Science Research to Advance the Amazon economy.

World Transforming Technologies (WTT) was launched in 2012 to promote innovation as a way to solve social and environmental problems. Concerned about the innovation ecosystem of the Amazon, WTT built upon the work of the CERTI Foundation to understand the stumbling blocks of the local bioeconomy across stages of knowledge development, business creation, acceleration, and growth. They learned that despite significant levels of education and scientific research on the bioeconomy, relatively few startups are created. In response, WTT created the Innovation Orchestration Center to mobilize researchers and help overcome barriers where Amazon’s bioeconomy success is limited by scientific development. Join us to learn more together with Andre Wongtchowski, head of WTT operations.

Recorded July 5, 2021

WATCH:

  • Sarah
  • Andre Wongtchowski
  • Marcelo
  • Danielle
  • Tony Lent
  • Claudia
  • David
  • Fiona

Unidentified participant:

Sorry. Because we’re part of another group where we’re trying to do research on the cocoa leaf. Ah, okay. Interesting. And so we’re always so right now we’re in the process of you know looking for investors to support that. Interesting. Well, well, this will be focused on WTT and what they’re doing. But probably, you know, it’ll be of interest for sure. So, I think Stacy’s going to dial in pretty soon. Okay, great. And I think Zigg Mu, are you there? You’re trying to connect with audio, it sounds like. I wonder if people are having struggle struggling with their internet.

Unidentified participant:

Hi.

Marcelo:

Hi Marcelo. Hello Sarah. How are you?

Sarah:

I am good. I’m good. I think I recognize you from the summit. Were you involved in the summit?

Marcelo:

I’ve been in some of the panels.

Sarah:

Yeah, I thought so. I thought so. It was such a overwhelming event that I you know.

Marcelo:

It was a lot of really nice information.

Sarah:

Yeah. And Andre is trying to come in. Some reason it’s not quite working. And you’ve been well, Marcelo. Everything’s.

Marcelo:

Yes. Yes, we are we are nice here now in Chingo River like the vaccines are going too fast like in the city we got the vaccinations of all indigenous people and the riverines.

Sarah:

Wow.

Marcelo:

We are in the slowly getting back to the other agenda besides co.

Sarah:

Yeah. Oh, that’s intense. Well, that’s congratulating to just getting that level of vaccination is a huge accomplishment.

Marcelo:

How about you?

Sarah:

Good. Yeah, I’m in Washington DC and it’s hot and but people are, you know, starting to come out of the woodwork and spend time with one another and just exciting stuff with the Amazon Investor Coalition. A lot so much great followup from the summit. There’s a lot of energy to capture and move. So, we got people joining. Our speaker though, I see is trying to join. So, we’ll see how that works out. Yeah, we might not have that many people today. It’s a holiday.

Unidentified participant:

I know. Green Coke. Who’s that? How are you, Marina?

Unidentified participant:

I’m fine. How are you, Sarah? I am good.

Unidentified participant:

Hey M. Hey, good to see you here. Good to see you, too. We still need to talk, huh? Oh, Cloud, let’s let’s set an agenda. Oh my god, look. David, nice to see you. Oh, you’re recording this. Turn it off. How are people doing? We’re slowly adding bit by bit here. For people who have joined, just wait a few minutes while everyone hops on. And see some familiar names. Let’s give I think Is Andre, are you on?

Unidentified participant:

I see your name, but I don’t see you. Yeah, here I am. There you are. Can’t you see my camera? Yes, now I can. Okay, great. Nice to see you. Is the sound and everything okay for you?

Unidentified participant:

Yes, everything is all right.

Sarah:

Great. Well, should we get started?

Andre Wongtchowski:

Yeah, let’s do that then.

Sarah:

Okay, great. Well, welcome everybody. My name is Sarah Ingresol. I’m part of the Amazon Investor Coalition team. And as many of you know, we are a coalition of investors and philanthropists working with governments and communities and forprofits and nonprofits to advance forest friendly investment in the Amazon. And we’re particularly interested in how we can educate prospective investors and donors about how they can participate in this opportunity. And that is why we’re really pleased to have Andre Wonowski as part of our conversation today because he’s been thinking about this a lot, thinking and working on this.

And he works with the world transforming technologies group and is going to share a little bit about how they were formed, the background that inspired their work and then many of the issues and opportunities that he sees in the Brazil. So without further ado, I’m just going to turn it right over to you, Andre.

Andre Wongtchowski:

Thanks, Aaron. Thanks for having me here. It’s a pleasure. Hello, everyone. Good to be talking to you. So I’m going to talk about two main topics here. The first one is a broad overview of the entrepreneurial ecosystem in the Amazon. If you saw our discussion on the Amazon Investor Summit a couple of years ago, this is what I’m going to talk about. So sorry if this is a repeat for you. And then I’m going to talk about one initiative that we launched last year which tries to address specific gap in the ecosystem.

