Amazon Region Trade and Bio-Economy Entrepreneurship

Raoni Rajao: Professor Raoni Rajão of the Federal University of Minas Gerais (UFMG) researches the relationship between science, technology, and policy with a focus on deforestation, trade, and payments for environmental services. How are trade policies impacting development in the Amazon? What are the primary drivers towards and away from sustainability? Professor Rajão joins us to help us all understand.

Recorded January 4, 2021

WATCH:

  • Jonah (moderator)
  • Raoni Rajao
  • Sarah (Amazon Aid Foundation)
  • Sophia Wood
  • Alex (GIZ)
  • David
  • Canari (Health in Harmony)
  • John
  • Other unidentified participants

Jonah:

Hello everybody. Welcome to the 28th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is January 5th, 2021, our first call of the year. Again, this is a call dedicated to advancing forest-friendly economic development across the Amazon region. And these calls are recorded and later edited as a podcast to help educate investors. Our presenter this week is Professor Raoni Rajao, who will say his name in English better than I will. From the Federal University of Minas Gerais, he’s a specialist in not only the science of deforestation and how corporate interests are driving it but also trade policy and how foreigners like the European Union and others can influence the game in town.

Before we welcome Professor Rajao to the stage, I thought it’d be interesting just for a couple people on the call to introduce themselves. Sarah, do you want to introduce yourself? You’re on mute. If you’re just listening in, it’s okay. Sophia, do you want to introduce yourself?

Unidentified participant:

Oh, hey. Sorry.

Jonah:

Okay, go first, Sarah.

Sarah:

Hey, I am Sarah [surname unclear]. I am the founder Amazon Aid Foundation and the producer and co-director of a film called River of Gold, which we’re about to release globally and are building campaigns around gold mining and deforestation in the Amazon rainforest. Please get in touch with me if you’re interested in this. So happy to be here. Thank you, Jonah. And happy new year, everyone.

Jonah:

Thanks so much. Sophia, you want to say hi?

Sophia Wood:

Sure, happy to. Thanks, Jonah. Hi, I’m Sophia Wood. I’m currently based in Seattle. I run an organization called Friends of Wallacea, which works to connect, tourism income directly to conservation outcomes in indigenous and rural communities worldwide in partnership with Operation Wallace, which is a British biodiversity research organization. And I’ve been working in the Ecuadorian Amazon for the last three years, which is how I ended up connected to this work. I’m very interested to continue learning more from these meetings. Thank you. Happy New Year.

Jonah:

Great. We keep on having new folks join us. So, I’m just going to call in a couple more people to introduce themselves and then we’ll move to Professor. Hey, John. You want to introduce yourself?

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, sure. Hey, Jonah. And hey, everybody, happy new year. My name is John Mesner from MXV Ventures in Oakland and we invest in early stage climate techreated startups and work with a lot of the US national laboratories in various capacities and we are very interested to keep learning more about how groups like ours can impact Amazonian deforestation and reverse the course. So as always great to see you Jonah and nice to meet everybody.

Jonah:

Great. And Logan.

Logan:

Hi everyone. Happy new year. This is my first call with the group, but I work I co-founded a group called Providence Capital and we’re focused on building a bridge between investors and enterprises in the regenerative agriculture space. We’re mostly working in the US right now but I’m definitely interested in expanding and I have a background in forestry conservation finance and forestry so particularly interested in this topic as well and the use of integrative finance tools to help advance conservation work.

Jonah:

Great. And if you guys can limit it to real quick Alex David and Canari we can all with you guys. Go for it Alex.

Alex (GIZ):

Sure. Hi everybody. Happy new year. I am Alexander Rose based in Bazia. I work for the German Corporation for Sustainable Development, GISZ. My focus is on sustainable use of tropical forests. I work with several value chains like Cocoa, Brazil, Asai, private sector engagement and restoration. Nice to meet you.

Jonah:

Thanks so much for joining us, Alex. And David.

David:

Yes. I’m David Bane in Washington DC. Project I’m working on right now is called treeid.org. I’ve worked in the technology space working on unique identifiers in information infrastructure. There’s a robust system for supporting unique identifiers and we’re taking it and we’re dropping it into this space to see what magical things can happen when you’re able to uniquely identify not just routers and servers but an Atlanthis ash aspen bald cypress beach birch buckeye kalpa cherry chestnut cottonwood dogwood elm etc. Great. And last and then we’ll start our program. Canari.

Canari (Health in Harmony):

Hi everyone. I’m Canary Web. I’m the founder of Health and Harmony and we do rainforest conservation. We’re throughout the tropics, but we are also working in the Shingu Basin now in Brazil and we work with indigenous and local communities for them to identify what their needs are for protecting the forest.

Jonah:

Great. Thanks so much. So I’m going to put everyone on mute if you’re not already and I’m going to invite Professor Hajon Hawi to join us. I do you mind if I call you Hajon or do you prefer professor?

Raoni Rajao:

No. Hajou is fine. I mean I’ve been living in different countries, you know, for five years in Italy and then in the UK. So, you know, different translations and pronunciations are, you know, are fully accepted. So Rajal so not everybody is used to the nazle sound of the tilda. So it’s professor Rajal it’s absolutely fine.

Jonah:

Great. So let’s begin. Tell us a little bit about your background before academia. Where did where did you grow up? Tell us a little bit about your family.

Raoni Rajao:

Yeah. So actually I’m from a family from the city of Mina which is you know in the middle of the country and actually I spent my childhood in a in a small city of less than 10,000 people just north of the capital of Beranchi. It’s called concaten with which actually is a family of farmers. You know my grandparents okay they were al also dentists my because of my grandfather but my but my great-grandfather was actually a farmer and so I really have you know I grew up in close connection with the natural environment but also agriculture so that’s not things that are stranger to me and but then at 8 I moved to a bigger city and I ended up studying in a in Italian school due to you know cultural interests and then after finishing my high school I decided to go we moved to Italy where actually I did an undergrad in computer science while working at the city of in the in Milan and ended up working for different companies including you know Shell also medium and small companies in Italy mostly related to it.

