Igarape Institute, Sustainable Development and the Rule of Law
Founded in 2010, the Igarape Institute works on security and democracy with a focus on digital, climate, and public interests. Since 2017, the Institute has mapped the scope, scale, and dynamics of environmental crime in the Amazon in order to help strengthen the rule of law and activate sustainable development solutions. Their research shows how persistent corruption, illicit financial activities, and environmental crime continue to play an important role in deforestation, degrading the environment, and impacting the lives and livelihoods of those calling the Amazon home. Join us to meet Igarape co-founder, Ilona Szabó de Carvalho, to discuss these issues and more. As a Brazilian, Ilona is a globally recognized civic entrepreneur, columnist, and podcaster. She’s currently a member of the UN Secretary-General’s High-Level Advisory Board on Effective Multilateralism, an affiliate scholar at Princeton University, a former Young Global Leader at the World Economic Forum, and a fellow at Columbia University.
Recorded June 13, 2022
References:
Green, Clean, and Safe – Analytical Dimensions and Metrics for 21st Century Brazilian Agriculture
The Roots of Environmental Crime in the Colombian Amazon
Banks, business, and bypassing Bolsonaro in Brazil
Ilona Szabó de Carvalho: It will take diverse networks to solve global threats like climate change
Getting to Zero Deforestation in the Amazon by 2030
Where Humanity’s Future Will Be Decided
WATCH:
Participants
- Sarah Ingersoll
- Ilona Szabó de Carvalho
- Fernando
- Rosa
- Manuel
- Louis
- Danielle Rappaport
- Unidentified participant
Transcript
Sarah Ingersoll:
We are we are very lucky to have Lona Carvado this today and Luna rather than mess up your bio and background I thought we would just start with a little bit about who you are both you can say a little bit even about you personally and sort of how you got into this work and what your primary objectives are with the work you’re doing.
Ilona Szabó de Carvalho:
Sure. So thank you so much John and Sarah for the invitation. First of all you know this is a very hard day to be talking here. We know we have two missing dear people that working in the front lines and we hope I know there are few hopes at the moment but we hope that we don’t have the final confirmation that was given this morning or given again but we know that they’re just adding to so many other people that lost their lives before them and so many others that we need to avoid them to lose their lives that are in the front lines trying to square the issues that we’re talking here.
So just before I start, I would say this was a horrible week. I think for most people in this call because we’re following very close. Most of us had some kind of connection with both John Dom and also Bruno. So personally, you know, we know Dom and his work for many years. So just to say I think we have to acknowledge what’s happening and this makes our conversation even more important. So just wanted to breathe and send the energies to the families and friends and you know just make sure we understand why we’re here today as well even more.
Thank you. And so I’m Elana Zabo. I’m the co-founder and president of the Gap Institute. But the personal side I grew up in a very nature preserved safe and med like mediumsiz city in Brazil called Nova. The only Swiss colony in Brazil in the region like a interior of realer state. So when I moved to Rio to study I realized my little bubble of Forgo was not the reality on the ground. So I was really confronted by two main issues when I moved the inequality and let’s say security insecurity and that led I would say by career I started in the financial markets very briefly while I was still studying but I was really touched by the let’s say the unknown reality Rio de Janeiro you can’t cross streets you can’t go up in hills and for me being raised where I was and you know having the privilege to be fear like free from fear and also from want coming from a middle class I thought I didn’t want to continue working in the investment banking sector so I was there five years and the last 20 years I dedicate to civil society so I started working with urban violence issues in a major Brazilian NGO I ran a gun by back campaign like what is a national one we changed the law we did a lot mobilization on gun regulation, police reform.
Then I ran two big commissions on drug policy reform. So the security lens was always there until I co-ounded the GAP and we started with you know public security and international security added digital because digital security was something that impossible to avoid given what’s happening in the technology world and the latest program we have is climate or environmental security where we are just coming with this background of looking to the rule of law and to what can be done in the region to enable sustainable development. So for us for those that don’t just ask like a gape is the small rivers in the Amazon basin that connect to the big ones is the way of a canoe and the name since the beginning even if it didn’t begin with this focus was because we wanted to channel like to be the links between different issues different sectors and really looking forward to finding solutions.
So this is a bit about me just I would like to say that I have in the call also a lot of people from my team on the environmental side today we have the team leader Andrea we have LA and Peter that are lead researchers we have Perolina that leads the regional part of our work we have Giovana who works with me on the UN side of the work we’re doing at the moment we’re also at a advisory board for the secretary general on multilateral effective multilateralism and we lead the climate governance front as well in this work.
