Agroforestry in the Amazon with PRETATERRA

Agroforestry is a land use strategy that unites trees and agriculture. It can restore forest canopy, sequester carbon and earn more per hectare than traditional crops. Can it help prevent ecological collapse of the Amazon? Can it replace the monocultures grown in the region today? Join Paula Costa and Valter Ziantoni to learn about Pretaterra, their startup consultancy that is attempting to scale agroforestry development globally by designing large tree-farm systems, conducting research, systematizing knowledge, and developing new software.

Recorded July 12, 2021

References:

Paula Costa and Valter Ziantoni, scaling agroforestry by complexifying growing systems using software

Farmers in the Amazon could earn 9 times more and prevent ecosystem collapse

WATCH:

  • Jonah
  • Paula Costa
  • Valter Ziantoni
  • David
  • Walter
  • Fiona
  • Marcia
  • Massimiliano
  • Philip

Jonah:

Hello everybody. This is the 40some 50some I forgot I’ve lost count call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing force friendly economic development and the rule of law across the Amazon region of South America. We do it in collaboration with governments and NOS’s and investors and philanthropists and lots of other allies. Everyone is welcome to post their names and LinkedIns and websites and email addresses below so people can get an appreciation for who’s on the call. This week we are featuring the work of Paula Costa and Valteri of Preta.

They are agroforestry evangelists and they are working to reforest the Amazon region with orchards and forest gardens and trees that not only sequester carbon but that produce an income for local communities. They’re working on large scale projects and small scale projects. Their ambitions are not just limited to the Amazon. They are globally minded as well. It’s an extraordinary honor to have you guys with us. So I don’t know if you saw I sent you guys a list of questions ahead of time that I was planning on going through. Is that do you guys want to do it that way or do you want to do a formal presentation?

Unidentified participant:

I think well first of all thank you for the invitation and we are absolutely opened for the format you’re more comfortable with.

Valter Ziantoni:

Yeah. And everybody thank you everybody nice to meet you all thank you Jonah and as you prefer and more than evangelist we are forestry designers and it’s Valter Ziantoni.

Jonah:

Zanton okay.

Unidentified participant:

The way you prefer Italian.

Jonah:

Okay great yeah let’s go ahead and follow an interview format okay so Paula Valter let’s begin with you guys as children. Where did you grow up? Where did you develop these eco entrepreneurial farmer ambitions from?

Paula Costa:

Great question. Well, both of us we are from São Paulo state. Actually, I’m from São Paulo, the city as well. Both of us. And well, I can speak a little bit about myself. You can go ahead. I was raised I was I grow up in the big city in São Paulo city actually and but I had this childhood living with my family in the countryside in forest gardens but especially with my grandmother who used to be a farmer. She used to plant coffee and so I used to hear from her and live by her all the stories of farmers of coffee producing of living the countryside and I had this passion but I also had the passion for nature.

So that’s why I ended up studying biology and afterwards forest engineer.

Valter Ziantoni:

Yeah. So I try to make this short but you said from my childhood so it’s difficult it’s long time ago but I’m also from São Paulo São Paulo city like the biggest city in the South America one of the biggest in the world but I grew up basically in the city and going to the countryside all the time. I come from Italian family from immigrants, Italian immigrants and they brew coffee since ever since they arrived in Brazil, my grandparents. And so I was always to living and visiting the countryside and being extremely attached to agriculture and life basically everything that regards forest and conservation.

I was there it was part of my family. So I grew this passion for forest and conservation and during my when I was a teenager basically I engage in several movements agroforestry. I donate and for peace and I camp a lot. I climbed things and I understood how men could how humankind could live in synergy with nature. So I decided to study forest engineering and in the very first year I met I meet Ernest Gotch. I knew what was going on with agroforestry in Brazil and that was 2001 and since then I’ve been doing agroforestry.

I developed my masters and everything and we founded Patera five almost six years ago now and that comes from the very beginning of our lives. Yeah,.

Jonah:

Great. Tell us about how you guys met, where you met.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, actually we met six, seven years ago working together in Fazinda Datka, which is one of the biggest agroforestry entrepreneur projects in the world. I would say where we had this challenge to apply the knowledge we had the empirical knowledge we had of agraforestry with small hooded farmers and with traditional communities indigenous communities into a large scale model. So that we back then we were leading the R&D section in Fazinata and we developed together a few designs and so that’s when we understood the challenge we had ahead of us which was to spread to disseminate agroforestry everyone everywhere.

So we need to understand these large scale logics to in order to do so. Yeah, I believe that at this very point is where the entrepreneurialship seed was well planted or irrigated let’s say and when it starts to grow because before that we worked for a lot of initiatives basically I myself I worked for FIO UNDP several countries in the world especially Africa and Southeast Asia long years in the Brazilian Amazon especially is where we have our biggest basically knowledge or experience. But then when we met at Fazenda we were selected because you were the probably the most knowledgeable people on agroforestry by that time that could work with different kinds of agroforestry.

