Root Causes, Rule of Law, and Delivery Units

Daniela Castro: Today we learn about governance, rule of law and the Brazilian Amazon. An attorney and impact advisory consultant and founder of Impacta Advocacy, Daniela Castro sought to understand the root causes of Amazon deforestation. Through a lengthy investigation of industry, policy, law enforcement, and government operations, she has identified key levers for change, including mechanisms that monitor and support the operation, transparency, and accountability of government programs – a “Delivery Unit.” Join us to learn more.

Recorded January 25, 2021

References:
Amazon Investor Coalition Survey on Philanthropy for Governance and Rule of Law

First UN Global Report on Environmental Rule of Law (2019)

WATCH:

  • Jonah (moderator)
  • Daniela Castro
  • Participant — European Forest Institute
  • Marina
  • Fiona
  • Nina
  • Walter
  • Unidentified participants

Jonah:

Hello everybody. Welcome to the 30th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call and podcast series dedicated to advancing forest-friendly economic development across the Amazon region. This week, Daniela Castro is our presenter. She leads an impact advisory firm called Impacta Advisory, part Portuguese, part English. That’s a some great branding. And she’s going to speak to us a bit about rule of law in the Amazon region. You can’t have healthy economic development without a healthy rule of law and governance system to back it. So Daniela, please tell us a little bit about yourself.

And then from what I understand, you also have a presentation to offer.

Daniela Castro:

Yes, thank you Jonah for the invitation. It’s an honor to be here and share some thoughts and also contribute to this debate. Well, my name is Daniela Castro. I am a lawyer and I have a master degree in economics and I started my career working at the private sector but most part of my career I worked to NGOs implementing advocacy plans and also I worked for the government. I w I was for 10 years a CEO of an advocacy organization that fight against corruption in sports. And I also received the title of emerging leader of a US federal program created by Hillary Clinton.

And in 2016 I decide to start my social enterprise Impact Advocacy and we help to build advocacy plans and implement them. We work only with projects that have positive impact and project projects that are related to the sustained development goals. So two years ago, I was invited by a Brazilian organization to help to create an advocacy plan to against the forestation in public lands. And last year a social investor in Brazil asked me to organize an analysis about the root causes of the forestation in Amazon and also to survey some advocaces.

So and also last year and I finished the presentation and I was in the beginning of the creation of Amazonia Viva and I was very moved by the problem in Amazon. So today I want to share with you a presentation talk a little bit about advocacy and root causes h advocacies and strategies. So and I want to talk about this focus on governance and rule of law and after this I will share the some points of this work that we did some analysis of the root causes and I and also I will talk about some strategies as deliver units or private agreements that could be a good way to create impact in this complex problem.

So I will share I wish I could be brief. So it’s okay the are you seeing? Yes. Okay.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, we see it.

Daniela Castro:

Okay. So let me arrange this ugly. So advocacy is an strategy used to change behaviors, policies or system. H is not lobbing is it’s a strategy that lobbing can be one of them but is not just lobbing or try to influence the government. So to we create impact we can do we can act directly with a social action with beneficuaries and it’s important because we have to do sometimes emergency measures and it’s as we saw with Amazonia Viva for example and a devocus initiative is more effective ive if you work on the root causes h but it demands long term and but it is longlasting.

So first I want to just you may know about changes but I want to if you want to create changes and we when we talk about governance and law and it’s very complex but h changes is complex we are talking about problems that are complex interconnected we have several stakeholders and interests and Amazon it’s a complex problem. Change is unpredictable. Obstacles are structural, political and sometimes related to the rule of the game. Most public policies have implementation problems such as poor management and governance. In 2017 the World Bank published a report talking about governance and law and it’s a problem in around the world to sometimes we have law it’s the case in Amazon but the problem is the implementation of them policies and decisions are created and made with or without us social participation and the decision came from those of those who are engaged.

So the first thing that we have to do is join the game and we have to know how to join the game also and but there is some it’s important I said this slide because it’s important when we will talk about strategies that there are some conditions that permits that change happen. One of them is political commitment. So if the leader is committed with the cause or with the with the change is easier. And the second is clear goals, efficient management, viability, constancy and measurement of public policies. A constant relation with decision makers.