But then I as my final job in Italy, I worked for a couple of years for the city of Milan. Basically working on applying information technology to monitor urban traffic and air quality and how the different policies being applied by the city were helping to improve air quality which is one of the biggest environmental issues in Lumberj and that’s when it really sparked in me you know the that I could apply and bring together it and computer science and environmental policy and then when I moved to my decided to do a masters and then a PhD at Lancaster University in the UK.

And I and I and I picked the topic of deforestation in the Amazon specifically the role of satellite monitoring to reduce and control deforestation in the Amazon rainforest is something that could you know bring me closer to my home country and since then I’ve been you know going from one topic to the next which you know and this long chain of specialization that goes from you know the satellite and the deforestation process and what goes on the ground agricultural development forest and forest products carbon credits red international cooperation monitoring supply chains infrastructure u actually I’m also working now on issues related to illegal gold mining in the Amazon as well that’s one of my more recent projects because in the end of the day what we find that all those topics are very much interconnected it’s like you know this big complex woolen ball that you push a thread and there is the next and there is an X and there’s an X and I think it’s it’s very important to understand it all interconnected that’s why in the end we have developed here a research agenda which is very plural in terms of approaches but it’s very so we go from you know studies related to the social sciences and history and even you know social studies of science and technology and going to issues related to calculating how much carbon there is in a forest and how much emissions have been avoided due to certain policy in that region.

Because it’s important to understand the different sides of the problem in order to address it.

Jonah:

Nice. Tell me a little bit about your first trip to the Amazon and your emotional connection with the region and how that informed your research.

Raoni Rajao:

Well, actually I started my first contact with the Amazon has been actually with the ugly part of the Amazon because most people they would first have their contact with Amazon from you know as tourists you know going there and visiting the you know the more the more beautiful places around Manaus and usually at the heart of the forest where most of it is preserved. And instead my first contact with the Amazon has been straight away on the issue of deforestation. So it was been has been working doing field work in the state of Mato Grosso.

Because basically for my PhD what I have done was to follow the object of deforestation from the detection of the forestation from space to the conceptualization of policies in the congress and by the ministries down to the fieldwork of forest rangers with you know machine guns at hand going in the middle of the forest after the foresters and I’ve been following those different steps including the work of forest rangers in the middle of the forest. So that was my first contact you know. So at one hand seeing this the grandeur of the forest and the beauty of the trees but then at the same time just after seeing the impact of large areas with you know with high levels of deforestation and sometimes deforestation followed by some very low levels of productivity.

So that sense that idea that the first station equals development was something that firsthand I could see myself that is not often the case. So that has been mostly my first approach with my first my first firstand contact with Amazon. I remember looking up your the list of scholarly articles that you’ve been working on and there are so diverse and so many. Tell us a little bit about the focus of the research. What is the ultimate trajectory of it and what is the gap that you are filling as an intellectual and as an academic that was not filled previously?

Yeah, I think initially one of the one of the gaps here has been that many people have been talking about the Amazon from a more social perspective and maybe in terms of for instance in geography have different people talking about immigration flows. Also have anthropologists looking at indigenous populations specifically, but and also a lot of more quantitative studies understanding for instance showing how much of the forest has been lost. But not so much at least when I started studying it and still not that many people which have been working and trying to understand how we can tackle deforestation in practice.

So what are the what are the people doing to reduce deforestation with their hands and if I may just you know can I just share my screen to show which I think goes very much hand in hand with the first impressions of as we were recollecting these are some of the pictures of my first field work now many years ago where we could hear for instance this is an area which has been previous forest And now it is you know from this big large corporation called Amaji. This is the work of the forest rangers actually going at the place of someone that’s not expecting from them.

And this is I think this is a very has been a very touching mo moment where you have the forest rangers followed by those guys which are with machine guns and these are basically police force a special police force that the week before were shooting at drug dealers in Rio de Janeiro and now they are in the middle of the forest still with the uniform of the rural place and this is a farmer right who which not all farmers are criminals. That’s very important to say, often a minority. And he’s in a situation where he’s basically hands up saying, “Please don’t shoot me.” At the same time, you have here the first ranger who’s, you know, with the with the hand in the back, it’s showing some discomfort because he’s noticing that the farmer is not at ease.

Of course, it’s creating some problems and because if the farmer doesn’t give information to the forest range of what is going on and who is the forest and where’s the forestation coming from because maybe this guy is not the guy is only the guy with the machine with the with equipment doing the deforestation. He’s not the owner of the place and the only person able to give the information about who is the owner of the place is this guy here who’s now being somehow intimidated. And in the end of the day for the next trips the forest rangers have asked the police to stay in the car not to intimidate the farmers and that would hinder their work.

Just to show you how complex these the these situations are and how important it is to go and see those understand those issues from in this case an ethnographic perspective. So how things happen in their cultural millure and then this very bottomup ground level understanding of how the forestation control takes place of how people react to this has been really very informative to my to my more quantitative work later on because nowadays I do not do as many as much field work as my as my students. Now I have you know a big team of about 30 people that work with me but every time we do some the research on this there’s always the understanding of how things work in practice and every time we talk to governments it also departs from the idea that we cannot ask from them something which is beyond also their institutional capabilities.

So I think this bottom up grounds up perspective was really helpful and it was something which was and it still is relatively new now jumping you know almost 20 years after the kind of work I’m doing today is that thanks to this understanding of how policy is created implemented in practice almost this street level bureaucracy not to cite some authors in this area this has been allowing us to do big data analysis of the way deforestation happens and how to tackle deforestation. So for instance, we developed with a big team of programmers, computer scientists.

So also getting back to some of my roots a software which analyzed individually the boundaries of millions of farms crossing satellite imagery overlaps with indigenous regions indigenous territories embargos among others information also supply chain. So information about production and in order to understand for instance what’s the level of contamination of Brazil’s agriculture production and exports and this has for instance been the main topic of the recent article we published and so we managed to bring together also this automatic procedures and also talk about how things are going on not only for the specific team of rangers have been falling but looking at the whole territory.

Jonah:

Wow. Tell us a little bit about your research and your article of the bad apples that spoil the bunch in Brazilian agribusiness.

