Weaving Philanthropy, Business, and Sustainability

The Humanize Institute unites strategies and networks to strengthen Brazilian philanthropy and key institutions of sustainable development. The institute works to weave together an ecosystem that integrates philanthropy, public institutions, private investment, and impact businesses in order to leverage resources and skills while contributing to regional development. How are Amazon projects financed? How are sustainability strategies adopted in businesses and markets? How do Humanize programs advance sustainable business management activities in the region? How do Brazilian philanthropies work together on the Amazon conservation? Join us to meet the Institute’s Sustainability Manager, Ana Carolina Avzaradel Szklo, and learn.

Recorded August 23, 2021

References:

Private Social Investment in the Amazon

Philanthropy in Brazil

Sustainability as a Market Differentiator

What does sustainability mean in business?

WATCH:

  • Jonah
  • Ana Carolina Avzaradel Szklo
  • Susan Keane
  • Fernando
  • Louisa
  • David

Jonah:

Hello everybody. This is the 55th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing force friendly economic development across the Amazon region of South America forest friendly economic development and the rule of law I should say. We convene grant makers and NOS’s and activists and journalists and governments and investors and others to learn together. This week we are featuring the work of Ana Carolina Avzaradel Szklo and Institutes which would be in English the humanize institute. Anna thank you so much for.

Unidentified participant:

Joining us. How are you today? Kind of invite.

Jonah:

You bet. So, you and I have had a little bit of back and forth. Did you want to make a presentation with slides or did you want to follow an interview format?

Ana Carolina Avzaradel Szklo:

I think we can go with the interview. I had some slides, but I think your format is probably more dynamic than mine.

Jonah:

Okay, sounds good to me. So, so let’s begin with you. Can you tell us a little bit about who you are and where you grew up and then the second question of that after that will be what did you do before arriving at the institute.

Ana Carolina Avzaradel Szklo:

Okay I am as we say kio from the yellow part of the egg meaning not only I’m born and raised in Rio but also that my parents are also from Rio so it’s a city that I love I’m an economist I have a master degree in environmental and energy planning and I have worked well I have a son 5-year-old I have a 17 stepdaughter we live right next to the botanic garden and unfortunately we’re very much locked up at home for the past year and a half but trying to have a sane life in the midst of everything that’s going on around here before human eyes still as an economist before I joined behind the environment agenda.

I worked for four years in corporate finance at the at the holding of globe organizations, the main media company in Brazil. Then I took my masters. Then I started working first as a researcher in the laboratory at the faculty at the university. Then I joined the Ministry of Science and Technology which had a very important role in Brazil at the time in climate change. So I joined the national authority designated authority in Brazil. I started working first on CDM projects the clean develop mechanism. Then I worked here in Brazil we have now what we call an interconnected system of electricity but at the time in 2008 we had subnational systems and we were trying to understand whether there was indeed some restriction some barriers in terms of transmission from one system to another that is important because when we turned this into an interconnected system we made it viable for projects CDM projects in the northeast for instance because there was a lot of imbalance in terms of the emission factor throughout the throughout Brazil throughout the country.

So I worked then I took some courses within the UNF trip and I focused on the energy sector. I coordinated the energy sector of the national GHG emissions inventory. I did a lot of work of cooperation with other countries especially Portuguese-speaking countries in Africa still within the government so that we could provide some capacity building so that they could implement the projects directly. I worked as a negotiator within the UNFC and also within the IPCC and I am still part of the roster of experts of the UNFC who takes as an audit work once a year we get together or more to do the national im JJ emissions inventory review for NX1 countries.

So I was within the government for three years. Then there was a shift in the government. I moved out to work in consultancy but still in climate change. My main background is in climate change for the past more than 15 years but focused on the energy sector. Then I worked at ICF the consult an American consulting firm main drivening in Brazil to the private sector. Then I moved to Sabadis, the Brazilian branch of the world business council for sustainable development but already looking at the sustainability as a whole. So not only climate change but also biodiversity logistics, social impact, waste, water, communications and education and sustainable finance.

