The Nature Crime Alliance and the Amazon
Challenges to the rule of law limit the economic development of the Amazon. Nature crimes in the region include criminal forms of logging, mining, fishing, wildlife trade, and land conversion. As one of the largest illicit economies in the world, nature crime is closely linked to terrorism, corruption, human rights abuses, financial crime, and other threats to peace and security. Set to launch in late 2022, the Nature Crime Alliance will help address these issues. It will be a global, multi-sector network that raises political will, mobilizes financial commitments, and bolsters operational capacity to fight nature crimes and related international criminal activities. Where did the idea come from? Who are the supporters to date? What are the goals? How will the Alliance help the Amazon? Join us to meet Yulia Stange, Senior Manager, Nature Crime Alliance/World Resources Institute, and learn.
Recorded June 6, 2022
References:
Charles Barber, Natural Resources Governance & Policy Director, World Resources Institute
Ruth Nogueron, Senior Associate, World Resources Institute
Nature Crime: Understanding and Tackling a Key Threat to the Climate and Land Use Agenda
How Crime Drives Deforestation in Brazil’s Amazon
Ending Tropical Deforestation: Assessing the Timber Legality Strategy in Tackling Deforestation
A Political Agenda in Conflict with Environmental Protection: A Critical Policy Essay from Brazil
Risk Tool To Help Companies Buy Legal Forest Products
Interpol Forestry Enforcement Team
WATCH:
Participants
- Sarah Ingersoll
- Yulia Stange
- Brad Spangler
- Ruth
- Grace
- Ilona
- Luis
- Kasia
- Marcelo
- John
- Ted
- Unidentified participant
Transcript
Sarah Ingersoll:
So my name is Sarah Ingresol and I’m with the Amazon Investor Coalition. I’m the chief operating and marketing officer and a co-founder of the initiative. Jonah is on his way to London as we speak to participate in a major convening of partners and organizations supported by partnerships for forests which is one of our core grantees and that’s going to be just a fantastic event. But so I’m have the honor of facilitating this wonderful conversation today. The weekly podcast that we do is very much an opportunity for key stakeholders and individuals involved in our coalition to learn more but also to connect with one another and to connect to leaders in this field.
So it is a not a kind of top-down formal presentation but really more of a conversation about the critical issues and opportunities that the Amazon Investor Coalition faces. I know most of you probably know who we are, but it’s just important to share that our goal is to improve and increase investment in the Amazon rainforest and rule of law. We’re really interested in how do we bring new philanthropy new private sector investment, new corporate engagement and procurement to work in tandem one another together reinforcing what can be a bioeconomy, a healthy bioeconomy that’s reinforcing both nature but also the communities that live in the Amazon rainforest.
So without further ado on this I wanted to introduce you to our speakers today. So the first well there’s going to be a couple one virtually but Julia am I saying that Sten is a senior manager. She works with the forest legality initiative atri. She also works with the forest program more widely the oceans program, the food and land use program. Secretariat and she’s partnering with the Meridian Institute which you’ll get to learn more about and they are working together launch a global alliance on environmental crime. The global alliance on environmental crime is a multistakeholder initiative to address illegal logging, illegal fishing, illegal mining, and illegal conversion of lands and forests to agriculture.
And we’re also going to be joined by Brad or we are joined by Brad Spangler. He’s a senior mediator and program manager at Meridian and leads Meridian’s resilience practice area. His projects have focused predominantly on advancing innovative freshwater management practices, building community resilience to disaster and climate change impacts and water se sector climate adaptation. But today I think we’re going to get to hear about even more broadly how all of these ecosystems are working together and how important it is to protect it and to support the individuals and the laws that enable us to do that.
So Julia, I hope I didn’t miss too much, but the there’s a lot there that you’ve been involved in and so I’m going to turn it over to you.
Yulia Stange:
Brilliant. So, a massive thank you to Sarah and a massive thank you to Jonah for having us on as the Nature Crime Alliance for this group for the Amazon Investor Coalition. I also have to admit there were some changes on our side. Chip and Ruth are both traveling right now. Chips in Stockholm Plus 50 and Ruth is at the Summit of Americas now. So, we’re very lucky to have Brad. So, thank you. And so, it’s not just me that you get some change in who you which voice you hear, which is great.
But what Ruth was able to do because she’s brilliant is she was able to put together her presentation and pre-record it. So, if I manage to do a screen share with my volume enough, we have tested this and I hope it works, but do give a shout if you can’t hear. And what so Ruth Neguron is a senior associate at World Resources Institute. She has been working in the Amazon for many years and she’s from Mexico, originally living in the US. And she works at the forest legality initiative working on various issues including how technology from the global forest watch program can be applied for addressing some of these nature crime issues and so she’s presenting a case study to start us off on crime convergence which is one of the themes for today you know looking at the intersection of gold mining illegal gold mining illegal drug trafficking and illegal logging in Peru.
So, I will attempt to share the screen now and hope that it works.
Ruth:
Good afternoon. Today I’m going to show you how environmental crimes converge in the Amazon, the impacts they have on local populations, and how indigenous communities are fighting back. This is the territory of indigenous community cayu in the Perumbian embassy. The territory sandwich between Colombia and Brazil. And this is an area where illegal logging and drug trafficking converge. Forests are illegally clear to grow cocoa using false information and legal documentation. The timber extracted from the indigenous territories by third parties by other people is laundered into vegan supply chains and traded in domestic and international markets.
The cockai sold to Colombians on the other side of the border for processing. And to make things worse, there is growing illegal mining, illegal gold mining in nearby rivers towards the north of the community which brings pollution and exposes people to and wildlife to mercury. Along with environmental health impacts, illegal gold mining is also associated with social conflict, prostitution and trafficking. The service of the people in Boardindu are common in the region. In 2019, in a 2019 interview with Bongab Latam, the leader of the community described a shooting between two rival drug trafficking groups in the middle of the community, invasions their territory, and the death threat that they have received.
