New Technology and Market Access for the Amazon

Keith Agoada: Today, we see technology connecting smallholder farmers and global markets. While some Amazonian producers struggle to access markets, Producers Market provides a technology solution. Bringing efficiency to the $4.3 trillion agriculture industry, the company connects buyers and producers, provides sustainability verification processes, develops “smart value chains,” and incorporates new storytelling technologies to help branding and marketing. The company founder, Keith Agoada, joins us to tell the story.

Recorded December 21, 2020

References:

Producers Trust

WATCH:

  • Keith Agoada
  • Unidentified speakers

Unidentified speaker:

Hello everybody. Welcome to the 27th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing force friendly economic development across the Amazon region. It’s a program of the global governance philanthropy network. This week we are featuring Keith Auada and his work on producers market and we’re going to do uh most of his um session as a presentation followed by lots of questions. So Keith, the floor is yours.

Unidentified speaker:

Great. Hi everyone. My name is Keith. I’m uh co-founder and CEO of Producers Market and uh we’re a company that’s based mostly between Europe uh actually Boulder we have some teammates there in California as well as Latin America and Panama and uh basically we’re a marketing technology platform and we are here to uh empower integrity and supply chains and specifically work to uh bring greater equity and value back to farmers and producers. And I felt the best way to kind of share with you all what we’re doing and some of our ideas for how we can apply our platform and technologies to um the Amazon is to to show you our technologies, how it’s functioning, and share some of our ideas.

So, I’m going to share my screen and um try to walk you through the different aspects of our platform, who we are and what we do. and from there uh can take questions and share ideas and brainstorm together. And actually what I’m going to do is open up our parent company site as it will I think be a good way to give you a quick overview and then I’ll jump into the different aspects of our platform. So um you know we have essentially four aspects to our efforts. Uh and it’s about again creating this vertical value chain model where products and stories and producers and their content can reach across value chains uh through businesses and brands reaching and consumers.

And our uh producers market is a uh B2B marketplace where we share the profiles of producers and their stories to connect with downstream businesses both regionally and internationally. A story bird is a application we created that allows for our producers, our downstream brands and retailers to add a QR code or e-commerce embed to the actual products so that the end consumers can engage with the traceability, transparency, uh impact metrics and other features of their actual products and consumption. Uh producers stories is where we take the storytelling, the content, the media uh and and also create original content around our producers and and different topics that are important to us and share across our blog and our community on uh our different Instagram handles and producers link is our development uh uh consulting tech enable consulting arm where we work with governments uh multinational nonprofits to actually develop these digitized ecosystems where we can connect directly agricultural producers and their you know added value stakeholders to uh different buyers at different scales.

So quickly with producers market uh it functions as a discovery or or marketing driven marketplace where our goal is to shift the industry from this concept of spot buys where buyers are constantly looking for a one-time buy at the lowest possible price to then add their value and um sell high and make their margins off of these kind of one-time purchasing arrangements. And we want to move into partnership supply chain models where buyers actually get to know their producers, connect directly with the um the farmers, the cooperatives, the collectives, the groups that are processing and packing and be able to form these direct partnership uh programs where it returns greater uh consistency uh and trust to the producers to know where their buyers are.

And ultimately for the buyers, they can share a story because if it’s one-time purchasing, it’s going through brokers and wholesalers and traders, it becomes really difficult, if not impossible, for a brand, a retailer, you know, to be able to actually share their story of their supply chain partnerships. And the idea here is we’re we’re, you know, we’re we’re thriving off of this we call the purpose economy that there’s consumers out there. We’ve seen studies 80 to 90% in in European US market that want to buy products from brands that are doing good. They want transparency. They want to know the impact of their purchasing. And so we want to make it much easier for these brands to connect in with different producers uh so that they can actually share these stories and share their products across value chains.

So, you know, what we do is we connect in with our producer networks and we’re working a lot through government organizations like the proxport groups. Uh we have a partnership with uh EKA based in Costa Rica that’s very strong across the Americas and working to um identify producer groups that have great stories that oftentimes are not going direct to market. they’re relying uh currently on intermediaries to get to market. And so what we do is we work with them to create profiles and uh basically through a 30 45 minute registration process they can have a a place on the internet that helps share their story in a very uh well-designed streamlined and professional way to connect with both regional and international buyers.

And any leads that come through us through this page goes directly to the producer. And uh in certain circumstances, we actually partner with the producers to become a sales representative. But that’s an added value offering of our of our team. But most of our producers are here to create a profile really identifying what their supply chain roles are. you know, their website, their social media, having the uh photos um and storytelling information, video, and then sharing their products where they can actually create a a product page. And when we look at certain products like coffee is one where we’ve been spending more energy and again we can look at groups that are either the cooperative or packer processor and this becomes a a data entry point of qualitative information where we capture in our system all the storytelling information.