It’s not only be there for one meeting. You have to be there all the time. Public demand. Of course, we can say pressure but also support. Take action to solve root causes and take care because sometimes we act on the symptoms and changes in mentality and culture occurs in a long term but also is long are longlasting. So when you have a clear vision of the change so we can choose some strategies, some approaches as lobbying, communication campaigns, coalitions, research and private agreements or litigation. So there is many forms to influence or and or to try to create change but I will focus on public policies.

So public policies and I focus because we want to change reality in a large scale. Most causes is not only about Amazon. We can talk about education, health, violence are related to public policy. We need to influence the government. We need the states to approve laws to implement public policy or to avoid setbacks. So rule of law I think it’s very important and I saw a lot of material good material in the in the website and this is one quote from the word bank. Governance is a process through which state and non-state actors interact to design and implement policies within a given set of formal and informal rules that shape and are shaped by the power.

So it’s governance is very important and you we have a huge problem in different causes related to governance. Oh okay but it’s impossible to change government. No, it isn’t. There are many progress in humanity that we succeed. It’s not easy, but we have examples and behind those initiatives, you can find a plan or an strategy and a constancy of funding and also a constant u work to change. So this is a few steps that I bring to you when I build a plan. It’s and it’s an advocacy plan is not is not to know the proposals or the solutions.

It’s how to implement change. This is what I think that civil society has to focus. How to implement? We know what we have to do but how to implement is so difficult and in this case is so urgent. So first so I some few only a few steps first clear define the change with measurable goals if possible I call it impact goal in the long term in order to achieve large scale results it’s possible to be more tangible to be more measurable sometimes a deep diagnosis focus on the root causes that generate the problem.

Define key results or intermediate goals that are necessary to accomplish change. This is very important. If you want to influence the government, you we have to be you have to know everything. It’s as like one day the government said to you, okay, you will be the environmental minister, you can do whatever you want. So the civil societ society has to know what are this key result what has to be done mapping trait resistance barriers stakeholders decision makers political power and context laws public policy budget international mechanisms risks so it’s very important to map everything in order to define better strategies And one point is important is the barrier is that if we can articulate different agents towards coordinate actions.

This is a very important thing coordinate investment coordinate actions and after all this then we define the activities. So and now I will show some points of this study that we made. This is Amazon. I use a photo from a friend and this is a huge problem. It’s a complex problem. So we this is an example for example that there is it is a complex problem. Where deforestation happens. We can say that the major deforestation areas occurring and on private lands, non-desated public lands, the major increase of deforestation since 2013 occur on non-desated public lands in private in private lands and environment environmental protection areas at the same with the wildfires.

So this is important because for example if we want to end deforestation private lands we have to analyze different stakeholders different laws different governmental agenda agencies. So the same for nondigenated public lands. So this is a complex and each plan or each action strategy you have to know everything about the ecosystem the system of the change that we you want to influence and the next step and I think it’s very important when we especially in governance and law but not only we is to map the root causes And we did an exercise here mapping the root causes.

80% of the problems come from 20% of all cause causes. So it’s very important and this allowed to be more effective when you are implementing advocacy plan. So we analyze this using some methodologies as the five W’s Shikawa diagram and we use these we start on prim on some primary causes land grabbing illegal logging agriculture livestock. It was an extensive work to do this and we found seven root causes categories responsible for Amazon deforestation. Bureaucracy, inspection, monitoring, impunity, private and public resources, marketing, mental mentality and culture. So if we take a look on these first four or maybe five we can realize that all of them are related to rule of law and governance.

So it’s we have to work influence the government. So this is clear when you look at the root causes of Amazon deforestation but not only in Amazon. It’s normal when you talk about some causes some social problems. This is something that we do. I think it’s an exercise. You can you can create another one but it’s when you have a lot of root causes how you can prioritize. So we did a prioritization here rate severity urgency impact and scale and we use this to propose solution in the short and long run.

So it helps to do this because when you see Amazon and the forestation rate it’s urgent. Maybe we are getting the turning point. So it’s very important to end the forestation and the government has the power and the scale to do this. So this can be a good compass for you to decide investment or decide which project will be implemented. So we found monitoring private resources that means that cut money to the legal activities are also create incentives to a new economy for example bureaucracy and inspection. So this is an exercise that we did to show that it’s possible to prioritize because when you look the root causes and you say oh my god it’s complicated what the first thing that I have to do so this is a way and that’s and another thing it’s good if a different kind different investors or organization they share this kind of analysis because they can talk about initiatives and avoid duplicity for example.

