Fashion and Future Amazon Sustainability
Beto Bina: Today, we discuss the fashion industry and Amazon. As a $2+ trillion industry, fashion affects Amazon deforestation. While consumption of uncertified leather drives cattle expansion, the purchase of native rubber pays for conservation. How can fashion help? What is the history and future of Amazon rubber? What are the market opportunities for Amazon plant fibers? What is the role of new technology? Join a conversation with Beto Bina of Farfarm to learn.
Recorded April 12, 2021
References:
Fibers from the Amazon
Tucum fiber
Jupati fiber
Kapok fiber
Banana fiber
Others: Buriti, Miriti, Piassava, Ramie, Sisal, Juta
Fashion industry tech relevant to Amazon
Article on Rubber History and Biopiracy:
The Thief at the End of the World: Rubber, Power, and the Seeds of Empire
WWF Brazil improves the valuation of native rubber from the Amazon
Mercur: Native rubber project reaches its 10-year anniversary
PAIMM: Corporate Sustainable Fashion from the Amazon
From rubber trees to the world, Manoela Paimm talks about her brand, using native rubber from Acre and honoring fair trade
On Leather:
Burning issue: How fashion’s love of leather is fueling the fires in the Amazon
On the Fashion Industry:
How Fashion Brands Like H&M and Veja Are Helping to Stop the Amazon FiresLVMH unveils its “Biodiversity” commitments and strengthens its partnership with UNESCO with a project in the AmazonH&M to halt buying Brazilian leather tied to Amazon fires
What are you wearing right now? If it’s rayon or viscose, chances are it comes from the Amazon
Fashion for Conservation – The Campaign to Save the Amazon Forest
Ethical Fashion Institutions and Networks
Fashion for Good
UN Alliance for Sustainable Fashion
The Fashion Pact
Sustainable Apparel Coalition
Sustainable Fashion Alliance
Fashion for Conservation
WATCH:
Participants
- Jonah (moderator)
- Beto Bina
- Alfie
- Danielle
- Lars
- Joyful
- Jessica
- Unidentified participants
Transcript
Jonah:
Hello everybody. Welcome to the 40th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing forest friendly economic development across the Amazon region of South America. And this week we are going to focus on the work of Beto Bina and we are going to talk about the fashion industry and how it influences the Amazon or could influence the Amazon. So let’s go ahead and jump into it. Betto, tell us tell us about you. Tell us a little bit about your life before Farfarm.
Beto Bina:
Sure, Jonah. Thank you so much for inviting me. Taking everyone. My name Beto Bina, from Brazil, and I my early career was always as a strategist in a in the creative industry. My mom is an artist, my dad is a designer, but I always been super connected with nature. So my dad used to work for FAI, which is the federal organization that works with indigenous communities in Brazil. So I always been super connected with the Amazon nature. I’m a surfer since forever. And then I used to work as a strategist mostly in advertising agencies.
I lived in New York for four years and as all the entrepreneurship stories goes. I was like in a in a career that I always dreamed. I was a strategy director in the largest digital agency in New York. But inside I was like super depressed. So I had to do something. So I did Farfarm six years ago.
Jonah:
Excellent. Tell us what is Farfarm.
Beto Bina:
Farfarm is not a place. It’s a it’s a energy. No, I’m just kidding. Farfarm is a it’s a it’s a business, a consultancy. So back in the day, I started to research what I really wanted to do and I got obsessed about agroforestry. Right now everybody’s calling regenerative agriculture but agroforest for me was this notion of using technology as an analogy but trying to implement that into nature. So when you have technology you have some logic processing when you look at when you’re programming or developing something you look to the logic of if this happened then something else happens if this then that so you apply that to nature using agroforestry always in two axis when is the horizontal axis which is the succession of species and the vertical axis which is pretty much sun and shade and how to integrate all these plants into this full ecosystem.
So I fell in love of that trying to design nature. On the other hand, I was looking on how can I have materials from nature from the system that could also tell a story that could have this value added because if I just like producing commodities just like food for example, I didn’t have like a competitive effort or couldn’t have like a strong value for people to pay a little bit more because of all these beautiful stories. So I got into the fashion industry and the natural fibers and I also got obsessed about it.
So was two big obsessions especially because natural fibers is part of our existence is so intimate always connected with us tell a lot about culture there’s a lot of craft ship involved so many elements that I started to getting super curious and also one major data point I was looking at that 85% of all the fibers in the market are what we call toxic which coming is either from oil from an oil industry like polyacer, acrylic, nylon or from monoulture of cotton which is which is a crop that using one of the most that use insect sides and other chemical fertilizers.
So 85% was I toxic at the same time all the major brands like inditex H&M they were looking to connected with sustainable development goals looking to next 10 years to have like 100% responsible fibers. So moving from 85% toxic trying to have 100% responsible fibers. So that was a huge business opportunity for us. So I connected agroforestry and cotton and we developed this concept called it textile agroforestry which is pretty much planting. Thank you. Pretty much planting organic cotton and natural fibers using agroforestry system like this one in my background.
Jonah, let me know if I’m talking too much. Okay.
Jonah:
No, you’re doing great.
Beto Bina:
Okay.
Jonah:
Although feel free to, you know, do something wild, you know, turn around in a circle, anything like that, just to increase the entertainment value.
Beto Bina:
Okay.
Jonah:
Just playing around. Okay. Next question. Tell us a little bit about what you do for Veja and what is Veja?
Beto Bina:
Veja is a French Brazilian sneakers company. It has been in the market for 15 years globally. We sell Veja in over 60 countries now and some of you probably know. Can you do just like just raise your hand if you know Via the ones you have video on? Great. So majority people knows Veja in Brazil is known as V. But Brazil is a small market represent less than 5% of the sneakers company. Thank you, Leonardo. And Via since the beginning, the core was not to not to do what the average fashion brand does or especially when goes to the shoe market which is injecting money into marketing or influencers to generate awareness about the brand and then sell the product later.
