An Inter-Governmental Reforestation Alliance for Latin America
Walter Vergara: In 2014, in Lima, Peru, at COP 20, the Conference of Parties of the 20th United Nations Climate Change Conference, 17 Latin American countries joined forces and created Initiative 20×20 to advance ecosystem restoration and conservation. Today, over 70 technical partners and impact investors have pledged to invest $2.5 billion across the region. Join the 20×20 secretariat, led by Walter Vergara, to learn their story, their strategies, and what it means for the Amazon.
Recorded July 27, 2020
WATCH:
Participants
- Walter Vergara — Initiative 20×20.
- Amalia — addressed by name before her contribution.
- Atossa — introduces herself by first name.
- Anka — introduced by first name; represents a foundation whose name is unclear in the captions.
- Daniel — Earth Innovation Institute; introduced by first name.
- Unidentified moderator and other participants, including a GCF representative.
Transcript
Moderator:
Okay. The call is now being recorded. So, the question is, what information would you like to see reported on a call like this each week or what information does your institution gather that you would like to report on each week? Go ahead, Amalia.
Amalia:
>> All right. So we have been on the front lines of delivering resources to grassroots communities throughout South America for 15 years at least. There’s a much bigger longer history before that. Right now, since Bolsonaro took office, the emergencies, the fires, we were set up to respond to the grassroots and design our delivery mechanism to actually respond in real time as fast as possible. So we have a very different design in a philanthropic structure than most, the more conventional structures that you have a lot of the decision at the top.
We do it the other way around. And because of that, we our demands we get from the grassroots are immense. And because we are set up that way, we were able to respond extremely fast when the fires started last year, delivering resources to defenders on the ground. Of course to do that, we had to use our immense, really rooted network. There’s a lot of learning. We had a huge learning curve to develop to deliver resources to the end of the spectrum, to get people who were in real danger really fast.
So we have a lot of a lot of that we could be sharing. Of course, there’s a lot of stuff there that I that we could that I think we must actually share. And then now with the COVID of course because we were already on the ground, the demand was very big. We were able to reorganize some of our committed resources from funders, local and international. We were able to raise additional funds and we were able to deliver also really fast over 200 grants in a [wording unclear], opening the call just to the Amazon and the Northeast because those were the hardest hit in the beginning and they still are of course but there are many populations.
We had 530 requests. We only had money to fund 130. We were now able to fundraise. We delivered around $450,000 really quick in 40 days. We had the call. We did the evaluation, the selection. We have very efficient mechanisms to get to this that are very transparent. So all of these things could be extremely I think useful and right now because the problem is increasing it’s not decreasing by any means and now we’re expecting new fires. So we’re going to have another level of emergency on top of COVID. Anyway, what I’m seeing, beyond that, that I think we could actually dig in because there’s a lot of learning is two main things.
One: some of the funds committed. The fastest to respond in terms of funders were international and more human rights funders. We have committed and in our account funds from large conservation foundations. They have not allowed the groups selected to use resources to adapt and deal with the COVID. They haven’t permitted the groups to actually reorganize their proposal. It’s a lot of money sitting in the bank account except of course those for that reason and also for the reason that some—they’re all for indigenous groups in the Amazon over almost 50 of them, at least 29, have gone into complete isolation, no communication.
They don’t want to come to town to sign bank documents so the money is going to be waiting for them when they are ready. But the problem for us was how in the world a funder that has the means cannot allow an indigenous community hit severely by this situation not to use the money to save their lives. It makes no sense. So this is a big one. The other one is Brazilians, and that’s the last point. Brazilian funders wealth, Brazilian wealth. We hear that there has been million billions, right, raised, like six billion reais or something.
90% of that money went to the health system. It’s not going directly to communities that are hit. The funders, the local funders responding are the ones that I just introduced you to but the network the Brazilian network Brazilian philanthropy network for social justice. >> It’s us and it’s the human rights funders. It’s the racial equity fund. It’s the community foundations on the ground. It’s the HIV fund there. So we were set up to make grants all of us in the last 20 years and we are making grants and of course and luckily we have been able to but none of the Brazilian money has gone to the ground or to us to deliver to the ground and you know all of us are here just to make grants and that really is to me is pretty shocking.