Raoni Rajao:

So I think this work actually has been a natural progress of the work we have been doing before and it actually departed from a question that kept coming up in every area we went people especially from the agribusiness were put pointed out and also from civil society because there has been this huge debate right around deforestation agriculture in Brazil in agro business specifically where the agribusiness would say that they have nothing to do with deforestation. Brazil is the most sustainable agriculture has the most sustainable agriculture in the world. The people who deforest are always the other it’s other sectors timber sector or just people grabbing lands that has nothing to do with the produ production of meat and so especially for export.

And on the other hand, you have especially environmentalists which point out and sometimes even suggest that most of the production agriculture production taking place in Brazil is linked to deforestation. And we certainly knew that neither were true. So not 0% of agriculture production is linked to deforestation. So it’s completely deforestation free. Nor 100% of the agriculture production in Brazil is illegal or linked to deforestation. So how much is it you know and where is it and how bad is the situation and then we started to do this procedure that I just mentioned we developed this set of software which analyzes every single farm and analyze the level of legality of that farm.

Of how much forest it has, whether it has more or less forest than it should in terms of the legal of the legislation in Brazil, when it has the forested and whether that specific farm is producing soy or meat and especially the in the case of meat has was particularly complex because we had to analyze not only how much how many heads of kettle have been sold from a single farm but what but where that far that kettle is coming from because sometimes you have a farm that’s selling to a bid big mcpeck a big meat pecker that’s exporting to Europe or China and this last farm is not the foresting but this big farm is buying from other places who the forest so it’s it’s moving on cattle contaminated with the forestation and so we put together this the system that is able to analyze also those different fluxes and what we found was first and foremost 85% of the farmers in Brazil have not deforested since 2008 with the cut date for the new the legislation and actually only 2% of the farms are responsible for 62% of all illegal deforestation taking place in the Sahara and in the Amazon and from this comes the title bad apples so this is not the problem of the problem is not the bunch the problem are the bad apples and we in a sense point out basically two main messages through this first and foremost this argument that sometimes the Brazilian government and also the companies put forward that oh it’s not possible to know yes it is possible to know we manage to know and we are not governments so in theory we have limited access to data so imagine if you are government what we could know you could know or even the companies which have which have more data than we do so we basically we broke the argument the technical argument against a better monitor of supply chain and second we basically showed that it is possible short term to have substantial gains in terms of monitoring supply chains.

And finally, we made a pledge to the good apples from the sector saying that the good apples should be the first to be wanting to expel the bad apples from the basket. Because right now what happens is that when you have the social civil society pressing Brazil due to deforestation all the apples bad and good they pen together and they protect and say oh we are the best already. This is all part of international clue plot to basically push Brazil out of the of the competition. And what we have been trying to convince the good apples that look you have much more to win by purifying yourself by getting rid of the bad apples than just trying to protect them or remaining silent while the bad apples are brought in the rest of the basket.

Jonah:

Tell us a little bit about how your work is discovering ways for the European Union and the trade relationship with Americ how can the negotiations surrounding those trade agreements influence the bad apples and the good apples and give one more leverage over another? And then consequently, how can Americans also use their influence to advance sustainability and reducing deforestation for the region? How can trade policy help?

Raoni Rajao:

No, I think it can help in different ways. So okay before our article there has already been some studies and especially the ones done by trace which is you know that group that brings together global econopy and also Stockholm Environmental Institute which do a very good work basically tracing the relationship between the food product produced in one municipality so looking at the municipality as a whole and where that is going to so they managed to say well the soy produced the municipality of Sohizo is been is being exported to Europe or to China whatever and so has the first but then when it comes to the negotiations with EU it has been it has been a bit problematic because what Brazil has been saying that look maybe someone is the forest in this municipal but not the producers who are exporting soil because previous studies have not been able to bring this debate to the property level.

And so when we brought the debate to the property level and it showed it’s possible to have a better monitoring. We basically have been showing that look you and look also Brazil to Brazilian government it’s possible to have an agreement which neither you know closing an eye to environmental issues as the current agreement has because actually the mechanisms in that’s not really good but and nor bringing a situation where we have no agreement at all which is what many people would also like to which in my you personally I think we are worse off.

It’s better to have an agreement with good environmental standards embedded in it than having no agreement. And so our study in a sense it provided it showed as an example that it’s possible to have something more robust and since then we have been talking a lot with the with the EU with also the different representatives from different European countries interested in the matter and I think it has been you know helping them to grow some confidence on the possibility of asking more and also helping them to develop specific asks. To the Brazilian industry and the government.

But I think going beyond Brazil, what we’re talking about here is not so much how to improve Brazilian environmental standards because we also have to think that Argentina we have the charcoal in Paraguay. You have actually the charcoal is being deforested more quickly in terms of the percentage of the of the remaining native vegetation than the Amazon. Not to forget other regions where you have the expansion and agriculture production which also bring environmental which has environmental impacts including for instance the United States. You know how much of the soy production in the United States actually follow the good u the good practices related to the protection of repairing native vegetations around rivers.

We don’t know. So what I think we the debate the kind of the debate we’re trying to push forward here is that we have the means technological means now to raise up this standard of agriculture production worldwide and have a standard that then can be replicated to other places not only Brazil but then you know Paraguay, Argentina, Europe, United States, Australia, why not? We need everybody to be at the same level and to have a better agriculture production. Can you tell me what you expect from the election of Joe Biden?

How can the arrival of a new presidential administration in the United States affect these issues? I think in different ways it has been really a big relief for Brazil especially in terms of democracy because well we still of course don’t know exact exactly how things are going to roll out in the United States but I think it’s it’s it’s very unlikely that Trump is going to manage to issue a coup deta and establish you know and restate itself. It’s it’s not that likely. It’s not impossible. It’s not that likely. But if had Trump won then Boson which in even in the previous elections have be already talking about election fraud the chances that he would basically have a coupeta with the support of local police and the silence of the army would be huge even if he lost.

