The Future of Amazon Ecotourism
Today we learn about the role of ecotourism in Amazon conservation from governments, operators, NGOs, and indigenous communities. Ecotourism is expected to be a $333.8B market by 2027, growing faster than the regular tourism industry before the pandemic. Tourism to protected areas also has the potential to channel 60x more income to these areas than conservation funding; Costa Rica is a prime example of the potential of this industry to transform economic development in the Amazon. However, the Amazon ecotourism industry is fragmented, lacking infrastructure that could connect the region and empower growth, and has proven to be vulnerable to shocks like the current pandemic. What investments, tools, and programs are needed to scale this industry nationally and across the region? How can governments, investors, and businesses capitalize on the potential of this market to fund the conservation of protected areas and indigenous territories? Join the discussion with Thiago Beraldo, Richard Bodmer, Jon Bruno, Carla James, Gabriel Minas Amaya, and Sophia Wood.
Recorded March 29, 2021
References:
The International Ecotourism Society
IDB 2000 Strategy on Ecotourism in the Amazon – Proecotur
WATCH:
Participants
- Jonah (moderator)
- Sophia Wood (host)
- Thiago Beraldo
- Jon Bruno
- Gabriel Minas Amaya
- Representative — Guyana Tourism Authority (name unclear)
- Art
- Richard Bodmer
- Jim
- Unidentified participants
Transcript
Unidentified participant:
But he did confirm that he was coming. So hopefully he’ll pop in.
Unidentified participant:
No worries.
Jonah:
Okay, great. We’re almost five minutes past the hour, so I’m going to go ahead and start. I’ve just started the recording. Here we go. One more attendee coming. Hello everybody. My name is Jonah Whitampamper. This is the weekly call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a podcast and call series dedicated to advancing force friendly economic development across the Amazon region. We started last year in mid 2020 about I think this is our 38th call. And this week we are going to look at ecotourism and the perspective of ecotourism to help advance sustainable development across the Amazon region.
And our host this week is Sophia Wood. Sophia, please reintroduce yourself and take it away.
Sophia Wood:
Wonderful. Well, thank you so much for the intro, Jonah. I’m very excited for this conversation and we’ll have a slightly bigger panel than usual I guess on the call. As I mentioned before, for anyone who’s joined since, I am Sophia Wood. I’m leading the ecotourism strategy for the Amazon Investor Coalition alongside my full-time job running a regenerative tour operation called Friends of [organization name unclear] alongside sister organization Operation [organization name unclear] which is a UK biodiversity research organization. So today the conversation is going to be about using ecotourism as a tool to conserve large areas of the Amazon and provide financial support for people who protect these areas especially but not limited to indigenous communities.
And before we got started I wanted to quickly u define the term ecotourism because I think it’s a term that’s become quite controversial over the past decade. What started as a movement to view and protect nature using income from tourism has often been used instead for greenwashing less than ecological or socially beneficial operations. So for the sake of our conversation today, I wanted to start with a definition to clarify what we’re talking about. So ecotourism as defined by the international ecotourism society is responsible travel to natural areas that conserves the environment, sustains the well-being of the local people and involves interpretation and education for locals and foreigners alike.
So the idea is to provide direct financial benefits for conservation, recognize the rights and beliefs of indigenous people and generate financial benefits for local people. This model has been lauded in Costa Rica and has proven successful in many other important conservation areas such as the African Savannah, the US National Park System, and many others on a smaller scale. Our panel today will seek to provide a temperature check on the possibility of developing large-scale coordinated ecotourism across all Amazon countries with the idea of promoting cross-border relations, funding protected areas in indigenous territories, and increasing awareness and interest in preserving the beauty of the Amazon.
So, I wanted to quickly give a minute to introduce our speakers and then jump straight into the meat of the conversation. So Thiago, would you mind introducing yourself?
Thiago Beraldo:
No. Hi Sophia. Hi Jonah. Hi everyone. Okay. So I’m Thiago. I’m from Brazil. I’ve been working for the federal government with protected areas management and specifically with ecotourism in protected areas for 18 years now. And we’ve been working a lot with increasing the numbers of visitors in the areas. At the same time, we protect the areas and promote conservation and help the sustainable development of the communities that exist in the Amazon. We have indigenous communities but in the protected areas also we have local communities that we they are not indigenous but they are traditional they have been there for very long time rubber tappers fishermen so we consider those also important communities for us at this moment I’m working to UNDP in a project in Africa Cabo Verde, but I’m still like helping in the Amazon every time I have the opportunity.
Sophia Wood:
Thanks, Thiago. So, we’ll move forward to John Bruno. If you could briefly introduce yourself and then we’ll we’ll jump into the conversation once everyone’s had a chance.
Jon Bruno:
Delighted to hello everyone. As Chava said, it’s an honor to talk to you today. I am the executive director of the International Ecoourism Society. We may remember us from 30 seconds ago when Sophia used our definition which I think is I can fairly say is the most widely used definition of ecotourism. A lot of articles that you’ll read will start off with the international ecotourism society defines ecotourism as our definition is used by the UN and lots of others major organizations around the globe. So we’re a membership organization. We focus on professionals but we also have students and representatives of every part of the tourism economy from government officials to journalists professors academics, consultants every part of the industry.
So we’re our focus is growing international ecotourism but we since ecotourism is a very local thing we are lucky to have a wide international network of experts that can operate in specific areas and have expertise with communities in specific countries and in specific regions.
Sophia Wood:
Thanks John. Gabrielle, would you mind introducing yourself quickly?
Gabriel Minas Amaya:
Of course. Thank you very much Sophia for the invitation and thank you very much for allowing me to share a little bit about the deep commitment the community does in the Amazon rain forest. I actually work for this community the marketing area and developing business for them. So I’m very excited to let you know a little bit more about what they do and what they have been leading in the rainforest.
Sophia Wood:
Thank you. And Camroll, I know you quickly introduced yourself before, but would you mind reintroducing yourself for those who didn’t hear?
Representative — Guyana Tourism Authority:
Sure. Well, thanks Sophie Sophia. Again my name is Camel Bash and I’m the deputy director here at the Guyana Tourism Authority which is the tourist board for the destination and I’m I’ve been heavily involved in destination development, product development executing train and capacity buildings not only for indigenous communities but for the industry as a whole and also been leading on destination marketing activities as well. Thank you.
Sophia Wood:
Thank you. I don’t know. Is Richard Bodmer on the call? I don’t think so. I’m wondering if his I think his internet is solar panel based, so it usually depends on it being a sunny day. Well, if he pops in, we’ll bring him into the call and have him introduce himself. So, we have lots to discuss today. It’s obviously a huge topic and we’ve got representation from countries all across the region. The first question I wanted to get into is just to kind of give a picture of what the major challenges and opportunities are on the ground in the Amazon.
It’s a massive region. We’re talking about as John was saying, you know, very specific localized level development of ecotourism. So we know that some of the biggest challenges facing the Amazon ecotourism markets are you know fragmentation of the market, lack of infrastructure and capacity for business growth, seasonality of tourism of being something that people are only coming for certain periods of the year as well as accessibility obviously of the Amazon rainforest being a particularly difficult place to operate the logistics of a tourism business. So in your view and based on what you’ve seen, what are the top three ways we can fix these structural issues?
And if you had a magic wand, where would you put your resources? And this is really directed towards all of you. So I don’t know if so, who wants to go first? I’m happy to go in the order that we introduced ourselves.