We have talked to some young, wealthy Brazilians but they wanted to know about Rainforest Foundation and their emergency fund over there. There has not been one cent coming from Brazilian wealth to deliver to the ground to the people who are the most hit. So I think these are two extremely important issues. If we’re serious about this, there’s got to be a way to I don’t know, maybe connections, people who can talk to people, but there’s got to be something we can do because there is money. It’s just not going where it needs to go because of whatever, you know, visions of the world that are not compatible with the emergencies that we’re seeing.
Luckily, we have just we just raised another $400,000 for the next stage of the emergency. We’re very quick as well. All from human rights funders abroad. But luckily we are able to continue delivering to the emergency. But the summary is what else you know how do we really get local money and how do we get conservation funders to rethink their posture?
Moderator:
So I’m hearing a couple of things. One is money that’s stuck and opportunities to challenge and help advance philanthropic accountability. Another thing that I’m hearing is a report from the front lines, which I think is important for all of us to [wording unclear], and also a little bit of a call to action. I think those are good things that we can hear from a routine basis as a report on a weekly call. Are there other things that people would like to see reported on a weekly call?
Unidentified participant — GCF:
>> I’ll jump in here real quickly. Going from what Maria Amalia was talking about, there’s so much need and then there’s this gap with the donors. And in the past two weeks, I’ve gotten or past week actually—I’ve gotten three or four proposals from indigenous communities that are on the front lines of COVID connecting COVID response, forest conservation, livelihood development, personal protection stuff, you know, everything. And the GCF does not, we don’t make grants. And I am in a position where I’m trying to figure out how do I connect this great need, this very big a lot [description unclear] of what’s going on the front lines that Amalia was talking about with potential donors.
And I have some lists and I can try and work through my personal contacts, but there does seem to be this need for connection that Amalia just mentioned. And I’m not sure exactly what that would be, but how do we map that out? How do we map out the information that we’re getting that’s really good and trustworthy and verifiable and communities that are dying with this money that’s stuck out there and do it in an efficient way and I hear Amalia’s frustration that existing grants can’t be redirected but we don’t have a lot of time to mess around here so whether it’s connecting folks some type of campaign some type of information sharing.
It’s hard to articulate, but I know we’re just kind of brainstorming right now, Jonah. And that’s that’s one of the things that we often get is the needs and the different communities that have these needs, but we’re not sure how to connect them with resources.
Moderator:
>> So, in response to that, and by the way, I’ve tried to put everybody on mute just to so if you’re on the phone, I think you have to dial star 9 or something to come off mute. And then if you’re on Zoom, you can just do it yourself. The there are two groups that I’ve heard of that have used a little bit of a celebrity appeal to help bundle money to help in this COVID moment. One is [initiative name unclear], and the other one is the Amazon Emergency Fund. Have any of you been involved in structuring those?
Unidentified participant:
>> Yes. Yes, we have been. Very involved with the Amazon emergency fund from the start but that’s an effort to raise money and there was a live and it was pretty well nice but they didn’t raise a lot of money. Most of the money so far—well, finally, we just received [phrase unclear]. The Rainforest foundation is managing the money that’s coming from that from the efforts to raise the French government just gave $2 million to the fund. And it’s already there and most of money will be going to [federation acronym unclear] groups.
Mostly, so far so far all the money has been going to the national federations involved with [federation acronym unclear]. There’s been a discussion that’s going on right now, and the agreement is that it will go beyond [federation acronym unclear] when there is enough money to share. But the expectation to raise $5 million by the beginning of July didn’t really happen. They think that they might do a push for other governments European governments to follow the French. But there are some details that need to be worked out. So the other one, I’m not involved.
I know that the Rainforest Foundation also did another live mostly to try to fund raise for their partners in different parts of the world including Brazil that also didn’t really raise a lot of money, but some. I think they’re dealing with it. The other. Initiative, I don’t know, but I know and we are supporting in several ways, is that Indigenous peoples, indigenous tribes are doing their own fundraising campaigns like the Munduruku and we’re trying to connect funders to them directly. We’ve been working with them for a long time, and usually they want us to receive the funds because it’s easier for them to manage.
So we do that too, whatever it takes. There’s a number of other tribes directly raising and doing their own campaign. The one that you mentioned, Amazon Viva, I don’t really remember now.
