Corporate Procurement and Conservation Finance
If economics drives deforestation, then is the forest worth more alive and standing, or cut and burned? What comes first, the Amazon forest produces or the corporate buyer of it? While some climate-conscious procurement officers may grumble about the supply and quality of select Amazon forest products, producers in the region complain about the lack of demand. Buyers and producers can join forces, but need help. Fortunately, some investors and entrepreneurs are starting to bridge the gap and launch new lines of business that finance Amazonian livelihoods and conserve forests. The innovation is the long-term purchase agreement and financial products based on it. Founded in 2018, Aliados conducts Amazon-centric R&D, promotes agroforestry, strengthens cooperatives, and fosters purchase contracts with foreign buyers. With partners like Nestlé, they have brought diverse produce to international markets, improved the incomes of numerous local farmers, and reduced deforestation. Founded in 2005, Maua Capital is an independent fund manager based in São Paulo, Brazil. Through new partnerships, the firm is leveraging off-take agreements for forest-compatible products to provide upfront finance, technical assistance, and structural community resources that catalyze the bioeconomy and keep forests standing. Join us to meet the innovators, Wain Collen of the Aliados Foundation and Carolina da Costa of Maua Capital, and learn.
Recorded December 13, 2021
References:
The Amazonia Sustainable Supply Chains Mechanism
Runa Foundation(predecessor to Aliados)
Innovation in sustainable finance: far behind the finances
Beauty Company Natura balances profitability and sustainability
Fully Alive: Using Lessons of the Amazon to Live Your Mission in Business and Life
SustainablePurchasing Leadership Council
RE100 (A leading example of using corporate procurement to foster demand and sustainability)
Cocoa: A Bitter sweet Supply Chain
Amazon Reforestation with a Profitable Twist
WATCH:
Participants
- Jonah
- Carolina Costa
- Wain Collen
- Juan
- Lauren
Transcript
Jonah:
Hello everybody. Welcome to the 68th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing force friendly economic development and the rule of law across the Amazon region of South America. This week we are featuring the work of Carolina Costa and Ma Capital as well as Wain Collen and the Aliados Foundation. Karolina and Wayne, I’ I’d love to go a little bit about into you guys and your backgrounds before your current institutions and then we can cover more of the professional ground during the presentations.
So Karolina, where are you based and tell us a little bit about what you did before MA Capital.
Carolina Costa:
So hello everyone. It’s a pleasure to be here. Thank you Janna for the invitation. I’m before MA capital I was in the academia. I was the vice director of a research and teaching university in Brazil a nonprofit and I worked like many years launching programs and also working with companies in innovation programs. So I understand this experience it gave me a whole sense of opportunities in some for innovation in some sectors. And in particular the affordances coming from companies that are actually committed with a more sustainable agenda and also I worked on like forming the next set of employees for them because I was also responsible for all undergrad programs including the engineering program which had a like a very strong technology based on circular economy and renewables and so all sorts of technology that is important for the ESG agenda.
I’m a PhD but also I’m a public administrator as a like as a background I think it’s like in and I’m also board member of some nonprofit companies institutions here in Brazil.
Jonah:
Great. Thanks so much. Wayne, give us a little bit about your background before Aliados.
Wain Collen:
Yeah, sure. Hey, Jonah. Hey, everybody. So before Alia, well, I’m South African. That’s where it all started for me. Grew up in South Africa and then when I was about 21 went walkabout like a lot of South Africans do. Ended up in England, China, Taiwan, and somehow my path took me to Ecuador. Arrived here in 2003. Was developing an environmental consciousness. You know, climate change was outraging me back then and managed to get involved in a nonprofit funion patchama worked very closely with the actual indigenous people on ecourism for several years and that’s really where my passion for working in the Amazon and also trying to find answers to this problem of how to foster sustainable economic development in the Amazon began.
Went and did my masters in Sweden came back to Ecuador and set up a consulting company focused on building sustainable community enterprise. That’s that was what I was looking at a lot. You know, how do indigenous communities organize themselves around enterprise as a solution and worked very closely with Maruna company back then and that was what led me to Aliados.
