Introducing the Rainforest Foundation Norway (RFN)

Founded in 1989 in the wake of Sting and Kayapó leader Raoni’s world tour, Rainforest Foundation Norway is a pioneer in rights-based rainforest protection. Building long-term partnerships with indigenous associations and environmental and rights-based organizations in key rainforest countries, RFN combines extensive activities on-the-ground in remote rainforest regions with targeted national and international-level policy action and strategic engagement with the private sector. Together with its 62 partner organizations in the six most important rainforest countries, RFN protects, on a continuous basis, more than 72 million hectares of rainforest (twice the size of Germany). Policy achievements include making Norway a global leader in public funding for rainforest protection since the UNFCCC COP-13 in Bali in 2007, influencing the world’s largest sovereign wealth fund (the USD 1.3 trillion Norway’s Government Pension Fund Global – GPFG) to make reduced deforestation and indigenous peoples’ rights one of its top responsible investment priorities and having the Norwegian salmon industry achieve that its Brazilian soy suppliers became the first soy producers in the world to deliver deforestation-free soy to all its customers, not just the environmentally conscious ones. More recently, RFN’s Falling short report (documenting that only a tiny fraction of official and philanthropic climate and forest support reaches forest peoples on the ground) played an important role in mobilizing the Glasgow $1.7 billion IPLC pledge. The ambitious goal of RFN’s 2018-2030 strategy is to ensure that the world’s large, contiguous rainforest areas are managed in ways that uphold biodiversity, forest ecosystem services, and the human rights of indigenous and other forest-dependent peoples and communities. Join us to meet Lars Løvold, Director of RFN from 1990 until 2018, and currently Special Advisor in RFN’s Knowledge and Learning team.

Recorded March 28, 2022

Recent Reports:

The RFN Falling Short Report, 2021

The RFN State of the Tropical Rainforest, 2021

Driving Deforestation 2021 – European car industry and Brazilian leather

Deforestation tools assessment and gap analysis: How investors can manage deforestation risk, 2020

Brazil: Protecting the Amazon through Indigenous Management Plans

Colombia: Forest conservation through Indigenous Local Government

Wampís Nation, Peru: Indigenous governance for rainforest protection

Indonesia: Expanding recognition of indigenous-owned and managed rainforests

DRC: Intact Forest Facility to scale up IPLC forest tenure and management

Other References:

Norway’s Government Pension Fund Global (GPFG) portfolio investee expectations – including on biodiversity and human rights, climate change and human rights

Norway’s International Climate and Forest Initiative – NICFI

WATCH:

  • Danielle Rappaport
  • Lars Løvold
  • Tom
  • Mark
  • Nicolas
  • Marian
  • Debra
  • Isabel
  • Natalie
  • Marc-André
  • Danny
  • Matt
  • Fiona Banister
  • Unidentified participant

Unidentified participant:

Hm. Okay. Let me try again. But I’m afraid it’s gna be the same. How is it now? Good. Now it’s good. Mhm. Now we’re cooking with gas. Say. Ja. Ja. But now it doesn’t change. Let me see. Hm. Do you do you see changes now? Ja. Aha. I see you. RFN’s approach. The goal. The problem. The problem. Ok. It works. Good. Fantastic. Stop share. Ok. Wonderful. The other thing I wanted to check with you is Norway really the largest investor in rainforce conservation, the largest single investor. It’s been since 2008 consistently.

Now Bos is probably g to take over, but it’s Mhm. Many that’s good. I just wanted to check that fact. Ja. And I think that all the questions I had for fact checking. So the my understanding from the exchange with Jon is that you guys talked about having a short presentation and then 15 to 20 minutes and then I would rather say 20 but okay. Perfect that works and then I’ll ask a couple of questions. Jon sent a curated list which is great and then open it up for some dynamic discussion.

Absolutely. Absolutely. Let me just go to the share screen once more just to see that I have other things up here so that I’m sure that I have it in the right present mode. Ja. Now I see I have one screen which is like every all and I have one which is this one which should be correct. Ja. Yes. Good. The only thing is that when I now try to change it like last time it takes like forever to change. I don’t know. Strange why are you trying to change it right now?

Ja. I’m going down the screen. That’s very strange. What did you do last time that enabled you? I just waited actually do anything. That is weird. It’s very weird. Mm. It’s not good now. It came to see. Yeah, but it took like a year. Are you changing now? Are you clicking or is it just changing on its own? No, I’m manually clicking. So, it’s just that first slide that seems to be sticky. So, I probably if it hangs up, I’ll let do some talking and hope it changes. Okay. Yeah, that works perfect.

Thank you for taking the time today. It’s useful because I hate this technical problems when you start a meeting. I know it’s the worst new reality is the remote work age. And where Norway are you calling from? Oslo. Fantastic. Great. Beautiful city. It is. Have you been here? Yeah. I took a road trip with my father. Enjoy the Norwegian Fords and we had a fantastic time. Don’t ask me where we went because we just took our car and we drove from village to village starting was so magical I was about 10 years ago.

