Film, Uncontacted Peoples and Tribes on the Edge
Today, we learn about uncontacted tribes, film, and more. The Javari Valley is home to the largest concentration of uncontacted tribes in the Amazon and the world. Adjacent to the Peru-Colombia-Brazil border, the indigenous territory is larger than Austria. In 2010, Beto Marubo, of the Union of Indigenous People, reached out and asked Celine Cousteau for help. Ten years later, “Tribes on the Edge” was released as a feature-length documentary reporting about the ever-present threats to tribal lands and health crises triggered by contact with outsiders. Today, Celine and Tadzio Mac Gregor work to support Beto and his people to advance local indigenous health, culture, livelihoods, and advocacy, as well as biodiversity discovery. What does the future hold for the Javari Valley and its people? How can films, brands, and celebrities work together to defend the vulnerable?
Recorded April 26, 2021
References:
Amazon indigenous leader: Our survival is at stake. You can help.
Jacques Cousteau’s granddaughter brings her documentary to Film Fest
A Long View: A Conversation with Celine Cousteau
Tragic attack sparks concerns for the future of isolated Amazon tribes
Op Ed by Beto Marubo in the Folha de São Paulo: “Bolsonaro and the Isolated Indians”
Brazil: Judge bans missionaries from indigenous reserve over Covid-19 fears
WATCH:
Participants
- Jonah (moderator)
- Tadzio Mac Gregor
- Celine Cousteau
- Alfie
- Hope
- Fiona
- Enrique
- Unidentified participants
Transcript
Jonah:
Hello everybody. This is Jonah Whitampamper. Welcome to the 42nd call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing forest friendly economic development and the rule of law across the Amazon region of South America in partnership with local stakeholders. This week we are featuring the work of Tadzio and Celine and their efforts to advance the welfare of the Javari Valley and the uncontacted peoples of the region. This region happens to be the world’s highest con concentration of uncontacted people peoples in the Amazon and on the planet.
A very sensitive community and something that all of us are concerned about. So before we jump too much into it, I’m going to go ahead and invite the panelists to introduce themselves. Tadzio McGregor, tell us who are you? Tell us a little bit about your life before the Jav Valley came on your radar.
Tadzio Mac Gregor:
Thank you, Jonah. It’s not a very long story. I’ll try to make it a little longer. I was born and raised in Mexico, Mexico City specifically to a Mexican father and a French mother. So, I’ve spent most of my time really finding the beauties of both continents, I’d say, both Latin America and Europe. And ever since I’ve been trying to really build those bridges and work upon those bridges between those two continents. I worked I studied political science, anthropology and I later started working with different organizations in the nonprofit sector very specifically in the environmental sector in the Sierra Gorda in central Mexico which is one of the most important biosphere reserves and that is where I really learned a lot since the very beginning working with indigenous communities as well women and the empowerment the important importance of empowerment of women in those communities.
I really learned a lot as I once told you Jonah the importance of not only conserving but also restoring and regenerating. Ever since I’ve moved to different places. I’ve been working in ecosystem services. I’ve been working in projects in Venezuela. I’ve been working in projects in Sumatra. A very interesting part in Borneo as well with Birut Galikas and orangutans over there and throughout these different projects I started learning about the importance of communication and storytelling. Really understanding that there was a lack of it apart from I’m going to say the biggest corporate NOS’s I’d really like to say that the grassroot initiatives don’t have the means and sometimes don’t really know how to tell their story the best way.
So I decided to get involved a bit in that side of things as well and saying you know there’s a lot of importance in sharing these stories and the world to actually discover them and so I started writing at the time I was I was still a student with the Huffington Post. I started doing interviews with what I or the people whom I considered to be agents of change at the time. So I really went from fashion designers to Jane Good to journalists Birut Galdikas again Artis Bertron back in France and one thing led to the other.
And I’d like to say that by pure will of life I ended up living in the Netherlands in Amsterdam with Off the Fence who yesterday won the Academy Award for best documentary for my octopus teacher.
Jonah:
Yay. Yeah, that was that was really great news. So we were all very happy there. And with Off the Fence, I started working as head of partnerships for the WaterBearer Network. And then I’d say that the roots crossed with Stellen I’d say over maybe two years ago now and we’ve been we’ve been working ever since together. Yeah. Great. We’ll get into that in a second. And the WaterBear Network. Celine, who are you? Where did you come from? What have you, what mischief have you been up to before the Java before the last 10 years of the job?
Celine Cousteau:
Before the last 10 years of 10 plus years of my life. I actually so my formal background my formal education background is psychology. I worked in psychiatric hospital mostly with adolescent some adults as well. And my graduate degree is in intercultural relations. So just very much studied for the interest of understanding human beings, the human mind, how do we function, how are we different, how do we shift, why do some people feel trauma and differently than others, why do we behave differently? And then how do we work across cultures? I was really interested in this notion that I grew up in a very intercultural family, mostly between France and the US, but with a family that traveled a lot around the world and understanding that all cultures are connected.