What’s their role in their supply chain? What certifications they have and again sharing their story in this scalable format. So these are our profiles. It’s really the uh marketing and storytelling entry point for producers and any producer of any skill can register and our team will do a basic due diligence to make sure that you know the producer is in fact legitimate and the storytelling the certification information is is there. And you know our sweet spot is more on cooperatives, associations, aggregators, you know, groups that have the opportunity to sell to scale. We do impact and work with small farmers of one hector, one acre, maybe do or don’t have a cell phone, but we interact with them through these uh aggregator groups who are already organized.

So, so our focus on market linkage comes in at the one step removed from the small shareholder farmer level and specifically for what we are looking to do for the Amazon is we want to create what we call an umbrella organization page. This is a new feature we’re launching in in January. And basically uh I’m going to show you an example of what we’re doing in South India and Andra Pradesh in a community of 50,000 uh registered farmers into 23 different uh cooperatives. We’re working with them to onboard all these individual profiles of the 23 cooperatives and even from those 23 cooperatives into individual farmers and be able to build their profiles uh into our overall global marketplace.

But then create an aggregated page so that regional stakeholders who are buyers or government or uh corporate buyers who want to reach a certain scale but can’t go to the individual level. They can come in and interact and actually see all of the products and all of the producers who are available across this organizational group and be able to individually learn about the specific producers but be able to interact at a scalable level through one point of sale, one point of contact. And so one thing we’ve discussed with Jonah um is creating a Amazon sustainable sourcing umbrella page where we can register profiles for all the different groups in our network in your all’s network in other government networks of you know verified producer organizations and create a home where we can aggregate their profiles and and whether they’re corporate buyers or regional buyers as mentioned they can come into this one umbrella page and see all the options, all the resources, all the groups who are there and are able to uh provide sourcing or who they can contact and get in touch with in order to uh provide support to these farmers.

So this is something that um we were going to do in kind. This is a um proposal that will be of no cost to to any of the stakeholders here but would be a a service to start aggregating and organizing you know producers of the region so that we can start mapping and start doing more direct interaction with buyers who want to engage in the Amazon as a as a sustainable sourcing uh partner but don’t yet understand like who are all the producers, where are they located, what are they growing, what scale are they at? What do they need? And we can start to um aggregate, you know, the stakeholders on the production side, on the added value processing and packing side, on the association and nonprofit side, uh and provide them all with profiles and then aggregate them into this type of umbrella organization page.

So um in terms of producers market um this is the main functionality and we are in the process of building out uh our uh proof of production application which starts to get into actually registering the contracts transactions third party logistics financial services into an application that our aggregators can use to actually engage in their transactions and fulfilling orders. But for now, our platform is more about directory connection. So, facilitating the leads and in some cases sales between buyers and sellers. But we uh are hoping for Q3 uh Q4 of 2021, we’ll actually be able to facilitate the the uh contracts transactions and do so on a a blockchain integrated system.

So um maybe just for the sake of getting through the the whole concept and then we can move into questions, I’ll I’ll go into our our storyboard in media and then from there we can just spend the last 30 minutes or so in questions. So um what I’ll show you now is our producers stories which is our content site. So what we realized is that our producers have amazing stories. Our contributors from our team through thirdparty partners are creating amazing content around producers and sharing the obstacles, the challenges, the solutions and just the stories in general of our producers and what they’re doing to uh achieve more direct supply chains for sharing recipes and sharing technology.

So we created producer stories as an organic way to bring more visibility to certain issues and our producers and uh their products. And so this is producers stories and we have a content team uh based mostly in Panama and a few freelancers in other parts of the world that work for us full-time to create original content uh in sharing the stories of our producers and products. And um we connect this in with our Instagram handles which we have about 12 what we call ultra premium handles. Uh this is the handle for the word organic. We also have healthy and vegans and fruit, veggies, seeds, uh, and and others where we basically take the content of our producers and the content from producers stories and shared across our, uh, network and also bring greater visibility to our producer members by linking our posts back to their accounts to help grow this community and awareness.

On the consumer side, what we learned is that there’s a real power in building this community and the click-throughs that can happen to websites and um to other accounts through social media. So, we have focused a lot of energy as well on you know creating and building this community and um in 2021 we’ll actually begin advertising and begin working with influencers. So as of now on these you know these 12 accounts it’s just been um understanding the formulas the content systems and now we’ll be working towards actually scaling up these communities and using these as uh as sources for our producers to connect in with um communities around the world and and just promoting their accounts and the growth of their systems.

So that’s basically our content. And finally is a storyboard and storyboard is a tool that allows the downstream brands or actually the producers if they have their own brand to be able to uh share their story, their traceability, their transparency, you know, what makes them unique uh as a QR code or e-commerce embed. And so by adding a QR code to a a package product or to an e-commerce, we’re able to basically go out and share the story in a digital application format that can be embedded through our site or through actually the brand’s site directly and be able to share different claims or values that the producer engages in, different certifications that they have with an explanation about those certifications.

uh information about the ingredients and then actually you know for this example it’s a cooperative in uh Peru that works with a distributor called Ferrasa that they’re now connecting this with a retailer in Holland called UDA and basically we’re able to show to the consumer through a QR code at the point of sale all the different steps of the uh the value chain the movement from the source to where it’s process packed the test results um the information about shift uh shipping, where it gets imported, when it gets imported, and how it then gets transported to the final point of sale. And we’ve built this out as a scalable tool that also can have multiple ingredients.

