The Trillion Trees Amazon Bioeconomy Challenge
Businesses, cooperatives, and others involved in the Amazon bioeconomy, as producers or market enablers, can access funders and global markets through the Amazon Bioeconomy Challenge. Brazil nut collectors, açaí harvesters, pharmaceutical entrepreneurs, ecotourism operators and allies can qualify alongside indigenous handwork retailers, fintech solution providers, legal advisory teams, and others dedicated to helping advance the forest-friendly economy. Where did the Bioeconomy Challenge come from? Who are the partners involved? What kinds of visibility, financing, and market access opportunities will be offered? What is the timeline? Join us to learn the answers to these questions and more with Florian Reber of 1t.org and the World Economic Forum.
Recorded June 28, 2021
References:
The Amazon Bioeconomy Challenge
WATCH:
Participants
- Jonah
- Florian Reber
- Beto
- Yves
- Maria Duran
- Marina
- Fiona
- Christina
- Matias
- Bruno Kato
- Philip
- Brad Smith
- Amanda
Transcript
Jonah:
Wow. This is exciting. We’re one minute into the call and we already have almost 20 people on. Floren, you’re a popular guy. This is a good sign. I So, I think that we can go ahead and start I’ll invite a couple of people to introduce themselves until we before we start the main program. Just because I think that we’re probably gonna have you know a few more people join us in the next couple minutes. So just to give people an appreciation for who’s on the call. Hey Beto, do you mind introducing yourself real quick?
Just tell us who you are and what Forest Trends is and like less than a minute.
Beto:
Sure. Greetings is everyone. I’m Beto Boures. I’m the director of forest trends communities and territorial governance program and forest trends is a US-based organization working globally to create in incentives economic incentives for conservation and the program that I run focus on indigenous peoples and local communities primarily in the Latin American Amazon in particular great to be here thank you.
Jonah:
Great and I’m gonna invite one more person introduce themselves and we’ll hear from Florian ye lean and would you mind introducing yourself real quick?
Yves:
Hi everybody. I’m Eve. I’m working with the IDB lab and we are happy to support the challenge that Floren is going to talk about and also I’m leading the development of the Leticia platform basically aiming to connect investor to project and business opportunities in the Amazon. So happy to be here and.
Jonah:
And for those who don’t know the IDB stands for the Interamerican Development Bank and the Laticia platform is the investor project connector developed in association with the Laticia pact which is an intergovernmental collaboration of the Amazon nations. Okay. So, I’m gonna go ahead and, you know, start my MC responsibilities. And then I’ll introduce Florian. Hello everybody. Thank you for the first call since the summit of the Amazon Investor Coalition call and podcast series. We call it Amazon office hours. Again, this is a weekly program dedicated to advancing force friendly economic development and the rule of law across the Amazon region of South America.
We bring together governments and investors and philanthropists and figure out how to make it happen. The go the theory of change is that there’s an infinite amount of money available to solve climate and forest issues and the stumbling block is inadequate investor education and awareness and strategy and collaboration. And so we exist to solve that problem. So this week we are featuring the extraordinary work of onet.org or and the World Economic Forum and in particular the Amazon Bioeconomy Challenge and Florian is going to be talking about the program. He and many others on this call participated in the summit that we hosted at the end of May.
It was called Amazonia Rising, a global summit on investing in the Amazon. We had about 500 close to 600 people join us over a course of five days. We had 45 sessions. Some small some very large. Lots of connections were made. Some money has changed hands. Some people got investors. Some people found co-founders for the organization. Some nonprofits got philanthropic resources. We’ve created a very important global learning community to figure out how to tackle these issues. And then there was a long break and I have been moving houses and things like that.
There’s been some changes in the team. Lots and lots of momentum. And so to kick off the call series for the second half of this year, we’re starting with the Amazon Bioeconomy Challenge. So, with that introduction, Florian, I understand you’re going to make a presentation and I caught a couple of questions for you and then we’ll release you to the audience who I’m sure will pile on with lots of questions. The microphone is yours.
Florian Reber:
Thank you, Jonah. Thank you very much. And, hello everybody. It’s a really pleasure to be with you. Thank you, Jonah, for the kind invitation. I will indeed do a quick presentation or maybe rather offer a few a few words. I won’t show any slides tonight. Well, tonight because hello from Zurich in Switzerland. I hope many of you are in a less rainy place than where I am right now. And maybe just quick word of introduction. I’m by training a political scientist. I’ve spent most of the last 10 years helping to set up and handle those public private initiatives that the World Economic Forum has increasingly developed over the last decade or so including the tropical forest alliance the CEO climate leaders did work also in carbon markets on with together with South Poland now since about two years been involved in the setup and now in the running of one t.org talk the trillion trees platform at the world economic forum and so yes I’m really delighted to tell you a little bit more about our bioeconomy our Amazon bioeconomy challenge the introduction I just gave was also basically to mention that many of you will be much more the experts in everything about the Amazon than I am and I’m a generalist I’m not an ecologist I’m not from the region and so I am not the Amazon expert.
Just want to get that straight. But we setting up platforms and processes to you know, help improve certain changes in the system and really help improve public private collaboration. That’s really and what the World Economic Forum is setting itself as its overarching goals. So when we launched one.org work just one and a half years ago in Davos. We did it from the get-go with the strong support by President Duk, president of Colombia who was present at our press launch and from the beginning it was quite clear that this initiative wt.org will have a focus on the Amazon.