Not only like there are specialists all over the world of course but we are generalists in a way of say you’re generalist is because you have been working with so many agroforestry systems around the world and leading this entrepreneurship the RD section the research and development is the is the very import point in our lives where we have this tipping moment where we understand that we should do that to everyone everywhere. And the way we find found to do this was creating Patera and yes by that time we met each other we fall in love and we became partners in life and in business.

Unidentified participant:

Exactly.

Jonah:

Excellent. You took you took the next question. It’s always nice to understand love is the source of any endeavor. So tell us, okay, let’s go le let’s put our roots in the ground for a little second in Fazenda. Could you tell us just in a couple of phrases what the history of it is, who owns it, and then also what is Rizma Agro?

Unidentified participant:

Great. So, Faza, it’s the it’s a company founded by Pedropo Denise. He was looking for firstly to implement organic orange production, orange trees production, citrus generally citrus production. So he was converting to organic and eventually he understood that the real challenge was not to convert to organic but to convert to agroforestry to a more biodiverse, more complex, more resilient production system. And so the challenge they faced in Fazenatka was to develop large scale agroforestry designs and not only agroforestry. Faz taco today also have one of the largest I would say the largest in Brazil production of organic eggs and with the experience that was developed in Fazina along probably eight years more even more than that with organic and agroforestry large scale production systems.

They started they founded his Omagra. Pedro Paulo founded his Omagro to scale even more and also to apply this knowledge to other productions to other crops especially grains. Right. Yeah. So and looking for large scale commodity organic regenerative and agroforestry production systems. So if I if I might complentate Roma is a spin-off of all the knowledge of fender talk for the talk is still there and Roma is now facing this challenges of doing regenerative agroforestry or regenerative agriculture rather than agroforestry per se.

Unidentified participant:

And yeah they are they’re really good.

Jonah:

Great. Now tell us about Preta where does the name come from and as a consultancy you know what is your business model forprofit nonprofit what are the services as an advisory venture that you guys provide? Well, taking your first.

Unidentified participant:

Question first, your second question first, about the business model, we prefer to name ourselves as a regenerative hub or a regenerative intelligence agroforestry hub instead of a company. Our business model, we are not an NGO, but we work a lot as NGO. It means like trying to do the best we can with the resources we have with the best partners we can find. The idea is to do agroforestry and what we do is to design and develop agroforestry models or agroforestry designs that are modular, replicable, elastic and that can be applied to any biome or any size of land.

And that’s what we have been developing since we were founded. We started this work.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. And actually we started it we were working in Fazoka and we noticed that we had this challenge and these this mission to spread this knowledge that we’re trying we’re starting to develop there. And well we’ve been always adventurous. So we started we figured out we should start our own way even if we didn’t know how big it could be. We were looking to be big but we didn’t know how big it could be. And actually we are called because backwards it means it’s based on or it’s inspired in what is the tea or the indigenous black earth in the Amazon.

So we know everybody knows that the soil in the Amazon is not fertile at all. All the fertility of the soil is stocked in the biome in the biomass in the forest biomass and not in the soil per se. But we know also that there are a few spots, a few patches wide around the Amazon basin that we can find these points, these regions where the soil is super fertile. It has a lot of nutrients as and it’s super black, super dark. And in the end, researchers found out it is the result of human management of these ancient populations that used to live in the forest for over 4,000 years ago.

Managing the forest, planting and chopping down and burning sometimes, but more of the time planting it and especially selecting edible species. And this management ended up in the super fertile soil that we have the so this is super magical. It sounds magical but actually it’s super real. So it shows that actually our in our DNA in our essence we are actually regenerative beings and not destructive beings and as we’ve been so for so long and actually it was a way of doing agriculture with the forest. So this is something that we it’s really inspiring from us because we like to say that we are ancestralists that we inspire in the technology in the logics in the in the knowledge of these ancient populations traditional people to inspire the solutions we are looking for today.

So that’s why we’re called.

Jonah:

Great. I now want to ask about agroforestry scaling. So it for the for the non-believer or the newcomer, it seems too good to be true. A story that sequesters carbon, that restores forest canopy and transpiration rates, that can produce more per hectare than traditional monocultures. You know if it’s such a dream come true for the region then it begs the question why doesn’t it scale what or why hasn’t it scaled yet and I’d love for you to give some thought to that and a response and I and there are several dimensions is it that I wanted to ask about is it simply limited market demand or available financing or labor costs or irrigation needs or is there a lack of farmer interests?

What are the stumbling blocks that limit agroforestry scaling all across the region at least to this state?

Unidentified participant:

That’s a great question.

Unidentified participant:

Wow, that’s a one billion questions u question or answer and yeah there are several points that are right in what you said but basically the very first thing is that it’s real. Agroforestry is real. What you just said is real. You have more plants per area. You work a threedimension thread dimensionally. You have a bigger rate of photosynthesis what have a big rate of everything else. The transpiration, vap transpiration, infiltration, water retentation and everything else. So ecosystem services what usually we take for grant it’s all there. We only have to do agroforestry and then why it can why it’s did not scale yet and it will it will scale they’re going to scale pretty sure I’m pretty sure about that there are several challenges it’s not one of them but is a paradigm is a way of thinking is a is a mindset that has to be converted before is the monoculture paradox that you have to work with.

