Conflict Resolution: Towards Responsible Mining in the Amazon
Juliana Dib Rezende and Vasco van Roosmalen: Today, we discuss how to do responsible mining in the Amazon. While mining is traditionally among the most environmentally destructive industries, new approaches to community involvement and dispute resolution can democratize wealth distribution and limit environmental impact. By facing the challenges and seizing the opportunities of the extractive industry in the Amazon, the Utu Social Impact Fund helps victim communities access environmental licensing finance to conduct local social and economic development planning processes. Julia Dib Rezende and Vasco van Roosmalen join us to tell the story.
Recorded January 11, 2021
References:
RSF Social Finance article about “Mining & Community: Deep Impact Investing.”
A Canadian fund similar to the Utu Social Impact Fund:
WATCH:
Participants
- Jonah (moderator)
- Juliana Dib Rezende
- Vasco van Roosmalen
- Bruno
- Paula
- Lars (Rainforest Foundation Norway)
- Susan
- Margarita
- Unidentified participants
Transcript
Jonah:
Hello everybody. Welcome to the 29th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. Again, this is a weekly program to advance forest-friendly economic development across the Amazon region. We are a program of the global governance philanthropy network born out of the United Nations 75 global governance forum. Today we have two presenters, Juliana Dib Rezende and Vasco van Roosmalen. You guys will correct me if I mispronounce your names. And they are talking to us about what I call responsible extractive industry meets the Amazon. They have figured out a way to make it a friendlier less ugly process that generates income for the right people.
And so we’re planning to do about a half hour of presentation followed by another half hour of conversations. I just want to remind everybody at the top of the hour we will convert over to informal time where there’s we have it’s you know the water cool moment where there we have unstructured conversation the chat room may open so you can copy the links etc. So without further delay Vasco and Juliana the floor is yours.
Juliana Dib Rezende:
Thank you so much Jonah. It’s a pleasure to be here with all of you. I’m going to soon share my screen but I just want to present and share how I met Vasco which was in a very it was in a very honorable situation. I was working at Google as a partnership strategic partnership product partnership lead and I was working with Google Earth and one of the project that I was managing was how Google Earth and this technologies could be more useful to people where we could not see what was underground all that green space right and then I found out that Vasco was working down there with indigenous communities and lumbalas communities doing capacity building programs of how to use such technology for self-governance model right and one thing that has always frustrated me was how much u local associations was not the protagonist of their story there’s always someone doing something for them right and before Google I was at the United Nations And the reason that I decided to leave was because I was flying out to Africa doing things they could be doing themselves most and now with the technology being more and more accessible right they could be leading their own paths so I’m going to share my screen to present what UTU fund is about and give some background as well so Just a second.
Just a minute when it’s not here. Okay. Okay. Here we go. Can you all see my screen? All right. Perfect. So we are talking about UTU social impact fund. UTU is sumerian means clarity right and once we have clarity about where we are going we have transparency right we have everybody on board we know that we are not going alone. Bringing light. It’s it’s liberating. It brings freedom, right? And not just by those that are not in there, but like as collective way, you can go further once you have this clarity of mind to take better decisions.
So before talking about UTU fund, I want to talk about ECOM and so Ecom is a nonprofit association leading by Vasco that has been working for over 20 years in the Amazon. His story his story is amazing. I love to hear how much he has experienced the Amazon and how much he has lived and learned by people that lives there. And this is for me the most exciting thing about his work. And who has joined EKA in the last couple of years to bring a more entrepreneurial activity and mindset as well.
Oman is a consortium project company that works mostly with companies and their relationship with nature and people. And then a con came in together of how much they could leverage local associations and indigenous communities potential into a relationship with companies that are operating and impacting their territories. So they work mostly of with companies and communities relationship community life plans development which is something that for some people can be a new thing but actually it’s a very unsatural how they plan the future and their life plans. The way that they do it in a westernized model by putting it into words and into maps it’s new for them and it’s new for us as well to learn that they are not used to it and locals association strengthening.
So most of these communities have learned how to adequate themselves into our model. So we can have conversations and for them to learn of how they structure their associations and again this is something not very common for most of those communities. So before we talk further about the fund, I just want to flag out how many people live under this green carpet that we see behind Jonah. So there are around 30 million people living in the Amazon. This is huge. This is a lot of people with wishes and with desires for better lives and with choices.
They have a choices and they already have a voice. We are not giving them any voice. They already have their voices. So they’re there and they are suffering everyday violation for human rights to life. As most of you guys are super engaged and I’m sure you already know just to flag out some of them there are just in 2019 two more than 200 conflict situation involving kinballas and riverines communities. And even another fact is even with supported organization is difficult to see and to have numbers and data of how much people are affected and how they are affected because this information does not exist.
Most of the information that we think we know are not actually in the records and accessible especially for governments and public policies. So how can you take decisions about sanitation for example if you don’t know how many families are living certain territories right and most of the times the government especially the federal government does not have capacity to go into the forest to leverage those data so what a co is actually doing is teaching them tools and technologies so they can be doing that themselves And then we have the COVID situation as well.
