A Brazilian Coalition of Companies and Environmentalists Working on Sustainable Land Management and Deforestation
The Brazilian Coalition on Climate, Forests and Agriculture (Coalizao BR) is a movement of 300+ groups from academia, civil society, finance, and the private sector. Created in 2014, they work on nature protection, conservation, agriculture, climate change adaptation, and sustainable use of natural and planted forests. The coalition collaborates on deforestation prevention, federal bioeconomy policy, green finance promotion, carbon market development, ecosystem restoration, and Forest Code implementation. How can the Amazon help Brazil become a low-carbon economic development leader? How can Brazil reverse the upward trend of deforestation? How important is it for the private sector to get involved? Join us to meet the Coalition’s Co-Facilitator, Rachel Biderman, the Senior Vice President of the Americas for Conservation International.
Recorded April 4, 2022
References:
Brazilian Coalition stands for the creation of a National Policy on Bioeconomy
Amazon deforestation hits record high and shows Brazil heading toward the abyss
Actions for a Prompt Deforestation Halt
2030-2050 Vision: The Future of Forests and Agriculture in Brazil
The Restoration and Reforestation Observatory
Debut of the Brazilian Restoration and Reforestation Observatory (video)
WATCH:
Participants
- Jonah Wittkamper
- Rachel Biderman
- Chip Barber
- Tammy
- Marian
- Jean-Louis
- Lars Løvold
- Fiona Banister
- Unidentified participant
Transcript
Jonah Wittkamper:
Hello everybody. Welcome to the 80s something call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing forcefriendly economic development and the rule of law across the Amazon region of South America. This week we are featuring the work of the Brazilian climate forest agricultural coalition which I’m going to affectionately call Kohz behi or the BR coalition and representing it is SVP of the Americas of conservation international Rachel Bidderman. Rachel say hi to us. Tell us a little bit about yourself.
Rachel Biderman:
Hi Jonah, it’s a pleasure being here. I have I see so many familiar faces and longtime friends. It’s a pleasure to be here with you. I am also co-f facilitator of the Brazilian coalition on climate forest and agriculture. This is my second year in tenure, but my daily job is to lead the work of conservation international in the Americas. So the work that I do for the coalition is a type of collaboration or voluntary work I do on behalf of our organization and I’m very happy to be here to share some of our work in the past six years.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. To start Liz with let’s talk a little bit about you and your affection for forest. Can you tell us a little bit about where you grew up and how you originally got involved in conservation?
Rachel Biderman:
That’s a long story, Jonah, but I’ll short I’ll do a short version. I actually since my childhood, I grew up in a in a in a small farm close to the rainforest with my grandparents very close to the waterfalls and forest and planting and doing restoration from a very early age. So that stick to me and as a lawyer I went into environmental law and joined work with non-governmental organizations in the early 90s and for 30 years now have been working with non-governmental and some private sector work and now I have the pleasure and honor to be part of the CI team and of the coalition as well and very recently I would like to point out I was with so it’s very close to my heart.
I see a lot of double eye folks here. So I was helping establish the Brazil office of the world resources institute before I joined CI for nine years. I was part of that wonderful team.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. Before we get into the presentation about the coalition, tell us a little bit more about CI and its work in the Amazon.
Rachel Biderman:
Thanks Jenna. So CI has been in the region for 30 years. Our first office in the region was in Bolivia. Now we have nine country offices and we work in another 20 we work in a total of 20 offices in the Americas but we have sorry we work in 20 countries in the Americas but we have offices in nine countries of the Americas. In the Amazon we have physical presence and team in seven countries. And we’ve been engaged more recently with efforts with the French government and with Estel and as well with the business fund working with many organizations especially indigenous people’s local communities and many not for-profit NOS’s in the environmental space.
We have a long tradition of working with the creation of protected areas but also with the sustainable livelihoods of forest peoples. So it’s a long story. I’m very proud to be part of this team. I’ve been visiting some of our work and was very impressed for instance with the work we do in Alto and Peru connecting all of those fronts. So there’s a lot of history and capacity that CI has been developing in the region.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. And then one more related question if you could share how does CI differentiate its work in the Amazon region compared to some of the other large international NOS’s like WWF or WRI or the Nature Conservancy that are also very much at play.
Rachel Biderman:
Well, that’s a great question and I and I hope and I see that more and more we’re working closer together with all of those organizations. But I would say that CI’s particular contribution is having foots on the ground. We work with communities on the ground in many of the Amazonian territories. We in Brazil for instance we’re working with the Yawan Nawa the Ashaninka and the Kayapo indigenous peoples. In Peru we work in the Altoayo region. In Colombia Peru we work in Putoayo. So we have been engaging with from farmers, small land own landholders, communities, indigenous people’s associations and big farmers as well.
We do a lot of the on the ground work that includes conservation but also in the outskirts or in the buffer zones of protected areas. We’re doing a lot of sustainable production and more and more working with indigenous women’s leaders and also rural women leaders in their sustainable livelihoods. I would say that we our work has a lot to do with the work that TMC has been doing. We are very you know we collaborate in many of those territories. With regard to I would say that we are very complimentary. I see that has been doing a lot of intelligence on economy that is very much needed for grounding our work you know in terms of the three of change WWF also works in many of the territories where we work but they are they work in others that we don’t so we are now working as part of the latisia packed NGO group we are actually mapping who’s doing what and where in the Amazon.
So very soon the community will be able to see where these different NOS’s or be it international or partners are doing work in the Amazon. I think we are in days today where you know adding our forces and our resources is more than urgent. So that I think there are many efforts in that regard. In Brazil I can mention the work of the coalition where many of these NGOs’s are part but also working with the Moore Foundation many of us do coordinator work or with the Norwegian. So just some examples of how u the different actors are collaborating but we can do much more in terms of collaboration.