Visiona never did publicity, never did ads, never paid any influencer. All the money goes to the supply chain. So we develop work with organic cotton in the northeast of Brazil with wire rubber. Our leather is super special. We still I think we use leather. We respect a lot of vegan consumers that disagree with that. But our leather is super special as well. We go deep into the supply chain of recycle PT. So all this supply chain we go as deep as possible even buying directly from the raw material and then selling to the industry.
So the idea is to develop a great product with a great story and let people tell this story instead of doing the opposite making like a super cheaper inexpensive product and putting a lot of marketing on it. So it’s a little bit different. There’s a lot of other things about Via. I’ll stop now and then can ask questions later.
Jonah:
Great. So le let’s get into the rubber soles of these shoes.
Beto Bina:
Okay.
Jonah:
I understand the story of rubber is one of the prime examples of bio biopiracy. The extraction illegal extraction of a piece of biodiversity that creates wealth elsewhere. But that doesn’t benefit local communities. There was this Brit named Henry Wickham and he was under the employee of Q Gardens in London and in 1876 he smuggled some rubber seas out of the country and that led to the eventual demise of the Brazilian rubber industry. But there may be a future rubber industry. Beth, tell us about native rubber. What is it and what is it used for?
Beto Bina:
So native rubber as the as the name says is native from the Amazonian biome. Because you can have natural rubber natural latex but it’s coming from the rubber trees that could be planted everywhere in the world. Right now one of the largest producers is in Southeast Asia. Native rubber or wild rubber is the one that you have the rubber trees growing naturally inside the forest. So just to give an idea on average you find only one rubber tree per hectare and then the senators like you call it or this family of producers they walk through these trails and they tap or they use a tool to tap these trees and extract the latex of around 100 trees every time they go walking through the trail.
So it’s a really hard work but it’s so beautiful because you are doing extractivism but it’s a response of extractivism because you’re generating this raw material from this bioeconomy that’s keeping a standing forest and that’s super important because when you have native rubber all the ecosystem is intact all the ecosystem services is still there. So it’s not just about carbon, it’s about biodiversity, water availability, scenic beauty, it’s about heritage of the people that live there. So all these things is still intact when you have native rubber. Moving to the natural rubber, natural rubber is natural.
It’s not synthetic, which is good. But most of the natural rubber is done using monoculture. So you’re planting only one species. So you are not actually diversifying or bringing all this biodiversity and all this cultural legacy that this people has and everything that related with the forest. One thing that you say internally at VA is we want all our supply chain to be a place where we can do a picnic with our friends or your family. So when you have a monoculture of eucalyptus or a monoculture of cotton, that’s not a such a good place to be because it’s almost like a desert, right?
When you see like the monoculture of cotton, even though it’s organic cotton, but it’s not a good place to be. So natural rubber has this problem of doing as a monoulture. There’s alternatives to do using regenerative systems or agroforestry system. I can explain a little bit more about agro if you want later but now okay just organize the whole spectrum and then you have the least good or the worst which is the synthetic rubber right it’s coming from the oil industry is one of the most polluting industry in the world 99% of all the shoes you see out there they are made with synthetic rubber so we’re trying to move to have as much as biiobased materials into our shoe.
So every shoe, every visa shoe has some percentage of native rubber from 10 to 30%. In the sole you also use another elements and another materials you call it silica or carus. Sometimes it’s just a powder but you use to doing the sole is like a it’s like making a bread right you mix a lot of ingredients and then and then mix them together to do the sole. So in our so have from 10 to 30% native rubber we use rice dust as well. Castor oil in some one’s banana oil and are also using the dust or the waste from the nuts Brazilian nuts industry.
So I try to put as much as possible biiobased or renewable materials into our shoes. Our latest running shoes it’s almost 60% biiobased or renewable materials which is for the category of running. It’s a it’s a really remarkable number to have. Should I move to agro forestry?
Jonah:
Go for it.
Beto Bina:
Just so everyone’s understand and I’m super passionate about agroforestry but the idea is to integrate forest or perennial trees or trees into agriculture. Most of the plantations we see are monoculture. Some plantations are rotational which one day they one season they plant cotton the other season they plant soybeans and so on and sometimes is consortium so it play like big roles of diversification all of these practices they are they are degrading soil especially if they are using chemicals they are using GMO seeds so they’re really hard for the soil so they’ll never be regenerative because they are degrading the quality of the soil.
At some point this that soil is not useful anymore. So you need to move to another plot deforest some plot and it goes. So the agroforest and regenerative system you have this alleys of perennial trees that you plant in between your cash crop, your major crop or other crop you like to plant. When you plant trees you have this bone of sucking carbon. Super important for sequesting carbon. That’s one of the most important things because carbon it’s right now the only unique metric that you can dialogue with the financial market.
So it’s the only one who can put dollars behind. So it’s important to look at carbon. A lot of brands got obsessed about carbon but you cannot neglect other units, other services that natures provides. So biodiversity is another one. So if you have trees, you have a lot more insects and a lot more of birds. So it was proven that when you have an agroforestry and you have a coffee plantation using agroforestry, the birds eats a pest that is an insect that eats the coffee. The same for cotton. We have something we call it budu which is the most important and the most damaged pests for organic cotle and we have more trees we have more birds these birds eat the pests we need to use less of biological inputs you lose less of your production so there’s so many different types of agroforestry what they are doing mostly in a where I work is the state more on west of Brazil.
It’s super wet. It’s the middle of the Amazon. It’s also working with rubber trees using agraforestry. So, they also plant cacao, Brazilian nuts. Sorry guys, I say Portuguese, but ingga, jatobba, they plant all the others fruits and nuts or oil. They are be able to have these different revenue streams for the families. That’s super important. Not just sell one thing, but have like a bucket of different revenue streams so these families are able to have a decent income and not move into illegal deforestation activities.
Jonah:
Excellent. Agroforestry has a very bright future globally in the Amazon as well as elsewhere around the world. Let’s get back to the fashion industry for a moment. So, from what I understand, the fashion industry reaches about $2 trillion a year in annual turnover. Sometimes more, sometimes less. It depends on the year. But it’s also responsible for an estimated 4% of global climate emissions. So, transforming it with these green alternatives is a giant market opportunity. One industry helping startups like yours or one institution is fashion for good. Can you tell us about the organization and how they supported you guys?