So I choose some triggers that we think that can create a huge impact and it’s again it’s I choose those but you can choose another others. So first implementation of public policy such as the designation public forest. I will give an example. Withdrawal of funds for illegal activity. You can use this through private agreements. Digitalization and transparency of data in order to monitor change because without this you can implement public policy and you can implement some private agreements if you can monitor things and if we don’t have access to data and also incentives to new economy.

This is some again an example of what we can do with this information. So bureaucracy for example we interview people from the government and we know that some of non-desated public forests are in the government in the in the regional level. So this number so maybe we can work with the governors to designate this land. So maybe create a delivery unit for this to support the government because some problems the root causes that we found said to us that the problem is bureaucracy for example lack of skills or resources to do this and deliver units.

You can support the government and also is a pressure also you can monitor and help the grow the government to achieve the change that we want. So this is the first part of the study and let me check the okay and I bring some ideas about new advocacy strategies related to governance and law. So I will talk about first about implementation delivery units, second private agreement and the last one is financing advocacy initiative. For me it is an strategy to achieve change and is more a conclusion than a strategy. So you may know about the pol public policy cycle.

So first there is a problem identification setting agenda after this create a solutions and make a decision and after this implementation and this is as I said a big problem not only Brazil. So and when we if you want to influence the government and work with rule of law and implement politic policies, we have to understand they are there it is a very complex process. It’s not linear. We face technical and political challenges, ideological institutional context, complex network and social of social and official agents. Sometimes we have windows of opportunities, sometimes we don’t.

We are talking about big institutions fight against fragmentation, inertia, bureaucracy and sometimes with conflicting goals. Maybe you have a goal in the agriculture min with the agriculture ministry and the environment ministry has a different one. We have a problem of short-term vision in public policy, especially in Brazil, but I don’t think that it’s only our problem and a lack of reliable information and of course information as asymmetry. So the barriers to implement h it’s so it’s a challenge. Implementation is political. We have to understand that we have to be on the game and changes in political we face changes in political social and economic scenario.

A lack of political support and resultsdriven leadership. Bad management, governance and opera operational plans. Lack of focus, skills, results, flows and process, routines, deadlines and monitoring. I’ve been there. I know mistakes in projects in project planning and difficulty in regional projects work with different levels in the government. Bureaucracy resistance, low project priority, lack of incentives and conflict interests, stakeholders, differences, scarce and poorly deployed resources due to lack of prioritization and discontinuity of programs, difficulties in institutionalization, public policies for example. So we have to know this in order to create an strategy.

So an strate that I like to talk about is delivery units. So this is a model was first created in United Kingdom in 2001 during the tenure of prime minister Tony Blair and after its success in UK the model was adapt to the reality in about 30 countries around the world. Erh also in Latin America and also in Brazil. You have we have some examples of delivery units. So delivery units are focused on the search for concrete results that commit decision makers to long-term goals based on a cons and technical team.

Delivery units focus on prioritization and use data for constant monitoring of goals. Enable efficient identification and res resolution of obstacles to delivery of quality public service. And most of the time they have a support of the president or the ministry or the secretary the leader. This process foster meth methological and cultural change in public management allowing focus on long-term effects in favor of adoption of a complex and innovative process and routines. Yielding more effective results with an impact on improving the result results of public policies. So I saw many examples also in Brazil when civil society helped the government to create delivery units.

This is an in a strategy we are used to create strategy as pressure litigation and proof loss but this is an strategy that it’s very good and for example it demands negotiation it demands sometimes maybe organization that not that have this expertise but it’s something that I have some few examples in Brazil, but I believe that is a way because if the implementations our problem for example the certification of land property and the problem sometimes is to implement the certification of course that we have resistance and sometimes you cannot create a delivery unit or the government don’t doesn’t want it but sometimes you can so h and this is a way h well now the private agreements I like private agreements I’m I think that see I co I coordinate one against corruption in Brazil we have 32 big companies And I create the governance and all the strategy to this private agreement and I believe this is a great strategy especially in Amazon issue because private sectors private sector has a political power.

So sectoral and multis sectoral agreements bring together stakeholders with a common agenda and impactful action as a solution for negotiating and seeking consensus or agreement in on complex issues. Self-regulation can help solve public problems. Laws and policies affect business. Most social and political and economic problems require action for by public authorities. So we can organize the private sector to do this. Pacts can focus on governance and rule of law to unlock process and implement policies on the necessary scale so that agreements can be fulfilled. I have an example in Brazil.

