The World Bank’s Amazon Sustainable Landscapes Program

Join us to meet Amazon Sustainable Landscapes Program (ASL) Program Coordinator Ana María Gonzalez and learn about this GEF-funded impact program and its joint efforts and future plans to promote conservation and sustainable development in targeted areas of the Amazon, under the premise of “Connecting People and Institutions to Connect Landscapes.” The ASL is currently being implemented in Brazil, Colombia, and Peru, and in the following months, a second phase will initiate with additional projects in Bolivia, Ecuador, Guyana, and Suriname. The ASL also includes a regional project that promotes collaboration among governments, implementing agencies, civil society, and the donor community.

Recorded August 9, 2021

References:

ASL Partners

ASL2

Putumayo-Içá Project

Join C4D (Collaboration for Development)

International Funding for Amazon Conservation and Sustainable Management: A Continued Analysis of Grant Funding Across the Basin Document

WATCH:

  • Jonah
  • Ana María Gonzalez
  • Mauricio
  • John Bruno
  • Christina
  • Eduardo Schenberg
  • Fiona
  • Pedro Gasparin

Jonah:

Hello everybody. This is the 53rd call of the Amazon Investor Coalition call and podcast series. Again, this is a weekly gathering of friends of the Amazon. Our goal is to advance force friendly economic development and the rule of law across the Amazon region of South America. We gather funders, governments, nos, businesses, investors, allies and each week we feature a different innovator, leader, idea maker. And this week we are featuring the work of Ana María Gonzalez at the World Bank Amazon Sustainable Landscapes program and this is a initiative of the global governance philanthropy network and nexus.

So Ana María welcome to our call. Tell us a little bit about yourself and your life before the World Bank and then we’ll jump into the slides. Go ahead.

Ana María Gonzalez:

Thank you. Thank you Jonah. And first of all, it’s impressive that you I that you say it’s the 53rd week and meeting. So bravo for that honestly to be able to engage so many people for that long. So about me maybe the two most important things is that I am Colombian and second I’m the mother of two boys teenager boys. Then after that I’ve been working in the World Bank since 2008 in multiple countries of Africa, Latin America, a bit of Asia but mostly Africa and since the last four years in Latin America and focus on the Amazon region.

And before the World Bank, I worked a bit in Washington DC in the Nature Conservancy and doing some research and before in Colombia in my home country. I work in different cities but mostly in environmental either teaching environmental studies, economic studies or doing some research or as program and project manager in rural areas for conservation and sustainable development projects. And my studies. I’m an economist and I did a master degree in environmental economics and then another master degree in envir in international development. That’s last one I did here in DC.

I came to DC only to do my masters for two years and it’s been 17 years since I’ve been at the US. So, I’m one of those Latin American people that came to the US thinking that it was a short time and then now I’m here. I have a husband, kids, house. I’m only missing the dog, but that’s me.

Jonah:

Nice. I love the summary. And from all of that experience, we get the benefit from as does the Amazon. So, give it to us. What are you guys up to? What mischief are you making in the region?

Ana María Gonzalez:

Perfect. So, thank you and hello everybody. It’s really good to be here and thank you Jonah for the invitation. So, well, one thing that I mentioned like my title, I’m a senior environmental specialist at the World Bank and I’m currently the coordinator at the bank for several initiatives in the Amazon including the Amazon sustainable landscape program. Next and Maria Ben who is and you will see it in the screen she’s my colleague and she works with me and she’s joining us in the meeting. So what’s the ASL that’s the acronym for the Amazon Sustainable Landscape Program is a regional effort for the conservation and sustainable development in the Amazon.

It’s a it’s a $113 million impact program funded by the Jeff the global environmental facility and it includes five national projects in Brazil, co Colombia and Peru and a regional coordination project. I don’t know if you see if it’s too small but the Brazilian project is its name is also Amazon sustainable landscape program. It’s a $60 million project. Is the largest project in terms of funding that the Jeff has ever financed. In Colombia we have two their names are very long but they’re commonly known one it’s called heart of the Amazon or corasonia and the second one is Amazon sustainable Amazon for peace Amazonia sustain paralas and in Peru there’s two different projects one that it’s called securing the future of the protected area natural protected area systems and the second and the Second one in Peru is called sustainable productive landscapes.

So and this project like together the goal of the program is to improve integrated landscape management and conservation of ecosystems in targeted areas of the Amazon region. The ministries of the environment are the in each of the countries are the ones who lead the different national projects but of course multiple national and international agencies and public institutions are the ones who support the execution of the projects and it they work in alliance with civil society and community organizations. The World Bank is the lead agency for the whole program, but together with UNDP and WWF, we supervise and support the implementation of each of the national projects as you can see in the in the logos in each of the in on the screen.

So the program is really possible thanks to this network of institutions from the Amazon countries that will work towards a common goal. Next so the good the very good news is that a second phase of the program is about to kick off. So, and it’s going to expand geographically and besides the three countries that I mentioned now we’re having program projects sorry in Bolivia, Ecuador, Guana and Surinam and new agencies calf and we miss sorry we missed here the logo FAO is going to be part are going to be part of the new community.

I hope no one is from FAO that will be and if it is sorry for that. Next so to achieve our program goal the program and its project are structured along four pillars which are interrelated and operate on the basis our main premise is that the protection of biodiversity the connectivity of between its landscapes and the integrity of the ecosystem services provided can be achieved with four different sort of conditions. One is that a representative area of the Amazon is effectively conserved under various regimes, protected areas, indigenous lands, ramsar sites and other conservation strategies.