Thiago Beraldo:
Well, Sophia, the thing that I think is the most important to the Amazon is access. It’s very expensive to visit the Amazon even for example for Brazilians, people who live in big cities. So, improve accessibility in this broad sense for me will be the most important key factor to improve tourism in the Amazon.
Sophia Wood:
Thank you. Any further thoughts, John?
Jon Bruno:
Sure. The to build on what Thiago said, I you know access it can go under the realm of infrastructure. So and I want to emphasize again that you know of the whether you call it eight or nine countries that are that are touching the Amazon region each one of them has different specific issues. A lot of the Amazon is in Brazil. And a lot of us think of you know Brazil as kind of an access point but you know Ecuador has a very strong Peru has a very strong and in Peru access is much easier for instance than in Brazil.
So you know that but there are each of those areas has specific challenges to infrastructure. So I would say that the that the major problem is first of all realizing that ecotourism has to grow organically and it has to grow with the impimeter of the community and it has to grow with the voice of the community and this is a very widely spread voice. So it’s difficult to say there’s one answer to the Amazon. But if there if we can take that up one level and say there is an answer, it’s that we need more data.
We need more information. We need more dialogue with these communities in order to be effective in assisting them because the desire is there for sure, you know, among these communities. A lot of them are thinking about it, but they have different things that are stopping them from taking those steps.
Sophia Wood:
That’s an interesting point you brought up, John, just because I know you’ve worked with ties, creating networks across countries of ecotourism, knowing that each individual business on its own might not have the power to actually bring people in, but bringing them together across a larger network and under a certain umbrella can make them significantly more powerful. Now, I know a lot of the work GTA has been doing is around that chem. So maybe you could speak to creating these networks of ecotourism businesses in the Amazon and how you’ve been able to invest in creating those networks in Guyana.
Representative — Guyana Tourism Authority:
Yes, thanks Sophia. I think I mean infrastructure is definitely a big point. But to add something else to the conversation, I believe there is the need for the need to achieve greater levels of alignment with the decision makers in any government. Not sure what the cases are in the other countries but here locally I think we should we should be able to seek a little bit more cognizance of the importance and the impact of tourism really on the ecosystems but not only not only from that but from a holistic standpoint you know in terms of national economy development so basically saying that we I think there is a need to have a seat at the economic head table you know and I believe that is the first step in charting the solution course because often times if it if the if ecotourism or anything in relation to the development of ecotourism I think if it’s not recognized as a pillar for the for national development then often times it will be pushed back on the back burner so one having the buy in and commitment from the highest levels of government or decision makers at the regional level is very important as one and on that note and I can speak for destination Ghana where we were able to I guess inring this in a policy it’s very important to do this to develop sort of your blueprint or your model or template that you’re working to help develop ecotourism products in within Amazon region.
Really to have your systems dialed have your processes dialed to know exactly what you want to do because it’s very critical to demonstrate that you’re able to develop and I think that goes a far way in convincing the stakeholders that are needed to be convinced you know to I guess to further the development of this agenda. But yes, within the last few years, we’ve really taken a developmental agenda to help develop very sustainable community and non-comm community tourism enterprises in within large in and within protected areas. So it’s an area in which we want to continue development.
Guyana as you know is positioned as an ecotourism sustainable friendly destination and yeah we’re hoping to continue that good work in the years to come.
Sophia Wood:
Thank you. And I want to come back to that point about channeling government and private investment towards ecotourism and especially bringing it up with you and Thiago comeroll because you are coming from this government side of bringing the two sides together. But before we go on to that, I want to give Gabrielle a chance to answer this question about the structural issues on the ground and how to fix them since you’re really in the nitty-gritty dayto-day work right now of working from the Amazon and actually in Yasuní National Park which has been completely closed off to tourists until about three weeks ago.
Gabriel Minas Amaya:
Okay, thank you very much. So well in our case accessibility is not a big issue. Amazon rainforest is to say the most accessible one. So but I would like to go to a more say to a wider issue that I would I would say is very important in order to develop tourism on a on a correct way and that’s sharing a little bit what just John said communication is very important and that’s because indigenous communities or non-indigenous communities but living there in the in the Amazon rainforest children or generations must be contacted and consulted.
What do they want? How they want to develop that development or that the objective they have. The key success factor I would say for the Anyangu community for its touristic project has been the fact that the own community decided to develop tourism. So it was it was a question or something they wanted to develop it was something they it was the path they thought it would give answers to their objectives. So they have these assemblies these communities assemblies every now and of and well frequently and that’s the space where they take decisions and that’s the space where after some time they decided to bet for tourism and I would say that’s been the core key success factor for the community to keep working with tourism for this 20 years and with perspectives of keep doing it in the Amazon rain forest.
And even many other indigenous communities from Ecuador have come to me trying to learn about the experience. But the base of everything was the fact that the indigenous community or say community decided to do it. So communication there is very important and after that after we have the scenario where the community wants to go through planning is basic. So training is very important. Communities doesn’t know necessarily how to manage a project. So they might need training or assistance but after knowing what the community want and after the community have expressed it’s easier to help the community it’s easier to plan the project itself or to direct the efforts through marketing for example in order to give to have the tourist in order to fund the project itself and some other things but debase is having the community to express first.
Sophia Wood:
That’s a great point, Gabrielle, and I’ll give you a chance to go back to explaining how the Enyongu community really came to that decision and what has been instrumental in the achievement of creating the Napo Wildlife Center. But I want to dig a little bit deeper into the question of how governments can provide support for these communities. We’ve brought it up a couple of times now that governments might be helpful in providing funding andor training for communities that are starting to get involved in tourism. So this question goes towards Camroll and Thiago who are obviously coming from the government side of working with ecotourism and I wanted to ask you if you have any insights or best practices about what has been successful in providing funding for ecotourism development in the Amazon and in particular with indigenous communities although not exclusively.
And what can we do or what can the government do from these areas to make more projects investable especially for foreign investors that are looking to come in and make a return? Whichever one of you wants to go first.
Unidentified participant:
Yeah, Thiago, you want to go first?
Unidentified participant:
No camera, please.
Sophia Wood:
Go ahead. Come roll.
Representative — Guyana Tourism Authority:
Sure. Sure. No problem. Great. Thanks again Sophia for that question. And picking it up from where I left off, the fact that we have a blueprint for development for ecotourism, sustainable tourism I think is I think is what lays the groundwork for sustainability. So we have our systems dialed in and 2018 we developed what is known as the blueprint for community letown tourism because Guyana is known for this type of type of u model in which the community actually owns the lands and they also own the assets and the majority of enterprises or businesses within the within the country is of this model.
So that is of significance. And how does government facilitate the development? Well, one I think it’s a high level of collaboration. Tourism inherently needs to needs to be a product of partnerships and that’s one of the things that we have been championing for a long time now. Here at the Guyana Tourism Authority I mean we do have a lot of expertise in house but you need to have supporting partners. So we have the ministry of Amarindian affairs which deals with all of the indigenous peoples and the rights and all the decisions there.
We collaborate with other entities like the ministry of public infrastructure that deals with everything infrastructure. So by having a model where we can have effective and sustainable partnerships with sister governmental agencies and non-governmental agencies really help to facilitate the development of enterprises. Just to pop in on that kamroll I know obviously you and I have worked together specifically on this. So, I wanted to ask if you could touch base a little bit on how GTA has worked specifically with private organizations, how you partner with private companies to bring in tourism to the indigenous people in Guyana.