So let me move on to that. So before we do that just tell you a little bit about WTT world transforming technologies is a foundation created here in Brazil but with an intention to work in all the countries in Latin America. And the reason behind creating WC was that we realized a number of years ago, this was around 2010, that the ecosystem for supporting impact businesses in the region was pretty strong. There were number of impact investing funds, accelerators, incubators looking specifically at these type of organizations. But the main complaint or the main gap in the system was the lack of a good robust pipeline with the potential for scaling.

So there was a lack of pipeline the perceived main issue in the ecosystem. So we decided to create an organization which eventually became WT. It was initially a program in another foundation called Fundio Navina which would try to figure how to bring innovations from universities and from national laboratories across the region to the market. So there was a perception there that there was a lot of brilliant people doing research basic or applied research in the innovation spaces in R&D spaces in the region but that there were not enough mechanism for bringing these science scientists and the researchers to the market.

So the was created with that aim to mobilize capital but also to support in management to create the connections etc everything that was needed to bring those solutions to market. In the first years we mainly supported scientists working in really disruptive technologies mostly around energy water treatment and recycling. In a second stage of WT we also started doing experimentation creating room for experimenting potential innovations in the field. So we realized that the al that was also a gap in the ecosystem. So there was not that many opportunities for inventors to take their technologies, take their innovations to the field and experiment with that really alongside communities, alongside investors industry.

So we created a second program aimed at creating this space, creating room for experimenting with innovation in the field. So that was the early days of WT. Eventually I will eventually come and talk about our new program which is the innovation orchestration center. But before that let me tell you talk a little bit about the ecosystem in the region. So can you see my presentation already? Yeah. Okay. So this is borrow from is an important foundation based in Florida here in Brazil. They’re doing been doing a lot of work trying to understand what are the gaps in the ecosystem in the Amazon.

So I’m going to use their material to talk a little bit about that. So this is their view of the pathway let’s say all the way from know creating knowledge and talents all the way to creating startups accelerating or incubating those organizations accessing capital and finally accessing the market. So this is how they see all of these all of this journey they call the Amazon journey. And now I’m going to talk about some of the numbers of what’s going on there. So in terms of knowledge and this knowledge refers to research lines u that are being carried out in all of the nine states of the legal Amazon and we have quite a lot of them.

So almost 2,000 research lines. So there’s a lot of knowledge being generated in the spaces that do science in the Amazon. This includes universities, national laboratories, universities, both state and national universities. Lots of organizations doing research, generating knowledge in the Amazon and therefore lots of talents being generated there as well. So there are almost 3,000 courses. This is post this is graduation up. So graduations and postgrads and PhDs, etc. That are related somehow to the bioeconomy. Okay. So all of the courses around bio economy given in the legal Amazon amount to 2,700 courses.

So that’s a lot of talent a lot of knowledge and a lot of talent being generated every year in the region. Now when we move on to the number of startups related directly related to the biodiversity of the Amazon, we have only 50 of them. And this is across Brazil. This is not only in the Amazon. So there’s clearly a very low conversion rate of all of these talent and knowledge being generated and actual startups being created there. Yeah. So we realize there’s something going on there. All of this knowledge is not translating into good profitable scalable startups.

When we move on to accelerators and incubators, there’s also 50. So this is kind of crazy. We have pretty much one to one startups to accelerators and incubators. So you can probably pretty much assume that accelerators and incubators are pretty empty at the moment. They’re not doing that much, but they are ready. They’re waiting for startups to come. And there’s not a month that goes by without, you know, people talking about creating a new accelerator, creating a new hub. We have plenty of that. But clearly the issue is the low number of startups.

Moving on in terms of capital, this is a capital that could be that’s in offer to all of these startups. Again, there’s more capital lines there, more capital organizations providing capital than startups that are able to access that capital. So, this is clearly another sign that there’s something wrong with in the startup phase, the startup creation phase. And finally, so the really strong ecosystem to support those startups. Yeah, we have plenty of accelerators. There’s lots of capital. Even in terms of market, there are a number of organizations that already access the bio products of the Amazon.

So in one side we have a lot of knowledge and talents being generated there. On the other hand, we also al also have a lot of potential for accelerating, incubating, providing capital to these startups, but clearly there’s a just jump this a really lack of good, you know, well wellunded well-run startups to benefit from all of this ecosystem support. So this is back in 2018 I guess we started to think about this and to think about how we can address this issue. Yeah. How we can make that a larger part of this talent and this knowledge being generated that there actually becomes no startups actually become products available to the market.

So starting from this assumption, yeah, this hypothesis that there are loads of really intelligent Brazilian scientists based in the Amazon doing really high quality research with a lot of potential for transform for social environmental transformation. So we start from this assumption of this recognition perhaps that there are brilliant scientists there. Many of them are willing to engage with industry. Many of them are willing to take their research further and closer to the market but for one reason or another they’re not finding the right tools or the right people to help them along this path.

And one of those pro one of the problems we realize is that is how science is financed in Brazil. Much of the science fin much of the all of the instruments that finance innovation science in Brazil of all of them I would say a very large majority are driven by individual research questions. So the way it works that is that each scientist or research group will write a proposal present to one of the many financeers of public financeers mostly of science in Brazil and they will receive a small grant that will enable them to take perhaps one step one further step in their research.

