Millions Invested in the Amazon Region
MOV Investimentos is a leading Brazilian impact investor. Since 2008, MOV has invested over 150 million USD in the Amazon, across diverse industries, including sustainable forest management, reforestation, distributed solar energy, REDD+ projects, and sustainable aquaculture of diverse species. How did MOV start? Who are the investors involved? What can we expect in the future? Join us to meet MOV Founder, Paulo Belotti, and learn.
Recorded October 25, 2021
References:
Investments in Amazonia: sexy branding
2021 Map of the Brazilian Impact Business Sector
WATCH:
Participants
- Jonah
- Paulo Belotti
- Bobby
- Julia
- Bruno
- Tatiana Alves
- Fernando
Transcript
Jonah:
Hello everybody. Welcome to the 61st call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing forcefriendly economic development, the rule of law across the Amazon region of South America. This week we are focusing on the work of Paulo Belotti and MOV Investimentos. Paulo, thanks so much for joining us. Tell us a little bit about yourself. Where did you originate as a human being?
Paulo Belotti:
Well unfortunately not in the Amazon. I am I am born and raised in S. Paulo Brazil. I lived in Baya in Rio in the United States and in Gu. But I’m based today in S. Paul.
Jonah:
Tell us a little bit about your career. Tell us about some of the things you did before MOV Investimentos.
Paulo Belotti:
Yes. Well before Maui I am a chemical engineer by training and I worked in prochemical Brazilian businesses before I there is Yeah. Thanks. And I worked in investment banking before moving. I worked at Paku and Rabbo Bank. I was one of the first employees of Rab Bank International here in Brazil and I stayed in Rabo Bank for almost 10 years. When I left in 2004 to start investing at the at the time we did not have the term impact investing. So I just wanted to merge venture capital and sustainability. I believed at the time and many others as well that it was a possibility and a necessity to bring together profits and public goods.
So we started back in 2005 2006 and six what became to be MOV Investimentos.
Jonah:
Nice. We’ll get into Maui in just a moment. I’d love to ask you a little bit about the impact investing ecosystem in Brazil. How have you seen it quoteunquote come to market or grow or professionalize over the past couple of decades? I realize that could be an hour conversation in and of itself, but just some broad brush strokes for those people who might be new to Brazilian investing.
Paulo Belotti:
Yeah. No, I think it started really in the early 2000s. A couple of people were very instrumental in it start. We have IDB L. We had people from FJ here in Brazil starting devices other investment funds, entrepreneurs, businessmen that were interested to look at this possibility to bring together profits and social environmental impact. It was on a deal by deal occasion pipeline building small accelerators but it’s really it was really in its infancy till 2009 then a movement started basically here in S Paulo with Vox Capital Motoia and others Artameisia starting to fill in the ecosystem in mentoring, acceleration, early stage investments and VC type of investments in impacting with impact objectives.
The pipeline was very weaker at the time and then we move from 2009 2010 to 2020 and we had a lot of improvements. I think the ecosystem grew a lot. We have initiatives in all states of Brazil. Accelerators funds looking at it. BNDS, the Brazilian Development Bank started to fund to invest in fund managers. But still today it’s small when you compare to the VC private equity industry in Brazil. The impact investing sector is still very small here but it grew a lot. It grew a lot in the last 15 20 years but it still has potential and I think what is key for the acceleration of the sector is that we have to now show that impact funds really deliver returns and social environmental impact.
We did not have till today. We had some deals some exits good cases but a fund itself closing its duration and returning capital to investors. We didn’t have this event at the moment in Brazil till now in Brazil. So I think when we start to show this the sector will grow even faster. Okay, let’s get to the big story. So, there was a moment when you were working in the big institutions. I heard you mention Rabbo Bank and you decided you got to go out on your own and start something.
What was the idea? What was the straw that broke the camel’s back that said, “Okay, that’s it. I’m going to do it.” And where did the name Mauvi come from? Okay. So this was the initial movement was in 2004 2005 when I left Robbo Bank I open a one company man looking for investors. To combine as I mentioned before venture capital and sustainability. At that time we were talking a lot about renewable energy and healthy foods sustainable agriculture that was it was in my mind and after talking to a group of people I came to know the founders of Natura.
