Amazonian Fish and Sustainability
While much attention is focused on developing forest biodiversity as the basis for the Amazon bioeconomy, there is far less recognition of the enormous economic potential of the Amazon’s managed fisheries and aquaculture, and the strategic role that fish can play as an alternative to beef. Aquaculture requires only 5% of the land required by conventional beef production to produce the same amount of animal protein. Brazil has a fast growing, world class aquaculture sector, and virtually all Amazon states are investing in aquaculture. At the same time, considerable progress has been made in sustainably managing the Amazon’s floodplain fisheries as a major source of subsistence and income for traditional and indigenous communities. Fish is the most important form of animal protein traded globally and has the market power to drive development of Amazon fish production. Large scale investment in developing the potential of Amazon fish could significantly reduce pressure on Amazon forests while increasing employment and incomes for Amazon farmers and traditional and Indigenous peoples. Join the conversation with David McGrath of the Earth Innovation Institute. Reference: Policy Brief – Can Fish Drive the Development of the Amazon Bioeconomy?
Recorded April 25, 2022
References:
State of World Fisheries and Aquaculture
Brazilian Association of Fish Farming (Pisciculture)
The development of Brazilian aquaculture: Introduced and native species
Tambaqui – A fish popular in Amazonian aquaculture
Arapaima / Pirarucu – Among the world’s largest freshwater fish
Taking the Amazon back to fish: A fish-based low-emission development strategy for the Amazon Basin
Community-based management induces rapid recovery of a high-value tropical freshwater fishery
Protect a Giant Fish for the Amazon
WATCH:
Participants
- Jonah Wittkamper
- David McGrath
- Mark
- Jean-Louis
- Jacqueline
- Maria
- Ricardo
- Sally
- Luis Fernando
- Sylvia
- Christian
- Matt Warren
- Fiona Banister
- Unidentified participant
Transcript
Jonah Wittkamper:
Hello everybody. Welcome to the 86 call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing force friendly economic development and the rule of law across the Amazon region of South America. This week we are featuring the work of Toby McGrath and or David McGrath and the Earth Innovation Institute. We’re going to be talking about Amazonian fish, both aquaculture, which is fish farming and managed fisheries. Toby, tell us a little bit about yourself. Tell us where you grew up and where you developed your affection for the Amazon.
David McGrath:
Well, okay. I’m where I grew up. My father was a diplomat so I grew up in a few countries but the last one that he lived stayed at when I was in my adolescence and early 20s was Brazil from the late 60s to early 70s and he’s the one that introduc introduced me to the Amazon and then I decided to do my PhD field work on Amazon river traders and I’ve been working on the Amazon ever since. So after you know it’s been about 30 plus years in the Amazon working on fisheries and more recently bringing aquaculture into the sea.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Nice. And from what I understand you have a presentation to share with us.
David McGrath:
Yes. Would you like to see it? Yes. Let’s go for it. All right. I got to remember how to do these things properly here.
David McGrath:
All right. No, I didn’t do that right. So, I have to go back.
Unidentified participant:
Screen sharing should be we see it. You do. Oh, good. Yeah. Well, it’s finished. It’s There it.
David McGrath:
Is. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Great. Okay. Good. All right. As said, I’m Toby McGrath, the Earth Innovation Institute. My talk today is about fish and the Amazon bioeconomy. It’s a little different from the usual talks I guess that focus on a company or some thing like that. What I’m just going to I’m trying to do here is call attention to the critical role that fish can play in reducing deforestation and developing an Amazon bio economy. Fish from managed wild fisheries and aquaculture offer a definitive solution for Amazon deforestation, conserving forests while producing the high quality animal protein the world needs.
Fish production and management are far more land inensive than beef. Fish is the dominant form of animal protein in global trade and has the market power to drive development of Amazon fish production. Brazil has a fast growing worldclass aquaculture sector led by wellorganized small-scale producers. Aquaculture and managed fisheries already play a significant role in the Amazon economy. Developing the potential of Amazon fish will require a concerted effort by all stakeholders and especially private sector investors and entrepreneurs. That’s the main pitch of my talk. I will get on to the substance.
Aquaculture is far more efficient than land efficient than beef. One ton of beef requires 16 hectares of conventional extensive pasture. Amazon aquaculture requires only half a hectare for the same amount of animal protein. That’s sort of the basis one of the elements for us proposing a fish strategy. Fish global fish is global fish trade is the dominant form of animal protein in the global economy. Fish accounted for 41% of trade in animal protein in 2017. Trade in fish grew three times faster than beef between 76 and 2017. Fish can drive development of a you know fish global fish trade has the market power to drive development of Amazon aquaculture and fisheries.
This map shows the area of the extent of the main fisheries regions of the Amazon basin. Focus here, Bellain at the capital of Parah at the mouth of the Amazon River and gets both ocean and estuary fisheries. Santaren upstream is an area of once important fisheries and now recovering but a important area for community- based management of fisheries. Manau is perhaps the main hub for both the internal port for the Amazon but is a hub in terms of developing fishbased appro approaches within the Amazon bioeconomy and generally speaking tee mamawa is the origin of the development of the piru management system which is currently the dominant most effective management system for Amazon floodplane fisheries.
Ikitus is the main city in the Peruvian Amazon and responsible then for the fisheries and agriculture development in that area there. U pirouf production. I’m having a problem here that I always have which is to get rid of this get rid of this title at the top. Is it like that? No. Sorry. I just did myself in. Pardon me. I was here. Are we okay? Yeah. I’ve forgotten about the fact that this menu that comes down from the top blocks off my titles. So we talked about the Amazon River system.
Here is a map of Piratu production. Piratuku is the flagship species for the management of flood community- based management of floodplane fisheries. Between 2003 when the system was first implemented and 2019 catch of managed Paku in the state of Amazonas increased from 20 tons to 2,625 tons expanded from 25 two to 35 reserves involving some 12 expanding from 12 to about 160 communities in the in the state of Amazon. Elsewhere. It’s also expanded into the Peruvian Amazon. We are using a system in the state of PA. And it’s dynamizing community- based management of Amazon fisheries.
Amazon fish are also an a forest product. There is a direct relationship between floodplane forest cover and fisheries production. 10% more forest cover results in a 10% increase in the productivity of floodplane fisheries. More forest, more fish. This creates the opportunity to create incentives for floodplane communities to reduce cattle herds and reforest lake barges. Here is an example of a community initiative involving the school and a group of fish fishermen to produce seedlings, reforest the margins of a lake. The community is shown on the right bringing the seedlings to the site for the for the re replanting.
Down on the left hand corner is the is the re the reforested site after a few years. Amazon fit trees grow fast. So that’s makes them very satisfying. And on the right a fisherman fishing in the canopy of that forest. And he’s just caught a tambaki. So this is sort of a model that could work on the flood plane. For aquaculture, the three main types of production systems are cage culture showing up on the left, the commercial pond culture in the middle, that accounts for probably 80 or 90% of all fish production in most states.
