Mining and Deforestation in Venezuela

Cristina Vollmer Burelli: Though not yet visible in newspaper headlines, the Venezuela Amazon may be suffering the worst environmental disaster of the Western Hemisphere. Cristina Burelli joins us to tell the story of SOS Orinoco and its efforts to mitigate the impacts of illegal mining in the Orinoco river basin, an essential process to prevent conflicts from exploding into the wider region.

Recorded September 14, 2020

WATCH:

  • Cristina Vollmer Burelli
  • Walter
  • Atossa Soltani
  • Unidentified speakers

Unidentified speaker:

Uh hello everybody. Uh welcome to the 11th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. Uh we serve as a partnership platform for the United Nations 75 global governance forum which is going to take off this week and we are operated by the Global Governance Philanthropy Network. My J my name is Jonah Wamper and I’m your host. These calls are recorded and are in the process of being re-edited for rebroadcast to investors around the world. We want to bring more philanthropic resources, more impact impact investing resources in order to help facilitate forest friendly economic development across the Amazon, all regions. Uh there’s of course a lot of Brazilians on these calls, but also a lot of international allies.

And today we’re not talking about Brazil first. We’re talking about Venezuela, which is seldom coming up in these contexts. Um, so before I uh hop more into it, I would like to say that today we’ll be hearing from uh Teresa Belli about SOS mat. I’m sorry, I was about to say

Unidentified speaker:

Christina Teresa is my daughter. [laughter]

Unidentified speaker:

Oh, okay. Sorry. Christina Varelli. Uh, I’m accidentally invoking the name of your daughter. Um, and I was about to say the name of a Brazilian NGO. Um, uh, Christina is the international liaison for SOS Orinino. And then we’re going to be hearing from Derek Gallo, who is the founder of AI Superfoods. Um, Christina, the floor is yours.

Unidentified speaker:

Great. Uh, can I share my screen?

Unidentified speaker:

Yes, you can.

Unidentified speaker:

So that I can put up my presentation.

Unidentified speaker:

Yes. And I’m going to go ahead and uh put most people on mute just uh so that we uh don’t have too much feedback. Go for it.

Unidentified speaker:

Okay. So I think I think you can see it, right?

Unidentified speaker:

Yes.

Unidentified speaker:

Okay. Presenter view. Okay. Great. Um so thank you so much uh Jonah. this is um a a really um

Unidentified speaker:

great to reconnect and and thank you so much for this opportunity. Um thank you to the Amazon Investor Coalition and and um and for your interest. So uh for many in the international community and indeed in the global environmental community, it’s probably surprising to learn that Venezuela is one of the top 10 mega biodiverse countries in the world alongside Brazil. But it’s also highly mineralrich and it’s suffering probably from the worst environmental crisis in the Western Hemisphere. The highest deforestation rate of the Americas and Amazonia. And many of you have probably haven’t you have probably haven’t read or heard about this in the media. So hopefully today I can walk you through what’s going on.

So first a little bit of geography. Uh this is a map of Venezuela and the Ordinoco River Basin is located uh both in Amazonia and the Guyana Shield uh a pre-cambrian geological formation which is one of the large relics of the earliest part of the world’s history. And what makes Venezuela’s Amazonian region unique within Pan Amazonia is not so much its size, but the fact that it comprises lowland tropical forests and a wide range of ecosystems along an elevational gradient of up to 3,000 meters above sea level. And this is what makes it so biodiverse. And of course, one of the jewels in the crown of Venezuela’s Amazonian region is Ganima National Park.

um otherwise known as the land of the lost world. Um widely celebrated as one of the most stunning landscapes on the planet. So much so that it was declared a world heritage site in 1994. So in this map you’ll see that basically the Odinco River uh splits the country in half and 60% of the country is south of the Oino River. Now, um [clears throat] the collapse of the Venezuelan’s oilbased e economy um has basically pushed the Nicolas Maduro um government to seek new sources of revenue and it’s turned to basically plundering the country’s vast mineral resources and selling them as contraband to international buyers.

