A History of UN Action on the Amazon
Charles McNeill: Today, we learn about corporate declarations, carbon, faith communities, and historic UN action related to the Amazon. Charles McNeill joined the United Nations in 1991 and spent most of the past 30 years working for sustainability, forest conservation, indigenous community leadership, and more. Join us to discuss the history of UN action related to the Amazon. What was the Rio Earth Summit? What is REDD+? What about the New York Declaration on Forests, the UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues, the Equator Prize, and the UN Forum on Forests? What is the Interfaith Rainforest Initiative? What UN member states support these platforms? How can private investors and philanthropists collaborate with them?
Recorded May 3, 2021
References:
New York Declaration on Forests
UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues
WATCH:
Participants
- Jonah (moderator)
- Charles McNeill
- Marita
- Atossa
- Leonardo
- Jon Bruno
- Fiona
- Unidentified participants
Transcript
Jonah:
Hello everybody. This is the 43rd call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing forest-friendly economic development across the Amazon region of South America. And this week we are looking at some of the historic work of the United Nations and its related agencies in advancing Amazon conservation. And we are beginning with an interview from Charles McNeill of the UN Environment Programme. Charles, welcome to the show, I guess I should say. T tell us a little bit about yourself and your life before you became a bureaucrat.
Charles McNeill:
Well, thank you and hi, great to be with you and everyone. Well, I’ve been a bureaucrat for a very long time, so I’m going to have to look back even before that. I’ve been with the UN for almost for about nearly 30 years now, believe it or not. And but before that, my life was characterized by a real commitment to nature and human rights and so on. I was always an activist in one form or another. I’m currently here in British Columbia during the pandemic and this is where I first learned to love snakes and lizards and wild things and I’ll go back to New York before long.
But before the UN, I started just before the Rio Earth Summit. I was in the academic world. I studied plant genetics, evolutionary biology, conservation biology at UC Davis and before that University of California at Berkeley where I studied conservation of natural resources. So I’ve been in this field of biodiversity conservation and political advocacy for even before I was with the UN.
Jonah:
Did you also have a stint at the Hunger Project?
Charles McNeill:
That’s right. That’s right. That was part of my activist days in India and Africa promoting the eradication of hunger and mobilizing populations in the north to take action back then. That was in the I guess 7 80s 1980s and 90s.
Jonah:
Nice. So let’s go ahead and jump into the Rio Earth Summit. So coming up, it’s always been a reference for me organizing young activists around the UN system for a couple decades now. I understand that event in many ways marked the start of your career. Can you tell us a little bit about the experience you had and what was the significance of it even to today?
Charles McNeill:
Yeah, great. Well, it relates to your earlier question that all my life I’ve been moving between the development human rights issues and environmental issues and I could never find a place where I could work on both issues and in fact these movements before Rio I found them to be often conflictual in opposition that we tree huggers were criticized for not caring about people and we development activists were criticized for running roughshot over natural resources and there was this tension between obviously aligning groups. And when I heard about the Earth Summit, I sort of knew this was a time when the integration of those issues could be happening at scale.
And in fact, that was my first assignment with the UN. I was just joined UN development program. And I and what was remarkable for me was it I think this was the time when civil society got invited into intergovernmental processes in a whole new way. Civil society came in fullthroated both feet and that was a Rio was a turning point. There was no going back and we’ve seen in you know more of that since then and it was significant obviously because the three conventions came out of that the ones on climate change biodiversity and the convention to combat deservation also I think we’ll talk a little bit more about that unfortunately there was not a forest convention that the politics at the time would not allow that to happen so we ended up with an agreement on forest principles and those forest principles have been debated ever since and so that was that was an outcome.
I really I remember distinctly leaving Rio after that series of events and I’ll never forget the flight. It took off from the Rio airport and it banked just as I could just see the lights of Rio and I felt this very powerful sense of the world would not be the same that there was a watershed event happened there a kind of coming together of unlikely partners and that’s really the story of my life is about bringing together unlikely partners to make unpredictable things happen. So the real was a great beginning.
I think we have re real plus 40 coming up or 30 coming up pretty soon. But that was a significant beginning as I said beginning of my time with the UN.
Jonah:
Wow. We certainly hear many references to it in popular culture. I believe that John Kerry met Teresa Hines there and some magic happened and now he’s the US envoy on climate. It’s definitely touched the lives of many and set many things in motion in.
Charles McNeill:
And also and also I remember there were sessions that ind civil society was had learning how to do email at the time the speed of email was like 1,200 bot or 2400 bot and so we were all there in back rooms learning how to send emails back and forth and who would know how that would morph and transform form and the power of telecommunications and social media, but it was just beginning there as people were learning to communicate in the most basic way.