The approval of the G digital plan different companies u helped to approve this plan and participate in the implementation of this plan. Political importance of influence with public authority but goals and governance of these agreements are very important for the success of the initiative. It’s not something that oh let’s sign a piece of paper. No, you have to define goals and governance and actions. So finance adox initi initiatives I think it’s an strategy that we need in Brazil. The funds for the focus. So it’s a very it’s difficult because you are saying that oh how we can change so this public policy is so complex so it’s not easy to raise a fund to advoc initiatives the investment decision must consider impact in this change the structural change and public policy.

So this is very important and this can bring impact and included unlock some process in different other strategies as incentives to new business. It’s important be sure whether pro projects works on root causes and the plan that the organization has and monitoring and be with the organization. It’s a very a good thing to do. It’s you can see the victories. You can understand what’s happening. And financing is a political force in the process of change. So, so I’m finishing and I will share some ideas. This is important maybe some ideas to the group.

I don’t know if I can do this Jonah but it’s create awareness about the importance to invest on governance and the material and I believe it and it’s urgent because the impact and the scale that some decisions have it’s huge. So we have to stop the firstation in the first place. We did a research about advocacy initiative. This investor Brazilian investor asked us to do this. It’s a first draft. It’s about the advocacy initiatives and we cross with root causes but it’s something very good that can help investor to decide investment in rule of law and governance or advocus initiatives and of course maybe some rules of causes we need some initiatives so maybe this investors can promote new advocacy initiatives so I finish with this ideas is and that’s it.

Thank you for the opportunity.

Jonah:

Great. Thank you Daniela for sharing with us. If you if you will, we’re going to move into questions now. I’m going to go ahead and start us off. I’m going to set the stage a little bit and then Yida Jesso already has a question. So first from me when I lived in Brazil my wife worked at the Kellogg Foundation this is the early 2000s I became familiar with sort of their impact analysis they pursued the three eyes the idea the individual and the innovation. I part of the opportunity here is for you to lead some investors and philanthropies in this rule of law direction and this implementation of delivery units.

So, I’d love it if you could share us a little bit about your experience dealing with sports and corruption surrounding sports because some of the same learnings there maybe apply to your leadership and your scholarship on rule of law in the Amazon.

Daniela Castro:

Well I work with human rights for 20 years and I with advocacy in a sport I start that’s when I start to study about change and I was a co so I have to deliver I that change could happen faster because it’s something that how can I be more efficient? So it was the first time that I creating I read a lot especially North America material because I think that you have great material experience and successful initiatives. So I create as a CEO a plan five year plan aocus plan and we decide we have a specific goal.

So we decide to learn everything about the problem and everything about public policies, everything about law and we interview stakeholders and we interview allies and opponents and then it was a an LO formed by 80 former athletes. Different modalities and they were they want to make an impact. So against the corruption but not only to promote public policies at schools and to increase the activity physical activity rate. So we created three goals. So double the physical activate in rate in Brazil. Physical activity in all the schools and a plan against the corruption.

So when we said that we could we decide some strategies. So let’s talk about the private sector. Let’s approve a law first that will that said we approve in fact in 2013 that decided to receive a public money sports entities have to follow some rules. So we have to some president of entity export entities remain in charge for 40 years. So it’s not possible. They have to share information about a transparency and accountability. So then if they do this they can receive public money. So after this we in the beginning after we was creating a coalition.

So we decide all this plan with other actors, other stakeholders and we try to share the tasks and financing and to avoid duplicity for example because it’s hard to raise money to advocacy. So we used to it’s better to work with others and in a coordinated way. So after this one thing that I always said that advocacy plan is a compass is not the plan is not the same plan when you do for example a project plan because part of the goals it’s outside organization. So you are trying to influence something.

So and so you have to know the path you have to set the strategy but it’s unpredictable. So after this I will tell because this private agreement a big company invited me to a meeting and said oh I know this law and it’s related to public funds but I am a sponsor of sport entities and I have risks and my compliancy and it was the same time that anti-corruption law was approved in Brazil. So how I can how can participate on this? And then I said why don’t you don’t to put this on your contract and said oh but if I do this my competitors can close the deal with the sport entity.

So we said if all the sponsors agree to not sponsor sport entities that are not aligned and are not following the law for example and it took one year and a half to build this private agreement. There isn’t a specific methodology for do this and we have to approve the agreement so we are talking about school and go competitors in inclusive so this is my experience in sports.

