Conservation Finance for the Amazon

Debt or equity? Stocks or bonds? What kinds of financial products can help conserve the Amazon? What kinds of economic analysis can assign financial value to ecosystem services? With diverse investor options ranging from long term sustainable timber holdings to deforestation-linked sovereign bonds, the disparate actors of public and private finance are all needed for new blended finance models. Join us for a panel discussion with a diverse set of conservation finance pioneers. Panelists include Fiona Banister of Decarbonized, Peter Elwin, Planet Tracker (article), James Magowan, Arboreal Capital, Leisa de Souza of the Climate Bonds Initiative (article), Scott Edwards of the Conservation Strategy Fund, and David Meyers of the Conservation Finance Alliance.

Recorded October 18, 2021

WATCH:

  • Jonah
  • Scott Edwards
  • Leisa de Souza
  • Peter Elwin
  • James Magowan
  • David Meyers
  • Fiona Banister
  • John Tobin
  • John Bruno
  • Barat
  • Raj
  • Mark
  • Bobby

Jonah:

Hello everybody. Welcome to the 60th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing forest-friendly economic development across the ant sorry Amazon forest-friendly economic development and the rule of law across the Amazon region of South America. This week we are featuring the work of several pioneers in the space of conservation finance. And the title of this session is about iterating conservation finance because there a lot of different ways to do it. I’m going to go ahead and paste the LinkedIn IDs and institutional websites of some of our invited guests.

John is new to the list that you guys will see. Of course my phone my computer isn’t figuring out how to paste so I’ll do it later. Let’s start out. Scott from the Conservation Strategy Fund. Can you give us a very brief like two-minute description of how can people calculate the cost or the economic benefit of environmental services?

Scott Edwards:

Go. Yeah, sure. Thanks John. Two minutes, huh? I had first of all I just said introduce myself Scott Edwards. I am with the Conservation I’m an executive director of the Conservation Strategy Fund. We’re a global conservation organization works and brings economics to those working in conservation so they can influence policy makers to make better decisions for nature and people. Just really quickly John I just want to kind of back up and talk about if I can just like a couple minutes of the value of nature that has been historically under counted or underestimated.

And governments and businesses are trying to do a better job of accounting for that value through natural capital accounting in one way, but we know that the benefits of nature are absolutely enormous. Costanza, an economist back in 2014, estimated that the value of ecosystem services totaled globally more than 120 trillion dollars. That’s an enormous number. Hard to hard to imagine. There’s a lot of There’s some controversy around that number because it’s larger than global GDP. So, how does that even happen? But the point is it’s big and it can get even bigger.

McKinsey released a report earlier this year around valuing nature. They said we could double you know, create 650,000 more jobs, increase by GDP by 500 billion dollars. So, there’s a lot to be captured through ecosystem services. There are four different ways to quantify or to I guess categorize ecosystem services. In provisioning, those are the things that commodities like water and food and fuel. Regulating, things like pollination, flood control, climate control. Cultural, those values around recreation, spiritual values, education. And then supporting ecosystem services that are really the foundation for those three different types of ecosystem services I just mentioned.

So, I’m going really quickly here and I apologize. So, this is actually my last point. So, how do we how do we capture those values from ecosystem services? An economist and economists in my organization that we spend a lot of time and a lot of effort around valuation. And it’s really about capturing those non-market values. We It’s easier to capture those values that things that people are paying for. But things that necessarily aren’t on the market, can’t be sold on the market, how do you capture those values? Well, there’s three principal ways you do that.

First is through a cost approach. And that is using like the avoided cost analysis. Really kind of estimating what would it cost to recreate that ecosystem service. And a good example of that is storm protection from coastal mangroves. And the avoided cost of the damage or the disaster that would result from floods. So we capture we can capture that value. A second way we can estimate ecosystem services values is through revealed preference. And that’s essentially capturing consumer behavior. What are people doing? How? You know, and we do this through travel cost analysis, through identifying and looking at what people are spending money on.

A really good example is where people decide to live. How do how are they valuing clean air, clean water, access to nature. This is another way to capture ecosystem services values. And the third way to capture ecosystem services values is through stated preference. So, maybe they’re not demonstrating this behavior, but you can ask people what they would be willing to pay. So, this you probably heard of willingness to pay surveys, asking people for example, what would they pay to you know, have a protected area in their state or their country.

Or what would they pay to keep a polar bear in existence. And we can capture those values and turn capture those values and turn them into sort of market values, if you will. So, that is essentially ways to capture ecosystem services values. And, you know, how you do that and which approach to use really depends on the data available. It depends on who you’re talking to, what’s the argument you’re trying to make, who are you trying to demonstrate these values to which really you know, lead you to the to the right analysis.

Jonah:

Great. Thank you so much for helping set this foundation, sir.

Scott Edwards:

Yeah. I hope that.

Unidentified participant:

Got it. Thanks. You did. Great job.

Jonah:

So, first we’re going to move to Brazil and hear from Leisa Souza from the Climate Bonds Initiative. Leisa, tell us what is the Climate Bonds Initiative and what is a climate bond?

Leisa de Souza:

Thank you, Jonah. It’s a pleasure to be here today and see some partners as well in this call. So, the Climate Bonds Initiative is a non-for-profit organization. We’re based in the UK and we’re working towards mobilizing the 100 trillion bond market to climate change solutions. So, it’s I think it’s good to bring these two definitions, right? So, when we talk about climate bonds, we’re talking about fixed income financial instruments that are linked to climate solutions. So, they’re issued either to raise resources for climate change mitigation or adaptation and resilience. So, if we’re thinking about mitigation, we’re talking about energy, energy efficiency, low-carbon transport, water, and so forth.