So it was quite broad. I was the focal point in Brazil for the world business and I did direct work with the companies in Brazil approximately 70 of the major groups we had like 40% of the country’s GDP and I work directly with the CEOs so that we could put together an agenda of sustain sustainable proposals for the past two elections mainly for the presidential elections so that they could have a at the first moment in 2014 a 22 proposals agenda and in 2018 a 10 proposals agenda. So there was a very important work of advocacy as well trying to put to the government some important agenda through the lens of the private sector and then I joined humaniz right before the pandemic coming to the to the philanthropic world and trying to understand how else I can contribute to the agenda.

That was probably the longest answer you got to the first questions. I’m sure I covered at least the first five or four of them, but please be comfortable to come with the others.

Jonah:

Great. So, I think one thing is clear is that you’ve had a little bit of experience. So, you’re you’re in the right place to take on questions of Brazil and climate change and sustainable development. Le let’s get into a little bit more into instead of saying the humanize institute I’m just going to call it umi to use the Portuguese word so tell us a little bit about where umi came from and why was it created and what’s its broad purpose as an institution?

Ana Carolina Avzaradel Szklo:

Okay, was born to bring more structure and strategy to a social private investment that had been going on for more than 10 years already. And was formally instituted in 2017. Then for the first two years, it was mainly putting the house on the ground and bringing people in and establishing the strategy. And from 2019 till 2021 we were implementing this strategy. So this is now a very crucial year for us because we’re looking back at what we have accomplished in this first years of experience and what we’re going to do in this next phase.

And because of the philanthropist heart or where he puts his efforts and attention to, we have a territorial focus in Brazil also with biomes and some specific value chains, social biodiversity value chains. So we work mainly in par in the state in the biome of the Amazon in far in Amazonas. We also work in the forest in the forest in Brazil. Sorry, I lost the words. Call Matlanchk in Portuguese. In Baya especially the south in extreme south of the of the state and here in Rio de Janeiro as well as in the Sado but we’re still aligning exactly.

Thank you, Atlantic rainforest. And we’re still aligning exactly the territory that we’re going to be working on within the Serado. So we have under my responsibility two programs of sustainability. One of them we call it sustainable use that focuses on some specific social biodiversity value chains mainly right now fishery and we have here with us Moniki Galvan which represents one of our main granties organizations rare that work very closely with us on the fishery segment. We also work with honey, cacao and seeds which is a very important and strategic agenda in Brazil right now especially because of climate change not only on Hi Maniki not only in the Amazon but also throughout the country.

We also have under my responsibility a program that tackles entrepreneurship and social impact business. So that is also where we settle the agenda of alternative financial mechanisms that we work with regard to blended finance or funds or specific credit lines that we launch here trying to boost sustainable development within this value chains. It’s not something as simple as it’s as it seems like but it has been very successful. And we also have a program that tackles public management in Brazil which for me actually it’s one of the most relevant contributions of Umani from the perspective that you need the public sector on board.

It’s not as we usually say it in Portuguese despite the private the public sector that we’re going to have things implemented is along with them and they have a lot of gaps that they cannot fill out on their own. So we’re there also to help them with people management, with tools, with advocacy. It’s a it’s a it’s a long way, but I think it’s important. We also work with education and although it’s not the biggest portfolio we have. I think it’s one of the most important in the country right now especially because of the pandemic but not only and we work with institutional development of social organizations in Brazil which I think also is something very important from the small ones to the to the big ones they all need some sort of support and given the current circumstances that has turned out to be also something extremely important.

Great. From what I understand, Umaani has a special belief in networks and the power of collaboration. And you guys have been involved in supporting that. Can you tell us about how you guys are bringing that approach to philanthropy for the Amazon region? Yeah, I can say honestly that this is the first time that I actually see it happen truly happening in terms of partnership building partnerships. Before that I’m sure most of you have heard of it but usually we used to seeing a slide where we can hang as many logos as we can and doing real partnership is different and it’s not that easy.

In the Amazon we have the concert the consultation for the Amazon. We have now with her Ana from the Wilson Center who also works with us on a specific project that I was I can address later. So we gather the philanthropist gather once a month to try to understand the main the main challenges that we have. Do you think can I share one slide? I think it would be helpful to Okay, it’s right here. So this it’s in Portuguese, but just to give you an idea of what we did within the this initiative, after a lot of conversations between this group of u philanthropist, we came to 14 I think we already up to 15 or 17 main challenges within the Amazon.