It’s a it’s a global initiative though it’s part of our portfolio of activities to help accelerate nature-based solutions and we essentially with onet.org for we do three things and they all come together in our emerging work on the Amazon and those three things are like the mobilization of the private sector and where we are convening a global corporate alliance that was just made public recently at the launch of the UN decade on ecosystem restoration for the moment about 16 companies making commitments for the conservation and restoration of forests so really also like beyond their supply chain And it’s cross sectoral from tech companies to food companies and financial sector companies for example small but growing.
And then we are convening a number of regional alliances. So we have an existing one torg chapter in the US that we are handling together with American forests. We have our Amazon effort on the way which I talk more about today. The Sahel and the great green wall is a similar effort to the one that we are driving in the Amazon and then also India and China are completing our regional portfolio. So and then the third element what we do is we have a strong focus on innovation and really also supporting grassroots actors that are driving restoration on the ground and that goes back to I think a promise that we have made when we launched one.org talk which was about setting this thing up in a way that improves also the connectivity in between the grassroots of the world and the grass tops.
The grass tops being those type of stakeholders that the World Economic Forum engages with in a more traditional sense. But arguably to meet some of the most pressing SDG challenges and maybe in particular the restoration of degraded ecosystems we have to find ways to better engage grassroots actors in those type of activities that the world economic forum is running and on that note and also when we launched one t.org talk we the web together with Salesforce, the UN, Microsoft, LinkedIn and Deoid has unveiled a new platform to help run all kind of SG challenges and that platform is called uplink.
It’s the World Economic Forum’s platform really to help crowdsource SG innovations and run challenges on an ongoing basis. We’ve done so since last spring 2020 and it’s been really a great exercise I would say and I’ve seen the World Economic Forum from the inside for number of years and I feel like this is really changing the dynamics quite a bit and it’s really refreshing also to see grassroots actors getting more of the spotlight I would say on that platform. So that maybe brings me to the Amazon bioeconomy challenge which I know we really want to focus on today.
And a maybe again a little bit about process. So as often right the we operate very often in an informal way at the World Economic Forum similar I would say to the to this coalition bringing people together in informal communities. And we so earlier this spring we got a number of stakeholders together and know including Eve Jonah you know the likes of Kus No also the government of Colombia EPAM grassroots actors like Brett Terra investors so kind of a multistakeholder coalition and we really started with a how can we design we started with the question and asking like how can we design a bioeconomy challenge that is credible socially and ecologically responsible and is making a meaningful contribution to improving also like some of the pressure points in the system right and I think here one of the one of the really interesting conversations that has emerged early on together with Eve and his colleagues is kind of the question how can we set up such a process so that it also feeds some of the existing funds and programs that are looking to support the bio economy in the Amazon.
So, how can we use a platform such as uplink as a as a funnel supported by the World Economic Forum with all the communications and messaging bio power and some of you might have seen some of our LinkedIn and Twitter videos that we do and that are highly successful. So, how can we use all of that and the expertise of all the great experts in our network to design something that is helping to meet the needs also of those who want to invest and really also want to support grassroots actors.
So that has led us actually bit of a and even made last night was a bit of a sprint that kept us busy during the month of May to co-design this challenge. We’ve launched it at the UN decade at the launch of the UN decade on ecosystem restoration on the 4th of June. And we’re now having an open submission phase that will last at least until mid of July. And the challenge is looking for startups and scaleups. So startups as we define it as companies that have a proven pilot and some operations and are ready to scale.
And those are I mean the scale up are those that have a little bit more experience and of course are ready to scale out and it’s really about know a number of bioeconomy actors working in agroforestry value chains in bio in ecoourism in fisheries and maybe also models that blend all of those some of those together in more holistic models. So really like the bioeconomy eopreneurs as we like to say and but then also we are looking for companies and startups that are more like working on the enabling environment and helping to meet some of those also like operational needs that eco enterprises working in the Amazon have so that their efficiency and their proficiency can improve.
So really also looking for submissions and participants in the challenge that work more on the enabling environment and then I guess the question is what do we do once the once the submission phase is closed and here again I think it’s three elements that I would like to highlight actually before that maybe it’s well I won’t come let’s see how many elements they’re going to highlight but one thing to say is that and so we do this for the first time now and one.org is a 10-y year long initiative. We want to run those challenges on an ongoing maybe on a yearly basis maybe actually on an even more ongoing basis.
So everything we do know we do it for the first time now but by repeating it over time we hope that the impact of the challenge will also of course be greater. And so the once we have selected the winning cohort members of the challenge, it’s really also about providing those actors access to the network and the platform of the World Economic Forum. So that means participation in events in communities through that giving that access but it’s also about providing access to investors and funders and you I’m delighted of course also to share that we are working very closely with ETH and Jonah on that.
So that know we have set some of the criteria for the challenge that they can the can also be more easily transferred also to the screening process of the IDB lab and its grant and investment mechanisms and similarly also and I think that’s also the idea of the conversation today right help connect also with investors and other stakeholders who are interested in supporting those type of bioconomy eopreneurs so access to investors and people with an interest to see more investment and flowing and then it’s also tied to each challenge we then run like a web specific accelerator programs.
So or maybe just more simply put cohort programs. So and I think here we are obviously not an impact hub and we are not a startup incubator. But we have the network we have the experts that we want to bring in also to help meet some of the more specific needs that each one of the eopreneurs or startups that we surface has. And then again also really it’s the storytelling and those videos and blog posts and that we produce on those type of biocomyreneurs and I think with each video that we produce an average gets about half a million views.
And I think here it’s really also about that long-term vision. If we hope that by doing this more on an annual basis that we can really also lend the brand and the communication of the web to put a spotlight on those type of grassroots innovators. And then also maybe this is the last point for now I’m going to make is so in addition to all of that and the challenge work that we are doing the processes we’re building around it we also regularly convening like what we call high level dialogues for financing the bio economy in the Amazon which goes back to what I said initially about President Duke’s support for on.org.
