Lush Cosmetics and the Amazon

Founded in 1995 in the UK, Lush has grown to be one of the world’s largest cosmetics companies with over 900 stores globally. Years ago, the company mapped the supply chains of its raw and processed materials to identify ‘sourcing hotspots.’ When layering data on biodiversity, carbon, and migration maps, the company realized that its sourcing communities overlapped with the regions most in need of conservation. Since then, as a buying strategy, the company created ‘sourcing hubs’ in key locations, setting up demonstration farms, forming trade relationships directly with communities, and supporting local processing infrastructure development. As intended, the process created new economic livelihoods as alternatives to poaching and forest degradation, while supporting the transition from conventional agriculture to agroecology. Join us to meet Ruth Andrade, Lush Head of Environment, and Livia Froes, Lush South America Sourcing Hubs Coordinator. They will share a decade of experiences developing these programs, talk about collaboration with philanthropy, and discuss plans to verify carbon and biodiversity impacts embedded into raw materials as part of an insetting strategy.

Recorded April 11, 2022

References:

Lush Buying

Article: A supply chain that works for life

Lush’s Buying Stories on YouTube

Murumuru 

Tonka beans

Cupuaçu

Lush South American Hub Ingredients (for sharing)

Regenerosity

Conexsus – helping community enterprises to access markets

Pur Project – carbon insetting and supply chain regeneration

Terra Genesis International – interventions for systemic regeneration

ReNature – regenerative agriculture transitions

Regen.Network – blockchain for verified ecological impact

Meli Bees Network – from arc of deforestation to arc of regeneration

Yakum – developing methodologies for carbon sequestration in Buriti Palm wetlands

WATCH:

  • Jonah Wittkamper
  • Ruth Andrade
  • Livia Froes
  • Ursula
  • Marcelo
  • Emily
  • Mark
  • Max
  • Marian
  • Fiona Banister
  • Unidentified participant

Jonah Wittkamper:

Hello everybody. Welcome to what I think is the 84th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing the rule of law and force friendly economic development across the Amazon region of South America. This week we are featuring the work of Livia Fruence and Huchi Andrai to say in Portuguese. They work with Lush and Regenerosity and they Lush is a global company with I think 500 stores or more than 500 stores all over the world. One of the world’s largest pharmaceut or sorry cosmetics companies sorry I didn’t mean to conflate cosmetics with pharma.

They have a longstanding history working with grassroots indigenous communities and others and that’s great news for the future of forests. So Ruth and Livia would one of you so a question for both of you where did you grow up? Where did your love for rainforest come from?

Ruth Andrade:

Wow. I’m from Brazil. We’re both from Brazil. So yeah, I’m from Brazil and I grew up yeah, crossing the Atlantic rainforest as a child and yeah, I also saw the destruction, you know, how Brazil changed over the 40 years that I’ve been alive. So yeah, I think that and also then learning about the issues like as I became you know once you once you dip your toe into this you just start learning more and more and more and more and then it turned me I became an environmental activist as I yeah as I stood and watched everything happening I also wanted to do something about it but my love I love the Amazon but I love the Atlantic rainforest maybe a little bit There’s only left.

So,.

Livia Froes:

I’m Brazilian, too. I still live here. Lived my whole life at the Atlantic rainforest. My mom’s house is nearby, a piece of forest. And I guess I was just very lucky my career. At some point I started working with some very ethical cosmetic companies and then find out that the ingredients can help keep the forest standing. So then my passion began. I guess it’s just because I’m a Brazilian and also I learned that I could help to protect just doing my work.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Nice. Don’t you love that when passion and the needs of the world combine? Let’s talk a little bit about your careers before Lush. What did you guys do work-wise? You know, what led you to stumbling into the front door of Lush?

Ruth Andrade:

I have a very unique story. I think I worked I worked as an English teacher in Brazil and then I decided to and I was already vegan and I was quite involved the vegan movement in Brazil and also like I come from a very progressive city so we used to have actually quite good environmental policies and the city had 100% recycling in the 90s and you know also amazing parks and. Reforestation programs and I was already wanting to have an ethical job so I moved to London just for six months to improve my English and I got a job at Lush and then once the MD like the founder of Lush walked into the store I was a sales assistant in the store and I just grilled him and I was like look we want to be this was 2004 like we want to be an ethical business but the packaging doesn’t even have the plastic identification code and the lighting could be so much more energy efficient and he said okay I’ll ask a director to call you and if you want to do it maybe you can help and then the director called me and said all right what are your ideas send it to me I wrote all my ideas on the paper and became Lush’s first environmental officer like by chance like in 2004.

So then I helped you know build that function within Lush. And also left lush to pursue other things so I have lots of things around organizational development how do we create organizations to become living systems so they really you know we really do governance as a living system and also with philanthropy how can we yeah how can we influence philanthropy to become more regenerative inside out. Like fund more regeneration but also transform philanthropy itself so I’m really interested in this transformation towards a holistic way of thinking regeneration not just you know it’s not just about soil regenerative agriculture is about changing our worldview I think towards a living systems kind of worldview yeah so that’s my story with Lush and then I’ve been doing various roles but all connected with environmental or ethical issues or philanthropy within Lush.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Excellent. I love that. I’ve never heard of such a powerful grilling of the boss outcome. I love it.

Livia Froes:

Well my career started with international business. I was working one in one fragrance manufacturer, international fragrance manufacturer and I was invited to join Nata, the Brazilian cosmetic brand and I stayed at Mata for some years doing different in different rows in buying so buying raw materials packaging all different types of raw products and at some point I thought that I wanted to have more international exper experience and in that time I decided to travel on vacation. I went to UK, so England, Ireland and Scotland and I saw some of Lush shops there and I thought, well, we should have these shops in Brazil.

We don’t have that. And when I came back to Brazil, I mailed the Lush team saying, look guys, I want to open a shop, Lush shop here in Brazil. And just email me back, oh no, we are opening our own production in Brazil and the shops are going to be 100% owned. And I decided to Google it. I went to Linkadine and I saw that they were hiring production manager. And I decided to send my CV to them saying, “Look, I have great experience in buying. Eventually, you’re going to need someone to work in buying.” Two days later they contact me to be the buying manager here for the produ Brazilian production.

