Forest Trends – Forest Communities and Territorial Governance
Forest Trends (FT) has twenty years of experience partnering with indigenous communities, governments, businesses, and civil society, collaborating to conserve forests and biodiversity in the Amazon and other regions in the world. Forest Trends’ Communities and Territorial Governance Initiative (FT-CGTI) works directly with indigenous and other traditional communities to secure their rights, conserve their forests, and improve their livelihoods, through pioneering new approaches. For example, FT-CGTI has launched programs such as the Cultural Mediators Program, which integrates topics like climate change and traditional indigenous knowledge in the curricula of schools attended by indigenous children and youth. The Capacity-Building Program on Indigenous Territorial Governance is a one-year long program designed to strengthen the integrated governance of indigenous territories. Forest Trends also develops initiatives with local communities to support their economic resilience by bringing their forest products to the marketplace. We also promote and monitor the flow of climate finance directly to indigenous territories: we co-developed the world’s first indigenous REDD+ project with the Surui people, and helped design the benefit-sharing mechanism for the Acre-SISA jurisdictional program. Both the Surui Project and SISA offer very important lessons to guide future place-based carbon projects as well as jurisdictional programs, among which is the need for FPIC to be a continuous process. Forest Trends continues to advocate for direct funding to indigenous peoples and other traditional communities (e.g., The Economics of Climate Change Mitigation in Indigenous Territories). Join us to meet Beto Borges and learn.
Recorded October 11, 2021
WATCH:
Participants
- Jonah
- Beto Borges
- Tom
- Bobby
- Sid Embry
- Lars
- Mark
Transcript
Jonah:
Hello everybody. Welcome to the 59th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing forcefriendly economic development, the rule of law across the Amazon region of South America. This week we’re meeting Beto Borges and Forest Trends. Forest Trends is a pioneer to put it mildly in this place of advancing force friendly economic development globally and Beto’s one of the leaders in this place globally. So Beto welcome please introduce yourself to us and I think you might have a presentation.
Beto Borges:
Thank you Jonah. Greetings everyone. Glad to see some friends here. Hey Lars and other friends. Happy to be here. An honor to be part of this ongoing exciting reflections in relation to the conservation of the Amazon and most importantly at least from our perspective the well-being of the indigenous peoples and other local communities that live in the region. So happy to be here Jonah. I think that I have some slides that perhaps we can walk through them and then some time for questions. How do we envision the presentation to go?
Jonah:
Yeah, let’s start with the slides. That sounds great. Go ahead and share your screen.
Beto Borges:
Okay. Do you see my screen?
Jonah:
Yeah, looks good.
Beto Borges:
Right. So, let’s So, do you continue to see it?
Jonah:
Yeah. Yeah, it’s full screen. It’s good.
Beto Borges:
Okay. So, forgive me for perhaps rushing through it a bit because there’s lots of content, but yeah, I run Forest Trends Communities and territorial governance initiative. I’ve been working with indigenous peoples for about 30 years or so. I’m Brazilian and with Forest Friends. I’ve been with Forest Friends for the past 15 years directing the community and territorial governance initiative program. I think it’s already this audience are already familiar with the stewardship role of indigenous peoples globally. And here’s just a sample of that of the impact that indigenous peoples have with their traditional stewardship of their territories.
Just in the Amazon alone, we’re talking about 210 million hectares approximately where indigenous peoples have their forest homelands. As you can see in the both in the in the light green and the map here, the sort of the circle map are indigenous territories. In Brazil alone. So, and you see the extent of indigenous territorial coverage in Brazil, which is roughly between 15 to 17% indigenous lands already demarcated. There are about twice that much still in the claims by indigenous peoples to be demarcated. And this is an old picture here of 1986.
But even back then you can see the see the extent of devastation here in between the two territories the Kao and Shikrindu Kate which is which is evidence of this data here that it the firstation rate in indigenous peoples is about 0.8% eight% as compared to other protected areas. And about 11 times greater than non nonprotected areas which represents an estimate 42 to 50 gigatons of carbon dioxide equivalent in terms of u green gas house greenhouse gas emissions u avoidance. The not sure if this top bar here is blocking the full v vision of the slides but it says here communist and territorial governance initiative the program it’s in place for the past 20 years 20 years for trends the communist initiative that’s when it first started the organization itself has about 25 years the origin of this program some of you may be familiar with the rights and resources initiative that actually was incubated within the communities initiative at forest strands that’s when I first came in when rights and resource initiative was launched incubated out of forest strands and then the communities and territorial governance initiative was born as it is today so and the our focus whereas rights and resourc initiative focus on landi rights for indigenous peoples and local communities.