So, if we’re talking about like a chocolate product that has four or five ingredients, this is an essential oil example. we could actually show across multiple ingredients um how it gets from source uh all the way to consumer uh across multiple ingredient categories within one product. And so this is um you know we call it our beta version of storyboard but we’re going to be adding more and more features for uh interaction for engagement for you know seeing what the the carbon or sustainable impact metrics are of products that we’re going to capture through our platform through thirdparty uh technologies that our producer groups are using and be able to create this seamless data layer where the you know impact act information as well as the product information and the traceability transparency information uh can be made available so consumers can make decisions based upon more information being available and and finally just an example of how we’re integrating this to e-commerce.

This is a sustainable seafood platform that we we launched our pilot test on for e-commerce embed where actually you can come in and through the e-commerce directly see the journey of products and see how it traveled from the source to um the consumers or or through the distributor to the consumers um you know uh digitally and then we’ve integrated with Vchain in this example where different data points are uploaded across the journey to, you know, help provide greater transparency as to who the producers are, uh, where the information is coming from and how it how a product moves across a value chain. And we’re finding this to be incredibly important in uh, products that either have a high level of fraud or have consumers very concerned with, you know, uh, the legitimacy of the product origin.

And so we’ve basically spent the last four years with these products, first producers market, now into storyboard in figuring out how to build this, how to integrate different data sources into one kind of seamless layer and then how to scale it at the lowest possible cost so that we can get this technology out there um to the um consumers, to the brands where it can be actually adapted and scaled And so we our model is to um facilitate a lot of transactions at the lowest possible cost by cutting out uh as many intermediaries as possible and creating as much transparency as possible back to the uh consumers.

And so uh in in summary uh we’re really excited to move into 2021 where we actually get to scale and and start transacting on our platform and we see um our partnerships with EKA our partnerships with uh certain governments in the Caribbean and and especially in in the uh Amazon region. Uh we’re starting some work in Surinam and Gana. We are looking at uh Colombia and Ecuador and Brazil as additional scale up targets and you know we’re working closely with the green climate fund and um as well the subnational climate fund that’s led by uh Craig Kogat who hopefully will be on a call here in the coming weeks where we can create that added value model of commercialization where we can facilitate these agroforestry diverse diversified growing mechanisms and build in markets, build in traceability, build in transparency.

um understand the needs for added value processing and leveraging our platform, connecting the buyers, connecting the data, connecting the impact metrics that occur at each step of these value chains to the finance earers and leveraging the the credibility of leading brands of the you know Fortune 500 food brands and other leading distributors and uh brands of um you know furniture in addition to just the food products and medicinal products and leveraging that to create lower interest uh project finance for equity and debt to support really a major scale up of infrastructure development to post-h harvest and connecting these in with markets transparently. So that is in a nutshell who we are and what we’re doing.

Uh we’re still a relatively small team. We’re about 33 people, but we are are looking for a lot of growth this coming year and hope that we can really leverage what we’ve built to come back to the to the source of what we’re most passionate about, which is helping small farmers. Uh really, they help us uh to feel, you know, fulfilled and and and really, you know, my uh my partner uh girlfriend who’s on the call today, Chibelli, she’s actually from Amazonas in Venezuela. And what she’s always taught me about the Amazon is if we really are passionate about wanting to protect the trees and the ecosystem environment, the best thing to do is is figure out models to empower the communities and the people who are there who already steward the land and already understand how to interact with the environment in a uplifting way and finding, you know, sustainable models of, you know, taking their products, their culture in a, you know, uh, in a way with integrity to bring to market uh these products and services.

And so certainly as we look to uh making an impact on the Amazon, we see it’s all about connecting with the individual farmers and caretakers and our role is to do that through the cooperatives, the associations, the packers, processors, brands, financers and building these kind of uh market driven digital coalitions. So

Unidentified speaker:

great

Unidentified speaker:

that that takes me to the end. That was a lot. So Jonah, I’ll pass it to you and then happy to answer any questions or share any ideas.

Unidentified speaker:

Uh great. Uh we already have one person in line for questions. Uh others feel free to go ahead and prepare your questions and post your interest in the chat or raise your hand. I’ve got a few to lead us off. So Keith, first of all, can you tell us a little bit about who is Spencer Woodard and where did the idea from of producers market originally come from?

Unidentified speaker:

Great. So um Spencer is a good friend of mine who’s an ethnobbotonist and he spent uh 15 years developing models around doing uh food forestry uh specifically in Bocaust del Toro Panama but has then worked in other regions of uh the equator into Mediterranean and and uh subtropical climates. Spencer uh learned from a gentleman named uh Bruce uh who basically was inspired by the cultivated landscape models of the Amazon and started to look at how can we copy nature and how the um different tribes of the Amazon, the tribes of Mexico City, how these different models for water movement and for land cultivation could be used for growing medicines and foods and wood products in a um diversified environment.

