The UN Principles for Responsible Investment (UN PRI), Investor Risk and Deforestation.

Deforestation is the main driver of Brazilian carbon emissions. It negatively affects agricultural productivity, biodiversity, and indigenous people while posing serious reputational and operational risks for companies and investors. As one of the world’s largest producers of agricultural commodities, Brazil has a lot to lose. Fortunately, some investors are getting organized. The UN PRI is a global network of investor signatories working to put six “Principles for Responsible Investment” (PRI) into practice. The PRI works to understand the investment implications of environmental, social, and governance (ESG) issues while informing investor decision-making. The PRI also serves the long-term interests of its signatories, the financial markets, the economies in which they operate, and ultimately the environment and society as a whole. Join us to meet Marcelo Seraphim, Head of the PRI in Brazil. He helps the Brazilian signatory network to advance the country’s sustainable economy. Together, we will understand how the PRI has been working to educate, raise awareness, and build capacity to help investors mitigate deforestation risks and explore green investment opportunities.

Recorded May 2, 2022

References:

European investors threaten Brazil divestment over deforestation

Investor Initiative for Sustainable Forests

Investor Guide to Deforestation and Climate Change

UN-convened Net-Zero Asset Owners Alliance

Deforestation Free Funds

Agroideal – Territorial Intelligence

Legal Risks to Investors from Forest Crime

American Financiers Invested More Than US$ 18 Billion In Companies Linked To Indigenous Rights Violations In The Brazilian Amazon

New study links major fashion brands to Amazon deforestation

Complicity in Destruction

WATCH:

  • Jonah Wittkamper
  • Marcelo Seraphim
  • Sarah Dupont
  • Leo Fleck
  • Simon
  • John
  • Christian
  • Ursula
  • Emily
  • Alona
  • Kale
  • Unidentified participant

Jonah Wittkamper:

Hello everybody. Welcome to the 87th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series del dedicated to advancing force friendly economic development and the rule of law across the Amazon region of South America. This week we are focusing on the work of the United Nations principles of responsible investment and the Brazil leader of that network is Marcelo Saraphim. Marcelo, say hi to us and before we get into your presentation, it’d be great if you could tell us just a little bit about your origins. Where did you grow up?

What are the things you did before working with UNPRI?

Marcelo Seraphim:

Sure. Well, first of all, thank you so much for the invitation. I’m actually a public servant. I work for I am in a leave of absence actually from the supervisor of the pension funds here in Brazil the governmental agency of the pension funds in Brazil and I am based in S. Paulo. So I got involved with the SG issues because this u this agency was part of a of a project called the fiduciary duty in the 21st century that was led by the PRI and the UNIPFI. So I got involved because I was working there and anyway I ended up like coordinating the road map that they implemented here in Brazil and then I joined the PRI like two years later and here I am.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great. And you’re originally from Brazil? I’m from Brazil. Yeah. And which part? From S. Paulo.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Okay. I’m based in S. Paulo too. Great. My old home as well. And from what I understand, you have a presentation for us today.

Marcelo Seraphim:

Yeah, sure. Let me Great. Let me share it. Do you see it? We do. Looks good. Me put in presentation mode. Okay. Well, first of all, well, thank you so much. I actually miss my colleagues from London because you know I handle I manage the signatories network here in Brazil. I am the head of Brazil for the PRI and but anyway I’ll be you know I’ll do my best to answer your question after my presentation and if I don’t have the answer right now I will take notes and get back to you.

Okay. So the agenda that my agenda is pretty straightforward. I’m gonna like make an overview of the PRI. I know that the Sent there person knows because Sent there is a signary to the PI but I think there most of you are not like institutional investors and maybe it’s worth to give you an overview of the of the organization and how it is you know working to tackle deforestation. So basically the PRI is like a community an organization like based on a community of investors whose objective is to help each other to incorporate ESG issues into their financial decision, investment decision and also develop tools to foster the active ownership ship what is the active ownership is the ability of the invest investor to influence the invest companies toward you know better prag practices.

So when you see Black Rockck like very being very vocal saying that they are not going to vote for the continuation the continuation of a director that didn’t comply with his object in terms of you know climate change in the in the company. So Black Rockck is doing active ownership and Black Rockck is one of is our senator too. So that’s what I’m talking about. And PRI was created in the in the United Nations I would say ambient ambiencece I would say and since 2006 we have two United Nations partners that are UNPFI the United Nations Environmental Program Financial Initiative and the United Nations Global Compact.

We have almost 5,000 signitories that are asset owners like pension funds insurance companies or family office or endowment institutions. We also have asset managers like Santandere and also we have some service providers which includes the Brazilian stock exchange for example the B3 and the consulting companies that you know work with ESG services. There are a lot of money involved in this 135 trillion dollars on u in terms of asset under management and the principles are basically commitments that the investors make when they join the PRI and they basically say we will incorporate ESG issues in our financial decisions.

We will be active owners when handling with when relate relating with our investing companies. We will foster the ESG agenda. We will we will demand ESG data disclosure from our investig companies. We will report at least once a year in terms of on how we are managing our ESG incorporation in our process. This is basically what the principles are. Okay. Any question? If you if you have any questions, you can interrupt me. I think it’s better. Okay. Great. And when we talk about ESG and the PRI is has been a very like process oriented organization and because ESG incorporation is a process of course and of course the PRI besides the ESG incorporation the PRI has been very concerned about the outcomes that the this ESG corporation is resulting in terms of the real world.