So we can actually say several things I believe but gathering information, creating a proper u agroforestry builder software gathering funds and doing that seriously properly considering agroforestry as a proper ESG investment that the risks can be calculated and mitigated is the key. We can do that in a modular, replicable and safe way for the planet and for investors.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, if I can complement why it hasn’t scaled yet. That’s a question that people ask us a lot and we actually we have the answer for that. It’s because it’s complex. It’s hard to do. It’s not simple. The knowledge it’s not there yet. We have to develop it. We have to do it together. So there are so many people dedicating great professionals dedicating them themselves to produce I don’t know games or any other solution or I don’t know cosmetics. Shouldn’t we be working and putting our efforts and knowledge and creativity in really this solution that we really believe in?

So that’s pretty much what we are trying to do now. And so the first thing first thing is to understand that it’s really complex. It’s not that simple. So once we understand it’s complex that’s why we have to systematize. So that’s why in our everything that we do everything that we plan we do it in a systematized way. So that the farmer can understand their system because most of the time when you see an agroforestry system an agroforestry design it’s not properly systematized. Probably the this one farmer just start doing it in a more empirical way and it’s not organized.

So you don’t really know what comes first, what goes next. And so when you organize, you systematize, you know the step by step of the process, you know all the costs, all the inputs, all the outputs or all the revenues you have planned ahead, then you can understand how to scale it, how to replicate it. So and well coming from that understanding that the complexity of this system there are so many others because all the market is organized all the logistic is organized for one single product. Every farmer he’s got in his mind I’m either a grain producer or I’m a macto rancher or I’m a civil culturist but I’m not going to do the three things at the time so we have to gather all this knowledge all this information so this farmer have got to access many markets at the same time so he need to organize not only with himself but with many other farmers he need to access finance as you mentioned and most of the finance that are available they are all the people who are in charge of saying if it’s yes or no for the finance they don’t really understand complex production system so they look at that and say how is this going to work when is the money starting to arrive and so if we don’t have the proper planning of this design of this agroforestry plantation ations of these agroforestry systems.

People won’t adopt it and that’s what has been happening for so long. Most of a agroforestry designs they work in a small scale because it’s what one farmer can do what he looks and works every day. So what we need to do is to systematize so that more people can understand and replicate. Right.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. Oh, there are so many things to say. Jonah, you could you could say like hours talking about the benefits and they wait to turn and turn all monocrops in the world into agroforestry and more or less biodiverse but basically do everywhere.

Unidentified participant:

And so if anybody comes to you and say no just do agroforestry because it’s very easy it’s very simple it’s going to save the world. No, this person needs to understand how challenging it is because it is you have to spend a lot of time, a lot of effort, a lot of knowledge to understand how the forest work, how the how each species of the system works. What are the costs, the time to do every management? So it is very complex indeed.

Jonah:

I get why the software development is so important. So I’m just going to pepper you guys with a couple more questions and then we’re going to open it up to everybody else. Tell us what is silo pasture?

Unidentified participant:

Silvopasture.

Unidentified participant:

You want to go for it? Yeah.

Unidentified participant:

So silvopasture is very simple. Silvo is the is the word for planting trees for planting forest for production and pasture is to cattle ranching. So you just do your cattle ranching with trees within the pasture. So and you can understand a number of benefits with that. So if the cattle have shade they will have much less stress. You can imagine in tropical regions how much sun they get in their backs how hot it can be. So the cattle will get much less stress. So end up producing much better. Even the grass produces better when you have the proper amount of shade in the area in the in the grass in the pasture.

And you can diversify your production system. Of course you won’t have only cattle. You won’t have only meat or dairy in your production system. You’ll also have trees and you can have a number of products from the trees going from timber to non-timber forest products such as nuts, fruits, essential oils, all kinds of resins. So it’s an opportunity for cattle ranchers to diversify and to diversify their production systems and to improve the productivity of their cattle as well and the revenue. To I invite you all for a live you we are going to have today an hour and a half after now after we finish this meeting actually it will be 6:30 8:30 Brazil time for a magazine called DBO is the most renew well-known magazine of Brazilian agro and they are talking a lot about regenerative system and we will be talking about Silver Pasture and one of our main projects, one of the biggest in the world.

Jonah:

Great. Okay. Next question for you. Just a couple more. Can you can you tell us about the nature of your partnership with Prince Charles, the Prince of Wales?

Unidentified participant:

Yes, it’s a pleasure. Well what happened is that his royal highness Prince Charles started initiative called first the terra carta that you might know and the circular bioeconomy alliance. So it first was created as a as a meeting involving some people that start to map actually the best people in the world to do their jobs in different fronts and EFI, the European Forest Institute receive was in charge of find these people in the person of Marqu Palahi. And then with several other people you’re invited honored invited to be the agroforestry front.

