The Quest for Land Rights and Tenure
Nonette Royo: Today we learn about indigenous land tenure. Traditional indigenous territories encompass 22 percent of the world’s land and 80% of the planet’s biodiversity, but governments only recognize legal ownership of a fraction of it, thereby putting lives and ecosystems at risk. The International Land and Forest Tenure Facility serves as a financial mechanism to help traditional communities secure land rights and live sustainably. It supports communities globally, including in the Amazon. Nonette Royo, the Executive Director of the Facility, joins us to tell the story.
Recorded January 18, 2021
WATCH:
Participants
- Jonah (moderator)
- Nonette Royo
- Fiona Banister
- Participant — European Forest Institute
- John
- Marita
- Unidentified participants
Transcript
Jonah:
Hello everybody. This is the 29th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing forest friendly economic development across the Amazon region, all nine countries of the Amazon region of South America. This week we are featuring the work of the Tenure Facility and Nonette Royo. Without more ceremony, I would like to invite Nonette to introduce herself. Nonette, who are you? Tell us a little bit about your background and how you came to this work on tropical forest and indigenous people.
Nonette Royo:
Thank you. Thank you, Jonah. I’m very glad to be here. I am a human rights lawyer by profession. My indigenous people commitment came all the way back when I was growing up in Mindanao, southern Philippines. My father is a healer. He has ingrained in me the history of the displacement of his three generations before his pe people and that connected me deeply with the land I was with and the neighbors that I grew up with and it was a land of conflict. So a big part of my whole life was about looking for ways to ensure that people neighbors talk to each other about the land and nature.
So then of course having been exposed to that I had moved on to really looking at environment and its connection with the practices of the people who live in forests and that with friends of the earth I at that time we started talking about that nexus of indigenous peoples and forests and the role of indigenous peoples in ensuring that the last standing forests are protected. So that’s about 35 years ago. I moved to Indonesia, you know, in between and spent 20 years there working many levels with indigenous peoples, village governments, local governments, provinces, programs, bilateral, multilateral, centered on the role of the people that protect forests.
This work in Sweden, we’re based here in Sweden. It almost is like a congregation of all those years having worked in Southeast Asia and connected with the networks of indigenous peoples globally around those years as well in Latin America and the Congo basin. So Rise and Resources Initiative found me and I found them when they set up the Tenure Facility way back in 2014. It’s a Washington DC based group. I was then with the advice and resources as a member our organization invited to apply and I since then set up the office here 2017.
It’s now independent from the rights and resources initiative and we partner directly with indigenous people’s groups. The modality is really a grant and it is in that area that I stop I guess.
Jonah:
We’ll we’ll get to that in a second. But backing up a little bit, can you tell us how indigenous populations compare to the rest of us as stewards of forest conservation?
Nonette Royo:
Yeah, there are two key elements that really stand out and it is relationships with nature that is not separate from the individual and the community. So as indigenous peoples the vision of that being separate is un unthinkable. The source of food but also the source of everything. Spirituality, culture is in forests and landscapes that protect and ensure this millennia of knowledge really. And so there comes a point where decisions are made especially to ensure that this relationship is reciprocal and intergenerational and those decisions over time have been challenged and modernity and aspirations for development.
Add to the complexity of that. But for all of us that have faced and tried to solve these problems, there is in indigenous peoples the clarity of that lifestyle and that relationship and that inter interdependence and reciprocity that many don’t have. Can you tell us a little bit about the difference that land rights and land tenure makes for indigenous populations? There is a right now and up to now this importance to protect and translate that protection into instruments that can defend the territory especially the forests. So the especially now the threats are coming closer to the last standing forests tenure enables and especially land rights and it’s a it’s a range it’s not ownership it’s also different types of co-management stewardship community forest management schemes enable the community and especially in this case is place places where there are guardians that are really clearly doing the work to defend that work to protect it to participate.
So there are areas where there’s land use decisions that are being made and the community groups that are directly present in that in that community in that area are self-defined and the government is needing inputs and also ensuring that they’re talking to the right people. So tenure clarifies all of those questions and it puts in place that which that element which is difficult to always obtain the information in the in the village and the districts with the maps that is that comes with registration of tenure.
Jonah:
So getting back to where we left you off be before I got into the questions. Tell us about the Tenure Facility creation story. When did it start? How are you guys funded? How much are you guys regranting to local communities?
