Forest-friendly Export Opportunities of the Brazilian Amazon

One of the biggest questions for the future of the Amazon is how to boost regenerative and low-carbon economic development. While many responses involve the search for new products or markets, Amazon has great room for expansion in the markets of the products its companies already export. What are the market opportunities? How will local Amazonian governments expedite them? What regulations can be applied for the enforcement of labor, environmental, food safety, and other issues? How can governments promote economic development despite certain restrictions? Join us to learn and meet Salo Coslovsky, an Associate Professor at New York University and an affiliated researcher with the Amazonia 2030 project. At NYU, he teaches courses related to government agencies, national development strategies, and local economic development. He conducted his undergraduate studies at FGV-SP, masters at the Fletcher School of Law & Diplomacy, and his doctorate at MIT.

Recorded August 16, 2021

References:

Salo Coslovsky’s website

Amazonia 2030 -Forest Friendly Export Opportunities of the Brazilian Amazon

Adoption andDiffusion of Green Innovation in Brazil

The Enforcement ofLabor Laws in Brazil

The Case ForSustainable Development

The EconomicImportance of the Amazon

WATCH:

  • Jonah
  • Salo Coslovsky
  • Tatiana
  • Yoli
  • Juliana
  • Jose
  • Danielle

Jonah:

Hello everybody. Welcome to the 54th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing force friendly economic development AC and the rule of law across the Amazon region of South America. We are a program of the global governance philanthropy network and supported by Nexus and a whole bunch of other stakeholders. And this week we are featuring the work of Salo Coslovsky of NYU and he has been focusing on forest friendly exports of the Brazilian Amazon and ways that economy and that kind of economic development can reduce deforestation pressure and improve lots of indicators in the region, environmental indicators, economic indicators, you name it.

Salo, the floor is yours.

Salo Coslovsky:

Thanks, Jonah. It’s a pleasure. Thanks everybody for coming. I see a few of my friends and colleagues here too. It’s a privilege. And let me So, I’m gonna introduce myself very briefly, move on to a presentation and try to save as much time as we can at the end for a discussion conversation. I’m Salo Coslovsky. I’m originally from São Paulo, Brazil. I live in the US. I’ve been living in the US for 20 years roughly. I’m now calling actually from Maine. I’m based out of New York, but I’m with family here in Maine.

Beautiful nature. And I’m going to share my screen to discuss to show you a little bit of what I’ve been up to in my research. So the idea here, so this is a part of the Amazonia 2030 research project. A very large research project based out of Brazil with multi-disiplinary team. We have maybe last estimate about a 100 different researchers and everybody is trying to tackle the same problem from different angles and the problem is how to promote local economic development in the region. What kind of blueprint would have not for immediate firefighting, the immediate problems that the region faces and not for the far future, something sort of mid-range, hence the name 2030 and my in this research I so what I try to do is find what are pragmatic possible options for moving ahead.

The debates on forest friendly economic development tend to revolve around three topics or three options. People love to talk about carbon credits and especially now voluntary markets because that’s the only one that addresses forests in Brazil. So that’s one kind of hot topic. There’s another hot topic is the discovery of new products and compounds. It’s the idea that the forest has is a has a hidden reservoir of wealth in terms molecules and enzymes and bioactive ingredients that can be harvested and help pay for the conservation of the forest itself. And the third theme is what in the Amazon people talk about in Brazil in Brazilian Amazon as agrearvalure to add value is usually what they mean is to process locally the ingredients that they tend to sell in raw form.

So you do the cosmetics as opposed to selling the oil. You do the final package products as opposed to selling the food ingredient and so forth. So those are the main avenues that people talk about and they are all very important and very promising. So this is not to dismiss any of them. But what I want to highlight is that there’s a fourth option that has been neglected for far too long and has a lot of promise as well. And this four fourth option is the idea that we can export much larger quantities of the primary products that are already in Amazon’s portfolio.

So the idea here is that we have to do more and do better of what’s already being done. It’s a fairly in some ways conservative or unambitious path. We’re not talking about inventing new things, not about creating new markets. Just let’s see what we already have, what we already know how to do. Maybe you can do a little more, a little better. That’s the idea behind what I’m going to discuss. When I present this, maybe this group is different. When I present this to Brazil, people ask me, why exports? Brazil is such a huge country.

It’s such a huge market and it’s so underexplored. Why should we look abroad? And I give four reasons. First is that global markets are incredibly large and tend to be fairly profitable. So there’s no reason to neglect that. The second reason that exports are a litmos task of competence. You have to I mean selling locally is not that difficult. Selling nationally is not difficult but it’s not that hard either. But selling internationally you need to be the best. There is no fudging around. You cannot get a can get some support but you have to be competent.

So it’s a it’s an indicator that you’re doing very well if you manage to export your products and that’s important when you try to design public policies you can use that and see who is doing a good job if they exporting they’re doing a good job so you can support them. Third is that in addition to being a test, it’s also an engine of upgrading of competence. When you export, you get in touch with investors. We get in touch with new market tendencies or trends. You get you make new connections.

It creates new opportunities for you to keep growing. So you have to be good to export. But once you start to export, it helps you stay good or get better. And even if for the business people it’s like you know what I could have the same kind of profit selling locally selling globally. Why should I get the headache of selling globally when I can be equally do equally well selling locally? Well for the local economy exporting creates a lot of positive spillover effects because it’s more demanding. You need better lawyers, better accountants, better consultants, better everything to be able to export and that forces everybody to be better.

And so that’s good. Might not be good necessarily for individual but it’s good for the economy. So that’s why I want to focus on exports. So what did I do with this research? All countries in the world pretty much they are members of a treaty in which they agree to use a standardized catalog of products to report the international trade transactions. So that’s mostly for tariff purposes, but researchers like me tag along or piggyback on this to understand who is selling what to whom. So we have this catalog has 5,000 products.

It’s not super detailed, but it’s detailed enough. In Brazil, I’m lucky that you get these numbers by state. So, I can single out the Amazon from the rest of the country and see what the Amazon is selling to whom and how does that compare to everybody else. So, I get a detailed picture of international trade. Once I collected this data, assembled this data set and start crunching it, first thing that shows up is that the standard products that are the bread and butter so to speak or the heavy duty, the heavy heaters of the Amazonian e Brazilian Amazonian economy are not forest products or forest friendly at all.

It’s the standard what you’d expect. Soy is a big carry a lot of weight. Iron ore carries a lot of weight and the other eight products in this list are equally largecale agriculture or mining. Talking about cotton, talking about corn, talking about wood pulp from plantations. They represent roughly 80% of the export portfolio. These 10 products, 80% of the export revenues in the Amazon. And that’s what people tend to talk about. What I did is look at the bottom of not the top of the list but at the bottom of the list.

The whole list has almost a thousand products that the Amazon already exports here. When I say Amazon I mean Brazilian Amazon. This thousand products. So what I did is that I put them through a fine comb and a magnifying glass so to speak and to look at each one of them to try to find those that are potentially friendly to the forest that can be produced in relative harmony with the environment. And by this I mean products that are originating in wild harvest, products that are typical of agroforestry systems, fish and aquaculture and tropical fruits and vegetables.

It doesn’t mean that they are intrinsically unequivocally friendly to the forest. Anything that you do in large scale or you do sloppily or you do with disregard for the environment can be damaging. What these products what distinguish these products that they can’t they it’s much easier to make them competitive with the forest than anything else. So that’s what I mean here by forest friendly. And when I put those thousand products through this magnifying glass, I found 64 that me and my colleagues we examine them all say you know what these 64 are potentially forest friendly.