Second, that agricultural lands, forest and freshwater habitats are adequately managed and restored with zero tolerance for illegal deforestation and also for contamination, water contamination. A third thing or pillar is that policies and incentives for protected and productive landscapes are enhanced and finally that key technical and institutional stakeholder capacity and regional cooperation is strengthened. Next, I will not go into details about this, but this is sort of the types of intervention that the program and its each of the national projects support. Each of the projects of course have its own emphasis and response to our particular context and needs but overall for pillar one the project support the expansion and creation of new protected areas and the improvement of their management plans.

The projects also strengthen governance in indigenous territories preparation or implementation of life plans, management plans for rams or sites and as well as the three mechanisms for the financial sustainability of the protected area systems ARPA in Brasília Colombia and Patrimonial de Peru. On pillar two, the projects have supported land use planning at different scales, the strengthening of value chains and green businesses, community forest management, nature-based tourism. And this is done through like innovative mechanisms such as the conservation, restoration, and non-deforestation agreements signed with local communities. These first two pillars are strengthening and find their enabling conditions through the development and strengthening of legal instruments, intersectoral plans and agreements and the development of economic and financial incentives.

Mainstreaming environmental considerations in plants from other sectors like mining, agriculture, roads, well transport that can drive the forestation has been a key element of the ASL projects. And finally the program is possible through the strengthening of institutional and community capacities, the exchange of knowledge, the development of communication and awareness raising strategies and regional cooperation that enable us to achieve the program goals. Next, as I mentioned, each pro each country and project has its own targets and goals. But we have been able with the regional coordination pro project to aggregate some common indicators and so our latest report showed that jointly we have been able to increase effectiveness in the management of 42 million protected areas.

4.2 million hectares of new protected areas have been created or increased. This is of course with support with from other institutions and other organizations where the projects have jointly promoted sustainable management systems in 2 million protected 2 million hectares outside protected areas sorry and we have restored 6,000 hectares of forest. The ASL in terms of protected areas has activities in 210 protected areas. That’s more than 96 million hectares, an area larger than Venezuela. COVID of course has affected our teams, our beneficiaries, and the situation has been alarming for the indigenous people especially.

And I’m sure you know that well not only for the reduced population from loss of life but we have there are concerns over losing traditional knowledge possessed by the vulnerable elderly. COVID of course has thus impacted some of the activities in the especially in the field and that’s why what explains that some of the targets that we have as a program are far from achieved. But the program has remained engaged with the institutions and most important the local beneficiaries and adaptation measures have been in place. There’s several activities that are just ready to start once travel is resumed while once vaccination in some areas gets higher rates etc.

Next. So the program operates with an integrated harmonized approach that ensures that national projects can achieve larger impacts that if they were implemented in isolation. So and this is possible because by working together under one large project program sorry the national project teams can learn from one another can attract partners to work nationally and regionally be part of a community of practice that can coordinate and collaborate to achieve common goals share ideas and best practices and align efforts to safeguard the connectivity of the Amazon landscapes. Next, this coordination between the national project is possible because the within the program sorry the Jeff allocated funds to have a regional coordination platform or project.

This project is led by the World Bank. Is implemented by the World Bank and it intends precisely to strengthen coordination, access to information and enhance the capacity of the of the stakeholders that are not only in the n like working in the national projects but will as well as other partners that work in the Amazon. So the project in a way this regional project draws on the progress from the national projects responds to their needs in terms of knowledge of specific knowledge and activities but in turn offers technical assistance for to improve their implementation.

Next and while it turns with this yes thank you with this regional project we carry out some coordination activities and here I’m just going to give a few examples so one is we have supported the regional processes that contributed to the efforts that resulted in the letsia pact I’m sure you this audience know what the Leticia pact. But in the Leticia pact the mandate 16 specifically refers to the Amazon sustainable landscape program and it the preparation of the second phase. So not only we are sort of delivering on that mandate by preparing that second phase but we are committed to support the implementation of its action plan and a way to track its accomplishments.

The action plan does not have yet a set of indicators so that institutions that are contributing to the action plan can sort of track how are we jointly contributing to this effort signed by se by the seven Amazon by seven of the Amazon countries. On another example, we also support processes to strengthen indigenous governance and we have worked here particularly with indigenous communities in the northern Amazon corridor. We are also currently supporting the an alliance between government institutions and civil society in multiple countries in the Amazon to raise awareness and address the impacts of mercury use in illegal mining.

And we recently have you mentioned Scott, we recently have a very interesting webinar as part of this effort on a work that has CSF has done in Brazil to calculate the impact of mining economic and social impact of mining. The another example is that the ASL has supported the regional coordination and calibration effort that has led the to the preparation of a joint initiative towards an action plan for integrated watershed management and the at the basin that is the one shown here in the map shared between Colombia, Brazil, Peru and Ecuador and now it’s turned into a project proposal that we are presenting to be financed by the Jeff and to be executed by WCS in collaboration of course with government institutions from the four countries.

And a final example here in this coordination large component of the project is that we have promoted coordination between donors. Trying to foster dialogue and establish synergies between what each of the donors are doing. And one initial step that we identified was the we did an analysis of the flows of resources that have reached the region. In and here the region I me I mean the all the countries in the Amazon and we were able to track $3.45 billion that have been invested between 2013 and 2019. And we were able to classify this funding by funer by country and by conservation strategy.