So, thank you so much Sarah and Donna.
Sarah Ingersoll:
Thank you. That’s beautiful. And I love the name. Makes it makes so much sense. The threads and the connections across are so important. So what do you think is the sort of more powerful in the Amazon region right now in terms of organized crime or virtuous economic development or how do those two even relate in your mind and in the work that you guys are doing?
Ilona Szabó de Carvalho:
Sure. So Sarah, we prepared a brief presentation just to highlight the three main points. So I don’t know if we could start to that and then we open for the discussion with the whole group. Is that okay?
Unidentified participant:
That would be wonderful. Let me make sure your my your screen you’re able to see. Let me see if I can you see my screen? I’m just gonna Yeah. So, let me just put my Let me just make sure I put my presentation. Just don’t stop sharing. One second here. I want to just go to presenterers mode. Just one second. I’m trying to put the full screen for you. Can you see it now? Yes. Okay.
Ilona Szabó de Carvalho:
So, thank you so much. Just very brief on Venara. So, we are I think Andutank founded in 2011 in Brazil, but we since the beginning we wanted to take the best of Brazil to the world and to bring the best of the world to Brazil. We are not a let’s say a Brazilian think tank persist since all the issues we work with are transnational. So we’re over 50 people today on staff in six different countries women led so we have that bias there over like 70% of our staff are women.
You know we got a few a few accolades through the hard work we’ve been doing and as I said phys just focusing on physical which we call in Brazil public security digital and the environmental side of that so over 100 partners everything we do we do believe that we have to do with know a lot of good people involved that’s the only way we’re going to move things forward and before I start because I’m bringing the security lens but just to make sure we are clear here that from our side we do believe that the solutions we need to bring to the Amazon have to come hand inhand with human social and economic development.
So yes, we desperately need rule of law and that’s what we’re going to focus today. But we have to work together with entrepreneurs and people that are bringing let’s say the responsible capital to the region and that’s also the aim of the third pillar of our work that I’ll present here and for the sake of time I’m going to oversimplify very complex issues so very happy to clarify any doubt in our discussion. So we all know that illicit forest economies and environmental crime are taking a very heavy toll on environment but also in the lives and livelihoods of those who dwell in the Amazon.
So far I believe we managed to understand that we do have a problem but I would say that for many the problem is not yet clear. So we do need the right diagnostics for the real solutions to emerge. Today there are many good ideas a lot of capital moving trying to move into naturebased solutions but we are I think lacking some understanding on how we’re going to be able then to make the solutions flourish. So also before I jump into the work we’re doing it’s very important to just highlight that there is such a great potential there.
So carbon markets, biotech, sustainable tourism, bioeconomy. When we see the numbers for Brazil in terms of bioeconomic products, so Brazil hosts around 30% of the world’s rainforest, 60% only on the Amazon and accounts for just 17% of the global market of like today $200 billion dollars in sustainable forest products. So in contrast, Costa Rica leads the world in this area. This is a very great work that Amazon 23 is doing. Professor Salo Koslovski and he just shows how Brazil is like a you know could be doing much better even for Brazil nuts.
I always say Bolivia exports most of the what we call Brazil nuts to the world. So there’s a lot of great potential. So what I’m saying here in this presentation, I do not want to make investors or people that are willing to invest in the region let’s say less interest. It’s the opposite. Let’s square what we need to allow the good economy to flourish because the people there need desperately the development. So the work we’re doing today at the GAP Institute is just in three main pillars. So the first we said we need to understand what is this ecosystem of environmental crime and we have two pillars dedicated to solutions one in the let’s say public sector and multistakeholder partnership side which is this on governance and partnerships and the third pillar is what we call the enabling sustainable development solutions which is focused on the work with private sector and financial sectors.
So the first and I think a very important part of the work because without the right diagnosis we can’t move forward is to understand what we call the scope the scale and the dynamics of environmental crime. So to do that we started really trying to understand what was happening on the ground and we developed an environmental crime typology with the economic motivations of what we’re seeing both the environmental destruction but also the social economic impacts that are there and from there we started to develop case studies we’ve published the Colombian Peruvian Brazilian ones but also started looking to specific illicit economies for example illicit gold mining and also when we talk about traceability the cattle soy and timber supply chains and what I would like to highlight here today is just a snapshot of the latest presentation latest publication we have which is the ecosystem on environmental crime in Brazil.