And we’re talking about adaptation, we’re thinking about flood defenses, and so on. And if we look at the climate themed bond universe, it’s broader than the labeled bond universe, which is where CBI is working globally and of course in Brazil, Jonah. And if we talk about green bonds, we’re talking about bonds that have been marketed as green and where the use of proceeds is going towards climate and green assets or projects. So, there’s sometimes a confusion in terms of green and climate bonds. And if we look about green bonds, they can go towards environmental projects, but in practice, we’ve been seeing a lot of climate bonds going towards green.

So, it’s this is a bit about the definition. And just bringing a bit of the numbers. So, if we talk about green bonds, we’re talking about 1.1 trillion issued globally. And the climate bonds aligned universe, we did a report this year where we identified 913.2 billion in terms of climate aligned bonds. So, just to bring a bit of what the climate bond does and a bit of what are climate bonds and green bonds.

Jonah:

Great. Thank you so much for that. Can you tell us a little bit about the report that you guys put out about the investment opportunity helping Brazil’s agricultural sector transition to a climate smart one?

Leisa de Souza:

So, we’ve we did a report back in 2020 to look at low-hanging fruits in terms of agriculture in Brazil. So, this was looking of course to forestry, agriculture production, livestock production, logistics and transports. And we mapped 163 billion US dollars in terms of opportunities. So, what could be packaged and labeled as green and go to the market. Of course, this has to go through a whole process in terms of identifying which activities would be eligible within this to go within a bond and even local structures and be issued as green.

And of course, a whole verification process in terms of the green label. So, we’ve been working a lot towards mapping these opportunities and bringing these to markets. And Of course, there is I think a challenge when we talk about agriculture. So, a lot of the work that we’re doing and that the report contributed to is to promote what criteria would bring these credentials for Brazil. So, last year we published the agriculture criteria so in September 2020. And this year we included livestock. So, right now it’s really building, you know, what is the criteria, what are these opportunities, and what should be met and the main I think criteria, which is almost binary, which classifies something as eligible or not, is deforestation.

So, we’re talking about zero deforestation. So, I think this is a very important point when we’re talking and of course also a challenge when it comes to this type of asset and infrastructure.

Jonah:

Great. Thank you so much. And feel free to post another link beyond what I the one that I’ve included, maybe about cattle and specifically the criteria. Next we’re going to hear from Peter Elwin of Planet Tracker. Peter, please tell us about your proposal for deforestation linked sovereign bonds.

Peter Elwin:

Yeah, hi Jenna. Hi everybody. Thanks for having me. So, Planet Tracker is a non not-for-profit financial think tank that focuses on the financial markets and great admirers of the of the climate bond initiatives. So, it’s a great to be on the same call as you Lisa. And our deforestation linked sovereign bond is sort of aligned with some of the work that the Climate Bonds Initiative is doing. The difference between the bond that we’re proposing and the green bonds, for example, that Lisa was that a sustainability linked bond does not bind the person borrowing the money, the issuer, to use the money for a particular purpose.

Instead, what you do with a sustainability linked bond is you promise to achieve certain KPIs, certain sustainability performance targets. And if you meet those targets, then you will pay a lower interest rate. If you fail to meet those targets, then you will pay a higher interest rate. That’s sort of broadly the framework now in market practice. There’s sort of variations on that theme, but that’s essentially what’s going on. And in this context, what we’re suggesting is that a sovereign could be a country like Brazil, could be a country like Indonesia, could be a country like Russia, where they have a lot of natural resources in terms of their forests, but also potentially a problem with deforestation.

If the government wants to effectively incentivize itself and convince the capital markets that it’s serious about its sort of zero deforestation policy, then it could issue a government bond, so it’s a sovereign bond, it’s a bond issued by the state, into the capital markets, and the government would be saying, “We will promise that we will achieve zero deforestation by 2030, for example.” Brazil’s promise is actually to achieve zero illegal deforestation by 2030, but you could make it tighter than that. And then you would set milestones along the way as to how you were going to reduce the amount of deforestation taking place, and at each of those milestones, you’d measure your progress, and if you were sort of beating that particular target, then the interest rate would step down by a pre-agreed margin, a number of basis points.

If you missed that target, then the interest rate could step up again by a preset number of basis points. So, the structure would be very predictable. You’d have a very clear understanding of what would happen in terms of the interest rate, the coupon. And that would all be based around your success or failure in terms of limiting deforestation. By doing that, you would build in an incentive clearly for the government, because they would want to limit deforestation and eventually stop it, and that would save them interest costs. The capital markets would be attracted to this bond, because by providing debt through this particular structure, they would be adding to that incentive to the government, so it would classify for a lot of asset managers as a sustainable investment, ESG-labeled bonds as Laser was talking about earlier.

And so, you would get a flood of investment coming in. There’s a lot of capital looking for sustainable investments. Sustainability-linked bonds are proving very popular. So, Brazil would raise finance for itself potentially at a cheaper rate even than it can currently borrow at the moment. And the international capital markets would see that Brazil was then and serious about the commitments that it was making. You could, if you wanted, tie this in with an aid package as well, but maybe we’ll come on to that in a little while. But that’s the basic essence of it.

So, the government is making a promise, just like they do with inflation-linked bonds. So, if you think of US TIPS, for example, it’s exactly the same comment concept. You’re making a commitment to meet particular targets, and if you fail to meet those targets, the interest rate goes up. If you beat them, the rate goes down.

Jonah:

Nice. Let’s move on to the active investing universe. So, James Magowan has some significant experience as an investor, as investment manager. And he is building Arboreal Capital, and has been looking at investments in sustainable sustainably managed forestry. James, tell us about some of your experiences, and tell us as an investor how you would regard these bond ideas.

James Magowan:

Well, thank you thank you, Jonah. I speaking today from land of the Coast Salish people. So, wanted to acknowledge that. I’m in Vancouver today. I James Magowan, I’m a managing director at Arboreal Capital, and I’m also a co-founder of Arboreal BV, which is a holding company built to scale biodiverse permanent forestry in the tropics for private investors. So, as Jonah mentioned, I’ve been investing and advising companies and funds in the forestry space for the past 15 years. And those have included public companies that are active in Brazil including precious woods is one that some of you may know that’s operating in that environment and forestry funds in North America.