And this analysis is in our website. We will share with you u the link to our website. And we are now preparing building on this initial effort a case study analysis on lessons learned towards effective collaboration between donors. We will also do and have committed to do this analysis this compilation of what is the funding that it’s coming to the Amazon every three years. And we in the process of doing this we already identified the need to better quantify funding that comes from the private sector. This was the inputs and the information that we collected in this previous study didn’t have a lot about private sector and also didn’t include non-grant instruments that we know are significantly important for the Amazon.

And finally we have a governance structure for the ASL that it’s composed of the of a it’s a consist of a steering committee that has participation of the ministries of environment the implementing at the executing agencies both public and from the civil society and this is the space where we share the progress of the national teams and we identify the knowledge sharing activities and the different activities that we want to jointly succeed. Next, the second well, it turns the second core component. Thank you. The second core component of this regional project is related to knowledge management and communications.

And here again, I’m also giving some examples. We promote knowledge exchange events. Of course it was the COVID restricted our traveling significantly. But in 2019, yes 19, there was a we had a study tour just to give you an example where team members from the from all the five national projects went to Pen in Guatemala to learn about community forestry where we are now designing a study tour to Brazil to for the part for the participants to learn about community-based tourism and this is demand driven. Is the countries and the projects that identified their interest in learning about this different specific topics.

We also developed guidelines and compilation of best practices including one that was related to the establishment of conservation agreements that we work with CSF in productive landscapes or a guide to be launched soon that we are working with WWF about the approach to design mechanisms for the financial sustainability of the protected area systems. ASL is lucky that it’s supporting three big as I would mentioned before three big mechanisms for financial sustainability. ARPA, Patrimon, Peru, and ENIA Colombia. And so this guide compiles part of the lessons learned of this the process of these three financial mechanisms plus others in the in the world not only in Latin America to facilitate practitioners that are interested in similar activities.

As I said we organize webinars to share our results but also the results from the partner organizations and we generate communication campaigns. We have in place a community of practice that it’s a live repository of the program’s information and a forum for dialogue on selected items. This is open to the public and it’s we are in the process of translating it to Spanish and Portuguese. We know that’s going to allow many more of our stakeholders to access. And we also have a program website that is hosted within the World Bank’s website.

Next, just to finalize, I wanted to share that the ASL is essentially an agreement between the governments and this and or and civil society organizations. And these organizations were established since the initial conversations when the program was just in the making in 2017. And they’re last and they have lasted until today. And what the program really wants to do is to seek to be a bridge between the different levels of government, facilitating dialogue on specific issues that transcend borders and facilitating work with civil societ between the government and the civil society.

And the ASL is always open to expand the networks, establish alliances, find synergies. And we have collected a few lessons from multiple reports. But I wanted to just finalize with a few first the importance of having a common framework built among all partners and that has ensured a sense of ownership of the program. Second by recognizing the sovereignty of each country is where it has been possible to promote collaborative efforts. To address threats that cross that borders, common threats and that approach of to common problems has made it possible to cross national and institutional borders facilitating the construction of relations of trust and cooperation.

Another very key lesson for us has been the recognition and respect of for local knowledge as fundamental for conservation. Therefore the importance of promoting dialogue between scientists, local communities, local researchers and build a common vision of the Amazon from the local to the regional. Another thing is to promote opportunities to allow the different voices to be heard and ensure the right mix between the technical and the political perspectives. The ISL promotes agreements at multiple levels and with different actors and sectors and in the process we have emphasized that benefits from the agreements have to be fairly shared guaranteeing that most of the benefit economic social environmental stays in the Amazon and its people.

We must celebrate the processes and not the just the products. That’s sort of our continuous moto. And finally, that the generation of trust between the different stakeholders is for us the main intangible asset for the pro for our process and the program. And thank you. That’s all that I wanted to share and happy to respond questions.

Jonah:

Great. Thank you so much, Ana María. I just posted in the chat we’re going to bring forward one speaker at a time to ask a question. Please raise your hand in the chat and put down your name, put down your question if you want and we’ll call on you in the order that they come up for the most part. So I’m going to go ahead and start us off with one question. So the many of these calls are focused on investors and the development of investment ready projects across the Amazon region.

Can you tell us a little bit about what existing or what future programs or collaborations you would like to see or that you think could happen with the private sector and investors and private industry between your program between the ASL and companies?

Unidentified participant:

Do you want to respond oneonone or wait for another question? We that one will take one. Go ahead and.

Ana María Gonzalez:

Okay, perfect. So thank you. I think that the at the national at the national level at each of the projects each as I was saying there’s different emphasis that the projects has have done but there are all of most of them have important initiatives of especially sustainable forest non-timber forest products and what like sustainable productive and value chains where there is has they have received support from the private sector and private investors. That said it’s always the doors and the opportunities to invest in the different activities that the projects are doing is open and it’s available.

So it would be a matter of discussing it on a on a opportunity basis. As far as our regional project, one of the things that for which the private sector has been important and we see an opportunity to collaborate is sort of in that broader awareness raising or identifying those like and reaching to the different stakeholders and allowing it to be to identify what are the what is the role of the private sector in the conservation and what are the needs for to strengthen the local communities to be able to engage and have a fair and equitable negotiation with the private sector.

