Payment-for-Conservation Innovations in the Amazon: The CONSERV Program

Today we learn about payment-for-conservation innovations in the Amazon. Initiated in 2020, CONSERV pays select farmers to conserve forests beyond the legal limits required for privately held Amazon land under the Brazilian Forest Code. The strategy addresses historic obstacles of forest finance, by 1) Applying the program across discrete geographies of highest deforestation risk, 2) Requiring landowners to comply with 100% of their properties, and 3) arranging time-bound contracts. With permanence, additionality, leakage, and jurisdiction concerns considered, will the CONSERV program scale? IPAM, EDF, and Norway are on board, but who else? Andre Guimaraes of IPAM and Marcelo Stabile of CONSERV join us for the conversation.

Recorded March 8, 2021

References:

Article: Rural producers in Brazil are paid for conservation in the Amazon

The UNFCCC REDD+ strategy on deforestation

The Brazilian Forest Code

WATCH:

  • Jonah (moderator)
  • Andre Guimaraes
  • Marcelo Stabile
  • Amrita
  • Colleen
  • Peter
  • Ruben
  • Sophia
  • Mara
  • Bjorn
  • Unidentified participants

Jonah:

Hello everybody. Welcome to the 35th or 36th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing forest-friendly economic development across the Amazon region. We are a project of the global governance philanthropy network and nexus. And this week we are featuring CONSERV. It is a new program put out to the world by IPAM and EDF the environmental defense fund and other organizations. We’re going to learn more about it. We are being presented or interviewed by or with Marcelo Stabile and Andre Guimaraes. And let’s go ahead and start with Andre.

Andre, tell us a little bit about yourself and tell us what you did before IPAM.

Andre Guimaraes:

Hi John. Well, thank you very much for bringing us here. It’s a it’s a privilege for us to be talking to you all about CONSERV and the challenges that we have in the Amazon. So, my deepest appreciation, John, for the invitation here. Very quickly, I’m an agronomist. I’m 53 years old. So I’m about my career has about 30 years old or so 29 30 years. All of that time as an agronomist. I’m an agronomist by training with a with a master’s degree at Cornell in environmental in agriculture economics. So across my entire career I’ve been working in different positions from you know NGOs I was officer at the World Bank.

I’ve worked in the financial sector in venture capital and in all that all of those positions I’ve mainly focused on the same subject regardless of the position which was to engage the private sector into CONSERVion efforts. I’ve worked in different biomes in Brazil. I’ve been I’ve served as VP for the for Latin America at CONSERVation International where I had the chance to look after the operations in 10 Latin American countries. So I’ve been working in that agenda of bringing in investment to the investment world the private sector as a whole to join forces in order to promote CONSERVion of tropical forest.

So that’s what I’ve been doing across my entire career. And just very briefly Jon before I hand over to Marcelo so that he can talk more about himself and CONSERV. So maybe this is a good time to introduce IPAM as a whole. Some of you do know IPAM very well. John Paulen here, Lars and good friends here, Ruben. But just very quickly, is gonna celebrate his 26th anniversary in a couple months. It’s going to be of course a virtual celebration. As you know, we are in a hardcore situation here in Brazil.

But anyways, we’ll be 26 years old. Across this time, IPAM has basically done produced information. We do have this belief at our institution which is good quality information, scientific based information has the power to promote changes and we have been exercising that across these 26 years. Was created back then in the early 90s mid 90s right after the Rio 92 where a lot of interest and attention was focused on the Amazon on the tropical forests and later on all discussions about the climate change which brings in the Amazon once again to the center of the debate.

So has served as this institute focused on producing good quality information and over the past 10 12 years we have expanded our operations that has begun in the Amazon also to the sahad to the Brazilian central savylvanas. We understand that there are lots of correlations or interactions between these two biomes. So now we work on the sahad and the Amazon since about 10 12 years ago and the focus and very actually the approach of our work is we start our work with scientific information and that’s precisely what we did with CONSERV we have identified through our science you know an opportunity for the private sector particularly private land owners to participate actively in the in the CONSERVion efforts that we believe are important for Brazil, for the Sahada, for the Amazon and that all of that started with science which is the first let’s say pillar of our work then we after science we test on the ground our hypothesis that’s what we are doing with CONSERV now and after testing our hypothesis on the ground we move on to the next stage which is to do advocacy so that those findings are transformed into public policies private sector policies investment policies and so on.

So that in a nutshell, Janna, is what we are trying to accomplish at the at the end of the day. We believe that we can coexist with nature. We humans and our business activities can and must coexist with nature. And that’s the main belief of our organization that you know humans and nature not just can coexist but can benefit each other and can you know prosper and can thrive if we do the right thing which is.

Jonah:

Excellent.

Andre Guimaraes:

That we have for the coming years.

Jonah:

Thank you so much Marcelo. Tell us a little bit about yourself. Tell us a little bit about your life before CONSERV and then I’ll ask you more questions about CONSERV.