I think we are geared towards that in this in this year and age.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. That sets a perfect stage to talk about the creation and the work of coalitions. From what I understand, you have a presentation. Is that right?
Rachel Biderman:
Actually, I don’t I was just working with my colleagues with some notes. So, I’ll just talk about some of the issues you sent us in advance or I’m open to any questions actually.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Okay, great. No worries. So first question tell us about the coalition when was it created its purpose who are the members?
Rachel Biderman:
Sure. The coalition was created in 2014 in the runup for the Paris COP. We realized in Brazil that many of the corporate efforts and the not for-profit organizations were you know very aligned and we decided we could do more together especially to attract investments for a lowcarbon economy. So we got together a group of about 30 leaders from corporations and NOS’s and we created this coalition and then during the COP of Paris we presented our you know grounding our ground rules or our plan of work and from then on we have been tackling many topics that relate to attracting investment to Brazil showing best practices influencing the adoption of policies, avoiding setbacks of our legislation which we saw in the last two years and working in Congress specifically in laws regarding the market, the carbon market but also payment for environmental services.
So we have been working now for six years together. We are about 300 entities. We have a governance that includes 20 members in a in a in a board. I am the co-chair of this board. We also have different instances doing a lot of the heavy lifting. So we call them the working groups and under the grow working groups we have task forces. So basically today we have 14 different groups working on different topics that include bioeconomy u avoiding deforestation or economic instruments payment for environmental services sustainable agriculture and cattle ranging.
So I think we have the best of the minds and also the organizations in the country who are proposing a more progressive agenda. We are fighting many setbacks in Brazil as you know but I think that together we have been able to present many solutions. One of the one of the founding principles of this group is that we are about solutions. We’re not about doing the diagnostics of how bad things are, right? We want to be constructive and proactive. And that’s one of the things I think that is the our recipe for success.
And many of these of the members of the coalition of the board are CEOs of big companies. We have people from also banks involved in the finance work. So I think we have a good sample of the main actors that want to put Brazil in a different in a different stage of its history. We’re hoping for changes in this election so that we can really progress more rapidly towards our goal. From what I understand, you guys are uniting sometimes what are politically divergent constituencies, for example, environmental interests and business interests and building consensus between such constituencies can be challenging.
So, I’m wondering if you guys do that and if so, how? And if you could give us some examples, that’d be great. Yeah, we work not on we try to work on the basis of consensus. So many of our manifestations or our statements are published publicly and we send them to the president of Brazil or to the president of Congress up to the ministers depending on the subject. And whenever we publish such a statement the way to get to that document or to that decision is through consensus and when we don’t have consensus we agree that those who are not totally for the manifestation will give their consent.
So we work with consensus and consent to get to have this public statements published. Some of them are controversial and it takes us a long time to get to. One recent example has to do had to do with the bill of law being discussed in the Brazilian Congress on mining in indigenous territories. So very recently because of the war in Ukraine. Brazil being a big agriculture economy saw itself in a in a threatening situation as we depend a lot on potassium from imported from Russia for our agriculture. So it’s a big source of mineral fertilizer and we saw ourselves in a very you know extreme situation.
Some members of Congress proposed to rapidly address this by allowing through law the rapid deployment of mining in indigenous territories. That became a huge controversy in the country and our coalition rapidly got together and addressed the topic and it was not easy to get a statement and but we finally did. One of our fi finding founding princ principles that is contained in what we call our green book. The green book is a book that took almost two years to be prepared and approved by all the members. This green book states our main principles and goals and there one of the principles is that we will defend and promote the demarcation of indigenous territories.
We believe that those territories are very relevant not only for the peoples that the people who live there and for their cultures and identity but also for our economy as a whole and for agriculture. So our members when they become part of coalition they have to subscribe or agree to that book and the green book and indigenous territories are a part of our vision. So we resorted to that founding principle. It’s like the American constitution or any country’s constitution. That is our constitution. Indigenous territories are key to our objective. So we finally agreed on a manifestation against that bill of law in Congress.
So that’s one example where we have many discussions and where we resort to our founding principles and have a solution. Sorry for the long answer.
Jonah Wittkamper:
No, that’s what I’m looking for. That’s what we’re all looking for. So another related question I think that a lot of funders and governments and NOS’s are skeptical of collaboration with the private sector. Can you tell us why collaboration with the private sector is particularly needed key strategic and maybe some of the obstacles that come with that and how to overcome them.
Rachel Biderman:
Well, I think that you know 30 years after Rio 92 or 50 years after Stockholm, there’s so much that has taken place in our society, right? So corporations have become key players of the sustainable world and they have the economic power to change things and many are really committing to net zero and they are committing to biodiversity conservation and they’re committing to social targets and they are agreeing to science-based targets. So we a lot has passed, a lot has changed and we are very confident at the coalition that we will not achieve the scale and the solutions we need unless we unite all forces and corporate is one of the most impactful and relevant forces we have today in our in our world.
So many of the organizations that are part of the coalition have been doing partnerships with corporations since the beginning since they were created and it’s a no-brainer for us. So we can find the coalition of the willing amongst all of those actors. And in fact, when we created the coalition in Braz the Brazilian coalition, we found that we had a lot more in common than we had in terms of differences and controversy. So we now find ourselves in a new moment here in Brazil in terms of the land use and agriculture and forest policy world where we are as strong we feel stronger as a notfor-profit organizations working with corporations than we felt in the past.
We still have our points of controversy, but we do a lot more together and we have very little points of controversy mostly. We agree and for the and for the climate challenge and the biodiversity and the big extinction challenge, it takes everything, right? It takes everyone. It takes all these willing people to make a change, to make a dent on this very threatening curve. Let’s talk a little bit about national policy. I understand that you guys have a proposal for a new national bioeconomy policy. It’s exciting. Can you first tell us what is your definition of bioeconomy and tell us a little bit about your proposal?
