Microphilanthorpy in the Amazon

Maria Amalia Souza: Microphilanthropy is not easy. It is the process of investing small dollar amounts in strategic projects. It is especially challenging at scale and in a region as complex as the Amazon. But Casa does it. The Casa Socio-Environmental Fund unites local leaders and large global foundations, offers small grant capabilities, and supports sustainability, justice, and community-level protagonism across South America, with a special footprint in the Amazon. Maria Amalia Souza joins us to tell the story.

Recorded October 5, 2020

WATCH:

  • Maria Amalia Souza — Casa Fund
  • Jonah — moderator
  • John
  • Lars
  • Juliana Santiago — former head of the Amazon Fund

Jonah:

Hey everybody, welcome to the 13th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. Might be the 14th. I’ve lost track. This is a weekly call series. We are dedicated to advancing economic development of the Amazon rainforest region. We’re talking about all nine countries, not just one of them. Our goal is to it’s a four-part strategy improving investment opportunities in the region and the amount of money and the quality of the money coming into the region. Second strategy is rule of law. Third strategy is carbon market and ecosystem service payment innovation. Our fourth strategy is investor education and it’s in that fourth strategy that these calls come to exist.

They are recorded. We are in the process of editing them for rebroadcast as a podcast series which we expect to be popular. Some extraordinary content and discovery that has come through these calls. This week we’re going to hear from Amalia Souza, or depending on how you present her Maria Amalia Souza, with the Casa Fund. And we’re also going to hear from John Comey, who also represents multiple organizations and he’ll give more background but primarily the Global Landscapes Forum. Amalia the floor is yours. Who are you? How did you come to join us?

Tell us about your Amazon work.

Maria Amalia Souza:

Hello. Well, I am a Brazilian who spent about 10 years in the US in the 80s just about when a lot.

John:

Were you kicked out.

Jonah:

I’m gonna put John on mute.

Maria Amalia Souza:

So, and [Moderator: Keep going.] When a lot of international environmental groups were getting set up to protect big forests like the rainforest action network with the international river Earth Island Institute, and I was involved with all of that in the 80s and just right in the beginning of my college years in California I went I met an indigenous leader in Brazil and I realized ized there 35 years ago that money wasn’t really getting in the hands of the most important guardians of these important places. So I started working with indigenous peoples with the rubber tappers with the alliance of forest peoples.

I ended up coming back to Brazil just to do that to try to mobilize resources to get to their hands. That’s all a very different logic and it’s not just resources, philanthropic resources, but it is visibility and conditions for groups like that to be able to find their own solutions, to articulate their own solutions and to implement them, not having somebody else tutor them always, right? You have which is kind of the practice the standard practice that somebody around them will access resources and then they will propose something to implement for them.

So along the years and the 35 years I’ve been working with this we started we have a little bit of a history. So if I could just I want to go through a very quick presentation. I just put numbers there and then we can share so I don’t spend a lot of time telling you the history. We just wanted to show you kind of the body of work that we’ve done as historically and as Casa fund for the last 15 years. I think these numbers will be very helpful in understanding where we’re going and then I want to discuss some ideas and some learning some lessons that we’ve had about the kinds of investments that we have seen work and the kinds that are dangerous to do and you know maybe carry a discussion.

I’d like to do that more as a discussion thing. But let’s see if I if I can share. Is that working?

Unidentified participant:

Yes,.

Maria Amalia Souza:

You can see. All right. I’m gonna put myself out along the way. We actually just kind of changed our face and our branding this year. So, we’re just inaugurating this new tagline, but it’s because it really speaks to what we do. You know, it’s about challenges and about figuring out solutions together. So really brief history, we were involved with [foundation name unclear] back in the 80s and they were the first ones beginning to give small grants to local groups, community- based groups, small environmental groups that had never ever accessed philanthropic dollars because, you know, they were kind of invisible to philanthropy.

So this breakthrough brought together a discussion the ones that actually received resources and it’s quite like that still a little bit has a little bit of the wall has been broken but not all of it you know we have millions in the hands of very few large NGO either conservation or social justice NGO and there was a discussion between them early on is no if you are in a country that is most people are hungry. You can’t be just hugging trees and the conservation vision at the time back then was you know remove people fence off and protect forests and animals and that wasn’t really working in the discussion.

