International Law and Protecting the Amazon
Astrid Puentes: Today we discuss international rule-of-law and the Amazon. You can’t have healthy economic development across the Amazon without the healthy rule of law. Founded in 1998, AIDA, the Interamerican Association for Environmental Defense, protects our right to a healthy environment by using the power of international law to create sustainable solutions across Latin America. As co-director of AIDA, Astrid Puentes joins us to tell the story.
Recorded December 14, 2020
WATCH:
Participants
- Jonah (moderator)
- Astrid Puentes
- Mate (Conexsus)
- John
- Atossa
- Unidentified participants
Transcript
Jonah:
Hello everybody. This is the 26th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. These are weekly calls that are managed by the Global Governance Philanthropy Network. It’s an outcome of the United Nations 75 global governance forum. Our goal is to a advance force friendly economic development across the Amazon region. And you can’t have healthy economic development without healthy rule of law. So this week we’re going to invite Astrid Puentes from Colombia and the Interamerican Legal Defense Association to talk about her work. And we’re going to conduct this interview in the form of an interview.
So let’s begin. Astrid, tell us a little bit about you and your life before AIDA.
Astrid Puentes:
Hi Jonah and hi everybody. It’s really a pleasure for me to join this call and see a lot of friends and people that we’ve been collaborating with for decades now. As you said Don I am Colombian. I am I was born in Bogotá. I was raised in Colombia and I studied law there and then I started working with environmental law since I was in law school and just fall in love with international environmental law and public interest and I did a master’s in comparative law at the University of Florida and at that time I already had learned about AIDA and have met a lot of colleagues from the region working on environmental law and got interested in that.
So after I did the LLM at the University in Florida in 2003, I graduated and started interning with AIDA U and Earthjustice in San Francisco. Actually at that time in Oakland and at that time I we started working with Atossa and Amazon watch with the UA case and other things for the Amazon and I’ve been with AIDA since then since 2003. So it has been a long time. Then I after six months or a year in living in California, we with Anna Cedarstep that was only the two of us at that time in AIDA.
We decided that it was better for me and the future team to be based in Latin America. So I moved to Mexico. The idea was to be here a year or two and then go to Colombia and then that become three and then I got married and have kids and I’ve been here for 16. So I’m based in Mexico City. And I work with and doing regional work including in the Amazon since then 17 years now.
Jonah:
Nice. Tell us what does AIDA stand for? What is the acronym stands for?
Astrid Puentes:
Yeah, exactly. That’s an acronym. So, it’s an opera as you all know and at the same time is an acronym in Spanish for I will say it in English first is the Interamerican Association for Environmental Defense and in Spanish that means associ. Tell us the birth story of the organization who thought it up where did it come from? So AIDA started in the 90s when at the at that time the MacArthur Foundation had a program that was established to support environmental law in the region. And so in addition to and to complement their work for conservation they started to invest on environmental law and they also did grantees meetings and in those meetings an organization from Colombia from the publicico that doesn’t I mean still exist now but it’s tiny.
But the founder Herman Sarento was a visioner that wanted to use and started to use litigation for the protection of public interest and through those meetings with MacArthur they met with he met with people or other environmental attorneys from Mexico, Peru, the US, Canada and Costa Rica and they all were sharing the same thread. It was the 90 at the end of the 90s a lot of the trade free negotiations were under negoti well the first between the US and Mexico just was negotiated and globalization was seen as a huge threat for the environment and a lot of the same threats and challenges were shared by all of these environmental attorneys that wanted to use international law as a tool to better protect the environment in their countries and in the region and that is the seed for AIDA.
AIDA started then with a funding from seed funding from MacArthur in the grant was 96 and AIDA was started in 98. We are registered in California and now we’re also registered in Mexico and since that since then we have been a regional organization mostly of attorneys. All of us are in Latin America and are born and raised and studied law in Latin America. And we also coordinate with scientists. We have three scientists in our team and communicators and development key people like Eli in this call that so we’re using the law to support communities and organizations all over the region for environmental protection and human rights and climate justice.
That’s one of the things that we didn’t include at the beginning and now we’re working for a few years.
Jonah:
Tell me about not your member organizations or maybe they used to be member organizations. Tell us a little bit about your partner organizations names.