We work on the governance aspect of that of working with indigenous peoples and local communities through advocacy, economic self-determination and cultural integrity. In the area of advocacy, what we’ve been working on over the years is really to both support indigenous peoples in their claim to so that their rights to their territories can be considered in evolving policy around low rural emission development policy as well as the flow of climate finance to indigenous to jurisdictional programs or other programs throughout about we focus in Latin America in this case in the Amazon.
We believe that not at all the flow of climate finance has been very hasn’t really achieved territories indigenous peoples and local communist territories in areas where you have the so-called additionality and even less in areas where you have high force low deforestation. And we did some a study few years ago where we reviewed some of the red commitments and out of $1.2 billion at the time only 378 millions was dispersed in seven tropical countries and no significant amount was really reported to benefit indigenous peoples directly. So the work that we do in the space of advocacy is really supporting indigenous people’s organizations both their political organizations as well as territorial based organizations to drive more climate finance and to respect their territorial rights.
This is a capacity building program that we have working with indigenous organizations at the at the territorial level in particular to support their advocacy efforts as well as economic self-determination cultural integrity. Jonah if you could please share the link to that program with the audience. I would appreciate it that I shared with you earlier.
Unidentified participant:
Sure. Coming up.
Beto Borges:
In the area of economic resilience. The work that we do is really to seek to strike the right balance between indigenous people’s traditional economies with that of the market economy. And in this way we are we’ve been working with different partners. In this case here, we just launched this 1 million trees in the Amazon indigenous lands reforestation program working some selected indigenous territories in what we call the top mosaic is about 1.5 million hectares. Indigenous corridor in the states of Hondon mto we’re working with the Shingu seeds network and with support from the Arbor Day foundation in order to plant 1 million trees.
It’s the first phase of this program that we have seeking to increase carbon storage, support biodiversity as well as increase food security and invest in some of the community based non-timber forest products enterprise such as producing asai Brazil nuts, cocoa, babasu among other non-timber forest products. We also been working with this project with the support of USA through the partners for the Amazon program where we are working with eight indigenous territories as you can see here within the DUP mosaic to support the development of community based enterprises based on the sustainable value chain of rainforest non-timber forest products.
Those are the selected indigenous territories as you can see in the small in the square here to the to the right. This is another example of the work that we’re doing in the space of supporting indigenous economy really to support their economic resilience over time in order to reduce their vulnerability to the sound economic pressures that border their lands. As you can see in this map here, the extent of the forestation surrounding all these indigenous territories here in the Gara Palour there’s all the brown dark brown and are the indigenous areas where we’ve been working and you can see that they’re surrounded by the forestation mostly cattle ranch and soy plantation in this part of the Amazon.
The canopy bridge is a partnership that we developed with equizion that you can see here. At the time this was supported by with funds from USA and later we had some funding from Nicki for this program and we partnered with KA as well as environmental defense fund and what we did here was really a map of indigenous enterprises or community based community businesses. Oops. Well, I went too far. Go back previous. Sorry about that. And where we mapped about 126 indigenous enterprises in five countries in the Amazon. And which we were able to confirm that about 83 of those enterprises has been located in the boundaries of buffer zones of 33 protected areas and 60 illegal legally recognized indigenous territories covering approxim approximately one 105 million hectares which is again another evidence of the stewardship of indigenous peoples and by strengthen economies.
We in turn are protecting large extenses of the Amazon. So this initiative is connected with a with another program that we have which is the Kumari. If you may also please share that link that will give the audience more detail on that. But the Kumari is a program as a partnership between forest trans and eco decision where we partner with chefs throughout the Amazon. Most of them so far are based in Lima with producers from indigenous communities so that can supply them with gourmet products from the forest so that can in turn support the community economies [clears throat and cough] in the in the area of culture what we call oh I did it again in the area of support and cultural integrity we’ve been working with indigenous partners in launching this what we call the living pharmacy program.
The living pharmacy program provides resources financial resources to selected indigenous communities to work wherein indigenous elders who still have the knowledge of medicinal plant use travel deep in the forest with younger with a younger generation that have an interest to learn about how to identify cultivate and use and most importantly will use those medicinal plants to bring to go into deep in the forest and bring back to their villages plants that are they have that they have medicinal properties to use for their own use. This is not for the use of outsiders but for their own use.
This is an example of that is a one of those projects that we did with we did with the Yawanawa people in the in Ary in Brazil. These are 17 medicinal plants that are used just for the treatment of poison snake bites. The description of those how to use those plants are in the Yawanawa language. And here is just I did some other description in Portuguese, but sort of the secret if you will on how to use those plants remain with them. And these were kind of big posters that we were produced that were distributed throughout the villages in order for them to also be able to better identify those particular plants.