And so this generation of new environmental groups were actually figuring out solutions to improve the lives of people in the who are the main guardians and protectors of very important biomes on this on this earth and I know South America holds a lot of them. So anyway the historically then the founder of Damian Foundation founded a local fund here Francisco [foundation name unclear], a partner with Global Greengrants fund from the start then he decided to close down and the board who was made up of the very first grantees who began to receive some of the first grants small grants and made them visible and made them be able to grow and propose solutions And you know it’s been over 30 years and some are some of these early groups are extremely important leaders of a number of you know networks and protection including the Amazon of course.

So in 2000 we beca we all became an advisor to Greengrants while we decided to organize a new fund and that’s when Casa was born in 2005. So up from then to now I patched a little bit of numbers here because in our site we haven’t put up the low the current numbers. So a lot of it’s in our site. You can just check all these things. But up to today, you know, we have grown in the last five years 395% somehow, you know, struggling to make people understand that to protect important biomes, you really need to invest.

And that’s and I’m not just talking about philanthropic investment. I’m talking about any kind of investment that is required by the local communities that are engaged in a number of networks but that almost never access resources. So that is our focus and our niche. So in the last 15 years we’ve made 2298 grants totaling about 12 million 13 million. Just this year, we’re going to break all records of our history. We’re making just this year. So I think finally the you know the understanding of having to put resources in the hands of groups that need to be engaged in the solutions is a very powerful investment to eventually then be picked up by somebody else.

So we are kind of the first comers, the first responders in a way, not only about rights but solutions to people in important territories also creates a sense of not being vis invisible anymore. A visibility that brings them out of you know their sense that nobody cares. That brings solutions and that and the trust that they have to implement them. So this is just a map. These are just five years. We actually did a survey with a lot of our grantees and it was between 2013 and 18. So it’s not total numbers but it gives you a very good sense of how we work and how spread.

We were actually set up to fund whole biomes looking at the integrality of biomes. Amazon, the wetlands, the choco, the Andes, the coast, etc. Because you can’t, you know, save half of the forest or half of the river. You know, that’s not how nature works. So, this is why we became a South American fund. Some of the impact that we’ve researched, [Percentage unclear: captions say 167%] of our grantees feel that their visibility has increased. 63% used the funds for institutional strengthening and managing the processes. 56% strengthening and expanding their network of partners.

So the strength is in the system of trust. We make small grants but we make them in a way that one supports the other. So it’s it’s about learning and knowing the territory and it’s about responding to the real demands of the territory and that’s how we designed the fund kind of back backwards because we were actors in the field. We weren’t funders weren’t coming from funding institutions. Our logic was backwards was what needs to be done and what kind of structure we need to create. Some of our public just to give a know an idea 68% of our grantees of course with those grants those 2300 grants of course reached and benefited millions of people across the territory 68% of them are women 66 are young people 56 urban so you can have an idea farmers children indigenous peoples fishing communities agrarian reform settlers, riverbank dwellers, quilombolas.

You see how little of that you know a lot of these numbers reflect our ability to raise the money to attend. It’s not that we put the priorities. It’s that we try to be a bridge between big funders to make small grants with in and so we need to make agreements and follow criterias of our contracts and that’s kind of where this is reflected. Some of our programs also have to do with that. Of course, the Amazon right now is the biggest of all and we’ve been funding dozens actually hundreds already of groups, river and oceans because we also are like the ones because we have such a strong local network in all of these different territories.

We also are the ones that are able to first respond to some of the disasters. So the fires the and then after the disasters how to build back the strength of those communities. So we’ve been learning a lot about that and placing the right amount of resources in the right way is the key to all of this. Some of the strategic lines just to give an idea. And those that’s you know the climate change actually was we’ve been trying to raise more resources for that and since last year actually now has have increased a lot but sustainable solutions monitoring influency public policies and all kinds of areas protection of territories this is really key if you’re talking about the Amazon everywhere you know these people have there’s nowhere in the Amazon right nowhere that is not threatened that these populations these traditional populations aren’t threatened.

So once we’re talking about investing and solutions for scaling you need to also think where to start and where to start is actually where we fill the gap as a fund. That’s our purpose. That’s where we were set up to do cuz know as we come first then these groups become better organized and eventually they can then reach other partners. That’s one way. The other way is because of our local networks. We access these groups and these local networks of NGO’s of all sizes that work in these territories are the supporters for the are the link between them and us.

They will recommend grants. They have a strategy for the for the territory. So we can work together in complementing others other organizations strategies which is one of the most successful strategies that we use. So here you just have an idea of the kinds of territories and the percentages you know of sustainable consumption, environmental protection, social participation, defense of rights, community and institutional strengthening are some of the main the main characteristics of the funds funding that we do. Also we discovered that communities support themselves as well in a number of ways.