Ok. Mhm. Yeah. I really enjoyed it. Yeah. By the way, you have a very good lighting in your face. I have a feeling it’s a bit strange here. Maybe I put on Is that better or worse? Looks good to me. Yeah. Yeah. I’m sitting right in front of the window. That’s why. Ok. Wonderful. Have you been working a long time with AIC? Since it’s been a year. Ok. So I’m one of the co-founders. I’ve been working with Jona. Yeah, for about a year now. Oh, we already have some people admit anyone until the top of the hour.

But I’ve been I’ve been singularly focused on Brazilian force conservation for the last 12 years. Mhm. It’s I was previously in the I’m a scientist for scientist. I was previously in the science of measuring forest destruction. Did my PhD on measuring the ecological legacy of human degradation in the Amazon Metal Grosso now I’m in the science of solutions which is a much better place for me to be in M trouble with science is it’s slow exactly that’s why I left traditional academia we would spend six years on one paper and launch it into the interwebs hing that would land on the desk somebody who has the with to do something with the knowledge and the technology so we don’t have that time no I agre yes now the role that I’m playing is more of a bridge builder between the scientists and the technology innovators in the markets and okay good yeah and how long have you and j been in dialog could be maybe year and a half maybe fantastic I really enjoyed your key presentationary presentation summit last year that was when I first became aware of you I’m gna starting people in.

Danielle Rappaport:

For hello. Hello. Welcome. Thank you. So working with Jon. I’m standing in for him today. How everybody doing today? How are you? Hello Emiliano.

Unidentified participant:

Hello Daniel. How are you? Fantastic. How about yourself? Great. Great. Hot day here in Paulo. Ja.

Danielle Rappaport:

So we’re gna have we wait for a few moments after the hour to officially start folks trickle in. In the me it would be great if folks could get off mute and introduce themselves name where from the organization representing I will start Daniel Rapport a cofounder of the Amazon investor coalition and.

Unidentified participant:

Chief research and officer based in DC Mark and Colom from Vera Chief Corporate affair so we were doing large Kale restoration Good day Mark GR from Rainforest Trust. Reinforce Trust is a USbased organization based just west of Washington DC and our focus is on establishing and expanding protected areas in the global tropics and subtropics.

Danielle Rappaport:

For those who are just now coming in, we’re gna start at around 205 maybe a few moments before but in the meantime, if you can get off mic and introduce yourselves where you’re from, what organization you’re representing, thatd be great.

Tom:

Yeah. Hi everyone, I can go next. My name is Tom. I work at the Sprado family foundation and we based in Bay Area in Mountain View, California to be more specific.

Unidentified participant:

Hello everybody this is part of the forest team of brail.

Unidentified participant:

Every carol theor of development atadasta foundation attending on behalf of our ceo and based dc.

Danielle Rappaport:

Start in about a minute. Anybody else to get off m and introduce before we geted with our official programming?

Unidentified participant:

Hello, I’m Zbignev Kozak living in Mandus and developing solar energy powered boats in Amazon forest. Thank you.

Unidentified participant:

Good evening.

Nicolas:

Good afternoon Ncolas work at the R Foundation Norway with Lars.

Marian:

Based in California theor of Amazon and fire programs at conservation XLABS I know some of you from my previous time at the more foundation which I just transitioned early this year.

Danielle Rappaport:

Great to see you Marian let’s go ahead and get started. Hello Amazon Investor Community and welcome to our weekly call and podcast. Series. I’m Daniel Rapport, a co-founder of the Amazon Investor Coalition and Chief Research and innovation officer. I’m standing injona be hosting the call today. Each week we invite leading Amazon facing investors, innovators, changers and experts to share their stories of how we’re working how they’re working to scale solutions for forced positive development in the Amazon region. This call series is a program of the Amazon Investor Coalition. We are a global learning and investment collaboration platform supported by Nexus, the giving back fund and others.

Our mission is to unite investors, philanthropists, companies and allies to advance for friendly economic development and the rule of law in the Amazon region. Today we are joined by Lars Level, special advisor to Rainforest Foundation Norway. Lars is going to share with us a bit about his journey with Rainforest Foundation Norway and Norway’s journey more broadly in becoming a global forest conservation leader. How did this small country in northern Europe become the world’s largest investor in rainforest conservation? So he’ll share with us a short presentation and then we open it up for dialog with all of you.

Laris take it away.

Lars Løvold:

Thank you so much. So I have prepared a PowerPoint just giving glimpses of the history of Rainforest Foundation Norway. So I start the screen share which we tested eh and which was very slow in the beginning. So eh if this first slide can you see the slide?

Danielle Rappaport:

Good. Yes. Ja.

Lars Løvold:

So what I will do is I will take you to sort of through a little eh ja exhibition into the history of the rainforce Foundation that started in 19 89 and I have the same problem that I had with Daniel that the first slide is very unwilling to go away but it will probably do as we did in the test eh that Ah ja let me see.

Danielle Rappaport:

In the meantime I encourage everyone to leave their contact information in the chat introduce themselves.