So what we did here internally was try to understand where each one of us is placed. Each one of us, Open Society Foundation later on, CLU later on and where each one of us was putting our efforts and energy not only now but historically then we were able to visualize where are the main gaps where none of us is acting right now and of course none of us is going to tackle all the 15 or 17 or 14 points here but it makes it easier to understand the huge challenge that it is sitting before us and if we are not going to tackle some of some aspects of it because we’re not I mean we have a certain we have a scope we don’t deal with everything but it makes it easier to understand what’s lacking and who could come on board to support that specific gap for instance if it’s something related to criminal ity is something that we it’s beyond our scope of work, but we acknowledge not only that ex that it exists, but also that there’s a strong connection with everything else.

So, it’s not just about saying, well, I’m not going to do everything, but if somebody doesn’t, then what we intend to do will probably be jeopardized and wasted. So, that’s why we wanted to see that. That’s one area of focus that we have. So we get together to understand within that scope what are the priorities, what are the opportunities and what can we do together in terms in terms of trying to reach a higher impact and of course not only reducing some of the risks but we share the risks acknowledging the role of philanthropy here in Brazil.

The other role that we have, I think it also comes to another segment. It relates to JIE here in Brazil. It’s an association that gathers more than 160 organizations of the third sector of philanthropy and institutions. And the idea is that I understand that not all institutions I mean some of them are smaller or they have a smaller scope of work and but a lot of them want to work within the Amazon want to do something but it’s not that easy to understand what how when and so something that we thought could be useful thanks Jonah was to provide for them easy ways in easy ways that they could have to jump in and programs that are already structured but that need funding so that we can somehow drive our resources to put it into more intelligent and strategic work and time not all the organizations are willing to do that kind of work.

So I think it I think it’s useful. And also connecting to other initiatives throughout the country. So s such as the Brazil climate agriculture and forest coalition that we’re very close to also understanding how can we be additional to what’s already going on. We have other partnerships within the Amazon such as the PPA the partnerships also for forest within us USAD and other partners in Brazil. So it’s a lot about connection. It’s about understanding what we can do together, how much effort we are willing all of us to put together in this effort.

What are the main strategy lines and be open to conversations. I mean, none of those aspects that were within that slide that I shared are easy to tackle. If we’re if we’re talking about regulation in Brazil, about regulating the ownership of the land, for instance, we end up it’s not only about receiving a proposal and providing the grant for we have to build the proposal together because nobody knows the answer. There’s no clear way to solve some of the issues. So we engage in conversations bi-weekly so that we can try to understand what could be the best bet and then we follow up very closely.

Yeah. So it’s beyond just putting financial resources. It’s putting time, it’s putting intelligence and doing a lot of articulation within the country to make it happen.

Jonah:

I’m gonna post the link for the project that you guys did with Jifi on Amazonia Pa Amazonia.

Ana Carolina Avzaradel Szklo:

Exactly. Yeah.

Jonah:

I made myself mute instead of posting it. Could do you want to tell us a little bit about that? Were you involved?

Ana Carolina Avzaradel Szklo:

Yeah, that was an interesting an interesting very short-term project. We put up together a platform on which we could bring visibility to a lot of a lot of opportunities. There’s a paper that we published. We launched it about two three months ago. So the idea was to explain to institutions that want to come closer to the agenda a bit of the context where are the main challenges where are the main opportunities. We had a very interesting workshop. So connections can be made very easily and again I think that there are very immediate opportunities like shelf products that are easy for a lot of institutions to just jump in and support.

They’re ready for that. But there are others that need to be built and that takes a lot of time and energy. So and not all not all of them have the experience, the expertise and the time. So that was an effort very quickly that we did to try to show to all of these institutions what their contribution can be and if you allow me to go a bit beyond it. I think one aspect that it’s really important that we were not able to tackle that product and that I try to foster here in Brazil is that we usually see everything in silos.

So we have a lot of studies that don’t connect to each other. We have the government was looking at how much it spends to the environment as a whole not necessarily only to the Amazon. So here we were looking at how does the philanthropy world how much is putting into it and where can it engage more but we don’t have a bigger study or something more linear that can bring all of these different types of capital together because it’s not about one or the other. It’s about a mixture and I think I think for me that’s I think this is something interesting to share him here.