Yeah, we started by discussing the concept as you know u many in different parts of the world by economy means different things. So there’s a task force at the coalition with I think more than a dozen people they started from scratch right first the concept and then where what we wanted to do the coalition the Brazilian coalition is not the only actor working on bio economy in Brazil there are many others there’s a consultation on the Amazon there’s the para state forum on bioeconomy and so on and so forth so we are one of the alliances that is focusing on the theme we basically chose those two topics.
One is the is the potential for forestry and agroforestry products coming out of the Amazon but we’re also including other biomes but Amazon is the big one and the other topic we chose is you know technology R&D so we think that to gain scale certain value chains we’ll need to invest a lot in R&D and we will need also to compile pile information this information regarding the bioeconomy is scattered around different governmental non-governmental academic organizations and initiatives. So we need to start from compiling data in one single space where we can really see the size of these different economies their scales and how we can attract investment.
The other topic is we find we need that through a policy. So we decided as a group to promote an agenda with Congress. We will be working this coming year and the next with Congress leaders to present a bill of law on bioeconomy because one of the things we find is that the incentives are not there. We need the economic instruments. We need the markets. We need you know the different taxes for the different value the different supply chains. So we are we’ll be working through policy to have this bioeconomy in place and we work hand inhand with the Amazon consultation on this topic.
This is another u alliance of leaders who work in the Amazon. So they have advanced a lot in concepts. So we are supporting each other in this joint effort.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Part of developing policy is ensuring wise and progressive implementation of those policies. So let’s go to another project of the coalition. I’d appreciate if you could tell us about the Brazilian Restoration and Reforestation Observatory. Give us a little bit about its background, what it is, and what your hopes are for its future.
Rachel Biderman:
Thank you, Jonah. So, Brazil has presented as part of it NDC a very, ambitious target for restoration. About 12 million hectares of restoration is one of the targets. We realized early on when the coalition was being built that we had the best u organizations, minds and technical people to be able to present contributions to Brazil’s MDC around restoration. The Brazil is a very advanced country in terms of restoration. There is a lot of knowledge and competence in the academia in the sylvvi culture sector. We have one of the biggest companies in the world in pulp and paper a lot of knowledge in many of governmental agencies like in Braa.
So under the collision we brought all of these actors together and identified the need for mapping restoration where is it taking place at what scale which type of restoration and so on. So we created the observatory there and we have organizations like TNC, DARI, conservation international you name it under this group but we also have the companies right we have support from Susano from Clabin from folks from other from the corporations who are have been doing conservation and restoration for over a decade now and we identified under the task force for restoration of the coalition that one of the ways to gain scale which is the name of the game these days is about gaining scale in terms of restoration as a n natural climate solution we would need to also invest in R&D for native silver culture economy so that means basically trying to put Brazil in a different help Brazil develop a different silver culture that would be based on native species.
Our silver culture is based on eucalyptus and pinus for pulp and paper and wood. And we see that we have a lot of potential if we would work with some of the native species from the Amazon and the Atlantic rainforest to start. And there’s a ongoing effort with academics with business sector to create this R&D platform and we have identified now sources of funding from BNDS and others to launch the R&D and the pre-ompetitive work around native species silver culture. So that’s one example of a very concrete result. But besides that, we also have different groups working on the connection between the not for-p profofit world and the profit world in terms of the scaling up of the production of sib seedlings, collection of seeds, everything that is on the very base of the supply chain for restoration.
So a lot under that umbrella in the restoration.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. Okay, one more question from me and then I’m going to invite everyone else who’s on the call to raise their hand, indicate their interesting questions, write out their questions in the chat. We’ll be calling on them mostly in the order that they get proposed. So last question for me. I took a look at the coalition’s 2030 to 2050 vision. It really inspires there’s a lot about the future for the Amazon for Brazil in there. One significant element inside it calls for aligned and integrated economic instruments. I was wondering if you could tell us a little bit about those instruments.
Rachel Biderman:
As we work a lot with leaders in Congress and many of our members have been you know are from the policy space. We know that Brazil since the 90s have passed the best environmental laws and but we lack enforcement to the degree needed and especially the last two to three years even more so. We have basically failed in terms of implementation of the high ambitions that our environmental laws you know established and economic instruments are not there in our in our policy. We have long studied and we envy the United States for some of their mechanisms, right?
We all studied the air the clean air act and others who that created some kinds of incentives in markets. So we have been trying for a long time here in Brazil to install the payment for environmental services or other types of instruments. I think we are now closer to that. Brazil finally has its payment for environmental services law. There’s a the regul the regulatory work of these laws is being done as we speak that the conservation movement and the coalition and others have been working on the this regulation. So soon we will have payment for environmental services probably at the large scale of the of the whole country and we lack the carbon market.
We don’t have the carbon taxes and carbon pricing yet to the point that we need it. So we envy Colombia for instance that has that and I know Fernando and Adrian are here. So Colombia has the carbon tax law. We want to get there and the coalition has put in into its 20 30 2050 vision that we will get to a low economy by installing such instruments and we’re working hard in Congress to get there. But to start with that I think the first step will be a carbon market and this is something that we have a working group very working very hard on.
We are hoping that with some changes in the near future we will be able to pass that law. And but the but in terms of the voluntary market Brazil is a very heated space. It’s there’s a lot of interest and many investors trying to bring those resources but we need the policies. Are not there yet and the collision is trying to push that envelope.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. Okay. First up, I all presenters, it would be great if you could introduce yourselves. Even those who introduce themselves in the beginning of the call before the recording. Please introduce reintroduce yourselves just so it gets captured. First up is Chip.