So the agroforestry and implementers all projects of the circular bioeconomy alliance. So since then we have had almost no three meetings with the his royal in person and several week with EFI and other partners. And now we have a project starting in August in India in a sun where we are literally going to turn all production of tea that this tea we all know from Darelene and a sun we turn that into agroforestry in the very first time with circular bio academy alliance that’s our design and we are doing that with cotton as well in the same region there are another project in Ghana where we are converting super culture just three planting into a grow forest reproductive distance and another one start in Nigeria where we are going to be the first to arrive there in August as well I believe in the beginning of August or beginning of September to start a cash net agroforestry system so that is still in the very beginning And so the circular bio economy actually started the alliance started last year in the November actually was launched.

And so we have we have been having these meetings these strategic meetings to understand which are these real glo global challenges and how can we set up inspire large projects that we can show and inspire people how to do agroforestry really to change a landscape on a huge area. So that’s why we are choosing these three points to start and of course there are many other projects in the circular bioeconomy alliance not only with agroforestry we are just we are the agroforestry representatives let’s say but yes that’s pretty much it.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah if I can it’s a little bit complex because there are lots of players there but we are founder members and advisors for agroforestry and the projects I mentioned the three of them Ghana India and Nigeria are projects that we lead. So it’s still ongoing big project.

Jonah:

Great. Okay, two more real quick questions and then for those who have questions after me, please indicate your interest by posting in chat or raising your hand and with that feature. So second to last question, can you guys tell us a little bit about Embrapa and the and the resources that they offer? Future agroforestry farmers.

Unidentified participant:

Well, Embrapa is a company that has government. So sometimes the name sounds strange for foreigners, but we worked for Braa. We studied with then when you do when you study in Brazil when you do your bachelor here you’re a lot involved in rapa if you are in a bio or agro science sites and well they developed they are the oldest institution in Brazil developing technology in agro agriculture or agro production agrail pasture production and well they’re really good. I don’t know what else to say besides that they have all credentials.

We are partners as Patera as an institution as a hub of intelligence. We are partners rarely we do anything that is there is no data from or a person a professional involved in our project. Is very seldom most of the time in BRA is involved directly in our work.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, if I can say most of the knowledge, the technology the basis of agricultural and biological sciences in Brazil are is developed by Embrapa here and we use a lot the their research data. Yeah. For playing our.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. If I if I can compliment one thing more disruptive being I up we have another way to see agraforestry and to see the speed we have to have to convert the whole world into a forestry. So in Braa sometimes is a bit slow in the way they produce science because it’s big.

Unidentified participant:

Because it’s big and because they do a lot of projects but they are really helpful and they have a lot of information.

Jonah:

Great. Okay. First question from the audience. David Bane, please feel free to come off mute and ask your question.

David:

Yes. Thank you so much. I was wondering about a project that I’ve helped with in Mexico that has pine forests. Pine forests in the region of Mitroan, which is you know not far from where the monarch butterfly makes its famous migration. And right now there is some on-site experimentation in the Ahilo with various types of agroforestry and going away from the pure monoculture. But I was wondering if you had ideas or thoughts about general directions for experimentation for pine forest in a region like Mitroakan. Thank you.

Unidentified participant:

Well actually I if I can tell in a very pragmatic way we need first to understand the context and the production system you’re already working with. So usually in our projects every time actually we do an extensive study of the local conditions the local context what the farmers are already used to planting what the this pine allows to plant with it what is possible to do with it. What the market around is looking for maybe what are the market opportunities that we can include in the production system. So I don’t know if we can say like straight ahead what could be something that we could plant there because we don’t know yet the region but you would have to do a profound research to understand the logics understand what’s going on understand the opportunities the possibilities the challenges and then you can identify which are the species that can be mixed with the pine which are I don’t know maybe bushes maybe other species that complement ment the strata you can say.

So, other species that can be planted in the shade of this pine or maybe other animal raising that you could do also or even you can complement in the succession which would mean that while the pine is still growing while the pine is not formed dead doing closing a canopy in the forest maybe you can have other production like grains like cassava like other annual crops within these pine that are growing. So you have all these I would say step-by-step process and these opportunities that you can look for in your species and in your context to propose a system.

Unidentified participant:

No I mean I think go for non-timber foresty products and diversify the silic culture. It’s a pine forest. I don’t I don’t know. Never been to Mitakan but I believe it’s highland. So you can have other kinds of trees there. It cannot go straight to agroforestry but can be a mixture forest and add flowers plants that have flowers that blooming all year long especially because if the monarch has passed there other butterflies or insects or other insects will fly them too. So it will be important for creating corridors of biodiversity.

So go for biodiversity nonforest products and diversify the silic culture. It’s already enormous.

Jonah:

Great. Okay. We’ve got two more questions up. First is Walter Vera and then Fiona Banister. Walter, you’re up.