This illegal trade threatens to destroy one of the world’s most biodiverse areas and decimate the region’s indigenous population. So in February 2016 without the approval of the democratically elected National Assembly, Maduro decreed that a section of the Amazon covering 12% of Venezuela’s territory, so basically it’s all of this red that you see here in this little red square down here. Um decreed that it would become a mining development zone. uh the so-called arco minor or the orininoco mining ark and it contains vast reserves of colultan iron boite diamonds it could hold the second largest gold deposits in the world um at 42,800 square miles 111 uh almost 12 112,000 kilometers squared it covers an area that is bigger than Portugal So, Maduro’s signature mining gamble gives the outward appearance of having this well delimited uh geographical scope, but in reality, its intent has spread out into areas not defined as being inside the Aronoka mining arc.

And this includes national parks, uh, including the World’s Heritage Site. has given rise to a gold rush throughout the entire region south of the Ordininoco River and now even parts of northern Venezuela and and the regime is is effectively signaling that indiscriminate mining has been given priority over the preservation of the extremely delicate environment found in Venezuela. This [clears throat] map um of southern Venezuela resembles uh a mosaic and it shows the diversity of strategies implemented by Venezuela in in during the the course of the 20th century in order to ensure conservation and sustainable development. So Venezuela has in the Amazonia Guana region 29 protected areas, eight national parks, 19 natural monuments and two biosphere reserves.

And throughout the 20th century, prior to the arrival of Chavez on the scene, Venezuela had probably the most conservationist policy for its Amazonian region in all of Latin America. Um, all various governments, you know, democratic, dictatorial, whatever, they all created laws that protected vast areas of pristine forest south of the Odin River. Indigenous people’s ancestral territories were protected. Ganima National Park was declared a world heritage site and numerous protected areas were created between 1962 and 1993 and all mining was made illegal uh in this large state of Amatas where you see the the cursor um and and it protected the freshwater sources that are among the most abundant on the continent and provide close to 70% of Venezuela’s hydroelectric power.

Now, this doesn’t mean that there was no illegal mining uh nor that foreign miners like Brazilian Gingos were not exploiting mines illegally, but it was minimal compared to what we’re seeing today. And these circles on this map um highlight the areas that SOS has been doing uh reports on. And I’m going to, you know, just show you uh a few of these. Um so a few examples of what’s going on. So first of all, the Imataka Forest Reserve on the Guuni River. Um this is the heart of the Arnokco uh mining arc and it is an area of extreme violence and um pretty horrific uh mining as you can see the satellite image.

I’m going to go quickly over these. Um, I do want to stop a minute uh on the the slide on Kana, the the World Heritage site. Um, because the the explosion of illegal gold mining in and around Canaa, which is the World Heritage site, is without doubt the most scandalous example of what’s going on in Venezuela. Uh, this is the violation of Venezuela’s most emblematic national park, home to Angel Falls, the world’s highest waterfall, and many other remarkable tabletop mountains known as sep or such as we. We share the border with Brazil um on Mount Tora. Um, SOS has been studying the situation in Ganima and reporting on a regular basis to UNESCO and IUN.

And at last count, in July of this year, um we were able to find, as you see on this map, 59 illegal mining clusters, each containing dozens of mines in and around the world heritage site. Um, this park is also the ancestral home of Lee Mong indigenous people, many of whom have been forced to abandon their traditional activities and tourism to work in illegal mines in order to survive. Um, SOS did an evaluation of the scope of mercury contamination and an estimated 70% of the Gon River, which is along the border here, may be uh polluted with uh mercury. This is another example. So, Ikawaru, this is the headarters of the uh Scaroni River.

Uh, it’s a protective zone and as you can see in this picture that the mining is horrific. Uh, this is right on the border of Brazil.

Unidentified speaker:

Christina, sorry, I think I accidentally put you on mute. One second. Could you Christina, could you unmute yourself?

Unidentified speaker:

Unmute there.

Unidentified speaker:

Okay. Sorry about that. Keep on going.