So very recently the PRI has implemented or has developed a three-year strategy where the main objective is to bridge the investors with the real world outputs. So we maintained our three pillars which are responsible investors like PR the main the core business of the PRI is of course building capacity and giving empowerment to asset owners and investment managers to better incorporate SG issues in their process. We work to have more sustainable markets through like driving meaningful data more and more consistent data and also like doing policy devocacy and we work for a prosper world for all which includes helping investor to achieve the SDGs and also to tackle climate change.

So this is about mitigate helping investors to mitigate risk and you know tapping the opportunities that these ESG issues can bring and I give like a more focus on climate change because deforestation for the PRI is under climate change. But of course you might you already know that deforestation has a lot of impacts not only in climate but also like in the indigenous people land use water scarcity and stuffs. So you just for understand that we put in the climate change because of course mo almost 50% of the green gas house emissions in Brazil are due to deforestation.

So it is in terms of materiality it is one of the our main topics and that’s why we are here of course but also we have like diversity equity and inclusion as one of the main topics in this in this agenda. So what is PR doing in terms of you know helping investors to tackle deforestation when we talk about climate change and when we talk about engagement for example we engage we help investors engage with companies that are in the meat processor supply chain for example which are the main companies that are responsible for the deforestation in Brazil.

So this climate action 100 plus which is the biggest engagement project in the world in terms of climate is one of our best example how to make the influence between investors and invest to happen and to improve the company’s traceability and transparency towards the issues that involve deforestation. That’s why I put here this slide because we have for example in Brazil we have the an initiative called investor paruka which is investors for climate that has engaged with Marfri with JBS which are one of the two biggest meat processor companies in the world to understand how they are tracing their suppliers to understand if these companies are sure that their suppliers are not offering meat that comes from cattle that are raised in def deforested areas for example.

So that’s why I put I included this climate change 100 plus because the investors for climate is also like has a very similar approach of the compared to the climate action 100 plus and also one of the of the activities that the PRI had during last year was of course a very important role during the COP 26 and the and the COP 26 during the COP 26 that it was launched a letter with a ped to tackle deforestation I mean with more than 30 investor that committed to eliminate deforestation by two 2040.

So I’m going to talk about this when I’m when I’ll talk about the when I talk about the practitioners group. But before I’m going to give you some historical background, very recent background on how investors are handling these issues. Okay, we as I told you deforestation is in Brazil is the main drivers are the agriculture business, soil and cattle processing activities. Okay. And the PRI partnered in 2017 with the series which is an organization based in Boston to create an engagement project. Okay. That whose objective was to have improve the transparency of these companies that are in the soil and cattle value chains.

Okay. And to have the commitment of these companies towards you know the transparency in terms of disclosure I’m sorry the commitment of the companies to eliminate deforestations and improve traability and of course the commitment to for them to collaborate to develop some standards that will help to you know to asssure that the suppliers are not bringing meat from cattle that are originated in degraded areas. So these are the these were the objectives of this of this project and it’s it started in 2017 and it ended last year in August. So it was a kind of lengthy pro project but you know the deforestation is a very complex issue and it demands complex you know solutions and it’s very it demands the involvement of a lot of stakeholder as you might know.

So the first step was this the companies like Minerva, JBS and Marfrig and other soil companies were invited to participate in the in the engagement process. It was they welcomed the initiative and so and from that point to up to August 2021 there were a lot of you know public commitments for example the in 2018 they launched the group launched the this investor expectation statement which was u this the expectations that the investors had towards the invested companies to have you know more transparency more traceability towards their in their supply chain and but one of the most important u activities in this process were this roundt discussions with the meat processing industry.

This is basically putting very powerful investors in a in a in a meeting room and the meeting meat processing companies and the meat processing companies explained how what they were doing to address the issues of deforestations to investors and I don’t know if you know it but the main issue in the deforestation in this commodity supply chain are the indirect direct suppliers. So the suppliers of the suppliers the direct suppliers the meat processing companies have control on over the direct suppliers but they don’t have control on the indirect suppliers and there are some meat processing companies that whose like suppliers like 80% 80% of the of the suppliers are indirect suppliers.

So when you say like a company saying hey we have we just announced that we have 100% traceability in our in our company you have to be very careful because you have to understand if the indirect suppliers are also traced tracked and we know that at this point this is not happening. Okay. They are still working on it. Overall the results of this engagement process was kind of you know modest or it was kind of disappointing some in some aspects but the process itself was very rich because the investors the educational part of this kind of issues of the projects is are very important because you know the issue is very complex and if you the investor don’t understand the details that are behind the this.

It’s very hard to engage with companies. It’s very hard to get their commitment and understand you know and to track their the their perform. So in this sense the this investors initiative for sustainable forest project was very successful although you know there were like some improvement in traceability some improvement in the perform of the goals that were set but it wasn’t enough. Okay. This project through this project the this group of investors understood that you know working with the private sector wouldn’t be enough okay and why 90% of the deforestation in Brazil are due to illegal deforestation because I don’t know if you are if you are aware the forest code that we have in Brazil allow to in the Amazon to deforest or to clean 20% of the of the area if it’s a private terrain, a priv private lane.