Walter:

Walter present so many times for your presentation. I’d like to know if you are aware of the ILPF. ILPF is a very successful agroforestry and slow pasture program in Brazil. They since 2015 to 2020 they converted 6 million hectares into agroforestry and civil pastures. Just that well a hider is a is a project supported by hido verde one of the partners of initiative 20 by 20 it grows in very compacted and dry soil. So the pine resin is the best technical solution and the business plan is quite good. The revenues from the pine resin should be able to are able to make the project successful financially.

What needs to be done now is to expand it because it’s being is being deployed in ehidario lands and the problem there is governance and technical capacity. But I would be very interested in learning about your opinions or your linkage to IPF.

Jonah:

Great.

Unidentified participant:

Nice. Thank you for your question. Super.

Unidentified participant:

So actually the ILPF it’s the first step I and also it’s very connected to Embrapa as well. Embra is one of the stakeholders that helped to spread this production system. So, ILPF stands for integration.

Jonah:

So, so I’m going to try to translate it because it’s important. So, integration of crops, pasture and forest, right?

Unidentified participant:

A livestock forest and livestock. Yeah. So in the end you have a system that well the traditional the classical ILPF you have eucalyptus as the forest species the forestry species pasture in the years a third or the fourth year when the eucalyptus is already grown and the animals the cattle won’t damage the trees and you have grain productions within the three lines in the from the year zero to the year third or four three year four right so it’s not that complex but it is one step it is the first step that we have to this conversion so for us it’s amazing because for instance if a if a cattle rancher accepts to produce grains and to put tree lines within their pasture It’s a huge mindset challenge change.

So for us it means a lot and as you said it’s a huge amount of area already converted into ILPF. So it is already this first step has been reached. So people are interested in doing this change. They are seeing the advantages in diversifying their production. So for us we understand the ILPF knowledge is the first step towards agroforestry.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. Most of the time as I said before about we use the knowledge of ELPF or PF what has been developed. So we don’t start from zero necessarily. This first step is a huge step as well and there’s a lot to see there but it’s too simple, not biodiverse enough from our perspective.

Jonah:

Fiona, you’re up next.

Fiona:

Hi everybody. Nice to see you all. Thank you. So yes, there was a few questions that I was looking at was really looking at scale and this is as a small seed investor in agroforestry and multiecies forest models meaning taking replantation or regeneration of older sort of destroyed land pastures and regenerating it back into community gardens and agroforestry as well as mixed timber multiecies models. I’m very interested in when we talk about this question of measurement and scale and the core areas I posed in my question was you know it’s great to explore the scale and how can we support also your growth of the models that you’re working with and then how do we also use technology on those measurements and we’ve discussed this where Jonah and his team deeply brought all these experts on during the summit it’s so important how do we measure it, scale it, and then be able to take it to the investors and say this is viable, this is vital and these are the measurements we can have and we are able to scale these agroforestry models mixed with whether it be mixed with a timber hopefully like something like Futurero forest styles multi-ecies multi-iverse package of not just trees but we look at the bio diversity, the protection of the rainforests and the habitats and a longer term sort of 100red-year model which they have under the generation forest model which again European and several investor groups have been investing in but how do we scale all this together?

Thank you.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you Fiona. Thank you for your question. Is extremely important question I must say because that’s is what make the huge difference when we can show that it’s ESD project that u ESG project that really works and how can we compare that’s the question how can we compare how can I say that this is more biodiverse than that or more profitable or there is this or that ecosystem service that should be paid or should be considered And that’s what we are doing right now. We are developing we already have a method called API agroforestry performance index that you have largely used in our project in the Amazon and we have very simple features instead of having technology there have simple features that can be can be followed can be compared and seen by the farmers for the farmers in the fields.

So like soil covering or tree diameter or number of species rate of survival and small things that together make an algorithm that I can measure if I’m in the same biome or in the same region. But right now you’re putting much more drone analysis in our projects and what you’re doing is selecting specific projects that are what we believe to be the state-of-the-art in regenerative agriculture in the world and you’re adding features or considering a specific features and giving marks to them and trying to have a comparison that can go across several biomes and say of course compensating if it’s not it’s not fair saying that agroforestry is less biodiverse if I’m in a temporate zone than if I’m in the Amazon otherwise it will not be comparable but it can be comparable it’s and creating those KPIs is the main way that we will unlock the investments and the profitability and the trust of investors and that’s what we are doing right now and I would say that drone technology, soil analysis and comparison that can be measured by farmers as the main resources we are using right now.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. Yeah. If I can compliment I would I understand that there are three points that we have to look for when we are measuring or evaluating a system. Especially for investors to look for. The first one is the ecosystem services in general. Second social and third one the economical part right. So an economical part I would say the investors already understand a lot but and but of course we can go very deep on that go into the productivity of each crop in species how much is producing the cost of each operation.

You can go as deep as that. But if we’re talking about social also some things that we evaluate a lot is because sometimes you’re not doing a social entrepreneur. You have your own farm and you’re looking for implementing agroforestry in your own farm. So what’s going to be the social impact? So maybe if you have a very replicable design, a replicable project and you show it to people and farmers around you start to adopting a project like yours. So that’s the adherent part right the adherent so we may we have a few indexes that we call it there are adherent adherency index indexes.