And the a practice which I think is illegal in most places but is often used of fencing off sections of river for production of some species such as the matric sha. The main species is the tambaki and related species that are collect and hybrids that are collectively called round fish. They are dominant in Amazon in Amazon aquaculture. The pintadu is a catfish that is also used with a much smaller lesser importance but also very good and the matrina is a third as I said better adapted to forest stream habitats. In terms of a comparison of the profitability of aquaculture and beef, here’s one that shows that aquaculture is far more profitable in a simple farm than beef.
For example, net returns for a hectare of agriculture are about 12,800 rayis versus 300 for extensive Beef production profit margins are 20% for agriculture, roughly 10% for beef. Take an example of a 42 hector farm. Two hectors of aquaculture will produce twothirds of the income of the farm. This is just a sort of a snapshot. There are more productive and intensive systems of beef production that would change the scenario quite a bit. But extensive beef production, extensive pasture production still is the predominant way that beef is produced in the Brazilian Amazon.
Small increases in the growth of aquaculture can have an significant impact on deforestation. It is not an all or nothing thing. Total aquaculture production of the illegal Amazon today is about 8% out of beef. By choosing fish over beef, farmers can save approximately 38,000 kilometers that would be needed for beef. This is equivalent to total Amazon deforestation between 2015 and 2019. So in this strategy offers producers a way to grow and diversify production and income while conserving progressively larger areas of forest and potentially offsetting Amazon deforestation. Here is three scenarios of aquaculture growth under different interest rates I mean rate rates of growth 5% 7.5 and 10% and over a 20-year period you see that this growth could allow the sort of retirement of between 21 and 50% of the 2017 pasture area of the Brazilian Amazon.
This could make over time a significant impact on not just deforestation but on forest cover in the Amazon. There are incentives for the fish beef for the shift from beer beef to fish instead of punitive measures to pressure farmers to reduce deforestation and forego production. Aquaculture offers incentives to invest in aquaculture and reforestation to diversify farm production. Aquaculture can harness the productive capacity of the Amazon’s commercial and small-cale farmers, progressively reducing the total area and pasture while expanding agriculture production and forestbased management. In some states, it should be noted that aquacult beef production ranchers or beef producers are have adopted agriculture.
The state of Hondonia is where this practice is most widely widespread and Pondonia is one of the major aquaculture producers not just of the Amazon but the Brazil. This is an example of satellitebased mapping of aquaculture in state of Hondonia. Individual ponds are shown up above a more sort of stylized vision of aquaculture in the lower. And this is example of how to harness modern technology to develop accurate databases to inform investment in Amazon aquaculture. Peterson Valley the president of Busula Farms I think is in on us on this talk and we’ll be able to talk more about his work as well.
What are the challenges? Well, the first one is the low quality and limited availability of data on Amazon fisheries and aquaculture. These hampers de investment decision-making. Without good information, you cannot make safe investments. The lower productivity of Amazon agriculture species reduces producers ability to compete in the national market. In most states, until recently at least, it was illegal for producers to you to produce exotic species such as tilapia. They’ve had to rely on Amazon species who which have not been yet welldeveloped for agriculture. Regulatory bottlenecks discourage investment in agriculture. This is another important factor.
And finally, logistical challenges and inefficient supply chain infrastructure exacerbate the problem of competing in national markets. Challenges are also opportunities. Investment in developing high productivity varieties of Amazon fish is a major priority for advancing the aqua aquaculture and fish agenda. Also identifying and developing markets for promising underutilized Amazon fish species and products. Amazon has got somewhere upwards of 3,000 species of fish. No more than 20 have any significant role in the in the commercial fisheries. So there’s a huge unexploited potential there. Company producer partnerships, technical assistance and market actions for fish producers and managers is a key issue and company producer partnerships could play a role in addressing those needs.
Modernize fish supply chain businesses and logistics. We need to have modern firms able to access the fish stocks and get perishable product to market in without losing quality. Carbon finance create incentives for investment in aquaculture and managed fisheries. And finally, I think there’s a huge role for marketing strategies that emphasize the role of fish in conserving forests and supporting indigenous and traditional peoples who are managing these piratu fisheries. Fish in the transition to the Amazon bio economy. Development of Amazon fish involves long-term collaborations between producers, researchers, companies, investors, government policy makers, and civil society organizations.
Amazon investors with their resources, vision, and commitment can play a decisive role in developing the potential of fish and ensuring a sustainable future for Amazon forests and peoples. So, thank you. That’s it. Turn it over to you, Jonah.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. I have several questions and then we’ll bring it over to the audience. First, I’d like to begin. Person, you introduced yourself before the recording started and a bunch of new people have joined since then. It’d be great if you could introduce yourself and tell us a little bit about your work and how it relates to fishing.
Unidentified participant:
Yeah, definitely. Thank you. So I’m Patrick Sale. I run a company that’s based in Hongonia, Brazil. And we do mapping of agricultural production across Brazil and we’re focused on aquaculture. So we are we have the only product that uses satellite imagery to map aquacult inland aquacultural production anywhere in the world and we’ve started with the Amazon so we can show how aquaculture production has been evolving in the state of Hondonia. And so I’ve been interacting with Toby a lot on aquaculture, PC culture, the relationship with deforestation and all the topics that certainly matter to everyone here.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. Okay, couple questions for me. Super exciting presentation, super exciting potential. I think you have a lot of allies on the call. First question for me. Do you either Pison or do Toby have an appreciation of current market share when it comes for raals or dollars? In fish procurement, the market share of managed fisheries versus aquaculture, fish farming, which one is larger and by how much?
David McGrath:
You know, I will start Peterson, you jump in, please. The problem is the data aren’t there. We don’t know what’s going on with Amazon fisheries. We don’t we haven’t The last scientific monitoring of fisheries ended in about 2011. So, we really don’t know what’s going on. It’s, you know, it’s ridiculous. FAO no longer publishes data from the Amazon or from Brazilian fisheries. With aquaculture we have much better data thanks to Besi which is the main aquaculture association. They estimate that aquaculture is producing about a little over about 850,000 tons now.
And I’m just I don’t know what Peterson, do you have a better idea of what that what the share of fish production that would be or fish consumption in Brazil that would that would make up? It’s been changing quickly with tilapia, but I don’t know where it is now.
Unidentified participant:
Yeah. No, well, Toby’s answer is perfect. And what I would add is that the picture has been changing really quickly in the last couple of I would say probably 20 years. And in my state, Hondonia is the proof of this. So Hondonia did not produce a lot of aquaculture fish at all. It was a beef oriented and it still is a beef oriented state. But in the last 15 years it’s aquaculture production has grown a lot and this is mainly because of the Manau market. You know, Manow is a large city in the middle of the Amazon and they consume a lot of fish.
U now the supply of fish from the rivers across Amazon has been going down including because of regulations. So Hondonia is the proof that the share of aquaculture is increasing a lot and this is because of the of the impossibility of fishing to supply all the demand that there is across the Amazon.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Okay another question a little bit different but just to entice the biologists among us. Can you tell us a little bit about Piruku and why it’s such an interesting fish?