And for people who don’t know, Guyana is a small country, but over 87% of it is still covered in original virgin Amazon rainforest. And so, they’re a really strong example of what it looks like to keep the indigenous communities involved in protection. Especially using tourism.
Unidentified panelist:
Right Sophia and that’s it the collaboration there being so for example if an indigenous community shortlisted for development you know we would take in the private sector enter enterprise so from the tour operators to the outfitters from the onset really to see whether this product would suit or fit a particular market obviously so there is a need again for heavy partnerships so when we go out to facilitate whether it’s training capacity building you know the Ghana tourism authority facilitates this and then to link them to the markets we bring in operators so it’s a very inclusive process that we’ve really defined over a number of years and it’s worked a very high degree of success in fact just last year we would have launched about two indigenous centric experiences and this was over the course of four three to four years which historically the development of indigenous enterprise ES have been done over 10 to 15 years plus.
So I think it’s a remarkable achievement of understanding the lessons learned previously from existing enterprises and taking that into consideration for you know in the formula that we would have developed.
Sophia Wood:
Thank you. And I know Thiago you worked for many years in ecotourism development in the Amazon with the Brazilian government. So could you provide some of your insights on how you’ve been able to channel ecotourism funding into indigenous communities and other communities throughout the Amazon and maybe how that has translated as well into private partnerships.
Thiago Beraldo:
Yes just a small I would like add something really small to Camro what Camro said Guyana I know French Guyana and we were working with them to try to bring more Europeans to the Amazon for example because for two French guy two French Guyana flights from France they are domestic flights so we are developing strategy is to bring people from Macho Picho and Peru because it’s the most visited destination in the South America and not just coming bringing people straight from the from United States for example but also driving the strategies to bring people to the to the entire Amazon.
For example th those two other options bring people there is there are roads that come now from that connect Peru and Brazil and then we are we are working together with agencies tourist companies in Peru to bring some people from the Andes to the Amazon also and particularly in the in the situation of Brazil and the local communities what we have been done with the as government is we understood that most of the project projects that were coming to finance echurism in the Amazon in our protected areas they were more on the organizing the community to receive the tourists but not preparing them to sell their products or to understand supply chain supply no productivity chain how it works to put their the product on the market.
So we have been working with USAD and US Forest Service to help to organize better the communities in the Amazon. We in Brazil we learned to do ecotourism in the south of Brazil in the mountains and in the marine areas and Amazon is very different. We have been studying for example Alaska to understand how people go to why and how they bring people to Denali to understand how we bring people to the middle of the Amazon and this is been help very helpful. We are understanding that we need to work in Brazil in Brazil Amazon at least with the water.
Water is the most important resource and how to move people in the Amazon is easier. So we’ve been working with understanding how when we use lodges and when we use cruises to bring people to travel through a protected area like an Aavanas that is close to the Manau and then we can go up the river the Amazon River and visit very nice places and you have a place to stay and other options. One thing that is really important that we are doing as government is regulating ecotourism. So now we have a we have different regulations for public private partnerships.
And this is really important. Now we have options for a community. If the community has the capacity to organize the entire tourism operation, they can they can do that. But if they can only but if they if the international company for example or a company from another place in Brazil wants to operate for example sports fish in the Amazon. They can do different contracts with the community depending on how the community is prepared to receive tourism different arrangements to so we can start the operation and then with time community can understand better the entire process and take control the a better control of the process and what we’ve been learning in the Amazon is that we don’t need millions of the of tourists like Rio de Janeiro or Fuzzy Guasu in Brazil we good amount of tourists that with that are willing to spend more money.
And then so we are investing in for example bird watching, sports fishing that tourists are willing to have a worse a more difficult logistic to access the places but they are willing to go to very far remote even more remote places in the Amazon to get the fish they want or to see the bird they want. So this is the kind of the segments that we are working more now. So we are working with regula regulations and special segments specific segments that are more willing to have more difficult logistics to visit the places.
Sophia Wood:
Perfect. Thank you so much. It looks like John would like to add on to that point. So please go ahead.
Jon Bruno:
I just you know first of all to sum up what all Gabrielle said some fantastic stuff. I you know he took the words right out of my brain and a lot of the you have great speakers here today. So but to build on what Thiago just said two very important things I think jump out at me from our experience in every country. One he said that a lot of and I and I have to be somewhat verbose about this so I apologize. If you imagine that there is this large global capacity right for receiving tourists that system is overcrowded because there we aren’t adding to it rapidly enough and these places have enormous amounts of potential capacity to add to that.
And using eco travelers to add in another of Chago’s points. Who are careful, who spend more money, who don’t require fancy infrastructure, who actually want an authentic experience. They’re the best ones to come in and allow there to be revenue so that this revenue can be reinvested in potentially having other tourists if those tourists are wanted. Right? So how to get there is we have to allow these people into the global financial system and right now that simply doesn’t exist. So if governments can say and Kamu actually you know laid this out.
If governments can say here is a path for an ecotourism community a community that has ecotourism assets to allow those assets to be seen by the global community to be booked or as Thiago said to even be gotten to. Then they have a chance to achieve that revenue. If not, then there may be the desire. But, what we’ve seen so many times is communities will say, “Well, how do we get to that next step? How do we get the travelers here? How do we know what they’ll want?” All of these things.
There’s a fairly standard set of answers to that. It doesn’t require much money. It doesn’t require anything really, but as Gabrielle said, communication. So, you know, we need to be able to take these lessons and say to this a massive amount of untapped capacity in the Amazon region, here is here are some simple steps you can take to allow your assets to be visible if you would like tourists. That way, you can control the number and the type of tourists that come to your community. You can control the revenue and you can manage your own growth in your own way without giving them the tools to do that.
We’re locking out a lot of potential ecotourism. And we’re also we’re not giving them a fine enough brain so that they can make their own choices which is I think as all the panelists have said the most important.
Sophia Wood:
Thing here. That’s a fantastic point, John. And I actually, you kind of, you know, read my mind about where I wanted to go next. So, I appreciate it. And I actually wanted to bring in Gabrielle and give you a chance to talk about since you’ve been, you know, you are running the marketing for one of these businesses on the ground and know what that looks like to work with an indigenous community that’s getting started and then is now quite successful. I mean the Napo Wildlife Center has won dozens of international awards for conservation and for the quality of the product that they have and this is still completely built for and by the Anyangu Kichua community.
So could you explain how the community made the decision to go down the ecotourism route and is there anything you wish you’d known before you started? What tools or programs have been instrumental to the success of the community? And then addressing kind of the last point that John was talking about, what are you still missing to be able to achieve what you’d like to achieve with this project?
Gabriel Minas Amaya:
Okay, thank you. So, well, pretty much there were a couple of things there, on why decided to take the touristic path. First of all, they were leaving their land. So they were looking for jobs you know to have an income for their families because even though they live in the rainforest like they’ve been doing by generations there are some other needs that modern life has created right and they are not far from that. So they were looking for jobs, they were leaving the land, they were abandoned the families in some cases.