Moderator:
Okay. There since we’ve started this conversation there have been a few people who have joined. So I want to just pose the question one more and then I want to allow a couple of people who are new to the call to introduce themselves and then I want I think it would be great if we could hear from Walter. So the question for those of you who are new to the call is this is a weekly call and what are some of the things that you would like to see reported out on this weekly call?
Some of the suggestions have been for example new grants that have been made in the context or investments that have been made in the context of Amazon conservation. Another one is reports from the front lines about what’s going on with COVID. Does anyone else have another suggestion of something that can be reported out weekly on these calls and that would be useful to the group? And if you’re on if you’re on the go ahead, someone had a suggestion.
Atossa:
Hi, everybody. This is Atossa. Sorry I’m a little late. I missed the beginning. I don’t know if this has already been mentioned. There’s been some, you know, obviously the stats on what’s going on with COVID. There’s a map that’s being put out by [organization acronym unclear] Latin America. [Organization acronym unclear] has an atlas on Amazon COVID cases. I’ll look for the link and put it here, but just how fast it’s growing and what where the affected areas are. Also I think that there are a couple of listservs that are going around perhaps.
I’m not sure if you’re creating another one here or a couple of pan-Amazon listservs that have been created. Those have been great venues for sharing news and updates. One of the updates that I’m excited about is that last week after four or five years of campaigning by the [nation name unclear] and the [nation name unclear] Nation in Peru, company GeoPark and also a lot of shareholder pressure from Amazon Watch and other organizations, GeoPark decided to leave the oil block 64 in a pristine part of the Peruvian Amazon. So that was a very big exciting development.
It affects other oil projects in that region and it sends investors a message that with oil prices low, marginal reserves, banks pulling out of financing extractives in these areas and opposition by communities these kinds of projects just aren’t going to be viable going forward, which is good news for us.
Moderator:
Great, thanks for that.
Unidentified participant:
I wanted to suggest. Yes, okay. I think a good type of report would be reports from like the governments in different countries or maybe state level governments. I’ve been in contact actually with GCF in Brazil like a speaker in one of their events and they’re like very organized secretaries of state in Brazil, and governors. They are making a good effort regarding Amazon despite of the federal level of government here. There would be interesting like reports from different like countries regarding Amazon governance and also state level or if it if it if it makes sense municipality level, regarding the Amazon, just to understand how the scenario is.
Moderator:
>> Okay, great. Thank you for that. So I’d like to move into a couple of introductions. I think most people on the call have introduced themselves. Anka, I think you might be new to the call. Would you be willing to introduce yourself?
Anka:
>> Yeah. Hi everyone. I’m here on behalf of [name unclear], the executive director from [foundation name unclear]. Unfortunately, she is in another call and couldn’t join. But [foundation name unclear] is not directly investing in the Amazon region because we understand that there is lots of funding going on already in the region and we had already some projects that we that we supported in the region. But our focus is mainly looking more into Atlantic Forest and the pine forest we have in the south. But still Amazon is within our interest as well and what we are mainly interested in is to know much more about businesses that are being developed in the region like impact businesses and that also have some positive impact like social and also in conservation.
So we are also working on—we launched last year a network for investors and investors network in order to bring the topic conservation closer to these people and to show them that yes there is a possibility to promote conservation and to make a business out of conservation. So now we have also many talks and discussions within this group. It’s already about 70 members in this network. Already. And obviously it would be quite interesting for us to have access to these kind of businesses that we have in several regions in Brazil including the Amazon region.
So that we can connect those businesses to potential investors, for example.
Moderator:
>> Yeah. >> What is the name of the network you created?
Anka:
We call it [network name unclear]. It’s more like [wording unclear], but that brings conservation and conservation of biodiversity closer into their reality. But I can send you more information on it. So later.
Moderator:
>> does it have a website?
Anka:
>> not yet. So it’s something pretty new that we launched like November or December last year. And but we have a monthly newsletter, but no website yet. But I can send you some more information on that. So maybe we can exchange some ideas as well.
Moderator:
That sounds great. Yeah. Okay. Is there anyone else who has not introduced themselves yet on the call who would like to who for whom it might be a first time call? Okay. Walter, if you’re there, it would be great if you could give us a five-minute presentation about, your work on the, initiative 20×20.