Local funds are the main ones. Local meaning national or Brazilian funds or funds in their own countries donations from individuals max sales of services and pro products. So we try when we make grants to figure out how much more they are bringing in of their own because what we are doing is investing in their in their capacity to appear in the radar. Of financial institutions of investors and of funders and once they are they move on and we have many we have many examples of that just to give you an idea you know the whole network we mapped some of their relationships and 39%.

Jonah:

I’m just giving you the two-minute warning.

Maria Amalia Souza:

Two minute yeah 39% of these groups have declared Casa has been the first grant they received. Actually, I was at the very end here. So, I was going to propose that we talk about this. I have some stories, but then maybe I can talk about them in later. But for example, [community name unclear] is one region of Amapa and they are the first the only native community açaí 100% certified vegan and sustainable in the world. They did it all themselves. Or Gurupá, which is the other photo there, you know these people were losing a lot.

I mean they were making they’re picking the fruit the açaí and they were having to sell to middlemen and making no profits. They prepared a project they asked for solar panels. They installed they had equipment to process the açaí, their income the women were leading it the income went up 80% the children in the schools or they’re selling this product are healthier they can they can grow. So if you have the local initiative, the local participation and the local guidance then you were making a really good investment and there are many examples that actually weren’t no didn’t do so well and we can look at them at some point but just to leave you with this message here you our essence, as they say: [quotation unclear in captions] [community name unclear], “which is our land, our home.

We would not have come this far had it not been for the organization and work of our community which is evident in our s symbol the union of our people around us. So that’s mostly the message. I will leave you. So then how do I actually stop sharing? Let me see here. Or can you do it?

Jonah:

Yeah, I think you need to do it.

Maria Amalia Souza:

Stop sharing. Okay.

Jonah:

So this is the moment we have about 10 minutes for questions and dialogue. Anyone who introduces themselves or anyone who would like to ask a question. I’ve basically put everybody on mute. So you have to take yourself off mute. It’s star 69 if you’re or star9 if you’re on a phone and I’ll go ahead and start off the questions. Amalia, can you tell us a little bit of your work with global foundations? Give us an example of how you’ve been able to open up their work in the region.

Maria Amalia Souza:

Yeah. Well, we so what we have we have a like a we are a bridge and we have two kinds of services, right? We were created to make sure that funders who understood the value of making grants to local communities in the level that is appropriate. They couldn’t do it themselves for you know probably know anybody who knows philanthropy knows how expensive it is to monitor and from afar and so it’s not worth financially for them. At the same time we saw because of our networks a lot of demand that was never going to be met not by international funders not by national funders and we wanted to make that bridge.

So we develop systems. So what we do mostly is that we can we are a kind of a we have a social technology let’s say of managing grants. So we receive grants. So anybody who would like to invest in a certain area in a certain kind of way that respects of course our mission they can we can work with them partner develop a criteria and develop a public that is of interest to that foundation and then create a process to reach those communities. That’s usually how we work. So we consult our network always grows every time that we have specific funding for a specific theme or region and we will from what we hear we will develop a plan that is that works for the funder and works for the communities that need to be funded and so we managed all of that.

We are kind of a buffer because it is right now but it’s been very difficult all no historically but right now impossible and dangerous for an international funder or investor to send resources to local communities mainly in the Amazon for many reasons. So because they don’t have accounts because they are in dangerous places because COVID now has kept them isolated and if they leave they endanger the whole community. So there’s a number of new issues as well as old that make it really difficult. So having local funds in local currency is crucial to really attend and reach these kinds of communities.

So that so we take upon ourselves the burden of all the management and we do the top auditing. You know we have everything we have we’re impeccable with the financial management and we’re managing a lot of money now. And at the same time we make it as easy as simple as possible as accessible as possible and educational for a community group to access funds.

Jonah:

Does great. Thank you. Does anyone else have a question? Go for it Lars.

Lars:

Thanks Amalia. As you know I’m a I am an admirer of the work you’re doing. The challenge of distributing small grants as you know is a lot linked to knowledge and to follow up. So when I now hear that you are with 500 projects last year have you increased your staff dramatically or how do you manage to really deal with all these actors in all those local circumstances?