And in the history of the Aanawa people because of this traditional knowledge of medicinal plants there have never been a death as a result of poison. She’s muted. So, and to the side here, just a little example of the work that we’ve been doing with indigenous women supporting their artisan work and we have a partnership with Tukum and other companies in order to create income streams for indigenous women in order to develop their artisan work and bring it to the marketplace. So by passing just quickly some of the results so far in our work we this work that we’ve been doing with indigenous women we mostly supported by the IKEA Foundation we’ve managed to raise the income level by 10% which may sound a small number but at locally it goes a long way.
We also managed to work with some jurisdictions in order to drive finance from for instance from jurisdictional programs such as the CIA in Anri where they received a funding from the red early movers program and we were involved in the setting of the indigenous soup program for Caesar creating the benefit sharing system or guidelines for indigenous peoples in the state of AR to receive funding. And we also for his trend some years ago about 8 nine years ago we launched with the Suri people and other partners the first ever red plus u project with indigenous peoples as protagonists and they were able to sell carbon credits that were double verified by VCS the volume carbon standard at the time NCCDA the clim climate committed by diverse alliance a gold standard at the time in our site if you may please share our site Jonath you will see several of our publications we have now more than 50 publications most of them the great majority 95% of our publications are meant for a community audience in these three areas of our work which are advocacy economic resilience and culture integrity.
These are some of our main partners to date. We work very closely with organizations on the ground that is really part of the it’s part of the DNA of forest trends. The work that we do is really through a participatory approach. We these are some of the names of the different organizations. AI in Brazil, Confine in Ecuador and so on so forth. IDE opak in Peru and Colombia and so on. These are in the course of this 15 years we’ve been working with most of these or with all of these organizations that are here and others that are I didn’t include these are on the top are our implementing partners whereas down below some of our funding base to date and some universities that have also been supporting our work as well and really where we continue to focus and expose Jesus.
Again. Oh, now it made it even worse. One more time.
Unidentified participant:
You’re good.
Beto Borges:
And we continue to focus our work really to consolidate work in support of indigenous and local communities to consolidate their territorial governance through institutional strengthening the support that we can provide to their organizations as well as leadership and planning. Work in partnership with territorial based organizations in particular to strengthen their economies through incubating support for local enterprises. We support their advocacy efforts to continue to engage with governments and the private sector in order to secure their rights and access to finance to finance and recognition of their rights within the jurisdictions that they are located.
In part for instance, we’ve been collaborating a lot with organizations in the space of the LEAF program that I believe we can talk more about that during the questions. It’s a new program that has been launched by the US Norway and England with a cluster of corporations in order to drive climate finance to jurisdictional programs to reduce emissions. So we’ve been working with indigenous organizations that have not really been consulted and as that program has launched you know there are still a lot to be done in order for them to really benefit.
So we provide our some of our understanding being in the space of ecosystem services for quite some time. For instance, Forest Tren just launched recently the publication the state-of-the-art of the voluntary car carbon market. And so we’ve been monitoring the voluntary carbon market. And as a result, we believe we can support and we have been asked by our indigenous partners to help them think through how to better advocate for their rights as programs such as LEAF get developed, get underway. And another area that we’ve been doing some work with our indigenous partners really to think through u new ways of measuring if you will their stewardship of their of the ecosystem services within their territories in order to hopefully think out of the box out of the different standards that exist.
So we think that it’s important for indigenous peoples to come up with their own culturally appropriate ways through which their stewardship of their forests can be recognized and recognized and supported by bilaterals by NOS’s by the international community as a whole. So and I will stop at stop here that is my email. We’ll be really happy to be in touch with those of you that we’re not in touch yet. That is just one of our sites and yeah so I guess great.
Jonah:
If you could end the screen share. Great. Thank you so much Beto. There’s a lot there. There’s so much there. Any one of those could lead to an hourlong presentation in and of itself. So I’m just going to come in with a couple questions and then we’ll open it up to others. Others who would like to ask questions, I encourage you to make your interest known by raising your hand or putting something in the chat. First question, Beto, I would like you to walk us through a little bit about the role of the private sector in indigenous territorial recognition.
So I know that you help establish spaces for indigenous communities and governments to dialogue. What about the private sector? What is what is their role in that process specifically [clears throat and cough].
Beto Borges:
In our case? Well, that’s a big question, right? Depend what you mean on the role of the private sector.
Jonah:
Yeah, sorry to take what you want.
Beto Borges:
Yeah. Well, the private sector that is destroying the environment. The role that we have is to support indigenous partners to really seek to halt the incursion of un unsustainable development in their territories. The spectrum of the private sector that it’s awakened to the importance of working with and supporting indigenous peoples. There are many companies that are you know see it differently. In we work with in two areas I guess in relation to private sector to date one is when I said earlier that we seek to find it to strike the right balance between indigenous people’s traditional economies with that of the marketplace and the marketplace that is where these private companies are s such as Baraka and original beans and other companies that are that already buy products from non-timber forest products from community based enterprises and we provide the technical support for to develop indigenous businesses if you will and make the and help them develop the value chain all the way from community all the way to these companies that are willing to pay this extra value that is very much needed and deserved by indigenous peoples.