However, there are a lot of lands that are public lands and the this public lands sometimes are rubber. We have a lot of a lot of problems of people that take over the land because it’s abandoned because you know there the areas are too big and then it’s very hard to for the government to supervise and they just take over this part of the land and they cut the trees and they somehow with they work on you know on the bureaucracy and they most of times are wait still waiting for the rule the regulatory framework to change so that they can kind of make something that is illegal to make it legal and so it’s a very complex issue.

So what do they what did they the investors decide to do? They said hey we have to talk to the government because the government is responsible for the legality the enforcement and so on. That’s why the investors policy dialogue on deforestation was created. Okay. The first movement for to create this other engagement process was this open letter to Brazilian embassies. So this group of a group of investment of investors sent out these letters to the embassies in the world and the Brazilian government kind of reacted. They the Brazilian government almost right away implemented like a ban to seize all the deforestation legal or illegal.

And so it was a kind of a positive movement at that time. Actually this the ban happened after our first meeting with the government. But anyway, it was a kind of quick it was kind of a surprise. However, as you know, as you know, this wasn’t it was only one it wasn’t a very it was a very good start, but the government didn’t do their proper properly their role. I mean enforcement in as you know the governor Bossonaru is very they take the ideology at the very seriously for them you know it’s like hey you are you are foreign inves foreigner investors and you are trying to kind of invade our so sovereignty so it’s that’s the mentality of the go bosonado right now and this jeopardized all the you know the objectives to achieve the objectives of this investors policy of investor policy dialogue on deforestation.

So just for you to understand the objectives were this significant reduction in deforestation rates enforcement reinforcement enforcement of the first code you know reinforcement of the supervising agencies prevention of fires and nothing of this happened. Although the activities that were implemented during this project was fantastic like I’m pretty sure to say that the investors of that participate in this project they have more knowledge about the deforestation issues in Brazil now than the average Brazilian investor because the this educational and knowledge sharing sessions were like very important and very you know there were like Carlos Nobody and Hajang I don’t know if you heard about these guys they are like very important guys and that really understand the issues and it and they and the TFA that was the organization that was secretariat of this of this project they really u had a very good you know project management Daniela Kaheda was the secret is still the secretariat of this project.

So although we didn’t achieve the these objectives but the again the educational size of the of this was very important and I think that again and for you for this coalition too it you have to understand how things work so that you know require other stakeholders to help you towards this agenda otherwise it’s very difficult to achieve you know the goals that you that just talking about well just for you to understand the PRI is part of the advisory committee of this IPD. So that’s why I included this actually we created the IPD and then we hand over to handed over to TFA to work as a secretariat because they had more structure to do it and then they did very a very good job although you know the objectives were pretty well actually it was very u challenging and you know because of the political situations in Brazil you know it didn’t happen.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Marcelo, I just want to say five more minutes so we can have time for questions.

Marcelo Seraphim:

Okay, cool. Yeah. There’s also an initiative called the practitioners group in Braz in the PRI and this is led by the PRI and this is going to end by the end of the of the year. It involves around almost 50 investors and 100 members. There are there are very big investor investment managers in this in this group too. And basically the practitioners group are investors that share experience on how they are tackling deforestation based on you know what they what are their asks, what are their metrics and practices. And one of the objectives too are align their policies and practices and to have a common narrative to in terms of tackling deforestation.

And to just to summarize there are there are 10 phases of this project and the we’ve already done the policy analysis the value chain analysis policy analysis metrics the practices and we are about to start engaging the engagement and the report. Basically the this group of investors come and share their practices and you know try to understand what are the best ones and what worked and what didn’t work and at the end of the of this process there will be a report that I think it is going to help you know better address the issue.

One of the deliverables of this practitioners group was the pledge that was launched in the COP 26. So more than 30 investors you know committed with the with the objective of eliminating deforestation by 2030. I said 2040 but it’s 2030 and you see the intermediate goals until there. So it was also very important for because through the practitioners group initiated the you know the group that committed with these goals and here in Brazil just to finalize we have some local initiatives we have we’ve organized webinars and we have organized educational sections like last Thursday and Friday we had two sessions to so that the investors could understand what are the best tools, private ones and the public ones that could help to like to build like a DDQ or you know tools that would help investors to decide and you know to tackle the this issue.

We are supporters of the investors for climate as I said and the next steps we are going to work on a DDQ on deforestation. We’re going to engage in a we were going to work in an engagement on deforestation but in a more broad with a more broad objectives considering the planetary boundaries like biodiversity land used and besides the climate and also we are going to engage with some investors initiatives that has like zero conversial commitments like the IFAC I don’t know if you’ve if you’ve heard about IFAC but we can give more details during our questions and answer session.

Okay,.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great. Thank you so much.

Marcelo Seraphim:

I just invite you I’m sorry just invite you to enter to access the collaborate collaboration platform which is in this in this address here so that you can see a lot of other collaborations that we have there. Sorry Jonah.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Okay, no worries. Okay. A couple quick questions for me and then those who are interested asking questions, please raise your hand or indicate your interest in the chat. First quick question for me, do you guys have a model deforestation prevention policy that you recommend to your signatorries?