David McGrath:
Sure. It is a fascinating fish. First, have you seen it? It look an ancient fish and it’s been around and it’s a smart fish. But it has a number of characteristics that the management system developed combines both biological characteristics of fish and the skills of the fisherman. First, the piratu breathes air through its swim bladder. So, it has to come up periodically to gulp air. And that was the basis for developing a methodology following from I think wildlife biology for estimating the population of pirus in lakes. And this way this system made it possible with trained fishermen who trained Piruku fishermen, harpoon fishermen who were used to seeing fish and identifying.
They come up and they just do a little splash and these fishermen can tell you whether it’s an adult or a juvenile. And this was then turned into a counting system with teams of fishermen so they can make an accurate estimate of the number of fish in a lake and use that for developing harvest quotas on an annual basis and monitoring. That system was legalized. So you have the system now where people can count the number of fish in the in the lake which you can’t do with virtually any other fish in the world and that provides security.
It’s the basis for a simple system that fishermen can develop and implement and that’s been the basis for it taking off in addition to the fact that it’s a high value species much appreciated in the Amazon.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Another question from me. I see these comparisons about the fish market and the beef market. Can you give us a little bit of intelligence about the nutrient profiles of fish compared to beef? Are they equal? Is one more healthier than the other?
David McGrath:
You know, it’s sort of standard to say that fish is more is healthier than beef, but in the last couple of years that I’ve been paying attention to news reports on different studies, it, you know, they’re they’re all over the place. So, in theory, fish is, and that’s the sort of the given wisdom, but it really depends on the study you look at about this. I’ve gotten I’ve the more I’ve looked into it, the more confused I’ve got, but I think it’s safe to say that fish is a healthier form of animal protein.
But I’m not going to go off the plank on that one.
Unidentified participant:
If I could just add the healthier part is pretty well known. There’s another component that I think is very important which is that the populations in the Amazon they eat a lot of fish. So if you look at per capita consumptions across per consumption across states in Brazil the states in the north they have by far the highest per capita consumption which is comparable to Asian levels actually and piru and tambaki the two main species that are cultivated in the Amazon they are very much aligned with those cultural preferences. So that’s very important.
David McGrath:
Good point. And so if you’re going to market fish elsewhere, Amazon fish, they’re not well known outside of the Amazon. That’s a problem. They’re not cheap. And that’s another problem. And but this the target for me would be those urban centers and areas that have a tradition of eating a lot of fish and they are there. They’ve been identified and they would make great targets for that kind of an approach.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. Last question for me and then we already have several questions from the audience. I heard an analysis one time. I think the global software industry is about 500 billion a year. Yet the global food and a industry I think it’s 8 trillion a year. So for those investors that are looking for outside investments, you know, figuring out how to scale Amazonian fish is a giant opportunity. I’d love it if you could share a little bit about how new technology may be playing a role in the future prospects of fisheries management and aquaculture.
David McGrath:
Maybe I’ll let Peterson take a shot at that first if you like since he’s in the in the new technology.
Unidentified participant:
Yes, definitely. So in Brazil aquaculture is increasingly seen as the new agricultural production frontier. So there’s a lot of talk especially related to tilapia. Now in the Amazon as you mentioned there’s a lot of potential but there are a lot of lots of weaknesses as well logistics and many others. So technology can help in allowing investors especially investors to know what the situation is and what the situation has been and where production is. So the front in which we are working is to provide transparency. So where are these agricultural operations located?
How have they been growing over time and are they related to deforestation or not? That’s something also that we can we can say and I have a little bit more on this if someone is interested. So this is one front and it’s the geospatial analytics front and it’s a very interesting one but then there’s of course there’s all the microlevel technologies that are applied to the to the aquacultural operations on the ground. So this is genetics. This is feeding and one of the key things that needs to develop very quickly in Brazil is an alternative to soybased fish feed.
So with everything that’s happened in the last two or three years with the pandemics, fish feed has become very expensive because of soy prices and there are many alternatives that use inputs that are available locally. So this is this is an area that needs a lot of attention and will certainly grow a lot. Yeah, that’s on my end.
David McGrath:
Yeah, I think in with fisheries management there’s a lot of potential for growth for development there in technology. I know it’s increasingly used in monitoring fisheries to have a tablet that’s linked to the internet with a little questionnaire that you fill out on a daily basis or whatever the monitoring system is. And those kinds of technologies are getting more and more widespread in Amazon communities that are managing their fisheries. There’s huge potential for this logistics. You know, I think I think you know Amazon logistics I think well Amazon uses practically slave labor.
So maybe that’s not a good example, but some, you know, we need to think about bringing in some of these abilities to, you know, make supply chains more efficient and to make sure that the quality of the fish is not lost between where it’s caught in a lake and where it gets to consumers in some part of the world. And so that is a huge challenge that I think is key to developing the potential of fish.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. We are at nearly half an hour top past the top of the hour. We’re now going to switch over to questions. This may be a record. We’ve already got five people with questions. So one at a time. Mark, then Jean Louie, then Jacqueline, then Maria, then Ricardo. Mark, you’re up first.
Mark:
Yes. Thank you. Great presentation. Very interesting. The question relates mostly to invasive species and tilapia. So the number you’ve been given you’ve been giving us do they include tilapia? I wasn’t sure really if it if they did and if there is any initiative to come down on invasive species thinking of tilapia but also I’m pretty sure at one point they will cultivate shrimp somewhere.
David McGrath:
Yeah. Well, I’ve these days I take a more pragmatic approach to the question of tilapia. And especially the Amazon basin all Amazon states in 2006 essentially aquaculture of the Amazon developed using early tilapia varieties which was pretty disastrous. And then in 2006 all exotics were prohibited from Amazon agriculture. By that point the cat was out of the bag or the cattle out of the barn or whatever you want to say with the southern tributaries the Amazon. So today they’re all working with these native species that are very little changed from the wild varieties.
So they’re not adapted for agriculture. And that’s one of the problems holding back agriculture in the Amazon. Amazon. Elsewhere, tilapia has exploded in Brazil, both for consumers and production. I think Brazil is now the main exporter of tilapia to the US. And they’re using these genetically modified version varieties that are in theory sterile or the males or they’re using all males or something. And I think the question of the concern of exotics especially in the southern tributaries of the Amazon needs to be taken in need to be evaluated in the context of the alternatives.
Those rivers have already largely their basins been deforested. The banks of those rivers have been deforested. Those streams are thoroughly compromised in terms of the original aquatic biodiversity and ecosystem positions. Aquaculture tilapia offers farmers a way to access or fish farmers a way to access the national and international market. They also give us time to develop native aquaculture varieties that are really efficient. So there’s a there’s tradeoffs. If we don’t do if we don’t make aquaculture in the Amazon successful, then cattle will expand and deforestation will continue. If we make aquaculture work and totally compromise aquaculture, I mean the aquatic systems in the Amazon.
So, where do we go?
Jonah Wittkamper:
Okay. Next up is Jean Louie.
Jean-Louis:
Yes, thank you. Very, very interesting presentation, very informative. Thank you very much. Two questions. They’re pretty broad, so please feel free to not go into detail. One is what’s your current sense of the sustainability of fish stocks as they currently exist and if we’re looking at the growth of those markets what could be the impact and you feel that there is a capacity to manage these stocks sustainably and then second what are some of the business models that you’ve seen that both support local needs as well as the commercial side and conversely is there risk right?