There was no school or high school in the community. There was no a healthcare center. So they realized that their ancestral land was being abandoned and probably on the hands of petroleum companies, logging companies. So pretty much they had a couple of these assemblies and these assemblies are very interesting because that how that’s how things were done before in the past in the in the old times. So everyone every single person every single member of the community has a say and has a vote as well. And there they just they just found that tourism would be a way to have income to protect the land and as a way to and because they were having this income a way to reinvest trying to solve their social needs, right?
And I think if they would they would say if they would hope to know something before they started I think it was actually training on how to how to manage an organization. They went through very complicated moments when they just started. They got the assistance of an international NGO and eventually the they had differences on the on the way the project was being managed. So they had to ask the local government, the local national government to help the community to regain the management of their project. And eventually well they are they are running they are managing the two projects.
They have two projects now small projects and probably they would u they would hope to know a little bit more about management and treating with tourism as well to with the visitors.
Sophia Wood:
And Gabrielle has is the Napa Wildlife Center able to be a registered business in Ecuador with a bank account and everything associated with that because we’ve often seen that these communities run very informally and are not able to get access to these kinds of tools. So are you able to access bank accounts, internet, all of these infrastructure issues that a lot of communities face?
Gabriel Minas Amaya:
Okay. Yeah, actually the community has every requirement that the local government has to participate as a as a community tourism organization legally. And the key success factor there was that the community because they has this democratic way of living because they decided to go for tourism they decided to get help as well. So once they re regain the management of their project they hired local people to help them. So they hired someone to be the advisor on management, some other people to be advisors on accounting and finance on the legal side as well.
And all these people help the community as I’m doing now with the business development in different in different subjects. So the community could reach the goals they had and one very important thing there was that they have this gathering these meetings these assemblies every month. So the general manager who is a member of the community lead the assembly with some of the core leaders of the finance side the legal side in order to see how the project is working right. So if they want if they would like to know a little bit more about any issue they can ask for it and that has been a very important part of why the people has been so successful there.
Right.
Sophia Wood:
What a great point about bringing in an outside advisor. We’ve often seen in the industry communities trying very hard to do this on their own which can be very commendable but at the same time leaves them locked out of resources that governments you know organizations like Guyana tourism authority and anything else might be able to provide. So bringing in outside advisors that are aligned in terms of values can be really helpful. I wanna I want to shift this over to looking at the size of the potential ecotourism market in the Amazon.
We’ve kind of flirted with this idea. It’s a huge area with that’s relatively underinvested in terms of ecotourism. And the fact that many of the communities that work in ecotourism as John brought up and as we’ve seen in some of the projects in Guyana require very few tourists to be s financially sustainable for the community. And so it’s an area where spreading horizontally rather than vertically can be really effective in protecting larger areas of the Amazon. So I want to turn to John since you have this perspective of the global ecotourism industry as a whole and ask what opportunities you see for growth and investment across the Amazon region and actually you know what is missing from the region to help this become a1 billion dollar industry.
If you think it can head towards that and if it’s capital, what should investors be looking for? How can they help?
Jon Bruno:
So if I’m going to tie in, if you don’t mind, that’s a big answer. So I hope everyone is prepared for me to talk for a few minutes. The Gabrielle, I have to you know, I just have to commend you on you know, your thoughts and your work. But to build on what was just said, the idea is if you’re getting somebody who’s who’s helping communities and transferring this vital knowledge to them, you know, we asked about investment. Investment as a mechanism is also kind of requires infrastructure. And so I’m sure everyone on this call will tell me there are difficulties with getting investment down to these communities in the right way.
And so we look for two types of things. We look for ways to invest without necessarily, you know, moving capital around, right? And actual e expert advice and people who can go and assist communities. Most importantly, and I just I can’t quote this enough. I can’t underline it enough to do what they want to do to accomplish the goals that they have decided to accomplish not to you know so often in the business of aid it’s a monologue you know we’re you know kind of telling and all of us if we go you know all of us I’m sure have dealt a lot with the UN and other you know folks I mean I understand this group is under the opices of UN75 I get told a lot, you know, well, we have this 20,000 foot view and a lot of the folks that I’ve discussed with, but really this is done at the local level and must the motivation for it must come from within these communities.
So, our job is to facilitate their movement in the direction that they want to go, right? Not to influence that direction, but to allow that direction. So, some of the first types of investment that could take place is experts, doing exactly, you know, what Gabrielle is doing, which is, going literally to, you know, these communities, not being in, you know, I mean, I’m not trying to be porative in any way, but, you know, unless you’ve actually gone and been a part of these communities, you know, you’re you’re not going to have quite the perspective that you might need to make sure that the revenue gets to the right places and the services get to the right places and that people are doing what needs to be done.
So, there just isn’t any overall consistent method to finance that. If I have right now, and I do, I have tons of, you know, young people with some expertise and people mid-career with some expertise who would love to assist, you know, Gabrielle or apprentice to him or would love to do these kinds of projects on their own, but they have no idea where to go, no idea where to, you know, who to talk to. So there is no there is no network of that kind of funding right now. It’s very fragmented.
It’s you know the governments don’t necessarily cooperate and you know comroll I’m I really I you know have a lot of great respect for your governments and the work they do but I could you know just advocate for slightly more handholding as we see in some of the treaties that have gone on some of the signers to the desire to protect the Amazon. So, and I want to, you know, it’s fortunate that, that Art Krebs is on the, on the call. Art, are you still on? See if he’s on.
Art:
I’m here.
Jon Bruno:
Okay. Yeah. So, so you know, I, you know, I happen to know Art, personally for a while and, you know, Art I is from the other side. He’s, you know, the private sector and is one of the few people in the world who’s worked on 100 million USD plus projects in sustainable development. There aren’t that many of those. So, you know, there’s only a few people who have that kind of experience. And I don’t want to quote you, Art. I’m reluctant to quote you, but you know working with governments and communities, there is sometimes, and I want to put this the right way, a tiny bit of a disconnect between the what the governments want to accomplish and what the communities want to accomplish.
So, you know, Art, I want to be very sure that, you know, when I advocate for communities to have access and expertise, that I that I don’t quote you incorrectly and your experience says that, when you’re when you’re dealing with, specifically when you’re dealing with governments and the challenges of individual operators, the main thing that they need is to be allowed to facilitate their direction. And what are you seeing in terms of how that operates at the local level with the projects that you have?
Art:
Yeah. So, so first of all, let me let me try to provide some feedback from outside the box and please don’t take this wrong for those that are working for the government, but the circumstances are very unique in every single situation. So in my experience unfortunately in some cases when dealing with the government everything starts becoming more into a process or a mechanism that takes a long time and at the end of the day when everything is set and ready to go the funding comes in and then the funding doesn’t reach the end point at the certain level that is needed.
So I believe that there is a need in order to utilize the right mechanism that will allow that funding to reach the right end goal and be able to create that progress as needed. In addition to that, I think that government is essential of course, but the approach and I totally agree with everybody as point of view that it has to be more of a consultative approach to the local people because at the end of the day, they are the experts. They know exactly what is that they need, what are their you know important areas of improvement, their lacks of things that are not there.
Infrastructure to be precise in certain situations. So you know if you don’t get the buying from the local people and you go the reverse of trying to approach it from the higher levels of governance and then you get to the local people and the local people you know reject the idea because they never got involved then we have a complete collusion and that’s really what I think that u you know I’m so happy to hear for example Gabrielle was talking about this and Thiago as well that they need to be approached and they need in my mind they should be approached first because if they are not buying into getting some additional help and they don’t understand what that help will bring to them then it collapses going in reverse that’s one of the points I think u secondly the mechanism of allowing the appropriate allocation of the funds to the right points is essential because otherwise there’s a lot of resources and time being wast wasted when at the end of the day the vision or whatever was needed doesn’t get accomplished.