Walter Vergara:
>> Thank you, Jonah. First, I want to say hello to Dr. [name unclear], who I haven’t spoken to for a while. It’s great to see him here. Also hello to [name unclear] from [fund name unclear], one of the impact funds working with us in Initiative 20×20. Initiative 20×20 is a regional effort in Latin America led by 17 countries. The objective is to change the dynamics of land degradation in the region. It had a short-term goal of promoting the restoration, initiating the restoration of 20 million hectares by 2020. The initiative has three activities: a political dimension, technical analysis, and investment by private impact investors.
On the political dialogue, The initiative has a very healthy and active network of ministers of environment and agriculture. Sometimes other ministries discussing the issues of restoration. We meet once a year. We used to meet once a year. We don’t know what’s going to happen in the future. Last meeting was in Buenos Aires. [Number unclear] ministers came as well as 200 participants from our network of technical partners and private impact investors. The objective of that first activity is to advance policy and regulatory issues, address obstacles, address barriers and promote a healthy policy environment for investment in [clears throat] restoration.
The second activity is a technical effort. We’re sponsoring nine analytical studies. Some of them have already been published as I mentioned some time ago to Jonah. We initiated with an assessment of what is the economic argument for land restoration. The objective was to answer the question why should the nation be interested in land restoration? Why would private investors care about it? It was published in 2018. Since then we have published reports on the policy environment for restoration. Germplasm, or the supply of vegetative material to promote restoration. We are working on reports on carbon markets, biodiversity, and incentives for restoration.
Other studies as well as are in the process of being prepared. The third activity is the most important and is the promotion of private impact investment in restoration. And I must say here that investment in restoration under the Initiative 20×20 has five windows: reforestation; avoided deforestation, which is conservation; landscape management; silvopasture and agroforestry; grassland restoration; and low-carbon agriculture. Most of the investments so far have been in agroforestry and reforestation. So the third activity is this network of impact investors. 5 billion. So far, 190 projects have been initiated on [number missing] million hectares of land.
In December—and with this I finish—in December of 2019, at COP25, ministers from the region led by the president of the COP, Carolina Schmidt, launched the second stage of the initiative with a goal to initiate restoration on 50 million hectares of land by 2030. We are right now at 25, so 25 more. But more importantly to get 30 million hectares of land-based climate actions in the NDCs, the nationally determined contributions to the Paris Agreement, and finally the minister has outlined a vision to 2050 to reach 250 million hectares under intervention and that’s a scale that would basically eliminate the carbon footprint if things go as they are going right now eliminate or reduce greatly the carbon footprint of the region by that time.
Our website is [website address unclear]. We have about 80 partner institutions, technical partner institutions, 17 governments as I said and now 23 impact investors. Very happy to address any questions.
Moderator:
I have one question. 5 billion pledged so far and of the 190 projects, how many of them are in the Amazon legal biome?
Walter Vergara:
A [fraction unclear]. I should have brought that here with me, but there are projects in a number of states in the Amazon. I can mention Rondônia, Amazonas, and [state name unclear]. There are projects that have started in other states and have expansion plans. Remember we are seeking to change the dynamics of land restoration along five routes. So it’s not just reforestation, but also conservation, conservation of biomes, conservation of forest. And in that regard I think one of the allies of this network that you are leading Jonah should be [organization name unclear], probably one of the most successful efforts in forest conservation in the planet.
Moderator:
>> Great. I’m going to ask you for an introduction to [organization name unclear]. I’ve tried to reach out to them haven’t had success yet. Does anyone else have questions for Walter? I can follow up with other questions. Walter, this is something that we spoke about on the phone. If most of the investors that are coming in are making multi-million-dollar commitments, can you talk about the how useful it would be for like a family office investor who’s making $100,000 commitments? How could they find the network to be useful? How could you benefit from their partnership?
Walter Vergara:
>> Oh yes. In fact conversations have started with network of family investors in Colombia that is being organized right now. I think that type of say involvement of philanthropy- impact investment hybrid would be very much welcome. There are a number of activities that require philanthropic action at the outset. So that would be very good. I think that’s one of the future directions that we should explore. If I may, I would like to get information on Emergent. Ruben’s team contacted us at COP25, but we it was not continued for some reason.