Lars Løvold:

Very strange. It did actually change when I tested it with Daniel. Ok. Took an hour but now we are here. I hope now it will work. Okay. So we all know the problem. We all know that the tropical rainforest is under very heavy attack and we know what we want. We want a sound eh complete integral rainforest but how to achieve it. So the point for me is to show you a little bit of the approach that rainforce Foundation Norway has been pursuing since the beginning. And an essential part of that is to build and support civil society actors in rainforest countries.

We do not believe that sort of foreigners can take the leading role in saving the rain forest in Brazil or in Congo or in Indonesia. It needs to be a drive by legitimate representatives of those societies. So since the beginning we have sort of had the model of building longterm partnerships recording in progress local organizations and eh giving them both you know program and project support but also core funding making them stronger over time. And we have since the beginning dealt with three different approaches to saving the rainforest. One and maybe the most obvious is to work on recognition of the collective rights of forest peoples.

So official recognition of their ancestral sort of link to the forest, their generations of living in there and to then work with them to manage those forests in a sustainable way. We have always also had the ambition which is now much more a reality than in the beginning of improving the policies and legal framework both at the national level and at the international level and to eh sort of to make that framework rainforest friendly and indigenous peoples friendly. We know that commercial actors are the direct links to rainforest destruction. So they need to be reformed.

So in essence we have a very long history of working on this issue. Started out in 1989 with these two people the world tour made by them extremely famous musician thing and the charismatic kaj leader rauni they went on a world tour talking not playing and it created rainforest foundation in many countries that start made for a double mission of the rainforest foundation norway to protect the tropical rainforest approbs about indigenous peop et at that time people talked more about the trees and the butterflies we have developed a strategy for 13 years.

We did it in 2016 and 2017. So the 2018 and 2030 strategy has an overall goal of securing that the world’s large contiguous rainforest areas are sustainably managed. And what we mean by sustainably managed means upholding the biodiversity of those forests, maintaining the vital ecosystem services that these forests provide both locally, regionally and globally. Not least in terms of you know temperature management rainfall patterns, rain rainfall production etc and to secure the human rights of the indigenous peoples and other forest communities so the consequence of that strategy was that we faced out our work in several rainforest countries to concentrate on six countries Brazil, Peru, Colombia, Congo Indonesia and Guine and six countries they contain 68% of the remaining tropical rainforest and 78% of the remaining intact tropical rainforest.

So we are talking about relatively small areas concentrated along the equator and the essence is really in what you see on this map. I give you a few glimpses into what we consider achievements during those years. First of all, we have been working with some of the same partners since the beginning of the 90s in Brazil. For instance, presently we have a very strong network of 62 longterm partner organizations within these six countries. And these partner organizations are both representative associations for indigenous peoples than forest peoples and more focused specialized proindigenous environmental and human rights NGOs.

And in addition to these 62, all of whom receive substantial funding from Rainforest Foundation Norway, we build strategic alliances with other NGOs and expert organizations including Rainforest Foundation, US and UK. Eh organization that we cooperate with for strategic purposes but we do not provide funding to them. So some achievements within work area one as you call it right spaceed sustainable rainforest management together with our partners on an ongoing basis we protect 72 million hectares of rainforest in many countries those six and that’s double the size of Germany in Brazil we are presently implementing management plans for I don’t know if he hears mean anything to you but that’s the sort of the denomination we use.

So if you need to sort of convert please do. But huge areas in Brazil, eh we have been working for more than a decade with indigenous peoples locally to develop management plans and the plan was that the Amazon fund basically funded by Norway as a government should finance the implementation of those management plans but then Bosson okay and now we have to do it. We have worked on protection of the indigenous isolated peoples people living in voluntary isolation and there are thousands of them over huge areas in Peru. Eh when we started working in Peru, government denied their existence.

Now there is law and a relatively effective protection system in place. And we have been advancing indigenous municipalities in the Colombian Amazon covering some 24% of the Colombian Amazon. Ok forefront of protection but they need support in order to live well which they do when they are not chased away invaded etc. You see these areas which are the areas where Rainfor Foundation Norway and partners work in Peru and Brazil. All together it’s an area the size of Sweden. So 435000 s kom kilometers. And I couldn’t find a good map of our sort of impact areas in Brazil.

So what I show you here is the areas where we do forest economy program implementing those management plans that I mentioned. So you see these areas in over indigenous territories over som extractive reserves for rubber tappers etc and a few other areas in terms of improving policies and legal framework. The probably biggest win ever was when in 2007 Rainforest Foundation Norway and Friends of the Earth Norway proposed that Norway should spend 500 actually 1 billion dollars annually on rainforest protection eh in order to save the climate and do something before a new climate agreement was in place.

Half of that was actually accepted by the government and the parliament. And since then Bali conference in eh UNFC Bali conference in December 2007, Norway has consistently given what is in Norwegian corona 3 billion Norwegian croner annually forf protection. Of course, the dollar value varies with the exchange rate, but it’s really a substantial amount going for rainforce protection eh every year. Also would like to mention a very old victory that our partners and ourselves had a major influence on the adoption of the Kanton safeguards in 2007 and 8. The climate negotiators had never heard the word right.