But this is all driven by the research or individual question. Not much science in Brazil is doing is done in a strategic way thinking about what are the really key points where Brazil should be investing in science. You know what are our main issues? How what are the questions that need to be answered? What are the problems that need to be solved? Or looking on the other side of the coin, what our capabilities, what our what is what is our potential that we could, you know, spur and transform it into products into solutions for Brazil’s many social and environmental challenges.

So we started know to talk about in this in this sense of how do we do more missionoriented innovation in Brazil. You may have heard this term mission oriented science or missionoriented innovation from professor Mariana Mazukato. She’s a Italian researcher based in London who has been write writing extensively about it and she writes mostly from a from a government point of view. So what are the public policies that could know help countries do more missionoriented science and less know research driven science driven by research questions. So she’s been talking a lot about that and we felt it was useful to use this to use this language of mission oriented but applying it to a very particular team which is the science done in Brazil and how we can create mechanisms strategies to make it more mission oriented.

So we spend perhaps a couple of years to talking to people here in Brazil. We spend a couple of months in the US visiting a number of organizations that are doing it there. And two organiz I would mention two organizations that were very important to us. One is actually two organizations DARPA and ARPA. DARPA is the defense advanced research projects agency and ARPA is its equivalent for the energy sector and basically what they’re doing is they’re trying to harness the best science done in the US to move along some really important issues for the US both in terms of defense as well as in terms of energy.

So trying to harness the power of the good science turned there in order to do useful things for society and they have a number of methodology to do that. DARPA in particular has been doing this for maybe 30 years. So they really know how to do this type of missionoriented innovation. And perhaps the central pillar of the strategies used by this those two organization is that they will they have no labs of their own. They have no scientist doing research for themselves. What they do is they try to find out what are who are the best people in the country to do this very specific thing that I need done.

So they come up with a number of missions or a number of strategies and then they try to figure out who are the best people I can invite for a limited number of number of years perhaps one or two years keeping them in their in their institutions of origin. So they don’t make the scientist you know change their career path they can still do science as they as they would normal as they would normally do. But part of their time would be dedicated to creating solutions for important problems. So this is were very inspirational for the way we designed the orchestration center.

I’ll talk a little bit more about that later. But just to mention the second organization that was really inspirational for us is the institute for transformative technologies. This is a this is an in institution that was created inside Lawrence Berkeley National Lab in Berkeley, California. It’s a it’s a very special place. They have perhaps 2,000 sciences or 1 billion dollars a year budget for doing applied science. And they realized at some point that you know they certainly did useful things. But perhaps they could do more for society if they came up with a number of missions that their scientists would embrace that would direct their work towards creating solutions for society’s problems.

So they decided to create this institute inside the na national laboratory. I think it’s the it’s one of its kind in the US. And the idea was that they would find the best people in Berkeley Lab and invite them to be parts of teams that would create solutions for important problems for sustainable development. So let me move on here. So little bit about how we do it and again this was very much inspired in DARPA and ARPA. So we have at the moment three programs one in circular economy, one in regenerative agriculture and one in bioeconomy.

This one is at this moment specifically for the Amazon. And the idea is that all of these pillars which are really broad would be perhaps focused or translated into a number of really addressable problems or missions. If you want that are no possible to possible to achieve concrete and that will therefore have the idea that you can accomplish this in a limited time frame inviting really good scientists. Yeah. So the first step is always to translate or to define a very limited and impactful number of missions or problems for each of these pillars.

The next step is to find the best people to run those missions. So the idea is that for each problem yeah we have here example three problems. Problem one and two and three. The idea is that for each of them we would figure out what needs to be done exactly. So this is not a broad mission. This is really something that can be achieved very concrete. So the first step is then deciding what are these problems and second step is finding the best people to know create solutions for these problems.

So what we do is then we do a mapping we try to understand what who are the best scientists working anywhere in the country that could help create a solution for these problems. Yeah. So the idea is that we will base take as a starting point the research that been done by these people invite the best of them for each particular let’s say piece of the puzzle. We see it kind of as a puzzle. Let me open it up a little bit more. So the idea is that we have a puzzle to you know to accomplish and we will invite different scientists to know develop each piece of the puzzle and then we’ll create a system where all of the pieces of the puzzle can be integrated.

So the idea is that each what we call sub project here is carried out by a single scientist or a research group and they will have their own deliverables, activities, resources very clear responsibilities, a clear schedule etc and their own budgets as well. And that all of these different solutions you know each part of the solution gets integrated in different moments in such a way that at the end of the process we have an integrated solution and our role as the orchestration center is first to define the problems and this is done in consultation with many stakeholders.

So the first step is defining the problems. Second step also done by the koi is finding these people know mapping the scientists and evaluating the quality of their research and understanding how it can help create solutions and finally putting these people together. You know and creating a system for managing these different groups of scientists working each on their own laboratory on their own universities but in a collaborative way with many moments where the solutions get integrated I’ll give a real example of that so this is the next slides so we one of the things that we’ve been doing is to create biiobased polyropylene.