Marcelo Stabile:

I’ll be very brief. I’m also an agronomist. I did my masters at Texas A&M in agriculture, precision agriculture to be exact. And already thinking about, you know, how to save the environment using more rationally the inputs that we use on farms. Then I moved to Australia where I did my PhD in land use change modeling and I’ve joined CONSERVd about uam about 10 years ago always working with sustainable agriculture, sustainable cattle ranching and trying to you know create this situation in which producers can produce more. We need to feed the world and we need to CONSERV more.

So that’s kind of where we were stuck in the early 201213 and thinking about how could we sort out these producers that had areas that could be deforested in their in their properties. And so you know as Andre explained at we have this approach of studying things testing them and putting them to scale. And you know that’s really exciting on our daily work and that’s why we’re here.

Jonah:

Excellent. Now after all of this hype CONSERV without the e on the end. What is that? What does that mean? What is the organization? What does it do and why was it created?

Andre Guimaraes:

Well the big guy at CONSERV is the guy next door to me here. It’s Marcel. But let me just Marcel if you allow give the a general intro John how CONSERV started. So given this approach that has of testing the grounds and etc. It happened about five six years ago when I joined I was recruited by you know head hunter and a process that I went through and so on. So I was hired in the market to let to lead. So that was six years ago. And when I arrived and the very first thing that I did when I sat on my chair for the first time at EPAN was to you know try to get a hold of or try to get a better understanding of where I was and I started reading documents and articles and papers and so on.

And I remember reading an article from Marcelo and other alters at Ibum which was basically identified or they actually calculated the what we are now calling the legal reserve surplus. In other words, areas in private inside private farms that could be legally deforested. Right? So there was a an initial calculation and they’ve identified 1.7 million hectares of land in that category that can be legally deforested only in the Amazonian portion of the state of Matroso, which is a smaller portion of the entire Amazonian biome. And that number really hit me hard.

That said well here is something that we can do particularly because of another article that I read from Ruben here Ruben Lubalsski actually wasn’t an article was a report right where you have identified that the opportunity cost of the land if they decide to chop down those trees and so you know a lot of area that can be legally deforested with a very low opportunity cost in other words they would make a little money out of that stuff those two numbers combined told me here’s here’s something we can do. And that was the spark plug of CONSERV about five years ago.

So we’ve agreed with Nicki the Norwegian the climate fund to invest in Alip so that we could test scientifically this hypothesis. Is this correct? What is the number for the Amazon for the entire Amazon? Is that a big number? Is that a small number? Is the opportunity cost variable depending on the region that where you are and so on. So we had several questions before we could hypothesize what we have now being implemented which is CONSERV. So that was I just wanted to give this intro and I’ll ask you Marcelo maybe for you to tell our colleagues here more in depth what is it that CONSERV is doing now because I think that’s where the curiosity is but the very beginning of CONSERV was that we had a scientific curiosity we fed this curiosity with more analysis and that analysis derived into the mechanism that we are operating now and I’ll ask Marcelo to tell the story.

Marcelo, floor is your for brand.

Marcelo Stabile:

Sure. Thanks, Andre. Yeah, so that’s, you know, it’s very hard to understand that in Brazil there’s a legislation called the Brazilian Forest Code. And sorry if many of you know what it is, but I believe there are a few that don’t. And that is the law that regulates land use on private properties. And it determines that a piece of the properties has to be set aside as areas of CONSERVion, what we call legal reserves. These are areas that are protected by law and therefore could not be deforested legally or illegally.

However, as Andre said, we identified that there were, you know, 1.6 1.7 million hectares of areas that could be legally deforested. So, it’s areas beyond the legal reserve. And so this is, you know, it’s an asset. So we call it legal reserve surplus or an asset because it’s an area that the producer can get a license from the environment environmental agency of its state and they can go there and deforest and well they can put cattle, they can put soy, they can put cotton, they can do nothing. They can just deforest if they want to.

And you know we thought well we need to figure out a way one to understand this a bit better than we do because we only at the beginning we only had this number and what can we do about it. So the 1.7 million hectares in the Amazon portion of Matugoso we expanded first to Matugroso state and Matugosu state’s really big. Has can’t remember exactly the number of hectares but it’s a really big state and there are actually 7 million hectares in the state that could be legally deforested and that’s a lot of areas I mean if you think of what’s standing there in terms of carbon stock biodiversity and all the environmental services that are there that’s huge and then we said well let’s do another calculation let’s do it for the whole Amazon the legal Amazon and we got to a number of 20 million hectares and these are areas as we said that they’re privately owned.

They could be deforested tomorrow. There’s nothing protecting them. So command and control.

Andre Guimaraes:

Just to as a as to compare Marcel, it’s about two times Pennsylvania state in the area that can be legally deforested in the Amazon.

Marcelo Stabile:

True. Correct. Thanks, Andre. And so, you know, command and control will not solve this problem. What can solve this problem is to create something that identifies where these areas are CONSERVd, quantify what kind of environmental benefits you have from conserving these areas, what kind of risk these areas are exposed to and how much you need to pay to CONSERV these areas. And we did all of these model models for Matugoseru and we’re expanding to the whole Amazon. So we figure out that one where we have deforestation pressure. I mean one of the things is we don’t have an infinite amount of money.

