcement. And what The other com- components and also banning mercury at the very source of mercury production. Um you know, we’d love to hear what Okay. Susan, before you respond, just in the interest of time, Matt, can you go ahead and answer your question and then Susan, feel free to respond both simultaneously. I won’t answer my question. I’ll ask [laughter] it. Okay. Hi Hi, Susan. Um that was a a great presentation.
Um super enlightening. I was just curious on the thinking of coming at it from a conservation perspective, some of those photos are really dramatic and often I see that with mines, uh mining in general. But if if there’s a push towards more small-scale artisanal mining, is is there also a push towards maybe habitat restoration because the scale is is a little bit better? Yeah, great. Thank you. So, I’m aware of the short time. So, I’ll answer briefly. Um the banning of mercury production um is part of the Minamata Convention on Mercury. Um the pr- original production of mercury will be banned by uh it was it was within 15 years of the um agreement of the convention, which was 2017.
So, can’t Sorry, I can’t do the math that fast in my head, but you know, in the next 10 years or so, um the production is going to be completely banned. But in a way, it’s a little bit um misleading because um there’s a lot of excess mercury being stored around the world uh for a variety of reasons. There’s just because a lot of other industries have stopped using it. So, because it’s a it’s an element that can’t be destroyed, um it’s being stored in places all over the world being and being made available to small-scale miners. So, we also have to really be careful about the trade, as you said.
Um and so, that is also part of the Minamata Convention, and there are substantial efforts to study and control uh the trade of mercury, as well. Um the in terms of demand, that is a big part of our program. Um not Well, I should say the the uh creating demand for responsibly produced gold is part of our um project. We’re really trying to work with the financial community, like this one, um and uh downstream buyers of gold to really create demand for buying gold that has been produced in this particular responsible way. Um cuz otherwise, you’re not going to have um any um trouble selling your gold if you’re a small-scale miner.
Uh there’s a huge demand for gold, especially in these uncertain times. And, you know, you can either go to sell it to the guide on the street, or you can have a market at that actually is demanding a responsibly produced product. So, the more we stimulate the positive side, hopefully the more the miners will be drawn to that positive side. Um there are other people, not our particular project, but there are certainly others that we are aware of and collaborating with um in the community that are working um to try to highlight the um the drug cartels and uh the money launderers in in Africa.
You know, it’s often used to support conflict. Um maybe also in Colombia a bit now. Um so, that is also something others are working on. It’s not a big element of our program, but it’s I would say it’s an element of the overall um small-scale mining, you know, community of practice. That that’s certainly something people There’s been a lot more in the press about it. There’s a lot more projects um working on that. The final uh topic about restoring mines, the answer is yes. Someone hopefully I yes, someone just put the reference I was just going to say Cynthia in Peru is a US AID funded scientific initiative to study ways to use native plants and and enrichment of soils etc.
The scientific details of how to restore these landscapes that have been devastated by irresponsible small scale mining. So that’s a really terrific effort and there there’s others here. There’s lots of other projects being sponsored on restoration techniques as well. And yes, Jonah just put in chat shout out to Sarah Dupont who actually you know invited me to this group and is working hard also on the campaign aspects of educating downstream buyers of gold about these issues of where gold is coming from. Great. Thank you so much Susan. We will be hearing a lot more about you and the industry. I know a lot of people in this call are excited to connect and follow up more.