The Gordon & Betty Moore Foundation & the Amazon

What does the impact of 18 years of donor engagement look like? The Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation’s Andes-Amazon Initiative has invested in the Amazon since 2003. Launched with the overarching goal of preserving regional-scale ecosystem function, the foundation has maintained a steady focus on protected areas and Indigenous lands as critical tools for conservation. Along the way, the initiative has explored strategies for supporting civil society and government, establishing sustainable finance, addressing drivers of deforestation, and building the scientific basis for understanding and conserving the Amazon. Recently, the initiative increased focus on Indigenous territorial protection, resulting in innovative approaches around technology and legal tools. Marion Adeney will lead a discussion on what the foundation has learned and on pathways forward for large-scale ecosystem conservation in the Amazon.

Recorded December 6, 2021

References:

Perspective: Indigenous land stewardship holds solutions for the future of the Amazon

Moore Foundation: Andes Amazon Initiative

Philanthropies, governments pledge $1.7B to Indigenous climate efforts

Funder Spotlight: How the Moore Foundation Works to Conserve the Natural World

Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation 20th Annual Report

International Conservation Funding in the Amazon: An Updated Analysis (2017)

International Funding for Amazon Conservation and Sustainable Management: A Continued Analysis of Grant Funding Across the Basin (2021)

WATCH:

  • Jonah
  • Marion Adeney
  • Bobby
  • Steve
  • Michelle Zador
  • Jacqueline
  • Tatiana
  • Ryan
  • Alexandre
  • Danielle

Jonah:

Hello everybody. Welcome to the 66 or 67th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a call and podcast series dedicated to advancing force friendly economic development, the rule of law across the Amazon region of South America. We’re supported by Nexus and the Global Governance Philanthropy Network and a whole host of other partners. This week we are featuring the work of Marion Adeney and the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation. Marian, how are you?

Marion Adeney:

Great. I’m well and thank you Jonah for the invitation to speak and thank you all for coming to have this conversation with me today.

Jonah:

Thank you so much. So we’re going to talk about the Moore Foundation. But before we get into that because more Foundation is a lot, let’s talk a little bit about you. So Marian, where did you grow up? Where did your affection for natural ecosystems come from?

Marion Adeney:

So I grew up in Berkeley in the in the Bay Area. But I was actually born in Asia in Singapore and my first two years were spent in tropical ecosystems. I don’t know if that’s where I got my affinity for the tropics, but ever since I was a child, I loved the outdoors and nature. I wanted to be an ornithologist. Actually, I wanted to be a tropical raptor biologist. I don’t know. I got somehow sidetracked over the course of my career. But I studied conservation biology. And this is skipping around a bit.

But after a foray into social sciences in my 20s, I went back to what I really care about which is nature conservation. And I studied conservation biology at Colombia and did research in Indonesia and Sumatra on birds and fire in tropical forests and then went to Duke for a PhD in ecology really focused on the Brazilian Amazon and on patterns of fire and how those patterns vary with human activity and climate. And I also worked on white sand ecosystems which are a really unique and special ecosystem type found in the Amazon as well as in Indonesia and in Africa as well.

Jonah:

Nice. Tell us a little this may seem a little.

Marion Adeney:

Sorry Jonah I didn’t I didn’t have a good sequence set for that question.

Jonah:

No, you’re doing great. And I’m gonna about to ask a question which is a little bit of a nonsequator but something that is so important for the Amazon region. Can you tell us a little bit about your research on Amazon roads?

Marion Adeney:

Yes. So, I’ll just step back and say that when I was in Indonesia doing my master’s research on bird communities and the impacts of fire on bird communities, I really got to see firsthand the devastation that happened in Sumatran ecosystems over the previous 20 years. This was in the early 2000s. And I went to the Amazon in part because I knew that the Amazon was a still a large enough and relatively intact is not the word, but well preserved enough ecosystem that I thought we could really make an impact in preserving it and particularly preserving the largecale ecosystem function of the Amazon.

And so that’s kind of h where I came from when I came into the Amazon as a graduate student. And I did some of my research on the impacts of roads on deforestation and fire. I used fire as a proxy and I looked it looked at 10 years of fire patterns in the Brazilian Amazon and how they varied with roads and protected areas and climate. And what I found, I think it’s still relevant today, although this paper is now more than 10 years old, but I found that what we knew, you know, the vast majority of fires occur within 10 kilometers of roads or rivers.

That’s still the case when roads go through protected areas, but they’re much reduced in protected areas and the effect is stronger in areas where there’s more pressure. So in protected areas where there’s higher deforestation outside, there’s a there’s a lower relative number of fires even along roads than in protected areas where there’s less threat. And it’s interesting because over the last almost 20 years of my career, I think I’ve seen this lesson repeated over and over again that protected areas are critical pieces of protection against deforestation and fire, but that the impacts of these other pressures continue to impact them and they’re not enough alone.

And that’s been really reflected as well in my work at the Moore Foundation.

Jonah:

So let’s let’s get a little closer to the Moore Foundation now. I know you have a presentation prepared. I’ll ask a leadup question to it. Who is Gordon Moore? Who is Betty Moore?