So basically taking you know the botany of tropical uh cultivation of harvestable commercialized crops and moving them into a model and then you know we worked with Spencer on projects in Panama and Colombia to say okay how do we take this like totally crazy food forest botany model and move it into a actual commercially viable crop system where maybe there’s 10 major crops and then there’s another 50 to 60 secondary crops that can be intercropped around those 10 major crops. And so we worked for years with Spencer developing these models where uh I personally worked and some of our teammates on how do we create the added value processing and commercialization strategies around a diversified planting that could reach a 200 hector model that could be scaled, you know, into 20,000 hectares or more that really mimics and replicates the forest.

And so that’s kind of the model and system we’re looking at with green green climate fund uh in Surinam and Gana as pilot projects and yeah

Unidentified speaker:

uh can you go ahead and tell us about some of your investors?

Unidentified speaker:

Sure. So uh and and just to your second question uh so producers market the history is um I was working for UNFI another large distributor as well and before that was in the greenhouse hydroponic business and in my uh work doing uh buying from the largest natural organic distributor in North America. I just got insanely frustrated because they wouldn’t buy from the groups that I was bringing to them. Uh even though they were paying me to do so. And a lot of it was because they didn’t have the scale necessary. They couldn’t actually export. They didn’t have the financial services to hold terms. They couldn’t get product to market.

They didn’t have the right certifications. Uh they preferred to buy from brokers and traders. And I could just see uh how obvious of a missing link there was between the groups on the ground and the uh brands and distributors and retailers in North America and Europe who are actually selling the product. And when we combine that with the growing demand from consumers to want to know their source, want to know their impact, uh want to know who’s growing their product and how it got there, we felt like there was a major opportunity to start creating a digital map and focusing that digital map on stories and the storytelling of the producers um who actually create the products and creating a platform that was actually built for the farmers and producers.

And um so our biggest uh equity shareholder by by actual category um is our farmers. We we put aside 20% of our cap table non-dilutive to do future issuance to small farmers in our networks. We haven’t figured out how we’re going to do it, but we’re we’re going to get there. And some of our other investors are uh leading brands uh in the organic space, some distributors uh impact investors, you know, specifically to Brazil and the Amazon. Uh Jazelle Bonin’s one of our investors and of course is extremely passionate about both the Amazon as well as um connecting with the small farmer stakeholders to get to markets.

And uh we see ourselves really from the beginning and uh where we’ve gotten the last uh four years is building this uh vertical data layer where the qualitative information like the storytelling as well as the data of you know the impact metrics uh the transactional data and metrics can move seamlessly across the value chain so that the brands can know and and actually share and gain that PR and marketing benefit. benefit of of their impact uh on communities, on the environment, on uh producers.

Unidentified speaker:

Great. One last question for me and then we’ll go to Amy and then Alex. Uh so the question is Keith, who are some of the buyers that you’re talking to and what’s the stage of the conversation?

Unidentified speaker:

Yeah. Um so we’ve been in conversations with um you know everyone from Carer to Walmart uni lever monles um pricemart um Ferrerero Mars you know it the conversations range and how deep we’ve gotten but it’s it’s a little bit frustrating to be honest with all due respect to all those organizations mentioned that I believe sincerely have strong initiatives to do sustainable procurement. When you actually get to the actual buyers and the procurement managers, it’s it feels like it’s a different tone from what their, you know, head of sustainability or their CEO level is saying. Um, but we do feel there’s a genuine interest to find out and figure out how to create these scalable, traceable models of um, procurement.

But what we feel is necessary is is the groups who are on the ground and who work you know at that farmer producer cooperative level of uh the value chain to be able to aggregate and get to a scale and a model that allows for these larger buyers to engage in a way that fits their needs. uh they’re unfortunately really pressed around price, quality and certification and it’s our job we feel to aggregate and get to uh levels of scalability and uh infrastructure where we can fit the needs of these different uh buying groups to you know uh provide the buyer force in order to get the financing to develop these models and the financial services is at low interest and uh it’s going to take both the buyers coming to the table to guarantee purchasing from these groups and from the finance community to uh trust these buyers and then trust the local operators to fulfill it.

Unidentified speaker:

Great. Uh thank you Amy, you’re up.

Unidentified speaker:

Hey uh Keith, that was amazing. Um I I come out of the cooperative movement um my previous life. So, I was really excited to hear that you’re working with cooperatives and associations and so I have lots of questions, but I just love it. I love the interface. It looks amazing. Um, it’s super exciting. I have two well two one comment and two questions. The comment is I would love to collaborate with you on in integrating land rights into some of your producer stories and actually focusing on land rights as as a as one of the value ads. um for for producers. I would love to do that.

I work for Cadasta. We focus on uh global land rights using also technology platforms. Um so that’s one comment. But the questions are one um could you your business model is your business model primarily um going to be driven by the commercial platform as a you know sort of percentage off the trade trading or or off the connections the the market connections. uh one and then the second thing is if you could talk a little bit more about the blockchain application and um how you see that evolving and how important that actually is to the model.

