The Securities and Exchange Commission Climate Regulations and the Amazon

In 2017, the Financial Stability Board‘s Task Force for Climate-Related Financial Disclosure (TCFD) released a set of recommendations for climate-related disclosures in financial filings. The framework has since become the de facto global standard for the financial sector to report on climate risks. More recently, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has proposed rule changes that would require companies to include climate-related disclosures in their registration statements and to submit periodic reports. Should the new SEC financial regulations also cover the forest and land use sectors, and not just industrial emissions? How could such requirements benefit Amazon? Climate Advisers is a climate think tank and advocacy organization that specializes in forest conservation and other natural climate solutions. Join us to learn about their reactions to the proposed SEC rules and their recommendations for investors during the commentary period closing soon. Together, we will explore why the forest, food, and land sectors have an outside impact on climate/deforestation and what the SEC can do to help. We’ll analyze the significance of “Scope 3” (3rd-party supplier) emissions, the benefits of mandatory reporting, options for incorporating nature-based solutions, and finally, the opportunities for standardizing sector-specific metrics and strategies. Join the conversation with Matt Piotrowski, Senior Analyst, Climate Advisers.

Recorded May 9, 2022

References:

SEC Proposes Rules to Enhance and Standardize Climate-Related Disclosures for Investors

Tackling Deforestation and Protecting Investors: Material Financial Risks from Tropical Commodities

First Climate Adviser Commentary on SEC Climate-Related Financial Regulations

Climate-Related Forest, Food, and Land Use Risks Threaten US Financial Stability

Chain Reaction Research Applies TCFD-aligned Framework to Assess Deforestation Risks

WATCH:

  • Jonah Wittkamper
  • Matt Piotrowski
  • Neve McCarthy
  • Mark
  • Paul
  • Fiona Banister
  • Robbie
  • Holt
  • Unidentified participant

Jonah Wittkamper:

Hello everybody. Welcome to the A8th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing force friendly economic development and the rule of law across the Amazon region of South America. This week we are featuring the work of Matthew Potrrowski and climate adviserss. The financial stability board created the task force on climate related financial disclosures back in 2017. Its work has become a de facto framework for climate reporting. This US securities and exchange commissions has come out with some proposed rule changes. Should land use be required in reporting?

Lot of big questions here, a lot of big impact. Let’s go ahead and launch into Matt. Matt, tell us a little bit about yourself before Climate Advisors. Where did you grow up? How did you develop your affection for the environment?

Matt Piotrowski:

Yeah, hi. Thanks a lot, Jeremy. I really appreciate the time and I really appreciate, the opportunity to present to this group today. And just to back up a little bit, I’m going to be presenting with Neve McCarthy, my colleague at Climate Advisors, who is ESG analyst, our ESG analyst, and has done a lot awful lot of work on this our comment to the SEC and also our original comment that we sent to the SEC last year. So thanks again everybody. It’s really great to have this to be speaking to this diverse group.

I’m Matt Petroski, senior director of policy and research at Climate Advisors, a Washington-based firm that focuses on US and international climate policy. We have a wide range of clients such as corporations, foundations, and nonprofits. Although we focus on all aspects of climate policy, forest policy advocacy has been a core part of our practice. For instance, two of our main projects, chain reaction research and orbitas, provide investors with research and analysis on sustainability risks in the land use sector and in soft commodity markets. And now we’re looking to influence the SEC and other agencies in the Biden administration to take measure measures to reduce climate related financial risk in the forest, food, and land sector.

And to go back to your original question, I grew up in a small town called Jarrettsville. It’s about a half hour north of Baltimore. So I lived on the east coast most of my life. I did live in Germany for a while when I was in high school. And that’s actually where I guess picked up a passion for protecting the environment as I think the Europeans are a little ahead of Americans in this regard. So I that’s I would say that’s probably I spent some formative years there. So I think that’s where I picked up some of my idealistic tendencies regarding the environment.

And now I’d like to hand it over to Neve and she can introduce herself some more and also get started on our.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Presentation. Great. Neve.

Neve McCarthy:

Yeah, nice to meet you all. And I’d like to just echo what Matt said as well, first of all, in terms of thank you for joining. It seems like a really varied and diverse group, and I’m so excited to hear all of the different perspectives. So yeah, my name is Nev McCarthy. I’m a senior ESG analyst at Climate Advisors. I have a background in sustainability management as well as corporate finance. I worked at General Electric and a bunch of different businesses over a few years before joining the climate world. And I grew up about a third in Ireland and a third in Singapore and a third in Chicago.

We moved around a lot and Arland is definitely is why my name is a little bit difficult to pronounce. So yeah, with that I’d love to get started and we’ve prepared a deck just to kind of get everyone on the same page, but feel free to let us know if any of this is you know duplicative, if you already know all of it. So, we’re happy to kind of skip ahead and we’ll answer some questions after that with the Q&A session and I think Jonah has some prepared as well. So, yeah, just to start we’ll be highlighting some of the major financial risks in the forest, food and land sector.

We’ll be talking about why this sector is so important to the financial regulation conversation and we’ll be talking a little bit about the SEC ruling and our recommendations for how to improve it. If you could go to the next slide, please. Oh, next one. Yep. So, just as a quick summary of what we saw in the SEC draft. So, the Securities and Exchange Commissions, the independent financial regulator within the US, they came out a couple of weeks ago with a draft ruling on climate related financial disclosures. They have a comment period that extends until the end of next week, about the 20th of May.