Jonah:
Nice. Let’s go ahead and move in into some of the other things. We could talk about the rehears all day. I know. This has to do with red plus. So from what I understand since the beginning you’ve been involved. It’s that international effort to as they say R for reduce E for emissions from D deforestation and for another D degradation redd plus. Can you tell us a little bit about your involvement and how that evolved over time and where it is now?
Charles McNeill:
Yes, absolutely. As I’ve mentioned, I’ve always been committed to the protection of the world’s biodiversity. And I’ve realized that we couldn’t make progress just talking to biodiversity actors. That the issue was too elusive, not taken seriously by the major actors, the drivers of the economy, the drivers of environmental degradation. And I saw that the climate convention had the attention of the economic sources of the problem. And because you can’t solve the climate issue without dealing with energy and transport and the building sector and land use. So I realized I saw that this recognition around 2004 2005 was growing that you can’t avert a climate cataclysm without protecting the forest.
So we needed to make the case within the climate convention for forests. And I and I think we all understand that by protecting forests for climate benefits you automatically get enormous biodiversity benefits. So benefits something like 80% of all the terrestrial speak species live in forest. So, so a number of us realized that if we could leverage the significant financial resources that are around climate action to protect forest that we would get a number of benefits climate biodiversity not to mention the allimportant rights of indigenous peoples and local communities. So at the time governments and NOS’s began talking about avoided deforestation that subsequently became red as you said reducing emissions from deforestation and forest degradation and this was one of the few areas in the climate debate where both southern and northern governments could agree southern governments know they need their forests we all need the climate benefits.
So, so this was a very interesting arena. And it came into existence formally in 2007, but it was in 2005 recall in Montreal when some initial beginnings of agreement happened. So, I think it was from my perspective I’d seen that a number of good ideas for climate benefits turned into bad ideas once they were implemented. There was you know a head-long push for bofuels. We didn’t really look at the socioeconomic implications or the implications on the big sucking sound on local communities and indigenous lands, endangered food supplies and so on.
So a number of us decided to really focus on the socioeconomic implications of something called red. And so we did a lot of research and consultations to make sure that when this mechanism got created, it would take into account the rights and livelihoods of local communities, especially indigenous peoples. And so that’s why I had the honor privilege of working with people to create the UN red program, which we designed it in a way that really led with local voices. And one of the most interesting innovations of the Yon Red program was that indigenous people’s local communities had seats on the board as with as much governance responsibility as the governments and the UN agency.
So it was a chance for indigenous peoples and local communities to build the initiative from the inside out. And so I was pleased to be able to develop that program with that perspective. And since then this program has grown. The UN red program is now I think working with 64 countries and so on. And the question the jury is out on whether this way of dealing with the climate crisis is really going to work or not. There’s really issues of sufficient finance. There’s issues of monitoring evaluation and so on. But it’s a promising dimension and it’s even I think even today if the if the you know the COVID crisis really kind of dislodged and obstructed some real progress and I’m hoping that we can get back on track and generate the not only the finance at scale but to make sure the safeguards are fully intact.
It’s an important body of work that still needs to go on.
Jonah:
There’s so much more we could get into with that. And so we’ll we’ll run through the rest of these questions. I know people will have a lot. So I’m going to go ahead and move to the next one. So I remember you are a key organizer of the UN Secretary General’s Climate Action Summit back in 2014 and of the New York Declaration of Forests, the NYDF they call it, NADF. Can you tell us about the Declaration on Forests? What happened then and where is it now?
Charles McNeill:
Yes. So the UN Secretary-General [name unclear] really took the climate crisis seriously and he organized in 2014 climate action summit. He divided it up into five major areas of intervention. One of them being forest. So it was notable that this was a time when the forest theme was recognized as one of the major both contributors to the problem of climate as well as potential solutions and UNP was assigned responsibility for overseeing that action area and I was the sherpa as they called it and so the job was to really convene all the different stakeholders UN agencies NOS’s those indigenous peoples and importantly the private sector.
This was a time when the business community, particularly the commodity companies, the ones that are producing those crops which are such major drivers of deforestation, beef and soy and palm oil and pulp and paper that these major commodity producers and suppliers had begun right around that time to really start to pay attention to their impact on forest. And the whole movement of deforestation free supply chains got started just a few years before that. So for that summit we were able to bring together the most unlikely again unlikely partners. That’s the story of my life of here we had indigenous leaders with CEOs of major companies sitting together negotiating this New York declaration on forest.