Marcelo Seraphim:

A policy? We don’t have this like a written policy but this is going to happen after we work with this DDQ. You know the DDQ that I mentioned explain it again. The DDQ is the due diligence questionary. I’m sorry this is like it’s like a jargon. Yeah. An investor jargon. So it’s a set of questions for you to that will help the investors to decide if they are going to invest or not based on you know procedures. Do you have you have you checked if the company use the what’s the name of the of the WWF tool to avoid deforestation in their operations blah like very detailed and very almost like a checklist but a very detailed one and I and I and the policy recommendation would will be done in this process of the DDQ that we are thinking of doing.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great. For those who want to learn about IFAC which is a coalition also associated with the tropical forest alliance to mobilize hundreds of millions of new investment resources for the Amazon region. See the link in the chat. First up Sarah Dupont and then Leo Fleck.

Sarah Dupont:

Hi. Hi. I’m Sarah Dupont from Amazon Aid. Work specifically on gold ASGM gold in the Amazon and I first of all Marcelo I want to congratulate you on the work that you’re doing and especially with all the challenges that you have. So thank you so much for what you’re doing. My question to you today is are you planning on working on the extractives at all as far as investment goes specifically in gold? Because as you know most likely know in Brazil ASGM is problematic because it’s not only dangerous because of the mercury but because of all the illicit activities associated with it.

So again my question is are you planning on working at all and the extractives specifically gold?

Marcelo Seraphim:

Yeah. Yeah. When I when I said when I mentioned this engagement on deforestation and planetary boundaries, I was I was I mentioned I meant to include you know other issues that are involved in the deforestation factor or issue that you know we don’t think of when we talk about deforestation right away. But when we put the planetary boundaries, we see the whole picture including mining, include land use, including you know biodiversity issues and also with and climate. So this is going to help us to develop some instrument or tools that will cover all this all the these issues besides you know the agriculture issues.

So the mining and stuff will be covered during this engagement. I mean the engagement will be one of the of the tools that we’ll have to develop tools to tackle the deforestation through the lens of the mining and other extractiv activities.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great. Next up Leo Fleck.

Leo Fleck:

Yeah, I just wanted to make a comment but first of all congratulations Marcelo and great to meet you here after so many years working with PRI on this subjects because before I joined I joined Santandere this year I was at the Moore Foundation and we were the core funer of many of these activities. So I was involved in the backstage of many of this efforts by you and other partners and I just wanted to remind something. I’m not sure you mentioned it, but even though you haven’t achieved that goal of reducing deforestation or persuading the government to change policies, this initiative I think made a remarkable achieved a remarkable goal of raising awareness among investors globally which put a lot of pressure on financial institutions and the government in Brazil.

So it actually was a gamecher in all that we have seen in the financial sector in Brazil. Thank you.

Jonah Wittkamper:

First up after Lao is Simon and then John.

Simon:

Hi thank you Jonah. H thanks Marello so much for your presentation and congrats for your work. H I’m Sam. Based in Berlin, a small NGO supporting the indigenous queen instead of Ark, Brazil, buying lands for expanding indigenous territories. And my question was these all these investors that you are working with if I got it right, they still invest in JBS and these companies. So what would be the next step to really put a serious pressure on these companies? Maybe this is a little bit too visionary or too simplistic but maybe you have some ideas on that.

So how we could really put some pressure on them.

Marcelo Seraphim:

Okay. Yeah. You mentioned a very important point when we talk about ESG incorporation. We are talking about some approach like which includes divesting a decision to divest of course from the from the these companies that are problematic. However, when you divest you are not solving the problem. Somebody else will invest in that company anyway. So we really prefer to have investor continuing to invest in that in those companies and influence those companies to change their behavior and to you know try to influence the rest of the value chain of the supply chain so that you know things are changed like towards the indirect suppliers that I mentioned.

So it’s not very it’s not easy. It’s like very difficult without the support of the government. I don’t think that this is going to be solved because you know the private sector don’t cannot do things by themselves. It’s very hard to work alone and you know without the government support. But you know the pressure over these companies are very strong in Brazil from you know in Europe as you know there’s a trend to u charge the Brazilian commodities because of this kind of issues overcharge like that will be like a commercial a trade war because of these issues.

So things are getting very much more you know important and for them and they are they have this as like a priority but investors have to keep make making the pressure so that it happens you know.

Simon:

So that would just to put on that would mean that investors would also have to communicate with the government or put some pressure on the government as well. Is there something happening like this?

Marcelo Seraphim:

Yeah, it is some communication from these investors with the government. Yeah, we advocate that there must be there must be like a policy advoc policy advocacy and the IPD was exactly like this investors engaging with the Brazilian government trying to you know to improve the enforcement but it didn’t it didn’t happen because of the situation in Brazil the political situation in Brazil so investors are really you know willing to change the situation but for this government at least I don’t think it will change you know so they will have to implement things that they can do in the private sector like helping the traceability with technologies that there are technologies to improve the traceability and I think they have to do it you know even without the Brazilian government support.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Just in the interest of time let’s go ahead and move on. Next up is John, then Christian, and then Ursula.

John:

Hi, thank you very much for the, presentation. It’s been, extremely informative. My question is very simple. In, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in your, in your concept of all this, where does sustainable development, which is so important to steward communities, indigenous peoples, where does it fit into all of this?

Marcelo Seraphim:

Well, I think it fits in the opportunity side of the of the of this issue, right? Because when we talk about deforestation, we’re talking about two things, risks risk management and opportunities as I mentioned. And the opportunity size side is very important. And you know when we talk about sustainable development there are a lot of opportunities that investors must know to help address this issue and this is this is very important. However when I told you that 90% of the of the deforestation is due to illegality. I think that the investors have to put pressure continue to put pressure in the in the government and you know try to implement the technological solutions to help tracking the deforestation practices.