So I think it know first stage first step is we have you know Brazil Brazilian democracy have become stronger thanks to the shift of power in the United States and why Bosonado would do that in Brazil because he would be able to do that and Trump would not complain would have Europe and others and then you know the most powerful military force in the world would not go there and say Brazil is a is has a dictatorship now and this would of course back boson’s intention. So I think that’s extremely important.

But I think specifically in relation to the environment, what we have is this is the acceleration of a shift that’s already happening in different places. We have here already this realignment first you know Europe pushing forward and then China following suit. China of 2021 is not China from 1990s. China now wants to buy soft power and the way it wants to acquire soft power is by having a better environmental policies. They are they are pushing forward a huge restoration forest restoration project of one quarter of the country is investing a lot in renewable energy and it’s changing its policy including you know talking about monitoring supply chains you know that’s something that would be unheard of a few years ago and then you have this you know this axis of US of Europe and China and if the United States and now that is on the chances that you have this third huge part adding up basically makes renders the environmental governance a better environmental governance something which becomes hegemonic.

So there is no way you can get out of this thanks to now the arrival of Joe Biden and even though Joe Biden might not interfere directly and of course now we have to see whether the campaign promises of helping Brazil financially and or eventually punishing Brazil if it doesn’t abide to certain environmental standards how those are going to go out. But certainly this shifts in the geopolitics of environment of environmental debate certainly going to make a huge difference here.

Jonah:

What advice do you have for investors in philanthropists in the United States and Europe who want to use their local political pressure with government, state government, federal government to help? What advice do you have for them?

Raoni Rajao:

Well, I think the one of the key advices here would be to know that u Brazil has the means to reduce deforestation drastically. It needs to want to do this. So no excuses, right? Our article shows very clear there is a map showing who is deforesting legal in the country. So something like okay use this map. Oh it’s so difficult don’t have enough personnel. But you can start for instance issuing a decree that for instance cancels the registration of all those farms that have the forest delivery. You bank can stop providing loans to those guys.

The banks are not doing this right now. The in you the companies are still buying from those companies u those farms deforesting legally. So there is actually still a very a huge gap between what companies and governments saying that they do and also there’s a lot of excuses right so leaf I like this expression you know fig leaf excuses related to the impossibility to do something about deforestation and what we are seeing right now in terms of scientific outputs remembering that I think the role of science here is to make the you know maybe a bit a bit grand here but making the impossible possible you know before people made an airplane it was not possible to fly now it’s possible to fly you know before not only we our group but other researchers around the world you know collaborators in the United States in Europe etc put together all those two sets that enables the monitoring of individual properties it was not possible to that have that to have that level of the control of supply chain today it is.

So let’s stop acting as if it was impossible to clean supply chains from deforestation. I think this is this is a very powerful message and I think this goes especially for investors who I understand are very concerned about taking their money out of Brazil because especially you know if you if you look at the biggest meers they are very profitable you know the biggest meaters in Brazil have their shares double in price last year double so and they don’t want to get to you know to step back you know Black Rockck still some still have some back big investments in those companies And I think when the investors will start really to take their money out, not only you know one investment fund in Sweden and that’s it.

I think that’s going to really you know send a strong signal because the truth is that politicians and many farmers they still thinking that this environmentalist talk is all bark not biting. Just you know just talk and they basically they had been doubling their bets and Bosonado represents this very clearly when he just defies everybody and say just you know I don’t care h because he believes that the world needs Brazilian food is going to starve if you know if the Chinese don’t have their steak they’re going to starve that’s not true they’re not going to starve they just have you know more chicken and I think you know it’s important to send a stronger message and saying that this is not just not just you know not talk there’s actually real decisions taking place behind that.

Jonah:

Speaking of the role of investors to divest and to send market signals are you aware of any pro particular proactive investment opportunities? Are there any new technologies or growth industries in the Amazon region that foreign money or even local Brazilian money an injection of such money could not only help advance sustainability but also have a high chance of providing a healthy return on investment?

Raoni Rajao:

Well, I think there are some interesting u opportunities. One of them actually just as an example it’s there is a there is a story of a guy called Demen Mendes and he’s a chocolate baker actually before that he was a scientist basically helping and to develop cacao industry in the at the heart of the Amazon around the transmazon and but then he became a chocolatier putting together a small company and they have started selling over the internet. It’s not that cheap, but it’s it’s possible to get. I often have their chocolate delivered to my to my doorstep here in Beler.

It’s thousands of kilometers away and it’s always, you know, hand packed and it’s delicious and it’s and the nice thing about them is that they have at the forefront the extractive cacao. So cacao found in the middle of the forest. They pay you know double triple in price than Nestle and other bigger cacao buyers would do and they have for instance being recently international investors have put money in these specific chocolate producers. In the same way you have for instance invest possibilities of investment in ecoourism. I just I just been to the region of the Tapajou in Ala and visited a community based community based touristic organization in the in the FA Taj which is a conservation unit.

It’s it’s absolutely gorgeous. It’s absolutely gorgeous. And even though tourism is arriving there, there are so many opportunities to actually go there, train those people, bring people there, do this as a way to actually cilibize a broader number of people in relation to environmental issues. There’s so much that could be done. And certainly private investments, responsible private investments could absolutely help. And I think a third opportunity relates to reforestation. According to you know Brazilian legislation requires farms that have been medium and big farms that have been deforested illegally up to 2008 they have 20 years to reforest.

And this basically creates an on the one hand the legal requirement for huge areas actually calculated that about 80 18 million hectares need to be reforested in Brazil by the next decade. And this could be done also with a business model behind this. You can produce wood. You can be you can produce forest and no forest products while you are restoring because legal reserves in Brazil are not areas to be fully protected and cannot be touched. These are areas of a forest economy of a native economy a native vegetation economic use.

So I think there are different big opportunities there related to those different possibilities.

Jonah:

Great. One more question from me and then we’ll open it up to the rest of the group and it’s about the Amazon tipping point. How close are we to it and what can be done about it? What should the legislators be looking on? Is the is the Amazon really about to shift towards grassland and will that disrupt the global weather pattern?