We got some data from the federal police and with other research methods we built a database that allowed us to just highlight some very important things here that are very linked to the situation that put Don and Bruno in trouble on the ground. So that’s why also I picked this study today. So what we see is that we have economic activities driving the forestation. In Brazil there are four main economic activities driving that. So illegal ones of course land grabbing, illegal logging, illegal mining and what we call agriculture and livestock farming, right?
Food environmental illegalities. And this with what we call converging crimes form the ecosystem. It’s very important to say that in since we’re looking at the Amazon basing the definitions of what is a crime environmental crime it will vary between countries many of the things that we’re just dealing here are not typified as environmental crime. They could be other kinds of crime in the in the environmental crime ecosystem. So we understand the relationships and both also because you know most of this illicit economists are really damaging the environment. So we’ll explain the methodology for you just in the next slide if I could move.
Something happened that I can’t move here. Just one second. Yeah. Can you see now? Yes. Okay. I’m sorry. So this is a just to start just a very briefly explaining we are on the left hand side here you see what we call the illicit economies that are driving discussion on the Amazon forest. So as I was saying not all are typified as environmental crime in the Brazilian also for example land grabbing or farming and ranching rifled environmental illegalities technically are not a crime. Equally important we have to harmonize understanding between the different countries in the Amazon basing when comparing because the definitions also vary.
So on the right hand side we have what we call the converging or related crimes. So these of course are not environmental related offenses but they act as an integral part integral part of this ecosystem that we’re trying to picture. So more often than not they are enablers of the environmental crime as well. So this classification here is based on a study of 269 federal police operations between 2016 and 2021 in Brazil. So what we see here on the top you’re going to see the illicit economies that we are using to call attention for the drivers or the focus of each federal police operation that we mapped out and the far left column what you see the criminal hypothesis the police was working with was investigating.
So this criminal hypothesis could include, you know, environmental on land offense crimes, but also other non- environmental offenses. So from corruption, money laundering to violent crimes, and physical assault. So what the study shows and this is just one table. There are many graphs and many tables. I invite you to take a look because it just explains the complexities but also gives like sheds a light on what are the solutions. They show us that you know investigations for example for land grabbing or agriculture and livestock farming are often interconnected with legal deforestation.
Illegal logging of course also appears interconnected with illegal deforestation. But also it shows the importance of other crimes such as for example fraud in the picture. So around 30% of the operations surveyed present some kind of fraud. And what we see also in the last years is that the percentage of crimes that are violence related could be gun related, slave labor, violent crimes or drug related are also increasing. What calls for urgent immediate actions. So of course we can talk more about this study. We’re presenting actually a second part of the study in the possibly beginning of July and brings other very interesting and worrying information based on the database that we’re building.
So some headlines of this. So as we’re saying there’s an ecosystem of environmental crime in the Amazon basing. These studies focus on Brazil but the previous case studies also show that there’s a very similar dynamic although some crimes take a different toll in different places. So these illegalities in crimes converge with non-environmental crimes and a very vast array of actors you know from actors on the ground to others that are not in the region or even in these countries. We see illegal logging and illegal mining as the main illicit economies in the case of Brazil when we’re surveying based on the federal police data.
The central role of fraud as I said and corruption in laundering natural like natural resources. This is very important because just shows how you know we need to really talk about the actors that are involved and that are promoting many times these activities and the network of actors that are destroying goes beyond the region. So this next study for July will show maps presenting where were these people involved in this operation found arrested where the company so just shows how much wider is the situation when it comes to the actors also that are involved here.
So just another important pillar of the work we’re doing and I think this is so urgent especially when we see the violence the increasing violence is the women defenders. So as we all know the Brazilian Amazon is one of the most dangerous place for environmental defenders and when we put the gender lens this becomes even more worrisome. So we’re working with local women defenders for themselves to be researchers and to apply surveys to understand the kinds of violence they’re facing and also building protection guides and trying to highlight policy recommendations in Brazil but also Peru and Colombia.
So we can also talk a little bit more about this work that for me is like a very urgent one. So what are some of the rule of law solutions? So the other two pillars of our work are devoted to that. So the first I would say the strengthening governance and partnerships. So we definitely need to build this accountable governance to be able to deal with the with issues on the brow. So we see overlapping of competencies. We see also a lot as we say in Brazil like hot potatoes like institutions passing hot potato to others.