There’s rarely the situation in where you know GMO was telling us that you know in his situation it worked great which is which is awesome but it’s not necessarily the same everywhere else.
Unidentified panelist:
Right and that’s and that’s so that’s like a flashback within a flashback for a panelist to ask a question of somebody else but I was I was going to quote him and I didn’t want to since he’s here on the call. So, so that I hope that answers the question and I’m delighted.
Sophia Wood:
I just wanted to be conscious of time and ask one final question before. I know Jonah asked a question which is funny Jonah because John and I have been talking about just exactly that system since we first talked. So I think there’s there is a need for that. I wanted to just wrap up and give, you know, finally address the what I feel is the elephant in a room, which is the effect of the COVID-19 pandemic on ecotourism and specifically in the Amazon. As we all know, COVID-19 has trashed the tourism industry, just to put it unllightly.
It’s led many ecotourism practitioners to question whether tourism can be an effective strategy for long-term protection of biodiversity hotspots because of the industry’s vulnerability to global shocks like this one. So, I wanted to ask you, do you believe tourism is still an effective strategy to help us protect large swats of the Amazon? And if so, what can we do right now from either the government or the private sector to ensure that these businesses don’t shutter permanently as a result of the pandemic that’s put a lot of them on their last legs?
I don’t know, Thiago, if you want to go first.
Thiago Beraldo:
Hi Sophia, thanks. It’s a very easy question to answer. I just want to point for the perspective of government. That in as government we learning that we have to move away from we decentralize the what we are doing. So we are giving more power to protect the data managers to and the communities to organize theel themselves with the tourism sector allowing them because they the communities they know what they need better than us. So we are developing this understanding in Brazil that we need to let them build the connections and get in contact with the marketing and the tourism sector to decide how they want to move forward.
We related to we are also working I am working with other countries in Brazil in the Amazon we have international group finan financed by FAO it’s called hed parkers and we have a group of tour in tourism and we are building capacity with protected area managers all over the Amazon to help then understand how to manage better the tourism in different protected areas. And another point that I want to point is another thing that I want to point is that we need in Brazil we need more tourism in the Amazon even though it’s not authentic and 100% echoourism is at is even mass tourism or not mass tourism but different options of tourism are better that what’s happening in the Amazon the ways of people are leaving the Amazon right now many ways.
So we understand that tourism is really important. Co I say that CO sucks because in two in into 2019 we had almost half a million visitors in Amazon protected areas in Brazil. So we are really happy that we are organizing better than the protected areas were receiving more tourists. Local tourists were coming in from different states in the Amazon and from other places from Brazil and other countries were coming and co what I understand that co just showed how important tourism and tourism are for the for the protected areas conservation instead of I see people saying that co showed how fragile is tourism for the conservation but my point of view is that co showed how important is tourism ecotourism for the conservation of the areas.
This is the most important ecosystem service or the more effective ecosystem service that protected the areas are offering to the society right now. So we need to help sustain tourism in this difficult moment. So the communities and the and the tour operators can cross this moment and continue developing. And we watch and just to finish. Yeah, go ahead. We understand that the local communities they should not leave just from tourism. Tourists should be one of the way of their they living is because of the seasonality and things like COVID so they can continue living their lives even if situations like this one won’t happen.
Sophia Wood:
Thank you so much Thiago. Just conscious of time because I know everyone will have to hop off in about two minutes and I want to make sure Jonah has a chance to answer his question. Well, I guess yeah, I’d love everyone to have a chance to answer this question about COVID, but I want Jonah to have a chance to ask his question before everybody hops off. So, do you want to ask your question, Jonah?
Unidentified participant:
It’s okay. Go at the end.
Sophia Wood:
Okay.
Unidentified participant:
And I can go over.
Sophia Wood:
Sure. Okay. Got it. Gabrielle, would you like to address this? I know obviously Anyangu has done a great job investing in other things because of tourism.
Gabriel Minas Amaya:
Well, I’ll try to be brief. First I do agree with Thiago and I think that this pandemic has shown how important tourism is for the indigenous community and particularly to the communities in the Amazon rainforest. And just sharing the Yangu experience there. Long ago in one of the community assemblies, Yangu people decided to create a savings fund in order to reinvest in the school, the high school, the healthcare center, you know, to improve the buildings to do maintenance to the projects. And well that savings fund is helping them well help the community basically this very complicated 2020 and that provision that the that idea that the community that decision that the community had long ago because they wanted to do it because they decided to just saved the projects for almost a year.
Sophia Wood / Guyana Tourism Authority — boundary unclear:
Thank you. And Camu I guess could you quickly address how GTA has helped the small ecotourism businesses in Guyana survive this period? Yes, I mean there’s.
Representative — Guyana Tourism Authority:
There’s no easy fix to this obviously you know tourism has been disproportionately affected from COVID 19 must say that but what we’ve done is facilitation again we’ve led a number of hygiene and sanitation training so basically equipping our stakeholders so whether they’re indigenous communities whether they’re private sector operators to be in a state of readiness you know to host travelers when it’s obviously safe to do So and obviously given a lot of interventions. So COVID 19 supplies and kits so that one they have the tools you know readily available to host again and obviously to develop standard operating procedures.
So everything from guiding to transport to lodge management and everything in between that. So a lot of facilitation during this time. It’s a lot of guidance is needed and yeah that’s one of the ways that we would have facilitated it.
Sophia Wood:
Thank you. And I know for example in Mexico they’ve been able to vaccinate lots of people in the tourism industry to get it restarted. So hopefully we’ll see that in other countries as well.
Art:
So may I interject for one second Sophia? Things are looking a little bit more positive in the tourism industry. Right now, although COVID continues to be an upside down cycle, financing is becoming more available. So, that’s a good sight into what is coming in the future. So, I just wanted to mention that to you.
Sophia Wood:
Thank you.
Unidentified panelist:
Yeah. And to and to Art’s point, yeah, we’ve really capitalized on some funding opportunities available for our partners. We did some proposals for quite a few of the indigenous communities. Just secure the funding and help them with their conservation efforts because tourism does play a major or the major role in their conservation programs and yet the more that we can secure funding whether that is internally or externally, we will continue to do so. Well, thank you very much to all of the panelists for your kind and insightful conversation about this issue.
I know we’re at the top of the hour, so I will let Jonah take over in terms of moving forward with water cooler time. I’m able to stick around. I don’t know if any of the other panelists are able to stick around to continue the conversation with anyone who has follow-up questions. Thank you so much for everyone who participated and joined us today.
Jonah:
Thank you, Sophia. This is the moment where we move into unstructured time. I encourage everybody to put their email addresses into the chat so that we can follow up with each other afterwards. I see a couple names that are new. It’d be great to be in touch so we can invite you to future calls. Thanks so much to all the panelists and Sophia. I think this is going to be a popular episode when the podcast comes out. Lots of people want to help.
Sophia Wood:
Yay. I wanted I wanted you to ask your question, Jonah, because.
Jonah:
Oh, yeah.