Raoni Rajao:

Well, it’s difficult to say about the global weather department because when you talk about the global we have to remember that for in terms of greenhouse gases, Brazil represent about 3% of emissions and land use emissions around 15%. So if you don’t stop burning fossil fuels, you know, we are going to be doomed anyway. But in terms of regional rain patterns, that’s already happening. And so it’s not about the future, it’s about today. Of course it’s you know scientists and we are always you know very conservative and very careful about the because in science mistakes are very heavily punished while when you are right it’s just tight so you should be right so that’s you know that’s why no science are always very conservative but the fact is if you ask me no I would probably write not I would probably not write that in an article but I would say informally that the tipping point is already is already there.

Some articles including some done by people from our research group shows that u the southern part southern part of the Amazon mainly due to deforestation the wet season has been already shortened by an entire month on average and that’s exactly the region which adjacent to the to the to the Pantanau which have the basically the water coming from the Amazon and also the sahado to fill the rivers and we have basically we have a dry rivers this year and which is crazy. You know, areas that have never been dry this year have been dry and 40% of the biome has been up going up in flames.

Of course, we’re not going to see the entire Amazon being becoming a savannah. And this, you know, if you look closer at the research done by Carlos No and others, a part of the Amazon is going to still bear. Especially the one more on the on the on the west. However, the eastern part and the southern part are very likely to southernize as it’s already happening due to degradation due to changes and patterns and this even though before the studies have been pointing out that the tipping point would be around 40%.

The new studies are now talking about even 20%. And we are already at that close to that. So I think we have rather than saying oh are we there we should be basically saying well we are already you know started to fall in this huge you know fall out of the of the of the abism and now we need to get back right we need to reforest we need basically to revert the process and so I think that the situation is pretty dire.

Jonah:

Thank you professor Haj Canari you’re up.

Canari (Health in Harmony):

First of all just thank you this is a fascinating discussion it’s so interesting I and that story about the bad apples is so powerful and you said you know you really were encouraging the good apples to put pressure on the bad apples did that actually happen they do that did they.

Raoni Rajao:

Well it’s well it’s it’s difficult because I what I’ve I’ve talked to before the publication of the article I talked to everybody in the prediction sector because basically what I’ve been telling them was look we don’t want to just you know bash at people and make them look bad you know if you know the sector the government wants to before the publication take a picture on by my side saying we’ve learned that it’s possible the technology here and we are taking action we would be there because we don’t have sides on this you know we don’t actually I would love to be a great president because that means having a better country.

However they have chosen not to do so. First because I think they there was specific reason to us yeah what an article could do right just science that’s that’s not you know that’s not really important. While actually they have been proven wrong because when the article came out it was a big repercussion and suddenly you have all the news you know reporters pointing their microphones towards the vice president and the minister. What about this article and so that luckily I’ve been talking to them beforehand but I don’t think they were aware of that but they probably did not expect such a big reaction and now what is we see is that for instance in this the state of par we I think they are taking it more seriously we indeed we just signed an agreement a couple weeks ago I’ve been with the governor and he was actually the first major political figure to go out in public and saying that we are now p partnering with professor Hajon to improve the more in terms of supply chains which is a very thorny issue you know many people in the agribusiness they would certainly you know I’m sure that many people have called alohabu to complain with him after he has made this declaration because it hasn’t a political cost at the same time what I see in the agro business is you know some people are in denial just for instance I’ve been in this group which puts together NGOs and this private sector to discuss the improvement of the of the beef supply chain and then this guy which is a representatives from the sector were basically going on and on saying how great the Brazilian agriculture is that to use data for animal health purposes for environmental purposes going to ruin what’s already perfect and then I had to call him to reality say look why do you think are we talking in this room it’s not because things are perfect if things were good and perfect, we would not need to have this group.

We not need to have this conversation. But things are not. We are in deep trouble. So stop acting as if we are not in deep trouble. And I think this is the problem, right? They just, you know, they just pretend things are great. And why? And I think that’s that’s important to emphasize. Brazilian agriculture, including those at the forest illegally, have never made as much money as they have been made in this last two years. So their pockets are full. So it’s very easy for them looking at the short term things, you know, this is all They yucking yaking yucking, but they still buying from us.

And that’s going back to that argument, you know, they have to be shown otherwise. Otherwise, they’re not they’re not going to take this seriously.

Jonah:

John Meer, did you want to ask a question?

John:

Yeah, let me unmute myself. Thanks, J. Yeah. So, a lot of examples of Amazonian innovation seem to be very focused on a specific industry like cacao or a small company that’s trying to work in a specific vertical like ecourism. Are you seeing examples of innovation or innovators having a broader systemic impact? I’m thinking like potentially unleashing markets that the current startups that you described could leverage to grow their businesses at scale or things that have a much broader impact than maybe one small business could have.

Raoni Rajao:

Well, it’s it’s difficult to point towards that. I think let’s say the forest industry I think could have a big impact mostly because you know timber is such a basic commodity and the demand for good timber it’s something which is going to grow in the next years but that’s that’s something which is which demands you know first a transformation the sector which is still you know lots of illegalities also transformation the way we because I mean Brazil has never had a sustainable large scale timber production sector. You know the only kind of timber production that has been produced in like that way is soft timber which are implantations but none of that with native and in order to bring that into the native which could have you know a huge impact because I’m sure the same way people are now consuming the Brazilian meat and soy all over the world in high quantities if we had you know very good hardwood so sustainably produced sold all over the wood that would be certainly be a huge demand for it much more than asai for instance but I think there are many obstacles in relation to that regulatory but also in terms of the way the sector is structured and also technological ones because truth is Brazil managed to scientifically reduce the time of eucalyptus production from 25 years in Australia to six years.

This is huge. Is the only country in the world that’s able to plant a tree and take it out in six years and sell it. And but we but we have not been able to do the same thing for other tropical timbers and maybe it’s not going to be six years but maybe we might be able to have 15 years cycle for a high quality hardwood and that would be fantastic for instance but we need we need investments in place and long-term investments in place to make that happen.

Jonah:

Makes sense. Yeah. Thank you. Alex Rose.