Unidentified speaker:

Ah, no problem. Uh, Guinima natural monument. Another emblematic um uh natural monument. I mean, completely got it out in in with illegal minds uh and mercury poisoning. Next, I want it mo moved. Sorry. Hold on a second. Okay. So, all of these were in the state of Bolivia. Now I’d like to focus uh our attention on the state of Amazonas and in particular Yapakana National Park um in in uh this is very close to the border of Colombia. This national park has basically become a FARC thieftdom where dissident FARC lorded over this previously uninhabited national park now [clears throat] home to two to 3,000 illegal miners.

The gorillas control all the illegal gold mining and provide all types of services to the miners. Everything from food, uh they pay the teachers, uh it’s it’s like a state within a state. And Yapakana has become a financial and logistical center for the FARC as well as their entry point to all of southern Venezuela. So drug money is laundered through gold mining. the the the D this FARC and Eln are investing drug money into gold mining and every gram of gold illegally produced enriches the coffers of the Colombian guerilla which is granted safe passage and haven by the Maduro regime. So as long as the FARC have unfeted access to Yapakana, Colombia and the broader region will be under the growing threat of their terrorist activities.

Uh now moving along to southern right right that you know the the tip of Venezuela and this is Brazil. Okay. And this is um otherwise known as you know Yanomami land. This is where the Yanomami and the and the Yuana live. Um this is also the upper Orinoco biosphere reserve. And the expansion of illegal mines in this uh region uh is also controlled by the FARC dissident. And they’re not only threatening the existence of the Yanomami indigenous people, but they’re also a threat to the neighborhood because the FARC are demonstrably in alliance with the invading Brazilian Gados or miners. The Venezuelan armed forces also profit by providing logistical and air support with helicopters, believe it or not.

uh that transport fuel, machinery, etc. to the mines, some of which are on top of the toui. So I here’s a a satellite image of Arakamuni uh national park. Um they’re doing mining on the top of this. At this very moment, Yanomami witnesses have informed SOSO that there are over 40 illegal Brazilian miners in Hashimu, which is right here. uh and that there’s a huge risk of the COVID pandemic exploding in this area threatening the Yanomami and Yaguana people. And in all of this huge reg region, all medical facilities except for one which is much further up north have basically closed down. And this is just a a a quick uh view of all the indigenous groups south of the Odin Noco.

I mean, it it’s a tremendously rich um cultural uh area with with all of this uh all of these indigenous groups um that are suffering uh from the consequences of this uh criminal um mining policy by the by the Maduro government.

Unidentified speaker:

Five minutes.

Unidentified speaker:

Okay. So um I just wanted to talk a little bit about the the m the dynamics um behind all this illegal uh mining. So the the mining and the trade has become a lifeline for the regime which has basically put the military in charge of management. The the military man the checkpoints, control access to the mines, manage the flow of gasoline used for equipment and extort tribute from workers and criminal groups. All other groups operating operating in this area including criminal syndicates, the FARC, the Colombian uh National Liberation Army ELN are basically in connivance with the military. Um so we’re in witnessing an intensification and expansion of mining operations by state and non-state actors that are being shielded by the government and they occur to violence 247.

This mining policy promotes violence, slave labor, child labor, prostitution, and of course a deep a deeply troubling dismantling of indigenous social structures with countless silent and not so silent killings of indigenous and non-indigenous people. It’s also responsible for the explosion of a malaria epidemic that is spreading to the rest of Venezuela and other neighboring countries. Um, there are close to 450,000 new cases of malaria in 2019. On July 15th of this year, the UN uh, Office for Human Rights accused the Venezuelan military of failing to prevent crimes against miners in the country’s south, including extortion, amputations, and live burials. Um, so Venezuela’s mine industry has become an activity that’s imbued in a vast organized crime scheme that reaches all levels of Venezuelan um, political and military power structure.

Uh, top government officials are being rewarded and loyalties bought by a regime that is parceling out access to this vast area. And these are a few facts and figures um, just that I wanted to highlight. So in conclusion, I think it’s critical to point out that the speed at which this tragedy is evolving is surely going to define a future transition and governability of uh Venezuela as a nation state for years to come. These emerging threats to security in Venezuela and surrounding countries cannot be analyzed or understood without considering the role of its vast minerals and its fragile environment. Um, and I think the international community needs to increase the tracking of these high value resources and the networks that traffic them in international markets in order to minimize the potential for these resources finance lasting conflict.