Like EcoTrust which have carved out strong positions in terms of both of those in terms of preserving existing forests and I think that one of the issues that we’re facing today is that while it is excellent to find mechanisms to preserve existing forests we also need to be looking at how do we how do we sequester carbon how do we take more carbon out of the atmosphere and to do that we need new forests to do that and to make that work we have to build organizations at scale and I think that is the central challenge here because while there are scaled public companies like Weyerhaeuser operating in North America and paper producers in Brazil like Suzano what we don’t yet have are the scaled operations sequestering new carbon with permanent forests that are also biodiverse because it’s no good if we plant in my view it’s not much use if we plant some eucalyptus and a few years later we cut it down rip up that forest and start again because it sequesters a minimum of carbon and in fact for some numbers about two recent project I saw eucalyptus project in Brazil sequesters two tons of CO2 per hectare over the life of the project versus a biodiverse permanent forest like the one we’re building in Panama, which does about 20 tons of CO2 over the lifetime of the project.

So, it strikes me that what’s needed is not necessarily strict bond financing that is tied to an existing project, but a willingness to be entrepreneurial. And this means taking some risk on a manager in advance. So some actors are choosing to do this through advanced purchases of carbon credits. So, you’ve probably noticed Apple computer, the formation of the HSBC Pollination Fund, Capricorn, the family office of Jeff Skoll, and the Grantham Foundation in the US have all made some efforts in this regard to be entrepreneurial to find projects that can be scaled and that is addressing a need that’s in the market.

We think there’s a need for private capital in the market to build institutions that have the scale that are matched to the needs of the planet, and that’s why we formed Arboréal.

Jonah:

Great. Thank you, James. Okay, we’re now going to move on to questions for our presenters. First up, David Meyer, please feel free to introduce yourself and to ask a question and of the panelists. And tell us about the work of the Conservation Finance Alliance.

David Meyers:

Okay, hi everyone, and thanks, Jonah, for the invitation. Some really great quick presentations there. So, I mean I of course I have too many questions for everyone, but let me just go with the with a with a bond theme. I mean we heard about the So, just for the background, the Conservation Finance Alliance is a global network of conservation finance practitioners. We’re sort of a an association of active people practicing in this field, and you can find us at conservationfinancealliance.org. And I won’t tell you it much more. But the questions I have then, you know, for we’re talking about the you know, climate bonds and green bonds, you know, one of my and there was a great example from Plan Tracker of these sustainability-linked loans or linked bonds.

But one of my concerns is that there aren’t enough nature-based bonds, bonds that are really directed towards concrete revenue-driven paybacks from investing in nature. And I was wondering if you know, anyone on the of on the group wanted to comment on how we can scale those up because, you know, obviously green bonds in general have scaled wonderfully, but it’s mostly renewable energy and other types of return-based investments. How can we get return from nature by doing conservation and positive impacts? I have some ideas, but I’d love to hear yours.

Jonah:

Any panelists, feel free.

Peter Elwin:

Well, I guess that is sort of the heart of the deforestation sort of linked sovereign bond concept. That you would need to be investing in your deforestation efforts. There are many reasons actually why governments should be doing that anyway, but this would sort of really build in a very tangible politically clear sort of commitment for a government to sort of to really kind of pin its colors to the mast, if you like. And to a to an extent, you will then economic success result of limiting deforestation and in potentially doing more interesting and sort of exciting and economically productive things with the forest that you’re no longer just tearing down and destroying.

That would actually help to fund the bond, but I can you know, in terms of your question, I can see that you know, there’s a there’s a desire to have something that is linked much more explicitly towards the sort of a and if you like a nature-based activity. There’s no reason why you couldn’t tie the bond into funding activities that were sort of designed to generate more sustainable agriculture, for example, and more efficient use of the land around the periphery of the forest, so that you were no longer you know, people were no longer incentivized to tear down the forest because that seemed to be the cheapest, quickest way for them to get land.

So, although the deforestation-linked sovereign bond is explicitly designed not to have proceeds being tied to a particular activity, there’s absolutely nothing to prevent the government in question saying, “Well, this is why we’re actually issuing the bond of this nature and we’re going to dedicate those proceeds towards this supporting sustainable agriculture as one example.”.

Jonah:

Great. Any other panelists wish to respond?

James Magowan:

Well, I mean I think it as I as I alluded to, I think there is a need to bridge the gap between the funding mechanism on the one side and the capacity of developers on the other to meet that to scale to meet that need. And it strikes me that there is a is a great challenge in bridging that gap. And so, there has to be some willingness on the part of a funding mechanism, if it’s going to be a bond-like instrument that for instance is say secured by future returns of carbon.

And that seems like that is a an area where there’s quite a bit of discussion at the moment. There needs to be a willingness to take some risk on a developer to scale and there needs to be a way to bridge those gaps because that ultimately is what we need. We’ve developed our project as an open source project and we think that biodiverse permanent forests are what are needed in the future if we’re going to meet our climate objectives.

Jonah:

Lisa.

Leisa de Souza:

No, I was just going to mention David that back in 2011 we did a report and I don’t know Jonah if you shared it with the group but on unlocking on forest bonds and I think the challenges still remain the same in terms of course demand side securing how you know where the cash flow is coming from to pay back those investments on the supply side of course reducing in structuring and I think it’s what James was mentioning in terms of you know having the risk and you know who pays for that risk and I wanted to test even something with James and something that recently came out from Brazil in this month.