Unidentified speaker:

Great. Um

Unidentified speaker:

thanks.

Unidentified speaker:

So yeah, great questions and thanks for that feedback and yeah, we’d love to learn more about integrating land rights as a value ad. I’m sure our product team would be super excited to learn about that. And what you’ve seen is just bas a basic infrastructure where now we can start to add in all different types of features customization to um communicate these values. So I appreciate that and you know our model is uh about creating a large network and through this building of a larger network we can take smaller transaction fees. It’s basically looking at an intermediary that might take between five and 10 or 20% or more um of the uh value chain and bringing it down to 1 to 2% from what we take.

And so we’re looking at different sliding scale models of what percentage of commission we take based upon how involved we are in that specific uh value chain. And our story bird is a software license fee. That’s a per year fee that we’re charging to retailers and brands. So, we don’t see that as something we want to put onto the producer. We feel like it should come out of the marketing department of the retailers and brands who are sharing the story of their producers. So, that’s a software license fee. And then, you know, one other aspect of our platform that I didn’t share is we are working towards our uh producers brand.

So we see this as like a scalable public label kind of like private label except we wanted to be uh fully transparent as to what where our products come from. So, in in a lot of our communities we’re working um some of the cooperatives, some of the small to midsize producers, they don’t have the bandwidth to start building a brand for themselves or managing a brand or going through that process of marketing in the United States or Europe where, you know, there’s a premium product. So, we’re going to roll out in in Q1 of of this coming year. um having our brand available for producers who really fit our our ethos in terms of, you know, how they treat their workers, the environment.

Uh organic certified isn’t mandatory because there’s value chains, as I’m sure you’re aware, that don’t use chemicals, but they couldn’t afford or didn’t want to go through the organic process. So, we see our brand as an opportunity to really be um a true representative of our producers with our brand and to be able to um you know share the stories with Storybird on our products and do a transparent profit share model back to the to the cooperatives or to certain projects where we’re we’re targeting a certain percentage of our revenues uh from the sale of the product to um directly to the communities where we’re sourcing from.

So, this is uh going to be one of our larger growth areas of profitability is through actually wholesaling and doing direct to consumer sales of our branded products.

Unidentified speaker:

Great. Thank you, Alex. Uh please uh reintroduce yourself and share your question with us.

Unidentified speaker:

Yes. Um hello. Um congratulations, Keith. That’s a really really nice um initiative. I really loved it. Even the way um that you included storytelling. Um I’ve been working the last couple of years with cooperatives and um associations in the Brazilian Amazon and these community organizations. They sure have a lot of good stories to tell and um it’s really hard for them to survive as they produce on a smaller scale as you well know. Um, I have two questions for you. Uh, the first one, um, how do you know if the cooperative or seller on your homepage is really in condition to sell? I mean, if they comply with, um, with the sanitary barriers or with novel foods regulations in Europe.

So, once they’re up there, if if there is a buyer, if you really can buy from them, if they can really supply the product, that’s that’s one doubt I have because at least in Brazil, it’s pretty complex. you need a different status if you want to sell outside the municipality then outside the state and even outside the country it’s it’s more complex and my second um question is um about the pricing I know you have the prices on um when you showed the the platform how do you get to the pricing are the sellers setting the price or do they have good idea what’s the real price in dollars or in in in euros or how do they get to the price these are my two questions.

Thank you and and congratulations. Very nice initiative.

Unidentified speaker:

Yeah, thank you Alexander. Uh two very very great great questions and we have at least part of the answer and you know the truth is it’s going to require a lot more collaboration R&D and bringing products to market to solve it in a scalable way. But in terms of you know supplying the right products to the buyers, this is where we get to know each producer that gets registered and understanding what certifications do they have, do they have experience exporting, what languages do they speak and understanding are they actually export ready or not and being able to also filter the leads from the buyers as they come in.

We we want in the future to have a natural filing filtering system that a buyer is not going to connect say a buyer in uh in Holland who wants to buy uh you know Brazil nuts from Brazil. you know, we want them to be able to filter through our site uh if the producer is already export ready, if their certifications are validated, what skill they have, what terms that they can use. And so uh certainly uh we want it to be a natural filtering process but in the uh kind of next six to 12 months uh our team is actually filtering these leads and making sure that if we’re going to connect a credible buyer to one of our producers that it’s not going to be a a dead end that the producer we’re connecting them to can actually fulfill uh the ordering and commercial needs of that uh buyer.

So, you know, part of what we’ve realized coming from the industry is this is not going to be just a digital solution. I think anyone who thinks that we’re going to solve these supply chain issues by just creating an app in Silicon Valley and giving it to people and thinking it’s going to work, they don’t understand at all the complexities of value chains. And so it’s going to require a very hands-on approach from the nonprofit associations, the cooperatives, the governments, uh, for-profit entities like like ours who are social impact. So I do believe it’s going to require a lot of handholding on negotiation on pricing specifications, managing the sale, you know, managing the logistical process that this unfortunately is going to be offline for at least the next 12 months.