Marion Adeney:

Gordon and Betty Moore. Gordon was a scientist who was one of the co-founders of Intel. He worked on the chip and he’s famously known for Moore’s law where he predicted that the space on a computer chip would double every I want to say it’s four years. And that he apparently he did not imagine that law would hold or would become Moore’s law. And it’s still holding true. Gordon and Betty are still alive. They live in Hawaii now. They are quite elderly at this point. But they are still interested in the work of the foundation.

For a long time. I think Gordon read every grant summary that we did inside the foundation and it’s only the last few years that he hasn’t been doing that anymore. And Gordon also has talked internally in the foundation about how he loved to fish and one of the reasons for the foundation’s focus on preserving largecale intact ecosystems comes from Gordon’s love of fishing when he was young.

Jonah:

Nice. Okay, let’s get into it. The presentation now and maybe with a bit of a focus on the Andes Amazon initiative within the foundation.

Marion Adeney:

Okay, so I’m going to share my presentation. Let’s see. I’ll just keep it here. The presentation is going to run for about 15 minutes and then I’ll have a couple questions after it. But I would encourage everyone in the room to feel free to chat your name, where you’re from, your LinkedIn, your email address, all that stuff. And then to also indicate your interest in asking a question around 30 minutes after the before the top of the hour, we’ll move into questions. Okay, we see it. So, are you seeing the.

Jonah:

Yeah.

Marion Adeney:

Are you seeing the slides or the notes?

Jonah:

The slides.

Marion Adeney:

Okay, great. So, you’re not seeing the notes page.

Jonah:

We It says no notes in the lower right hand corner.

Marion Adeney:

Oh, so you are seeing the notes page. Okay. Okay. Okay. Now, are you seeing the full screen?

Jonah:

Yes.

Marion Adeney:

Okay, great. And I will, John, I’ll try to go through this quickly. I know this is a little bit of a hybrid between a presentation and a conversation. So, I’ll try not to spend too much time. And then we can always go back and dig into the topics that people find the most the most interesting or people’s questions.

Jonah:

Great.

Marion Adeney:

So, when you said that you were going to ask a little bit about my research, I So, I stuck in a slide. Okay. Here just of a couple of the things that I worked on that I just talked about and I put that picture in just to highlight as I was saying the congruence between the work that I’ve done in the Moore Foundation and the work that I did as a grad student. That picture was taken a couple years ago when I went on a trip down the BR319 with the Moore Foundation.

And that little hut was a place that I spent the night on one of my first field expeditions in the Amazon. And at the time we had an very harrying motorcycle/foot ride to get to it. Now you can get to it by a road and there are buses that go by it and that’s in one of the white sand companas where I work. So that’s just to say how much things have changed and also how much things have stayed the same in the last 20 years. I should also mention that I’ve been at the Morris Foundation with the Andes Amazon Initiative for five years now.

And before that I was five years within US A as a tripleas science and technology policy fellow, two years in DC and three years in Peru working on the Amazon regional program as well as the Peru and Brazil bilateral programs. I just talked a little bit about Gordon and Betty Moore. I’ll say I have a couple more things to say about the foundation and you know I’m happy to answer other questions offline about the foundation but the foundation is focused on mainly environmental science and conservation with some a couple of other smaller programs in nursing and preserving the character of the Bay Area.

And we’re very much an outcomesbased foundation, one of the largest foundations that focuses on the Amazon and one of the largest foundations in the US. And the founders wrote this document called the founders intent that was meant to kind of give us a road map for how to how they would like the foundation to work now and in the future. And so we measure all of our grant making against these four filters. And you can find this on the more foundation website. But you know we ask when we’re going to work on a problem is it important can we make an enduring difference and this is actually really the critical one in the end because we don’t work on projects that are too big for the foundation’s intervention to really move the needle on something.

So that’s something that we you know most of the pro problems are important but whether we can make a difference is very important whether it’s measurable and whether it contributes to a portfolio effect. I’ll skip this. This is the four areas that the foundation works that I just mentioned. And in the environmental conservation program we have a real focus on strongholds for nature. So preserving large relatively intact ecosystems and their function. And I put this map, one of my favorite maps from my colleague Clinton Jenkins. This is a map of mammal biodiversity in South America.

I’m sure you all know the importance of the Amazon for biodiversity. But the point here is that we need to look at these big areas in order to keep them functioning at a large scale. And this is also, as I mentioned, one of the main reasons why I went into conservation in the Amazon in the first place. Also because I love the Amazon. So, and in the environmental conservation program, we have the Andes Amazon initiative which has been around since 2001. The foundation was founded in 2000. The first grants were made in 2001.

The initiative started in 2003 formally. And then we also have an initiative on conservation and markets that works on decoupling both deforestation in South American ecosystems and seafood from environmental degradation. And we have a marine conservation program that does a lot of work in the Arctic and on marine ecosystems. But you find that focus on large intact ecosystem throughout. The Andes Amazon initiative has a core strategy that has remained very steadfast and steady over the years which is on protecting large areas and reducing the surrounding threats. And I’ll talk a little more about that when we get into the infrastructure work.