What we want to do is be very efficient. So we are targeting areas that have that are under threat of deforestation. So places where you have active deforestation going on may it be legal or illegal. So it’s a place where you do have deforestation. It’s a place where you do know what sort of ecosystem services are there and we looked at carbon stocks, we looked at connectivity to generate ecological corridors, we looked at water production and we looked at presence of biodiversity and that helps us determine where to go. And so what we are doing is testing CONSERV on the ground in a few locations to prove that or to test the hypothesis that through targeted compensation we can avoid legal deforestation.

And I’ll leave you to more questions Jonah. Thanks.

Jonah:

Great. So I love this. This is a combination of payment for ecosystem services and strategy and maybe we can even rival some of the red plus financing stuff of the past. So let’s compare it to that a little bit. Can you tell us how this strategy com compares to Red Plus? Tell us a little bit about Red Plus for those who might not know. And then how do you guys through this system address questions of leakage and additionality and permanence?

Unidentified participant:

So.

Marcelo Stabile:

Okay please compliment me Andre if I miss something. So red was you know conceived back in the early 2000s and was part of that conception which was the reduced compensation for reduced emissions and it added a red and it added the plus and the idea is that you find areas that have an additionality in the sense of there are areas that are not protected and you need to protect them. The issue is that you know a lot of the red finance that’s been going on it has to do with carbon projects or a lot of carbon projects and private properties and where the way you design the baseline is not something that necessarily identifies the exact locations that are at risk.

And what we are doing is we’re looking at locations that are at risk and that are potentially deforestable. Sorry for the strange word. But that could be converted to cattle ranching or to agriculture, but we want them to stay as forests. And so what we are doing and we’re testing this experiment one to see if our hypothesis is true that through targeted compensation we can avoid this deforestation. But more than that, what we’re doing is talking to partners to try to find a way that we can make this become more permanent, John, in the way that we can have the farmer having his business of meat production, soy production, and ecosystem services.

Because at the end of the day, and you know, I always say this, it’s not a matter of if these 20 million hectares will be deforested, it’s a matter of when. And we need to delay that as much as we can. Actually, we should avoid it forever because that does have serious implications to agricultural production in Brazil, to agricultural production in other places, and to the climate of the world. So, we need we have, you know, we have to keep these areas standing, and we need to be efficient in it.

And so, we’re trying this thing, and, you know, it’s novel because it’s never been done like this before. Anything else Andre?

Andre Guimaraes:

Yeah, it might be worth complimenting eventually. That’s one of your questions, John. But where CONSERV is right now and putting it a little bit in perspective, CONSERV is we are like one-third invested already. So when we are going to be fully invested in maybe three to four months, we’ll be fully invested. Meaning we’ll have contracted somewhere between 20 and 25,000 hectares. So that’s the size of CONSERV. We like to call CONSERV an open sky experiment. So as Marcelo said, we are testing the ground. We are testing the hypothesis of if we pay a certain amount, they will give up their right at least for a certain period of time, they’ll give up their right to the forest.

So that’s the hypothesis we are testing with CONSERV. And if that hypothesis is confirmed, we have all the elements to you know convince the government to create public policies or investors or private investors to go in that direction because we do believe that’s a very reliable carbon credit if it is developed under a jurisdiction just like we are trying to do with CONSERV. It’s also important to say John and friends that CONSERV is not generating carbon credits at this point in time. It’s basically as I said an experiment. We are contracting these areas for three years.

So across three years we’ll ma monitor and make sure that you know we document and we evaluate everything that is happening in that in those farms and in those areas so that we can expand CONSERV in size and in time. And expansion in time means converting these areas in the future in the near future two or three years from now into carbon credits for example. We do know that in average and please Marcelo correct me if I’m wrong but on average each hectare that we are protecting has somewhere between 100 and 120 tons of carbon stored there and we are hiring those hectares for less than $100 a year.

So it seems to be a natural way to in the future convert those areas into carbon and the permanence of those protected areas within private properties would depend upon the carbon markets which we expect to be functioning in the in the near future. Well that just wanted to compliment Marcel.

Jonah:

Okay let’s get practical for a second. Let’s imagine that I have a 100 hectares. It’s high deforestation risk area. It’s in one of the two municipalities that have qualified for the program. How much do you guys pay me to not deforest one of these hectares that I’m allowed to legally and that income what does that compare to what I might earn otherwise?

Unidentified presenter:

Excellent question. We try to match Jonah. This is a principle we have. I mean the farmer you know they certainly have their expectations of return over that area. So we do know we and we have analyzed that expectation. So we did a very in-depth study about the opportunity cost for different lands for different crops for different types of land use and so on. So we have an idea of what’s the expectation of the farm the farmer and we try to sort of match the amount that we’ll pay with that expectation.