That these opportunities would be seized by very large actors that might maybe compromise the local benefits of these emerging markets. Well, that was a lot of stuff. Let’s go back to the beginning. I think I lost the beginning of what you were saying there asking just could you sort of summarize briefly what current capacity to manage stocks. Thanks.
David McGrath:
Yeah. The current capacity to sustainably manage stocks is very limited. Okay. There is very little of the Amazon is there effective control over fishing for wild fisheries. And that’s a problem and there’s no information so you don’t know what’s going on. Responsibility was in the last couple of years transferred from the federal government to the state and now states individually are finally picking up on that. Okay. There is a sort of prevailing ideologies that says oh well the natural evolution is from capture you know wild capture fisheries to aquaculture. And so we are now facing the inevitable decline of aquacult of wild fisheries and they will be replaced by aquaculture.
Well that’s what do you call it when you have a you know you I can’t remember the name for it but anyway the idea that you wishful thinking well not well wishful thinking no but it’s the idea that your actions create the outcome that you are prophesizing feeling statement. Yes, self-profiling prophecies. That’s what that is. The fact of the matter is that while some stocks like the Piranuku and others are very depleted at Tabaki compared to their original levels, nothing has been lost. There is still the potential with decent management.
The flood plane is largely intact. And that is where a lot of these species are growing. So, there is the potential to develop and recover a great deal of the fisheries. The one exception are the commercial catfish fisheries. These species that do long-distance migrations. They spawn in the Andian headwaters and pass their juvenile phase in the estuary of the Amazon. Those species have to run the gauntlet up the Amazon with fishermen all along the way looking for them. And now that dams are going on the upper sections of those rivers, it’s access to spawning habitat is being cut off.
So the largecale commercial catfish and migr migratory species that have sustained the commercial fisheries for export are increasingly in trouble. The floodplane fisheries that are feeding mostly local populations are already squeezed but there is potential to recover them with a significant with significant effort. Business models. I’m not aware of much in the way of business models that work seek to support community- based fisheries management. There are some there’s interest circuling circulating but I think in the state of Amazon with the piru fisheries this is something that needs to develop and it needs to develop quickly and some initiatives are taking place on that front.
There are some big indigenous and organizations and others that mix traditional indigenous people that are taking a active role in that and hopefully these issues will be develop developed but it’s to groups like you that I’m talking just to help move that process forward. Yeah, just in the interest of time, let’s go ahead and move on.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Jacqueline, you’re up next. Hi, how’s it going?
Jacqueline:
Hi Toby. I’m Patterson. Lovely to meet you. My name is Jacine. I’m actually from Capital for Climate. I actually originally had a question about ornamental fisheries. I also heard like this was ages ago. That I actually heard that ornamental fisheries in the Amazon had a huge potential for not only economic development but a chance to recover wild stocks as well and also to preserve biodiversity. And I was wondering like this was back in 2007 I think when I when I was reading about this but nothing really has scaled up significantly for those ornamental fisheries.
Maybe this is not part of your study but I was wondering like what are what are those barriers and are those barriers the same sort of barriers as for commercial aquaculture for protein?
David McGrath:
Well the first thing about ornamental fish thank you for your question I do not study ornamental fish but I happened to consult a friend of mine recently who knows what’s going on in Manau and so he can talk about that. Okay. But, I mean the major ornamental fisheries has gone through some ups and downs, some pretty catastrophic ups and downs. And but they’re important in Peru. They’re important in Leticia or they used to be important in Leticia. And in the Amazon, there’s been some somewhat of a collapse and there’s concern about some species.
Somebody I see mentioned zebra catfish and I think that’s an example. There are problems with these little rainforest, rainforest, streams and rivers populations. One of the real challenges of ornamental fish is that you get a you get some breeding stock and you take them to Southeast Asia and you develop you know domestic varieties for the aquaculture aquarium trade. So, so they’re they’re very limited I think in the space they have and after a complete collapse of at least the business end not the stocks in the Rioenegro basin they are now recovering and smallcale initiatives are taking place throughout the Rioenegro fishing area.
Jacqueline:
Awesome. That’s great. And can I just ask just a quick question is when you were talking just now about the business models, do you have any idea of actually how much investment would be needed to kind of like set up a commercial fishery like or was that something you spoke about because I was a little bit late. I’m sorry. But do you have like a rough number?
David McGrath:
No, I have no numbers for that. I think that is a real potential. There was an industrial base for exploiting the largecale the commercial catfish fisheries beginning in the 60s. Okay, so along the Amazon there are places where you encounter fish processing facilities, some in better condition than others. Some of these are still actively functioning, others are in decline. But there is this industrial potential for producing high quality fish for export that has been a practice for now for a couple of decades and is in dire need of funding. I’m not at all sure what the what the needs would be to get something up and going, but I think it’s a key part of a solution to recovering those fisheries, especially in partnership with community management organizations and other organizations.
Jacqueline:
Awesome. Thank you. Yeah. Patterson, did you want to respond to that question about how much it might cost to set up a commercial fishing operation?
Unidentified participant:
Not really. I don’t really have the numbers here either. I just want to say that taking the example of the region that I know very well. I think what we need is not exactly support to establish fish operations but to provide some oil into the into the chain. And that is done through different parts of the chain and one of them that I think is very important is skill development. So we have a lot many parts of the chain are already established in the Amazon but they don’t work well together and one of the lacking parts of that is skills.
So what I would say is that the you know we need to think about ways in which we can help farmers to improve their skills so that they can use the assets that they already have in a better way.
David McGrath:
Yeah. And I think that’s just to follow quickly on that. I was referring mostly to the commercial fisheries of the Amazon, better to agriculture. They have two different histories. They have two different supply chains for the time being. I would like to see sometime in the future where we begin to think about wild fisheries as sort of the high end of that fishery for restaurants and global and aquaculture as providing the largescale volume of fish for global consumer markets, national and global.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. Maria, you’re up next. Thank you, Jonah, and thank you, Toby and Peterson. My name is Maria Vendoran, and I work with the I’m a sustainable landscapes program. But also we at the World Bank are developing with the help of WCS and the governments of Ecuador, Peru, Colombia and Brazil a project a cousin project of the ASL that is called the Ptoayusa project and we are focused on the Ptoayusa basin and the connection and one of our components is the actually the bio economy processes in with agriculture is one of could be one of the options to do that this part of the project.
One of my main questions was and thank you for the information is really it’s really great is your the information you’ve gathered and are the fishermen and the people that is in charge of these agricultural processes is part of the local communities are part of the local communities they are leading these processes or are the external companies that are hiring maybe the local people doing the local fisherman’s to do this processes of agriculture. That’s one of the questions and the second comment I would like to say is that we will greatly appreciate if we have any sort of communications between what our project is going to be implementing and doing and of course what your institution is also doing.
Thank you.
David McGrath:
Great. Well, I learned something about this from a friend of mine, Gilmo, who is based in Manau and works for WCS. So, he had just told me a little bit about this project, and he and I are constantly exchanging ideas and stuff like that. Essentially, in general, agriculture is done in upland areas by people from various parts of Brazil, okay, living there. Whereas the river fisheries are all by traditional and indigenous populations that have been on the flood plane for a long time. So they’re two different groups and diff two different kinds of regions.