So Konaki which is the Kilmbala association and Abipi which is the indigenous Brazilian association have mapped the cases themselves because there are not actually a federal and public data gathering system that can do this. And then in our perspective, the main challenge we see here is the lack of visibility of those people in terms of decision making process. Right? For most of the world, they are considered invisible. When we talk about the Amazon, you know, like the image of the rivers, the forest, the animal, the trees comes to mind. But then we have to remember there are people living there for millions, thousands of years, right?
And then another challenge that we want to flag out there is this study done by Oxford that the local NGOs are not receiving most of the inter the financial support and tools that they’re available. So it says that local and national angels received just 0.4% as a directly to our international humanitarian assistance. Right? So still we have this challenge of distribution. Most of the donors and grants it goes to non and institutions that they already have their names out and that they already they’re already visible. But what about Kind? What about Arimo?
You know, they are the associations that are leaving the Amazon. They are the people that are struggling to take a shower, to wash their clothes, you know. So how can we guarantee that these associations can be visible and be seen and be trusted to receive a grant to lead their own way and their own path. So and another thing that we want to flag as a challenge here is the direct impact of the infrastructure works in those territories due the lack of visibility as well. We see here that the impact that the company have in two more than 2,000 kilobalas communities and for those that are not familiar kilomalas are the communities done by slavery enslaved people that run away and created their own communities.
All right. And after the slavery period was finished in Brazil, they received a document stating that they have the right for those lands. So the impact that the company has in the territory, it directly impacts this communities not only from a social perspective but also nature perspective, right? And based on this impact that we see directly from the company to the communities and the work that e and has been doing for a couple of years, the lack of autonomy that the community have in terms of the negotiation table, they decided to bring out to life the UTU fund.
So just a step back here I just want to also bring the infinite cycle of the violations of human and nature rights the lack of visibility and the industry impact. This is a non-ending looping. If we don’t work on one of these things and make sure we break the system, we’re going to still be operating in a dependence model. So the youth comes to open doors to realize that these communities have conditions enough to be in the negotiation table with a company to work and bring those terms to life. So and we are talking about a demand a global demand for minerals for example that are coming into this tsunami of renewable and green revolution right we’re talking about this technology that are still pretty much dependent on what is underneath earth and where people are living for centuries of years.
This is some cases that ecom and uma have worked in terms of how much they facilitated the negotiations for either compensations or royalties. So we are talking about compensations and financial transferring to the communities of at least $10 million and up to $50 million. And this has to be done responsible. This has been done in a way that the communities are part of the decision making. And we and they must have all the resources to make the right decision. So we are talking about bringing lawyers, good lawyers to talk with the communities as well, right?
So just a brief overview as well of how the fund works. So u we invest during two years in the strengthening and the development of local communities in a way with the consentment of those associations and the invitation by them as well. And we have already settled a strong ground with those communities in a national international level. And they already know the work that we’ve been doing for a while. And in this two years we’re going to be working upon our methodology that we’re going to go over for a while in a while.
That the main point here is to bring autonomy to the communities. We are not here to take decision for anyone. And then in two years time we would be able to work with the company the me the industry to find an agreement that meets everybody’s term and I think it’s important also to know here that for the company this can be a first step to a ESG agenda as well. So they don’t have to go over that in the future and spend more couple of millions for example. I think by respecting communities wishes is respecting nature because they live out of nature they have different motivations when we take communities and industry right and I think everybody here might feel the same the motivation is completely different it’s passion it’s rational and it’s hard sometime right to make sure we are on the same page talking about the same thing if you think with your heart or if your mind.
So I think it’s it’s important to leverage this as the UTU impact fund as a mediator agent and just to go over our methodology. So we are talking about achieving out bringing autonomy to those communities. So we start our process by a planning process bringing dionist survey community development plans participatory methodology all with a technology based approach. And most of this technology we have a long-term relationship with some partners where we have developed a technology that are suitable for different perspective and experiences as well. Most of this runs offline as well and then we when you have access Wi-Fi or so forth there you can go up to cloud and then we will go over capacity compliance governance financial management which again there are a couple of years dozens of years of experience of how make this capacity model being something that works for them and to be something that will be suitable for their reality.
We are not here to impose anything. They know the best way the govern governance will work in their own reality, right? Everybody, every community have their own way to build up your own compliance model. It doesn’t have to be all the same participation. So we have our safeguards where informed consent and particip participatory forums are essential in the negotiation table. So there is no way for us to go into a case if we don’t have informed consent by the community. We go over transparency of how much this information should be organized and available.
Obviously they will choose what it’s going to be public or not. This is not also up to us to decide what should be open and what should be public and what should be confidential and then going towards autonomy right and this autonomy includes education it includes how you deal with investment and diversification and there is something that I think it’s worth saying as well once the community has this autonomy model they can go after their own brands as well right and not be dependent of just one income. And then just to finalize here, I just want to bring up some safeguards that will guide us through the process.
So again, for the fund to operate will be only operating where we are invited by the community. Okay. And again just in Brazil there are over 5,000 kilomalos communities and they are the one helping us out from the beginning. The fund will ensure full participation from the public sector entities. So we are not going over any laws. We will be definitely in accordance with all public policies and make sure all these public policies are also be implemented in the best way possible. The funding will bases all this action the free pry informed consense process that will follow the ILO 169 protocols and we’ll also be oriented according the Ecuador principles.
