Meet the JBS Fund for the Amazon

In September 2020, the world’s largest beef producer announced the “JBS Fund for the Amazon” and pledged R$250 million in support for the region. The fund will invest in three primary areas, including forest restoration, economic development, and research. Where did this historic generosity come from? What dynamics of investor pressure and corporate sustainability made it possible? What projects have been financed to date? What other corporations and allies have donated to the fund so far? Join us to learn and meet Andrea Aguiar Azevedo, the Director of Programs and Projects for the fund.

Recorded September 13, 2021

References:

Brazil’s JBS launches fund to foster Amazon preservation

XP, Aviagen and Overseas Resources invest R$5 million in the JBS Fund for the Amazon

JBS unveils “Together for the Amazon” program

JBS Fund for the Amazon Approves the First 6 Projects to Receive an Investment of R$50 million

Grow, Forest, Grow – A Tookit for investors concerned about deforestation – Focus on Brazil and the Protein industry

WATCH:

  • Jonah
  • Andrea Aguiar Azevedo
  • Rafael
  • Kathy Hamlin
  • Fiona
  • Barat
  • Colleen
  • Lars
  • Bruno
  • John
  • Merrill

Jonah:

Hello everybody. Welcome to the 56 call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series organized by the Amazon Investor Coalition. We are a project of the global governance philanthropy network and Nexus. Our goal is to advance force family economic development across the Amazon region of South America. I should was supposed to say economic development and the rule of law. This week we are featuring the work of Andrea Aguiar Azevedo and the JBS fund for the Amazon. Andrea, tell us a little bit about yourself and then I understand that you have a presentation to share with us.

Andrea Aguiar Azevedo:

Yes, thank you and I apologize for my delay. Okay, I am Andrea Aguiar Azevedo. I’ve been working for about 15 years on Amazon region issues such as environmental development and its relationship to deforestation. I’ve been working normally with mood stakeholder groups jointly with the private sector for several years. In my previous life, I work I worked as a researcher in an executive of nonprofit organizations in Brazil. I worked at Fundova and Conexus before coming to JBS fund for the Amazon. Currently I am the director of the JBS Amazon fund and I have a degree in biological science.

I have a master degree in economic management of the environment. My PhD is in sustainable development from the University of Brasília. And this year I took an exactive MBA degree from Fundon Cabra in Brazil. As you told me you asked me who where did me I had grow up grew up. So my dad used to be a cattle producer in Mato Grosso where I grew up. Is a state that is part of legal Amazon. And I am married and I have four kids. O a complete presentation. This is my life.

Jonah:

Great. Now, now feel free to go ahead and share your screen. And just so everybody knows of the remaining time left, about half of it is going to be dedicated to Andrea presenting and I’ll have a few questions then we’ll open up to questions for everybody.

Andrea Aguiar Azevedo:

Okay, let’s see. Can you see the full screen?

Jonah:

Yeah. Yeah, we can.

Andrea Aguiar Azevedo:

Oh, okay. Okay. So, I would like to introduce talking about JBS strategy. So, last September JBS took the leap and launched the JBS strategy for the Amazon which holds two main branches. The first one is related to JBS supply chain traceability and the second one is in regards to the fund itself. As you may know this year JBS launched the net zero strategy for 20 240. And yes I think that’s it. So the funding is part of the sustainable sustainability strategy. Okay. So and the traceability is in the business in the core business not in the fund.

In this way the purpose of the fund in the long term is to help conservation the Amazon as well as providing support for the improvement of quality of living of its populations and its economic development. The JBS Amazon fund has its own legal aspects since it works as a nonprofit institution have a separate governance from JBS company with external and recognized members as I will show you for you. It works with an approach of impact philanthropy using we try we are trying use blended finance with reimburse and non-reimburse resource and it intends to go beyond the JBS supply chains as you see on the right the fund has three main pillars of work the first one is conservation and restoration of forest the Main goal here is to foster an increase in cattle farming productivity for example small holders using these degraded areas.

As you may know 60 million hectares is degraded in the Amazon within Amazon. This pillar also intends to promote initiatives which can restore these areas using for instance agroforested systems called saffing in Brazil or other kind of systems. The second pillar is the social development of the communities is linked to we believe that with this in this pillar is the front where we can add more value to community businesses by connecting them directly to a broader range of consumer markets. Of course that we have a lot of bottlenecks here and we intend to help to overcome.

The last pillar is science and technology. We are talking about applied science and the goal here is really to support research and development and innovation especially for those areas which could be applied to foster aggregate value in the forest supply chain. Also we are looking for disruptive supply chain and new ingredients essences and others. Okay. So the beneficiaries are communities associations communities associ associations and cooperatives civil society universities and so on. The governance consists of a board of directors followed by a fiscal council, advisory board and a technical committee. As you can see advisory board and a technical committee they are very wellknown people like for example Carlos no is very small.

