Building a Sub-National Climate Fund with an Amazon Focus

Sub-national Climate Fund Panel Discussion with David Cogut and Patrick Scheurle of Pegasus Capital, Christophe Nuttall from R20 Regions of Climate Action, and Pierre Rousseau of BNP Paribas: Today, we discuss climate-focused infrastructure investments and the Amazon. Concerned about planetary sustainability, a team of investors, non-profit,t and government institutions joined forces in 2020 to launch the Sub-national Climate Fund Global (SnCF) to finance nature-based solutions to climate change. Positioned to mobilize $750 million with seed funding from the Green Climate Fund, the group is poised to support projects in dozens of countries, including the Amazon region of South America. Learn from several partners representing a private equity group, Pegasus Capital, a bank, BNP Paribas, and an NGO focused on sub-national government action, the R20 – Regions for Climate Action, originally founded by Arnold Schwarzenegger.

Recorded February 1, 2021

 

WATCH:

  • Jonah (moderator)
  • David Cogut
  • Patrick Scheurle
  • David Albertani (R20)
  • Bobby (International Finance Corporation)
  • Christina
  • John (MXV Ventures)
  • Danielle (Conservation 4.0 Consulting)
  • Alex (GIZ Brazil)
  • Amalia
  • Mara
  • Nonette (Tenure Facility)
  • Unidentified participants

Jonah:

Hello everybody. Welcome to the 31st call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. Again, this is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing forest-friendly economic development across the Amazon region of South America. We simultaneously look at impact investing as well as the rule of law. You can’t have healthy economic development without a healthy rule of law. And healthy economic development is an essential process to avoiding deforestation. This week we’re going to be featuring the Subnational Climate Fund or SNCF Global as the acronym goes. I’m pausing to let more people into the call.

This is a fund that has been supported or derisked by the Green Climate Fund. We’re going to learn about that story. What is the Green Climate Fund? Where does it come? How does where does it come from? How does one collaborate with it? We’re going to be hearing from Patrick Scheurle of Pegasus Capital, Christophe Nuttal from R20 Regions of Climate Action, and Pierre Rousseau from BNP Paribas. Wow, this is really popular call. This is a good sign. Lots of people want to hear you guys speak. Before we kick it off, I wanted to just acknowledge that Craig Cogut and David Cogut D Craig founded Pegasus Capital.

They were going to be original presenters on this call. I believe that David has joined us and so I’d love to just let him present and Craig is unable to make it because of some family issues and COVID 19. Craig, if you’re there, do you want to just come off mute for a second and say hi and tell us a little bit about you and your dad and is everything okay?

David Cogut:

Sure. Sure. And I’ll be quick since frankly hearing from Patrick will be far more interesting than me and he’s really been spearing spearheading this and thank you Jonah. As you mentioned my grandfather looks like he is going to pass for from COVID in the next day or so. So it’s just about making him comfortable at the end. So we’ve been a little distracted, but just briefly on Pegasus, it was founded by my father, as you mentioned, Craig Kog in 1996. He had originally been one of the founding partners, of Apollo Advisors at the time, what is now Apollo Global Management, and led the deal that really put them on the map.

It was a distressed junk bond portfolio that they purchased and it was called Executive Life. Wanted to focus in the middle market still. So as Apollo got bigger left started Pegasus and really since early 2000s or 2000 has been a pioneer in the field of ESG incorporating it before it was a core term into our funds and our primary areas of focus have been sustainability is one core pillar and health and wellness is a second. So a lot of ESG tailwinds behind those sectors and we’ve deployed five funds 2.6 billion dollars invested.

I joined in 2011 or so have sort of led up our wellness initiatives and as well as supported initiatives like this. So, a lot of great deals we’ve been fortunate to be a part of in great areas and particularly excited about this fund that Patrick is heading up for us and the impact we can make and change the world for the better. It’s you know, it’s very nice when you’re passion on a personal level intersects with work and we’re fortunate enough to say we can do that. So, we’ll turn it over to far more interesting people than me, but thank you again, Jonah, and everyone for taking the time to listen about us and, looking forward to presenting.

Jonah:

David, thanks so much. And please give your dad and the rest of your family our best. So I want to go ahead and turn it over to Kristoff and Patrick and Pierre. They’re going to make a pre presentation. I also invite the three of you gentlemen to introduce yourselves and give us a little bit about your background. And I just want to appreciate how remarkable this opportunity is to bring the savvy of New York City private equity to the challenge of forest friendly economic development of the Amazon region with a coalition of extraordinary allies.