So we always try to pull it down. It’s always a negotiation that we do one-on-one. It’s a one-on-one negotiation and it depends on the expectation on one side and our capacity to pay on the other side. The average payment at this point in time, we have signed seven contracts and have hired close to 10,000 hectares, 9 to 10,000 hectares already and their average is around 300 eyes, right Marcelo? So it’s a little around $5560 per hectare per year. So it’s a three-year contract. So it’s three times that amount. So it’s around $5560$60 per hectare per year.

That’s what we are paying.

Jonah:

Wow. Save the Amazon for $50 per hectare per year. This could gather a lot of interest especially from the carbon markets. It’s very affordable for the ecosystem services that it provides. Tell us a little bit about the municipalities, the city level governments and their role in monitoring and enforcement.

Unidentified presenter:

Can I go in? Do you want to go?

Unidentified participant:

Go ahead. Go ahead.

Unidentified presenter:

Basically, we’re operating in one municipality, Jonah, but we’re actually, you know, prospecting properties in another three locations. COVID did not help us very much in our field trips as you can imagine but we are managing you know to talk to a lot of producers. We were having you know meetings every other week and finding these producers and you know that’s one of the points that IPAM does very well. We have a lot of data platforms information platforms. That’s one of the roles that IPAM sees it can have when CONSERVd gain scale is monitoring.

So what we do is quarterly monitoring of the farms and we do that through satellite imagery, image classification using public and private data and we do also go in the field at least in this you know beginning to talk to the farmers and it’s really interesting because one of the successes comes from the fact that you know you build a trust relationship and with these farmers and Andre was you know was talking that we do three-year contracts in And it was funny because right after we signed the first contracts, these guys wanted to extend it already and we said wait let’s you know we’ll get we’ll get there so keep on going.

But we do as I said you know quarterly monitoring the payments are twice a year and you know farmers are glad to participate. We have some curious stories from the field. We were there recently and it’s it looks very good. Fires. There are a lot of fires in the Amazon seasonally. Sometimes you can be implicated in a fire you didn’t start. Or you can claim you didn’t start it.

Jonah:

What happens if, if some if some my land gets burned down?

Unidentified presenter:

That’s a great question, Jonah. And you know we have a legal contract that contract that stipulates what happens in that case. So the first thing is you know the people that are contracted they need to show us a fire prevention plan and there are places in the Amazon you know more in the Sahadu actually that do catch on fire relatively easily and what they have to do is have this plan. We haven’t had any incidents of fire yet, thank goodness. And the thing is, you know, if fire comes, people are have to implement the plan, show that they’re doing their job, and we need to, you know, say it’s close to a payment, then we’re going to pause that payment, not do it on the date and talk to farmers and try to figure out what the cause of the fire is.

If there’s minimal impact to the contracted area, there might not be any consequences. But if there is significant or if there is con if there are consequences to the contracted area, depending on him or her doing this intentionally, I mean, if there’s an intentional fire, there’s, you know, a fine. They have to give us all the money back and some. There’s a fine on that. But if they can prove it’s not int unintentional that they put in place their fire prevention plan, we can just resize the contract and exclude that area.

But we I don’t think that’s going to happen. And you know, that’s one of the cool stories. About three weeks ago, one of the farmers sent us a photo and he bought a 20,000 liter tank, one of those like petrol tanks that one of those trucks that takes petrol around the c around the highways, but it has it has a water pump that will throw water 200 feet from it. And he said, I bought this with, you know, some of the other farmers so we can fight any fire that comes to the properties.

So that’s, you know, good use of the money. We were very happy about that.

Unidentified presenter:

He actually named the truck concert is the name of the truck.

Jonah:

Excellent. Okay, couple more quick questions. People are excited to ask questions which is great news for you guys. So we’ll be quick. Give me quick answers if you can. What is the motto groso PCI strategy in the rur the red early movers program and what role do they play?

Unidentified presenter:

Okay. Well, that’s a difficult one to respond quickly, but well, the PCI John, as you might know, it’s a it’s a it’s an effort from Mogroso State that groups together the P for protection actually for production, the C for CONSERVion and the I for inclusion. So, it works with the three dimensions, the economic, the environmental and the social dimension of land use. So, Matroso is a it’s a land use state. I mean is the single largest producer of agricultural products. So they’ve set up about four or five years ago the PCI which among other initiatives is promoting the implementation of red plus initiatives in matroso particularly on the under the sea under the CONSERVion efforts.

There are still several stages to go. Mroso is being prepared as a jurisdictional to participate in the red plus markets. They’re not ready yet. They’re coming. They’re falling into place. They’re modifying their legislation, adapting their procedures, creating a an accounting system. So, there are quite a few things being done at Matagroso so that they will be eligible and prepared for red plus. They are on the way. They have re recently received a grant from Germany and the UK if I’m not wrong to increase their capacity. It’s a red early movers program that they have received funding for improvements in matroso and it’s important to say that CONSERV is one of the projects of the PCI program.