So there are a number of those companies that we are engaging with and we are welcoming new companies that would be willing to work with us. And but mo most importantly willing to work with the overcome the constraints that exist in order to get this community based projects off the ground. Understanding that there are different transaction costs. There issues of quality control and we work within that space in order to really create a viable economy because it’s only through creating we believe creating a strong resilient indigenous economy over the over time that we will help will help contribute to decreasing their vulnerability to the unound economic forces that are encroaching upon their lands.
So they will have more options. And the other space of private companies that we work with are companies that are in the space of buying offsets. So we do believe that well you know red is a positive mechanism provided is done properly. We believe in jurisdictional red as we believe in projectbased carbon projects as well. So we are in discussions with companies that are that are already buying like I said earlier we launched the first indigenous red project at least that we are aware of the sur project back then we haven’t changed our position in relation to carbon markets so we believe carbon markets have a role have a positive role as long as they respect indigenous rights as long as free prior form consent processes are respected above.
Jonah:
I was trying to get specifically around demarcation and legal recognition by the government of indigenous land rights that normally that’s NOS’s and indigenous communities and governments negotiating and I and I haven’t seen I think it’s very interesting to embed the private sector in that negotiation process. Is that something that you have seen go corporations using their legal and advocacy expertise to support indigenous communities in the legal recognition of their land?
Beto Borges:
No, perhaps I something that I said came out the wrong way, but I’m not aware if others are aware of corporations that are investing in the demarcation of indigenous peoples. If anything, corporations continue to be a major threat to the demarcation of indigenous territories or to the even the recognition of indigenous territories already demarcated in the case of Brazil currently is a major problem that they’re trying the government is trying to undermine the demarcations that have already been secured given the constitution of 1988. You know where companies have a way to support indigenous peoples in their processes of either requests for new demarcations or maintaining the their forests that have already been demarcated is to support their autonomous econ economies local economies by way of investing in ways that are fair based on free prior consent processes.
That way they can help strengthen the governance of indigenous territories because demarcation itself will not resolve will not protect indigenous lands from being invaded is really the rights with governance that is in the long run is what’s really going to deliver God willing the conservation of indigenous lands and the and the well-being of their people of indigenous peoples their good living or as they say in Spanish. So the private sector has a role has a role in order to help provide the right incentives even though that word is a tricky word because indigenous peoples don’t need to be incentivized to defend their forest.
They’ve been doing this at the cost of their own lives. But if anything, the private sector can provide markets that are just that are fair for indigenous people’s products and at the same time not create perverse incentives that are causing dis deforestation. But the role of the it is up to governments really to uphold their constitutions and respect indigenous people’s rights.
Jonah:
Okay, I have one more question. I’d love it if you could tell us a little bit about your previous incarnation before Forest Trends and your work on Shaman Pharmaceuticals and then just give us a couple sentences about Dragon Blood and its commercialization by Jaguar Health.
Beto Borges:
Yes. Well, it’s been many years now. It’s I think it was fair to say my previous incarnation. Yeah, I used to work for Sham Pharmaceuticals here in California, but that’s where I’m based. At the time was continues to be now their reinvented themsel is called themselves is called Napo Pharmaceuticals. When I worked with Chamber of Pharmaceuticals, I was responsible for sustainable management of bringing the raw product for the dragons dragon’s blood. It’s a it’s a sap from a tree in the Amazon from the dragon’s blood tree that we did at the time to create a drug to treat HIV diarrhea.
It was about to be launched. Then the FDA required more clinical studies. We had to switch gears and it became finally it was launched as a supple dietary supplement as opposed to a pharmaceutical product. Oh, it was very interesting. I spent three years of my work there as manager of sustainable harvesting working with the forest communities to supply you know the raw material for that particular drug as well as working with the scientists at the company and indigenous peoples throughout the world in order to identify other plants with bio that were bio bioact bioactive towards given diseases through the science of ethnobboty that’s what we did at the time and so I’m not sure what else.
Jonah:
Great.
Beto Borges:
Still out there and I think well if one thing I you know I guess u when I think of my days back in the labs of shimmer pharmaceutical seeing what it’s possible and thinking of comparing carbon markets with the potential of true benefits coming from biorrosspecting and you know sort of coming up with economic incentives based on the conservation of biodiversity or ecosystem services from within such as biodiversity. I think the biodiversity offers a greater opportunity than carbon markets per se. So because carbon markets in themselves have a finished cycle whereas biodiversity does not.