This is the PP plastic. This started as a broad as a mission as a broad mission to or a broad pillar in the bioeconomy pillar. We realized that doing biodegradable biiobased plastics was an interesting thing to do for many reasons. You replace fossil-based plastics, you create value to u to the forest, you generate income for the people of the forest. So there are many let’s say advantages in going for a biiobased plastic chain. We started also having discussions with the industry in the Amazon. We have an important industrial zone called Paul industrial manau.

Many industries in Brazil are based there because of fiscal incentives. So it was a one step as well was to talk to the industry and say so we’re thinking about doing bioplastics in the Amazon. Do you use PL where do you use plastics? Are you willing to replace fossilbased plastics by biiobased plastics? Exactly what type of plastics would you do that? So we had number of conversations with industrial players operating from an house from the Amazon to come to the conclusion that polyropylene was one important one important plastic that they use also know marrying let’s say that view that demand from the industry with what’s possible what’s available in terms of scientific research.

So at the so on one hand we were talking to the industry trying to understand what are their needs. On the other hand we were talking to universities to researchers in the Amazon to try to understand what is being done related to bioplastic that I can take to market in perhaps one year maybe two years what are really advanced research researches or really let’s say things that are that are really outstanding. Yeah. And then we came to the conclusion that polyrop poly polyropylane was one of them. Yeah, there was demand from the industry and there was also excellent people doing brilliant work related to that.

So coming back to the project so this is three perhaps there are three components to this project. The first one is to characterize the fibers. Yeah. So we’ve chosen two let’s say two things that are leftovers from other processes. These are wood chips. So wood is used for many things and there are some chips that are kind of a leftover. So there’s plenty of that at cost zero. And also Brazil nuts shells also. So you basically have a lot of material outside the Brazil bario nuts itself and perhaps four fifths of it of the of the organic matter there is left over.

So there’s also thousands and thousands of tons of this which currently is just standing there. Nobody has any decent use for that. So this is these are two starting points you know industrial waste let’s say that’s there at cost almost zero that could be used to do biiobased plastics and so we found the best researcher doing characterization of these fibers really understanding how they behave what are how you can process it how you can what are the uses for this what useful features they aggregate to material. So we went and find the best researcher studying fiber these two fibers in the Amazon and it’s his based at universal the second the second trench there is testing different formulations in the lab first in the lab and there are many possibilities there we could use virgin polyropylene with the fibers recycled polyropylene with the fibers or even a biiobased polyropylene with the fibers.

So we’re experimenting with all of these possible combinations to understand what is the result of each using each one of them in which percentage what is the best prep treatment etc. So we’re going to investigate what are the best formulations really running perhaps hundreds of tests and the lead institution there is federal. So the first one was the stud this one is the federal university. H we went and f found a really brilliant researcher doing this kind of test with different formulations in we invited him for the project. Finally, the third leg there is to how we industrialize this process and the formulations.

And then we brought someone who is not in the Amazon is at University Federal Pana in the south of Brazil who is really a materials engineer. So she understands really well how to bring different formulations and different process from let’s say a semi-industrial scale all the way to an industrial scale. So how do you adopt them, adapt the machines? What are the tests you need to make? Know how do you come back and again test the formulations in the lab so you can then take them again to the industrial process.

So someone who really understands how to do this. So we also brought her to the team. So we have a team of three people each with their own clear responsibility and each but they’re also working together. They’re all standing at their own labs. But they have no moments in which they discuss what’s what’s the best approach. They hand over work to the next person. So the idea is that at a fine at the end of this process, we will have an industry scale process and formulation ready to be taken to the industry.

Sarah:

So, Andre, I’m that I love that story and I’ve been so impressed by how grounded it is in that analysis that you all did and how strategic you are in setting this all up. I want to make sure to turn it to other people to ask some questions, but I have one myself very quickly, which is this how is this being funded? You have the foundation piece but it sounds like a pretty expensive endeavor once it’s scaling and then what’s the process or what’s the plan for investments in the solutions.

Andre Wongtchowski:

Yeah so that’s a great question actually I’m going to move to the next slide to answer that one so number of number of let me take that those questions one by one for how is it been finance at the first stage so the stages of defining the problem, mapping the scientists, evaluating their research and creating the research or the development project. All of this has been financed by a German foundation called Kha Mau which is very much interested in seeing bioeconomy become a reality. So we presented a project to them saying we need to get to this stage where we have the projects specifying who is going to be involved, what are they going to do, how much is going is it going to cost etc.

So we had we counted on philanthropic resources for up to that stage. Now from that stage one is when we actually need to invest in development it’s a different ballgame right it’s much more expensive. But fortunately we have a couple of things in our favor here. First is that in Brazil as I mentioned there are hundreds of different research financing lines for doing innovation either public or semi-public or semi-private if you if you have which can be used for doing these kinds of things. I’ll give an example. FAPESPI which is the foundation that sponsors public research here in the state of Salo which is the biggest in Brazil has a billion dollar annual budget.