I am not sure if you are looking if you’re if you can see but here is Fabio Barbosa Marina I am sure that you know almost everything everyone here you can see the advisory board that in so this advisory board guide us on strategic issues such as the assessment of the project portfolio and keeping track of our strategic KPIs Our technical committee help us with the evaluation of each project. At least three of the these specialists of technical committee perform an evaluation and give the projects the green light to move on with the partnerships.

Joanita here on the on the left is the she is a former CEO of Sara food industry in Brazil bio famous and I am the director. Okay. In this slide summarize of our allocation strategy and the supply chain we are going to prioritize. So we are going to make assessment about bottlenecks and leverages of each supply chain these supply chains. We are going to work with and also learn with some projects that we have been supporting. This will create strategic intelligence and will bring about two important elements that we are looking for scale and systemic change in the supply chain especially the forest supply chain.

Those forest supply chain we intend to work with three kinds of supply chains. The established ones like livestock as I mentioned very common in our red clear areas but still producing low yields especially in ismo holder properties small holders properties and the expandable supplies chains are the ones that make use of the standing forests such as asai fishy cocoa and Brazilian nuts among others. We are looking for tourism, community tourism also. And then the last kind of supply chain we call disruptive is the one that normally will provide new ingredients as I told you and new raw materials.

In general, we don’t know those supply chains very well. This disruptive so it’s a very accomplished with the pillar of science and technology. We have evaluated more than 50 projects in this first portfolio and we have chosen six projects to start work on. These six projects will have a period of two to five years to be carried out and involve a donation around 52 million riis around $10 million. We select the projects looking for those that fit with the funds criteria as you can see in the right side such as self- sustainability scalability innovation social and environmental impacts local networking low or zero carbon initiatives and so on.

The projects in this portfolio are related to these sustainable de development goals that you can see but the main ones are no poverty, climate action, live or on land and the last one decent work and economic growth. Here we have the complete portfolio that has been approved so far. These matrix show us the chains and pillars where the project fits best. In green are those projects directly linked to the priority chains. In brown are those with those that improve the business environment. Okay. Our monitoring approach is very focused on results but we would like we also would like to learn about the process behind these results and of course to help overcome the main challenges in practical terms we generate a quirly KPIs report and we have an annual report of the results.

Lastly, our finance are audited by KPMG. More two slides and I finish. In terms of money, the JBS Amazon fund aims to make $200 million donation by 2030. The JBS group has pledged up to $100 million for each dollar the fund can raise. So to begin with they have invested $50 million for the first five years. Okay. Our funding model incompass first of all the private sector. We are looking for companies that could join this strategy pro Amazon together with JBS fund since we cannot wait only for governments to do something.

So it’s I would say that it’s a private platform robust private platform to do something together. So here is a call for action from the private sectors towards sustainable solutions for the Amazon. The second model we are thinking about in some sort of joint venture investment with other funds or governments. So if for example a national or international fund shows interest in merging its resource with ours, we may raise a thematic fund like some restoration fund for a particular location or a particular supply chain fund for small holders for instance.

So we are very open to create this kind of arrangements. Also we stimulate our applicants to bring together some of their counter counterpart resource. And lastly we have built an individual investor strategy through the peak pay application and others other applications. Here are our partnerships so far. On the left side you can see our implementation partners. Here we have community business and Joe’s public institutes of research. On the right side we have our co-founders partners. We have the pleasure of present eleno foundation aviaen overseas resources foundation as well xp investment.

XP is not here sorry. But they already set a compromise with the fund as the early movers to support the fund. So they these are our early movers and is that in a nutshell this is a brief history of the fund. It’s a long process to change as you know the market to find incentives to attract and create new businesses to strengthen public policies and as well to create value for commu for the communities. So it brings the Amazon region prosperity we hope without destroying it. So I really appreciate your attention and I can answer your questions.

Thank you. So I will let me let me take this out. Let’s see.

Jonah:

Sure. So I’m going to go ahead and just share a couple of questions. For those of you who are in the audience who would like to ask questions, please indicate your interest in the chat. And there’s a lawn mower outside my window, so you may hear a lot of background noise. So just a couple questions for me first. One thing that I think may be top of mind for a number of people, Andre, and we’ve communicated about this through email leading up to the call, is there’s a lot of Amazon philanthropy that gets at the link the link between deforestation and the cattle industry.

And how does the fund avoid conflicts of interest between potential grantees and JBS?

Andrea Aguiar Azevedo:

Okay. We are not going to invest for example in traceability cattle traceability. This is a issue that the company JBS company the business is working on. So what we are going to invest in cattle supply chain is to invest in location as settlements etc that we are going that we are we are going to work with small holders in this supply chain that need technical assistance and investments. So also I guess that as the fund as JBS pledged that the fund will go beyond your supply chain. So I think that in this field there is no conflict of interest.