A news report also in 2019 documented a visit from a verbal environmental prosecutor to deal with illegal deforestation. But there is some hope since 2018 when the cayu and other 35 communities in the rep in the nap river basin have been working with local with a local indigenous federations to use satellite monitoring to combat environmental threat. This animation shows the glad alerts. It is an early warning deforestation alert system that uses satellite measuring to identify areas where are lost access to the alert. Somebody needs to mute their phone. There is no civil society organization.
Sorry, I just paused it, but I’ll go back 10 seconds. Hold on. With access to the glad alerts, mobile applications, drones, and support from a civil society organization, the people from Wardin de Cayeru and other communities in the area are patrolling their territories. They are documenting invasions and illegalities, expelling invaders, and dealing with community members that do the clearing, preparing legal complaints. And they are also working with local communities to create legal cases. A recent scientific study published in the proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences showed that the monitoring activities on the 36 communities reduce the forestation in the in their territories by half in one year and by 21% in the second.
I want to show you this animation comparing the territory of Walind Cayeru in green and a neighboring community north of Wadin and in this community there is no monitoring activities. The search. If you are looking here at the glad alerts from 2020 to 2021 for both communities and you can see here you can see how they are appearing as the time passes by. But the difference in the number and the extent of the alerts in the community where there is no monitoring and inadu there is there are no known new alerts.
So this is a very positive story and there are very promising results but still much to do. There are criminal organizations operating in the area. They are still threatening the lives and livelihoods of the communities. The prosecutors and the law enforcement actors while they are paying attention and taking action they have extremely limited capacity. They operate in dangerous environments surrounded by corruption and in places where they are far away where they are unsafe and they need to travel in groups which is expensive. And when the authorities launch operations, the criminals only need to jump on a boat to sc to escape by river to Colombia or Brazil.
There is no coordination multilateral coordination between forest and law enforcement authorities. And on the other side when the communities start you know restoring their lands planting alternative or agroforestry management they need access to market. They also need capacity to conduct the restoration and in some cases access to finance. And this is one example of one community in the Veruian Amazon. This is an example that can be scaled up. And this is a list of additional resources particularly of this example in Thank you.
Yulia Stange:
Thank you Ruth in her absence. She did ask me to you know to welcome any questions and I’m happy to share that presentation with the contacts especially at the end. It’s a great example I think of something you know an example of what’s working and some of the various issues that are coming together the convergence of crime but also some of the bits that we’re hoping to address with an alliance where an alliance can see. So I’ll maybe jump into that presentation. You know she’s talking about you know looking for examples that can be scaled and it was a good example of using tools as well such as satellite imagery to help with the fight against nature crime.
So just to give you a little bit of a sense of what we’re talking about when we talk about the Nature Crime Alliance. We’re very lucky in that we had time as an interim secretariat and Brad is on the call from Meridian Institute and myself from World Resources Institute also food and land use organization was involved. The Norwegians, you know, we can talk a little bit later about how this all started, but we were really lucky that we had funding from the Norwegians who recognized quite early on through their climate and forest initiative that this nature crime is such an important issue and we need to look at ways at how we can change the scale, how we can you know make a difference by an order of magnitude greater than what we’re doing already.
And so I think so we had over a year of consultations to form an interim secretary and to have these conversations with stakeholders to really look at what we could do that would be useful. And so what we’re presenting today is a snapshot of where we’re at. And I’ll we’ll talk a little bit about where we are at the end. But first to give you a sense of what we’re talking about we’re talking about when we what do we mean by nature crime. If you move just to one slide further.
Perfect. When we talk about nature crime, as Sarah mentioned, we’re talking about illegal logging, mining, fishing, wildlife trade, land conversion, and land grabbing. And just to give you a sense of the scale of the issue, most of you are probably already aware, but Interpol estimates annual criminal proceeds of 110 to 281 billion annually. That is far exceeds several countries in GDP. As you saw in Ruth’s presentation, these crimes are increasingly converging with each other as well as with other serious crimes like drug trades, even human trafficking in some cases. And in just in terms of illegal logging, because I know many people on this call are particularly interested in timber, UNEP estimates illegal logging to exceed 50 billion, which represents almost 30% of all timber sold in the world.
And in terms of some specific examples in the Amazon, many of you are probably, you know, in the weeds in some of these countries more so than we are. But just some pretty scary scale numbers here pulled out of a 2018 report where the Ministry of Environment, for example, estimates in Colombia that 47% of timber sold is illegal. And that represents 750 million US dollars a year, which is equivalent to about a third of the drug trade. Just to give you a size of the scale, it’s not it’s right up there.
And often we’re seeing criminals trade in both drugs and in timber. And yet timber still has, you know, we have an image issue to a certain extent because illegal timber, you know, we’re we’ve already, you know, we’re in the field. We know how important it is. But in general, environmental crimes are still seen as, you know, it’s just a few trees, but they’re not victimless. They fuel all sorts of other illicit activities. So, putting it right up there with drug crimes in terms of how we talk about it, I think is one of one of the issues that the Nature Crime Alliance hopes to address.
To give you a sense of who we’ve been talking to, we’ve, you know, like I said, we were lucky enough to have a year of interim secretariat funding to really get the lay of the land. And we’ve been talking with intergovernmental organizations like UNEP, Interpol, UN Office of Drugs and Crime, which are also funded by NICVI via the law enforcement assistance program, LEAP, which some of you may have heard of. They’re quite active in Peru, as well as Papa New Guinea. We’ve talked with donors, with civil society and academics, with law enforcement officials, with governments, with indigenous people and local community groups, and also with companies and financial institutions, and really asking that question of what is working, what isn’t, what can an alliance add value, what shouldn’t an alliance do, because it would be duplicating what’s already being done.