We thought this was a chance to really have a historic moment for agreement among these powerful constituencies that until then really hadn’t come together very strongly. So this was a chance the New York Decoration is ambitious. We’ve just missed a key part of it. The a major target is about cutting in half the rate of deforestation by 2020 and stopping it by 2030. The truth is we’re not on track to get the 2020 2030 target either. There are targets in there regarding u deforestation of free supply chains. There’s a number of things and an independent group is following up on that.
Each year tracking the progress and I have to admit the progress is not great. We’re losing we’re losing ground on most fronts. But I think it’s important that these constituencies came together. Over 200 governments and NOS’s, indigenous people’s groups and companies came together to really make an effort and the fact that we’re tracking it is important and there is some progress on a few fronts, but it was a I think a very important milestone in international collaboration and we need to redouble our efforts so we can actually meet some of those guals by 2030.
I believe that some of those companies that made those commitments and haven’t followed through are were created by parents and grandparents of Nexus members. So, we’ve got some internal work to internal family work to do when it comes to pushing for compliance.
Jonah:
Fantastic. Fantastic. So, another question for you. Tell us about the equator initiative and the equator prize and why you created it.
Charles McNeill:
This also relates back to Rio. In 2001 nearly a decade after the real earth summit in the UN we were taking stock of where’s progress being made and for the life of us we couldn’t see a lot of evidence of progress at the national level at the global level but we were seeing absolutely strong evidence of progress and local communities all over the world like these beams of light and the more we looked we more interesting that became a kind of explosion vision of local innovation and achievement in the north and in the south in terms of local communities.
And so we were in the runup to Rio plus 10 we wanted to sort of keep take stock of this you know how do we find and document these innovations and learn from them and connect high achiever communities with other communities so they can share their invert innovations learn from each other and even influence the policy of their local government and national government. So what we did is we and we at the time we also realized that this traditional model of de development north to south we just download basically technology and approaches that work in the north and think they’re going to work in the south at that time we saw that wasn’t happening that the ecological differences between the southern countries the health differences between the north and the south tempered versus tropical were just rendered northern solutions inadequate for southern challenges and So we created the equator prize which was part of the equator initiative to really begin to shine a spotlight on all the innovations out there.
So, we created sort of the Nobel Prize for local communities, the Equator Prize, and we launched it at Rio + 10 in Johannesburg, not Rio. And since then, we’ve discovered thousand, literally thousands and thousands of innovative, powerful, local solutions for the sustainable development challenges of our time. And we’ve learned a lot from them. We’ve documented these winnings, these learnings. The exchange has been powerful and so it’s a it’s a way to really track the below the radar achievement that’s so important for us to meet the sustainable development goals of our time.
Jonah:
I can speak to its influence. I know several grant-making ventures that use the Equator Initiative and the Equator Prize as a reference when developing their grantmaking strategies. Okay. Let’s keep it moving. We’re talking about all these global programs. It’s just it’s a remarkable 30 years. So next, the interfaith rainforest initiative. Tell us about it. Why are you so encouraged about it and how did it get started and what is it doing now?
Charles McNeill:
Well, good question. And I never would have predicted somebody who grew up in a household with almost no formal religion. My father, the son of a of a of a Scottish minister who instilled so much religion in him that he said he would never talk about religion with his children. How that I would devote my life now the last three or four years to supporting religious leaders and faith communities in taking on the climate challenge. And Lars Lovel who is participating this broadcast is one of the creators of this initiative.
It started inspired by Pope Francis and other religious leaders who began to pay attention to who’s shown some real interest in the climate issue. And the question that I think we’ve had is that in the past couple of decades, governments, NOS’s, scientists, indigenous peoples have been working hard on this on this forest challenge, recognizing, as I said before, that we can’t solve the climate challenge without dealing with it. And I think it was it was three or four years ago that Lars and the government of Norway realized that no matter how many billions of dollars we spend, no matter how much we talk among ourselves, if we don’t leverage and mobilize the 85% of humankind who affiliate with one religion or another, if we don’t make the moral, ethical, even spiritual argument for protecting forest, pro protecting our climate, that we’re not going to get there.
We’re not going to turn the tide. So, so I was asked to work with others to do this experiment to find out is this an issue of interest and concern to religious leaders and faith communities. And we convened a couple of hundred religious leaders and indigenous leaders in Oslo three and a half years ago under the opices of King Herald. And we discussed the science of tropical forests, the links to climate and importantly the importance of indigenous peoples and their rights. And after three days there was a kind of a realization that yes tropical forests are in the wheelhouse of religious leaders across the board.