Nonette Royo:
Yes. So it was designed with deep consultations with indigenous stakeholders, indigenous peoples in 2014. Is an extensive process for that and the conclusion is that indigenous peoples have found it very difficult to access larger funding to secure the territories and often these funding comes through you know forestry programs gender programs community development rural livelihoods It’s not specific to land rights and land tenure. So the idea is to dedicate this institution, the Tenure Facility to enable it to finance larger funds directly to the groups that could continue doing the work using the legal system that allows them or provides them that process to register themselves.
And so the grants would be ranging from $800,000 to a million dollar a year for three years renewable three rounds and it’s so it’s not small and it is dedicated and UNOPS and different surveys that were done prior to the setup of the Tenure Facility has found out that none of these organizations not even the World Bank provide that amount of money specifically for tenure. So we set it up such that there is capacity to do it as well. And yes and that’s essentially where we are different from other organizations.
We build that capacity and we essentially work with the ones that are already having a momentum in the area of recognition and working with the government units that could do it with them.
Jonah:
And where does the funding originate from?
Nonette Royo:
Okay, it sorry it originates right now from mainly from Sweden and Norway. So Scandinavian countries. It’s a climate funding for the Norwegian government Nurad Niki and but it is for Sweden. It is global environment and development. So it also looks at environ environment but there is also equality and poverty alleviation in that in that pot. So for Nicki it’s only forest countries that we can dedicate the funding for. That’s 80% of our funding and it’s averaging $12 million a year growing in as we speak. Yeah.
Jonah:
Awesome. Can you tell us which countries of the Amazon region you guys are supporting and tell us a little bit about those countries and maybe give us some country bycountry detail?
Nonette Royo:
So yes, so in the Amazon basin we are currently funding Colombia, Peru and Guyana and there are initiatives that are coming in from Ecuador and Brazil. So for the current one in Peru, this is our third round and it is largely in Lorettto and Madrid provin provinces. It’s working in tandem with the ministry of agriculture that’s in char in charge of titling and the ministry of culture and ministry of environment and it is done in part active partnership with indigenous groups but through a selected a agent NGO that is SPDA they have anou and they have a very transparent process of prioritization of communities for titling.
And this enables the indigenous organizations and the local governments they work with actually to assign technical people in the local in the provincial government and in the ministry. Yeah. So that’s that’s for Peru. H so far we have had that’s the largest the most advanced in terms of getting community titles approved. We at the moment in the last three years got to up to 3.5 million hectares of communities under title and 2.5 million for the process of really ensuring the protection of the uncontacted tribes and.
Jonah:
Can you just repeat those numbers are amazing. Can you just repeat those numbers again? So 3.5 million hectares.
Nonette Royo:
Areas that had already been titled in to communities. So it’s at the moment there’s about I’m 70 communities that have that received this and then the special process in the uncontacted tribes is more of a legal ensuring that the legal protection is applied and not violated and that there is a consistency in government policy to ensure that process. So that’s.
Jonah:
Colia.
Nonette Royo:
And in Colombia this is a process that we work two different ways actually three first with Afro descendants and their claims in not in the Pacific co coast but more to expand the titling of the territories in the areas where there are forests because they have co-managed many of the boundary forest boundaries in these area in these locations. Second is with the Tyrrona tribe working in collaboration with the land agency to commit to the setting up of an observatory for land rights ensuring that there the more of those titled territories are really protected and then expanding.
And then the third one is working with GAA in preparation for a big grant that the Norwegian government in the end provided directly with their local partner the rainforest foundation Norway in Colombia. So the await the Tenure Facility provided the support for the preparation of that big grant and that’s covering the boundaries to the Amazon the entire stretch of territories that are autonomous regions in Colombia autonomous indigenous territories. But now that’s that’s under Gaia. So that’s for Colombia. And then for Guyana, it’s working with the APA, the peoples of Gosh, I it’s an organization of indigenous peoples in Guyana that’s working with their own the district that is pure indigenous districts in several territories in the border of the Amazon.
The idea is that they are able to they will be able to with advanced maps really work with the Ministry of Land and Environment to set to set and finalize those boundaries in Guyana. And in that process actually the because Guyana is a NICE partner the aspiration is to assist the government in the delivery of that their targets for low emissions development.
Jonah:
Yeah. Great. Tell us a little bit about your future plans for Ecuador and Brazil.
Nonette Royo:
For Brazil. It’s it’s currently being developed through Coyabi. So, Coyabi has many member organizations and it’s a it’s an association of indigenous territories. They are prioritizing five and they are working with the federal governments that are interested in pursuing the clear identification of these territories. They are currently looking at a million dollar a year proposal for prioritizing those five and it is it’s its submission is supposed to be next week so I can’t provide the de the very much details the other the other set is in the western Ara side province it is currently also being developed with the Yawanawa and the Ashininka councils.