So we have something called a green CPR which is a local instrument but what Brazil is trying to do with this is finally have an instrument and this is of course looking at future carbon markets and the challenge here is also how you pay that back but it’s an instrument that it’s a regular CPR so it would it would work as me as a rural producer I’m going to issue that but instead of using crops as payback I would be using forest preservation. So this goes directly towards preservation. So I think in terms of a mechanism it’s quite innovative in what it’s proposing but of course there’s that issue on how are you going to pay that back and it’s mainly I think what government wants is to have that as James mentioned, you know, Apple that you want to of course capture carbon.

You’ll pay for that, but I don’t know how it’s going to work. A lot of things are unclear on how it’s going to, you know, the different mechanisms, but in terms of an instrument, I think that, you know, focuses directly on preserving native forests. It’s really important and an important move as, you know, this is just a decree coming from government and of course giving this a bit to the private sector saying, if you want to preserve our forests, you know, where is it where is the resource to do So, so, I think there is yeah, Raj was mentioning, there is a lot of things that are unclear, but I think this is also an opportunity to come in and propose a few things in terms of we have, as Peter was mentioning, different best practices and mechanisms from green bonds and climate bonds and so on that we can, of course, propose and adapt and we have an open channel with government, but I think this is just, you know, would this instrument be interesting, you know, James, in terms of, you know, an investor perspective?

Does it have traction or not because I think here in Brazil they’re putting quite big stakes at, you know, this can be scaled and this could attract a lot of investment towards preserving forests here in the country.

Jonah:

Great, guys. Next step, we’re going to hear from another one of our invited guests, Fiona Bannister from Decarbonize. Fiona, please introduce yourself and feel free to make a question to the to the panelists.

Fiona Banister:

Okay. Thank you. There we go. Hi, it’s Fiona Bannister. I have personally, I am just representing many different indigenous communities that I’ve been able to learn from on this planet and on this universe. And part of the area even with right now Decarbonize, one of our wings is that we have the honor of being one of the rainforest indigenous women scientist run teams and it’s every day I’m learning from our teams what the value and the visions of their request for compensation for how they want you know it’s not carbon credits it’s not soil credits it’s like what about studying and managing the forests and managing the plants and the people that are the stewards of the forests and it’s been a very deep learning lesson even for myself.

You’ve met James but James and I have invested in microfinance for many years into indigenous communities and women learn run community projects including those in forests and conservation and you run into the question of scale and then scale to whose vision? In the European Union right now there’s the discussion of you know these climate bonds as we have in the US we have the leaf coalition we have Bezos’s new fund but where is it getting to the indigenous peoples how is it getting to feed their family but also what knowledge do they need to preserve and conserve that they wish to share and maybe we need to learn from that so it’s been a very long journey looking at also investing personally small investments into women nurseries conservation projects and how do we get it to scale and what are also the questions that bring about their voices where what time of education are they wanting their children to have I mean I don’t want to say which competition we also were able to get into the finals of another large competition around the globe.

And in the essence of it, it’s not about competing. It’s a challenge. It’s a question. You know, part of our team is Naiara Tukano. Naiara is an environmental lawyer. She’s a social rights advocate lawyer in Brazil and the Tukano tribe. She is also part of the tribal management of a large asset of entitled land and people and culture and social values that we need to learn from, I think. So, when we talk about forest investing, I’m just asking us to also come to the light of, you know, good to think to invest, but what are you investing?

It’s not just a forest. The Amazon is also water. It’s fish. It’s people. It’s a biome and we need to look at long-term protection and then using our ESG or United Nations Sustainable Development Goal framework, look at the values of how we want to invest and what are the areas that are of our deepest concern and then pilot towards not what we think, but what we collaboratively do with our indigenous communities and support their needs. So, and technology is great for some of it. I mean, I feel like we’re blessed with a lot of advanced technology, but again, who’s collecting that data?

How are we processing that data? And what is the use of it going to be? Is it just that I need to finance more funding? I was just at the BMW Foundation here in Germany and they have yet to still invest in a forest product. They’re very open to it, but again, how does it meet the needs of a larger infrastructure and how we need to create those vehicles to help us all. Thank you.

Jonah:

Great. Thank you, Fiona. Panelists?

Peter Elwin:

Well, I think your point is a really important one, Fiona, in terms of the necessity of looking at a forest not simply as a carbon sink or you know, in a sort of a what you might call a sort of mono track view of one particular ecosystem service. I mean, forests like other biomes are very, very complicated ecosystems. Pretty simple obvious point to make. They provide many, many ecosystem services if we want to use that sort of, you know, econometric sort of language. But they also provide, you know, homes and shelter and sort of, you know, cultural enjoyment, spiritual enjoyment, whole range of other things which are you know, with great respect to Scott’s sort of efforts, actually really hard to value and sometimes I think perhaps one needs to be a little cautious around sort of attributing a price to something and failing to actually understand the value of it perhaps in non-monetary terms.

I think the indigenous peoples’ rights, land rights generally, are very, very important around these sort of assets. And as soon as we start using that language of assets and ecosystem services, it does naturally drive sort of, you know, financial markets practitioners like me and many others to start thinking, “Okay, well, who owns it? Who does it belong to? Who’s going to get the money? Who’s going to get the reward?” And I think those are very, very important questions to sort out at a very early stage in any of these projects.

Otherwise, you can certainly end up with some pretty negative unintended consequences.

Jonah:

Other panelists?

Leisa de Souza:

Just one point, Fiona, and then I’ll share. We did and so the climate bonds we do coordinate criteria for where, you know, that defines the eligibility of projects as green. And for our forestry criteria, FPC is something that is there and it came across in the public consultation exactly I think with the points that you raised in terms of importance of traditional and indigenous communities. So, I’ll share that with you and of course it’s a challenge. We include that. It’s easier said than done, but I think this is a recognition on how important you know forestry ecosystems are for these communities and I’ll paste the link here for you.

Jonah:

Great. I’m going to go ahead and invite John Tobin to come on and ask the last question and then it’s open up to everyone else. John.