That’s really the reason why the foundation has been had this focus on largecale infrastructure over the last few years, the last five years actually. And this is a BR319 from now road. So I don’t want to spend too long on this, but this is kind of our overall theory of change. The outcome that we set hold ourselves responsible for is a core set of protected areas and their surroundings managed effectively and then the infrastructure piece and I’ll talk a little bit more about how we how we manage that protected area strategy across scales from individual areas mosaics and systems drivers I can talk more about it in the discussion if you like Jonah but I haven’t included much in my presentation since it’s a little bit outside of well it’s not my portfolio but I can certainly talk about it but we focused on roads and dams and reducing the impact of roads and dams through knowledge management understanding better infrastructure finance and improving governance and that strategy really was a bit of a test case.

The board approved that strategy in 2016 and we’ve been working to see if it would yield the type of results that could potentially allow it to be expanded. So as I mentioned and as some of you I’m sure know well the foundation’s focus over all these years has been on creation of protected areas and demarcation of indigenous lands. And there was a particular window in the early 2000s that you can see from this little animation from Woods Hole, now Woodwell, in the early 2000s when the initiative focused a lot on really the creation and protection of these areas.

And the last 10 years, a little less than 10 years, has been more focused on their management. Although we still work on creating new protected areas when that’s possible. And this is the status of protected areas and indigenous lands in 2020. I’m sure most of you have seen this map from rise. And it shows that about 47% of the Amazon is on under current protection. One of the important fundamental assumptions of the Andes Amazon initiative from the beginning was that it is important to preserve enough forest cover to prevent a tipping point.

And then the actual exact number of forests needed standing to prevent that tipping point is still a matter of some debate. But the foundation settled on the number of 70% of original forests needed to remain standing. So the goal of the foundation has been of the Andy’s Amazon initiative has been to facilitate that through the create creation and demarcation of protected areas and indigenous lands but also thinking about the areas outside and that’s where the mosaics come in and really thinking about these protected areas in a more holistic way within the landscape.

This is a map of the current working area of the Andes Amazon Initiative from 2016 to 2021. And you can see the protected areas in light green, indigenous lands in that kind of darker green and then the sage type in the background is the mosaics that we’ve chosen. These are arbitrary areas. They’re made up of the municipalities within which the protected areas are set that the foundation decided to use for a focus on more integrated management across the landscapes and working with regional governments. And then the blue areas are the areas that outlines where we focus on infrastructure corridors again particularly roads and dams.

So within the protected area strategy, we have this type of work across scales and at the individual level of the protected areas, we focus on what the initiative calls consolidation, which is basically a way of saying that these areas are resilient to threats and future pressures that could that could impact them. And so at the level of the individual protected areas, those 142 that you saw in the last slide, and I’ll use protected areas to include indigenous lands as well, we focused on these six indicators which are u management, some kind of governance structure, a plan for use, sustainable use of resources if that’s relevant, monitoring and potentially enforcement, integration with regional development, and sustainable finance.

At the mosaic level, we work sometimes with regional governments, sometimes through official mosaics, sometimes through sort of integrated landscape management to try to actually set these areas within a larger system. And then we also have a system level strategy that focuses on sustainable finance, particularly through project finance for permanence projects. And Jonah, I can talk more about that if you want, but I’ll be quick now. In Brazil the example is ARPA and then also we have Patrimonio del Peru in Peru and Edencia Colombia which is under construction in Colombia. And I think I should mention if I didn’t already that the foundation works in Peru, Brazil, Ecuador, Colombia and Bolivia.

Then we’ve also had some more some other types of donor collaboration in an attempt to make up some of the gaps in sustainable finance. So one of those in Brazil we have the Lita project which is a collaboration with the Amazon Fund of Benesi Brazilian Development Bank and then we also had a collaboration in the Andes with the Andes Amazon Fund and the Whis Foundation that does similar these types of donor collaborations that can fund the management of areas that aren’t necessarily covered in the big project finance for permanence. And then we also have under this strategy largescale monitoring such as rise such as some of the work of Woodwell climate research center and also helping to integrate good monitoring systems within the government agencies of the countries that we work in among others.

There’s a lot so I’m just mentioning a few things. One of the things that the Moore Foundation has done that I think is really quite unique among large donors is tracking our progress and figuring out a way to measure progress over time. And so those six indicators that I mentioned in the last slide that we used to track the progress of indi individual areas, the foundation has tracked those since 2013. And this was partially in response to an external evaluation that was asking us to better measure our impact on protected areas.

And so we have targets for this year. Those the targets are a little bit extended because so many things have been delayed because of the co 19 pandemic that many of our projects that were due to end this year will actually continue for another year or two. But we’ve really been looking at within each of those 142 protected areas, every year, the program officers sit down with the grantees that work in those areas and also with other types of sources of information, protected area managers or others to evaluate these six indicators for each one of those areas.

And we’ve been tracking that since 2021. And I should stress that these indicators, this is not an official measurement. This is really an internal measurement for use by the foundation, but it’s a collaborative qualitative assessment of the state of each one of those protected areas in terms of their consolidation over time. And that’s something that I think not too many donors have implemented. It’s quite tricky because sometimes the state of those six indicators doesn’t necessarily reflect the state of the threat of the area. And so that’s something that we’ve struggled with.