Jonah:
Great. We also have a new participant in the call that I’m going to call on a little bit later and I’d love for him to introduce himself as well. Hirod, could you give us a one minute introduction about yourself?
Unidentified presenter:
Sure. Hi Jonah. Everyone. Sorry be late joining in here. Here at Sebetti, I’m with a fourth sector group. We’re basically an NGO that’s focused on promoting social, sustainable, equitable, regenerative, whatever you want to call it, purpose- driven enterprises which comprise a fourth sector, the economy around the world. And our work is mostly focused on enabling the ecosystem that surrounds them from public policy to financial markets to standards and assessment protocols and training education. All the different kind of ecosystem services that enterprises need to be able to function effectively but focused on businesses that are oriented towards public benefit and environmental sustainability versus private gain.
Jonah:
Great. We’ll get more into that work later. A little bit about framing. So probably 15 years ago the or 10 years ago the RE 100 started. This is a campaign in the United States to compel large corporations like Apple to pledge to buy their future energy from renewable sources. The game caught on and it spread and it created a giant pipeline of demand for renewable energy. If you look at the website of re0000.org, you’ll see this story. The Amazon needs the same thing. You can produce and sell rubber in the Amazon, but if you’re you have degraded land and you’re going to restore it and plant rubber trees, it takes eight years before those trees begin to produce latex.
Who can tolerate that delayed profitability? It’s very important for corporate procurement to step in and give a demand signal to the network so that entrepreneurs and investors can line up and satisfy this the these long-term financing needs that are that have to be in place for a larger regional sustainability strategy to work. So we’re going to first look at it from an investor perspective and then we’re which is Karolina’s work and then we’re going to look at it from the producer intermediary perspective which is Wayne’s work. Karolina is working mostly in Brazil.
Wayne is mostly working in the Andes. You’ll see how these two regions have some things similar, some things different. And then you’ll see this larger picture of what we can do to scale. Karolina, feel free to go ahead and into your presentation.
Carolina Costa:
Sure. Let me just share with the audience. I think I have a couple of slides that might help people to understand a bit. I don’t know if everybody is seeing it. Yeah, I think it helps the audience to understand a little bit the rational and fair far away from saying that this is the only way to produce change when you’re talking about Amazon. We’re mostly of the producers are small producers that have to be inserted and embedded in supply chain systems. So one thing that I understood and I learned from solidarity network which is a it’s a NGO I’m a board member and has over 40 years of experience working with small producers is that most of the time when you’re talking about investment teases people often mistaking the investment case with the business case and the business case has to do with the producer and understanding his reality.
That is not is not only access to financing but also access to technical assistance, cooperativism and all formers or all forms of organizations that help this producer to really get productive capacity in order to really engage in keeping forest standing. And I think when you’re talking about Amazon, you have a huge competition with activities that are much more profitable for this small producer and that doesn’t require so much technical capacity in order to produce. So the change theory here and is not like the only one was not the only ch the only way but is important one and is the one that Ma Capital which is a small asset management firm.
We have 1 billion dollars under management and our focus is to do this very specific tailormade financial instruments together with companies that really solve these two challenges reducing the cost to change for the producer and also increase the gains with preservation. The two things are important here. So in terms of reducing cost for changing you have to talk about ways to provide financial resources in a very attractive rates which is something very hard to get because the small producers usually lack documentation and all sort of guarantees that bank lines like require.
So when you are and only giving them credit and money, it’s really sometimes giving them a pro a trouble because they going to have a hard time in paying back this money that they borrowed. So you have to provide at the same time attracted financial rates, technical assistance and some source of in knowledge for them to get on cooperat cooperatives that make them strong and they increase their productive capacity. At the same time, what we believe is the importance of having big offtakers like companies that can have these producers in their supply chain system integrated and these companies are the ones that might help to provide commercial agreements that are advantages advantageous for them.
And also technology and knowledge to help them to increase productivity. And hopefully that is something that is not easy to find. But I keep looking and I only work with companies that are willing also to pay a premium price or a better price compared to the market for having access to these raw materials and these products that are really produced in a more sustainable fashion. So you have to have an economic model for the producers to get engaged. So this is what we call the business case for producers and this is what has to be interesting for them to engage in this new way to produce and actually reducing the pressure for them to go to activities that are not compatible with the forest for activities that are more compatible with the forest.
