Philanthropy for a Low Carbon Economy of the Amazon: Climate and Society Institute
Gustavo Pinheiro: The Climate and Society Institute mobilizes resources and develops networks to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by advancing low-carbon economies, promoting policy engagement, and transforming land-use strategies towards conservation and away from deforestation. Gustavo Pinheiro joins us to share the vision.
Recorded November 23, 2020
WATCH:
Participants
- Gustavo Pinheiro
- Jonah (moderator)
- Marita
- Unidentified participants
Transcript
Gustavo Pinheiro:
Full screen, all right. So, I’ll just give a brief introduction about ICS and then I’ll I’d like to talk more about this development of this ecosystem and like well, Marcia just brought a lot of information also to the table. Fundo Vale has been a key partner and a key funder of this ecosystem early on since the inception of Fundo Vale. When was that, Marcia? 10 years ago, eight maybe? I think Fundo Vale was the first one to actually look at the Amazon as a place that could receive not only philanthropic money and international aid for conservation but also as a place where we could develop in a sustainable way empowering local communities and despite of the fact that all the challenges that a mining company has and Marcia is probably can speak a lot about it about the challenge that is to be doing it at the same time that you are in the mining company.
I think they have done a critical job to show other funders that this is possible. And if today I’m doing that thing through philanthropy there is probably a good level of showing the way that was developing in the early years of Fundo Vale. And today they are in this very interesting transition to become a venture philanthropy organization that which is also part of my vision of where we should go. So two slides on ICS. We’re a philanthropic organization established in Brazil aimed at developing prosperity, justice, low carbon development in Brazil.
We bridge international funders to local partners. We work to build evidence, promote advocacy and communication, create space of interacts, attraction and encourage knowledge exchange between Brazil and the rest of the world. We are we have five portfolios, climate policy and outreach, low carbon economy, which I lead, transportation, energy, land use and food systems, and we are also grant making for specific philanthropists who need a mechanism to do so. Most of our work is grant making, like 85% of our resources are fully donated to other implementers, mostly civil society organizations in Brazil.
We do implement a few projects when we don’t have an organization from the civil society that can do it or which is willing to do it. And we try to make our all the time the bridge between Brazil and international landscape, which you see it’s quite challenging as Brazil is historically a country that has done a very good work in isolating itself from global spaces. Despite of a few moments in history where we went the other direction like when Lula was the president or Fernando Henrique Cardoso was the president. But those are very through history those are nothing.
Those just a lapse in our history. So Brazil is two countries in many different ways. Here we highlight the Amazon, but the same could be said of most of the north northeast of Brazil. One of our major influential economists of this century called Brazil Belindia because we’re a mix of Belgium and India. The developed areas like Rio, São Paulo, the south industrialized have indicators like Belgium in terms of development indexes, GDP, and everything. But we still have this India Brazil with very low levels of development including areas of São Paulo and Rio, right?
25% of the population of Rio lives in slums. So, there is a lot of India throughout even the Belgian areas of Brazil. And this inequality is very important to understand why we have such a hard time developing in a sustainable way because a lot of Brazilians actually benefit from that. And then we have the Pan Amazon, right? This area which is majorly conserved despite of all the fires and land grabbing and illegal deforestation and cattle ranching and all illicit that happen in the area. Which is not only Brazilian, it’s important to highlight.
It’s also from Peru, from Ecuador, from Suriname, from Bolivia, Colombia, Venezuela, Guyana, French, and the Suriname. And but it’s majorly managed by the countries. There is very little transnational interactions. There is very little policy coordination. And well, Lars can talk a lot more about that as they’ve been funding I have from inception which is the ones that produce this map in partnership with MapBiomas. And this is one of the challenges like the countries all of them have the Amazon in their backyard. So it’s not where developing and most of the people are.
In Brazil it’s 60% of the territory, 12% of the population, just 8% of the GDP. So you may imagine that in Brazil when policy makers decide what to do, the Amazon is not exactly where they have most of their votes. Despite of the fact that the Amazon representatives in the house and especially in the Senate where you have only two per state are very vocal and they have managed to ensure some level of funding for public policies in the region especially in the last three decades since when that was developed the industrial zone in Manaus free trade zone now industrial zone of Manaus.
And also in the years of growth under Lula’s term when the region was growing at a Chinese speeds especially due to transfers from public funds from the national budget. So I started my journey in São Paulo. I’m from Piracicaba, the city that hosts Brazil’s largest agricultural university. I moved to São Paulo where I studied businesses business and I worked in consulting and banking before moving to São Gabriel da Cachoeira in the upper Negro River watershed frontier of Brazil, Colombia, and Venezuela in 2005. I have already left São Gabriel da Cachoeira.