We didn’t follow up. So, I am taking advantage of this network to reach back to Ruben and try to reconnect with him. [clears throat]. And I also would love to hear from others, in particular from Dr. [name unclear], on how are his activities in Brazil coming along.
Moderator:
>> Go ahead. Ruben and Daniel and anyone else?
Unidentified participant:
>> Oh, I actually had a question. I mean I’ll follow later with a one-on-one to restart the conversation, but my question was about actually private investors. How do they connect to this initiative? And is there a mechanism?
Walter Vergara:
>> Yes, it’s a very simple mechanism. Of course it has to come from them. We are not seeking out people in the open. We might [wording unclear], but it has to come from the impact investor and it has to meet three conditions. They’re very simple. One is very stringent, very strict social and environmental safeguards. We’re talking about people who are not just looking for a financial return but also an environmental and social return. So that’s condition number one. Number two is that they have a niche a business niche that they want to explore within the five windows of the initiative.
We are not covering the entire universe but I think it’s pretty much open. If this impact fund is working on reforestation, we would welcome initiating discussions with them. And third, we want to hear from them. So the first one is the safeguards, the second the business plan, the business model. And the third is they need to offer us a goal, a financial goal. It is not a legal commitment. Is not a legal paperwork, but it’s a goal, an intention from this fellow from this group that they would invest so much money by what date in one of the five windows or all the windows.
So it’s very simple. The last. Group that joined last week is the [fund name unclear]. It works in Central America. It works on. Restoration for adaptation to climate impact purposes. It has an initial fund of $30 million. It only works in a few countries in Central America. So that’s a typical example. The smallest fund is a $15 million fund, the Forest and Climate Change Fund of Luxembourg. The largest is the [fund name unclear] which has $500 million for investment in Latin America.
Moderator:
Can you tell us about Terra Match?
Walter Vergara:
Oh yes. TerraMatch is a relatively new effort. We recognize that multi-million dollar investments while they are required to reach the scale of the solution to address the climate and land-use problems in Latin America, do not cover the entire universe. There are many cases where the investments are much smaller, $1 million or less and the TerraMatch has been designed to address that niche. It basically is a platform that if once it is in operation seeks an efficient way of communication between small investment projects and investors that are interested in smaller projects or companies that would like to promote a particular line of action.
It is not directly tied to Initiative 20×20, but it’s an instrument, a parallel instrument that would help advance similar goals.
Moderator:
>> Great. Any other questions for Walter?
Unidentified participant:
I have one quick one, Jonah. ”] hello, Walter. [Name unclear]. It’s been a couple years since I saw you at the initiative 20 by 20 and just for background we are a technical partner but haven’t had that much interaction lately. So would like to pick that up and hear from and we can actually join the biodiversity subgroup as well the working group. I think we were on best practices. The one question I had for you was you know when the news of the fire spread last summer, it caused such an amount of attention for the world to focus just for a very short time really on the Amazon and a lot of people understood you know outsized role it plays in the climate equation.
But one of the things I noticed right after was that a lot of people were talking about doing reforestation and you use the word restoration. We were using the word regeneration. I don’t like using reforestation because you cannot reforest a tropical rainforest a complex ecosystem like that cannot be a plantation, right? How have you seen a change as you know a lot of those schemes came up not many of them really were implemented and I was just curious what you’re seeing on that trajectory. And you know there were so many I lost count and they were always in the sort of hundreds of millions to billions of trees and trillions of trees but my question always was: who’s doing the planting?
Where’s the planting? How is it being done? What is being planted? Are there any plans for what’s going to happen, not just at day one, but at month two, or a year or two? Was it really you know if you don’t know about climate, local climate, soil, number of things it’s not going to work in a tropical forest, right? It’s very complex and I have just wondered I’ve been wanting to actually reach out to you, so I’m taking advantage that you’re here to ask you what do you think has happened in just educating where everybody is?
[Question ending unclear].
Walter Vergara:
>> it’s a very complex question.
Unidentified participant:
>> I know I know [laughter].