Beto Bina:
Sure. So fashion for good is based in Amsterdam and they basically has three major models but all of them connected with acceleration of startups. So we were the first on Latin America joining and I think the first one on regenerative agriculture as well and basically they do three things the mentorship they connect you with brands and that’s where I met the Veja founders Fran which we end up working with them and the third one is basically networking so there’s a lot of other cool startups Some of them I’m going to talk about later.
Agra loop is one of them I share with Jonah. So pretty much these three so the mentoring clients and networking and then we move to different stages of acceler acceleration. We did the early stage and right now we’re discussing to maybe move to a scale program or a next stage. Fashion for good also has a really beautiful museum. If you if you if you go in Amsterdam, of course, right now it’s probably closed, but they have a beautiful museum of materials and like a library of materials actually and have a store as well.
So, it’s a pretty cool place to be and also follow them on social networks as they always posting about new startups, new projects, new technology connecting mostly fashion and sustainability.
Jonah:
Nice. So let’s talk about fiber for a moment. Beyond rubber, fashion depends a lot on fibers to weave new clothes and things like that. And you have been doing a bit of research about fibers in the Amazon. Tell us what you’ve come up with. Tell us about some of your favorite plants.
Beto Bina:
There are so many, Jonah. And I think it’s fascinating or maybe the fact that is most crazy is that we don’t we don’t know what we don’t know. So we know maybe 5% or less of the fibers in the Amazon. There’s so much biodiversity and so much work needs to be done. And so the research I started to do with farm was trying to find a fiber that we could connect with the industry because most of the fibers and I can talk about them they have a limit they are really artisal fibers and we don’t have technology all the technology in place right now is just designed for cotton everything we do is mostly cotton but for example there’s a fiber which I found through a friend in Par went to this place was like I had to sleep in a boat going to this place vista was the city’s name and this lady did like beautiful artal purses with this fiber it’s a palm tree called a jupachi and there’s another fiber called a tukun fiber it’s from this other palm tree there’s You may heard about tukuma.
Tukuma. It’s an oil. It’s pretty amazing oil. Natur has been using for some products. And there’s always tukum which is a super similar palm tree. They have this huge spikes in the trunk. So it’s super high hard to extract. And basically the leaves of the tukun you can take out the soloic or this like blue element and it’s a really beautiful strong fiber. And there’s a lot of projects already evolved. The place that is most known is Epicuna in Amazonas and they do beautiful work with tum fiber but again still artisally.
Another fiber is super important is juta or jut. Jut is not native from the Amazon. It’s actually from Japan. It’s a it’s a type of grass but grows like for up to three meters high. And the cool thing about Joot is that it grows by the rivers. So they plant during the beginning of the wet season. So all this J gets almost like underwater throughout the season and grows really well. And then during the dry season they harvest the jute. So you don’t use irrigation, no chemicals, fertilizer whatsoever. Grows super fast and a super long and strong fiber.
This one they do have a spinner, a gin and a weaving machine. But they do mostly this big sacks to export coffee and potato. So you see a lot of jud in India as well. So it’s a super beautiful fiber but again super rustic. If you might have seen some maybe some rugs or for home accessory you see a lot of jute but it’s definitely no good to use in contact with your skin. But if you could work with the technologies and try to sort of like cottonize jud this could be an amazing fiber.
Jonah:
You want to name one more? Good. Go for it.
Beto Bina:
Yeah. Just really quickly. I think like banana or pineapple. All these things are super cool fibers as well. And also using the cellic or the biomass from the Amazon to do fibers and alternative for leathers and other types of materials. That’s a huge opportunity.
Jonah:
Great. Let’s let’s talk about this word cottonizing you used. Tell us what it means and then let’s get into these four technologies that you educated me about that are part invented by the fashion industry and that if brought to the Amazon could give life to new markets let’s start what is cottonizing mean and then let’s get into agrial loop.
Beto Bina:
Yeah so Jonah most of these fibers they are really rustic strong fibers like the jupachi especially from palm trees or they are too short fibers like the pinea there’s the largest tallest tree in the Amazon sama and it’s a type of pinea and the pina in English called it kpock it’s a beautiful fiber but it’s super short so in the middle you have a fiber that it’s good on the touch it’s around 30 millimeters. So, it’s a it’s a longer fiber which is cotton. And all the genie machines that extract the seeds from the cotton, the spinning machines that makes the yarns and the weaving or knitting machines, they’re all designed to use cotton.
So when you say cottonized, it’s trying to get these type of fibers that are not designed or not adapted to the factory or the spinning weaving machines and try to work them prior in order to using this large machines. Why is important to have these large machines, right? It’s you need to have scale. If you if you really want to get into the fashion market and make an impact, you need to have a scale. All these fibers could be used artisally. People makes beautiful products especially for the luxury market but we won’t have the impact that we need just working artisally.
So in order to cottonize you have many different ways to do it. These technologies they use each of them use one type of cottonization but you could use microbiology with enzymes to work on the fibers. We could use like electricity and a shock to or some of them has like a closed intellectual property. They don’t tell you exactly what they do. But they but they do cottonize. And super important as well, I forgot to mention there’s not hemp in Brazil. Brazil is still not allowed. We’re years behind other markets. But I know in China, especially in Nepal, they have hemp and they are also cottonizing hemp, which is super important if you want to use hemp for the fashion industry.
Just important to mention, Jonah, sometimes we see, okay, you have like a but I have a shirt with hemp. You either or maybe coconut or maybe bamboo. All these other fibers, they especially bamboo and coconut, they’re super hard to extract. So sometimes you need to use costic soda, you need to use some chemicals to do it. So it’s super impactful. Or sometimes you just use the biomass and you put together with other synthetic elements to do wasting. So it’s super hard to use. Or sometimes you just have like 5% of hemp.