John Tobin:

I suppose I would have to fall back on some of the questions that have been raised already that are incredibly important, but you know, ultimately it comes down to you know, finding value to what the market is I think we could probably all agree either not pricing or pricing incorrectly now, but the question I would have for the panelists is what should we be doing in the short term? What is the right sort of strategy if we’re going to scale up conservation finance. Should we be focusing on working with the private finance sector?

Should be we Should we be acting through policy mechanisms? And should be Should we pilot a lot of innovative transactions or should we be on the contrary trying to scale up already tried and tested transactions? I this is a you know, it’s a it, it’s a broad set of questions, but ultimately what it come comes down to is in practical terms, what is it that is most urgently and effectively done today to grow this space?

Jonah:

Panelists, you’re welcome. Anyone can just come off mic and address.

Unidentified participant:

Well, yes. I mean, I think we do have to be careful about our definitions and also how we define things so that we don’t create unintended consequences. I mean, one of the things that I’ve seen and I’m somewhat concerned about is that in this rush to secure carbon credits, there is there is this danger that we push aside the needs of the communities and create a new colonial carbon footprint on our forests and on the indigenous communities that live there. They need and have been using the forest for centuries and if we ignore that and say, “Well, no, we’re just going to set this aside for carbon for our use in the north.” I think this creates a problem, a bunch of a bunch of problems at the same time.

And then who’s going to actually manage that forest over a long period of time? Because if you don’t have these projects properly run, they’re going to fall apart. The trees will be cut down in the middle of the night when no one’s watching and the incentives will create or the lack of proper incentives will create problems for us. So, so we have to be careful about that. And I think the need is how can we scale? We have to scale to you know, to sequestration on a gigaton scale. We have to re-create biodiversity on a on a massive level as well.

So, how can we do that? How can we measure that properly? And value that. We have now carbon bonds, but how can we create biodiversity bonds? It strikes me that figuring out how to measure that and value that is something that is essential to our to our being able to preserve it.

Fiona Banister:

Our panel It’s quite James. I will say that I’m not going to say who, but somebody is working on that bond. I was fortunate to encounter them in Dubai when I was a guest speaker last week on climate mitigation and issues on women and women empowerment. But there are a new bond looking at specifically at biodiversity and how we can measure that. And so it’s still in its works, but again, it’s going to be worked out. Going back just to that point on indigenous communities, it’s not it is Sorry for being really blunt about this.

We have a blend. Even my DNA, I’m all mixed from all over wherever. So, how do we stay on the that essence of are you indigenous? Are you 100%? Nobody’s 100% anymore. There’s the French communities, there’s the collective action, and how then can all of the French communities and blended communities participate in the action of not just working on the rainforest. Remember, the rainforest has the river, and the river brings the fish and the food and the nutrition to the soil. And so it’s this ecosystems that has to be protected, not just thinking of the upright tree.

And then looking at what are the alternative income that these communities can thrive from while they are being paid to steward and protect the forest, the water, and the water sources. So, I always look at that as a as a as a swing as if you were in the jungle holding on to one of our sacred vines and thinking about what is the whole system and how can we measure and value and pay the different services for people to protect these environments. Thank you.

Jonah:

Okay, space for one more panelists. Okay, questions from the audience. Do any others who have not gone have questions they would like to and ask of the panelists? Feel free to come off mic. This is a first come first serve thing, so Ta-da! You’re welcome.

John Bruno:

I have a question if.

Jonah:

Go for it, John.

John Bruno:

My name is John Bruno. I’m the executive director of the International Ecotourism Society, so we’re on the community and sustainable development side. And to be frank, I’m a tiny bit dismayed that, you know, we got 30 minutes in before Fiona talked about the ecosystems and the communities’ role in the ecosystems. And I hear, you know, everybody talking about theoretical KPIs and I think that you know, we need to be sure that we come at all this from I mean, let’s face it. You might have a 70-bit premium on your demand for green bonds, but everyone in this room knows that it isn’t just for restrictive conservation.

It’s for sustainable development and taking care of the communities that are that are affected by what we’re doing. And to do this kind of flyover enforcement of these sort of vague KPIs, I don’t think does anyone a favor in these communities. So, what I’d like to understand is how are how are you who are coming up with these policy standards and that are communicating with governments, how are you engaging the indigenous communities in your planning, in your KPIs? How are you taking advantage of their wisdom and their hundreds of years of stewardship in your in your assessments of what this financing should do and how it should be distributed.

Jonah:

Would any panelists like to take that on? Even those who’ve asked questions previously.

Fiona Banister:

James, should we talk about the model in.

Unidentified participant:

Panama Well, I can I can I can I can.

James Magowan:

Just talk a little bit about what our we are integrating a company called Futura Forestal, which has been operating in Panama for over 25 years and they have worked alongside indigenous communities since their beginning. And I think what’s what’s important to understand is that we recognize that the indigenous communities have the knowledge of the forest that is far greater than anything we’ll ever have. And that’s why it is absolutely in our plan to put indigenous communities actually in charge of for instance building a nursery. So, today we’re working in Panama with indigenous communities who go into the forest and find, seeds to plant in, to select for optimal qualities as we work to build rebuild by the biodiverse forest that we’re standing alongside their land.

And then how can we be a partner in terms of our land strategy so that we protect the wild forest that they occupy. How can we build in adjacent to that, green corridors that are productive so that we can be economically, valuable to them at the same time protect the biodiversity that is available in the adjoining lands. And so that those are our at the core of our of our mission. And I should also say that at the core of our mission is that we’re doing this on an open-source basis taking that 25 years of experience and gradually we’ll be putting that out for everyone to understand what has been done and some of the practices that we think are valuable as we go forward.