And can think about for improving in the future. One of the gaps that’s been recognized in previous external evaluations and also internally within the foundation is indigenous lands. There aren’t really very good models for sustainable finance of indigenous lands and other efforts as well such as governance etc. We felt like we really needed more focus on that. So over the last couple of years, we’ve developed and I led the development and implementation of an indigenous substrate that I could talk more about. But the it’s had a lot of focus on improving the capacity of indigenous organizations to be their own to be protagonists for their territorial integrity.

We’ve done more work than the foundation had done in the past directly with indigenous organizations. Generally as subgrantees but directly through small grants through working with Koyabi and others. We’ve had a focus on integrated systems of top down bottom up monitoring where we integrate we work directly with indigenous organizations to integrate their boots on the ground patrols with satellite and other spatial analysis type monitoring and then link that with legal actions. And also we’ve had a lot of focus on legal tools such as working with an indigenous lawyers network in Brazil particularly and also working with indigenous lawyers to bring to come to international fora such as the UN, the COP and other bodies.

So and I want to finish because I told John I’d keep this to 15 minutes. It’s been about 15 minutes, but there’s three kind of pillars I think that as we look back over the 20 years of the foundation that really rise to the four. One is the work of enabling the policy environment and working with government. Another and very important I would say is strong civil society and the foundation has worked for many years to really build that civil society within the Amazon. Focusing on supporting and sustaining local grantees and then also sustainable funding sources which I talked about and these three pillars complement each other but also can we’ve seen particularly in the last years that have been rather difficult politically we’ve seen for example civil society really stepping up and so they can compensate one another a little bit there’s some flex there but as we know, we need them all really to be effective at conservation.

And then another piece that I think Jonah may ask about that I haven’t talked too much about is building the evidence base for conservation, which is something the foundation has focused on for many years. I’m going to skip over these threats are changing. We’re seeing we’re seeing the mining. We’re seeing huge forces between international markets and illegal entities and corruption that are impacting and our conservation in ways we hadn’t before. We’re seeing climate change. This shows fire in the Amazon during that week of fire that happened in 2019. And the black circles are protected areas and indigenous lands.

And you can really see how they’re they’re still holding on and really showing their effectiveness. You can see that also here in this map. But they’re not enough. And so the foundation and among others are thinking about how do we work beyond and around protected areas to bolster them from the threats that keep increasing from the outside. And this last slide has some new approaches. I’ve talked a little bit about them. So I won’t belabor that here, but I’m happy to answer questions and join the discussion. Thank you.

Jonah:

Great. Thanks so much, Marian. And if you could pull up the slide so we can see you again, that’d be great. So two questions for me and then everyone else. So one, permanent project finance for permanence. This is such a large area for conservation philanthropy, but also the general public doesn’t know what it is. True. Could you describe it to us?

Marion Adeney:

Sure. The project finance for permanence are basically syncing funds whereby a set of donors get together and work directly with governments to create a fund where there’s a initial input of resources from the donors that are used to fund the management of a set of protected areas. And then over time as those funds are spent down the government increases their commitment to provide funding. And so this basically creates a financial mechanism by which protected areas have a sustained and steady source of income over a per a long period of years.

And this financial mechanism was pioneered in I believe Costa Rica actually some years ago and there’s been there have been several that have been implemented over time and they’re kind of catching on. There’s a lot of new funding coming into the creation of these types of systems. I think one important they have a lot of there’s a lot of details about them but one important detail I think to mention is that they have a single signing condition so all the donors can bring their funds together and activate it at the same time which reduces risk.

There was something else I was going to say about them that I’m that’s I that just flew out of my head. So, I’m happy to answer questions. I think the examples that you might be familiar with are ARPA for Life in Brazil. That has actually withstood some political winds and is still functioning well. And I remember what I was going to say. The way that these programs work is that they go through the government and so there it’s important to have the right conditions in place for the funds to be accessed.

So, for example, in Brazil, which is the one that I’m the most familiar with, you have protected area managers access those funds through their yearly budgets and then are able to draw those funds. But for example, if you don’t have a manager in a park or you don’t have a good manager, those funds may not be accessed. So, it’s not a perfect mechanism but it’s certainly a robust one and one that we continue to learn from each one that’s implemented. We’ve seen them stand the test of time and political shifts.

And so it’s a really promising mechanism for actually establishing long-term stable funding for protected areas. We don’t have something similar in the case of indigenous lands which are of course much more complex.

Jonah:

We’ll let the audience get deeper into it. I posted a couple of articles about project finance and project finance for permits that’ll be helpful for those who want to go in deeper. So last question for me Marian. So, the Moore Foundation recently had a board meeting and you guys were going to make decisions about 2022 and so I’m wondering if you have any news to share with us about future Amazon focus or the more foundation next year and beyond.

Marion Adeney:

That is everybody’s question. So, just to fill those of you in who may or may not know, the foundation is reaching the end of the Andes Amazon initiative as it currently stands at the end of this year. The end of this month I guess. And we have undergone an external evaluation with recommendations that was presented to the board last month. The current status is that there is some investigation and development going on to think about a potential new initiative for the MOR Foundation that would probably have themes around freshwater and indigenous land stewardship.