And then you say this shirt has hemp, but they don’t tell you how much of hemp. So sometimes 95% cotton, it’s 5% hemp. And then you think it’s a it’s a ham shirt. So that’s so it’s super important to customize these fibers in order to have the impact we’re looking for.
Jonah:
Great. So I’m going to ask Betto to walk us through each of these four technologies. Then I have one quick question for him and then I’m going to open it up for questions for everybody else. So real quick, maybe just like a sentence or two each. Walk us through these technologies. Tell us about Agraloop.
Beto Bina:
So I’m going to tell you what I know Jonah because for example Agraloop they are amazing but they have a protect protected IP and they don’t tell you exactly what they do but it’s basically you use the fiber for example if you get banana you extract the banana fiber mostly there’s many types of bananas but mostly from the trunk so they get a and you can do that artisally we’re trying to do that and cottonizing with the enzymes but they get all these trunks and they put into their machine and what they what this machine does it’s dissolve all the other biological elements but the fiber and then what comes out of this they call their curtification the curtification I think that’s the name I could be wrong and then what comes out of this machine is the fiber itself so I if you guys are interested maybe send the link later but they explain a little bit in the in the website.
Jonah:
Great. The next Lenzing tell us about Lenzing and I did I posted the links in the chat.
Beto Bina:
Great. So Lenzing it’s a it’s a super large company. It’s from Austria and they do visos. Viscos basically it’s getting some cellulogic biomass you put together with other elements and through extrusion you press it through a machine that does fiber like smaller than your hair. What Lenzing does differently is that they don’t use any chemicals and all the water they reuse into the process. So it’s a full circular process. There’s a lot of other companies, big companies trying to do visos with less impact. Important to say that less it’s not necess necessarily good.
So some of them they say we use 50% less water, but they’re super impactful. So be careful on that. Bal Lenzing in my opinion at least is the most advanced technology for a visos or rail super similar process with the least impact possible.
Jonah:
Now tell us about seph which is used with hemp and then natural fiber welding.
Beto Bina:
Great. So seph is a really cool technology. It’s a crazy technology and never heard about before. But what they do they use mostly hemp fibers and they do they use electricity and they do a huge shock with a high voltage that the hemp fibers once extracted they become cottonized. They become similar with Cotto that the farthest I know about the technology but you can definitely check them out in the website and they did and they provided all the hemp fiber for the latest Levis collection they use a lot of hemp from these guys but it’s I think it’s super interesting technology because just use electricity doesn’t use water doesn’t use any other type of chemical inputs so it’s an interesting technology And the last one is natural fiber welding.
What they do is an alternative for leather. Some people call it vegan leather. We cannot actually call it leather but because they use biiobased materials. Most of these alternative for leathers for leather guys. It’s pretty much the same thing. You have a base which could be organic cotton, could be any other fibers and you have a coating on the top with this formula. All the products out there when you when you hear about ah this pineapple leather, this is grape leather, this orange leather, they’re pretty much using the same thing which is using PU polyurethane which is synthetic coming from oil mix it with the biomass from that fruit that vegetable.
So what natural fiber welding does they use they develop a 100% biiobased or plant-based material. So they use the same base which could be organic cotton but on the top instead of using PU polyurethan they use rubber and we are in touch with them because they really want to use the white rubber but I should be saying that.
Jonah:
I so I want to say one special thing about the fashion industry as a match for the Amazon. If you’re trying to take pineapples for the Amazon and sell them, people aren’t necessarily going to pay for a pineapp one pineapple over another just because it comes from the Amazon, but they will for fashion because fashion is a industry that extends into luxury. It’s a place where the where a markup on the value is part of the culture and part of the industry. So please those who are interested in asking questions come off video raise your hand put your interest in the chat area.
Last question for me Betto tell us a little bit about what you know from the existing global sustainable fashion networks. I’ve heard of the sustainable apparel coalition the fashion pact alliance for sustainable fashion and others.
Beto Bina:
Jonah what I think most of these organizations and the fashion agenda they do I think it’s a super important and strategic to join them because they are they are taking they are taking some directions and some priorities because there’s so many things you could do in fashion and they’re they’re aligning on priorities. So most of them are aligning with the SGS. So it’s super important to have the targets and to understand where are you going and how can you measure success right so they’re mostly helping on that but I think there’s two main things maybe three they’re also doing that you should look into greatest opportunity in the next few years one is to focus on biodiversity so you measure the impact and the success of your supply chain because of biodiversity the challenge is how to measure biodiversity.
It’s super hard. If anyone has technologies, clues, any guess I love to hear more about it. But most of the practices and the research I’ve seen, it’s just like artisal measurement, you know, getting like a super small sample counting how many species you see there. So, it’s super hard and the most important fact is that we don’t know the impact of biodiversity. We know sometimes when you deplete it right but is not much of the impact. So I would say that moving from carbon to biodiversity I think that’s one important direction.
The second one is that 80% of the fashion supply chain are women of color from emerging markets and they probably getting not a beyond living wage. So we need really need to look into the fashion market and not apply the same colonialism that we’ve been applying to this industry but trying to understand socially and when you talk about regenerative fashion regenerative super important word right now right you need to also regenerate socially. So especially in factories and with these women one crazy thing about fashion is that every single piece of sims this was done by a person.
There’s no much technology that can sim a garment without a hand of probably women of color from emerging market. So looking to social aspect is important. We work a lot of agricultural families. That’s also super important because most of the supply chain look to large holder farmers. Brazil you see like this crazy rich people. There’s five families that owns all the farms of cotton in Brazil. Brazil is the fifth largest cotton exporter and most of them is from five families. So they’re increasing inequality. Our work is pretty much getting these people.
They are the victim of inequality. They have like small plots of land of land for example. But they are also the solution because if you build them, if you educate them on new practices, they can develop the most important raw materials with the value added like you’re saying and so on. And the third one is traceability. So it’s really hard to trace. There’s so many elements and people involved in this supply chain from the farm to factory to consumers. So technologies that implement for example it’s almost like a DNA that can read exactly where it’s coming from.