So with the signature of the Leticia Pact and Eve has mentioned the Leticia platform which is part of the implementation system to support the Laticia pact. So as part of all of that we started convening regular senior level dialogues bringing together the presidents of the IDB of oto the vice president of Brazil and the president of Colombia together with a number of experts and CEOs of companies to have that exchange on how can we also work on improving the system to finance credible bio economy. In the Amazon. So what we are seeking the opportunity that we see I think is really also to bring those pieces closer together.
So the higher level convening power by the web with those more grassroots focused innovation challenges that we run. So the challenge remains open and I’m once I’m done I going to share the link in the chat. I think it was also in the invitation that Jonah has shared, but I said it a couple minutes ago. It’s officially open until mid July. With a little bit of a wiggle room, so we might be able to extend it a little bit. The idea is that then at the end of September during the UN General Assembly week when the WE is holding its yearly sustainable development summit that we use that platform to announce the winning cohort of the challenge.
So maybe let me stop here. Jonah. Yeah.
Jonah:
Great. Thank you Florian. So I’m going to come in with one question and then for those who want to come in with questions please indicate your interest by okay Belain you’re you’re first up please indicate by raising your hand or indicating your interest in the chat. So the first question that I have for you Florian is a little bit of a philosophical one and it’s one that I encountered in the process of organizing the this the Amazon Investor Coalition Summit and it has to do with sort of the perhaps it’s a worldview or ideological divide on this question of forest friendly economic development and indigenous communities.
So there’s a perception that leaving the forest alone and indigenous communities alone and just protecting them is really the best way to protect the forest. After all, historically they preserve the forest better than anybody. But that doesn’t really tie into this universe of investing. And so how can it and what is the role of the or how can or how should it or you know just some thoughts about that and then what is the responsibility of the global economic machine in restoring you know the ecosystem in a way that is an ecological balance.
So I guess it’s a philosophical question of if you’re trying to deal with an ecosystem that needs sustainability but sustainability is not the pattern of the global capitalist system. How do you square that fitting a round peg into a square hole? So it’s a it’s a philosophical thing more than anything else. And then Maria Bellain is up and then Marina go ahead.
Florian Reber:
Thank you Jonah W. That’s a big question. Let me try and offer an answer and I know like well many of you on the call will probably have better answer. So I guess know what we talk about the bioeconomy. And I think it’s important to recognize that’s not a panacea and it’s not the solution for everything and it maybe it shouldn’t be we shouldn’t have that lens to all the landscapes and territories in the Amazon and maybe also elsewhere in the world, right? I mean that’s I guess there is parts of nature that can just be nature and there should not be an economic angle to it at all but at the same time we also have to work with a more and build a more responsible economy and there are lots of opportunities to do it and I think that’s where we have to push the system really to show like the models that work and how you know enterprises or activity ities, economic activities led by local indigenous communities can be recognized as such built upon and built further anchored in a really solid understanding also of the needs of the local communities and maybe starting with that first rather than somewhere further up in the supply chain but the two have to meet and I think it’s about well also a certain worldview and how we develop how we develop economic activities in a in a responsible way.
So I think it’s absolutely not the solution for everything and I think in our in our challenge we recognize that as well. For us as the World Economic Forum, I think we also see of course the opportunity to mobilize the private sector for more of those activities and know restoration and conservation based value chain development in strong partnership with local communities. I think that’s an absolute fundamental aspect of not avoiding the same mistakes of the past that just don’t work as you have mentioned and then yes I mean the responsibility of the global system of course that there is a lot to be improved and we know that the inertia in the system is such that it takes a long time until suddenly it goes very quickly.
And I think here you know we have to be humble as well and just recognize that the complexities couldn’t be bigger. And I think also a challenge for us is to understand like how can we make a meaningful contribution and I guess I would actually also love to hear some answers from the group to that recognizing that complexity and the need to really transform entire economic systems. What is a meaningful contribution actually to be made by an actor like the web?
Jonah:
Okay, great. Maria Ben Duran, in addition, I would like you to come up next. Please feel free to come off to come on video. When you make your question, please introduce yourself. A lot of people just make questions without giving context and you’re working on some super important stuff. Thank you.
Maria Duran:
Okay. Hello. Can you hear me? Yeah, great. Well, my name is Maria Duran. I work at the World Bank within the Amazon sustainable landscape proh program which is a program a regional program for Peru, Brazil and Colombia for its first phase and we’re adding Ecuador, Guana, Surinam and the three other countries for a second phase and it’s a program that is funded by the GF. I found the presentation very interesting and I would love to hear more. I was looking the links that you want to send under the chat and is I think it’s really interesting.
However, I do have some questions and I’m sorry there are four questions. So I hope you could answer all of them. The first question I had is the challenge funded by the IDB idea of the by economy fund that was presented by President Duk some couple months ago. And the second question is what is the role of mid authorities within each country within the challenge like are I don’t know technicians from the ministries of environment of ministers of a agriculture or the of or the authority that is in charge of the by economy idea of each country are they going to have a role in it?
Are they going to review the proposals? Are they c they’re gonna comment on the proposed roles or what is the role? The other question I had is are the eight countries of the Amazon within or is available to send proposals to the challenge. I know that the idea is to have other sectors not the government itself but are the eight countries like including Venezuela within the challenge. And my last question is you mentioned the Leticia pact in your presentation and how it is going to help the countries accomplish it and implement it.