I think that there is a sum of synergies. So I think that I don’t know if I answer completely but I think that it’s another element that can be a safeguard for any conflict of interest is the governance as you see which is formed by these external members and who participate in this selection of projects. So.

Jonah:

Okay great and others may come in with related questions. Another question. You guys are doing a lot of grants. Are some of your investments expecting a return on investment? Are you guys doing some impact investing?

Andrea Aguiar Azevedo:

Yes, we are thinking about this. So next until next year we are looking for to set not to maybe we are going to stud first but to set a fund or a fund of funds where we can we can attend like a seed business seed money, give some seed money without interest, for example, or even have some business that could be some interest. So what we are going to do is to set a fund to work with what we call a venture philanthropy and maybe a capital not philanthropy a venture capital fund.

So it’s something between these two kind of things but right now we are working only with not rainburst fat.

Jonah:

I remember reading in the materials preparing for this call that part of your investments in R&D and research and development are industry specific such as helping to develop better packaging perhaps for from produce coming out of the region. Could you tell us a little bit more what could the Amazon bioeconomy industry so to speak look forward to in terms of innovation that you guys might be investing in to help scale the whole region?

Andrea Aguiar Azevedo:

Yes. To start we are working with Embrapa. So is a Brazilian research company. I think that everyone knows Embrapa know I need to explain but Embrapa is a public research institute that has helped a lot to develop the agriculture in Brazil and now we hope that they do the same thing to buy economy. So we have agreement with them to research three fronts or two three fields. First is new ingredients or new ingredients looking for new vegetable proteins. Other thing is to how we can add value more value to the forest products and connect with some industries.

For example, especially not only in the Amazon but could be our best investment could be in the Amazon. When if you have a for example, we are looking for a bioplastic right now that works with sub subroducts of Brazilian nuts and there is a industry in man that they are very interested in to join to this arrangement to this to this set of research. And the third field we are looking for R and D is the new systems of low carbon. So what is species of trees for example that can absorb more carbon that could be could be part of agroforest system a for example.

So these are the kinds of things that we are looking we are looking to support in R&D and of course all of R&D and sc science and technology we look for the for the allong the supply chain. So we are looking for the beginning the beginning of this supply chain the on the ground they are on the beginning of this supply chain and they need to be connected with all sort of industries that could give some that could give could give more scale to these supply chains.

Jonah:

Great. Okay. First up, Rafael Volushian. And please introduce yourself too. Yeah,.

Rafael:

Thank you, Andrea. Well, Rafael from the Norwegian Embassy here in Brazil. Well congratulations for the fund and the presentation in itself and sorry for being perhaps redundant on the question but as you mentioned that the fund will go beyond GBS own supply chain. Does that mean that within the six projects it also includes some of GBS own small holders and will the fund be used to improve its supply chain like small holder supply chain efficiency and environmental compliance standards.

Andrea Aguiar Azevedo:

Yes. So we are going to improve the this is small holder yield and the environmental regularization but it’s not something with exclusivity to JBS company is that it’s supply chain there is not agreement between this project and JBS as oftaker did I answer your question have I answered your question is that you asked you did but so then within the six projects that you’re supporting so far there will be part of GBS supply chains and nonGBS supply chains as well.

Rafael:

Yes. Yes. Okay.

Andrea Aguiar Azevedo:

Yes. We have one project only one project from the six that are that cattle is included. The other is from is with acai fish and this with cattle is with cocoa and kettle. Okay, Raphael, you’re you’re good.

Jonah:

Okay, great. Okay. Chamlin, you have a question up. You’re you’re up next. I’m sorry if I mispronounced your name. Shamlin, cha m.

Kathy Hamlin:

Yes. Hi Jonah. This is Kathy Hamlin with USA Brazil. So that’s.

Jonah:

Okay. There we go. Welcome.

Kathy Hamlin:

Thank you. I mean I put my question in the chat box, but it’s basically just if I could ask a little bit more detail about what are the systems and partners that you’ll be working with on traceability. Because I think that’s a that’s a sticking issue right with JBS and also how is that going to be applied for the indirect suppliers that are the ones that have been a challenge right for traceability issues. Thank you.

Andrea Aguiar Azevedo:

Okay. Let’s see your name here. Charming. Okay. In fact we are not going to work at least at this first moment with traceability of scatter supply chain as I told you this is a issue that the company the JBS is dealing with they are creating a system using blockchain and so on I am not so informed but they are creating a system and after 2025 this system will be will block the indirect the indirect suppliers of the of the supply chain. Okay. So at the we are not working with this kind of issue unless the traceability of this supply chain a forest supply chain this we are looking for to work with like sai for example and others.

Jonah:

Okay thank you. Do others have questions for Andrea? Feel free to come off mute. Please, not all at once. I we have 45 people on the call. I’m sure others do. Fiona, feel free to come on and ask.