So in those macro regional activities and knowledge is where we see fit. And at the national level as I said it would be like it’s it would be a matter of identifying those opportunities but many of in all of the countries there are opportunities in terms of biocommerce value chains fisheries where the role of the private sector is important.

Jonah:

Great. Okay. Any questions from the audience? Feel free to just come off mic.

Unidentified participant:

Go ahead. Maui too.

Mauricio:

Ana María, thank you so much for the very interesting presentation. Jonah was talking about investors. I was wondering about the approach considering the local population. With our company which has a quite similar name Amazon Sustainable Forestry we focus on providing income to the local population while preserving the forest. Because if we just go there by saying you have to preserve the forest, but we don’t provide income to the locals, we don’t get the local buy in. So we’re not talking about indigenous populations, we’re talking just the normal guys who are looking for a job, who are looking for income.

What is your approach in this respect?

Ana María Gonzalez:

Thank you. And here I’m going to give you of anam like the general approach but an example of what we’ve been doing in Colombia in Colombia the in the Amazon projects in Colombia the we have established what it’s already known as the deforestation restoration and conserv non- deforestation conservation and restoration agreements and in a way is a process by which local communities and yes it’s not only indigenous population it could be it is our farmers non-indigenous afro descendants that agree on and based on a participatory process and a land use planning of their farms they agree to allocate some of their territory to agroforestry to conservation of standing forest like to make the their farms sustainable and in exchange they receive an economic incentive but also some technical assistance.

So the that is the way in which it’s similar to if I understand correctly which what you were referring but it’s important in this approach that it’s participatory that the decisions of what am I going to conserve and why and what do I and why do I get in return is highly participatory and that has to come with a process of strengthening the communities in addition we don’t consider the farms in isolation but there’s also a land use planning by which if you’re allocating areas of conservation it will contribute to the connectivity between protected areas between conservation areas.

So it’s not isolated understanding them with farm by farm but it also has that regional or larger perspective.

Jonah:

Great. Thank you. Next up is John Bruno. John, you’re up. You’re on you’re on mute.

John Bruno:

Can you hear me?

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, there you go.

John Bruno:

So you probably know tourism is one of the important private sector industries and is sustainable tourism and ecoourism are very closely related to conservation and preservation and there’s a lot of activity in the private sector there and you know a lot of the private sector relationships go all the way up to the ministers of tourism. So there are some concurrent relationships from the private sector to the ones you’re describing. How can that gulf between what the large NOS’s are doing and some of the folks who are pioneering sustainable tourism in the Amazon, how can that gulf be lessened so that there’s more so that there’s less, you know, reinvention of the wheel and more collaboration between those private sector efforts that are already going on and the work that you’re describing, which sounds amazing.

Well that’s a tough question because I think that it’s to ensure collaboration I think it’s all about and not reinventing the wheel. I think the having sort of platforms and having the openness to learn from one another is the starting point. And I like even though COVID has been brutal and devastating and terribly sad for the whole world, the idea that we now can connect easily easier and be and have these spaces allow for those trying to do some tourism activities to learn what others are doing. And that’s that is one of the reasons why as I was mentioning we are supporting a knowledge exchange tour and we are waiting crossing our fingers because eventually we will be able to have a group of people go to Brazil and to learn about community tourism.

And our goal here is like our effort is to support the local the local communities sort of when to engage and better present sort of their value added to the to the private investors and say we can make businesses together. This is our conditions. This is our way of doing it together and to exchange between the different initiatives that are we’re starting with the three Colombia, Brazil and Peru so that they can learn from one another. That’s our effort and goal.

Ana María Gonzalez:

That sounds amazing. And I since it’s sort of similar to what our mission is I should have introduced myself. I’m the executive director of the International Ecoourism Society. I hope you know we can we can reach out to you and possibly you know get in your you know sort of your radius so that there’s some possible collaboration there if we’re needed if we can be of assistance.

John Bruno:

Wonderful. Thank you.

Jonah:

Great. Next up is Neil. Neil, also please introduce yourself. You’re on it says you’re off mute but your microphone might not be working. It’s hard for us to hear you. Yeah, I see you’re speaking but we can’t hear you. If you want to type your question, I’ll be happy to ask it for you. Okay, while you get that working, I’m going to Yeah, we still can’t hear you. While you get that working, I’m going to go ahead and invite Christina Belli.

Christina:

Hi, everyone. Hi. Nam Maria, I’m from Venezuela and obviously Venezuela’s the big absentee here. And we all know why. And we know it’s pointless to think of working with the with the current government, but is there any way by I mean we I head up an organization, an NGO, and I’m actively working. We’re funding, we’re raising funds to work with indigenous people doing agroforestry. And we’re doing this right now very successfully, completely under the radar so that the Maluto regime doesn’t come after them or start investigating where they’re getting their funds from, which would be fatal.

But I’m just wondering whether there’s any way of tapping into these funds and bypassing the government going straight to the private sector and to NOS’s and to indigenous people.

Ana María Gonzalez:

So I have as a multiple answer. First the Jeff the global environmental facility that funds our program operates via the national governments. So that is something that it’s beyond my reach and my system. It is the each national project na national country has an operational focal point for the Jeff and they’re the ones who decide the projects the agencies and most of them are within the ministries of environment in Brazil it’s in the ministries of ministry of economy but mo usually is there that said we can sort of engage and have knowledge exchanges with organizations from Venezuela.