So I worked for the Brazilian production for four years and because I’m based in Brazil. I knew lots of the supply chains here. I introduced some great sources to Lush to globally not only in Brazil. And I didn’t know but they already thinking about the buying hubs. And when Lush decided to leave the country, they invited me to be part of Lush UK team. So I never left Lush. I just moved from Lush Brazil to Lush UK as a buying coordinator.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Excellent. You guys have a big story to share with us. Why don’t we go ahead and u make way for you guys to do the presentation that you have and then I’ll follow up with questions after that and then we’ll throw you to the lions which means questions from the audience.

Ruth Andrade:

I like that idea. So I’m going to try to cut the presentation a little bit short so we have more time for talking. But yeah for I wanted to start with just a very brief overview because I think I don’t know as more and more businesses start talking about regeneration and using the word regeneration I do I do want to invite people to have a very systemic and holistic view of regeneration and show a little bit how we’ve been thinking about that at Lush. Yeah we have the purpose of leaving the world lusher than we found it.

So you know the brand means abundance and thriving and how can I always think like I don’t think Lush is there yet but how do you design a business that every single part of the business is creating life right every part of the business every decision that the business makes moves us moves humanity towards more diversity and complexity on the planet so that’s hopefully we can do that one day. Oh, and then I’ll Yeah, we started in the UK. So, it’s actually a UK brand that started in a small town called Pool.

That was the first shop. That shop’s still there. And now it’s a pretty big bread in like 49 countries, over 900 shops and 14,000 staff. And then we’ve been doing Yeah, we’re just like a tiny piece of the cosmetics market. And alush, this is like 2018 figures, but also of becoming a keystone species. So, you know, a species that has a larger or brings a bigger benefit into the ecosystem in relation to its size or the size of population. So, how can we become a keystone species in the cosmetics market and really try to influence other brands and try to, you know, move cosmetics industry into more regeneration, less packaging, no animal testing and all the things that we care about.

So, we invented iconic things like the shampoo bar. So, all like Lush was the first to make shampoo bars. So, that’s a kind of an innovation that we now it’s you know main has become mainstream. We have also have a really solid giving program. So today we’ll talk a little bit more about giving but we have a specific fund for regeneration that also exists already for a few years and we have funds for activism for animal testing for campaigning and yeah we have given over 60 million pounds in the last 15 years and that’s from lush like we don’t have a foundation we just we just give as a business which also makes it so much easier to give and we can be very political with our giving and we can be very strategic with our giving without the same barriers that like a charity would have.

And we are very political so we engage in a lot of activism. We’re even, oh I probably shouldn’t say that we even need to be careful to not get in trouble with like the Indonesian government or you know we have had so many because of our political activism and this is a campaign for SOS Sumatra so for we supported local purchasing of law large areas on the buffer zone of the Luca ecosystem and the Gaia Lewis National Park. So yeah, so also how can we use you know the work that we do to move money in the right direction and help protect, conserve and regenerate.

Yeah, animal testing, campaigning and all of that. But the main thing we wanted to talk about today is like our creative buying. And then of course Livia would talk a lot more about that. Just to give a little bit of a history, in 2007, we found out that some of our essential oils were being tempered with and the quality wasn’t as good. And then we asked that question like, what would it happen if we really developed direct relationships with suppliers? And we started this really long journey of developing direct relationships with suppliers.

I think Livia I don’t know the current stats but from what I remember it was like 30 60% direct purchases and only 40% through distribution and it’s usually synthetics like most of the naturals are really direct purchasing and this gave us the kind of freedom to do like unthinkable stuff that I’ll share some of it now like it really opened the business to doing very good projects with a high level of integrity because we had full traceability and direct access. Yeah, that’s the vision for buying. So, you know, having a regenerative impact but still with quality m materials.

Yeah, and then the Amazon and what Lea is going to talk about is part of what we call the lush sourcing hubs that she already mentioned. I will share the story. I’m not going to read that all of that. But mainly we wanted to map the hot spots where our raw materials were coming from and we also mapped what were the biodiversity hotspots, climate migration hotspots, bird migration roots and large carbon sinks and then of course like everyone using you know natural materials all the materials are coming from those places.

So then we ask that question like we know that we can be part of the problem and we can be part of the destruction or we can be part of the solution and use instead of having like an extractive relationship with our supply chain we can have a regenerative relationship and really invest in protecting and regenerating all those big areas that we mapped that you know need to be protected. So that kind of twofold in terms of strategy. One is how do we create sourcing projects on the buffer zones of high priority habitats and large carbon sync.

So how can we really support regenerative livelihoods? So communities don’t need to poach or encroach on the forest and there is fewer drivers for deforestation and also how do we support transition from conventional to regenerative agriculture. And when we started this, it was like 2009. We weren’t even using the word regenerative like our buyers do did a permaculture course. We started bringing permaculture specialists and partnering with permaculture groups around the world and then conservation organizations and this like global collaboration around our supply chain started to emerge. And then we divided that into hubs.

So we have four hubs. Mediterranean and Middle East, South American hubs of which the Amazon is a hot part of it. Africa and then India and Southeast Asia. And every hub has a herb coordinator really actively developing the supply chain in those areas to be more and more regenerative. And just to give a few examples before we talk about the Amazon, this is some land that we purchased in Lebanon that was completely degraded, like completely degraded land. And then we’re like, right, how can we transform this into a thriving productive landscape?

There were even refugees living on the land and now are working for us. And the idea is create a demonstration site for organic naroli oil and work with the farmers in the bio region to source oil from the farmers. And this like one strategy that Lash has had is we buy a lot of high value products because they’re essential oil or essences which means that and we support infrastructure. So there is a lot of value addition on the ground. And then of course more, you know, more value is retained in the communities.

And yeah, and essential oils like Nuroli oil. I don’t even know how much it is now, but I think it’s like 4,000 or no, 2,000 pounds a liter. We’re talking about, you know, really, really highly priced raw materials. Oh yeah, and I also wanted to say something that’s really important. It’s like contracting with farmers. So that region like for us to buy from a farmer the farmer has we contract that they are going to turn their farm into a no hunting zone. I don’t know like Lebanon is one of the places that hunts birds mostly and there are like 55 million birds that are hunted in Europe and the Mediterranean and Middle East.

So how can we actively support you know also the biodiversity by contracting in the right way? That’s another beautiful one in Somatra. Again, as I showed, we helped purchasing the buffer zone of the national park and then funded a permac permaculture demonstration farm that train farmers in how to grow pachuli without encroaching in the forest. And that has been very successful. We’ve been buying pachuli. Pachuli oil is produced locally with microhydropower. And yeah just like cascading benefits for mixing that like we didn’t even know the term blended finance but this is what it is like we put a lot of philanthropic capital we put some investment and we are also the marketplace but we didn’t have to do all of this like now I’m trying to really promote the adellet stop doing everything and like do more collaboration get more impact another one is like we mapped the migratory roots of birds And then we’re like, right, what can we buy in the migratory roots of birds that can support bird migration and biodiversity?