Okay. And another thing that guides us is to obviously be in accordance with the UN guiding principles on business and human rights as well. We have we have our guidance on the SDGs. So we are and we’ll be always be aligned with what is already going on and make sure that we are here to act and we are here to learn from everybody that is engaged especially the communities that are leaving it. So this is it about the fund. And I thank you all for being here. It’s a pleasure for me to be part of the fund.
I left Google because I think we can do better with technology. When everybody that I was every time that I was at Google doing plannings of how people could be spending more time online it bothered me knowing that there are people that could be doing more but they are not reachable they are not visible right and this has never been a priority the priority for those that already seen and they already know that they already have their data out so and I think if those people that are not visible, they are under the green carpet.
They are guided by passion. You know, the first time that I went to the Amazon, I remember looking and seeing that we don’t have to go over all this crazy cycle to realize that we already have everything, right? That nature is what brings us this unity. And I think people that are living in the Amazon they have what we live in the city have lost. So once they are they honor their own path I think they can take amazing decisions for the future. And the fund is really looking for that is really looking for the communities to take ownership of the decisions.
So thank you so much Vasco if you want to come in and share a little bit about yourself as well feel free and then we are also open for questions. Thank you Jonah for the opportunity and I wish you all the success with this amazing network.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you Vasco.
Vasco van Roosmalen:
Hi. No. I’m just here in support of Jon and Juliana of the presentation. I also would like to note that Bruno Gomez, who’s the fun of who’s our was the equal partner in the development of the fund is also here. And so we’re here to help answer any questions or to discuss. The idea of the fund is something that’s been developed over a while. The original idea of the fund was the concept was created in the United States about 10 years ago by a group of academics and the founder of green grants.
He has his own organization called RTC impact fund. And the idea was to reduce the conflict of interest in cases of impact benefit agreement negotiations where companies come in and have the loan economic power, financial power in these negotiations and again this is in cases where communities have decided to engage with companies and so for example the concept and of impact benefit agreements was developed in Canada. The Flight Group is one of the groups that works extensively with this and this is where communities have decided or have made the decision that to engage with infrastructure can bring benefits to their communities but they need to be empowered to make the right decision to be able to make themselves heard in the negotiations.
In the case of the Brazilian Amazon and other regions in South America, this is sometimes the case. In other cases, there are places where mining or infrastructure is already taking has been taking place for quite a number of decades. And so there are negotiations to be done around past impacts and compensations for past impacts and also what future impacts may look like and what type of compensations need to be made. And as was emphasized the idea of the funds to only work and to only engage in processes where communities invite the fund to join them and to support them in these processes and then to sit down with all the stakeholders in the region who are involved in that process to find the best ways forward.
So that’s it and like I said myself Bruno Juliana were here to respond to any questions that people may have.
Jonah:
Great. I’d like to begin with just a couple of questions before opening up to everybody else just to help set the stage for things. Could you guys remind us what is the Brazilian legislation that sets up this market opportunity and what are the numbers? What that legislation? How much of the wealth created from an extractive process is required to share with local communities?
Vasco van Roosmalen / Bruno — boundary unclear:
Actually Bruno do you do you want to resp the main law that requires that’s around royalties for mining companies is around seph which the contribution the contribution of mining to land owners where mining is made and that’s a calculation that is to the land owners and to the federal and state government and municipal government. So these royalties are paid out based on production numbers. They’re calculated then they’re paid out to the federal government that redistributes them to the state and municipal government. And there it’s very important that municipal governments have the capacity to effectively invest these resources and we’ve seen in many cases that’s not the case.
In some cases some municipalities receive up to 800 million rais a year or a billion rais a year in these royalties. And so and in many cases very little development or effective or positive impact of these of these payments is seen in our cases in the fund. It’s another part of the stephen which is that’s paid to the land owners. So in cases where communities are land owners of land were being mined and with the new laws of CFM there’s also the possibility where mining infrastructure passes through their land such as a mining duct for example which there are many cases as well that they would be able to receive royalties.
And so in one case that we’re working on the communities have the potential to receive up to $3 million a year for example in royalties. That’s just in royalties. In another case that’s very well known in Brazil, it’s the Julichi case where KA operates. The settlement community that receives royalties over the last 10 years has received about 60 million reais in royalties that’s gone to the association. 16 million has today’s exchange rate about $15 million. So these are significant amounts if you’re just talking royalties. But these amounts are compounded when it also involves compensation for damages and in many cases these are past damages that weren’t considered in the original licensing procedures.
So that is much more where the judicial areas of the minist mandates that a study is done on the material and immaterial damages of the past of past mining or past infrastructure on the community’s lands. And based on that study an amount is negotiated between the company and the communities and again zi is a good example of that where the mining company has to pay about 40 million rais to the community still for past damages and that payment has been held up for the last seven years because of a lack of infrastructure by the community to receive those funds.
So the judicial the mean state publicly understands that unless the community has a fund in place or some type of financial mechanism that they should not be receiving those funds but at the same time the community has is living with the impact. So in this case it’s a process where they are receiving royalties but where these royalties have shown very little positive impact because of the way that these funds are managed and you have the process of elite capture and all these other things that we understand with community development and that’s actually what RTC stands for.