For me that’s one of the main challenges that we have because the philanthropy is willing to discover to try to risk opening the way for the private sector the private capital to come in. But then for that strategy to be successful first you need to actually understand what is going to be the trigger to bring the capital of private segment in volumes and then make it happen but it’s not something organic and those connections are not yet established so I think part of our role is to do that to bring that narrative that story say we have the numbers we tested works and now you have to come in here and there and that’s the beauty of it because we have now in certain sectors at least five or six different models that can be implemented.

So which one should be the target of our attention right now where should we bet there are different possibilities of technical assistance of providing credit line different credit lines. So we look at the challenges we talk to a lot of experts we hire studies nothing comes directly and straight from our mind but then we try to test some of the solutions we come up with the numbers we follow up directly we monitor and then we have something that we see and say okay this works and then we try to make it bigger two or three times bigger but to make it 50 times bigger then you need somebody else to play that game with I think that’s where we should be heading together.

Jonah:

Nice. What an appeal for higher level partnership. And I saw someone from one of the Amazon dial in right as you were saying that. So, we’re in the right place. Okay. Two more questions for me and then I’m going to bring the questions in from the audience. So, for those of you who have questions, feel free to raise your hand, indicate your interest in the chat. So just in a couple minutes those will come forward so please go ahead and prepare those. Second to last question for me Ana Carina can you tell us a little bit of the work that has done to support Amazon carbon markets?

Ana Carolina Avzaradel Szklo:

Yeah. Well that was one of my main expertise areas before I joined especially because it was one of the segments that I took care of when I was in the government as a negotiator within the UNOC and then in the private sector within Sebis we did proposals and we engaged very closely with the private sector and the government to make that agenda fly. It’s not something that tackles directly in terms of working on the carbon market. We just did maybe two three weeks ago a dialogue that we have established with Wilson Center that is here represented by Ana Pruza.

It was an intended dialogue between Brazil and the United States and we began that dialogue through article six and carbon markets. So that’s something that we are we are boosting. But we are coming more from the ground. So not directly to the carbo market but mainly trying to make it viable because people will look will usually look at it in a top-down approach. For instance we have in Brazil our end our NDC one of the most important thing is to reforest 12 million hectares by 2030. We don’t have enough quality seeds to do that but nobody’s really looking at it.

So that’s some of the things that does. We see from the projects on the ground that they don’t have seeds quality seeds where they stand. So they have to buy seeds from elsewhere. Well from which from the bio perspective it’s definitely not the best solution. So we incentivize that they be that they establish networks that they provide capacity building. That was an agenda strongly impacted by the pandemic. But we were beginning in Baya for instance to gather some indigenous tribes very poor ones so that they could also collect seeds directly and realize that there’s economic potential behind it and also fostering some studies so that we can try to visualize the full potential that the value chain the specific value chain we’re looking at can provide.

Sometimes we’re only looking at the seeds, but we can explore a lot of other potential that are within in terms of oil or sustainable tourism if we’re talking about lavender for instance, which is beautiful. Everybody wants to see cosmetics or pharmaceutical industry. So there’s a lot more that we can do in that in that arena. So is much more working on the ground with the seeds with cocoa plantation as an important strategy to reduce deforestation in par state for instance. They are also here now trying to prove a thesis, a theory that shows that you can actually get a high a higher quality cacao if it is planted near or within a much more complex and diverse forest area, which would be amazing if we get to that.

And we are trying to also start to monitor the pos the extent of carbon that is stocked through the plantation because if you talk about there’s a specific way to plant cacao we call it kabuka because you have the low the highest part of the trees they are they can cover a lot in terms of shadows. So from photo satality images you can you can capture approximately 90% of the carbon that is being stocked. Even if you don’t go on the ground to measure exactly on the soil how much is being captured by the soil directly but you are can have an idea.

So there’s a lot of initiatives like those that are beginning to take place here and we are trying to connect with them and incentivize local producers that are not part of this agenda to start incorporating and bringing indicators that make them able to monitor the carbon stock in the in the plantations. So that’s more where we stand right now.

Jonah:

Great. And then last question from me and then I throw you to the audience. Would you mind telling us just about a couple of your grantees that you haven’t mentioned yet?