Astrid Puentes:
Right. And that was a key change I at the beginning the idea was to do to be a only a general secretariat so that it will be coordinating the work that the organizations in different countries were going to implement regarding international law including bring bringing legal cases at different international fora. And very soon they realized that was not possible because people already were overwhelmed with work and it’s not the same to be an attorney in each country than to do international law and that’s when AIDA’s staff started to grow and so we work very closely at the beginning we used to have and we still have participant organizations that are organizations that we closely work with and these are SAMA in Mexico, Justice in the US, EcoJustice in Canada, SPDA in Peru, Sedarena in Costa Rica, and then others came like FEMA in Chile, Echollex in Ecuador, Turalesa in Costa Rica and Fundico in Colombia that used to be very strong and with the time and the founder passed away.
So that’s not we’re not working with them that much. And so that was at the like first years. And now what we do is we basically coordinate directly with organizations and communities in different countries including in Brazil where we don’t officially have a participating organization but we do a lot of work. The idea behind that is that the participating organizations were going to be our only or most like sister organizations and now there are many more other environmental law organizations and people litigating and using international law or that we coordinate with.
So that’s one of the things that we are changing or have changed in the history of AIDA. We still coordinate very closely with these organizations and others that are using law or directly litigating.
Jonah:
When we spoke earlier I remember three pillars of your work environmental governance environmental justice climate justice. Can you tell us how you came up with those a and give us a little bit more details about each of those?
Astrid Puentes:
Sure. So as we all are working in this there are tons of things to do that there’s a lot of work as you know Latin America and the Caribbean are more than 30 countries so that’s a lot of work and we over time have been always identifying how can we be more strategic about the work that we do. We’re working in a region as you know where there’s a lot of inequalities. It’s one of the most biodiverse regions worldwide. We have mega diverse countries like Brazil, Peru, Colombia, Costa Rica. And so at the same time, you also have wonderful constitutions and sometimes legal frameworks.
And the rule of law is one of the challenges. And so for us, environmental governance is key. So it’s not only advance with a decision or have a good legal decision from a court but specifically strengthen environmental governance in general participation transparency and collaborate for the strengthen of the rule of law. So that’s one key pillar that has been in our work. The other element that we have been working a lot is linking environmental protection and human rights. So the work that we do as attorneys is not only about protecting the ecosystems and the species but linking that with the human right the protection of the human rights and I mean this is same thing in the Amazon or Mesoamerican region where communities are linked with the ecosystems and the areas that need to be protected and at the same time it’s about the rights.
So that is another pillar which we call environmental justice. That in the US traditionally seen more with an agenda linked with for example black communities or Latino communities and in Latin America when we talk about environmental justice is crossing this environmental protection to make sure that human rights are also protected and that’s is another pillar. And the third one that is crossing everything and is transversal and with time gets more attention and understanding it’s climate justice. And it’s on the same idea. We don’t work in AIDA for only diminishing emissions or numbers of hectares to protect or how many tons of CO2 we need to take out of the atmosphere which is key.
But we need climate action including people and communities in the center. Also because Latin America is one of the most or actually is the most unequal region in the world. So we don’t want to have environmental protection or climate or climate action without having people. And so that’s the third pillar. Thinking also that communities and people that are less responsible for the climate crisis are the ones that are suffering more today the impacts and so that is one of the key things that we have been working and even including human rights in climate so in the negotiations in the NDC’s everything that it’s done about climate we have prioritized over a decade to include human rights let’s talk a little bit about attorneys and attorneys in the United States compared to Latin America.
Being an environmental defense lawyer or environmental defense litigator is an identity. It’s a it’s a march for justice. But how many are there? How does the environmental defense attorney landscape in the United States look compare to this the equivalent landscape across Latin America? So there are not concrete numbers and we have tried to have some numbers for Latin America but we don’t I mean we have dedicated more better the time to do the litigation or the work but as far as we know there are around dozens in Latin America environmental attorneys doing this work in AIDA.
One of the things that we’re proud of with other organizations is that we have h a group of teams that are professionals full-time dedicating their our careers to this with you know with salaries and with organization that support us. That’s that’s not the general we have we see a lot of attorneys that are working in our countries with very little resources. And if we compare that to the US or Europe, the numbers are really worrisome. No, there are hundreds even in one or one organization in the US, one of these large organization of environmental protection, there hundreds of professionals.