Fiona:

Thank you so much. I was just looking at you know you are also in Brazil based but I’m thinking about the nine Amazon countries and thinking where’s the scale what are the collaborative and how can we support you in finding alliances with other groups because we have many of us have been working on technology under our decarboniz.org or we are an alliance. We have groups obviously environmental lawyers and technicians and forest products as well as forest conservation, regenerative land entitlement projects as well as regenerative forest models out of Panama, Ecuador.

So how can we collaborate? Where is the open visions and values for us to join forces? Thank you.

Andrea Aguiar Azevedo:

Hi Fiona, thank you for this offering. It’s very interesting. We could we could exchange information. The fund the target of the fund unfortunately is only in Brazil, the Brazilian Amazon. But of course that we are very grateful to understand what we are doing in other countries that are forming the Amazon basin. So welcome to talk to be in touch and to call me to set some calls or visits u presential visits. Now we are beginning to do vi to make visits to do visits on the ground to our projects and eventually we can go in some other places and other countries to exchange informations and experiences.

So we are totally open to this kind of thing.

Jonah:

Next up is Barat followed by Colleen. Barat you’re up.

Barat:

Thank you very much Urea. Great presentation. Thank you very much. Now, now I know a lot more about DBS. The one question that I’m going to be asked by a lot of institutional investors, especially in the UK and Europe, because a lot of them read the Guardian newspaper in the UK and get really upset every time they read it and then come to me. Is isn’t this going to be seen that the actual fund itself isn’t this going to be seen as greenwashing by the biggest meat processing company and obviously carbon emissions company in the world now that’s not my question that is questions I know tomorrow morning when I speak to institutional fund managers because they’re motivated by u media will be asking me of why should we actually put some money in eventually into the you know a very good fund that you have set up.

Andrea Aguiar Azevedo:

Okay, Lars. No, I this question of course that people do this kind of question. I think that it’s normal. It’s natural. JBS is a is a big company. It’s the biggest in the field of animal protein or the second one, I’m not sure. So what I can first of all what I can see is that fund JBS fund is not a greenwashing because they are committed with other things. If they are not we could say this people could say this but they are committed with the this system of traceability. So they are doing this right now.

If for example if you’d like I could call for Marap and others here that could explain what they are doing. Second of all they launched the this net zero strategy based on size and it’s very hard to do for the for the size of the company. So they are they will give I would say transparency to what they are doing to what they promised they pledged. So in this in this landscape I can’t see the fund as a as a how say greenwashing but as a as a synergic or a complementaryary measure going beyond the company going beyond their own supply chain.

So my it’s my opinion but of course I’m not saying for I am not saying on behalf of the company it’s something completely separate to have an idea I don’t know exactly what they are doing I maybe I know the same the same information that you see in the media it’s not something that I am dealing in my in my day so but Hey, this is my opinion and we are doing a very serious work that in 10 years I am sure that will give some results structuring results to this supply chain especially the forest supply chain.

So I think that with time we can see that is not greenwashing.

Barat:

Okay, great. I might have to follow up with you because being a salesman I have to just sell this as a narrative to fund managers just to get them on a call to actually support this, you know, very exciting project going forward. So, Jonah, if you don’t mind, I might just send you a quick email to pass on. And then see how we can actually change this narrative for scared fund managers over in the UK and Europe, you know, to get this moving. Because one thing I’ve noticed today amongst the actual, you know, very intelligent, very a lot smarter people than I am is that it takes everybody’s involvement to actually save the Amazon, not just, you know, some activists somewhere in the middle of nowhere to actually change the Amazon.

It takes all stakeholders. So, thank you very much for answering that question, Andre.

Jonah:

Barrett, I’m happy to I’m happy to pass on a message, but just to be clear, the fund is a is a philanthropic thing. You mentioned fund managers. It is true fund managers do some philanthropy, but it’s mostly for-profit investing. Okay. Our triple play up next is Colleen, then Lars, then Bruno. And please before you ask your question, please introduce yourselves.

Colleen:

Sure. I’m Colleen Scan the Lions with the Governor’s Climate and Forest Task Force. Thank you so much for a great presentation, Andrea. Good to see you. And I am wondering how you’re working with subnational governments and what are the bottlenecks as well as the opportunities for achieving scale by working across entire jurisdictions as we work with nine governments in the Brazilian Amazon as well as a load of others. What’s your take on opening up that black box of working with governments?

Andrea Aguiar Azevedo:

Good question. And hard.

Unidentified participant:

It is a tough one.

Andrea Aguiar Azevedo:

Good to see you, Colleen. Yeah, I think that we’ve met when I was in at working at TIPA. I’m not sure last time. So, we from the fund our perspective is that we need to work with governments. Yes. We are not very sure how to work with the states direct directly. So the executive secretary from the from the coalition this coalition is one of members of our technical committee is Sira. Yeah. So we are looking for this new project this green recovery and we are assessing how we can collaborate in this new plan.