It’s a sanctity of life issue. It’s a human rights issue. It’s an environmental justice issue and the connection that happened in that launching event between indigenous leaders from Asia, Africa, Latin America and the religious leaders from all faiths all over the world and a recognition that together something unpredictable can happen. And that’s when we decided to let’s just focus on a piece of the problem. Not all of it, a piece of it. So we chose five countries to work in. Brazil, Colombia, Peru, Indonesia, and the Democratic Republic of Congo. Five countries that comprise 70% of the world’s remaining rainforests.
70% in these five countries. And so we’ve gone we’ve gone to each of these countries, met with the religious leaders, met with the indigenous leaders, and they’ve picked it up and run with it in the most inspiring way that now there are advisory councils in all five of these countries with leaderships from all the major religions, indigenous peoples, NOS’s and the UN. And then I we can talk more about it. Lars and I could talk for hours about all the work that’s happening in these five countries. And it’s truly inspiring.
And just a couple of weeks ago, two major national legislations were passed, one in Colombia and one in Congo. That are very significant that had the strong support of all the religions through the interfaith reinforcement backing it because in because religious leaders have political power, moral authority and economic influence as well. And when that voice comes in behind the forest issue, behind the climate issue, and behind the indigenous people’s issue, things happen because we know that the change comes from political will. And this is generating political will in a way that I didn’t expect in my 30 years in the UN.
I’m happy to be able to be ex, you know, witnessing a kind of a an influence that I didn’t know was possible. So that’s a few words about that interfaith rainforest initiative.
Jonah:
Nice. When you and I spoke you told were began to tell me a little bit about what’s happening at local levels in Colombia. Can you repeat a little bit about.
Charles McNeill:
Yes. Yes. That’s right. Colombia has been very creative. And they in 2018 they the organizers there knew that there would be local elections all over the country for mayors and municipal leaders. And so they began by influencing the national legislation to embed in the national development strategy of the country a recognition and a commitment to tropical deforestation as a as a priority and secondly a commitment to develop an action plan from the government. So armed with this national level legislation, the leaders went to local communities and met with the candidates for mayor in each of the communities and they organized debates where the mayor mayoral candidates would debate and actually make a commitment that if elected they would focus on reducing deforestation in the Amazon and protecting the rights of indigenous peoples.
And then sure enough once the elections happened the interfaith rainforest initiative colleagues went back and said okay now it’s your time to deliver and so interfaith rainforest initiative representatives are put on the land commissions land management commissions and they’re able to track and monitor progress. There’s now 36 local chapters active in the hotspots of deforestation. So they chose the areas where the threat to forest was greatest and now these local chapters are working hard. Again it’s this multis sectoral all the faith indigenous peoples local communities and NOS’s working together. So it’s that multis sectoral nature of it and again in this initiative the unpredictable partnership this time is the religious leaders and the indigenous leaders them coming together in an unpredictable way in many ways beginning to heal the 500 years of a most difficult relationship.
It we see hope for reconciliation but these local chapters are being created in all five countries in a similar kind of model but Colombia is the most advanced. So we can see what the potential is in that country in particular.
Jonah:
Amazing. Okay, two quick questions from me and then we’re going to open it up to everybody else. Those of you who would like to ask question please feel free to indicate your interest in the chat. So second to last question tell us about the UN forum on forests and where it.
Jonah / Charles McNeill — boundary unclear:
Came from. Yes, you know it’s.
Charles McNeill:
Interesting that as I mentioned the UN forum on forest I mean the Rios did not result in a convention on forests but it did it did lead to forest principles and the and then the UN morphed in its work on these forest principles it morphed into a number of forms. There was the what was it called the I’m trying to remember the particular.
Jonah:
It’s okay.
Charles McNeill:
Precursor to the forum on forest it was just I have a note here on that is so the agreement reached in Rio was you’re not going to believe this non-legally binding authoritative statement of principles for global consensus on the management conservation stable development of all types of forests in short the forest principle And then following the earth summit the UN established the intergovernmental panel on forests. And then it evolved into the intergovernmental forum on forests u to implement these forest principles. And then finally in the year 2000 the UN economic and social council ECOS established the UN forum on forests and this is an intergovernmental body that’s committed that dealing with the management conservation and sustainable development of all types of forests with an intent to strengthen long-term political commitment to this end.
And so this group meets regularly. And I’ve participated in a number of meetings over the years. The principal functions are to really enhance cooperation among the UN agencies and the V governments in particular to reverse the forest loss.
Jonah:
So it sounds like a platform for conversation and politics versus a platform for action. Would you say that’s a correct character?
Charles McNeill:
Yes. It’s not like a funding mechanism like the green climate fund or the global environment facility or even the UN red program or the forest carbon partnership facility by the world bank. It’s about dealing with the more the political dimension of the of the issue.