And that’s the list that you see in your screen in the Brazilian Amazon. The biggest one, the most important one is black pepper and black pepper hole. Those little dark grains. The Amazon already exports around 100 million of that product and they represent a third of the Amazonian forest friendly portfolio. The list goes on and has other products. Has fish here is mostly talking about seawater fish in fact from the Atlantic coast of the Amazon has acai that’s hidden here under the juice and other fruits has palm oil has Brazil nuts and the list goes on.

In total the 64 forest friendly products they bring a revenue around $300 million to the Amazon per here. For Brazil that’s not a lot of money in total exports is almost $40 billion so 300 million is not a lot but if you consider these are products coming out of indigenous communities small peasants kilon ballers which are maroon communities or riverine communities $300 million exchange rate of five and 5.3 it’s a billion dollars a year a billion he eyes a year is not so the there’s there is some capacity on the ground.

And this is maybe the highest impact slide that I have and the punch line one of the punchlines of this research is that what I did next said okay what’s the global market for the same 64 products I’m not here about inventing new products are not in the Amazonian portfolio yet maybe what if we could produce it I’m talking about the ones already there. There’s already somebody in the Brazilian Amazon that can produce these things. How well are they doing? Not well at all. The global market for the 64 products is 176 billion.

So each one of these green balls represents a billion dollars. So we have 176 of those. To find the share of the Brazilian Amazon. Brazilian Amazon has onethird of the global tropical forests. So 33% roughly. Its market share in the products it already produces and exports is 0.17. So you need a magnifying glass to find this little yellow half a pizza slice here that represents the market share of the Amazon. It’s really small market share that Brazil has given all the resources at its disposal and then I mean this is in the aggregate what happens if you look product by product each one of them people don’t usually tend to think of these products as the engines of growth or the avenues of that’s how you’re going to get rich we how we going to get rich computers electric cars, self-driven, self-driving cars, or black pepper.

I mean, that’s not something you hear very often. But you look at the black pepper market, for instance, that Brazil has $und00 million exports. The global market for that product, that’s the first line here, is $1.5 billion dollars. So, it’s really gigantic. The market for Brazil nuts, shell, so the one they’re ready to eat here. Number seven, Brazil has 16 million. The global market is 364 million. A few products that not even in this list, this list is just the ones that are top 10 in Brazil. If you go down the list, you’re going to find pineapples.

Pineapples has a market. Brazil has a few one or two million dollars of exports. Pineapples are native from the Amazon. By the way, the global market is two to3 billion dollars. Brazil has a percentage that’s just like you need a lot of decimal points to find it. Coco, same thing. People tend to think that Koko is originally from Mexico because the Aztecs and pre-Colombian times peoples in people in Mexico were the ones who really developed a technique of using it. It’s actually comes originally from is native to the Amazon before spreading through the continent.

The Brazilian Amazon has a tiny percentage of the global market share. The total market for Koko is $9 billion. So we are talking here about really astronomical large numbers. To put this in perspective, the global market for voluntary carbon credits for forests, this is all average for three-year average for 17, 18, 19. So you compare the same number, same period for carbon credits, we’re talking here about $130 million. The car the market for carbon credits is growing very fast, but it has to multi you have to multiply by two and a half tree to so it reaches the size of Brazil nuts.

It has to grow by 10 times to get the current size of black pepper. So these products that have been neglected in Brazilian discussions about development present enormous opportunities and that’s a big message that this research conveys if not Brazil who is doing it who are the leaders in exporting this products people in Brazil sometimes they love to think about sophisticated products they’re going to export chocolate they’re going to export electronics, consumer goods, crackers, and cookies and so forth. To do that, you’re going to compete with Germany, with Israel, with Silicon Valley, US, and so forth.

The products that I’m describing here, you’re competing or you’re operating the same space as other tropical countries. For the most part, are poorer and have less resources than Brazil. The global leader in Braza exports is Bolivia by far. In fact, I just published today a revised version of an earlier report examining the Bolivian story. The global leader in pineapples. So, the pineapple market is $2.3 billion. The global leader is Costa Rica has 50% of that market. Brazil has 0.01% or the Amazon has 0.01%. The market for pepper, the global lead is Vietnam, they have 42% of that market and each one of those products that I’m singling out here, they follow the same pattern.

We have other tropical countries that seem to be doing a much better job than Brazil. So the they one of the next steps for this research is find out how do they do it and what lessons can we learn? How can we cross-pollinate across this these countries, get ideas and resources so they can all advance together in this fight for forest friendly economies and preservation? Why does Brazil have such a tiny market share? So, this is I’m going to bring from a few of other pieces of research that I’ve done, but one that I want to highlight over the past year, I interviewed 45 people involved in the food sector in the Brazilian Amazon.

And to copious notes and transcribe all my interviews and analyzing it, they talk about two a few different things. A lot of them like all business people talk about how much they invest in private goods and services, their facilities, their equipment, their brand, their inventory and so forth. That’s fine. They also talk about their reliance on public goods and services, roads and internet, water, sanitation, electricity, and so forth. In fact, they talk a lot about their need for better public services, but that’s a separate story. Another thing that they talk about a lot that they don’t even they don’t really give a name to but that’s a name that I’m giving.

They talk about what they call shared goods and services and this share they are in between. They’re not private because they benefit all companies in a sector but they’re not public because they only benefit companies in a sector. So they fall in between and they are chronically scarce in the Amazon in more advanced or more developed business environments. These share goods they get provided by many ways by the market itself. In the Amazon you have individual investors doing this. And I’m going to give you a quote that I translated to illustrate.

This is from a person who buys ingredients from the Amazon and sells it to restaurants, processes it, sells to restaurants and home cooks, consumers. Our suppliers, they are not ready to supply. If I need to buy a kilogram of kumaru seeds, it’s not that I can’t call one up and say, “Ship me a kilo of kumaru.” Rather, I need to develop the supplier so I can have a professional supplier. All this working needs to be done and it’s a huge challenge and I call this a sectoral good because this supply once it’s fully developed once you know it’s formalized once you know how to put the label in its packaging when it has proper packaging has proper business procedures and so forth it can supply to anyone it’s not going to supply just to the person who developed it becomes a shared resource the same for techniques on how to quality control which is a very big deal.

The same for understanding the characteristics of the products. What’s the difference between the asai from this region to the asai of that region? What’s what’s the shelf life of these different products? What’s the best way to process it? Which are the markets and what do the markets are looking what people in different markets are looking for? All this kind of knowledge I would qualify as se as shared resources because it’s not something you can keep private. It just ends up benefiting the whole sector. But if it’s not there, somebody has to develop it.

And what we see is a few hero investors developing this shared resources, but not nearly enough. And obviously not enough because it’s shared. So you fall prey to a free writing problem. And then I had another interview that I that this person gave me this quote that I think was one of the best in all the conversations I had in which she said to work together in the Amazon can be quite difficult. People here, they’re like crabs in a cooler. Everyone sniping at everyone else. And whenever someone makes some progress, another one pulls you down.

So yeah, they could work together, but it’s difficult. They’re competitors. It’s hard to get competitors to work together. And but it’s possible and that’s one of the things I discuss in my Brazila research that I just published an updated version today and I’m getting close to my to the end of the of the presentation but this slide here the chart on your left show exports to the EU from Brazil and Brazil not exports to the EU from Brazil and from Bolivia back in year 2000 they were even since then the Brazilian exports collapsed.