I guess that something like that is a better way to work with the states a plan that involves everyone. This is a way to work. The other way is dealing directly with each state. For example, we have this big project in par in the trans Amazonia road called it Amazonia that is exact that is being implemented for solidar and we need to call with the government about the environmental regularization about incentives for cocoa production in trans Amazon. So every this is a product that encompass 75,000 hectares and at least one 1,500 small holders.

So this magnitude this of project involves automatically involves the governments because what we are looking for at the first at the first step is how we can unblock some bottlenecks of this supply chain. So we don’t know all bottlenecks. We are studying right now four supply chains asai, cocoa, fish and Brazilian nuts and we hope that until the end of year we can have more clarity we can see more clearly what are the main bottlenecks and to see how we going to where we are we are going to put our energy our money, our people in business, community, business or other or in structuring measures in measures that for example we know that in the Amazon in the Amazon state the state of the Amazon they are the biggest producer of Brazilian nuts but they don’t have a laboratory to analyze to set to measure the aphletoxina that’s the main problem of this kind of product.

So this kind of bottleneck very structuring we hope to help but also the business itself on the ground. So we have no sure Colleen we don’t know exactly we hope that with one or two year of work two years of work we can see and we can we can go deeper in our strategy to understand where we are going to put our efforts together with governments I am sure. Thank you.

Jonah:

Lars.

Lars:

Hi, I’m Lars from Rainforest Foundation Norway. Thank you for a very interesting and very solid presentation. So you have a very ambitious fund. You have a very sort of strong advisory council. And yet I have a qu sort of speculative question to you in terms linked to what BAT asked you about in the sense that JBS is a very controversial company. You may know that the Norwegian government’s sovereign wealth fund you know the largest in the world withdrew from JBS in 2018 due to unacceptable risk of corruption. And in a sense you say that there is no greenwashing involved but what do you think sort of sparked JBS to set up such an ambitious fund and wouldn’t you say that if the fund succeeds but is detached from JBS operations doesn’t that sort of provide a certain cover for doing business not exactly as usual but still not up to world class standard.

Sorry for the importance of the question but Jonah, could you help me with the translating this question to me? I’m not sure if I understand everything.

Unidentified participant:

Laura speaks Portuguese. Bonus etc wash.

Andrea Aguiar Azevedo:

Yeah, I think I get I get I get your question. Lars, I guess but you mean corruption through the fund. This part I did not understand. I.

Lars:

Mean that JBS can do business almost as usual since they try to attract attention to their good deeds through the fund which are is detached from their normal business operations.

Andrea Aguiar Azevedo:

Okay. Solars my this is my opinion okay because I am not on behalf talking on behalf the JBS company but if they weren’t doing nothing anything about the traceability I would say that your hypothesis is would be true but they are doing a lot of things to overcome the problem of indirect deforestation. They do this they follow the direct deforestation since 10 years ago there they were following they were monitoring this. So now they give a new step to monitor the in indirect ones. So I guess that be about corruption.

And I don’t know what to say. Okay. But in terms of the deforestation, the indirect deforestation, they are doing they have to show to the people to the community civil society they will they will charge they will ask for them because they did a they did they did a commitment with the society. So I can’t see that the fund will be so bright and people won’t won’t look for this kind of problem. I think that they are synergic they are they need to go together. So if the fund is going so well and this traceability is not going so well I think that they will be they will be charged for this.

So I’m not I don’t see a problem itself only if for example fund is going very well and they are doing anything for traceability but until now we can’t say this.

Lars:

Thank you.

Unidentified participant:

Okay.

Jonah:

I’ll just add in one thing. These questions about reputation, greenwashing, reputation washing are many of the things that drive philanthropy around the world and are worth asking at a global level and are super certainly very relevant for this call and anyone who’s trying to do investor donor education needs to wrap themselves in these questions. So I think these are good questions. They’re they’re fair game for everybody. Bruno.

Bruno:

Jonah Andrea congratulations for your presentation and your achievements in your life. Very beautiful to see it. And well I will you I will use some hats as entrepreneur as investor and as partner in Amazon Bay green business accelerator. Okay. Well you talk about sometimes in donations and sometimes in investment. I know we are talking about philanthropic investment too but I’d like to understand what kind of instruments the fund will you use to invest or to do the donations or something hybrid for example.

Andrea Aguiar Azevedo:

Good question Bruno. I think that first of all the fund is a philanthrop philanthropic fund. Okay. But we are trying to do is to do what we people normally call of venture philanthropy is to one part or hybrid or blended finance to operate as blended finance. One part to foster a lot of things like for example technical assistance is a donation and one part that goes directly to the business community business or other could be seed capital without interest and come back to the fund to us invest in another projects.

So this is the idea the concept in general but we don’t have this instrument to the reimburseable fund we don’t have reimburseable resource so we are we are designing this with the some help of palagian we are designed this to see if what would be what will be okay I answer your question Bruno.