It’s probably a piece of that we have in Latin America. So it is definitely not the same. And that’s one of the things that we have to invest and continue. And I think that’s one of the key things that we have seen over the time that AIDA and other organizations have worked. When I started I remember that even before I was with AIDA in the masters I took a class on environmental entrepreneurship and the professor asked us what was our dream work job and I describe it as do international environmental law in Latin America but there was none position for that there was no other person was doing that and I was the first attorney in AIDA and now we are about a dozen and then also we have there’s a lot of other organizations having attorneys in across the region including with indigenous organizations universities but again we’re not even close to what we need and that not only is about attorneys is about communicators scientists community organizers know all of the parts of the puzzle or the petals of the flower that we need in the region.
We also as you probably know Latin America is the most dangerous region worldwide and we have seen that and a lot of us in this call have seen that our friends family you know close people have been threat even killed and so here in Latin America is not only about using the law to protect X or Y ecosystem but it’s about making sure that the people that we all are safe and that is definitely a challenge that other people do not have in no in the US or at least not the same challenge.
I mean we I’ve had colleagues in the US being subpoenaed or going to court because of all of the work that we do. But is the threat is different. So that is definitely something that we still have to strengthen. The amount of resources that are that is available is also still very unequal really. Let’s go a little bit deeper into the work of AIDA and the legal planning and litigation and defense. So when it comes to gold extraction or mining, illegal or legal, and large infrastructure projects like roads and dams, tell us a little bit about your historical work in these areas.
So one of the things that AIDA does is that we look at the strategy. I mean at the end the law laws and the legal actions that we have are tools. And so we identify which tools are going to be useful for whatever is needed. One of the things that we are seeing as you mentioned is that in general extractives is a huge challenge and threat really to the ecosystems and the communities in the region. So we have identified have worked for example in dams for over a decade because it’s not clean energy and that’s one of the key also problems that we have.
They’re seen as clean energy. They’re getting now funding for from for example climate and seeing a solution. So what we see is how can we strategically first of all prevent some projects that will be mostly destructive and also strengthen the rule of law and strengthen standards and legal frameworks. And so in the case for dams and mine mining and infrastructure AIDA has research for international best practices. We are about to publish a report that we already have read. It’s only in design about the key best practices for EIA for environmental impact assessments.
It’s going to be available in Portuguese, English and Spanish. So that most of the continent will have it available in the hemisphere. And so we are identifying strategically how to create these general legal best practices to implement to implement in specifically projects. But we also know that we can’t advance and get the victories that we need project by project. There are hundreds of dams. That’s illegal mining in all the Amazon. So we are investing also and u advancing on capacity building and so we just started some workshops on mining in the Amazon that some of you have seen and we just last week had the three first workshops so that we can talk to communities and organizations and even key people scientists in the region to strengthen that knowledge.
We also have produced a few documents on for example science and standards but what are the things that they a government has to have in mind when doing EIA from the scientific and technical perspective. And also we have advanced a little bit on solutions and this is definitely something that we would love to improve and increase more because we have said no to dams or mining or fracking or now coal. We also are working on coal but we also need to give governments and help identify solutions. So that’s another key thing and we have seen that there’s a lot of communities that have implemented solutions that are key and that is the root of the mining or the whatever is tractive that the Amazon is happening today’s mining a century ago was Rob no or the robbers.
So that’s a lot of the things that we’re doing is trying to use the law to face the root of the problem and using international law has been key because our countries use international law as a as a source and also it’s a key thing to increase the pressure and to advance things that maybe nationally are not able to be seen. Bel Monte is one example that it’s h we 10 year more than 10 years ago we had the dream to stop it. We unfortunately couldn’t stop that monster in the Shingu River but at least today there it is an example of what should not happen and investors know about that insurance know about that banks know about that and so creating at least precedents to avoid these kinds of things to be repeated in other places.
Whenever we can’t prevent or stop a project then at least creating accountability is something that we are working on.
Jonah:
Let’s go a little bit deeper into the question of international law. So there’s a all countries have law and environmental law and there’s a relationship between local law, national sovereignty and international law. And sometimes when a country’s laws on the books don’t go far enough, the employment of international legal instruments becomes a way to find justice. So could you tell us educate us a little bit about the treaties that are involved and also the intergovernmental and interamerican judicial structures like the interamerican court of human rights and how you guys have used such structures.