It’s reversed the curse. So the way that financial resources associated to extractive u industries have not brought development. So you have the royalties and then the damages and then you also have voluntary contributions. So another case that we worked in there was a combination of all three where the company is paying compensation, paying royalties and also making a voluntary contribution over a period of 10 years to help promote community development. And so the level of resources that you work and that’s amazing when you think about the Amazon, but in most these cases you’re talking about 2025 million to be dispersed over 10 years.
This is for up to 10, 15, 30 communities or one community in the case of the land settlement, but for 2,000, 3,000, 5,000 people. And there as we’ve mapped out there are a number of other cases just in the Brazilian Amazon and certainly in the rest of Brazil where you have different in types of industries not just mining but also solar powered solar projects, wind projects that are impacting local communities especially in the Brazilian northeast and where payments have to be negotiated and models for royalties have to be negotiated.
Unidentified presenter:
Vasco, maybe I just I just like just to add some something about this voluntary contributions because I think it’s very important for our subject here. Even if there is no obligation of course voluntary contribution nowadays we see that it’s really seem like a part of the business by the companies because the obligations with the light the environmental license and the compensation agreements are not enough to avoid the social conflicts or to avoid any troubles. So most of the companies the big companies or the big projects they understand that they have to have also a voluntary agreements and voluntary contributions if they want they really want to promote development in the communities in the territories.
Jonah:
I have another follow-up question. So, let’s say I’m an investor who’s interested in supporting entrepreneurs like you who want to innovate the relationship between the extractive industry and local communities and unleash financial resources that are otherwise stuck. What is the size of this market opportunity? Do you do you have a number for the Amazon, for Brazil at large, larger than that?
Vasco van Roosmalen:
So for the cases that we’ve m map mapped specifically for just for kilola communities in Brazil for the different industries is about $200 million currently that needs to be le that can be leveraged. Each case will require in terms of an investor the fund is looking is working to raise $20 million and each ticket is about $2 million.
Jonah:
Great. And then I have one last question. There are a lot of investors who stay away from the extractive industry because of ethical reasons. But in order to scale solar across the world, there’s an argument to be made that the extractive industry needs to continue inevitably. Can you do you have any numbers about that? Do you have any a lot response to those ethical.
Vasco van Roosmalen:
Naysayers? Yeah. So for example the just the last week number of articles have come out but just on Sunday I think there’s some great articles in the in the Guardian about this the fact that we’re entering a new super cycle for extractive mining industries which are absolutely necessary to provide the raw resources for the green energy transition. So, we’re not just talking lithium, but we’re talking copper. We’re talking aluminium. We’re talking all kinds of minerals that have to be expanded and in some cases doubled in terms of the production in the next few years to meet the demand for the green energy revolution.
So, we’re going to be shifting our investments from the gas and oil industry and those investments are going to go to the mining industry. There is not much there’s no way out of that. There is in the sense that solar the materials necessary for solar panels for large windmills wind energy generation all of those are going to have to be generated by the mining industry and so there is an anticipation that there will be new super cycle of investment in the mining industry and there’s actually another article about two weeks ago in the guardian that’s called white gold that actually talks a little bit about this and also the fact that this we’re not just talking here about South America or Africa We’re talking about Portugal where there’s going to be an expan a large expansion of mining and impacting communities.
So as the world shifts and it needs to shift because of climate change to transition its energy sources, the fact is that the mining industry is going to bear a lot the brunt of that in terms of demand on the mining industry. And it is I will I will send you guys the links of those of those articles there. They’re really insightful and so if we are to move to this green energy revolution or transition the mining industry has a lot to clean up and that’s what where we position the fund.
The idea is that the fund can operate not just as a model in South America but also can operate for example Australia. I don’t know if you guys followed the case with Riointo where Riotinto recently exploded the cave on native lands which had the oldest remains of human habitation in Australia. That case has had a lot of repercussions in the industry. There was wasn’t an agreement in place by Riotinto and the community and Riotinto was considered to be a reference case in terms of their good relations with the communities much like Samu the Brazilian mining company was before their dam broke in Marana and the CEO they decide to blow up that cave a little while later the CEO lost his job number of other top people lost their jobs investors have moved very clearly.
The Hesta super fund as we said, which is one of the large pension funds in Australia, has said that the way mining companies negotiate agreements with communities needs to be completely revised. So, we’re really looking at something that is global. And so it’s not just in the Amazon, but it’s something where we can develop new models.
Jonah:
Great questions from others. Feel free to just blurt it out or raise your hand or put it in chat. A friend of mine once told me that if you make a presentation and no one asks questions, it means they didn’t understand. I’m pretty sure that someone out there has a question. If you’re on phone star nine or star six, we’ll bring you off mute.
Juliana Dib Rezende:
I would just share some questions that it usually comes. Some people ask us why is the fund and I just want to attach to what Vasco just said about the scalability. I think having the format as a fund allows us to work more independently in a global level doing partnerships on the ground as well. So I think the fund model is really a flexible way to adequate into different experiences and different opportunities and be able to work also with local players in Australia, in Indonesia, in Portugal, in Brazil, in Peru.