Sophia Wood:
John and I have been talking about this basically since our first conversation when you put us in touch to start talking about this conversation. So I wanted you to I guess ask the panelists. I don’t know that this exists. I we think it should. So there’s a question for all the panelists. So I if I’m a tourist and I want to go to Peru and I want to visit the Amazon while I’m there, I might type goo into Google Peruvian Amazon tourist destinations or something like that and I’ll get, you know, something kind of random.
But my guess is that someone who’s got a lot of experience could create a site, you know, to all of the great ecotourism destinations for Peru or for the entire Amazon. Does such a site exist for Peru, for any other country? Does it exist for the whole region? And if it doesn’t, well gosh, let’s create it. What does exist?
Jonah:
Okay,.
Sophia Wood:
Art, how excited are you to take that question? Jonah, we’ve been having meetings like once every two weeks to talk about this between John and Art and I. So, so glad you arrived at that, too.
Art:
Yes, J. I think that is a great opportunity and you hit it right on the head because at the end of the day it’s something that we’ve been really focusing in and we got you know multiple solutions that are pretty much in the development phase including a mechanism on the availability of ensuring there is governance and monitoring and execution on allocation of funding. So Jonah to answer first of all the real problem lies in the fact that there are at least 50,000 assets in the Amazon region that are almost unknown.
So the model of going to a place being there and finding out from someone that certain assets are available is the only way that these places are on the map. They’re not bookable. They’re not even findable in many cases to the international community. So and a lot of the folks that do sort of client-f facing work at that level are part- timerrs who would love to be full-timers if they could, but and that’s not unique to the Amazon. That happens right here in the US. I mean, that’s there’s a lot of people like that are sort of part-time tour guides that would do more if they could or part-time areas that are visitable and, you know, people will open them up for tourists if they’re there.
So, you know, the question is to how if those were made available, if those were made bookable on a trustable platform, then, you would see as Thiago advocated for, a massive pickup in business, but one that’s again controllable by the community. So they can say we want this much, we want that much and control that access and that ingress in into their community. But that is a that would be and tragically to answer your question, no it doesn’t exist. And it doesn’t even exist on a country level. In fact, lots of the countries and I won’t name them specifically don’t actually have an inventory of what their assets are.
That again that’s not in any way unique to the Amazon region or South America. That’s every continent has that issue. So, one of the first things to do would be to actually inventory those assets. Find out what where they are in terms of their readiness for tourism, what their appetite is for increased tourism. And then take the ones that are ready for tourism, place them in a system where they can be seen and be booked and what we know is that within 36 months, they’ll have a steady stream of revenue coming to them.
From eco travelers and intrepid you know eco travelers but also as time goes by more of the I guess what we would call the mainstream travelers so that needs to happen that very much needs to happen it’s funny that you immediately saw that I guess that’s something that.
Unidentified participant:
Kind of becoming obvious.
Unidentified participant:
Obvious as we had the conversation I mean we do we have written up a what two pager of what this could look like of what is needed to make that happen. What the basic level investments are and infrastructure is to make that happen down from you know marketing and you know training as well as I think payments infrastructure is a major part of it and marketing infrastructure call center and booking and that’s actually part of why I was so excited to have Gabrielle on the call because the Napa Wildlife Center is one of few places that actually has an online booking system has an online presence has a digital footprint and can speak to what that looks like but It still remains, you know, part of a very fragmented market.
Even in Ecuador, you have maybe seven eco lodges in the Amazon. They’re not all on one platform where you could find them all at the same time.
Unidentified participant:
Exactly. Right.
Gabriel Minas Amaya:
Well, you cannot find all the projects online. But there are there are quite some travel agencies and touristic operators that are actually more into the community tourism right. So they are experts in community tourism ethnourism travel and some other agencies and they you might probably find different community projects on their websites. But additionally in Ecuador there’s an association of community tourism as well. I was trying to see if they have a web page. Unfortunately they only have a Facebook page. I’m going to copy it for you. And they do have all the community tourism or organizations here in Ecuador legally established and some other that are looking to become legally to work legally right.
So there is this idea as well but it’s very local a very local theme and they might work trying to coordinate some things with national government but not necessarily to show the projects at least yet right so that’s a that might be a second stage for the for the association but it’s a very interest it would be very interesting if there’s something like more wider more I don’t know regional or even bigger so people who is looking to do a different tourism might find easily different projects around the world where their money is going to be invested on a on a best way right.
Sophia Wood:
Yeah I think that’s a really interesting point Gabrielle as well because you know there was an effort about 15 years ago to unite ecotourism across Brazil and across a couple of other areas called pro-ecur. And it probably might, you know, one hypothesis for why that isn’t as active now might be just because of the internet age that we have now with the timing that we have today of access to platforms of the ability to build them and people’s use of them. How used we are to you know reaching out to places in the middle of nowhere on the internet might mean that we are in a better time today better than you know 20 years ago to actually build something where a platform can represent the whole Amazon and Airbnb for the Amazon type thing.
I see Richard was able to join us. I think we might have had a slight timing snafu based on the changing time zones constantly. I know we’ve had the UK change and the US change differently. So, I just wanted to give since we’re here, I wanted to give you a chance to introduce yourself and mention a little bit of the work that you’re doing in Peru and our Richard.
Richard Bodmer:
Yes. First of all, it had nothing to do with the time change. It has to do with internet problems. I’m currently have it. The internet went out and I finally rebooted it. So I first of all let me apologize for that and let me apologize in case you lose me because it’s still very unstable saying that right in front of my face right now. Your network is unstable. I’m sorry. So I’m Richard Bodma. I work in the Peruvian Amazon and I’ve worked also in other parts of the Amazon. I was in bang du paragraph for time and I’m part of a fun foundation called fun Amazonia and we have different types of tourism and ecotourism and educational and research activities under that umbrella.
Sophia Wood:
Thank you. And Richard, are you are on a boat in outside of Equitos right now? Am I right?
Richard Bodmer:
Yes. And that’s one reason for these internet issues. When it rains, I lose it. And it was raining, but now it’s sunny, so let’s hope it stays sunny for a little bit. Well, most of us have worked in the Amazon, so we’ve are empathetic towards the sporadic internet access in that region, which I guess speaks very well to our point about the lack of infrastructure. Yeah, it’s actually a battery problem. The communications tower has a solar system to it and the batteries are dead and they haven’t replaced them. So it only works when there’s actually sun and there’s enough to get those batteries enough to give you internet.
So it’s actually a problem of maintaining infrastructure in that case.
Sophia Wood:
That’s a good point. Well there’s another person still here who I wanted to bring up in case you are connected. Jim was part of some of the conversations I had while we were setting things up and is working with the center for protected areas management and has been doing a lot of management of protected areas in Latin America. I don’t know if you’re here, Jim, to introduce yourself since we’re here. We’d love to hear from you.
Jim:
Hi there. And I see my former colleagues from WCS, Richard Bobber, colleagues, Thiago, Anna, Maderos, Hodrigo from Brazil that I’ve had a chance to work with. A pleasure to see you all online. And thanks Sophia for the invitation. And sorry I had to get on a little bit late.
Sophia Wood:
Oh, we’re pleased to have you here and it seems like it’s a small world in Amazon ecotourism development if you know half the people on the call already. Could you maybe just mention a little bit of your background and the work that you’ve done in the region, Jim? That would be great.