So, we would be very happy to talk to any of you on this call or make recommendations if you’re interested in submitting a comment or if you are and you need some extra support on that, we’re happy to help. Just to kind of highlight some of the key items within the draft ruling for anyone who hasn’t had the time to read about the 500 and something page document. It relies very heavily on the task force on climate related financial disclosures which was established by the financial stability board. As Jonah mentioned, this has been extremely important for international alignment and standardization of methodologies in climate related financial disclosures.

So, it’s fantastic that we’re able to start kind of moving towards a more common model in this area. Some of the key areas that it discusses are governance, how oversight by management and board would work with climate risk, disclosure of short, medium, and long-term climate related financial risks. Incorporating climate risks into risk assessment processes and disclosing materialized risks within financial statements. Also looking at the impact of these risks on strategy. And finally the scope one and two emissions and intensity would be mandatory on a phased in basis and scope 3 emissions and intensity would be mandatory if material based on an internal materiality assessment.

So one thing to note here is that we didn’t see a lot that was sector specific. You know this is very much kind of a broad kind of a high level start that they’re making. We didn’t see a lot on deforestation. All of these proposals will however be really important and helpful for investors in the forest food and land sector or investors of companies and sectors traditionally linked to deforestation just because of the need to analyze defor basically climate related financial risks. But of course you know there are a lot of areas where I think they could improve as well.

So as I said we’ll we’ll talk you through a few of our recommendations. In particular we do think that scope 3 disclosures when we look at deforestation is really important because for companies in the US tropical commodity supply chains will always ma mean that deforestation is going to be in scope three. So there’s we won’t be capturing those emissions for US companies without it. Next slide please. So just to step back for a second, the forest food and land sectors are just extremely high risk especially because of the combination of environmental and social factors.

So the food sector in particular is responsible for about a quarter of global emissions alone. And that this increases to about 37% if you also include pre and post production activities which include things like fertilizers etc. And deforestation in particular is driven by primarily by tropical commodities. It’s the largest driver, but there are many other drivers including mining. It sounds like there’s a few people who work in the mining industry on this call. And it’s responsible for about 11% of global emissions and almost 40% of deforestation emissions are exported through international trade.

So that brings us back to why these disclosures are so important and one of the reasons for this sector’s really outsized climate impact compared to other sectors is the impact of reducing future carbon storage capacity. So, not only is deforestation creating emissions in the current year, but it’s also depleting our ability to store carbon in the future. On the other hand, if deforestation is halted by 2030, it does have the potential to provide 16 to 30% of climate mitigation that’s needed to stay under the two degrees of warming threshold that we’re targeting.

So it does have the capacity to be a major win on the climate side as well. And on the social side, it’s just really important to note that most deforestation that’s linked to traded commodities is illegal. And these complex commodity supply chains often obscure impacts to marginalized groups like indigenous people and traditional communities. It also obscures labor violations and human rights abuses as well. And illegal encroachments into indigenous and traditional lands have led to increasing land disputes and violence against international defenders. And there’s a lot of information that’s reported on this through global witness every year.

Next slide, please. So, when we look at the kind of the groups that are able to have significant influence on these processes, whether it’s in the US or around the world, it takes us back to the SEC’s definition of materiality and what their legal basis will be for defending these regulations as it faces inevitably it’s going to face legal battles. One of the key things that determines materiality is whether a reasonable investor would require this information to make a decision. And that’s where investor statements become really critical because if the SEC can point to a number of investor statements or investor discussions on why they need the information that in itself can determine materiality along with a probable likelihood of whether it basically the likelihood of what’s going to happen in the future and the magnitude of the risk.

That’s the other measure for materiality. And the final one is shareholder resolutions. So that’s another way that investors can really engage the companies within their portfolios to tackle these risks and it’s another indicator of materiality for the SEC. Next slide please. Yep. So I think a lot of people when we talk about climate related financial risks are really wellversed on physical risks. So risks to company assets or operations in certain areas, for example. I think what’s less well known so far based on research we’ve done and surveys we’ve done are climate transition risks and they’re kind of a big deal for downstream US companies in particular.

So some of the kind of examples of things that would impact climate transition risks are, you know, 140 countries pledging to end deforestation by 2030, for example. Looking at supply chain laws or financeers and downstream companies implementing really strict policies like NDP policies which are like no deforestation, no Pete, no exploitation policies. We also have changing consumer preferences that are happening at an accelerated rate at the moment. And the result of all of this is that downstream US companies are at either high risk of reputational damage when we see results of deforestation linkages or they’re also at risk of supply chain disruptions as a result of sourcing high climate risk inputs.

They can also be at risk of price fluctuations as their inputs increase in price over time. And these risks are only rising over time as well. So next slide. So, just as an example, we’ve done some peer-reviewed research through our Orbitas project and we’ve looked at like modeling all of these different inputs over time and we’ve seen that climate transition risks looking at out to 2050 in a 1.5 degree scenario resulted in a reduction in global agricultural land availability and a 50% increase in land prices. Which would in turn increase commodity prices and we also saw up to 19 billion in emissions costs that resulted from increasingly internalizing the cost of carbon around the world.