Maria Amalia Souza:

Well, first of all is our networks, right? We have built over the years such a strong network of relationships of trust in territories that involve me now NGO’s as well and other funders but that the way we work is that we have yeah we increase not dramatically we have 13 staff right now and we add staff as we add contracts let’s say so we managed and So the system that we designed also facilitates because we don’t need because of the trust network that we work with and through we are very close to the territory we can monitor without having to travel all over the place which would be impossible right now anyway but because of the relationships just today one of the groups that we funded in [place name unclear], very complex place now we were waiting to hear from them but their communication was so complicated that one of our trusted friends in the region and advisor he just took up and went there and took a picture just we just got it today.

It’s we are so close to the territory that we don’t need to move around. What we do is see what’s the maximum number of projects per program that one person can or know can follow and can monitor and it’s and also we have an incredible database that is very sophisticated that was one of the main focus in the last 10 years but it’s so efficient now that we have a mapping very quickly of all kinds of indicators most of the of the proposals already go straight into the database. No one staff is responsible for different kinds of programs.

We have a very efficient system and that’s why we are able to do so much with you know it kind of sounds crazy and impossible but it’s been the design of the system that has is allowing us to do this because we have just we have 518 projects just this year but we’re monitoring the ones that are sending reports know there were 200 plus last year and so it’s it’s a continuous relationship but it works really It amazingly it works because of the design of the system.

Jonah:

Great. Juliana Santiago and Juliana, please introduce yourself when you ask your question.

Juliana Santiago:

Sure. Hi everyone. For me it’s good afternoon maybe not for all. I’m Juliana Santiago. I’m currently in the sabbatical at University of Florida getting my graduate studies and I’m the foreigner former head of the Amazon Fund. I was the head of the Amazon fund from 2013 to 2018 and before I left took my sabbatical here at UF. And Amalia congratulations for your presentation and I got really interesting about the type of funding Casa social is giving like you mentioned a lot of like a lot of times about the proposals and so I was wondering if the type of grant the type of funding you provide is like project grantori oriented or it would be specific oriented donation like for example for a purchase of equipment or if it would be micro finance or if it would be a little bit of everything.

So what is really the way you really work? And you also mentioned that you keep the money or at least I understood that you keep the greater amount of funding in the organization and you actually I understood at least now based on your last explanation that you transfer like maybe either in tranches or you or Casa social pay itself for the for the expenses that the community that is being supported. So just want to understand more the logistics of how Casa works with the communities. Thanks.

Maria Amalia Souza:

Yeah it’s first of all we are fund so we don’t execute any project so we make we a call for proposals that is spread through the networks that is very clear about what areas regions population etc. Our network of you know we’ll spread this in their network so that we actually access some of the most remote and inaccessible groups. They come up, we have a very simple form that they will fill out with help or you know of their networks or not. But and we will then we have a mechanism of matrix of ranking so that we it facilitates for us to select if we don’t have enough money to fund all of them and of course now we don’t anymore.

We will make a selection of the of the ones that we can approve. We take it to we discuss internally. We take it to our board. We approve and we pay the grant and then the amounts of the payments depend on the amount of the grant. Usually on historically we were the maximum grants were 15,000 [currency unclear], so $5,000 more or less. And we want to keep the majority of our grants in that level because that is the amount that actually is appropriate for a small group in experienced to learn.

You saw that we are you know almost 40% of our grants are the first time grants that group got and we do that in an educational way. So we require all the specific documents. We make a contract with them. Usually for those we pay 90% upfront and then we’ll pay 10% at the end when they send the final report. Now we have grants in the in the neighborhood of [amount and currency unclear; speaker corrects herself] 50,000 [currency unclear]. For those, we make payments of 50%, 40% and 10%. Just this year because we have had the demand we are managing some of the bigger grants for the Norwegian embassy also we are the strategic partner of Oak Foundation for their mid-sized grants So we because we have been partners, we agreed to make bigger grants this year that will go up to [amount corrected by speaker] 600,000 [currency unclear].

So this is a very new thing, and we’re having to set up a whole new system. So it really depends but all of it is grants. The group manages them themselves. They will report back. We have manuals explaining what we need report back. We will help them to understand the documents they need to save so that they are safe and you know the context [word unclear]. So it could be anything you know in terms of we look at the major you know the macro we have a macro vision of a territory.

So you look at the nine countries in the Amazon. What are the challenges? What are you know the problems? Who’s working there with the solutions? The larger organizations and who are they working with? Usually they are the link from between the groups they work with. So it’s so that the grants we make they are they’re how do you say connected so that you actually reach results. So one could be solar panels to improve the livelihoods and income generation. The other could be [protocol term unclear] or for life plans for communities which is one of the most important ways that groups come to the next level.

[Recording ends.].