Patrick Kustaf and Pierre, the floor is yours. If you’re dialing in, star 9 takes you off mute.

Patrick Scheurle:

Excellent. Thank you so much, Shona. And let me head off briefly. So it’s really great pleasure meeting so many of you and apologies if it’s a bit dark maybe on my side. I’m in Portugal and it’s already 900 p.m. So that’s the reason behind that. But nevertheless, I’m super excited to be joining all of you today and tell you a bit more about the Subnational Climate Fund. About myself the last 10 years or basically most of my professional careers I have spent in impact investing I’ve built a asset manager called Blue Orchard.

Some of you might have heard about it. It was one of the pioneers in micro finance. We sold the firm last year to the UK asset manager Schroers. And so I’m super excited now to basically be working alongside with an investment legend or investment legends like David Cogut and Craig Cogut to embark on this on this great initiative here with the subnational climate fund. Now before I before I go into details on this on this initiative, I would like to hand over to Kristoff Nutal or perhaps David Alberttoni from the R20 Foundation who are also on the call today.

Very important partners here with us on this initiative and so over to R20.

David Albertani (R20):

Thank you Patrick. Thanks a lot and indeed I will be representing Christophal on this call. So I am David Albertani. I’m the deputy CEO of R20 and R20 is a foundation mostly known because we’ve been founded by the former governor Arnold Schwarzenegger based on his legacy in California and the role of our foundation has always been to support subnational entities identifying developing and financing their sustainable infrastructure. So we’re active in renewable energy, waste management, water management and sustainable agriculture and we’ve been working in the past seven years now in multiple geographies, multiple countries and we are very excited two years ago we started this initiative of the subnational climate finance initiative and we are very excited to have been able to partner with Pegasus Benpe Gandar and IN and with this amazing consortium, you know, we spent the last year working very hard with the green climate fund to manage, you know, to have them as anchor investor.

So, we are very happy and thanks again for inviting us for this amazing audience. Thank you a lot.

Patrick Scheurle:

Very well. And we have also prepared a small presentation which I try to share. I hope I hope you can see it and.

Patrick Scheurle / Unidentified participant — brief screen check:

You’re excellent. So this is just a.

Patrick Scheurle:

Bit to structure the discussion but we don’t need to go through the slides in great detail but it helps to hopefully visualize a bit what we are aiming to accomplish with the subnational climate fund and so maybe starting with the name of the subnational climate fund to give you a bit background right I think there is two important elements in the name one is subnational and the other one is clim climate. So, overall what we are aiming for here is really to scale up private investments in midsized climate green infrastructure projects and the history of the name is as David Alberttoni mentioned somewhat related to governor Schwarzenegger and his work in California.

So at this subnational level subnational is everything below the national level. So being at the city, being at the state level and the overall vision is really to have climate or more generally environmental initiatives in terms of commercial successfully investments materialized in a midsized range. That typically applies to the regional level like the Amazon region but also cities or states. And this is where the name subnational comes from. But it’s really it’s a commercial initiative. There is not more or less government involvement than in any other infrastructure project. But this might explain somewhat where the name comes from.

What we are doing is like a typical infrastructure investment fund. We invest in infrastructure projects. We invest in here the midsized range which is that we take tickets in the range of 5 to75 million US and we believe not only this is this is an area which has tremendous impact but we also believe it’s really an untapped opportunity from a commercial perspective because very often what you see is that investors go for the very large infrastructure projects $100 million plus or maybe more on the philanthropic side where you have very small tickets, one two million US dollar investments, but there is there is not many institutions out there covering the midsized range and we have the opportunity here to tap into these uncharted territory to some extent and the reason why we can do that is first of all we have worked on this initiative for many years.

We started with the R20 foundation to really establish the proof of concept. We have done couple of investments in Brazil for example in the Amazon region and this founding capital that we have had for the R20 foundation really has allowed us to build a great track record here that otherwise would not be available and would not have otherwise allowed to start now really with a largecale fund to do it in what I would say quite a unique way of systematically scaling our private investments in that in that space. We are investing in three areas.

One is renewable energy, the other one is waste and water and the third very important area is nature-based solutions. Nature-based solutions is for example reforestation projects, regenerative agriculture but it can also be more on the aquaculture side. So there’s a I would say a range of projects that fits into the naturebased solution space but broadly speaking we cover these three areas. We further invest in green field projects. So we really take projects from a piece of paper. So to speak up until they are realized and operational and then later on sell them on.