Chip Barber:
There. Hi again. And hi Rachel. It’s been a while. Good to see you. I’m Chip Barber with World Resources Institute and my question is about the Biden administration’s global forest plan which was announced at the Glasgow conference. I’m sure you’re familiar with it with a 9 billion target for spending supposedly a new money between now and 2030. There’s a bill in Congress right now trying to put that $9 billion aside as an authorization. And we and others get a lot of questions about if you had you know if you were trying to take a whole of government approach and you had some new resources and you were trying to save the critical carbon force carbon syncs of the world Amazon being the number one among those although they’re also looking at Congo and Southeast Asia what would you do you know that’s basically what would you do in 2022 and what would you do for a strategy going forward not only in terms of foreign assistance but in terms in terms of trade policy, in terms of diplomacy.
And you know I think people are seriously scratching their heads and saying okay we made this commitment how practically we take it forward we’ve given the answer along with a number of other people here in part well you need to consult a lot more with people on the ground in the key countries that you’re going to focus on you can’t just talk to you know some experts and NOS’s and people in Washington so I’m you know. But it’s an opportunity obviously and what do you think are some of the key things that the US government as you know in government to government relationships you know as well as a donor can do both at the for the region in the Amazon but particularly with Brazil because I think there’s a lot of questions about well you know it’s no secret the administration there is a bit hard to work with on a lot of these issues right now as you know and you.
Know subnational approaches civil society but what are the best ways to engage and you know a lot of people asking those questions around here So be very interested in your thoughts on that from the coalition’s perspective or your own thoughts. Thanks.
Rachel Biderman:
Thanks, Chip. It’s wonderful to see you. I miss you. I miss working with you. Chip and I were colleagues at we did a lot together. So it’s great to hear you. So, so there is a working group now as we speak getting together to work on a proposition for the discussions in the US in Congress for that bill of law. We are trying to engage with other alliances in Brazil to do that to go beyond Brazil right because it pertains to Amazon which is not only regarding Brazil but we are doing this now and we hope to send some recommendations so I cannot speak to the you know on behalf of the collision on this because this is ongoing work I know you know from conversations I’ve been having with Adriana Lobo at and other colleagues year has been doing work on the new economy for the Amazon.
I find that a lot can come from that effort with regard to the to this new law. But in my personal view, so now I have a personal opinion about this, you know, as a lawyer trained as a lawyer in the initial phase of my career, I’m kind of obsessed these days with law enforcement. I think we have to go back to the 90s where we did a lot of work with judges, lawyers, state and federal prosecutors, police, all law enforcement agents in the Amazon to simply enforce laws. We have good laws in all of the Amazonian countries and we need that physical presence of law enforcers.
So for me it’s about if we could do a lot of that in partnership with not for-profit organizations and using the different tools we have out there right we have the global force watch we have rise we have the work that Amazon do so there’s so much out there that we can use to be more effective in terms of law enforcement I also find that we need a strong communications effort and the instit here and clu have done a lot in terms of identifying where we could progress more quickly. So it’s no it’s not no-brainers like we have these big institutions already thinking about solutions.
It’s about sitting down and putting those together and presenting to the decision makers in the US Congress. Also we learned a lot from the Amazon fund. It’s very unfortunate that it was cancelled under the Bolsonaro administration. There’s still money there and need to co-inance I think between Amazon fund and whatever funds will be channeled in terms of Brazil but we there are many lessons learned and there are many of you here who are part of this investors coalition that have been doing this yourselves. So I think that the more we work together to present the acupuncture points right where we will make the most with the amount of money we will have because these resources are not nearly enough for the challenge we have ahead of us to avoid the tipping point but also all of these in my opinion has to do with building back better after COVID and pandemic and war.
So we need to consider the 40 million people living in the Amazon. It is about livelihoods. It is about fighting poverty. So if that is not the number one topic in our agenda, we will not succeed. We have people living there. They’re encroached and pressured by all criminalities. Recently you probably have access to the Egarap study. They did a good mapping of how connected all these different illegalities are and how big narot trafficking is. So if we don’t we don’t give options for the population they may be they may need to work for an illegal activity.
So we need to avoid that and also in there are so many experiences now that I am at CI I can see how much we have been engaging with the local communities in de in developing all sorts of local production alternatives there. You know, recently in Brazil, Conexus did a big mapping and they identified over 1,000 economic activities being led by micro or small enterprises. And they’re all over the place in Colombia, they’re all over the place in Peru, Ecuador, you name it. And if we could make a joint effort to sustain those initiatives, they’re they are small in terms of the unit, but they are big in terms of the whole of the Amazon.
So I’ll stop here. I know you guys have much more ideas and experience. Oh, but one last point that I always like to bring, you know, engaging and working with Carlos Nobi in the last couple of years, I’ve been very lucky to listen to his you know, wisdom and he has been there for decades, right? And Carlos talks a lot about the Silicon Valley of the Amazon. It’s about high-tech. So at the same time, we need to have the high-tech investments that will bring us to the next century in terms of food and protein production, but also cosmetics and mostly pharmaceuticals.
So there’s a lot to be done in the Amazon.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. Thank you. Next up is Tammy and please introduce yourself.
Tammy:
Hi, good afternoon. Thank you so much for such a stimulating and well-informed well to me presentation. You talking about corporates before and certainly the names which were thrown out are the pulp and paper industry which I think have done a relatively good job relative to most corporates because that’s what they have to do. I specifically want to understand where JBS or MAFR or Brazil beef are in this in the width in their willingness to participate. Because certainly if some of their business can be scaled back or recalc calibrated that would be a wonderful case for juris jurisdictional or volunt or involuntary sorry jurisdictional or voluntary red projects.
Thank you.