Natura is a large cosmetic company here in founded in Brazil. Today they operate in many countries all over the world. And we started to look for opportunities in sectors that we have been working since then. The sectors are forests which is why we got so involved in the Amazon. The second sector was education. It’s a very key and important element to the sustainable development and equitable development of Brazil. And the third sector what we call is what we call environmental sorry resilient cities and below resilient cities we have distributed energy recycling applied u circular economy.
We have land titling and infrastructure in favllas in Brazilian slopes. So we worked from 2006 to 2012 in a more dealby deal basis. At the time I was a partner at Pragma. Pragma is a multif family office here in Brazil looking for investments. And in 2012 we decided to institutionalize the organization the effort. So we founded MOI and MOI the name Maui was really trying to cap to capture this idea of energy movement transformation and it was suggested to us by Lu Sabra who is the founder of Mura. We it was a very interesting story.
We talked to him and said what we wanted to do and said, “Oh, give me a two or three days. I will come back with a list for you.” And he did. So, and we chose MOV investment at the time. This was 2012.
Jonah:
Nice. Let’s get into the portfolio a little bit. I heard you mentioning the land titling in urban areas. I think that is Tehan Nova. Could you tell us a little bit about that investment and then land titling in the Amazon is a really complex story and is one of the stumbling blocks that is limiting the growth of agro sustainable agro industrial development. Could the model of that company be adapted to rural landscapes?
Paulo Belotti:
Well, more or less Tanova focuses on urban land conflicts. So, here in Brazil, we have more or less 25 million people that are irregularly occupying land in cities. Brazil is a very urban society. We have close to 90% of the population live in cities. And most of this land are irregularly occupied. Half of half of this land is public, half is private. And in private lands, you have judicial conflicts. You have a lot of eviction processes going on in the judiciary system. And what tries to do is to solve this conflict through a negotiation process.
When this conflict is dissolved we try to reach an agreement in which the population that occupies this land we are talking about areas with 300 to 8,000 families more or less they through a series of contracts and urban improvements they buy their plot of land so they avoid eviction. Eviction is what we call a kind of poverty trap because people have been living in these areas for 10, 15, 20 years and when they got evicted they immediately lose all the assets that they had built in these lands. So when we reach an agreement there’s a very important impact for these families.
It’s an structural impact that goes through generations. So, and then they start to buy these plots of lands that they pay you normally between 20 to 25,000 he eyes which is today be around4 to $5,000 over a period of 10 years in monthly installments. When they when there is disagreement the land can then be subject to infrastructure improvement. So sewage companies, electricity companies, the municipalities can enter these lands because before they were not entitled to enter into this land because it was a private land in the conflict that they enter and they build infrastructure.
So there is a lot of value delivered to these families to the municipalities because it started to be a legal land. They can then start collecting taxes and to the cities in general because it transforms slum into a neighborhood with all public equipments and so forth. So this is the model of the hanova. Thanova today operates in Kurichiba, Sao, Belizi and Fortalisa. And those are the cities we are in 38 areas working with close to 100,000 families in Brazil. So this is the model of which is urban conflict resolution and the Amazon.
Part of the knowledge that the HANA has accumulated is could be used to solve land conflicts basically remote sensing geospatial knowledge and so on so forth. But I think other parts which is related to a community that occupies a land are not that much applicable and even and it’s an important point there is no clear legal infrastructure or legal nor a normative legal system to solve legal conflicts in the in the Amazon. Whereas in the cities there is a legal u law. There are laws that you follow and that you can solve this these conflicts.
Jonah:
I see a big future opportunity for exploration research there. But I’m going to move on. Let’s go to different areas of your portfolio. You guys have moved 150 million to the Amazon over the past 10 plus years. It’s a really significant number. We’ll we’ll look at some of those larger investments. Tell us what you have invested in the sector of Amazon fish and aquaculture and how did it go how should it go in the future? What’s your advice for future investors interested in that sector?
Paulo Belotti:
Okay. Yeah. Well, the idea we invested in a company called Marita in 2008, 2006, 2007 and that company wanted to develop fish meat white meat, boneless meat, healthy meat from the Brazilian biodiversity produced sustainably to the world. So we started with pintado and mros and then we incorporated other fishes but basically piru as well in the state of piroubaki and pint in the state of we operated the company for quite some times and it got sold to a cooperative from par from the parliament state it’s a I think it’s a tremendously interesting business.