And I’m just going to give you two examples. In 2018 where we have we have a na an annual conference where we invite all our stakeholders from the national projects and we also invite other guests. And in 2018 we had our annual conference in Iikitos in Peru and we invited representatives one representative from the ministry of it. Sorry if it has a very long name, but the Ministry of Environment in Venezuela. And he was he gracially attended and he told everybody about her his views and his mission or his interest and it was a very it was an important moment from all the governments to first give him the floor to talk and have the dialogue.

And we also invited regardless of our political differences and we also invited representatives from the NGO Proita and they also shared their knowledge and their information about the what they had about the about the Amazon. And a second example is that we recently within what I was telling you about the alliance for the contamination of mercury we have and I’m sorry I’m try I was trying to look while talking but I it’s too much for me the name but we invited maybe Mariain remembers the a person from an NGO in Venezuela that has a lot of experience and knowledge in about mercury and about the contamination that it creates.

So we are not we in those kind of a spaces we have the possibility of engaging and allowing people from Venezuela to share their knowledge to share their experiences and to build dialogue because the we share the we are neighbors and we share the same problems. So if that’s the way that we can work together but unfortunately like the flow of mo money that’s within the reach of the government at least for the Jeff or for now I don’t know if eventually the Jeff will change and will there are however and I can contact to with you but there are possibilities within the Jeff to have for NOS’s to reach to small grants funds that can be a possibility for the NOS’s in Venezuela.

Well, and in other countries too, of.

Unidentified participant:

Course. And Maria, just to tell the name of the organization is RICE.

Ana María Gonzalez:

No, Rice is the Yes, it was a representative of the NGO that is part of Rice. Uhu. Yes. Thank you, Mar.

Jonah:

Great. I’m going to go ahead and read the question that Neil was going to ask but had microphone issues. Neil says, “I run an organization which has recently started an agroforestry project with various indigenous communities in Putumayo to promote the planting of native seeds instead of cocoa plants. How can projects like mine engage in collaboration with ASLE?”.

Ana María Gonzalez:

Well it’s wonderful. I think that if it’s in the I don’t know if it’s pu if it’s Colombian Putumayo I think we can get in touch because I besides the whole overall program I’m also the coordinator of the Colombian Amazon project and the preparation of this regional project in the pujo isa basin between the four countries and it’s in under preparation but one of the things is that there’s going to be some competitive like process of allocating funds to organizations that can support value chains in alliance of course and benefiting local communities.

So there are we c we can expand on that. And there will be opportunities to work together or facilitating or allowing for technical assistance and support to the local communities that are already producing well non-timber forest products or other sustainable products. We’re not, of course, we’re not promoting any activity that will derive in deforestation and bringing cows or I don’t know palm to the Amazon.

Jonah:

Great. Thank you for that. I have one more question that was asked by Bobby Duny who was also having microphone issues. And Bobby wanted to thank you for your very insightful presentation and to ask about the state of COVID in indigenous communities now and what long interm long-term impact will it have on indigenous wisdom knowledge bases moving forward.

Ana María Gonzalez:

So I don’t have exactly and I’ll going to look but there is a I don’t have exactly the numbers of course because they change a lot. I checked and there’s this our source of information because the it’s different. It’s hard to find a single source of information for the whole Amazon. But there’s this sineras this religious organization that collects some information from the from the from churches and seems to be doing a good job in terms of aggregating at the Amazon level. So the I think that the situation is better of course than before.

Unfortunately the COVID highlighted brutally how connected the Amazon is and how the COVID arrived via the river to Brazil and quickly spread just crossing one street to the other to Colombia and cross the river and then you are in Peru. And one thing that I when I’m thinking about the COVID and with indigenous communities, let me share with you something that really stroke my heart honestly. And it was in a in a webinar maybe four months ago, an indigenous leader who unfortunately died. He mentioned that he was making reference to the Leticia pact and to the all the agreements that governments have and institutions have to collaborate.

No. And he just said look you are have all these documents have all these papers but we are dying here and when it comes to do a collective effort to support us you’re there’s nothing to be done and so it was a it was like of course I couldn’t we none of us individually can solve the problem but it was very heartbreaking to hear him saying to and this was a webinar there were government representatives were people from different organizations and he was saying look this is this is your urgent chance to work together to collaborate to see beyond the political border and help us out because we are dying here and the sad thing is that they’re still dying like their vaccination has gone it has gone well in some areas I’ve heard from directly from people around Manau that was like was hit so badly that some a lot of indigenous communities in the areas of Manau have been vaccinated and they’re willing to be vaccinated.

No, because that’s another issue. So there are some areas of hope. There are some areas that we still need to hope and try to engage the institutions that are in charge of that. We are we are we do not work with the health institutions. So we are doing our best and our projects for instance supported the especially the organizations in charge of protected areas to provide assistance and also a lot of communication and raising awareness done by the NOS’s mostly to prevent the contagious of the COVID.

Jonah:

Thank you for that. Next up is Eduardo Shenberg.

Eduardo Schenberg:

Hello everybody. Thanks Jonah. I’m from Brazil and I’m the creator of a new smartphone application called Amazon Alerta and we use cryptography and blockchain technology to help indigenous people and local people in the Amazon to safely and reliably record what’s going on around them. And we believe this project can be of immense potential for multiple partnerships in the Amazon. At this point I would like to ask regarding Brazil if the program has a local committee or group and who should we contact to discuss possible partnerships and if we can apply for funding and how we can cooperate.