They’re still talking about it and they are working with a an indigenous facilitator to prioritize. They have their title but they’re looking at assistance for governance of their territory especially because it’s it’s a big area and protection of forest there is requiring resources and that so the Tenure Facility actually has these two strain two streams one is when you we want collective title to be really finalized and recognized and also some other tenure instruments that could if it’s not title. It’s other potentially acceptable instruments for long-term management and or governance of territory.
Making decisions that enable the territo collective councils and their members to adapt and make land use such that it sustains but also are able to is a is able to integrate what aspirations for development that is sustainable would be in the territory. Story.
Jonah:
As I study the Amazon issue and I understand the obstacles to informal communities, informal income, informal associations, I can imagine that there may be obstacles of absorption capacity of grants at the [amount unclear] level. Can you tell me how you guys address that for some of these larger grants?
Nonette Royo:
Yes, it’s a it’s it’s a challenge because the conventional organizations the requirement that you know the system of understanding what a good organization is for conventional organization doesn’t always and necessarily apply to indigenous organizations. So there are two ways we address this. One is to look at an inception phase where the indigenous organization could show actually that since they have operated before and they’ve operated but for lesser amounts of funding. They are willing to go into a process of building their own capacity to set up and incrementally add the amounts that they can manage with their organizational capacity growing.
So that’s financial organizational and systems that’s required. So that’s one way inception and then an incremental implementation. And the other one is that they decide to assign an NGO with a clear agreement and participating in the process of making decisions in the pro project. They would then u assign that NGO to be their fiscal sponsor and so it would be a fiscal sponsorship arrangement with a project management unit that they participate in and it’s also important to note that the organizations that we work with are not new. So they’ve kind of operated for years.
They have negotiated the rights the laws to and the rights recognition instruments and then they would have had relationships with not only the network but also with the government that did that and did the recognition. So they are in many ways they have appeared in international negotiations. They would have represented the country for those. So these would be the type of organizations that we start working with and that comes with through the knowledge of that comes through triangulation along the way.
Jonah:
So in line with the goal of directly supporting local communities you’ve spoken about one role of NGOs is sort of midwifing that process. Are there other ways that you guys collaborate with the NGOs? Are there other roles they play?
Nonette Royo:
Yes that’s the ongoing the challenge of the facility is we come in and support the work within this system where the government provides already or the government has some either a law or a or a court decision or an implementing local government order to recognize or to work with local communities. The analysis of that and the translation of that into sort of legal instruments sometimes the capacity to take that forward is in the NGO supporting NGO. So what sometimes we do depending on what is defined as the need of the local indigenous organization is that we come in and invite and support with a contract or a subgrant an NGO that supports the indigenous organization.
So it’s kind of a collaborative agreement.
Jonah:
Great. We have a significant number of Europeans on this call. Let’s switch our focus a little bit to the flag action plan of Europe. What is the impact of the flag action plan on your efforts and tell us a little bit about its influence on Africa and do you think it could be relevant eventually for the Amazon?
Nonette Royo:
Yeah. The active work we have right now with the European Commission is in ensuring that the def deforestation free trade is really applied in country and In this case, it’s it’s several countries that we have signed that we have we have involved in the signing of the EU European Commission is to ensure that it is involving the indigenous and local community groups in the process of cleaning this chain. So that they would either be providing information for monitoring or ensuring that if these timbers is what we’re we’re really looking at is indeed taken from or in collaboration with or respecting the rights of indigenous peoples in those territories.
So it’s in that it’s in that process. So it’s timber legality and applying the existing laws and regulations that recognize indigenous people’s rights and participation in that process in the monitoring of that of that chain of legality. So it’s transparency monitoring and legality itself in that in that participation. So that definitely could and if it is and the challenge is looking at the countries in the in the Amazon that have voluntary partnership agreements or are signatory to the flag. And in I think it is Guyana is part of this and it be interesting to see.
Yeah.
Jonah:
Great. Yeah. So go ahead.
Participant — European Forest Institute:
So yeah I mean you just mentioned an issue that European forest institute is actually working on. I don’t know if the audience knows that my organization actually hostesses the EU flective facility. So meaning that we provide supports both from the pre-negotiation of one of the instrument of the fle action plan which is the voluntary partnership agreement from the pre-negotiation to the licensing phase. So as N yet indicated currently there are only two countries in Latin America or in the southern part of America that are actually engaged in the VPA process or the voluntary partnership agreement of the fle action plan.