Jonah:
Okay, now’s the time to open it up to everybody else. Tom, I saw you come off or come on video. Did you have a question?
Unidentified participant:
Okay.
Tom:
Oh, no. I didn’t. I was just wanted to make sure he had a face to look at while he was talking. So, appreciate all your presentation, Bezo. And very informative. Thank you.
Jonah:
Great. Okay, Bobby Kia, you’re up first. Please introduce yourself as well.
Bobby:
Thanks, Jonah. Hello everyone. Thank you for the presentation. That’s so my name is Bobby Keian. I’m the co-founder of the Peace Department, formerly the IFC, the World Bank’s International Finance Corporation. And my question is in the chat and it is as follows. If we can bring ultra high netw worth investors and other forms of private capital that have that’s flexible. Are we able to identify some sustainable business models that can be proven to empower indigenous rights?
Jonah:
Go ahead.
Beto Borges:
Yeah, I think that we are by the way Forest Trends is not the only organization working in this space supporting indigenous people’s local economies. Then themselves have their own initiatives Qua for instance which is the Panamaian indigenous organization representing indigenous peoples throughout the Amazon the Mesame American alliance of peoples and forests I think one way is to the extent that is possible and their willingness to engage it’s always best to go straight to those organizations to see what programs they have and I believe they have evolving programs in this space particularly the Meso America all lines of peoples and forests given that forestry in me America’s is more advanced than it is in some of these indigenous territories that in the Amazon and so again one caveat that is really important is really to understand that working with indigenous people’s economic community based enterprises takes a lot of time to develop in a way that you can really achieve the quality of products in a way that really is in balance with their the culture integrity and their ways of living depending on the on the territories on the on the given people.
It really varies from community to community. The institut the social environmental institute already has some really good programs in place. Perhaps Jon you can also share their site here as well. In the northern Amazon with selling pepper and other products. So there are I believe our friends here Rainforest Alliance Lars is on the on the call as well. They are also involved with good community based programs as well. So it’s really there’s there are several organizations that are already working in this space and we can you can I shared my email here.
I’ll be happy to either through us or through our partners or connecting you directly with some of our partners to explore further but it takes time it takes a commitment and really u most of all again most importantly is really to respect indigenous people’s autonomy and their free, prior and informed consent processes not only and free, prior and informed consent is not only related to carbon projects it related to any engagement that any one of us can have with indigenous people’s organizations be it to develop a business in order to sell Coca-Cola or Brazil nuts or be it a project to sell carbon.
So it so they need to be comfortable with what is being expected from them and one needs to invest the time and resources that are necessary but I can guarantee that is worth it in the end. Anything that can secure their support their stewardship of their forces is a is a is a good investment. I hope that I respond to your question. Yes. Thank you so much.
Jonah:
Great. Sid Embry.
Sid Embry:
Hi. Yes. Thank you. That was a wonderful summary, Beto. And it sounds like you’re involved in a lot. I hope you have a team helping you with all of those activities. And yes, I first heard about the Studi project from Jacob Oander who I’ve known gosh for like 25 years or whatever. But I understand so have been looking at potential red investment opportunities throughout the Jaguar corridor biodiverse corridors in Latin America and I understand the Sudowi project was suspended. I don’t know if it’s been reinstated but my limited understanding is perhaps that was due to invasions and land grabbing.
Whether successful or not. And so I’ve been struggling with well wanting obviously to find investment opportunities working with indigenous communities no matter whether it’s Amazon or Mosquitia or wherever. But I’m wondering what like obviously taking care of the patrimony of the indigenous communities is important but what are the practical steps on the ground? Is it you know things like biorrosspecting and investing in productive activities so that there are people in the properties in the lands on a regular basis. Or is it more, you know, organized programs such as LEAF? I’m just, you know, I look at other red properties even in the Amazon that are private sector own and they’re also trying to deal with land grabbing and illegal logging and people coming on their properties and so yeah, anyway, I’m just challenged.
We would certainly love to anywhere we’re investing to make additional investments in studies that would benefit communities as well as our fund to identify you know payments for ecosystem services opportunities bioprospecting do you know species and ecosystem valuations basically to broaden the range of information and understanding of what’s the potential probably hopefully identify even unknown as yet opportunities. But I’m still like a little other than you know getting guards which I really don’t like the idea of at all. What can be done to strengthen the guardianship of the patrimony through red or maybe it’s not just through red?
Sorry to ramble, but thought a lot about this.