So all of this obviously depends on how governments act and what policies come into play and how consumer preferences change. But this is just an example of you know modeling that shows some pretty significant risks for investors and downstream companies over time if climate related financial risks are not considered. Next slide please. And just when we think about financial stability, I also just wanted to give a quick case study because deforestation in particular when we think about the Amazon poses a major risk to US financial stability as well as financial stability in Brazil.

And one example of this that can shed some light on the issue is looking at the tipping point in the Amazon. So we’ve already deforested about a fifth of the Amazon rainforest. And this is important because scientists estimate that when we reach about 20 to 25% deforestation, we risk crossing a tipping point that would result in the majority of the rainforest turning to savannah. And that would release about emissions equivalent to seven years of global emissions currently. All of this would result in a medic slowdown in medical innovations and increased risk of infectious disease emergence.

So for example about 46% of invest of infectious diseases result from land use change in agriculture. A change in the water cycles that the current rainforest currently regulates would also have a significant impact on US agricultural production. So about a 25% of reduction in rainfall in Texas would impact US agricultural output. And finally, looking at these water cycles, they provide drinking water to about an economic area responsible for 70% of Latin America’s GDP. So that really means significant risk for investments all around the world. As well as obviously irrigation shortages regionally risking agricultural output that supplies many US downstream companies.

So, as I say, this is just an example, but it really is important to kind of just show the interconnectedness of our financial systems and the value of the ecosystem services that are currently provided by the Amazon in kind of increasing financial stability both in Latin America and in the US. Next slide, please. So the SEC’s inclusion of scope 3 disclosures, I know a couple people have mentioned their interest in this area. You know, we think it’s a fantastic start that they did include scope 3 disclosures and they did include a lot of wording that we and other organizations suggested in terms of considerations that companies should think about when they’re assessing their scope 3 exposure.

But we do think that more guidance is needed on what qualifies as material. And we would appi propose that basically materiality should be universally applied if a company has likely links to deforestation or is in a sector with high deforestation linkages. And I say this because companies in these type of sectors really are synonymous with scope 3 emissions. So about 83% of food section se sector emissions and about 90% of fastmoving consumer goods emissions fall under the scope three bucket and many companies in particular are higher. So Nestle for example estimated in their own internal company analysis that 95% of emissions fell under scope three for them.

And if these companies could find a way to exclude scope three from their reporting, from their goal setting, from their targets, we do feel that would be material materially misstating their emissions numbers when you look at their total value stream emissions. And that misstatement would be, you know, by upwards of 80% frequently. So you know when we think about making sure that we don’t create market imperfections or we don’t misallocate resources to high-risisk investments this is a really important consideration as to how we treat scope 3 emissions and as I said scope tropical deforestation will always fall into scope 3 for US companies.

So, it’s important that if any of these your organizations or if you’re interested in this topic, it’s important to highlight the need for scope 3 because you know this is going to be one of the key ways that deforestation is reported on in the US draft ruling. On the next slide. So looking at the really high environmental and social risks related to tropical deforestation and similar to the US already has mining industries disclosures which were passed by Congress. So a slightly different mechanism to pass these disclosures, but effectively we would argue that the environmental and social risks are so high for deforestation linked companies that standardized metrics very specific to deforestation are necessary.

About 60% of deforestation emissions come from Brazil and Indonesia. And looking at the US, you know, sectors that rely on industries that have some deforestation exposures or tropical commodity exposures make up about 40% of US GDP.

Jonah Wittkamper:

So sorry about that. Nam leave. I accidentally muted you when I tried to mute another. Go ahead.

Neve McCarthy:

No problem. Can you hear me? Okay. Yeah. Okay, perfect. Yeah, I was just saying so there’s a very diverse group of sectors that are dependent on basically commodities linked to deforestation. So, you know, with this in mind, we just think, you know, using the CDP as an example would be a really smart approach because, you know, we need more information from these companies on what they’re doing to mitigate deforestation risks in particular. So whether it’s, you know, a qualitative disclosure or these quantitative metrics that we’ve recommended, we think we really need companies to explain to investors what they’re doing to monitor what they’re doing to, you know, address grievances that are filed in terms of company complaints of deforestation.

Next slide, please. And you know looking at our main kind of recommendations I would say finally we have a lot of alignment already with the TCFD the task force on climate related financial risks or disclosures and we would also kind of advocate for inclusion of the TNFD so the task force on nature related financial disclosures which were recently released in their beta form and you know these disclosures are extremely important when you think about ecosystem services risk or biodiversity risk. And they align extremely closely with the TCFD in terms of their format.

They also look at the governance mechanisms, they look at oversight, they look at risk. And you know, as I say, I think this is extremely important for investors if a company relies heavily on input in a in a region with high climate change or high deforestation risk in particular. And you know considering that over half of global economic generation or 44 trillion in GDP is at least moderately dependent on nature and ecosystem services and that their high risk of both physical and transition risk impacts. We think that these disclosures would go a really long way in terms of protecting investors and just kind of explaining the sustainability of the re the revenue streams in the future.

So, you know, we think that basically our three main takeaways would be incorporate more of the TNFD as well as the TCFD. Although we definitely applaud them for considering the TCFD in their original draft filing, we would encourage them to kind of add to the make the scope 3 disclosure and materiality threshold a little bit more concrete. That could even mean just saying that we know that companies with over 40% of their emissions that fall under scope 3 will always be material. So maybe we do a quantitative threshold alongside internal materiality assessments.