Somehow. But a lot of people don’t have that kind of upbringing. So, I was just interested in the dynamics of cross-cultural conversations, whether it’s verbal, non-verbal, and, and all the intricacies of what that meant. I by my family name, I’m assuming most people know the family I come from. And so my upbringing was in essence a bit perhaps different than the norm in that I was always surrounded by storytelling, surrounded by a family that went on expeditions that brought back stories and for me that was normal. I didn’t I didn’t know differently.
So I just figured everybody right has access to at least some part of the storytelling component. It wasn’t until 2006 that I started working on documentary films. My father was doing a series for PBS called Ocean Adventures and I had a bit of time on my hands. So I offered my assistance in doing field production and logistics to help his expedition work. At the time I was finishing my master’s degree. I was also a biking and hiking guide. I had worked with an artist for a while, worked in psychiatric hospitals, and I was like, “Okay, let’s let’s do this.” So, I ended up on an expedition.
We were filming the blue sorry, the grey whale migration from Baja California up to Barrow, Alaska, and I was out there on the tundra with the Arctic Sea on one side and just, you know, blistering cold on the other. And I had, this was one of a series of moments where all the pieces of the puzzle started coming together, you know, where you sort of have all these moments in your life and then the picture starts coming into focus. I loved being out in nature. I loved being out in the elements, but it really only mattered if I could bring something back and share it with other people because the world is extraordinary and I didn’t want to keep those experiences to myself.
So I started working in the documentary films around 2006. 2007 I ended up in the in the V ja in the Brazilian Amazon on one of these expeditions called Return to the Amazon. Going back to places my grandfather had been to. I’ve been going back to the Amazon ever since. I’ve worked on a dozen documentary films for Chilean television. I’ve worked on documentary films for French television. And now what’s happened with this global pandemic is that I’m coming back around to my artistic side as well because I studied art and I’m bringing together the storytelling component with the artistic component and the new technologies in trying to reach people where they are not just sitting in front of you know PBS watching an hour and a half long documentary but are they watching or participating in VR and AR are they wanting more immersive experiences and I know we’re going to talk about Tribes on the Edge, so I’m leaving that part out.
Jonah:
What, tell me about your trip to the Amazon briefly, when you were nine.
Celine Cousteau:
So, I traveled down with my grandfather. He was, his crew was on a more than 18month expedition at the time. They were navigating from the mouth of the Amazon up river. Early 1980s. I spent about two weeks aboard Calypso with my grandparents. My mom was off on some land team. She was an expedition photographer. My father and brother were on a raft somewhere. And that was my first contact with the Amazon. It was the first time that I had experiences that obviously would influence me for the rest of my life.
And I didn’t know it at the time what that meant.
Jonah:
Nice. Part of our agency as an organization is to mobilize resources and investors around activities in the Amazon that advance force familyfriendly economic development and mobilize greater solidarity and support for the region and film unlike any other medium has an extraordinary power to do that. Let’s jump into that for a second. Tadzio, tell give us just a couple just a few sentences about the Water Bear Network.
Tadzio Mac Gregor:
Sure. WaterBear is a platform that started with the aim to some sort of imitate Netflix but really dedicated to a very specific niche which was environmental and conservation and anything aligned along the SGS specific to sustainability and today the it’s a streaming platform that is available in order to provide a service, a platform really for filmmakers and storytellers who really want to share those stories as I was saying at the very beginning. Today that allows us as well within that connection with water bear to also tell those stories and share those stories of what is happening in the Javari and maybe also the surroundings.
I’d like to think of that as a as a possible partnership, an alliance that will be useful for today. Yeah.
Jonah:
Celine, give us a sentence. It’s about cause centric.
Celine Cousteau:
Centric productions was the production entity that I created to really answer a call for support in telling stories. A lot of grassroots organizations and individuals on the ground don’t have the financial support or the means to create their own stories. Which is a marketing tool. It’s a fundraising tool as well. And I wanted to be able to offer that as my support. So it started out being the intention was to create three to five minute films for nonprofits and small grassroots organizations to tell their stories.
Jonah:
Nice. Okay, let’s hop into the main the main subject here. Tribes on the Edge. Comes out in 2019. What is the story that you guys feature?
Celine Cousteau:
Well, Tribes on the Edge is my first feature documentary film and it was started at the request of the indigenous people for me to tell their story to the world. I was there in 2007, as I mentioned earlier, on a film called Return to the Amazon. And that’s when I learned about the really high rates of hepatitis. They have a 50 to 80% rate of hepatitis ABC and delta. And we were filming a conference of the then contacted tribes and we’re having this conversation and filming and the government healthc care officials that were there were at the same time delivering the news that funding was getting cut and they weren’t going to be able to help more.
They were actually going to pull funding. So here are people who are basically saying we’re dying. Help us because this is a disease that came in from outsiders. And the healthcare workers were powerless. They left in the middle of the night to go to another conference. Mind you, it’s two days by boat. And here we were left this you know international production team and we couldn’t we couldn’t bring more help at the time and I left really devastated. I you know, you see the news and you know what’s going on in the world, but when you’re in the midst of people telling you they’re afraid of dying and they don’t want to go extinct, it’s a it’s a whole other level of humanity.