You know, we’re working on solving it, but the reality is it’s it’s very complex as I’m sure you all know. So we think that our platform is a hybrid tool. It requires a lot of offline work, a lot of relationship and communication based work in order for these transactions to happen. And you know the reason that we call ourselves a partnership platform as opposed to like a spot by marketplace is because we can work through these issues, invest the time to set up a value chain because as you all know once a value chain is set up then it can start to move and scale but it might take a year or two years for the first container transaction to happen because of all the certifications you know added value quality control and all these issues.

use, but then once that first container is going, then it can go to two containers, then 10, then 20, then 50. So, we really see our platform as planting lots of seeds to build partnerships and then allowing for that offline online kind of hybrid model to to take hold. And and to to also touch on what Amy asked too about using blockchain, uh you know, anyone who thinks blockchain or or proposes blockchain as this like silver bullet solution, I think is doesn’t make any sense at all. I mean, blockchain is just a great technology that can be applied for building in different trust, but the data that goes into it has to be validated, verified to be trustworthy.

And you know the data integrity of the producer groups making sure that you know the information that’s collected whether it’s marketing and data or qualitative that it can be exchanged and permissioned and to the benefit and transparently used to the benefit of the users of the producer groups that that’s where blockchain I think can play an amazing role and for downstream value chain stakeholders like brands like the retailers distributors logistics providers can all plug in to one real time data bilateral uh network can be another area but I think it first starts with um organizing who are the aggregators who are the agreneurs the aggrepreneurs being a concept in India and Africa that’s become just massive where there’s you know community resource persons in the areas where the farmers are that can actually onboard board small farmers, onboard data, information, go take photos, capture transactions, audits that can be done through local people in these communities that this agreneur model as well is where something like blockchain and validating information, auditing, but it needs a system to plug into.

And so what we’re working to do is to plug these different um you know ERP data systems uh information capture systems into one omni channel architecture where essentially you know these interoperability systems. So whether you’re working on IBM food trust blockchain or vchain or banku or Oracle system or Microsoft system and so on and so forth that it doesn’t become a a burden to the aggregator to the packer processor to the small farmer but it can easily move the data in and out of different systems based upon what buyer wants to use that system. So if if Uni Lever wants to use IBM system and Carver wants IBM system but Walmart China wants to use Vchain system, you don’t want the producer groups to have to work across three different applications or 10 different applications.

So we think part of the uh solution is to allow for diversified marketing channels by having data interoperability so that a producer doesn’t have to get married to uni lever simply because now they’re in their data system. We think it should be a democratization of markets and marketing channels.

Unidentified speaker:

Great. Uh thank you Alex and Keith. Ruben, you have a related question. Yes, I think you partially answered it. Uh, and hi, I’m Ruben, work at EDF, Environmental Defense Funds. I was just wondering if your model is is mostly about information sharing and creating transparency versus uh impo or requiring particular standards or or certifications or um or you know sustainability uh requirements of some sort. And you mentioned that you were trying to encourage certain ethos of u of producers, but I was wondering how you uh if you provide some kind of screening. It sounded like there’s some informal method, but if you could say more about that would be great.

Unidentified speaker:

Yeah, great question, Ruben. And this has been a a philosophical debate amongst our team since we started because we’re all here to make regenerative agriculture and sustainable supply chain become not the the 0.1% but the 99.9%. Right? That’s the goal. the the reality that that we’re facing on supply chains is that a lot of the the uh groups and individuals on the supply chains are not exposed or are scared of sustainability or think that it’s just going to lose them money or it’s going to cost too much. And so what we really want to do is build an inclusive network. And you know, for example, we’re not working with any groups that you know, on the animal side.

We we won’t touch anything that’s factory farmed or that’s uh GMO corn and soy. We’re just there’s some things we’re just not going to touch. But we do feel like when it comes to our brand, when it comes to us engaging in trade facilitation, when it comes to our platform, doing our content, our storytelling, all of that is going to be centered entirely around the producers that are doing um at least organic but into fair trade, into sustainability focused. And so what we want to do is become an inclusive platform so that if people want to build profiles, we now have engagement with all different types of producers all around the world.

But what we’re really working to do is build the incentivization programs and to connecting with the buyers that are willing to incentivize producers to move into these sustainable metrics. So the approach that we’ve taken and to be honest, it’s an experiment. You know, we don’t know if it’s going to work. We hope it does, but we want to build an inclusive network and then leverage our added value operations, our added value efforts to use our uh traceability tools, our transparency tools, our market connectivity, our buyer relationships, our media sites, everything around how do we promote, how do we support, how do we finance, and how do we help the groups that either want to move into that type of production or already are in that type of production.

Unidentified speaker:

Uh I have another question. Um Amy had questions as well, but she had to go. So if others are in line and have questions, uh they’re welcome. Um my question is about the financial models. Sometimes land acquisition is a major stumbling block. You want to start a new farm, the cost of acquiring that land is prohibitive, but you might be able to rent it or something else. just wondering if you guys have innovated a way around this as you explore financial models.