Walter Vergara:
>> it requires a long answer but I will not do that. I will point out to a couple of developments. First under the analytical activity of the initiative we started an analysis of fires, restoration and fires, the role of restoration in fires. You’re absolutely right, we changed the topic to landscape restoration as a response to fires. There is a famous scientist in Portugal who says that the equilibrium point—and Dr. [name unclear] knows this much better than I do. The equilibrium point for these biomes is very delicate and once you upset that equilibrium point, things will go down the tube from then on.
So we have to be aware of that. But all that to indicate that we are sponsoring analytical effort and it recovers the experiences in Chile with subtropical forest fires or extratropical forest fires in Colombia in the Amazon region and in Colombia in the transition zone between the Orinoco and Amazonia, and in Peru in the Amazon region. This report is being authored by a series of practitioners in fire prevention, fire modeling, fire response [phrase incomplete]. There are many co-authors. One of the leaders is Dr. [name unclear] from Germany, is very well known.
So wait for that to come out. It will not have all the answers, but it will provide a recount of some successful experiences dealing with modeling, mitigation efforts and response efforts. But I’d be very happy to talk to you offline and discuss this in more detail. Even if you want to be a peer reviewer of that report, I would welcome that it would be a welcome participation of your institution in Initiative 20×20.
Daniel:
And I might weigh in here.
Unidentified participant:
Would love to do that.
Moderator:
Go ahead, Daniel.
Daniel:
>> Hi everyone and Walter, thanks for your comments about 20×20. Great to see you again and others on the call. I’m from Earth Innovation Institute and you know and getting back too to the original comment I think the question from Jonah that is what types of information would be really helpful. And thinking back on last year’s fire season, which was not a very dry season, and it was mostly sort of a deforestation related fire year, a big year and a damaging year, but very few intact forests caught fire. And, this year it’s looking a lot drier, especially in the southern Amazon, and there could be a lot of fire going into healthy intact forests.
And Walter’s comments too, I think, call attention to the importance of understanding the fire regime and ways of intervening so that we see fires early. We can get teams out to put them out. This creates a critical role for communities for farmers. Most serious producers in the Amazon they want nothing to—they do not want accidental fire. They do depend on fire for management and when it’s properly managed it can do good things and not escape and not burn forests. I think this year, in addition to being a very dry season, also has the complicating factor of the effect of smoke on COVID patients.
It’s about the worst thing you can imagine. In a typical year about a thousand people die from respiratory ailments in the Amazon from the air pollution. Now with COVID, I think that’s an added problem, but there’s a real shortage of voluntary networks and fire brigades you know one of the most successful is probably [brigade name unclear], which operates mostly in Mato Grosso. They’re going into this fire season without enough budget. They’ve trained about 700 firefighters in the southeastern Amazon who can be mobilized once the word gets out there is a fire moving into a forest on this ranch, on this property, in this community.
And they all know—half of the folks trained are Indigenous people from the Xingu Indigenous park and the Xingu [place description unclear]. For me, it just strikes me at how much forest can be saved if you have early warning and then trained people who can go out voluntarily, you know, contributing their time to put out fires. I think there’s sort of a you know and in our call it’s interesting a lot of what we’re talking about are sort of these near-term emergencies which are critical needs for funding for collaboration and there’s also this medium and long-term element as well that I think we need to pay attention to.
You know, and as Walter was alluding to, I think the challenge of forest regeneration which I agree 100 percent with [name unclear], mean, in the Amazon, most land will go back to forest if you let it. There are about 12 million hectares of secondary forest in the Amazon today that will go back to forest if it’s protected from fire and, and if it’s not cleared for cattle pasture. But just the medium-term solution to fire is really more productive farms. You know, communities that are making more money that are shifting to agroforestry, that are shifting to treebased systems.
You know, we found that when that happens, the tendency to use fire declines and the tendency to invest in fire prevention increases. How do we get to those economic opportunities so that we’re moving towards perennial production and diversified production and away from cattle? Anyway, one suggestion: to sort of think of the really near-term needs for finance for investment for collaboration but also not to forget this medium and long-term view you know what is the endgame it’s really productive farms and agricultural systems with indigenous people getting to Colleen’s point, you know, finding good markets and good investors and partners for the community enterprises that for them are a way out of poverty and a way to get better health care and a way to see their people get education and really become leaders at different stages or on different stages, I should say.
Anyway, I’ll stop. There. Thanks.