I had wanted to bring medical support at the time and realized that I didn’t have the facility to do that. In 2010, so three years later, Betto from the Marubo tribe, who I had originally met to bring the team in, reached out to me with a very simple oneline email. He says, “We want you to tell the world our story. We want them to know we exist and we don’t want to disappear.” And I said, “Yes.” I didn’t know what I was getting into. It took me three years to film Tribes on the Edge, 2013, 144, 15.
Just as many in post-production, just as many in outreach film festivals, finding distribution, creating an education campaign. And I felt that this film I had to merit being asked for help. I had to be worthy of being asked for help. And that meant standing back up every time I stumbled. And it this project tested my conviction in my ability to do what I was doing. So that’s how Tribes on the Edge came about. Yeah.
Jonah:
Amazing. Tell us about the Javari Valley. How large is this place and where is it?
Unidentified presenter:
So the Vale do Javari is 85,000 square kilometers. It’s about the size of Portugal, Austria or in the United States the state of Maine. It’s at the triber area of Colombia, Peru and Brazil. So it’s really, remote as far as access is concerned. We also have crossber considerations of with all the complications that are there. There’s about 7,000 indigenous people 5,000 of which are contacted in six different ethnicities. There’s more than I think 15 villages at this point. It’s constantly shifting so I don’t have the latest number. And there’s also, as you mentioned earlier, Jonah, there’s the largest number of uncontacted people in the entire Amazon living in this area.
It’s affected by a lot of illegal activities. So there’s illegal gold mining, deforestation because of cattle ranching and agricultural production. There’s also a big narot trafficking route that goes around it, although it’s not directly impacting inside at the moment. And there is illegal hunting and fishing. So it’s a really complex area that most NOS’s don’t know about, most Brazilians don’t know exist, and not a lot of people work in.
Jonah:
Wow. This is a question for either of you. Why is it so dangerous for uncontacted people to make contact?
Celine Cousteau:
I’ll jump in, but Tadzio feel free as well.
Tadzio Mac Gregor:
Go ahead.
Celine Cousteau:
So uncontacted people haven’t had any they’re considered uncontacted when they haven’t had contact with the outside world. They may have come into conflictual contact with outsiders. They may have come into conflictual contact or friendly contact with other indigenous groups. But they have not been exposed to any of the diseases that wiped out up to 90% of certain indigenous populations in the Amazon. The common cold, the flu, malaria, well, malaria is kind of rampant now. Hepatitis, tuberculosis, COVID, all of that is foreign to their bodies. So, they’re very vulnerable in terms of their health.
I think we’re also adding to what Celine just said. We’re really talking about forced contact as well. So it’s their unwillingness to be contacted, but this is then breached by illegal mining, illegal deforestation, illegal poaching. Many of the things that we see in other parts of the Amazon, and I’m sure many of the people here know about. But we’re really talking about as you said Jonah the place where the largest amount of uncontacted peoples in the world live in you know so that risk of contact is even is even bigger.
Jonah:
The in Hollywood the power of a movie is often informed by what they call moxy it power the ability of someone’s charisma to lead to the commercial success of a film. The Amazon is in the global spotlight. The president of my country, the United States, talked about mobilizing $20 billion for the region. Making films about the Amazon seems like an extraordinary way to help with access to resources, but also the story of uncontacted people. This is an extraordinary opportunity for us as human beings to understand our own origins, but there’s so many there’s so many complexities.
Tell us a little bit about your efforts to support indigenous communities or uncontacted communities and the pitfalls that you observe.
Celine Cousteau:
Pitfalls there are quite a lot of pitfalls. I mean first of all as we I see Todd laughing you know as was explained earlier this region is very difficult of access and really complex in terms of all the illegal activities and human beings are complex. We’re all very complex and so working across different ethnicities that they themselves also have their own history together and it’s not always friendly. It’s very delicate. I you know in the film making process I don’t go in anywhere that I am not invited and we’re always you know calling well radioing ahead at the time and to come into the territory.
I’ll give one example. We had an agreement with one of the Mayoruna villages but when we arrived they met us with machetes because they were upset because another white person had upset them and therefore it was us. And so in those circumstances, you say, “Okay, that I mean there’s nothing there’s nothing worth crossing people’s home in disrespect no matter the story.” So that’s one complaint and that’s just human beings. That’s anywhere. We can all change our minds at any time, right? The other part of it is that we as a team are also putting ourselves in moments of danger.
And for those of you who want to see the film, you’ll see that there’s a very specific case where one of us fell, I guess, victim to something that indigenous people face all the time, and that’s poisonous snakes. The person is alive. Just to just to put everybody at ease here, I don’t want to put you on too much of a cliffhanger just to get you to watch the film. But these are the moments you your own life really comes into focus. And I’m and I have gratitude for that. I really have gratitude for the privilege that we have.
The other part of it in film making and I think Tadzio can speak more to this is that it’s a very crowded theater. There is a lot of media content and people will perhaps choose to watch the threeinut piece as opposed to an hour and a half documentary or they’ll choose to watch something entertaining as opposed to something that’s really hard-hitting and difficult. I have a hard time finding the balance between entertainment and education. And with this film, I wanted to honor the way the indigenous people chose to speak. I also was mentored into putting myself on camera, although that’s not what I wanted, because I could act as a guide for the audience to follow me into the Amazon as somebody that they might identify with or trust.