It has a lot of impact because it’s a long value chain. You create a lot of high quality jobs. It’s a science and technology business. You have to invest in genetics. You have to understand how fingerlings can grow. You have to investigate nutrition management of the growout phase marketing processing sales and marketing. So it’s a very long chain business, complex business, but it adds a lot of social impact because it create very good quality jobs and environmental impact because it goes hand inhand with the preservation of forests if you do it correctly.
But the business is not that easy. The challenges of this business is basically the competition that you face with other species like salmon and tuna at specifically salmon in retail chains. And you also compete with fishes got naturally in nature right fishes that are not produced in captivity. So there is a price point that you can go to put your products that is not very high. That is not very high. The Amazon is a very far away place. I mean there are logistic issues manpower issues and so forth. So it’s not that easy to obtain a very profitable businesses but I do believe that in the future long-term future it will be possible to create a healthy business in this area if we invest a lot in genetics and marketing market segmentation and the promotion of Amazon fishes specifically paragraphs.
Jonah:
Great. So for those long-term investors out there list opportunities for outsiders I hear that word genetics a lot of investing to really scale. Let’s go ahead and move to another industry. Tell us a little bit about your investment in bopilica and carbon markets.
Paulo Belotti:
So yeah, that was a very interesting investment. Bophilica manages. Bophilica does not own land but it enters into partnerships with farmers, land owners, communities in the Amazon region basically in which we produce carbon and market and sell this carbon and for that we get a profit share a revenue share on the proceeds of the carbon sale. Bilica today manages it’s I think it’s going to finish the year with almost 2 million hectares in the Amazon managing these areas producing close to 2 million tons of carbon every year we sell 30% of this in Brazil and 70% abroad 100% as voluntary markets we invested in b in 2009 to 2006 is six7 it was a very difficult business because carbon markets even voluntary carbon markets took a long time to develop.
But now with the ESG movement there are many companies racing to zero and buying credits to mitigate their emissions. So bopilica in 2018 started to see some growth in the its operations 19 it was a very good year 20 it was an excellent year and 21 it’s also going to be a terrific year and we sold part of the company in a secondary and primary transaction toiparip is a Brazilian environmental company that is listed in bet the called extra stock exchange and we reduce our position from 35 to 16%. And the company got a lot of money to invest in new types of carbon.
So we are now entering originally it was only red carbon. Now we are entering into blue carbon. We are entered into restoration carbon and carbon from agricultural activities as this is a business that it’s going very well now and it’s a success story.
Jonah:
Great and as compliance carbon markets come to life in Brazil hopefully someday soon and elsewhere it’ll only begin to grow more so let’s go ahead and move to One of the last questions for me and then we’ll get into taking questions from the wider audience. I want to ask about sustainable forestry management in Brazil and your investment in Amata and what went wrong. And then finally and you can speak to all these questions in one answer. Wh why is it so hard for legal Amazon sustainable forestry managers to compete with illegal loggers?
Paulo Belotti:
Yeah. Well, we Amata is not a direct investor from MOV. Some of our LPs invested in Amata and we participate at a board. Participated a lot in the investment process, the governance and we are I am still a board member in Amata. Amata has four operations. We have an operation in Barana and another one in Matrosu Pinos and Paliptos. Very standard operations. And then we have an operation in Honduran sustainable forest management and plenty of natives trees in the state of par. Uhuana they go very well. Par it’s going okay.
It’s not an excellent business but it’s going okay. And Hondonia which is the sustainable forest management operation had problems first in the market because it’s very hard to compete with illegal wood illegal products because they are priced very low so it’s very difficult to develop a market segments it took some time for Amata but he did succeed to create this market segments basically in Europe and part here in Brazil and some part of it in the United States. That will pay for well done, well produced, well harvested wood products in there.
So that it was very difficult because legal competition. But then with this new government that we had in Brazil, there was a deterioration of law enforcement and Amata’s operations got invaded by illegal loggers. So it started to be very hard for us to maintain our team operating in the same area that illegal loggers were operating. It was basically difficult even the risk of physical injuries, conflicts and so on. So we decided to reduce substantial operations in Hong Kong because of that. So basically it’s very difficult to if you ask me would you invest today in sustainable forest management in the Amazon very difficult because very difficult to compete in the market and second very difficult to maintain the integrity of the forest that you manage or own.