And you know really brilliant cross-section of what stakeholders are working on and where an alliance could help amplify those efforts and bring together and connect the dots on some of these and like Ruth was talking about scale the solutions that are working again by an order of magnitude. This is a word we keep using in terms of what we came up with at the end of all of these conversations and where we’re at now in terms of our three strategic pillars. What the alliance is looking to do and what’s been informed by all these people that we’ve talked to is we want to raise the political will to pursue the powerful criminal networks and actors that commit nature crime.
And just to be clear, when we’re talking nature crime, what we define as, you know, we’re talking about the powerful organized crime syndicates. Are not going after the individual person that needs to put firewood for cooking in a national park. That’s obviously an issue as well. We need to deal with other issues, but we’re talking about the organized crime syndicates here that are powerful, operate at a global level, and are trading in multi-millions. The second pillar that we that we’re looking at is mobilizing financial commitments. The amount of money that has been committed to addressing nature crime is so far from what is needed.
And so part of what the alliance is looking to do is to raise the money needed via commitments and we’ll go more into how we’re going to do that in a second. What we’re also going to do is bolster operational capacity to better identify, disrupt, and prosecute the individuals and syndicates controlling nature crime. And we’ll talk again in the structure a little bit more about how we’re going to do that. But the real goal here is to connect the dots and to amplify what’s already working and to scale examples of work that’s already working.
Not to duplicate anything. And so that really brings us to why a Nature Crime Alliance and that’s where we’ve gotten to really looking to a step change in order of magnitude. And underlying all of this is not just the convergence of these crime types and this issue that we see, you know, there are people that look at drug trade and illegal logging and there are people that look at the convergence of wildlife trade and illegal logging or for example. But overall people the nature crime finders nature crime fighters or the nature defenders as we call are called starting to call them are more still operating in these by crime type whereas what we’re seeing is that the drug sorry the crime syndicates are increasingly commodity neutral.
And so there’s much more nimleness and flexibility amongst the criminals in going to where the money is than those structures and programs that we have in place to fight the crime. And that’s what we’re trying to change with the alliance in part. Another underlying assumption is that all of this nature crime is undercutting all our global commitments and work on climate, biodiversity, and sustainable development. So, you know, we can make all the commitments that we want in the world, but if we’re still having rampant nature crime, we’re not going to make any progress on that.
In terms of who will be involved, I mentioned most of the key stakeholder groups. Here’s just another diagram with them. I think in terms of what we don’t want to do is we don’t want to create you know voting or decision- making in that way is we want to kind of be consensus building. We’re not trying to speak with one voice. So, we’re trying to bring people together, but the alliance isn’t intending to come up with positions so that it leaves the door open for people to work together that have different views on certain topics, but that will we will structure our topics by experts on specific working group topics.
We are looking to like I said amplify existing work and promote opportunities through existing tools and technology. In terms of how we’re seeing this all working together, we have, you know, a secretariat where we have an interim secretariat so far. I’m not able to announce that we have funding in place for the secretariat for three years. But I am told verbally that the amendment is signed. So hopefully we can very soon announce that we have three years of funding for the secretariat in place which will be hosted by World Resources Institute.
We are there to support the partners and the partners and the participants will be comprised from all of the stakeholder groups that we’ve mentioned. We will have a steering committee that will advise and input on all key decisions including the formation of the working groups and so forth. Governments will be part of it. We have the US, Norway and Gabon as leading partners and we’re just about to start a campaign of increasing government signups. And the working groups. So, we’ll have a broad level of participation at the at that level.
We’ll also have specific working groups on specific topics that are informed by all of our bilateral conversations and group convenings that we’ve had so far. Looking at really drilling down into certain topics and really certain challenges, certain gaps where by bringing people together small groups really curated groups of experts that can get to action and catalyze outcomes. These working groups is really where the meat of the alliance will be. And depending on funding and capacity, we can we can have those be quite many or you know sometimes subgroups and sometimes but all time bound in for the most part.
We want to actually get to an outcome with these working groups. Although we do leave space for some of them being the outcome being the dialogue in itself. So there might be some work like what the UNODC is doing with private sector and financial institutions on quarterly meetings for example on anti-moneyaundering for illegal logging. So there’s some there’s some role in dialoguing in and of itself, but mostly these working groups will be time bound. And in terms of maybe just for a second to speak to you know what would we at first thought we’d be open to everyone but in all of these conversa conversations that seemed like it was reflected back to us by the people that we spoke with that was too low of a bar of entry and we did want participants to sign up to a certain level of commitment as an organization or as a country.
And so in participating in the alliance, we’re looking for missional aligned governments, civil society organizations, academics, indigenous people, local community groups, business, financial institutions, donors, and we’re asking them to affirm, you know, to take, to commit to taking appropriate action within their own mandates to support the cooperative activities to combat nature crime and associated criminal activities. And then these are the three guiding principles for that. So that is the what we’re asking to sign up to. I think in terms of the next two slides, I think I’ve mentioned some of this already.
This is where we’ve gotten to. We’ve talked with a lot of people. We formed an interim secretariat. We have a website. We’ve secured initial funding. And now we’re moving to a phase of ramping up country engagement. So with Norway and the US together and possibly including Gabon, we’re just now going into a phase of kind of intense diplomatic effort to get countries to sign up before the launch, which will be sometime between September and December, probably a series of launch events. And we are hopefully securing additional funding because securing funding for the secretary is just part of it.
Part of what we want to do is mobilize a huge amount of funding for participants and funders. We don’t intend to become a funer in and of ourselves, but we intend to fulfill a matchmaking role. And part of that, yeah, so then we’ll also continue to have these expert convenings, which is, you know, will work towards some of the working groups that we are intending. I think I’ll pass it over to Brad just to give a little bit of an overview of some of the working group or the strategic priority areas that we’re looking at that might turn into working groups and where we’re at with that.