They thought the climate eh question was a purely technical question about carbon. But the inclusion of forest opened up a totally different agenda for them. And the fight to actually have these safeguards approved was intense but successful. Every year we work on with our partners on particular legal eh action or policy actions inside these six countries. So while before Bolsonado it’s a question of improving laws, now it’s a question of preventing destructive setbacks and many of the worst proposals have been prevented. We have the law can even see my screen here because of som eh let me see the law and protection isolated IPS in Peru eh which was eh adopted eh already several years ago and I’m concentrating mainly on Amazon facts here but I would like to include indc unable pig peop who are those who are sort of called indigenous peop in drc extremely discriminated couldn’t get ids etc and now our partners have developed a law proposal and has been adopted by the parliament in M ja an image from Glasgow this is on the left there is Norwegian prime minister and to the further to the left is the eh director of the DGPA the national pigmy network in DRC.

So one of the things we do is to make direct connections between decision makers and representatives of forest peoples. And Patrick Saidi, which is his name, is also here on eh the platform speaking to the audiences under the conference in Glasgow. Third element to halt the commercial drivers deforestation. We work on deforestation free supply chains with the timber industry, palmil, biofuels, soy for animal feed. And I would like to highlight just one very important victory. After years of working with Norwegian salmon industry and the salmon feed industry, they all import Brazilian eh soy to feed to the salmons.

They have for many years been able to get deforestation free soy but the eh producers and the traders they can deliver forestation free soy to those very demanding customers like the Norwegians but they sell all kinds of deforestation soy to everybody else. Now the Salman industry in Norway has worked with their suppliers and all three of them have since last year eh decided that they will not sell deforestation soy to anybody. So they have made their whole production chain deforestation free. Huge inspiration for the bigger ones like caril and others who have not done the same.

And we have worked with Norway’s government pension fund global for many years. First attacking them for investing in high risk eh companies for deforestation and human rights violations. Later working closely with the leadership for them to have very strong expectation documents that they expect from the 9000 companies that they invest in that shall not contribute to tropical deforestation should not contribute to violation of indigenous people’s rights and they shall have they shall have policies for doing so they shall report on it and the government pension fund global has a very active dialogue with really quite many companies in tropical forest countries.

We have also worked with the investors who you know they are not directly contributing to deforestation because they are indirect investors in all kinds of companies eh and there has been a huge progress working with both larges scale Nordic investors and strong networks of major investors like the principles for responsible investment network the emerging markets investor alliance etc and we are working with banks in Australia in Asia etc for them not to fund deforestation risk enterprises so in the invitation to this meeting there were several links to the expectation documents elaborated by the government pension global they make annual report on what they do in order to have responsible investment and it’s really worth having a Ok figures on rainfation Norway this year budget is 38 million US dollars.

I said we had 62 partners eh in the six countries. We have more than 75 partner contracts because there are is a diverse set of activities that we fund. RFN staff in Oslo is 72 and we have one external office, a national office in Congo with 10 person congolis staff eh plus including the director. An important element is I mean as I said to build strong civil society. So in 2020 eh we spent 74% of the budget to project managed by local partners. The percentage tends to be more or less the same year by year and we spent some 8% on the oslobased policy and private sector work that links strongly with what the people do on the ground in the rainforest countries.

Eh strengthening their initiatives, linking them up to international processes, etc, etc. I would say that and you will find that on our website eh a series of report for instance what came in last year state of the tropical rainforest the first fully comprehensive overview of the original state of the rainforest and the present state of rainforest in all tropical rainforest countries. The essence of that report is that 13d of the original rainforest is totally gone. One third is degraded and 13d is intact. And if any of you were in Glasgow, you must have heard reference to the falling short report.

The essence of that report is an investigation of climate funding showing I mean international climate funding from 2011 to 2020 showing that less than 1% of ODA official development assistance for climate funding went to tenure security and support indigenous peoples and most of that 1% was actually managed by huge organization World Bank larg in the fraction that reach ground just a small fraction of the 1% rainforest foundation ambition is to have a holistic and integrated management of large contiguous rainforest areas irrespective ownership so indigenous territories protected areas public forest private forest in order to save these last large contiguous rainforest areas.

It’s essential to develop an overarchic approach. Eh, indigenous territories are extremely important and in Brazil cover, you know, soman Amazon. But you cannot save the tropical rainforest by only focusing on indigenous territories or even indigenous territories and protected areas. We need to have an integrated approach to all those forests. We want to establish two corridors for isolated indigenous peoples along the Brazil per border. These two corridors are the size of UK. You see it here. We just launched before Christmas a study on one of those corridors documenting the existence of a series of indigenous peoples eh in these territories.

And we want to increase our international funding because we have a lot of funding from public and private sources in Norway. We have relatively modest international funding and we need to double the present budget in order to save the large contiguous rainforest until 2030. We need the rainforest forever. So thank you so much for listening to me and I will try to now stop sharing the screen and that was easy. Thank you.