So this is the rational and then as a asset management firm my role is to work with partners. So I have many NOS’s that sometimes work with me with the knowledge with KPIs with governance system but as a financial market agent my role is to put together the financial instrument. But to be very honest here, the financial instrument is the least challenging piece. The most important piece is this economic equation that is worthwhile for the producer and is actually reconcile productivity and sustainability. So talking about Amazon, this is very relevant because Amazon although contains 6 67% of the world’s tropical forest cover, it only represents 0.2% of the global market on forest compatible products.
So even our casta dupara which is a Brazilian nut and it has this name Brazilian nut the biggest producer is Bolivia is not Brazil and it’s a interesting questions why it’s so hard to have forest compatible products in a region that is the lead that has the most the biggest territory on the on the on the type of bio ingredients. So you have other activities that compete with forest comparable products because they either have more access to credit or because they don’t need so much capabilities in order for them to get to get going.
So you have a system that lacks systemically access to finance, robust value chains, productive capacity and local infrastructure. So when you talk about a financial instrument that actually foster forest compatible products that is possible through small producers you have to get all these variables in your equation in order to really do something that is going to is going to produce an impact. So our model and like we are like going into the idea of having companies as anchors in these transactions. You have companies that offtakers in fact they actually advance money in exchange for purchase agreements.
So the producer has an agreement with the company and the company based on this contract can advance money considering some sustainability commitment that this producer will have with the company and in return the producer will have upfront finance and other sources of resources such as technical assistance and sometimes companies can even think about considering ing some philanthropic money for helping in this other variables that are important for the structure. One thing that doesn’t work is just giving them money. You have to give this whole package of resources also for capability and for development.
The instrument trying to make it easy to explain you basically have this anchor company that actually have this receivables like ingredients and buy ingredients with their supply chain system. This is small producers. The company itself can participate on the fund structure as an investor. And we actually have some numbers that show that companies that participate in these types of receivable funds that in Brazil is called Fijiki, they can actually capture a lot of return because of one simple thing. The company knows very well the ones he the company is providing credit.
So information is everything. When you’re talking about origination of credit, you have a company that has a contract and knows very well the supply chain system. So that is a risking mechanism very powerful. So the companies can participate in the fund and sometimes the company can also lead or attract some philanth philanthropic donors that provide money for the other variables such infrastructure capabilities and other resource resources other than money to make these producers more robust in terms of production. So the mechanism was a mechanism that we validated at climate policy initiative.
We were one of the two proponents selected for the lab in 2021 which was great for us because we had the chance to really listen from investors and other potential stakeholders. What is the attractive attractiveness of this instrument? And we learned that a lot of people understand the offtake agreements and this sort of this type of financing that actually embeds producers in big companies supply chain systems can be very promising in the condition that is not only giving money but also providing this whole sort of a mechanisms to develop the suppliers and of course the agreements has to be favorable to them.
So because companies used to have a much bigger burden power so it’s important to some to be something as I said in the beginning of my talk it has to be something interesting for suppliers something that really adds value for them in terms of a business case and when we look at in Brazil some companies who have participated on this receivable fund not necessarily looking at sustainability or is small producers but just using this type of financial mechanism called fidikis in which they actually participate as investors they actually can capture in the subordinated trenches a lot of value and return just because they know very well the ones who are being granted with the credit line.
So it’s a it’s a gain for everyone because companies can actually accelerated the mechanism as investors but they can also capture the value of actually providing credit for producers that a company knows well in terms of the commercial and commercial agreements. So in a nutshell just getting back to you, we are talking about using the financial market instruments benefiting the development of ecosystem having companies as protagonisms. I like to use the expression Grace was telling that she’s interested in new economic models. I’m interested in the same thing but basically as having companies as almost development developmental banks in the sense that they already financing their supply chain system.
Why not to do that in a better way? Why not to do that? Actually having KPIs providing resources using blended finance mechanisms sometimes when like you have companies and you have commitment at companies you can also attract concessional capital to the instrument that actually helps to lower the concession rates for the producers. So there’s a lot of things that we can do with like old instruments but like instruments that actually revisited in a different mindset that actually looks much more to a systemic development and takes the side of the producers relying on the capabilities of big companies in actually fostering their ecosystem.