But it’s still quite uncertain whether such a proposal would be approved, although we are certainly hopeful that it would be. So, we’re in a bit of a period of transition. Many of the projects, as I mentioned, are actually continuing for the next year or even in some cases two years. But the and we’re hopeful that the foundation will continue in the Amazon, but it’s not certain yet.

Jonah:

Thank you so much, Marian. Okay. Call participants, feel free to indicate your interest in the chat or raise your hand using that feature. First up is Bobby Kia. Bobby, please introduce yourself as well when you’re asking your question.

Bobby:

Sure. Hey guys. Thank you Jonah. Let me come on video. Styling in from Art Basel, Miami. And, I’m from LA and co-founder of the Peace Department and the new global solution deployment initiative we’re working on. And, my question was regarding the permanence model. Sounds brilliant, very good to coordinate up front. And I noticed you mentioned donor capital. I was curious if there was also room regulatory as it were in that same structure for investment capital, impact investment capital.

Marion Adeney:

That’s an interesting question. I have not heard of anything like that. I guess there would have to be that would have to be kind of worked in to the agreement and each one of these is slightly different. And as I said, I think that we’ve been learning from them and making them more robust as we go along. But I have not heard of a way that impact investing can contribute to this. So that’s something to think about. If you have any ideas I’d love to hear them.

Jonah:

One thing that comes to mind is if part of project finance for permanence is the release of funds as a trickle over time then it’s the question of how those funds are invested. You know is it the traditional capital markets or something else that’s relevant for impact investors. Okay another question. Feel free to just come off mic. Don’t make me start calling on people.

Steve:

Can I’ll go ahead and ask a question. I’m Steve Baki, the director of conservation strategy at Rainforest Trust u based in Northern Virginia. So I just had a question around, you know, when you’re looking at, you know, all the progress that’s been made in titling indigenous lands and you know, obviously the struggle right now is real. But I’m curious what you see as a way forward in the hopefully near future for increasing you know, titling of indigenous lands and what are the major hurdles that you see in scaling that up?

Marion Adeney:

Well, you know, I can speak most for Brazil because that’s where I work the most directly. I think the situation for land titling for titling indigenous lands in Brazil is quite difficult right now. Because we have a national government who that doesn’t that’s not committed to doing that. However, it is their constitutional obligation and the federal prosecutor’s office is the entity that works to hold the other government offices accountable. So, one thing that we’ve seen actually have quite a lot of success in the last few years has been the impact of indigenous organizations themselves.

Working with the federal prosecutors, working with the Brazilian Supreme Court and working with the international bodies such as the UN Human Rights Commission and others to pressure the Brazilian government to fulfill their constitutional responsibilities in terms of protecting indigenous people and that could also go for titling lands. One thing also that we’ve seen is that some indigenous lands may be you know the process in Brazil is very long. I believe there’s seven steps and there’s a whole series of things that need to happen in order for the an indigenous land to be titled including various different types of studies and the physical demarcation of the lands etc.

And so one strategy could be to support indigenous organizations and their partners to actually complete those steps to move the indigenous land closer in terms of all the things that it needs to have in place in order to be demarcated. So that’s one approach. And I you know if other I see a lot of folks on this call from Brazil and I know that there’s many people on this call that have a lot of expertise in this area too. So I welcome other comments. But I think I think just to finish that we’ve also in our sub strategy on indigenous land supported and an indigenous lawyers network that’s been working to bring indigenous lawyers who are already trained as lawyers into this into a space and network to really be able to use their legal skills to protect their territories.

And we’ve seen a lot of excitement around that and positive impacts from that. So that’s another approach that we’ve that I think is really important and really powerful. Indigenous organizations and indigenous leaders in Brazil in particular, but across the Amazon have been taking asserting their legitimacy and their capacity in these areas with really great results. And so I think that’s a that’s another important strategy to continue to support. I don’t know I saw the chat Jonah. I don’t know if there’s a formal name of this network u but they’re certainly closely they’re closely coordinated with coy.

Unidentified participant:

Great. Michelle,.

Marion Adeney:

It’s more like an internal network for them to work together and receive the training that they need that they didn’t actually receive in law school around environmental and indigenous law.

Jonah:

Okay, Michelle Zador.

Michelle Zador:

Hi, thanks so much for that informative presentation. I’ve certainly heard about more foundation being in a state of transition. It’s not the first time we all go through transitions. Nature of sort of being donors, I suspect. I was wondering if you could describe a little bit more. Are there any actual transition plans for your existing grantees and partners in place? The reason I’m asking is because I know several of your geographies actually overlap with CPF’s geographies and I’ve certainly heard that yeah more is not going to be funding us for a while and so I’m just trying to really understand like our approach to working in several of those geographies given that you’re in a transition plan.

So you know for example have there been has there been support for sustainability just trying to understand how you’re going through that transition in terms of supporting your local partners and the sites.

Marion Adeney:

Sure. Sure. And that’s definitely a question a legitimate question. So there you as some of you know the Moore Foundation has kind of gone through this before. The initiative was set to close in 2013 or 2016 I guess. And then in response to an external evaluation, the board approved another five years. So there were quite a few exit grants and institutional capacity grants given at that time. And we’ve done less of that this time around, especially given the five-year sort of we’ve been repeating this. It’s almost become a mantra. We’re closing in 2021.