Danielle Rappaport:

Thank you so much Lars. Fantastic comprehensive presentation on the history of Rainforest Foundation Norway and really wonderful to get that perspective. I’m gna ask a couple of questions and then I want to open it up. So in the meantime write any questions that you have in the chat. And we can get to folks. So Lar love to hear a little bit about your personal story in this path. Youve been involved with rainforce foundationway since the 90s. Where did you grow up? What did you study academically and where did you do your field work and how did that inform your devotion to this work?

Lars Løvold:

Ok. I grew up in Oslo, Norway eh and I relatively early became engaged in international eh questions and so on and so forth. I studied social anthropology eh and I ended up eh going to Brazil eh with my girlfriend, now my wife, also a social anthropologist eh and we did field work eh in Hondonia eh the northwestern state of the Brazilian Amazon staying with the Gavia and the Soro Indians there for a year and a half and that those years that year and a half really changed you know made the destiny.

So after that eh a lot of whatever I’ve been doing has been to work on forest issues. I actually went there because of the culture and I discovered the rainforest while leaving there and that combination is very strong and it was a extremely impactful eh event which eh you know made me join the rainforest foundation before it was started in a way and to work on it I was the first staff in rainforest foundation Norway I was working alone for some time and now we are What a story. So how you touched on this a little bit in your PowerPoint but it would it would be helpful to revisit the difference between sustainable development and rights based sustainable development.

How would you define those differences? I think it’s essential that there has been a long fight and that fight still continues for recognition of the rights of the peoples who have their ancestral history linked to tropical rainforest areas. Early conservation approaches looked at eh conservation as a way of keeping people out as you know eh often limiting the access of those people who has the rainforce as their home. And we have always believed even back in 19890 eh that the first step for rainforest protection is to recognize the collective rights of those people who live in the forest and to work with them because they are also under eh pressures for change.

They get news. Eh they used to live without money. Now most people have some more or less marginal or more involved you know linkage to the monetary market. They have new needs and they need to meet those needs in a way which eh is in their longterm interest eh which maintains the ecosystem eh as intact as it can be and they need some kind of support and benefit for protecting those forest giving us all a huge service for the global eh you know ecosystem services that we benefit from. So eh in many ways it’s eh based on their rights, their will and working closely with them.

Eh so that their answers can be discussed eh and that we can find solution which are also in the benefit and interest of the next generation.

Danielle Rappaport:

Wonderful answer. Thank you. One last question from me and then open it up. So please leave any questions in the chat Europe first. So back in 2007 Norway have a policy on tropical deforestation. Youve since developed a super competent team and program. Now you’re the number one single investor in rainforced conservation. I’d love to hear a little bit about the pathway of how Norwegian investments have improved over time.

Lars Løvold:

You can definitely say that eh the decision to establish what we call the rainforest billions programs in Norway eh was extremely unusual in a sense that it did not come from political leadership. It didn’t come from bureaucracy. It came from two NGOs. The timing was very eh in a sense lucky. Eh people were waking up to the climate crisis. The Stern report had shown that rainforest protection could be one of the most cost effective ways of contributing to controlling climate change, etc. And everybody was sort of waiting for a new eh post Kyoto eh climate agreement that in should be sort of was expected to be done in 2012.

So we had five years waiting for a new agreement could include forests and we were able to convince Norwegian politicians that they could over five years invest a lot obtain huge results but that after 2012 we thought there would be an international financing mechanism that would provide you know funding from all countries within the climate agreement. Now that didn’t happen. So in the beginning eh the first staff came to Rainforest Foundation under the orders of the minister say go and learn from rainforest foundation Norway. So we had a lot of influence but then the staff grew.

So we still have a very good relationship with Norway International Climate and Forest Initiative Nikfi but at the same time eh many years ago stop question asking us for everything. Now we have strategic discussions and they operate for instance with the leaf initiative. We had very little influence on doing that although we had contributions so it has become you know a strong and well established part of official Norwegian brokers.

Danielle Rappaport:

Thanks Lars. Debra do you wanna come off mic mute and ask your question?

Debra:

Thank you. Hi Lars. Thank you for that great presentation. Given your role in the knowledge and learning space I wonder if you could speak a little bit more about your program or agenda around knowledge and learning and also you know where it is now and where it’s going to help bring I’m sure very rich body of knowledge to the private investor community the public investor community and other actors in the space.

Lars Løvold:

In connection With the 2030 strategy, we made also an internal organizational reform restructuring ourselves and creating a knowledge and learning team. And that knowledge and learning team is focusing on both you know internal like eh you know log frames, risk analysis, indicators these kinds of things that donors need in order to trust you. But we also focus on eh you know eh making eh we have a staff which is very specialized. A lot we recruit them for Indonesia if they speak bahas knows Indonesia etc for Congo they need to know Congo and speak French etc they have a lot of experience and a lot of that experience is in their heads so we are systematizing eh you know what does it take for right spaceed rainforest protection to succeed what are the elements eh in protection eh that eh can be managed locally.