That’s the blue line. And the Bolivian exports took off. And the reason is that according to my research has to do with food safety, sanitary controls. On the graph on the right shows the border apprehensions, the rejections of shipments that were prevented from getting into the EU because they’re contaminated. Brazil had a spike in year 2000 1, two, and three. Eventually got so bad and it got so difficult to get Brazilian shipments to the EU that the EU closed its market to Brazil and Brazil gave up exporting to the EU.

Bolivia sale true has very few rejections throughout and managed to get a monopoly almost a monopoly on that market and they did that by working together. The Bolivian firms, they’re still competitors. They still hate each other, but they created us a way in which they all pitch in to have a convenient, cheap and fast turnar around lab very next door. In fact, it’s housed within their business association. They managed to hire experts in this case where con they got consultants here from the University of Georgia. They had expertise in controlling aphletoxin in peanuts and they imported they brought them over to Bolivia to teach them how to control aphletoxins in Brazil nuts and that’s how Bolivia managed to do so well in the EU market and now from then on globally.

This type of cooperation is what I’m studying next in my research. There’s plenty of cases both in Brazil and abroad and they often get ignored or dismissed. So some of the cases that I’m looking at there’s a famous one in Petrolina which the northeast of Brazil in which they produce irrigated fruits especially grapes and mangoes and understand how those farms managed to work together. There’s a case interesting case in S. Follow in which sugar prod and ethanol producers managed to work together to upgrade their capacity. And one case that I’m just finishing to write a paper on that’s fascinating is on specialty coffee in Brazil.

In all these cases, people at the outset say it’s impossible. It cannot be done. It’s far from our reach. Competitors never going to work together. And today you look at the specialty coffee in Brazil that’s 20 30 years after the naysayers are saying it’s impossible. They bring in a revenue of1 billion dollars by working together to improve their quality and create the shared resources that they that they all need. So what I’m doing is trying to understand from these cases what kind of insights we can be transferred and applied in the Amazon.

And it’s the product of this research suggesting that’s the way to help these industries that have been underperforming for so long to catch up with what with their full potential. Thank you.

Jonah:

Great. Thank you so much for the presentation. I’m going to ask one question and then I’d like to open up for questions. Everybody else Tatiana Bautellio already has a question lined up. My first question to you is I believe the word that you have that I’ve read and that you’ve used to describe these market collaborations are pre-competitive arrangements. Is there a how do you find these? Are is there a list of precompetitive arrangements out there? How do you go about studying them? And then I’ll end by saying please put your email in the chat.

People will follow up there and everyone else is also welcome to introduce themselves in the chat and include your LinkedIn contact information to facilitate networking. Salo,.

Salo Coslovsky:

Thanks John. I know this is this a key question. People tend to think of competition. That’s easy and obvious. That’s what companies do in the market and if they get together that’s collusion. They’re going to try to manipulate prices and defraud somebody just they’re going to try to gain at somebody else’s expense. That’s these are well-known sort of ways that we think about firms in the marketplace. C collusion versus competition. But there’s this space in between these two things that it’s cooperation that is not well understood. It’s not well studied.

People don’t even tend to pay a lot of attention to it. But I a lot of my research has shown that it’s fairly prevalent. It happens a lot especially more sophisticated sectors. And has a lot of potential. The firms, they have a lot of competing interests. Of course, everybody wants to be the biggest, the fastest, the strongest, but they also have shared interests. They all need to know how to prevent affltoxin in Brazil nuts. I mean, the Brazil nut market is less than 2% of the global edible nut market. And here, I’m not even talking peanuts, just talking about almonds, pistachios, macadamia, cashews, and so forth.

Brazonut is really an afterthought in that market. Very few people here in the US and elsewhere I would say know that every single one comes from wild harvest by indigenous people that is intrinsically sustainable and all the benefits of consuming more Braz how this would go directly into the forest. It’s to everybody’s every single producers’s interest to advance this image. In the US, you have all these campaigns got milk and avocado and pig and all these commodities. All these producers, they found ways to work together to advance their interest. That’s an example of precompetitive arrangement.

In the Amazon, you have very little of that and I think we should have more. But of course, it’s not something that you it’s not that easy to create where it where it doesn’t exist. And so that’s the challenge. How do you do it? And how to do it in a way that is really to everybody’s interest and not to be captured by a few of the more leading companies. So it’s a tricky balance. How do you find it? You keep I mean to me I just keep my antennas up and keep sniffing because I see it all the time and then like let me learn more about this.

Let me learn more about this and that’s how I’ve been collecting these cases. But I’m always open to hear more stories of people who have seen this specimen in the wild.

Jonah:

Great. My guess is that there has been substantial research on precompetitive arrangements in other markets around the world and perhaps some knowledge there can be adapted for the Amazon. Okay. Now we throw it out to you. Tatiana, you’re up next. Please introduce yourself in addition to your question.

Tatiana:

Hi everybody. I’m Tatiana. I work for the climate and land use alliance. I’m responsible for the community forest management portfolio. Thank you very much. It’s nice to see you again. I was wondering if you have an idea of how much I mean I know you said we have 0.17 I mean we as the Amazon Brazilian Amazon 0.17% of these markets and by how much do you think it’s necessary to increase in order to have like an economy that can face the deforestation economy and if you have an idea of how much investment is necessary to do that.

Salo Coslovsky:

Oh, hi Tatiana. And those are great and very difficult questions. I don’t think that a market-based solution like what I’m discussing here can stand on its own or can even be expected to hold this massive challenge of preserve preservation on.

Tatiana:

Can I just say one thing quickly? Amazon in 2015 had put a number out of 700 million US. That’s the amount of forest economy that was necessary. I don’t know if you’ve seen this number or where it comes from, but looking at your numbers, especially at the numbers of the deforestation economy, it seems like 700 million is low for.

Salo Coslovsky:

You know I haven’t seen this number. I mean, Amazon is pretty reliable and I’m they are lead leading members of this Amazonia 2030 project that I’m involved in and in fact I’m a board member at Amazon now since of last year. But what I would say is that none of what I’m saying here precludes the need for monitoring for enforcement for having strict laws and being sure that they are enforced. And luckily Brazil has very fairly strong conservation laws. I mean they fluctuates back and forth a little but they are not bad in aggregate.

And he has shown that he knows how to protect the forest when he wants to. There was massive decrease in the forestation between 2004 to 14 or so. And that’s I would say it’s essential you get not just to channel activities in the right ways but also for asurances all these companies so let’s just take a step back all the companies are buying cocoa from ivory coast Ghana and Nigeria but especially from ivory cos all these large multinationals they all have a huge lawsuit on their backs here in the US for aiding and abetting child labor and they are kind of like running around trying like how what they going to do about that well in Brazil they would have the advantage that until recently the government had a very strong labor enforcement system that would help them make sure that they have no child labor in their supply chains.

So not only is necessary to pro to channel activities in the right direction, but it can even be helpful as these companies get more pressed more and more to respect with their commitments to labor and environment. Another thing is that what I’m describing here is the beginning I would say beginning of a dynamic like you get the ball rolling by supporting this these industries and then they get a breath they get some sort of speed on their own. They start lobbying the go the lobbying the government is another shared resource once if you had a strong Brazil sector they would be lobbying the government for more support for more resources for better loss for themselves instead of just fighting with each other just sniping each other at this crabs in a in a cooler and the same for all the other sectors.

So in a sense what we need it’s not that we need an in a number and an infusion of capital when this ball gets rolling they going to start knocking on doors they’re going to start demanding proper credit lines they’re going to start looking for investors domestically and abroad a lot of the things that we think are ingredients that can be should have to be brought from the outside once you get the right dynamic going they can be produced from within so that’s why I’m just not I don’t think that trying to come up with a number it might even send the wrong message.