Astrid Puentes:
Thank you. And I don’t know if you hear in the background that my neighbors are doing some renovations. So there’s they just started the more sound. So this is the pandemic really. So with international law we have exactly we use the universal system that is the UN. So the UN has all of this structure. There are human rights treaties but there also environmental treaties and other treaties that are related even with labor like the whole international labor organization. So we use basically as I mentioned the tools whatever treaty or report that can be useful.
But in general the UN has for example not only the treaties but also special procedures that are called the rapper tours and there are more than 20 rapper tours or special raer tours for a lot of different topics and so that is something that we can use and in addition to that we have the treaty bodies. So each treaty even the there dozens of treaties but the treaties on the rights to children the treaties on the elimination of discrimination the treaties on the elimination of discrimination against women there’s several treaties that can be used and we have used them in at the UN less that the interamerican system but we also use that and the other system that you mentioned is the regional system where is in the organ it’s the organization of American states.
So it’s in this hemisphere and there we have the interamerican court we have the interamerican commission and we also have the possibility to have rapper tours or the political space with the general assembly there that’s a lot of challenges with the geopolitics today as you can imagine but as at the same time there are different scenarios that can be used one of the things that we are very proud of and I think that this is A key tool that we still have to use more is that recently the interamerican court has an advisory opinion.
So it’s not under a case litigating a community or a person against a state but was an opinion that the state of Colombia requested to the court asking about obligations of states linked with human rights when there is a threat to the environment. The advisor opinion is number 23 of in 2017 and that one is establishes and clarifies the obligations regarding the environment including related with indigenous communities and others and it’s the same the first time that a court of that level worldwide recognized that climate change exists for starters and that it’s linked to human rights.
And so that is a decision that we’re using not only regionally but also and more nationally. And we know that sometimes our states need that international pressure or a leverage. It’s a additional leverage to either comply with their constitution comply with a decision or advise advance decisions that we need in different countries that for example we are using today in Colombia fracking that is the destruction of gas and oil using hydraulic fracture is has a judicial moratorium today in Colombia and has had for almost a little bit more than two years.
And so these are tools that we have used. Same thing with the Paris agreement. We also are using the Paris agreement that is b binding in our countries because it was ratified. So once it passes congress then it becomes an it becomes an obligation. And so yeah there are a lot of u international treaties. We also have used a lot the Ramsar convention that is a convention to protect wetlands. And we have for decades used well for 15 years to used the Ramser convention to call attention from the secretariat whenever there’s a project that can be destroying one of the wetlands that the Ramser the convention protects.
Yeah, there other treaties that maybe slip my mind now, but it depends on what we have done. And this is definitely key to be part of the strategy. We know that there’s no silver bullets. And in the case of I don’t know the UA case or bell you know there’s like a combination of things where people and the communities are at the center and they are identifying what is needed and we as attorneys help to identify international law so that we can see how that can strengthen the strategies under development.
Jonah:
Great. Okay. We’re reaching the midway point. I’ve got three more questions and then we’re going to open it up for other people. So the next one is Astrid, you and I spoke previously about the design of legal systems in the region and the need to increase risks for business as well, not just for governments and civil society. Governments need to see more viable economic opinions or options to conserve the Amazon for example so they can leave oil and gold in the ground instead of just litigating what is wrong. We need we can strengthen what is right.
What ideas do you have to make that possible?
Astrid Puentes:
Right. That’s one of the things that I mentioned at the be or that’s what I the things that I was related to when I said that we and in this we I include everybody in the movement not only AIDA that we have to continue and strengthen working on alternatives and solutions and not only say no to projects and that’s a huge challenge. We I mean there are a lot of solutions. One of the key things that I think we have to do and it’s pending is to put to actually put communities and people in the center of the work that we’re doing and we don’t see that still in the climate action still climate action and I don’t know if you saw like the ambition summit on Saturday and the proposals from countries all of that is still done from a technical perspective with only one perspective and communities are still not included there.
So we really have to see what are the things that we need to still do. For example, when we’re talking about energy and again Belmont is a good example. It was a project that when we talked with people from Ben that were funding the project ex people that used to work with the bre that were was one of the companies that built the project. When we talked with people from the government there’s not one single person that has told me that they wanted the bamonte to be built or that they thought that blemon was a good idea.