Rachel Biderman:
Thank you Tammy. Actually these beef corporations, the big groups are part of the coalition. We’ve been working with them on traceability and they are super important. I think they are getting more and more engaged and they are establishing their targets. The point is, you know, today we have the IPCC new report, right? We are running out of time. So for certain commodities, certain chains, we will need to accelerate solutions and you know it’s about leap frog leaprogging. It’s almost like you know quantum leap. It’s so the acceleration certain supply chains needs to be in coherent with the with the with the size of the challenge and that’s I think the biggest challenge for organizations like them and it’s a it has to be a rapid learning curve.
It we will need to see a lot more investment than we are seeing these days. It’s not about small projects. It’s about changing completely. It’s almost like the energy revolution we saw happen in Germany for I don’t know decades. It will have to happen in five years. So how do we take that quantum leap is the big question for me.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Thank you. Next up Marian and please introduce yourself.
Marian:
Sure. Thank you Jonah. And thank you Rachel for this great information. I’m Marian Aidney. I’m the director of Amazon and fire programs at Conservation XLabs. And we do a lot of work with te technology and open innovation for improving conservation practices. You spoke a little bit to some of the aspects of my question. Actually I have a ton of questions but in particular you know there’s been a lot of efforts to scale forestbased enterprises and you know Kexus has worked quite a bit on this as you mentioned but I was just wondering if you could talk a little bit more about what is that approach to scaling from these small projectbased type things to a mediumscale economy and then related to that how do you bring in the urban populations of the Amazon, many of whom have a lot of different views on the use of the forest and potential production value of forests.
Rachel Biderman:
Oh, I think there are people here who know more than about this than myself. We have been addressing those topics at the quadition for sure. I think the big the big scaling up that we need to do of certain sustainable supply chains in the Amazon is one of the best solutions we can bring. Very difficult in terms of the beef sector as I was just saying you know we have to do those huge accelerations as we reduce u meat consumption at the same time that the technology world is bringing us you know protein produced in laboratories we may not need the animals in the future so I think as we evolve we are we are working on these different solutions.
I find that we need to work. I don’t have an answer for you and unfortunately Marian but what the one thing that I know you know being in this space for 30 years is that we have to get these minds together these corporations together the investors together I think that’s one of the best one of the beauties of the work we do when the coalition we finally got to a space where we have the coalition of the willing and we can attract you know the decision makers from the investment world to the small scale producing world.
So having that convening power is super relevant. My big dream is to have a coalition of this sort for P pan Amazonia and organizations like ours today here meeting here have the power to do that. You already are something like that as an investors coalition and perhaps if you if you expand to I don’t know if you’re bringing invest producers as well you would have you would be like our coalition in Brazil so I think that we have huge challenges we need to get the best minds and we need the resources to do those piloting and labs where we will scale up I find that in other commodities like soy for instance, we could learn a lot.
There are some pilots going on in Brazil for instance on large scale restoration where you work with the whole chain to help them not only comply with the forest code the forest laws but also go beyond the legal requirements and do restoration at a bigger scale in the Serado for instance. If we could do that in the Amazon and get the main supply chains to work on promoting more conservation, more restoration and producing more intensively in smaller areas, we could perhaps avoid the tipping point, but we need to have the biggest supply chains together.
I know of this wonderful effort in the recent past led by the Moore Foundation with TNC and WWF. I think they were getting close to a good solution there. I don’t know where that stands right now, but I think they were in the right track.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Marian, do you want to explain where that last thing she was talking about where that is now? Do you know?
Marian:
You mean with the more foundation?
Jonah Wittkamper:
Yeah.
Marian:
Yeah. I can I can just give I guess a small update although I left the more foundation at the end of this year. So the things sorry the end of last year so the things that have happened have happened since I left but I’m sure many of you have seen that the more foundation board approved an additional 10 years focus for the Amazon with a 300 million allocation and the main themes for that I think they’re they’re doing detailed study this year to really nail it down But the themes that they’re focused on are freshwater ecosystem conservation, indigenous and traditional land stewardship, including increasing the amount of indigenous and traditional community lands.
And then the enabling conditions for preservation of those areas outside including infrastructure and potentially mining. And again, this happened since I left the Moore Foundation, so I’m not speaking for the Moore Foundation, but this is my understanding of where they’re going.
Rachel Biderman:
So, it was it was great news actually. It was it was really it was great to see the board approve another 10 years. That doesn’t happen often. So, I think that really shows the commitment of the Moore Foundation. And I have spoken to Avisita and the team and they are very focused on maintaining the at least 70% forest cover to avoid the tipping point. So that’s sort of like the driving focus which has been their driving focus for a long time.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. Okay. Next up we have two people who have raised their hands asked questions. Jean Louie and then Lars. And if you guys can keep it brief so that we can finish before the top of the hour would be great. Jean Louie. Yes.
Jean-Louis:
Yes. Thank you, Jonah, and thank you, Rachel. This is really amazing. I was wondering if you could speak to the role that the landscape approach plays in your work and specifically in two ways. One, we talk a lot about value chains. What do you see as the role of landscapes as the context for making those integrated investments that can help accelerate a variety of projects, right, that if they thrive together can create transformation together and then second the role of different kinds of capital and in particular the connection between philanthropic capital, venture philanthropy for what we like to call project preparation, feasibility, early stage acceleration And then the larger investment vehicles that can get created but often kind of end up in a void because there isn’t the preparation stage that’s appropriately covered.
Rachel Biderman:
Thanks Shri. I would say that under the coalition we don’t necessarily work with the landscape approach but many of the organizations that work at the coalition are doing that right. I think that’s the one of the main approaches and methodologies used these days is they seem to be more effective. So I’m a big fan of the landscape approach myself. And to be able to visualize and grow I mean and be effective and measure landscape approach makes total sense in my opinion. In terms of the finance, I think that we work more and more towards blended finance in sustainability.