I think getting the right dynamic is more important than having a number of course but at first getting the right dynamic you need a there’s need for investment there’s need for support but eventually hope what you hope is that it’s going to move on its own.

Jonah:

Great. Tatiana you okay good you satisfied you got okay great.

Salo Coslovsky:

I avoided her question but that’s the best that’s the best you’re gonna get from me I guess.

Jonah:

Good enough next up Yoli.

Yoli:

Hello everyone hi thank you Salo for your exposure here today was great just a quick introduction here I’m Wii I’m an advisor for institutional projects at Elay which is a network for local government and we are connected to cities all over the world and we’ve been questioned about as we are in Brazil we’ve been questioned about the Amazon area and my question is focused on if you have studied articulation of partnerships with local or with local governments for this compatible production matter. I know it’s a huge economy economic matter that you have been studying but we believe that local governments here in Brazil especially in Amazon have a really strategic action.

So I’d like to know if you have thought about that or I don’t know.

Salo Coslovsky:

And let me ask you a quick a quick question. Do local you mean municipal, state or both?

Yoli:

Especially municipal, but we do work with regional metropolitanian areas or big important area that are connected, especially in the Amazon. Because it’s such a huge territory, usually small cities that are really well connected, we already consider a very strategic point for territory. So we believe in regions too. So local means all that for us.

Salo Coslovsky:

So I’ve been I’ve been talking in the context of this research a lot with the state government especially with para and they are very which is pretty much the elephant in the room here. They are the heavy hitters. All these numbers that if you I’m now breaking down the study state by state and par is by far the biggest in terms of the products he has and the market potential market that it could reach. So it’s really the main show here is PA and I’ve been fortunate enough that people in the state of PA has been very interested in this stuff and they want to create a different sort of initiatives to support this these industries in their territory.

So this is early stages but it’s moving. I know that people in other states are also interested at the state level next this week or next week. So for people who are not following the Brazilian a lot historically the federal government in Brazil is the one that calls the shots in the Amazon for many reasons and state and municipal are kind of like secondary tertiary actors over the past couple years as you can imagine the federal government has been totally missing in action not to say playing for the other team.

So the governors are taking matters in their own hands and they created their own coalition of governments. You back in the day that you used to call federal government but now it’s called the coalition of government governors and they are pushing for their own pro- sustainable agenda and I they all I know they also interested in this so I’m working with them at that level at municipal level I haven’t been we haven’t made any inroads but I’m not the one to dismiss potential allies I know that people tend to think that municipal governments don’t have a lot of leverage in the region But it I take whatever we can get and there’s plenty of there’s a not plans but there are cases of municipal governments that really have been very proactive in fostering the kind of policies that we defend here and of course the prime example is Paragon Minas which has a famous story of being lawless wild west some decades ago to shifting its stance completely to be a much to be a much different place today.

So I think there is opportunities for municipal governments to get involved as well. I personally part of my group we haven’t had made inroads yet but I would love to be in touch if you have advice.

Jonah:

Great was that it.

Yoli:

Yeah thank you was just I would like to share to with you all then this forum that we it’s new actually we are starting it’s based on cities for cities on the Amazon territory, but it’s all in the South America and we have a lot of these matters that interest all the mayors on that forum. So, I’ll just share with you all the web link for that discussion too.

Jonah:

Great. Feel free to feature that. Okay, other people other questions feel free to post or to come off mute. I have a question. Salo. I am familiar with one coalition of Amazon organizations that is trying to promote an Amazonwide brand. They would just like got milk as a campaign in the United States increased milk consumption. The ideas that you know got Amazon or got Amazon rainforest can be a way to encourage people from Sa Paulo and other large markets to increase their consumption of sustainable produce in the region. Is there a chance that you have connected with that coalition?

Salo Coslovsky:

I don’t think so. No. I mean, it’s a theme that comes up many times and it’s something that seems to be ripe for implementation, but I haven’t I lumped this as when as one of the shared resources that I that I discussed in terms of commercial promotion and looking for new markets and ways of selling your stuff. And I think it’s very important has a lot of potential either product by product or territory by territory for the whole region transnational Brazil with Bolivia and Peru and Venezuela and Colombia together. There’s the nine Amazonian countries.

I think it’ll be great. The US example for milk and for pork and for raisins it seems the not the green deal since the original new deal there is a tax that the government imposed on the sector and they pay it’s not I don’t I’m not sure if legally it’s technically a tax but like works like a tax collects this money it’s called a check off program and all producers have to chip in and the government enforces That’s how there’s no cheating, no free writing, no and the US government has been doing it for almost I don’t know 80 years.

And that’s where the money comes from for these campaigns for avocado, for milk, for raisins, for pork, the other white meat, and all these campaigns that people in the US know about. Just purely voluntary is very difficult to do because who’s going to pay for it? Everybody’s going to hope that somebody else is going to pay for it.

Jonah:

You said it’s called check off. Is check off a last name or do you mean check off? Oh.

Salo Coslovsky:

Check off. The check off. Yeah. It’s not a he’s not a Russian inventor. No.

Jonah:

It may be interesting for us to brainstorm on the call other precompetitive arrangements that we have seen and I know there’s some entrepreneurs and investors on the network and something tells me the more we discover from other regions the more we’ll be able to recreate locally for the Amazon. I know one for example called the World Food Bank which guarantees a minimum price for a lot of produce in Africa and then stores that produce in nitrogen-free containers which extend the shelf life a huge amount of time and then they resell it to the network when the you know when the prices go back up and as a result it guarantees a minimum price throughout the whole year which keeps a lot of you know producers operating.

Which would have disappeared otherwise if there wasn’t a guarantee price. Other questions for Salo or Salo, do you have questions for the audience?

Salo Coslovsky:

Yeah, I have I could I think somebody here asked about the promotion black pepper and the top 10 items on your list. How can this research be helped to can be used to help promote capital investments and or pre-sale of projects and help companies grow successful projects like what kind of that’s where I would go what do we do with this? How do we move on? A lot of this precompetitive arrangements and or setups that I that I’ve studied are stuff that I observe in the wild that sort of emerged on their own or emerged through actions of people within those sectors.

It’s not we don’t have a lot of cases of the deliberate creation of those things. Let’s snap our fingers and make it happen. Okay? We don’t have a blueprint. I don’t have a manual of how to do it. So that’s the biggest challenge and that’s something that I’ve been struggling with. How do we do that? My insights now is that it has to be done product by product. Each product has a different challenge and I started to investigate some of these challenges. There is a if you want to call it a precompetitive arrangement of the three largest Brazilian banks with Unibanchu, Santandere and Bradesco.

They a few months ago, maybe a year ago, they join forces in their sustainability efforts. You know what? We’re gonna have an Amazon plan and they have 10 items in their plan and they even though they’re competitors, they want to work together for this end. And one of the items to support what they call the bioeconomy and I’ve been discussing with them trying to convince them like let’s debug the sectors like what’s the holdup? What’s the bottleneck? It’s like programmers have a complicated algorithm system that need to debug part by part and find what’s holding them back.

We need to do that for these products. And so each product and it has its going to have its own bug or its own bottleneck. And when I started doing this, I discovered, for instance, that in the case of Brazilian pepper, what seems to be a massive bug in that system is that it’s way too often contaminated with salmonella. Brazilian pepper has had a red alert from the FDA since 1986 and it started to raise flags in the European Union over the past few years. So, the number of border rejections is going up.