Ana Carolina Avzaradel Szklo:

Besides rare and wisful center that are already here, I can mention climate ventures. They have a very interesting project in Brazil that tackles in the Amazon the issue of logistics, which is crucial because we have now I live in Rio. We have now access to a lot of products that come from the Amazon, but they’re usually very much more expensive because of logistics. So that’s very important to be tackled. The center of entrepreneurship of the Amazon is also very interesting. They work with young people trying to boost entrepreneurship and at a very early stage.

We are just about to renew a project with them for the third time. EDA that works with us on the acceleration program. They launched just recently the AMAS program. We have now TED with us from USID and from the PPA that I had just been mentioning you to Sittowi SITAWI also works with it with us in the PPA. They have a very interesting platform that allows people to invest directly in projects. So not only gathering resources from companies and institutions but from people directly and that was one of us one of our main concerns within the pandemic because in 2020 we were in a very interesting stage of confidence of trust and people were coming in to support directly some social impact business in the Amazon and we were afraid that because of the pandemic and the slowdown of the business we would have also slowdown investments.

So we came across also along with USA and other partners to make it happen so that they could they could breathe a little bit longer. I can also mention Conexus Institute Conexus they do a very important and interesting work and especially with the communities in the Amazon. So, so something I think it’s important to understand and for me it’s a gap is that we usually when we talk about inclusiveness what people have on their minds is that they will invite people after they have a project that has been developed and presented and publicized.

Then they will invite people to they will present and they will invite people to talk about it and listen to what they have to say. But it’s completely different if you invite them at the first stage of the project to build a project with you to develop it with you to learn about what are their needs what they want not just to tell them what they need it’s completely different and I think conus has an important role in that agenda and just to close I would also mention fun we are just to beginning with them a project and they are a very important player on the ground when we talk about entrepreneurship because they go from the beginning of the journey when you when you try to understand how where innovation where the process of innovation comes from how the how do you boost it how because otherwise I feel that you already start talking but you’re in the middle of the story so you’re in the tunnel but you’re you’re not at the beginning where you can boost more ideas to different projects that can be developed.

So you’re beginning where people already have some notion of what they’re going to do and you try to help to make it better. But you can you can you we have to enlarge the beginning of this journey with more ideas for more projects for more diversity. That’s where we want to be tackling right now.

Jonah:

Great. Okay, questions from the audience. Feel free to come off mic, raise your hand.

Susan Keane:

Hi. Hi Jonah, it’s Susan Keane. Go.

Jonah:

For it.

Susan Keane:

Hi. Thanks for the presentation. I was very interested in what you said about partnership between the private sector and public sector. And you mentioned that one of the things as a you know philanthropists can do is really be the experimenters and you know document the results of certain experiments and then you know h help that mobilize the private capital. But one question I have for that is specifically you know have you what have you done to document the results in a way that attracts the capital because my experience has been that public projects often document results but document certain kinds of impacts and metrics that aren’t necessarily you know the same impacts and metrics that the private sector cares about.

So do you work with private sector partners in advance to make sure that you’re monitoring and evaluating the kinds of impacts that will attract them in the future?

Ana Carolina Avzaradel Szklo:

Bingo. I think that’s the main point. Susan, thanks for the question. I think mainly the institutions they work very internally when you talk about metrics and indicators. We had some conversations for instance with BNDS because our main target u women institute works to contribute with sustainable development focusing on income generation and it’s not easy to follow up on income generation if people don’t even know exactly how to calculate how to measure so we approached the BNDS to understand how they were monitoring this type of indicator through the Amazon fund that they also had a lot of difficulties so when I joined Umani by the end of 2019 and then I was able in 2020 to go to Baya and visit some plantations and talk to the to the local people.

Then I understood exactly what numbers they had. They have they have everything. I started talking to IDB for instance because they were also tackling at targeting large investors and saying well we never have the good projects there aren’t good projects I’m looking at the pipeline and I don’t see anything so when I when I explained to them what we’re doing with cacao they said okay that’s a good project do you have the number say yeah I have the number so what we need to do right now is exactly to address the question you brought is to put that and bring a narrative because I think the numbers we have everything from what how much you can since how much you put in terms of financial resources exactly how it translates into productivity into a higher aggregated value that comes to the to the agriculture.