So understanding how that design or that agroforestry is adherent to the region or to neighbor farmers and things like that. So that’s would be the social part. So how many people will adopt a system like that and the third one the ecosystem part which is actually the more complex. The first thing we should we shouldn’t get so complex or so expensive ways of measuring because in the end the measuring part would be more expensive for the farmer than the system itself. So it doesn’t make that sense. So that’s why Valer mentions this technique that we’re using this method that we’re using that the farmer themselves they have this step-by-step process to evaluate how is this part of the system how are the trees how are the fruits how is the soil covering how is the soil color so there are a few KPIs that are very straightforward that are very simple that we can we can do a correlation to larger and more complex indexes I would say.

So yes actually we still have to develop one measure. We are having our own methodology to measure in our in our projects but we should have a unified one probably to compare different projects. That would be ideal. So this is something that we should be working with. We are working with inraa in a few projects to develop some ecosystem services calculation quantification. So and it comes together with the software that we are discussing with some of you here right now.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, exactly.

Jonah:

Great. Next up is Marcia from EcoArts Amazonia and then Masameilliano after that.

Marcia:

Okay. Thank you. Thank you Paula and Valta. Not to mention India and Nigeria. I’m Brazilian too and I want to ask you if you have any experience of planting in Amazonia Bayama once Equarks is a nonprofit organization. I am the third generation of big farmers there. We are seven sisters. We started this nonprofitable organization because we realized that u ketta was a man thing and we should we could do something more than that once we care we take care the forest I’m not sure you are familiar but in the region we are based and where we act where we put all our profits you have to preserve 80% and you can explore 20%.

So my first question we have Embrapa is as a partnered in north of Matros is where we act and my question for you is if you have any experience of planting agroforest system in north of Matrosu and if you could not in a big number which is the profit per actor year. Once we decide to implement a product of agroforest in that region. We are not only us but we have around 280 farmers big farmers there and we are 20 years fighting and learning because it’s very hard to plant in Amazonia very expensive you have very few technique and research because in Braa they are you know they are very not only a little bit lazy but they are very good in production not in preservation and they don’t have experience and research in native spec species.

So, my question to you, Valt and Paula, and I’m sorry to make it in English. It could be easier in Portuguese, but if you ever if you could help me with those two questions.

Jonah:

Great.

Unidentified participant:

Of course. Nice to meet you almost personally. We heard a lot about you from Stephan backwards. Yeah.

Unidentified participant:

And so, we have heard a lot and it’s a real pleasure to be addressing.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. And congratulations on your work on your it’s very beautiful. Yeah, amazing work.

Unidentified participant:

And we are well we know pretty well the val and that’s preservation law that we have from of conserving and thanks to God you have to conserve 80% of our Amazon beyond and how you should work with that and yes we want to.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah no it’s cool that you asked because definitely we understand how hard it is to plant in the Amazon we know that it’s not only hard to plant but it’s also hard to sell. So if you have anything producing there how are you going to transport it? If you cannot even transport seedlings right if you cannot take seedlings from one place to the other how are you going to move I don’t know any kind of project. So first thing you have to look for something that has a huge aggregated value to really make up to all the costs you have.

So definitely.

Marcia:

That’s why we started with art and because the limitations are hu the distances are amazing is almost a copy.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah it’s a continent. So definitely.

Unidentified participant:

So we have a few experiences and of course we since the continent we need to consider that for each region for each moment it is a different solution right yeah it has to be adherent that’s what I about to say right exactly.

Unidentified participant:

That has to be adherent it has to make sense to the context that we are working with.

Unidentified participant:

So yeah and you have to evaluate I know you asked how much it will be the revenue per hectar per year but there is no question there’s no answer a straightforward answer for that you are producing bio and you could have like millions of dollars per hectare you’re doing arts but if I only produce cassava you have 6,000 heis thousand dollars per hectare if I produce like fine timber within 30 years you have something around 50 60,000 heis per hectare or 10,000 $12,000 per hectare per year in net value if I if I bring the amount back so it’s difficult to answer but I think the main answer here is has to be adherent you have to understand where you are and you have to find the solutions that are around.

Yeah.

Unidentified participant:

Thinking in a in a bio in a bioeconomy mindset and looking around and see the labor you have available, the resources you have, the biomass you have, the plant that it grows well there and the market you should target. And if you do the right math, there is no recipe for agoristry. Every single project is a completely new project and if you have a hard a tailor made solution because.

Marcia:

I got it. Thank you.

Unidentified participant:

So if you can just explain to you a few contexts we had. So for instance we’ve worked in Juri in par. So it was one specific context. So in that case we worked with cassava non-timber forest products and rosewood such as rosewood and Brazil nut and other which one the baron nut baron nut as well kumaru nut actually and a few fruits and we worked with small farmer farmers and in that case the count we had was 30,000 36,000 per year, per hectare with the design we had comparing with the cava that was the business as usual cassava monocropping that was calculated more or less for 6,000 heis.