I don’t know if you if you agree with me. I mean it’s like I’m giving like also a personal opinion here but when you have like 90% of the of the deforestation due to an illegality we have to tackle this issue and of course we have opportunities and so on you know all the all the projects that you guys are showing in the in your in your site which is fantastic but you know we have to we have to stop burning the forest and that the government has to you know at least diminish the damage I would say that’s the unfortunately that’s that we’ve have done so far but the more pressure that investors make the better.

Jonah Wittkamper:

We might slightly differ on the percentage but absolutely that’s a critical initiative thank you Marcelo perhaps also to help you could talk about IFAC.

Marcelo Seraphim:

Yeah. IFAC was just launched actually last week. So I know from some investors that are that are senators to the IFAC they are very engaged in this project. They are very the expectations are really high. They think for example launching products, financial products that are based in active ownership which means like forming a portfolio of companies that are somehow involved in deforestation but with the with the commitment to work with these companies to improve their traceability and so on. So the product was ba is going to be based in this in this group of companies of share of companies that are that will sign a commitment to decrease deforestation in a determined time but also there are a lot of other projects in terms of fixed incomes.

So the investors are really excited about it and they think that it’s the best opportunity ever to work towards you know the opportunity side of the of the equation. So it proactively gets at the sustainable development opportunity that is asking.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Okay next up Christian. Hello Marcelo. First of all thank you for the beautiful work. I wish you great success. My question is about traceability and data collection. You mentioned that 80% of the suppliers in the in the meat market are indirect suppliers and as we know in a lot of similar issues when you trace ownership and the chain of custody for environmental resources and natural resources. The problem is always in the beginning of the assessment or at the end of it because as we know there’s you know child labor involved into shrimp farming and then that shrimp goes into the certified supplier.

Same thing with you know child labor involved in collection of rare minerals for electric batteries and same thing in Brazil because there’s wood laundry as you know part of the load is certified legal part of it not and comes along. So my question is if you could speak a little bit about the technology and the ways for the data collection for the traceability of the indirect suppliers. My question is the is data there? Is technology there? What’s the missing piece for us to be able to trace the indirect suppliers?

Marcelo Seraphim:

Yeah, just a quick correction. There are some companies where 80% of the of the suppliers are indirect suppliers. Not all not all of the companies you know I think I maybe I was misunderstood but anyway it’s a yeah it’s a it’s a very serious issue. We for we for we to have to have like a complete solution the government should provide the data because there are some data that only the government can provide. Okay. So if the government doesn’t gives us the data that the solutions are not you know you don’t you won’t never have a the best solution because you don’t have the data that the government has.

But in terms of technology, there are a lot of technology to do it like a ship in the cattle ear you know a ship that will make a checking when it pass through an illegal or a legal land or whatever. There are a lot of technologies on this. But the thing is that if we don’t have the government’s support, it’s going to be very hard to tackle the issue from you know from the beginning to the end of the of the value chain. So I think it’s a that’s a real problem.

Plus if the government don’t don’t put the right structure with the agencies that are that are you know supposed to supervise their activities it’s also be very difficult to you know to implement enforcement. So, it’s a it’s a mix of stuffs, but I have some I can I can send to you later on a site of a company that is that works with u what’s the name of well I forgot the technology but anyway I can send to you the one of the technologies that one of the companies that is implementing a very good technology to tackle this but again without the government providing the data.

I don’t think we’re going to get to, you know, to a good solution. Thank you.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Just in interest of time, we should move along. I’m sorry. Okay. Next up is Ursula.

Ursula:

Hello. Well regarding the soybean here in Bolivia and obviously the suggestion that the government has to do something that’s 100% impossible. Bolivian government has very little funds to control and the companies that control the soybean production are mostly international companies and what they do is what I just written in the in the chat is they provide the loans, they provide the seeds and then later they purchase the soybean. So in their hands actually is actually the solution because they know what areas of the of the country have been devastated by deforestation, what areas are being planted by illegally.

It will be very simple just control whom they are given the loans. I don’t think that they are really honest about that the they really want to control the forestation. So that’s my.

Marcelo Seraphim:

So you in Bolivia you mean that the private sector can solve the pro can solve the problem?

Ursula:

Absolutely. Absolutely. Because they are the ones that are giving the loans to the people are the first doing the forestation. They don’t have the ability to receive loans directly from the banks. The banks simply close the door to all those companies because they are not legal companies. But these companies ADM is one example. They give the loans to the to this illegal farmers. So and it’s not a very little. We are talking about at least 1 million eto. I see. In Brazil, it’s a bit different because we the government controls the land use the paper that says that area is legal.

But the thing is that there are almost one 100,000 illegal lands with fake papers in Brazil. So it’s if this is something if the government controls this and they don’t if they don’t supervise it’s impossible to know the truth. It’s I understand but you know that soybean especially soybean it’s pattern on seeds and they follow up very closely who uses them and how much they use them the amount. So it’s simple numbers if Yeah. Yeah. For soil it might be easier than cattle I would say. It might be.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Yeah. Okay. Yes. Thank you. Let’s go ahead and move on which I think will probably be our last question but we might be able to spill over into the top of the hour. Emily you’re up next.