Many of the investors are you know now more connected. There are different investor investors forum like this one trying to blend the different types colors of money. I only find that we are falling short of what we need. Right? We are not nearly where we need to be at this point of climate change crisis and biodiversity crisis. So we need to move faster and we need to be able to attract the billions that we are not attracting yet. I see an effort being led for instance by the business fund in that direction also by you know some governments like the US so that’s I think good news but we will need on the on the supply side to be able to manage all those funds I find that many organizations are not ready to manage the big level of resources that will be needed for the for the challenge we have ahead and a big part of this solution can be done through market and as we see the carbon market heating up after Glasgow I find that there’s one way to deploy solutions through companies through big operations and all of these models are welcome I think they all will have to coexist and be better aligned my question is always on how where is the space where we align So philanthropics are already organized in that sense.
There are many funders tables that take place. I think with the bilateral financing world they do get together and organize the multilaterals as well. I wonder where is the place where these all of these funding mechanisms get together. That’s what I’m not seeing and I find it’s important. But also on the part of the takers I’ve been learning I’m learning a lot at CI in terms of partnerships with indigenous peoples. We are as you know sustainability community are putting a lot of hopes in the hands and the shoulders of indigenous communities and we created a very heavy bureaucracy to lend money to lend to grant money.
This is not something that these communities can manage in the time frame that we need nor does it make sense for them. So I think we will need to rebuild rules around grant making to communities. Indigenous peoples is just one example because we are demanding all sorts of you know guarantees and controls and systems that they don’t have. We will never have. So we need to work more on the basis of trust. We will need to find other metrics as well. We will need to get our lawyers to come up with more simple contracts.
And as donors ourselves, we will need to perhaps become less risk averse. We will need to take many risks in this challenging world. So these are my thoughts in terms of a large investment to tackle all these huge challenges. Not sure that was what you wanted, Jean Lee. Sorry.
Jonah Wittkamper:
No, this is great. Thank you. I appreciate it. Okay. Lars is up next.
Lars Løvold:
Thank you, Rachel. So good to hear your wise insights. I’m Lars Lovel from Rainforest Foundation Norway and I just want to make a question into the sort of delicate internal functioning of the coalition. I mean obviously it’s delicate to deal with NOS’s, scientists and business in the same organization arriving at sort of joint approaches. So my question is would you say that the parts of the business sector that depends on sort of demanding European or US markets are more willing to change than those who have maybe a less demanding internal Brazilian or local markets?
Do you see that difference? And how do you handle like internal discrepancies within the business sector within the coalition?
Rachel Biderman:
That’s a that’s a great point you bring Lars. Great to see you here. I’m a big fan of the work that Lars does and we are partners in crime right not in not in crime in solution for the international religious initiative for rainforest. So it’s great to see you here Lars. So I think it’s it is a delicate balance and it’s a delicate question for me to answer. But perhaps in trust here in Chattam House rules I would say that yes the companies that are moving faster are those who have the more demanding consumers and definitely from Europe first and we but they have been doing that for more than a decade or so.
So it’s not something that they just realize today. So the consumer market driven by citizens I would say has been demanding that for quite a while. It’s only much stronger now and we feel it more strongly. But also the investors right as big investors you know and central banks from Europe get together and say climate is our biggest risk. And you and you see, you know, every year coming out of Davos, there’s re this survey showing that climate is top of their top of mind for decision makers all over the world.
So more and more there are different forces, not only the consumer market and so if you want to become relevant in this world, you need to follow. I think there’s also the point of the new generations. The whole Greater Thunberg movement is playing a role. It affects students, it affects young people in most of our countries. It’s so it’s not only consumerdriven anymore. But I would agree that you know the European demand makes a difference and makes a dent. It makes a difference u for these companies. But also some of them have realized you know there are opportunities some of them will thrive.
It’s like u 20 years ago we were talking about the energy revolution now we’re talking about the nature climate solution economics and they are seeing a lot of opportunities. Brazil is a country of agriculture and forest. So we have a lot of capacity here and this big decision makers are also seen from the investment point of view as a big advantage only. We don’t have the all the policies we need and not.
Unidentified participant:
16 hours.
Rachel Biderman:
Not the law enforcement. So the incentives from policies are not there. We’re depending a lot of voluntary markets and consumer behavior. But hopefully this will change in the nearby elections.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. Thank you everyone. That brings us to the top of the hour. Rachel, you may not know this. This is where we switch over to what we call water cooler time for unstructured conversations. You know, the afterparty. Do you have a few more minutes or do you need to go?
Rachel Biderman:
Actually I need to go. I’m sorry about this, but I am I am totally open for future engagements and it’s an honor being here with all of you and seeing so many friendly and familiar faces.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Can I include your email address in the chat or do you should I include other.
Rachel Biderman:
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Totally. Yes, please. Please.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Okay, I’ll do that. Okay. Thank you so much for joining us. We’re now officially water cooler time and give a thank you to Rachel and for those who wish to stay on the it’s now open conversation.
Rachel Biderman:
Thank you. Good to see you. Byebye.
Unidentified participant:
See you Rachel. Bye.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Byebye. Any anyone else is a is free to share shameless self-promotion.
Unidentified participant:
It was a great call, Jonah.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Thank you. I agree. Yeah, it was it was great to see her. As she said, she was she basically set up our Brazil office in for so.
Unidentified participant:
A lot of good stuff. So it was good to see her.
Unidentified participant:
Yeah. Thanks a lot for organizing.
Unidentified participant:
Fantastic pal for fantastic talk. Thank you.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you J.
Jonah Wittkamper:
And Tammy. It looks like your dog really liked it too.
Tammy:
Sorry about that.
Jonah Wittkamper:
No, we I think we all love pets on calls but you see seem very discussion.
Unidentified participant:
So I think I can do this call more. Jonah, I apologize for not being on more before, but now you understand. It comes up kid pickup time. You won’t know this, but I managed to pick up and drop off my 16-year-old and now I’m on route to pick up sixth graders in another school queue.