Jim:
Sure. As I mentioned already, I spent much of my career working for the bingos, the big international NGOs. A long time at WCS working in Latin America also with CI and WWF earlier in my career and I continue to collaborate with all those organizations on capacity building activities and for the last 12 years I’ve been at Colorado State University which has a long tradition of working in protected area management actually over a century and over the last three decades in Latin America and we do a lot of short courses and capacity building together with in NGOs together with bilateral multilateral agencies and in the past seven years we’ve worked a lot with Thiago and his colleagues at the mibio on a specific initiative regarding promoting community- based ecotourism in the Brazilian Amazon.
Sophia Wood:
Thank you and thanks so much for joining the call. Appreciate having you here. Jonah, I saw you unmute yourself a couple of times. Not sure if I cut you off on something.
Jonah:
No, I just love to know about the resources that already are used. You mentioned Airbnb for the Amazon. I’m sure there are some Airbnb sites, you know, that are listed in the Amazon. So, what are the primary internet pathways that people use to date to get to the region? I’m not sure if anyone else wants to speak on that. I personally actually yesterday was looking at the Airbnb availability in the Ecuadorian Amazon and it’s quite limited to areas outside of Tenna which is not the most beautiful of cities but is in the Amazon.
So it’s pretty limited as far as I’ve seen on something like Airbnb. And a lot of a lot of what I’ve seen is, you know, each and every company having their own website and then their ability to actually do any SEO and web development and have a marketing person like Gabrielle working with them. The communities I’ve worked with generally don’t have any or much marketing capacity. And I know obviously through my personal work with the Guyana Tourism Authority that they’re working really hard to get all of their investable villages connected to international operators so that they make it onto a platform, but they’re not everybody’s necessarily ending up on the same platform.
Unidentified participant:
I might be able to shed some light on that and answer your question in it and build on what Sophia just said. So I’ve had good conversations with Expedia and Booking.com and Booking.com is just now starting to get into the world of sustainable travel. All of them are really, so they’re they’re just entering. The problem lies in the fact that almost all travel assets today that are booked internationally come from one of 29 what are called aggregators which take assets and package them for the large travel sites. So the A-list sites like the ones we all know here, Airbnb, Airbnb has their own inventory but they still package them.
So if you go to what is the one home key, there’s Verbbo. There’s a couple of others. You’ll see a lot of the same assets and a midsized one that like Marriott’s Place Pass for instance, all of their assets come from these aggregators. They don’t build their own inventory themselves. So, for an asset to list itself in the international market, it has to it has to go to a specific site either through the Expedius program or one of the others and has to fit itself into a certain set of data that they can then turn around and sell.
And it has to go through specific agreements, specific financial capabilities, and a review process that’s arcane, difficult, and you know, almost like an IRS tax form. So, the IRS for internationals being the American tax agency. So, to make a long story short, there’s a there’s a initiative at Expedia to try and reach out to, sustainable assets and to try and onboard small community assets, but they’re just beginning that. And, they’re only beginning to talk to people who have that expertise about how to do it. So, there are a couple of providers that are addressing that problem by allowing small assets to pipeline into these, large booking sites, but as Sophia said earlier and as, as Daniel said, it’s mostly local and very fragmented.
So, there’s certainly no way that you could say, well, you know, here is the capacity for the world or here is the capacity for any specific region. Some nations Iceland has a very good system for this but I would say that the nations that have that you know you can count on one hand and even in those nations there’s a very you know there’s a serious process now of course Iceland you know that’s a that’s a small place and very tourism centric and they have a very mature model but to give you an example a lot of the Ecuador is a perfect example since you know we all have familiarity as I’ve said before and as Daniel just said, half of the assets are not functionally registered.
They’re not known to the government per se, right? There’s no SQL query that you can run and get these assets to come up. So, it relies on making the process available to those in those communities so that they can add themselves to the global booking capacity. And that’s we’re quite far from that. That bridge is unbuilt right now. This seems like a great opportunity to I mean it doesn’t take a lot of work for someone in some corner of the world to do a lot of mapping and to create a you know more comprehensive list than is already visible.
Unidentified participant:
Right.
Unidentified participant:
That’ll attract a lot of investors.
Sophia Wood:
Some of what John and Art and I have started working on I know Art’s been has a lot of the backend infrastructure already at his fingertips because of the development he’s done to other places and know he didn’t bring it up but our first conversation when we talked the first time was about the work he’s been doing with six sense and some of which has been in the Amazon and so I know you know starting to create that map might be part of you know starting to create this article for the ecotourism strategy and what we can do as the Amazon Investor Coalition to help bring together those companies, even if it’s just first a list on the internet, even if it starts as an Excel document, and becomes a platform, starting to put those lists together, I think, would be incredibly helpful.
Jonah:
Art, can you walk us through a little bit about the financing of the ecotourism industry? How much of it is it is it debt? How much of it is equity? How much of it is about infrastructure builds versus, you know, just bringing marketing to those who need it?
Art:
Well, it all depends on the different circumstances, of course. I would say that, you know, if we’re looking at the Amazon, as we heard before, some of the infrastructure is already there. I think for in the case of Richard’s comment, I know that the for example the communications in Peru, we’re very heavily invested as far as you know internet and towers all over the country, but the problem comes down into the maintenance like he’s saying, you know, the batteries don’t work, but the system is there. And that happens throughout the you know, I’ve been to locations in the Andes that you would never believe that there’s signal and they have pretty good signal.
So it also it’s all a variable I would say conglomerate of different percentages of allocations if you want to put it in that way. But at the end of the day if I understand your question correctly what is a typical allocation of let’s say for example the equity and infrastructure it all depends also on the ownership because at the end of the day u private investments with government could be one but then if somebody is owing a reserve of let’s say a thousand hectares in the middle of the Amazon then you’re dealing with a different perspective where there is equity already in place and the funding is relative to what you want to be developing.
The infrastructure might be there, the infrastructure might not be there. So then it’s a very fluid circumstance and it really needs to be looked at individually. Does that make sense?
Unidentified participant:
Yeah,.
Sophia Wood:
Absolutely. Well, one question I’d had for Richard and Thiago, and since you’re both here now, I thought I’d ask what takes us a little away from the investment side is just talking about infrastructure a little bit more and access, the role of Amazon cities like Ikitos and Manau that are accessible by plane. Because they are hubs where people can get to relatively easily compared to other areas of the Amazon. What are the role that these cities play in getting people deeper into the Amazon? And how could they be more effective in channeling tourism into the Amazon as these major international hubs where people can easily access.
Unidentified participant:
Well, I can say.
Unidentified participant:
Oh, please go ahead. No, please Rachel, you have to.
Unidentified participant:
Go first, please.
Unidentified participant:
Yeah, in case your internet.
Unidentified participant:
Okay.
Unidentified participant:
Yeah. So, I think that these cities Well, let me just speak specifically of Aikitos. Okay. Ketos has some major issues to it in terms of the pollution. It has noise pollution and air pollution in terms of the city is not what you would call a sustainable city. I think that’s part of where these cities needs change. While there might be a hub to come into, the city itself has a lot that it can do. And we’ve been involved in some of those projects. One is the cultural and historic tourism. We have two museums there.
The indigenous cultures museum, the historic boat museum, and we run a hotel which is a historic monument. And so, you know, part of it is that is to bring some life into the city, not only have it as a hub and don’t care about the city and all the people don’t like it when they go there because of and all the rick shores. And so electric rick shaw is a kind of the perfect size for an electric vehicle. It was a golf cart been developed a long time and things like that.