So that’s the story.
Jonah:
Great. I’m going to ask one more question and then I want to invite those else on the call to raise your hands to indicate your interest in chat. We’ll have a full half hour of questions with Paulo. So last question for me Paulo. I have been advised that one reason why investing in the Amazon is so difficult is because of the lack of diversity of financial actors in down south in Sa Paulo. You have angel investors and venture capital and private equity investors waiting in the wings until a business is mature enough to buy it up.
And so the angel investors see liquidity, you know, sometimes three, four, five years away. What is your advice about how to improve the financial ecosystem in the Amazon to attract more investors?
Paulo Belotti:
Well, I think the first thing is that it’s I mean it’s very difficult to start operate and be successful in a business if the legal environment is not enforced. So this is one precondition we have to have enforcement of the law across the board in the Amazon. Okay. Amazon is very big. You have areas which you don’t have problems with that but you have other areas as I was mentioning to you in sustainable forest that’s so that this is my first wish in the wish list law enforcement second I think carbon markets I think carbon markets either voluntary or regulated markets when they pro.
I believe they will u send a strong signal to investors that an investment in naturebased solution in the Amazon together with carbon is really attractive could be really attractive. So I think one the second wish in the list is to have a strong well functioning carbon market here in Brazil or elsewhere.
Jonah:
Great wish list. Okay, any questions? Feel free to just come off mic and ask. Hey Jonah, this is Bobby Kia.
Jonah:
Go for it, Bobby.
Bobby:
Hey. Thanks again for the presentation and my question is about if the group is at all familiar with Open Earth Foundation being led by Martin Weinstein. They have a an ongoing pilot to look at nested jurisdictional accounting framework to connect the voluntary carbon market into the NDC Paris aligned reporting framework for Brazil. And I’m not I’m I can’t speak exactly to where they are, but I think in that process, but I’d love it if anyone could share thoughts around whether they’ve heard of them and whether they’ve heard similar attempts to connect the private and the public reporting particularly in the Amazon.
Thank you guys.
Jonah:
Paulo, I’ll just add one layer of question for you to respond and then maybe even others want to respond. The Open Earth Foundation has a technology stack that can integrate diverse carbon accounting mechanisms to make the data interoperable which can breathe to life a lot of the cottage industry carbon investments and make them more internationally available.
Paulo Belotti:
Okay. The should I should I try to answer?
Jonah:
Sure. Bobby, Bob’s question.
Paulo Belotti:
Yeah. I’ve heard of open earth foundation terrific work and I think it’s I think it’s a it’s a very key point to account properly avoid double accounting of carbon credits in terms of voluntary NDC regulated markets. The last piece of information or the last paper that I read which was very interesting that trying to solve this issue of double was that a voluntary carbon should not count either for the country that produces it or the country or the company if the company is outside the country that is buying it and I thought it was a very clever way to circumvent this problem of the world country.
Meanwhile I think my personal view is that article six that is going to be discussed now in Glasgow and the issue of deb accounting and so on so forth it’s going to take a while to solve this. It’s going I think it’s going to take at least five six years for the even if we have article six it’s pretty well defined I think the agencies that you have to build in the countries the infrastructure the accounting infrastructure the rules the specificities it’s going to take some time and I hope the voluntary markets I believe the voluntary markets will continue to grow so the red credits rent voluntary credits today are 150 million tons a year and we believe it’s going to grow 10 times through 2030.
So I think it’s going to go in parallel voluntary and regulated infrastructure and then they will emerge in I think five or six years. That’s a humble expectation.
Jonah:
Great. Other questions or responses to Bobby’s question.
Julia:
Hello, thank you very much. I was actually ask you for exactly your prognosis on the potential of voluntary carbon markets and how far we will see that grow could see that grow. But as you already answered that maybe an additional question on sort of the business case of Bophilica that you shared. We have seen in many cases that the most difficult part for companies to actually access the potential of selling carbon credits in international markets or even local markets is to prove the additionality of their reforestation efforts, their conservation efforts.