Much Eduardo. Yes, thank you. If I can share with you the if you send put in your in the chat your email, I can send with you the name of the person that is in Brazil sort of directly in charge of our ASL project and she will give you a better information about how to access. But sounds really interesting and good to have the smartphone. I hope you have succeeded with the connectivity issues that are in some areas that make it difficult to access and connect.

Ana María Gonzalez:

Okay, thank you. I put the emails in the chat.

Eduardo Schenberg:

I took note. Thank you.

Jonah:

Great. Next up, Fiona. You’re on mute.

Fiona:

Hi.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you so much.

Fiona:

I’m got an echo here. Just checking in here. Let me sorry about that. Sorry checking in on three areas specifically Ana María on the integration for Colombia with Gaia Amazonas Paco or Franchesco and I are involved in several projects but we’d very much like to learn how do we collaborate deeper with you as we go forwards. That’s the first and secondly help educate the others that are also in here on how can we work across multiple countries and so that we are deploying systems and then the third part would be as decarboniz.org is a nonprofit that is specifically related to research and deployment of collaborative strategies and projects.

We have been chosen also as a qualified team for X-prise rainforest called act now and it’s led by right now co-led by five indigenous scientists women from different countries and one of the core areas is how do we look at data and analytics as well as utilizing this data for biodiversity to support and protect the forest. But equally there’s a flip side. Will there be an opportunity working together with you and the World Bank to look at their opportunity for carbon trading to be delivered down at a level for indigenous peoples to get paid to protect their forests and their land entitlement.

Thank you.

Ana María Gonzalez:

Thank you Fiona. You mentioned Gaia, the Colombian NGO, right?

Unidentified participant:

Yes. Thank you. So we the ASL and.

Ana María Gonzalez:

The regional project has supported several NOS’s and then and the alliance that has it’s not it’s a GA mason but also different NOS’s in Col in Peru is in Brazil is a issa yepe echosensia so there’s a group of NOS’s that we have we have received proposals from this organiz organizations and we have supported them in their activities to strengthen let’s put it let’s it multiple activities but let’s call it governance or strengthen governance of indigenous communities. For the sake of like given their emphasis of these NOS’s so and how we usually operate is that and that was something that I w that I highlighted maybe not strongly enough is that we in a way we are demandd driven like our the leaders of our projects are the national governments and the environ and the ministries of environment and that has a plus and a minus, right?

So we in our in a way when proposals come to us we have to submit it to our steering committee but we have succeeded in showing and leading the way in the government’s in this space telling us go ahead let’s work with the NOS’s let’s do this together especially with the sake of being that regional perspective if I was asking for a specific project in one country then I would have to go through the national sort of governance structure but I think that has been something that has been very positive in how we have set up the governance of the of the ASL because that sort of that break between if you are if you like that you will not get past some of the barriers from like the political barriers we have been able to achieve.

Of course going and being very clear on who is benefiting from the activities that it has to be the local communities and it has to be with of course under conservation and sustainable development action. So we like to receive proposals we unfortunately don’t say we cannot say yes to all of them. As all of us have limited resources. But our goal mo mostly is sort of to engage and when it is it’s not about only financing but sharing what we have do done then we are more than welcome and we can put in place the ways in which our stakeholders will learn from what others are doing.

And that is and that is u like that’s part of our mission. Excellent. Okay. We have five minutes left. Are there any other questions?

Jonah:

Feel free to come off mic. If not, I have one.

Unidentified participant:

Yes.

Jonah:

An Maria, could you tell us a little bit about the, the interactive data platform that you guys provide and how people use it? I was just studying it this morning and I saw the timberflow website which I had never seen before. It’s an extraordinary amount of data that you guys aggregate.

Ana María Gonzalez:

Yes. So this is this is done by not directly by us. It’s like a World Bank office that does a lot of they’re the technology gurus. I’m definitely not. So they provided that service to our program. And what they did is that they collected in one site just to be a one-stop shop to the different open opensource databases about the Amazon. So that we so it’s open to the public is for people to understand and to learn how to gather information about the Amazon. We have pending to do like sort of a in a way a training for the our stakeholders like and park rangers to have access and to learn how to navigate better the data platform.

That will come easier when we have this translated to Spanish and Portuguese. So it is a sort of it was a good product that the World Bank did for us. And so we in a we also did sort of a subgroup of that platform only specific for the PUA isabin. So it’s the same but narrowing down to databases and information for this by basin. And when it was possible the people from the geographic system office sort of highlighted and traced the margins of the pumo isa because not everybody like people know where is the Amazon you kind of located but not this basin.

With the disclosure that the limits are not because they’re not political limits. It was sort of our creation of for our project. What do we understand by the limit of this basin? But visually it helps for multiple stakeholders. If you want to find something about no scenarios of climate change in the basin, you go to the portal, you click on the proper the proper database and you see the no it’s easier for dummies like us like me to see the limit. So it’s welcome everybody and of course if when you’re clicking that because I saw that it’s in the chat you know of other open sources databases we will add it no pro so because that’s the whole idea to receive feedback and inputs because it’s for everybody.

Jonah:

Great for people who would like to follow up what is the best way that they can do so.

Ana María Gonzalez:

So you can reach to me I’m writing my email and it has it’s not self-explanatory my email because it’s a V as it’s my second last name but it’s V Gonzalez 3 World Bank and Maria if you can type your email so you can be my backup so we don’t take too long in responding. But thank you very much. This felt like a very I think it’s the nicest interview I ever had.