So it’s a lot of money that goes into research. So part of it can be accessed for purposes like this. Another fund potential funding line are the corporations. Yeah. We who are interested in producing these things or using these things in their products. In this case here we have for example for this for this phase here the fiber preparation and extrusion and injection which are industrial processes. We have approached a number of organizations in Manau who do it for fossil based plastics and one of them showed a lot of interested in being the producer of these biiobased polyropulate in the atmosphere.

So they are going to invest their own money in the research and to build an industrial capacity for them to be able to do it. So we have an industrial partner which is willing to produce this and they want they were also willing to fund at least part of the research and here for example in the US so who are they going to sell this to we’ve been having discussions with Honda for example which is also has an industrial plant in the Amazon which is saying I want to use these plastics as a wrapping for my motorcycles.

We discussed using it for the motorcycles themselves, but you can imagine to change anything in a motorcycle, it’s probably years of research and test etc. So, we decided to take the easy way and use it as a wrapping for the motorcycles. So, we have lined up someone who actually going to produce the sink, prepare the fibers, do the extraction injection, produce the final bit of piece of plastic, and someone who is saying I’m going to buy it. So there’s a let’s say a market already inside for that program. Now in the Amazon and that’s important to say there’s one fiscal instrument called Pepe Bio programario in bio economia which funnels some of the R&D money there’s it’s complicated but there’s one demand that people organization that are based in pol industrial manau they re they receive fiscal incentives and therefore they must invest if I’m not if I’m not mistaken 5% of their of their profit in R&D.

So that’s a law that states that 5% needs of their profit needs to be invested in R&D. And now since perhaps last year there is a mechanism which enables the ind this the industries to canalize the part of these are indeed two projects in bioeconomy and this is how we’re talking here also about billion dollar figure. So there’s a lot of money in the Amazon that can be invested part of it must be invested but can be invested in R&D related to the bioeconomy. So it’s a it’s a complicated you know financial engineering to get all the way from you know mapping the scientists all the way to forming the teams and actually doing the doing the creating the product the process and the product.

Sarah:

It’s brilliant and will be such a useful example for other industries and products. So I want to turn it over to some of the participants here to ask questions. We had two in the chat room. Andre asked, “How do you see the scientists and the researchers connecting with the, you know, as you put it, the real problems of the Amazon rainforest nowadays?” So, you talked about kind of the how it’s tied with the strategy and there’s sort of missionoriented, but I don’t know if maybe you want to explain it a tiny bit more, Marcelo, in terms of what you’re thinking there for that question.

I stepped away.

Marcelo:

Just to explain a little bit more. Thank you Andrea for your amazing presentation. I think this is a very hot issue in the Amazon rainforest. From where I see like there are a disconnection between many researchers that is going on the field with the major pro problems especially on bioeconomy development on a community level u based solutions and so on that’s why I’m asking you that from this point for connecting like researchers scientist is to the problems of the Amazon rainforest. How far you see them to the field or how close do you see them to the field?

Andre Wongtchowski:

I think they’re pretty far, but very much willing to engage. Our experience so far talking to scientists and explaining them what we want to do and explaining them, we found your research brilliant. I think you’re doing amazing work. What do you think about taking this another step and creating real solutions with this research usually the response is very positive I think well everybody really wants to have a positive effect on society so that’s kind of we can take that for granted I think there’s also an a real interest in being part of a really extraordinary teams.

Yeah. So, we’re trying to for example, one strategy important to us is to have a scientific committee at the Koi made up of really let’s say outstanding people who can attract outstanding people. So, we’re trying to create some sort of a virtual cycle here having really know good people, inspirational people attracting good scientists as well. So, that’s kind of been working. And there’s also other things that we can offer to you know bring the scientists closer. First is money. Yeah. So if you can usually this research this research line public research lines are very limited in what you can do.

You cannot buy equipment you cannot pay salaries. There’s lots of restrictions and we’re trying with philanthropic money at least at least with that part of the financing structure. We can do whatever you want. We can have them buy equipment. We can have them, you know, hire people. So, we’re pretty much flexible in that sense. So there’s lots of things there, I think, that are useful to attracting good scientists. What we also want to do and that’s the kind of the first phase is asking the right question. Yeah. So we spend quite a lot of time trying to figure out what is the right question to ask what is the problem that we really want to address and in that part of the work we really work closely with the communities with people that are working with the communities so there’s a lot of effort there in getting the communities on board from a very early stage so they can be on board all along the way I don’t know if that answers your.

Sarah:

That’s great. What can you say a little bit more about what you think the hurdles are for attracting international and national financing at the various points of this process?

Andre Wongtchowski:

Yeah, I think from our experience is the long-term nature of the project. Yeah. Lots of people would say I’m not interested in doing you know getting this research from basic research all the way to a product because there are so many scientific hurdles before you can even start talking about market hurdles. Yeah. So there’s a challenge to actually get a product in the first place before you can even start talking about creating a startup getting this product in the market. So it’s risky and it research or app research can cost a lot of money.