So it’s a new role for companies. It’s a very important like corporate responsibility role. And companies can at the end of the day also capture a lot of value not only having a much more robust supply chain system but also capturing the financial incentives of being part of this type of mechanism. So Jonah in a nutshell that is that is it.
Jonah:
Great. I’m going to give a little bit of context and then we’ll go ahead and move into Wayne’s presentation. For those who have questions, please write them down. You know, hold the spot. As soon as Wayne goes, we’ll we’ll we hear a little bit from Hirod and then we’ll come through with them. So the one piece of context I was going to share is that this is a really unique mechanism. It blends philanthropy with for-profit investing. Two weeks ago, we had the Moore Foundation, the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation present on this call.
They’ve spent hundreds of millions of dollars creating permanent protection areas. They set money aside that drips money into conservation arrangements. We had the we had some of the largest permanent protection area funders on the call. None of them were working with corporations. – which was fascinating to recognize. Philanthropic money in and of itself won’t last forever. And so coming up alongside some sort of corporate partnership for permanent protection areas presents a giant frontier that’s very much unexplored. So getting into this question of the role of philanthropy in developing and sustaining the landscape, let’s zoom in on the Aliados Foundation.
Wayne, the microphone is yours.
Wain Collen:
Thanks, Jonah. Share my screen. Here we are. Okay. So, yes, I’m the executive director of Ali’s Foundation. We’re an and quick you know we’re an Ecuadorian and US NGO and our vision is to fundamentally transform the way business is done in the Amazon. Taking a step back in history though we were not we didn’t start as Aliados. We started actually in 2009 as Runa. You may or may not have heard of Runa, but Runa was set up as a hybrid for-profit nonprofit business. And here in Ecuador set up a vertically integrated supply chain for WUSA tea.
So, WUSA is a is a caffeinated plant that was previously only produced in very small holder settings. Each family had one or two trees. The team at Runa identified the you know the potential in this product and brought together forprofit resources and nonprofit resources and set up a brand new value chain which to date through Runa has generated over $2.5 million for small holder farmers and beyond that has actually set up a small market you know why Runa is no longer the only company. There are several companies who are producing WUSA.
And then in a sign of success, Runa the company in 2018 was acquired by AMI, the guys who produced by the Coco. So I think that’s testament to the fact that they set up a business that you know actually worked and at least in the Amazon space back then it was quite an achievement because most of the organizations working on you know economic development were NOS’s NOS’s doing alternative economic development. Anyhow in 2018 Runa was acquired and the foundation needed to decide what are they going to do? So that was the birth of Aliados.
The foundation rebranded with a new name Aliados which means partners or allies in Spanish. And our guiding question was can we take the experience with yusat and can we do it with more products and more communities. Before we could actually answer that question there’s there were a set of other questions we needed to look at and that’s what we’ve been doing since 2018. It’s like what is our value proposition as the NGO in this economic development space like what do we have to do here as the NGO and what is our service delivery model like do we actually have a model for doing what we do and could we replicate and we’ve been working pretty hard on you know answering these questions over the last you know four years almost and this is where we are at the moment.
But our value ad, it’s been mentioned a number of times, is to cultivate the entrepreneurial ecosystem for bioeconomy ventures to flourish in the Amazon. And the reason we talk about cultivating an entrepreneurial ecosystem is, as you guys probably all know, it’s really difficult to set up a business anywhere on the planet. It’s incredibly difficult to set up a business in the remote regions of the Amazon. The ecosystem really just doesn’t exist. And we boil it down to three core steps. Convening the necessary set of actors. No one can do this by themselves.
You invariably need a set of different stakeholders collaborating effectively. Aligning them on a pathway towards a similar direction. Nobody arrives at the same from the same place. You need to be working to make sure that we all have the same principles in place. And then once you have the right set of actors and everybody wants to go in a fairly similar direction, it’s enabling these partners with access to skills, resources, and networks they need to be successful. So that’s the space that we’re working at. And in referring back to the previous question, can we do this with more products and more communities?