These are Hundras and then Guana and then both countries have already signed the VP agreement meaning that they are currently what we call it at the implementation phase and the kind of support you provide that also links what the Tenure Facility is doing is that we provide supports to countries for instance to help them establish a multistakeular structure to review the different forest related laws and policies and then one of the aspect we actually look at is you know the rights of local communities, indigenous people, land right, treaty and new rights and related issues.
There where I see the overlaps or commonalities there has been I’ve been following this process for almost now 10 years and I know those different countries in the Amazon who has actually showed interest to be part of this process but for some reasons is it political or other reasons they didn’t want to engage in this kind of legally binding u political process to address or enhance governance in the forest sector. I stop there if someone has any question with regard to this action plan the fle action plan in general or one of the key element which is the voluntary part partnership agreement I’m happy to say something or comment thank you.
Jonah:
Great we have a few more questions prepared with nonette and then we can open up for questions so nonette tell us a little bit about how technology is changing the work of the Tenure Facility and what is this techn technoigenous story that I hear about?
Nonette Royo:
Yeah. So technology has advanced in leaps and bounds since we started mapping territories in Southeast Asia, in the Philippines and Indonesia. What is what’s been really apparent is that you know before we worry about good images right now that’s available we worry about you know the how the distance and the kind of GPS that we were using now that’s that’s very much available in very cheap as well. So what we have done in many ways is focus the work more on this is a social process and a technical process. So a social process really is the strength of the indigenous people’s local community groups and the support groups that we have funded and that is ensuring that at the beginning consultations are clear.
It’s based on law. It is boundaries are witnessed and are clear. And boundary negotiation is the most intricate, difficult, complex one. And that’s done. And then the technicians just come in with either their drones or their GPS’s to read it and to analyze the information and that easily gets developed into a map. And the shape files are very much u accessible. The important components of components of this is really the trust in the process and the capacity of the younger generation to catch up and to access it. So these two processes especially with technigenous has become a the conversation.
So the space in which so it’s the nexus between traditional knowledge because in the consultations there are there’s a huge effort in remembering and looking at the symbols and the totems that had become you know the basis for passing intergenerational information and so that requires a lot of really trusted facilitators and trust in the conversations and it used to be that there are there are unknowns that you cannot talk about but because of technology everything is known right now but there is still between that the space of respect and valuing and understanding with in the v in the village and passing that on to the next generation and also the commitment for the sustainability of the next generation.
So the technigenous as a conversation started between us and Natero es. It was really the initiative of Nateo to kind of open it and invite different actors that had used technology to either reflect or you or build upon traditional knowledge but never had recognized that. And to make that clear and known and also make it a trusted process and then make like needs right now be for example be addressed through a responsive set of solutions that is very much grounded in technology. So that’s an ongoing conversation and we’ve looked at that in this first session the first series but there’s another series coming up for that.
So it’s a it’s an open learning process and it’s very much by indigenous peoples themselves especially the younger generation you know catching up to the stories of the elders and vice versa and then trans transmuting that to something that they trust but also advancing it with the technology that’s emerging.
Jonah:
Thank you for that. I’m familiar with the living forest thriving communities vision. Can you tell us what is needed to ensure that tenure secure territories align with the vision of living forest thriving communities?
Nonette Royo:
Yeah, that’s it’s a deep conversation. It comes up a lot in the visioning of the planets Dvida. Yeah, the importance of aspiring for selfdetermined development is an iterative it’s it’s it’s very prominent and it’s an iterative process and that talks about so it’s that they’re not community groups indigenous that are sort of preserved in time. They are adapting and this process of making the decision to develop requires a thinking process and looking at finance and understanding that and setting themselves up for that. So what I have been observing in the process because we our entry point is secure tenure and that enables the community indigenous peoples and local community groups and their leaders and their council and their process of consultation to really surface the aspirations and translate that.
So what I’ve observed is that secure tenure and those that are advancing in that process need to look at now what are the options. So some questions you know practical questions be yeah you have a title but can you eat that paper you know that’s the very you know stark set of questions I’ve encountered that myself in the field when we talk about this so no it has yeah so this that’s just an illustrative of the kind of questions they’re looking at so they’re looking at options what’s sustainable what would education look like for their for their next generation to be able to handle that.
This including dealing with u third party interested in the land and in and holding you know these processes of dialogue about what is development that can be accepted. And it also sometimes comes up when they are resisting something they don’t like and they need to offer something that they like and to find common ground. So that’s that’s the challenge and also the as inspiration of those indigenous and local community groups that are really facing what is development and what does that mean for them into the future.
Jonah:
Second to last question here. What emerging efforts have you made to connect indigenous populations with commerce, income generation and external markets and entrepreneur opportunities?