Blockchain it’s super important. I see blockchain more as a database. It’s super hard how to collect the data on how to trace them exactly. All the certifications it’s important I really like and we join Odian origins Brazil they have some type of K code they show exactly the community this raw material is coming from so I would say traceability to trust all the supply chain is important we’ve seen a lot of people even buying organic certifications realize it’s organic anyway I would say these three strategic pillars is the one that these organizations are helping us to focus.
Jonah:
Great. Our first question is from Alfie. Go for it, Alfie.
Alfie:
Unmute myself. Hi. This has been fascinating. I’m actually talking to a potential brand sponsor for my green superhero IP. It’s a major global brand. They have a focus on ocean plastics and creating apparel from ocean plastics. One thing I’m keen on for them to do is go from ocean plastics to fibers from regenerative agriculture. Is there I mean do they integrate well these ocean plastics and plant-based fabrics do you know just so that when I have a conversation with them I can give them kind of a road mapap to integrate these regenerative fibers.
Beto Bina:
Super interesting question, Alfie. I think that there’s a few challenges. One of them is in order to recycle any fabric, if you have a blend, it’s super complex. There are some technologies. For example, you have 50% recycled PT from the ocean. Beautiful project. 50% cotton, but then this got discarded. And then you want to recycle, you can just downcycle, which is like chopping everything and making like a poor fabric. Or you need to find a technology that can separate the polyester than the cotton. So these materials still have the same qualities to be upcycled.
So I think that’s important. The other important point is that for the ocean, it’s super hard to collect this material in scale. There’s some companies doing probably know but I know SQL it’s a really cool company from Portugal and Echone is from Italy and they are actually using nylon which is the material from the fisherman nets just remind me that I just watch a suspicy the documentary on Netflix it’s dying so it’s definitely important problem to try to solve thank you for the question.
Jonah:
Alfie you can follow up if you Why did you ever.
Alfie:
One of the other things as well as I’m talking to partners around hemp is obviously you know in the US is booming and so we’re looking at hemp apparel as well and so you one of the you mentioned electricity being used that was kind of a waterfree but what was that process called again just so that I can take a note of that.
Unidentified participant:
That’s seaf ef got it okay.
Alfie:
Thank you yeah.
Beto Bina:
Of course Yeah, that’s great. Yeah, because the ocean because I do know that sea spiracy that the ocean plastic issue is there’s a lot of misinformation around it. And that’s one thing I know is that once the plastic’s in the ocean, it’s pretty much useless anyway. So, it’s trying to get and also longer term they’re aiming for like 90% of their apparel to be sustainable and I don’t think Ocean Plastics is going to do it for this brand. So it’s great to have that give them a road map to kind of transition from ocean plastics into more just regenerative fibers because I think that’s where the real impact of the company is going to be.
So but I’m going to I’m going to ping you on LinkedIn and I’d love to kind of continue the conversation. There’s a lot for me to learn. So thank you very much for that.
Alfie:
Thank you.
Jonah:
Great. Thanks so much. Next up is Danielle Rapaort.
Danielle:
Hey Beetho and everyone. Great talk. Thank you. Super interesting work. One comment, one question. The comment I’d love to chat with you about some of the latest innovations in acoustic monitoring to detect biodiversity in real time and overtime because that really represents a attractable solution to the problem of biodiversity monitoring at and really cost effective. So feel free to shoot me a line or I can I can follow up with you about that. My question is about kind of how do we wean consumers off this fast fashion problem. You had you had mentioned that Veja doesn’t invest in marketing so that you can spend your resources on supply chain itself.
How do you deal with you know and yet most consumers probably have never heard of regenerative agriculture. How do you deal with the consumer education piece of things?
Beto Bina:
Great question Danielle. I think you have connected before. I’m not sure but I would love to I’m not sure but I would love to learn more about the biodiversity solution you have. So regarding consumers one interesting thing about visa is that even though we have all the this process and responsibility 95% of via consumers doesn’t have a clue about our supply chain and our sourcing initiatives. What we’ve done I think was smart was even though we don’t do ads we don’t do publicity but we do marketing. Mark seems to have like a pretty good website connecting with journalists.
We do some we don’t interrupt people with ads, but we have a strong communication effort for people that can change or influence opinions. So we bring journalists to our supply chain. We walk them into the rubber trails. We show how much we are paying to produces our contracts and everything we do. And these journalists and talking about vision. So a lot of influencers like Megan Marco, Emma Watson, they love to use Veja because of the cause. They’ve heard about it and they use it because they have the same cause and same passion and then their followers end up buying Veja.
So I don’t think we have a direct solution. What is important to mention is that first of all you need to be fashionable, you need to have quality, you need to have design and then maybe the fifth or the sixth will be like sustainability, right? So if you just focus on sustainability, we won’t have a market for that. So we need to achieve all these major elements, you need to have price, you need to achieve all these elements and by the way be sustainable if you want to get consumers attention.
I think other factor I want to mention is that I believe fast fashion is changing a bit. I think one of the good things about the this pandemics is that we realize that the economy the economy stopped because we just stopped buying things that are not vital for our lives right because we’re still buying food. We’re still buying the things that are important. When we stopped to buy the things that are not important all the economy was got in collapse and then for the fashion a lot of people realize that the reselling the secondhand market and all these new business model are growing a lot and it’s super interesting and cool it’s an amazing experience so there’s this data that in a few years not sure how many but the resell market will be larger than the fast fashion market and I think that’s a super insightful and super important and an opport opportunity who wants to get into the fashion industry with a new business model that’s not the same fast fashion because I think this is going to lose space and I hopefully become obsolete in the future.
Jonah:
Great. Thank you. Are there any other questions? I’ve got one for you Danielle. Can you tell us a little bit about your biodiversity acoustic monitoring?
Danielle:
Sure thing. Yeah. So all vocalizing animals, birds, bats, insects, mammals, fish, they have distinct acoustic signatures that we can detect in real time using AI methods. Just like Facebook detects our faces, we can use the same kind of deep learning methods to detect animal sounds. And so using a cheap recorder you can you can inventory the animals in surrounding footprint in real time. So it’s a really valuable method to kind of complement what we can see from space about change. Happy to elaborate to whomever might be interested. My email is in the chat box there.