And then we also would advocate for including more sector specific disclosures for deforestation just given its outside outsized climate impact and its impact on so many vulnerable social groups around the world. So that’s kind of our main kind of takeaways from the SEC. As I said, I know that this group has a lot of expertise and knowledge in this area. So we’re really excited to hear your perspectives as well. And we’re very happy to answer questions. In this area. So yeah, let’s let’s continue the conversation. Thank you so much for listening.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great. If you could stop the screen share, that’d be helpful. Just a couple questions for me and then to those in the audience, please feel free to go ahead and use the raise your hand feature or put a an indication in chat and we’ll call on you. I read in preparation for this call that 70% of those reporting through the carbon disclosure project do not include deforestation related reporting. Could this ruling from the SEC get it up to 100%. A and related to that, what is the power of the SEC for scope 3 reporting?

Theoretically, you who not everyone has to report to the SEC, right? Would give us a little bit of information about the power of the SEC.

Neve McCarthy:

Yeah, that’s a really good point. And I should note we have we have another slide if it’s helpful on some of the phase in processes. So just to note these SACE regulations would apply to larger medium and large companies first. And then they have phase in requirements both with regard to who is going to report and with regard to the level of auditing that would be required for that particular group. So yeah I think that the CDP study that you brought up was extremely on topic and we have done our own analysis as part of our orbitas work within climate advisors too where we did in collaboration with PWC we surveyed a whole load of financial institutions.

We found about a third of them considered climate when assessing investments and none of them considered deforestation when assessing investments. So of course it really depends on the financial institution but you know I would say when you look at the current ruling it does require companies to do some and basically to be accountable for analyzing their climate related financial risk and that automatically helps all areas of climate risk. Right? So if they have extremely high exposure to deforestation I would hope that would be in there. I will just mention though when you look at the way companies currently report and the guidance that’s currently given to them by consultants frequently a lot of times they recommend prioritizing your climate impacts whether that’s through the SGS or some other reporting mechanism and they say what based on a materiality assessment what issues are the most kind of material to your business what areas do you have the biggest impact on the environment around you and the communities around you and they encourage organizations to report first and foremost on those and tackle those first.

I will say that through that we found that areas in studies often areas like life underwater or life on land can often be deprioritized compared to emissions and the forest food and land sector historically has been you know a lower priority for many organizations. So, while I would really hope that this would increase drastically the number of groups that were reporting on deforestation, it doesn’t specifically say that they have to. It says that they need to report on their biggest climate risks effectively in the short, medium, and long term. So, while that’s extremely, you know, it’s a huge step, it’s really a groundbreaking step compared to what we’ve had in the past.

You know, that’s where we think having the TNFD, having mandated that they need to look at their ecosystem services, their biodiversity loss risk, and having sector specific deforestation disclosures, for any companies that have material risk of that. We think that would help to close some of those loopholes as companies both, you know, they there’s going to be a lot of companies effectively that are just starting on this journey. And they’re going to start with their biggest impacts or what they interpret as their biggest impacts first. So I don’t think this will get us to 100%.

I think it’ll be a major improvement, but I do think the couple of recommendations we’ve mentioned would kind of help to close some of those gaps.

Jonah Wittkamper:

From what I understand, the reporting un the public commentary period under the SEC is kind of like the amikas brief period for the Supreme Court. Friends, allies, consulting agencies deliver information, but the SEC doesn’t have to take it. In order to push for 100% of these recommendations, is federal legislation required? What to what extent can the SEC go and what influence do investors have to really get the SEC to sign off on everything you want them to sign off on?

Neve McCarthy:

I think it really goes back to that definition of materiality, right? So the fact that the SEC’s major any of the past rulings that would be used as precedent in court here relate to the value of this information for investor decision-m. If investors clearly speak up and say this information in particular would be of extremely high value to our decision-making process, then that’s obviously a major win because the SEC is able to see that is material. That is, you know, a part of what investors need to assess their portfolio risk.

So I’d say that is probably our biggest mechanism for change here. Just through showing the investors care. I’d say the second one is probably like shareholder resolutions. Just to, you know, we’ve seen increasing shareholder resolutions in this area recently. And we’ve seen the Proctor and Camp Gamble case in particular last year. The fact that passed with a vote in favor for Black Rockck to increase transparency around deforestation risk. Over time that’s something that we can point to as a major kind of vote of confidence from investors in attaining this information and the importance of this information.

And then you know the other factor that relates to materiality is the likelihood of this happening and the magnitude of this happening. So climate related risk obviously we can point to significant research from a scientific perspective of both of those things there. So I would say when you think about the investors community investor community’s role I think submitting the comment letters making statements in this regard just expressing publicly the impact of this information on the decision-making process that in itself is a major kind of vote of incompetence of what the SEC is doing.

Jonah Wittkamper:

First up Mark you have a question. Yes. Well, I think I think Nam has u already brought some of this forward. Do you have more examples of SP500 that are I mean that you have contacted or been in touch with that are reacting positively to these and are already you know disclosing materials.

Neve McCarthy:

Are you referring to investors or companies?