I know that Bophilica has a great sort of technological edge to it with a lot sort of to show for, but if you could just briefly comment on what has been key to make it work for Bophilica. Do you see makes it work for companies out there that may be interested in also ex entering that type of market or maybe even like accessing that additional revenue streams to other more traditional businesses that may not be as technologically advanced as I know that Bopilica is.
Paulo Belotti:
Okay. Thanks Julia. Let me try to answer this question. I think the original bet of bopilica was in red credits and red today even if it’s a voluntary market it’s a pretty well developed market you have a lot of companies certification companies that keep track of credits produced credits sold what credit is are what’s the word in English opposant retired credits or are not retired. So even the market is voluntary but it’s very well organized. So what Popilica does is that we follow strictly the methodologies of VA and try to obtain certifications.
We do the both certifications VCS verified carbon standards and CCB community and climate and biodiversity standards. And then if you follow these processes and methodologies and get these status additionality is proved. Of course you have to leave through the project and through a series of auditing and certification a third party then can issue in fact if you had additionality or not and then you can sell the credits. So this is what happened in red and I think it works pretty well and it’s very serious what they do. Other carbon markets voluntary carbon markets such as blue carbon or agricultural carbon credits or even restoration credits are now getting up to speed regarding red credits.
I think so blue carbon and restoration and I think it’s they are today at a stage that red was six seven years ago but they will they will be able to develop themselves. I think the methodologies sampling processes are going to be well established and well accepted by buyers. What the what we think in bophilica today is that if you have this methodology you did a proper certification auditing the market will buy it. It functions extremely well.
Jonah:
Great. First next question u Bruno Kau and also when you ask question please introduce yourself some of the call might not know you.
Bruno:
Sure. Hi Joanna. Paulo excellent work and well my name is Bruno Ku. I’m from Bain. I’m an a green entrepreneur here and work in different sectors of the economy with different business and Paul we have a lot of challenges to carbon business and if you can could you could you share with us some methodology what kind of calculation today you can use to measure the carbo sequestration for example if I plant agroforest we have different species there sure today we can do a calculation u to approach this kind of context and if you can to share with us and how what kind of models you are thinking of monetiz monetization of environmental services.
Paulo Belotti:
Okay, Bruno, thanks for the question. Yeah, as I was mentioning before, I think credits from rel to nature-based sequestration or restoration. The methodologies are not well developed at this stage. As you correctly pointed out, there are challenges. But I believe that in a couple of maybe one or two years the methodologies are going to be settled and the methodologist will determine how you measure how you sample how we evaluate the growth of carbon sequestration over time I think it’s very difficult to sell up front you have to first build sequestrated carbon and then sell.
I think that’s the way the market will play out. But I believe it I mean my suggestion I’m not sure if you follow Vera the institution that is doing a lot of work in methodology development. I can even speak later on and I can connect you to the right people so you can u understand the discussions and the issues that they’re dealing with in terms of methodologies.
Jonah:
Great. Bruno, did you have a follow-up question?
Bruno:
Sorry about the monetization of environmental services. Do you have some examples to share?
Paulo Belotti:
Oh demon sorry demonetization of environment but today I what we are able to do is car I mean you mentioned other environmental services like water or biodiversity. The main environmental service that we are able to sell today is carbon. When we add this u certification CCB community and client climate and biodiversity you can have an overpric you can have a better pricing so you will be adding biodiversity and community to the to the carbon but it’s basically carbon that we are selling today we are developing researching trying to innovate and develop top markets for other environmental credits as biodiversity and water but we are far from having substantial transactions in this.
Jonah:
Great any other questions feel free to just come off mic and ask I have a question, Paulo, and it has to do with time horizons. You guys are long-term investors. What is it that allows you to do that? Is it because you have really patient capital partners that you work with? What’s this what’s what’s the secret?
Paulo Belotti:
No, we use u a structure an investment structure in Brazil that is called FIP. It’s an investment fund for private participations in companies for equity or convertible debt participation in companies. And the whole investment thesis is that we invest in a company at stage A and we want to bring the companies to stage B. When we have eventually a liquidity event or liquidity will happen over time when they pay the interest in the convertible B. So that’s the whole story. We normally our funds are not very large. We are talking about $25 million 304 $40 million funds.