Beto Bina:
Super interesting. What about the silence by the like fungi maybe trees?
Danielle:
Oh, so yeah, it we’re only sensitive to the component of the of the community that vocalizes. So, animals principally.
Beto Bina:
Super cool.
Jonah:
Great. We still have, 12 minutes left, so plenty of questions. We’ve had an unusually large turnout for the call, so I know there’s a lot of interest. People, don’t be shy.
Lars:
I’d like to jump in, Jonah.
Jonah:
Go for it. L than joyful.
Lars:
Thank you, Beto. It’s a truly amazing story. It’s really fascinating. I learned a lot. And of course the fashion industry has huge impact. What we have tried to do is you know affect like leather consumption for instance with H&M and stuff like that. But what you signal is in a sense much more impactful if it can be done at scale as you say if they really start using other types of fibers etc. So it is not clear to me if you see any particular opportunity or possibility or potential in one or two of those fibers that are sort of close to possible breakthrough to be used in large scale.
And also if you have thought about sourcing once something is used in a large scale then there is also a massive sort of uptake of the raw material which in itself can be harmful. So how to do large scale sustainable sourcing?
Beto Bina:
Thank you Lars for the question. Regarding the first one, our approach and I feel many brands are doing this is to moving from like a binary material like one or they used to have just leather and cotton, right? To have a huge diversity of materials. So I wouldn’t say there is like one next fiber that will be like a breakthrough. But I feel that the strategy of having a different types of material in your portfolio might be the smartest strategy right now for a for many reasons like we still using leather and there right now the market the leather market is crazy in Brazil.
So the prices are doubling. If you have a product selling around the globe and your major raw material, most expensive raw material is doubling the price, it’s affecting all the supply chain, right? So, we’re finding alternatives for leather. But just to give you a straightforward answer, I feel that the alternatives for leather that using any type of biomass that’s going to have a huge scale because they have collaboration with the major chemical industries. For example DA stal probably it’s I think it’s from Europe so all these major chemical companies they are trying to solve the alternative for leather and it’s super important because some people that they’re super fascinated about sustainable fashion sometimes they keep into the artisal modules but you need to connect and dialogue with the industry right so if this chemical industry is jumping in to solve that but asking it’s other huge industry in Brazil they’re they’re replacing the sush shows with other renewable materials where these companies are batting I think it’s a it’s an interesting one so I would say alternative for leather using biomass and regarding the sourcing question one thing that we try to do ls is to have a positive impact throughout the supply chain so the work we are doing with wild rubber we are compensating these people with two major things.
We’re doing carbon credits. So we are using the REDD+ methodology from the UN. So it’s avoided deforestation and then they get paid because of that. And we’re doing we’re paying a conservation bonuses. We’re using a satellite image. Not sure if I have time but I can share. I have it open here to show you guys. Can I sh go for it? It’s a It’s a podcast, right? But in.
Jonah:
Oh, ju just be fast because we have two more questions.
Beto Bina:
Okay. So, I share it later. So, this platform, it’s a monitoring system. We use the same system that the Brazilian Feder institute used to monitoring and then the producers that have low deforestation, they get more bonuses. And then we’re using the carbon credit as an input. We call it insetting into our supply chain. So it’s providing a positive impact and offsetting our impact as a whole within the supply chain. So you can have as large as possible supply chain as long as you are having a positive or trying to have a positive impact distributing income, sequesting carbon and so on.
Jonah / Joyful — boundary unclear:
Great. Joyful, you’re up.
Joyful:
Hello everyone. I’m joyful. I am so happy to have listened to this. Thank you so much Jonah for letting me in and for sending the invite. I think Nette’s not here and I’ve brought in bunch of other people in here. It’s so wonderful to listen. I’ve been working with many other people on a project with one my partner called Thingi. And thingy. Our mission is to collect and share a simple moment of interaction. And so the simple moment of interaction that we have with our everyday tools and if we could say our clothes or fashion and stuff as a tool of expression, right?
So we just start as a base of wearing a shirt or wearing a hat. And how does that hat make you feel? How does that shirt make you feel? Danielle, you were asking how do we actually I’m not sure if someone was asking like how do we get the consumers to be able to think differently on how they are reacting with the material themselves and then you were saying well the material actually goes beyond the physical actually enters vibration of sound right so this project is called a thingy and our focus is to be able to collect moments that people are having with the with clothes that they’re wearing or their home or any material that they have around.
And so I would love it to share with you because it goes back to how do we measure like this simplest moment that someone has with I don’t know like mine this throw that I’m wearing is from a collective humanity and it’s called the joyful throw. Like I wear this when I want to feel the most joy, right? And so and all my friend when they see me, they know exactly what this represent. And so it’s being able to narrow down on not only consuming but knowing the emotion that is invoked by the consumption or by the thing that I have.
And so I would love to invite you all to share even just like your sunglasses, your hat, whatever it is at thingy at that world. I’m sharing it right now. But thank you so much, Beto. I’ve added you and I’m emailing you and Danielle, I’m gonna be emailing you. And then also, Peter, I’m gonna be emailing you. Thank you so much. Really appreciate you.
Jonah:
Great. Thank you so much, Joyful. Jessica, you’re up next.
Jessica:
Thank you, Jonah. Hi, Beto. I think I heard about you through Filipe from Ree. So I’m very a huge fan of regenerative approaches. But something that I always have this huge question is about how do you guarantee sustainability with an industry like fashion industry that you said that needs so much scale to the local communities like I work with local associations and it’s very difficult for them to be structured as an organization to provide like legal everything. So how can you manage to support local communities guaranteeing the scale scalability of the industry?
Beto Bina:
Super important question Jessica. I think there’s so many so many challenges. First of all it’s really educating cooperatives and helping them to organize themselves. We work a lot of NOS’s that be able to turn from association to cooperative so they can have an invoice for example and they can do the all the legal paperwork required and most of these families cannot so having this intermedi intermediary that is not there just because of the money but they can help structure that’s a really important point I don’t have a lot of time but I’ll say maybe the second most important is a company that has a fair trade practice ices.