Tammy:
Yeah, my dog’s fine. So, I apologize, but since my dog behaved, I think I can manage more calls in the future.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Very pleased. I actually read an article about a startup that has started renting out animals for Zoom calls. I don’t know if because they’re people find them so entertaining. They add color to the Zoom call.
Unidentified participant:
Well, it’s Yeah, it’s kind of interesting. In at least three of my colleagues have sort of ostentatiously or explicitly put their guitar collection behind them in the picture. So, we’re actually having an in and I play the guitar, too. I have like five guitars in this room, but I don’t put them in the pictures. And so, I sort of challenged them all. I said, “Okay, guys, we’re finally having an in-person retreat meeting in May after years.” It’s like, I’ve been looking at your guitars for a long time. Everybody’s going to have to play a couple songs because I have seeing all your guitars on, you know, on there.
So yeah, there’s all sorts of different decorating tricks for the.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Nice. Nice.
Unidentified participant:
That’s what they ran away, right? They were like, “Oh, it was just the background. You caught me.”.
Unidentified participant:
I was on a call with the.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Everyone’s appreciating you.
Chip Barber:
Go ahead, John. I was going to say I was on the call with some folks from the Biden administration and each and every one of them had a guitar on the left and a collapsed bicycle on the right. It’s like a requirement for the administr I had one suggestion if I could Jonah for a future thing. I know you and I talked a long time ago about the nature crime alliance that we’re trying to get going and that’s not moving ahead quite spritly. We’ve got the Norwegian government it looks like is going to be providing anchor funding.
The United States government is coming as a partner. Gabon, many NOS’s some of whom are on you know are on your calls. So, at some point, maybe doesn’t have to be right away, but like in a month or two, it would be good to we can I can get a couple of my colleagues on and we can talk about that specifically as those issues relate to the Amazon basin. I have one colleague, she’s a law student. I haven’t convinced her to quit law school yet, so she’s only part-time right now, but she’ll be full-time again.
She did an amazing paper looking at synthesizing all the information on illegal gold mining in the Amazon area, right? Which you know is you know is one key topic there and there’s a lot going on that. So I think we could probably pull something together fairly interesting.
Jonah Wittkamper:
I think maybe we can make a couple of calls out of it. I think we’re booked until mid to late May. So we’ll we’ll shoot for around then.
Chip Barber:
Yeah. No, we you know that’s fine. It’s you know it can be you know June or whenever that’s fine. But just you know as you’re thinking about what would fit and maybe if there’s other people that want to talk about similar topics that you know that we can pull in or something like that would be great.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Yeah, that sounds great.
Chip Barber:
Well, thank you so much so much. I’m about to have sixth graders come in the car, so that will that will be loud, so I’m going to take myself off.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you so much, J.
Chip Barber:
Thank you so much everybody else.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Thanks for joining us.
Unidentified participant:
Thanks again everybody. Bye.
Unidentified participant:
Bye.
Marian:
Yeah, I was I was glad to hear Rachel talking about the law enforcement piece just in relation to what Chip just said because it seems like that’s I mean that’s really standing in the way in Brazil and in other places as well.
Chip Barber:
Well it’s a double-edged sword too though. It’s like it’s interesting because when in trying to pull together this idea of you know and the nature crime alliance we’re covering not just the forest stuff but illegal fisheries and wildlife trafficking you know engaging with representatives of indigenous peoples in particular who are very interested in this because they suffer a lot of the brunt of you know of this but they also their stuff gets criminalized a lot. So they might just be doing traditional shifting cultivation and you know other things and you know get thrown in jail.
And so, you know, it’s kind of walking a line between, you know, basically defending grassroots environmental defenders, indigenous and local communities, and, you know, fighting against their being criminalized like what has happened, you know, under Bolsinaro and also in Colombia, you know, in recent years and it’s gone on I know Southeast Asia best has gone on forever there, you know, people. So walking that balance between saying yes, we need to enforce the law and go after transnational criminals, associated corruption, corrupt officials, money laundering, all that kind of stuff, but at the same time saying we aren’t going after the, you know, person that’s collecting fuel in the national park or something like that.
You know, that’s not what this is about. So, it’s been interesting to see how you put those two pieces, you know, in a in a delicate political balance. And then also, you got to cooperate with governments because that’s what law is about. It’s about, you know, it’s no point in NOS’s talking to each other about it. They do that already. But how do you engage with governments who are not perfect to say the least, you know, what’s the bar that you set? I think we don’t want to probably engage, you know, with the Russian government right now, the Chinese government or, you know, any number of others I could say who are not going to be good partners.
But you get places where it’s kind of split. There are progressive good people in government and there’s some bad people in government. So what’s your strategy for engaging? You know it’s so you know it’s interesting set of issues I think all of us face a little bit so anyway I think it’d be interesting to have in not so much a big presentation but a round table discussion on we know this is a fundamental barrier to a lot of stuff that needs to be done in the world how do we go about doing it in a more effective and efficient and coordinated way while respecting rights and all those kinds of things certainly relevant for a lot of countries in the Amazon.
Jonah Wittkamper:
It would be interesting to see a range of options and costs benefit and how serious and non-s serious. Not all environmental crimes are created equal and some of them are easier to enforce than others and some are you know bogus new laws where others are you know things that people in power vested interest don’t want enforced. So having some sort of dis spectrum of impact on where philanthropic or extragovernmental interventions or media expose could make a difference I think could inform a lot of people there a lot of people who want to help the rule of law challenges in the Amazon but don’t know where to start because they’re they’re.