So we invest in companies at the small early stage the VC type of companies and in this naturebased solution space we believe it takes a while it is our experience that it takes seven eight sometimes 10 11 years to reach a liquidity point the liquidity point and well legislation allow allows us to do this in Brazil and we are upfront with the investors. So the investors are long-term investors, patient investors. They are not going to have big liquidity in a short or medium term but they could have important liquidity in 8 n 10 years.
What we try to do is that we invest we buy minority stakes in companies relevant minority stakes between 25 to 35% and we actively participate in the governance of the company doing basically four things. We help the entrepreneur develop the strategic priorities. We help the entrepreneur to identify, attract, allocate and retain good quality human capital. Third thing we help the entrepreneur over time to leverage our capital attracting other capitals either that equity private equity funds that will bring not only money so financial resources but also knowledge independence reputation and networks to the companies.
And the fourth thing that we do we try to develop a very disciplined governance processes. So we invest in the minority we buy a minority stake always through injecting capital and we do these four things over a period of six seven eight nine years. Trying to build a very robust solid sustainable business financially sustainable and with relevant significant environmental and social impacts. When we are able to do that we can have liquidity but it takes it takes some time. It takes on average 10 years.
Jonah:
Tatiana.
Tatiana Alves:
Hi Paulo. Very nice to see you again. I have a question. We already spoke a couple of times before but I think I wanted to hear from you. You know what is the kind of capital that is still missing in the region? What are you know the companies that you’re working with? You know the your market scoping your interactions with the people that are entrepreneurs in the region. What kind of capital are they looking for and what do you think are the barriers that they face in trying to get these resources for their businesses.
I think a naturebased solutions blended capital philanthropic capital could play a tremendously important role at this stage in two three four years from today to the future and that’s I think it’s the space of time that we need to develop better the carbon markets when the carbon markets are really developed, private commercial capital will flow very aggressive to the region. Today this private commercial capital is not flowing to the region because the business are risky. Some of them they use business models that are not yet proven h and the returns are very long-term.
So I think the combination of blended finance with private investment today will make a tremendous difference in the ecosystem impact ecosystem or investment and nature-based ecosystem in the region. Blended meaning having concessional capital providers which are prone to not receiving any kind of returns on their investments or that are you know ready for actually losing part of the principle as well. But I also gather that you’re also talking about what Jonah mentioned before patient capital, right? So, long-term debt at the end of the day or not true because I think that in at least in Brazil, you know, some of these, entrepreneurs could have access to shorter term capital, but maybe not so much long, meaning beyond 8 years, 10 years or so.
Paulo Belotti:
Yes, I think it’s very patient capital very junior capital. I mean very junior debt that will get repaid in years 8 9 10. I think this is lacking a lot in the region.
Unidentified participant:
But.
Paulo Belotti:
And large volumes and large volumes because I mean I was just making a calculation the other day if you if you want to do agroforestry system restoration for example 400,000 hectares a year in 10 years you do 4 million hectares which is 30% of the of the aim of Brazil probably we going to restore 12 million. So if you take 30% of ages system 400,000 hectares a year you are talking about 8 billion to 10 billion AI a year of investment. So it’s is 1.52 billion dollars a year. This is this capital is not available in the region today.
And I think blended finance has is a very important could play a very important role.
Tatiana Alves:
Well, concessional yeah concessional capital providers they say so much about you know ways that we need to put in place to protect and restore the forest. But then when you knock on their doors asking for that concessional capital well it’s not really you know what they have to offer. So yeah, it’s a pro it’s a big challenge and I think that you know we really need to sort of be hammering them, you know, and saying back, well, listen, yeah, we need that. So please do that. Don’t only say that you are a concessional capital provider if you’re not.
So yeah. Okay. Thank you, Paulo.
Jonah:
Tatiana, could you just introduce yourself very briefly to the community?
Tatiana Alves:
Sure. I’m Tatiana Alves. I am the director for sustainable finance and markets at Palladium Group, which is an impact consulting company. I’m also the fund manager for Selva, which is a fund that aims to provide long-term debt to entrepreneurs in the Amazon region.
Jonah:
Great. Thank you. Paulo, I have a quick question for you and then I think we should invite Bobby to come on and talk a little bit about their long-term plans. Can you tell us about some of your future plans for agroforestry investing?