Mark:

I’m more I’m more companies at the moment. I mean we have we have uni lever we have Mars that are you know making declaration after declaration about their commitment of pledges right but that doesn’t mean that the disclosure is transparent first and that you know it helps you figuring out whether or not that model is going to be accepted or not.

Neve McCarthy:

Yeah, definitely. I think I think you’ve pointed to some of the big ones like Nestle for example I mentioned that they did their internal assessment and found that 95% of emissions were in scope 3. Mars I think they’ve determined that 29% of their emissions were related to deforestation in particular. We have in this these sectors we have like a short list of leaders and then we have a lot of organizations that haven’t moved as much yet. So this is one of the kind of arguments for it as well. When you have you know part of your sector which does report on it and part of your sector which doesn’t it’s very difficult for investors to have comparability across sectors or across companies or competitors and it’s also detrimental to the leaders who have to invest a lot of resources in doing this analysis and making progress when not all of their competitors need to.

So that’s you know that’s a hu that’s a really good point. I think we do see obviously leaders. But we don’t see I think I would say we see more scattered reporting in this area. So for example palm oil has gotten a lot of pressure from NOS’s and journalists. So we’ve seen much more kind of progress in that area in terms of releasing supplier lists or addressing grievance mechanisms publicly. We have a much longer list of companies that do that in particular than companies that address deforestation risk in every area product.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Line basically. Others who have questions feel free to just go ahead and come off mute and ask or indicate your interest below. I.

Mark:

Have another Yeah, I just have a quick followup. You speak of NOS’s and the pressure they put right on this on the supply chain basically right so does it mean that there is the need for a campaign a grassroot campaign to further this agenda.

Matt Piotrowski:

Yeah I’ll take that and then Ne can provide any follow-ups what we’ve seen particularly since the early 2010s is that there’s been a lot of NGO pressure on both like investors and companies in the soft commodity supply chain whether they’re upstream downstream or they’re traders and what we’ve and what we’ve seen is a big evolution in these markets particularly in palm oil as ne brought up is that in Southeast Asia they have a NDP markets no deforestation no pe no exploitation and that certain traders and certain companies will not purchase palm oil from suppliers that are connected to deforestation and this type of these campaigns from NOS’s has really changed the markets there and we would like to see it more in other supply chains too and it’s important that these campaigns do continue to put a spotlight on even palm oil even though there are all these changes but also in the other commodities so that we can get certification and we can get those with market power to influence others in the supply chains to reduce deforestation.

Paul, go ahead. You have a question.

Paul:

Yeah, thanks Jonah. Then maybe just a quick comment on your question earlier because I think the putting this in context is sometimes very hard because it’s a requirement for corporates and other issuers of securities in the US for their financial disclosures. And so you’re adding to an existing structure of information that the SEC deems relevant to an investor. So with that, you’re you’re in this period as you talked about where you’re able to provide in feedback to the SEC who is trying to make a judgment call after all the feedback and they’ve been doing this for about a year and a half on this topic which is following Europe’s mandatory disclosures on a lot of these same topics.

So they have, you know, a pretty wellestablished path to see how that’s working in Europe for the European financial markets. And I just would encourage everyone on the call, it’s pretty interesting to see if you log on to the SEC’s website and there’s this proposed rule, you can actually go on and see the comments or people are making real time. And it’s a pretty interesting commentary about people’s perspective on this topic because they’re very divided, let me put it that way. From one group who I would put in the category of we don’t need any more regulation, we don’t need disclosures, this is not an issue to another group who are very educated on the issue and supporting it and trying to get the best disclosure possible which has multiple objectives of not only for the investment community but also solving the mission objectives of a lot of the organizations making comments.

I think it’s great that you know climate adviserss and Matt you guys are spending a lot of time on this because I think it’s one of these critical windows to shape policy in a way that you never get as a as an individual or as a citizen of the world and you don’t have to be a US citizen to make comments. Anybody on the call can lob in a comment two sentences right on the website takes 30 seconds to do it and they read them. And so the question I have is when you when you and I’m a little more cynical than most I think having been in the financial service industry for 35 years.

The issues around deforestation and particularly around land sector emissions are often the they’ve been historically the most complex to measure and manage and then attribute to a company. So actually quantifying the company’s scope 3 emissions is a task that’s been easy to kind of push off by the companies to say well I don’t have good data and even the major trading mechanisms unlike the energy sector have rejected like the European trading ETFs on credits and offset credits even California struggled to get I would call it a fair representation into the ARB trading credits for forests and other land sector missions.

So you’ve got this window and I would just say is there anything from the way climate advisors you know question you guys is there a tactic that you think is important now that if you do make comments maybe you can coach us all into how best to do that because we know this isn’t going to change overnight. You know it’s a gradual stepbystep transparency goal and I think from my perspective the SEC is trying to make a decision. Do we do this and if what way how far do we go?

And I don’t know if you have a view on that because that would be really helpful for others who can really just lob a sentence in after the call and it would be pretty impactful.

Neve McCarthy:

Yeah, I think that’s a really good comment and I definitely applaud your encouraging others to submit a comment because as you say it’s very easy to do. Yeah, I definitely think our kind of what we’ve heard on this area is that if there’s anything that we like in this draft ruling, we should kind of mention that because it’s going to get a lot of push back. You, as you said, there are a lot of groups commenting both direct another. And one tactic I think is to argue in the alternative. That’s one thing that we’re doing like to make sure that there we’re submitting multiple options.