Right? So this is a pretty nice and independent model that we are looking towards and again this is something very different. It comes out from our experience of having worked with communities for example on payments for ecosystem services in terms of helping communities develop the tools and the methodologies that they need to attract re because the in the end the challenge is how do communities get long-term financing for their development and that balances environmental protection but also demands for improved healthcare educ education which are part of the human condition. So the fact that you have 30 million people living in the Amazon, about 400,000 of those are indigenous peoples, another 800,000 or so are kilola traditional communities.
And then you’re talking about other rivering peoples urban populations and others. And the fact is that as a conservation movement, if we are concerned about the future of the Amazon, it is truly important that we are able to answer the other questions that communities have, not just about the protection of the land and the forest, but also about how that will generate or how they can generate development for their long-term development plans. And that’s something that we’ve worked on for the last 20 years is to help communities develop their long-term development plans.
And then the biggest challenge is okay, how do you get sustainable financing, not financing for one year project or two-year project, but long-term sustainable financing to promote community development. And so ecosystem services will be one option. As we worked on the SUI carbon project, we saw that there’s still a lot to be learned and a lot of work to be done to reduce the transaction costs for communities in those types of projects. We also understand that just doing family income projects which are really important for family income are not enough to provide communities as a whole with the governance resources that they need to protect and manage their territories.
And as we were mapping out where potential resources are for community development, the private sector came up as one of the largest potential sources for this community development. And in most these cases, we’re talking about development that’s going to happen anyway or has happened or has had its impact, but where communities have not had a voice and have not been able to access the resources that due to them in terms of compensation.
Jonah:
Paula, you have a question.
Paula:
Yes, I do. First of all, thank you for being here. It’s my first meeting and I think I’m breaking the ice. I am the program manager for Brazil at Amazon watch and I have much more like questions and things to learn from you right now than to tell but it’s one question regarding the way that you approach also the parliament like laws and how things happens because we do know that in Brazil right now there’s a huge pressure from the government to change and approve laws of to mine in indigenous lands and process and protected areas.
And that bill was proposed in February. And this year we already know that everything that we try to prevent from happening in terms of opening these lands may be back stronger this year. I was today in a meeting with the indigenous national movement and we together with other partners such as institutes social and environmentalist and lot of indigenous organizations we understood that mining will be one of our main focus of studies campaigns pressures. So how is that you understand the these forces and pressures that we see happening in those lands to change completely the regulations and allow the exploration to happen and also we know that pressures as you say was add up by the what we are seeing in petrotorial industries oil industries and also the price of gold for instance.
So this is one part and the other part of the question is how do you interact with local organizations that has clearly they’re trying to prevent mining to happen like saying like no we don’t want the other parts try to regulate it. So just understanding your how do you relate to other groups that are now trying to prevent for instance the installation of Bellisan the Canadian company or fighting Anglo-American new requirements that were recently approved to mine in lands that we know they will impact indigenous lands. So just some two things.
Vasco van Roosmalen:
Excellent point. So for one thing the fund in Brazil will not work with indigenous peoples because there’s no regulation for mining on indigenous lands as we know. So the focus of the fund in Brazil is for other communities traditional communities that are impacted that are currently not protected. So as the kilola are not protected settlements inca settlements are not protected that mining can happen there and the rivering people for example who are impacted tremendously and there’s except for some recognition in bleonte where was a great advance that they are recognized as traditional peoples and rights to their lands that’s never moved forward and that’s something that’s really important.
So in terms of the fund in Brazil, its objective will is not to invest in any process that involves indigenous peoples because there are no legal mining processes with indigenous peoples in Brazil because there’s no regulation for it. But the idea is to develop models to help develop models that can in the future support those in case something like that happens and where there is a decision. One of the main the main safeguard of the fund is that it will only operate in cases where the community invites the fund to operate.
So where there’s where there is already an existing situation. What we have today in many of these cases is there are existing situations. The fund will not operate in places where license environmental license has not been given yet. So that’s another one of the safeguard. So the idea is to work in cases where there’s existing infrastructure or where a license has already been given where the infrastructure is going to be built and all the cases that we’ve mapped out and meet those criteria. So that is that the fund will only work when it’s invited by a community when it’s already been when it’s being impacted and so that community voice can be heard.
So one of the main investments of the fund will be to help local community organizations structure themselves hire lawyers and other specialists that can help them understand the impact that’s going to be had on their lands because that’s also one of the main the access to information is truly important for a community to make an informed decision if they will allow in the cases where they have that voice if they will allow a project to move forward or not. So you have the cases where you have past impacts where those impacts need to be compensated whether I mean you can’t undo the past but they have a right to receive compensation to have to study what the impacts were on their past and to receive compensation for that and to make a clear decision of whether they want to continue to engage with that process whether it’s it’s a wind farm in POE or a mining operation in par where they where a new mining duct is going to be built for their lands.