Alex (GIZ):

Okay. Yes. Hello, Professor Hajon. Nice to meet you. I don’t know if you’re familiar with the work GSZ’s been doing in Brazil, but I just wanted to say that we have been supporting the Brazilian government in the approach to document the properties on basically on car level. I’m sure you know the car system very well and the CC car system very expensive softwares they cost about 400 million AIS over the long term. This is just the setup of the software and now several multilateral givers and donors have been investing in its implementation as mostly states and municipalities don’t have the cash to implement it.

So what we have seen basically GIS has a project it’s called car specifically to support the ministry of the environment in its car approach and environmental compliance. So what we have seen is as you know the first step was the voluntary fulfillment of the car meaning the farmers declares by himself voluntarily the size of his property and how much forest he has and so on. And then the second step would be the validation of the car the numbers he has really declared and this is basically where the where the train stops because the validation is expensive the states are in charge to do it and they don’t have the staff the capacity or the money to do it.

So maybe my first question would be how do you suggest to validate the car system and the work that has been done already and my second question is I don’t think there’s a lack of technology or monitoring instruments with map bomas and other instruments to know who is deforesting and where and many times the fines are already applied by Obama millions and billions of fines but in any event the fines are not paid by the big deforesters and it goes into a trial or into litigation which can take 10 20 years and even be forgiven at one point of time.

So these are the two issues I would like you to respond. How do you suggest to deal with the validation of the car system and the cart and secondly how do you suggest to deal with the non-paid fines?

Raoni Rajao:

Yeah, thanks for the question. Yeah, I know JZ very well and actually worked with JZ in different projects and u and so and you know and certainly if we start talking names here I’m going to find you know people that we already know specifically in relation to KH which actually the grandfather of Kah has been the object of my PhD back in the late 2000s. So I’ve been I’ve been look at following this from its birth in the state of Mato Grosso and then the state of parah and so I understand its potentialities and also the challenges here especially in relation to validation but I think again we are hitting an issue that it’s it’s more related to the lack of willingness to pay the political price to do work rather than the means to do the work.

Because so we have done a project called Validaka which actually has been built upon the work of our research team here but also in collaboration with u the forest code observatory it’s a set of NGOs and what we have found is that depending on the states we you we can apply a series of automatic futures that analyze the situation of the farm and then basically define that who are the farmers the farmers that do not need to go under a manual validation, a manual analysis. So they can be automatically approved and those that need to have to be suspended and need to have manual validation and in this way we could quickly actually validate depending on the state up to 30% even more of the farms.

However, if you validate one/ird, you unvalidate the other two/3s, which means bring giving problems to the other two/3s which are then going to knock at the door of the president, the boss and the governance and complaining that they have problems, they have issues, they have pendenc, they have dependencies and many of the of the problems that valid are going to raise are not solvable because it’s basically people reving each other’s lands. These are conflicts. These are things that cannot be simply solved technically. And the fact is even though we have we have showed this solution and showed and talked to Colato and his team many times, they have simply do not want to take up the solution.

And even though you know the University of Lavas has been invested in those software, they are very good in developing technological solutions like you know Microsoft Word, they are not good at writing text, you know, they’re not good at analyzing the policy. They’re not good at being critical about the policy because they’re not they’re not a research group. We are and so we are basically we publish internationally, we publish in science, we publish in nature. We know what where are the issues are and not simply there to develop what the forest service ask us to and this allows you know independency to actually push forward for solutions and I think that’s the situation right now u they are not being pushed forward for solutions and in the end of the day pushing advancing with the validation of the car would bring some political cost they’re not willing to pay and this concerns us also because for instance you have another project also supported by the German collaboration corporation which is called Novakahn which actually has within its scope the monitoring of supply chains and the monitoring of cattle and this that’s that’s not happening why because it brings a political cost and so I think you know I understand that there has been a lot that has been achieved but what has been achieved has been in areas with very little political cost to register someone at KH has very little political cost because we basically exchanging some form of visibility that might not entail a punishment with the ability to access credit.

So farmers do that because they want to access credit. But when you move to the next step and actually have something that has consequences then they don’t want to go there and then they claim they have environmental or technical difficulties. Then in relation to the second issue well we cannot analyze the effectivity of fines by looking at how much of that is paid especially for many reasons. First the bigger fines such as the fine against the PhD dam explosion here in eyes which costing billions have not been paid and will not be paid because it’s much cheaper to keep up a huge team of lawyers just pushing forward and not paying this than doing this.

That does doesn’t mean that doesn’t have a cost for the company and when you find someone when you embargo someone you prevent that person from selling the produce. However, this only works if the companies who are buying cattle for instance or buying soy take the embargo seriously. In what we understood is that quite often farmers are find farmers are finding ways to bypass that often with the agreements. So the underlying agreement of the companies themselves and the government’s not looking at that because it’s not investing in monitoring the mon of the supply chains.

So when you when you from the moment onwards you have a situation where a fine means that someone is driven out of business regardless of that being or not the fine I’m as it was actually a few years ago because a fine and embargo a few years ago when those you know bypassing procedures were not yet known had a much bigger impact and that explains why an increase in the forest in the number of fines has explained the decrease in the forestation. And now we don’t not only have a decrease in the effectivity of the fines because farmers and the big companies have find ways to bypass that but also you have a decrease of the fines by half in relation to previous years.

So we have a almost a complete dismantle of the ability of the government to actually punish for illegalities. So I think this you know this is a big issue here we have here.

Jonah:

Thanks. We’ve reached the top of the hour, so we’re running out of time. If we could, have one more question from Sophia.

Sophia Wood:

Sure. Yes. Hi. Thank you so much for your presentation and for everything we’ve discussed today. I wanted to ask you kind of following up on John’s question, what underlying infrastructure might be missing in the Amazon region that would help these Amazon businesses that you mentioned scale more effectively? I’m imagining things like internet and banking, but I don’t know if there’s specific solutions that you would imagine would be helpful.