So, this is our first choice. If you can’t do this, then here’s what we would recommend. And if you can’t do this, then here’s what we would recommend. And we think that this is especially important for scope three because scope 3 out of everything in these disclosures is going to get the most push back in our opinion. And we think, you know, of course, ideally, we would want there to be a very clear you know, materiality threshold and phased in auditability of the scope 3 requirements. But when you look at you know right now it’s just a an internal company assessment of materiality.

So that’s one where area where you know we can say our first choice is of course a more holistic view of materiality and all of these much more kind of stringent mechanisms. But maybe in the meantime an approach could be to say that are there any companies with over 40% of their emissions in scope 3 that are not material? And if not then why don’t we have a quantitative threshold to accompany this internal materiality analysis threshold within a company. So it’s kind of thinking outside the box in that regard as well to say that you know of course this is what we would like.

Alternatively if this isn’t possible then we would at least advocate that you do this and this. So as I say I think that area will receive the most push back. But being able to kind of support that and to provide multiple options for how they can address these issues is important. And as you say, they read every single comment. You know, we submitted a comment last year and it was cited a number of times in the in the draft ruling and we were definitely impressed with how they incorporated language even if they aren’t able to kind of put include everything that we asked for.

Paul:

What do you think about and thank you N for that. The issue of I call it you know it’s I think in your first letter that you guys proposed to the SEC a year ago the why it’s important was adequately covered and I think they’ve gotten a lot of why should we do this the real question is how do we do it and so when you’re in this world of deforestation and trying to measure emissions in deforestation where there are all these competing voluntary standards for methodology ies for actually calculating the emissions for standards and you’ve got some other initiatives where they’re trying to tokenize emissions and put I call it monetizing the emissions so which helps measure it.

Do you have a preferred view of how they should do this and how they should accept information by companies? Because if you look at the TCFD and then you go and it references the GHD protocol and you look at the GHD protocol, there’s really nothing in it about how to count carbon for land sector in the GHD protocol, which is pretty remarkable. So then you have to look at an annex they came up which put together that basically lays out some guidelines on my how you might count emissions in the land sector.

So that’s still like a I call it a jump ball or a loose a loose thing that needs to get pinned down. And so I just hope they don’t back off and say well until that gets done we’re not going to require people to do this. I think so I’m personally taking a view you got you guys have the only power that can deem this important and make everybody start and if you do that now even though you know it’s imperfect that’s better than not doing I don’t know if you have a reaction.

Neve McCarthy:

That’s a that’s a really good point and I will mention as well that there’s one question that’s specifically directed around that this exact topic it’s asking companies what they would recommend or asking any commenters what they would recommend in terms of dealing with the land sector since it hasn’t been adequately addressed in the greenhouse gas protocol yet and they’re asking if we would recommend having companies use internal data. And one thing you know basically our recommendation will be that they should go ahead and report on this and use the best available data greenhouse gas protocol or best available data as it improves.

So that we don’t just kind of punt the ball backwards and until we have everything 100% crossed and I think the same thing can be said for scope three because that area of course is the main push back is data and you have different kind of perspectives here you have some groups that say that scope three is so broad that you have your supply chain side of scope 3 for those less familiar with scope 3 it’s basically any indirect emissions that don’t fall within your energy use or your electricity use for your direct operations.

So your value chain emissions, your supply chain and your consumer end use of the product for example. The supply chain emissions are much more kind of feasible I think for companies to use their own data eventually and the consumer and use emissions will often be a kind of an assumption or you know industry standard data. So there’s also a push for, you know, would it make sense to kind of slightly differentiate those two categories to say for upstream suppliers? Would it make sense to have more stringent regulations than for downstream emissions for consumers because that might be harder to you know see how does a consumer use my product for example in the end.

So I think we have to kind of be creative about some of these solutions that we’re recommending and if we can say that for example you know scope three would be mandatory if material based on xyz criteria and also we would recommend you know more stringent phased in approach for the suppliers than the downstream emissions that’s an approach to take as well.

Paul:

Yeah, just maybe one last thing and John, sorry to monopolize this by this, but you’ve spent six years trying to get to this point. The issue of like for our colleague on the call who’s sitting in Argentina and the looking at mining impacts, it’s one of the few opportunities where you can actually chime in on the specific issues you think are important about mining in your home country, particularly Brazil and the Amazon basin. Because of what I call the layering of misinformation. You know, the guys at the SEC do a good job, but they listen to everybody.

And so, if they have the closer you are to the land sector activity, I think the more powerful your comments and they’ll take that in. And so, maybe one other encouragement is just because you’re not in the financial service investment area, that doesn’t mean you don’t have an unbelievably powerful capability to contribute into this call they’re going to make.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Well said. Next up is Fiona. Fiona, if you’re not there, others are.

Fiona Banister:

Thank you so very much. Hi. Yes. I was really just looking at, you know, this is much more US-based, but after working with the European and working with more global strategies, how can we utilize some of this to build it out and empower others to collaborate? And then on the scientific side, where are we utilizing the science to support these actions? Thank you.