Jonah:

It’s great. You’re great. We’re all on the same side. We’re huge fans of what you’re doing. We want to collaborate. I sense lots of support on this call. We are at the top of the hour and this is where we switch over to unstructured time and half the time our call guests leave and half the time they stick around for a few minutes to you know have unstructured conversations. So, thank you. And, yeah, now it’s the free-for-all. Greetings, everybody. Feel free to tell us how your week was or to say goodbye.

Either way, are you able to speak to stick around for a couple minutes?

Unidentified participant:

Yes. Okay, great. Thanks everybody. Great presentation. Ciao. Thanks for joining us, Peter.

Jonah:

I see a couple of new people. Pedro, would you like to come off mic and introduce yourself? Oh, he just disconnected. Ana María, you’re quite popular. We almost got up to 37 almost to 40 people. That’s the You’re at the higher end of our popularity.

Ana María Gonzalez:

Thank you. But I was nervous. Well, Mauricio is here. Mauricio put me on the spot with one of the hardest questions. What were the Oops.

Mauricio:

Ana María, Ana María, if I may, if I may add.

Unidentified participant:

Yes, of course. If I looked at the map.

Mauricio:

Correctly, we should already be cooperating because if I read the map that you showed of the Brazilian Amazon, you seem to have the 900,000 hector of the Reserva Chico Mendes under the protected land that you have. And these are some of the communities that we are cooperating for sustainable forestry. And the practical side of this is it has been quite a challenge to get those communities to deliver the amount of wood that we need. We could be making much more for them. But sometimes you need to have some centralized organization like some of these reserves have.

And if you have too much power divided downstream so to say you end up by not getting anything done unfortunately.

Ana María Gonzalez:

Well yes I think that for and I have to admit here that I am the coordinator for the overall program no with the five projects and now it’s going to be 10 but there are pro with when the other four countries come but for the details of what’s happening in Brazil because it’s such a large project there is another person that couldn’t join us so I’m happy to if you give me your email I can introduce her to you and you can discuss exactly what are the activities that are being done in the Chico Mendes Reserve because yes like it’s a well this is the Brazilian is a massive project so it has first it has the ARPA the that I don’t know if you know the ARPA for like 117 protected areas are benefiting for from the this project and from the funding for ARPA, but there’s also a large a lot of areas where sustainable management practices are being done.

I can look on my in my computer and my folders if what are the exact activities that we’re doing in this reserve. But it’s easier and quicker if I put you in contact with the right person. Because if there are opportunities of working collaboratively that would be like I’m sign me up.

Mauricio:

Super. I just sent you my email address.

Ana María Gonzalez:

Excellent. I’m taking note.

Jonah:

Pedro, you’re you’re back. I think you disconnected. Would you like to introduce yourself?

Pedro Gasparin:

Hello. Sorry, I was having problems with my connections. My name is Pedro Gasparin. I’m an economist and director for CSF Brazil Conservation Strategy Fund. It’s a pleasure to be here.

Jonah:

Great. Thanks for joining us. I saw you join right at the top of the hour as we were ending. I’m not sure if you have the time zone off. This is the sort of the afterparty just so you know in case you’re looking for the main event.

Pedro Gasparin:

Okay. Thank you.

Jonah:

The afterparty.

Pedro Gasparin:

So I think I had this problem with the time zone. So sorry for that.

Jonah:

Okay. No worries. This is the time for the unstructured conversation.

Pedro Gasparin:

Okay. Good.

Jonah:

Yeah. I think Maicio is the one who brought the wine. This just a joke just to be clear.

Mauricio:

Yeah. Well, would be difficult to share it virtually.

Jonah:

Well said.

Unidentified participant:

I just having a cup of tea for the moment.

John Bruno:

Ana María, thank you so much for your presentation. This is John Bruno again. So what we focus on ma mainly is sustainable tourism and ecoourism. And all the major I NOS’s IUCN U WWF that you mentioned UNDP RAMsar convention they all identify ecoturism and sustainable tourism as a way to help generate revenue around conservation and so what you know just since we’re in unstructured time what is if I may what are what are your thoughts on tourism in the Amazon region and how could it could be useful to help bring revenue directly to communities around conservation.

Ana María Gonzalez:

Well, I think that it’s a it’s a still an unexplored gem. But it but it has to have the limitations the proper limitations. I think that to ensure that we’re not sort of overcrowding or over sort of to for the sake of tourism the Amazon cannot be put in danger. Let’s put it that way. So it is an important opportunity as I was saying for us one of the lessons learned that kind of sometimes feel obvious but they’re not and you need to repeat it is that the benefits of any nature-based solution in the Amazon most of the benefits need to remain in the local communities and the way to ensure that is treadening the extreening the local communities so that they can better value the services that they’re providing better value the activities that they’re doing.

And so that’s part of what we sort of intend to do. And I think that the Amazon has well it is it is it’s not the same of course to seeing tourism in the Amazon in the whole region. As I was saying at the beginning, I’m Colombian and there are some places in Colombia that unfortunately are beautiful and that it would be wonderful to be able to visit, but there’s no there’s not a possibility to visit because there is this there’s violence. So, we cannot do that. So, there are limitations to h to where and how tourism can be there.

But it is like the an a great nature-based solution and it’s sort of the one that ensures that standing forest is important. No, you don’t need to cut like it’s on the other side. It’s not a matter of cutting the trees to produce something. It is the one and only maybe activity that the more pristine you leave the thing the nature and the landscape the better. No,.