I imagine that’s I haven’t really done the research yet, but I imagine that’s very consequential. If you’re a buyer, you don’t want to risk buying a shipment that’s going to be rejected at the border or you’re going to have to send back or worse, it’s going to create an outbreak among your customers. You’re going to lead to a recall and a total disaster. So, why is Brazilian pepper contaminated with someone else? And how come Vietnamese pepper doesn’t seem to be contaminated with someone else? What can we learn? And so that’s sort of what that’s what I mean by debugging.

And in the case of pepper, it’s someone else. In the case of cocoa is a different problem. In the case of Brazil nuts is a different problem altogether. Food safety seems to be a common theme. But for Brazilian pineapples for instance, people who know Amazonian pineapples, they know that it’s the most delicious pineapple in the world. And it’s the most delicious because it’s so sweet. But the fact it’s so sweet means that it gets bad faster. So it doesn’t preserve as well. So that’s a different problem. How do you keep the pineapple equally good for longer?

Jonah:

Juliana Enis, you have a question.

Juliana:

Hi everyone. Yes, thank you for having me. My name is Juliana. I’m a reporter for Mongabay. I also work with the climate reality project with lobbying for u green policies. And I was wondering because these this research that you showed, I mean I think that the main goal there is to avoid the forestation, right? By further developing economically on the forest. So do you when looking for a new market to further develop or for a new product, do you look into areas that are at a higher risk of deforestation or not necessarily?

This these are things that should happen organically by developing. You hope that deforestation will be avoided or how do you look at this together?

Salo Coslovsky:

Well, thanks for your question and I’m a big fan of Mongab and I read and rely on the information that you guys publish very often. So, I appreciate you being here. I’m not sure if I would say that the main goal is to pres prevent deforestation here. I think it’s one of the goals. I’m not sure if it’s I would not say the main goal. It’s about economic development. That’s sort of the first one. Not far behind is protecting the forest. Make making sure that this development is not done in the way that has been done for so long.

That is a trade-off. It’s somebody’s the forest has to lose for somebody to end. How can we have two things that are positive at the same time? But the best way to prevent the first station is by preventing the first station is with satellite pictures with fast enforcement is with tying credit to your documentation making sure that the C the land registry the very preliminary land registry are solid and not fraudulent. There’s plenty of things that need to be done can be done have already been done and show how to prevent deforestation.

This is a it’s kind of the aside not calling aside is the next objective over which is to promote development and they are compatible. I mean by design we are trying to find ways to make it compatible. So that and here the instruments that are important to pro promote deforestation do not preclude to promote development do not preclude the instruments that are important to prevent deforestation. The Amazon has already has more abandoned degraded land and pasture. So it’s not part of this research but a few weeks ago I did this math the so a degraded pasture is pasture that you cut the forest you plant you get the pasture grow or you plant some of those seeds your cattle eats it and you don’t take good care of it gets kind of patchy and a mess and the cat the cattle is not fattening fast enough so a pasture that’s not good it’s not efficient if all the degraded pasture in the Amazon was a country it would be one of the biggest countries in the world would be bigger than 175 other countries.

So be I don’t know maybe the 20th 25th largest countries just a degraded land. So there’s so much land in the Brazilian Amazon that has already been misused and abandoned and is literally being wasted that there’s so much if you plant agroforestry, if you expand the production of pepper, expand the production of pineapple, if you intermingle different coffee, cocoa, there’s enormous amount of growth that you can have with no impact in the forest whatsoever. So I think that this is more what I’m talking about here as opposed to preventing the encroaching into the standing forest and of and the effect on the I mean when people get richer you could have two effects.

You have more money you might decide to encroach even more and now you have more money to pay for logging and for deforestation and so forth or it can decrease. So I think the key variable here on preservation is enforcement. The key variable for economic development is the deliberate promotion of economic development. I would be careful not to cross the wires.

Jonah:

On that note, let’s go ahead and move on to the last question. You got just have three minutes left to the top of the hour, so let’s make it quick. Jo Jose Herto Bronco, you’re up. Jose, are you there? Am I here? Should I just.

Jose:

Oh, yes. I was just having some trouble with my microphone. Hey, S. How are you doing?

Salo Coslovsky:

Good. Good to see you,.

Jose:

Man. This has been a great talk and I would like to know if you are connected to other projects such as the Normia 4.0 Oh, and Sisada and they I believe that you guys are talking about the same subjects and perhaps you could cooperate to reach their goals much faster. Are you talking to them? Are you planning on doing something together?

Salo Coslovsky:

Well, thank nice seeing you. So Jose is a professor of innovation entrepreneurship at UFO at the federal university in Santarin and we taught a class together last semester in which I brought my students he brought his students and we all worked together. It was a great experience and I’m yes and no. I’ve talked to May I talked to Kylo Nabi before we go over this in a few settings. I’ve heard many good things about Cert’s program. We are not coordinating directly and deliberately. We are not c we don’t have a forum.

We don’t have a standing meeting of any of the sort. But we are moving in the same circles and we’re trying to help each other when we can and stay out of each other’s way when we can and then find the spots that the other ones are not occupying that needs to be occupied or the points that need to be pushed. So that’s my answer. There’s plenty of there might be plenty of options for more synergy in the future, but we also need to be careful not to overcoordinate. You just there’s space for everybody to try and we going to see how this evolve and I’m glad that they have such competent knowledgeable people working in the same space.

There is so much to be done that we cannot preclude of any kind of competent effort just like Amazonia 4.0 and Septi. It’s a pleasure to know that they I’m kind of coming just behind.

Jonah:

It would be great Joerto or someone else if you could post the websites of the Amazon and Amazon 4.0 in the chat for those who are not already familiar. This brings us to the top of the hour which is where we switch over from you know an organized structured conversation to less structured stuff and usually a couple people stick around. Salo, do you have time to stick around for a few?

Jose:

Yeah, my pleasure.

Jonah:

Okay, great. Any other questions? Anybody or Salo if you have any questions for us? It’s now open. No, I’m loving I would love to hear people’s imp. I mean the challenge here is how to move from retrospective studying what happened to prospective what can be done and I’m if anybody has any want to brainstorm over this next steps and how to make this potential come to fruition and what you see within your domain. I’ll be happy to hear and to engage.

Unidentified participant:

In the absence of comments from others, I can say that not only does the for-profit sector need to benefit from precompetitive arrangements, the academic and nonprofit sectors can as well.

Salo Coslovsky:

It’s true. These are but these are I mean there’s a cost to them too. You don’t want to overdo it.

Jonah:

Agreed. Any other questions or comments? Self-promotion. It’s open to everybody.

Unidentified participant:

We have a smaller group. Thank you. I just was very interested in diving in a little deeper relating to the specific opportunities. Was there any women led projects and or production like for example one of my investor friends she’s doing a lot of in Bolivia as well but not just black pepper she’s doing hot chili peppers and has a good export market for that. Is there other projects that you feel are strong that we could look as investors? How do we support some of these projects? Thank you.

Salo Coslovsky:

Well, thanks for asking. So, I’m going to give you two answers. So, last semester I joined forces with a colleague at NYU Scott who was here. He just left. Colleagues in Berain, in Santar, and in São Paulo. And we recruited we brought our students together and we recruited six firms that producing foods from the Amazon to be objects of case studies that the students would write. So we had this instead of lamenting that everything’s done through Zoom say you know what there’s no spaces through Zoom. Let’s have a multinational classroom and six of those so we should chose six enterprises.

If I remember correctly, I think four are women were women led and that was not by choice. That was just like happened that we chose the four most promising kind of most interesting diverse and so it’s it might even be representative of the universe. We’re not choosing on gender of leadership. And some are much more advanced than others. But they all trying to buy ingredients from local communities, indigenous people, maroon communities, riverine and so forth. Somehow process it and sell it mostly in the domestic market. And some are doing better than others.