Brad Spangler:
Thanks, Celia. Yes, here we go. So yeah, in terms of substantive topics that the alliance, so we have the sort of the three pillar mission that Julia described within that and again based on the consultations done to date. These are sort of the six strategic priority areas where we’re concentrating our efforts with expert working groups. So looking at financial flows, beneficial ownership and accountability. So basically we’ve been told, you know, follow the money. There’s a lot of really interesting investigative methods and so forth coming out of civil society and we’re trying to play a role in linking up sort of the civil society expertise with the financial institutions especially progressive ones that are trying to really tackle these issues and the links to anti-money laundering efforts etc.
I’ll say a little bit more that’s one of the topics we’ve dug into the deepest so far and I’ll say a little bit more about that momentarily. Also a focus on sort of what we’re calling choke points or sort of pinch points both virtual and physical. So the transport of goods where the you know where are nature crime sort of commodities moving through supply chains through ports etc and also online. We’re seeing a lot of virtual sort of marketplaces and so forth and trade especially in wildlife parts online. And so looking at strategies for ramping up monitoring and enforcement in those areas.
A whole host of tools and technologies that are out there to be leveraged around and I know there’s a question out there about this but for enhancing the fight against nature crime everything from remote sensing technology AI and machine learning to sort of mine data the use of blockchain for example pre preventing document fraud at ports and things like that and there’s a lot of innovation happening again these are not necessarily things the Nature Crime Alliance will do but like Julia said trying to connect the dots and figure out who are the real innovators and how can we bring them together to cross over across crime types or different disciplines and sort of bring more innovation to this the whole endeavor of fighting nature crime.
Obviously law enforcement and legal frameworks is a critical area. Again just sort of exploring what are the laws on the books, what are sort of some of the gaps what can be done to sort of to strengthen frameworks around the world and help enforcement and get to prosecutions. In many cases, you know, folks sort of get off with a small fine and or just like a year in prison or what have you because these crimes aren’t treated seriously enough. That’s also links to the focus on financial flows because often kind of we call it sort of the alapone strategy.
If you can get them for any money for moneyaundering or other financial crimes sometimes the sentencing or you know if they’re prosecuted the penalty is much greater than what it would be just for an environmental crime or nature crime alone. A whole component on supporting frontline defenders which Julia talked about that’s both you know fina especially financial support to the extent we can channel that and then also technical support like you saw in Ruth’s presentation there with some of the new technologies and getting those in the hands of the folks on the front lines especially indigenous communities and then a whole we’ll have a whole component around strategic communications and just amplifying the issue and especially the ongoing work of all the great partners that have taken the time to engage with us and we do sense a lot of enthusiasm and momentum around sort of coming together in a new way to tackle these issues.
So we’re excited about that. And just quickly on the financial flows piece which we see is really powerful and important. Again the sort of alapone strategy we’re seeing the alliance playing a role in because we’re very well positioned with civil society as you know as a global leader on a lot of these issues and so forth and then making inroads to the finance sector as sort of a becoming a broker in the middle there to help with the sort of co-design of solutions between the civil society experts and the financial institutions and especially in the realm of kind of know your c customer and AM ML compliance.
I saw Marcelo on the call. I know Finance for Biodiversity is involved in that realm and they actually participated in our one of our early convenings on this topic. So that’s moving forward. We’re starting to build a working group around the idea of creating typologies or sort of profiles of nature crime that banks and other financial institutions can use for trying to screen and weed this activity out of their portfolios. I will stop there. This is our information and happy to answer questions or just carry on with the discussion. Sarah,.
Sarah Ingersoll:
These are fantastic presentations. There’s someone outside me beeping. So, I’m gonna Brad, I just actually either of you maybe you could share just a little bit more about the origins of this and what was sort of the driving force. You shared a little bit from a you know in terms of the how the organization is being structured and how you’re developing it, but I wanted to see if there was anything else for like a broader audience. What’s what made this happen?
Brad Spangler:
Thank you. I was muted. I needed you to trigger me. Can you hear me? Yes. So yes, the origin of the Nature Crime Alliance goes back to a 2019 report from the Food and Land Use Coalition who is technically one of the partners in the Secretariat now sort of during the course of this moved from another organization to being housed at. The report is called Growing Better: 10 Critical Transitions to Transform Food and Land Use September 2019. One of our colleagues at Norway’s International Forest and Climate Initiative, Nick Fee, who’s been the primary funer, was one of the principal authors of this report, which includes a recommendation to form a global alliance against environmental crime because of the ways in which, as Julia alluded to, nature crime or environmental crime undermines food security goals in particular in this case which, you know, can be extrapolated to climate, biodiversity, etc.
So there is literally a recommendation in this report saying someone should form this alliance and so Nick Fee sort of grabbed that. And as in Meridian’s role as a strategic adviser to Nicki and’s role as a longtime grantee we sort of they brought us together and partnered up and we started exploring this idea with early consultations as far back as spring 2020 and on since then to where we are today. So that is the quick story. We started asking the question of should there be an alliance and we quite quickly got further to how exactly should the alliance have an impact.
So we kind of started to refine the question halfway through which is great because we’ve never yet been told that there shouldn’t be an alliance of this sort. So seems like it’s a resounding yes from consultation so far. Now we’re trying to refine it further and to make sure that we can have maximum impact.
Sarah Ingersoll:
Sorry, seem to having tech problems today. There are a couple other questions we were going back and forth about discussing in our prior email, but I think maybe we’ll turn it over to get some questions answered and maybe we can pop those answers discussions into the conversations. So it would help if people want to raise their hands and then on virtually and I’m going to start with Grace.
Grace:
Yeah. So, I have a couple of questions. One of the questions is about business, like who’s buying these things, right? You talked about how much of this is being purchased and I noticed that you didn’t mention that in your slides as part of the alliance and so I’m wondering if you’re getting a tremendous amount of push back from industry about this because they were not participants and I have a second question and let you go through that one.