We all aim for a portfolio in the range of 15 to 25 projects all of them with ticket sizes in the area that I’ve mentioned up to 75 million US. We typically aim for some of the larger range in this in this 5 to75 million US dollars and we have we have a great pipeline. I will come back to that in a in a couple of minutes together with David. But there is really a lot to do in that space. Then the second point that I believe is very important and here I would say Craig is not only an investment legend he’s also a pioneer in many ways.

Something else that he has pioneered with Pegasus is that with Pegasus he is the first and only US private equity investment manager that is accreditited by the green climate fund. And in simple words, the green climate fund is basically the development bank of the United Nations for everything related to climate. The accredititation of Pegasus allowed the subnational climate fund to obtain a commitment of 150 million US in funding from the GCF. And it’s not only funding that is provided as a as kind of an anchor investment. It’s provided as a so-called first loss investment.

So that means that any potential losses in the fund up to 150 million US is covered by the green climate fund and only if there are losses beyond 150 million private investors would take a hit. And this is obviously quite a substantial drisking of the fund. And now as investors who might say yeah I’m more the type of a private equity of an upside oriented investor. You could say okay I don’t care so much about the downside protection. It’s nice to have but it doesn’t really help me. There is also a couple of elements in that first loss investment that boosts the IR of the fund to the upside and one of them is that as it works in practice when there is exits of the projects all the capital first goes back to private investors and only if private investors have received the money back then the GCF will get the money back.

So this shortens your investment period and by that just technically improves your IRO. And secondly the capital from the GCF is also concessionary. So they have an preferred return of 3%. Whereas for the private investors it’s 8%. So also that kind of concession that they make on the return side is to the benefit of the private investor. Now you might ask wonder why would a green climate fund do that and provide such concessional capital. The explanation in that is quite simply that the mandate of a development bank usually and here very specifically on the climate side with the GCF is to increase the impact and the development area of their work and basically by ma by contributing 150 million in concessionary capital it allows the green climate fund to scale up their overall initiative Here the target size of the fund is $750 million US.

So there is basically the option for private investors with an amount of up to $600 million US that they can invest and be protected by the green climate fund. And so for the green climate fund the great part of the story is out of 150 million US they can scale up to 750 million US. And for the private investors they can come in up to $600 million US and enjoy the protection of the green climate fund. So it’s really a win-win situation for both parties. Now the third element that I would like to briefly mention is that the critical element in such an initiative is of course not only that you are commercially successful with the investments but that you also deliver on the impact side that you contribute in a in a in a meaningful way to a social element and an environmental element and that you that you very carefully manage and measure not only the investment side but also the impact side of the of the business.

And in order to do that very independently and according to best practices we have partnered up here with a an foundation called gold standard. Gold standard is one of the pioneers and leaders in the carbon credit market. So very established institution and what gold standard does here they independently verify measure the impact that the fund generates. So as investors in the fund they will they will know in the end okay every CO2 ton of CO2 that we claim has been avoided by the fund every ton of rainforest that has been protected by the fund in the end investors know this is independently verified by gold standard and on every project there will be an independent support that is issued by gold standard to ensure that whatever is claimed here in terms of impact is also truly achieved.

Now before heading into some of the projects and pipeline which I think is very exciting a couple of maybe overall terms on the fund. So as I mentioned the target size 750 million US the target return net to investors is 12 to 15%. Net in US dollars. The structure is it’s a Luxembourg investment fund very established private equity hub and product structure. There is maturity 12 years quite typical for a private equity fund and where we stand now is we are just basically finalizing the paperwork with the GCF. So we are quite hopeful this will be done actually this week and then within 30 days we will get the first launch of the capital of the green climate fund and with that basically we can start investing.

So we basically expect to be in business at the beginning of March latest and can then start to execute the pipeline. Now in terms of regions and now we’re coming closer to the concrete projects that we will invest the SCF is a global fund with a very strong footprint in Latin America. It’s a bit special how you get to your investable countries when you get capital from the green climate fund. So you need to have basically the local buyin from the government that basically approves it’s okay for the green climate fund or any fund sponsored by the green climate fund to invest in a particular country.

So there has been quite a long process that Pegasus went through in order to obtain these so-called non-objection letters and overall the Pegasus obtained 42 of them. GCF told us this is a record what they have seen. So we have we have quite a big mandate here with these 42 countries. In the end as I mentioned right we were aiming for a portfolio of 15 to 25 projects. So we will not invest in all of the countries. And as you can see here from the list of countries, there’s quite a strong buyin from Latin America and the Amazon region where we also see quite a sign significant deal flow and where we are also I would say most advanced in terms of the projects that we are aiming to execute.