And but across the board they all struggle because it’s very difficult to do business in the Amazon. They are progressing fast some fast some not so fast but I would be happy to give you the lowdown kind of what I found from this six and I know for instance that there’s a new effort in Dallas I think Mariana was here not long ago as part of the an incubator accelerator called AMAS.

Jonah:

Yeah he was here a couple weeks ago.

Salo Coslovsky:

They just published the result they had a so they’re trying to recruit companies they put a who wants to be accelerated by us. They had 156 companies that applied and we I don’t know all the details. He have the details. So there’s plenty of optimism in the region. Plenty of dynamisms like people are starting companies. They want to they have ideas. They want to move forward. But it’s a very inhospitable environment for new companies. So for them to actually thrive it has been very difficult. Having money and having advice and having expertise from people who have done this before would increase their chances tremendously.

So I think it’s this is great. If there is interest there’s if there is interest in this on this side I know that there is demand on that side as well. Jose, do you want to tell us about a couple of the links that you posted before Jose comes in? Fiona, does did that answer your question?

Unidentified participant:

Thank you. Yes. No, I mean it’s quite fascinating because we have this ability for different incubators to bring forwards and anyway just thinking about 5,000 startups or 500 startups knowing that rarely after three to five years we have such a challenge to make them support them to get to scale and how and what products could be scalable and if there are certain models that could be synthe emphasized or utilized in different communities. I think that’s for me in micro finance that’s my most important thing is finding success models that can be replicated and adapted to different communities.

So thank you.

Salo Coslovsky:

Sure. Yeah. My impression based on this research is that I mean the credit the accelerator all this ecosystem it really focuses on the private goods and services. It’s stuff that goes directly within a company’s perview and generates benefits that can be almost fully appropriated by that company. And I feel that what they struggling the most is with the absence of the share goods. The stuff that no single firm can afford to pay on its own. The kind of knowledge, the kind of expertise, the kind of connections, the kind of knowledge about the product, about the best ways of managing the operation, about the best ways of packaging, of having the suppliers in place, the consultants, the advisers, the all the different inputs that go into production that service the whole sector.

Those are seem to be the neglected weak link in this chain more so than the goods and services that can be fully appropriated. But we don’t have a good system to provide those either. Agreed. And that’s the challenge, isn’t it? Where how do you take those systems and support them and who’s paying for that education slash natural capital resource and then the metrics like who’s measuring these metrics and who can afford to measure these metrics and how is that being utilized. So very good answers and I look forward to seeing further the development of your research.

Thank you. No, it’s it has been exciting and because the government steps in for the really public goods, it’s not doesn’t do an amazing job, but whenever you bring a problem to the government, it’s like, can we shape it in a way that’s going to benefit the most people? Why should I just give it to you? Why can’t I give it to everybody? And that waters it down. So you get a reasonable supply of public goods and you get a reasonable supply of private goods, but the shared ones end up falling through the cracks.

Jonah:

Jose has posted a couple of things. He says his microphone is acting up. Are you there Jose? Do you want to try? Is anybody on the call involved in the world bioeconomy forum that’s coming to Bain?

Salo Coslovsky:

Well, I do I’m not involved, but I know a little and I may participate in different ways. It’s an event that’s you if I what I know is that it’s usually held and organized out of Finland, but this year it’s going to be the for the first time. It’s going to be held elsewhere and it’s going to be done in Bain in October. And they were hoping for a full inerson, but that seems increasingly unlikely and it’s likely more likely not to be a hybrid inerson online event. And a lot of the initiatives that I’m involved, people have that as their deadline.

They want to have results to discuss and to announce during this event, which is always a helpful thing to have a deadline. But the and I know there’s going to be official event, there’s going to be parallel event and I think it’s going to be a fairly large endeavor. The state government is involved. The local federal universities involved. They all organizing different activities and events.

Jonah:

Great. Anybody else like to comment?

Unidentified participant:

I’d like to thank you for your presentation. Is so very interesting and you mentioned a couple of times the pork producers I happen to know the guy that came up with the slogan the other white meat he was just a reg and which doesn’t really actually mean anything in terms of the health it people take it to mean that it’s much healthier for you but really that was a stretch but nonetheless the gentleman’s name was Rick Pasco and he is part of my Toastmasters club on Capitol Hill. Very clever guy, but still just one guy.

And so I think the lesson is to not underestimate the power of people’s capacity to come up with a clever brand or a clever label. It’s a separate issue.

Unidentified participant:

Was he a lobbyist? What? What?

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. Yeah, he was a lobbyist for the pork producers association. And as far as I know, he’s still in DC somewhere, but that was his claim to fame was having the other white meat. It really moved the needle for their industry. Separate matter is the what was a was a related but separate topic that you brought up was related to a certification program of things that met a certain standard and that’s more complex. We have negative examples of like the dolphin safe which was has been accused of being a fraudulent certification label but I think that’s that’d be a very interesting area to explore.

Thank you. Yeah. No, it’s a very hot topic and people tend to think I mean my now that we are over and you’re having a beer after the talk not on the on record anymore. People tend to think that certification would be a intervention that changes things that once you certified and all kind of good things going to flow from it and I’m very skeptical of that. I tend to think that’s something that can help you lock your gains into place. But to advance to get gains in the first place, you need other kind of things.

It just it helps stabilize the situation more than it helps promote an a few steps forward. But people love certification. They think the certification is the panacea is the answer to everything. And I’m having studied some of this, I’m skeptical. I think it’s a either a sideshow or a capstone to a much larger set of efforts that culminates with a certification. We cannot just skip the important steps and go straight to the celebration. That’s not going to not going to have the same effect.

Jonah:

I have a couple of questions about black pepper. Does black pepper is a bush, not a tree, right?

Unidentified participant:

Yes. So, but it grows well in shade. How it is. Okay. So, that’s why it’s force.

Unidentified participant:

It grows well.

Salo Coslovsky:

I mean, that’s not doesn’t mean that they it’s not something that I’ve delved deeply yet. It’s something that came up in my research. Did not expect black pepper to be the top item in my in my list. But then I since then I got curious and I did a little digging around, but I haven’t done the full works yet. Is that it can be planted as plantation monoculture. So maybe in Vietnam that’s what they do. I’m not sure yet. In Brazil they try to do that but anything you do of many things that not anything but many things that you try to do in monoculture in the Amazon it just become a feast for the bugs and the pests and that it gets destroyed and eventually the people who are investing in this and it pepper has a long history in the Amazon I mean a few several decades they learn to do it interspersed with other species and mixed in and that decreases the bio pressure on the bugs and the pests that eat it and that’s how they managed to make it successful.

Jonah:

Do you know if pepper is integrated with another particular species or several different species?

Salo Coslovsky:

I don’t know exactly what it is. I do know that it comes from Tomé-Açu. Tomé-Açu is a city most of it come from toasu which is a city not far from Bain in Par which has this fascinating story. São Paulo in the south of Brazil is the largest Japanese city outside of Japan supposedly. There’s this large immigration of Japanese immigrants to Brazil. Many of them went to São Paulo. A good chunk of them ended up in the Amazon. So there’s this whole Japanese community in Tomé-Açu and they are the ones they are very their descendants very involved in producing pepper.

They have been since the 1940s I think 1950s. And they also are proponents and people who adopt agroforest system that they invented themselves and they developed and so I imagine that they have a very sophisticated intermingling of species to make this work that includes many different many different types. But this is all hearsay from a distance. I haven’t been able to check it out in loco yet.

Unidentified participant:

I got a couple contacts at in involved in tou if you are having problems.