Nonette Royo:
Yeah. So this is the thank you that nexus of rights based approaches and benefit sharing comes to this. So there are tenure secure places now where there can they can offer or be eligible for payments for ecological footprint payments for carbon restoration. So these are the questions that are now coming up. Panama is one case where they have advanced so much in getting their tenure recognized their decisions in courts have reaffirmed that they are positioned in the key sort of 2.9 million hectares of forests right now there. So they’re saying don’t give us grant money and small amounts of money.
We would like to be able to present ourselves to with this vision with a vision to our government and to whoever would like to work with us and pay and generate the resources that we need but nailed to the vision of sustainability and protection of forests and lands that are available. So there is where we can kind of bring the tenure secure communities to a level of readiness institutionally to then meet the other party the other sector and here the private sector is really one and go towards the next step and that is a point where we do not kind of creep beyond the mission but turn it over to a set of players that could then take it further.
Jonah:
Great. So I want to encourage everyone to go ahead and start preparing questions. Feel free to paste them in the chat. Feel free to go ahead and raise your hand. I have just one more and then we’ll go to who’s ever first of the questions. In all your work, Nonat, is there something else that needs to be said? You have something else, other insights to share that we haven’t covered yet?
Nonette Royo:
Yeah. There is there is a challenge and an assumption also that and it is true that talking about land rights is something that the that is considered advocacy. It’s activist. It’s, you know, it’s not it’s not riskfree and we’re always looking for risk-free efforts to invest in e even in you know in grants. What I’m realizing is that the very needs that are out there that if not addressed cause conflict are the very things that our partners are working on. And this is really just clarifying the rights knowing where they are, agreeing to who and what is out there and who’s in charge and then so unusual partners happen.
Yeah. So the government that didn’t used to want to talk to the local community groups that are seen as in opposition are talking and this generally comes when there’s an urgency to really resolve or there is a vision that can kind of marry the two interests. So unusual partnership can occur. That’s one lesson that I have. And at the moment the trends in the Paris agreement and climate so and sustainable development and the CBD the biodiversity goals are merging and with the pandemic this has become very prominent as well. So that there is there a kind of a reminder that the our common aspirations come together in a place where there is still the knowledge of a millennia.
That’s reminding us that we actually all know it. Our ancestors, indigenous, non- indigenous, went through this process of learning. And that’s something that can be remembered when we work with groups indigenous peoples local organizations that are grounded in these processes themselves.
Jonah:
Thank you, Nonette. First up, Fiona Banister.
Fiona Banister:
Thank you. So Nonette, thank you. Also, I want to say for supporting Paco or Franchesco and the Hilderbrand family and the indigenous tribes in their work in through the Colombian basin. It’s been a long journey and it will continue. I wanted to look at innovative financing structures. As a small seed investor in forests and global forests. We have forests in our portfolio from Ghana through sorry through I’m just thinking more western pines type things are in u New Zealand. We have forests and inventments into Panama. And we’re looking at how do we innovatively structure a longevity fund for these assets holding the spirit of the indigenous people as they are the keepers and the stewards of this.
And my second side to that is we are collaboratively working with Futura Forestal and the generation forest model out of Panama. And those models again mostly we have European family investors and it’s scaled to such a degree that it will expand quite rapidly and the area that we’re looking at in that forefront is collective responsibility so mostly it’s always been European investors and how do we hinge that CSR as well as the corporate social responsibility to groups like Walmart through using 8% of the Panama Canal is actually used to transport goods through without paying for any of the fresh water or the resources and that sort of also matches many of the issues for Colombia.
So opening that. Oh, and I my last one is that Fasamazonus also I’ve been working with Fasamazonus as a volunteer in Brazil looking at their business models. So open to express some answers. Thank you.
Unidentified participant:
Lynette.
Nonette Royo:
Yeah, I wish I have more. Yes. Thank you for asking and I’m very interested to talk more with you. The elements that is for longevity really is in this vision and a common and a common understanding of the challenges and the of the institution to navigate that carry that one out and understanding that there’s limits to certain components of the parts of let’s say in a community or in an institution. Ution if they register themselves there their limits but there are such potentials and that and it’s interlin with their relationship not just as individuals with their family and community but also with their district or their village in their district and the land use that’s determined within that yeah and the and the decisions that are being made in that process.
So it’s it’s it’s not that complex if we start from a certain point and u and in this case it really is looking at what’s common and also what’s what’s what’s a first step towards something you know that would be braver you know some so it’s it’s starting small but also starting clearly with an idea that this is addressing a need and not just common ground but maybe a higher ground. Sometimes common ground is finder to have a harder to find what harder to find but then there is a higher ground that I think aspirations are meeting and then translating that you know clearly such that there are no expectations that you know can be or disappointments it’s it’s yeah I think it’s it’s practical for each and it’s unique in context and I think that’s where I hope I hope Yeah.