I was I was wondering how are you thinking you’re going to measure the support that the challenges is given to the implementation of the laticia act. Yeah. So that those are my questions.
Jonah:
Excellent. Thank you so much Florian.
Florian Reber:
Yeah. Thank you Mariah. The last one is a particularly difficult one and so I’m glad I have a little more time to think about my answer. So number one who’s funding the challenge? It’s funded by Salesforce. So Salesforce is the donor of one.org and also of Uplink. So we have a very strong relationship with them and it’s actually in the case of one.org it’s actually you know Mark and Lynn Ben off so in their personal capacity who gave a grant to ont.org and that allows us to hire a team and work on it.
In the to clarify the relationship also with the IDB lab is that it’s not funding the challenge per se. It’s about using the challenge as a funnel to identify know startups that the IDB might want to actually support. So it’s that collaboration to basically you know meet the needs of both of us. So that so that’s the I hope that’s the answer to the first question. Your second question about the role of local authorities and experts is an excellent one. We actually were really happy also to receive the support from the office of the vice president of Brazil who shared the challenge with all kind of local development authorities states and a number of you know there were a number of acron acronyms in that list with that of organizations that I was not familiar with, but really keen also to make sure that the challenge which exists in Portuguese and Spanish by the way is being is reaching also those local levels.
And then thank you also for asking about how those type of actors contribute to the review process which is again a collaboration. We invite interested parties. We also look at our own network but also if any of you here are interested in taking part in this we are keen to engage experts to help review the proposals reviewed only those proposals of course that we have prevetted as being valid and serious and you know gives anybody also the opportunity to learn a little bit more about the type of project sourced. All eight countries are available are eligible of course to participate and any project that is locally led and within the granted hard to define boundaries of the Amazon but projects operating within the Amazon are eligible to participate in the challenge.
Now about your last question. Yeah, I think here I mean our impact the way we measure it I think it’s more from an internal perspective at the World Economic Forum from the time for the time being it’s about you know making sure that we do increase the participation of really good ecoreneurs and that you know we also have that shift in the stakeholder map of the web over time also of course that we know help unlock additional investment for those innovators that we surface and it’s like know then providing those proof points and showing having those case studies that show like how things can be done maybe also differently and bring those models then also to the decision makers that are that are involved with the latisia pack, for example.
But I think really the it’s the we measure impact more like from our internal perspective and from the time being but then of course it’s also and it’s always difficult I think also to then really aggregate know if you have like those smaller project focused activities to aggregate impact in terms of hectors conserved or restored and there are I think there are other initiatives about like more systems change initiatives that would lend itself better to those type of impact measures which is something that we actually also exploring as one.org and ref how we can in addition to that more project focused work that we’re doing with uplink how can we also support those larger system change initiatives and dialogues where I think the impact measurements would look different.
Jonah:
Great. Next up is Marina Compos.
Marina:
Hi, thank you. Thank you Florian for this very insightful competition or initiative. It’s a it’s indeed a very much needed in the Amazon and other places around the globe. So I congratulate you and your organization for doing this. My question has to do more with a what kind of impact. So it’s a kind of like a combined question. What kind of impact you looking for? Because I understand you’re you want to focus on the ecore ecopreneurs as you said small startups and scaleups but are we are you looking for 15 50 and the reason I’m asking you this is because this has to do with how much money are we talking about because I didn’t see maybe it was it was an oversight from my side but I haven’t seen anywhere that it says what is the cap of a if there’s a limit for applying because that would really make it you think about how you can bring systemic change or you can just bring like little bits of change right so if you could just clarify that would be very helpful thank you.
Florian Reber:
Great thank you Marina so in terms of how many people or how many startups can apply there is no cap and this is also know we are trying we’re offering a platform for people to connect and each challenge becomes also like a community and so once you submitted your solution you’re basically part of that uplink platform and what we observe is that know the bigger the more people participate in the challenge the more lively then what we call the action groups become and then of course if we get like to give you an example We last summer we did our first global trillion trees challenge and we received around 300 submissions which you know we were quite happy with and we eventually then worked with a cohort of 20 startups and some of them were actually also you know more like initiatives than startups.
So it was had a different focus than this one here. And so with those 20, you know, we ran a four month cohort program which was quite bespoke and lots of like facilitated interactions and again like smaller community building and connections with investors and companies and so that’s much more curated and you know I think the lesson learned there is as is as well that those who make most proactive active use of the opportunity given often get the most out of it. And I think here also I really want to highlight that now we are in a way still piloting what uplink is and so it’s sometimes it’s a bit like know handcrafted in a way and now we actually work with you know it’s yeah we actually spend quite a lot of time on it and we hope that over time this can also become something much more automated right and know there right now there is for example no fund attached to uplink but maybe that’s this can become something you know of the future I mean there I guess now we are we are very entrepreneurial there ourselves.
And if we together with our partners identify that something like this could make sense to help improve the accessibility to appropriate funding for those type of startups why not then I think we could do that but so Yes, we have no let’s let’s say typical cohort it’s about in between 20 12 to 20 companies but anybody there is no cap in terms of how many people can submit their solution. Was there another part of your question that I missed?
Marina:
No. Okay,.
Jonah:
Great. Okay, up next Fiona.
Fiona:
Thank you so much. Nice to see you Jonah and thank you all for everything you’ve all done in this summit and this fruition. I have very specific questions for Florina and I also would like to take a moment to say that Philip Ger and Nara are in visiting also our organization from Brazil. They are here. Her Portuguese is excellent of course. So I’m glad that there’s an inclusion in these this project going forwards. But Niara Yusi Salo Deabella Dolabella is nature rights lawyer out of the indigenous leader team out of the Yea Mesa nation.