But I will say some of the donor collaborations have been an attempt to create a little bit more stability over the slightly longer term for our grantees. And in the case of Brazil I would mention Lita which is a collaboration we entered into with the Amazon Fund. It’s managed by EPE, the Institute of GPSas. And in through LEA, we have projects in all of the six mosaics of protected areas that you saw in the map within Brazil. And the Amazon Fund put in a some resources. The Moore Foundation put in some resources and that program grows through 2023.

And one thing I would say about that program is that it has a really wonderful structure and team in place and is really creating a network of these grantees through all of the mosaics of the Amazon fund of the foundation in the Amazon. So that is one of the ways that we’ve approached that in the Andes. We worked with the Andy’s Amazon fund in a similar type of arrangement, but the one in Brazil is unique because of the way that EPE, which is also a civil society organization, is managing it and creating this network.

And so that’s actually a collaboration that I would like to see continue in some way because there’s a whole structure set up to work with all of these different organizations and most, not all, but most of the more foundation grantees in Brazil are part of it in some way.

Jonah:

Great. Jacqueline, you’re up next. You’re on mute. There you go.

Jacqueline:

Sorry, issues with Zoom. Hi Jonah. Hi Marian. How’s it going? Thank you very much for your presentation. I’m my name is Jacqueline. I’m actually based in New York City at the moment. I am a senior associate here at Capital for Climate. I think my question really is twofolds. One is and it kind of goes back to this project f finance for permanence. One you actually talked a little bit about like governmental commitments increasing. I would just like to know in terms of what has actually worked in the past how are the governments getting funded how is this fund continuing to grow over time as donor capital decreases and the second question really follows on from Bobb’s is that from your point of view what is the role of private capital in scaling up these protected areas how does how does private capital or private investments actually does it actually have a role in scaling up protecting these areas.

Marion Adeney:

Okay. So I would say in terms of your first question about the PFPs, the way that’s arranged, of course it’s different with each one because it’s an agreement with the government, but it’s a it’s a commitment that the government makes at the outset for certain amounts to continue to raise those funds over time. And there’s various different ways that the government’s can raise those funds. In some cases, it’s allocation. In some cases, they have other types of plans such as for tourism or for sustainable enterprises, etc. That can go into those.

So it varies with each one, but figuring out how that commitment is going to be reached and especially building it in such a way that it has staying power over changes of administrations is a really critical piece of that. In terms of private investor funds, again, I think there’s quite a few different ways that can be approached. One of the things that the LEA project has looked at is actually potential for sustainable forestbased enterprises in the different protected areas, particularly the sustainable use protected areas and indigenous lands that can that could be developed in those areas.

And we’ve seen some really powerful work particularly in the Shingu region in Brazil of work with companies to actually collaborate with communities to grow some of those enterprises and then establish commitments to buy products over time so that there’s a stable source of income for those communities. So I think it’s important to I think it’s important to think beyond just the role of grant making and think about how as you as you pointed out private investors and private companies can directly collaborate with communities and governments to support these areas. One thing that we’ve also seen in Brazil particularly is that there’s often funds for projects, but there’s not a lot of capital available for people to scale sustainable businesses that are based on forest economies.

So, many of the traditional banks and lending agencies that lend funds for development tend to favor agriculture, cattle, more traditional forms of development. As opposed to forest-based enterprises, community enterprises or other things that are that are based on different types of models. So thinking about how we can scale those and actually give communities and small sustainable type enterprises capital to grow and scale is I think another important piece. But I should say that it really requires a close relationship with communities or andor local organizations that are partnering with those communities to ensure that this is done in a way that benefits both the environment and the people.

I would say that none of this is simple in the Amazon and I just want to make sure that I that I mention that. I don’t want to be glossing over some of the challenges that are out there. Does that answer your question?

Jacqueline:

Yes, it does. Thank you very much.

Jonah:

I have a question if no one else does. So there are some multi-billion dollar companies that do source from standing forests. Fmanish from sources fragrances and Nata sources oils for cosmetics. And more and more are going to be sourcing carbon credits. I’m wondering if any of the if there have been convers if you are aware of any of the large multinational conversations sorry multinational corporations getting involved in project for fin project finance for permanence agreements.

Marion Adeney:

I am actually not that doesn’t mean that’s not the case but I am not aware of that. So if anyone else knows the answer to that question feel free to chime in.

Jonah:

Tatiana, would you mind coming on and sharing your piece?

Tatiana:

Yeah, I’m sorry that I’m on the street. I’m walking around and I wanted to participate in the call. It’s very nice to see projects for permanent scaling up as it did. I worked on the Costa Rica project several years ago and then I worked also in the ARPA project while I was at the Lynden Trust for Conservation in New York City. And I’m quite familiar with how it works. And I think that the next step would be, you know, to work with businesses, enterprises that are surrounding these protected areas that have linkages to the protected areas or to indigenous lands and straighten those business models that at the end of the day, you know, make the protected areas themselves more resilient over time.