Now I live in Rio. I left São Gabriel da Cachoeira in 2009-10. But since then I kept working with issues and challenge connected to the Amazon and especially development and now trying to leverage investments there. So I started my journey in São Paulo. Here you can see me with my team at ABN AMRO Bank. And this is me in the Içana River with young Brazilian and or Colombian, some of them were are born in Colombia. Baniwa and young guys studying at Baniwa traditional school, Baniwa Pripaco school which is run by their own organization and over there I was teaching them the developing proposals for projects and teaching them well, theory of change and how to develop project, how to leverage resources to solve the their communities problems both assessing philanthropic, international aid, and our public funding.
And at time I had just moved it to the Amazon. This is today’s my wife and the one that actually took me to the Amazon because she was the one working with indigenous peoples. I was the banking guy. And she developed this project with indigenous organizations and socio-environmental institute focused on developing markets for their own products. Here we are at a food fair at Wari Law, which is the house of indigenous products of the upper Negro River in San Gabriel da Cachoeira. Well, I made lots of friends in the Amazon.
Here we are having a swim at the Negro River. If you excuse me, someone is ringing my bell insistently. Just 30 seconds.
Jonah:
This is a moment for another Amazon joke.
Gustavo Pinheiro:
Hey, did you guys I’m sorry. It was just my wife that forgot her beach tennis racket, the one you just saw in the first picture. And well, Gustavo, 10 minutes. You have to blame her for the swim and I made lots of other friends. Those two are two heroes from the Amazon rainforest. Unfortunately, both of passed away already. Rubão and Margarido. But what brings us to this conversation is if you look at the news today in Brazil or in the world, those are world news. I just Googled Amazon forest. What we see?
We see a little science. We see challenges like a stupid infrastructure like BR 319 designed in the 70s cutting the forest connecting nothing to nowhere and ignoring our hydro traditional infrastructure. We have deforestation. We have the military deploying protection to the Amazon, what’s absolutely ineffective and non-cost efficient. And we have our President Biden trying to save the Amazon. And we have the gold rush that is challenging the Amazon in another cycle of destruction both in Venezuela and in Brazil both in the Tapajós where are the Munduruku Indians and also in the upper Negro River where are the Yanomami lands now with 20,000 illegal miners.
But we don’t see anything like about the Amazon businesses. Where are Amazon businesses despite of illegality? So I changed my Google search and then I found a BBC news talking about products actually coming from one of Partnership for the Amazon PPA program accelerated startups. These products come from a startups that they are accelerating. And then we come the we see the Earth Fund from oh from Amazon, right? Which is related to the forest but till now not present in the region. And then we if we go for Google Brazil then we start seeing like manioc the same startup.
It grows 60% a year since 2014. It was invested. Now there are other investors actually fighting for it. And then we have the biotechnology treasury that Embrapa the Brazilian research company for agriculture sees in the Amazon for the for the Brazilian agribusiness. Bio-inputs for agriculture already movement already 1 billion. It’s already a 1 billion reais market per year and growing fast as it reduces costs for even for soybeans but for any kind of agriculture you do today. And we can discuss that later. That’s another very interesting thing. But what I want to bring new for this conversation is and this is data from Fundacao Certi.
And they are funded by us, by Clua. I’m not sure if Fundo Vale jumped in already or not. We’re co-funding a lot of things. So we asked them to analyze what are the potentials for the Amazon. So they did an analysis by municipality and they’ll kill me if they know that I showed this map because they’re afraid of the of the political implications that the mayors might see on seeing them in red or blue. But the thing is there are four sectors that they see as low-hanging fruits for the Amazon.
Beverage and food, rubber, cosmetics, and pharmaceutical. And if I won’t show you the details, but there are like hubs which you see in blue, which are the ones with more potential. And this is directly related to infrastructure or human capital or access to markets of these places. So they have nothing against pharmaceuticals where I lived in upper Negro River. It’s just that it’s hard to develop a market and facilities there cuz it’s just so far away from the centers of well, what we call civilization despite of our lack of it.
So they are designing these journeys from a long time and they were responsible for the development of the industrialization of Santa Catarina and Florianopolis. And that’s why we went for them. And they started mapping undergraduate courses in the Amazon almost 3,000 over almost 2,000 research lines linked to conservation over 1,800 initial stage ideas for startups over 360 startups running 140 with potential to add value to the forest almost 50 on biodiversity technology on services over 50 accelerators in the Amazon I got like shocked with this number we didn’t know that 84 investors funding investing startups in the Amazon already but what is most importantly important 350 potential off-takers for business in the Amazon and this is important because that’s how we can actually leverage receipts to those entrepreneurs in the Amazon so I’m going to go fast around that and I’ll jump to the ecosystem so this is the mapped ecosystem already 1,700 organizations this is how they split around the entrepreneurship journey and now we have a challenge of how we actually make those guys to collaborate as in an ecosystem because you know in an ecosystem the plants and the animals they do develop a symbiotic relations and people and civilized organizations not as much we tend to think that competition is better than collaboration despite of the fact that many research prove otherwise.
