German Investment Strategies in the Brazilian Amazon

Alexander Borges Rose: The German Corporation for International Cooperation, or GIZ for short, is one of the largest funders of Amazon conservation in Latin America. Alexander Borges Rose joins us to explain some of their investment strategies in the welfare of indigenous peoples, bio-economy entrepreneurship, forest financing mechanisms, land registration, and more.

Recorded September 21, 2020

References:

International Climate Initiative (IKI)

KFW – Germany’s development bank

Amazon Fund

WATCH:

  • Alexander Borges Rose — GIZ
  • Jonah — moderator
  • Jody Weiss
  • Atossa
  • Lars
  • Marina Campos
  • Cristina
  • Maria Franco — Dalbergia

Jonah:

Hello everybody. Welcome to the umpteenth, not sure what the number is, call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. Again, this is a weekly call podcast series. The podcast will be coming out soon. This is hosted by the Global Governance Philanthropy Network. Last week we had our big launch. Our website is now live, amazoninvestor.org, and we hosted a session during the UN 75 Global Governance Forum. Some of the people on this call were present. We had a good audience. The feedback has been good. This is a march to advance forest-friendly economic development across the Amazon region.

And this week we’re going to be hearing from Alexander Borges Rose, who works with GIZ, the German Corporation for International Cooperation. And looks like we’ve got a good turnout so far. Alex, I hand the car keys over to you. Before just before you begin, Alex, at a around 40, 45, 50 minutes through, we’re going to transition over to Amanda Gant, who is going to be telling us about her program, the Land Accelerator. Okay, the microphone is yours.

Alexander Borges Rose:

Thank you very much, Jonah. As Jonah mentioned, I am Alexander Rose, working at GIZ. I’m a project manager, and I’ve been involved with sustainable development in Brazil for the last 15 years here. I will try to share my screen, and talk a little bit about our work at GIZ in Brazil. Can you see my screen?

Unidentified participant:

Yeah.

Alexander Borges Rose:

So, GIZ is the Sustainable Development Corporation of the German government. In Brazil GIZ has been active for a long time. I have a little bit of the history here. It started out in 1962 actually with the first project. And there were lots of milestones like for example the production of apples, something very typical for Germany and we made it happen here in Brazil too. And the first apple production, sustainable agriculture, certifications, participative processes with cooperatives, with smallholders. So, it’s been it’s been an experience I’d say over the last 50-60 years.

These are all the milestones. We had several ministers here. Our Chancellor Angela Merkel was here in 2014 and 15 and acknowledged some of the projects. Today I will show you how the cooperation for sustainable development between Brazil and Germany is structured. Usually the points or the highlights or the topics are decided in the governmental consultations which happen every 2 years. The both countries get together and decide what’s really important or where’s the synergy between both countries and where can we help each other and complement each other. So, Germany’s connected in terms of sustainable development since the ’60s here.

But in 2008, the two countries signed a strategic partnership which is really diplomatically a high-level agreement of intense cooperation on different issues, you know, like climate science, environment, energy, business and trade, defense, social affairs, labor. We go on. So, the first question, why cooperate? We get that a lot because nowadays Brazil is not really a poor country anymore like it was in the 50s or 60s when the cooperation started. But Brazil is a big emitter of CO2 emissions. It’s got the largest biodiversity in the world as you know with about 20% of the world’s biodiversity within the borders.

Brazil has a very advanced legislation for access and benefit sharing which is important to the German supply chains as well. And the country has been committed to the sustainable development goals. For Germany, Germany as a country has committed to combat climate change on a global chain on a global range. As you know, Germany is pretty small so it only makes sense if you combat climate change on a large scale. And for this you need willing partners and who were committed to the same goals and to the same ideas you have.

So in this sense, Brazil has over this last 40 50 years always been a very good partner. Germany has a lot of green technology to offer and carbon-free technology. And in this sense, there can be a lot of knowledge transfer from one country to the other. This slide here I particularly like very much. It shows you the species. Brazil has 1.5 million species that are known. Of course, there are several thousands or hundreds of thousands species that we have not known yet in the Amazon or in the Atlantic forest. And while the Amazon is being destroyed, we’re losing these species without even getting to know them and knowing their benefits, for pharmaceuticals, for pharma industry, for cosmetics.

And if you see a middle a moderate climate country like Germany with only [species count unclear] species. So, for me this is this is pretty impressive, and it’s one more reason why we need to collaborate and support and cooperate with Brazil. These are the three major biomes or ecosystems we work in Brazil. The Amazon, of course you know, it’s it’s the largest biome in Brazil, the largest ecosystem, and it’s the largest hydrological basin in the world. And it’s got 1/5 of the known global biodiversity, hundreds of indigenous peoples, social issues.

Then we have the Cerrado, this is where I’m based, I’m based in Brasília, it’s it’s a savanna, but a very biodiverse rich savanna. So, it’s the largest biome largest biodiversity savanna in the world, and most of the big rivers they spring here in the Cerrado. It’s a very it’s very important really to maintain these river basins and the and the biodiversity. The third one is the Atlantic Forest along the coast, this is where most Brazilians live, São Paulo, Rio de Janeiro, and this is a biodiversity hotspot, very rich in biodiversity.

And unfortunately, only 12% of it is left until today, and there’s massive initiatives and calls for restoration. Here we can see the three biomes we cooperate on the map. The largest one, of course, is over 4 million square kilometers, the Amazon. Then in the middle we have the Cerrado, which is [area unclear in captions], and then the Atlantic rainforest going all the way up to the northeast and down to Santa Catarina and Rio Grande do Sul 1.3 million Just interesting if you see the size in comparison, even a smaller biome in Brazil like the Atlantic rainforest is about four times the size of Germany.

So it’s really it’s really amazing if you if you take a look at the size. Here we can see the three main programs we work with we work on. The biggest program is protection and sustainable use of tropical rainforest. This is where most of our products are embedded in. Our second program is the renewable energy and energy efficiency program. And the third one is cross-sector programs. These are usually global initiatives. And programs we work in Peru, Colombia, Bolivia and Brazil or in China, India, Brazil and Germany. Usually on climate. And then we have the transversal issues we’re working with.

Urban transformation, basically urban mobilization as well with electrobuses and other issues. Vocational training, biodiversity protection, we work with gender and human rights and of course with climate change. Here we have some expenditures per year. We have expenditures of around 30 million right now. The pledges are a little bit higher like 40, 43 million. And on this slide we can see that the tropical rainforest is getting the highest investment. When I say the investment, maybe I should make this a little bit clearer. GIZ is a government organization. It’s a government company and the owners are the German Ministry of the Economic Development [acronym unclear], and the German Ministry of Environment BMU.

And our shareholders, these two big shareholders, they basically give us the tasks and assignments to work, and the funding usually is from these two ministries as well. I will talk a little bit about the highlights of our program for protection and sustainable management of tropical rainforests. And within the program, we highlight four different themes we focus on. Green economy, this is where I work with, which is like building a bioeconomy, working with some with value chains in the Amazon like acai berries, like nuts, like fruits, like oil seeds, like all the products that come from sustainable productions like certification, like materials for cosmetics and pharma industry.

Then we have the main biodiversity, which is reinforcing or helping Brazil to protect its protected areas, that they stay protected, and they keep it protected, help the management of these areas with monitoring and direct management. We work with territory management, as I mentioned on Friday at the conference. In Brazil, the land reform has not been carried out totally, which means basically that most of the country doesn’t have land titles or registered to the land. In the Amazon, it’s even more even if I drive 20 km outside of Brasília here, there’s no land title anymore.

So this is called the land reform. And you can see this small holder lady is very happy with the project, and she got the environmental registration legislation and registration first and as a second step she managed to get her land title. So we are we’re supporting the Brazilian government in territorial management and land rights as well. And the last one is in climate protection in the broader sense with tutoring with counseling for legislation. Here’s some issues territorial management working with legalized land use implementing the forest code the new forest code from 2012 monitoring the system.

These are just some examples. Green economy. Basically building a green economy with sustainable value chains from the forest products from the forest or from sustainable chains like certification schemes and of course they’re trying to increase people’s income from the sustainable value chains and our belief is if small holders in the Amazon in the Cerrado if they’re receiving a decent income for their sustainably products they will not start in converting their land into pastures and they will not start to deforest because deforesting is usually quick money you can cut down your trees in your own your property and you get some fast buck.

So we’re trying to work with small farmers to use in the long term the standing forest as a source of permanent income as well with fruits with some vegetables but also with the wood itself. Climate protection. So we are working on helping the country to decrease deforestation which has been working very well, basically between 2005 and 2012-14. But unfortunately, over the last years, as you know, we have seen a rise in deforestation again. And of course, our idea is biodiversity preservation. Yeah, Brazil, as mentioned, is very biodiverse, extremely rich for fauna and flora.

And only the legalized land use and the managed land use, we believe, can bring them can keep this biodiversity safe, really. So, GIZ has been working on the preservation of almost a thousand endangered species. Research and innovation, we’re doing in our projects. Usually, we have one component on research and innovations, like new product lines, like, in this example, the [project name unclear], that developed a new latex serum from the rest products of latex production in Acre. And this is something new. The same we’re doing right now with Andiroba nuts, producing some new products for the for the for the shell of the Andiroba nuts.

And the same we’re trying to do with the açaí pits. There’s right now a problem in the Amazon with the açaí production. Nobody knows what to do with the açaí pits, which make up 90% of the fruit. So, solutions are needed. Scientific and business solutions are needed for that. We’re working with indigenous people, supporting them in the sense of land demarcation, land mapping, making sure the lands are demarcated and stay demarcated, and continue like this, so they can live in the future and preserve their lands. As you know, the most preserved lands today in Brazil are the indigenous territories and then second come the protected areas.

We also work with some offshore marine preservation. This project, for example, Terramar. It’s it preserves coral reefs. It works with some with fishermen on the coast. He let’s say the amateurs fishers on the coast. There are some very delicate areas like Abrolhos, very the large reefs in the south of Brazil. So, this is what this project is trying to protect. Our second big program is renewable energy and energy efficiency. I’m not in this program, so I would speak less about it. But Germany has a lot to offer as a country in terms of technology.

The focus in this sector is energy security, making sure the country produces and continues to produce more and more secure and safe energy and sustainable energy. Bringing in new technology like concentrated solar power, [technology term unclear] and wind power parks. This has been coming very strongly and with this comes also the demand of education of new courses for these new technologies of the new engineers. So, it’s kind of a knowledge transfer. And the last one is urban development. How to make sure you spend less energy or spend energy more efficiently in urban settings.

This is a project we have, [project name unclear], energy efficiency and sustainable urban development. Energy security. So, we are trying to leverage our investment by in additional investment in the public or private, which has been very successful in this project. They’ve been leveraging about 125 million euros. And they’ve been able to save a lot of energy, [quantity and unit unclear: 170,000 MW in captions], in energy efficiency measures. Then we have, of course, as mentioned before, several cross working access and projects. So, climate change legislation, supply chains are one issue for us.

So, policy making, we are I don’t know if you know, but the most project managers at GIZ working with the Brazilian government and they’re really sitting inside the government. So, they’re sitting usually in the ministries. In the Ministry of Environment, I’m sitting in the Ministry of Agriculture. Other colleagues sitting in the Ministry of Energy. And this we can work together and develop new policies or participate at least in the process of new policy making. We’re working with sustainably sustainable green funding, trying to drive more sustainable green investment into supply chains and sustainable urban infrastructure development.

One example, for example, for the last World Cup here in Brazil, we built one of the football stadiums, the entire roof with the solar panels. It was the stadium from Atlético Mineiro in Minas Gerais, which was really a nice piece. So, the stadium is totally sustainable now in terms of energy and can even [unclear verb] the energy back to the company. Pro clima is a project focused on reducing annual emissions. This is focused on recycling refrigerators and providing capacity building programs for air conditioning maintenance technicians. So these capacity building projects can really have a very powerful impact.

So well as it’s technical cooperation, GIZ and we are almost focusing on the technical part and capacity building is usually one of the parts we transmit and we invest in. [Project name unclear] is [unclear project description]. It is a focused on changes of public policy in terms of climate and we’re working with municipalities and with the federal government on integrating and creating new policies more climate friendly. And of course like in my area we are working a lot with small farmers and small holders mainly in the Amazon and trying to create market access, trying to create aggregated value to their to their production, trying to get their products to new markets like to new fairs, international fairs or to export, trying to engage them in a or public or private certification schemes to add values.