And then yeah, we have like five salt pens. The whole of Japan has different materials that are supplied on the migration route of gray buzzard, which is a keystone species. Yeah. So it’s like really radical level of thinking around supply chains. Yeah. And over to Livia so she can finally talk about the Amazon. Leia, so.

Livia Froes:

You keep moving these slides for me.

Ruth Andrade:

Yeah, of course. And I don’t know if Sorry, I don’t know if people want to ask questions before we go into the Amazon. If we leave them for the end and Okay, we’ll leave the Okay, leave.

Livia Froes:

Okay, so like I said, I’m responsible for the buying hub in Latin America. So this means that I look after new ingredients, amazing new ingredients to present to our development team. I look after new sources, amazing new sources. Some of them could be already established, could be a private company, grassroots projects, a project that we need to start from scratch means that I project I do a project management of the pro of projects that we need to start or they’re in implementation phase or even projects that have been implemented already.

And we can all work with different types of structures. So when we have when I have my first conversation with a group that we’re going to partner with they usually ask okay so how do you work it’s basically very tailor made it’s built together with in four six hands so what does the project need what does the group need what is a requirement for that specific ingredient that the groups are going to are going to produce so can be just supporting exist existing suppliers to enhance Equip practices could be that we are going to buy a land are going to invest on equipment could be a community ownership contract farming or even a refund project that became a buying project that happened.

So we kind of tailor made each of our projects. This is you can go this is not a buy map but this is these are the projects and sources that we have in Latin America. So in blue you’re going to see the refund. So projects we have funded through refund in Latin America. They are not related to buying. So any anything related to our supply chain we just funded them. And in red and in green you’re going to see the sources that we have implemented are in green and ongoing are the projects or sources that I’m still working on it again it doesn’t mean that it’s a all of them are projects that we started from scratch means it can have just a very nice source that were already established I just found them and introduced to the buyers so we have a regular buying team that’s based in UK and do the contracting placing POS.

So we work in partnership with them. I guess you can go to the next slide. I’ll give you some three examples each one from a different type of structure. The first one is our lush concession in Peru. So in 2011, we were alerted about illegal logging activities in the Amazon in the Peruvian Amazon and we decided to buy to purchase the logging rights for 600 actors timber con concession. This was in the end of 2011. In 2012, we started pro producing a rosewood oil. So we invested in two large distillation kits, boats.

We built a house at the concession for the staff. We had like 10 people working there producing the essential oil, the rosewood essential oil. From 2012 to 2016, we did some exporting of rosewood. However, in 2016, cities listed rosewood from wide sources as category two. So since then we stopped any production of rosewood at the concession. Since then we have been in contact with the Peruvian government trying to get approval to extract from wide trees from the Amazon but proven government didn’t grant us the authorization. So we kept doing surveys at the concession.

We have teams going there every year. We still haven’t decided what we’re going to do there. But we kept the whole staff. So now they’re just doing surveillance and protecting the area. We still keep the 600 6,000 actors there. As you can see in the pictures, there’s a river that crosses our concession and lots of illegal timber. This picture was taken from the kitchen at the house while our team was there doing the survey. And what this last surveys showed us is that the concession is working as oasis for the wildlife at the region.

There were it was found 12 different species of mammo in our concession which can compare to the menu national park where there are 13 species of mammals but the park is two million has two million actors is much bigger than our concession. So considering all the hunting and illegal logging activities surrounding the area, we think that we’re doing a pretty good job there. And let’s see what the next months and years will give us, what the future holds for us at the concession. We’re still deciding if you’re going to explore carbon and any other ingredient there.

Oh, okay. This is Chief Howy at from Hi Institute helping with our Tonka beans from the Amazon forest. This is Bra a Brazilian project, a community-based project. You can go to the next slide. We have a very short video to introduce you to the project. Oh, there is no sound. Okay. There we go. It’s still no sound here. We hear a little. You heard a little.

Livia Froes:

Okay, this video was produced by IMA Florida. We are we are partner we partner with them. We were one of the first members of the regions program. You probably already heard of it. We started talking in 2016 and they introduced us to the traditional communities at Kalanorti and some indigenous groups at Shingu area and our first purchase was in 2016 but was just a trial of very small quantity and we kept buying the Tonka beans from then since not our whole demand but part of it. As you can see in the graph here our purchase has been increasing except from 2020 we cannot see the 2021 but in 2021 we purchased something very similar to 2018 here so sorry Olivia I accidentally muted you please unmute yourself and come back.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah you’re on mute right now we can’t hear you okay where did you stop hearing just about a minute ago. Okay. So, go back to the first.

Livia Froes:

Yeah, thank you. So, like I said, this is a partnership with IMAF Florida. We were one of the first members of the region program. We start out talking with them in 2016 when we purchased our first trial of Tonka beans and we kept buying from them. We buy all the Tonka that the project can supply. We have been supporting them not only by buying the tonka beans but also to establish the supply chain because this was a project that we started from scratch. So we helped by we have technical consultancy that visits that visit them twice three times a year if necessary.

We helped them with working capital. Can you go back to the other slide, Ruth? No, the one next that. Yes, thank you. So you can see we were growing in our in our purchase. Then we had the pandemic the numbers the sale the purchase reduced basically because everybody I guess were prohibited to actually leave their lands. So indigenous groups were not allowed to get out of the their villages and people foreign were not able to get in. So but now in 2021 we went back to the numbers of 20 2018.

So I guess we’re now back on track. Hopefully we’re going to increase our purchase from them and directly buying the Tonka. We are talking about 132,000 hectares that we are supporting. In the video you saw 11 million 11 million is the whole origins program but the areas where we’re buying the Tonka beings are just 132,000. I don’t know if you heard but we’ve been supporting them with technical assistance as this is a project we started from scratch. They have never been work working with Tonka. So how to dry, how to prepare, putting bags, everything we started doing from scratch with them.

And as you can see in this picture, so in 2018 that’s how they were drying the beans. They are still drying like this, but they built suspended dryers. They built storage facilities. So these pictures are from 2021 from our last visit, from the last harvest. Okay, next one. Ah, nice. Now I’m going to Well, just to finish the Tonka beans. So, the Lush Peru concession is a project that’s owned by Lush. So, we purchase the land. The Tonka beans is a community- based project is a partnership with Lush Ima Florida and the regions program.