We’re now working with a basket of I mean actively with eight products and we’ve been working quite actively with the private sector to identify demand rather what a lot of organizations do is identify a product and then spend a lot of money working with farmers to help them start producing the product and then it can be difficult to find a market. We start with the corporate sector. Look for partners see if there’s the product is interesting producing samples and once you get some sort of you know yes this is great we’ll take you know 500 kg or 700 kgs a month then you go and start building partnership with small holder farmers otherwise it’s just it’s just not responsible to do it the other way around.
We’re now working with a this is the set of partners that we’ve brought together in the upper Napa watershed in Ecuador. As you can see, there’s a set of corporate partners, community partners, financial partners, and conservation partners who all have skin in the game. All focused on trying to build a new model for economic development in the Ecuadorian Amazon. And yes, us as Alia, what we’re doing is just trying to bring these stakeholders together, make sure they know what their role is, understand what the bottlenecks are for them, being able to play their role.
And yeah, creating that ecosystem. I’ll finish off. This is the landscape that we’re working in. I think it was great working with WUSA one product, but we I mean we’re quite ambitious at the moment. We’d like to work with, you know, this much larger basket of products over a wider landscape. So this is the upper and upper watershed. It’s an area of around 220,000 hectares of forest. Very important ecologically, but there’s very high poverty levels. Deforestation is creeping in. And we feel we feel quite confident now we’ve brought together the right set of stakeholders.
We work mainly with grant funding at the moment. Karolina was talking about you know how you help farmers get through this valley of death before they’re actually making money. We work mainly with grant funding but it definitely is a blended funding approach and is very yeah dependent on the context. So yeah, that’s a little bit about our work and where we’re at, where we fit into this.
Jonah:
Great. And then to round us off, HRD, can you tell us a little bit about your work with the Bif forbenefit coalition and chief sustainability officers and manufacturing demand for the sector?
Unidentified presenter:
Sure, happy to. So we’ve sort of been coming at this basically from a few different angles. One of them is mobilizing corporates to create demand for products that are produced by companies that are you know basically driven by purpose and sustainability and equity and who prioritize those values over profits. So the kind of hybrid I think that we just heard about there are somewhere on the order of tens of millions of those kinds of businesses being started around the world each year. So it’s actually quite a versus traditional for-profit enterprises.
So it’s quite a let’s say generative part of the economy and obviously increasingly more important. To solving many of the big challenges we’re facing. And the you know as I think we just heard basically the demand for the products that those companies produce is a big bottleneck in the in the equation of allowing them to get to scale. So we kind of focused on it at more of a macro level rather than specific industries or regions sort of looking at the level of national economy. And if you think of it at that scale basically there’s a there’s a just as we just heard at the local level you need a sort of proper enabling environment or ecosystem around enterprises.
You know that scales all the way up to national and national policy and international trade agreements and so on have a lot to do with you know creating the right set of incentives and market conditions for those kinds of businesses to be effective and be able to thrive. So one piece of the puzzle we started with was trying to aggregate corporate demand. So there are multinationals who you know have a very large footprint you know in local economies and who are consider who concerned about pursuing purpose and sustainability. And one of the biggest things they can do, you know, aside from CSR programs and corporate philanthropy and all the rest of the stuff that we typically hear about, one of the biggest things they can do to actually affect change is to aggregate is to leverage their purchasing power and create incentives and the right conditions in their supply chains for more of those suppliers to basically you know, align line with sustainability and equity and so on.
So we worked for a couple years testing that theory. We managed to get a number of large corporates who basically thought it was kind of a no-brainer at the high level. Yeah, of course. If we’re really serious about purpose and sustainability and so on, then we should you know, put our money where our math is and align our purchasing power and procurement with that. But you know once you get past the first level of it then it gets really complex you know how you actually these large wellestablished supply chains how do you start to shift them towards more for benefit enterprise models.
So and that leads very quickly to even if you so first you got to figure out the problem on the corporate side you know how do you identify these enterprises how do you know one when you see one and how do you trust what they claim when you hear it. So th those that all gets very complicated. But once you get past those issues, then those enterprises themselves need more than just a willing buyer, basically a corporate buyer in order for them to be able to you know, effectively compete and scale.