So I say those two things make it harder. So there are many things we can do about that. We can start from research which is not that basic from technology ready readiness level I don’t know four or five for example which is a little bit more you have some sort of a minimum viable product already built. So perhaps you can start from there. Using philanthropic money as an initial seed fund. So I can then access the big money which is in the in the hands of the various government institutions or private institutions in the case of incentivized R&D money.

So that’s those are some of the strategies that we have been using to you know try to make the whole thing happen.

Sarah:

Danielle, you have some questions that I think are good ones for the general audience here.

Danielle:

Hello everyone. Hey Andre.

Andre Wongtchowski:

Hello Dan.

Danielle:

Hi. How are you?

Andre Wongtchowski:

Good.

Danielle:

I really I really loved what you shared at the summit and yeah I really applaud this work. You’re running science like a missionoriented business. You know with product market fit front and center of mind that’s I pivoted away from my career in science focused in the Brazilian Amazon because before I joined the team of the Amazon Investor Coalition squarely because of the lack of strategic thinking of science and so bravo for doing this work so focused on kind of solutionsoriented innovation. I’d love to email you separately to follow up on this.

Just a few questions here. You said the innovation ecosystem is there but the conversion rate is low because of the kind of ad hoc manner that science is being done and financed. There all of this knowledge is not being translated into good profitable startups. Are there places in the world that have a more integrated pipeline that we can learn from? You know, what is the conversion rate that we should be aiming for? And then do you have a sense of the turnover over the last I don’t know relevant couple decades of how many there are now 50 existing Amazon bioconomy startups that you’ve mapped.

How many what is the creative destruction process? How many attempts and then fail and what does that rate look like?

Andre Wongtchowski:

I wouldn’t I don’t know how to say for sure but the feeling we have is that there are a number of them being created every year. Many of them wouldn’t survive the first couple of years of operations for a number of reasons. What I what I think is a must is to think about the whole supply chain. So in this case that I showed here yeah bioplastics. So we first of all we need to find some raw material that is available all year long in sufficient quantity in a standardized quality.

So that’s one hurdle that’s limits what type of what type of activives from the forest you can use. Then there’s a whole issue around logistics. Yeah. So some of these communities are really far and transporting them over large distances typically by boat is costs a lot of money. Sometimes even the shelf life of their material is just not long enough. So you cannot transport it in a raw form. So you need to do some processing in the communities and then there’s some complexity in complexities in doing there in doing that starting from the lack of electricity for example so stable electricity so many challenges there as well then you need someone who will receive this material and process it or know transform it into something else I think that is the perhaps the easiest part but someone will only do that if there’s a clear market opportunity U and I guess in many cases know the market is very dispersed that’s it’s there’s competition from other countries as well so it’s a business risk there so lots of disincentives to do it as well.

And finally you need ideally some someone who commits to purchasing that. Yeah. So we worked with sustainable cotton for example a couple of years ago. And we there was one company which was VI which makes fashion sneakers who made something which is really rare in this in this in this space which is a long-term commitment to purchase any amount of cotton sustainable cotton produced by a number of number of communities and this was lifechanging for the communities. Yeah. So they had like a for as many years as much as you produce I will buy for this price.

So everything was agreed in advance which gave huge incentives for you know family farmers in those in that area to you know switch their productions to sustainable cotton and I’m not sure how many examples of that we have in the Amazon. This example was in the semiarid of Brazil and I think it’s an outstanding example but really rare. So I would think that more organizations willing know to make this sort of long-term commitment would be needed for this to really happen in a large scale.

Sarah:

Thank you for that. We got a quick question from Tony Lent about the process and then Claudia and then David I think has a great question for us to round this out. Tony, did you want to go ahead and ask that question?

Tony Lent:

Sure. What you know the there’s a lot of different ways of making biio-based polyropylene and as you probably know in Brazil Rascam has been pursuing an ethanol dehydration process. You’re I’m assuming you’re using biomass or you’re using cellulose and from what I can tell Mitsui Chemicals is focused on that route. Have you done a global scan for who’s doing biomass pulp to polyropylene and what the process is because it’s probably already been semicommercialized somewhere.

Andre Wongtchowski:

Yeah, this is not my specialty but I had to learn a little bit about it. So there are a number of companies doing it. There are different types of what they call green plastic. Some of them are biodegradable which is not the case of bras kings for example. Bras is biiobased. So it’s you it uses ethanol, sugarcane ethanol as a base, but it is not biodegradable. So in the end you have the exact same problem you have with traditional plastics. With the benefit of having grown sugar cane and not straight away from oil, but it’s not biodegradable.

What we’re trying to do there is as we use as a base some microbes that usually work with cellulose to produce the base let’s say in which we add the fibers. So the idea is that and this is also a commercial product you can you know buy it from the shelf this there are a number of how do you say it acronyms for it. So PLA, PHBA, PHB, there are number of ways to produce it. You can buy from the shelf, but in Brazil at least, there’s no one producing it in any decent scale in Brazil.