So it’s in the pipeline of the PCI and it’s contributing because it’s investing precisely on CONSERVion inside private properties in MATL. So it’s completely aligned with the efforts of the PCI. I don’t know maybe Ruben can compliment me. I don’t know. I was going to say that, you know, EGF Yeah, EGF put together a pitchbook for the PCI and can serve as one of the initiatives. The only thing is we’re also contributing to the production because there’s another farmer that spent a good part of his money investing in genetics to improve his cattle herd.

So, we were happy about that, too. And you know, that’s what we see is the future. If they get compensated for doing good in terms of CONSERVion and they can improve their productivity and their on their already cleared lands, that’s a win-winwin situation for everyone because we’re producing more, conserving more, and valuing the forest and the producer doing the right thing.

Jonah:

Okay, last question from me and then we’re going to open it up. Let’s talk for a moment about scale. So, the word in Portuguese is bashidoris. In the, circles of Congress, there’s a push to open up Brazilian, carbon credits to international markets. If this happens, it means that Brazil may be the home of some of the largest forest financing mechanisms in the world. I’ve posted a link about it. This spells an opportunity for carbon markets and your program. I also understand that ARI has been developing a carbon accounting mechanism. Talk to us about scale.

Tell us about the role of the future of Brazilian carbon markets. Tell us about ARE’s carbon accounting program and tell us about the future scale scaling opportunities of CONSERV in collaboration with private investors.

Unidentified presenter:

Let me just say one thing John about that. Within this 20 21 million hectares of land or forest actually that can legal can be legally deforested in farms. We have done a very rough calculation and we’re talking here between five and six gigatons of carbon that can be released to the atmosphere. That’s three years of Brazilian emissions more than three years of Brazilian emissions of carbon. So it’s a it’s a huge potential and that is important to say that the efforts the governmental efforts the Agri efforts the matroso efforts most of those efforts go in the direction of fighting illegal deforestation because that’s the majority of the forest more than 90% of the deforestation in the Amazon is illegal right so most of the efforts are to drop down the deforest the illegal deforestation and very little if any is being done on the on the legal side of the of the deforestation.

So we see that the combination of public sector efforts whether they are state level or federal level combined with incentives which is the case of CONSERV to private land owners the end result is as Marcelo was saying eventually more production or more intensification in the production and more CONSERVion at the same time generating the benefits that we need. I don’t know specifically about Acri. What I know is that Akri maybe Marcel or Ruben can compliment me but Akri Acri has launched Akri was actually a pioneer because they’ve started this you know carbon credit calculations and the potential for the insertion of a in the red plus system pretty early in the process more than 10 12 years ago.

So a has created the structures but this last time this last election the AR has changed its political orientation and the new government which you know has just arrived and it’s completely different in the opposite direction of the previous four governments in a in a row. They have they have still they haven’t yet found the right position for a potential in carbon credits but you know in different levels John the different states are trying to develop their own agendas GCF as Colleen might agree here with me has been instrumental in you know pushing the states to debate legislation and adapting themselves to the future the potential but you know it’s we’re talking here about potential Because you know it the regulation, the jurisdiction, the law, the centralized accounting are not ready yet, at least not for carbon credits despite the big discussion that we are having in the Congress with a new bill that has been discussed in the Congress, the Brazilian the National Congress for environmental services.

Actually, that one was approved. There’s another bill that discusses particularly the carbon the Brazilian carbon markets which is also under discussion. There’s another one for forest concessions which is also under discussion and might allow for forest public forest concessions for red plus side projects. So there are quite a number of initiatives both at the state level and the federal level that would go in the direction of you know allowing for those standing forest storing carbon to have a value in the market but we still have quite a bit of a way to go.

Jonah:

Private investors and then we’ll move on to Hamriita as our first question. Could you guys just tell us a little give us one or two sentences about the role of private investors?

Unidentified presenter:

Oh that one is for us.

Unidentified presenter:

Yeah. Sorry, sorry. Come again. Johnny,.

Jonah:

What is the role of private investors in the long-term scaling of CONSERV?

Unidentified presenter:

Uhhuh. Well, I see well quite a few roles. The first role is to invest in the agricultural intensification because we need to produce more food to more mouths across the world. So I think there’s a tremendous potential to invest in the turnaround of farms. There are lots of farms that are degraded, you know, degraded pasture, but they are still a farm. They have good you know conditions to produce more. So one way I see the potential to invest it is to invest in the turnaround and the intensification of Brazilian agriculture and there are many different techniques and methods of producing agriculture to produce more per area and port dollar invested and so on.

So this is on one hand on the other hand to invest in the environmental services. The most mature markets are the carbon markets. You know, there are many corporations that are looking for carbon credits in the Amazon. And I think there’s a there’s a challenge there on the on the Brazilian side which is prepare the necessary legislation and incentives and so on to have them in place so that when the market would come in a organized manner, the legislation and the capacities of the institutions to respond to the to the demand are prepared.

But at this point in time, as I said before, there is still a couple of years at least of a time to go until the states in the Amazon are prepared for the private investors to come.

Jonah:

Great Amriita.