I would love to talk a little bit more about that with the more foundation. And I have already spoken with them a little bit and I think it’s really the way to go you know because it is the next level it’s the next layer you know into protecting these areas engaging with the private sector engaging with financial institutions and funds that are interested in you know providing upfront finance long-term upfront finance to these businesses including offtakers that as you mentioned Jonah are sourcing forest based products in the regions has you know a pretty strong strategy to actually increase their sourcing of these products straighten the communities that are near protected areas and so forth.

So it would be great to actually talk more about that with the Moore Foundation and with others here in the call.

Jonah:

There are several other permanent protection area grant makers represented on the call actually sever you know a fair number of them. I’m wondering those of you who are here a and those in the private sector would you guys be interested in joining a brand new working group to sort of bridge this gap project finance for permanent for permanence it’s hard PFP which is sort of led by the philanthropic community alongside some of the large multinational corporations that are trying to improve the voluntary carbon markets or just bring more cosmetic industries ries into the Amazon.

Feel free to come off mic any of those who would like to voice their interest in such a working group idea just to explore what’s possible.

Unidentified participant:

I think I would I speak for Capital for Climate. I think we would be very interested in exploring those options. Yes.

Jonah:

Anyone else?

Tatiana:

Well, I for sure Tatiana.

Unidentified participant:

Okay, great.

Jonah:

I’m thinking of the Whis Foundation and Rainforest Trust. You guys do this already?

Unidentified participant:

I can speaking for Rainforest Trust. So we fund essentially protected area creation or expansion which includes indigenous land titling and other types of protection. I sort of put quotes around that. But what we don’t generally do is ongoing grants that are just about management. So that may change in the future, who knows? But at least currently no.

Jonah:

Maggie, do you want to talk about your work in this area and the appetite you guys might have for integrating with corporate strategies for PFPs? I was calling on Maggie McDow from the Andy’s Amazon. Maybe you’re not there. Okay.

Tatiana:

I think it’s also about increasing sort of straightening the enabling conditions of these businesses surrounding the protected areas themselves. Linkages with communities. Well, there’s a lot to talk about actually and I’m really not in the best place to lay out more of my ideas here.

Jonah:

Okay. Ryan, I saw you come off mic. Did you want to add?

Ryan:

Yeah, I would just I would say that there’s a strong partnership that’s emerged called the Enduring Earth Partnership that several large NOS’s are working together to try to accelerate PFP establishment around the world. That includes the Pew Charitable Trust, WWF Nature Conservancy, Zoma Lab and others. I’m sure that one of their staff would be delighted to present to this group and talk a little bit about how they’re approaching the problem and trying to replicate this strategy across the globe. I would say that group has reached out to a lot of donors and I’m sure many of you about potential engagement either in general or in specific geographies that they have identified as potential opportunities.

We certainly have been a part of conversations around several geographies. Like Steve mentioned, you know, the Whis Foundation has traditionally focused our philanthropy on protected area establishment. But we have seen these PFPs be a tool through which protected area establishment can occur as a as one of the commitments that governments make as a you know and can be enforced through the closing conditions and u agreements in a PFP. So we’re certainly intrigued. We have a lot to learn still. But I think this could be an a strategy that we would take a look at in some parts of the world where sustainable finance has really been you know one of the shortcomings in terms of securing government commitments to establish new largescale protections.

So that’s sort of the filter that we’re looking at it through. But you know but I think there are other obviously have different priorities and so I think the idea of bringing all of those together in a structured way is obviously what makes that tool attractive where it’s the right fit and that won’t be the case everywhere.

Jonah:

Great. We’ll explore Magros. Feel free to share. You made a post. You’re I think you’re on mute. Sandia from Institute.

Unidentified participant:

I think at the end it says she has to run. I don’t know if she left the call.

Jonah:

Okay, maybe she.

Marion Adeney:

But I just wanted to add thank you Ryan for bringing that up. And I was actually looking for a link for that and it looks like Jonah’s put something in the chat. That’s another partnership that’s just come online. And I think one of the things that they’re thinking about, as far as I understand, is figuring out how to create a structure such that, the donor group doesn’t have to be recreated every time. But the you know the conditions can be put in place and then as the funding comes online for a given PFP it can be launched and the more foundation is also part of this although not directly through the Andes Amazon initiative.

And so this is a really important step towards scaling this model because the amount of time and effort and coordination it takes to actually put one of these things together can it can take years. It can be really a long time and a lot of efforts. So, this is an exciting initiative in terms of thinking about scaling it. I want to also just say I know we’re out of time about Jonah, but in terms of indigenous lands, this is a an issue that has continued to be it’s continued to be difficult in terms of thinking about what types of funding mechanisms can be put in place to support indigenous lands.

And we have seen some of the bigger indigenous organizations start their own fund. So for example Fini from the upper Rioenegro area in Brazil has launched a fund with support from Norway I think in putting it together and are looking for funds to go into that fund also to support sustainable management of theirs their areas. Coyabi also has one the Podali fund. So these are very new and still being developed and so we haven’t had a lot of opportunity to see how they work yet, but I think this is also a really promising and important development that I would be remiss to not mention.

Jonah:

Alleandry, go ahead.