Beto Borges:
Yeah. Well, first of all, thank you, Sid. Yeah, I do have a team, thanks God, working with me. In fact, Jacob Olander is part of that team. So, he’s working closely with us. And, well, the sur beginning with the surbon project, it is on hold. We suspended because of diamond mining that was then found in the territory which was not part of the methodology when we developed the methodology we did as in Brazil which is one of our partners in Brazil we were not at all thinking of diamond mining at the time we were the methodology was based on the baseline was based on timber extraction there were that was the main reason really there were some governance proc problems as well.
In some of the leadership begun kind of some were there was too much expectation raised which one of for us one of the lessons learned is that FP which is free, prior and informed consent process doesn’t have an end in itself it has to be continuous continuously revisited. So in order to you know keep people engaged and asking the right questions and minimizing and controlling expectations making them realistic. Leaf you know it’s an interesting program I think it’s people are really well-intentioned we have some reservations we as forest friends and myself included which is you know it’s things are happening really fast and there they haven’t had the time really the governments to those willing by the way and that you know that varies right in the spectrum of all the governments that partake into the that have I believe submitted proposals to the program they the whole process has been rushed therefore they didn’t have time to conduct proper consultation with indigenous peoples those indigenous peoples that I meaning through the organizations that everyone that I talked to that have come to us the great majority are clueless about some you know they don’t even have a copy of the proposal that was submitted.
Article the Cancun safeguard S I believe points four and five the conc safeguards speak very clearly that red mechanisms need to involve indigenous peoples and local communities in the in the architecture of those mechanisms. And to us then it’s a bit concerning that the program is already this far when proposals are being considered whereas indigenous peoples didn’t have a chance to participate and local communities didn’t have a chance took a chance to co-develop that those proposals. And so then you it’s a subject for a situation where a proposal is approved and then they will have to presade the jurisdictions the governments will have to present some kind of a benefit sharing mechanism which will in turn establish a percentage a percentage that will have been thought out just by the governments without the participation of indigenous peoples and I think that is one of the in my understanding that could be wrong.
That’s one of the weaknesses of the red early movers program where the percentage was established without the participation of the stewers, the most important stews of the forest. So somehow they will have to correct that in the process. That’s what we hope. We, you know, we think, you know, we’re glad the leaf is here because more finance is needed to control the forestation, but you know, they need to sort of correct the path a little bit in relation to the engagement of indigenous peoples and, you know, my email is here.
We can there are some things that we can talk more, you know, offline. So in order to other people here to ask questions if they want but this is complex. Again we believe that indigenous peoples don’t really need I think nesting indigenous people’s carbon projects is one way but I don’t think it’s the only way I think indigenous people should have their own right to engage with a company because we believe that they have the carbon ownership rights to their territories it varies accord the interpretation varies from country to country but at least In Brazil the time of the suri project we hire is a big word but pro bono almost we paid a little bit towards Becky McKenzie which did a six months review of all the legal framework of the Brazilian laws and concluded that indigenous peoples in Brazil do have carbon ownership rights at least for what it concerned Brazil.
Where I believe most of the Brazilian Amazon states submitted proposals to leave they will have to come up with terms with that you know Who determines the percentage of benefit sharing when indigenous peoples themselves have the rights to the carbon in their territories? And here we’re talking about u 50 15 to 17% of the Brazilian land mass belongs to them.
Jonah:
If somebody could post a link to that Baker Mckenzie study that would be great. Next up is Lars.
Lars:
Hi Beto. Thank you. That was a very good presentation. You’re focusing in on you know a lot of very important issues like you know cultural sustainability, economic opportunities, building resilience and all that stuff. I was just wondering since we’re sort of 15 people here, small group and with your 15 years with forest trends and 30 years working on the issues, we all know that not always indigenous peoples are really giving priority to long-term long-term sustainability. You know, economic gain in the short term is very attractive. And I wondered if you could share some of Forest Trends experience in dealing with those issues in a sense how long do you work with people who don’t give the same priority to sustainability as you ideally would like them to do?
Do you have a policy for choosing which communities to work with? And maybe give some insights into sort of what you consider like the key aspects or elements for success in the long run. Difficult question and a bit tricky but I know you can answer it.
Beto Borges:
Thank you Lars. I’m sure you’re dealing with the same question in your mind over the years and this is indeed a challenge because you know there is we don’t want to be in the in the place of romanticizing right that it you know indigenous peoples are all you know they are we believe that for the most part they are the true stewards. You just look at the stats, right? And most of the forests that are still intact is because indigenous peoples are there. However, it doesn’t mean that all indigenous peoples think the same way.
In fact, one of the problems that we had with this carbon project was because some didn’t think the same way. Some of their leaders wanted to sell continue to sell wood to illegal loggers. And the same is true from territory to territory. So but what we do that’s it’s human nature I would say I don’t think in indigenous peoples are any different than we are in terms of you know being attracted to and sometimes illusioned by the power of capital right and sometimes they perhaps not wanting to be paternalistic but sometimes they’re some they’re manipulated by some you know unound business interests and we’ve seen that happening The way that we go about it, Lars, is that we have this and I believe if you haven’t yet, my friend Jonah, if you can please copy and paste the link to our capacity building training program that we have.