Any other panelists? Sure. I wanted to just expand on that. One of the areas is also the research data that is held by the indigenous communities. There is a very rare library of about 18 years of work that was saved from a burning building. It was a miracle that we have it. And you know, that is a an intense amount of research collected with indigenous communities and indigenous tribes. And that needs to be digitized not for the western perspective but for locking it also under the Nagoya protocol so that some of that very important data and species data, not just for them cultivating it in their private cooperative women-run, indigenous-run nurseries, but to have them look at the value of these assets and being able to not just protect them, but give knowledge and value to these rare species and their content, not just for now, but going forwards for the future.

And that, I guess, in the side of the X-Prize rainforest, when I really curated the teams involved for that was really it was from that seed of that rare indigenous library that needs protection. That was what also seeded us forwards to be able to say we need to have a challenge. We need to have help. Data cannot just be extracted by drones and other entities or Google pulling out all this precious data. We need to protect it for the indigenous people and their values and for their next generation. And equally though, we again bring in this model of education.

The indigenous peoples’ transformation of their knowledge, needs and wishes between one tribal community to another tribal community is also sacred. And those seeds and that going back in history, we’ve been seed explorers and cultivators. So, why can’t we change other products that could give them higher commodity returns? For example, black pepper is a huge commodity. So, why can’t we plant pepper using specific models near their tribal community and so they get a high income from the pepper while they’re protecting their herbs and their species that are valuable to their communities and learning further how they need those medicines to be protected.

And we need them for our lungs, too. Thank you.

Jonah:

So, we have 11 minutes left. I’m going to ask the next two questions to go back to back for the panelists to then respond. First up is Barat and then Raj. And please introduce yourselves in addition to your.

Unidentified participant:

Questions. Yeah. Barat Suriya, head of.

Barat:

Practice for impact investments with TopTier Impact, which is a global impact investment ecosystem. My question to all the learned people who are actually creating these bonds and deciding on the bonds and the metrics, have you got any indigenous people actually part of your teams to help you create these metrics?

Jonah:

Great. And then before responses, Raj.

Raj:

Hi. Hi. I’m Raj. I’m sorry. I’m just going to take a second to make a comment. I think like I’ve been in so many Well, I’ll present myself. I’m working to create a bank for nature, a joint impact nature bank. And so, a lot of these questions that we are addressing and, you know, tapping around from different perspectives seem to have that same blockage and also the language in terms of what’s happening really on the ground and the tools that we have. It’s like we can we have the mathematical financial tools, but they’re just not We don’t have the bridge on the other side in terms of how we value.

So, we have like a structural problem and a market addressing problem. You can read that, you know, there are trillions of dollars in funds waiting for sustainable projects, but we just unable to get the money there and back. So, and it’s like we’re we should like really slow down and look at those building blocks and find a common language so that we can actually, you know, put the pieces together to do the activities we want to do. So, that was just a more of a comment than a than a question.

Thanks.

Jonah:

Great. Thank you. Responses, panelists.

Peter Elwin:

Yeah, maybe if I can jump in on Roger’s comment. I completely sympathize and I and I and agree with your sort of well, frustration, I guess, Roger, if I’m not sort of putting too many words in your mouth. But I actually feel we are we are getting there. I think there’s been extraordinary progress over the last literally two or three years around the whole climate debate. And actually, I think that what you might call the nature debate is catching up fast. I mean, people are now really getting on board with the idea that you can’t just solve the climate problem.

You have to consider biodiversity and you have to consider that sort of the broader nature sort of side of things at the same time and the two are completely interlinked. So, I think that actually that sort of bridge that you were talking about and the language that we need, the concepts, and ultimately the regulation, and sort of policies, that is actually getting there. That’s not to say that it couldn’t happen faster and it and it won’t happen unless we all continue to push, but I’m actually probably in the optimistic camp in terms of that.

Going back to Bharat’s question, to be completely honest, no, we’re a very small think tank and although we’re a sort of, you know, diverse group of what you might call sort of northern hemisphere people, yeah, we don’t have anybody who I would recognize as coming from a sort of a indigenous tribal background, but we are currently recruiting. So, if you know anybody with a financial analysis background who actually comes from one of those communities, then please do send them my way.

Jonah:

Others?

Leisa de Souza:

Well, I think just resonating I think what Peter said, I think when you talk about of course, you know, green bonds and so on, but sometimes I there are so many different labels that come out, but it’s you know, one thing and we see in our if you’re talking about green bond for agriculture, it has to have biodiversity. And when we developed our criteria, we have an adaptation and resilience checklist which looks at biodiversity because it’s these things are so interlinked, and I think, you know, we’re advancing quite a lot.

And I think it’s also using tools and mechanisms that are out there, so people can start understanding and making these connections and directing, and I think every investment should be impact investment, and we’re getting there, and I think we’ve advanced a lot. So, I know that there is a lot to be done, especially when you talk about nature-based solutions and forests and so on, but I know that the there’s a window, and we understand there’s a window to 2030, and it’s urgent, but I think that, you know, together in this debate is really important to kind of, you know, bring everyone together and, you know, discuss these solutions.

And Bharat, we also don’t have at least in the climate bonds as well anyone. I’m third generation indigenous, so my grandmother is indigenous. So, I’m as Fiona mentioned, I think there’s this, you know, kind of blend in terms of things, but I think when you’re talking about indigenous communities and so on in the label, of course, if we’re talking a lot about the social bond, which is a new kind of you know, label that has come up. It’s going to be, you know, developed with the issuer with the investors many times.

So, I think there’s space, especially if you’re talking with, you know, these traditional communities to kind and define what are these KPIs, you know, where the investment is going towards. And of course, you know, a lot of this is going to be piloted by their space and what Peter mentioned also about sustainability-linked, you know, and these KPIs. These are These are not only defined or built, you know, the market is testing quite a lot of this. So, there is scope to define and I think, you know, investors as, you know, James and so on, you they’ll come back and say, you know, the market’s being tested that we will accept this KPI isn’t ambitious.