Neve McCarthy:

I think that’s actually a fantastic leadin to something I wanted to make sure, man. I just wanted to make sure to kind of mention that ISFB as well, the International Sustainability Standards Board is also expecting comments. They have a comment period that’s open until the 29th of July of this year. And they have two standards out they’d like comment on. One is more general sustainability, one is more focused around climate change. And I think that would be a major mechanism around encouraging alignment in this area. So you know especially for those interested in commenting on the SEC disclosure, you may already have some research done.

So when you look at the ISSB disclosure and you might have some ideas that come up and you know this is kind of a more international body. So we don’t know yet which groups will be leading. For example, the ISSB could be much more kind of fall into a leader role and then that will kind of pull company countries along or you know the SEC could become much more ambitious and pull countries along or the EU. So we just basically we’re kind of we have a number of different bodies who are kind of approaching this slightly differently.

But I think that the reliance on the TCFD as a kind of a internationally recognized and widely accepted framework is really powerful here because both the ISSB comment or the draft disclosure and the SEC draft disclosure rely heavily on that. So you know I think one of the key areas is making sure that our comments apply not only to the US right now but also to other regions as they’re releasing comments. And we did also submit a comment for Canada’s CSA comment period that was in March, I think February, the springtime.

Jonah Wittkamper:

I have a question about the task force on nature related financial disclosures. So the time frame of the task force on climate related financial disclosures 2017 till now five years later you know that impact is still coming to fruition. What’s what’s the expected timeline for when companies are going to be required or even push to think about biodiversity reporting?

Neve McCarthy:

That’s a really good question. I really wish I knew the answer to it to be honest. I think since it’s in draft, you know, it’s in beta form right now and there is a request for input on that as well. I think that, you know, some bodies would be cautious about including it already. I would really argue though that the TNFD has so much in common with the TCFD. If you look at every kind of the structure of it effectively, it’s effectively a very similar mechanism, but it’s all it’s just looking at nature related risk versus climate related risk.

So, I think it’ll be much easier to incorporate personally for companies that already are considering TCFD or standards already considering TCFD. But again, I wish I knew a little bit more about, you know, when we’ll see.

Jonah Wittkamper:

More adoption. I hope soon. Mark, you’re up.

Mark:

Hi everyone. Wonderful conversation today. You know, just wondering how you know, we’ve talked about SASBY and FASBY and various accounting standards boards for the purpose of valuation reporting and coming up with some standardized methodology. But in conversations with the NYSC and the internet exchange group, they’re looking at the UN methodology of valuing ecosystem services and they, you know, claim there’s a 38 point valuation system. I mean, I can think of things like oxygen credits, soil health credits, coral reef credits, biodiversity credits, research credits. I mean I is there a way that we can look at one automating in a in a highly effective methodology through you know satellite drone monitoring sensors the growth and the improvement in soil tree biodiversity one and then two how do we move from that measuring to monitoring valuing and reporting it in some way and I’m grappling with this as I’m starting a company called NAT assets which unlocks the value of non- extract nap natural capital and ecosystem services and finding ways where we can just leave nature alone or regenerate it and unlock the value in some way.

Neve McCarthy:

I think I think that’s a fantastic question and it’s definitely something where we’re at climate advisors we’re part of the chain reaction research consort consortium which does a lot of investor risk analysis and one of the groups we work with aid environment does a significant amount of satellite monitoring for deforestation which we incorporate into our analysis. So definitely you know for deforestation you know it can be done and for a lot of area there’s a lot of groups doing really innovative things in this area. I guess I really hope that we can continue kind of pushing the barrier in this area.

I would just say that typically when we look at companies assessing deforestation risk, a lot of them are or a lot of the market leaders in forest food and land are already using satellite or partnering with satellite companies that help them monitoring their supply chains. So I could see that becoming a much bigger area as more companies are under pressure to assess their risk in this area and hopefully it will expand from you know when we look at as you say deforestation we looking at biodiversity loss looking at all of these other areas as well as the satellite imagery we are getting much more sophisticated satellite imagery now so yeah I think as I say we’re already seeing it on the company side we’re already seeing it on the NGO side in terms of holding groups accountable But it is a lot to ask investors to you know do a significant amount of satellite imagery analysis when they have really big portfolios.

So.

Mark:

Definitely regulations will be helpful in this area. I’m just not sure if anybody else on the call has any sort of leads on who may be doing this effective automated algorithmic AI type of measuring monitoring value and reporting.

Jonah Wittkamper:

I can share a couple of links right off the top of the hour that are related. Let’s get in Robbie and then maybe a quick comment from Holt before the top of the hour.

Robbie:

Thanks all. Really appreciate this conversation. Was curious on your insight around whether or not it’s it’ll be possible to incorporate sequestration in terms of assessing for net emissions in supply chains. Noting that some suppliers are kind of regenerating deforested land in the opposite direction.

Neve McCarthy:

That’s a really good question. To be honest, I’d have to follow up. I’m not sure if that’s currently included. I’m trying to remember. I know that currently there’s a lot of discussion. There’s particular questions around carbon offsets and making sure that any companies that are making net zero commitments or commitment similar commitments are showing the percentage of reductions that are taking place through carbon credits versus operational efficiency improvements or emissions reductions. I don’t know for sequestration. We can definitely look into it and let you know. Maybe somebody else on the call has some insight into that area.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Anyone’s welcome to comment. Holt, I know you wanted to share.