John Bruno:

I 100% agree. I don’t want to shamelessly plug you know nature based nature-based ecoourism but the money from ecoourism does tend to remain in the community. In fact, lots of work has been done uhifying that it about 80. So it’s a very efficient way instructure loan investment and as you said the most important part there’s no need to in any way affect it tends to provide a revenue stream that there should be like in Costa Rica for instance where 25% of the land’s protected and they have the highest tourism spend you can actually have tourism that is that allows more protected areas and more sustainable practice and get people behind it because it generates good revenue for them and their families.

Ana María Gonzalez:

Yeah. Yeah. And the ASL has done some the sort of tourism is not our mayor activities but it’s a raise it’s being more and more identified as important and so there are some piloting activities even in Colombia that I was mentioning it as a as a as a bad place but it’s not that there are some places there are very nice pilots of communitydriven sustainable tourism in that are being supported by the project. Yes. So happy to talk about that more.

Jonah:

I have a question about the recent philanthropy study that you guys did about in you know the followup from the 2017 more publication that the conservation strategy fund was involved in. Has the process of gathering that data created a learning space where those investors and philanthropists, governments come together in an ongoing way.

Ana María Gonzalez:

Yes and no. So the while we were preparing the project and we will be gathering the information. Yes, the we had very active participation and in a way it showed like we were able to sort of convene a lot of organizations not only NOS’s and but also multilaterals and bilaterals in a single moment in a single meeting and they were very generous in sharing their information. And we agreed on as we will continue and we have the commitment to continue the process maybe every I think it’s every three years and so the next publication is going to be quite interesting because it’s the funding while COVID and we’ll see how this have shifted and after that.

When we were presenting the results this groups of this group of donors asked us to have meetings, thematic meetings every six months and that’s what I that’s what I’m saying yes and no because we agreed on that but the six months are coming in September and we don’t have a plan but it’s because there’s so many cups and events that it would be silly to just gather another event they will not come they’re too busy. So we are that’s what I say like you brought my in my to-do list that’s one that it’s in capital letters to say where how am I going to convene them but what we’re going to do is that we also because of their request we’re going to do a study based on case studies that they help us identify of projects where more than one donor contributed and so to extract some lessons learned not only from the donors but from the recipients of that financing of what is effective conserv collaboration because we talk a lot about let’s get together, let’s collaborate donors, you can you need to know what the others are doing to establish synergies.

But what does that really translate in the identification of the project in the preparation of the project in the implementation like in the different stages of the project? How can you really ensure and give tips to the donors to how you can collaborate? Is it creating a steering committee? Is it creating a forum? Is it creating an investor platform like Jonah does? Like how what do we what are the kind of tips? And that is something that they ask us for ask us to do. And so we hope to start next month.

And with that with that study then we will be able to convene and call them again for a for a real re like and not to disrupt like there everybody’s busing now.

Jonah:

Well said.

Fiona:

Can I ask something Jonah?

Jonah:

Sure if Maria has time. Sure.

Ana María Gonzalez:

Yes. I need to leave in two minutes. So, I have a I one of my two important things is that I have two boys and one of them needs me to needs to I need to drive him to his soccer practice.

Fiona:

That is the most important and I apologize. I’m also in taking care of grandma who’s late cancer. So, I’m in a in her painting studio. So, we all have commitments. I’m want just wanting to know you know where Panama has not been part of this scope is there a possibility you know part of Futura Forestal and the team that I’ve worked with there we’ve also were co-managing the management for some of the Harvard forests in Nicaragua in Colombia and we’re looking at several models in Bolivia right now on doing the multiecies multigener generational forest with the degradated land and then it has the nursery structure involved with it.

How would we approach you? Is it since Panama is not coming in at this point do we have to go through the Nicaragua or the Colombia side?

Ana María Gonzalez:

Well for I have a two ideas here. One is that first in terms of if it was only about knowledge exchange, we will be happy to learn about more about what you’re doing and engage and invite the Panameanians, the Colombians, the Amazon. That’s a like we as I was saying, we went to Guatemala to learn about in Pen to learn about community forestry. So that’s in our we and I have and we are in conversations to give you a very other extreme of the planet of working and learning from people in Indonesia who sort of have somehow similar problems and solutions because it’s not only about the problems so happy to organize and to talk to you more about but also I can give you the information of the World Bank also is the manager of another Jeff impact program that it’s called the global wildlife program and that global wildlife program has national projects sort of similar like we are but this is not regional for the Amazon it’s for the theme the wildlife and it’s and they have projects in Asia Africa, Latin America and one of them is in Panama.

So there are some stakeholders in Panama that could be sort of that could be also an entry point to what we do because we are also working with that program sort of to do some exchanges in ter in issues related to wildlife and human wildlife conflict too between the ASL and the Amazon country. So there are.

Unidentified participant:

Yes.

Ana María Gonzalez:

Yes. Like I’m going to say something cheesy. The world the World Bank is supposed to be a knowledge bank. So we’re happy to promote engagement between different countries. Yes.

Jonah:

Great.

Ana María Gonzalez:

Thank you so much for your time everybody.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you very much Jonah.

Unidentified participant:

Have a good afternoon everybody.

Jonah:

Thank you. You too. Have a good one. Bye. Bye, guys.

Unidentified participant:

Bye.