So we’re training small holders that they can be part of a certification or they can be able to produce more sustainably. One last slide, our staff. We are about 200 people in Brazil. And most of them are local staff and then of course we have some colleagues that come from Germany as project managers or director, some consultants and some integrated in São Paulo usually sitting the Chambers of Commerce and Industry. There’s the biggest the second biggest German Chamber of Industry and Commerce is located in São Paulo. So the Chamber represents more of the German companies in Brazil, but we also have a close relationship with them.

I think this is the organization in Brazil in a nutshell. I didn’t want to go deeply into each project because we’re having right now 30 projects. It would take a long time to talk about each and every one of them. So this is an idea what we do, how we’re doing it and what we have been doing over the last 50 years or 60 years. I give back to go back to Jonah and I’m open for questions.

Jonah:

Great. We have nearly 20 minutes for time for questions, which is great. I know that I will have a lot and other people will have questions too. I have put everybody on mute just to manage background noises. So if anyone wants to ask a question before in addition to posting in the chat, I encourage you to come off mute. I’d like to begin with one question and I encourage everyone else to go ahead and start posting questions in the chat and prepare them. I saw you talk about the discrepancy between the amount of the expenditures and the amount of money pledged.

I think the expenditures was around 30 million euros and the pledge was around 43 million euros. What happens to that gap of 13 million? Is that money that is not being delivered to projects just because there aren’t enough quality projects that have been proposed?

Alexander Borges Rose:

Exactly. Sometimes or for some reason And don’t have enough projects that are approved because the pledge comes before the project. So, the government makes a pledge and says, “Okay, for this year we are pledging 40 million euros.” then, basically, the teams, the German technicians here at GIZ and the Brazilian technicians, they have to elaborate the projects and go through all the approval levels within the two governments. And can be that you’re not fast enough to go through all the approval levels and have enough time to let’s say, to use all the money available.

So, this money goes back to the ministry and probably comes back in the next year.

Jonah:

Great. I have a bunch of other questions, but I want to open the stage for others. Does anyone else have a question they’d like to make of Alex? Again, you’re all on mute, so you have to come off mute. Okay, well, I’m happy to hog the microphone. Okay, there’s one from Jody Weiss. Jody, do you want to come off microphone and ask it?

Jody Weiss:

Yeah, hi everyone. I was just curious about that, you know, that it’s a shame to have funds go back to the government when it’s already been allocated, and it would be so I know colleagues down in the Amazon who are just struggling to raise capital for very important initiatives, and it would be really interesting to have like I don’t know, before that money is sent back call to action to NGOs on the ground to see if there could be fast-moving capital that’s deployed instead of having to recycle it through another calendar year.

Just a thought. Yeah.

Alexander Borges Rose:

Thanks for the comment. This basically, as you know, this the projects are bilateral projects. So, all the projects that are carried out, for example, my project is with the Brazilian Ministry of Agriculture. So, it’s not like a project, for example, from the Amazon Fund where an NGO like WWF can propose and can get funding. But in fact, Johnny, if you if you go back and look into Brazil’s history, it has always been very difficult for everybody, the World Bank or the USAID, for other givers as well, to be able to spend the amount of money also in the right time.

I know many projects where from the World Bank where 80% or 70% of the of the proposed funding had to go back because it was not spent. It’s That’s possible, unfortunately. But in our case, as we are bilateral projects or multilateral projects with the German government and Brazilian government, this funds these funds have to be spent also in bilateral projects. And the process to approve one bilateral project is not an easy one. It takes some time.

Jody Weiss:

Yeah, that’s super helpful. Thank you for the clarification. I totally understand.

Jonah:

I think we can get deeper into those funding questions. Atossa, you’ve got a question?

Atossa:

Hi. Thanks so much for this great informative presentation. I was also just wondering about the other ending in the other Amazon countries, how is the funding compared to what’s available for Brazil? And are you able to reach bilateral agreements in easier ways or harder ways right now given the politics in Brazil?

Alexander Borges Rose:

I think the focus has a little bit changed. If I take a look like in Brazil, I can only speak really for Brazil. In the past, most projects were connected to the Ministry of Environment. I would say 70 or 80% of the portfolio, the project partner was the Brazilian Ministry of Environment. And today and for the next years, we can say that the Ministry of the Environment is still a partner, but not really the biggest one anymore, rather a smaller one. And now, most projects are usually carried out with other federal partners.

Like the Ministry of Regional Development, the Ministry of Agriculture because it depends really on both sides. The Ministry has to go forward and say, “Yes, we want to do a project with you. We want to do this and this and this.” And then we can engage this project together and try to get it approved. For example, if the Brazilian Ministry of Environment doesn’t come forward and doesn’t raise his hand, “Hey, we want to do a project with you. We have real interest in doing this and that.” then nothing will happen really.

No one will build a project and so it depends really on the productivity inside the Brazilian government. So, today you can see the focus is shifting more on sustainable use. In the past, it was more command and control, monitoring, and now we have more biodiversity, sustainable production. So, it’s going more in this in this direction. And the energy program is younger, too. And the forest preservation program is pretty old, it’s the oldest, and the energy program is younger. So, over the years, it changes a little. I hope this answers your question.

Jonah:

Atossa, did you have a follow-up? Yeah,.

Atossa:

Just a follow-up is there right now, are there some governments that are being Are there governments in the Amazon basin that are being I guess, progressive within their ministries of environment, more ready to go, more excited to, you know, take advantage of the resources and the technical assistance you’re offering?

Alexander Borges Rose:

Yeah, I think the government of the state of the Amazon is, is very much ahead, I’d say, of the others because they have developed their own, public policy for bioeconomy. This is something that the other states in the, in the Brazilian Amazon have not developed. So, I’d say they have the biggest infrastructure, as well. They have some science institutions, they have universities involved already in biodiversity and bioeconomy. I think they are, the forerunner, I’d say, for partnering, if you want to partner with a state in the Amazon. If you take a look at the countries, I can really not speak for, like, for the other countries, like, GIZ Brazil, Bolivia, Peru, or Colombia.

I know we have a big portfolio in Colombia, as well. So, I believe over here, yeah, Colombia and Brazil are the biggest, and then in and then Mexico’s pretty big, as well. In Latin America, in Latin America.

Jonah:

Okay, our next questions will be from Lars and then from Marina. Right before you guys begin, I just want to say that I posted a bunch of relevant links, not only to Alex on LinkedIn, but also some of the federal German ministries, and also a bunch of links to regional GIZ programs, relevant for Amazon countries. Lars, go ahead.

Lars:

Hi, Alex. Thank you for your the presentation. The I have a curiosity question in a way because having observed sort of German development cooperation over the years, it’s a special characteristic that you tend to have quite a lot of German experts involved in the project, in the bureaucracy, or in the organizations, etc. And I’m curious to know if GIZ ever did a calculus of sort of or for Brazil, sort of what is the proportion that goes to these technical experts in terms of finances versus to what we call the so-called local projects?

Is that an issue with you or something to be discussed or is it just a part of the modus operandi?

Alexander Borges Rose:

I think it’s just part of the modus operandi. Most staff really are local staff, regular Brazilian staff, project managers, and technical advisors. But of course, over the years, GIZ has developed a lot of competencies within. So, people who have worked in the past in the Amazon, in Peru, or in Venezuela, someplace, and they have they have acquired a lot of knowledge. So, we have in our data bank a lot of expats or people who work in a different department in a GIZ in Germany or who work as consultants in Germany, we can hire for specific assignments because we know they have they have yeah, specific knowledge and they have experience and they know basically how the how the how the process and the procedures and internal procedures are.

But, but it’s not really an issue with us. I think it’s just a modus operandi. Haven’t discussed it yet.

Jonah:

Okay, Marina.

Marina Campos:

Hi, hi, Alexander. I also wanted to thank you for your presentation. It’s always good for us to have the idea about the big picture because we usually take care we have contacts with small pieces of the German cooperation. My question is there are some initiatives some big initiatives in Brazil in which the German cooperation has worked with other government corporations with other bilaterals like the Amazon fund is an example like the ARPA project. So one what are the instances in which you work with other governments? Do you have to have also the permission of the Brazilian government?

How does it how does it work I guess in a plain way to say how does it work when you wanted to do a collaboration that involves more than one country Brazil and Germany? How do you go about to try to have a greater impact?

Alexander Borges Rose:

Okay. I think I would go in two parts Marina. The first part is the other initiatives that are not bilateral initiatives like the Amazon fund and ARPA. What I presented here is the technical cooperation. So most of the investment is spent really on technical labor capacity building consulting. Then we have a second part which is the financial cooperation represented by our investment development bank KfW. And the investment for example in the Amazon fund and in ARPA an investment that goes through the financial cooperation through KfW. So this is this is a little bit different.

KfW can also give out a loan for example to an energy company in Brazil for a sustainable innovation project. That’s possible too but that’s not the technical cooperation. Your second question was Yeah, basically what happens is the different governments have these consultations every 2 years, like Germany, Brazil, like Germany, India, and so on. And if you notice that several countries have interest in the same issue, let’s say solar energy or wind energy or something specific, then you can also draw up bring these people together from the different countries and draw up a global project.

That’s interesting as well. So, it works basically the same way you develop a bilateral project, you can develop a global project. It just takes a little bit longer because you have also more actors you have to talk to. And of course, every country is at a different level, so you need to consider that you know when you when you set up the project. It’s not easy to write a project where different countries are involved if they’re in different continents, like India, Brazil, and South Africa, or something like this. I hope that has answered your question.

Jonah:

Marina, did you want to continue? Are you good? Okay, Christina.

Marina Campos:

No, thank you.

Cristina:

Yeah, I’m just curious, do you only work with governments? I mean, local or federal, whatever, or do you also work with NGOs and you know, sort of the private sector?

Alexander Borges Rose:

Mhm. Okay. So, within the within the bilateral projects, for example, the project I’ve been working in Green Markets with the Ministry of Agriculture, we have our funding available. So, let’s say that was a project of about 4 million euros for 3 years. And of course, after paying staff, you have funding available. And to carry out actions, the projects usually hire specialists. This can be on the specialists are usually NGOs. So, we can hire, for example, WWF to carry out soil management in a specific area. Or if I want to work in the extreme southern part of the Amazon, I have to check out which organization is working there already.

And then I know it’s either or it’s TNC or it’s Conexsus is working there already. So, they have their baseline and they have the relationships, so I can basically hire with the funding I have consultants. These consultants can be NGOs, they can be private businesses, and carry out specific parts of the project. For the private sector, oh, they can also be private companies, like a private consulting company. And then we have a specific program for private companies. It’s called develoPPP. It’s an open editor or tender where companies can propose a project together with GIZ.

And if the proposal is accepted, the cost is shared. Let’s say if the project cost is a million dollars, then basically the company is pledging half a million and the German government is pledging half a million, and they carry out the project together over 3 years, but there’s no money transfer from one to the other. The company is investing its own money, and Germany is investing its money, which is being managed by GIZ through the within the same project. So, it’s a develoPPP project. I can put it in the link later on.

This is our main instrument for private sector engagement.

Jonah:

Great, thanks. Maria.

Maria Franco:

Oh, thank you, Jonah. And hi, everyone. My name is Maria Franco. I’m part of the Dalbergia team based in Washington, D.C. And thanks, Jonah, for inviting me. And I’ve actually made met Alexandra before in a investment round table we organized in Brazil a couple years ago. So, it’s nice to see you here again. I mean, I think my question is a little bit related to what you were talking about a few minutes ago on the work that you’re doing with private companies and others, but specifically, I was wondering if you have worked with a specific NGOs and projects that have been able to make a jump from receiving donations and grants to receiving some sort of private investment because they have moved from either like an idea or project stage to becoming a profitable business that can attract private investment.

Alexander Borges Rose:

Okay. Nice to hear and see you again, Maria, as well. What I’ve seen, basically, is that cooperatives, like agricultural cooperatives, were subjects of donations of projects in terms of capacity building, soil management techniques. And that many times after the projects, they were able to access investments, either from an impact investor or from local banks like Pronaf or Basa or other private public banks here in Brazil. This has This I have seen a lot. Some cooperatives also have opened their own like their business their private business arm. Like the cooperative is a little bit lim- limited in terms of behavior and management.