And finally, you know, I think we just have a responsibility to to fight uh, you know, to allow you know, we can’t allow for the fight for mineral wealth that has decimated a number of African countries to take hold in the middle of the Western Hemisphere. that has never seen this kind of causes. So with that, um, thank you so much and and let me know if you have any questions.

Unidentified speaker:

Uh, great. Uh, let’s go ahead and start into questions. Uh, someone whose name has registered on Zoom as E. Ren, you you may begin.

Unidentified speaker:

Oh, hi. Uh, thank you for this presentation, Christina. I know that it is challenging to put in so much information um in a limited time frame and I was wondering if it was okay if we could get a copy of your slideshow or some other supplemental information about this that I can share with people from Nexus Global Philanthropies working indigenous issues group and for my colleague Lyanna from the New York City Indigenous Kinship Collective and my other colleague from Meil Lynch wealth management.

Unidentified speaker:

Absolutely. I’ll I’ll um send it to Jonah and then you know you can uh share it with with the group. Definitely.

Unidentified speaker:

Uh great.

Unidentified speaker:

Thank you.

Unidentified speaker:

Christine, if you can send it to me now during the second half of the call, I’ll make sure to get it and put it up on Google Drive and share the link. Um

Unidentified speaker:

Okay, perfect.

Unidentified speaker:

Uh Walter, you have a question.

Unidentified speaker:

Yes, I was unmuting myself. Great presentation. Uh congratulations Christina. Desperate situation. Um this is truly an example of the force horsemen of the apocalypse uh neighboring Venezuela. But uh besides the image and the pleading to international actors, what else can be done? Uh the state of Venezuela is not responsive to any help. They’ve they’ve excluded themselves from 20 by 20. very difficult to bring uh impact investment to Venezuela. Uh the situation of governance is dismal. Offer us a ray of hope please. [clears throat]

Unidentified speaker:

Yeah, it it’s difficult. Um I think you know there are two two different things that that that can be done. one obviously is is bringing this into the spotlight and and um today uh a very gutsy journalist called Bram Evos I’ll put this on the chat published a very in-depth um uh study on the the the the smuggling and the traffic of mercury um and and he goes there into the fact that you know there are ways for the international community particularly countries that are part of OECD such as Colombia uh and I think Peru is also part of OECD uh to implement you know strategies to stop the the the flow of blood gold basically.

So we are you know putting this out there. Countries need to stop you know the the flow of gold that is produced under these uh conditions and and we can only really do that if we make these countries and companies aware of the flow of this kind of gold. um and and and just make sure that big companies that are using gold for you know smartphones etc actually understand where gold is coming from and to ban gold that comes from Venezuela. This worked with uh blood diamonds in Africa and I think it’s really important to start implementing this with regard to gold. That’s one thing.

The other thing which is a little bit more complicated in my mind um because it’s a mind change is a mindset change is the fact that the opposition in Venezuela is trying to find ways of funding a transition. And sadly, uh, we are starting to see people within the opposition trying to embrace these same mineral policies, but thinking that they can rebrand them and that just because, you know, it’s going to be in the hands of the opposition, this article will be, you know, uh, sort of cleaner. So what we’re trying to do is drive the conversation to um make people in Venezuela understand that they need to look at sustainable ways of developing the Amazonian region that we cannot um fall into the trap of these extractivist policies just because we’re desperate and we’re poor.

And and I think that helping um the opposition in Venezuela, helping the uh international community to understand this and to see where the pitfalls are is really key because otherwise if we do when and if we’ve got a transition, we might fall into the same trap of this horrific extractivist um approach to dealing with southern Venezuela. Uh, I want to open it up for other people who might have a question. Uh, and for those of you who are dialed in, I just for sound reasons, I’ve muted most of you. I think either star six or star 9 will take you off of mute. Um, so feel free.

Anyone else have a question?

Unidentified speaker:

Um, Jonah, this is Susan Keane speaking. Can is it okay if I just make a comment here?