Amrita:

Hi, thanks Jonah. It’s a good segue. Hi Andrea and Marcelo. Thank you for your presentation, all your good work. We’re private investors in projects that invest in natural climate solutions, payments for environmental services and carbon. So this work that you’re doing is highly relevant and much needed. So thank you. I’m curious to learn more about sort of the technology and the tools that you use to for monitoring and for you know ensuring that the payments are actually working as intended. Could you speak a little bit more about that? Thanks.

Andre Guimaraes:

Excellent question, Brit. I’m sure Marcelo would love to respond that one, right, Marcel?

Marcelo Stabile:

Yeah, I mean, we use a series I mean, Brazil has a pretty robust deforestation monitoring system in place, but it only publishes its data once a year. And what we’re doing is we’re looking at areas that we’ve contracted quarterly. So, we do a lot of image classification in house and we’re automating that. We’ve tested, you know, our algorithms that are automatically identifying change are performing very close to manual inspection. So, we’re doing that. And you know, in this experimental phase, we want to go a lot to the field to see what are the challenges that producers see and to have this interaction because we believe it enriches the whole process very much.

So we do go a lot to the field that’s you know a high transaction cost but it’s part of the experiment once you gain scale you can do sampling and you can do the remote monitoring and when you have you know a red a yellow flag you can go there or a red flag you go there and you stop payment so you know it’s the criteria for decision making and I lost the second bit of the question Marita sorry.

Amrita:

No I think I think you answered that my question. That’s great.

Jonah:

Great. Philippa, you’re up next. And if Philip is not there, then Colleen.

Colleen:

Okay, I’ll jump in quickly. And I think you’ve really alluded to this already. Thanks for this great presentation. I’m always trying to figure out how do we help states go faster, further, all of that stuff. And Macho Groso actually arguably has the most money, the most support. They’ve got a really pretty robust state government compared to the rest of the states even like Ara. And so I’m always wondering what from your perspective do you see are some gaps and opportunities if we think about how can we capacitate these states because they don’t move quickly and they don’t have a whole lot of resources often.

So what is the case of macho grosser that we what’s if you were going to say like a wish list, how do we best help these states to prepare for this because I see the private sector moving faster?

Andre Guimaraes:

I would this is a tough one to respond Colleen and you might agree with me but I see two main challenges that the states have to face. The first one is people you know human capacity you know technical people to address the matter to understand the potential you know they are very good at for example in paran you know they have lots of expertise within the state for mining for you know licensing for agriculture etc but you know zero if any capacity to deal with environmental services so this is across the states in the matroso and for me are exceptions you know mroso for the dimension and the intensity and acry for the fact that they’ve been talking about it for a long time but there are except exceptions so I think one is human.

Capital you know to address to understand to you know challenge the governor to propose to the governor to create a better debate within the states so this is one challenge the other one. Is a more institutional challenge the institutions within the states they’re not prepared you know as you know in a they had to create a company an independent company you know to deal with the with the environmental services schemes because within the state they wouldn’t do that because of the Brazilian legislation which sort of you know creates lots of obstacles for negotiating assets public assets like carbon credits for example so.

It’s I’d say that there is a human capacity challenge and an institutional challenge and both of them they have to evolve you know at the same time and in most of the states you have none of them. Acre and [state name unclear] are definitely exceptions.

Marcelo Stabile:

Can I just compliment real quick? And I think there’s this thing I mean a lot of the folks that are there, the producers, they see the unfor the forested land which they can still clear as you know the alter they don’t see the alternative of keeping the forest standing. They see the alternative of I’ll chop this down. I can get a license. I can chop this down and I can put cattle and I won’t make a whole heck of a lot of money, but you know, it’ll be some money. And we need as investors and as citizens to show them that there’s value on that area.

There’s a lot of value on the CONSERVd areas because that’s essential even for their production in the future. I mean if you look at the local implications of climate change and we have papers on that areas that you have more deforestation you have more water stress then you don’t than where you have more forest and that implies on planting dates how much you spend to produce. So it’s an education also of the people so that the farmer can see that he’s going to have an income from soy which this year is great and from cattle ranching which this year is great and maybe an income that this year from the CONSERVion might not be as great as soy but it’s more constant through time.

So we need as a group to develop those solutions and that’s what we’re trying to do.

Jonah:

Peter, you have a follow-up question to Colleen’s. Oh,.

Peter:

Hi. Thanks, Jonah. Yes, and congrats Marcelo and Andrea on the presentation and very interesting CONSERV. Yeah, just following on from Berlin there. It’s my impression sometimes that when one wants to get things done in lots of places, but especially Brazil, that the less you get involved with the state at all, the better or the more likely you are to get somewhere. And I don’t know to what extent that’s fair for your model.

Andre Guimaraes:

No, I just saw your question here. I’m glad you’ve asked, Peter. This is an excellent one. Right now in this experimental phase, CONSERV is 100% private. So, I have I don’t care if the state has a law or a person or an expertise or legislation. Honestly, it doesn’t matter, right? Because it’s a private to private is a private organization signing a contract with a private individual. But that’s only because of the experimental phase. When we go into the market phase, when we start trading carbon, Peter, we can’t do it. We have to have the state.