Raoni Rajao:

You know I think I think communication is the first kind of infrastructure that Jeff jumps to mind and then there’s the issue of logistics and I think one point here is really how can we revolutionize water logistics by bringing it to the 21st century. Because right now there is basically you know we’re still thinking that old you know rusty boats do the job and the government wants to basically cons build roads which are good for moving cattle all over the Amazon with huge environmental impacts. But then how can we you know bring solutions you know in terms of new boat designs of new ports of new types of water infrastructure of including for people that would basically show that it’s not really needed to build roads criss-crossing the Amazon since we have the rivers that for centuries have been the roads of the Amazon the way the means of transportation I think you know those two those two dimensions brought together I think that would be a major change here.

Sophia Wood:

Thank you.

Jonah:

Professor Hon, can I share your email with the group?

Raoni Rajao:

Yeah, sure. That would be a my pleasure.

Jonah:

Great. I’ve pasted it in the room. I normally at the top of the hour, we go to what I call water cooler time or office hours, and we have we leave space for unstructured conversation for those who want to stay on. We leave the chat room open for those who want to copy. Thank you so much for your time. You’re you’re welcome to go or to stay whichever you wish. I’m going to stay around.

Raoni Rajao:

Yeah, Jonah, I think thank you very much. There’s been, you know, a great conversation. Fortunately, I have I have an appointment following up, but please, you know, everybody get in touch. Please send me emails, you know, if want to have further conversations from this. That would be really be my pleasure. And that’s it. I hope it has been helpful.

Unidentified participant:

It is very helpful. Thank you so much. Really appreciate it.

Jonah:

Thanks so much.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. Thank you. That was great.

Raoni Rajao:

All the best.

Unidentified participant:

See you later.

Jonah:

Hey guys.

Unidentified participant:

Hey Jonah. Hey. Following up that last question from Sophia, do you know has there been any look at sort of like a marine hydrokinetic or sort of like power extraction from the waterways down in some of these Amazonian areas?

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, there has Brazil gets like some extraordinary percentage of its electric power from hydro. It’s like 60%.

Unidentified participant:

Maybe it’s 40%. And there are some active hydro plants in the Amazon region, but there have also been some that they attempted to build, but protest stopped them from being built because they would flood indigenous lands and things like that. So, it’s controversial.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah.

Unidentified participant:

I don’t know too much about it.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. That’s interesting because there’s some of these there’s been a few companies in the last past decade and some of the labs up here have been looking at some of these like run of river type devices and kind of current devices that get away from the needs for these huge dams.

Unidentified participant:

Oh, really?

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. And I know some folks in that space and I’ve been kind of I hadn’t even thought about it as something applicable here, but it’s very good for sort of like onsite power or a village on a river maybe could use these kinds of things. Not sure, but.

Unidentified participant:

Well, that would be super interesting.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, I can I’ll see if I can poke around and send you some stuff.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, that’d be great. Wow. That there’s obviously a lot of water flow in the region.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, right. Exactly. Water everywhere.

Unidentified participant:

You could tap that without putting up a dam. It’s incredible.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. Yeah, it is. And they’ve even so some of the applications even in North America have in Europe have been for a you know can you put in sort of like a semi-permeable non-permanent dam structure that can you know like serve the load for the local sort of like tractor needs or whatever that kind of a thing.

Unidentified participant:

Wow. That’s huge. And I bet there are ways to do it so that it’s biologically friendly so you don’t have.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah.

Unidentified participant:

You know fish or whoever getting caught in it.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. Yeah. Especially because a lot of the investments come from European governments and the US government into some of these technologies. So, they’re always extremely worried about that and a huge amount of funding has already gone into things like tracking not just efficacy but safety for wildlife and everything. So, yeah.

Unidentified participant:

Nice.

Unidentified participant:

There’s two associations that have resources overlapping there too. There is a small hydro association the association just for the small hydro not the major dams the other one is EGSA which does that’s the association for distributed power generation which includes everything from small solar array small hydro to just your regular run-of-the-mill backup diesel generator. There.

Unidentified participant:

Wow. I’m gonna post these. I’m searching for them online.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, I’ll send you a couple. Here’s a I’ll put a couple in chat. Here’s this a couple ENL papers.

Unidentified participant:

Great.

Unidentified participant:

Here’s one about the environmental impacts for marine and hydrokinetic. And that’s the MHK is that subindustry of hydro power. It’s marine hydrokinetic energy, which basically means it’s either like ocean devices that bob up and down in the waves and generate power or that are tidal devices that you run the tide through a through a turbine on the seafloor.

Unidentified participant:

Or some other kind of similar types of devices. But yeah, let me see what else I can find.

Unidentified participant:

David, are you also involved in hydro entrepreneurship? You know I am not entirely involved in hydro entrepreneurship. I just happen to have a neighbor who was the senior policy advisor for this association.

Unidentified participant:

And looking at her LinkedIn, it looks like she left there a number of years ago, but the name of it is the American Public Power Association that does not for-profit electric utility sector.

Unidentified participant:

Interesting.

Unidentified participant:

She was the hydro person there.

Unidentified participant:

Rebecca Blood.

Unidentified participant:

Nice. Yeah, I’ll actually I’ll text my friend at ENL. He lives in Seattle, but he’s he’s big into the MHK stuff, and he would know about some of the riverbased systems. Actually, here’s a there’s a startup called Empower. It’s these guys. I’ll check this down.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, it’s an interesting area and it’s still it’s it’s still relatively it’s tough because you got to find the right application for it for the economics to pencil out. So, it’s.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah,.

Unidentified participant:

It’s something that hasn’t gotten to scale yet, but a lot of research money going into it. The price of internet access in the Amazon consistently goes down because of satellites because the cost of putting up satellites is consistently going down.

Unidentified participant:

So I think there’s a an emergent boom there, but the great majority of the population is in the urban Amazon.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah,.

Unidentified participant:

Those cities already have access.

Unidentified participant:

MRG is the company I was thinking about. Emg I just posted a link to their site here.

Unidentified participant:

Great.

Unidentified participant:

They do this kind of run river thing.

Unidentified participant:

Great company name.

Unidentified participant:

Well, you know what they Yeah. The woman who found it, it name is Emily. I think that’s where the em.