And now I’m going to introduce you to the peace community in Colombia. We have a very short video too. Hopefully, you’re going to be able to hear because there are some interviews that are worth hearing. And here Sorry. Print. Foreign. Supposed to be. Mr. Where did I come? Thank you. So, we started buying from the peace community in 2009. This is not a project that is focused on environmental or environmental restoration but in human rights protection. Since their formation in 1997 over 200 people from their group have been murdered and many others have been abused, injured and threatened.

We’ve created a massage bar called peace that we use it to fund their project to help the with their protection if they are fight. The community has been caught in the crossfire of the civil war and they have been since then struggling to break the circle of violence and refusing to bear arms and taking part of the conflict. Unfortunately we can people imagine that since 2017 things have been gone better but unfortunately they haven’t improved. They are still being threatened to leave their lands. So paramilitary groups fractions of the FARS are still threatened them to leave their lands but they still fighting and we are still trying to help them.

We’re contacting lawyers, contacting international human rights organization in order to support their them in anyone in any way we can. So share their story. It’s beautiful. Hi. Great.

Livia Froes:

Okay. Ruth, did you want to conclude? You’re on mute.

Ruth Andrade:

Okay. Okay. I managed. Sorry. Hard to unmute. Yeah. Just to just to wrap it up also with questions that I thought we could discuss. So I think one of the things is you know how do we support through the whole business. So we’re also funding a lot of regeneration. We set up Regenerosity to continue philanthropy outside of Lush and have been supporting the Amazon as well with two really beautiful projects working with agroforestry and protection. I’m not going to go too much into that but we wanted to share a little bit the drivers of success and our learnings because we’ve been doing this for a long time and there’s been a lot of trial and error.

So yeah, we also wanted to have this conversation, but yeah, Jonah, up to you if you want to have this conversation as an open conversation. If you want to ask us questions, I’ll yeah, I’ll leave it to you.

Jonah Wittkamper:

There’s a lot here. Let’s leave up the slide for a little bit. I do have one question and then we also have several questions from the audience and normally we start questions at half hour past the top. So we should prioritize questions from the audience I think. So first question for me is please explain to us two of your partners regenerosity give us a little bit more detail about that and then also it would be great if you could tell us about the British beauty coalition.

Ruth Andrade:

Sure. Yeah, regenerosity it was we were doing spring prize and we did quite a few years of spring prize which was this prize for regeneration and every year we get like 400 applications where you know 150 of those projects are probably fundable 50 projects are very fundable and get shortlisted and we could only fund 11. So we got together with the Buckminister Fuller Institute that had also been running the Fuller Challenge and then we also connected to UNDP Quater Prize and said right let’s bring our vetted shortlisted projects together and then work with other funders and work with other foundations to eliminate a level of due diligence and say right there are already this these projects that you’re you know that they’re ready to receive funds.

And then we also created a program of peer learning. So we connect the projects in peer learning circles. So we can actually accelerate regeneration and accelerate transformation through sharing learnings which I think is absolutely like crucial between us between the projects between funders. So yeah we try to start this community of practices at project level and also at funer level. And the sustainable beauty coalition. This is also something that I want to do more and that Livia I actually wanted to show. I’ll put the link in the chat. So, Livia, maybe you can talk about your research with all the ingredients from the Amazon and like sending sample boxes and things like this that we’ve been trying to get into the hands of our inventors and more companies as well.

Basically the work I’ve been doing there are so many amazing ingredients at the South America and Latin America that Lush doesn’t use many of them. We use quite a few to be really honest. So together with the buyers we decided to prepare some rainforest box to give to the development team. So one beautiful box to each of them so with new ingredients so they can in amazing sources so they can look at ingredients try to use it and maybe be inspired by the those boxes. So that’s what we’ve been doing and well first box was success I believe three new ingredients are going to be used in the future in near future.

So, we are doing a new box from the Caribbean with the Caribbean ingredients to be introduced to the inventors as well. Yeah. And then Yeah. And just to say that what then I’ve been doing is because we’re part of the sustainable beauty coalition with like 100 cosmetics boxes. It’s like how can we get all the work that Livia did and the amazing PDF and share with everyone. So, we’re going to share it here. So, you can also share it with everyone. And then Livia, you also offered to support with connecting to the supply chains, right?

Yeah, we have amazing sources and people that we would love to they’re struggling to get the products into the market. So, how can we support them even at Lush? So, a new development can take years in a cosmetic company and that’s normal unfortunately. So, they’re struggling. So any connections you guys need or need to be done, I’m happy to do it.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great. Thank you so much, guys. Okay, let’s move into questions. If you’re interested in asking a question, you haven’t already indicated your interest, please post it in the chat. Ursula, you’re up first. If you’re there, you might be on mute. There you go.

Ursula:

Hi. Excellent presentation. I love it. As a woman and obviously one person from the Amazon. I’m I already checked your map and you are not working in Bolivia. I would love to help you contact some natives here, some tribes that are already producing asai and other products, especially oils. And well, just congratulations. I know already that you’re not working in Bolivia. The map you show the map later.

Livia Froes:

No, we aren’t. I’ve been in contact with two or three groups in Bolivia from the spring prize. They were not winners. So, but I saw they were producing some great ingredients and I contacted them, but it didn’t move forward. So, I guess you already have my email, so feel free to email me.

Ursula:

I’ll write you. Yeah, for sure. I can I can we can do a win-win with the with the indigenous communities here.

Livia Froes:

Definitely. That’s how we how we like to work.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great. Yes. Thank you. Okay. Next up, Marcelo. Yes. Hi, good afternoon. This is this is great work. Congratulations. It’s an inspiration to hear you and really I wish there were more lush in more industries all around the world. So, that was great. My two questions are well I think the PDF you just sent kind of answers a little bit but I wanted you to give us more detail about other value chains especially in the Brazilian Amazon for me that would be interesting. What other what other ingredients or value chains would you be looking for?

And also if you here in the Brazilian Amazon, if you only work through OD Brazil or if you also could work outside of it and go for other suppliers that are not certified by Odigent yet. Those are the two questions. Thank you.

Livia Froes:

So no, in Brazil we don’t work through regions only. We have different partners. We only buy the tonka beans from the regions and also we are trying to expand our s our supply chain for tonka beans because as I said in the during the presentation origin is still not able to deliver everything I need so I’m still buying from other sources so I would love to have more projects on tonka but other ingredients as well so origins only supplies the tonka beans other supply chains in the Amazon I guess you’re going to be a little bit frustrated because we don’t have that much.