Everybody thought that it was a bad idea and still they didn’t. Right? So making sure that frameworks are implemented and that we see other opportunities from the Amazon beyond extraction of anything whether it’s biodiversity, oil and gas. There are a lot of other possibilities for protecting and we need to be that to do that in a way that is profitable for communities in also and the way to learn that is to ask them and to include them and a key element also and you’re thinking about like suggestions or proposals is also to have a gender perspective because women are not only the most impacted we with this infrastructure whether in indigenous communities or local communities or cities, women are most impacted by the climate and the biodiversity crisis, but they’re also part or we are also part of the solution.
So that’s another key thing that we have to do. And definitely use the potential that our countries have. It is possible to do energy transition. It’s possible to do it correctly. There is also a lot of inequalities. So advancing in the responsibility from all the change you mentioned governments and also businesses and we think in AIDA and that’s one of the things that we want to explore more is how to make businesses worldwide accountable for the destruction of the Amazon and how to increase not only the responsibility but also the solutions because we most mostly we see the legal including legal work done against countries which is key and we or and governments which is key and we need to continue but there’s a piece of the chain that is not being responsible and that is the companies and local no consumption and consumers.
So that’s one thing that it’s important to see and make sure that investments are actually accountable and do and are done in a way that is sustainable and that will actually be consistent with all of the promises and the international treaties that we have.
Jonah:
Can you tell us a little bit about the rights of nature and where that’s had success or not and what it is for those who might not know? For those.
Astrid Puentes:
Exactly for I will start with the last one then so rights of nature is a concept that has been developed for the last few years that considers nature as a subject of rights and not only an object of exploitation or extraction. We have two constitutions in Latin America that include them that it’s Ecuador and Bolivia and that has helped a lot to at least have nature as or consider the concept that nature actually has rights and thus we have to protect her and conserve. One of the challenges that we have seen is that while these countries or other in laws have mentioned the rights to nature those same constitutions and we have it in the cuadorian constitution also considers extraction is extractive of oil as a national priority.
So there’s a lot of inconsistencies while protecting right to nature continuing doing this extraction. We have an experience in Colombia. We helped application for the Atrat River that is a key river in the Choco area which is absolutely key and for decades has been impacted by illegal mining of gold mainly and here it’s a lot of illegal mining by small companies but mo mostly communities or illegal actors. In the Chakor region we also have paramilitaries and guerillas so it’s all the conflict in Colombia mixed there and so it was a litigation that a Colombian organization worked with the indigenous communities and the afro descendant communities in that area and they thought that considering the Atrato River as a subject of rights will help them to increase the protection because it was not only as I mentioned an element of an ecosystem that is the river.
But also whenever the river has rights then it increases the level of protection at the constitutional level which was recognized by the constitutional court. And that has been advancing and it really needs a lot of background and really a movement to be that or to have that behind so that it actually moves beyond only a recognition of a decision. In Colombia there’s also another decision that declares the Amazon subject of rights and that decision has been still pending to be enforced and one of the challenges there is that for example indigenous movements were not included as part of the litigation and so it has been difficult to advance.
But that is so recognizing rights is definitely something that is advancing. We have decisions in New Zealand and other parts of the world. And it helps or it can help as a tool but at the same time it makes us think whether we need to recognize rights to everything in order to protect it which is kind of a failure of the legal system. And so that’s one challenge that we have today when Wall Street included water as a commodity that now is being under negotiation in the in the in Wall Street and water is also a human right so it’s it’s again tools that we need to implement in reality and that’s one of the challenges that we have as an attorney is to make sure that law is actually being implemented to change and to create justice in the ground.
Jonah:
Last question for me and then I know people are super excited to ask questions of you. So we’ll we’ll make this quick. I remember the work that you guys did on coral reeves and how it was able to influence policy in six countries. And it inspired me to imagine that there might be some model package of legislation that could be delivered to subnational governments or national governments around the Amazon region. Could you just tell us a little bit about that experience and we’ll be able to extrapolate from it how it would be helpful for the Amazon?
Astrid Puentes:
Right. So that was a work that we have worked on the protection of coral reefs and marine for all the 20 plus years of AIDA. And for years we have been trying to convince governments why it was important to protect coral reefs and there’s international law and other thing and other laws and legislation but it was hard to advance that those legislations. One of the things that we started doing also is to identify best practices. So even from the psychological perspective to talk with governments about positive examples of what kinds of things they can do that was one shift.