Emily:

Hi. Thank you and thank you Marcelo. The I’ve written this in the chat and you have already been touching on some aspects of this but I’m kind of asking about those spaces where you’ve got illegality policies national as well as regional packs that are intended as protection of the forest and the ecosystems to protect from these massive extractive industries. But what happens often is that the indigenous and local communities smallh holders they’re losing their land rights access and they are really being cut out of the picture. So they don’t have the power and influence to do what the larger corporate extractive industries are doing which are manipulating and navigating laws to suit their interest.

And the ones who really get hit are the indigenous and locals who do not who often are the ones who have the capability for appropriate ecoultural land stewardship. So how are you navigating these very complex tricky spaces?

Marcelo Seraphim:

Oh, Emily, I think I have to send this question to our environmental team in London because this is very tricky and I don’t I don’t know how to answer actually. I’m sorry. I can I can like take notes and send it to you.

Emily:

Okay. Thank you. I that’s very honest because it’s it is not easy. But I do I’m interested in where there can be more engagement from indigenous and local people within the policy spaces and building those relationships for but I know it’s very tricky.

Marcelo Seraphim:

Yeah, it’s tricky because you know the Boson’s administration has indeed incentivized the invasion of miners, these gold miners, illegal gold miners in the indigenous land. So, it’s and there’s like a group of deputies and in the congressmen that support this, you know, it’s very tricky. So maybe we can we can talk offline.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Thank you. We have a couple minutes left. Christian, I know you may have had a follow-up question and Alona, if you want, you feel free to come on and share your comment.

Christian:

Yeah, just one question is that if the presentation will be shared because there’s quite a few links that I like to access if could be shared would be great. Maybe if it’s sent to you Jonah and you might send to the group. And the second one is Isabelle the importance of creating a pathway for data collection outside of the government because as we know agriculture and cattle raising groups are the most powerful in the country and I don’t I don’t see this administration or maybe another one I don’t know that they’re going to go against that.

We all know the difference between what the forestry code establish and what really happens. So I’ve been thinking how can we create some level of data collection that would allow traceability even if not perfect at least good enough that could direct investors decision- making. So that would be my only comment similar to example that the lady just mentioned about was that Bolivia is a similar situation.

Marcelo Seraphim:

Yeah, in theory it might be a solution, but it’s you gota you gota agree with me that if the government doesn’t help it’s going to be harder much harder because the area is so big and it’s so complex and there are other you know it’s like a multi- it’s deforestation is driven by a lot of different variables and drivers. So it’s going to be they are trying to do this like since the beginning of the Bosonar’s administration without any support and it’s hard. However, I think the pressure you’re right the pressure towards the private sector must continue.

They have to find a solution because you know if you see the value chain they makes a lot of money. I mean the meat processing companies make a lot of money so they have to spend to you know to try to solve it even without the support of the government. I agree with you in this.

Christian:

Point. Yeah. Although it’s not going to be perfect but anyway I know that I know that. Thank you.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Elona did you want to come in real quick?

Alona:

Yeah just super briefly. So Marcelo just would be really good to talk to you. I think we spoke to the previous person at PRI and would love to discuss what other metrics you could in just include in your due diligence like a questionnaire to the financial you know investors or companies because we do believe through what we’re seeing now and we’re actually going to publish about that. We did a previous publication just showing how there are already indicators that could guarantee if companies or financial you know markets would really like to know if they were at a risky investment.

They can know and we are building on public data asking with the information access law you know unstructured database and just structuring databases that give us a very good proxy to illegalities. So I’m very happy to discuss this further because I think it’s key that we know that of course the government has a part and we won’t say that it’s a small one. But I do believe today with the data and tools that we have companies can do more and I think we should ask them to do that especially when governments are not doing their part.

So just to say that I would really love to discuss with you and you know join up forces on this very important issue.

Marcelo Seraphim:

Yeah, I just have to mention something that is not related to the trade of cattle or soil which is the land grabbing because you can you can take over a land and you don’t sell anything but you still you’re still robbering public lands you know so it’s I don’t see I don’t know why I don’t know how this private sector solution would cover this kind a problem for example you know because it’s not related to the operation by themselves you know.

Jonah Wittkamper:

On that note I just want to recognize that we’re at the top of the hour for those who weren’t following the clock for those who need to go welcome to do so Marcel are you available for another 10 minutes or so to stay on.

Marcelo Seraphim:

Sure.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Okay great so for anybody else who has follow-up questions this is now where we move over to what we call water cooler time where it’s more unstructured good conversation. Thank you Marcelo so much for joining us. Thank you everybody else. And I know several other people have questions. This is the time to ask those questions or to introduce yourself. It’s now open mic time.

Unidentified participant:

For me. Go for anyone I would briefly introduce myself. So, hi.

Kale:

Everyone. My name is Kale. I was happy to see that. Well, first of all, this was a fantastic AIC call once again. So, thanks everyone. With Forest Base, we focus very much on the stability of the land title itself. It was briefly touched upon. To give you a very small anecdote, I have a bit of a history back in Uganda where I see parallels in when it comes to the land system. And a Ugandan land lawyer once told me, he asked me the question. He said, “How much would you be willing to pay for a house if you have about 20% chance that after the acquisition it’s going to be yours?” well, if you have a very western mindset, that’s a bit of a surprising angle to work with.

But it helped me understand how in tropical countries or developing countries, uncertainty of land is a very big issue. And the Ugandan land lawyer added to me that in my country I’m used to having val well price and value being more or less on par where he says in his country intrinsic value can be very disconnected from price because the asset itself is let’s say wrapped in an unstable legal financial format. So he said if you can if you can wrap a land a house any asset in a stable way you can unlock so much value.