And some of the work that they’re really building is you know how do we scale the models to support the structure so that we can look at a five to 10 year investment line and then they are part of our team which I hope it’s okay Jonah just to make the announcement is that okay.
Florian Reber:
Sure.
Fiona:
Okay we did a very long extensive ex-prise rainforest application and again I’m going to say why I’m excited Florian for this next one is that it can be in multiple languages. Ours was in all in English, all in sort of very advanced technology words and biodiversity and kingdom but act now Amazon action alliance is the I think the only nonprofit under decarboniz.org that has been chosen as one of the competing teams for X-Prise rainforest for 2024. So, we’re really excited, but equally we’re looking at what are the models that we are building now because the cry that’s coming from the Amazon is we want access to clean water.
We want our indigenous rights, our biodiversity protection using the Ngoya protocol. How do we help support models that can be utilized with technology but how are we doing it for today’s needs especially after the resilience issues of co which are very rampant in the team Nantar Ingga our head of our ecology team environmental biologist she’s pushing and making kombucha today she feels that’s her most important special business that she has in Ecuador that she uses the medicinal herbs and she makes her own kombucha called amate kombucha and today she’s not on the call she said Fiona I have to work on gut flora I need the medicine the women are growing these herbs we are using our medicinal value chain how do we help scale these businesses so Florian I ask you where and each level what aspect can we you know I’m a nonprofit sort of US but also our team is based in Ecuador Panama and Brazil as well as we have partners in Peru and we even have the Maui team in the indigenous communities in New Zealand and most of them are women scientists or women leaders and indigenous wisdom peoples.
So how do they collaborate with you to make this work? Thank you.
Florian Reber:
Thank you Fiona. I’m glad you asked. So we actually also work with X-priseze Rainforest and we’ve had exactly that conversation with Peter from the X-Prise Foundation and now we want to know find out exactly that how can we also cross-pollinate this and upcoming OPILink challenges with the teams competing on the DXP prize rainforest and that you I think there is I guess the modalities TBD but there is I think a shared willingness to have that exchange and maybe that dialogue and see like what type of might there be a team competing in the X-prise that might benefit from an additional set of expertise that somebody else that know we surfaced would have and could bring into that team and vice versa.
So I think I couldn’t now specifically give you an answer about your specific team but maybe we can have a follow-up conversation on that but generically I think this is exactly the type of connecting the dots or joining up dots that we are very interested in facilitating. Does that help? I know this is not a great answer but I think you know maybe we can have a follow-up conversation. Thank you. And it is I you have to laugh. I didn’t realize that it getting into a challenge would also limit the capacity for myself and more of my beautiful friends who have dedicated a long term to the rainforest and the conservation and are living and breathing there and even for my own small seed investments in forests and conservation models in Panama and in other countries.
So I agree. But you know I let’s not leave contracts or you know I’m very much open to collaboration. That’s one of the reasons that you know as a research institute decarbonized we’ve really tried to open it up. We’re not after the prize. We’re after the collaboration of having us work all together and I really want to respect that and Jonah’s deep work with the Amazon Investor Coalition. So thank you all. Yes.
Jonah:
Great. Christina, I see your hand is raised. You’re up next.
Christina:
Hi. Hi, everyone. This is super exciting. I’ve actually gone on Friday, I went in and I looked at the whole website, the propo, you know, how you submit ideas, proposals, super exciting. And somebody mentioned Venezuela. Yes, we’re an Amazonian country as well. But obviously difficult to work there, but we are working there. From so I head up a 501c3 and my question is whether a 501c3 could submit potentially you know more than one proposal to this challenge and these are you know small startups and more than startups in Venezuela and Amazonia.
Florian Reber:
I would say absolutely but now being Swiss and not familiar with some of the probably nonprofit legal terminologies that you just mentioned. Is that just the legal tax name for a nonprofit?
Christina:
Yes, correct. It’s an American nonprofit. Exactly.
Florian Reber:
Yeah. Yeah. So I mean in principle, look, yeah, we are definitely more interested in the in the for profits, but we also realize that there’s a big gray zone. And many startups at the beginning that have the potential to become you know forprofits absolutely you know rely on grants of course at the beginning that’s the case for everybody and even if it’s so the short answer is yes and I think it’s also about to the earlier point who ends up in the in the cohort is but one part of the challenge and what I should also say is fitting in the init initial form is not that time intensive.
So I think it probably takes about an hour or so. I’ve learned from others. Yeah. So yes, please. And we are also I mean absolutely interested in receiving submissions from the regions and geographies that are also more difficult to work in. So we’re not shying away from that. Yeah.
Jonah:
Great. I would like to invite someone from Convergence to introduce yourself and talk about your organization and your interest in collaborating with the Amazon. Matias, I think you posted.
Matias:
Yeah, thank you Jonah. I was just going to note how I think this is a great initiative and I and I’m noting some similarities in just some of the early stage design funding out there to support Amazonian and other initiatives. So just by way of background, Convergence is the global network for blended finance and we run design funding programs where we manage grants on behalf of third parties and provide early stage grant funding to those who are developing innovative blended finance vehicles. And we are increasingly focused on natural capital, nature-based solutions.
Previously we had a window that was globally focused. Currently, we’re a little a little bit focused on Asia Pacific, but are very keen to expand to the Amazon, Latin America generally. And I just think that there’s lots of opportunity for those of us in the world who are interested in this space, to collaborate, whether that means, you know, sharing pipeline, sharing, you know, technical assistance services. I think there’s just there’s more to be explored in the way of collaboration here. And so very glad to be a part of this conversation and keen to follow up.