Chip Barber:
Complex. Yeah, that paper I dropped a link to this paper that we did last summer for the climate and land use alliance on this specific topic of you know if you were thinking about how to spend philanthropic money till 2030 on combating nature crime what would you do you know where are the areas that would be effective where are the associated areas the financial crime pieces and the online stuff there’s a lot of different pieces looking at beneficial ownership and corruption things land grabbing that’s a you So often when you’re talking about illegal deforestation, it’s not just the bulldozers coming in and the chainsaws.
It’s that someone has manipulated the land certificates and titles and bribed people in order to legalize what should actually have been illegal, you know, as you know. And so there’s a lot of different kind of nuances to it. It’s not just kind of cops and robbers stuff that you catch people in the act of, you know, throwing bombs into, you know, into the water to catch fish or something like this. It’s a lot more, you know, a lot more complicated.
Jean-Louis:
I wonder along these lines, and John, I don’t know if you’ve had them on this call, if Lendessa could be a good addition to the conversation, and their long experience working on land rights and corruption and indigenous rights and the whole body, right, of legal work. An honor on that.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Landessa has not been on this call. A lot of their work, real success work has happened outside the Amazon biome. We’ve done a little bit of research about them. There are other land tenure, land management NOS’s that have been on this call that have been relevant. But I yeah I think that actually one question I was going to ask you Jean Louie or anyone else when it comes to investment rule of law issues can be motivated enforcement can be motivated or demotivated depending on how you know future financial opportunities look.
You know, there are bonds out there that reward you, you know, based on positive social environmental outcomes. I’m wondering if you have any experience designing financial instruments that help improve force legality.
Jean-Louis:
Not directly. We just we’re completing a fund design around red that looks at the blend where we’re looking to attract private capital to support red plus to accelerate red plus project development and looking at the role of philanthropy working hand in hand. So one thing that we are doing is kind of testing the hypothesis that if there is private capital showing interest for instance linked to a framework that already exists such as red that requires a lot of work on land tenure. Could that help accelerate some of the legal work?
Right? And so how and then in turn could philanthropy then have an incentive to come in not just as a standalone right just working on land tenure and whatnot but as a way to accelerate that process of moving private capital into those landscapes because there is a recognizable revenue stream that depends on secure land rights. I don’t know if that makes sense. So it’s less the private capital that would be investing in that but it’s more the private capital coming in saying we’re very interested in this pipeline of projects and in order for us to go all in we would need to see A B and C and that might create motivation right for governments and others to act and I’ll add to that in fact we are exploring jurisdictional bread which then would create more of a sovereign framework around this project.
So that could lead to a bond by the way that could absolutely lead to some kind of bond mechanism.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. There’s one insure tech startup that just like fintech is the place where technology meets financial innovation. Insure techch is the place where all these new technologies reach ins insurance innovation. There’s one insure tech company called Democrants which allows you to create insurance products in emerging markets when limited data limited market of viability and things like that are available and they’ve asked us to develop a deck for the Amazon opportunity. I think that if there are some insurance products that can come in and mobilize or derisk a lot of different kinds of investing related to upgrading, you know, local red to jurisdiction red, for example.
I think there’s a lot of opportunity. So, I’m super interested in what you’re putting together.
Jean-Louis:
Yeah. Yeah. That’s great. Well, maybe add to that actually. And I don’t know if it’s a theme again that’s relevant, but in thinking about and I’m just going to use red as an example, not because red is the end all be all, but because it is somewhat mature, right, as a as a potential stream for these landscapes and many others will follow along. That preparation funding that’s sorely lacking is really making it difficult to accelerate these projects. And so there is a really natural role for philanthropy to come in because to date it’s been primarily public donors that have funded that work but it’s very slow and is very cumbersome.
And where again it’s a different kind of blended capital where it’s not concessional capital in investment but it’s philanthropic capital working side by side with the private capital toward a joint goal that does require different kinds of capital. What our analysis has done is that to date we’ve overburdened the commercial side with things that could be pulled out of these projects and funded philanthropically so that the projects can be more both profitable derisk and bring more to the communities. So that’s a topic that we’re especially keen to continue exploring is really how to enable these different kinds of capital to work by side by side to take different chunk chunks of these projects that to date have unfortunately been bundled together to the point that they make it very hard for these projects to be investable if that makes sense.
And a lot of it speaks to land tenure regulation things like that. Yeah. Marian just posted, there’s, there are a lot of technology solutions to these uncertainty questions. Have you seen in CPIC and the you know finance for 100 sustainable thousand sustainable landscapes I don’t remember these there are several conservation finance collaboration platforms out there have you seen them do sort of an expose or an exploration of a lot of the different technologies that can address some of these uncertainty issues that come with designing financial instruments. So we are Tammy and I are working closely with the 10,00 landscapes for 1 billion people.
In fact, we’re kind of starting a landscape finance accelerator process for them. And they’re working with a group called Terraso which is out of Tech Matters in the Bay Area. And Terrasu is working hand inhand with 1000 landscapes to develop some of these technologies and we’re starting with the landscape finance assessment as something that will hopefully become an online tool that can be made available to these hundreds of landscapes that have to grapple with similar questions. So, Terraso could actually be for you, you know, maybe to invite to these calls because they’re doing really great work.
Jonah Wittkamper:
How do you Is it just T R T E R A Z O? Is that how you.
Jean-Louis:
T r e r rso?
Jonah Wittkamper:
Ao. Okay, great. I’ll follow through email if I can’t find them.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. Ursula and Fiona, I see you guys are on. Did you want to follow up? Okay. No worries.
Unidentified participant:
Okay.
Jonah Wittkamper:
All right. Thank you so much.
Jean-Louis:
Okay. Thank you so much everybody. Really great to reconnect. Going to look forward more to everyone.
Fiona Banister:
Thanks everybody. It’s Fiona. I was listening mostly so just to keep it keep the flow. Okay.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Okay.
Fiona Banister:
Speak to you soon Jonah and all. Thanks.
Unidentified participant:
Thanks everyone. Bye. Bye.