And the other thing that helped a lot is to help governments understand how much they were actually also losing by destroying an hector of a coral reef. Because for Costa Rica for example it was about six years ago we used working with Econo environmental economists identify that one hector of Aora reef produced about 600,000 per year $600,000 per year that was something that they were not even considering. So we started to collaborate in those conversations and then help identify how the government with the analysis of the legal frameworks how they were not conserving corora reeves and they were basically considering cora reeves as invisible and so we started with Costa Rica that is I know that is not the typical government that we have in Latin America there’s a lot of differences perspective there but we started there with a regulation or helping the government to advance a regulation to protect coral reefs.
And then we collaborated with other countries as you mentioned now six to start having at least regulations to better protect those areas that are key and maybe this is a key thing that we can do for the Amazon. And complementing the law and the numbers because we again as with the example of water in Wall Street not everything has a price and cannot have a price. So identifying also with governments why is it important and how can they benefit by conserving an area and it’s not only because we want them to be green and we don’t want anything to be developed but actually it was a good investment for government to protect coral reefs and so that is something that we have events with Guatemala, Colombia, Honduras, Costa Rica and yeah and so and the lease.
Jonah:
Mhm. Great. Thank you. My mind is swimming. Okay. Mate, please introduce yourself and you’re first up.
Mate (Conexsus):
Hi, good afternoon everyone. My name is Marina Teresa Compus but people call me Mate. So I am from Brazil and I work as an executive director of Conexsus which is the Institute for Sustainable Connections and we are currently working with a community- based enterprises in entire Brazil not with a special focus on the Amazon but in lots of regions working on to improve their business models open different channels for commercialization as well as creating a whole a whole suit of financial investments that they can grow and that they can be a stronger inclusive Amazonian economy that we always hope to have.
But thank you so much Astrid for your for your conversation actually because it was not even a lecture was even more pleasant. So I know I have heard a lot about the AIDA work but I had never had a chance to meet anyone from there. So, so it’s it’s a ma a major pleasure for me but and I do know the importance of using international law to leverage and to call international attention to a lot of things that happen nationally but ultimately if I’m not a lawyer so but ultimately as far as I know people got the fines or go to jail or all the things in their national court systems and as you can imagine all our national court systems at least I can tell you more about the I know in Brazil it’s really slow and things really take it if things get some kind of ending it takes decades.
So how can we work in really improving rule of law when you have a judiciary system that is so slow and so counterproductive? I don’t know if what other things can be done that you see could be possible. Thank you.
Astrid Puentes:
J. Nice to meet you, Marina. I maybe I think that we met some in a cup or something. I have a recollection. So that’s one of the key challenges that we have. The rule of law in our countries, it’s very slow. And even the fact that when we go to law school, there’s no environmental law in law schools yet. I mean, there’s some universities that are advancing. And so when we go there for judges today that are maybe in their 60s 70s I mean they never took environmental law. So one of the key things is how to educate judges on that and there’s other organizations with that.
We did some efforts in Bolivia over the summer or the spring with more than a thousand Bolivian environmental lawyers who were very interested in environmental law. So that’s definitely and as I said there’s no silver bullet. One of the things that we have seen and Belmonte and evenango in Colombia are good examples where using international law is a way in which we can increase accountability and that pro processes na nationally in the courts advance because they know that there are eyes looking at them. Recently in Brazil with the climate litigations there are there was for example an amicuse by the UN special reperator on environment and human rights and so that is a way in which we can definitely collaborate and I one thing that I think that I didn’t either mention or was very clear is that we can use international law in national courts and advocacy as Well, and so that is something that we do.
We do a lot of amikus, so there are briefings to support national litigation. A lot of I mean, as much as we can because we’re 30 about 30 in the region and 15 with including 15 attorneys, but we review a lot of the legal briefs that our colleagues prepare even in Brazil for example from MEPFA. And so help to prepare them how to incorporate international in their argument so that this can be advanced but yes Marina we don’t have I mean the legal system that we have is what we have and so it is not only that but by doing that it’s not going to only that help and at the same time we systematically hear communities saying we need an attorney we need a lawyer we need a lawyer so that is definitely something that is needed and just to finish that is also something that we see that works to influence the business sector and the financial sector because and again Belmont is an example we after years helped now that the Norwegian pension fund decided to take out Electrograss from their list of investors.
And we have been litigating Belmont at the commission at the Interamerican Commission for more than 10 years. There are dozens of litigations against Belmont in Brazil going nowhere and the biggest thing that has happened was this year elector grass being take out from this investment. So again this is what I mean about coordinating strategies within ritual was the same thing. Now there’s a criminal prosecution against the decision makers of this dam that is the second largest in Colombia. And by the time that we brought a case, the community brought a case that we support them at the IDB mechanism, accountability mechanism, no one wanted to talk about anything bad about the dam.