What can you do if you don’t have support from eh the local government? So eh we try really to eh to systematize eh our and our partners accumulated experience eh and that goes in very specialized directions. So you will see for instance that we have been working with the investor community eh how they can incorporate eh risk assessments you know deforestation risk assessment eh human rights violations, risk assessments, etc. In their investment decision making processes in their assessments. So there is a link for instance to a one comprehensive document which is a meant to help eh these communities and we also provide these links between as I said decision makers and local people so that actually CEOs in huge companies can actually meet Sonia Guarasara who is leading the strongest indigenous organization in Brazil for instance and these meetings and these encounters have quite a strong impact Eh, actually on both sides.

I don’t know if that’s an answer, but the beginning of an answer at least.

Debra:

Thank you. Be great to follow up with you on this. Thank you. Isabeled by Natalie.

Danielle Rappaport:

You might just for the purposes of time could do two and two Isabel you ask your question and Natalie very similar and then Lars can respond to both.

Isabel:

Thanks and thanks Lars for the presentation me by conratulation conratulating forest for work I to work in NGO supporting indigenous rights in Brazil pretty much familiarized with rain forest work and support which is actually really helpful to civil society here so it really nice to see your presentation I was just wondering and would like to hear a bit from you how you see considering the context that we have now in Brazil our political context that is so challenging how do you see that the international cooperation and all kinds of stakeholders that work supporting environmental issues and also IPC rights are facing right now.

Natalie:

I appreciate than you Lars. My question is along the same context as we take a step back in order to affect change at scale we also have to have a policy framework that provides protection and that really creates a path for an enabling environment and so I guess I’m interested in hearing from your perspective how you go about connecting this really deep kind of knowledge that you’re getting on the ground and that you’re supporting with also do you look to other organizations to bring in the policy realm by through kind of your strategic coordination or is that the foundation is also working on and how do you bring those closer together so you don’t have policy separate from all of the on the ground work?

Lars Løvold:

Ok, thank you eh to Isabel. Yes, with Bolson Naro and even the predecessors eh things have become more and more difficult. So for one eh our local partners in Brazil used to be able to have a direct dialogue with government entities under Bossonaro that is impossible. Screaming to Bolsonaro we found to be very ineffective eh and we have done very little of that. Eh but eh what eh the agrobsiness eh and Bolsonar listens to is the market. So we have intensified our work eh with market actors. You may have noticed that several eh you know coalitions of really major investors have written to through the Brazilian embassies saying eh we consider the present development lack of environmental policy etc as high risk and we warn you that we cannot continue to neither invest nor buy products from Brazil if you cannot change that and that makes a kind of difference at the same time we have also stepped up support to observator duima and other Brazilian NGOs who are sort of vocal and effective eh defenders in preventing crazy law proposals from being adopted in parliament and so on and so forth and we have worked with EU and EFTA eh for EU and EFTA to put environmental conditions for ratifying the pretrade agreement.

So these agreements have not been ratified. Eh we have not been alone and working on that but we have worked with a coalition of European NGOs. And Brazil has to listen to the market, has to listen eh to external governments. So we have seen that as maybe the most effective way to sort of prevent damage and give strong signals eh under the present regime. As for policy Natalie eh we have a very strong policy team so we do a lot of policy work and we also have sort of strategic alliances and local partners that are specialized on the policy field arena.

So but for instance when it comes to ja to influence EU eh Norway is not even a EU member although we are part of the economic market common market so we of course need to work with you know French Spanish, German organizations in order to influence decision making in those systems and but we have a direct activity when comes to for example UNFC eh so the climate negotiations I mean we are part of sort of specialized in geonetworks working on text working on formulations working on where the comma should be and so on and so forth so we that’s what I meant when referring to the sort of the alliance building eh organizations we do not that we do not fund but that we cooperate with on strategic issues.

Danielle Rappaport:

A long list of people asking things in the chat but should they Mark Andre and Danny if you wan come off mute ask your questions one after the other and Lars can respond to them both ok so thank you Lars for your presentation a great and.

Marc-André:

Okay, so thank you Lars for your presentation, a great and very inspiring one. You say you are working with 62 partners, mostly in UK, US and also NGOs. Do work with people in Canada and also with for profit eh corporation that specialized in defens free commodities that figured out how to eh put together social economic and environment and if so how does those partnership looks like? Or how would look like if you don’t.

Lars Løvold:

Thank you. I wait for the next question and then I thank you for presentation.

Danny:

I’m hypercious of the fact that in rainforest environments the dynamics at the very local level are opaque to those outside of it. You can only really understand things when you’re there in person seeing the way that the bureaucracy generally doesn’t work or the local dynamics of the economy and personal interests work. How do you translate or do you have insights into at high level how to translate a large scale vision into effective action given those hyperlocal dynamics that are so prevalent in rainforest environments?

Lars Løvold:

Eh, først Mark Andre eh the 62 partners eh are local organization in the six trinforest countries. Eh, I mentioned UK and US but that is our sister organization, Rainforest Foundation US and Rainforest Foundation UK. Eh, we engage with the private sector in a sense that we both shame and blame them which is often the start of a dialogue. Eh, once people would like to have a dialogue, we stop shaming and blaming and work very closely eh and for free. So we really provide a lot of consultancy services to private sector, you know, investors, companies, eh can be tropical timber importers in Norway can be to influence the government regulations for building so that they don’t use tropical, you know, eh timber in public buildings eh except on their extreme, you know, caution.