Brad Spangler:
Yeah, I mean I have a I could start Julia. So well in terms of illegal wildlife trade the major market is certainly China you know by all accounts. In terms of some of the other commodities it’s sort of I think one of the challenges we face with this is sort of the distinction between legal and illegal and how can you actually decipher that which is you know the force legality initiative atri is very focused on that in terms of timber and coming up with some technologies and so forth for traceability but often we you know much of private industry is sort of and finan financial institutions are sort of unwittingly implicated in all of this.
Something that F4B is working on is sort of the notion of extended liability and how do you sort of use some of the laws on the books to put pressure on companies and financial institutions to do more. The ethos we’re trying to create with the alliance is not a name and shame type of approach. It’s more of a everyone knows this is really complicated. If you’re serious about tackling it, please work with us. Even if you’re exposed right now, that’s not, you know, that’s okay kind of thing. And we’re trying to build an alliance to come up with solutions that work.
So, Julia,.
Yulia Stange:
Yeah, I think it’s a tricky one. And I wasn’t sure if you meant also that companies weren’t mentioned in our consultations to date. Is that what you were saying, Grace, or did I misunderstand?
Unidentified participant:
Yeah. No. Oh, you can’t unmute.
Yulia Stange:
Yeah. Yeah. No, but just to say that I think companies come in a few different places and I think many of you are probably aware of the due diligence regulations putting the onus on companies and demand side regulations that are being put in place in many parts of the world and I so I think the alliance is following that from the perspective of the legal frameworks strategic priority area. I think in terms of then helping companies implement certain bits. We’ve been in discussions with some of the financial institutions and some really interesting discussions with financial institutions where you know working with those that are that are looking to change I think is the first step.
So, so not so much yet looking at the ones that are the lyers but looking at some of the hurdles that the front runners are having as a first step and I think you know an interesting you know even just interesting shift in terms of perception that banks used to put a nature crime in their sustainability department you know the same department that deals with recycling and now they’re starting to think about it more in the fraud departments and so it is a crime it should be thought of in the fraud department so the people in just inms of how they organize themselves within banks.
So even just a shift like that is what we’re you know looking to see where we can make changes. In terms of how finan sorry how financial institutions and companies in general we’ve been members of the alliance we’re still you know we’ve been in touch with some we have you know technology partners we’ve partnered with Google Earth as worldw world resources institute to come up with some of these tools like global forest watch but how exactly they’ll participate in the alliance that one’s still a little bit gray because we need to do a few more consultations whether we want to have individual companies join or whether we want you know company associations and trade associations or work via the world business council for example so or consumer goods forum so I think there’s yeah any ideas you have on how the private sector can be engaged in this way I think there’s various avenues and then by also supporting law enforcement so I can keep I know there’s other questions by supporting law enforcement by connecting law enforcement officials which is a whole another strategic priority area and we see there being a huge need for increased coordination between prosecutors judges and customs agents even within one country much less transboundary And that’s a role, you know, the connecting and lessons learned is something that the alliance hopes to play a role in that by getting law enforcement working also holding those companies to account.
So it’s an indirect way that we’re working on it in that sense. If that I don’t know if that answers your question.
Brad Spangler:
Well, I’ll just add as you would imagine it’s a very delicate issue to raise with a company because of statistics like the one you just put in the chat. So, we’re approaching private sector engagement very carefully as you would imagine.
Sarah Ingersoll:
I’m going to turn to Lona. I hope I’m pronouncing your name properly.
Ilona:
Thank you, Sarah. Thank you, Julian Brad. I from the Gap Institute to actually present on the same topic next Monday with the same Donna which I see also is here and you know I saw the email from Jonah and there was like three links from our work but we haven’t had the possibility to talk again like about this alliance and we are super keen like we’ve been developing not only a typology but a lot of case studies and like very similar strategies are ongoing regional consultations, women defenders, private sector in like Amazon basing only and lately we started to reach out to like colleagues in Indonesia but also the Congo basing like Bernu and so on.
So would be very like glad to exchange notes. So we are a little bit I think more advanced in terms of the let’s say the data and the strategies but we’re primarily looking at the regional component for the second. But I think it’s very important. We also signed a partnership with Interpol. We launched the first product with them. So same partners. So I think we should definitely speak.
Yulia Stange:
Yes, let’s do that. Absolutely. And but also because I think this is time has come for this really and you know I just came back from Davos. I saw two of your colleagues and they mentioned Julia. So just very interesting that this is coming the week before we’re also coming here to talk about the same issue. So just I’ll send it out the typology here because it was not listed in the in the email but it would be very glad very good to just talk to you afterwards as well.
Unidentified participant:
Sorry Elon I missed your organization when you got Institute.
Unidentified participant:
Wonderful. Wonderful. Very nice to meet you. Thank you. Definitely. Yes. Let’s connect. Thank you.
Sarah Ingersoll:
Just the kind of connections we want. Louise Villars.
Luis:
Okay. Good afternoon. Thank you very much for this opportunity. I work for fast foundation for the Amazon sustainability. I’m the CFO at fast but I also very particularly interested in all this enforcement issues and I’d like just to make two comments. First of all, first of them is about the studies that I’m just like to know if you’re going to have some kind of studies upon the documentation that is underlying all wood transportation and all these issues. I think it has to do with your second point of the joke point or and I am very interested to understand this because as we are aware of in Brazil the origin the document the documentation for forest products origin that we call do it has many issues that it’s like some pitfalls that we find in this kind of the documentation that allows for very much illegal things to happen such as a long time for wood transportation.
So the wood can be transported back and forth. So you have the possibility to transport much more wood than what is in the documentation. Then you have some confusion between cis floor and documentation. You have some difficulties in framing this the exact amount of wood that’s going to be transported and all in all what happens is that you have such a kind of a wrong traceability. There is a traceability but the traceability is wrong. What you have the data that you see is not the correct thing about what’s going on.