Unidentified speaker:

Yeah, really great question. Um, the way we’re looking at our platform is to be able to plug in to groups that have unique solutions. So, you know, there’s a group called Steward that is doing crowdfunding for farmers, uh, you know, to buy added value equipment or to do different, you know, asset investments. And where we see our platform is a great connectivity point to groups who are solving these types of challenges whether it’s financial services or investment or gaining capital to uh be able to lease or own land. We don’t see ourselves directly engaging. We see ourselves leveraging our ecosystem, our partnerships and our kind of exposure to support groups that that have that singular focus to achieve those goals.

Jonah, I think you’re on mute. Yeah,

Unidentified speaker:

I am. Yeah. Uh, I’m gonna paste a link here. This is an article that, um, Keith recently reviewed. Uh, it’s something that I put together over the past six months looking at the market opportunity of agroforestry to replace soy and cattle in the Amazon. Um, you you so part of our goal as a network is to work at a macro level, macroeconomic level. How can we use the power of global markets and global philanthropy to accelerate forest friendly economic development across the region? Um, you’ve been talking with a lot of different stakeholders as well. Um, global stakeholders who haven’t yet come together on the Amazon but can and you represent one pathway to make that happen.

Uh, and and part of your story illustrates that just you guys becoming a um a successful company. uh could you tell me a little bit about the um the threshold question that some of the small producers face and how to make their um their products viable. So for example um myoba beans um or white cacao beans uh from the Amazon. I remember I was talking about how one or two pallets isn’t worth it for most retailers and somehow you guys might uh might provide a solution for that for such producers.

Unidentified speaker:

Yeah. Yeah. Thank you, Jonah. And and I highly recommend everyone checking out that article that Jonah included. I it’s long overdue that an article like that’s come out. So, uh, definitely kudos and and thank you Jonah for for creating that document. Um, yeah, I mean the the big challenge is it’s when someone’s thinking about the livelihood of their family and and they know that, hey, if I put down some soy or if I cut down trees and do some cattle, I know there’s a market and it’s established, it’s available, it’s easy, and I’ll get what I need. And then looking at this model of agroforestry or growing a makambo where people may not even know what a makambo is or or acai which they know is highly perishable.

How does it get to market? I think what we really want to achieve is connecting in the buyers and the aggregators and creating that map, that digital map and framework of who are the processors, who are the packers regionally, who are the logist logistics providers that can fulfill these orders and what’s missing. So if maybe for makumbbo they need a drying facility. Okay, now how do we work with these aggregate investor groups to connect in to financing you know that infrastructure development based around knowing that there’s a market contract on our platform ready to buy those Mont combo beans. So we really see ourselves as as nothing more than connecting the pieces of what’s already happening and where the intentions already are and identifying where those gaps in the supply chain are.

So, you know, again, like building out that regional sustainable Amazon procurement uh platform, we can start to basically like funnel some of the buyers we work with and say, “Hey, here’s some of the producers that our partners are working with within this region. What products are interesting? What would you like?” And then it takes that value chain value chain by value chain uh exploration and and understanding how do we build these scalable models around added value processing and infrastructure and investment um based around um you know these uh digitally integrated systems of connecting markets with finance with production.

Unidentified speaker:

Great. Any other questions for Keith? I’d like to call in a couple people to introduce themselves who are new to the call and who I believe will be able to help. Uh, hey Walter Link, if you’re there, I’d love you to introduce yourself and talk a little bit about your work. You’re on mute.

Unidentified speaker:

I am unmute. Hi. Hi, everybody. Um, what do you want me to say? Te

Unidentified speaker:

tell us about now.

Unidentified speaker:

Okay. Um, so I used to um co-own an industrial group of companies. Uh, and 30 years ago I wanted to make that sustainable. I realized that you can only do that when you also um work with the whole system because the the problem as you all know is that individual organizations can only uh you know in a way uh do what the overall marketplace uh asks. And um so at the time you know we were representing very large corporations that had their products like Zemens and Carrier and Merc and so forth and um so we could do a lot in our companies changing uh our companies but we could not uh change our products to the degree that we wanted because these products depended on these big multinational corporations.

So I left um the the management of the group to my brother and I went to create the first sustainable business networks together with the owners and uh and leaders of companies and at the time it was like you know people like Anita Rodic who founded the body shop and Ben Cohen who founded you know Ben & Jerry’s and many other companies the names of which you may not know and um as you all know the movement ment grew and I look around the screen and I it’s wonderful to see so many younger faces and um and see how huge this movement has become but I think the movement obviously still has to grow much further and so what we’re doing with now partners is we bring together the people who can really transform companies especially large companies so not so much uh you know smaller ones uh and for example you know, one of my uh main partners is the founder of the BCO movement in Europe and there uh you know, the BOP movement in uh throughout the Americas called system and um you know and we’ve just worked for example with Natura

which is Nura Group which started out as a very valuedriven small company in Brazil and now has become the fourth largest beauty group in the world to help them develop their vision for uh the next 10 years and you know do the same with uh other very large companies and also with a lot of familyowned companies throughout the global south. So we provide under now.partners partners. You can see that a full range of transformation services for large companies, multinationals and um and also a large family companies as I said you know that uh and we also build um you know continue to build the the B corp movement and other business movements and we entered into a big uh uh you know collaboration with for example example, the Vatican to help um think about how could somebody who thinks of themselves as Christian or Buddhist or an other secular valuedriven orientation transform their business into uh a valuedriven business that fully integrates economic success with the regeneration of people and planet.