And of course overall we need to we need to diversify the fund across different regions. This is somewhat less relevant here. In terms of our discussion I would like to focus really now on the Amazon region and the projects that we have in the pipeline here and across the three areas. So maybe starting with agriculture naturebased solution. So as I as I hinted this can be projects in the restorative sustainable agriculture. There’s really exciting projects out there that help not only to protect rainforest but in the end be carbon negative.

So it means these projects not only they are carbon neutral but they in fact they save CO2 emissions and have a positive net contribution to the overall worldwide CO2 balance. So this is something we are quite excited to look at. There is also a number of biomass projects that we are that we are looking at here. We have very strict criteria. None of these projects can have a negative impact on the forest or more generally on the environment but also not on the local population. So there is a very strong safeguards in place.

There is a very comprehensive environmental and social management system in place and it’s even public. You can look it up on the website of the green climate fund. So with every with every project that we invest and we realize we need to ensure that there is that there are no people displaced by the project that there is no forest or any other environmental harm being done and that I think is also something which is quite unique compared to a lot of a lot of the other green or sustainable initi initiatives out there.

Then of course waste management lowcarbon waste energy projects is something that we are that we are looking into. We see a lot of interesting opportunities in the in the waste area. It’s a it’s not it’s not an easy area to invest. So it’s something where we are we are extra conscious in terms of environmental risks that are often associated with these type of projects. But if we look at the pipeline there is there is really very strong deal flow in this area of projects. And then of course what might you might be most familiar with is everything that is related to energy production, renewable energy but also on the other hand energy efficiency.

This is also an area where we see very strong deal flow here. Generally the challenge is not necessarily the deal flow or the volume or getting the projects. It’s much more to make sure that they are commercially viable and achieve the target return. The space has become quite competitive over the last the last years. So it’s also an area where we as investment managers need to be very careful in terms of our investments not only here in terms of the impact the CO2 emissions but also very much on the commercial side.

This page just basically summarizes again the structure of the fund. So you can see here this 150 million first loss piece by the green climate fund and on top of that you have the senior trunch the private investors which are protected by the 150 million US and there is a kind of a special feature I would say and I would hand over to David Alberti on that to tell you a bit more about how this part of the fund works. It’s a so-called technical assistance facility which is grant funding $28 million US which is a separate pool of capital that the green climate fund provides that helps us to support projects with feasibility studies, market studies with implementation of technologies.

So basically everything that helps a project to become successful, we can tap into an additional $28 million US to support those projects. And as I mentioned, it’s grant funded. It’s a separate pool of money. So this in addition to basically the concessional capital that GCF provided as investment capital, this capital allows first of all to support projects ensure success of the projects by that also again derisks the projects and in addition to that is potentially 28 million US dollars that otherwise would be fund expenses that are saved by the fund and again to some extent support the IR of the fund.

And with that I would like to hand over to David Albertani. We can give you some concrete examples on what we have worked on with the foundation in the past in the Amazon region but also give you a bit more meat on the bone in terms of the projects that we are currently looking at and then of course I will be more than happy to discuss with you and answer any questions you might have.

David Albertani (R20):

Thank you Patrick. So indeed I believe you know the technical assistance is very important for us and our experience in the past is that you really definitively need some you know development cost and to get this you know pipeline of bankable deals in developing countries very often you need this kind of grants to support the activity related to the creation of the pipeline. And just to mention that the GCF actually is providing 18.5 million of these 28 grant mechanism for technical assistance and we can finance any feasibility studies. So technical assessment but also very importantly we can finance environmental and social impact assessment.

A lot of project that you see out there sometimes have very good technical details. However, the environmental and impact social assessment is not up to our standard. So, this is also something we can fund with grant assistance. So, to make sure that the project inde has the best you know impact assessment. We can also I just want to quickly mention do capacity building. So we can make sure that once we find a good project and once a project has been successful we can start replicating the project make blueprint out of it and make sure that the local authorities around it are well aware and can replicate on their own this type of project and ju just to mention also this technical assistance manager the technical assistance manager sorry is that I’m pretty sure you’re very familiar with And this is also a very good guarantee for us because IUCN has been really pioneering in all those kind of nature-based solution.

And we feel that especially tackling alge geographies such as the Amazon definitively first you want to bring some positive aspect with your sustainable infrastructure but also you want to do not harm and make sure that you’re very close to biodiversity and that the impact is of course the greenhouse gas emission but the biodiversity is also a very strong impact that you want to be you want to be positive ultimately even you know when we speak about solar panels there are ways today to include nature in the design to make sure that this will have a positive impact on biodiversity and not negative.