So I think this is an interesting side of the illegal ways to find about illegal consume. And the second point is just a question about the public prosecutors in Brazil is like the minister political have an impact in this issue or a conversations and relationships with the pro prosecutors in Amazonian countries because I think they are the ones that are closer to the solutions and many times It’s quite difficult to have their strength enforced. Thank you very much.
Unidentified participant:
Is it okay if I jump in, Sarah? Yes, please. Yes. Did you want to take a few questions? Yeah. No, no. I want you to just go for it.
Yulia Stange:
No, thank you, Louise. I think I mean documentation is a huge problem. Having the right document or even if you have the right documentation, you can have duplicates and have it wrong. So there’s multiple ways of illegality. There’s a huge issue with several countries, I think it’s either Peru or Colombia, not even requiring there’s no standardization of species. So not even having a sense of how much is being exported because all of the customs documents have different species listed and some of them are quite informal or local names and mean the same species.
So it’s a huge issue. Absolutely. I think there’s in terms of addressing it in possible solutions there is this is a great example of something you know in terms of how the alliance is set up that if the members said you know we want to really look at this issue from a lens of documentation then a working group could be formed looking at how we can you know I don’t for example as a first instinct and I’m not the expert in documentation foresee different legal systems or different you know different rules in different countries being aligned glob globally on trade in timber.
I mean, I think because of national jurisdictions, that’s going to be difficult. But in terms of creating systems or coming up with ideas and using artificial intelligence and other tools on how to look at this documentation and look for anomalies, I think there’s a lot that can be done. And if the members wanted to look at it from there’s different ways that you can approach the issue. And if we wanted to take the documentation lens, a working group and getting a few people together that are, you know, customs officials and an investigative NGO that’s looked at this documentation issue and someone who’s just looked at international trade and has read a thousand custom codes and I actually know someone like that.
You know there are there are ways that we can get a working group together that says okay how can we solve the documentation issue if that’s seen as a key barrier to getting legal timber trade happening or to stopping illegal timber trade how can we do that so I think to kind of yeah I don’t have an answer for you but just to agree it’s a huge issue and to say that’s the kind of thing that hopefully the alliance can help with in terms of your point on the public prosecutors also you cut out in the middle so I hope I didn’t didn’t get your point but in terms of getting prosecutors together to share information.
That’s another, you know, area that is definitely on our radar in terms of the need to convene in a past life before I worked on the Nature Crime Alliance. I did a series of workshops in Eastern Europe bringing together prosecutors, judges, and customs officials and in many cases I was very surprised to learn it was the first time they had ever talked between different agencies on nature crime specifically. So, it’s definitely a need and there’s others that are doing this, but how can we scale up? You know Ruth Nugaran who presented at the beginning she has done a you know a project between Colombia, Peru, Brazil and the US on sharing information with prosecutors that some of you might be aware of and that’s great but it was kind of a time limited three interventions you know how do we take that and what worked and do it bigger and longer and more and how do we you know involve more people so yes to what you’re saying I don’t know Brad if you want to add anything to that no great I see other hand.
Sarah Ingersoll:
Great. So, Casia, you had a question and then we’ll go to Marcelo and then Lona if you wanted to talk some more. Oh, okay.
Kasia:
Thanks. Hi everyone. I’m Kasha Malinoska from Open Society Foundations. Actually, nice to hear some see some old friends here. Hi, Hela. My question may or may not be relevant, but let me put it out here. So, as I hear your conversation, it sounds like state actors are perceived as the good guys, but there are plenty of situations where state actors are actually not good guys at all. And you know, I’m thinking, for example, about the BA forest in Poland where Polish government just decided that it’s okay to basically chop half of it out even though it’s UNESCO protected and so on and so on.
I’m sure there are plenty of those examples in Brazil and in other places where the government actually became not a helpful actor. I’m thinking of a situation where Colombian government with US assistance is spraying huge parts of the cocoa crops destroying nature all around polluting water table. Will you have a relationship to those sort of those sort of situations or is that outside of your of your scope? Thanks.
Yulia Stange:
That’s such a good question and I’m very glad that you asked it if we came across as supporting all governments joining the alliance. That is not the intention and so thank you so much for clarifying. I think we are looking to align governments that are looking to combat nature crime and so you know looking to commit to those guiding principles and that was a huge part of the conversation that we had with our informal advisory group. You know we were lucky enough to have advice from several NGO leaders and civil society and government leaders on our governance structure that we’ve put together.
And we really, you know, it’s a tough one to think about because we all, well, on the one hand, we don’t just want people joining the alliance that have per and no one’s perfect. Let’s be clear, the US has issues. Canada has issues where I’m from, Germany has issues. So, no, no one’s perfect, but recognizing that the government has a role in law enforcement in holding criminals to account, but also is sometimes a source of corruption. And sometimes that’s within the same department. Sometimes there’s front runners or people trying to do really good work and leading departments within an overall corrupt government.
So how can an alliance support those in governments that are trying to do good work is it was an issue that we really grappled with and I think what we came up with and we’ll you know see if it works and we can always review our governance structure in two three years is what we intend but to have governments sign on and to commit to those guiding principles which also then give us a mechanism for kicking them out so that they can’t just join and be a greenwashing country in that sense.
As well as joining, we’re also asking countries to comm make commitments. And that doesn’t have to be obviously donor countries. We’re looking for financial commitments. You know, it would be great if the UK and Germany and France and Norway and the US all came out and said that they were going to give a hundred billion dollars to fighting nature crime. That would be great. But also, what are you going to do? Are you going to increase collaboration between prosecutors? Are you going to increase capacity and training for customs officials? The US is putting in place fish and wildlife service agents.