So those are those are the safeguards that the fund works and th there are so many cases in Brazil that meet these criteria and then we’re not even talking about Peru, Colombia where you have just in Peru you have over a,300 mining companies that operate in Peru. You have the huge expansion that’s happening in Colombia. The idea of the fund is not to certainly not to support expansion but to really help communities to build the model so that they can be heard. So the one of the main investments of the fund in these processes is to support them with the right legal and technical advice so that they can have to make the right that they have the information available to them to make decisions about how to move forward and that they can be heard.
Jonah:
So that’s a yes go ahead. We have 11 minutes left and three questions. So everybody let’s keep it short and sweet. Lars, you’re up next.
Lars:
Hi, I’m Lars from Rainforest Foundation Norway. Thanks for the presentation, Juliana and Vasco. What I didn’t understand is could you say something more about the UTO social impact fund? How long has it been in existence? What amounts are you working with? And is the idea that you will also gain so that the fund will get a portion or a percentage of what you’re operating with. So there will be a kind of return to the fund. So that’s one element of the question. Second is that you seem to focus a lot on I mean extractive industries mining and I understand the good intention in helping those suffering from mining operations that they haven’t agreed to.
So that’s laudable. At the same time, why do you focus so strongly on as a social impact investment fund on a business that is really not very compatible with the Amazon rainforest with sort of the Amazon 4.0 approach, new approaches to the Amazon, etc. To those elements.
Vasco van Roosmalen:
Yeah. To respond quickly. In terms of the returns of the fund, the expected returns of the fund is 15% a year payout as of the third year. The total raise of the fund is the 20 million $20 million to invest in 20 to 25 cases over its 10-year period. So we are currently in talks with investors and the idea is for the fund to be launched in 2021. The we understand the whole that’s what we talked about the focus on mining companies is one we have a lot of experience with that there’s a lot of existing mining companies in these regions who are already including Norway which has a very large presence in mining presence and impacting communities in the Amazon but as we said we’re not just focusing on the Amazon not just focused on mining the idea the cases that have been mapped out are also for example the wind farms and we understand that other countries.
I’m going to make more investments in wind farms in the northeast and these are directly impacting kilola communities and other communities who live in these regions. So the idea of the fund is not just to work with mining but also directly with the new the newer industries that are being set up in other regions of Brazil that are impacting communities and where joint agreements as we said in POE that needs to be a collective agreement in the state between the communities and all the companies setting up wind farms and solar farms and that needs to be negotiated and those communities urgently need legal and specialist advice to make the best possible agreement.
Ment for them because they are in the way of a huge wave which is coming the new super cycle. And so there is a lot of urgency to get the them the support that they need.
Jonah:
There was also the question about how much has been invested, how much has been returned and then the return on investment.
Vasco van Roosmalen:
So yeah, so the return on investment is 15% a year. We’re still in the raise. So the fund is still is not operational yet. The first the raise is $20 million to operate for 20 for 10 years with a 15% a year return.
Jonah:
Great. And then you want to mention how much you guys have earned to date.
Vasco van Roosmalen:
Well, the fund hasn’t so we for example in terms of leverage we have currently worked with about 240 million AIS to be invested in communities through these types of agreements in the Brazilian Amazon. That is leveraged just working as an NGO, working as consultants, working on these processes.
Jonah:
W with some of the income to pay for your operations coming from that same source.
Vasco van Roosmalen:
So that’s above that. So that’s above that where either through donations or companies paying to help build the agreements. So working as consultants in these processes. So that is an additional amount where companies pay for either companies or donations or grants are made to help communities structure themselves in these processes. The idea of the fund is exactly as was said is to be able to give skill to this to make it to have the funds available in any of these processes to be able to directly apply to the community.
Jonah:
Okay, great. Let’s go ahead and move forward. Susan.
Susan:
Yeah, thank you. As those on this call have heard before, I work on a large UN funded project to improve smallcale gold mining in the in the world really, but in several Amazon countries as well. And I’m wondering how this kind of model, if you’ve thought about how this kind of model that you’re developing could be used to help professionalize and improve and capture the wealth in a positive and responsible way from smallcale gold mining that’s happening in any case in the Amazon. Especially in as you know you know the lack of funds for these communities to invest in development.
How could the gold mining wealth be invested in that fashion and how could you use this model to do so? So we haven’t directly looked at the guild at the smaller scale mining yet for the fund but that’s the idea is that as the model develops that we do so the there is completely the ability for a fund like this to invest for example in community organization around cooperatives of for them to organize themselves and invest in that and then as they are able to impose a level of governance and management then be able to pay back the fund or the resources that were spent on helping them organize because that’s a lot of where the funds goal is to help communities organize themselves.
So it’s not just around the negotiations but also around the necessary governance.
Unidentified presenter:
Structures that they need to set up to be able to govern the use of the resources. So in the cases where the community has decided they want to invest in small scale gold mining h there needs to be an investment to help them organize that the governance of that the how are they going to the community meetings the informed consent process because even if it just if the leaders said want this needs to be go through an informed consent process with the community. So all of that requires resources. So it would be possible for a fund like this to invest in those processes and have a compensation system that comes in afterwards as resources flow back to the community based on that organization on the work that they do as a cooperative to then pay back the fund.