I’ll leave it there for now, but thank you. Thank you, Florian. Thank you, Jonah.
Jonah:
Great. And I’ve got a question that is posted by Bruno Santana from Brazil. His microphone is not working, so I’m going to read his question. He works with Elay South America, which is a global association of local governments working towards sustainability. Bruno says we have two projects that we would like to try in the region. One which is already focused in the Amazon region where we try to bring sustainable agenda to local governments and another which I think is the one that fits better with this opportunity where we seek to encourage the generation of technology applied to the demands and challenges of cities with a focus on sustainable urban development by supporting startups active in the areas of innovation and sustainability for local public management is an organization such is ours able to be part of this challenge or are you looking for local entrepreneurs only?
Didn’t find much information unfortunately? Florian,.
Florian Reber:
Thank you Jonah. And thank you Bruno for the question. So I think an organization like Elay for this challenge might probably not be the usual one. And but nevertheless I mean I your work sounds particularly know if it’s cities in the Amazon obviously it sounds relevant. What I would actually highlight here for you Bruno is that we have another piece of work on the way at web which is called biodiversity cities it’s supported by the van humbold institute in Colombia and it’s about you know one part of it is helping to come up with a framework for how do we design and measure what a biodiversity actually is.
Another part of this will also be that we run an innovation challenge for biodiverse cities. This one will most likely go live in September. So, Br, I would I would actually encourage you maybe to focus on that one because I think it’s more relevant to your work. And of course, you can if I mean there’s no harm in already taking a look at the Amazon challenge and maybe you upload your solution, then it’s already done. But I would definitely keep an eye on the biodiversityities one.
Jonah:
Great. And Florian, if there’s a website or a newsletter that people can join in order to get that announcement, that would be great.
Florian Reber:
Yes, there is the uplink newsletter. So, I just put that in here again.
Jonah:
Okay, great.
Florian Reber:
And you get like a every Friday you get a digest. Yeah, great. And then also if you follow if you follow web and uplink on Twitter and LinkedIn, every time we launch a challenge, we do a social media campaign with videos and other assets. So that’s also an easy way to stay up to date. And you see it’s actually quite a lot of those uplink challenges that are being launched almost on a monthly basis.
Jonah:
That sounds great. Okay, Bruno. Kato, you’re up next.
Bruno Kato:
Yes, thank you Jonah for my name is Bruno K. I’m a green entrepreneur. I’m a partner of different companies here. I’m from Bain. I live in Bain in Paris state in Brazil. And I’d like to understand a little bit more and I will use my head of Triago. Okay, Triago. It’s a it’s a company, a private company and we plant trees actually and we already engaged five investors six years ago to plant 65 actors of asai. Okay. And today we try innovate with NFTts to fund force. So the idea is we are already launch three 300 NFTts to fund the investment in forest in agri forest with native species of Amazon.
So how the this challenge can help triag to escalate this kind of business model.
Florian Reber:
Well I think it would be great Bruno if you can participate. And the way we can help you scale is I would it’s three elements in particular right one is for every winning cohort member we again we produce web assets on their work so no a web branded video on the work of Triago with half a million views across social channels gives your visibility globally mostly I would say actually you know mostly globally I mean obviously you can share it in your local networks but I think we also have our gaps in terms of what type of audience we reach then access to our events communities tell telling your story raising awareness and I guess it’s the same point but then it’s also about know understanding what type of additional investors or impact investors and funders that might be helpful for you and that we could help you know getting help trio getting in touch with just like in the case that you would be participating and actually being a member of the cohort those type of services is what we can offer.
It’s not obviously like it’s again this is also not a panacea right and then we are not there’s not a $5 million on the table or something it’s more like thatworked community and also communications support that we can give and I but I will say I mean and as an example right I mean and that goes to the point before about us also making use of the network so like for example, right? We hear of JP Morgan running an in running a basically looking for some of the great natural capital startups out there.
They know that we do that type of work. They ask us, hey, do you have some good people in your pipeline? And then of course we share the profiles of the innovators that we have surfaced because we want them to succeed. And so some of them have just like received half a million dollar of quart million dollars and it helps them. So it’s know it’s that’s a little bit how it works as well. So it’s really also like how we make use of the network and understand the needs of the people in our community and then there are of course limits to that.
I mean we are not a huge team but I think we are missionoriented and we want to help.
Jonah:
Great. Bruno was that okay great. So we just have a couple minutes left. I want to mention something. In the process of convening the summit, I found about 10 maybe more consultants who specialize in developing investment ready projects in the Amazon region. Right? They move from one startup to another. They help people prepare financials etc. I know that in order to qualify for the challenge you need to have a pilot project that is already on its feet. You know it’s idea phase is not enough. But there are a lot of pilot projects that are already on their feet but don’t know how to do the financials.
And so I think there’s a big opportunity to use the network that’s on this call and then the wider network that’s on the mailing list of Amazon Investor Coalition to put together an advisory team of proono consultants that can help, you know, smaller level indigenous communities package their projects as investable, you know, opportunities for either grants or investor money at various rages of risk appetite. So I think it’s my homework to put together an email to blast out to everybody saying who wants to be a consultant and who needs a consultant and then we can prepare things perhaps in for this challenge but also for other opportunities.
So that’s one takeaway I have from this call. Are there other people who would like to chime in the few minutes that we have left about last minute things, questions to the group, announcements feel free to come off mic. Was Bruno going to speak? Because I know he’s got some innovative ideas andor if Philip would love to come and join in and if Naera is there I would we have others that could translate from Portuguese as well. Thank you.