And so on so forth. So we have a comprehensive work with the private sector but I would say that we are not in a sense partners with them eh but we help we help them become you know make their eh supply chains deforestation fre improve their investment practices eh maybe stimulating them eh to also provide more support and be more conscious of the sort indirect eh effects of their investments or their operations and it has proven to be a very fruitful area. It took as I said years of blaming the government pension fund global before they started to listen.

Eh but now extremely good cooperation and that’s actually the biggest sovereign wealth fund on earth. It’s not unimportant and when they withdraw from a company they publicize make the whole reasoning eh documented and public. So it is a quite strong effect. As to Danny eh your question is complex in the sense that eh both we and our partners eh work very over very long periods with local communities. I mean so for instance in Brazil we have been active with partners institute of sociambental and others eh since 91. We still work with eh we still visit the same areas and we know the same people.

So in that sense some of them have come to Norway as well for certain gatherings and so on and so forth. But eh of course we depend on good partners inside the countries. Now our staff people they travel, they follow up, we discuss strategy, we discuss approaches, we discuss priorities and then we agree on a program of work which is normally a fiveyear contract so that has a certain horizon. Eh, we would still like and why I said we want to have a bigger eh budget even though it’s relatively substantial is because I feel that we have not managed to work consistently with the public sector.

I mean we have concentrated a lot on NGOs and indigenous associations and so on and so forth. We have good contacts in research community but we need to be closer to the sort of decision making structure for that goal of holistic integral management of all rainforest independent of ownership structure. So that’s a huge challenge. We hope to really reach that. But we also see surprising receptivity when these people from different worlds meet. Eh so eh you know one of our colleagues from Congo can have a huge impact in a meeting like in Glasgow.

It’s these people never meet but they meet in the corridors and meet on the side event and sometimes even in the plenary hall in negotiations and it’s not unimportant but there is a long way to go.

Danielle Rappaport:

Danny and Mark Andre do you guys have a response otherwise we will move to Matt and Marian?

Unidentified participant:

Eh a response to a follow up a follow up question or just a response? I didn’t know if you wanted to respond to anything he said or Yeah.

Marc-André:

What do you think about producing the first free commodities from degraded land? You know, lands that have already been degraded and have are no fertility and what do you think about this kind of business model to create you know like local economy for the people locally? I mean.

Lars Løvold:

To a large extent that depends on when it was degraded when it was deforested. Eh of course eh there is a lot of waste in the Amazon a lot of degraded land. Eh so eh the needs to be used it can be used for several purposes. Some of that land is very apt for reforestation for regrowing forest for linking it to the standing forest eh other areas should be used for to intensify production so that the need to expand into the forest eh is diminished. Eh, I mention those three soy producing companies in Brazil eh that now can eh I mean even if a Chinese buyer say I want some cheap soy, he will get def station free soy.

Eh, but they have their cutof date in August 2020 so they will not sell anything from any area that has been deforested after August. Eh 2020. So that’s relatively recent. Now the soy moratorium in Brazil earlier from the rainforest areas had a much earlier cutof date. So it all depends on the circumstances but of course eh one of the craziness is that expansion eh for land grabbing reasons for land speculation reasons etc into the forest in order to obtain cheap land control it sort of cut it opp eh create a road and then sell it.

Dynamics need for.

Danielle Rappaport:

Matt is up next, and Marian.

Matt:

Hi, really nice to see you. Thank you for your presentation. I had a question regarding one of the areas that you showed in your presentation, the Javari territory, given the complexity of the region inders complex evering dynamics of all the threats all the particular stakeholders that inhabit that not only inhabit that area but also potentially threat that area.

Lars Løvold:

Two levels in my answer. Eh, we have been working in those regions for many years. Eh recently not in Javari directly eh we had to withdraw there from for financial reasons some time back but we have been working a lot on the perian side and we working a lot in akre and various other places and you I agree it’s a complex landscape there is a lot of illegal activities dangerous eh even on the good side it’s a complex organisation structure etc but I wanted to present and what I refer to are two studies that has been going on for a long time documented the existence of indigenous peoples without contact many different tribes eh spread over a long area continuous are and what I launched which is just about to be launched is the ambition to actually create national corridors for the permanent protection of these indigenous peopulable as you know for you know western diseases or the flu or whatever eh and the way to do that is to work with the surrounding communities so supporting the surrounding communities in their development aspirations combined with the protection of no expansion into the territories of the people who do not want contact.

These huge areas I say they are the size of United Kingdom. The forest is extremely biodiverse and almost without eh deforestation. So it’s in the world context it’s absolutely magnificent and unique area. So we hope eh in the så in the months and years to come to be able to raise that as a kind of joint effort to create those large territories in which the forest is protected and these people can continue what is there will to actually live as they have used to live and not have contact with us.

So it’s a fascinating area eh but extremely complex. So it needs large scale cooperation and substantial funding.