Jonah:
Great. Okay. Last on my list. What is the UN permanent forum on indigenous issues and why does it matter?
Charles McNeill:
Yes. So I’ve had the pleasure of participating in the UN permanent form on indigenous issues over many years. It’s a high level advisory body again to the UN economic and social council ECOS. The UN permanent forum on indigenous issues UN FP UN I’ll say UN permanent forum that’s more clear. Was formed in 2000 with a mandate to deal with indigenous issues related to economic and social development, culture, the environment, education, health and human rights and they provide expert advice and recommendations to the UN agencies and programs. There they raise awareness and pro promote the integration and coordination of activities around indigenous peoples for UN system.
They disseminate information and they promote the UN declaration on the rights of indigenous peoples. They meet every year for 10 days. This year it’s been virtual and they have different themes each year and thousands of indigenous peoples from all over the world come to these meetings. I’ve had the pleasure of speaking to and working with this group for many years. And it’s one of three UN bodies that are mandated specifically to deal with indigenous people’s issues. The other is the expert mechanism on the rights of indigenous peoples and the third is the special raptor on the rights of indigenous peoples.
So it’s a major consultation body that meets and it also helps put pressure frankly on the UN system and the agencies to deliver on our commitment to implement the you know the declaration the UN declaration on the rights of indigenous peoples. So and one more important UN mechanism.
Jonah:
Excellent. First up with our questions is Marita Kokavvesa. You’re up, Marita. I think you might be on mute.
Marita:
And I just have to get live again. Hi, Charles.
Charles McNeill:
Hi, Marita. Good to see you.
Marita:
I have I have two questions. One with regard to your work with religious leaders. And remembering our old friend Maurice Strong who started just about anything you’ve been talking about all evening. Yes. One thing he started was the Earth Charter which was an interfaith group trying to define universal values that the different religions could sort of agree on. I is that at all in today’s discussions where has the Earth charter gone? So that’s one of my questions. Great. Maybe you want to ask answer that first because the second question is quite different.
Charles McNeill:
Okay, great. Yes, and thank you for remembering Maurice Strong. And I he’s a hero of mine and always will be and it was in fact I was inspired in my whole career by him and I’ve had the pleasure of engaging with him over the years and I’m aware of the Earth Charter and UNDP. We were participating with Maurice right after Rio in promoting it and so on. It still lives on. It’s I have my own copy of it. It’s referred to but it’s not as I’m not aware of an active campaign around it right now.
It’s I think it inspired us all. It has all the principles of the universal values that you said and it was a precursor. It paved the way I think to the work that we’re doing right now.
Marita:
Okay. Well, my other question relates to climate and to all those wonderful promises that any municipality, any large industry, any country now makes the race to zero by 2030, 40, 50 depending on the case. And we all know that large part of this we hope will come from technological and policy innovation but quite a bit of it has to come from offsets from carbon syncs and so I was wondering within the UN system you know you have one part which talks about the climate and the other part of which you are part that talks about the forests and red plus and all those mechanisms.
How does that get integrated? Because somehow you know in a sort of unanalytical non-analytical way I feel there’s more talk about offsets than there is carbon sync to set off in. So what do you make of this?
Charles McNeill:
Yes. Yes. There a couple of points in there that you’ve made and one of them is about the prol proliferation of targets and goals and the difficulty of actually making those goals and reaching those targets and I mentioned the New York declaration on force that I had a lot to do with is already missed a number of those goals and I think it’s important that the international community really think carefully before making goals because when we set goals and don’t deliver on them. It undermines the overall movement. And it weakens our ability, but we also can’t we can’t give up.
We have to be bold and ambitious. So I don’t you know have an answer on how to walk that line exactly. I think the 2030 framework for the sustainable development goals and the 20 uh30 agenda I think has to galvanize all of our attention in a way that none has so hereto for we know this next decade is critical. It’s we’ve said that for decades and it’s been true for decades but it’s true in a whole new way for this way. So my strategy is really to focus on the 2030 goals, all of them, and to just redouble our efforts in every way that we can.
So I’d like to kind of put our attention there. With regard to offsets and carbon sinks and so on, red is a an important dimension of that. And I think that many of us hoped and thought that we could by this time be having a much greater impact in terms of offsetting and u funding the protection of forests. There have been a number of problems that have been encountered, methodological problems included, but I think the major problem has been not having a framework in place that would allow significant enough funding to really take off.
I’m hopeful that now that I’m seeing signs that governments and businesses with a strong framework are ready to unleash some serious results in the forest sector. I spend a lot of my time on safeguards, social environmental safeguards to make sure that these offsets are undertaken in a way that can be monitored, can be measurable, can be sustained and that don’t have undesirable consequences. So I’m encouraged that there’s enough concern about that we do have a framework that can work. I’d be interested in other people’s thoughts on this. Not working directly on the red mechanism.