Some cooperatives open like a trading or private company as well. And then the third I’d like to mention is I’m I don’t know if you know the PPA, Plataforma de Parceiros da Amazônia, Maria, which is an organization managed by Imazon or coordinated. And the main funding comes from USAID, but some other organizations are supporting the funding as well. For example, Marina from Conexsus and then other companies. And the very idea is to invest to find young startups, young companies, or cooperatives in the Amazon that have sustainable programs or products, prepare them through a acceleration program with accounting, with management, with marketing, with packaging, with sanitation rules.

And then at the end drive impact investments towards them. And this has been working very well. The PPA has been working for 2 and 1/2 years. It’s growing in terms of investors and in terms of companies. This I’ve seen mainly. Does that answer your question, Maria?

Maria Franco:

It does. Thank you. And I see that Jona shared the link for the PPA. So I think I had heard about it, but I will check it out as well. And I think this relates very well to what Amanda is going to talk about in a few minutes. So thanks for that answer.

Jonah:

Great. So as we transition to our next session, it looks like we’ve gotten through all the questions. I have one more which is about intergovernmental learning. I’m wondering if platforms like the Global Partnership for Effective Development Cooperation have been a place for the German government and others to compel other aid agencies to take on the quest of securing our climate through investments in the Amazon and things like that. Is there a channel and then related to that So one of the organizations I represent Nexus, there’s a very significant community of German philanthropists in our network in Germany.

Are is there a some campaign that can happen at a German level that would make Amazon philanthropy more effective from the German government?

Alexander Borges Rose:

I guess so. I guess. I mean there have been events in the past but I think it’s very difficult like to raise funds for campaigns for yeah specific campaigns let’s say like public relations campaigns and public affairs campaigns. It’s not that easy. Because it’s it’s not technical cooperation with someone. It’s I think it’s a challenge.

Jonah:

And about the global partnership for effective development cooperation. Has that been a platform to spread awareness about Amazon activity?

Alexander Borges Rose:

Not that I know of.

Jonah:

Okay, no worries. Okay, any final questions for Alex? Okay, great. Let’s go ahead and [recording ends].

Jonah:

Hello everybody. Welcome to a special session of the Amazon Investor Coalition. We seek to advance force friendly economic development and the rule of law across the Amazon region of South America. This is a call series that is supported by Nexus and the Global Governance Philanthropy Network and the Amazon Investor Coalition. And this week we have a two-hour special session on blockchains and forests or putting it in geeky terms tokenizing for nature protection. We have seven invited presenters and we have two hours and we have a very ambitious agenda. The primary purpose and outcome of this call, the primary thing will be people connecting with each other.

So I encourage all of you to just go nuts in the chat. Post your LinkedIn, your email addresses, your websites. Shameless self-promotion. We’re also going to be posting some things about the call itself. So for example, I’m going to put in the agenda. I’m going to post our presenters first and some framing. So what is a blockchain? I think everybody probably knows, but just to put it in words, it’s a database that is shared across many servers at the same time. Transactions are collectively recognized. They are immutable. It creates a ledger.

This is a new technology relatively past 10 years and it has made a world of technology advancement possible. There is a glossary about blockchains and tradability and many other things. I’d ask like to ask one of my colleagues who is co-oddering this call with me, Matt and Rob, if you guys could post the glossary at some point a little bit later, you could do it now. That would be great. I’m going to invite each of the presenters to come on and to talk about their startup, their.com, whichever it might be.

And each of them is going to get two minutes maybe with a tiny bit of leeway to share what they’re working on and they knew in advance that there were six considerations that we suggested for them to talk about. So your product its description a description of the market second a source assessment and its relation sorry a source market assessment. So that you’re creating these tokens. What is the source of these tokens and what’s the relationship local communities? Third, token valuation. Are you using a for-profit or nonprofit model? Number four, questions of monitoring, credibility, accountability, maybe that means certifications.

Five, transactions and protocols for market standards. And six, market size at startup. Are you guys working with a giant region, a small region? Just to give context, the technologies developed here can be used for forests all over the world. This is about forest conservation, North America, South America, Southeast Asia. This organization is especially focused on the Amazon. So, please guide your comments to that purpose. So first presenter to come up Alex Gordon Brander and Peter Cork and others from Century and Territory. You got two minutes and at the 10 seconds.

So two minutes I’ll say you have 30 seconds more. Go for it.

Alex Gordon-Brander:

Okay. So I’ll talk quickly then. Hope people don’t mind. Quickly background hedge fund Wall Street technology built trading systems that are traded like 20 trillion dollars to date. So lot of experience on that side been full-time in crypto since 2016 but it was only in 2019 2020 I started really thinking about the need for using trees and natural capital as a foundation for a sort of stable coin system. That’s kind of a little bit of background what Sentry is and Peter’s gonna talk for 30 seconds at the end. So give me a 30 second wave.

So quickly, Sentry is tokeniz NFT that tokenizes an area of forest which is measured in the census tree centuries. So the total age of the trees in that forest area with a liquid currency sitting on top of it that is denominated in tree centuries. So we’ve got a two-tier market structure with an aim of creating both sort of fundraising vehicles for local forest protection and a global layer on top of that. It’s a for-profit model but with land trusts and significant profit participation for indigenous and local communities. So sort of the investors are meant to be providing lubrication as opposed to actually sort of being extractive.

And we’re p we’re piloting probably up in Ferry Creek. So that’s going to be something in the order of a $25 million initial project, but we’re talking to various folks in the Amazon, some of whom are here about doing a second project in the Amazon. Anything in five seconds, Pete?

Peter Corke:

Yeah. No, it’s very much a unifying framework considering all stakeholders in the environment because it’s an economic counterbalance to an economic systemic problem. Rather than a philanthropic one. We’re able to engage with all stakeholders on both sides of what are potentially often conflicting situations and bring them around a unifying scenario because it’s bringing a new asset class into play and bringing a set of funding into protection of old growth from a completely new source that creates a truly counterbalancing economic position. Great. And I’m based I’m based in British Columbia, which is where the original Ferry Creek Link came from.

So, a lot of the conversations I’m having local to here.

Jonah:

Great. Thank you so much. Just adding a little context after our first pair of presenters. Thank you so much, guys. And that’s just recognition of how complex this issue is and the why the role of technology is so important to moving forward on it. And we will have space for questions after presenters go and as we move into the agenda. So, we’re just going to go backtoback presentations now and then feel free everybody in the audience to write down your questions. You’ll have space later. So, next up is the team from Invert, Andreas Bill.

Go for it.

Unidentified participant:

Is that okay if we present in the end? Andre is having some problem joining. So,.

Jonah:

Sure. It’ll be right before the end. There is one other spot that I’ve already reserved for the guy at the end. Okay. Next up is Oh, actually I’m not Is there a member of the team from O2 Reserve on the call? I think it’s possible they weren’t able to make it.

Unidentified participant:

Okay.

Unidentified participant:

They said they were all in the jungle. Jonah, there was a male that came in the other day, maybe two days ago. So, I think they can be excused. Can I just say one thing that I think is very special about O2. We had conversations with them and they were especially interested in the concept what I would call micro microtokenization where you would connect small tokens to for instance items like clothing. So, you could protect one square meter of forest by buying a t-shirt. And it’s a it’s a little long to explain it here, but I think the idea as such might be very interesting if you go into the B2C market.

So, I just wanted to see that idea from them here. Thank you.

Jonah:

Great. Next up is David Dao of GainForest or another representative GainForest. Two minutes.

David Dao:

Hi, David D from GainForest here. I’m an artificial intelligence researcher leading a lab at ETH circ so where we work on monitoring biodiversity and deforestation as I have experience with the United Nations delegation process just coming back from Glasgow last week. So we know that forests are really important. Also the people from the United Nations know and they have pledged money, billions of dollars to give back to local communities, United Nations threat plus program and other stuff. But it doesn’t work. And the one reason we think it doesn’t work is because there’s no trust.

There’s a trust issue between people who apply for getting this money because they have to self-report progress and then of course United Nations and countries taking too long to approve that process to send the money back to the communities that applied. So we tried to solve that with two things. We use artificial intelligence models based in satellite images and our research at Esur and also outside to provide an independent look at territory you protect and territory you don’t protect and therefore we can provide you an transparent look at your additionality of your project as well as then when we have that we connect basement and donations with a blockchain based like transfer system.

So we connect communities that are usually financially marginalized outside from our finance world by using cryptocurrency. And the idea is very simple. Donors fledge money and the money doesn’t it leaves your wallet immediately but so you put your money where your mouth is but it doesn’t directly go to communities yet. The money gets stored in a smart contract and only when our artificial intelligence oracles are detecting that certain indicators are fulfilled combined with a set of independent validators, we release the money to the communities. It’s that simple. And donors can then trace back their impacts of their donations while getting rewarded with our cryptocurrency gainforce governance token for their trust into the system.

We are selling 10 million gainforce governance tokens in a private auction. Currently that’s 10% of the global state of 100 million tokens and that’s GainForest. It’s already I’m faster than expected done this pitch so many times.

Jonah:

Great. Okay. Feel free to go ahead and paste your email address if you haven’t already. Okay. Next up is the team from Regen Network, Gregory Landoa or a colleague. Hey.

Gregory Landua:

Everybody, this is Gregory here. I’m one of the co-founders at Region Network. Really nice to see some familiar faces. Jonah, thanks for having us. I’m calling in from Western Massachusetts and we have a long deep relationship with the Amazon as well. So region network is a domainspecific public blockchain dedicated to ecological claims and credits. We have a fullfeatured decentralized registry that lives on the region ledger blockchain. We’ve been doing a lot of work in the Amazon, including a pilot with the Ecuadorian Ministry of Agriculture for agroforestry regeneration credits, as well as a pilot with the Awar Nation and a and several other tribes in the upper Amazon and Ecuador.

One thing that’s very unique about region network is our model is based on local stakeholders generating their own credit classes and participating in the governance of both the public blockchain itself as well as up the stack into the market and I think that’s quite a unique element. So regen as its own layer 1 blockchain dedicated to ecological health and regeneration allows participants both to be securing the public blockchain which is live has a market cap of about $250 million as well as engaging in the marketplace. So some of the things that we’ve already accomplished at region network are providing about 15% of the carbon that’s backing the KLMA treasury currently all in high quality forest carbon selling the largest historical purchase of soil carbon removals to Microsoft earlier this year and launching our mainet in the Amazon.

As I said, we’re very focused on local stakeholder engagement to complement the work we’re doing with the open-source science and development work that we’re doing to make it possible to cheaply and accurately verify forest health and monetize whether it’s biomass or biodiversity, carbon removals or avoided deforestation. So, hopefully that’s good for yeah, my two minutes. I’ll give the floor to the next one.

Jonah:

Okay, great. Great. Thanks so much, Greg. Next up is Kel Clarice from Forest Space. I think you might be on mute. Yes, go for it.

Kjell Clarysse:

Thanks, Jonah. So, about a year ago, I read an article about a South Korean sugar company that wanted to buy large amounts of, pristine forest in Papua and in Indonesia. And the article was about how ridiculous it was that they were offering $8 per hectar. And I thought, wait a second, $8, like even per square meter, that would look cheap. And this is per hectar. And I was at the day at those days a little bit occupied already with investing in Bitcoin, Ethereum, some other coins and some stocks. And I thought this is going to be an asset that’s going to go times 100, maybe times a thousand, but even more.

If I could buy that, could I maybe outbid that company? I mean, I don’t have money to buy tens of thousands of hectars, but there is something like the crowd that’s very powerful today. If you look at Wall Street bets and GameStop. So this triggered me very much but I was sad. I thought okay looks like forest is really cheap everywhere in the world. If you really look it true, you can find things at $50 $100 per hectar easily. And typically the economical principle says if something is cheap, it means people don’t want it.

That’s why it’s cheap. And I was sad to accept until we did market research and that made us realize that the demand is crazy high. And that’s just retail. So I’m not even talking about funds yet because if you talk to funds, you’re going to hear even crazier stories. So if the demand is so high, why is it so cheap? And the answer is very simple. It’s admin. Land titles are tens of thousands hectars big. The duration of acquiring something like that is very long, many months. You have to be there locally.

And people can easily invest in stocks in coins from their couch. So they’re not going to do that. The asset is locked up. So what we do is we unlock market access to forests in the form of hectars. And why do we do it? Because market access is a very strong price driver. And that’s what we are after. So by 2030 we will be happy if somebody logs a land for pasture that his friend says that was a stupid move because it was worth much more if you have kept it as a forest.