So there are places especially now with a huge like emptiness of institutional actors and of course then the grievances are being resolved with violence. So what we’re doing there is to first identify these gaps and filling recommendations to strengthen states institutions capacity. So we’re dealing from environmental institutions to law enforcement the community of justice to the role of the armies. We are gonna issue for Brazil now like in the coming month as well what we’re calling a multi-dimensional security agenda for the Amazon to discuss with the with the presidential candidates hoping that we can improve the situation in the coming years because right now we have a very few I would say hopes that until the end of this government things will improve the way they need to.
So we’re also working to build trust with regional actors. As we know also this is a region Latin America and especially when look at the Amazon basing where there’s very little action in terms of coordinating effort exchanging information. So we organizing regional consultations between like officials of Peru, Colombia and Brazil in partnership with Interpol but also the sea. We’re talking to Otka, the organization for the treat the treaty of Amazon Corporation and other bodies to try to, you know, while also the governments don’t do a lot of this work to just foster and to promote what we call the 1.5 track diplomatic conversations which is of course led by like unofficial ways of cooperation at the moment.
Also working through networks participating different ones to strengthen this global regional national but also subnational cooperation we are part we’re taking this issue and this highlighting be UN forum at the world economic forum as I said at the region organizations for the Amazon concert for the Amazon Brazil coalition and many others that are arising now and our Third pillar which I think it’s a very key here is to working also with the private sector and financial markets to enable sustainable development solutions. So we do believe that you know there is a huge role for the private agents here.
We understand that command and control has to be done by the government. So that’s the second pillar of the job we’re doing. But we do believe that even in a situation like that transparency, traceability and I’ll say more informed risk analysis that can actually then inform the decisions that we have to take in terms of investing or in terms of demanding a transition plan for a company are really key and I would say more than ever. So on the one side we’re trying to promote technologies what already is work how to scale up for better let’s say traceability and transparency on the other working also to engage corporate and financial actors and regulations in this kind of a the fight against illegalities in supply chain.
So here for example we’re now participating in this innovation lab with civim which is the Brazilian sec exchange commission and IDB to try to harmonize the task force for nature financial disclosure to Brazil. So this is a just a work that is starting with many other partners. And we’re also developing on the risk analysis front a more let’s say what we’re calling it a ESG triplea. So we’re developing metrics and run correlations with let’s say v like variables such as credit to find better impact metrics for those that are really investing let’s say in green products.
So we are starting the conversation with some like houses financial houses to make sure we could be also a partner in helping them to ask the right questions look at the right impact metrics and do like a let’s say what is needed when it comes to ESG today when we look at what are let’s say there’s a self-reported ESG matrix and look at what we’re look at we’re seeing in the illegalities front. We see there is a lot of let’s say work to be done there to make sure we use the tools that are available but also the metrics that we should be looking at to make sure we are treating let’s say we’re attracting responsible capital to these investments that are out there and finally and I’m finishing here so we go to the debate we also for just like to highlight all these issues to put this information in the agenda.
We do a lot of communication and outreach. We have this platform that is just a as a first let’s say MVP which is called echo crime. We’re going to have a more robust one where also other lines of our work. For example, we’re having some research also money laundering on this ESG dashboard that we’re putting out and others that all figure there. Let’s say from the second semester onwards. Today you can find stories and maps. This is done in partnership with Azri and we’re also making sure the stories go further with partners such as AP Reuters, Mongab, Monga Bay and others and just on the communications front as well because what we think is very key to understand is that environmental crime for many law enforcement agencies is a secondass crime still and we need to make sure understand this is key and highlighting the ecosystem of crimes helps because then we can show how they related like interrelated with many other fences that receive more attention.
So unfortunately we need to also use the data to build the narratives to let’s say increase the priority of these issues in the public debate but also in the public agenda. So we’ve been, you know, taking part in several events in Brazil and worldwide in the region writing to several newspapers and this is a key part of the work we are doing. So I’ll stop here so we can talk. Thank you so much and happy to hear your questions, doubts and clarify. I know this was very fast so I’m sorry for bringing so much information in a short time like that.
Sarah Ingersoll:
That was beautiful. Yeah, we’re so grateful for what you’re doing and so important to get that level of detail about the landscape and make it accessible to people and then be communicating. Very impressed and also very excited to see more and more the integration between the naturebased crime and the violence and the economics and what that what that means. Both from a negative standpoint but also from a from a solution standpoint and the work that Amazon Investor Coalition is trying to do and how important it will be to make sure that the metrics and the work that we’re doing doesn’t in any way contribute to what we know is a problem.