And to be very clear the fund is set up as an equity fund. It invests in processes. So it’s not through debt. So it doesn’t create debt in the communities. Communities do not owe an obligation. That’s very clear that for the fund as well. So in cases where the community receives investment from the fund but in the end decide they don’t want the process to go move forward because they understand that damage is its impact is greater than its benefit. Then all the funds of the fund have been are an investment.
They don’t the communities do not owe the fund a repayment. Only in cases where the it actually moves forward and where the company makes the investment to move forward with the agreement then it’s the company that has the largest interest and it’s the company that pays back the fund.
Jonah:
Okay thank you Vasco okay last question Margarita.
Margarita:
Hi everyone happy 2021 it is still possible because it is only the 11th right it feels already.
Unidentified participant:
I am talking about September but it is January.
Margarita:
So thank you so much for the presentation this is super exciting what you are yeah you’re thinking and planning. I had just a moment ago a comment on and I heard that you’re not going to work in indigenous territories and I was just thinking that particularly in Brazil there are several concessions that are not active in indigenous territories and that would become active once the government or if the government manages to change the legislation. So I was curious whether there was any thinking around this. And then I was just curious how are you going to set up the team because you mentioned that you’re going to have 20 25 initiatives over four or five years.
So I.
Vasco van Roosmalen:
10 years.
Margarita:
How many sorry.
Vasco van Roosmalen:
Over 10 years 20 to 25 cases for over 10 years. Yes.
Margarita:
And I was a bit curious about that because I know that all of these consultation processes take a lot of time and take a lot of staff working on those things in order to do them well. So I was just curious how are you excellent.
Unidentified participant:
Question organize yourself.
Vasco van Roosmalen:
That the idea is for the fund to invest in local NGOs that work with these communities. So the idea is not for the fund to set up it its own staff just it’s it’s funds like this are limited to 2% of total for their management. The idea is that as part of the investment made that the technical assistance to the communities is done through local NGO partners of the communities who have the capacity to provide that local assistance. So that is that the fund not only makes investment in communities but is also able to strengthen the local NGOs that work in these regions who are already partners to these to these communities.
So that is where the workforce of these processes the inform consent processes and others. So the fund has a line of investment to for to strengthen the local association that represents the community but also the local NGOs that work with them and that have the technical capacity to provide that assistance. And finally on indigenous peoples, yes, there are many concessions within indigenous communities territories in Brazil. Currently, there’s still a legal process that has to go through for that to regulate mining in communities. That process is not going to be immediate.
But yes, if there is a legal process available for communities and there are cases where communities want to engage and need support eventually, then the fund would be able to work with indigenous communities in Brazil. This does not preclude the fund to work with indigenous communities in Peru, in Colombia, in Chile who are already impacted. But for now in Brazil, it would only be with communities where there’s legal where these processes are legal or and it’s not just mining, it would also just wind farms, anything else. And you could even potentially think of a fund working with cases that are for payments for ecosystem services to advance the resources necessary for communities to organize themselves to receive payments for ecosystem services.
That is also a possibility for investment. This has brought us to the top of the hour. I want to thank our participants and our speakers. Vasco and Juliana, can you guys stay around? Do you have time?
Jonah:
Okay, great. So this is the class is dismissed and now we have unstructured time and most people usually leave at this time, but sometimes there are these really awesome unstructured conversations. So I encourage you to stick around if you can. It’s now a free-for-all. Anybody feel free to ask questions or to promote your new event or tada.
Susan:
This is Susan speaking again. Sorry to take the floor again, but u, Vasco, I really appreciated your answer to my question and would really like to talk more about how possibly we could work together with or at least explore opportunities for collaboration because as I mentioned, I’m working with this big UN funded project. It works in a number of countries around the world. It’s about to expand to be a total of 16 countries of which I think five are in South America. Many touching the Amazon region and we’re explicitly looking for a new model for trying to professionalize that sector including private sector investment, equity investment in particular.
We’re very interested in that. There are local in each of those countries. There’s also national efforts to try to also get commercial finance you know banks and that sort of national banks even to open green windows for improving the sector. But we’re also extremely interested in finding interested impact investors. And you know, I can see opportunities for, you know, we’re we already have incountry operations doing things like trying to help with formalization and legalization and permitting and all that kind of stuff. And that would really butress you know, an investment opportunity.
Vasco van Roosmalen:
Oh, definitely. I put my email here in the chat, but obvious Jonah has and so just let us know and we’ll set up a call. Bruno, myself and Julian and our team are ready to discuss this. Like I said, we’ve had a lot of experience over the years in different types of these processes and love to talk to you more about how this model could be applied in the context that you’re working and help you develop a model that could be implemented anywhere. Yeah, we have been looking at cases all around the world like I said Australia, Canada, Philippines.
Right now the focus of the fund is South America because we had to obviously create a geographic focus that base is in Brazil but it doesn’t but one of the objectives of the fund is to create models that others can replicate or support others in replicating that or creating additional mechanisms to help that in other in other countries and other regions. So, definitely, just let us know when it’s good time for you to talk and we can talk extensively.
Susan:
Fantastic. I’ve I’ve copied your email and I also put my email as well as the, the website for our project called Planet Gold. Not very original, but what can I say? Just one last point also very interested in talking to you about the FPIC dimensions. Because that’s one thing we found to be quite lacking in small scale space is reasonable processes for FPIC. Of course we still need to do FPIC in a small scale space but the procedures that have been established envisioning large scale mining are really just too cumbersome for small scale.