So how do we do it? We re-engineer actually part of how ownership looks like legally. We involve local communities in that very actively and we go to market via security tokens. A question I have to the community here today is something that we have been spending quite a lot of time on already is how do you set up a project that’s not proof locally then for five years but that is let’s say intergenerational proof. Thanks Jonah.

Jonah:

Great. Thanks so much for joining us. Next up is going back to my agenda. Andreas from Invert. Andreas is having some problem with.

Lisa:

Connection, but I can present Invert. Hi guys. I’m Lisa. So basically it’s a little bit similar with the last project we presented but basically what we want to do is to allow conservation at scale using the blockchain technology. So like overall what we in a nutshell what we do we buy token we buy private land that has some risk of deforestation we tokenize it and we sell it to consumer. We are going to sell it through a metaphor that’s basically backed by real land and allow user to gain tokens through contribution to the ecosystem.

So we basically merge traditional core game play mechanism conservation strategies and use this to engage the users and let them trade, explore, interact in the in the metaverse land and expanding this metaverse land. The idea is also to always be connected to the real land. So every time we expand the metaverse land, we will expand the real land. And yeah, that’s basically it. We are just starting. We have until now 26,000 actors and we’re looking to expand that and engage more users.

Jonah:

Great. Thanks so much, Lisa. And then we have the team from Bit Green, Gilead Goran.

Gilad Goren:

Hey everyone, how’s it going? My name is Gilad and I am the co-lead at Bit Green and we’re a DeFi native protocol built in the Polkadot ecosystem. So we’re a layer 1 blockchain which means technically we could build anything on top of our chain. Our focus is entirely and strictly about impact. We see ourselves as being a home for all forms of ESG on blockchain. And moreover helping missionalign companies who have a use case for blockchain but don’t have their own tech team or don’t have the ability to do so but have u a valid use case to go on chain through our service, our help.

So basically blockchain as a service and really what we’re trying to tackle is the $50 trillion dollar question. How can we prevent the irreversible damage done to climate change? The UN SGS has the number at 50 trillion. Biodiversity alone is 715 billion. And while we know there’s a ton of amazing u projects out there, demand for capital and a lot of supply of capital waiting to be spent in the right places, there isn’t really the platform to connect between the two. So our points of focus is on building the infrastructure for that.

Be it a marketplace solution for impact investing with a focus on debt like project finance, waste energy plans, solar arrays, stuff of the sort. Or a the infrastructure for originating, tokenizing and then enacting commercial activities in the carbon credit market, in the plastic credit market, really the entire ecosystem. So, we’re building the infrastructure to easily make that happen. And we’re the first ones to say that we’re the technologists, we’re not the experts. So, I’m really excited to see the kind of folks who are, you know, in this room, who clearly have the expertise.

So, please reach out to us. I’m at gilladbit green.org. We want to work with you in order to help you make, you know, take first advantage of blockchain. Be it NFTTS, be it security tokens, anything of that sort. Last really quick thing, last week we were able to fund raise through crowdfunding. Did 5 million, which is the max capacity. And from the beginning in the get-go, we’re here about the crowd. So we’d love to work with you.

Jonah:

Great. Thanks so much, Gilad. And I want to apologize. I missed I didn’t see you. We do have participation from single. Earth Merritt Valdasu.

Merit Valdsalu:

Yes. Hello everybody. Very happy to be here. So thanks so much for having us here as well. So very exciting to see all these conversations happening already. So I am calling in from Talian Sonia. So which is kind of on the other side of the world from the Amazon rainforest. So our so what we do is basically in the same space. So we take to tokenize nature. Maybe to add to what has already been discussed from the tech technology side is that I think like we are trying to get a more holistic overview of the value of nature in terms of not just carbon but also biodiversity and other ecosystem services.

So I would say that this is perhaps one of the things that we are trying to challenge the most in the market currently. And with me I also have our technical co-founder and CTO here who is taking care of the technical stuff. So maybe he wants to say hello as well. Andrew, do you want to say hello?

Andres:

Yes. Hello everybody. Nice to see so many people excited that the same thing which people so far have communicated will be ending our world because of the energy consumption will finally try to at least moderately save it as well. So it’s a great achievement and finally the good technology but in good technology but in good use. So I think the tokenization of the nature is really something what blockchain is good for.

Merit Valdsalu:

Yeah. And maybe to maybe raise some topics to discuss here I think like one of the big elephants in the room is the is the legislation regarding and the regulations regarding the tokens and all of that. So maybe that’s also something to see if this could prevent scaling the markets for conservation projects as well. So just a topic to throw out in the air up in the air to and see if anybody has any experience with that.

Jonah:

Great. Thank you so much Andress and Merritt. I’m now going to call on a few other people that were not announced at the beginning or in the email invites but who I thought could make great additions to the call and everyone should know that they’re here. So I’m scrolling up to the list. Yiz Leonfont from the IADB, the Interamerican Development Bank. Could you please introduce yourself?

Yves:

So, hi everybody. Very impressed by the attendance of this meeting. So, I’m Eve. I’m working to the in the Interamerican Development Bank in the Amazon unit. This is a new unit that is completely dedicated to support efforts in the Amazon region and we are very interested to understand better all the technology linked to the tokenization and mostly how we can also be sure that it can benefit local communities and also having this bottom up approach because we’ve seen a lot of projects that are much more top down and we have been also talking about territory ries and the way we want to engage with local people.

So, thank you so much for the invitation, Jonah, and happy to be here.

Jonah:

Great. Thank you so much. I’m going to call on another presenter or participant who may not be prepared, but I think what you guys are doing is so important. I’d like to call on Christian Weezenthal or another member of the Open Earth Foundation which is working on a technology stack to make carbon accounting interoperable globally. Christian are you there?

Unidentified participant:

Yes I am. Yeah. Hello everyone. Happy to be here. However the team that’s prepared to present Rafa and Ned I saw them joining the call earlier on.

Jonah:

Yeah.

Unidentified participant:

Sure. Okay guys, I’ll let you guys take on from here.

Ned Harvey:

Yeah. So, hi Ned Harvey from Digital Gaia and I’m joined by Rafa as well. Very similar to other people were talking about. We’re trying to solve the problem of verification and validation of natural capital assets to bring forth new asset classes. And we’re taking approach of a federated essentially verification validation engine for pricing risk and value and valuing natural capital. We think of us as an infrastructure play to enable scaling of a lot of the different ideas that are here. As these digital assets come online and frankly even in the in the regular world we both a federated approach I.e.

Crowdsourcing the verification validation and using inference based AIS to define the value of a given set of activities in an ecosystem. I’ll stop there. Ralph, do you want to add anything?

Rafa:

Yeah. I think we’re still very early in the process. We’re going to be sharing our website and other materials really soon. We’ve been collaborating with Open Earth as well as leading AI and AI researchers to define what we’re seeing what we think is the next step that of building out what we’re thinking of as a valuation engine not just for impact but also for claims about the state of nature and bringing it all together data predictions and impact into a cohesive valuation infrastructure. Ructure to support all the great projects that you guys are doing here.

Jonah:

Great. Thanks so much. Sorry to cut you off. Just in interest of time. Next I’d like to invite Aaron Bloomgarden from the Emergent Finance Accelerator and the Leaf Coalition to talk about your work. Are you there?

Aaron:

Sure. Thanks. I’m in Europe, so it’s a bit late here, but nice to see everyone. I’ve been involved in climate and forest for about the last 20 years. So, it’s great to see all this brain power focused on this issue. So, Emergent is a nonprofit, but we operate in a commercial market. We announced last week at in Glasgow that we raised a billion dollars to from public and private sources to change the economics on the ground basically to finance reductions and deforestation. So we have 20 companies now and three governments as part of what we call the LEAF coalition.

So it’s leaf coalition.org. And basically there are pay results based payments for reducing deforestation at the jurisdictional level. So either at the national level or the state level. And the unit is carbon basically carbon credit. The certification standard is called the architecture for red transactions or art which is hosted by winrock. We announced three things at COP. The a billion dollars that we’ve raised seven new company large companies that have joined including Walmart and Black Rockck several others. And then we’ve signed LOIs with five jurisdictions or five countries Ecuador, Costa Rica, Vietnam, Nepal Ghana and then and then the interstate consortium for the legal Amazon which includes all the all the state Brazilian states that are part of the Amazon.

Thanks.

Jonah:

Great. Thanks so much, Erin. And then one last person I’d like to introduce himself and then we’ll move on into the wider agenda. Simon Fel from OMI, are you there? Okay. We’ll include Simon in a future call. Rob and Matt, if you guys could now post the glossary, that’d be great to help set the stage of what does tradability mean in this context. Let’s go ahead and take let’s go ahead and take an inventory now of the different business models that we see. So I’m going to ask a question and then three of the presenters are welcome to come on board and offer the business model as it responds to the question you know how does your solution apply?

Then we’ll have a little bit of space for those in the audience to ask questions from which other panelists can respond to. This is a first come first-s serve thing. So feel free to just raise your hand after I write the question. This is to the invited presenters. So here’s the question. In terms of business model, how do you deal with the question of land tenure, of land ownership, ownership versus leasing? Would anyone like to respond?

Unidentified participant:

Jonah, can I add one can I one sure possibility more to it because there’s probably more forms and we’d like to hear from others as well. One of them that was mentioned the to buy the obligation to protect a piece of land. So you don’t need land to buy land but you make a contract with the party and they get money for protecting it. That’s another form which might be much easier in many cases and much more equitable as well. Thank you.

Jonah:

Go ahead Peter.

Peter Corke:

Thanks. Yeah just to react to that. I mean basically the way our the way our conceptual framework is coming into form is that it exists separate to that to land ownership which means that in circumstances where for example there might even be dispute over the rights to the land between governmental positions and indigenous communities you have the ability to use our framework as almost a mechanism to drive decolonialization efforts as well. But it also means that private land owners can put our framework on top of land that they’ve purchased as well.

So it’s quite variable basically in the way our system works that it sits at a at a different level above and it’s very much about people all around the world being able to funnel their funds into land trusts that then create as Rob was just alluding to their kind of protection mechanisms that are covenants of protection for land. So what you’re really buying is through our system, you’re not buying the land. You’re buying the right of protection. We talk about as a counterbalance to logging industry primarily here, but it’s obviously counterbalance to clearance and other industries elsewhere, but that it’s effectively we’re converting logging rights into living rights and it’s those living rights for the trees that you’re funding.

So it’s a source of income for land owners or forest communities that’s come coming in from a new direction and sits separately to land title. But that means it can be layered on top of it if that is an option or a solution that’s more appropriate for certain other parts of the of the world as well. And it helps mean that it can move and scale to other areas quite easily.

Jonah:

Great. I like to call in Gregory Lando. You would post in the chat you want to give some feedback. You want to elaborate?

Gregory Landua:

Well, I mean I think that the territory approach is generally right on. And I think there’s also some sticky, you know, there’s the need to also be engaging with land tenure and ownership and reg registry systems, I think. And one of the ways this actually sort of emerged out of a pilot that we’re doing in Ecuador where there’s significant land trafficking and actually a lot of the red plus carbon credits that have been sourced out of the specific set of communities have been used to further land trafficking where essentially there’s bribery taking place and land is being stolen from you know the traditional owners of the land and then you know, capital is being fl the red plus carbon credits that are sourced from there are essentially paying the people who traffic the land.

So that’s actually one of the nice things about approaching this with a decentralized and distributed ledger approach where you know what we’re working on in that context is essentially to spin up a community land ledger where community members can sort of inter subjectively verify that you know that family has been there for x number of years and has whatever the different rights are. So that there’s actually sort of a an alternative when there’s disputes taking place. Not necessarily to replace the old system, but to just ensure that there’s recordkeeping that’s accessible to the communities that are taking place.

And then that can interface as Peter’s mentioning with this sort of like this other level of rights associated with the living capital or the natural capital and the stewardship and the provision of the value to the public goods value. And I think there’s a whole interesting conversation to have about, you know, sort of like the intersection of private property rights markets and public goods, which warrants, you know, a deep dive and probably, you know, some beers together or something when that becomes more normal. But, hopefully that’s just a little bit of helpful context and I imagine many other people are facing similar sort of intersections and challenges.

Jonah:

Great. Would any of the other invited panelists like to comment on this piece?