Yeah. I to learn from what you’re doing too. Yeah.
Jonah:
No and Fion and I encourage you guys and anybody to share your email addresses in the chat so that people can follow up with each other directly. Next up we have a double question from Yeu followed by John.
Unidentified participant:
I just because know that you have such you know extensive experience looking at your web page on LinkedIn and then you know listening you I really wanted to hear what are examples of positive change that you have seen happening in the context of tenure resource environmental governance. Could you name a specific success story? You know that has actually happened in a specific country in a specific place in that context. Thank you.
John:
Yeah. And hello I was just going to piggyback on that question and if you also have one that maybe has to do with linking innovative technologies to indigenous communities. That would be fantastic. Thank you.
Nonette Royo:
Yeah. So I in some of the stories in the website there are but what I can point to that’s really pulpable and concrete are what’s happening in so Panama, Indonesia, Peru. Yeah. So, so what’s common is that there is an even bise right now where we also have work worked there is the emerging momentum towards something and in Indonesia the momentum is in the districts defining villages and districts self-defining their priorities for lowcarbon development and that generally is informed through the you know bottom up through a planning process that meets the top down mid medium-term development planning of the government and where it has come together is when the districts issue regulations that include the maps of the territories the indigenous people’s groups in Indonesia and when that happens what has not happened before has happened that keeps happening is that on the table are the even before the title even before that are the indigenous groups that have the stake in that decision and they’re participating actively and they’re informing and they’re and then key decisions that are adaptive like say protect this watershed don’t cut over there reforest here you know plant here are very clearly done and made yeah and there is this really unique levels of convergence and it doesn’t mean there’s no conflict.
There is but there’s a process of talking about it and there are trusted representatives from the border you know of the different villages that talk about it and try to resolve it and so it minimizes and a big challenge in for example conflicts is the lack of clarity in the policy that applies. It’s not even refusal to receive the you know the input or the or the recognition. It’s that the policy that applies was either dated or was not appi the new one was not applied or there was a misunderstanding and so all of that becomes clearer in the process.
This. So this is really interesting to pursue as long as this communication continues and if there the ideal situation there’s never an ideal situation there’s always a l like capturing land there’s a commodity coming in there’s always this yeah but you can always find these elements and it’s it’s so that’s what’s happening for example in Indonesia to a level that even the president is calling these very actors into the office to talk about these solutions and to really concretely implement them and none of the big projects are called into these meetings.
It’s internal and why it’s because their citizens are the ones that are acting are our partners. They’re not even bringing our name because we’re just really supporting a process that they have set out. They are bringing that into the conversation where the ministers would have to listen to it too. Yeah. And influence that process. So this I’m I’m I’m talking concrete terms about the recent meetings that have happened for example in Indonesia. The same in Liberia. Yeah. And the same so that’s Liberia. It’s happening. In Peru it’s the same. And there even in these places where they’re shifting positions in politics but there are relationships in the you know not the heads but the people that are running the show in every unit in every office.
Yeah. So that’s and that’s a continuing process. It’s aggregating over time and it just really needs to be bridged in such a way that it’s useful for those that are coming in and not duplicating and confusing. That’s the other thing is this coordination is complicated because projects come with larger funds and they’re they’re not they’re coming in with their own log frames and they’re not understanding that there is a logic to this that’s continuing. It’s not project based. It’s it’s long-term and it’s understanding that logic that actually grounds it and so working with the actors that are not there for the project is really important.
So that’s that’s the and technology has helped so much now because of because of a lot of things you know even just if you go to a landscape and in places where we have worked they actually have a time series information what’s happening now versus what was happening 15 years ago. They also have drones now to monitor and describe what they do. So it’s a very inspiring process to see that and there’s also their access to for example Zoom and computers because of because of the pandemic there’s more reallocation funding to computers and to internet accounts and they have more people participating you triple the level of in interest and participate and essentially accountability because of it and technology is really added to that.
You know we would not have known that if there was not no pandemic know that can that can empower in a way that it has. So that’s the that’s the that’s just some examples.
Jonah:
So, we have one minute left. Nette, if we wanted to learn as much as we can about the land tenure challenge, is there a book or a movie or a website or an article that you would recommend that we all read?
Nonette Royo:
We have some stories in currently in the website, but there are more films that are emerging from this. So that would be good to access and these would come from the partners themselves as it’s probably in their websites or and their co-writing. So that’s and then there are some writeups that I can provide but maybe through an email to you and then you can send it also.