Holt:

So just back on the biodiversity analysis topic, you know, because you do have this great introduction of remote sensing and also databases that can track large areas with very minute specificity around certain activities within them now that you didn’t have 10 years ago. And so about a year and a half, we started looking really hard at how would you come up with a ranking system for corporate activity within a biodiversity output of positive or negative scoring, which is like the first way you look at anything in the ESG sector. And so what we found was, and these are primarily my conclusions, so don’t blame anybody else.

The it’s if you think carbon emissions in the land sector is hard, biodiversity is about five times harder. And it’s harder because you have a lot of very specific activity that’s really hard to manage that’s highly focused in these silos by the scientific community and very limited broader scale biodiversity metrics that are agreed on by anyone anywhere. And so you have this platform called the earth that has all these micro systems and you know microbiomes and ecosystems major biomes trying to function in these healthy sustainable ways that if you just disrupt or degrade part of them it’s really hard to put that in context when you’re measuring something that a company’s doing.

Maybe they’re doing a mining operation and they disturb a bunch of area and just happens to be the one place where this one species grows and you know that starts a trickle effect of that biodiversity factor. And so the EU came up I think they approved this a year and a half ago almost two years ago put it into the into the link as an effort to try and force companies to deal with this issue and added biodiversity disclosure. It’s still a pretty loose definition in my view and so we’re trying to come up with projects that.

Matt Piotrowski:

Allow some standardization around certain largecale agricultural or forestry activities knowing you’re going to get to mining and you’re going to get to other smaller footprint areas. But that’s a huge area. That’s very complex and to me it’s got a shorter impact future than climate change. I climate change’s impacts will gradually disrupt more biodiversity sooner than the actual effects of climate change. And so to us it’s a higher priority focus. And so you know if anybody has any insights into that, we’d love to hear it. We’re kind of taking all input at the moment still to try and come up with shaping good.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Products. I need to intervene briefly into here. We are now at the top of the hour. This is a really ripe moment for conversation. We’re going to leave the room open for networking and comments and unstructured conversation for the next five minutes or so. Then I need to hop to another call and use this room for it. So, thank you presenters. We’re now transitioning over to water cooler time. And anyone is welcome to comment. Thank you.

Matt Piotrowski:

Thank you, Jouer. We really appreciate this. And this was a really great group. A lot of really great questions and in I think it’s about a week and a half before the SEC comments are due. And if you have any follow-up questions about what we are going to be commenting on or if you want to see like our comment a draft of it within the next week or so, please feel free to reach out to us and we’d be happy to help in any way.

Jonah Wittkamper:

I just posted Matt’s email below. Nev, if you want to paste your email, that’d be great. Would any others like to share?

Neve McCarthy:

I guess I would just as a quick statement just kind of reiterate the comment that even if you only have two sentences to say about this you know I think it every they have to read every comment. So, it’s definitely worth taking a quick look and even if you just respond to one question or you submit a general comment, we’d love to see more groups commenting on this and feel free to reach out to us if you need kind of any specific recommendations or want to chat through it further.

Matt Piotrowski:

And any comments from investors or financial institutions carry an awful lot of weight obviously, so that’s even an extra bonus.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great. I do have a question. Have you guys engaged series and UNPRI on this? Okay, great. We haven’t talked to UN We’ve talked a couple of people from UNPRI. There’s.

Neve McCarthy:

A couple of working groups that have been working on this that were a part of and we’ve had a number of conversations with series as well. They’re doing a fantastic job of really engaging investors on this and collaborating with investor statements and company statements. So, we’re definitely impressed with their work and working with them.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great. Excellent.

Fiona Banister:

Can I just come back to a quick moment on the Canadian side? As I’m sitting up here in Vancouver right now and it seems we are still you know not aligned but could be. Is there any support that I can get for you from this side?

Neve McCarthy:

From the Canadian side, I think we’ll we’ll maybe take down your email if it’s possible and we might follow up. We have one of our co-workers is been really involved in the Can Canadian Forestry Service for a long time and has a lot of a lot of network there and as I say, he might have some interest in following up in this area in particular. But yeah, we submitted our comment and we’d love to kind of lend our hand to help in any way we can. There. So definitely would love a follow-up chat.

Fiona Banister:

Wonderful. And we can on decarbonized and Jonah knows we also have links to some of the new technologies and of course the monitoring and I was just on with our team is part of the X-Prise rainforest. But we are aligned also that’s under our act now with the indigenous women the only women team for ex-priseze rainforest but also the only indigenous co-led team with all five women actually being co-investors in forests and actually owning forest title as well as being environmental lawyers and diversity experts. So it is a big challenge when we talk about data and analysis because who’s actually getting the cost effectively paid for who’s monitoring it and at what price and where is that data being expanded and utilized.

So I do wish to continue on that discussion as we go forwards and then I’ve been offered to help to coordinate for the UN in September for the science division meetings and so I’d like to also look at further discussions because we do need to include this very abstract part of where is the science including this data and the analysis and how do we measure that and map it and be able to provide it so the governments can take action. Thank you.

Neve McCarthy:

That’s great. We’ll definitely follow up with you for sure. Pleasure. Thank you.

Matt Piotrowski:

Sorry, Jonah. I know we’re going over a little bit here. So, I think that’s the end of our time. So, thanks again everyone. We really appreciate and we hope to be in touch soon.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you so much. Really appreciate. Bye everyone.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great. Go ahead.