I think that are supporting in law enforcement in countries around the world as part of their program. So, I think there’s things that they can commit to that aren’t that aren’t donor, but how what actions will you take? Are you reforming the forest code in your country? Are you aligning documents? So I think there’s also commitments that we’re asking the countries to make in joining that are that are changes along those lines. They don’t have to make, you know, tangible commitments like that, but they are they do have to the minimum bar for entry is to agree to those guiding principles.
So I think yeah we don’t we don’t we do want those that are trying to be part of this so that we can support them in it but it is definitely an issue that you know we hope to have a steering committee that can help keep advising us of you know day-to-day issues as they come up you know for example you know GAO is joining the alliance and there’s definitely you know been different things in the news over the years so you know but there’s also you know some you know government officials that are really trying to make a change.
So, I think how do we balance those? But it’s a it’s a really good point and it’s something we’re going to have to keep looking at as the alliance develops.
Kasia:
Thanks. I assume that you would want to avoid a situation where you have Saudi Arabia on the on the human rights council, right? Like those things become.
Yulia Stange:
Super I can confirm that Saudi Arabia is not a country that we’re currently reaching out to join.
Brad Spangler:
So, we have well just to add the guiding principles and then we will also have a code of conduct for individuals. So we have we are building in back stops and a suspension process should we have bad actors in our midst. Yes. Go ahead.
Sarah Ingersoll:
Well, we just have three questions and not much more time. So I’m going to ask people to try to keep their questions brief even if you’ve been waiting for a long time or so and the responses brief so we can make sure we covered them.
Marcelo:
Well, mine is not really a question. It’s just to share some feedback. I think the biggest m and I being part of many coalitions, I think the biggest mistake a coalition could do is to think about how to be a good coalition and forget what you’re a coalition for. And I think if we keep the focus on the goal is to solve a problem of stopping nature crimes, it truly doesn’t matter who is joining in or out because there will be a natural process of cleaning and recycling and so on.
Now on the focus of the work, I just want to underscore that one of the things we’ve been discussing a lot at financial biodiversity is the difference between proactive strategies from reactive strategies. And reactive strategies are the ones that you look at screening typology of approach versus proactive strategies in which you look at due diligence mechanism, reliability and including voluntary approaches and I think that we should encourage voluntary approaches because we need some testing exercises to happen and if there are individuals, companies, government, state level, whatever are willing to do that.
I think it’s very useful as a learning tool. The final comment is about how do we engage the and who do we talk to? We need to expand and I’m happy that Casia brought that up the issue of what do we do when the enforcement agents are part of the problem but the truth is there are checks and balances within the enforcement agencies that can also be exploited and explored on a positive way and I think that the more open we are to engage people that think different and engage unusual suspects the better.
Right now we have an indigenous u agency leader and a journalist missing in Brazil and the most important work has been done in terms of raising awareness by the journalist community. And so sometimes the skills and the and the correct answers will come from where you’re not expecting. And I think that an alliance for this kind of goal should be very open. Thank you.
Brad Spangler:
Julian, do you want to agree that’s my answer?
Yulia Stange:
Yeah, I think a lot of the points that you raised I think are right in line with a lot of the discussions we’ve been having. So yeah, welcome further conversations. And you know, you touched on a few points. I think in terms of welcoming different views, I think that’s absolutely what we need to do and bring different people in the room at the right time. And I think that’s the core of what we’re proposing to do. I think I take your point about you know coalitions you know there’s so many of them and has formed so many coalitions and platforms and alliances and Meridian’s been involved in them as well and so I think we did spend some time on the governance structural just to keep it as flexible and nimble as we could and I and I think when we you know in terms of getting to action we’re really hoping that these working groups by being time bound and very defined and create their own terms of reference on a specific topic and that’s also why we’re partnering with Meridian Institute because they’re you know experts in facilitating towards action.
That’s what they do. And so to how you know our own measures of success as to how have we solved this concrete problem that we are you know this one bit that we’re tackling via working groups. I think yeah I’ll leave it there because there but yeah agreeing with what you’re saying.
Sarah Ingersoll:
Thanks Marchel. John go ahead. Just really quickly and Marcelo I appreciate everything you just said. So that saves a lot of time for a couple of points I wanted to make there, but I did want to go back to the government for a second. And first of all, I’m with the Amazon Conservation Association. We’ve been in the battle for seven years there in Peru developing a governance model and helping develop the that now USA ID and NORAD together. But where I wanted to go with going back to what Marcelo just mentioned and Julia, you’ve answered part of this, I think if there’s a very flexible way we can work with governments across the Amazon, we’ve got to figure that out because governments fortunately are not a monolith in the sense that you can work with certain parts of the government.
In Brazil, we’re working with, you know, state level governments while things nationally might not be the best. Same in Bolivia and then in Peru we’re able to do it at both levels and so I think there needs to be a real flexibility there and we would need to figure out a way to stay out of the kind of the political positioning that would be an issue for us all I think if we had certain governments you represented on this. So, it needs to be flexible and we’re going to have to be able to call out, you know, when things aren’t going well in certain countries and that’s hard to do when they’re on the coalition with you.
And not that we want to put one against the other, but I do think there’s a much more flexible way to do this and very excited for this initiative that you guys are having and I look forward to talking to you guys in the future about this.
Yulia Stange:
Be great to talk more. Thank you so much. I think in terms of the flexibility going back to the governance although it’s not perfect but just to say yes there will be forums where maybe we have a working group with just law enforcement officials where we’re just bringing governments together maybe we have law enforcement officials in the working groups whose countries haven’t signed up to the alliance and that’s okay so we need that flex absolutely echoing what you’re saying and sometimes we might need an NGO group that’s not having any government involved so by having flexibility in how we structure the working groups but having a steering committee that’s comprised of all stakeholders I will hopefully be a way to balance that hopefully and again we’re revising the structure in two three years in case it doesn’t work right at the moment for the launch which is what we’re sort of focused on right now we want sort of buy in at the highest level of whatever governments sign up at the outset but yes working across different agencies and closely with US state department and others to sort of vet that and make sure we’re getting to the right actors within governments whether it’s regional within agencies etc.