So aquaculture is not welldeveloped on floodplane areas with a couple of exceptions south of Manau along the Amazon River. The paranva is an area that is important for aquaculture development. I haven’t been there yet so I don’t really know how it you know what it’s doing but it’s certainly there is some aquaculture along there. I don’t know about the puay is in the area that I work the lower Amazon of Amazon around Santang. We have a couple of one big initiative for pirou production and otherwise some limited experiments with cage culture on in the river but nothing that seems to have taken off.
Okay. And it’s hard for there because all these fishermen for these aquaculture people from Hondonia come there and dump their fish in the local markets. So these days you don’t know what you’re eating.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Okay, we’ve got three more questions coming up. First is Ricardo, then Sally, then Luis Fernando. Ricardo, you’re up.
Ricardo:
Hi, my name is Ricardo. I am I live in Israel originally. I’m from Brazil. I’m working in a project in Hondonia to develop a knowledge center for Tumbaki. It’s a knowledge center to develop more technology for the fish market and I have one question to Toby and Peterson. Maybe you can confirm or not that what I saw is there are a lot of people growing tumbaki in Hondonia but what they said to me there is a problem of the in the in the process proc processing the tumbaki fish because people they have the fish but there is a lack of technology to do all the process automatic and there is a lack of people to do that because today you have the technology to work with another kind of fish like tilapia but tbaki there is no technology to do all the process of tumbaki is it right?
Do you think this is this is a big problem or what do you think?
David McGrath:
All right. Should I take a stab, Peterson? You correct me. But the real problem with Tambaki is it has this Y-shaped bone in the sort of the I don’t know what you call it, the sort of the upper part of not the ribs, but the part that goes along the dorsal fin that the filt machines couldn’t handle. Therefore, they there was a big chunk of the fish speed that they could not use. So, they have a lower productivity in terms of growth rates. They had this problem. Now my understanding is and Peterson you may know better than me in the last couple of years they’ve developed machines that can deal with that bone and that’s a critical limiting factor in bringing you know increasing the efficiency of meat production on tabaki.
Yeah. So I have been interacting a lot with the processing part of the industry in Hondonia. And what I hear is I haven’t heard a lot about technical challenges. So I don’t think well not that I’m aware of. I don’t know about major technical challenges. What I know is that there is a disconnection between u demand and supply and the capital that can create that infrastructure for the processing. So there is capital, there is demand and there is supply but those things are not necessarily connected the way they should be.
So we work very closely with one industry in Hondonia that supplies to Bolivia, to the United States, and to many other parts of Brazil. We know lots of producers in Hondonia that sell to industries that are located in Brasília and that actually process those fish without any technical problem. So the major issue is that we need to organize that chain better and the chains are devoted to supplying to Manau the Manow market which is a very low value added market and in order to supply to other markets we need you know better coordination yeah that’s a problem there these whole aquaculture strategy was aimed at the Amazon market where they had a lot of people eating fish they’re they’re they know how to deal with whole fish.
Whereas if you’re going to supply fish to other markets, you’ve got to have fililets. You got to have a whole range of other products. And that’s a huge area of opportunity for developing Amazon fish.
Ricardo:
Okay. Thank you very much. Yeah.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. Sally, you’re up next. You’re on mute.
Sally:
Can you hear me now? Yes. Yes. Great. Couple of questions. How long does it take roughly to grow these fish to maturity? So, what’s the sort of what does it take to get a fish to market size? And then what’s the opportunities to just talking about the supply chain, what’s the opportunity to freeze have freezing as part of the process? Because obviously as soon as you catch it the life the quality starts to deteriorate. Is that something that’s well set up at this stage?
David McGrath:
No, I mean you know fish are caught by a fisherman in a canoe, paddle canoe or now with a little slow outboard on it in the lake and then put on ice taken either directly to market or to a fish processing plant depending on the species. And you know, often not with enough ice to guarantee the maintenance of quality. That’s something that’s being worked on and in some places there’s a great deal of care about that. But in terms of what you’re talking about, I think it’s mostly would be the pirou was your question related to the pirou.
Can you repeat the essence of the question there a little bit?
Sally:
Yeah, I just I was just interested to know what’s how long does it take to typically for that fish to grow from a fingerling to size that it’s that you would want to take it to market. How long does it take roughly to get that to adult maturity that is worth harvesting?
David McGrath:
Okay, the pirou is relatively fast growing species. It’s only legal to sell p to catch and sell pirou when they reach a meter and a half in length. Okay. So that’s around two years as I understand it or a little bit more. That varies with the with the region with the with fishing pressure size to maturity changes. And that’s happening with the pirou in some areas. But, but you need to get it to maturity reasonably. And so, that’s a meter and a half and about two years. You get you get much more fish for your effort if you go to three years or more.
So that’s the status of that. Others like the tambaki, the law says 50 centimeters. Tambaki probably spend their juvenile phase in lakes and begin to migrate you know when they reach sexual maturity. So I would say that’s over two years two to three years before they start moving out of lakes and are achieving the size that the law the law requires. Although the amount of unders sized fish in Brazilian markets would not make you very confident in enforcement.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. Thank you. Yeah. Next up is Luis Lena.
Luis Fernando:
Thank you Jonah. Actually I just like just to make a comment from an investor perspective. Actually we invested in a in a company in the Amazon in a state called Amazonia to our investment fund I mean Kay investment and starting by the end if I if I have to choose one sector to invest in the Amazon if I if I don’t have a chance to choose two options If I have just one option, I would choose a culture. I really believe that it has a Oh dear, we’ve lost you for me.
My statement because we invested in three companies in the Amazon and we have we have success in two of them and one of our investment failed and the investment that failed is just is exactly the agriculture investment but there’s another reason why the investment failed and it’s not related with the sector by itself I mean we invest in a company we set up a figure link laboratory, a Russian factory, a processing plant as slaughter house and all sectors of the company worked very well. We had no problem with the market.
We had no problem with the logistics. We had no we have had few problem of supply chain in the beginning but I bet that it’s ve it’s definitely possible to organize the supply the supply chain and more than that it could have a huge social impact because small holder farmers can produce very efficient fish in the Amazon. So the I just like to make this comment from the investor perspect perspective. I really believe that it’s a very promising sector in the Amazon.
David McGrath:
Yeah. Thank you for that. I think we’ve talked once years ago. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yes.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. We are reaching the top of the hour. I do have one more question myself. Is it legal to import tambaki and piruku into US markets and can they be canned and instead of just a cold chain? Can you can caneries put them in cans and preserve them that way?
David McGrath:
They are legal in the US market. Whole Foods was selling piru. I think it came from Peru but it was there. And Tambaki is also legal. It is worth noting that pituku is on the site’s list as some kind of an endangered species. But I think the management efforts have been so successful that classification should be changed. It’s no longer valid for the managed fish. What was the other part you were asking?
Jonah Wittkamper:
Can the flesh be canned? You can it but it would be a real shame to can it. I mean, you so.