So thank you for sharing that. So, so the next part of our podcast, we basically open it up for discussion and basically you can raise your hand using your little icon and so that I know you’re interested and you know important to you can share a little bit about who you are when you start just so we understand but also try to keep the questions or the comments brief so that everyone has an opportunity to contribute. So I will now open it up and if people are shy I have another set of questions but I’m gonna wait.
Fernando and Raza are there already so up because I can’t see my screen places. Yeah. Well, so Fernando is recently joined the Amazon Investor Coalition team to help us lead our catalytic philanthropy roadmap and it comes with the deep expertise in what is going on with the bioconomy and what’s going on in the region and we’re very excited to have been part of this and so Fernando you want to go ahead and share a little bit.
Fernando:
Oh, thanks. Thanks for introduction, Elona. Thank you very much. Your work is wonderful. I’ve been following you. I’m Brazilian here in south of Brazil right now. So you’re doing a great work. I’ve been working Amazon for a long time. My question is from your point of view if you’re going to start for example a new project in the Amazon region where you have some such of problems a crime problems as you described what’s your best advice you know what’s your best advice to do a good work I’m saying you know I know of course you had to avoid crime you had to try to tackle work with good people work local communities.
But your advice, what’s the best way to do to do a I mean construct and to build economic vi social viable project in the Amazon nowadays.
Ilona Szabó de Carvalho:
Perfect. Fernando, I think I do believe that you have to understand where you are so exactly the land issues around you. So where you are and what’s around you, the competencies of the different institutions government institutions that are responsible for every jurisdiction that is close to you because this can be handy. And that’s part of the work we’re doing also not only understanding better where there is like let’s say overriding competencies but also what can be improved and so we will be following up with this work on institutions and their competences for the Amazon.
So I think that’s a key one. And by talking to entrepreneurs that failed in the Amazon, one thing that strikes me is that I would say if you can go in a group like find peers that are interested in the same like it’s good competition but you’re gonna be doing better if you’re doing like let’s say in an ecosystem also of entrepreneurship. And for that reason I’m also trying to put there that you got to be dialoguing with policy because there will be issues on regulation on you know discussions in Congress.
So I didn’t say much but we’re also working of course to map the let’s say the legal changes that will affect any possibility of having let’s say the rule of law and like legal security in the region. So I believe that entrepreneurs need also to find the best partners. They’re amazing organizations. They’re doing different work like for the region. So depending on what kind of work you’re doing, join up forces. Don’t don’t shy away because some many times the private sector do not want to work with the public sector at all.
But for this region we need to understand who is responsible for what in the public sector and what are the changes that might affect my business. So I join up forces be with civil society be with multistakeholder coalition. So going alone today is very hard. So get into an ecosystem and the ecosystem today are in the networks you know there’s a consultation for the Amazon their coalition Brazil forest and agriculture there you know there you’re going to find the partners but also the institutions that are following this let’s say the regulation and the policy debate because this is a new frontier for many issues so if I just like my two cents here.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you very much very helpful No, thank you. Great question. Rosa.
Sarah Ingersoll:
Rosa, probably.
Rosa:
I’m from the Brazilian Biodiversity Fund. First of all, thank you very much and congratulations on the work you do. The illegal issues in the Amazon are not new. We know that it has been happening for a long time. But we haven’t seen in the last three, four years an increase in the problem and a dismantle of police and actions to contain this illegality. In a in a eventual change in government of next year, beginning of next year, what do you think it will take and how long it will take for us to revert again to a better and improve the situation of legal actions and not illegal activities.
Ilona Szabó de Carvalho:
Sure. Thank you so much, Ros and also thank you for the work you’re doing. It’s very important. So, I would say good news and bad news, right? Recommend the good news is that we’ve done that before in terms of reducing the forestation and I think there are many lessons from the past and we don’t need to reinvent all the wheels but that said I think there are new let’s say elements at the table these last years were as you’re saying these are not new problems but they are they are aggravated they aggravated because there are lots of let’s say new actors and empowered a actors that are involved in the illicit economies.
And here if I if you allow me are also just to make sure when we look what’s going on the ground, you’re going to have the let’s say the poor people that are involved in the illicit economies, but that they should not necessarily if they’re not violent be the target of the repression. We need to think about public policies that will help those people and I’m just really like we had a let’s say examples in the past as like a cash transfers public policies that we have to retrain these people.