Paulo Belotti:
Yeah, well, we are raising a fund. We are in the final stages of raising a fund. It’s a $40 million fund to invest in degraded lands in the Amazon to recover the graded lands and this is going to be do be done basically with agroforestry systems. We invest in companies and we are trying to match this capital this VC type of capital long-term patient capital with blended finance and healthy long-term facilities that facilities to scale up agroforestry companies that are implementing basically kokua timber products short-term crops as well and the states of par mugosu and hondora carbon is an important part of this of this revenue stream and that’s why I also mentioned that well-developed carbon markets could facilitate a lot the attraction of private capital to.
Jonah:
Great Bobby would you be willing to mention your catalytic capital And you’re on mute if you’re there.
Bobby:
Yes sir. Absolutely Jenna. Thank you. Just briefly, I mean the peace department which I co-ounded in January with my Nexus co- James Stern has several initiatives and one of which is around interfaith ecology and creating a moral kind of compass around the need for ecological preservation and bioexistence. But then there’s this there’s a thread around financial and infrastructure and legal infrastructure that I’m working on that involves you know our former my former employer and our partner the World Bank’s International Finance Corporation. And so we’re in the process of constructing a two-part endowment.
One for investment capital and one for catalytic capital. And the way we’re defining catalytic is exactly the way Tatiana just did in terms of not just being patient but also being willing to take you know forego returns willing to provide liquidity in the event that’s needed and so forth. And so the opportunity we see is to be able to plug the catalytic capital endowment as needed in projects and facilities that either need subordinated positions or you know or as I said liquidity facilities and other reasons. And so as we build out partnerships with the IFC, it we’re trying to identify through our network of allies like the World Bank’s climate investment funds and other partners in the private sector who are creating for lack of a better word carbon explore codes and understanding how we can partner with car digital and carbon providers like the Open Earth Foundation to you know to really start putting catalytic capital to work in these longer term projects that like you said like everyone’s been articulating these projects require a new level of thinking and flexibility and the challenge of aggregating the capital on the front side is really just being as we see it is the challenge of articulating the vision for what it can all do together and so yeah we’re standing ready to help.
We haven’t yet raised the amount that we’re looking to raise, but we have good backing. And so I’ll just leave it at that and happy to answer any questions.
Jonah:
Great. We’ve got two minutes left. Any questions for Bobby or Paulo?
Fernando:
Yeah, if I may jump in, please.
Jonah:
Go for it.
Fernando:
Hey, I’m Fernando Tunes. I lead government affairs for Salesforce Brazil. Thanks for the invitation, Jonah. So just curious about if you have any direct relations with the governments. It can be a subnational scenario or federal one. You just mentioned Paulo about BNDS. Are there any other public private initiatives on your pipeline?
Paulo Belotti:
Yeah. Well, we interact a lot with the Amazon states, the government of the Amazon, specifically with PA and Hondon as well. We interact a lot with them. I know they are very trying to build up a very progressive agenda. Par and especially a has been doing many things for a long time now in these areas. And I think they are going to be ready really ready to mature in the next one or two years. It’s we are going to see a big change in the opportunities that state governments are developing in naturebased solutions.
Fernando:
Many thanks Paulo. No, just because Salesforce globally speaking is a great investors in terms of leaf coalition and other reforestation efforts or like one trillion trees is one of the founders companies but well let me know if you need some institutional support as a tech company that cares about sustainability or car carbon markets creation. We also have a great product in terms of tracking the your car carbon production inside your company or in a state level too. So let’s sync afterwards.
Paulo Belotti:
Thank you.
Jonah:
Great everybody. This brings us to the top of the hour. I’m going to leave the chat room open for just a few more minutes. I’ve got another call and unfortunately this is the line that I have to do it on. Paulo, thank you so much for joining us. I think we’re all super pleased and inspired by your work and I encourage everybody just to take last couple minutes to share in the chat. You have any final words for us, Paulo?
Paulo Belotti:
Oh, thanks a lot for the opportunity. I was trying to take notes about the comments here. They are all very interesting, exciting opportunities. Thanks a lot. It was a great opportunity for me and let’s keep in touch. Hope everybody takes care.
Jonah:
You too. Thank you so much.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you Paulo. Thank you Jonah.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you. Bye.
Unidentified participant:
Bye.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you all.
Jonah:
Thanks everybody. Take care. Bye. Thank you.