Unidentified participant:

Nice.

Unidentified participant:

Accessing which is hard.

Salo Coslovsky:

Yeah. No, they it’s a fascinating story. They have a very strong cooperative. They have a museum. They have a hospital. They paid for their own electrical power lines. They so that’s an example of what Tachenna asked like how much money do you need? Well, the people in Tommy Assu once they started their ball rolling, they collected the money, they found the money, they paid for their hospital, they paid for the power lines, they paid for public safety, they made it happen. So, it was not an injection from the outside. It was a lot of it demanded from within.

Daniel, there’s a lot to be learned about them.

Jonah:

Agreed. Danielle Bruy, do you have a question? You’re on mute if you want to come off.

Danielle:

Yes. Sorry. Thank you everyone for this presentation. I was just wondering if I understood correctly. You looked at the at the products that had the least market share from the total exports and you focused on those. But I was wondering if there are some products that are forest friendly and that for which the Amazon is a major market player. Are there any kind of success stories within the Brazilian Amazon that can be looked at?

Salo Coslovsky:

So I mean that’s you my fault but that’s not exactly what I’ve done. What I’ve done is that I look first at the tops. So you have the 10 top 10 which is soy, cattle, iron ore and so forth. And then there’s a list a thousand more. And then I looked at this whole list and found 64 which are forest friendly. Then I ranked the 64 by amount of money that they bring. The top one is pepper and then it goes the list goes down very fast. So I was not looking for the ones with small market share.

In fact, it’s some of I even cut the I mean too small I don’t even consider that a rounding error. I only cons so what happens that all of them have tiny market shares maybe the largest one is one of the largest significant one is Pepper that has 7%. And the only one that really stands out in the list of Brazilian products. So I rank them by money not by share and starting with the top amount of money. The only one that has any significance in terms of share is in shell Brazil nuts which is Brazil nuts that have not been the hard dark shell has not been taken off yet.

Brazil has a market share of roughly a little less than 50% in the global market for this specific product. And what’s happening here is not that Brazil is that successful is that Brazil is failed so terribly in processing its Brazil nuts that it now sells raw nuts in shell to Bolivia and Peru. They process it and export to Europe and other countries including Brazil itself. So Brazil only gets to have 50% share in this product because nobody else wants it and actually Brazil is exporting to Bolivia not to a final market.

Unidentified participant:

Where was asai on the list?

Salo Coslovsky:

So asai is a tricky one because it doesn’t have a code in the catalog. So it’s not easy to find in the list each export. So the way this works that there’s this five this catalog has 5,000 products. You’re going to export something you have to declare using the code the asai gets declared depends on this on the format. If it’s asai juice he gets one code. If it’s asai pope pure in fact that’s the technical name it gets a different code. If it’s dry sort of the p powder form it gets a different code.

So, it’s hard to find it in the in the list, but it in my list here, it’s mo and I can send the presentation. It’s mostly in the other fruits and other juices, which together add up to $40 million maybe in Brazilian exports. But that includes not just asai includes all kinds of other things. But coming from the Amazon, you get a lot of asai in it. And there’s a wild disagreement on what the global market for asai is. The best estimate that I got was from one of the maybe it was one of I don’t know if it was one of your call.

Maybe it was a different No. Did you organize an event with him? Sambazone.

Jonah:

Yeah. Sazone presented on a call.

Salo Coslovsky:

Exactly. So that I think I shared the panel with Ryan.

Jonah:

Yeah. Yeah, you did.

Salo Coslovsky:

Exactly. Out of that event that I got the best insight on Asai when he said that the American he estimates the American market wholesale market $200 million,.

Unidentified participant:

Right?

Unidentified participant:

But the wholesale price in Brazil is 10 times lower than the wholesale price in the US. So that would bring Brazil export market at $20 million to the US,.

Unidentified participant:

Right?

Unidentified participant:

If you double that, considering Europe, China, Japan, you got a $40 million. I mean, it’s in the list, but it’s not by far. It’s not the biggest one. It’s in the top. We’ll say the top five. I is it possible to do a similar kind of ranking taking into account how large the Brazilian markets are? Right? Things like acai or beef, you know, a majority of it’s already consumed in Brazil. Brazil is so large and that’s the reason why we’re not competing effectively with other countries because the internal, you know, country market consumes so much of it.

Salo Coslovsky:

Yeah. I mean this is a tough one. The eBay the Brazilian statistical agency they collect some data on production and consumption and things. It’s not clear how accurate though or how good those numbers are and we don’t have the same kind of data that we have for international markets. The point for international market is that by cheating all these people all the producers have to declare using this catalog of codes and not only that you have an organization that operates out of France a research organization they get the data from all countries and match them against all the other countries and they have an algorithm they say who can I trust more here.

Brazil said it exported a hundred million dollars of asai to Germany. But Germany says that they only imported 95 because each number gets reported twice by the import and the export. And they use they have an algorithm to reconcile this whole thing and get as good a number as we can get. In the domestic market don’t have any of that. I’m trying through different channels to get some numbers through the internal tax reporting system.

Unidentified participant:

Which is a federal entity.

Salo Coslovsky:

Which is a state it’s managed by the state it’s a very like everything Brazil is incredibly complicated don’t even ask me but it’s a state level tax so we would get all the products that leave the state and go to a different But even then they don’t have a unified code. You have to use keywords to try to search this database and you have billions of transactions a month or even I don’t even know by a week. So I planted some seeds to try to get this data would be great, but I don’t really I don’t have a lot of hope that we’re going to get good information to understand the domestic market and but the domestic market I mean it’s big in some cases but it’s not an engine of innovation and upgrading.

It’s very slow moving and people are used to eating to buying and selling crappy stuff. Sorry fellow Brazilians, but it’s true. The fancy stuff goes to export. So you don’t get a lot of positive spillovers out of the domestic market.

Unidentified participant:

Did handcrafts and art things like that come up on the list? Do you know?

Salo Coslovsky:

Yeah, I mean you have codes for that stuff. I did them in the end. I didn’t. So another thing that we I could have included I didn’t include and I hope to have a separate there’s no timber in my list and that’s by choice. I didn’t want to deal with timber because it’s too fraught but there is some potential for sustainably harvested timber. It’s not as much as people used to think. The new study showed that the forest regenerates fast but the timber doesn’t regenerate as fast as people thought. So it’s less than anticipated.

And there’s traditional crops produced by small communities like cassava and beans. Those are those can be quite big too. And so they are not done in the shade of the forest. You have to clear cut. But you can do kind of as part of a portfolio of activities and they have some potential of bringing economic development to this to these regions. The handiccrafts and things like that, they show up too, but it’s certain things are very hard to understand. I was trying to get here stuff that I could map the local market to the global market and the global market for handiccraft is just I don’t know hundreds of billions just the numbers are astronomical because it includes everything and it’s so much stuff from so many countries is so diverse.

It’s such a broad category that I ended up nixing it to keep a more focused portfolio like pineapples and mangoes and those are not there’s only so many different types of pineapples you can do but handiccrafts and jewelry.

Unidentified participant:

It the original data did you get it from the World Trade Organization? So.

Salo Coslovsky:

Anyway, just to finish answering your question, there is potential. I just I was conservative in my estimates. I don’t want I didn’t want to overplay my hand, but that doesn’t mean that they’re not something to be looked at and to be discussed and be examined and be supported. There’s plenty of potential. There’s the capacity. There’s potential. Just for not to dilute from my message, I decided not to include that. So the this the data so each country reports to the UN and the UN distributes it. You can download it from the UN itself in its raw format.