And that comes with its own challenges for myself as well as for perhaps criticism of the way the story was told. But I’ll just say one last thing and then I would love Tadzio to chime in is that my audience, my boss, the people I did this for and who I work for are the indigenous people. At the end of the day, no matter the awards, the laurels, the praise or the criticism, if they if they give me their stamp of approval of how the story was told, then I have done what I set out to do.
And I was able to do that with all the fear in my heart. I was able to do that in November 2019 is to bring them back the film and have them be witness to how we told their story. And know that at that point I had accomplished what I set out to do and there’s always more. There’s always more.
Tadzio Mac Gregor:
You it’s hard for me to add much more to what Justelene just said. I think everything she just said resonates with how I think and I’d like to think that’s also why we’re working together. One very important thing she said and I’d like to reemphasize it is trust. I think filmmakers need to feel they’re trusted by the person they actually filming and who they’re working for or with. And that is something basic in this project and tribes on the edge since the very beginning. I think Celine has that trust. She has gained that trust from the indigenous peoples of the Javari and that trust comes with responsibility as many of us know.
And that responsibility is do we want to film this for entertainment. Do we want to this to make this appealing to just the people who are here or do we also want to just actually tell the story that they want to tell and there is a very thin line between those two worlds. And that is something that I’ve also seen personally and maybe this is something I didn’t speak too much in my introduction, but I started working in entertainment and with production companies with France television and with Off the Fence in Amsterdam with Mexican production companies here as well and that line is really very thin and I think that needs to be respected and you have to gain above all the trust of the people you’re going especially in documentary.
Jonah:
Let’s talk about the philanthropic resources that you guys are mobilizing. I understand there are three pillars. It’s the tribes on the edge project or the Javari project. There’s biodiversity discovery, livelihoods, health. Walk us through the pillars of this advocacy. I remember.
Celine Cousteau:
Yeah. So knowing that a film can be a catalyst and that’s what this film really has been. It’s about creating an impact campaign that can leverage the film to gain attention towards the action initiatives. So Tribes on the Edge has become the Jaari project and its nonprofit and we’re we’ve founded the organization in the Netherlands. We are working and have started the biodiversity analysis because for several reasons. One being the IUCN had declared the Javari territory irreplaceable in terms of biodiversity but no studies have been done in the area. We know and I think all of us here know that indigenous people are the best guardians of that biodiversity and yet their human and land rights are being violated through illegal activities and an everchanging government or policy towards indigenous people.
And so what we are endeavoring to do is a research and journalistic approach to understanding the biodiversity of the region and its threats so that we can have the data to understand what is happening where. We’re using all technology at hand. I think technology and innovation can be an amazing tool at the service of nature. So we’re working with several partners on that who are experts in the research side of things, the scientific side, the AI for the analysis and the information. The alternative livelihoods project. We’re also working with a couple of NGO partners forest trends and cultural sanctuaries being a few of them looking at cultural and language preservation as well as creating a life plan for economic self-determination and land governance so that they have options because of course like anywhere the youth are leaving their homes.
They’re wanting to either find another way of life or they’re wanting to find a continued education. But what they are coming across in the border towns is unfortunately what we find in a lot of places which is alcoholism, drug prostitution and falling into the economic system of the illegal activities and the dependency on government. So that’s just a that’s like the very brief of those two sides of things. Tadzio, do you want to come in with some of the other information?
Tadzio Mac Gregor:
I think also to very important to mention is at the very core of the Javari project, which is a continuation to tribes on the edge, we decided to create some sort of a untraditional foundation in the sense of bringing a coalition of different partners, many of whom Celine just mentioned. We aim to bring these partners as some sort of this project being theirs as well. And of course working with these indigenous communities means we have to be very close to their opinion and at all times consulting everything with them. So we don’t move if they don’t agree.
We offer what they are in a way demanding as well. They are asking help for. So that is really at the core of the Javari project since the very beginning and yeah I was going to say something else and I totally forgot but I’ll go back to that afterwards.
Jonah:
Okay, great. Just a couple more real quick questions and then we’re going to open it up. The this is a really popular call. I can tell a lot of people want to speak with you guys, so I’ll keep I’ll keep it real brief. The next question I have is really angled from the investor perspective. So I did some research in preparation for this call about a recent survey of filmmakers revealed that 22% of recent documentary filmmakers were able to break even or have a return on investment or have a profit from the production of their film.
By comparison, startups, only 10% of startups succeed and only 25% of venture-backed startups succeed. So having a profitable film, you know, compares, if you will, to the startup scene, and some films really make it maybe not, you know, to the 100 times on investment sort of ways that some venture capitalists want, but there is a valid investment thesis here. I would love some feedback from you guys on how investors who are focused on the film can consider documentary or feature type vehicles or media properties with respect to the Amazon. How viable is it?
What do you need to have in place in order to make it profitably profitable? Either of you. I’ll.