But we have the murmuru butter, kosu butter, tonka beans, coffee. We have we’re establishing a new supply chain for coffee, organic coffee. We have approved the Sacha oil, which is not in the Brazilian Amazon. Hopefully, it’s going to come from Colombia. A nice project, too. And we also use Brazil nut oil which is coming from Peru not Brazilian. I guess these are the biodiversity ingredients.

Ruth Andrade:

Leia, I think now it’s also a good time like we were talking so much about the like one of the key things for access to markets is for projects to be ready and you and I talk a lot about this. So I think it would be really nice like from the perspective of a buyer, right? What is needed because I think Lush has a lot of patience and we actually invest in the development of the projects but many buyers won’t do that. So yeah, I think it would be great for you to share some of your experience with that.

Livia Froes:

Yeah. So please keep in mind that I’m giving you a buying perspective. So, so once when I connect to a new project for a new group that in introducing me to a project, I usually get that oh the project is ready to go. They are producing the oil and they are ready to sell. And when we go and put the first order or have the first chats, we realize that no there they don’t have all the legal licenses to export or local licenses Brazilian environmental ministry or whatever. So that’s where I jump in.

So I connect these projects with people that can do the exporting or can teach how to export and can prepare the cargo. These bureaucracies and paperwork that sometimes the community is just not ready or not just not willing to do it and that’s completely fine for Lush. But some other companies don’t have a position like mine or a buyer that’s or has the willing to do that. So they most of the companies want something ready to go. We place the order and we receive the product. So it’s not a complaint.

It’s just alert. Some companies will just run away from things that are not ready to go. Is not lush case because that’s why they we have the sourcing hubs and we are trained to do that. So we rather prepare the group to export to ourselves and then to other clients. But there are this I’m not going to say tiny because they are not tiny details. They’re are very important details that are required to do an exporting and local invoice issue, international invoice issue. They’re not just details, they’re really important. So part of my job is actually connecting these groups with tradings or companies or exporting companies that can do finalize this process for them while they’re not ready to do it.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great. Next up is Emily and please keep it brief. We’ve got a couple other people asking questions in just 10 minutes left.

Emily:

Right. Right. Thank you. Hi. Full disclosure. We know each other and connected through regenerosity. So I did write three questions in the chat. I’d like to you’ve already answered in part the facilitative nature in the relationship with the growers to go a little bit deeper in this incredible model when because a lot of these communities are facing complex vulnerabilities and both for the model and having consistency with your supply chain but then also with the values and intent that go into this to support these communities for their well-being and regen generation of the social ecologies.

Are there facilitators are there space for facilitators to support problem solving within the complex political, social, ecological dynamics that local and indigenous communities may be facing as they’re also trying to leap through this incredible opportunity to work with this the selling to Lush.

Ruth Andrade:

Thank you, Olivia. I think the peace community is a good example of that. It’s like we started working with them with no partner like no mediating partner like straight with the peace community and you know they came over we built a relationship over years but there have been cases where the cacao cargo was stolen. There have been cases where you know some of their leaders died. There were cases where you know the cocoa beans got moldy so there were quality issues. So, so I think I think when you’re working like same thing even with the Kaya and during the pandemic that they also couldn’t supply us, you know, what we needed and or for example with the with the Tonka beans, the Tonka absolute went into a product that became a top seller at Lush and then the communities, you know, are geared to produce a certain amount, but suddenly that product is a global seller and then you need, you know, you need three times more and it’s different from a factory that you can just go oh can I can I triple my order you can’t go to an indigenous community and say triple my order right so I think also one of.

During the pandemic yeah especially during the pandemic yeah like and like we were in a pickles like a bestselling product like where did you get it from in the end.

Livia Froes:

I was on maternity leave people were calling me we need more dona beans in the end of the harvest I was like oh my god what am I going to do now I’m not even working. But yeah, we had to buy part of the absolute from the market from other companies that produced the absolute, but part of our tonka beans are now coming from two different projects in Venezuela, not Brazilian Venezuela.

Ruth Andrade:

And I think I think it requires and this is why I know that this the Lush is a special a special place because it requires patience. We like the business needs to have patience to work and you need to be able to work with not the perfect conditions and we put it as one of the learnings like we need to build resilience at two ends our resilience so make sure that there are backup suppliers and maybe those backup suppliers are going to be more conventional but at least they derisk us buying from indigenous communities.

So using, you know, sometimes more conventional supplies to derisk buying from these really amazing products and then how to encourage them to access other markets that’s not just Lush because then them being 100% dependent on Lush, it’s also it’s also a risk. So yeah, I think thinking about that is important.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great. We have we don’t have much time left, so let’s go ahead. Mark, keep it quick.

Mark:

Yes, of course. So mibbo is native we work mostly with forest people and in a value creation process of their traditional medicinal traditional knowledge and system. So my question is considering you know the all the products or the different initiatives that you’ve put forward what would you say are your main criteria to select one project over another.

Livia Froes:

That’s difficult I guess we would go for how big would be the impact of us connecting with that project so sometimes we do have more than one project to select and we go through different criterias. Obviously, there is quality of the ingredient because we have the ingredient tested before. So, if you’re talking about an oil or even an essential oil, sometimes the quality doesn’t match what we need. So, that’s a criteria definitely. Whether the project is ready to go and we need the product right away or something that we can wait and we can invest in that project.

And also how if let’s let’s imagine that we have two projects and they’re in the same level ready to go. Quality is good. We definitely sometimes we go for both. We buy a little bit for both of them if we just are passion about passionate about both of them. But if not, we go for that one that we’re going to have a bigger impact. So they’re needing more need of support.

Ruth Andrade:

And just to say that we’ve made like the this alignment between the heart and the head. I think we’re becoming a little bit smarter around that. We’ve made so many like beautiful mistakes. But you know like we had this amazing project in Indonesia where we funded planting seven kilometers of lemongrass as an elephant barrier because the elephant encroaches in the community and the community then kills elephants. So you know the le the lemongrass it creates a smell barrier to elephants and they didn’t test and they planted the long lemongrass. So it’s not the lemongrass that works for essential oil.

So we funded the seven kilometers and now we can’t get the essential oil from the lemongrass. So it’s like we’re like we’re learning. You test everything first. You do small trials, small demonstrations, test the partners, test exporting, test, test, and then you scale. I think we’re learning that more. We used to be very guided by let’s do this project full. Yeah. With a heart. It was like 100% a.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Heart. Now we’re like maybe 5050. Yeah. Ruth and Livia, are you guys available.