David McGrath:
Modify the flavor of the fish that I wouldn’t I you know, I know there is a group in Manau that’s canning fish, but I, you know, I wouldn’t I mean, you’re going to have the same problems of getting it someplace where it can be canned as you would to get it someplace where it can be frozen. So, I would prefer to do that and save the value of.
Jonah Wittkamper:
The fish and the flavor. Sylvia, do you want to give us a couple sentences about Piruku that you’ve mentioned in the chat? Might be on mute. Sylvia, if you’re there, you’re on mute. There you go. Okay. Hello. We hear you.
Sylvia:
Okay. Thank you very much. I just wanted to tell you that I made myself at my master thesis in the Amazon in the Colombian Amazon with Pure Coup and.
Jonah Wittkamper:
According to I think that and according to Are you listening.
Sylvia:
Better now? Okay. And according to the fishermen and to the review of literature that I made, I found that pirou reached its maturity at about around five years. But since you told us piru has a very fast growth. So fishermen and the common people think that the paru reach that the size of maturity about two around two or three years. So that’s a pointing like or it’s having a very big impact in the in the over exploitation of the populations that had happened in the Tarapo Tarapoto lakes that are as lake systems that are in the in the Colombian Amazon in the frontier with Peru.
And I think that the that issue is not important when you made like the kind of management that is happening in Mamiraa for example because they don’t they are not focusing in the in the age at where they are like sexual mature because they p also the nesting the nest ing activities because Boku has an extra thing that is super extraordinary that they made nests and the they both the female and the male take they have parental care and they both take care of the nest. So they can see how many nests are or how is the nesting activity in a lake because the nesting activity occurs in the flooded forest of the lake for in the high water seasons.
So they are a securing also that the pirus that the population of Piruku is having a good management because they know that the that the nesting activity is not decreasing or but is at least at the same or increasing. So that’s an extra thing that I wanted to tell you.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. Great. Thank you. And sorry and I have an extra thing. Okay. I just want I’ll let you add that extra thing. I just want to recognize that it’s the top of the hour, so some people will need to go. But otherwise, Toby, are you able to stick around for a few more minutes?
David McGrath:
Sure.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Okay, great. So, for those who want to stay on, please feel free to do so. Sylvia, go ahead and finish your question.
Sylvia:
Okay. And the next thing is that for example, it’s for the counting method. You can know the number of piracles but and we adopt that counting method in the Colombian Amazon but the there’s a need for the authorities also to recognize in each country for example in Brazil it’s also has been recognized but in Peru or Ecuador or Colombia it have it haven’t it hasn’t so there’s not a management plan official related to the to that counting. Yeah, it was all Thank you very much. In Brazil, it’s all by states, nothing.
David McGrath:
Federal.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. Lots of discovery, lots of interest. Toby, is it okay if I share your email address in the chat for people to follow up?
David McGrath:
Of course.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Okay, great. And he it’s David McGrath and Toby is his nickname. That which is why his email address begins with a D. Anyone else have any questions or things to share? This is now unstructured time.
Unidentified participant:
Yes, I do have a question if I may to Toby. Go forth. Go ahead. Great work Toby. Brazilian background and also diving, commercial diving and Amazon. So it’s great that you know all that comes together. I’ve seen product really big, really small is my dad actually told me to be a marine biologist because in the future all protein will come from the ocean. I didn’t do that. Became an environmental lawyer. But anyway, so at Digital Gaia, we’re looking at new ways of measuring social environmental impact in create naturebased assets. And one thing I would like to you speak a little bit is the connection between some of the of the methodologies for fish farming and co- benefits to biodiversity and carbon.
I saw one of the lines of your presentation fish and carbon because in what we’re looking at doing and we all know that carbon alone doesn’t mean a solution of a problem but carbon alone carbon with the measurement of other co- benefits and social environmental all different levels then it’s something that can you know show a good direction can you speak a little bit about methodology that could be actually positive for carbon and for biodiversity as well.
David McGrath:
I’ll give it stab. That’s not my area. I have colleagues that is Matt still there and Claudia that may or Dan I guess is not that may be able to provide more information on that. But I think the way we I’ve been thinking about we’ve been discussing is that if you if a rancher decides to produce aquaculture and he vests in aquaculture say he does two hectares of agriculture. Okay, he is going to be able to produce a quantity of protein on those two ectors that is that could free up a considerable amount of forest area or pasture area that he was using u with beef and then he could reforest that pasture area without losing income.
He would be maintaining his income level. So you could have a forest offset model in which you give people instead of telling them they can’t do something you say why don’t you invest in agriculture instead for part of your thing. We will use the forest offset money to fund you to invest in aquaculture and to then reforest the area of pasture that you no longer need to maintain the total area total amount of income or production that you want to have. So that’s one. And in a flood plane environment, you have you know more fish, more forest, more fish.
You’re not there’s no choice there. They it’s a positive benefit. So you have another way of making coverage and it decreases the productivity of fishery of making some kind of carbon argument there. I don’t know whether Matt or would like to say something about my logic on that one.
Christian:
Well, the first one sounds great. My mind is already working on that. A big part of my concern was because as you might know in regards to mangroves and efforts around blue carbon you know there’s a big threat to mangroves or is shrimp culture farming and especially it’s located in three mainly in three countries Vietnam and two other Southeast Asia countries and you know it might be I mean there ways where it is financially viable to have you know mangrove credits that would, you know, either coexist with some sustainable fish farming or be a better opportunity.
And I’ve been thinking about the margins of some areas in the Amazon and how that effort for fish farming can impact, you know, the margins or and is there a way to do it in a positive way. So, but that first piece, it is very interesting. I might contact you to maybe get a contact information from the man german you mentioned to see if that can be, you know, further structured.
David McGrath:
Yeah, he’s right there. Matt Warren on the screen. Oh, got it. You’re on mute, Matt.
Jonah Wittkamper:
You’re on mute, Matt. Right. I can’t hear him.
Unidentified participant:
We can’t hear you, but you don’t look like you’re on mute. Can you guys hear me right now? Yeah.
Matt Warren:
Oh, okay. I had to switch my microphones. Sometimes Zoom does this to me. Still trying to figure out that issue. But yeah, anyways, I think, you know, all that’s I, you know, all that’s been said is pretty spot-on. I think it’s just another tool in the toolbox. You know, shifting away from deforestation intensive land use to more integrated systems. So as we think about shifting towards things like silva silvo pastoral systems or agroforestry systems when we’re talking about trying to increase sustainability in agricultural production we also now can start talking about aquaculture which provides a great alternative revenue stream that’s that is indeed forest friendly and then also as Toby mentioned it also incentivizes forest protection within the watershed.
So there’s you know you have more forest in a watershed, you have more productive aquatic communities, more productive fish and then you have that opportunity to supplement farm incomes which is really important especially for smallcale farmers. So yeah, I think it’s, you know, it does fit in well with as a co- benefit of carbon programs and I believe it could be you know, very similar to what’s going on with the sustainable mangrove management and blue carbon projects. You know, it’s these things all kind of go hand in hand. So be interesting to explore more for sure.