Bruno:

Okay I may be I try to call you to understand some details of this kind of this kind of instruments or discuss if some projects or companies would be available to become to receive this kind of investment.

Andrea Aguiar Azevedo:

Okay. Yeah. For nonreimburseable fund. If a private company for example catalyze a lot of small holders or like a integrate system that is fair of course we are looking for this kind of support. Okay. But we can talk in more details about your doubts your questions.

Jonah:

John and Morel, if you guys would like to come in and ask the questions you were putting in chat, please do so. And feel free one after the other because we don’t have how much time left. John Bruno, do you want to come off mute and ask your question live if you’re still there?

John:

Oh, I apologize. I didn’t have a question. It was it was already answered in chat. I apologize.

Jonah:

Okay. And Merrill did you w to come online?

Merrill:

Yeah thanks hi thanks for this opportunity and thank thanks for the presentation. I’m Mel Vandermark from finance coalition. I yeah I also have a question about the greenwashing. We actually recently criticized the JBS emission sustainability linked bond because we feel that there’s a lot of greenwashing in that bond itself. It has some a goal to reduce scope one and scope two emission intensity but not the scope three which is really the largest part of JBS emissions by JBS admission itself. It’s more than 90% of its emissions. So we feel that JBS should really do a bigger effort in reducing those emissions just like it should do a lot more effort in reducing its deforestation and we feel that JBS has been you know they’ve committed to mapping all their scope all their indirect suppliers since 2009 and that still hasn’t happened.

So I guess I understand you’re not JBS and it’s separate but still wouldn’t the money from JBS be better spent if it was all invested in making sure that it’s not involved in reforestation and let NOS’s do this kind of philanthropic work rather than JBS which is struggling to controversial companies.

Andrea Aguiar Azevedo:

I can’t see Mer is the your name I can’t see here. Yes, that’s it. Melo. Okay, Maro, thank you for the question. Yeah, I am I am I feel not so comfortable to say about JBS here to tell the truth. But again, I would like to reinforce what I asked what I said. If you are doing what they need to do, this is a contribution for society. The fund I mean they need to do what they had to so if they are doing this I can’t see any problem that a company is helping to develop Amazon to develop is indigenous communities and others I can’t see problem in this in doing this so this thing come closer this thing come together as I told the lawyers I think they cannot be separate fund is going very well supporting a lot of business community things are going well and about and about cattle and deforestation things are going bad so if they are go in the same in the same rhythm I would say I think that we have no problem that a company want to help communities and business in the Amazon other kind of business.

This is my opinion, personal opinion.

Jonah:

Great. We are at the top of the hour. I’m going to ask another question. And then I have a feeling that a lot of people are going to get off because the meeting of the concert is beginning. Andrea, my question for you is, how is donating alongside the JBS fund for the Amazon a way to leverage one’s philanthropy? You guys have persuaded XP investimentos to come in alongside you instead of starting their own fund. Explain to us the advantage of that.

Andrea Aguiar Azevedo:

There are two ways to contribute to the fund. The company or the other funds they can contri contribute direct directly to the fund and we choose the projects we are going to support or they can choose a project for example XP contribute to a specific project link it to credit unblock crediting and they are look they are monitor they will go monitoring this project with us so we can choose a project and support that project through the fund or we can put the money in the fund to be a partner or co-founder.

And also we can as I told you we can create depending on the on the amount we can create a third part fund a third fund or a third arrangement to do the to apply to support or to do some for example a specific fund to do what the fund would do. Okay. So for example Amazon fund when we have from norway Amazon fund and valley fund valley they were just doing some arrangement where fondu valley would put the money reimburseable money and the fund Amazonia would put the not reimburseable money.

So this kind of arrangement and others we are very open to do.

Jonah:

Great. Okay this brings us to the top of the hour. This is the moment where we convert into water cooler time. I’m not sure if Andrea will need to leave or if she can stay but others are certainly welcome to introduce themselves to have an unstructured conversation. I’ll leave the room open and thanks everyone for joining us.

Andrea Aguiar Azevedo:

Thank you Jonah. Thank you everyone. I’m not sure if I answer properly all questions. I need to go to the consultation concert also. So it was a pleasure to me and I have put in the chat here within the chat my email address and my telephone my phone. So be free to call us to ask things and if you would like to know more about the traceability of JBS, I put in touch you or whoever we would like to put in touch with them and they can explain better with more property.

So the net zero strategy also. Okay, thank you.

Jonah:

Sounds great. Thanks so much.

Andrea Aguiar Azevedo:

Bye-bye. Thank you.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, Ricardo. It’s only going to be me and you left me.

Fiona:

Hey, there we go. Hi.

Barat:

Hey, Fiona. How are you? You’re well.

Fiona:

I’m very good. So, just I know you were grilling up there. We’ve still got a but agreed and very challenging questions to be posed for a young woman who is representing a philanthropic fund. There we have it. So challenging by all means her position even of her elegance of being well educated and articulate it is going to be her challenge as she goes forwards. So and wellappointed but you know the opportunity is also to see you know I just heard in there and did you all hear it that palladium’s also hooked in.