Philip:
I see Philip. Go ahead. Hi everybody. Thank you very much for the presentation. Thank you Flor. Thank you Jonah for bringing everything together. Naara is not with me today. But I would have two questions. The first one is how do you avoid monoculture? So how do you really ensure that the bio biodiversity is [screaming] supported and we don’t just go there and plant trees and then have some unwanted consequences which we don’t know yet. And the second question would be coming back to what Jonah was saying linking capital with indigenous people will say solve one issue but you will open other issues because u indigenous people and communities often are not prepared on their cultural space and they don’t have any meaning what money means or what money can do.
So there need really be a cultural process that supports not only the technical and the infrastructure of getting investments to indigenous people but really like where a collaboration is happening and a mutual learning process is happening. So how can we really support this process?
Jonah:
Great. I just want to mention that we’re two minutes from the turn of the hour. Most people have to leave the call be able to stay on. The room will stay open. So everyone’s invited to stay. Brad, I would like to call on you right before we the time hits to introduce yourself and to ask your question or comment.
Brad Smith:
Thank you. Good day everybody. My name is Brad Smith. I’m representing the One Small Planet Foundation. And I don’t have any questions at this time. I just want to introduce myself and let you know I look forward to attending these calls. We work with a number of partners, nonprofit, grassroots as well as for-profit and larger projects, largely focusing on decarbonization, carbon markets and indigenous support. Part some of those projects are in Brazil, Peru, Ecuador. So just want to introduce myself and say thank you to everybody for your energy and effort as we, continue to turn the tide here.
Jonah:
Great. Thanks so much. Anyone else? Hi,.
Amanda:
My name my name is Amanda. I’m from Tun Brazil. Tukun is a brand that work with more than 72 community indigenous community in the Amazon. And I answer a little bit of Philippines. Last question. We’ve been doing this work for 10 years. Indigenous community in Brazil are really prepared to deal with money. But they don’t know how they don’t have like the technology on their hands now. And also we’ve been developing a social technology with them and we have our the first plat marketplace platform that sells indigenous art in Brazil and our mission and our goal here is trying to raise some money to give them the those communities access to this platform and the technology so they can access the market directly.
Thank you.
Jonah:
Excellent. Thanks so much for joining us. I see lots of collaboration opportunities. So we’re at the top of the hour. This is what I call water cooler time where you know class is dismissed most people leave but anyone’s welcome to stay around and the chat room’s going to stay open so you will have time to copy it down. Thank you so much Florian for joining us. I don’t know if you’re able to stay on for a little longer. I have a feeling people have unstructured questions.
Florian Reber:
Thank you Jonah. Thank you everybody. I will I would love to answer Philillip’s question and then because it’s a little bit late and I have actually surgery early tomorrow morning. If it’s okay I will drop off the call after this. So yeah Philip we set criteria for the challenge including like ecological criteria. So of course we are know we will ask people if they are about growing trees know how this will look like and it’s not about monoculture plantations at all. So we look at that and know if this is the case then I guess this will get not a very good rating.
So and but it’s also like one among other criteria and they’re all weighted equally. Yeah and I think the other question is really I mean I guess in a nutshell I think it’s about the responsibility of those who invest to make sure that the money is also being deployed in a way that is respectful to local cultures and not detrimental to it. So and how can we maybe this how can we support a more broader shift towards that type of thinking just becoming the norm for everybody who has the ability to invest.
So if it’s okay for me to wish you all a great rest of the day and thank you for your super questions and for your time and your interest. Really thank you very much. Thank you so much for joining us, Florian.
Jonah:
Thank you so much, Florian. There was one more question. If it’s eight countries, can the models be taken from like Panama, the reforestation model that has been already financed by a group of funders out of Norway, out of for example, Switzerland? Can a model like that be then replicated into another country?
Florian Reber:
I mean, in principle, yes. And I think we are we are again like interested in facilitating some of that to the extent possible and actually even also like beyond the Amazon and we are you know running a challenge I’ve mentioned on the Sahel very different but still like you know there are some skill sets that might be helpful also for people working in other biomes and ecosystems in the world. So but the replicability of a model I think yes and I think that’s what we would like to support by using our platform effectively.
Fiona:
Well thank you Florine. I guess in the in the specs of the application it was just a challenge to know who and from which point and which country you would like the applications or is it.
Unidentified participant:
Is it July 13th.
Fiona:
The actual date or so help us. I’m trying to curate for you with you along with you some great projects with Jonah and others as well. And so it’s really sort of specific on those little application questions.
Florian Reber:
Yes. And maybe you know if maybe let’s have a separate conversation on that because I think we could take us a little bit more time. So I think I shared my email with you Fiona directly. Why don’t we set up a specific call on that? Yeah, just here to help, you know, facilitate where we can and get you and the collective group some of the most fascinating people’s projects and many of them are, you know, hidden behind, you know, construction in the back of the Amazon right now in the middle of COVID.
So, they’re not maybe going to make the July 13th application and they really are needing this support from you. So, I really want to thank you for that.
Unidentified participant:
Initiative.
Florian Reber:
Thank you. Thank you, Fiona. Yes. And so yeah, let’s have that conversation and the mid July deadline. I think that it’s also because we have like that logic that comes afterwards. But we do see an opportunity to keep this also as an like an open challenge and know maybe we can tweak it a little bit but that basically the window stays open and then because we build that community and network around it. So the cohort program might be tied to a timebound submission period, but there’s something in addition, right, that I think we can all cooperate.
Okay, great. Thank you all. Yeah. Bye.
Unidentified participant:
Bye. Thanks so much.