Jean-Louis:
Yes, that is very interesting. Toby if I may I have two quick questions. One and thinking about the audience for this call the role that investors or philanthropist funders can play and maybe taking philanthropists on one side or grant makers and then investors on the other. For philanthropists, what kinds of programs do you see as being critically needed in order to build capacity, advance the capacity of the system, or maybe it’s policy or something where grant money would be critically needed? And then if you were an impact investor, what are some of the opportunities that you see that you’re especially excited about?
David McGrath:
Well, let’s see. I have mostly dealt with the philanthropy side. I’m only now getting into the other side of this process and I’m learning. So, I’m not sure I’m very useful on that one. The philanthropy side, I think the real problem is that most conservation is about forests and preserving conserving forest biodiversity. There are few organizations that pay much attention to the potential of managed fisheries. One I see Meg Cusheen is on here from Tinker. She’s been a supporter of our work for a long time at through the Ticker Foundation.
They’re one of the few. I think the in some areas the Moore Foundation has some work on that. And then I run out of alternatives. You know, there’s a new foundation in Brazil, the Jabesi Foundation, which is interested in fish, and I think growing interest in aquaculture. But I think that it’s the paradigm is so focused on forests and we have a generation of specialists on what to do about ranching and beef. And they haven’t really sort of other things don’t really get on the on the you know the what do you call it?
Get onto the screen. And I think fish is a huge one. You know, when I point out to people, I mean, I was shocked when I looked at the FAO data and saw that fish was, you know, three times, you know, way more important on the global market than beef. You know, you always talk about beef in Brazil in the Amazon. So, you always think that’s the thing that everybody’s eating in the world, and it’s not, you know, and it’s not at all. But that’s a huge piece of information that we should be building on, you know.
Jean-Louis:
Great. Maybe just a little net. And you’re probably aware of these groups, but I’m wondering if groups like the Packard Foundation that has been very active in both climate of course and on seafoods as well. And so there’s a little cluster of foundations. And they work closely with the Moore Foundation actually in some other collaboratives whether there could be a little you know network to be developed and of course Jonah you may have some folks in mind as well.
David McGrath:
Yeah right well one thing I would say there’s a whole lot of difference between freshwater fisheries and ocean fisheries there’s lots of interest in funding for ocean stuff and you go down you say oh they’ve got fish on their list of things that you they’re going to support and you immediately run into the fact that they’re ocean fisheries. They’re not interested in inland fisheries. So, the real hole is inland fisheries.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Thank you. I have one question about numbers. So we see those numbers out of FO FAO saying that fish really dominates international trade. Do are those numbers also reflective of consumption? So for example, from what I understand, 80% of the beef that’s produced in Brazil is consumed inside of Brazil. So its exports are not are not reflective of, you know, the total volume of consumption. Do you know if that 40% of 41% of global market share of trade and animal protein is just for international trade or is it a reflection of consumption as well?
David McGrath:
Well, presumably it’s food fish, so it’s getting consumed somewhere. I’d have to go I don’t go deep enough into FAO statistics to I’m a little worried about them, scared about using them because I’m not sure what’s behind them. If it’s anything like the numbers that Brazil was producing, then we’re in trouble. But yeah, I you know, I think if you look at production numbers, for example, then beef is much higher up and the difference with fish is much lower. And well, poultry blows everybody else. Well, it poultry grew faster. It’s not bigger in global trade.
And then they’ve got something that they now call supply. And I’ve never really figured out what supply is, but it’s their attempt to get at demand and, you know, at global trade and production and how to look at those. I at some point I need to do a very deep dive into FAO statistics so that I’m I know what I’m using and what I’m talking about.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Fish caught in international waters, ocean fish that are unclaimed by any country might be might fit in international trade whereas domestic production might not. Just a thought. Yeah. I don’t I mean I probably it’s less where it was caught and where it was landed that’s getting into the statistics, you know, right?
Unidentified participant:
I have a very short question if it’s still time.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Yeah, go first. Yeah, I’m sorry. I just joined a even after the talk 20 minutes ago because there was some confusion with a with a time frame. But so probably you tackled already what I want to ask. We work in with the indigenous community in Acra, Brazil, the honey queen, and we see that they have a big problems about getting their protein because the rivers are empty in the area we’re working and also so are the forests. So for us, it’s very interesting to implement. But my question was what do you feed them?
What do you feed the fish? Is the main thing that because they have to live from something and I’m worried about they have a hard time even feeding poultry because not so much corn available. Mhm. Not enough in the area where we’re working and don’t speak about any animal protein source. So that there would be nothing available there. So what would be the solution?
David McGrath:
Well, that’s a complicated question without knowing a lot more about the situation. I mean, I think what most people that are doing aquaculture are doing are they’re doing one of two things, neither of which is much use in your case. One is they’re either using commercial feeds or in some cases and infuriating their neighbors. They’re going out and catching fish and feeding them to their fish in the tank in their aquaculture ponds. Right. So that’s, you know, that’s just sort of cannibalizing your resource. So I, yeah, I don’t know. I mean, sounds like they got a hard problem and they need to probably go to, you know, who knows?
I mean, maybe game animals like peckeries or something. Fence in peckeries and let them go or something. Something that’ll eat, you know, what they produce in their gardens. Manio, right? But for most fish you would.
Unidentified participant:
Need some kind of animal protein, right? To feed to the fish.
David McGrath:
Well, depends on what the fish eats. You know, if you’re getting herbiviverous fish, ones that feed on alga and you know, microorganisms and stuff, solar plankton, phytolanton like the map, then that’s what they’re eating and you can go with that. But you’d have to have a system for producing the algae, you know, the phytolankton that they would be eating or the zop plankton. I’m not sure which it is. Is tambaki.
Unidentified participant:
Okay. Yeah, I have to do some research on it. Yeah.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Is tambaki carnivorous or herbivorous? They’re mostly fruit eaters. They seem they may have an early phase when they’re sort of carnivorous or omnivorous in the sense of going after other amugas but I mean they’re well known for their eating fruit and nuts and stuff like that on the flip plane. A lot of these species go through life changes in diets over their life cycle.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Yeah. Also as a followup to Jean Louise’s question, one thing that I often find helpful in developing a philanthropic strategy is figuring out priorities. You know, so if you had a million dollars to spend on research or market development or you know, what have you, you know, which corner of the for of the aquaculture managed fishery market would you aim at first? Just sort of because knowledge or discovery or awareness of that issue would lead to many other issues falling in place. Do you have a recommendation for aquaculture?
Unidentified participant:
Or managed fisheries or managed fisheries.
David McGrath:
Well, I think with aquaculture you’re in a better situation. You have you know, it’s a supply chains are more less complicated and things. I think I think you really need to well one of the things we’re doing is like how do we structure local markets so that they value sustainably managed fish. That would be for smallcale fisheries. And that’s important, you know, to be able to if you want to be marketing and moving sustainably produced fish into national international markets, you really have to develop that culture locally first so that people are aware and sensitive and working that way.