So that’s the UK forest fund that’s being run by palladium now. So they are managing that. So that’s going to be again just a question on how far does the you know the funding or as we say how far does the meat go the rotten meat.

Barat:

Well yeah I mean hey you know this is Alice in Wonderland isn’t it? How far does the actual how far does the tunnel go down? But just to answer one of your questions from the chat, I work very closely with Alexandra and an because I run the investment unit.

Fiona:

Excellent. Well, that’s a vital part of it. We will then have our another meeting al together. As I was thinking of I have to go to Dubai so I don’t have to but I might be going through back through London again. And then our partners were just in London and they’re in Geneva and Netherlands because we set up a forest fund in the Netherlands as well.

Barat:

Okay, gotcha. Yeah, got you. Where are you normally based in the I’m assuming the UK, but I’m maybe not.

Fiona:

Oh, no, sorry. I’m actually I moved the family out of the US but we have an investment bank in the US as well as I’m an independent seed investor very small in forest and conservation for many years and micro finance and then we have the Netherlands BV as well as Swiss as well as I am sitting in Canada and I’m lucky like you at least I still have a.

Unidentified participant:

British passport too. Yeah, this is it.

Barat:

This is it. Yes, we will have to definitely catch up because there’s a lot of Yeah, a lot of things about greenwashing. And I and I got chucked out of my MP’s office this morning for saying to him that you know, that’s the MP and the Labour Party have absolutely no idea about climate change and your you know, your manifesto is not very good at all. It’s been written by a six former. So, that didn’t go down too well. So, I was asked to leave. So, I said, “All right, I don’t care.

I’m a political, by the way. I don’t really care too much about what these people say, but that’s just my usual rants that I have.” And I had Matt You put, “Do you know Matt Portman?”.

Fiona:

Yes.

Barat:

Yes. So, I had Matt sending me messages saying, “Say something, say something, say something controversial.” Because I’m not, this is my first call with the, you know, with the Amazon Coalition. I’m not going to get kicked out already, you know, but it wasn’t controversial because this is a obviously everybody else was asking the same question at the end is what about the greenwashing side? But anyway, I will well it’s what time is it? Just gone past 9:00 in the evening over in London. So I will take your leave and then you know see what we can do.

Unidentified participant:

Good.

Fiona:

Excellent. Well, thank you for joining us. I know that others have gone on to so the IUCN and the other meetings that are going on right now on the globe and so I am welcoming you to our coalition. I say ours cuz it’s everybody’s. And you know, the joy of being aligned with Jonah and with the team that are really working deeply on the research. And as you heard, this is our 56th call, which is quite phenomenal. And then we did two months nearly ago we did a summit where we had 400 people and it was very strong.

It was so amazing that you know for my side working deeply with the indigenous communities and with several investment groups on the other side. It’s was a an equal balance of visions and values and looking at governance and collective consciousness really which is the core of how do we get to do anything that can scale and how soon and how do we take the multistakeholders visions and values into perspective and Jonah is an expert at weaving this together. Yes, Matt told me about this because he was with TTI at that time and he said, “I’m taking a week off to well, he took two weeks off to do the Amazon coalition summit and he never came back.” And I’m thinking, “All right, well, fair enough.” But we, you know, we’re good friends.

So, we do talk now and then and we wind each other up about how slow the progress is, but you know, thanks to people like you, Fiona, the progress is happening. So you know well I’m only one small seed and I’m a volunteer on this advisory board and it’s really just eye opening even for myself to be able to talk with multiple scientists working we are also by the way but we are one of the ex-priseze top rainforest teams for the competition. So I put together during CO a series of women scientists, indigenous women leaders, environmental lawyers.

Nayara Tukano from the Tucano tribe in Brazil. Their indigenous communities hold the land entitlement for more than 260,000 hectars. And that’s just from her and her sister’s family side. And then the other three to four other branches of that family also. So we’re talking that the leaders that I’m working with, they actually aren’t just leaders, they are the land entitled owners of forests who have visions and values. And as I said, she’s a social justice lawyer, environmental lawyer. And the community is really outreaching to how do we structure you know really scalable solutions bringing in not just technology for those that want to take excuse me extractive behaviors but how do we make it constructive together so I’m open for a call together and absolutely yes and then sit through with an as well a little bit on the other side the sector that I’m also in is decarbonizing shipping.

Unidentified participant:

Ah right. Yes. You know this is the lucid catalyst guys and you know that came up in a conversation I had with a fund manager this morning about synthetic fuels and green hydrogen and blue hydrogen and all the wonderful things. Georgia the Georgian government the prime minister there is moving towards be making Georgia another u you know a the Saudi Arabia of green hydrogen because we’re developing the hydroelectric. This is nothing to do with Tai. This is an outside project of mine. And there’s a startup that you may be interested once it gets to beta which is taking all the data sets from the five major triggers of irreversible climate change which is obviously the Amazon, Antarctica, Greenland ice sheet and the Gulf Stream and the tundra the Arctic tundra.