Celine Cousteau:
Jump in and then I Tadzio has a more diverse expertise than I do on that question. Tribes on the Edge was set out as a nonprofit project. And so we had a fiscal sponsor and all of the all of the donations were tax-deductible donations towards the project. Anything that is that we might make from any distribution will go back into the nonprofit impact campaign. So, right now we’re working with a university in the United States to do an education program. So, that would be one of the first places that it would go back into.
I’d like to use and I always think of nonprofit as a it’s the wrong way to describe something. It’s for impact. It’s a for impact project. And the investment is in our in our future and our well-being. I think everybody here probably agrees that they like to breathe and you know, a fifth of our breath comes from the Amazon region and indigenous people are the natural guardians of that territory. So, investment in a film is one investment in them because that’s what they asked for. But as far as the forprofit side of the film industry, I think I’m just going to I’m going to stick to the way I do things, even if it’s quite it’s quite tough, but it’s really well worth it when you’re trying to save human lives.
T, if you have a.
Tadzio Mac Gregor:
Yeah, it’s a it’s a tricky question, Jonah, because I think a film depends of so many different parties. It depends as you know of distributors, producers, broadcasters and today that model stays still quite traditional. So we still depend and I’m sure many of you here as well know that we still depend of the big broadcasters such as National Geographic and the BBC and France television and so on and they are the ones who get that final call. If we go if we talk about the traditional route of films and documentaries now I think and I’ll be very brief.
I think that is why water bear was set up that is why projects like tribes on the edge work today because I think they are connected to the human essence which is emotion. Why do startups compared to films have a bigger success? Because films convey us of many other things in a much easier way. They’re less academic. They’re less if you look at my octopus teacher today, well my octopus teacher is actually a project. It’s a project called the sea change project. And it wasn’t known. It wasn’t known until my octopus teacher was turned into a movie into storytelling adventure.
And that is how it got the investment. That is how it got eventually a profit. And that is what happens with today the movies. I think there is a change in the industry more tended towards nonprofit films which tell stories that need to be told. There is a shift towards films that actually portray much more the emotions and not just what is happening. I think you can see that with the BBC, you can see that with the David Atenboroough that at least I grew up with and I’m sure many of you as well.
Which used to tell us tell us, you know, show us the beautiful gorillas and show us the giraffes, but don’t tell me what is happening to them. And that is changing today. We need to talk about what is happening. We need to talk about all these problems. And that is why I think the industry is shifting towards that and therefore the investments has been much more open to these kind of films recently.
Jonah:
Great. Thank you. Questions? It’s your turn team. Go for it Alfie.
Alfie:
Unmute myself. Yeah. I’m curious about the actual campaign to activate the audiences around the content. I’m doing a whole superhero franchise very much like a Marvel thing but around climate themes, indigenous rights, rights of nature and all that fun stuff that I know we’re all passionate about. But I’m curious about how you’re actuate actually activating the audience around the around the content if there’s a specific strategy there.
Celine Cousteau:
We did a couple of outreach campaigns where we were speaking directly to audiences. I mean, I did a West Coast film tour in the back of a van with the film, like real grassroots. And we had different partners. We went to Salesforce on in San Francisco. We went to Yuseite National Park at the theater there. Just different community centers, different theaters, different groups, and we just reached out to our entire network and then we had conversations with people. So, that’s very time consuming. But I think that’s where real change happens is because you just have to have the right person in the audience or the right 10 people,.
Alfie:
Right? I mean, just a quick follow on from that. How do you measure the impact from the content? Is there.
Celine Cousteau:
That’s something and I will full transparency admit that I’m not very good at that part. I’m good at the communications and the front end or the front end of the house. We do have donations coming in from those kinds of events and that’s one measure. I don’t think donations is the only measure however because really what a lot of this work is about and anybody that is in the cause focused film making world whether they understand it or not because I had a mentor tell me this we’re shifting consciousness.
Unidentified participant:
Yes.
Alfie:
And that’s hard to measure because somebody who watches a film may walk away being inspired and go you know what I don’t want to do this anymore or I don’t want to eat this anymore. I don’t want to behave like this anymore.
Celine Cousteau:
That measurement is impossible unless somebody calls you and lets you know.
Unidentified participant:
Yeah.
Celine Cousteau:
I’ll go back and a few other ways. Sorry. A few other ways that we have done it is reached out to schools using Skype in the classroom when it existed before we were all on lockdown in front of our computers. I spent three years reaching out to students around the world, on web platforms and would talk from kindergarten kids all the way up to university kids, 30 minutes at a time, talking about different subjects around Tribes on the Edge, pending the age group. And you can see it. You can see the shift and the understanding.
They’re like, “What? There’s palm oil in my Nutella and it cuts down trees and people are d Yes. And that’s it. Light bulb on and let them like go out and rule the world.” I think a lot of it too for me and I and I hate to no I don’t I love beating the same drum over and over again. I go back to the indigenous people and I tell them what’s been done and Betto Marubo and I he just left me a message on WhatsApp. Beetto is the catalyst to me doing this film and I say I don’t know if my film is making a difference in your world.