So they need the entire enabling environment around them, especially access to the right kind of capital supply and so on. And so we’ve also been working then with trying to aggregate some philanthropies who are interested in basically seeing more of more enterprise sort of shift in the direction of purpose and values. To figure out how philanthropy can invest resources in strengthening that enabling environment. And sort of close the gap basically that exists between you know the competitive gap that exists between for-profit and for benefit suppliers and then also working on policy with governments to try to get them to recognize the importance of these kinds of businesses to their economy in the long term and to their policy objectives and then figure out what they need to do to basically recognize them and level the playing field, if you will, by strengthening the enabling environment, providing the right incentives and, you know, for capital providers and for corporate buyers and other actors so that basically for benefit and for-profit producers can compete on a level playing field.
So that they’re not disadvantaged and everything. You know, we have to figure out workarounds every step of the way. So, at a high level, that’s it. I don’t know if that’s helpful, Joan. Happy to kind of zoom into any detail on any of that.
Jonah:
Great. Super helpful. So, we’re hearing lots of different angles here. Organizing the investors, organizing the corporations, organizing the grant makers, creating the policy enabling environments, upgrading the capacity of intermediaries to create these moving parts, set them in motion. There’s so much opportunity. I’m going to ask Wayne two more quick questions and then it’s to all of you. So, if any of you guys have a question for any of the presenters, please feel free to indicate your interest in the chat or to raise a hand. Wayne, tell us real quickly about jungle peanuts and Amazonian vanilla.
Wain Collen:
Okay, so very quickly, wild jungle peanuts. They’re they’re an attractive peanut with purple stripes. They’re good-looking peanuts. They grow very well in the Amazon. They’re native to the Amazon. We start first started working with them four years ago. We did a very small part. We identified opportunity. That’s you know the first step. It’s like is this an interesting product? Worked over three hectares to learn a little bit about how jungle peanuts grow. Developed samples shared the samples with a few potential clients and actually terraertil the Nestle subsidiary indicated you know this looks great.
Actually the general manager of the company who has an allergy to peanuts loved them because they didn’t give him an allergy when he ate them. That was you know 18 months ago they said we’d take you know a ton a month. We were like oh whoa that’s you know we definitely don’t have a ton a month. But we’ve been working very closely now with four different communities to try and get them to increase the production and profitability of their farms to meet this demand. We’re on a good path. It’s not easy working with peanuts with the affletoxins.
It’s a very complex product, but these are things you go learning along the way. But yes, it’s on a good path. We’re increasing production. We’ve got strong commitment from the company. They have they’re pretty they’re selling a product a branded product in the biggest supermarket in Ecuador. So I think it’s a success, but there’s still some way to go. The Amazonian vanilla. That’s an interesting one. We did a prefeasibility study on Amazonian vanilla. The very short answer is that there are a number of Amazonian varieties of vanilla. The big companies are really only interested in Planopolia and Odorata.
I think the ones that are already being marketed. It’s going to be a very difficult pathway to get Amazonian vanilla on the market. The big buyers are interested in supporting supply chains guys like Unilver, Simrise. And there is actually interesting that they’ll put some money forward to produce high quality vanilla. Grows very well in the agroforestry system. We’re going to be definitely working hard on that as one of the products we’re working on. A quick intro to those Jonah.
Jonah:
Great. Thanks so much. Those with anyone else have a question feel free to just come off mute. The presenters certainly welcome to ask questions of each other. Karolina, did you have something?
Carolina Costa:
No, I was like was listening to Wayne teases on how to actually for forest just forest compatible products and I was just curious whether he came across financial models for that or are you working with some financial solutions in the region just because I’m always curious because I’m much more into the having big companies to foresting to actually foster ing this development and most of them are looking to their own raw materials and ingredients. But when you’re actually looking at from bottom up like finding products and then develop the product producers, get them to get organized through cooperatives.
So it’s a it’s a very labor intensive model that also requires capital. So I like I was curious whether this coming more from philanthropy or whether you have some have seen other financial models that is you’d like to share with us.