And so having a partner such as IUCN in the consortium is really something that we’re very proud of because they are really the best and leading this kind of effort on naturebased solution on Amazon also. I just wanted to say that one of the board member of R20 and also advisor to Pegasus is Mr. Terry Taminan that you may know he has been the CEO of the Dicaprio Foundation and he has been very active in the Amazon. When they were the fire two years ago the Daprio Foundation made a huge commitment and was very active for the Amazon and Mr.

Taman was really leading this initiative and he’s currently an adviser to Pegasus and on the board of R20. So he’s really someone committed on the Amazon and thanks to his expertise we know we also have some deal flow coming to us. So, long story short, definitively Amazon, we see an extensive pipeline and as Patrick said in the in the agriculture and nature-based solution, we really see that u many municipalities and cities around the Amazon are looking for new ways to basically shift from the traditional agriculture that, you know, usually burn forest to create new land and to see how we can really create new ways to do agriculture that will have you know as high you know high yield crops but in the meantime not destroy the forest.

And if you combine that with waste management today, what we can do is really have a more circular economy when we grow fruit and vegetables, basically we eat and there is only a small part that can be commercialized. And most of the of the crop, you know, can be composted or carbonized to the biochar. And if you mix the compost and the bioshar you can really do additional project on the side of this land where you recreate new ecosystem or not new ecosystem but basically you restore destroyed ecosystem. So we are working in all those type of project and as you’ve seen for instance Brazil has signed a nonobjection letter and a lot of the Amazon is in Brazil.

So this is definitively a geography where we see a lot of momentum and definitively this is something where we will have a lot of pipeline and we’re really excited about this opportunity Patrick maybe I give it back to you.

Patrick Scheurle:

Yeah fantastic and yeah Jono and to all the viewers I would really like to open the floor for questions. I’ I’ve seen that we have also signed for Saison who is the lead investor on the fund. So I was hoping he can make it and so it’s great to have him on. So we can also really go into the technical details of deal structuring etc. But over to you Jonah and everyone who has a question.

Jonah:

Great. As we move into questions I encourage people to indicate their interest by posting them in the chat area. Just saying you’re interested or you can even post a question or you can raise your hand using that function. So I just have a couple of questions I’m going to bundle together to get us started. One is indigenous communities. Is there a strategy for engaging them? Second, how can people engage the people on this call, the broader public? Another could you guys share an email address for people who want to follow up?

Another is what’s the future website address of the of the subnational climate fund? And then three other quick ones. What Amazon countries are you guys active in already? What investors already in the pipeline? And what investment opportunities are in the pipeline? It’s a lot of questions. Feel free to just answer one or two or one word on each.

Patrick Scheurle:

I just noted them down so I don’t forget any of them. So maybe on the indigenous communities I think it’s an excellent question and something that is very important for the mandate to basically really have all safeguards in place first of all not harming anyone and ideally also involving and engaging them and I think in particular with the subnational climate fund and subnational is really it goes down to the to the to the individual communities that we want to support with that fund and I would like to hand over the question more to David Alberttoni as well because he has been working on a on a number of projects across the globe with exactly local communities and has a lot of experience in that area.

David Albertani (R20):

Yes, thank you Patrick. So especially for indigenous communities we have a very strong framework. So one is of course the one from the IFC with the performance standard which you know to be honest is not the strongest but with regard to the green climate fund and our very strict environmental and social management system we respect the IFC performance system but on top of that we have Gundar who has a very specific framework for indigenous people. So this is also mandatory for the fund with respect to our environmental social management system.

And the third point maybe which is also very important is that there is mandatory stakeholder engagement meetings that we do on the ground and this is something that for instance is paid by the technical assistance that we mentioned prior. So within the budget of the technical assistance, we always do stakeholder engagement meeting and we have to do a specific stakeholder engagement meeting with the indigenous communities and if there is any harm towards indigenous communities that have been raised the our environmental social management system automatically exclude the this type of investment.

So as soon as we trigger the IFC performance standard of indigenous people the investment become excluded of the universe. So here we have a very strong firewall for the do not harm but additionally of course we want to be more on the positive side and to empower them.

Patrick Scheurle:

Excellent. Then maybe I capture briefly the question on the investor side. So we’re working here with BMP parib in a in a partnership with different activities. One of their role here is also to act as the distributor and the placement agent of the of the fund. So we are we are reaching out basically since the beginning of this year to private investors. We already got the commitment to 150 million from the green climate fund. On the private investor side, we are talking to generally professional investors. So these are professionally organized family offices up until of course pension funds, insurance companies and so on.