And of course, the CBI is doing a lot of this on green and climate. And you know, there’ll be others that will come and support in defining these KPIs and saying this is what is, you know, strong in terms of these different elements. So, we’re doing this for green and hopefully we’ll have people coming and doing this for social and for other labeled bonds.

Jonah:

Any others? We’re also reaching near the top of the hour. So, as sorry, also invite panelists to make their closing comments. Maybe as sort of a request for action or something for this group. Any others?

Unidentified participant:

Well, let me just take a few seconds to point out that, you know, one of the challenges we’re finding is with and it was mentioned before with scale. So, and this touches on the indigenous issues as well as the, you know, getting the all those assets that are sitting on the sidelines is that you often have very small-scale projects that are happening at very local levels that could receive, you know, could receive investments, could probably produce a decent debt type return, but they’re just, you know, you can’t so hard to scale them up or aggregate them to the point where they can touch these larger investment sizes.

Even bonds are by nature extremely large. So, there’s a really important connect that has to take place between small-scale actions and indigenous actions on the ground, and one of the, you know, solutions to build up that capacity are really important. And then, just one final thing is that nature conservation in general has you know, struggled with it with involving local people, you know, for years. And all these methodologies now have been put in place to and basically they involve communication and validation. And the indigenous peoples of the world, they control the majority large majority of un- sort of untouched ecosystems.

And they’re they’re so important to work with and find these solutions so that we can use these finance mechanisms to help these indigenous populations maintain these incredibly valuable ecosystems for the rest of the planet. And it’s a huge challenge because of that scale issue and the aggregation issue. So, anyone that comes up with really great solutions, I’d love to hear them. And thanks so much for including me.

Jonah:

Great. Any others?

Fiona Banister:

Sure. Just wanted to say that it’s not about me, it’s about us all seeding and pollinating together. And I think that the core value is realizing that it’s we can talk about a big climate bond. We can talk about it as an external. But, even in your own backyard, even in your own community, know the value of the trees, plant trees, invest in some trees for your children. I mean, it’s very important to have things growing. Whether if it’s not just a tree, it’s an herb garden. Really take it into your own nature-based solution and look at it of what is your value, how much have you collected and impacted in your daily life.

First, for yourself, and then from there, how do we talk about climate? You know, the challenge for me at the UN this year was you know, this 200 plus companies that have joined the LEAF Coalition. But when and where is that money going to be dispensed? And who and how is it going to trickle down? Or is it going to be chomped at a bit by the governments and by those that get the dispersed payment from it? And then who’s trading that carbon? And so there’s a question every time I’m also approached by a young group saying, “Oh, we want to do an NFT, a coin.” I said, “I’m not trading I’m not going to advise any of our indigenous people to trade a carbon value of their forest right now cuz it’s actually personally it’s not their right to do that because that is a honorer of the earth.

It is their right to get paid to be a steward of it, but not to trade it at a price that’s controlled by an external market value. So, I think that’s what I’d love people to think about. Do what you can, plant your own seeds, choose some vegetables today, and think where they were grown and what you can grow for the future. Thank you.

Jonah:

Would any of the panelists like to have final words? We’re at the top of the hour, so we’ll be ending real soon. Last comments?

Unidentified participant:

Well, I would just encourage all of us to find projects that have the highest quality environmental social biodiverse carbon sequestering capabilities, preservation capabilities, seek them out, hold them up and let us share and create standards as we go forward together to rebuild the you know, the planet that we have.

Jonah:

Great. Lisa, John, David, any final words? Peter?

Peter Elwin:

I guess I would actually go back and answer John’s question where he had a multitude of should we do this, should we do this, or should we do this? And I think the answer is yes. We need to do all of those things. So, right from the micro that Fiona was describing so eloquently in terms of our own personal circumstances up to the macro in terms of influencing government policy, tax, subsidy, international trade negotiations, all of those things, and all the way in between with financial markets sort of playing a very important role.

I think all of these levers are incredibly important, and you know, frankly, we just have to pull on them all as hard as we can because we’ve got you know, a short amount of time to make what is going to be a very important big difference.

Jonah:

Go ahead.

Leisa de Souza:

No, no, I was just going to say that I think there’s a lot being developed and there’s other things that are you know, going on, and I think going back to John’s question, I think we need to do everything in terms of you know, policy, the instruments, and bringing it to scale, and this is what we do. I think it’s how fast we deliver, and each of us have a role to play as Fiona was mentioning, as Peter was mentioning in terms of you know, the financial tools, and each of the different organizations are trying to answer I think different questions, and together of course, you know, we bring all these efforts together.

So, if anyone has any or feedback for the climate bonds, feel free to connect, and we’re happy to discuss. Thank you.

Jonah:

Great, everybody. We now switch over to water cooler time, which means unstructured conversations. Most people will get off the call, but the chat room will stay up, and I’m going to hang around. It’s office hours free-for-all. Thanks so much for joining us. Thank you so much, panelists.

Unidentified participant:

Thanks for having me. Thank you.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you, Jonah.

Unidentified participant:

Take care.

Jonah:

You bet. Thanks so much, guys.

Fiona Banister:

So, I’m going to place it out there. Who has actually been in the forest this week? And or hugged a tree. Yay. You know, let’s get it down to earth. And who has been working in a garden? You know, I think it’s Yes. Leading to work in the garden and know where our vegetables and our fruits come from. So, I mean, it’s part of that education. I’m also a Steiner Waldorf teacher, but it’s like it come on. Why are we not actively involved in producing what we eat. And you know, so just opening it up to other ideas.

How are you, Mark? I see you there, Sir T. How are you? Tell a little bit about your work as well. You have amazing work.

Mark:

Thank you, Xena. Bonjour. Bonjour. I’m well. I’m actually helping a group of indigenous people that will be that were was already in Madrid for COP 25, it’s called Minga Indigena. And I’m I know Jonah is also is helping with them. To apparently they need they need accreditation for the blue for the blue zone. So, I don’t know I don’t know how to do that. I’m still, you know, far away from all these little details, but yeah, well, as far as my work is to Hey, James. Nice to meet you, too.