Jonah:

Great thank you for that some of the same experiences there can apply to the bankers in the private sector that is putting money into the Amazon region So, as we begin to move into questions, I just want to share with everybody. I’ve posted in the chat this link to this rule of law philanthropy survey that we’re doing. We’ve identified 26 different strategies to help defend and improve the governance and rule of law across the Amazon. We’ve identified about 90 different grant makers and bilateral agencies that are putting money into the Amazon region across all nine countries.

In our doors to figure out what are the strategies, what’s working, what’s not. We’re collaborating with Daniela on the design of it. The that is not the document I posted is not set in stone. You’re all invited to help make it into a better effort. So first up, we have Yida Jessu from the European Forest Initiative and then Marina from Kexus. Yida, you’re up.

Participant — European Forest Institute:

Ah, okay. Thank you very much, Yan. Thank you Daniela for a very insightful and rich presentation. I really enjoyed it even if I missed the first part of your presentation. You mentioned that implementation is one of the main problem which I do share basically based on my experience in several tropical countries. Don’t you also think that a lack of mechanisms to implement laws and policies also a problem which is different from implementation because we have come across or worked with a number of tropical countries which actually struggle to develop and then establish governance mechanisms.

It could be now creating a multistakeholder structure you know for u citizens to participate in you know decision making process or implementation of policies. So I would like to hear your opinion with regard to that you know lack of mechanisms or governance mechanisms as one of the main challenges. Well, the other point I have is that you in one of your slide where you put you know priorities of the root causes of deforestation or governance in general. How do you advise governments to you know prioritize out of that list of priorities you list there because countries have limited resources limited financial capacities and human resources.

I faced a similar question when I did a similar consultancy for the Congo vising countries. I was asked to come up with that kind of list as well. So how do how do you advise because it’s a long list what you have there but you know for those countries with limited resources how do you do that? Yeah those are my questions.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you.

Jonah:

Go for it Daniela.

Daniela Castro:

So at I have to say that the root cause exercise it’s used by government to create plans for example we had not anymore a environmental plan to end the forestation and it’s called pep pepam it’s the first was made in 2008 I think it’s a very good so the government h the government made this exercise in order to decide public policies so it’s when the government has a and sometimes available you can check on internet and the is the better when the government has this exercise and this analysis we have to use it and the first thing but if they if they don’t have you have to do it but sometimes and of course the civil society with this can choose for example if you know the impact and in Brazil for example Amazon deforestation we have some reports of civil soci society telling us that this experience or was successful.

This was a key to the decreasing of deforestation a few years ago. So, so we know things and we can choose for example the idea of that’s why I think that when you establish goals for your advocacy plan it has to be something outside organization. So I know that if I had the power to change I will have to do this and then as organization you can choose it’s impossible to do everything. That’s why I like to use the prioritization system. It’s something that I can measure my pri priority when I create an advocacy plan.

And sometimes if you do this within a lot coalition is better because you can share tasks and this is something that for example the private sector when they want to influence the government they share information. Sometimes they share strategies. So we have to do this and you are correct the implementation is a big problem and it demands the civil society new skills and new to influence.

Jonah:

Great. Thank you Marina.

Marina:

Hi Daniela. Thank you very much for your presentation. You was really insightful. My question to you has to do with I what I see with I used to work for several foundations and I agree with you that there is very little money going towards advocacy. I was wondering if you have seen anything like this maybe donors getting together and thinking about how they can pull the resources of advocacy together to make more effective campaigns from one side and on the other side if you have seen organizations also coming together to have campaigns that are actually combined campaigns because usually what you see also is that each organization want to have their own campaign.

Oh my brand is that I campaign for this or I campaign for that and how it would be very helpful if for example when maybe you are in a good position to do that to influence that okay let’s see out of this list what are the most impactful ones and let’s try to combine donors from one side and also combine organizations to do more effective things together. Have you seen this movement at all on the advocacy field? That’s my question. Thank you.

Daniela Castro:

I think it’s a challenge. I work with an organization for 20 years and I think it’s a challenges because sometimes that we have to we want to have our project and duplicity in advocacy is damage because and this is something that we have to learn. I saw some initiatives. For example, a coalition against the modern slavery in Brazil, for example, they create a private agreement, for example, with the federal prosecutor in Brazil and but it’s a challenge because I saw many coalitions, but and to be a leader in a coalition, it demands patience.