His brother Elsio is now a lawyer. They both left the indigenous territory ordered by their by their father, the chief of the village to go study the white world. Elsio has become a lawyer and he sat me down the last day Todd and I were together in November 2019 and showed them the film and I said, “Eliesio, I’m not sure if this is the way.” I said, “Yeah, you know, how do I know I’m making a difference in your lives? Like, it’s great. We’re educating people, but are you surviving anymore?” And he stopped me and he said, Celine, he goes, “Your film has saved lives.” He’s like, “You’re just going to have to trust that even if you never see it.” And I just had a moment of hum just being humble for a moment and thinking, “Oh, we love to measure things in numbers or in likes or in returns or an amount of donations or just fill in the blank.” And here is the very essence of why this project started because people are going extinct.
And he’s reassuring me that my film is making a difference. And I’m just going to go I’m just have to trust it because he knows it. That’s how I measured this and I don’t have the answer maybe everybody wants but that’s the one I’ve got.
Alfie:
Hey I mean I have the same conversations and I think it’s the same thing. It’s the shifting consciousness which changes behaviors but it’s very difficult to do that. So thank you.
Tadzio Mac Gregor:
Alfie. If I if I may just add to that I think a great way to do it. I think measuring impact has been something that a lot of people have been trying to do for a long time. One of the first companies to do that was participant media back then and they failed because they wanted to measure the shifting of consciences and a way I’m not saying this is the way to measure impact but a much easier way to see tangible impact is by partnerships. So you create partnerships with the grassroot initiatives on the subject you’re working with and you see if that audience finds a way to get involved with those people on the ground.
I think that is a great way of actually connecting. So you become a connector know your storytelling becomes a connector for the people on the ground who didn’t have a connection before to that audience and creating those multiple partnerships goes from going to NOS’s grassroots but also try to go away from the niche no try and get those people who don’t care about the environment try to tell them about that story try to go to try to go to the people who will all eat red meat and I’m not going against the people who eat red meat in here.
But they go every single day and eat red meat and say, “I don’t care about the environment.” So, try to talk to them as well and try to tell them about your story and let’s try and see if there’s a shift of consciousness but also an impact in the dayto-day. No,.
Alfie:
Beautiful. Yeah. And sign me up. Thank you. Yeah.
Jonah:
Let’s go ahead and move to the next question. Hope.
Hope:
Hey Jonah, thank you. And Celine, thank you very much for your discussion. I’m curious if you talk a little bit about your personal journeys through developing what I would call your own ideology about how to best support these tribes. And I know as you spend more time with them, you that probably progresses as you learn more and more. And I think educating others is great, but I’m curious how you think about it. You know, these gaps in cultural distance between the tribe and the rest of the world is so enormous.
And I’ve gotten I don’t know maybe cynical in the ability to actually support him in ways. So I’m curious where you are in your journey on that.
Celine Cousteau:
Thanks Holt that’s actually a really good question and the journey constantly evolves. It is really complex to your point and I understand the part about becoming cynical towards it. I’ll go back to when I was negotiating to bring my father’s team in 2007 and I sat down with Betto who at the time was working for Funai. He was working for the government organization for indigenous people and we were just going to go in to see the Matis because that’s who my grandfather saw in the early 80s. We radioed in and you know back and forth over the course of an hour of radio into the jungle and then back out and then we wait and then they radio back.
They sent a list of demands to allow us to come into their village. And that list of demands started with a satellite dish, a 10-in television, three barrels of fuel, couple shotguns, an outboard motor or two. I’ll spare you the details of the rest of the list. And I looked at it and I didn’t say you can’t have this. I didn’t say you no way, stay in the jungle, don’t have these commodities. I just said I actually can’t facilitate this. One on a practical level we didn’t have the means to do it because we were a small nonprofit project.
This was again back in 2007. The second part of it is that I didn’t know that morally I felt right buying my way into one indigenous village to help tell their story. And at the same time there is a question of reciprocity. They’re giving me stories. What am I giving back? And this is sorry, I’m a storyteller. I’m just going to go back to another story. I was in the Peruvian Amazon again, negotiating to bring my father’s team in to the Ashawar community this time. And the man says to me, we were we were not in the in the village.
We were in a city. He says, “Well, if I let you come in to film my people, what are you doing for me?” And at the time, 2006 now, at the time I said, ‘Well, the world is going to see your story and they’re going to see what’s happening to your land with the oil spills and they’re going to understand. And he kind of verbally patted me on the back and said, “That’s nice.” He says, “You know, you’re and by the way, all outsiders are white, so pardon me for the color of the skin.” He goes, “You’re white people.
You’re white doctors. They want to come and study our medicinal plants and we let them in our village and our shamans take them into the forest and we teach them and we show them. And then they say, “Well, we’re going to come back and help you.” But then they go back to your world and they make your little white pills and we see nothing. He goes, “You’re anthropologists. They come into our land and they want to know our myths, our legends, and our history. And so we sit with them and we tell them and we teach them and they say they’re going to help us and they go back to your countries and they publish your white papers and we see nothing.” thing.