Unidentified participant:

Well, from our end, one of the challenges that we’re trying to solve for is actually more on the compliance and legal ability side specifically in the United States. With regards to the question of actually futures and so in a situation for example if there’s u owners of a large forest in Mexico or somewhere else who are willing to essentially sell 30 years worth of future carbon credits for a certain price right now. With the idea being that the funds are used to go with conservation and also do you know spend all the money that’s needed to get a vera accredititation or something of the sort currently that’s not really possible in the United States.

So it brings to the question of you know ownership and what are the different layers of ownership and will we be able to innovate in this space in a way that’s you know kosher according to certain agencies in the United States. That’s something that we’re deeply entrenched in right now.

Jonah:

Great. So there’s a lot more to discuss here. I’m going to call on one person who wasn’t one of the invited presenters, to comment, then we’re going to go move to the next session. For those of you want to share, put it in the chat. Nette Royo, could you please introduce yourself and tell us about the, tenure facility and share your comments.

Nonette:

Thank you, Jonah. I am Natoo the executive director of the tenure facility and the tenure facility what it does is provides large grants to directly to indigenous peoples who have decided to implement land laws and regulations and court decisions in countries where they have land rights and it’s recognized and so far right now we have 14 million hectares advancing in tenure recognition and actually 4 million hectares already recognized in the last 3 years. So, Mike, this is a really good question, Jonah, and I’m curious how the tokens that we’re talking about here could in many ways be the incentive.

This is the big call. I was just in the cup and many of us were. The indigenous peoples are saying the land standing forest right now that are absorbing carbon are from their territories and it’s been protected by them over generations. So if and the direction of the discussions is that we are paying for these services that’s been done lives gone and we are interested and many of the indigenous peoples we work with are interested in the manner by which when they secure tenure and this is already what’s happening how will they be able to access and work with you and so it’s very it’s not easy if it’s your land actually that’s being talked about as a public good.

Right? So it’s something that we would like to have some kind of a pathway as well for those rights that have already been recognized.

Jonah:

Great. Thanks so much.

Rob:

Yo, I’d have a follow-up question for Nette, please. Is it do you have some sort of models there that you’re already working with to a sort of a contract that you have with the local people and are there things that you could share? Thank you.

Nonette:

There are many that can be shared. Tenure instruments vary from ownership collective ownership to community forest instruments and customary forest instruments and some of them would be 25 years 50 years and renewable and some of them are in many parts of Latin America it’s for long-term so and that’s where I think it’s important to really learn how that could in many ways be part of the transaction that is secured and it goes to the people. Yeah. And it doesn’t change hands because these are actually their assets. Yeah.

Rob:

Okay.

Jonah:

Thank you, Nette. Thanks, Rob. Okay. We’re going to go ahead and move on to the next question. And remember the chat’s there for everybody. So this next question is about the valuation of tokens. Where how does the token earn its valuation? How is it calculated? And where does the financing come from? Would any of the invited presenters like to comment? We’ll take three of you and then we’ll go to the others. Feel free to just come off.

Unidentified participant:

Sure. Well, I can start. I mean in our model we’re more interested in empowering the community to generate the type of eco credits that are necessary in the different context. And so from that perspective different eco credits will have different pricing mechanisms. So the soil carbon produced in Australia from holistic grazing will be different from the Amazonian forest protection credits and they may have different markets as well. Being able to bundle those and basically sort of create an index where there’s a stable or there’s sort of like more deep liquidity and more price discovery available is also part of our model.

But you know, I think it’s premature to have sort of a single approach. I what I like seeing here is that people are trying different pieces. And I think having assets that are tradable, having assets that are non-transferable and are simply payment for services. These are all important things that need to be experimented with. So we have sort of on running on region ledger. It sort of spans the full gamut essentially. Great. Others from the invited panelists.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, if I may. For me,.

Jonah:

Sure. I’m gonna say Kell and then Alex.

Kjell Clarysse:

All right. Perfect. Thank you. The way we look at it, it’s incredibly important. That’s specifically when it’s forest coming to market. It’s not seen as just trees. We like to make a parallel with the art market, for example. Ecosystems can be really small. Sometimes you will find some species that only are present in 5,000 hectares and that’s it. So it’s very important that when an ecosystem comes to market is valued correctly and sufficiently high, it would be mistake to price nature too low because a high price is very important in protecting it.

It’s exactly that market access and that price point that will lead to it becoming cost prohibitive to destroying it. We state this very clearly because we’re sometimes afraid that there’s a little bit how can I say it’s sometimes reduced to just trees and that’s dangerous. And when it comes to token value if there is a real asset that is underlying you have to watch out how it is valued today because if you would look at how a forest is valued today people will typically say okay how much timber is in there?

How much is that timber worth? What’s the distance to log that timber? Is it cost prohibitive or is it already close enough now? And it’s a battle against those valuation mechanisms and there is information asymmetry. I would say some people will not understand that you calculate it differently and that’s something that’s going to have to be introduced more broadly.

Jonah:

Great. Thanks Alex.

Alex Gordon-Brander:

So our tokens are assetbacked. So for any particular forest area there’s an NFT that has essentially a share of the revenues being generated from carbon and other sort of local living economy going on at the individual NFT level. But what happens is instead of those just being dividends that go to the owners of the NFT, we have this additional layer that essentially says every hundred years that a tree has stood on this earth is basically worth one a thing. So we’re creating like a market liquid price for a century of all growth tree age.

So even though each of the different NFTts and each of the different forest areas will have their own economics, those economics just basically go into a pool that pays staking rewards to anyone who is staking a century token against a particular NFT area that we’re trying to protect. And then there are mechanics around that essentially we’ll keep selling tokens and it’s a 2 to1 fractional reserve. So we have some wiggle room and we’ll keep selling tokens as long as the price is higher than the average protection price for the forests, which is, you know, a little bit like this as we’re doing the first project, but we’re is going to get more refined as we go along.

And then just finally then you know the tokens we’re going to want to have liquidity access and so questions about which is the right you know balance of carbon footprint and liquidity in terms of getting tokens to market but certainly we’re pretty deep in conversations with Greg and Regen about working together on the on the tokenization side and really trying to do our part to help build more liquidity in general into the regenerative asset ecosystem.

Jonah:

Great. Thanks. Okay. Comments from others.

Gilad Goren:

Hey, Jenna, could I just jump in then?

Jonah:

Yeah, go for it.

Gilad Goren:

Without getting too much on what the big green governance token will be about, you know, my team is really steeped in the world of DeFi. And we see that there’s a ton of opportunity both in tapping into the current DeFi DJs out there that have hundreds of billion dollars locked up already on things that you know outside of the world of DeFi are kind of meaningless. It’s just money-making money. U but also a lot of investors and potentially institutions in the future who are looking to get involved and yes are seeking extra yield.

Why not? And so, the, you know, when we’re talking about different tokens out there, our focus is going to be about how do we drive as much capital into the world of carbon credits, recycles, Rex, and all the rest. And so, for us, we’re not building necessarily an asset backed coin, but rather a tokconomics, a tokconomic system that drives basically extra yield. And that yield happens to be based on positive impact. So that in impact investing, we’ll throw in extra tokens to sweeten the pot for investors who are looking for the extra yield.

And also it happens to be lower cost of capital because we’re not going through lawyers and all sort of middlemen. A lot of it is software, you know, code. So you’ll have smart contract use and all the rest. Same thing with carbon credits. U, we intend on working a lot on the securities side or enabling securities for the first time for these commodities. I think that’s where it gets really exciting and kind of on the frontier edge of impact finance. That’s what we’re going for.

Jonah:

Great. Thanks, Gilad. Okay, two more comments and then we’re moving on. Feel free to just come off mic. Oh, please not all at once. Anybody?

Jason Camp:

Hey Jonah, this is Jason Camp. I’m just gonna say one thing that I heard for with respect to valuation and making sure that everything that everyone’s doing collectively, you know, the at no point do we undervalue things. I think the you know, it kind of goes without saying, but someone said it and I think it’s worth just keeping that at the forefront of everything you’re doing. I heard one person saying they were thinking about, you know, 30 years out selling carbon credits at a price locked in today. And you know, while I would love to be able to accomplish that goal, I also think that you know, at some point over time, depending on how much you do sell, that could be counterproductive to some of the other things as everyone’s initiatives and efforts get integrated.

I just think it’s worth really thinking through some of those models and being really aggressive with respect to how you think about pricing. The market pays almost nothing for any of this stuff today and the goal is to make the market pay for it dearly. So being aggressive is really maybe the only way the only way to get your point across. But the upside of that and all and I just want to say that I love all of the technologies and all of the innovation was unstable. Okay. Any last takers?

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, I’d be happy to jump in just for a half second. Interested in a couple of things like one is the death of potentially old growth trees as they start to get valued which is like a hard thing to imagine being able to put a timeline on and sequence those timelines and then also the energetics of the human element is like the stewardship of the lands and how is it that some of these ecosystem services which are also maintained by the peoples that are also actually on these lands some of it state parks or parks institutions but also So, the indigenous peoples that are obviously tending these lands.

And then the other question or the other comment that I’d like to address is the fractalization of these NFTTS and the and the energy and expenses of the cost of current technologies that are out there that once you start to value all the participants in there, there’s obviously a lot that’s eaten up in the fees and just wondering what’s going down that from the computational power but also the costs involved that at the current price that would be garnered from expanding this out. So sorry that’s a lot of things but I know there’s a lot to be shared.

Jonah:

Great. There’s a lot packed in there and it’s a great segue to the next question which is that of monitoring. So you create a token and a bulldozer comes along and how do you keep the integrity of your token over time? How do you update them? Anyone wish to respond? Go ahead Peter. Yeah, could I.

Peter Corke:

Could I speak to that and a few of the other points that have been made actually. I think one of the keys is there’s a lot of discussion at the moment about the you know the upfront purchase of future credits either carbon or biodiversity etc. And maybe a important pivot point to talk about with respect to what our token does it looks at things in a very different way. So, so when we create an NFT for the old growth forest area, and we have the Century token, which acts as a bridge between traditional finance mechanisms and currency to buy into that NFT, it’s not buying into the future benefit of that area.

It’s recognizing the value of it to date. So, you know, if you if you want to have got 10 trees in a hectare and each is a thousand years old, then you’ll need a hundred of our tokens to buy into that NFT. One of the key things about that is that brings a value proposition into the asset as it is right now rather than how it’s going to benefit society going forward. Then the ongoing benefit that’s generated by that area which can then be realized through biodiversity credits or carbon credits etc as Alex pertain to our system are then shared with the indigenous community.

So going right back to what Nette asked about earlier. It’s like you know that gives an economic option for indigenous populations or communities that have had a land back process and maybe got tenure of their land back. It gives an economic alternative to the other extractive economics. So you know a lot of the time the proposition is do you protect and give up economic opportunity or do you take make the most you know create some extractive economics. So the framework therefore generates revenues on an ongoing basis that actually drives the stewardship.

So to then pertain to some of those last parts of that question, you know, the whole advantage of these kind of tokenization technologies if the framework and the conceptual framework is right is you are capturing a new form of currently unrecognized value in years already invested by the trees if you like in that forest area. And then through the use of that you’re funneling in an a counterbalance to the extractive forces which allows you to carry out that process up front and then create an ongoing revenue for stewardship. And when you talk about the bulldozer there, we’ve even been engaging for example with communities here that the ongoing stewardship could include maintenance of the data that fundamentally drives the NFT asset value.

So we’ve been talking for example with education specialists who are working with indigenous population here that actually that’s something that then forms part of the community’s nature connection process for their children so that actually the land stewardship becomes the ongoing revenue generator and that of course is what we really want to all happen.

Unidentified participant:

Great thanks Alex. Yeah, I just wanted to my Anya just clarifying the thing about the historical century thing you know it the unit of a currency generates senorage and a lot of what currencies around we’re talking about mechanisms here but it’s also about story and about narrative. So just to sort of clarify, there is a local living economy layer and then there’s kind of our crypto layer above it. And the crypto layer is essentially to fund and create the local living economies which can be based on both carbon and other you know other things that can be sustainably generated from the ground.

And but by framing this in terms of valuing the years of the trees already on the ground, it’s a real switch in sort of in mindset which I think is part of what actually creating a you know on the consumer branding side and really getting kind of decentralized sort of crowdfunding interest in this. That’s kind of something that is I think both you know both important on the consumer side and just like actually fundamentally shifts the nature of currency and we can talk about the you know the deeper metaphysics of this another time but.

Jonah:

Great thanks any would any of the other invited speakers like to share.