Yeah, it’s really to value to traditional indigenous knowledge. And through a process that of course involves first and foremost indigenous people to assess that traditional knowledge in different contexts. And one of them is modern context. So, how to add value to that knowledge so it does not disappear because it’s it is disappearing quite quickly. And the issue with that with some something that does not necessarily reach everybody’s mind is that the way indigenous people identify Not all of them, of course, because some have more urban, more modern indigenous people, but for the most part they identify with the forest.

And so, if that tradition is that knowledge is eroding, then the systems that have helped supporting this knowledge will also erode. And that system is the forest itself. So, that’s what I do. Thank you, Hannah.

Unidentified participant:

Mhm. Yeah.

Fiona Banister:

But, your work also is very powerful in supporting communities and young women to let’s say you’re mentoring or they’re mentoring you. But, I think that’s part of it is this education system. And then, did you want to express a little bit about the herbs and the herbal community actions that.

Unidentified participant:

You’re doing? Yes, so everything is.

Mark:

About, you know, a reciprocity. What’s friend of mine has coined the gift economy. Right? So, yes, the we have And I don’t know, you know, every time every time I try to get a number I read sometimes 20,000, sometimes some other time 40,000. So, I really don’t know how many plants have been identified in the Amazon rainforest, but out of, you know, 20 or 40,000, we know that there are about 3,000 that have properties that can, for instance, be used for or to treat cancer. So, but there is so much more than that.

There is this body of knowledge around medicinal plants that I feel is not recognized. So, the idea that we’ve been developing for the last 8 years is to make these into actual products that can be used both by indigenous people, but be eventually sold to you know, in markets anywhere in the world. And that’s a model that can be easily scalable and replicable in any part where, you know, there is still knowledge around plants. So, and that serves also as protecting the forest and so the what has been fundamentally into and I’m and I hope I’m not taking too much time, but what has been fundamentally into bringing these to life is to recognize that there is anywhere in the world a need for you know, healing and creating something.

One of the aspect that has been a little bit underlooked or you know that we’re not considering that most of these people A do not speak English. So, that’s why they have people like us, you know, and I to well, to always remind people that the beautiful job you’ve you’ve done today, Shannon, with reminding people that yeah, they are the guardians. They’ve been doing that for dozens of years and when you know, we look at how we call the Amazon the this or, you know, how the Americans or Anglo-Saxon portrayed the waste as this wilderness like as if nobody inhabited these places and attended to the land.

Actually, the Amazon is a product of indigenous people attending to that land. I’m just going to leave it there. Thank you.

Bobby:

Well, I’ve just been listening. My name is Bobby Kia. I am I’m a good friend of Jonas and yeah, I just got back from Oahu, actually. The North Shore of Oahu and it was it’s quite tropical, quite lovely. But yeah, figured I’d say hello and thank you guys. It was beautiful to listen. And at the Peace Department, which is a group that I found recently with the son of Barry Sternlicht from Starwood Capital Group. We will be attending COP together, you know, this coming COP, and we’re excited to be meeting with, you know, people like Carney and Alok Sharma and others, and hopefully be advancing some public-private partnerships, the first of which hopefully we’ll be able to announce, but it confidentially is with my former employer, the World Bank’s International Finance Corporation.

So, the idea is to have a private-funded aggregated vehicle. And at the moment, we’re just targeting climate transition leaders in different markets that IFC’s venture-backed, but the opportunity, I think, in the future is to think about, you know, on the on the on the bond side as well, work working with the IFC Treasury. And beginning to think about, you know, ring developing bankable projects, right, that could then ultimately benefit from proceeds that are ring-fenced from the sale of these types of biodiversity bonds and others. So, if there’s any, you know, any advice for the private sector, for those who are, you know, people from the industry, and you know, Barry Sternlicht is on the he used to chair the Robin Hood Foundation out of New York City, which is quite cool, cuz it’s like the whole it’s the whole titans of finance industry, you know, with the Dalio, Paul Tudor Jones, John Updike, a few others, right?

And so, it’s just interesting to think about you know, the message that we want to be positioning, and I enjoyed listening to the way you guys talked about it. So, thank you so much again and you know again, any ideas around connecting high finance to you know, scientific based nature, please do look us up at the peace department.global. And yeah, actually a good friend of ours you guys might know this gentleman his name is Satyarth Tripathi. But he used to be the head of the UN, I think DP for North America and he was assistant secretary general level and he’s now he’s now created something called the Global Alliance for a Sustainable Planet and he just sent me a what’s it called?

A Jamaica Agro-Park deck, which looks quite interesting and so we’re you know, he’s thinking about replicating basically the tropical forest finance initiative that he created for Indonesia in the palm oil industry. He created that the original with the USAID. And I think he’s going to try to replicate that in the Caribbean. So,.

Unidentified participant:

It’s pretty interesting. Hey guys, sorry to interrupt. I need to use the room in the next 2 minutes. I apologize.

Fiona Banister:

You’re saying something Mark, we can unmute. Jonah, you are fabulous. You are always bringing us together, weaving a basket of wisdom and leaving us to keep sprouting. So, thank you cuz we now have lots of seeds to continue for our next Thank you so much Jonah.

Unidentified participant:

Lee Mary, thank you. Hello. I know we haven’t connected in a long time, but good to see you here. And Mauricio, maybe one day we’ll connect it. But I know Babacar, we said we’re going to meet at one point, so we’re going to we’re going to figure that out.

Unidentified participant:

I just had Can I just say a quick hello and thank you? And I would love to learn more about Mark’s project and also Fiona’s open source and James’s open source data. I’d love to find a way to contribute through my contacts and knowledge if I can learn more about what you guys are working on because I really very much appreciate the personal touch with working directly with these communities and it’s really important and I’d like to somehow find a way to contribute.