I haven’t for a couple of years, but I’m tracking it. I’m focusing, as I mentioned, on mobilizing the religious and faith communities around that agenda. So, in summary, I’m hopeful that the forest can be protecting force can be part of the solution. There’s a long way to go still, but I do see some hopeful signs coming up. This is a really important topic and we probably could benefit from the advice of other people who are participating in this but maybe I’ll stop there.
Jonah:
I agree important and controversial and with limited time to address. We’ve got two questions on deck. Atossa Sultani you’re up next.
Unidentified participant:
Yayosa.
Atossa:
Hi Charles. Nice to see you. Great to see you. Decades of amazing work and commitment to the forest to our global you know forests everywhere. I wanted to ask you if you’ve been following some of the process around the Amazon science panel which the UN is supporting and kind of housing and what aspiration you know going back to this idea of like zero deforestation targets are not being met but what about biome level targets for protection of the percentage of the biome that is required to avoid a tipping point you know that’s you know what’s being discussed some of what’s being discussed at the science panel What hopes do you have for what how the science panel can boost the efforts to put some as you say targets are hard but in a way we if we don’t address the biome level targets on the Amazon we are you know reaching the tipping point so you know I’d love to hear your thoughts on that and again thank you for all of your amazing work and being such an ally to indigenous peoples too for us.
Charles McNeill:
Thank you so much so great to see you and in fact I haven’t participated did with the Amazon science panel. I’m aware of it but don’t really know enough about it to speak intelligently. I am aware of the effort to have a jurisdictional approach that avoid problems of leakage by making sure that an entire sub state or subnational jurisdiction is dealing with the challenge all at once. I agree that needs to happen. Otherwise, you have random projects and you can produce a benefit in one part that gets under undermined in another.
But I’m all for the idea of biome level targets. I just don’t know enough about it to be able to give some useful input at this point.
Jonah:
Okay, next up, Leonardo and.
Leonardo:
Okay, thank you, Jonah. Charles, of course I know that, you know, the Bosonaro government is not really, you know, it’s not holding great reputation on protecting the Amazon. But it’s also I think I’m curious to hear know from inside. So not only you know in this general two years but also in a recent shift in the know the speech having the government very pressured the last two months. So I like to listen a little bit on you know what’s going on you know in the teams and how the Brazilian government is really behaving inside the day-to-day you know work in the UN and the other work that you do.
Charles McNeill:
Great. Thank you. And you’re from Brazil, Leonardo?
Leonardo:
Yeah. Yeah, I live in Cinas, S. Paul State.
Charles McNeill:
Oh, great. Brazil was my last international trip. I thought it was a good idea to travel to Brazil on March 12th of last year. I was assured by everyone the day before that COVID was not a problem in Brazil. By the time I landed on the runway in Brasília on the 13th of March, all of the meetings that I had gone there to have got cancelled. It was explosion of texts from onto my phone saying that CO has hit in a serious way. And but I’m my heart goes out to you and everyone in Brazil for the most difficult situation of all.
And I’ve watched it from a different from a distance. I with regard to Brazil the interfaith rainforest initiative has been exploring ways to make a difference there that clearly the religious leaders and faith communities. Some of them had a large role in electing that current administration and surely could have a large role in any next election. So we have u convened the range of religions the Catholics the Protestants the range of Pentecostals evangelicals the Muslims the Jews the Hindus and others along with u a lot of the indigenous leaders that you surely know and a and the major NOS’s that are so dynamic and this group has been exploring very various ways to impact the situation and there have been a number of educational events and so on so forth.
The you know the situation in Brazil is such a tragic one in the sense that remember between 2004 and 2012 Brazil managed to reduce the deforestation rate by 80% while increasing food production and growing the economy. It’s absolutely stunning how the solution to that challenge is available and known and it has not been applied so far. I guess there was a hopeful sign last week and the week before with the with the leader summit. There was some signals that maybe a different commitment would be coming. The new head of the interfaith rainforest initiative, Carlos Vicente is was an one of the architects of that reduction from 2004 to 2012.
He’s also an evangelical himself and he is now working hard on developing a plan to deal with this situation and be happy to talk to you in more detail about that or put you in touch with him. That the idea of course is for these religious leaders to mobilize their constituencies to prioritize the protection of the forest indigenous people’s rights rather than the opposite. It’s a huge potential. We’re not there yet. It hasn’t evolved as well as in Colombia yet or others, but I’m very hopeful for what can be achieved in Brazil in the coming in the coming months and years.