So there is a economic inclusion needed to just give alternatives to the lowlevel echelons that are involved in let’s say informal illegal activities. I think the silver lining there is violence and that has to be a message that is so clear by any government that enters that says you know whatever is committed with like whatever crime passes the threshold of like violent crime you cannot do let’s say any transition plan or anything there has to be like a clear advice because the fear that I have and What happened this week was so serious also because it did cross many let’s say untold limits that you have and by talking because of the work we’re doing with the women defenders Rosa like the amount of indigenous especially indigenous women not only but the amount of leaders that tell us that they’re threatened that they suffer intimidation on their day-today lives that they’re suffering several kinds of violence including inside their groups many times because they are fighting the man that are sometimes willing to cooperate with some of the let’s say illegal loggers, illegal miners and so on.
That we have to kind of be super strong in terms of what’s the new rule and that said we cannot forget because when you look at what happened in the history there and I think this is this is a very pedagogical moment for all of us you know there were demarcations of land there were changes and the people that were there before were not taken into account in social policies So they were led to their own luck dare to say. So after a while you know survival cries louder and they start doing you know legal fishing in the let’s say in the indigenous reserve they start cooperating with drug traffickers that are passing down that road.
So we cannot forget the people. And I think when we talk about the Amazon, we always talk about the forest and we’re not talking about the people. So we have to think about the people in policies. And of course then in the long term there are many wonderful things that can be done to include the younger generations in let’s say the future economies and we can discuss that. And on the other side, a very clear message on what is going to be the priority for repression and violent crime has to be the first.
I would say a second for the ammonite should be mercury like any legal minor caught with mercury and you know like you have to kind of we’re preparing something that will be more clear in a few weeks in terms of proposals for that. And I would say a bigger thing is money laundering as well because we have to take the let’s say the big criminal organizations out of the picture like they were not so involved they are not so involved yet but they are much more involved than they were before and a lot in logistics a lot in you know opportunity crime so it’s not that they are taking over the rural parts they are much more present in the urban centers but We saw an advance of let’s say organized crime like crime organizations that we haven’t had before.
So look at the people and very smart repression with clear messages and focus and of course rebuilding of these institutions from Funai to Sibu to Burma and we’re also looking into like how one of the works we do in the civic space like realm of the work because we’re being let’s say crunched in Brazil is to understand how institutions also are suffering the same civil society journalist academia activists but also institutions and there like let’s say public servants are suffering you know harassment censorship and all sorts of things which was also the case of Bruno so we’re looking at FAI and other organizations and we’re going to have some let’s say insight and recommendations for the next government.
Unidentified participant:
On that front as well thank you thank you Manuel.
Manuel:
Hello first thank you very much for your lovely inputs. It’s really nice to hear a lot of new insights I got. So I’m from Switzerland. I studied geographic years ago and I just joined a huge project in Ara in Brazil. They supporting 360 families on 61,000 hectares and I help them to get investors from Europe to get money into this project and also get certified with carbon mark offsets to create a cash flow they can use in for the project to even grow more and support more farmers. And what I’m struggling right now a little bit is I have this all these documents we put together about the project and showing potential investor hey everything is here and but the investors I know in from Europe they’re really concerned ex especially because of frauds and stuff like that.
Do you have any recommendations for me how I can really get the information that this is really not a fraud? It’s not a scam and to yeah convince the investors that this is a real project and it’s a good one and it has many levels of beautiful things or the other questions where can I maybe find people in Brazil investors is there some network there are so.
Ilona Szabó de Carvalho:
I think this is so key Manuel because the fear we have now is that the Amazon will be tainted for good business, right? I mean, because of the reputational costs and that’s started to happen. So, there are many investors, you know, worldwide that say, I don’t want to touch that. Many investors in Brazil that don’t want to do projects in the Amazon as well. So, and I think we have a transition like this year will be very hard because there is such a disservice to the reputational front and of course the tragedies that are happening are so serious that it’s a wakeup call.
So I would say we are in an emergency model that we have to make sure we pass these months and get back to some kind of was never normal never easy as Rosa was raising with us but you had very good public servants doing their work. Okay. So I don’t know exactly what your project entails but my advice would be in a couple of months and today you know we can even talk after here we have we know who to talk in these institutions. So depending on what you’re doing we can tell you these are the key institutions to deal with you and who are the people that you can trust there because today unfortunately you have to pick and choose.