Gregory Landua:

Yeah I’d like to share briefly and also introduce my colleague Sarah Baxenddale who’s our director of business development she’s going to be I’m going to be passing the baton on to her for future questions. So just to speak briefly to the how do you monitor the value of an eco credit in real time? I think you know there’s sort of a couple of different layers of how we’re approaching this. First off we have a registry program. You know, similar to how you think of you know, either a compliance or voluntary carbon registry system in which the agreements that are backing the credit like the carbon credit are outlined and clear, right?

So, we have what we call region registries program and different credit classes are going to have different ways of answering that question as I’ve been sort of mentioning previously. So for instance there can be credit classes that re that are sort of ongoing provision of a like proof of forest in which the existence of the forest itself and its conservation value is only emitted you know on a quarterly basis when the satellite verifies that is indeed true. For instance, you might also have a credit class that is sort of the more traditional avoided deforestation credit class in which there’s actually legal agreements that bind you know the land ownership and the land rights etc.

And you know at the moment we’re really playing with different forms of this with people in the ecosystem because again there’s so many different opportunities to pilot and play with as Alex is talking sort of the social construction of value. What are we actually going to choose to value? How do we trust it? You know, at the end of the day, those are both technological questions like can we use can we leverage satellite information and machine learning in order to create highly detailed quantification of.

Jonah:

20 seconds.

Gregory Landua:

About value? But also this is about social construction of value. What’s the quality? What’s the intrinsic value of this space and how do we support that? And you know from my perspective you know we sort of need the full gamut of experimentation taking place and really vibrant sort of cooperation and competition between approaches.

Jonah:

Sarah, would you like to introduce yourself and comment?

Sarah:

Hi. Yes, my name is Sarah from the regen team. Thank you for alliterating all the details, Gregory. I’m happy to answer any questions that folks have about regen and our approach. I think first and foremost we’re trying to create a community first and ecosystem first approach to the marketplace and really we’re focusing on tools and utility that allow everyone democratic access to the market itself. So happy to answer any questions and thank you for having our team.

Jonah:

Great one more comment from anybody and then we’re going to move on to the next question. Feel free to just come off mic. Okay, I’m going to go ahead and move on. The next question is about biodiversity and deforestation risk. Not all carbon credits are created equal. Not all tokens are created equal. There are a lot of new technologies out there that can automate the assessment of biodiversity, such as audio of bird sounds. And there are also a lot of models out there that can calculate deforestation risk such as prices of commodities and proximity to roads and to previous deforestation.

There are statistical models that can provide that. I’m wondering if any of you guys are taking these metrics into your evaluation process. Three invited presenters can go and then anyone else can respond. Go for it. Kale, you’re on mute.

Kjell Clarysse:

Before we start with measuring it starts being present in the forest and assessing the actual deforestation risk right there that can be dormant for many years and suddenly you can have a spike. It’s not like there is a permanent lingering risk always. One of the things we look at very much is a physical one being well what I’ve learned is that mostly when deforestation starts is that up to two weeks up front you can actually start knowing that because you will have trucks heavy machinery sometimes being driven into a certain area already and then the marking of the trees will start and the preparing etc.

It can take 10 days before the actual logging starts. So as of today, we’re looking much more in into how we can set up monitoring in that kind of way. And only once we are active and up and running, we will be able to assess risk and therefore also the risk to biodiversity. And that’s like I said going to be in spikes probably not in a permanent thing.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you David D.

David Dao:

I think one thing to mention here is that even in our artificial intelligence discipline, there’s no way we can we have solved this problem. So there’s it’s still very uncertain to monitor anything that is below like let’s say 3 meters per pixel. So like very small logging has not been able to be discovered. And I also very doubt the questioning that any kind of like eco acoustics models can actually either predict accurately or monitor deforestation. I think the one thing we have to take into account is we have data that has been collected historically sometimes for annually sometimes monthly with satellite images that are very coarse in resolution 10 m per pixel 30 m per pixel landset sentinel that allows us to monitor large changes in deforestations and so when your project site has a specific size let’s say 10,000 30,000 hectares on size then you can see changes but if it’s smaller than that then you actually need to involve the communities in it.

So what gainforce is doing is we have ways for participary mapping where we involve the communities that are living in that area that also can draw into the map and tell us specifically because no one knows better the place in the forest than these communities who are living there exactly what are the changes what are selective logging. For example, selective logging is impossible to measure through cells because for people who want to cut down a very precious old tree, they are smart enough to cut pathways through the forest that are hidden by the tree canopy.

So you don’t see the street, right? The street is very small to transport that old big old one. So we really rely here on participant mapping and I think that’s the only way possible. And everyone who tells you that your AI or machine learn based model can predict or even estimate deforestation. I would heavily like as a scientist doubt that because the AI models are only as good as the data they have and the data is heavily biased on towards like North American and European forests we have currently.

Jonah:

Great. Sarah,.

Sarah:

Hi. So I think with regen we’re a little bit different. You know what you were just describing is very detail oriented and methodology oriented. Whereas we look at this on the perspective of how can everyone who has a different type of method to quantify a specific ecological outcome have a pathway into the marketplace. That’s where our program is developed to essentially allow everyone who is a scientist to be able to have these debates together about what are good solutions and how do we bring those into the marketplace quickly so we can get our monitoring moving faster.

But when we step back from a marketwide perspective, I think actually the value for this from a marketplace perspective really is in what you can do when you curate those outcomes. So, the idea of being able to pull together Amazon protection credits from a lot of different projects and get them into the marketplace faster or allow those credits by bundling together to create more efficient liquidity pools is another lever in this ecosystem that kind of comes up to the pattern level of not just how do we quantify and what’s the right quantification method, but how do we bundle those assets into the marketplace and move liquidity along fast enough that it then funds the projects.

And the methodology developing evolving very quickly on the ground.

Jonah:

Great. Would others like to answer this question? Okay, I’m going to go ahead and call on some others who have joined the call. Simon Fel, it’d be great if you could introduce yourself and introduce yourself in two minutes. We’re all excited to learn. You’re on mute.

Simon:

Myself and others have been car developing carbon since 2006 through combination of red but also savannah burning and also soil carbon. Now in terms of remote sensing 4 GHz cameras are doing 2500 pixels per square meter. One with the amount of data that you can get you can create a real dense data cloud and really measure forests. Two we’re using DNA sampling. So taking water from waterways and using able to extract micro DNA in order to do a full biodiversity audit of all the species in a forest that’s happening here in Australia right now.

And three you know digitalize everything. We’ve been working for some time now in terms of digitalizing every single one of the SVGs and that’s what it’s all about. It’s about digitalize, measure, reporting, transparency, and we’re putting a lot of time and effort and investment into that. So, and in addition to that, connectivity so that we’re doing there’s blanket connectivity that’s going to immediately towards the end of the next year, there’s going to be direct space to mobile links on everybody’s phone, even if you’re 100 miles from the cell tower. And we’re partnered up with the people who have got that technology.

And we’re also putting phones and recharging devices into the hands of over the next year we’ll have over 100 million people in and around forests who will have devices in their hands and rangers. We also have a ranger app which we’re readapting from the Philippines where everybody’s talking about collecting additional data other than what you can do remotely using satellite and what have you litter and it’s an observational app so that I could I could put the link to it onto the screen here. I’ll put it on the notes. You can have a look at it where you.

Jonah:

Have 20 seconds.

Simon:

That’s it. That’s all I need.

Jonah:

Okay.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah.

Jonah:

Great. Thanks so much, Simon. Okay. I’m gonna we’re getting to know each other. We’re getting into the meat and potatoes of blockchains and forests. I’m going to ask a couple more call participants discreet questions and then we’ll get into the more industry defining questions. How do we make this market? Erin, I have a question for you and the Leaf Coalition. Are you aware of technology solutions or even blockchain solutions that bring jurisdiction wisdom to token development?

Aaron:

So far not nothing that’s gained traction. One of the things that we think there could be use case for is basically tracking the payments to communities. Most of these jurisdictions will have benefit sharing programs. So ensuring that those benefit sharing programs are followed and that the money gets to the ground I think could be an interesting use case for the for blockchain. But we haven’t seen anything yet at least that’s got that seems to have traction.

Jonah:

Okay. Okay. Provocative questions for the group. Should we this is open to anybody. Should we as a network develop some regenerative currency or system together? That could be a single currency, could be a technology that makes many of the best available here interoperable. Any responses?

Brad:

I mean, hi everybody. U my name is Brad from One Small Planet and thanks for that Jonah. I feel like at the very least it’s what I’m most interested in is how do we all play together to accomplish the same vision. I don’t know what that looks like. And I do think that everything here is going to be interoperable when we move forward far enough. And so I wonder what this group can do to begin to build the foundation of that communication and collaboration and growth. Great. Others welcome either feel free to talk about the technology angle to that all together or about the sort of political influence angle of how we enroll corporations governments.

Unidentified participant:

I can jump in real quick. I there’s a thinker by the name of Bernard Latier who’s no longer with us and he came up with a theory about money that’s based on ecology actually and information sciences and u his findings found out his findings kind of demonstrated that having a robust ecosystem of currencies is a lot more safe than having one single super national currency that could be brittle you know more efficient but much more brittle and also a lot less agency to local, you know, collectives, organizations when you have this one currency.

So, in a way, I’m much for having a coalition of currencies that are instantly interoperable and liquid. And that’s kind of the beauty of what cryptocurrency could provide. In fact, you know, most of the people that are going to be our end clients aren’t going to care or even know what blockchain we’re built on, whether it’s Polkadot, Cosmos, and all the rest. We’re all awesome, by the way, because the world is the future is multi-chain. Same thing with currencies. That the important thing would be what are the currencies that are going to reach scale and then really how are they built?

Do they have impact built into them? Like I am thoroughly impressed by the words of the team at region and territory who are talking about taking into account historical perspectives on the land and making sure that you know the legacy holders are going to be made good. And that’s the kind of stuff you could really only do with a digital currency. So, I wouldn’t vote for having one currency like the Ministry of the Future, but having several currencies that have the right kind of intentions literally coded into them.

Jonah:

Great. Other responses. Feel free to just come off mic.

Sarah:

This is Sarah. Sorry, I just want to chime in really quickly to kind of add on to what the last gentleman just said. I also think from a market force perspective that we’re really talking about utility that is runs the gamut from semifable to fungeible and the understanding those core concepts in the marketplace is actually really critical at this time. So let’s say you bring a credit onto the blockchain, it brings all its data. It’s semifable. It’s one of a batch from a particular vintage, a particular place, a particular practice.

It can be bundled into something that is fungeible like a base carbon token and then brought into the marketplace and I agree that it won’t be one currency that rules them all particularly as carbon becomes bound to existing cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin but ultimately it’s about understanding the utility onramps and the utility connections between these ecosystems and allowing the community to define what types of credits and what’s brought onto the blockchain with what data sets. So from a community perspective, there’s a power lever in defining what qualities and information comes onto the blockchain and how that’s used to audit transactions, representations of credits, etc.

But then there’s also this power of fungeible liquidity coming into the marketplace that can drive funding very efficiently and that will take us.

Unidentified participant:

And I added something to the notes, but I think I think we can’t avoid having multiple currencies. I think what we could work on together is defining the overarching protocols for collateralization so that we make sure that all those currencies have really high quality client aligned risk adjusted collateral in them and that and the methods for valuation of natural capital. That there’s a standard protocol for doing that and that every and then ultimately we can make sure that ecosystem currencies is backed by truly wellvalued natural capital.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. And just to add to that, which I think what the other side of that is to what Gila was saying, having multiple currencies is and that biodiversity metaphor naturally implies that they’re they form a network and they are, you know, they’re bound to each other. You know, as you’re talking about each of these currencies have embodying some kind of algorithmic intention. These intentions talk to each other and that’s encoded also in how they’re cross funding each other and so what you end up with is this kind of like distributed basket of currencies that will have the where we can get indexes out of that and have the best of both worlds in some sense.

Jonah:

Great. Okay, one more comment on this question then I’m going to move more into the market making questions. Anyone else? Okay, let’s talk about setting standards and protocols and using those that already exist. I’m sure everybody’s heard of the international standards organization. What are the professional associations that are helping to set standards for this sector, these many sectors actually? And let’s just have a brainstorm. These are people that we would call to a new constitutional convention designing decision-making pathways for helping forest finance and token accredititation and more. Brainstorm who are the institutions to involve very impressive lists.