So a fair trade practices is not just paying the bonus that most certifications do but is also having contracts. We do three years contract with them. So even before they planting they already know they can sell this harvest and the next two harvests. That’s super important. So as you mentioned they can keep going and developing the project they have. The hard thing is that Veja it’s a it’s a luxury product. We don’t need to pay the commodity price. We have a value added. So I think we need to bring more these type of companies and get sustainability more fashion.
So these type of companies that can pay extra for these materials and are able to tell the story to connect together with these families. We say that they need to have a agricultural budget. Most of these companies they just neglect or use third parties to do the work. The companies even it’s like a I think caring is doing a beautiful work. They are really engaged in working with biodiversity and so on but they need to go into the field be closer with these people and providing the security they have. Just another thing to mention Jessica you might have seen the innovation forum report about fashion and small holder farmers.
Super interesting report. They talk about all these challenges from cooperatives to having these type of brands, educating them financially, how can get a loan, giving providing micro credits and other important challenges. Thanks for the question.
Jonah:
If somebody wants to paste the website of that innovation forum report, please do so. And Beetto, if you would like to paste your email address, I have a feeling some people may like to follow up with you who might not use LinkedIn. We are at the top of the hour. We still have a minute left in case anyone has a last minute question.
Unidentified participant:
Fiona had a question over there in the chat.
Jonah:
Fiona, do you want to come online and ask? I can answer John’s question. Okay, go for it.
Beto Bina:
So John, with the leather, it’s pretty much we use native fields. We use a biome in the south of Brazil, call it pumpa. So when you have a grass taller than 12 cm, you have more carbon sequestration than entic emission from the cattle. So we don’t do we don’t use the cattle in confinement. They are like there’s no overg grazing and so on. So you can measure that through LCA’s life cycle assessment and you can make sure of course with the data that you are sequestering more carbon providing benefits impact into the farm industry and then you have also the teneries all the other in that need to measure that’s where doing the farm stage.
Unidentified participant:
Interesting. So it’s all kind of accounted for in the ranching area where the cows are raised. There’s a lot of content around regenerative agriculture or cattle. The Savory Institute is the one most known. It has a really cool TED talk. But it’s mostly the practices around rotational grazing. No overg grazing. When you do that and measure, you can have a climate positive environment.
Unidentified participant:
Ah very cool. If you have anything you could post in the chat or I can connect with you too, I’d love to learn more about that.
Beto Bina:
Of course. I’m writing now Savory Institute.
Unidentified participant:
Okay, perfect. Thank you. Savory sounds good. All right.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you, Vita.
Beto Bina:
Of course.
Jonah:
Thank you everybody. We’re now at the top of the hour. We’re converting over to unstructured time, which is where most of the people leave, but some people stay on. I leave the chat room open for people to continue copying down website links and things like that. Betto, thank you so much for your time. You’re welcome to stay around if you would like. It’s been a very enlightening experience.
Beto Bina:
Thank you, Jenna. Thank you everyone for your time. Pleasure to share my story business. Happy to connect.
Jonah:
Great. Betto, if you did post your email, I didn’t see it. I think maybe you possibly posted it to one person who sent you a private message. I posted at 4:59.
Beto Bina:
Okay, if that helps. I stay maybe five 10 more minutes if I just want to read all the messages.
Jonah:
Oh, I see it. Yeah. Yeah. Okay.
Beto Bina:
Joyful. I love the project. It’s so important to have because I think mostly the stories people are telling and sharing it. I feel it’s the one of the most important thing. They need to be able to own the products, right?
Joyful:
Yes, absolutely. We are selling I mean we sell emotion humans we sell emotions. We are storytellers and we’ve you know we’ve sold story through sound we’ve sold stories to visuals we have sto stories to taste you know all of our senses and now because of co everyone at least maybe I should speak for myself I feel more and more aligned to knowing which emotions I’m longing to balance which emotions I’m longing to bring in which emotions I’m longing to send out and even not only emotions but also energy right that goes with it and so from the plant to the body from the body to the plant right and everything else so it’s so I’m so excited to learn more about your work your.
Beto Bina:
Sorry to interrupt have you tried Iawaska before I’m serious.
Joyful:
I live I live in our land.
Beto Bina:
I did it a few times And it’s so powerful. It’s exactly the feeling, but you go to like an extra level of feelings. It’s super it’s super good if you’re connected with nature. And I think you love it.
Joyful:
Yeah. Well, I grew up I grew up in nine different countries in East and Southern Africa. And so I grew up in Rwanda, which was in the garden. And so the whole program of my belonging is being with plants and being in the forest and being with trees and but I’ve not yet been in South America, but I am excited for the next few years to dive there. Actually, Betty is on right now. She is Betty Igama if you want to but Betty I’m working with Betty in Chiaas Mexico to really understand to really understand how to communicate the colors from the Mayans the in chapas like we just want to communicate color we don’t want to even have words we just want to have colors Devon is on too we are trying to figure out the strategy how do we get artistic to be able to communicate also those emotions right away.
Brands not just only telling a story but brand being the story. And so and then also Francesca is on too and Francesca has been doing some really great work with one of my dearest friend Manali and to be able to really think about the diversity of ideology around plants and medicine but mostly plants gardens in Ethiopia and in Somalia and all the way south to Rwanda because we have such an incredible biodiversity that no one would know about it until you like you know you’re in a desert you look at some little, you know, plant and this plant when the sun comes out, it just pops and then when a sudden goes down, you know, it hides, you know, and so there’s so much life around us and I feel like that’s why I say I live in a skull.
Everything is there. But I’m so grateful to be here. Thank you so much.
Beto Bina:
Thank you, Joffrey. Thank you for the kind words.
Joyful:
Absolutely. And I’m happy I’ll connect you offline to share a little about Thingy. And Jonah as well. I’ll share with you both. But thank you so much. I really appreciate it.