So really the professional the professional investors or investors who have a professional setup who want to make a difference in the world. I think the mindset is very important here. So it’s absolutely key that we have investors in the fund that do not try to greenwash in or try to greenwash with their investments. So beyond just having good partners in terms of the amount that they can invest etc that they understand what we do it’s also important for us to have like-minded investors here who want to make a difference in the in the world and on the questions regarding countries and what is currently in the investment pipeline maybe Simon if you have the possibility to speak would be great to hear a few sentences from Sure.

Hi everyone, this is Simon Foresight here and very pleased to have all of your interest in the fund today. I would say in terms of countries specifically, we would highlight Brazil and Ecuador today as being countries that we have the letters from for their interest. We are actively seeing investment projects in other Amazon bordering countries. Peru and Surinm come to mind and there’s a potential for the future that these will be added to our mandate and so you know I don’t think I’m allowed to promise that to you but that’s things that we’re working on.

In terms of the pipeline I think Patrick covered at a high level and we’re not able to give you know specific company names at this point but we are seeing a.

Unidentified participant:

A great pipeline so far. They cover the primary subsectors that we consider being in energy in renewables as well as in efficiency projects. In waste there’s a number of forms sometimes purely waste management but often with an energy component and I think we’re excited to see of course in this context nature-based solutions as well. Globally it’s not always easy to define the category and certainly in the Amazon region it if I can say it takes on even more increased prominence and so it’s great to see things like agroforestry and that sort of thing that may protect the region while still allowing activities to take place.

Jonah:

We’ve got seven questions for you guys. So I’m going to take two at a time and I encourage all question folks to be real fast. So Bobby Kia from the International Finance Corporation and Christina Varelli from SOS Finino. Bobby, you go first. We’ll ask the questions back to back and then you guys can respond. Go ahead, Bobby.

Bobby (International Finance Corporation):

Thanks. So thanks so much Jenna. Just briefly about the currency potential you know volatility going forward. Have you guys worked with TCX or have you as is BNP thinking of that or how are you thinking about the net US return projections?

Jonah:

Chris, thank you.

Christina:

Yeah. So I realize that Venezuela is regarded as a very difficult country to work in and it is it is an Amazonian country and but as a Venezuelan working in Venezuelan and starting to you know do small projects in agroforestry and with the indigenous community, is there any interest at all from any of these investors in Venezuela?

Patrick Scheurle:

Great questions. Thank you. Regarding Venezuela, to start with that question, it is unfortunately not one of the countries that we can invest with the fund. I think it’s of course a shame in one way because Venezuela would be one of the countries that of course would have the most need for investments. But unfortunately it’s not a country that we have a nonobjection letter and the investment environment I think it is it is very challenging in Venezuela on unfortunately on the current currency hedging side. I’ve worked very much with the TCX in the in the past.

I think it’s a great initiative to have it to have it available. Here since we are investing in green field equity projects the currency hedging is typically quite difficult because you don’t know exactly when you’re going to exit what are the exit proceeds etc. So there is quite a bit uncertainty around that. So we are not ruling out that we do currency hedging depending on the currency and the situation at the time of the investment. What we what we certainly do for all investments is that we take the currency risk into account and when we when we start the modeling on any of the projects we basically incorporate a certain depreciation in most cases it is a depreciation against the against the US dollars that we take into account and so the net 12 to 15% US dollar return that we aim for here is after taking into account a certain currency depreciate depreciation.

Jonah:

Great. Thanks for that. Next up, John and Danielle. When you guys asked your question, also please name your institutional affiliation. Go ahead, John Misner.

John (MXV Ventures):

Thanks, J. Yeah. Hi, this is John Meisner from MXV Ventures. I had a question about the grant funding that you mentioned. You talked about I think it was 28 million available. Was part of that from GCF and part of it from IUCN itself? Maybe talk a little bit about the sources of that. Is any of it government funding for example? Thank you.

Jonah:

Go ahead Danielle.

Danielle (Conservation 4.0 Consulting):

Hi there Danielle Rapaort, Conservation 4.0 Consulting and I’ll be working with Jonah on the Amazon Investor Coalition. My question is can you can you speak a little bit more about any trends that you’ve observed in terms of investor appetite across those three subsectors and whether there’s one that is harder to sell to investors in terms of risk and reward.

Patrick Scheurle:

Yeah, sure. David, would you like to take the question on the grant funding?

David Cogut:

Sure. Sure. So on the grant funding so the technical assistance indeed the total size is $ 28 million US we already secured $18.5 from the green climate fund there is three millions coming from IUCN and that is coming from national government but for the naturebased facility of IUCN and we are fundraising for the for the extra for the one left and within the prospect indeed we have European governments with who are targeted.