Any others on our end? You know, we’ll be the first one to say that we’re not the experts in the different sectors. We’re technologists, we’re deepens, we’re social entrepreneurs, but you know, we heed. And so what we at least have been doing is reaching out to more legacy institutions like Vera and gold standard and the big players in carbon as an example. We just spoke with some registries and the Rex market and honestly called them on to bring him on Shane to bring the adult into the room. So that for really sensitive sectors where trust is so important obviously the irony trustlessness but trust is really important when it comes to carbon and stuff of the sort.

The last thing we want to do is have a wild west. So honest it’s been tough. A lot of the institutions are slow. They’re glacial technologically speaking. There’s a lot of whether it’s bureaucracy or you know interest, but it’s really tough. But I think it’s supremely important and again this that’s our position that we hit to the experts because we’re definitely not the experts on that front. Feel free wrap for Sarah. I saw some hands raised.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, I mean I think we are instinctively approaching this by we I think I mean Ned and myself we end up approaching this from a go to market perspective rather than a standard setting perspective. Hopefully the outcome is the same but we get we get the speed to market angle a little bit better. And by that I mean the facto standards are the best standards right and we can we can try to design up front the ultimate be all and all standard but we should at least consider having a minimal de facto minimally usable and intentionally limited standard that plays a role in just getting us started and having some measure of interoperability comparability and so on rather than waiting for the for the ultimate standard to be ready.

Jonah:

Ruff, do you have something in mind? Rough, do you have something in mind?

Rafa:

Sort of. We’re working on a part of it and we’re happy to share a little bit more, but it’s still kind of on the in the in the realm of Well, I mean, I don’t want to hog the discussion here, but we do we’re coming at this from a from a theoretically based approach, which is looking at all of Earth and its component ecosystems as a free energy principle following mechanisms which is the kind of the Gaia hypothesis as seen by the lens of Corferson’s active inference framework and that does allow us to start talking about to some degree of approximation.

Some standard ways to describe systems and the attendant social biological systems and the attendant currencies and be able to put on the same footing different ways to measure and to claim observations as well as to model for and forecast present, future and past impact. So, thank you. Have a little bit of that.

Unidentified participant:

Could you share anything that if you have any more material there to share? I think well this was completely over my head so far but maybe if I read something I might be able to get it.

Rafa:

Yeah, we’re still working on the translation layer to normal people speak which is why I didn’t want to talk too much about it.

Jonah:

Great. Feel free to post anything that’s relevant. Sarah then Nicholas.

Sarah:

Yeah. So I think that regen holds a slightly divergent perspective on standards than what has been mentioned here. And what it really rests in is that from our experience with on the ground partners, these existing standards are great. They’re really great starting point, but they really don’t work at all scales. The cost of doing them, the cost of going through the methodological development process, the access and true reflection of the users on the ground being designed with and for, you know, indigenous and local communities for local action. There’s been a lot of push back to a lot of these forestry methods that have existed and so the way regen approaches this is slightly different.

So we have this program that allows any grouping of experts that once creates its own methodology to partner with people on the ground and in real communities and design methods that make sense for that practice, for that place, for that community, for that culture. And that although we too you know work with Vera and existing registry standards our registry is seen as a sort of super registry of registries. People can bring their projects from other registries and represent them on ours as well. We actually think the innovation is going to come when you when you let people create their own standards when you let people develop it authentic to their communities.

When you get the process and the expense of it out of the way and you say, “What do the people’s methods look like? What do the community’s methods look like?” And we’re willing to accept having slightly less accurate or slightly less complex forms of carbon calculation if that’s what’s appropriate for communities and seeing credits through two lenses. One being community or flexibly designed to really meet a community where it’s at and the other being, you know, highly accurate institutionalized credits for that particular buyer type. But if we can’t get everyone to participate in the marketplace, we’re just going to run out of Vera credits and have nowhere to go.

And I personally am interested in evolution that goes beyond that.

Jonah:

Great. Thanks, Nicholas.

Nicholas:

Thanks. Yeah, I mean just to piggy back on Sarah, she spoke to so much of what I was excited to share as well is like what I’m most excited is the collaboration and cooperation tools, the network that brings everybody to the pages that shares these you know whether it’s strategies, standards, technologies, actually methods on the ground and what’s able to share these things live time as opposed to when the research is only published. As a researcher myself, one of the biggest problems is we have to wait one or two years to find out something failed.

When we’re all working independently and siloed all in different boxes and why are we competing to save the world in so many ways especially in this DeFi technology and you know finding some narrow-minded focus of like how do we all get on the same page is like I think naive to believe that we have the perfect solution so far and getting as many different opportunities at this solution I think in all forms from the actual on the ground to the digital to the financial end of things we need to be able to exercise as many different options as possible and then I think the synthesis of what is the best is going to be how we move forward to the greatest solution going forward.

But I think we’re far off from that on every strata. That’s it. Cheers.

Jonah:

I want to recognize the irony of my question. Part of the appeal of crypto is its startup ability to solve problems. The government system hasn’t solved yet. My question is how does it set standards? So it’s there these competing flows of energy and requirements. Okay, we’ve now reached that part of the call. We have a half hour left, 33 minutes where it’s open mic. So who has questions for the audience? I’ll make one general open-ended question which is what can we do together? Who’s interested in joining a council of marketing, market making, fundraising, political liazing?

What do you guys need? How do we improve these access to market strategies? Open-ended list of questions. Please try to reduce to keep your comments to two minutes. Feel free to raise your hand. I’ll just call in people in order and if there’s something urgent feel free to just come off mic and interrupt somebody. Anybody go for it Simon?

Simon:

We’ve already created a $500 million bond and that’s already in the market now. It was announced just before COP and we’re going to do more bonds that purely for carbon origination and meanwhile I’m working with people who are kicking goals in the whole blockchain sector because I can see that we’ve got a whole wall of carbon credits coming on next year. We’ve already got over 20 projects. I’m very likely to be signing a whole of jurisdictional red with one country in Africa in January and we’re already got contracts on with five provinces in Papa Newu Guinea and they’ll be signing starting on 27th of this month.

Okay. So you know the bond thing is happening but the next piece and we’ve also put an index we have indices on carbon which is on the S&P plat platform. So that means that just like oil just like gas just like copper there’s now an index for carbon and it’s called carvex I put it on the on the chats you can have a look at that. So we have that as well. Now the key the next step is this whole securitiz sorry tokenization of these assets and I Gard was right on money.

I don’t think it’s going to be this meta currency that is going to cover everything. I don’t see that. I think it’s going to be sectors. I don’t I think it’s going to be that the carbon that is generated for example you’ve got Corsia for the aviation industry. So there will be which is a carbon platform for the aviation industry. There will be different platforms for different industries shipping telecommunications steel all of these things. And the critical thing to my mind is to inset the story of the solution into the carbon generation so that they are offsetting but their story is inset into the very origination of the carbon.

If you can get that concept. So complete the circle. So you’re creating a customized carbon through the lens of a particular industry rather than just creating carbon and selling a finished product. Okay. So I think this sector by sector and you know I’ve got a sector which we’ve now got I think about 39% of the sector. It’s one $1 trillion a year revenue sector. We’re doing that very solidly and I think that there’ll be other like I say other sectors other currencies and then of course there’ll be community currencies that could operate country by country where people want to actually see you know I’m talking about right down to an individual household that’s it.

Unidentified participant:

Okay thank you sir others.

Unidentified participant:

You know, I’ll just tag on that. I launched an insighting program that’s cora compliant as a when I was at RMI for aviation called Saba. I would say we should be thinking about that collectively, but it’s very difficult to do. And is always at risk of being compromised by the special interests that have compromised the current standards because by no means perfect especially when it comes to the ecological side of things but the idea of figuring out how we can direct insing into the Amazon rainforest by industries are dependent on the Amazon I think would be a very interesting way of doing it.

We could we could use a lot of the things we talked about today to overcome some of the challenges we have with aviation.

Jonah:

Great. So there’s a model for us to follow others.

Unidentified participant:

Actually, I’d like to comment there that it does sound indeed difficult to get everybody on the same platform. But on the other hand, we are in an incredibly urgent situation both as a globe and the case of the Amazon rainforest, we’re talking about a tipping point, dieback where we’re already in. We need to reverse that within let’s say this decade or the thing gets out of control. So even if it’s difficult, I think it’s very important that we do the effort and do not we don’t have too much play time like you had with the with the Bitcoin for instance which took 10 years.

We don’t have that time.

Jonah:

Alex up next and then Galad.

Unidentified participant:

So look, I think it’s a question of how. I mean, if we all were entirely competing standards and we’re trying to kind of have our version win and go out and compete for money, that’s obviously not the right way to do this. It’s not the it’s not how we’re going to succeed and it’s not the ethos of the technology. But at the same time, you know, if we all spend our time in some sort of consensious bureaucracy that’s trying to generate standards and we don’t really engage with the urgency of the situation and drive our own projects forward, then we’re all going to fail too.

There’s got to be something in between where practically the sort of the consensus or collaboration model between us is intelligently designed in such a way that we actually all get something out of collaborating and it’s not just a goodwill thing because the goodwill things are all very well but they never actually get to the point where they’re generating something good. So they’re actually taking energy away from the very important fight that we’re in. So I think we are so on for collaborating and I’ve got thoughts with you know numerous of the people who’ve spoken today about ways that we could intersect and then it’s just kind of you know want to so to speak the urgent there’s enough urgency that we also can’t afford to do things to be nice we have to actually be doing this to get as much capital through as good methods into the right structures as we can and I think learning from each other is a huge piece of that collaborative edge as well because it may be that some projects are better at raising money and some are better at deploying and some have better indigenomics and some have a better way of dealing with Wall Street and you know if we can weave those threads together over time then obviously we’re going to be in a better situation than not.

Jonah:

Well said Gilad.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. A couple of things. The simple easy one which sounds almost trit but actually I’ve really been noticing the impact that I’ve been receiving and people on my computer receiving is as simple as even having a telegram group of the right folks batting around ideas and then actually because everyone here is quite connected and quite intelligent and there’s a lot of potential here for a mind. So something as simple as that could actually be quite effective. On our end I think the top three complaints that we have noticed amongst impact focused investors are u lack of access to deal flow lack of standardization of metrics and lack of ability to find liquidity when it comes to things like debt.

A lot of this could be solved with obviously blockchain, right? But even when there’s a platform, there’s still there’s so much there’s so much lack of access to these deals. A lot of them is it’s from our experience again is, you know, word of mouth. It’s small syndicates. There isn’t a place to really drive a lot of folks to actually invest with their hearts. So there’s a lot of projects here that are focusing on tokenization that are either looking for finance or representatives of family offices and syndicates that are looking to invest.

Having the platform to make that happen would I think ease a lot of the friction points. That’s really the friction points is what we’re talking about. Again, there’s a lot of supply of capital and there’s a lot of demand of capital and they’re just looking for a place to connect and that’s what you know we’d love to work on and we love to work on with you guys.

Jonah:

Great follow on Eigor, feel free to share.

Igor:

Sure. So I represent Impact Investment family office fund. And you know I don’t have as much knowledge as you guys have, which is why I’m on this call and trying to learn as much as possible. And I feel like a lot of people are coming at this from a kind of a search for alignment investment and trying to figure it out. And it’s hard to process all of this information. You’re trying to as an investor pick out what is the most efficient that’s your intention and so you basically end up having to do it in your head.

So it would be amazing to like people have been saying have a kind of platform that would basically assist investors in assessing what is the most effective and perhaps it can be something simple like a you know like a matrix like a file with columns with the different values and kind of components that we find effective in all of these different approaches. And so you can kind of simply see quickly, you know, what’s working, what’s not just by assessing it. And that’s a really easy way to kind of show other people you know, what to focus on.

And so there has to be some kind of consensus on that. So obviously that can be an evolving tool. But yeah, so it would be amazing as an investor to have that tool and to be able to share that with others and it would make the process so much more efficient because I’ve seen so many people, you know, having kind of billions and billions and billions of dollars of private capital. That they would like to divert into this and they just have no idea. And some of these people like you know I have a friend who’s worth like 20 or 30 billion and she’s inheriting that money now.

She’s married to an indigenous activist lives in the jungle and has no idea and her team has no idea how to do this. So like for example for her she would need something simple to like map things out and direct her team. So it’d be amazing to like know what that tool is and to see it kind of formulated. Thank you. Thanks. Next up, Raph.