And many interests. So it’s you have to that’s why it’s the same in private agreement. I think that we have to set an agenda and sometimes is they can agree and in everything and governance and a plan and a devocy plan also that’s why I recommend the better would be that a coalition create an advocacy plan and they can coordinate efforts because that’s again it’s the way that private sector produced business when they are trying to influence the government and we have resource but it’s not in a mufficient to work so this duplicity so it’s a challenge I’m saying I saw different collisions but it’s a challenge to have the same plan coordinate actions and but I think that we are learning to do this because the problems are that we are facing and the problems in the political field that affect all of us is demanding us to do this.

I don’t know if I answer.

Jonah:

Marina, did you have a follow-up?

Marina:

No, I don’t. But thank you, Daniela. Congratulations on your work.

Jonah:

Fiona,.

Fiona:

Thank you. First of all, Daniela and Jonah and all the team involved, I want to just take a moment to thank you for your dedication to these very complex, very diverse questions and nobody knows the answers and so the solution even is that we have to work together. So, thank you for bringing us together. So I was looking at for example an advocacy group that we’ve been working with fast Amazonus and I was asking for example after their representation in the Amazon of 250 different tribal communities and outreach groups I have you know done quite a bit of analysis with them and through the community outreach of their groups.

How do we help to advocate and bring not just the voices of the indigenous people together but also bringing in a capability for them to gain funding and global advocacy and other groups like that. So thank you for exploring some of your talented work and helping us to finance the solutions.

Jonah:

Daniela,.

Daniela Castro:

Hi Fiona. There is not a simple solution or one solution. You are right and that’s why when I some initiatives you can you have to work with several approach. So you have to lobbying, you have to work with coalitions, you have to communicate sometimes litigation, but you can choose it’s not just one and when you analy that’s why for example stakeholder map and to analyze power and for example when we are talking about stakeholders we can map the media we can we c we have to I when I created the voxy And I interview a lot people because sometimes it’s just politic the politics you doing talk with people you have to talk because sometimes you can you if you look the website you don’t have the information and you have to know the agenda.

Some things are not said. So it’s not a formula that I can give you to you but it’s for each of these strategies there is methods and ways and the diagnosis is the first step you have to know everything and then it’s natural and another thing is the capacity building I think for example here in Brazil we create advocacy hubby to with some classes to create a professionals and people that can work with advocacy strategies. So because it’s we don’t have this kind of thing. Of course you have, but it’s not something that we have to you we must have more courses teaching advocacy for example.

Jonah:

Nina,.

Nina:

Thanks Jonah.

Jonah:

Just to be clear, this will be our last question. We’re near the top of the hour.

Nina:

Lucky me. And thanks Daniela for a great presentation. I work for the global landscapes forum and we will be running pretty big com forum online conference two-day conference in the week of the 20th of September. We’ll be taking a landscape lens and a bioultural lens to the Amazon and really looking Amazon inside out. So what kind of great solutions ready to scale? What has been proven to work in the Amazon that you know could work and then do a kind of bringing investors to it and see what we what we can do.

With your experience what would be and we’re at the moment right now to shape this conference. What would be your advice to do or not to do so we can drive the biggest change with this?

Daniela Castro:

I don’t know if I get the question. So, in terms of the projects or.

Nina:

Well, we have we can bring we can bring a lot of people together. So, our conferences typically have like 5,000 people attending and reach between 30 and 40 million people. So, and we work with a big network of established big organizations like the World Bank, like WWF. But we’re right now creating this conference and a couple of things are clear as I just explained that we really want to focus on good examples. We want to really put rights at the center, the people at the center, the people of the Amazon at the center and looking what kind of solutions there are with regards to business solutions, innovations social actives rules maybe in some areas of governance solutions and what can be scaled and I’m and this is This is part of a six month will be part of a six-month kind of campaign for the Amazon.

As we’re reaching going towards the tipping point the point as the political environment is changing that there could be a window of opportunity. And so how can we put this amazing reach and convening power that we have to help effect change more quickly.

Daniela Castro:

Okay I think that maybe the conference is not only to share information but to take action and bring this subject the governance and law and vox initiatives. It can be very important because some for example maybe sometimes a social business they want to scale but the we have to change the law and we have to create incentives. So if that’s some the ideas I think that Jonah can talk more about it but it’s to promote and funding more organization that are working with governance and law and this is very important because even to avoid setbacks to implement politics or to clear the way for the new business and new ideas.