And we often say that the Amazon is too cheap or tropical forests in general are too cheap. So we look very much at how you can stabilize land ownership and we believe there is a method to it and if I may briefly add still there is the famous economist Hando Dotto who wrote about the structure of poverty who wrote the book the mystery of capital where he explains that in his native Peru you need about 207 documents if you want to transfer a house from person A to B. And he also said it’s impossible.

Not a single Peruvian will do all that work. It’s crazy. So people just see which kind of documents they can find in the first two three weeks and then they do the asset transfer. Of course the price is renegotiated after you come there on the table with only like 15% of the necessary documents and hence the asset stays cheap. So with forest base we work on that and hereby I consider myself introduced a little bit. Excellent.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Responses, more questions. Anybody?

Christian:

I can make a comment about that because this is a topic I look quite a bit into it. I’m those that don’t know, I’m originally I’m based in San Diego. I’m originally a Brazilian attorney and I’ve done quite a bit of work in Amazon and sustainable forestry and I have worked with people that mentioned that there are areas in the Amazon where the government is simply not present. So the cost of deforestation is basically the cost of maintaining all the logistics for it and maintaining your own private act army to protect everything and the cost of bribing all the politicians that need to not do anything.

So what happens is that these people go in take a certain area harvest everything and the government looks at it from a helicopter from a certain distance and nothing really happens and this these operations have an internal rate of return. Unless I looked into it about 15% a year and that is nothing to do with land ownership. The land is for free, the resources are free. It’s pure operational cost. So that’s something that there’s just no government presence and that’s you know that’s a problem and I always keep thinking how can private sector create some level of data collection data visibility.

It might not come into the enforcement or enforcable realm, but at least some consumers that be sensitive to that would have information to make decisions because I know grew up in Brazil. I’ve been a vegan vegetarian forever, but probably the only one from all my friends, people eat a lot of shuhas all the time. And I wish that could diminish. I don’t know how that’s going to happen, but the lack of the government presence in a lot of the Amazon is a problem. And obviously recently with this all these areas being open to illegal mining is another one because not only the government is not there, government is allowing it to happen.

It’s not enforcing the little bit of rules that are there. So I keep thinking what is the I understand what you mentioned Marcelo about government needs to do something but I don’t think we can count on that. So what can we do that’s a big question I don’t have that answer but I know technology and blockchain and IoT and different time different ways of data collection and management will be the solution to that.

Alona:

Just a quick follow up on that Marcelo before you say something like I really believe also that you have other questions to ask. So the car like the land registry I mean it doesn’t it doesn’t mean land title. So if you’re investing and you really want to know you cannot limit your you know analysis with the you know with a fraudulent kind of document that you know is a problematic one today. So I would really argue that and I think also we have to change the premise that the private sector cannot guarantee because agreeing with Christian if you cross satellite data with you know indicators on the ground we’re doing a proxy for example mapping all operations from federal police so we can just tackle where things are happening and then looking like asking two or three more documents that won’t come you can judge that your investment is pretty risky and then it’s just more on the basis of like how much do you want to actually get involved.

So it’s like how do you really include the risk analysis into your investment you know let’s say opportunities or choices. So I do think we have to transfer a bit of the responsibility back for investors and private companies because I totally would say that with three pieces of data if they were asking they would know if they’re contributing to illegalities or not today and the technologies are there for that. So I just love to hear your comments there.

Marcelo Seraphim:

Yeah, I would say that yes, you we I think we should we must continue to pressure investors, but if you don’t have the land use issues related to the soil or cattle operations, you can you will not capture there that how you how would you do that? Because the land the land robbers will destroy the forest and that’s it. It’s destroyed and then they will try to sell and to try to harvest and etc. But the land is already destroyed. I mean the forest is already destroyed.

Alona:

But you can know it’s free to know for example if you access the Norway free planet platform or map.

Marcelo Seraphim:

Yeah. Yeah, but this is Yeah, but this is a public land and the government don’t do anything to solve it, you know. So what’s the private what’s the private sector role with that?

Alona:

Well, don’t buy cattle from that land and as you’re saying since you have today possibility for example to have a chip like have a earring in the cattle from the birth you know where this cattle come from like so it’s from public land don’t buy it.

Marcelo Seraphim:

Yeah, I understand it. But the land the land is already destroyed. I mean the forest is already Well, but I mean.

Alona:

Well, yes, but then you’re contributing to you’re paying these people, Marcel. So you’re paying for the companies that are, you know, let’s say a producer goes there and it’s totally clear that it’s on grabbed land, public land, and they’re saying, “Oh, never mind. This was deforested.” So let’s just say, “I don’t think we can buy this argument because they know they’re buying from people that clear that illegally, so stop buying. They have to like the main thing is it’s a big ask because of course it’s profit but we cannot do this tradeoffs anymore you know like the companies know they’re buying from irregular or illegal if it’s irregular with good heart to regularize great but if it’s you know people that don’t want to transition please cut off from your supplier list right yeah I understand it but you know that there’s a limitation on this because if you know If there is no kettle or soil involved in that, you cannot do anything because the what’s going to what’s the private sector will do with that.