So we have to import the whole thing. It’s today is pretty expensive. So in what we try to do in our formulations is to have the as much fibers as possible in as a percentage of the whole thing because we can buy the fibers for zero cost pretty much. So that’s one way we’re trying to reduce the cost of the biop here.

Sarah:

Thank you. Claudia, you have a question.

Claudia:

Hi.

Sarah:

Or comment.

Claudia:

Thank you very much. And Andre, excellent presentation.

Andre Wongtchowski:

Thank you.

Claudia:

Are you well I’ve sent you a message through the batch papu. Have a look later please. Okay. And also are you thinking in one of the things I miss in Amazonia is in the Amazonian projects is design marketing lots of things that should be in my view being included in a multi-disiplinary team as you are putting together and thinking new products especially products from the communities. Are you thinking this as well or not yet?

Andre Wongtchowski:

Yeah. So there are loads of things we can do. We decided to start with bioplastics. Because we were told there are people researching that. Really different things coming out of the of the Amazon. We understood that it was an interesting way of adding value to products already taken from the forest. So this is just a starting point. I think there are loads of things we can study. And perhaps a challenge there is where to focus. Yeah. So there’s so many things, so many u you know bioactives useful for pharmaceutical industry, cosmetics industry, food.

So how to how to choose? So that’s always a bit of a huge debate. But you know experimenting with bioplastics. I think we one thing important to say here as well is that when we began we heard repeatedly you’re not going to find interesting research in the Amazon. There’s all of the labs there are really old no it’s going to be waste of time. We actually heard that a number of times even which is amazing. When they mapped the all of the research coming out of the Amazon, they’re the ones that mapped this 2,000 research lines.

We asked them did you find something in bioplastics? And they told us we didn’t. There was nothing. But actually there is. So I think there’s also some things that need to be improved in the way of you know how do we talk about these things. How does how do people know what is being developed you know in the Amazon by people not only from the Amazon biodiversity but from people living in the Amazon. And part of our work here is to know make this visible is to tell the stories. So for example, we’re running writing a publication right now to talk about these people.

Now who are these people doing really interesting research in the Amazon? So I think an important part of our mission here is to vis I don’t know if this there’s such a word in English visibilizer make visible the brilliant research been done in the Amazon.

Sarah:

Yeah. And one thing you didn’t mention so much was the work that WTT does around your own some investment, right? And strategic planning and project management and networking for those projects that do exist and that are more investment ready. Is that correct? Or did I misread that on the website?

Andre Wongtchowski:

Yeah. Yeah. So part of our work is to support really, you know, frontier science. But that’s even trickier to do and even harder to do because these are things for example we’re we found a Brazilian inventor who’s been living in California for perhaps two decades who my honest guess is that he will be the first Nobel laureate Brazilian Nobel laureate. He’s absolutely brilliant. He’s has he has invented a way of transporting energy as light. So that’s you’re going to heard hopefully you’re going to all heard about this guy in a few years.

But it’s really hard to do. It’s really expensive. It’s really hard to do that kind of thing in Brazil because you really need equipment which is hardly available here. So for example, we had to hire the Franhoffer Institute in Germany to actually build the thing. So he had the idea, he had all the formulas, but we couldn’t do it in Brazil. We had to hire the Franhoffer Institute in Germany to they were the only ones that actually had equipment to do it. So, and it’s harder hard as well to raise money because know this is high risk.

Who knows if it’s actually possible to do it in a large scale. It’s there are scientific hurdles, there are engineering hurdles even before you can start talking about you know what’s the market, what’s the price, what’s the cost. So it takes years of investment to actually get to a point where you can answer this type of question and no normal investor no certainly not have no fund has the patience or the timeline to invest in this kind of thing. So we end up you know counting on mostly on you know friends and family and friends of friends who are really inspired by what this guy is doing for example and are willing to put money to see it happen but no you know no proper fund with an investment tees and the you know the need to pay back their investors in 10 year times will be able to do it.

So it’s really hard to finance that kind of radical things. So we had kind of create other strategies to make it happen in a shorter time span.

Sarah:

Well, the wonderful thing about the Amazon Investor Coalition is there are some creative investors and people who would be interested in that kind of long-term radical thinking. And in fact, David Hodson asked earlier in the chat, you know, so what would an Amazon bioeconomy innovation fund need to look like to enable this innovation ecosystem? And it could be a very innovative innovation fund. It sounds like it might need to. I don’t know. David, did you want to add any more to that question?

David:

Oh, no, not really. I mean, yeah, I was just thinking about Yeah, I mean, if we’ve got to accelerate the emergence of the bioeconomy, right? I mean, how I mean, how many different parallel threads could you basically be running right now, Andre? I mean you’ve you’ve got the basic pro you’ve got the you know an amazing process developed there and it really just comes down to how do you know accelerating the emergence comes down to parallelizing just injecting a whole bunch of money into that core process right so we can run it against way more things than you’re capable of.