Unidentified participant:

Past the top of the hour? Yeah, I am. I think I also share the PDF.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Okay, great. So these next two questions, it would be great if we could ask them back to back just so they get in before the top of the hour and then, so take notes while the questions are being asked so you can go over them. First is Max and then Marian.

Max:

Okay. So, hi, I’m Max. I’m founder of Mata. It’s a superfoods company working 100% with Amazon and ingredients. And, the question for you is, well, first of all, I’m a big fan of Lush. I remember when you guys opened your store here at Jar Jeans. I got really wondered with u all of the new products that I was trying to change in the sense that I didn’t want to use that kind of deodorants and my gut reaction was it seems so natural that I’m going to eat all this stuff and I could as well eat it and use it in my body which I didn’t do that but it was great that I had that perception.

And my question is basically in this category I heard from people that work with cosmetics that it’s very hard to get product performance at the same time base you know your ingredients all of natural and regenerative products. So I wonder what’s your thoughts on that. Is it like a category you know philosophical or real dilemma or can we really go after 100% regenerative solution that can really dominate the market when you know competing with the companies that work with chemicals and deliver performance but bring all of this bad stuff as a consequence.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Oh wow. Yeah, before responding, let’s go ahead and get Marian’s question in.

Marian:

Okay, sure. Thanks. Yeah, and I am gonna have to jump off. But I’ll listen as much as I can to the answer. I thank you for this great presentation and the work. I was wondering about regional economies in the area. There’s a lot of youth. There’s a lot of people who don’t have opportunity. And I was wondering how you are engaging that wider community beyond the communities that are the focal point of your.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Work. Go ahead, guys.

Ruth Andrade:

Yeah, maybe I’ll just share about the network of farmers and maybe you can talk more specifically about the Amazon. I think like we’re small like it’s not like I think one thing that at Lush we’re we are understanding through a lot of pain is we’re not a development organization we are a business so it’s like there is a limit to how many of the systemic pro problems that we can tackle but one of the things that a pattern that we have followed from the beginning is to fund demonstration farming and education So for example in Indonesia we have funded a permaculture school in Ghana permaculture school in Kenya like and they usually work with local youth and they train local farmers and local youth into regenerative farming methods and permaculture and also sometimes helping develop.

So like our project also that reature then continued like Lush supported at the beginning and now reenature actually got I think even more money to support them. We develop aloe vera production but we also helped the women set up a small local cosmetics you know manufacturing. So we do have some case studies of trying to support in other projects like creating this ecosystem like yeah e economic ecosystem of small businesses but yeah or like also Ghana they have 30 microenterprises that came from the same permaculture center. One of the businesses is moringa for lush but we also funded mushroom production.

And we also fund it. So that’s how we combine like philanthropy with the raw material. But Leia maybe you can speak more about self.

Livia Froes:

But not only through our supply chains but there are dozens of projects that we funded through refunds that were that where they were investing they’re willing to create demonstration farms teaching techniques bringing the youth to learn the practice from the elders. So in some dep depending on the ingredient for example tonka women’s are very involved in the tonka production opening the fruits drying the beans so we kind to like I said I’m looking for new sources of tonka so one of new project that I’m scoping it’s focus on women so bringing them to the production of the beans and collection and everything so not only through the supply chains, but I guess lots of the projects from refund especially that we funded were focused on bringing these groups.

Ruth Andrade:

And to answer the first question because that’s a very interesting question and I can probably spend a whole hour talking about natural and synthetics. I think from so two things from a performance perspective that’s probably true especially like new molecules and you know that there is so much hype around synthetic cosmetics versus natural ones from an ecology perspective like if you really do a life cycle assessment a lot of naturals have a much higher impact than synthetics. So even at Lush, we’re also not 100% natural. And when you compare like the impact of a rose absolute or rose essential oil and you compare the impact of a synthetic rose fragrance, you can’t compare.

It’s like 280 times more impactful the natural one. So but you know, we’re committed to using natural materials. So then how do you make natural materials carbon negative? That’s basically it. Like truly regenerative. And you were really supporting you know ecosystem restoration or preservation and you can measure that. So for me that’s for me that’s like the next stage and part of something that I would actually love to come back to talk about is like how do we embed measurable impact at raw material level through tokens through blockchain. There was someone here from region at work.

We’re talking to them about this. So then it’s guaranteed that product is really has a truly regenerative impact because we have to be a little bit careful about naturals and synthetics. And the last thing I want to say is fatty acids. There is so you mentioned like R&D in your question like there is infinite potential for creating synthetics from fatty acids that currently are coming from palm oil but we know that babasu oil or green coffee oil have a very similar fatty acid profile. So we really need serious R&D into that.

Like how do we not just how do we sell burichi oil or macakuba but macakawuba as well has amazing fatty acid profile like it’s how do we turn them into the synthetics that the industry wants to use because they’re superior to palm oil or just as good. So I think that’s also a frontier for the development of the Amazon that we still need to touch. Yeah. Yeah. Kusie oil.

Livia Froes:

Yeah. I’ll add two things. First one is do the cosmetic industries want to use natural ingredients? That’s my question because hopefully I don’t have any competitors but synthetic tend to be less expensive. So the price wise is better. Okay. Logistics they just place the order with the synthetic producer and three days later they have the PO delivered quite easy. Not much work, the price is down. I’m giving a buying perspective. But unfortunately, yes, sometimes the synthetics are more stable in a formula than a natural. So, for formulation, if you if you use palm oil or any synthetics in a product instead of a muru butter, a kuasu butter, they will be more stable.

So you can produce large quantities fast and you’re going to have the same product easy. While when you’re using a natural ingredient, it requires more work to get to the same type of product on a batch.

Max:

I was just going to say that, you know, we face the same challenges and opportunities in the food industry and I’m focused on the Amazon tonka, it’s Kumaru, which is part of our ingredients. So maybe I would love to connect with you guys and see, you know, what we can learn and collaborate. Yeah.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great. Great. Okay. This brings us to tap the hour past six, which is where we flip over to what is called water cooler time where it’s unstructured conversation. Sometimes indigenous people come on and say, “You didn’t talk about this or this is like open mic session. Self this same shameless self-promotion is permitted, etc. You guys can ask questions for those who are going to remain on the call. You’ll see some people have already, you know, class dismissed, have already left unstructured time. So, have at it. Anybody else have more questions or ideas?