In the past was the opposite. We picked and choose you know the let’s say it was like mostly very competent and let’s say people willing to do good. There was always problems but we are in the other way around. So first understand what you’re doing and who could relate to you in that sense. We’re also working very close to the prosecutors in Brazil the federal prosecutors and they understand a lot. They, you know, so this is a good contact depending on what you’re doing because they can, you know, they have a more they’re not so contam they’re not mostly contaminated with the what’s going on.
So they have autonomy. So it’s a good institution also to you know talk and to get close again depending on what you’re doing. I don’t know. So I can we can talk afterwards. So you give me the information and on the on the part of the networks I mentioned in my presentation a few ones in Brazil that are full of people that are doing there. So this coalition Brazil climate and agriculture and a consultation for the Amazon. These are huge coalitions like with hundreds of companies, entrepreneurs, civil society, activists that are exchanging a lot and helping each other in different you know be the task forces that are inside the networks be outside in more let’s say smaller groups for bilateral project.
So a lot a lot happening there also help like happy to put you in touch. I’m sure Sarah and John also know the heads. I don’t know if there’s anybody here from those coalitions, but we could we could put you in touch with the right people if you’re interested. And you know, to say I do believe that it doesn’t matter who will come in 2023 this, you know, unless you know, of course, it’s the same government. If it’s not I do believe that u we will we will go back to public service being a plus for the region.
There are many things that need to change there and we’re going to have to rebuild a lot of these capacities but there’s so many people that are not in public service now that they ask for a license and so on that are so incredible and they were doing great work. So we want to make sure the region you know like we need to support the institutions in the coming months so they regain and also reshape their profiles to deal with the new challenges that emerged.
Manuel:
Yeah, perfect. Thank you very much. I just saw Sarah and Fernando wrote me so I going to get in contact with you. Thank you very much. Thank you.
Ilona Szabó de Carvalho:
And also if anybody from the team, Andrea Ala, Peter, Carol, just feel free to jump in and add. I’m speaking here. You can you can add if you have anything to say, please.
Sarah Ingersoll:
Go ahead, Louis.
Louis:
Yeah. Okay. All right. Well, first, thanks Yolana for the presentation. It is, as Jose said, I mean, it’s quite shocking to see the problem is well known for us Brazilian worldwide. Today is a very sad days for us in Brazil. But what is quite striking for me is how fast once we change the federal government and you have like a new ideology in place, how fast deteriorated the governance of the Amazon. So my question is how on a state level you believe that can serve as a counter way to the federal government, right?
Because I don’t have much visibility today. I mean what’s people are doing in the government of para the Amazonia a and so on. So I’d like to have like a little bit more color if you could give on like how those states on a state level can help support the private community.
Ilona Szabó de Carvalho:
So Louise, I think this is so key and the challenge was that the challenge is that most governors of those states they supported or support still the actual president in the moment. So there is and why is that and that’s very important for us Brazilians also to understand the narratives that we have in general about the region do not include the right to develop that they you know they have and I think what we have to strike is a conversation of what is development with all the information we have with all the resources that will be available for let’s say the economies of the future that take into account of course the you know the amazing richness that we have there with the standing forest.
So, but we are not talking to them and so we involved in several initiatives today that are mapping let’s say electoral preferences to understand what are the main grievances and also on the narratives group in the consultation for the Amazon on like striking also like how can we talk to the people of the Amazon because I think we are not communicating well and we’re opening a door just to say you cannot not develop and the people that live there almost you know like if you take the Amazon basing 30 million people they there right so what do we do with them so on that front Louise I would say that we have to do a huge work in terms of building a national idea of what is development for the Amazon and for those people I think we have to as I said we lost capacity institutional capacity very fast.
We’re going to have to rebuild it. It takes longer to rebuild. And when it comes to the governors, it’s also election year. I would say that for us in the work we’re doing, they are key. We are even now starting to, you know, to there’s a public security task force within the consortium for the Amazon, the governor’s consortium for the Amazon that we’re starting a dialogue and regardless of the result of the election. I think we have to empower them and this is also true when we talk about LEAF coalition or we talk about bilateral cooperation.
Are saying do look there because not only governors but some of the mayors even if they support the governor the government you can I think have a more pragmatic let’s say based on proposals and based on an agenda relationship with them than you can have today because today it’s very hard to have any relationship with the federal government. So for us they are already let’s say an important stakeholder. They also formalized this governor’s coalition as an alter in 2019. So this is an opportunity to work and I think they do need support.