Jonah:
Great. Can you say your website just for the podcast?
Nonette Royo:
Yes, I will write it here: thetenurefacility.org. The Tenure Facility.org.
Jonah:
Great. Okay, this is now we’re at the top of the hour, so the call is now officially over, but we leave the room open for what I call water cooler time, people to connect and talk with each other in an unstructured way. Thank you, Nonette, for joining us. You’re certainly welcome to stay around. Yay. Thank you so much for having me. I’m I’m I’m thrilled to share. Lots of beautiful comments coming over the chat. Anybody got any questions or announcements or news to share or questions for Nonette?
Unidentified participant:
I have one. Go for it. Sorry.
Jonah:
Go for it. You Jessu.
Participant — European Forest Institute:
Yeah. Excellent. It’s not specifically to but to everybody. A couple of things. First is we’re conducting one global study where we are looking at cases where trees and plantations and land use rights are used as collaterals for you know for loans or mortgage. And then in case if you come across with that kind of cases, please let me know. I will drop my email down there in the chat box.
Nonette Royo:
Yes, that would be Yeah, I’d be thrilled.
Participant — European Forest Institute:
Excellent.
Nonette Royo:
Thank you. Thank you. Glad to connect with you.
Participant — European Forest Institute:
You can call me the first four letters is really difficult to pronounce. That’s an Ethiopian name.
Unidentified participants — boundary unclear:
Okay. Wonderful. Yes. Excellent. And the second thing is that European forest institute together with the sustainable market initiative under the world economic forum we launched the global alliance called circle by economy alliance and some of the activities that nonet you are doing also linker to that and I will drop the link in the chat box. Please have a look at it and if you are interested you can Okay, it’s already there. Yeah, you can actually send us email. We are always ready to actually share our activities and maybe look for potential collaborations and synergies and that’s how we got to know about YA.
Nonette Royo:
Okay, wonderful. Yes, thank you. Thank you for this. Yeah,.
Jonah:
I know others will have questions for you guys.
Unidentified participant:
I could.
Jonah:
Go for it.
Unidentified participant:
No, Ned, I this isn’t actually a question and I apologize. I just wanted to I never do this, Jonah, so I hope you’ll I’ve been on 17 calls so I hope you forgive me. You’re I just want to thank you for your work. I’ve heard a lot of presentations here and a hundred times as many out in the world. And I love the way that your work is so focused on the community, on the people. And I love that you mentioned spirituality and consider the entire life of the indigenous people their entire experience and everything that you do.
And I just want you to know that you know other people are probably properly embarrassed to say this, but I just want to thank you for your work outside of all of this and for the way that you presented so beautifully. Thank you.
Nonette Royo:
Thank you so much. Yeah. Appreciate that u recognition. I’m very humbled. Thank you.
Unidentified participant:
Yeah, I wanted to second that as well. I really appreciate this and I’ll I’ll be in touch. We’re we’re trying to buy some land next to the Hunquin tribe also in an area where you’re working and once we’re through due diligence we’d love to be in touch. So thank you.
Nonette Royo:
Yes, please. Yeah, thank you. Thank you.
Unidentified participant:
All the best everybody. Bye-bye.
Jonah:
Thanks for joining us, Alan. Thanks so much, John. Any other messages of love for Nonette or other questions?
Fiona Banister:
Sure. I mean it’s it’s such a challenging area to encounter and look for resolution and looking at all the different you know thinking of that we go back to the indigenous herbs and to the cycle and the protection of those special formulas and knowing that it’s for all of us a dance to listen to first the plant. I always remind us it’s the biomimicry of the plant and then it’s the people and the stewardship and the collective. And then you know after working in land entitlement I was down in Peru working with the Hernando Stos sort of early on land entitlement and looking at how do we structure these loans and how do we support the families and their processes.
It’s it’s a such a long journey. Now we can do it with our drones. Yet we do it with the drones, but they don’t own the drones. So there’s still that argument of where does the dog bark and how do we protect each tree and support it around the community action. So, I really I was working in Panama again for the last few years, and I was so thrilled to have my collective folks in these multiple communities that now are environmental lawyers. They speak for their people. They now ask for what they need and they’re getting their land titled back to them and they are being able to take the bridge forwards and we are just helping that passage.
Thank you. That’s so beautiful. Yeah. Thank you, Fiona, for sharing. Yeah, I would really like to connect with you.
Nonette Royo:
Thank you.
Unidentified participant:
Yes, thank you.
Jonah:
Marita, did you want to share?