The state is the one that will supposedly have the centralized accounting of what’s going on in their territory with regards to reductions or increasing carbon emissions. Because we have to know that at the end of the day we want the sum of these parts all of the states all of the countries in the world to contribute positively to end deforestation. So if I don’t have a centralized accounting system to make sure that I’m going positive, my efforts are my efforts meaning mankind’s effort as a whole are going positive. You know, if I don’t have control over it, I may have some what we call leakage, right?

So if we don’t have a centralized accounting system of the carbon credits that are being generated and eventually traded, right? If you don’t have control of that, you may have parallel negotiations. So at the end of the day, we have a very strong and robust carbon credit markets with lots of transactions all across the globe and zero or little contribution to the object of these markets which is to cope with climate change. So I don’t know if I was clear but this is unfortunately at some point in the future we’ll have to deal with governments.

Peter, there’s no way out.

Jonah:

I want to invite Ruben to speak, but just Colleen if you would like to make a comment just to follow on the tail end of this.

Colleen:

It’s okay. I was just actually talking about how state sharing capacity because Andrea is right. Ara and Mroso, they’re the leaders and everyone else is kind of following behind. And so I’m always trying to think of how can we be most efficient in getting resources in there. And I think you hit it on the head, Andre, when you said, you know, people. You got to get the people that know these programs and then the institutions. What’s get which gets into Peter’s question because without a state system, without the laws, without the policies, there’s no way to have it truly be jurisdictional.

That’s it. Thank you.

Jonah:

Great, Ruben.

Ruben:

Thanks, Jonath. Hi, everyone. I just wanted to highlight that I think one of the exciting things about CONSERV is it’s starting with some small areas to test and refine the approach but the goal is to really create a programmatic strategy and mechanism that’s really can be scaled because a lot of traditional carbon projects one of the challenge is that they have a lot of you know we heard a lot of high transaction costs a lot of subjectivity in the methodologies and the idea here is to create an approach that can really have a standardized setup that can scale across you know a huge you know basically all the private lands in the Amazon and eventually other biomes too.

So the idea is really you know I think this is what makes it really exciting that it’s sort of a scalable approach that could fit in within a jurisdictional you know system but that goes beyond sort of oneoff projects you know for particular locations it’s and part of the inspiration was in the US there’s something called the CONSERVion reserve program the CRP which since the early 80s has paid about $2 billion a year to private farmers to keep environmentally sensitive crop land areas out of production and in environment you know environmental covers like trees and other habitat and you know this is this is an area of about 35 million acres since 1985 it’s based on a reverse auction approach it’s run by the USDA I mean this is and it’s worked extremely Well, I mean, there’s questions about how it could be done better, but basically there’s a lot I mean, it’s a lot of money, but it’s been estimated to have, you know, 10 or 15 times the benefits relative to the cost.

And you could imagine something like that in Brazil where the benefits would be even more dramatic and the, you know, relative to the cost. And it wouldn’t necessarily have to be run by the government. It could be run privately. But there’s a precedent for this kind of atscale approach.

Jonah:

Great. If somebody could fetch the web link for the CONSERVion reserve program and paste it in the chat, that’d be great. Next up is Sophia.

Sophia:

Hello. Sorry, I was just finding my question. So I wanted to ask, you know, whether you find that the land owners that you’re working with are aware that they can legally deforest this land. So they’re aware of the kind of legal rules around their land use and then what has been stopping them from cutting that down in the past so that it is still there today. Thanks so much for your presentation.

Unidentified presenter:

Hey Sophia,.

Unidentified presenter:

That’s all yours my friend.

Unidentified presenter:

Okay. Well they do know that they can deforest legally. There are challenges in Brazil with, you know, what Colleen and Andrea were talking about that, you know, you might have the right to get a license to deforest and you apply for that today and you it might take you three to five years to get that license and you don’t want to be an outlaw. So, that’s a real issue. There’s an issue of you know some of the farmers that see it’s funny because they don’t identify it directly but when you speak to them and you talk to them they see the importance of the native vegetation and so they know they can they don’t want to be outlaws.

Some of them understand the importance of CONSERVion and some of them have been waiting for this opportunity to rise for them for years and years to come. And there was one guy that he wasn’t contracted but we spoke to him a long time ago. He said my kids won’t let me do anything because I would have chopped it all down. So you know you get extremes from all of the ends. And at the end of the day, I think, you know, the idea is that once they see the value of it, they can realize that and think of it as a business.

And so, you know, they do know what they what they can do. And just on another note on our trip to the field, from the 6,480 hectares that we’ve contracted of areas that could be legally deforested, roughly 4,200 roughly are areas that could be could have grains, could have soy, could have cotton, could have corn. And 100% of the areas could become pasture lands for cattle ranching. So, we’re not contracting, you know, these really slopey areas with rocky and very bad soils. It’s areas that could be in production. So, yeah,.