Yeah.
Sarah Ingersoll:
I’m gonna So we are actually at the top of the hour, but we can continue a little bit more because Ted’s got a question and then there’s sort of what we call the water cooler period where we can have a more offline conversation. But first Ted, let’s just make sure that you have an opportunity to ask your question or make your comment.
Ted:
Great. Thanks. My name is Ted Gear and I’m the USAID director here in Brazil, the US Agency for International Development. I was a great presentation, really interesting and important work that you’re doing. What I wanted to maybe I missed it in the presentation, but you know, it’s definitely focused as a sort of a global alliance, but I was wondering how you will decide when to drill down into the issues of a specific country. Some of that was answered with your discussion about governments joining or not joining or committing to work.
But is that would that be required for example for Brazil to be part of this just as an example if the government doesn’t join but you’ve got you know a network of civil society organizations like Egaripe and others that want to join or want to be part of this. Could they be a member Brazil or does the government need to be involved? And then when you decide to work, how will you decide to work specifically on issues related to a specific country like Brazil? Is it just will you just be looking at issues that are global in nature or across the board or would you be able to through the alliance sort of drill down on issues specific to a particular country?
Thanks.
Yulia Stange:
Thanks so much. I think so quick answer is that no. So I mean we definitely can take sorry yes we can take other NGO actors or other stakeholder groups from that region or country even if that country is not signed up and especially when we launch we expect you know because the timeline is now so short till September and the diplomatic engagement is really just going full force starting kind of now we might launch with less than 10 countries we hope to increase that by next year’s annual you know first annual meeting of all partners but we might jo you know start with much less than 10 first initial countries.
We expect NGO kind of membership drive to be slightly more simple than getting governments on board. So no, absolutely no limits or matching of countries or regions. In terms of topics that we address, we’ve definitely discussed the possibility and the need potentially to have region specific working groups especially for example Papa New Guinea keeps coming up as well or Amazon. So definitely or Congo Basin, you know, there’s a reason these are areas that keep coming up. So far in the strategic priorities, many of the ways in which we’ve looked to tackle the crime are crosscutting tools and so are necessarily kind of or are just broad or crosscutting in nature, not even by crime type.
We initially thought we might end up with some crime type working groups, but it’s looking like most of the tools to address are quite you know across crime types as well as across geographies. That doesn’t mean that if there’s a you know a strong need or a strong that we could so again the structure is flexible if and those working groups can be proposed by anyone in the membership and then the steering committee and the secretariat you know there might be way too many proposals and we’ll have to vet them down but really where there’s opportunity and where there’s drive and where there’s interest and as long as the secretariat has capacity and funding to kind of convene those working groups and do the background research to make sure that they’re not just meetings that they actually you know move from meeting to meeting to having an output then yeah absolutely I don’t know if I’m speaking out of turn.
Brad, go ahead.
Brad Spangler:
Well, just great question, Ted. So yes, you know, the strategic priorities I outlined are very crosscutting. Yes, they need to be applied in certain countries. So, I think and then the other thing that Julia alluded to is this idea of like matchmaking. So, thank you. Yeah. So, to the extent, so let’s take this sort of crime typologies for financial institutions notion. You know, if we can get to something that’s practical and usable there, perhaps, you know, we could work with some financial institutions in Brazil to like run a pilot and start to apply those in that region.
You know, we could, and the other piece of this is like when we say the working groups are time bound, we’re trying to drive toward sort of, you know, forging some new partnerships, developing sort of concrete project ideas that could then be sort of spun out of the alliance. So we have this idea of a resource mobilization work group so that we would kind of take a c an idea to a certain level perhaps even getting folks and we hope to have seed funding to sort of provide some resources to even form project proposals and then use the alliance as like a forum to connect those project ideas to funders that want to fund them.
Then it would just they would spin off and kind of grow out of the alliance but not be overseen or managed by the alliance. So there’s a lot of sort of intricacies in there we’re working on. But so you could imagine you know folks coming and saying you know we want to bring actors in Brazil together in a new way and we could create a forum for that in the nature through the nature crime alliance for a certain period of time with sort of some concrete objectives and then spin something out.
Yulia Stange:
Then at some point it might not be nature crime alliance anymore. It might be its own thing that runs and that’s okay. And we still have some issues on, you know, some discussions to have as to how and when that, you know, like and how we measure success. And that’s a whole another topic we can deal with. But the idea that it’s we’re not trying to keep, you know, incubating things and letting go of them is part of the intention. And as far as we’ve understood from donors we’ve spoken to so far, and you can corroborate this or not, is that, you know, there is a need for kind of well-curated projects that will have an impact.
And so that the alliance would also be doing, you know, while bringing participants together that it would also be performing a service for donors. And that’s why we’re trying to include them in the alliance kind of from the get-go. Yeah.
Yulia Stange:
Some of your colleagues at US A is it Rowena who’s who we’ve spoken with? State Department. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Others. But anyway, through the through the inter agency group that OES convenes the information’s trickling through there.
Unidentified participant:
Yeah. But yeah, definitely. Great.
Ted:
Yeah. My I’m focused on Brazil. So yeah. Yeah. I was on a one of those global ones but that’s very useful.
Sarah Ingersoll:
Thanks very much. I am sadly going to circle up again. This is the formal session. I want to thank Brad and Julia and Ruth in absence for a really powerful presentation of a very exciting initiative. And again we can stay on if people want to have a little bit more conversation. If Julia and Brady are available for a few more minutes.
Unidentified participant:
I can stay for a few more minutes. I’m gonna stop the recording and thanks everyone again.