How much they can produce more and where the markets the but the difficulty now in Brazil is that we have specifically in this value chain we have the price of the commodity is very high. So the incentives for organic more quality cocoa is very low right now. So that’s something that we’re dealing with trying to attract the private sector by dealing directly with private investors impact investors that turned to be very successful and very quickly and now in a in a more slow pace we’re doing conversations with the main big banks in Brazil such as the Brazil bank and bringing to them chocolate producers so that they can provide a guarantee so that we can try to access more credit and directly capital because otherwise it’s not going to tackle everybody I mean just to give you an idea we launched a financial instrument financial instrument last year with an approximate amount of a million he that is able to help about 150 families in Baya, but we have 40,000.

So, it’s not it’s a it’s a very nice experience, but it’s definitely not going to be the solution. And we have Pronafi, which is where we tackle public funding in Brazil, but we need to restore the confidence that B the banks lost in the family agriculture. So that is a lot of talking and especially within the pandemic. I’m mentioning Kaka because from my experience I think it’s a value chain from which we can learn and bring the rationale to answer your question and to be the example for several others because it’s easy to tackle to identify the challenge that we have before us which is mainly lack of access to credit lines and technical assistance and then we have different models of solutions that we have been experimenting and then on the second and third year you say okay this works we have been for instance before we launched this credit line we engaged with several family offices in Brazil to understand what were their concerns they say and they told me well I think you’re in the right path but just try exper bring me the numbers and then you won’t know what to do with so much capital that’s going to come in to a project like this.

So I think now it’s the time to organize that narrative and put the numbers forward. We were at this moment still gathering the feedback. So for instance in this first year out of 82 people that gathered credit in the first six months 81 of them has already paid back and we only don’t know the information with regard to last one. It’s not that they he didn’t pay back but we just don’t couldn’t couldn’t have the answer. So it’s very effective and in contrary to what we have with regard to the banks for instance because their return rate is very low.

So that’s why we need to engage and have a lot of conversations with them. But I think we’re on the on the right track but your concern is the same as mine.

Jonah:

Great. Thank you. Other questions? People feel free to come off of mute. As we wait for other people to come off mute, I’ll go ahead and hop in with a question which is in addition to cacao, is there another promising agroforestry commodity or opportunity that you guys have been zeroing in on to invest in the capacity of?

Ana Carolina Avzaradel Szklo:

Yeah, we’ve be we’ve been doing a lot with regard to seeds and I think this is an agenda that a lot of institutions are interested in. We also work with honey but I think that’s more complimentary. It’s a small still small village chain in Brazil and but it can provide an additional funding for the agriculture because regardless of the potential of the bees directly helping with the specific culture that is being planted. But if you only work with the box of the bees, you can have an additional maybe 800 he eyes per box that they can sell.

So that’s something interesting and the women can deal with it directly while men is out there on the on the field. Something interesting that I just read this weekend. It’s not something that we work directly. It’s the cashew. We have in Brazil we call it Brazilian cashew or para cashew. But it’s something that only grows in the Amazon. And now from what I’ve seen, Bolivia has taken 94% of the international market because you have just we have as with peanuts and corn. There’s a specific a specific characteristic can it can be a toxin that you have to control.

And if you don’t to export that to Europe is much more complicated. So Bolivia developed a way to identify that toxin and to clear it and also I don’t know what how but also to by providing human safety conditions to do that because it’s basically by using u I think ultrasound lights that you can identify the toxin. So basically now they buy they buy it from Brazil and sell it back to us and then sell it also to Europe. So that’s a huge potential as holds a huge potential but of course you have to always understand and that’s my main concern when you talk about other chains is to understand the possible negative impacts that they have.

For instance, asai depending on how it is collected, you can have a very serious issue of child labor and it’s very difficult to track it down because you usually not talking directly to the people that plan. There’s always somebody in between and then you lose track. So it’s very important I think to work on an agenda of certification of keeping track that you can actually guarantee that everything is being done in an environment and social best way practices possible.

Jonah:

Other questions for Anna? Do you have questions for the audience? Anna.