Unidentified participant:

I have a friend named Jennifer who has a lot of energy and her email address is Jennery.

Unidentified participant:

No way.

Unidentified participant:

What? Oh my god. Which is sort of fun based only on backing creatively named startups.

Unidentified participant:

You’re good.

Unidentified participant:

It’s easy as that. I do like the idea of looking at a broad cross-section of innovation in the United States, you know, people who’ve never thought of the Amazon and bringing them together on the Amazon and having, you know, a big brainstorm with some of the Norwegian governments and others watching, you know, to it be fun for us to put together a list of.

Unidentified participant:

I think that would be very fun and I don’t think it’d be too difficult to find a bunch of North American experts who’d be very interested in looking at this problem.

Unidentified participant:

Nice giant business opportunity.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah.

Unidentified participant:

I’ll send you guys an email about that. Do you guys know each other?

Unidentified participant:

We just met.

Unidentified participant:

Just met. Yeah.

Unidentified participant:

We’re gonna try to hop on the phone in the next couple weeks here.

Unidentified participant:

Great.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. You guys have similar tones.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah.

Unidentified participant:

Well, yeah. Great, Jenn. And I’ll I’ll shoot you an email with some more of this information about the MHK stuff and great to sync up on your thoughts on this experts conversation because I’m happy to think about people that might be good for that.

Unidentified participant:

Great. We’ve got some big news coming up this year for the Amazon Investor Coalition. Some expansion. We’re gonna be doing a big event like a global summit on the this is just planning phase now but maybe a global summit on the Amazon focused on investing in April.

Unidentified participant:

Oh wow.

Unidentified participant:

Focused on facilitating the transactions and in scaling.

Unidentified participant:

And our podcast just went live. I don’t know if you look at the website you can see it there. Our TEDex series. We’ve got 30 more episodes, you know, in the pipe that have already been recording. So, yes,.

Unidentified participant:

30 episodes. When did you have time for that?

Unidentified participant:

Well, it’s just the recordings of all these phone calls, you know, that we just haven’t posted online yet. So, so I haven’t had time to do all the editing, but I’ve got colleagues working on.

Unidentified participant:

So,.

Unidentified participant:

Super excited to have you guys on board, and there’s they’re giant opportunities. So very happy to follow you.

Unidentified participant:

I’m looking at the So it’s on the Amazoninvestor.org podcast site then.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. Yeah. If you see it says podcasts and videos.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. Congrats on getting those things out there. That’s exciting. That’s really great. And nice. So did you have a do you have a nice New Year’s and holiday and everything?

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. I know my kids better now than I have in so long. And their friends and their video games.

Unidentified participant:

Sure. The video games. Absolutely. Yeah. Right.

Unidentified participant:

How was your holiday?

Unidentified participant:

Flexing some video game muscles you haven’t used in a while.

Unidentified participant:

Exactly. How was your holidays?

Unidentified participant:

Mine was good. I was up I was up in Sacramento visiting family for over Christmas and then just back in Oakland for New Year. I don’t have any kids or anything. So, it was a lot of Zoom and video calls, catching up with friends and finding excuses to drink champagne.

Unidentified participant:

Didn’t need many excuses, but it was a lot of fun. Yeah.

Unidentified participant:

How are your holidays, David?

Unidentified participant:

Thank you. It was It was uneventful, but we’re we’re happy for that. My daughters are both home 23 and 15 and they were watching they watch thing British baking show. There’s some new Sean the Sheeps that are out and we watched some of those and the old series Merlin. We watched we watched that. And my 15-year-old, I’m teaching her to drive. So, I’m getting some getting to know her because.

Unidentified participant:

She’s got to talk to me if she wants a driving lesson, you know, otherwise she’ll just play her video game.

Unidentified participant:

That’s funny.

Unidentified participant:

That’s great. My I have a 16-year-old and a 11-year-old and the I’ve been itching the 16-year-old to study the driver’s manual and get into driving and he’s for six months just saying, “Oh, yeah, that’s a great idea.” Not doing it.

Unidentified participant:

No hurry there. Let them ride autonomously.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. Well said.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. No kidding. That lane assist going. And Dave, I just realized that you have an X-wing in the background, so that’s pretty exciting. Yeah,.

Unidentified participant:

Pretty good.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. One of the startups that I advise here on the east coast is a DC startup of the year called Airgility that uses AI with their drone video capture for all sorts of it’s safe AI anonymized and yet it’s giving useful information to the Air Force and the Department of Homeland Security and that sort of thing. And so we have our aviation and it sorts of backgrounds for those conversations to keep things interesting.

Unidentified participant:

Those are those are pretty good. I had my I had a call this morning with a with a client and in the background I changed this here but I had my Zoom from my some holiday stuff. So it was like Charlie Brown and Charlie Brown’s Christmas tree in my background. Hi which is like oh yeah that’s right. Zoom doesn’t doesn’t default or anything.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. Something to talk about.

Unidentified participant:

Neat.

Unidentified participant:

Nice. This is my very first time day using a Zoom background.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, you got a good one there, too. That looks like the Amazon.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, it is. I don’t know where, but that’s what Google images told me.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. Yeah, exactly. Very appropriate. Nice. All right. Well, thank you Jonah for setting these things up. I’m finding them very valuable and they’ve been great jumping into.

Unidentified participant:

How many speakers you’ve gotten these things. They’re all they’re all top-notch.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah, I it surprises me as well. You’d be surprised. And we’re we’re booked until midFebruary. So.

Unidentified participant:

We’ve we’ve the lineup continues.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. Great. Well, enjoy the start of the new year here. And yeah, I guess I will talk to I’ll follow up with you in an email, but we’ll all see you next Monday. Me or Andrew.

Unidentified participant:

Sounds great.

Unidentified participant:

All right.

Unidentified participant:

All right. Take care, fellas.

Unidentified participant:

Hey, guys. Have a good one.

Unidentified participant:

Later, David. Nice to meet you.

Unidentified participant:

You, too, John. Cheers, Jonah.

Unidentified participant:

Cheers, David. Have a good one. Bye, John.

Unidentified participant:

Bye, Jonah.