It’s so urgent. I you don’t I don’t need to remind you.
Leonardo:
Thank you. I know a little bit of Carlos. I know a lot his daughter Yara and although evangelical, he’s very progressive and close to Marina. So great.
Charles McNeill:
Exactly. Exactly.
Leonardo:
Thank you.
Jonah:
Great. Leonardo and Charles and anybody I encourage you to paste your email in the chat area to be able to follow up afterwards. Next up, John Bruno. I think you’re on mute. I’m.
Jon Bruno:
Just trying to get the camera won’t Come on. Can you hear me?
Jonah:
Yeah, we hear you. Go for it.
Jon Bruno:
Okay. Well, you don’t you don’t get to see me. Okay. Well, Charles, first I want to congratulate you on apparently, you know, you’re you’re you’re able to bring together some of the most disperate communities on the earth and in all history. So, that’s a wonderful thing. I wanted to echo your observation that a lot of corporations and governments are now beginning to seriously realize the power of sustainability and to aggressively genuinely implement programs in that direction. But I also wanted to say that you know the very first few sentences of your talk you mentioned the difficulty between development sustainable development and environmental u causes and I and I you know is it is it just the magic of the UN that created a solution there because there’s still a lot of a lot of acrimony and a lot of suspicion on both sides of those that I’ve unfortunately personally been involved with and had to see in.
So I wonder if there is any progress towards uniting those two great and powerful communities into one path that we could all get behind.
Charles McNeill:
Yes. Great. Thank you, John. Great to hear from you. Yes and I didn’t mean to suggest that in June 1992 that debate got resolved and that got by any means that I think a lot of progress was made. It was a like I felt that like an ice it’s a perverse analogy but like the an iceberg cracking and then the and the piece breaking off. There was a breaking off of the division a little bit. My hope and my sense is that the sustainable development goals, this framework of 17 goals cutting across all the human and environmental issues really provides a framework that can really hold all of those views and all of those different perspectives.
So I’m really thinking and they really evolved from the Millennium Development Goals which were the precursor to the sustainable development goals which really go a long way to integrating all these issues. And so John my sense is that’s the framework and it’s part of the what’s called the 2030 agenda. And it’s a place for everyone. There’s room for all of us no matter what perspective we have on the human or the environmental dimension there and they’re very carefully very thoughtfully designed these goals to have you know to bring it all together in a in a cohesive integrated way so I would you I’m sure you’re aware of them but I would I would just argue that investing in that framework monitoring those goals driving that agenda from the private sector or the public sector is really the way forward.
Jon Bruno:
Absolutely. I agree.
Jonah:
Great. We have we got up to 24 25 people on the call. We’re almost still at those numbers. We’ve got about eight minutes left. Certainly some of you have questions for Charles. Feel free to just blurt it out. Come off mute. Atosa, I saw you come off mute. Did you want to? There you go.
Atossa:
Well, how could I waste this opportunity to, you know, Charles, back to the science panel conversation. I mean, you know, the obviously the sustainable development network is a big part of it, the Amazon part of that network. And I do think that there’s a potential for, you know, just like you said, there was an intergovernmental panel on forest. Well, you know, there’s now this potentially non-governmental panel on the Amazon. And I do think that, you know, there is all of this discussion about 30 by 30 that’s leading the framework leading up to the biodiversity convention.
There’s conversations about half the earth. So conversations around global deal for nature and our ambitions that need to be higher you know and truly I’m just wondering what do you suggest to what would you suggest to the science panel participants of which I’m many of us are part of that could help bring this idea of a biome level target to the forefront. It’s not part of the SGS. It’s not, you know, in the agenda 2030 yet. The tipping point of the am, you know, the tipping point of the hydraological system of the Amazon is the most urgent thing we’re facing.
So, I guess I’m just want to push back a little and say, what do you suggest where can this go? I mean, don’t could we have a more robust laticia pack that looks at a biome level target if it were truly looking at you know, one earth says the one earth organization that’s doing a global safety net on eco regions says you know 85% is the target for protection and restoration. Anyway, I just wanted to kind of pick your in front of every no one else.
Charles McNeill:
Well, you’ve piqued my curiosity and I’ll definitely get more involved in this and see if I can be more helpful, but I totally agree that biome level targets is the way forward. It’s a little it’s a little innovative in a sense in the sense that I certainly haven’t worked in that domain, but I agree. So, I’ll look into it further, but I but I don’t really know enough about it to say too much. But thank you. And what about your own work on the Amazon that when we were traveling in Ecuador and so on?