The WTO has the same version. And I’m pretty sure I like many other researchers use the version that’s produced by this French research agency that does this reconciliation process to match imports and exports eliminate a lot of error because they trust they have a system in which they find which country is more trustworthy than others and they use that country’s report as opposed to the other one.

Unidentified participant:

Could you post that? Sure they I have to.

Salo Coslovsky:

Find the exact link and it’s freely available.

Unidentified participant:

While you’re looking for that, I think my interest of course is in the timber and looking at mixed species in the multi- generational types of forests similar to the work that part of our team has been doing with Futura Forestal in Panama and with our biodiversity experts. So it’s fascinating where you’re saying there’s a challenge on the finance on the export. Do you think that of the timber is it also a combination of the presidency and the corruption or do you think it’s just a slower market at this point?

Salo Coslovsky:

So I didn’t mean to say this on the finance of timber. I think what I what maybe this is a better link here but that’s the in this website you get this data and for Brazil I got it from comx which is also easy to easy to get there is a few I so there’s all kind of tricks that I learned doing this research the countries themselves. If you want to give me one second, I’m going to get to your question. There are the countries themselves, they might decide to have a longer catalog than the 5,000.

The 5,000 is the one that all countries agree on, but you can have a more detailed one. Brazil, for instance, has one has almost 10,000 items. So, some items on the Brazil side, I can get into more detail than what I gave here in this presentation. That’s how I know for example when I say oh the fish and this is mostly red snapper from the Atlantic coast because Brazil has a code for that further down and the US has a detailed code and the European Union has a detailed code so I didn’t get there yet but I could devise a system in which you dig deeper into the US data the European data and you get a much more detailed picture instead of having this fairly broad names you can get what do you mean by all the fruits What do you mean by other fish?

Which kind of fish are you talking about here? What kind of shrimp and so forth? It’s possible. I’m not there yet with this research on the timber. What I meant to say is that people who which is not my field, but I my friends a lot of my friends do that. So that’s how I learned. People used to think that a 25 rotation period was enough for the original track to regenerate fully until you come back. So you get your land is divid into 25 tracks and you harvest timber one at a one per year.

And the more recent research for the people who really defended that model they realize you know what after 25 years is not there yet might take double might take 50 years. So it brings your harvest area or your revenue source cuts it by half. So then I guess it gets you’re just ahead of me on this one. The financing gets much more much trickier. So that’s one problem. The other problem is that the most valuable species are the ones of course that have more illegal trading, illegal harvesting and illegal trading.

And one of and it’s very hard to tell what’s what. And people mislabel their timber and they export mahogany and all kinds of names and it gets at least in Brazil one of the few things that helped stem the illegal logging of this very highly valuable species was not to have any gray zone. You don’t have legal mahogany or illegal mahogies. If it’s mahogany, it’s illegal and that helped bring the for cut down on the forestation caused by these species. If you start reopening that tap again, there’s a high risk that illegal deforestation is going to pick it back and use that all kind of ways of laundering or illegally harvested wood and passing it on as legal and it gets very complicated.

That’s why I was staying away from it. But it’s the potential is enormous. I have seen the commercialization of mahogany from the Amazon, but it’s African mahogany. Is that the reason why they’re choosing a non-native mahogany? Just so they can.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, probably. Very well.

Salo Coslovsky:

So the mahogany big leaf mahogany it was I mean I used I did some work in this way back in the day and when I so before being a researcher I worked for the Brazilian Ministry of Environment and I was part of the task force looking for ways to combat illegal logging of mahogany. So I was embedded in this pretty well but had been so long that I forgot a lot of it. It was in 2003 maybe or 98 around that time that the government had been trying different ways of stemming the illegal of m of Amazon mahogany and so at some points like you know what if it’s mahogany it’s illegal and that’s when the government managed to seize vast amounts of mahogany in the Shingu River in those floats inside the Kayapo area some of it had already inside the Sios there’s a massive shipment or lo load in a warehouse in Santa Catarino Parana that was been ready to be shipped.

There’s mahogany that was already on boats moving to the US that got seized and was going to be sent back. So that’s kind of really put a stop the by having a bright line it really helped stop the trickling of illegal logging and people say oh no I logged this before and it is a different species it comes from different land all kinds of tricks in which it was lundered. Do is was there any estimation of how much was illegal and laundered versus how much was legit? I don’t think so.

No, I don’t remember. Maybe. I don’t remember anything. I mean, the challenge of the illegal is that it was being sold off as different species. It’s being sold as under different names and or some of it was counted as legal even though it had been harvested illegally. But you get proper paperwork from a different area. So it looks legal. It’s a it’s a mess. So I don’t think anything anybody could. Maybe some people had better ways of doing this, but I don’t know any numbers.

Unidentified participant:

And do you know if the boss administration has pushed to legalize it again?

Salo Coslovsky:

I don’t I don’t think mahogany because now it got into sites the international convention for the protection of endangered species.

Salo Coslovsky:

Oh wow. It sites has a few levels of protection and back in around that time when Brazil soon after Brazil made it illegal it also I think moved up in its protection status internationally so it’s very hard to sell it so even if you harvest in Brazil and you launder it in Brazil you try to sell it in England in Germany in Japan in the US it those countries cannot take it in.

Unidentified participant:

Do is that what also happened to rosewood by any chance?

Salo Coslovsky:

I don’t know, but it’s probable.

Unidentified participant:

Okay. Yeah, I’ve seen several of these Brazilian woods disappear.

Salo Coslovsky:

Yes. Yeah. Jakar Jakaranda and P Brazil, of course, the big one. They all get added to just like leopard skins and ivory which is of course the most famous they get they move up in this list and there’s a whole global system of trying to stop this so yeah I mean you could bring it into the US under false name and then try to sell it as old maha but it gets increasingly expensive and complicated and risky to do which is the point of raising the cost making crime make sure the crime does not pay or does at least does not pay at full Great.

Fish and wildlife services in the US has been very historically over the many decades very active and increasing cooperation with Brazil. I mean you brought your the guy to the event Brian I forget his laundry.

Unidentified participant:

Landry. Yeah. Yeah. I heard I may have heard wrong that the US government gave $150 million to Brazil or NOS’s in Brazil to work on illegal species trade. If that number is true, it’s makes up a an enormous fraction of the bilateral budget to support the Amazon. But I haven’t gone to the source of that data to figure out if it’s really.

Salo Coslovsky:

Yeah, I don’t really know. Sounds like a lot of money. I mean, a lot of money given how much gets invested in this kind of stuff, it’s.

Unidentified participant:

Probably not nearly enough.

Salo Coslovsky:

Yeah, true.

Jonah:

Well, this has been great. Any other questions? Anybody? There’s one person on here who hasn’t introduced themselves yet. I just want to create an opportunity for you to do so. Bina Gaspar from Agrosmart. You want to come off mic and just introduce yourself?

Unidentified participant:

Hello. Good afternoon. I am from Agrosmart in Manow, Brazil. We are working with bio economy here in the region and I am listening only and to know many things about the meeting and I am enjoying it a lot. Thank you.

Jonah:

You bet. Thanks so much.

Unidentified participant:

Thanks for joining.

Unidentified participant:

Agrosmart’s a real amazing company with a lot of growth and corporate clients on Amazon that is friendly to our mission. Okay everybody.

Salo Coslovsky:

Yeah Jonah I mean there’s a lot of happening on this front with the government of par with the ITB with the banks and all kinds of and it’s great to be in touch and see ways in which we can work together cooperate trade ideas and insights.

Jonah:

I’m going to take it off record and then I’ll I’m gonna say a couple things.