And what we are trying to do with them is to develop the bio-economy synapse. So apply the same methodologies that they did successfully in the south of Brazil to the Amazon and for the bio-economy. So we have a five-year vision. This is like year one and I can share the slides later. Just take off the one with the municipalities. Year two, year three, year four, year five. The idea is to leverage over five years 120 million reais. That’s not much. That’s like a what in we’re like almost six to one dollar now.
So we’re talking 20 million dollars to run this. To reach 44,000 people, leverage 4,000 ideas, generate 400 startups, and have 42 of them that will reach the point when they are actually invested by private investors. And this is just the beginning. You know, we have a vision that this is too small for the potential that the region has. But that’s what they believe from their insights that it’s possible to do now at the level of human capital and funding available to the region. So what are your bold visions for the Amazon?
And I like to invite you guys to join those this vision that we are developing in partnership with other Brazilian funders so that we can add some zeros to this numbers and make this an area a region that is not seen only by deforestation and its potential but that it becomes a reality of sustainable development human development and well being for the populations that are there. Thank you very much and open for conversation but of the fact that I took most of the time talking I’m sorry.
Jonah:
Gustavo thank you so much. Does anybody have questions?
Unidentified participant:
I have a question.
Jonah:
Okay.
Unidentified participant:
Gustavo thank you so much for your presentation. One thing that I never understood very well is what are the similarities and the differences between the funding that does versus the funds of Clua? If you could just explain if there’s any relationship between the two organizations in terms of donors strategy or anything like that.
Gustavo Pinheiro:
Well each of our portfolios has its own strategy as Clua has theirs. I cannot talk about Clua. I but we develop portfolios with specific strategies we fundraise for them and we disburse those funds to reach our goals. I believe they do the same as most philanthropies. So we’re different organizations probably with different strategies. I know a lot about Clua. I’m just not going to comment on other people’s strategies right? Wouldn’t be nice.
Jonah:
Go for it Marita.
Marita:
Yeah. Gustavo do you have any particular vision for what should happen in Manaus in the free trade zone or in industrial renewal etc. How does that link up with the vision you presented on biotechnology?
Gustavo Pinheiro:
So the free trade zone due to the cap the program that directs 5% of all the receipt that companies that benefit from tax breaks due to the Brazilian technology legislation is probably the biggest largest source of funding for research development and innovation. Today we’re talking like 5 to 700 million reais a year. There are five priority programs for investments. The newest one is the bioeconomy program that was launched in 2018. It doesn’t runs it. Last year which was the first year they were fundraising for that with the companies. They raised it already 10 million reais.
Which I think is very successful for a first year of implementing a public policy in Brazil. But the potential is huge and I don’t see the free trade zone changing in political terms. It would be like a chaotic for the politicians in the north. Today we maybe considering the president of the Senate is from Amapá which is an Amazon state outside of free trade zone. I think would be easier to enlarge the free trade zone for the states that are outside of it than ending the subsidies like some in the other areas in Brazil would like to.
Marita:
Thank you.
Jonah:
Any other questions?
Unidentified participant:
I have one Gustavo which is I you asked what our vision is for scaling the bioeconomy of the Amazon and more. How can we express that? Is there Is there a platform? Should we just send you emails?
Gustavo Pinheiro:
Well, so Well, Imazon does not need funding. Actually, we are because of Bolsonaro, today we have more funding than we are actually managing to manage. We are like spending more time hiring people to help us invest our resources than we expected. And we grew like fivefold in last 2 years. But we don’t need the funding for many of the things that we are funding. We need co-funding. And we need especially to leverage private investment to the region. You know, philanthropy money is good for some things. It’s not good for everything.
And I think what Marcio is doing, what I am doing, what Humanize is doing, what many funders which have already seen that if we don’t want to be just trying to postpone the end of the forest. If we want to change the way the forest will evolve, we have to leverage private investment to the right things. Because it will always be there for illegal mining. It will always be there for illegal deforestation. It will always be there for land grabbing. That’s the history of Brazil. But it’s very hard to make investors, internationally, but also national investors, to understand that they may have to take a leap of risk.
It’s not about faith. It’s just about being able to take this leap of risk. But that they will do, very riskier investments in a very risky region, but it will be legal and will be aligned to their values. And if they do so, they’ll probably, prosper and they’ll help the region prosper, too. And you’ll change the history of this region. At least the last 500 years history, because before it was Eden. But, it will decolonize the country. And if you’re in the wrong side of the history today, you might be bad for you.
But if you want to be in the right side of history, it’s probably the best investment you can do.
Jonah:
Great. Great visionary statement. Okay. We are now at the past the top of the hour. I want to say thank you to all of the presenters. And I usually don’t need to go to another call immediately, but I do today. I’m going to leave the chat room open. In the whole session open in case you guys all want to connect with each other. But signing off from me personally, thank you to everybody who joined. Thank you presenters. Extraordinary process of learning. And, feel free to continue the conversation. Thank you, everybody.
Unidentified participants — closing remarks:
Bye-bye. Thank you. Thanks so much. Thank you so much. Bye-bye. Thank you so much. Thank you, everyone. Mhm.