So, but it we’re talking about that specific design with the costs that we considered in that design with the selling price we considered in that context with those farm with those families with that market. So, we already have another completely different project in Peru in Pichanaki with ginger and turmeric as well. So completely different design. So we are comparing the monocropping the ginger and turmeric monocropping with agroforestry designs. We.

Marcia:

I thank you very much. I want I don’t want to monopolize here the discussion. I think we should I came only to say hello to know you because and congratulate you and Walter for the initiative not to mention the others who are certainly here for a good reason and u I want to I will close my video and let the things flow here but perhaps we need another talk. Okay, thank you. You can send us an email if you if you’d like to.

Unidentified participant:

Yes, if you can share. Okay, great. I will. Thank you.

Jonah:

Great. We are at the top of the hour, but let’s get one more question in. And if those of you need to go, so be it. We’ll we’ll stay on as long as we can. Next is Masiliano, if you’re still here.

Massimiliano:

Yes. Hi, Balter. It’s nice to virtually meet you and yeah, thanks for your talk. It’s really inspiring. I love the idea of having this kind of modular replicable design that then takes different shapes at a local level and I guess there are a lot of beautiful challenges in building this like general pattern but that is always shaped kind of different according to the context. I think both for the design and also the KPIs you mentioned. Yeah, I was wondering what were the kind of what’s the main number one challenge but actually I think I will reframe the question of what do you see in your experience would be the biggest the element that can that could fast track regenerative transition in the projects that you see.

Is there something that sometimes you feel like wow if there was a bit more of that we could really move faster in the process and is there something that do you find more like similar across different projects to this regard I would be curious to hear that good question.

Unidentified participant:

I would say that gathering information data a software and trustful and robust KPIs that you good trust. Yeah.

Unidentified participant:

And I think that if I could say that one thing that we should look for more in this the projects is this business mindset because it’s hard to say that but it’s true. You have to work agroforestry as a business. It is a business as any other. You know you’re just investing your money and since you’re investing your money you have to understand where this money is going. You know what how it’s being spent and many people many farmers around the world most of the farmers around the world they don’t they don’t do that they just don’t have this feeling they don’t understand they don’t have the point of view of business so that’s just it I think this is the mindset that we need to change.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah basically yeah I think we have together good information. Yeah. And avoid greenwashing and do a serious job. I think that’s the most is the key is the main door is the biggest gate of interest to turn the whole world into a forestry.

Massimiliano:

Mindset and software. No, that’s a great reflection. Doesn’t sound like the easiest one, but it’s needed. So yeah, great. Thanks for your answer.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you, Max Milliano.

Jonah:

Great. So, this brings us to what I call water cooler time where some people leave the call as many already have and we shift into unstructured conversation where you guys can ask questions of us or other people can introduce themselves. It’s a it’s a free-for-all. And thank you so much for your time. And if you guys have time, you’re welcome to stick around.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you, Jonah. Thank you everyone. Nice to be here.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you. It’s really good. I just want to thank you once again the opportunity and the time of you all to be here and the questions were really nice and Jonah, thank you so much to put us in the middle of this u this sabotin of questions. It was really good. It’s always good to talk about agroforestry to everybody.

Jonah:

Excellent. Okay. Are do you guys need to go now or are you able to stick around a little bit longer?

Unidentified participant:

We have another in 25 seconds.

Unidentified participant:

We have we are inviting you all that’s actually in an hour and a half but we have a prep. So if you can online there is this magazine called DBO and we will be really nice to have you there as in their YouTube channel. Are you send the link here?

Unidentified participant:

Portuguese.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. It’s called DBO, but I can send the link to you. They just sent me the link right now. Yeah, they did.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. Can you can you send the link there?

Unidentified participant:

Mhm. Great.

Jonah:

But great. Is there any more questions?

Unidentified participant:

Eric has one. No, if you do, we can.

Unidentified participant:

I don’t. But I think Eric Hoffner, who’s on the call, he just pasted one. Oh, but we can if you have any other question. Have you seen this work on oil? Let me see. We’ve been we have we are starting now. We’re kicking off a project with Pomo. Where is this project located? I don’t know. Is it in Brazil?

Jonah:

Eric, if you’re speaking, we can’t hear you. You I think you’re on mute.

Unidentified participant:

Oh, yeah. It is in Brazil. It is.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, it’s the same one.

Unidentified participant:

So, yeah, we know this project.

Unidentified participant:

We are working with K right now with Natura and K. Mhm. In this in this very project. So there is this huge effort in par state this k which is the cooperative of agroforestry farmers that are converting their monocropping their palm oil monocropping into agroforestry. So palm oil with cacao with roboba with many other timber species with asai as well. So they are doing this super cool design. Actually they have many designs over there. And now after I think it’s been eight years. It’s been eight years of this project. They’ve been experimenting designs and evaluating u possibilities.