I think there’s a very powerful initiative that would be worth mentioning here too that you and Amazon Watch and Pachoma and others have been advancing.
Atossa:
Yeah. I mean, we’re very excited that the Sacred Headwaters initiative is now has a in the final stages of releasing a first draft of a bio regional plan which looks at the bio region as a whole and looks at a transition strategy that moves beyond extractive industries into regenerative restoration conservation mostly indigenousled vision for this region. We’re very excited to share that, you know, soon with more people and also really need to pick your brain on funding mechanisms that meet kind of the criteria because we are concerned about carbon markets and indigenous peoples often say they don’t want the you know some do and many don’t want to engage in markets and in countries like Ecuador you don’t you know there is no markets because Ecuador did not in the constitution support carbon markets.
So within that sense, we’re looking for innovative financial mechanisms that can really elevate you know that can meet our help us meet our goals but aren’t necessarily in the market. So I’ll be picking your brain about that soon.
Charles McNeill:
Great. And as you know, I’m a ma massive major supporter of the sacred headquarters of the Amazon idea and concept and we’ll do everything I can to support that and understand your concerns about carbon markets. And I think there are some win-win solutions here that we can figure out. Thanks, Charles.
Jonah:
Marita, you have a second question.
Marita:
Yeah, Charles. I work with Carlos Nobre and others on a program called Amazonia 4.0. Nice. And as you may know it sort of has this ideal and you know we see it as a major medium-term alternative to build an economy based on standing forests and flowing rivers.
Charles McNeill:
Yes.
Marita:
And of course that has to be science-based otherwise you know we just talk about sustainability and we don’t know what we’re talking about. But it also depends very strongly on the formation the training of people the so-called human resources I don’t like the word you know from local producers to people who sit in banks and consider credit modalities to consultancies and policy makers in parliaments. So we have the first rainforest business school in my house and we are building associated with this the Amazon business school online and I was just wondering as I was listening to you and you don’t have to answer it now but I wanted to leave the thought with you what could UNEP do to contribute towards the building of our curriculum because clearly There is a lot of knowledge a lot of past talks, papers and so on which all should go in the knowledge hub we are building for sustainable rainforest business.
Charles McNeill:
Wow.
Marita:
And so I would be delighted if you could keep that in mind.
Charles McNeill:
Yes. And I just love the concept of Amazonian 4.0 Oh, and I know in my own work around the Amazon in the Congo basin and Indonesia as well is that it’s not sufficient to just say protect conserve. There needs to be an alternative economic model. One like you say that creates alternative incomes shifting the extractive industries to others. And so that the training of the people the online school you’re doing is so important for the from the interfaith rainforest initiative we have tremendous amount of materials about forest protection in many languages as well as from the perspective of all the major faiths.
So we have produced a lot of educational materials that will be are being pushed out by the formidable educational channels of the religions in all these countries. So I could imagine we also may be able to help you push out education materials that you produce through the religious leaders may be willing to advance your own outreach or some of our materials may be of use to you as well. I’d love to keep in touch with you about that important work you’re doing.
Marita:
Let’s do I think there’s a lot to do and fast. Yeah,.
Charles McNeill:
Indeed.
Jonah:
We still have 30 seconds left in case there any last minute questions.
Charles McNeill:
Or comments too, not just questions.
Jonah:
Or comments.
Fiona:
How can we best support your work and how can we collaborate on a longer term valuedriven opportunity? And I bring that question from some of our team that are competing with a group for the rainforest XPRIZE, but they are don’t speak English. They’re in the middle of the Amazon. And how can they participate? Thank you.
Charles McNeill:
Wow, good question. That was Fiona, right? Well just one thought there many UN programs many UNEP programs I if they’re well if they’re in any of the five countries I mentioned and if they’re affiliated with indigenous groups or religious groups they can participate in the interfaith rainforest. The UN decade on ecosystem restoration is being launched this year and that’s another platform that has lots of avenues for participation for groups and individuals to participate. So I would urge people to go to the UNEP website on and just search for UN decade on ecosystem restoration which is all about forests and other landscapes.
But there are many ways to participate that are outlined on that website. So that’s one resource I would direct you to Fiona.
Jonah:
Great. I posted the website [website address unclear]. Ww.deckatonrestoration.org. Thank you everybody for joining us. This is the moment that I refer to as water cooler time where we transition. Most people leave the call but it becomes unstructured conversation for anyone who wants to stay over and I stop the recording. Charles, thank you so much for joining us. You’re welcome to stay around. What an amazing experience.
Charles McNeill:
My pleasure. And I see Dr. Lars Lobo, my dear friend and comrade in all things. Good to and great to see all of you. Marita and Atosa. Thank you.