Wain Collen:
Yeah. Well I think you and I should have this a conversation offline as well because I think there’s definitely a match where we can combine skills. Yes because but the short answer is we’re address the same problem from the bottom up. It’s we want farmers to have more profitable more productive farms. And as I said we’ll we’ll we’ll try to identify an interesting product. We’ll identify demand. We have not been successful so far in finding corporate clients who are willing to put money upfront to finance the change for smallh holder farmers.
I’m not saying that doesn’t exist. Clearly it does because I think you’ve worked with companies like that. And that would be amazing. What we do is we raise grant funding to invest to help farmers move to regenerative productive systems. So it’s like helping them with seeds, with inputs, with training to start producing much more productive farming systems and then also to help them do the cooperativism as you were saying, helping them organize. And that all based on market signals from clients and then clients, the ones we work with are very happy to buy and are very happy to say, you know, give a fair price, a fixed price and commit to complete offtaking.
That’s how we’re doing it at the moment. We’re investigating a fund that may be, you know, something in the next, you know, few years. But I think there’s a way that, you know, your model and our model probably connect in the middle and might make our work easier.
Jonah:
Juan, did you have a question?
Juan:
No, not really. I was just getting into the themes and the people and the projects. Thank you.
Jonah:
Lauren,.
Carolina Costa:
I see that Lauren made a question for me. Lauren, thank you. Thank you for your question on if I have seen how this investments has be has been promoted from the side of the producers. And the biggest motivation for companies Lori is like the company having this type of bio ingredient in their supply chain system. This is one region and one reason this is for development of products for preservation the company has to probably be in an agenda of exporters. So for example that doesn’t work so much for the Amazon like in particular for cattle.
So the company usually wants to make sure the supply chain is not being produced in areas that are like associated to deforestation. So the company’s sometimes worried with the with the reputation and some barriers the company might face when export products outside Brazil. But I’ve seen also in other biomes of Brazil companies who that are committed with the preservation and restoration because they have products that actually help to recover degraded lands or increase productivity in a certain supply chain system. So basically I’ve seen these three sources of motivation either the need to develop the buying ingredients some concern with the barriers to export to like companies who that export abroad.
So they have to make sure that are actually producing in areas that are not assert associated to deforestation and companies that actually have products and methodologies that help to recover or preserve lands in general. So you’re talking about having products that are compatible with this agenda of like reconcile productivity and sustainability. So then companies actually look either for to suppliers or clients as a way to make this agenda to work. So of course it’s a very important question because then you see is limited for if you see for example Wayne’s agenda so it’s much broader because you can actually develop all sorts of products.
So this won’t be in company’s agenda. So we all have to like dig in order to find sometimes I do this type of thing. I joke that I’m actually not a person from the financial market. I’m a person who actually try to build bridges and sometimes I go after companies and say listen don’t you think you should pay attention to that and that and there’s a mechanism that you actually could financing your suppliers or your clients and this can really like be linked to sustainability and some companies listening to me other companies don’t so it’s a it’s something that is beginning to develop so I’ve talked to many companies in Brazil.
I can say that I could say like not even 10 is highly committed with actually having this type of fin but when they are committed we are talking about like a huge impact and scale. So for example in restoration I’m talking to a company that is seeking to restore 1 million actors in Sahadu which is another huge biome in Brazil. So we’re 1 million actors is a lot of land so when companies engage the impact can be huge but I believe that we like people who are engaged in this agenda has a very important job of actually linking and bridging the several stakeholders in order to actually make sometimes companies see things that they are not seeing or opportunities that they are missing in developing or for example using agri agriforest systems.
So I know of a big Brazilian company that works with like a pinus forest like eucalyptus pinus that actually just realized that actually can work together with a cattle system for forest and cattle. So companies have to talk to each other in order to find mechanisms in which a company can cooperate with another company in different supply chain systems in order to produce sustainability. So there’s a lot of opportunities but we have to help companies to see the agenda in a more effective way for sure. Important question. Thank you.
Jonah:
Lauren did you want to add on or we’re good?
Lauren:
I’m good. Thank you so much. I appreciate it.