Of course, as you know, possibly as a Brazilian, we have the, you know, the non nondes in English maybe it’s non-desated public forests that are state level. You know, there’s the federal level. So, they have actually a lot of work to do in their own land. And we’re looking when we’re looking at this multi-dimensional security agenda, we’re also looking at the state level let’s say institutions and competent like competences that we can boost up or we can you know help to improve to deal at least in the land where they have the jurisdiction for.
And it’s true also if you want to let’s say build a harmonized policy you need to work with the urban centers because they are many times like a you know isolated from the discussion about the force they don’t see themselves as part of that. So let’s say an avenue of possibilities of working with governors challenging today election year but we decided that we’re going to start to prepare the ground for 2023 onwards like do more kind of let’s say hopefully proactive work but I would encourage to reach out there is a secretariat of this consortium that I would encourage the that those that are you know working public policy do reach out to them.
Thank you.
Sarah Ingersoll:
Anyone else who might be more shy? Any you can anything you don’t have individuals who are new to this space and so every question is very important.
Ilona Szabó de Carvalho:
Yeah, we know these are very tough issues, but it’s so important that we all have an understanding of what they mean and how what can we do and don’t don’t feel discouraged in my presentation, please. The opposite here is the intent.
Sarah Ingersoll:
Danielle’s also part of the Amazon Investor Coalition and she’s our chief research and innovation officer with a good strong background in forestry and all sorts of good things. So Danielle, you just disappeared.
Unidentified participant:
Oh, I’m still here. Oh, good. Okay, there you are. Thank you so much for the.
Danielle Rappaport:
Presentation and for sharing that really wonderful overview of your of your work. Love to get your sense on what you’re what are the technological innovations that you’re keeping an eye on that you’re most excited about in terms of really being able to put a kibos on illegal forest deforestation in at scale.
Ilona Szabó de Carvalho:
Perfect. I think there are many Danielle and I’m sure there are people in the in the call that could jump in and add more but from I’ll say when you see smallcale traceability from cattle to timber this is already happening a challenge we have that we haven’t developed yet and I know WWF is going to that direction we’re helping them to think in terms of advocacy is like gold traceability but when you think other supply chains there are many things being used so for example, you know, Brazil already exports you know, beef that is traceable for the European Union.
Why not to other places? Why not to local markets? Simply because we’re not asking to. So, it’s a matter of like scaling up, you know, with the timber. We also have a lot of work done which sometimes gets in the problem of fraud and so on. But there are technologies that could be let’s say scaled up and I would say understanding what where the gaps to be closed. I think we are we are with a serious let’s say public environment around us we could be doing much better on traceability in terms of technologies that map for example the genom the DNA of the forest and so on.
So I think there we need a lot of investment. So there are efforts in task forces for example linked into the world economic forum to map like the whole genome of the earth like when you think about the richness and what could be still discovered in these places. So there is let’s say a huge investment to be made on that front but also in the governance of that information given that we should think about you know how to benefit the local populations how to treat this more as public goods that just private patents and so there is a balance that we need to strike between private public governance issues and I think this is important.
Another set of technologies that I think are really key now is the mapping of biodiversity because that’s also you know less let’s say it’s could be part of this bigger DNA but it’s not so it’s not about only that it’s more about what kinds of let’s say resources biological resources are there and I think for carbon markets and for valuing unfortunately putting let’s say a dollar a dollar figure that will be needed when you think about the let’s say decisions tradeoffs and so on we are advancing so we are also you know talking and many of these startups that are doing amazing like let’s say already trials have come to us and we’re talking with some on the on the biodiversity field.
So I’ll there is a lot of need for more robust investment but I think we can not only think on that especially when you talk about let’s say the DNA of the forest in terms of private money we need to strike also a conversation on the governance of this information. When you think about pharmaceuticals and so on so I think this is a huge topic that I don’t see a lot of debate because we have so any more let’s say mundane debates but I think we have to look into the future and start talking about these issues now and what kind of investment would be necessary to make them possible because this would just enhance the case of why we have to protect and bring sustainable development and so on.
Thank you.
Sarah Ingersoll:
Great question. Alona, thank you so much. This sort of this concludes the end of our formal section of the podcast. I want to thank you all for joining us. I hope this was productive for you. But a very huge thanks to Institute for the work that you’re doing. And if folks want to stay on a little bit more, we call it the water cooler time. It’s unofficial. Just behind the scenes if there was a kind of more private or question you wanted to ask or were a little bit shy with everybody,.
Unidentified participant:
You can stay on. If that’s okay, Elona, can you stay on just a few more minutes? Yes, of course. Of course. Yes. Sure. Stop. Stop the recording.