And so the Amazon is also very much a a region that we’re interested in. And there’s a big uh you know movement of um a Brazilian companies that we are close to that are um uh you know working on creating agroforestry and and all kind of other uh you know businesses. Natura has a big production facility in the Amazon, has been working for decades on uh sourcing products but also producing them there, empowering people locally to develop their uh their their entrepreneurial capacity to uh you know in a way make more money with the trees standing and it’s a as you all know very complex undertaking and um and now I’m looking at how can we connect these Brazilian and and Latin American Amazon related uh uh businesses with for example the uh you know the the all the uh for example with the with the religious communities that have so much influence in these regions you know uh and so we work typically with big institutions and and so forth.

But of course we love very much uh what you were just uh describing because I think in addition to these large institutions you need to have a lot of small producers. you need to have a lot of connection to uh uh consumers and and because it’s not only that they buy the products I think the I think the key is that they are that they realize a different economy is possible and I think that’s what we all do together and the more people know that and participate in it the more we can actually bring about systems change so

Unidentified speaker:

nice so I see your original connection opportunity on this call as uh CEOs of corporations are inspired to go sustainable and look for ways to make it possible. Keith’s technology uh presents an opportunity and this is the beauty of the connectivity on this call. Uh Keith, I’d love to ask if you can share your email address in the chat so that people can follow up with you.

Unidentified speaker:

Uh yeah, of course. That would be amazing. I’m gonna write it here. And you know, as we get closer to actually creating our umbrella organization uh page for the different, you know, producers, we’re going to speak with Jonah and hopefully with all you folks if you do have great producers or groups within the Amazon that you know, you guys know are doing great work that we can add in to build this kind of a connection point that we’d love any support and any ideas that you guys have. Uh, I just want to recognize that we’re at the top of the hour. Uh, this is the time that we switch the conversation over to less of an interview and more of an unstructured conversation and usually most folks chime out.

Uh, but the line will be open, the chat room will be open and I’ll be here as will others. So Sarah, I see you coming on. Uh, did you have a question? It’s great to see you.

Unidentified speaker:

Ask Hi, it’s good to see you too. Thank you, Keith, for sharing. Um, I did ask a question in the chat um about whether or not this is mainly um food specific or if you’re um like the production materials can affect beauty products um maybe cleaning solutions. I know you mentioned essences if it can be a marketplace for that as well or if it’s just food specific right now.

Unidentified speaker:

Yeah. And then I do have a second question is I know that it’s Amazon focused, but there are other regions within um let’s say Peru that might not be Amazon um but still have that similar ethos of supporting small farmers and producers. So I’m wondering if that’s on the table as well.

Unidentified speaker:

Yeah. Um so yeah, we’re focused on any of these products from the natural environment. So uh we’ve done a project in in sustainable organic cotton supply chain so textile um some beauty skin care uh shea butter things like that from Africa. Um and we work with actually a sustainable uh a sustainable land management group in in the Amazon in Brazil that does uh sustainable forestry. So for wood products, um, and so yeah, we’re open to all different types of producers across categories. We just tend to focus a lot of energy on food products because it’s kind of like our sweet spot, but we’re happy to work with producers and work with supply chains outside of it.

Um, outside of that focus and now even into aquaculture and seafood as well. Um and yeah, I mean really the focus for the call is is the Amazon and it’s such an important you know region for us but you know Peru uh and other areas in South America, Latin America is is as well a big focus. So, we know there’s tends to be more organization amongst co-ops, amongst outputs and other areas of like Peru and Colombia and elsewhere uh outside of the Amazon, but we’re happy to engage with, you know, all different types of producers around different geographies.

Unidentified speaker:

Okay, great. Thank you.

Unidentified speaker:

Yeah, thank you.

Unidentified speaker:

That’s great. Um, keep up the good work.

Unidentified speaker:

Thank you. Any other conversations? Okay, I think that that may be a wrap. Thanks so much for joining us, Keith, and everybody else. Uh we won’t have a call next week, uh just so you know, between Christmas and New Year’s. Um it’s great to see everybody.

Unidentified speaker:

Yeah, thank you Jonah and thank you everyone for you know uh spending your energy today to hear hear the presentation, learn about what we’re doing and uh we’re here to answer any questions and thank you guys.

Unidentified speaker:

Bye everyone. Thanks Jonah.

Unidentified speaker:

You bet. Thanks so much. Bye everybody.