Jonah:
Okay, great. Han, I have a question for you. You’ve looked more at this from the policy angle than me, maybe more than others as well. Creating incentives is so important. Do you want to add a little bit? I don’t know if you have much experience with within Brazil.
Unidentified presenter:
Not within Brazil specifically, although one of our UNDP and the Eber American general secretariat have been doing fair amount of work on kind of paving the road for these kinds of businesses in Latin America and in Brazil as well. The you know a lot of the problem here is we keep trying to fit a you know fundamentally a business that is born and exist to create benefit for its stakeholders. You know whether it’s the natural environment or the people who are involved in it and it in a supply chain and so on like a benefit oriented company is a completely different kind of animal than a profit oriented company.
They’re just fundamentally different. It’s like the difference between a for-profit and an NGO. They’re just different types of organization. And these hybrid we’ll call them hybrids or for benefits or social enterprises or purpose- driven businesses, whatever you want to call them, they’re just a completely different species of organization. But the policy and regulatory environment which basically which the markets exist within the market structures exist within including the incentives and the rules and the you know requirements and the sanctions and so on. That whole environment just is very bifrocated. You’re either a for-profit business or you’re an NGO.
And the stuff that’s operating in between where you’re leveraging the market to advance public good in a responsible way. Those things basically just have to kind of get shoehorned into the policy regimes that aren’t suited for them and the market rules and structures and incentives that are not suited for them. And they have to compete you know against profit oriented businesses that can extract and externalize costs you know and therefore be more competitive. So you know unless the policy apparatus and the markets recognize that this class of entity is fundamentally different and fundamentally important.
You know that we’re still going to be operating at the fringes, but you know broadening the aperture of economic development and economic policy to recognize there’s a fourth sector of distinctly different entities in addition to the public and the traditional private sector and the philanthropic or nonprofit sector. And setting up the right you know rules and incentives and accountability requirements for those entities. Until we do that, we really are still going to be stuck in the fringes trying to do you know just shoehorn these models into existing capital market structures or you know the you know whatever supply chain practices of corporates and so on.
So yeah, I mean I think that the policy thing is a really big deal and once you do that imagine a world that did not have any NOS or philanthropy, institutionalized philanthropy, right? Well, you would see that you know if you rewind time 20, 50, 100 years in most countries you will see that world you know that’s the way the world looks. We did not have a formalized third sector. We do now and you see what that unleashes. We didn’t have a formalized private sector a few hundred years ago. And so, you know, I think as this as this whole movement of, you know, of purpose and equity and sustainable development and so on continues to unfold and scale, I think we’re going to see more and more formalization you know, policy recognition of these entities and therefore the right set of incentives that level the playing field.
So an entrepreneur that is driven by purpose and values can compete you know in the market effectively with one that is driven by you know short-term profit.
Jonah:
It reminds me Carolina Karolina of what we saw in your slide about the role of carbon and systems of payments for system services trying to integrate within this larger corporate model. There was a whole bunch of there was a flurry in Brazil at the end of this year about bringing Brazil’s carbon markets online. It was up for vote and ultimately didn’t go through, but that’ll be a giant game changers for so many of these businesses.
Carolina Costa:
Absolutely. That’s a way to increase gains with preservation.
Jonah:
Well said. There’s a lot there and we’ll do a future phone call on these subjects. Any closing words from anybody? Thanks, Jonah.
Unidentified participant:
Appreciation for everyone’s work. Thank you.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you.
Jonah:
Great.
Unidentified participant:
This has been fun. Thank you.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you.
Jonah:
So this when we get to the top of the hour and usually it’s class dismiss we call it water cooler time where we move into you know instead of back and forth with people lining up for questions and stuff it’s networking. It’s shameless self-promotion of events that people are organizing things like that. So if anybody else wants to move off topic or introduce themselves feel free to do that.
Unidentified participant:
I’m gonna have to jump off. So, I’ll just say goodbye to everybody and thanks for contining this and learned a lot and look forward to seeing your faces in future gatherings.
Unidentified participant:
Thanks for joining us here.
Jonah:
You bet.
Unidentified participant:
Same here. Until next time.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you.
Jonah:
Goodbye. I’m going to go ahead and stop the recording.