It’s a video that we have. We have this capacity building training program which is a one-year long program that we developed in conjunction with some indigenous organizations as well as local universities the sort of the methodology the and the curricula for that. As opposed to two weeks workshops, we work a whole year and we meet every other month in presence at the at the local level with they are the selection for those participating is very participatory. And you can see in the video that will tell you more about it. But essentially we work with the indigenous community rep mostly community associations that partake in those trainings really to think through what really money represents and what is the power of money?
How can money be an instrument for the integrated governance of their territories? How can money can be can pro can provide a collective benefit rather than benefiting one person versus the other. And really working through a long time with them in order to and where we’re developing most of our hands-on economic projects have been in the top mosaic. And also in the state of AI in Brazil where we’ve been working for 15 20 years with selected indigenous territories. We already we already have the relationship and we’ve addressed some of these issues years ago and we are making progress in terms of u because they’re starting to see the benefits of u you know working towards the common good as opposed to benefited individ individually.
But from time to time there are those that for instance, oh no, I want to sell my Brazil nuts to outside of this co-op because I’m going to make more money with that. And ultimately it’s their decision. So as far as a policy, we don’t necessarily have a policy on paper, but our practice is that if we don’t see that there is a community consensus wherein there is a good representation of the community from elders, women and youth and leaders together driving a given economic enterprise. We you know in time we really we stopped working with them over time to a certain extent that also played a role in the SUI project because they started to disagree with one another and we said well here’s as far as we can go the methodology can be revamped.
We think there is still a chance there but ultimately it’s in their hands if they really want to take it that project and any other economic development project with indigenous peoples. So they’re the ones that need to you know to agree to work for the collective as a whole as opposed to individual benefits. My best answer at this point at this time my friend I would be I would be intrigued to hear your how you go about it. Could learn a lot from you guys as well on this topic as in others.
Jonah:
You can respond Lars.
Lars:
Long-term engagement is essential insisting on participation as Beto did. So that broad participation I mean he mentioned the youth women and we see in many indigenous community that very strong influential smart individuals are able to actually benefit themselves to the irritation of the community but not to the sanction of the community. So one has to be quite knowledgeable and willing to also be very unpopular.
Jonah:
Good. Great wisdom sharing. I have one question that might take us to the top of the hour. Others are also welcome to come on. Beetto, thinking about pre-existing supply chains in consumer networks here in the United States as an author, you used to make it if Oprah Winfrey brought you onto her show. I want to ask about the bioeconomy aggregators, as I call them, Canopy Bridge, Tukum, and Odian’s Brazil. Do we just need more celebrities to tweet about consumption of indigenous goods? Is doubling the consumption, you know, over the next six months, an important and priority pathway that global civil society and allies on these phone calls could pursue or should pursue?
Beto Borges:
Not necessarily. I think that the solution is not just in really boosting indigenous economies to the point that they become commodities and so that indigenous people if we were to do that we would probably have an a detrimental impact on indigenous people’s territories because again like I said at least for us we think that it’s important to strike the right balance between their traditional economies with the with the market economy We don’t want their traditional economy to be destroyed because all of a sudden they have to produce you know 100 pound of a month of cocoa to the marketplace because of Oprah said it’s the greatest thing after sliced bread.
So we don’t I think what Oprah can do given her audience is to have people rethink how we consume and also consume less consume products of a high quality and invest the market I think needs to have the you know the will and investment capacity to develop this markets with indigenous peoples that take that take time and the time that it takes is to find again this to strike this right balance. Okay. What is the elasticity of supply that indigenous people’s economic enterprises can have to the extent that they will not destroy their traditional economy.
The traditional economy of exchange, the traditional economy of you know I fish I give you my fish and you help me with you know with my cassava my cassava you know cultivar so that cannot be destroyed because if the market all this bioeconomy that everybody talks about no nature-based solutions that everybody talks about if that becomes a new encroach and south encroachment upon Egyptians lands then we will have failed you know, I wish I had a silver bullet for Oprah to just announce and I think this is in the making, but the more we come as a society thinking what are the ways that we can partner with indigenous peoples to recognize their rights to recognize that perhaps they have a better way if not a better way but a complimentary way of living on this planet to not consuming so much resources.
Perhaps we can come up with a better way of you know looking upon indigenous societies, indigenous social structures. How do they relate to one another? How do they take care of their elderly? How they’re teach their youngsters. You know it’s not all about the market. It’s about a change of paradigm.