Unidentified participants — brief exchange:

And on okay on the sorry go ahead Patrick.

Patrick Scheurle:

On the second question in terms of trends and the three areas so all three areas have their of course very exciting parts they have their they have their challenges renewable energy, energy efficiency I would say overall is the most established of the three areas. Here the upshot is there is a there is a lot of volume there. There is very established and proven technologies. The challenge that comes with that is more on the commercial side that it’s very competitive. Returns often are not great. So you have to be very selective in terms of the projects that you go in here in the waste space there.

I think we see a lot of great opportunities from a commercial perspective but the environmental and social safeguards are extremely challenging that you need to be very careful to look at and where I where I would say in terms of the most dynamics from a trend perspective I think they are in the in the naturebased solutions area and nature-based solutions It’s a it’s quite a wide and somewhat unspecific term that goes from shrimp farms to regener regenerative agriculture to reforestation projects to agriculture projects etc. So it’s a wide a wide space in that sense but I see a lot of innovation in that in that space.

I see a lot of investment opportunities that come along in the in the in the naturebased solutions area. The challenge that comes with that is it’s often highly in innovative stuff which is great and exciting. But from a from a commercial perspective of course you would like to see something that is that is established has a track record that is proven. So these are a bit the challenges that we see in that space but it’s great the variety and the opportunities that come from that side.

Jonah:

Great we have about 11 minutes left so we’ll move a little quickly. Next up Alex and Amalia please go ahead and say your institutional affiliation right before you ask your question. Alex.

Alex (GIZ Brazil):

Okay. Hi Jonah. Hi Patrick. This is Alexander Rose from GZ Brazil. I’m from the forest program and I work with sustainable use of the Amazon forest. I have a question specifically for the smart agriculture and nature-based solution solutions you’re financing in Brazil. Considering that there are not that many companies in Brazil that could really take on a loan or credit of that size you’re operating and the few companies that can do it, they usually have access to lowcarbon agriculture credits from state banks that are usually cheaper and subsidized. When you take the public side according to the Brazilian law of responsibility, fiscal responsibility, they basically already in that and it has to go through Senate.

It takes a long time. So how do you make yourself competitive in Brazil for Amazon investment on naturebased solutions? Can you can you tell me something on that in that respect?

Patrick Scheurle:

Yeah, absolutely. And.

Jonah:

Let’s just let Amalia ask her questions as well and then you’ll take both questions at the same time. Go ahead Amalia.

Amalia:

Hi, I am Alia Sza from Kaza Sosa Environmental Fund. We are a small grants small medium size grant from in Brazil and we fund a lot in the Amazon. I’m just curious u who are you who you are working with here? What kinds of organizations what kind of knowledge are you tapping into that actually make your investment solid and strong? I hadn’t heard of your initiative before and I’ve checked with a few of the NOS’s at least which is our area that haven’t either. So I’m just wondering if it’s how that plays off.

How do you see the real population of the Amazon, not just Brazil, but across the border actually benefiting?

Jonah / Patrick Scheurle — boundary unclear:

Great. Thanks. Go ahead, Patrick. Yeah. And so in terms of the partners I unfortunately I cannot disclose some of them that we working with and where we are under on the NDA. What I can say is certainly that two important partners that we’re working on the foundation side is R20 and IUCN which are which are both part of the consortium and of course the networks of R20 and IUCN and so there’s a lot of environmental nonprofit organizations that partner with IUCN and through our relationship with IUCN we also partner with them on the ground and then there is of course on the commercial side there is there is project developers which are more private and commercial oriented in nature but those I’m unfortunately not allowed to disclose at this stage but I’m very happy that we have such a strong network with R20 with IOC with our local partners that we also see such a strong deal flow in Amazon in the Amazon area and in particular in Brazil, I would I would say.

And in terms of the benefit for the Amazon population, which is of course at the front and center of every of every investment that we do is the local the local community. And we have we have seen really bad cases in the past where you had a large scale renewable energy power plant next to a small village and no one in the village had access to energy. And at the same time, these large-scale power plants could not feed into the national grid because the national grid was totally overwhelmed already and could not take in the basically the energy that was supposed to be produced with the these projects.

So this is also why we take a very community oriented approach here. So we want to make sure that the energy that is produced through our renewable clean power plants that they of course they deliver affordable clean energy to the population in the area that whatever we whatever projects that we realize that they create jobs on the ground for the for the population that are training programs for the local communities and so it’s really a multi-dimensional approach that we take here that ensures that it’s not only one element that we take into account that we want to achieve but really comprehensively benefits the local population that is living in and around these projects that we realize.