Changing the city into a more sustainable city needs to be done in the future. Otherwise, it’s never going to work as a hub. People don’t want to go to that type of mess. Unsustainable. And so, I think that’s where a lot of our effort has gone into in the city is to be able to have the f some of the first museums there that function and things like that. And we’ve redone a few plazas in the traditional way. And until that happens, until the city actually changes, it’s always worked as a hub, but it’s not going to work as a good hub.
Until ISOs itself becomes a destination that people want to go to, not because of the chaotic in the tourism world, you say vibrant, right? When you read vibrant, you know, that’s going to be a chaotic city. And that I think is one of the main points.
Sophia Wood:
Thank you. I know Thiago, you had jumped in to talk a little bit more about.
Thiago Beraldo:
I just I want to add that it’s but it’s important to have those hub cities in Brazil. We should have more international airports in other states in the Amazon so people can fly through those different areas. And we need different types of tourism and other business that need to use those flights because the thing is just few people just few tourists they for to build infrastructure in those big cities is they it’s not economically sustainable. We need some things going on and this those cities should be more sustainable environmental sustainable but we need those large hubs and big cities in some areas and international flights.
So we can create opportunities for the communities for more real ecotourism but if we don’t have a minimal infrastructure that this big business generate then it’s much difficult to bring the tourists to the remote areas and to genuine opportunities for community based tourism and equism. I think it’s so interesting that you bring that up, Thiago, and the point that you brought up earlier about the importance of rivers and water travel to Amazon ecotourism. Because if you look at the example of, you know, the African savannah and access to game parks in Africa, a lot of that is done through small bush planes and boats and less traditional transport, I guess, not cars basically, and not big planes.
So it’d be interesting to, you know, consider how these smaller bits of infrastructure could be used and scaled up in the Amazon as they’ve done as they’ve been able to do in, you know, African safaris. What I wonder what we can adopt from the success of the African safari model for the Amazon. And one thing that is important in this subject we realize it that sports fishing despite not being echurism as per se that everyone understands but we saw for conservation if the community instead of taking the entire fish and selling to a cheaper place in the city if they if they work with sports fisher sports fishing it’s more they have more income to their area and many of those visitors they are willing to go to Manau for example and they take another flight to a smaller airport in the Amazon and they take an hydro airplane and then go and then land in the river to be in a very remote area and for we are understanding now that for example The same way that photography safaris and safaris are the Amazon fish fishing is Amazon is for fishing.
What safari is for the Africa for Africa.
Richard Bodmer:
And well what we found here in the Peruvian Amazon I would say unfortunately is that the Iawaska tourism is probably bigger than ecotourism. I put ecotourism in a in the category of sustainable tourism. I kind of make three categories. Sustainable tourism, neutral tourism and harmful tourism. Neutral tourism might be a hotel in tourist but really is involved in anything sustainable. It could be if they had sustainable energy for example then they move over more to sustainable and ecotourism is over very much on the sustainable. Then you have the Iawaska. I put Bowasa in and I’ve seen the damage it’s done not only people but does a lot of damage but it’s very big here and that’s one of the things that we see in our hotel we have people who go on Iaskca tours but they’re not allowed to take in the hotel that’s completely prohibited as in all of our infrastructure so what we have here in the Amazon also in terms of that is we have this type of tourism which is not a very pleasant tourism that’s dominating the tourist landscape here and that’s something the government has tried to regulate find it very difficult to do that because they’re in that same conflict but we regulate this and put restrictions on it then we don’t get the tourists to come here and they’re the major tourists to come in large numbers it’s illegal drug in most other countries that here and I think Colombia, Ecuador also have IASCO tourism.
Sophia Wood:
I’m glad you brought that up, Richard, because it’s something that we’ve talked about a lot at some of the Amazon Investor Coalition meetings and obviously ISA is a huge part of the tourism industry in the Amazon. I don’t know if Teddy’s around, but Teddy has been on some calls with me about Iawaska tourism, specifically in the Peruvian Amazon, and ways to make it more sustainable. So, it’s very interesting to hear your perspective on that. And I don’t know how big it is in Brazil or if you have any insights, Thiago, about Iawaska in Brazil.
Maybe not.
Thiago Beraldo:
In Braz in Brazil we are having some in AR is growing in Iawaska tourism the many indigenous communities now are creating festivals and bringing tourists to have this experience of withaska. Also some rubber tapper communities are producing and bringing tourists to participate in those rituals. It’s not so big as in Peru. Peru is the hub for this kind of tourists but a is growing. I think that can be it should be regulated. As Richard said, if you if you make it more sustainable and it could be organized it in a way that won’t be harmful and can also help to organize the culture and not organize fortify on the some local cultures and people learning and learning to respect the Amazon through those different access to learning with the culture with the those indigenous communities.
Sophia Wood:
Yeah, that’s really important. I don’t know what it looks like specifically in Peru, but I do know one of the major challenges with Iawaska tourism has been the disenfranchisement of indigenous communities. And it is certainly something that is worth talking about further as we’re talking about ecotourism to ensure to make decisions I guess about what it looks like to be involved with those businesses.
Jonah:
Yeah. Iaska businesses will never grow. The reason for that is because the US has it listed as class A drug which means that the companies can’t get bank accounts and banks that work with the US and all banks work with the US. I’ve seen so many people come down and try to grow an Iawaska business and it all collapses for the same reason. They have to do everything outside the banks and of course you can’t run a bigger business outside the banks informally. So that I don’t think is, you know, until it’s regulated and agreed upon internationally, the US isn’t going to allow this to grow.
Unidentified participant:
That’s a great point.
Sophia Wood:
I will have to run in a few minutes to another call. I appreciate everyone being here and if any one wants to make any last points or bring up any questions for further conversation happy to field them now. I just want to say it’s a great honor to talk to everyone here. It’s amazing to participate in a conversation with so much knowledge and experience and I you know I could do this for like 10 hours but I know everyone’s got things they have to do. I also just want to say thanks to Sophia and Jonah for the opportunity and see some good folks that I know already like John and Jane Barbarak, Anna, Hodrigo and other people.
And say that I respect and I admire the Amazon Investor Coalition and I hope that it continues growing and we can work more coordinately through the entire Amazon to promote sustainable activities and sustainable tourism to know how to conserve the Amazon but also bring people and to know and visit the area because it’s really important. Thank you, Thiago, and thank you so much for joining. I guess Richard, go ahead if you if you want to jump in.
Richard Bodmer:
So, I just want to say I thank you and sorry I came in right at the end there, but internet held out and that’s been really nice and it’s been it’s been great hearing all of this.
Sophia Wood:
It’s been great to have you on the call. I know that the you have the solar panel challenges in the Amazon. So, total empathy and understanding for how that works out there. And thank you to all of you who were able to come and anyone who’s stuck around for this conversation afterward. I feel newly energized about the working you know the work that the Amazon Investor Coalition can do in ecotourism and how we can build a united strategy for the whole region. Very excited to see where this goes next and we’ll continue to keep you all in the loop as we start to develop a bigger strategy for ecotourism development across the region and help bring more people to see the beauty of the Amazon because anyone who’s been there pretty much falls in love with it.
It’s such an incredible place. Thank you all.
Unidentified participants — closing remarks:
Thank you. Bye. Bye. Bye. Thank you. Bye. Anything? Please. A key. A.