Rafa:

Yeah. Know, it strikes me that this is a microcosm of all these kind of like large scale coordination issues, which is well, you want to bet on you want to see an outcome get achieved, but you have to pick specific projects and you know there’s scarcity of resources, time, energy, money and so on. And you know there’s approaches to it. Markets are one approach. Organizations are another approach. And you know, today we’re in the era of ecosystems and where, you know, basically toss things into a wall and get some level of self-organization that makes some of it stick and progress.

I wonder if there’s some there’s some learnings from complexity theory that we can use to get this to get a little bit more streamlined. It doesn’t have to be anything too complex, but I’m just wondering like there’s given that you actually want outcomes, why not invest in outcomes, right? And I think there’s a bunch of instantiations of these approaches and I’m not familiar with too many of those. But u can you get to a point where folks like the folks that I mentioned don’t have to try to figure out if they are actually investing in the one thing that will get into the place that they want but they get some builtin diversification towards that strategy and that those outcomes that they want.

Sorry if that was too abstract.

Jonah:

We’re good. Any questions or follow on from Igor or Ref? Okay, I’m going to start to work on a little bit of synthesis. So Amazon Investor Coalition, we’re in touch with a lot of investors and grant makers and bilateral aid agencies and it’s our job to help create some connectivity. So this call is what I believe will be the first of many aimed at upgrading the conversation, creating shared learning experiences and creating facilitating some transactions for primarily the nine Amazon region countries but all of those who have global offerings are certainly relevant.

One thing that comes to mind is the importance of organizing the grant makers and the investors in an upstream fashion. I’m wondering if anyone on this call has experience working with the carbon council of the international chamber of commerce or with the task force on scaling voluntary carbon markets on these issues. Okay. Well, th those Go ahead, Simon. You’re on mute. No I haven’t personally but a member of my team has and also doing a lot in where we’re members of my team have been advising governments on their red platforms and also they’ve been doing thing creating methodologies and what have you.

So I say yes but not me but I have the people that can do that have done that. Okay. Okay. Great. Erin, could you tell us a little bit about your experience with the task force on scaling voluntary carbon markets and the ways that we as a group might be able to plug in with the deliberation processes to explore their interest in blockchain solutions.

Aaron:

So sure I was on the consultative group and participated in most of the calls. The they’re now in a they’ve just transitioned from a task force that they’ve got a new name I think integrity. It starts with integrity. I’m forgetting what the initials are. But they’ve basically selected secretariat for a new governance body. And they’re really just kicking off kicking off their work. I think they’ve picked two or three organizations to act as the secretariat. I know that C2ES is one of them. I the others, but I think it probably would be worth a call as they get started to check in with how they’re thinking about using these, you know, technological solutions, blockchain, tokenization.

They’re still trying to get their legs underneath them. But happy to make that intro if that’s helpful. Yeah, that’d be a great a great intro. Any others on those two particular institutions? Okay. On the grant maker side, I have asked many of the largest carbon concerned grant makers about their tie-ins with blockchain. It’s so many for it’s so new for so many of them. Does anybody know of a grant-making foundation that is looking at blockchain and force financing issues in significant detail? Maybe even has a program officer focused on it.

If there is such a person, I don’t know them. Jonah, we don’t have a specific program officer focused on it, but it’s certainly on the foundation side of One Small Planet, something that we’re very interested in, and we took a couple steps this year. And we’re looking forward to continue doing that largely through program related investments.

Jonah:

Okay, great. Does anybody know the people at Climate Works or the Environmental Grant Makers Association or the Environmental Funders Network? Not necessarily just the staff there, but the people who may be tasked within those sort of larger grant maker environmental grant maker associations to look at new projects, new technologies as they might relate to carbon markets. Does anybody know if any of those groups has like a professional blockchain employee or consultant they’re working with? Can.

Jonah:

I talk? Go ahead, Dougger. Go ahead, Simon.

Simon:

Yes. Look I know those organizations but we’ve got we’ve now got resources we’re already have in order to get create the index for carbon we used AI in order to use AI in order to do that we’ve got an AI lab what so what I want to do in relation to blockchain is our AI our funding which did the AI for get creating a carbon index and is now doing the AI to create indices for SGS. I would love to fund a blockchain solution. So, we have funds for that. Okay.

So, and I also ask for some help in the group on a special project which some of you might be able to it’s alongside the blockchain. I’d like to ask for some help and if anybody then wants to get in touch with me that would be fantastic. And what it is this. We can turn the voluntary markets voluntary carbon into compliance carbon which will expand its market very considerably. How that’s going to be achieved is collecting more data. There’s now 4 gigahertz LAR cameras which can mount by from airplanes. We’ve got one coming here to Melbourne next month to be mounted into a plane to do Southeast Asia.

That gives us data if we want up to 2,500 pixels per square meter. Practically, you’re talking 4 or 500 pixels square per square meter. What that means is this. We can dig we can collect the digital information and we can actually through the lasers shooting at different angles and a real mass of lasers over the forest. We can actually measure every single tree in a forest at breast height its diameter. Every single tree. All right. What that means is that’s a huge data set, you know, to be to be crunched in order to then get the carbon inventory extremely accurately quantified.

That quantification will create a compliance grade carbon credit. I need help with people who can say, “Yeah, I got my hand up in terms of creating the analytic platform to take that huge data set and bring it right down.” So, if anybody out there in this group says, “Yep, you know, I could do that.” I want to hear from you. I’m recruiting people right now to participate in the analytics piece of what we’re trying to do.

Jonah:

Great. Would anyone like to just sit raise their hand or message Simon and then we’ll move to Suzanne and Isabelle and Rap. Okay. In response to Simon’s question, feel free to post in the chat or to message Simon directly. I posted his email address. Okay.

Unidentified participant:

Jonah, just in response to your question about grant makers. I just wanted to say that at Rainforest Foundation, we did get seed funding from the McGovern Foundation. They didn’t have a specific blockchain professional on their team, but they were interested in the technology and their board was. And so they gave us financing for developing a direct payment system, a blockchain based direct payment system for indigenous communities that prove that they’re protecting forest using satellite verification. So at least mention them.

Jonah:

Great. Great. Isabelle.

Mariana:

Hi all. It’s actually Mariana. I’m using my daughter’s tablet. But Mariana from Kerasos in Colombia. So we’re working the bio biodiversity credit kind of ecosystem and we’ve piloted and now developed and operated several habitat banks and leading the way on that front and as and that’s mostly a B2B market right the clients of biodiversity credits are mostly companies that need to offset their impacts but we’re slowly entering sort of a voluntary biodiversity market and we see that, you know, tokens might be the proper way to get us there. And in that process, one of the things that we’ve done is kind of develop a standard for what a biodiversity credit is.

And we’re working with multiple organizations including the IDB Natural Capital Lab. We’re working with a program from the UK government called UK Partnership for Forest. We’re working with oh my gosh, USAD a specific program here in Colombia. So it would be really interesting to connect with folks here that would be interested in exploring the way that we can use tokens to really leverage and put biodiversity credits out there. And just to give you a sense of what we’re doing, each credit represents one hectare of a threatened ecosystem that is protected for 30 years.

So we’ve learned a lot. We’re developing the standard because there’s a high risk that people will start selling air and that’s one of the concerns, you know, when you hear about all these different tokens. I do worry about that. So I think it’s good to be talking about standards. And maybe our experience can help that process in any way that people might think it’s possible.

Jonah:

Great. Mariana, could you please post your full name? I assume it’s Mariana Penzon. And email address and LinkedIn below in the in the name of the institution.

Unidentified participant:

Okay, great.

Jonah:

Eager, I see your hand raised. Was that from previous?

Igor:

I’m actually typing out what I was going to say, so it’ll be in the chat. So, hopefully every everyone reads it. Okay, Alex,.

Unidentified participant:

Just earlier on someone who dropped off the call whose name just escaped me posted about the natural what’s it called? The now the name escaped me. The IADB New York Stock Exchange natural capital company or natural capital corporation structure that was just announced and I’m curious if anyone here knows what’s going on with that and would be interested in having a cycle to talk about that. I’m curious if that’s a structure that could be actually built in as part of the sort of legal entity over the you know the blockchain products that number of us are working on.

But it may be the person who knows about it dropped off the call. So that’s the research.

Unidentified participant:

Alex, I’ll write you a note.

Unidentified participant:

Great.

Jonah:

Okay, great. Okay, Raph.

Rafa:

Yeah, back to the grants and funding and coordination of investment topic. One pattern that I see the Ethereum Foundation using is getting a lot more popular in recent years is this notion of you have a DAO and you endow the DAO and it has some algorithmic criteria for algorithmic criteria for what the DAO is going to invest in or subsidize and so on. And that might be an interesting thing for this group here to explore where I see all these kinds of funding sources whether they’re for-profit or not nonprofit that are interested as I mentioned funding outcomes and a Dow with a proper governance could be a good vehicle for taking away the kind of like prospective and trying you know private information versus anyway all the coordination aspects of it.

So TLDDR Dow you put money in it gets pulled proposals come in and money gets allocated according to some governance criteria.

Jonah:

Great. I included a wiki link about Dows. Feel free to post more about the one you mentioned. Okay. We have five minutes less. This is you know sudden death period where oh I got to say one more thing. The call unfortunately will need to end right at the top of the hour. If there is anyone on this call who has not been in touch with me through email, please email me or post your email here privately. If anyone wants a copy of this chat which has extraordinary number of resources in it, feel free to email me jonah w nexusglobal.org and I’ll reply with the chat.

So here’s some invitations. Th this has been the most popular call we’ve had so far. We had we got on of the Amazon investor coalition. We’ve had almost 70 people join. There’s obviously a very big future in solving these questions whether it’s for us or the Amazon or for the world. There’s a huge amount there. It seems to me that one of the biggest needs is understanding the appropriate space for collaboration and competition. Understanding the space for organic startups developing minimum viable products and developing more collective standards. There are many other open questions here.

There is a huge amount of learning going on and no central global expert. So invitations for you guys one please go crazy in the chat and post the white paper that everyone here needs to know about. Another thing if you haven’t posted your information already your u your email address LinkedIn please post that. And then here are the more structural invitations. I believe that we will try to create a conversation at a global level on these issues among grant makers and separately among investors. Of course there are many more of on investors going on these issues.

By organizing and governments I think that will the four governments that are putting money into the Amazon I think are outside of South America are all very interested in these issues and don’t have the answers and recognize the needs. So I think that as we convene these stakeholders and professionalize the conversation, we’ll be able to set up the transactional bodies that allow all of those who are looking for funding to connect systematically with those who are trying to figure out how to invest in invest philanthropically or for profit. And I think that there are huge number of public private partnerships that can come together to finance many of these vehicles.

Some are represented on this call. The Interamerican Development Bank is very deep in this. So anyone else on the call who would like to call for a discrete convening of those in this constituency or would anyone on the call like to introduce themselves who may not have done so yet?

Unidentified participant:

I’d love to have a call for anybody who’s interested in on the protocol side of things. The how would you tokenize? So the I’m forgetting all the names of the companies, but if you were going to tokenize this and try to get a common way of building protocols. So I don’t know how we organized that, but I think there was a couple people out here in the deep on the token side of things and the currency side of things versus more on the application side of things. Although that’s the most important, the front side, we could all be running different directions.

Back side.

Unidentified participant:

Okay, we have to set up such connections.

Jonah:

One minute left. I encourage everybody to go ahead and the chat. Feel free, Greg, to introduce yourself.

Greg Barry:

Yeah. So, everybody, my name is Greg Barry and 25 years ago, I was designing currency systems with Bernard Leotar and a number of other people that are connected into the system. Five years ago I became a whole wealth adviser and I’m working with a firm that’s an emerging MFO multif family office. I’m working with a number of young progressive people who are very interested in these issues. So I’m keen on sort of both sides of this conversation. My day job affords me more flexibility to help coordinate funders. So Jonah, I’d love to tune in.

I’ve got two reasonably new clients. We’re both particularly passionate about the Amazon. And so it’s got my attention hyperfocused on this topic with a you know a really strong mindset around sort of digital assets and all the things that we can do to build these things out. So it’s a it’s fun and an honor to be reconnected. Jonah, I’m just amazed at your mastery of facilitating such a dynamic and a flowing call. And if there’s an opportunity to work on the particularly for-profit but also nonprofit funer side, I’d be happy to co-co-create that with you if it’s useful.

So nice to meet everybody.