Marita:
It’s good. Well, I just saw some affinity with client earth u on the on the environmental legal defense side and I think this Tenure Facility is a long-term it’s it’s a long-term assistance not just to get tenure but to keep it which is a different thing and so I just wonder how you are probably already structuring yourself for that long-term task. You know, one thing is to get the titling and then the story really begins to become more complex continued and u so it would be very nice for you to keep that staying power which you showed just now.
Nonette Royo:
Yeah, thank you so much Marita for really raising that. That’s that’s the first thing that really comes to mind actually in this work that we’re not here. In fact, it’s almost like erh the thought that keeps me awake is really that we are not we cannot design ourselves to be the center and the source of support because the real center and the source for our support are these landscapes we’re supporting and that they and the people that are caring and guarding and nurturing them and that’s when we really need to ask our questions of how are we generating that they can because they are in the places and the land that can generate it and in what ways will that generate such that it supports the value that has kept them together over a millennia you know in relationship with their brother sister forests and you know all other beings.
They’re co-beings. So, so that’s that’s the one thing. And it’s so easy to forget that when we’re so much into our institutional ego and I face that every day. So, thank you. And we’ll keep thinking and drawing you into this conversation if you’re interested.
Marita:
Yes. Very good. Very good to meet you. Yes,.
Nonette Royo:
Very good to meet you.
Jonah:
And Marita’s work is part of that long-term answer, bringing the fourth industrial revolution to the bioeconomy of the forest.
Nonette Royo:
Yeah, thank you so much. Yes,.
Marita:
That’s one. But in Brazil, I work a lot on Brazil, just as a last one. And of course we and I’ve worked a lot on indigenous territories in the 1980s and 90s to get the funding for the first demarcations which today are on the map. But when you look at that map, then you see mining legal and illegal, you see that the forest and the land belongs to hopefully the indigenous people who live on the earth, but the subterranean riches at least in Brazilian legislation can belong to somebody else. So that’s why I raised and I know in two minutes we cannot discuss it here but I think it is something to keep in mind this long-term you know legal defense which local people do need and will need.
Nonette Royo:
Yes. Exactly. And that’s that’s really beyond tenure but also grounded on that connection with some kind of tenure legality and that’s what you can then that’s what we can defend.
Marita:
Over time or build upon you know or evolve.
Nonette Royo:
Yeah. Yeah. But that is so important. Yeah.
Marita:
Well, thank you very much and I hope we meet again.
Nonette Royo:
Yes. I hope so too. So, I hope I can get your email. Yeah. Yeah.
Marita:
Yeah. I will put it in the chat before I turn off.
Unidentified participant:
Let me see. Oops.
Unidentified participant:
Yeah, I got all the emails in the.
Unidentified participant:
I lost the chat thing. The chat won’t let me do on all. I’m getting there.
Unidentified participant:
Okay,.
Unidentified participant:
I can put it yours in there, Marita.
Unidentified participant:
Yeah, I’m I’m I’m getting there.
Unidentified participant:
I just put it in there. Mcco3000.org.
Unidentified participant:
That’s it. Okay.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you.
Unidentified participant:
Wonderful.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you so much.
Unidentified participant:
Bye.
Unidentified participant:
Bye.
Unidentified participant:
Bye. Bye. Thank you.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you. Thanks. Thanks, Jonah.
Unidentified participant:
It’s been really good. Yeah, thanks for this. It’s it’s it’s always very inspiring to meet people and hear from them. Yeah. I’ve been following Fireflies actually too because of last session.
Unidentified participant:
Okay.
Unidentified participant:
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Unidentified participant:
Well, thank you all. I’m moving off towards oceans next meeting, but the oceans touch the forests and it’s all one.
Fiona Banister:
So, and Jonah, you’re so inspirational. So, I wanted to take a moment to thank you for your heart, soul, and spirit to dedicate to the planet and what you’re doing and invoking us all to be deeper, more curious human beings and collective as a community. So, thank you.
Jonah:
Thanks so much, Fiona.
Unidentified participant:
Yeah,.
Unidentified participant:
I echo that. Thank you, Fiona.
Unidentified participant:
I got you.
Unidentified participant:
Bye.
Unidentified participant:
Bye.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you. Bye. Bye.
Unidentified participant:
All right. Bye. Thank you, Jonah.
Unidentified participant:
Bye. Bye. Thanks so much.
Unidentified participant:
Thanks.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you. Bye.
Unidentified participant:
Bye. Thank you.
Unidentified participant:
Yes. Bye. Bye.
Unidentified participant:
Bye. Bye. Have a good one, guys.