Unidentified speaker:

Yes. Um so as I mentioned at the beginning um I am working on a on a big project on this exact issue of um well uh gold and the use of mercury and gold production and and I uh there are quite it you know to give a ray of hope someone asked for array of hope there’s already quite a substantial effort under the OECD uh to try to address conflict gold um really it originated in the U great lakes region of Africa but it’s a global effort there are standards ards for uh refiners, downstream gold users uh to abide by when sourcing gold. Uh there is the Minimata Convention on Mercury which is trying to reduce mercury use in the sector etc etc.

So there is a lot of international policy tools uh that can be applied. I I guess I go back to the question of you know in this setting where you have such a recalcitrant government and essentially exploiting the people um who are I’m sure you know most of the people engaged in the sector as they are worldwide uh including in Colombia has quite a bit of its own small scale illegal small scale gold mining problem as does Peru as does Bolivia as does Guyana um so you know how what I kind of maybe a bit uh challenging is really this issue of how do we work uh with those kinds of policy tools when you don’t actually have a collaborative uh government.

Um although I guess working with downstream um gold [clears throat] buyers might might be one approach. I don’t know Christina if you’ve engaged your uh with with that kind of community of for example the London um bullion market association which has its responsible gold uh good delivery requirements etc and inform them about um the situation in uh Venezuela. Yeah, actually um I haven’t but uh the the interim government, the Guaido government um ambassador to the UK, Vanessa Nuoman has um done a lot of this. In fact, she was instrumental in stopping uh the Maluro uh government from putting its hands on the gold that was in the the the central bank in the UK.

Um, and and I hear that there’s a new I think there’s a new law that’s going to be I just saw something today. I didn’t even have time. But anyway, she I know is very involved with this. Um, but but that’s key. That’s key. Yeah. I mean, you know, I think um the only thing we can really do at this point is educate and inform. Um, I I’m I’m very uh I to me one of the most important things is to educate the Venezuelan people because many of them and you know many of of our politicians journalists don’t even know what they have south of the audiople they don’t know the the importance and the the the the just the wonder that exists south of the noco and just by educating people and and making them you know um hopefully making them stakeholders um people who care and who will stand up to whatever government um I think

Unidentified speaker:

um we have one question from Tossa Sultani

Unidentified speaker:

um hi Christina thanks so much for your excellent presentation I’ve actually um used to spend some time in this part of the um my question was just basically whether any of information that you’ve documented been presented in either a complaint or a thematic educational hearing to the Interamerican Commission on Human Rights given indigenous people’s impacts and also human rights um impacts.

Unidentified speaker:

Yes. Um we we’ve had uh we haven’t done it in a in a public um arena, but we have spoken to people at uh at the OAS um and and the groups in the inter in the internal government that are working with OAS the the sorry you know so they are yeah that that is people are active on that as well and and um and the Bashal report um went into I mean obviously it’s a it’s a limited report so there wasn’t you know too much space but they did announced what was going on with the Bon people and other uh indigenous groups, but obviously there’s a lot more to be done.

Unidentified speaker:

Um, great. Thanks. And then one last question from Lyanna.

Unidentified speaker:

Hi. Um, yes, Christina, thank you so much for this this presentation. And I think I maybe heard a couple of u specific mentions just now at the end of your thing, but you’re you’re a bit muffled your audio right now. Um, but anyway, I was just um wondering if you have any specific indigenous leaders or tribes in the region that you are like actively working with and including in this conversation. Um, which is obviously really important and involves them directly. I’m just curious like who you’ve been with the we’ve been working with the Pong people but also with the Yanomamani. Um in each of these uh on the presentation there were those circles.

So that each one of those circles corresponds to a report that SOS has done on those areas and and some of those areas uh have more indigenous people so there’s more information. So on our website you will find the reports there in English and Spanish. Um and there’s a lot of detail on uh particularly the Yanomami and the and the Beong who are the most affected um by illegal mining. Also, we have not done one on the situation in the GA region which is affecting the healthy uh indigenous people but um it we kind of mentioned it as well.

Unidentified speaker:

Great. Uh Christine, if you could post your email address um or if anyone wants to get in touch with her, please feel free to email me and I’ll pass it on to Christina.

Unidentified speaker:

I will put that and the mercury um and the and I’ll send you the the presentation.

Unidentified speaker:

Great. Thank you so much.