And briefly on the question regarding how do we make ourselves competitive. Of course this is something we work very hard on every day and one element I believe we do have a very strong edge here is that we are a green field equity investor. So we are not we are not a loan or a debt provider. We realize projects that we are part of from the very first day that we help to bring to invest to investability through the grant funding that we have. There is not many funds out there that have grant funding available to sponsor feasibility studies and so on.

So we have a very strong package and with our great partners on the ground also a unique network that brings project opportunities to us.

Jonah:

Great. We have just a few minutes left in the call. The Zoom room will stay open past the top of the hour. So I encourage you guys from Subnational Climate Fund to stay on. More people will have questions. So let’s go ahead and hear backtoback from the representative of Self Ventures and then Nette.

Mara:

Hi there. Thank you. I’m my name is Mara. I work for Sentinest. We manage the N green fund which actually has a of similar investment targets of sustainable land use very much focused on Brazil. And I was just wondering about your impact targets. I heard CO2 sequestered and hectares of forest protected I believe but if you could elaborate a little bit more what your main impact targets are how they are defined.

Jonah:

And Nette.

Nonette (Tenure Facility):

Thank you I am cons I am looking at the areas of land where you are locating your projects the interest being that indigenous peoples who have secured tenure and are owners of that land could likely be if you look at the standards and the safeguards partners and invest co-investors. So my question is that made possible in the if they are indeed taking the hat of being an investor in this whole initiative will you partner with them? So, I’m curious. I asked earlier, did you were there are there matches in the countries that you have non-objection letters from countries?

Who are those and are they matching with indigenous peoples that can actually carry as partners in this investment.

Jonah:

And no networks with the tenure facility?

Nonette (Tenure Facility):

I work with the tenure facility and we are investing in grants that secure tenure in territories and we’re realizing there’s a lot in the in the Amazon area. Yeah,.

Jonah:

Go ahead Patrick.

Patrick Scheurle:

Thanks for the questions and maybe starting with the second one. We are we are very open to local partners who want to co-invest with us in projects. That’s I think that’s again some something that is to the benefit of the projects that is to the benefit of the fund. We typically aim for majority stakes in the in the in the projects just for also efficiency reasons but be beyond that we are we are very open for having local partners investing with us. It can be local communities it can be of course local developers it can be other parties on a case- by case basis if it’s to the benefit of the community or the project we also fine to take a minority stake on an exceptional basis so here we are just hit us up and we are of course very happy to discuss that.

David Albertani (R20):

And Patrick if I can just add one word also on that within the technical assistance as I mentioned before part of it is dedicated for capacity building and one of the targets of the capacity building is to target potential local entrepreneur investors communities so to have this capacity building element so that we can explain them how to invest in the equity structure the deal with them so the technical assistance has a grand component to make sure that we can include them and we have a sufficient capacity so that we can co-create this project with them.

So the technical assistance can support this process actually.

Patrick Scheurle:

Very well. And on the impact target so since it’s a climate fund, the overarching target is to avoid 82,000 tons of CO2 emissions with the projects that we will realize with the fund. But beyond that we have we have additional impact targets metrics on a project by project case. So it can for a water treatment project it will be very different to a reforestation project. So this will be very individual on a project level. It always comes with two metrics or dimensions. One is always a safeguarding dimension and one is a one is a target that we want to achieve and this again is also in each of the cases independently ensured and verified by gold standard.

Jonah:

Great we have reached the top of the hour. This is what I usually call water cooler time where classes dismiss so to speak and most of the people leave the call but I’m going to stay around. I’m going to leave the room open in the chat room and generally there’s ongoing unstructured conversations. This is where we cover questions that weren’t able to be covered otherwise. You guys from the subnational climate found are certainly welcome to stay around or you’re you’re welcome to go. Thanks you so much for sharing your email addresses.

Thank you so much.

Unidentified presenter:

Well, it was great pleasure. Thank you all so much. A fantastic session here. I left my email address there. You will find us at pecalp.com. Hit me up on LinkedIn. I’ll be happy to connect and I will stay around a couple of more minutes. So if you have any more questions, happy to take them. Anybody’s welcome to come off the microphone and ask or introduce yourself. This is that moment in like a radio show where the announcer says, “Okay, and our first call is.

Jonah:

Amalia, you came off microphone. Do you want to ask some questions?”.

Amalia:

I guess I hit You’re still recording though.

Jonah:

Oh, yes. Okay, I can stop the recording so we can go into confidential questions.