So really working with the community of practice to try to identify a reasonable balanced approach to FPIC. So talking about that too.
Vasco van Roosmalen:
Yes, that’s excellent. And we actually worked on a lot of that on the ecos system services projects like the SUI carbon project. So how do you support a community to do that internally when they don’t have those huge resources from companies and actually it becomes you can still create very trans you obviously still can create very transparent very strong processes without having to go through some the requirements that these larger companies have to do obviously as it if it’s internal in the community and we have a number of methodologies of those including published that we can help share with you and help discuss and that’s where also the technology project that we have with Google and Google Earth outreach is very useful because it helps the community also to collect the information that they need amongst themselves to get the information they need because many times community leaders don’t have all the information that they need to have to make the proper decision.
So we usually assume that just because somebody’s a leader of a community, they have perfect information what’s going on in their community, what everybody thinks. And we know that’s not the case. But there are ways using technology and using these methodologies where you can do it in a much more streamlined process and a much less costly process, but still achieve all the transparency necessary that you need for making such a momentous decision as that.
Susan:
That’s fantastic. Thanks.
Unidentified participant:
I have a question. Are you guys working with the Alliance for Responsible Mining?
Vasco van Roosmalen:
No, we are not yet working with them. There are a couple also in industry initiatives that were in touch with. No. We very much right now the focus we have is on doing the first raise of the fund to then work as the as a fund team to expand those networks and alliances. But it certainly is worth already discussing with a number of we’re available and definitely looking for additional discussions with people who are working on these issues.
Jonah:
Great. Does anybody else have questions or campaigns to promote sometimes?
Unidentified participant:
Yes, maybe I can just like share one thing like last year Amazon watch has launched a report where we identify violations on indigenous rights on the Brazilian Amazon. One of the companies that we listed was Anglo-American because of the impacts of their activities on the on par in para the Munduruku people are now like they did an assembly on December because like I understand Vasco that maybe it’s for legal reasons why you’re not dealing with indigenous people because of the regulations and legal aspect but the fact is that they already impact in many areas and so or will impact if those projects happened without previews like consultations and risk assessments.
So we are launching today a call for action or angl with a letter signed by a articulations they call articulation but is associations of indigenous people from Brazil and the Munduruku assembly asking them to commit to one of their answers like they reply to journalists saying after we send the report for due diligence and for their appreciations that they have given up on the requirements on requests on mining indigenous land that they would not do it. They repeated that same information for our partners as that business in human rights sensor center resources resource center I’m sorry saying the same thing but there’s not a public commitment on how they would do it or a request official request to leave the Brazilian platform of the mining agency.
So we are asking for the co and anglo to start a negotiation a following a meeting but also for them to publicly announce that they will not explore indigenous lands. So just sharing that we are doing this today and if you can also share or we find ways I don’t know if you have a group where we can share materials and those documents.
Vasco van Roosmalen:
Yeah, I saw that report. I read the report. I think it was excellent. And on Anglo-American, I would definitely encourage them also to point them to the Rio Tinto case, for example, in Australia. Where the CEO lost his job because they didn’t do a good job in terms of understanding what the community wanted or they just bulldozed over it. So yeah, definitely and anything we can do to help spread to partners and in these cases, yes. So the idea of the fund is to work in these specific cases. That’s not doesn’t make it impossible to share models and to develop models for those cases that are under construction, right?
Because it is really important for us to build models where we can help these communities build the capacity that they need to be able to make those decisions and then have those decisions enforced. So the idea of the fund is to have also a team obviously the legal team in Brazil and other legal assistance available to help communities in these cases. So everything that is going to be built by the fund and also the idea of the legal teams is to work with indigenous and kilola interns, legal interns that help and accompany the process and to strengthen community professionals in these cases.
So the fund’s objective is at every one of its investments to always prioritize community strengthening. And so the model the financial model of the fund is very conservative in the sense that we expect 50% of the cases where the fund invests in the first few years of the fund to not reach a settlement so that the community ends up deciding that they don’t want to move forward and it’s because of the way that the fund is set up it still allows the fund to reach the 15% return. That’s why you have what I talked about earlier more than one case.
That’s the scale of the level of the fund allows the fund to make investments that they that the fund will know will not be returned financially. But the social impact is one of the key results of the fund on the key. So you have the environmental and social KPIs of the fund. And so one of the things that we can guarantee investors is that the social and environmental KPIs will be will be achieved. So independent if an investment ends up pay being paid back the investment to strengthen the community will have will achieve its results.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you.
Jonah:
Great everybody. I think we’re at a good stopping point unless anyone else has something.
Unidentified presenter:
Just wanted to thank you Jonah for setting this all up for inviting us to speak and everybody who’s here with us. So thank you so much.
Jonah:
You bet. Thank you so much. Thank you.
Unidentified participant:
I can’t wait for more and I will be following up through email and we’ve got a long road ahead of us. Thank you so much.
Unidentified participants — closing remarks:
Thank you. Okay. Bye, guys. Bye. Bye.