Yeah, I do actually. Go for it.

Mark:

So I came back like about five days ago, four days ago from the Amazon. And so the work we do as I explained very shortly is working with indigenous people through a value creation process around their traditional medicinal knowledge and systems. So we have here just to show you I don’t know if you see so we have we have already developed quite a bit of products and wondering if there is ways that we can present these products to you and see which one some you know could have a value into your product line work or some of your partners and how that process This goes.

Livia Froes:

Mark, you can just email me, send me the list of products and can we can start talking from there.

Mark:

Okay, that was easy.

Livia Froes:

I’ll be your contact. This is easy. This is also something that like Leia talked about the sample box like it’s so important to get really nicely like nice samples in abundance. So sometimes you only bring like small little samples from, but bring samples in abundance so formulators can really work with the samples and one of the barrier that we have inside Lush that I imagine other companies have the same and you know the Amazon investors coalition also will have to address that is people don’t know how to formulate with the ingredients from the Amazon.

So it’s hard for the formulators to get their heads around like what’s the benefit, how does that work in the skin and I often wonder if we need some kind of guide like people to actually guide inventors and formulators on how to use Yeah, I don’t know leave.

Livia Froes:

Yeah, I think that you have found that issue as well. It’s not that they don’t well they don’t know and they don’t know the ingredients. Everybody that’s working at Amazon know about the bud oil the asai oil but Europeans when they are going to develop a new product they rather use olive oil because they already know it. They’re buying from Spain from hundreds and years ago and they know how it’s made and how good it is, but they don’t know the bud oil. So, we keep introducing the oils to them and hopefully they’ll be they’ll be using it soon.

So, that’s part of my job to pushing them to use new oils. Not only oils, butters and other ingredients. So, yeah.

Unidentified participant:

I have one. Sorry, Jenn. Do you want to go ahead? Go ahead, Marcela. No, no, you go ahead. I’ll go first. Oh, I was I was going.

Marcelo:

To ask about payment and sharing with native communities like hypotonic issues and payment for environmental services and this those types of new arrangements that communities and companies are formulating so that more resources are transferred to them outside or inside the price being acquired. Are you guys doing stuff like that with the KAS or other communities that you’re working with in Brazil?

Livia Froes:

Well, I’ll give you I’ll explain. So this is another challenge for Max’s question about the cosmetic industry. So when a when a cosmetic industry decides to use a Brazilian ingredient, this company will have to pay the benefit sharing according to the Brazilian laws, which doesn’t happen with the food industry. It’s very different from other countries the legislation here for Brazil. So we pay over the final product sold worldwide while in almost all the other countries is based on the ingredient not on the final product the profit of the final product.

So this is different and that’s why Brazil is a challenge compared to other countries. So sometimes a company instead of using a co cocoa butter from Brazil will use a cocoa butter from another country that doesn’t have such a difficult biodiversity legislation let’s say like this but yeah Brazil paid all the benefit sharing for the years that we’ve been working here so I just finalized it last week we would we wanted my original idea I was doing that was to pay through a project. So not sending the money to the government but actually investing on the project with the groups.

But le Brazil closed and I needed to pay the benefit sharing before the company was closing. So we had to send the money to the fund. So the money was sent to the national fund and we are waiting for the developments on Nagoya because Brazil just signed Nagoya in July. So is still not clear. I’ve been in contact with our lawyers on how we need to do and to be in order with everything that’s required but it’s not clear yet for foreign companies that doesn’t have that don’t don’t have a local institution in Brazil but saying that we for example with the projects we have been funding things for them outside the benefit sharing so for the kaya we’ve sent money for medicine during the pandemic so we have been selling perfumes and all the profit from some perfumes for a while were sent to the kaya.

We have produced some films for them to share their experience. So we do some we fund other activities not necessarily because it’s required by the government but because we believe in that but when it’s related to Nagoya we need to be needs to be very clear what we need to do in order so we can actually fulfill all the requirements that the government the Brazilian government is asking but we don’t need that to actually fund you can talk to the capos.

Ruth Andrade:

That’s true and I think This is this is always the you know the we’ve used a lot of philanthropic capital in a lot of those projects to get the projects off the ground to supporting the bio region like I think we’ve used a lot like few projects have been like a pure investment and we don’t have a lot of successful case studies of like good return on investment on the projects that we have invested like I think this is give you even an I’ll give even an example we can we usually invest on a processing facilities in some of the projects like we’re doing we’re going to invest in facilities in Paraguay not because the government is requiring because it’s a bio a Paraguayan biodiversity because we need to invest and maybe if there was a law that needed investment on that community maybe we would use it through the law and do the investment through the law but we’re doing anyway because we want we want to increase their profits And yeah,.

Ruth Andrade:

But I do worry about Nagoya protocol. I do think I think it’s an insane system that every country is creating their own like interpretation of it. And I think in the end it will it will have a detrimental effect to non-timber forest products and to products that I think I think it will really switch buyers off because it’s too complex and this especially the Brazilian one.

Livia Froes:

I guess we have two that are very difficult to work with. Brazil and Kenya. They’re the most difficult ones. And I was in some of the Brazilian biodiversity discussions with the government. And I me I even mentioned then like if we make it too difficult for international companies, they would just buy from other countries. And that’s not what we want. So, we have to find a middle term where it’s it needs to be something very similar to what other countries are doing. If we’re trying to make so much money over the profit of the final product, I don’t know.

I we might be scaring investments away, you know. I’m just worried about that. I know Lush won’t do it, but like I said, I worked in other companies. I know how the cosmetic industry, it’s a business.

Ruth Andrade:

And then payment for ecosystem services. This is this is also I think it requires its own conversation and like with regenerosity the two projects that we’re funding in the Amazon. One is Guana monoculture to agroforestry and the idea is also to follow a methodology for credits and another is in Ecuador. It’s like forest conservation. So we don’t want to do red but we do want to have a methodology that would allow for significant you know tokens for forest conservation being paid into the community and the conversations that we’re having with region network and other players is like is there a market for this because you know we can create the tokens that are not that cannot be used for offsets and cannot be used for sorry that cannot be used for offsets is this is there still interest even when they can’t be used for offsets.

So I think it’s going to be a growing market. But yeah, we’re trying to do that research. Do we have enough offtakers? Yeah. Of to you know to do payment for ecosystem services because Yeah. NFTs. Yeah. Yeah. So I have this dream. I don’t even know if it’s possible to be 100% honest. I and I’ve been trying to sell this idea to Lush, but it’s like can we do NFTTS which are connected to impact and they are connected to a raw material. So like when I buy a kilo of Burichi oil, it comes with certain NFTTS connected to impact and then those NFTs can even become collectibles to consumers, right?