Unidentified participant:

Running it against right now. Yeah, I.

Andre Wongtchowski:

Think it’s at the end we’re just one organization. We this program the innovation orchestration center is went live end of last year. So it’s pretty recent. We’ve been we have four pro four projects at the moment running. We’re still you know building our team. We’re using people from our own team part-time. We’ve finally been able to bring really u experts in all of the theatic areas, experts in R&D management, experts in accessing public funding. So we’re finally being able to know with the sum of all of these project that we’re running there’s a little bit no R&D manager a little bit of it in each of project that we run.

So now we’ve been able to actually build a really expert team. But we will always be one. So I think part of what we do here is really to set an example to show that it is possible to show that there is intelligent life in the Amazon. There are brilliant researchers doing brilliant research huge potential. I think part of our role is to tell these stories and show that it’s possible. So hopefully we have a few know examples real examples in a couple of years that will inspire other people to do it.

And again, I think there’s a as I showed in the beginning, there’s lots of investment, a lots of commercial interest in things from the Amazon. We’re kind of creating a new route here. Hopefully it will, you know, be complimentary to the ones that are already there. All of the ones that are already there are important. Accelerators are important. All of the programs, you know, trying to support community- based organizations are really important. So we just have you know perhaps one extra strategy in the in the to add to the mix there.

Unidentified participant:

Nothing is going to survive if we don’t add a lot of knowledge to it and especially in this time of the 21st century. So what you are doing is fantastic in this sense and that’s why I want to talk to you later but more deeply and it’s we need a we need a knowledge otherwise we’ll be always totally and knowledge is there we need to harness the knowledge that is already there.

Andre Wongtchowski:

That’s why we call it orchestration because we felt that an orchestrator was lacking you know there are brilliant scientists there are willing to do we need to work with the communities with to in order to produce really useful things for society but they know they don’t know how to run to and for example what’s also there’s a lot as well here in Brazil you know is this open calls for innovators so you launch know a challenge or something like that and wait for the for the scientists to come scientists you know they’re not trained to come you need to actually knock on their door and say here this is we created all the tools here we need you are the centerpiece but we created all these tools we formed this partnership with this and that so perhaps together we can do something useful.

Unidentified participant:

And I am an academic so you need to talk their language otherwise even understand what you.

Sarah:

Well I mean what’s so exciting Andre is you’ve really mapped out the inflection points the opportunity points and the barrier points and we are so grateful to you for the work that you are doing and the opportunity for us to be working with you as we move forward to help connect those dots and bring in the points that can be supportive to this agenda. So, we’re going to close out the formal session here. But you can stay online if you guys want to continue to have the conversation and again just thank you Andre and for the participants on this.

You know, we’re very excited and pleased to have you as part of this conversation and look forward to continuing.

Andre Wongtchowski:

Thank you Sarah and please I invite you all to let’s do this together. You know, we’re just again we’re one, we’re small. We’re trying to do interesting things, but we need, you know, all the all the good people we can have on our side. So, everyone really is invited to try to find answers alongside us.

Sarah:

And can you stay on for another minute or two? Have some.

Andre Wongtchowski:

Okay.

Sarah:

Okay. Thank you. Byebye, everyone.

Unidentified participant:

I think we just lost. Thank you so much, Andre. I’ve got to run. I would love to I’m gonna message you for followup.

Andre Wongtchowski:

Okay, let’s do that.

Unidentified participant:

That’s okay. Thankfo.

Fiona:

Hi there, Sarah. Great, great, great. Sorry, I was having likewise technical issues on getting internet working or computer issues. Good. So where do you think this can go in relationship to you know Andre’s work and is there a way that we can help support and you know what is the best that we could do to you know catalyze this technology and is there any thoughts that Andre has that wants to add in there? Thank you.

Sarah:

Yeah, and I know Andre, you and Jonah have had many, you know, many conversations, you know, at various points and he is moving across the country right now and really wanted to be part of this. But yeah, I would love to follow up on that question from Fiona’s you know, I think it’s saying how can the Amazon Investor Coalition and the network that we have how could we play a role in supporting this pipeline, advanced pipeline.

Andre Wongtchowski:

Well, I think events like this are really useful. Let’s I think couple of people I haven’t read the chat yet, but u I think there are some good connections here. I think really what we need to is get to get the word out, you know, tell people about what we’re doing, what’s the strategy, what we’re still what we still need. I think that’s kind of what we’re trying to do at the same time while we, you know, try to run the whole thing and figure out what needs to change, what needs to be improved.

Sarah:

Is to, you know, tell the story really. And this is also kind of the you’re doing a paper on the sort of here’s this incredible resource. What are the plans for distribution? And is there sort of a who Yeah. Who’s the target audience there to be most strategic in getting that word out? Who needs to know that?

Andre Wongtchowski:

Yeah, I think that what we ran one study already which was around collabor scientific collaborations for COVID 19 which is unfortunately it’s just in Portuguese but we kind of mapped collabor scientific collaborations that happen in Brazil and beyond Four.