Jonah:
Joyful, could you talk a little bit about Thingy right now if you had a few minutes because.
Joyful:
Yes. Actually, is it better? I think it’d be really better if I share with you. Can I share with you on a.
Jonah:
Sure.
Joyful:
Okay. For those who are staying, let’s see.
Jonah:
Checking it out right now. I can see the forms and everything.
Joyful:
Yeah. Hold on a second. Let me just close all these things that I have open.
Jonah:
And Betto, thanks again. I think I said BTO on accident at the end there, but.
Beto Bina:
It’s okay, John. In the US, most of people call me BTO because the E sound is just like don’t worry about it.
Joyful:
Okay, my screen’s quite a bit messed. But so this is thingy. My partner Braille is not here to be able to share it, but he is the mastermind. I am the community person who’s gathering all of us to come and play and to organize and to share. I love sharing. So thingy we have you know our mission is of course to capture organize and share creative way of being to foster belonging. So creative way of being is we were interacting with that because we want to say ritual because I feel like some people get really scared when you say a word ritual and they want to run away.
So a creative way of being is it’s more of like ritual. Other place you can even say ritual. It’s it would seem like a voodoo or something like that. And so we have the three places that you can be able to connect with us. You can share a thingy. You can explore and you could join our community. And so I what I would like to show you today is to the platform itself that we have been working on for months. And we did our best to not ask for any money to just see how far we can go with just using platforms.
So it’s running on a lot of platforms. Sometimes takes quite a while. But here you are. If you dive right in you get these call them thingy cards. And so they’re like tarot cards, but for a moment a moment of interaction. I probably Let me see if Devon is still here. Devon, are you still here by any chance? Do you want to talk about your card or should I just go ahead? You know what? Even better, I’ll talk about my cards. It’s much better to talk about my cards. So one of my card is as simple as this one.
So, one of my card is listening to the ocean. You know, not that many people get a chance to be by the ocean. What is what do what is it that you need? You need you need a con shell. How long is going to take you up to 0 to 5 minutes? You do it intuitively. My intention and my intention is to hear the sound and the gentle humming of the ocean. Actions only takes three act three steps. You know, find a quiet spot, hold the con shell near your ear, hear the sound gently the gentle humming ocean.
The most beautiful part of this platform is it’s right here also in the background, but you know, you have to really want to read it. But also my favorite part is the emotion component. So let’s say hope. So when we press on hope we have all well actually wow we have all these different cards that are able to bring you a sense of hope. So if you are looking for sense of hope go no further just find a card and then you take the action. So you could find a sense of hope in understanding your original clothes and picking a piece of nature or quotes and so let me go back here.
So you could also search based on emotions. So however you want to feel you could come here let’s see say joy. So if you click joy, you will have all these different resonating cards that are followed by joy. And so I hope that explains a little bit, but right now we are partnering with different brands to be able to be able to really understand how they want to bring themselves forward. So.
Unidentified participant:
That’s really beautiful. Yeah, thanks John. And thank you Sento. You know, thank you so much. I know like the Yale Institute for Emotional Science, they do a lot of like trying to categorize emotions. And I’ve read some about a bit of it. And it’s always difficult to well not always, but it can be difficult to kind of tie what your current emotional state is to words or like in essence. And it seems like this would be a good way to do that. You know like if I if I feel a certain way and I type in into thingy or something it could pop back with some very visceral kinds of descriptors and ideas for how I actually feel.
So I like.
Unidentified participant:
Absolutely but also it could go the other way around. So for example yesterday my masseuse told me she said oh every morning when I wake up I ask my daughters like right away what is your morning dance? What is your morning moves? And I was like what is the morning moves? Like I just want them to move around. That’s the only time I could interact with them without talking to them. And so that becomes a morning move. That is a moment of a connection point. That is a moment of joy.
That is a moment of really an understanding, right? But if that moment is not captured, it’s lost, right? So we are encouraging everyone, each one of us to capture those moment. But also that moment to go with a particular type of object because the things themselves we are things sometimes and that thing and so I said is that particular song you do something you do and she’s like no I just get my coffee and when they come was like okay then I’m going to use coffee to be able to connect to their morning the morning move so she’s going to create her card today within that but now I really want to do it and then she was like wow I did not know that was interesting.
I was like, “Is it another thing that you do?” She’s like, “I wake up in the morning and I just hold myself and I say, hello heart, you know, just hello heart. What do you want today?” Like, not me. Hello, heart. And then I thought, okay, so what can we do to be able to attach that moment to something? And so, she’s still coming up with an object that she’s going to be using.
Unidentified participant:
But it’s really great. So, but imagine if every plant that we’re interacting with there is a particular type of emotion and there’s a particular type of even a moment or grouping and then also how that it resonate to the material itself that will be a library of like emotion expansion and so that’s what we are working on and so we are getting in every meeting to invite everyone to come and share.
Unidentified participant:
That’s super beautiful.
Beto Bina:
J I have to go but I want to tell the last thing which I mentioned Iawaska before but that’s one of the Iaska plants which call it shakrona or yakuna in Spanish and it has a beautiful seed and they do a lot of artisal work with the seeds because has the power like they call it. So I think it’s not about selling the product itself but maybe these fibers might have an extra element that can help you with that emotion. Right.
Unidentified participant:
Absolutely. And where are you based now before you leave?
Beto Bina:
I’m in S. Paulo right now.
Jonah:
S Pablo. Okay. Perfect. All right. I’ll come over maybe.
Unidentified participant:
I’m gonna shoot you a note too and connect because in a different life I was looking at a textile recycling company and I explored some options around some technology out of a US national laboratory. I’d love to kind of hear your thoughts on the closed economy and how that relates to your work. But.
Beto Bina:
Let’s connect for sure. You got my email?
Unidentified participant:
I think I do. It’s in the chat, right? And in.
Beto Bina:
Yeah, [email address unclear].
Unidentified participant:
Okay, I will.
Beto Bina:
Jonah, thank you so much. Byebye.
Jonah:
Bye, Betto. All right.