Danielle Rappaport:

Thanks Lars. Marian do you come off mute?

Marian:

Sure. Thank you. Thank you Lars for this great presentation and all your work over the last decades. I think you addressed part of my question in some of your previous answers but we see in the media and elsewhere this continuing narrative of conservation versus development. And we know thatally among close to 80% of Amazonian inhabitants that are urban many of them see little value in protected areas indigenous lands and standing forest and that those attitudes are directly translated into policy as we know both on the subnational and national level so my question for you is how do you think we can work to change that narrative and really bring div thanks.

Lars Løvold:

Very good question I don’t think we need to talk to we can talk about what we get from the forest so parts of agbusiness now knows that reduced rain is a threat to their productivity and reduced rain is consestation but I think we need to talk very little about conservation very much about the value of the forest and to invest in eh economic development in forest some of that development is sort of eh upscaling the traditional ways of you know marketing products that there has been so many meetings in this Amazon investor coalition meetings.

Eh, another aspect is actually what is needed is to provide eh a benefit, you know, a benefit structure for those who protect the forest so that it’s not the guy who cuts a tree who get money. It’s a guy who let the tree stand who get some form support. Doesn’t have to be money. It can be social development. It can be schools, it can be health. Can be many things but you must link benefits to forest protection increase the understanding of the value of the forest and we must be modern I have great sympathy for what you know Carlos Nobre and Antonio Nob talks about as Amazonia 4.0 zero investing in eh biotechnology, biomimicy, eh genetic resources finding ways of utilizing and making modern businesses that are sort of forward looking eh in using these resources sparingly.

You know, traditionally either cut down the forest to have the cattle going there or to have, you know, a soy plantation. Eh but the longterm benefit also economically if you really invest in that’s what is needed. So green development is a slogan but it needs to be filled with content and people need to see that it actually has some concrete results and that’s extremely important.

Danielle Rappaport:

Beautifully said. I think we have time for one more question before the top of the hour if are any. Otherwise we can migrate to what we call water cooler time. If Lars has a few moments for less structured discussion, any last questions?

Fiona Banister:

Yes, is it okay to speak? It’s Fiona. Hi, thank you all for everything in your devotion for such a long time. I would like to ask on behalf of several of our indigenous communities that are also based in Ecuador. Is there a possibility for any modeling from your existing programs so that we can actually support the work that is being done in Ecuador by some of our indigenous community leaders? As discussions and then the third part of layer was going back to the team in Colombia with the Amazon investor coalition is a way that we can also support all these alliances a good question what do you need Lars how do we help you thank.

Danielle Rappaport:

Fiona, do introduce the organization you are with.

Fiona Banister:

Oh, thank you. Yes. Hi, it’s Fiona Banister. I have the honor of standing on the land of the Squamish nations right here in Vancouver BC. And we have been working over 20 years in and around the communities from Indonesia through to Asia across to Latin America and then I was a political journalist and worked on land entitlement down in Africa. So I am here only as a seed of knowledge to continue the pollination. Our team is act now we are one of the team competing for the XP rainforest under decarbonized.org.

And we have mostly all women scientists and women leaders, indigenous, all forest owners that are in the game trying to see how do we emphasiz, build and curate the right contacts and also have their voices heard and protect the forest. Thank you.

Lars Løvold:

Briefly we are over time but eh we worked in more countries than we do now before. Eh so we have for instance worked in Ecuador, we have worked in Venezuela, eh we have worked in Malaysia and so on. Given eh the focus on saving the large contiguous rainforest, we took the hard decision of concentrating our efforts eh you know on these six major rainforest countries. Eh, we are open if opportunities exist and funding exist to may be expanding, but eh we are in terms of alliances, in terms of exchanging experience, in terms of exchanging knowledge, we are extremely open.

Eh, so that’s in a sense a different story from engaging on the ground in new countries which was always a very hard decision and we took some very it really hurt when we drew from several good projects in order to concentrate the impact on the major rainforest countries.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you Lar. Reports try to summar some exper will find for instance on experiences.

Lars Løvold:

Right space rinforce protection you will find experiences in creating indigenous education system bilingual bicultural etc so you will find a lot if you follow the report link on the website of rainforest foundation norway.

Danielle Rappaport:

Excellent wonderful that concludes official programming for today. If I don’t know if Lars has any time to hang around after if there is more interest in having dialog.

Lars Løvold:

It’s dark outside. I can still wait if people have something.

Danielle Rappaport:

Already looks like everybody’s neurons are still bouncing around and stimulated. So unless there’s more from folks, we will liberate you Laris. Thank you so much for sharing your rich experience.

Lars Løvold:

Thank you for having me. Eh I enjoyed speaking to you. So one day also figur out why this share screen thing doesn’t work on the first slides.

Danielle Rappaport:

Well, I think you did a fantastic presentation. So thank you all and thank you so much for all of all of the Amazon Investor Coalition allies for coming with your great questions and passion and devotion.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you Daniel. Good to meet with you. Pleasure. I’m close the room.

Unidentified participant:

Ok. Bye. For now bye everybody. Bye. Ja.