Moderator:
>> I have a follow-up question for you, Daniel. Maybe others can get in on this, too. As someone who is organizing investors who are interested in agroforestry, is there a particular kind of crop or agroforestry that is most fire resistant?
Daniel:
There’s some that are very unresistant [laughter] and the u you know there’s a lot of sort of natural fire breaks like mango trees are great for stopping fire the shade they cast is so dense that even though there’s a lot of leaf matter in the on the on the ground fires have a hard time passing through a line of mangoes. You know I think the a lot of it is about you know finding the markets and the supply chains. You know, a lot of farmers in the Amazon will say when we come up with a new production system, a new product, like [fruit name unclear], like açaí, which is coming from managed forests in the estuary, pretty soon the [producer location unclear] producers will have it and they’ll be way ahead of us and they’re close to the big markets.
And I see that as the major bottleneck really. It’s how [clears throat] do you grow when you’re so far from significant markets? In western Rondônia, there’s the [model name unclear] model that’s been there for decades and is successfully growing fruits. You’ve got the [cooperative name unclear], demonstrating how a network of cooperatives across an entire state can allow agroextractivist populations to commercialize their products and get greater value and real income increases for, in this case, rubber tappers and Brazil nut harvesters. So there’s some great examples and I love what was commented earlier about oh Anki I think mentioned businesses that are doing sustainable production systems you know I think of [business names unclear], for Brazil nut oil, it’s incredibly difficult to make a profit with know those principles in mind and u and That’s a problem.
And there’s today a group of smallcale businesses that are organizing to basically say how can we no longer be sort of vilified or you know as businesses operating in the Amazon call attention to our products and find that sort of market differentiation that they feel like will be necessary to compete with those you know illegal or bad actors that are that are.
Moderator:
Competing with them. Other related questions.
Atossa:
>> I have a question. Hi Daniel, this is Atossa. Nice to see you. It’s been years. I you know it’s election year here in the United States. Obviously there’s a been a few conversations, and during the debate Biden mentioned the 20 billion for the Amazon. Didn’t mention much detail. He said, I think, a G20 know commitment for $20 billion for the Amazon. You know I don’t know if you were part of the you know you’ve made some recommendations to the administration on policy and climate on forests but so I guess it’s a general question sort of like what do we know about you know what is a platform for the US presidential elections looking at that 20 billion what do we know about that 20 billion and you know what is it that we can be keeping in mind in terms of not just the presidential elections—obviously those are important but so many state and local and national congressional level elections can we make the Amazon which you know the fire season’s corresponding to the election season can we make the Amazon an issue given the US you know influence at the IMF level or US influence on trade issues and you know those kinds of things just wanted your take on that.
Daniel:
>> yeah great to see it’s a great question and unfortunately Joe Biden’s the climate bill I saw or policy did not include that 20 billion. I think the best climate policy from my perspective was [name unclear]’s, the governor of Washington who ran for president for a while and is advising Biden, and they were really open to including in their massive climate policy a spec specific focus on the Amazon. And like you say there’s so many ways in which there could be partnerships, investment flowing in from the US that are at the state level and here in California there’s growing interest in that among tech companies with you know Salesforce leading the drive on the Trillion Trees Initiative, and there and the possibility that there’s a group of tech companies that could you know inject some serious finance into the Amazon is really intriguing.
And but also just sort of the collaborations, right? So, as we’ve talked about in the past, you know, there’s a big sort of rule of law efficiency issue in the Amazon, you know, how [clears throat] do you get the CAR implemented, for example? There’s tech solutions to that could be part of a broader collaborative agenda. So I think before we get to sort of the market mechanisms here, you know, it’ll be a few years before California regulates the international offset provision, but we do have the tropical forest standard. Could that be a way of saying this entire state in the Amazon is good to go for business investments, for sourcing agreements and that sort of thing.
Unidentified participant:
Just to follow up, I think that also there’s probably the actions that local and state level champions we could be you know we could be calling on candidates, civil society, come up with as a platform for calling for action from the Biden campaign, from other congressional offices, as well as LA did something really incredible to not buy Brazilian beef from the Amazon for their school district which is a really big contract. And that was something that you know happened really it was really exciting to see and other cities could also follow.
So you know some of us are thinking about what that could look like a platform for action a call to action to that we can insert into the election debates and it’d be great to hear from others. I’ll put my email here if you have any thoughts on interests and thoughts and collaborating.