It’s already well I mean I would I would love really to continue and I want to continue to discuss with you because I think there is including for land speculation today for carbon markets there is a big risk that you know even if there’s no production involved we are putting like carbon cowboys out there and buying or investing in projects that will just sell credits from grab land so I think we need to raise the bar in the private realm of the regulations and the questions we ask to make sure we are not contributing to the legalities and I would really argue that if you want to know as an investor as a company you have enough information today not like in your fingertips as it should be I agree it has to be you have to have very top level public information but you can triangulate you know three pieces of different like a satellite public databases and risk analysis and you’re going to make a pretty good you know saying on that but let me say this is something I really want to discuss because I’m on your side.

I want all right to do it. So I want to just take this conversation out there. I don’t I want to respect here of course the time and the everyone else but I really think we have to do that because the message to the companies that they cannot do it. I think it’s a bad one.

Marcelo Seraphim:

Yeah. But that’s not the message from the investors. We are talking about ourselves here. We’re talking about the issues we have. I don’t I don’t think the P the PR I will not tell investors to say hey tell your investig companies that they cannot do anything that’s not the point we that’s the contrary actually but we are talking about the issues the very serious issues that we have currently and you know the private sector is trying to solve this like from like five far for five years and it’s really hard and but anyway I think it’s yeah we can do it through the private sector, but there’s a huge limitation because of the, you know, lack of data and all this 100,000 cars,.

Unidentified participant:

Fake cars. Do you know what it means? 100. Oh, I agree. We have to No, that’s number one for the next.

Alona:

Government. We need to, you know, and ask the state governor to do. I agree totally with you. That’s absurd. Yeah. And but anyway,.

Jonah Wittkamper:

No to be continued. Marcel, thank you so much. Sorry for giving you some heat in there, but I want these metrics to be included in your in your DDQ. I’ll send you some.

Marcelo Seraphim:

Absolutely. We are still discussing this. Excellent. For those who don’t know, a fake car means a fake rural environmental registry marking in a nationally available.

Marcelo Seraphim:

Database. Yeah, it’s car means kadastro ambient which is kind of agro or I cannot how can I translate this rural environmental registry. Yeah, it might be. Yeah. Mhm. So there are 100,000 fake cars which is like it’s ridiculous. And we have to stop it. Well, we actually were able to decrease deforestation from 2004 up to 200, I’d say 14 to decrease we decreased deforestation and the government was another one and it’s not it’s not a coincidence that in this government in particular the deforestation raise like at this point it’s like ridiculous.

Anyway, but we do have to continue to pressure investors. I’m with you. I mean, but it’s it makes things pretty harder.

Christian:

I have a question if I may, Marcelo. About the UA European Union tax on products that carry emissions on its supply chain. I looked into it, you know, a few months ago when it came out. So do you think that I understand that’s a trade war and all that, but there’s a reality, you know, if you don’t pay the cost of carbon, then your product will be less expensive, will be will not incentivize, you’ll be unfair to other companies that are covering that. Do you think that this may cause may have some effect into looking at better managed emissions in a cattle industry in Brazil?

Marcelo Seraphim:

Absolutely. Especially if China follows the same the same path, right? Because the most of the exports are to China from Brazil. So, but I think it’s I’m actually, you know, wishing it happens like they are planning because it’s still it’s still a bill, right? It’s not a.

Christian:

I think it was effective. I haven’t looked at it in a few months, but I really liked it because no solutions are perfect, but they put some level of pressure and there’s people that will only act on compliance, but there’s people that will act on trends. Some people are going to be, you know, okay, listen, we got to clear that out because someday this is going to be going to be a real cost for importing you know, products with low carbon management. So I’m going to look into that because just interested what type of impact the private sector can generate.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Marcel I have another question which will be relevant for a lot of investors. The new task force on financial disclosure on nature related financial disclosures and climate related financial disclosures. Could you explain to us a little bit about what they are and what impact that you think they are going to have on investors in the region?

Marcelo Seraphim:

This is you know I haven’t I haven’t been involved with this so far. Jonah I think we have to talk to my friends for this one too. Okay.

Unidentified participant:

I think it’s a very early stage so far. They’re still developing. I haven’t.

Emily:

Read anything like robust on this yet. So well, but you know my feelings is that this is going to happen help a lot. But let’s see. Yeah. One interesting topic around this very good topic that you brought up, John, is that whatever measures that companies said, oh, we’re going to reduce our emissions under this the CFD, you know, that you’re going to have to create a plan that’s going to be vetted. It’s going to be tracked. It’s not just saying, oh, we’re going to reduce our emissions by whatever by 2030.

What are the plans? How is this going to happen? And then, you know, what are the teeth around that? That’s another question. But that’s one of the active topics I’m researching because that’s what’s designed.

Marcelo Seraphim:

For and the accountability on measures I think is a really big strong point on that framework. Agreed. One significant impact I think it’s going to have is on biodiversity assessment assessments. There’s some clauses in the mandate of the task force on nature related financial disclosures that call for biodiversity monitoring and at the moment mulner cultures can out compete agroforestry poly cultures and it shouldn’t be that way. It’s not so good for the soil and the environ we are still struggling with the DCFD in Brazil. So, this next step is going to be it’s going to take a little bit longer.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Agreed. Great. Any more questions from anybody? Okay. Thanks so much everyone. What a great call. What a great group of people. I’m going to stop the recording and I’ll leave the channel open so the chat is up in case anyone needs to take things there and if anyone else has more offcord stuff, you know, now is your time.