He goes, “You are no different. You come here and take our stories and think that our world will change, you are wrong.” And I have to say that as hard as it is to be in that position, I welcome the moment when you just get hit across the face with something you never expected. Because in all honesty, I walked in thinking I was doing something good for them, but I never asked them what they needed. And that moment shifted everything for me in a being a storyteller is I said, “Okay, what do you need?” And he said, “We need camcorders because we’re recording the oil spills.
We’re being trained to record the oil spills to tell our own stories.” I said, “This I can do.” So, I think part of it is you have to one, you have to have close contact and this is the trust that I have since 2007 created with the indigenous people in the Javari. And you have to constantly ask and you’re going to run into conflict. You’re going to run into doubt disagreement. There were things that I’ve been asked for I completely disagree with in terms of understanding that it won’t shift their lives.
It’ll just enhance a few people’s. So there are choices to make and they’re not easy. We are on the ground. We are a small organization working directly with the indigenous people and my mother has always called me stubborn. I think I’m tenacious and I will not let go because I made a promise. And so this much I can say is that what I say I’m going to do may evolve but I will follow through.
Jonah:
Thank you. Fiona, you’re up. You’re also on mute.
Fiona:
Great. It’s Fiona. I’m on the Suelatuth sacred land here in Vancouver, Canada. It’s nice to see you, Celine. It’s been a long time. So coming through under what we’re you know under decarbonized we’ve been working with Jonah and with so many different indigenous communities with FA Amazon with the team from Gaia Amazoness with many of our mutual friends. There we go Celine. And the question I pose is really also with yourself. Sorry my background is also I used to work for French TV so I knew Selen’s father quite well and I actually was working with him into some of the work he’s done around the world and so as we go forwards between media to money to infrastructure and micro finance you know that’s what came to me from media to micro finance how can we catalyze and collaborate to actually build the infrastructures that they need not what we think they need and then again following those ethics and it’s similar you know sitting in the village in Africa after four years of negotiating for the Namibia tribal bushman group the chief said on his land with his stick on the ground he wrote to me that’s fine you’ve come in you’ve taken me to the United Nations the same as Celine’s story but what are you doing for my people my people are dying I need more wives so that was the next day we left on trucks and we went and visited one, two, three, five months.
The film didn’t matter. It was following what my relationship to him like Celines is to these people was that I had promised him that he could s have his own choices. So I place that on the question on micro finance and financing impact and then you know Amazon investors group and the X-priseze you know this is a big quest for the X-P prize to work on the rainforest. So I’m still trying to collaborate with others on the research there. So please share insights where you think we could all evolve and impact their lives.
Thank you. T do you want to jump in because I’ve been talking a lot.
Tadzio Mac Gregor:
I think right now with the project that with the pillar that Celine mentioned is really the alternative livelihoods and that is where as I as I heard from a colleague of mine not too long ago, it’s very easy to start these projects. It’s not easy to continue them. So being aware of that I think we are proceeding with extreme caution towards understanding really what they want. No again Fiona as you said not what we think is better for them. I think this is something I’ve always very personally as well came across by growing in Mexico.
Which is very similar to all of Latin America a continent with extreme inealities. No a historical problem and the indigenous are at the bottom of that I’d like to say at the at the very bottom of that pyramid and that is why for me this is also a very important story because it doesn’t matter if it’s in the Amazon or if it’s in Mexico it’s very similar I think we have the crossroads here of a place that has undeniable importance for biodiversity but an undeniable able importance for cultural diversity as well.
And therefore working with those alter alternative livelihoods is vital. We can’t move ahead without that. We are in the process of understanding where we’re going to be situating that project very specifically. So I’d like to say we’re open to exploring new possibilities of saying okay how are we going to work with them? How are we going to proceed? When are we going to do this? Of course, as you all know, the pandemic has slowed down things and understandings in many ways, but it hasn’t stopped us. It hasn’t stopped us at all.
So I’d like to discuss that with you, Fiona, if that works for you afterwards.
Jonah:
Great. I encourage you guys to share your email addresses. Next question. Enrique.
Enrique:
Thank you, Jonah. It’s a question for Celine. I’ve been in the area with mythical Sydney Poso and you know very well Sydney you as a person that you can never forget. And then when I met you and then the years passed and there is Bonaro you know so the priorities have shifted very much during the last several years. So here is a question you know when you decide to make this film I guess you are asking yourself who is your audience and if you want to save lives that’s a critical question because it is quite different to hit funai to hit bonaro or to hit the international media but what happens on the ground is a different story what are your thoughts about that of when selecting your audience to make the greatest impact.
Celine Cousteau:
Thank you for that, Enrique. First of all, I certainly feel like you have so much experience to share in the region and I remember our conversations from a long time ago and the audience that I that I chose was a general potentially somewhat educated audience but not necessarily about this territory. The age group, I mean, my son is 9 years old and he’s seen the film. I would say that’s probably the beginning age group, but it can go all the way it can go all the way up. It wasn’t meant to move government.