Unidentified presenter:

This is one of one of the criteria of you. It’s a very important question because this is one of the criteria. We don’t want to contract areas that are not at risk. So that’s why we’ve put together a number of indicators and we basically have an index of priority and one of the criteria is precisely risk of deforestation or risk of conversion.

Jonah:

Up next is Mara.

Mara:

Hi there. Fascinating initiative. I’m very excited. I was wondering if you could say a little bit more about the farmers that are interested in this in terms of are there more cattle farmers, soy farmers, or there any other characteristics that emerge as that’s the type of farmer that is willing to enter into this experiment.

Marcelo Stabile:

U maybe Andre can compliment me, but I would say a couple of things. All of the farmers that have been contracted they want to be in line with the law. So we do a very thorough due diligence and check. We do background checks. We check the property. We check a lot of things. But all of them are committed to following Brazilian law. And I think that’s something that has been undervalued internationally because it’s not an easy task. It’s very it’s a very complex legislation for you to do things in the time that you need to do things.

So, 100% of them are compliant and concerned about that. We do have cattle ranchers that do complete cycle. We do, have cattle ranchers that are doing finishing. We have soy cotton farmers that do double cropping of soy and cotton. We have other double crops. So, some of them do soy and then they do pasture. And there’s one that is doing soy, cotton, and pasture as three crops. So we have kind of a myriad of options thus far.

Andre Guimaraes:

Just complimenting very quickly, Mariki. There’s an issue because you know some of those products like soy, cotton are export products. The exports of Brazil have increased substantially in the past couple of years particularly soy to China and also the exchange rate has is now benefiting exporters because the dollar is up. So you know that combination of exports increasing of some products and the favorable exchange rate has pushed the opportunity cost of the land up. So, you know, and but again, we still don’t have enough information to measure the impact of that.

But we know that some of the farmers that are still coming to talk to us are talking about higher numbers than they were talking one year ago. And most likely that’s because of these two factors combined. So, you know, the expectation of the financial return of the land do have an impact in those contracts. Indeed.

Jonah:

So, we don’t have much time left. So real quick from Bejorn.

Bjorn:

Right. Thank you CONSERV for this very interesting presentation. So I’ve been working with carbon offsets in central Africa where reforestation was the selling point. And this ties in with the previous question. What would be the cost for you to commission a farmer to re replant or reforest an a hectare?

Unidentified presenter:

Do you know.

Unidentified presenter:

What is the investment needed to restore one hectare?

Bjorn:

Well, if you want to pay a farmer to do it, yes. How much would you have to pay?

Unidentified presenter:

At least minimum $1,000 per hectare, but it could go up to $5,000 per hectare. John, it’s extremely variable depending on the level of degradation of the land, depending on the on the you know, the investment that you need to make to bring the seedlings from far away. I mean, it’s very variable. So, it varies between one and $5,000 per hectare. That’s the investment needed,.

Bjorn:

Right? Thanks. And the farmers that need to restore, they have a they’re not complying with the law. So, they’re behind in that term. And if you’re helping them reforest, what you’re trying to or what you’re doing is in effect, you’re helping them become compliant with the law.

Unidentified presenter:

Usually,.

Jonah:

Great. Did you have a followup, Yorn?

Bjorn:

Yeah. What? You’re helping them be compliant with the law or helping them to become outlaws? Reforesting. Sorry about that.

Unidentified presenter:

No, what I’m saying is usually the farmers that are doing restoration is because they don’t have enough forest cover on their property.

Bjorn:

So they’re they are not following the legislation.

Unidentified presenter:

So in our case, we only have farmers that do more than the legislation. Obviously, obviously you can do an agroforestry system, cacao, asai and other stuff that can give them an income, but not as part of the restoration of their legal reserve areas in Brazil.

Unidentified presenter:

Yeah, but we’re not looking just to be clear, we’re not looking at restoration at CONSERV. Now there’s a huge potential because the deficit of areas because we are looking at the assets or the surplus but there’s a deficit also in many other properties and deficit is way bigger than the potential of CONSERV but at this point we are focusing CONSERV on the assets on the surpluses but the potential is there and we are we know where the potential is and we are beginning to you know make up our minds on how can We through the CONSERV mechanism also invest in restoration but we are we are not there yet.

We haven’t yet finalized the analysis but there’s indeed a potential but a different one.

Bjorn:

Right. Thank you.

Jonah:

Okay we are at the top of the hour. Thank you so much presenters. What a remarkable presentation. What a remarkable innovation. What remarkable science has gone into the design of it. Thank you call-in partners for joining us. We are now converting the call over to free time. Most people leave, but I’m going to stay around. The chat room is going to stay open and I’m going to turn off the recording. Thanks so much everybody. See you next week.

Unidentified presenters — closing remarks:

Thanks, John. Thank you all. Nice to see you all. Thanks. Bye guys. Thanks.

Jonah:

May 24th through Oh, wait. I’m gonna stop the recording.