Now they really ready to scale. So we gather with them to help this scale process. And it’s a huge a huge challenge because the first challenge it is to organize inputs. So they don’t have enough organic inputs available around. So you have to systematize everything. The first thing is to systematize inputs. So yes it’s a very serious project actually very serious. So very step by step pragmatic and it’s happening. Please.

Jonah:

I have a question which is about agroforestry training. I think that there are a lot of farming entrepreneurs in the region who would like to get involved in agroforestry but don’t know where to start. And so I’ve heard that Proetto Heeka offers in-person training. And I’m wondering if you know anything about it if you can share some. And then second part of that question is do you know about any distance education programs that people can subscribe to learn how to become agroforestry entrepreneurs without losing leaving their homes.

Unidentified participant:

Nice. That’s an excellent question.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. About the hecka actually unfortunately I haven’t met in person yet. I haven’t been there yet but I’ve heard a lot of great things about them. So it’s one thing that I have to check in one box that I still have to check is to meet their project. So no we don’t know them yet in person do you? No, no, no, nobody from Ekka. But from addressing your sec second question, we know an agroforestry academy that is probably the best we know. It’s called Preta Academy that we are launching next month.

We have basically finished the filming. So the team is putting together and turning it into modules and we are gathering all the material the writing and reading material that will be available and we are finishing the platform and it will be online in a month probably in a month even sooner.

Unidentified participant:

So please help us to spread and to broadcast. Just answering your first question of all the main the main challenge is to train people. We need an army an army working with agroforestry and these people are they’re not available. They’re not there. They didn’t study agroforestry yet. So that’s why you said okay let’s systematize all the knowledge we have so far organize it into a step-by-step course and well we just did. It’s been a work in process for a few months now. It’s been a challenge for us as well because there are so many work to do but it’s working.

So soon we’ll launch it.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. I think it is answer mimilliano too in a way of creating this huge body this horde of people that are able to do agroforestry and to turn agroforestry into their work. Yeah. A real work or simply turning their lives and going to a farm and growing their own food is key and that will be in a documentary way that we will present featuring our own farm and putting all the knowledge we have especially the empirical the one that’s not written we are putting together in this course. Yeah. So, yeah.

So, thank you for the question.

Jonah:

Am I on mute?

Unidentified participant:

No, no, no, we can hear. Yeah,.

Jonah:

Okay. Excellent. Any other questions?

Unidentified participant:

Cool.

Jonah:

Okay, great. I have a feeling that Phipe is gonna stay on a little bit and wants to talk to me about some of the things we raised last week.

Philip:

I’m just translating.

Jonah:

Oh, okay.

Philip:

Actually, is there does Naara would she like to speak in Portuguese and ask any questions together? I think that would be important. We have open space for that now. So she wants to know if what is your goal? What is your objective in Amazon? What would you see would be and your vision for Yamas? Can I Philip her name is Naara right?

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. If I can quickly address to her directly in Portuguese, it will be easier. But forchech. Agra sing. For Amazon. Mhm. Yeah. Complex. Army is not dimension. For stamp. No technology. Is you intend to Jonah Fiona I don’t know how your Portuguese is and also here but we were just talking about our nar and oh you understood.

Unidentified participant:

I understand only a quarter one quarter but I understand the depth of her passion and passion so give for Andre as well if you could give us a mini small translation.

Jonah:

Yeah, go ahead.

Philip:

Thank you. Sorry, Philippe. Wrapping up, Naara was saying that it’s very strange sometimes seeing Amazon being featured as this big white elephant where everybody talks about but in an invisible like an invisible environment that nobody’s knows for sure and that everybody tries to ignore that there’s people living there and there will be no solution for the environment. If the solution does not involve people, these people living there and you’re basically talking about the possibilities using old timber forest products, payment for ecosystem services and adherent solutions that considers what these people consume, which market would address and where logistically the inputs would come from for the biggest challenges of implementing agroforestry in the Amazon.

Yeah, if I could wrap up everything.

Unidentified participant:

It’s okay. Great.

Jonah:

Okay, everybody. I think we’ve reached a good stopping point. It’s wonderful conversation. There many more to be had and I can’t wait for more.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you, Jonah, for the invitation. We talk to you soon.

Unidentified participant:

Deeply thankful for real. If you need anything, talk to us. You all guys and thank you Fiona for your question. I loved it. It was really important to address this comparable way of understanding biodiversity and what is regenerative agriculture and agroforestry. Yeah and I think that’s also the difference between brings in for Philip and for Nayara what is biodiversity valued in a western context or even a measurement context with the technology comparative to the indigenous the land the rights the spirit the plant the medicines and then hence the future for their next generations and their knowledge.

So I just want to empower that is no.

Unidentified participant:

Often not measured in the context we would want and I think this is where maybe has been one of our greater mistakes in the last hundred years and we need to really empower Niara’s voice and others to hold that value system.

Unidentified participant:

Exactly. I agree that’s I use a lot of ecological and empirical knowledge that’s is the adherenty or adherency part of a designing process and you are absolutely right that will be there that will be there.

Unidentified participant:

Look forward to our next conversations al together.