Ana Carolina Avzaradel Szklo:

Yeah. What are if I can address some questions more broadly. Usually I think when we engage people from Brazil, especially those that are on the ground, we’ll try to understand what do I have to do to make a project ready for investment? What are what how do you see a good project and what would make international investment to come in? What are what are the main concerns? We know the obvious ones, but how can we address and go beyond on the conversation because I honestly feel that we do a lot of talking and I find it hard to actually get it on the action.

So, how can we make it happen together because otherwise I love the conversation and we’ll be having plenty of those but I think we all want more than that.

Jonah:

Fernando, you came off video. Feel free to.

Fernando:

I just have one single word, accountability. It seems so easy concept, but it’s so hard when we work in different countries and environments to be accountable and sometimes donors and funders, they look for that at first.

Jonah:

I’d say that one of the primary stumbling blocks for outside investors is the fear of going first. So I if someone else has already put money into an investment ready project, surely it must be investment ready. So g getting that first line of capital is a great stumbling block for many would be first time money arriving to the region. Others I know perhaps you could answer your own question if you have ideas.

Ana Carolina Avzaradel Szklo:

Yeah, I think we can we can evolve and maybe I can throw you a follow-up question also because we also come from different cultures and perspectives. So when you say about it’s hard to step up first and I understand that would it make it easier because what I’m what I’m thinking here is we already support a lot of projects so I can just bring a portfolio and say where we’re in and where people can join. But some partners want to develop it together from the ground and really understand and put everything together or others are find it easier to come in and say well I have a local partner he did that he did his homework and he understand this is the right path, and I can come in along with him.

And I get Fernando’s point that’s very important with regard to accountability maybe something that we could work on is to have more transparency because internally I think all institutions they have their accountability and very rigid ones, but that’s something more that’s more an internal conversation than external or at least with partners that are very close so that we can actually open up in a conversation and say well this is a safe space this is risky but let’s do it together and I think what I would love to do is to be able to have that level of conversation with international partners to say well these are our concerns would you like to join in and in trying to figure out together with us or would you would you also be able to risk with us?

We can we can take the first weeks. Can you take the second one? We’ll join in the second or third year and we do the first for instance. We have we can be creative in terms of modeling. But if we can have a better sense of how to engage in that conversation, maybe we can have a bigger chance of making it happen.

Jonah:

This sounds like a good invitation to the wider network and to those on this call. There is a lot of foreign money that comes wants to come into the Amazon but isn’t sure entirely sure how to do so or whom to partner with. And so a wide open call for opportunities for learning and collaboration I think could get some really interesting people to show up. I have seen three or four separate initiatives in the Amazon that are all trying to solve the transparency and accountability problem using some sort of new incarnation of blockchain.

Whether it’s tracing wood coming in and out or bringing the magic of blockchain to last mile financial transactions or taking the increased connectivity that’s coming with Starlink starting this December in the Amazon you know to be able to take pictures and GPS coordinates inside of apps there’s a whole cottage industry of startups that are trying to use technology to solve these origination you know, and supply chain transparency problems that have existed in the past. So maybe getting some of them together with the on the ground Brazilian grant makers could allow us to discover things or put together new coalitions that haven’t existed previously.

Would anyone else like to add to that brainstorm?

Louisa:

Yeah, Jonah, it’s Louisa, may I jump in?

Jonah:

Sure. Yes.

Louisa:

First, thank you so much for the invitation. Okay, so I am Louisa. I’ve been working in the Amazon over 20 years. Right now, I’m talking from out of floresta. I am deeply in the frontier. And I just want to share that what you just said I think it’s very important that we understand how much those technologies I would say not only blockchain but I would say around tokens I am absolutely convinced that this is what we are lacking right now to match to make a match between whoever is willing to support the different supply chains around sustain ustainable production and producers and those that own directly the asset.

And this is a what I call we have what I call a middle miss we have a gap we have a problem there because there’s so much resources worldwide but it’s so hard that it comes really to the ground for those that really have to have their services or their assets like environmental assets compensated and I’m very much convinced that the we’re going to have a revolution when we learn how to match the digital economy, blockchain and tokens with the opportunities that we have on the ground because they exactly can help us fill the gap that Anna has just said around transparency and trust.