It wasn’t meant to influence government. I don’t think that this story or this film could change the way the government behaves because reasoning doesn’t and the heart doesn’t seem to be there. So, I’m unsure that any beautiful story would ever be able to create the change we would want to see on that level. I do feel like we have an opportunity now in the next year to influence voters to think more clearly about our common future. I think we’ve done that in other countries most recently and we’ve seen that there can be success that way.
I’m trying to be very apolitical. Can you guys see? I’d like to be able to continue to travel to the region, which is why I’m trading very lightly. And that’s the other thing is that it didn’t it wasn’t an issue for me to go to Brazil until 2019. It was the first time that government officials were calling and asking why I was there. So, you know very well and I think everybody on this call probably knows that environmental and humanitarian activists are targets and we need to be careful in what our goals are, what we’re trying to impact and do.
And I need to continue to remember that I am at the service of the indigenous people I work for and if I am no longer allowed in the country or I am taken off the planet, I won’t be able to do that. And so I’ I’ve chosen to not fly under the radar because I’m here speaking publicly. But I’m treading lightly to be able to continue the work I do for them. It’s a hard one, Enrique. It’s a It’s a really tough one because anybody who knows me knows that I probably would like to speak and scream a lot louder than I do.
Jonah:
Enrique, would you like to answer your own question?
Enrique:
Yes, please. Wow. Well, you know, certainly, you know, things have changed so much. I mean, you see what is happening today and Funai, which is, you know, the imperfect agency for indigenous affairs, has a budget that is less than half it used to be three years ago. I don’t know. I mean I am Brazilians are very proud of the Amazon and their indigenous heritage and sometimes I think that the audience could well be the Brazilians themselves but again it’s a it’s a hard one. I mean there is no there is no simple solution.
So I really don’t don’t know what’s the answer for that.
Unidentified presenter:
We have just if I can just jump in we’ve actually just heard from our international distributor that there is interest for Brazilian distribution. And we had been talking to, and this is a good reminder, we’d been talking to a Brazilian production company that does distribution of educational material for kids in Brazil. So, the hope is that once we have created the educational curriculum that we are currently doing with the Institute for Integrative Convers conservation at the College of William and Mary that we’ll be able to distribute that in Brazil. And to quickly just add to that to what I was telling Alfie before, I think the essence is the collaboration and the partnerships and those partnerships do not only mean internationally.
No, I think those partnerships have to be placed in the place we work in. Today we work in Brazil, yes, but that border is some sort of an invisible border. So we’re we also have to work with Colombia. We also have to work with Peru, you know, and those partnerships have to be made.
Jonah:
Yeah. Go for it, Enrique.
Enrique:
Yeah. No, I just wanted to add one thing that Bonaro and the Korean government in Brazil have a special place for the French like and the history in the last two years has been pretty bad. So, you got to be careful with that, Celine. And as a proof of how difficult to trust or reach Bosono is that you know last Thursday you know he said that he was going to double the budget for environmental issues and next day he actually cut it in half you know so that’s the word of a guy that doesn’t understand don’t worry Enrique Celine will fly me in with my Mexican passport flying.
Unidentified presenter:
We have our secret passageways in you No, I just I want to I just want to say one thing and I think that you know people who are working on the ground know this is that the Funay and SAI workers who are on the ground are doing everything they can to do their jobs. They’re just not being given the support to do so and they’re actually being put in the line of fire. Since the beginning of the pandemic, there have been increased illegal activities in the Javari territory in part because there’s a lot less support at the borders.
And so with Bolsinaro’s arrival, those conducting these activities are feeling emboldened that the president doesn’t support the protection of indigenous land. And so why would they respect those who are at the borders? They’ve the funai workers get shot at by people who are coming onto indigenous land. And so you know everyone that we have met in the field and that I’ve met every time I go there is doing the best they can. They just have very little.
Jonah:
We have reached the top of the hour. This is what I like to call water cooler time. We move into unstructured conversation. The chat room stays open. The rest of the room stays open. And if you if you guys, you know, still have an opportunity to stick around, you’re welcome to do so. Thank you everybody for joining us. What an amazing conversation.
Unidentified presenter:
Thank you, Jonah.
Unidentified presenter:
Thank you, Jonah. Thanks a lot.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you. You.
Jonah:
Anyone who wants to encourage you to leave your email addresses or other contact information in the chat. It’s so good to see so many familiar faces. It feels like, you know, a reunion of essence. Excellent.
Unidentified participant:
Oh, I know the all Oh, there’s Nant as well. All of the hard work. Now, where do we get to just leave these baskets of all our knowledge and share it with the next generations because we have been so honored to learn from the elders and the youngers and the forests and the plants. So, it’s really, you know, it’s wonderful. I want to just take a moment to thank Jonah and his team and the incredible, you know, love he has for the planet because and the people and his purpose and I am really honored to be able to support the Amazon Investor Coalition and anything that’s needed.
So, thank you Jonah.
Jonah:
My pleasure.
Unidentified participant:
Celine, I just wanted to come and say hello.
Unidentified participant:
Hi again. I tried to stay behind because I was going to eat lunch, but my lunch an hour later is still sitting next to me. And that’s I think breakfast, too. I can’t even remember. How are you? He did so.