Jonah:
Great. Not great. Sorry. What amazing wisdom. I celebrate it. This is a perfect moment for it for the whole world to see it. We’re at the top of the hour and this is where you probably know we convert to water cooler time and classes dismissed but people are welcome to hang around. Do you have a few more minutes to spend time with us?
Beto Borges:
I do. I do. Yes.
Jonah:
Okay, great. Thanks everybody for joining and tada. Now’s time for unstructured. Thank you all so much. Experience. If anyone else has any other questions or self shameless self-promotion or whatever it may be decision,.
Unidentified participant:
I just sent Sid Embrya a LinkedIn message in case she’s interested in exploring Venezuela. I know it’s kind of off the grid, but there are interesting opportunities there.
Jonah:
Great. How exciting.
Mark:
Yes, Beto, I maybe you can confirm that great presentation by the way. Really u really appreciated you take. In Ecuador, the communities that I’m u involved with have told me that they receive about $165 every six months from the U Red Plus scheme. Is it is it the number that you’ve encountered as well that little money?
Beto Borges:
You know, it looks awkward. 165 every six months in exchange of what? It could be a small project. I don’t know. I’m not familiar with that. It’s.
Unidentified participant:
Person will receive from the red scheme in Ecuador maybe. Well, there is in Ecuador they have the S soioski program. Yeah, that’s part of it. Yes.
Beto Borges:
Okay. It could be depending one person receiving $165 every six months. I’m not familiar Mark with the details of Socio Bosski to that extent. It’s plausible that they have to the extent that I remember they don’t have individual payments but they invest more in programs but it could be that I’m misinformed. So you know we think that a benefit sharing program would be don’t necessar doesn’t necessarily need to or I perhaps wouldn’t be the wisest to make individual payments because we’ve seen for instance and that wasn’t even an individual payment when I was very much involved in the state of a in Brazil and this indigenous soup program where it channeled funds from the red early movers program.
Some of the allocations were really paid out to indigenous organizations but used the money really to for emergency projects that they had which are were all very much you know in need. But in order for this to really have a systemic impact of what is really needed, I mean I’m not making passing judgment. I mean I’m sure this person that received this money you know benefited from I hope benefited from it. But what I’m talking about is that programs rand programs and other carbon programs and other biodiversity payment programs they need to really be invested in terms of the benefit sharing aspect of it in a more integrated approach in a more systemic approach that really takes the territory and the wellbeing the livelihoods of the given community as a whole as compared or as opposed to an individual sort of pay payment to a person because that could be taken completely out of hand depending on the circumstances.
Unidentified participant:
Yeah. No, I agree. I agree. And it’s probably you know the trickle down effect of going first to the Equadian government, then the socio boss program, then to indigenous organizations and then split it towards communities and communities do whatever they want with the money eventually. But the what I see very often in terms of when you speak of programs it is very often something that is forced upon indigenous communities to adopt and unfortunately it does have its own you know problems down the line where when we speak for instance you had that experience with shaman pharmaceuticals Right.
And there was strong accusations of bioparacy. And it tends to follow a very similar type of mechanism whereas it is something that is forced upon and if it doesn’t work if the organization induced organizations reject that which happened also with red plus in Ecuador then you know it they tend to move towards more friendly or more needy I would say indigenous communities.
Beto Borges:
Agreed. That’s why it’s important to respect the free, prior and informed consent and for it to be a collective you know ownership of a by the community that’s at least was the practice even though there was some u you know criticism there’s always going to be presence some is fair some perhaps not so much at the time of chamber pharmaceutical the exchanges were based on FP which didn’t even was called as such back and the programs that exist now you know they also they all need to be u evaluated from this standpoint of whether communists have been consultant what type of consultation took place was were the legitimate representative leadership of those communities at the forefront of those negotiations and so I think that would that’s a good way to evaluate the give the existing programs that exist and like I said unfortunately I think LEAF needs to correct its course in relation to that so it doesn’t fall prey to the same problems that other wellintentioned programs have found you know.
Jonah:
All right well now I just look at the clock and remember that I have a meeting that I’m already five minutes late for. Thanks so much for joining us. Sorry. Yeah,.
Unidentified participant:
It was it was a pleasure. Thank you.
Beto Borges:
Likewise. You know, please I will look forward to be continue to be in touch through link. You can we can be connected through there and also through email. And thank you again, Jonah, for this opportunity. So, it’s a lot to share. I think I kind of rushed through it, but I hope I managed to share some of our work with you all.
Unidentified participant:
You did great. Thanks so much. Was very interesting. Thank you.
Beto Borges:
Thank you, Mark. Thank you, Sid. Thank you all. Okay, Jenna, take it easy.
Jonah:
Stop recording. Okay, hold on.