And I think that transparency and trust is something that this is the revolution that we can have with those new technologies that we did not have so far in the past two decades when we were already trying to make it greener let us say this way and to support the different supply chains. So that’s it just to introduce myself. I didn’t know you personally and to say that I’m very much aligned with what you just said. Great. Anna, do you wanna Anna Louisa, do you want to tell us a little bit more about your institutional work?

Unidentified participant:

Wow. Okay. So, I have started my work 25 years ago here in the Amazon. I graduated in S. Paulo and the my very first company was actually the very first benefit corporation in the whole Latin America. So when we call the B corps the benefit corporations this benefit corporation that we had it was like 200 2013 was called veri Amazonia that was the very first company that I created with my ex-husband and we used to work with indigenous communities and we had a topofart extra virgin oil from Brazil at that time that was 2001 2002 two, we started this company.

Our product went to France, went to we exported it and it was in the almost all the markets in S. Paulo, in Rio, all over Brazil, but at that time very few people talked about what we’re talking these days like we were back in 2002. So at that time it was hard to convince people that it was very important to be fair trade. So we had a fair trade company and back in 2014 we sold the company to investors and after I left the company I started working for the IFC World Bank helping because I live in the I mean I’ve always had a very deep connection with the Amazon.

I started supporting the word bank on creating the criterias for greener supply chains around agro around forestry but also around the agro because where I live right now the agro business was coming so hard it was it’s really the frontier so I worked for some years with the word bank and after that I joined the owner of Natura it’s called Pedro Pas one of the owners of the company Natura. I worked personally with him for eight years trying to work on public private partnerships around public conservation areas. So we were trying to see how we could support conservation in the Amazon through public private partnerships around what we have as public areas because we have a lot of public areas and they should be taking care of them.

And just recently I just recently I joined another initiative. So now I’m working with some people from capital markets and.

Jonah:

We’re running out of time.

Unidentified participant:

Yes. Sorry. So that’s it. That’s.

Jonah:

Okay. Okay. Great. So what we hear in that is you’re a great collaborator for these supply chain and tracing and accountability task. So we will certainly be reaching out about that. So we have three minutes left in the call. Anna, thank you so much for your time. Would you like to have any closing words or welcome any closing requests from the audience? Anna,.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you so much.

Jonah:

You bet.

Ana Carolina Avzaradel Szklo:

Now just to thank you Janna for the kind invite. I remain at your disposal and everybody else’s so that we can continue this conversation. And I think it was the first conversation not ours but with many others and I think we should continue and go forward. So congrats on the initiative. It’s I think something extremely healthy that you are providing for everybody in creating this space. I think it’s very important that we do something about it. So that’s my invite for everybody. Thank you.

Jonah:

Great. Anyone else? I’m going to go ahead and call out one person, David Bane, could you just tell us about the idea of tree ID? I think it’s relevant for this conversation.

David:

Oh, hey. Yeah, sure thing. Very briefly in the universe of unique identifier schemes there is an initiative underway here in Washington and with Western Governor’s University to build a unique identifier framework for individual trees and I hope at sometime soon I’ll be able to give a presentation to our group here about how that’s going. It has many interesting opens many interesting possibilities for forestation and carbon credits and everything connected to that. Thank you Jonah.

Jonah:

Great. It’s so interesting the Amazon this center of human history and legacy yet the conversations to save the regions turn to the role of new technology and transforming the story on the ground. Super interesting. Okay, we’re at the top of the hour unless there’s anyone else. Thank you everybody for your time. Anna, Carlina, thank you so much for joining us. I think we’re all going to be excited to learn more about Institutani and your work and your portfolio moving forward and your style of collaboration. It’s been a great learning process and I look forward to more.

So we’re now transitioning over to what we call water cooler time. You’re everyone is welcome to leave. This is where we end the structured conversation and move into unstructured stuff and I you know eventually stop the recording and we get into the meat and potatoes of what we learned together and things like that. Are you able to stick around for a little bit Anna Carolini?

Ana Carolina Avzaradel Szklo:

Unfortunately not. But I have another meeting starting right now. But thank you very much for the invitation again.

Jonah:

Okay. Again, thank you so much for joining us. We’re going to leave open the chat room for people to copy links and things like that. And I’ll remain here.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you.