Unidentified participant:
I want to add Trump mentioned trees and planting lots of trees in his state of the union address. I think that one thing that can come out of our group and possibly Nexus is policy recommendations for every country in the world with respect to the Amazon. The United States has the Lacey Act. The EU has the [law name unclear], I think it’s called. Many other policy agendas that we can help educate people about.
Moderator:
>> Daniel, did you want to respond any [name unclear]’s final comments.
Daniel:
Oh, just that you know really quickly I think my sense is right now in the time of the pandemic where budgets are getting hammered, the state governments there’s this urban to rural flight that’s that’s going to push deforestation rates up and it’s creating a lot of desperation that we really need a lot of collaborative solidarity shows of support. I feel like that’s a bigger more important signal right now than sort of pulling out of markets or not buying since it’s so difficult to know how that impacts on the ground and I do think there’s a real need for how and this was brought up by Amalia earlier.
How do you get the money into the hands of the people who really need it? And Colleen mentioned that as well and there’s some cool mechanisms that are that are being created to do that. You know, something like the CDSA in [place name unclear], the institutes in Mato Grosso, are examples of some of these organizations that operate outside of governments better positioned to get money into communities and under the onto the ground.
Moderator:
Daniel, could you post the links to CDSA and [place name unclear], and [institute name unclear] in Mato Grosso, if you can find them? I also have. News. I spoke with someone, Dennis [surname unclear]. Some of you might know him. One of the his family is one of the largest business operators in the Western Amazon. They have a big bank. I think it’s called [bank name unclear], that has—there are eight million people in the Western Amazon. They’ve got two, maybe two and a half million customers, financial service customers in their bank.
And I asked him about the idea if someone wanted some crazy philanthropist came along and wanted to deliver solar panels or water purification systems to all residents of the western Amazon, could they help? And he said he probably could. Anyway, so there’s a potential delivery mechanism in case people have such ideas. In the two minutes that we have left, does anybody else want to share anything more. If you’re on mute, star nine to come off or feel free to unmute yourself.
Unidentified participant:
I would like to request Ruben’s contact points and to follow up the discussion with Emergent and Initiative 20×20 directly.
Unidentified participant:
>> Yeah, I’ll send you an email just now.
Unidentified participant:
>> Thank you.
Moderator:
>> Great. Okay. Unless there’s anyone else.
Unidentified participant:
Jonah, can you put those names in the text that you just mentioned.
Moderator:
Oh, yeah. The bank in the western [sentence incomplete].
Unidentified participant:
>> Yes. >> Thank you.
Moderator:
>> Okay. Thank you everybody. Talk to you all soon. Bye-bye. Thank you so much,.
Unidentified participant:
Jonah. >> Thank you so much.
Unidentified participant:
Daniel is posting links.
Unidentified participant:
>> Okay.
Unidentified participant:
>> Bye, everyone. Nice. I see you all.
Unidentified participant:
>> Thank you. Bye.
Unidentified participant:
>> Bye everyone. Thank you so much for your time.
Unidentified participant:
>> Bye. Thank you.
Unidentified participant:
>> You know, we can copy this all and put it into a text.
Unidentified participant:
>> Great.
Unidentified participant:
Yes, same. If I can have two minutes just to copy this information.
Unidentified participant:
>> Yeah. [brief fragment unclear].
Unidentified participant(s):
>> Yeah. And there is a feature that allows you to download, but then you have to know where what folder it goes into on your [phrase unfinished]. These are always. Helpful. Jonah but once you close it, it disappears. So that’s always difficult.
Unidentified participant:
>> Great. I have a I have another phone call now that I need to switch over. So.
Unidentified participant:
>> Thank you.
Unidentified participant:
I got it. Thank you, Jonah.
Unidentified participant:
You got it? Do you have it, [name unclear]?
Unidentified participant:
>> Yeah.
Unidentified participant:
>> Okay.
Unidentified participant:
She left. All right. Hey, Jonah, I know you’ve got to jump to another call, but if we can connect.
Unidentified participant:
>> Okay.
Unidentified participant:
>> We connect today or something later.
Unidentified participant:
>> Sure. Send me a text. Okay. Bye.