Putting them all together, creating new models, and then basically putting those models out as scenario planning for corporations and governments and large nonprofits. The nonprofits will get it for free. Everybody else can get charged, but it’s scary to see one if one or two collapse, what kind of situation we’re going to be because I don’t think everybody understands how it’s all interconnected because it’s so complicated. But yeah, I’ll if you don’t mind, I’ll keep you in touch with those guys, you know.

Fiona:

Yeah, that would be great on.

Unidentified participant:

Very much so because as I see that onet.org has now hired some people down from the World Economic Forum to sit in Brazil running the outreach there. We also, I mean, now it’s just us on the call, but you know, we are actually in the finals of the finals of the World Economic Forum, but I actually had a big discussion with them this week, and I said, you know, I’m not sure your model, you’re financing this idea. We actually do the real work on the ground. So I said, you know, in fact, I think you need us more than we need you because you’ve got to get you got to put it really there because he’s saying, oh, you know, you’ve got this amazing group of indigenous women and scientists and we’re with FA Amazonas in Brazil, the top NGO there, Gaia Amazonas in Colombia.

And you know, I have my teams of the Schwar nation in Ecuador and teams of the other women coalition, KOA. And you know, it’s actually I would have said the opposite is they should have hired one of these existing organizations, not a new person with a that lives in Geneva to run it. I mean, I asked him and it was quite funny. I said, “Do you know who the Jakanu tribe is?” And he’s like, “No.” I said, “Okay, can I give you do you have do you mind if I give you a bit of Brazil’s history?” You know, like, “Did you have a three minutes for a little bit of update then?” You know, do you know who, you know, the Waroni people are?

Do you know who the Schwar women are? And what their values and their social systems are and how it’s very much a monarch range of you know like the butterflies they have held wisdom for thousands of years and so yes they’ve hired the wrong folks and that’s what always happens but instead of that I’m inspiring them to collaborate and reach deeper with those that need the voice and the place and also have the history and they’re like I said they’re all not all but many of them are trained you know niata is Tukanu is an environmental lawyer.

Her father changed many laws as a lawyer in Brazil as well. So, you know, these are people that don’t think them that they’re just smallcale protesters. No, they hold court, Supreme Court. Well, well, I mean, one other thing that may come into play next year, I’ve just proposed to Epic Games, you know, a games company that has a video engine that powers most of the video games and the environments to create virtual environments. I’ve just proposed to them to come on board with the new startup that’ll be looking at all the five different triggers to actually create virtual scenarios based on corporate data that we actually mix together.

So you know yourself myself we can actually step into a you know in a future scenario where let’s say the Amazon has collapsed or you know we don’t that’s not going to happen because people like you are there but if the Gulf Stream collapses what would happen to various cities and what have you. So because I’ve just you know I use Unreal Engine myself for you know video projects. You do. I’ve been talking to the VR XR people this week as well. So, so we definitely have a lot to talk about and you know looking at some of these larger scale use of it and so it’s very complex.

Yes.

Fiona:

Yes. Very complex.

Unidentified participant:

Unreal’s valuation is unreal.

Unidentified participant:

Yes, it is. It is. But I spoke, you know, I spoke I was put to get put I know quite a few people in Unreal and they put me in touch with the head of their space and defense simulation because they’re the ones who’ve got the raw power to create something like the Amazon, you know, in real time based on data that’s coming out from satellites and what have you. That’s the actual beauty of this new startup. It’s that they’re not they’re taking it very seriously. Yes, it’s for profit. We appreciate that.

And NOS’s will get all this facility for free as it were completely for free. So the Amazon what have you.

Fiona:

So is it utilizing ESRI ARGIS or is it like our other groups that were merging with like the Netherlands space agency because they have some of the top data and technology. I mean there’s.

Unidentified participant:

I just joined them and I need to speak to the CTO and I’ll find out what data sets they’re actually trying to access. I mean the ultimate would be to have your own satellites up there doing your own data, but that’s prohibitive unless you have a Elon Musk type evaluation, you know.

Fiona:

Well, and I’m still going to I will wiggle a little bit of Elon’s he’s going to have to juice up the Amazon for that asai berry that he likes to drink. So,.

Unidentified participant:

Right. Oh, there you go then. There you go. So, we can get, you know, Elon, just give us a couple of billion. You know, and Mr. Bezos, you’ve named your company after Amazon. You can give us a couple of billion as well, you know. So, but yeah, that’s not going to happen too soon. Okay, bye.

Fiona:

Thank you very much for your.

Unidentified participant:

Cheers. Okay.

Unidentified participant:

Bye.

Unidentified participant:

Bye.