It is important. So, and we have a lot of work to do. It’s very urgent and that’s why I keep saying and I was very glad to contribute with Jonah in this subject governance and law because without the public policies the we can have a scale. So, this is my point my opinion. Okay. Thank you everybody. We have reached the top of the hour. Daniela, I have posted your email address in the chat for people to be able to follow up with you.

Nina:

Thank you.

Jonah:

This is the moment that I call water cooler time where we end the formal proceedings and we dismiss class and people hang out and network and talk afterwards in an unstructured way. So Daniela, thank you for joining us. You’re certainly welcome to stay around. Everyone else, thank you so much. And tada. Now we’re in our unstructured time.

Daniela Castro:

Thank you. Jonah, do you want me to stay?

Jonah:

Yeah. Yeah. I think some people would like to follow up with you if you have time.

Daniela Castro:

Yes, I have.

Jonah:

I put everybody on mute. So otherwise I think we would be hearing people saying goodbye. Does anybody have any questions or announcements or followup?

Unidentified participant:

I have not an announcement but I have some comments. Daniela, hi. Very nice to meet you. So regarding coalitions, I think one very interesting Brazilian example for a very large coalition is what is happening in the education system where the leading foundation institutes, nonprofit organizations are working closely with various levels of the government to map in a first step. They mapped the entire challenge of the education system and then each organization took on specific challenges allowing them to both have their priorities and also be seen as major contributors while also serving the whole.

Right? And I think that this is something that we can learn a lot from. And then you know together with acete that who you might know who have been so successful. PA is one of our partners and an old friend and so forth. We created a alliance of many of the leading health oriented organizations in Brazil and they also have each their particular focus, their particular identity and work but they cover together the field of health you know and then in so these are so that so we have facilitated their collaboration for several years at the outset of coming together and I think you need to first go through yes it’s wonderful let’s all work together then you actually start to work together and then you say oh my god you know they’re not doing it like I’m doing it they’re doing it wrong.

My way is much better everybody should just do it my way and then you help them. To see isn’t it wonderful that you are doing more research and I’m doing my activism because if you’re doing the research I actually don’t have to do the activism which I actually don’t like to do so much and so then we helped them to facilitate you know a process where actually they recognize the richness of their diversity. And it was in that they you know and this is not just a conceptual process this is a personal process you need to get to as you said you need to get together in person.

You need to like each other. You need to want to work together. And the more you meet each other, which of course has become more difficult in the times of co, the more you develop the capacity to also find conceptual agreement, policy, collaboration, sharing things. And I think lastly, of course, it is very important to pull together you know, forces that align all of these organizations that have different interests and different business models that oppose them in some way. And so we do that for example in the in the field of business and you know regenerative business where large companies can actually be a very forceful strong convening force that brings all these different approaches from circularity to BC corp to this that and the other into one conceptual room one large tent.

Because you have this splitting up of forces in every movement and this is actually one way how the mainstream prevails because all the you know innovative forces are separated and individuated and so individually they’re never strong enough to challenge the mainstream only when they come together can they really do that so I think this whole topic of alliance building and so forth in a very pragmatic manner is a really key for this and I think later on Jonah we can you know dig down more deeply into this but anyway I wanted to give at least two Brazilian examples that I know that worked well you know.

Daniela Castro:

Yes the coalition it’s great I used to use as an example I know Paola we organized together a conference about advocacy in Brazil and it’s I couldn’t remember when they asked me but you’re right and in education and Anamarina knows a lot of coalitions and great projects and I think that one thing that you coalition is not easy I know that h that’s why is we have to we must have a method and set agendas and we have some agreements about how we can do this. For example, in this private agreement that I’m in charge of the management of it with we have banks on paradors.

So it’s not easy but we have to learn because if not it’s something that we are we are going to lose the fight because the decisions are being made all the time and so we have to learn this is my just for you is it’s my I have a critic in on the civil society. We don’t work together very well and we have to learn be more professional on this because the benefits that you said they are real.

Walter:

Yeah, I unfortunately need to go. So, I say thank you to everybody and thank you Daniela especially for your not only your presentation but the great work that you’ve done for so long. It’s wonderful.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you.

Walter:

To be involved with was you even though we didn’t even know each other.

Unidentified participant:

Byebye.

Walter:

Byebye.

Jonah:

Thanks so much, Walter. Hey, Nina. If you’re around, I’d like to talk with you. I’m going to go ahead and put it stop the recording.