Or you’re competing against sort of other things. I don’t feel like I’m coming up with any good ideas for you right now. I shouldn’t be thinking about this, Jonah. I will think about this and come up with some I think it’s in fisheries in the Brazilian Amazon, there’s so much that needs to be done to get the groundwork. I mean, the policies need to be there. If it’s if you don’t have the policies in place, then you’re fighting against illegal fish all the time. Developing markets and I think there’s one area that people have been working with that I think has potential is identifying and working with restaurants of high-end restaurants with chefs that are value fish and Amazon cuisine and ingredients.
That’s important in Peru and Lima and it’s important in Santaren and it’s important in some of the other major Amazon cities. So there is a an angle in to educate people on Amazon fish through those kinds of activities starting at the high end getting people excited about Amazon fish. The searai people have done marketing center to identify the urban markets in Brazil that have high consumption rates of fish and focus on those. And I would say internationally I would do that because I think that Brazilian fish, Amazon fish, given the low rate of consumption of fish in the Brazilian market and the dominance that tilapia has now, we need to look outside the Amazon for potential markets.
So finding places where people eat a lot of fish, where they’re open to new fish. I learned of a restaurant in New York City where they eat you could get akadi. Akadari is the armored cat catfish which is a favorite of people in Santana. And I would not have thought that you would find in a restaurant in New York. But this was a restaurant that specialized in a whole range of different fish species that you could go there and get, you know. And a friend of mine, a native Amazonian, is very pleased with that situation.
But I think there is a role for you know identifying these kinds of places and channeling fish into them you know a high-end well taken you know fish that is an excellent quality when it hits the market you know and building up a base overseas for fish you know and for agriculture you know I think they’re developing entry into the national market, but they’ve got to develop the products for that. And I think there’s a huge opportunity for just marketing strategies to say, hey, if you’re eating Amazon fish, you’re helping conserve forest.
You are if you’re eating managed fish, you are supporting indigenous and traditional populations in the Amazon because those are the ones that are producing those fish, you know. So building on those connections and people’s interest and concern about the Amazon, I think fish, that’s a very useful strategy.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Sylvia, I’d like to encourage you to share your email address and anyone else who wants to network with others on this call, please feel free to share your contact information. Go ahead, Christian.
Christian:
A quick question here on the lines that you just mentioned, Toby. I is the is the fish farming in Amazon is production steady through the year through the year because one thing we all know about it’s one of the most amazing things about the Amazon is how much the water level varies sometimes 60 to 100 feet every year every six months and wouldn’t that impact fish farming in other words can you can you have a steady supply through the year or is that seasonal?
David McGrath:
Well, the agriculture is mostly done on dry land. It’s not done in the river where it’s done in ponds on the river. For example, the operation I know in front of Santang on the flood plane, they have trouble big floods, they lose a lot of fish. But for those that are doing cage aquaculture, that’s not a problem. Oh, because their cage just goes up and down with it, you know. So, so yeah, those kinds of seasonality issues would not be an issue.
Christian:
Okay, that was my question. Thank you. Yeah,.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Fiona, do you want to talk about this report that you just pasted?
Fiona Banister:
Oh, sure. I just I’m a very small collaborative investor in Aqua Spark and I just feel that it’s always on the top leading edge on some of the research that we can develop and so I just thought it was a vital set of articles. It’s a 96 page report and love to share if anybody needs further introduction through to Aquaspark and the scientists and I think it just frames out some of the multiple actions around the globe. Aquaspark is a Holland Dutchbased actually it’s not in Amsterdam, it’s outside of Roderdam.
And group and it’s Amy Novagrats and some of her family members that have really aligned with a few American investors. We are a part of it through our donor advised funds as well as doing some more European investors that have backed it. But when you just talked about alternative fish feeds for example, we’ve done a lot of studies over the years and keep doing relating to black far blackfly larvae looking at alternative fish feeds obviously glycospatree fish feed as well as the aquaculture and aqua fishing industries. So again I’m just a resource to pass on.
Fabulous resources.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you. Great. Thank you very much. I already grabbed it.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. Anyone else like to introduce themselves or ask questions? It’s open mic session.
Jean-Louis:
Yeah, maybe to follow up on what Toby you said about funders and what is needed and I think many sectors experience what you just described here right which is that we know there are funders that have coalesed around some issues that are very active that are very well organized wellcoordinated in some ways and this sounds like an area where there’s both enormous potential but also lack of organizing let alone funding right well lack of funding let alone organizing around funding so I don’t know maybe there could be some follow up around that and John I’m sure you and your group are thinking about it already but you know to see like and really thinking about a group like the packet foundation for just as an example while it’s true that they’ve primarily invested in oceans they’re just very keen to invest in sustainable seafoods and climate mitigation at scale.
Mhm. Right. So these are two different programs but I think if a case could be made as you made it on this call right and maybe made a little more detailed that you know there is a very strong case for investing in Amazon fisheries of a certain kind when I say investing it’s putting some philanthropic money right because the investment side would be different but there are kind of enabling conditions to be created for a group of funders that to Jonah’s point could together bring say a million dollars would be a really exciting proposal to put together and it’s hard to imagine that given the moment we’re in that you know we couldn’t find some people very interested in doing that.
Well, anyways, just as a as a little followup, and I can’t even imagine that a massive amount of work given the knowledge that you and your colleagues have, right? I mean, you already have a lot of that knowledge. It needs to be aggregated in some way, but then it’s a matter of finding who are the folks and how to organize them to start flowing money into these beautiful projects.
David McGrath:
Yeah. Well, I forgot to mention that the Moore Foundation is developing an aquac aquatic conservation program. We’ll see how that develops and where it goes, but that’s another example. And to your point about philanthropy, I think the Jotabesi work or at least the their approach to fisheries and also the German government IKI have been very focused on supply chains. And so yes, we want managed fisheries and we want fish projects that are going to strengthen their supply chains. So I think that’s in the direction that you’re talking about in terms of developing the capacity to you know generate market support for sustainable fisheries in places like the Amazon and hopefully for agriculture as well.
Jean-Louis:
Yeah. Well, not to go too far here, but the more Foundation works very closely with Packard Energy, a few others already. So, there could be just an interesting little even just getting them together in a meeting and say, “Hey, you know, these are some opportunities.” And even half a million would go a really long way. And for groups like that, that’s really not a whole lot of money, right?
David McGrath:
Yeah, it’s true. Yeah.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. We’re reaching we’re reaching the top of the 90 minute mark. Does anyone else have any questions or things to add? Otherwise, I think maybe we can call it a wrap. For those of you who are new to the call, please feel free to share your email addresses with me. Just for future invites. Toby, thank you so much for your time.
David McGrath:
Thank you for the opportunity. Yeah, you bet. There’s clearly a lot more that needs to be learned. So, we’ll we’ll revisit this in many moments.
David McGrath:
Good, good, good. Well, I want to thank all of you for participating in your excellent questions and you’ve got lots of things I need to learn more about so that I better prepared. But yes, it was really very useful experience for me. Thank you.
Unidentified participant:
Great. Thank you. Great presentation. All right. Good. Take care all of you and maybe we’ll do this again. Definitely will. All right. Bye. Bye.
Unidentified participant:
Bye.
Jonah Wittkamper:
James, are you still there?