I buy a lush product, I can see what it what it connects to, the tokens or the NFTs that it’s connected to and then I become a collector and I can collect, you know, connect collect all this beneficial work because of the raw materials in the product. I don’t know. I need to organize this better and do more research to see if it’s possible. I’ve heard that it’s not possible. I’ve heard that people are doing it already.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, they had I don’t think anyone has yet.

Ruth Andrade:

Say it again. They had this little thing called symbiome where a percentage of the earnings of the NFTs goes into some project pool that is directed towards you know whatever projects they want to fund.

Ruth Andrade:

Yeah. But I think we need to tap into that market and me like from an environmental perspective again at Lush we don’t want to do offsetting. So you know we talk a lot about in setting and the easiest thing like even if we sign up to science-based targets and all of it the easiest thing is to look at supply chain our supply chain is 80% of our impact. So for us, for all brands, if you then can go into the market and say, “Right, I’m like I didn’t show the last slides, but we use cork packaging and we actually calculated the carbon sequestration potential from the cork.

So the cork is carbon negative. So we know that if we buy a kilo of cork packaging, we’re sequestering this many kilos of carbon, which I think is like 10 times or 33 times the weight. So for every kilo of cork, we sequester 33 kilos of CO2. That can go straight into our insetting calculations, right? We are literally removing that carbon through our supply chain, right? Brands are going to be desperate for this kind of things because it’s a lot easier than having to set up our own projects whether it’s offsetting in settings much nicer.

So can we start thinking about a marketplace that includes you know the impact at raw material level. So I know when I’m buying a kilo of burichi oil, this is, you know, that’s the impact and then I can use that. That’s our so now we’re Leia is working with Petty Grain Oil that we’re going to we’re going to do that we’re talking to per project courageous lands in Brazil to try to work on you know this impact assessment especially for agroforestry and a methodology like how do you allocate the carbon sequestation to the different product products we’re having all those conversations but it’s so early days it would be really amazing to have some you know share shared learning around this with people that are working Yeah.

Or that would like to go into that direction because brands will be all over this. Yeah.

Jonah Wittkamper:

I have a question. Rainforest Trust said hi on the line. They several people join us. They left. They’re they’re involved in funding mechanisms called project finance for permanence. They basically negotiate with the government. They set it the government sets aside some giant piece of acreage all these economic incentives in place and sometimes business ideas in place. You know that’s a form of conservation finance. As far as it and there have been tens of millions of dollars put in these project finance for permanence projects to date. As far as I know, corporations are almost never involved.

When they if they could get involved, then they could create these investment products, you know, debt or equity that can capitalize, you know, the future income potential of an indigenous community, Google, Amazon.com, these giant companies, you know, spent billions before they started making profits. I’m wondering if you guys have been in dialogue with any of these project finance for permanence or conservation finance. You know there I mean they’re giant. There’s one fund that’s $4 billion. Wow. The value of getting involved in something like this is that investors can come in, they can look at the future potential earnings that you could bring a product.

There can be a lot of speculation you know about the future of Udachi or whatever it is. There can be equity and debt participants and you know the all of these investors play in the in the viability and the commercialization of the venture as it grows and you guys could just be you know the guaranteed buyer or whatever you know once it measures up to some sort of product quality. The is are the things I’m saying like real new to you or has the Rainforest Trust talked to you about it yet?

Ruth Andrade:

No, we’ve never spoken with Rainforest Trust. I see we also put that in one of the learnings. I see that a blind spot that we’ve had in the last I think when we started a lot of these things weren’t really being talked about. So we did everything ourselves. So we did it the we did the f the philanthropic capital, we did the investment and we were the offtakers. And since I got a little bit more into this world, I have been saying folks, we just need to be the offtaker. Really, we only need to be the offtake.

That’s the most important piece as long as we can guarantee like we can get the other investment, right? So, I think now we’re beginning to but we even we’re even talking to the buying team. Get some training around what are the existing financial pro products like how can we get you know how can we prepare the project to get more financing like we just don’t have that knowhow internally like we just don’t have that knowhow so that has been yeah we managed to do it like for Sierra Leon we actually we were just the offtakers and because we were the offtakers they managed to get funding from GISZ I think u or BMZ was one the German development agencies also with Kenya, but Reeer had to do it, right?

They were the ones that applied for EU funding and the project that we funded for many years now got half a million euros to continue developing before the Amazon. That would be amazing because we can be very good offtakers. And I think that’s what’s missing, right? That like the kind of work that we do of being so patient of working with the groups on their timelines that’s what you need but yeah we are not very good at that it would be amazing to get some support and help and yeah understand more how this works.

Jonah Wittkamper:

We’ll make it happen thank you anybody else and Ruth Thank you so much.

Ruth Andrade:

Oh, Livia, you have you share our contact with everybody. I received lots of messages with asking for my email. So, you can share with everybody. I appreciate.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Yeah, absolutely. Feel free to post it in the chat and anyone who asks me, I’ll make sure to share. Yeah, super interesting. It’s not often that we see companies like this like yours go so deep into the regenerative model. I’m very excited to see how we can partner.

Ruth Andrade:

Yeah. Great. Yeah, we’re really happy to connect with all of you. It’s I also put it in the chat like we did we did the mapping. We use 317 species of plants and fungi which is a huge diversity in the supply chain. It’s just huge. So yeah, we’re always interested in like new materials or new Yeah. New herbs and just yeah understand.

Fiona Banister:

Have you heard of these mushrooms that go that I think it’s in Zambia that women grow on actually they grow out of termites nests and they’re huge women use them for you know food mostly but also medicine so just throwing that here oh and another organization perhaps that you’d like to connect with is called oc2.org, one step closer in America. And I know I’ve introduced one of the founders to you, Jenna. But they do they do they push the envelope, but there’s much smaller organizations.

Ruth Andrade:

Yeah. I And thank you very much. And yeah, happy to I mean we’ll we’ll we’ll try to come to more of these as well to engage with the network more. Thank you so much.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Great. Thanks so much everybody. Bye. Thank you so very much all. Yes, really.

Jonah Wittkamper:

Thank you Fiona. Emily, good to see you. Great to see you. Thank you.

Unidentified participant:

I’m sorry. Hey. Hey. Hey.