Alexandre:

Hi, thank you. Nice to see you, Janna, and thanks for the opportunity. I just want to say hi to Marion because we went back to a few years ago at USA Brazil here. So, just want to say hi to her. Thank you for sharing all this very good information. And I’m available also to pursue, you know, a more deep conversation in terms when it’s involving, you know, the private sector and how can we together brainstorm a little bit on some models that could make it work. Thank you.

Jonah:

Great. Thank you so much. So this brings us to the top of the hour. We call this water cooler time where formal class is dismissed but the chat room and we’ll stay open. I’ll stay on for a few minutes. Marian, can you stay around for a few minutes in case in case people have questions or.

Marion Adeney:

Certainly I can. Yeah.

Jonah:

Okay. Great. So.

Unidentified participant:

Hi Alandre.

Jonah:

So the it’s open mic time everybody feel free. Shameless promote, self-promotion, whatever it is. The most significant things coming out of these meetings are the connections made. So, please use the chat to let people know how who you are, where you are, how to find you. And thanks again, Marian. Great call.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you for the opportunity, Janna.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you.

Jonah:

Thanks so much for joining us. Anyone have a question for Marion?

Danielle:

Hey Marian.

Marion Adeney:

Hi Danielle.

Danielle:

How are you doing today?

Marion Adeney:

Good. How are you?

Danielle:

Doing well, thanks. Loved your presentation. It’s really great to hear more about Moore’s incredible legacy in the space and future plans. I have a question about project finance for permanence. I’m totally new to the concept. Is there so in this structure where donors first provide the upfront funds to establish permanent protection areas and then governments have some kind of commitment to fund th those areas in POS for posterity. Are there are there legal clauses that prevent future downgrading and degas what how do you pronounce the word? Resentments for in the future like for in perpetuity or how does that what are the legal requirements for on the government side for maintaining these for.

Marion Adeney:

That’s a great question and that is something that I believe differs and I’m apologize I can’t speak in detail to for example Patrimon Peru and Edencia of Colombia that’s under development but in the in the Brazilian one in ARPA there is language that prevents the government from downgrading or degasetting the areas and that actually has been an issue particularly with Hondonia. So I think figuring out how to include language that really holds the government both to their commitment and also accountable over time for supporting the protected areas is one of the difficult pieces that has to be negotiated each time.

And there are people who have a lot more experience with that aspect than I do. I wasn’t actually around for the construction of any of these funds. But that’s something that we’re learning from previous efforts and trying to build that, you know, figuring out how to build that permanence in to new ones. But ARPA has stood up well. So awesome. Thank you.

Jonah:

Tatiana, could you share your email? I think I already have it, but I’d love to follow on some of the things you said. Yes, I can share the email. In terms of the question that was just made my experience when I was in the Costa Rica forever deal is that it was really a give and take.

Unidentified participant:

Situation in which you know the government has a lot of leverage at the end of the day. And what we try to do is you know work along the lines of having the fund condition its dispersements to the government maintaining you know a certain level of resources on an annual basis to the protected areas. But of course, you could you could demand a law where the government approves with its congress to actually keep a certain percentage of its budget to protected area management. You can have a decree. You can have, you know, simply anou, but it really depends and it depends on the amount of money that at the end of the day you put aside in this fund.

So that you know, the larger the amount, the more leverage you have. But it’s well it’s a political negotiation as well, right? It’s not only, you know, the Minister of Environment or, you know, the Secretary of Biodiversity. It’s, you know, it’s there’s a lot at stake. But at the same time it’s really rewarding you know to see all of the people around the table trying to come up with something that it’s feasible on all side that at the end of the day really you know maintains a certain level of resources into the protected areas.

Jonah:

Sorry I was just letting Megan back into the room. Let me write here my email.

Jonah:

Hey Megan, welcome back.

Unidentified participant:

Hi, Megan.

Jonah:

Maybe she can’t hear us. Okay. Anything? Anything else you guys want to cover? Oh,.

Marion Adeney:

Thank you for the opportunity, Jonah, and I hope that people found that useful. There’s a lot to cover and I think that the private the questions about private investment are I mean obviously very relevant to this group and something that the Moore Foundation hasn’t really explored a lot. Something that I’m certainly also really learning about. So it’s interesting to hear.

Jonah:

Yeah, I think there’s a giant opportunity there.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah.

Jonah:

Okay. Will you help with her for a second? Megan, you’re did you if you just ask if you can speak? Yes, absolutely. We’re helping. We’re excited to have here. I think she’s going on and off mute because she has a lot else going on in the background. I do I think that the project finance for permanence as it intersects with the private sector is a giant frontier that is everybody’s going to care about. So we’ll we’ll pursue it.

Unidentified participant:

Yes.

Jonah:

Great. Okay. Any anyone else any questions? Any discussion items? Okay. There will be a lot of followup. Marian, I’m sure that people will ask me for your email. I’ll just forward those messages on to you. It was a pretty good turnout. We got up to 30 people on the call. Some real significant players. I’m excited.

Marion Adeney:

Great. Thank you so much, Jonah.

Jonah:

You bet. Thanks so much for joining us.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you, Maria. I write to you.

Marion Adeney:

Okay. Great to see you.

Unidentified participant:

Bye. Bye.

Unidentified participant:

Bye.

Unidentified participant:

Bye, Jonah. Thanks.

Jonah:

You bet. Thanks so much.