Fiona:
Anybody else have any other questions? Perhaps maybe just for a moment Philip you could express a little bit about the work of Niara and how it’s potent and so that maybe you have a moment to share with Jonah a little about the community and others might be fascinated to learn more.
Philip:
If there’s space for that. Yes, I’m very reading too. Nara, my wife is from the Yepabarasa nation which in her community they have indigenous land about size of Ecuador and two years ago I was able to visit with an expedi expedition that was led and coordinated by indigenous leaders. So they gathered a group of people that were traveling with them in order to understand the threats the opportunities. We met the SWAT analyzis together with the communities there. So was in a bit participary way where we also looked at the at the challenges they have they are meeting.
So we work with indigenous communities in order to collaborate with the western world to really open them and are able to get access to technology and infrastructure that the modern world is really offering and is a enabling a improvement of the lives while not losing the traditional culture and the traditional knowledge. What we are seeing is when there is internet coming into the communities, when there is money coming into the communities, there are also other things coming in like alcoholism, there are also other things coming in like prostitution. So things that are really we don’t want to share with indigenous communities but it’s really difficult because in some ways they are not prepared to do the economic pressure that we are bringing.
So we want to understand what is it that we find a current level or a common level to share with each other to bond with each other to build really a trustful relationship in between because it’s not it’s not the money that is missing. It is us to listen and say hey what we have been doing for the last 200 300 400 years is a genocide. What we created was like we destroyed their eco ecosystem, their environment. We are really like pressuring them in doing acts that they naturally would not do.
So understand that there is needs a healing process that needs to go on and I know that saying that in a investor community it’s not easy because healing as such we need to take responsibility and it means also like not going there now with no we have a lot of opportunities and we know we want to help and we can help but it is really like sitting together and listening sitting together and really sharing ing what we how do we want to build a different world. So we also inviting people to join us.
We want to make some more expeditions which are led and coordinated by inditionist themselves. So it’s really important and it is a different approach and a different invitation if you go there and meet indigenous by your own wish or if you’re really invited and this is something that we want to honor. We really want to honor that there’s a trustful there are trustful relationships built up because I also believe that inditioners have the knowledge have this the solutions and we have to work together we really have to come together and work together in order to work towards the climate changes.
Jonah:
I see an obstacle for both investors and philanthropists. Working with indigenous communities is a learned process. There have been a lot of attempts and with some success and a lot of failure. And I have done research online about in you know this quest how to work with indigenous communities as a philanthropist as an investor and there’s not much available there’s not much guidance and so I think that I think that we some has been written I so I think that gathering some of the information that has been written on both sides and coming up with something that we can publish to a larger audience for how I think can be helpful to bringing more money philanthropic.
Unidentified participant:
Investment and otherwise. J I think.
Philip:
What would be good would not be just something written and maybe it’s not important the first step to spread news from a huge audience. I would suggest a study group really where we bring together people that are able to listen right now and to share experiences. Those you will not find a lot of things out there in the internet. I know I have friends that are working with Ian Kaki who is an advisor for them bringing in family funds advising family funds. We are also working with a family that is really wanting to invest in indigenous communities and it’s not easy.
It is exactly and I understand when if Amanda says hey they want to of course they want to participate of course they want to need money but what does it mean? It means that normally in a in an indigenous structure the man is receiving the money is going to the city receiving the money and stays there really kind of very vulnerable getting in touch with alcoholism having a lot of money and then going back to the community with less money sometimes and really like with more problems. So there is a lot of social aspect that you will not find things written in the internet because first of all not there’s there are few people that really take this journey and this means that you don’t go there and offer money.
You make your personal journey. You really like you start connecting with people that you trust and you really there needs to be a very deep ethics and it’s really hard to find people that are really like showing this ethics because it needs time and patience and it’s not based on the indicators that we have for investment. No, it’s really going in it has a completely different mindset. It has a completely different way of looking at this. It’s a completely different perspective. If you go to Amazon, you meet people that see trees and plants as their relatives, as our relatives, that see us as part of the whole nature system.
What we as white men never do, we come in as the creators, as we have solutions, we have technology, we create technology. We are arrogant in we listening and seeing other beings acting and working towards a change towards transformation. We are acting in a very one-dimensional way. Using money is not only a one-dimensional way in a way of focusing on economic development. It is just on the third dimension of not including emotional and spiritual and energetic dimensions that are around and that u science is proving more and more what indigenous have been knowing for many years.
So what we have to know or to do is to sit together and share with people that are interested and that are able to listen. If we come here and just shoot solutions that we have been showing in the western world and that were successful very successful in the western world and we want to apply the same the same my daughter’s coming she no you okay. So she we cannot replicate those solutions in this cultural context. What is happening is we have to really learn together. We have to open to be open to bring our experience to bring our technology and knowing that we don’t know where we are going.
So I like the challenge of the one trillion trees but we have to be aware that is it’s a very western approach and very limited in we bring economic force and this will save the world that will not save the world. We need spiritual guidance deep spiritual guidance we need to heal ourselves. We have we have to disconnect from our efforts of wanting to consume and consume and consume. But it is very easy to do to invest and then go back to our dinner parties and really like consume the next technology that is coming out from the Amazon.
And we are talking for big numbers. They’re really huge numbers. There’s not small family office will be able to capable to beat in this fight or to really like avoid this fight. We are talking about nations really wanting to get yeah resources that we have to be very clever and without really having this alliance with indigenous and non-Inditions that understand how to work together it will be very difficult.
Jonah:
Well said. So I sense a deeper opportunity which is about learning and exploration and approach and we’ll we’re in touch through email. We’ll we’ll we’ll mature that. I’m going to go ahead and stop the recording now and we can.