And now that the fact that there’s a case with no teeth, by the way, I mean, Miy the IDB doesn’t have any teeth, but the fact that their eyes from this mechanism helps advance a criminal investigation, a civil action in Colombia. So, some responsibilities.
Jonah:
Great. Thank you. Hey, John, you’re next up. Please introduce yourself and go ahead and go straight into your question.
John:
Great. Thanks Jonah and thank you so much Astrid for the talk and presentation today. This is really interesting. John Meisner from MXV Ventures in Oakland, California. So you talked a little bit about valuing natural resources like the coral reefs and how that was a method to show the governments that there’s what the actual value is beyond sort of extraction or degradation. Are there standards around that type of a thing, international standards, or do the methods kind of change every time you try to do this? You bring a different consultant in, they do their method kind of that type of thing.
And then also follow up to that, do the governments in South America recognize the validity of those assessments for the value of say a hectare of coral reefs?
Astrid Puentes:
So, John, there are not international standards for valuing that. And there is as you probably know there’s a lot of contro controversy to even talk about that because as we know I mean nature is not only is not only valuable because it has a price because nature doesn’t have a price as we know right but when we’re talking about investments or projects it is important for governments to see why in the balance a project is a good investment or not and that is something that is why we’re are working a lot with these investments or with these procedures.
There is this is one of the key things that we still need to do in the environmental impact assessments for example and policies nature is not included the value of nature is not included so it’s free it’s elimmited so water is not eliminated as we know and so making sure that even th that those costs are adequately included is a key thing and that is something that has helped a lot in fracking with the fracking discussion in Colombia for example that the government has seen that they need to include the cost of how much money if there’s an accident or the lack of the certainty of the fracking how much money the government will have to be investment in when if something goes wrong with fracking and they know that’s another thing that helps a lot is the insurance the insurance policies and I think that’s a key thing that we have to learn from the no coal or the stop coal campaigns worldwide where one of the things that they have done is to increase the insurance of the coal projects and there’s a lot of insurance companies that are not invest that are not insuring coal because it’s way too costly the ritual that I mentioned before in Colombia because of the disaster of the EIA and everything that was done wrong because it was wrong planned it is today the biggest loss for the insurance business worldwide in a construction project in history right it’s huge and I mean we have been sharing the information IDA by the way is tiny as can as no we’re 30 including admin and communication so we do everything that we know but or that we can but this is the key for examples that we need to share I mean a dam that was not very bad planned.
There was millions of dollars investments and today it has been the biggest loss in history of the insurance construction because of the it’s not an accident that one of the tunnels collapsed and flooded all the turbines. And so these are don’t it’s we don’t have we don’t have those standards. We have to advance that. But I think that we also have to advance smartly and strategically in this example like how to document that so that governments and banks and investors actually see that it’s not about hugging the trees and it’s not about saving the penguins.
It’s that we are investing in the wrong way. No, it’s a lot of money that is they’re losing. I mean for others are human rights and the rights to nature but even for business sector they are losing millions of dollars by not by not protecting the environment and human rights in the right way.
Jonah:
Thank you. That’s great. That’s a serious damn fail. Wow. No kidding. Atosa, you’re up next.
Unidentified participant:
Hello Astrid. I’m really delighted to hear your presentation today and you know I’ve worked with Astre since the 90s since the beginning of Aayita. We’ve worked on several big cases together and I’m you know just so grateful for your work. So I think it’s so important and I hope that you know Aayita is gets to grow significantly to basically scale up the work you’re doing because we need legal defense everywhere. I just want to make one quick qu u comment and then a question. You know, I think that the combination of campaigning with communities on the ground doing you know, PR and campaigning targeting investors and financial institutions that are funding the mega projects is just goes handinhand with the legal strategy and feeds on the legal strategy.
Saw that in, you know, fighting the Bellamancha dam or the UA case in Colombia and many others that those two things are really both need to be resourced and seen as you know complimentary definitely even if a case is filed and doesn’t seem to get through the courts in time, the investors are basically have due diligence staff. They’re there to really look for risks and anytime there’s a legal action that’s a red flag for investors to do due diligence and that makes a difference. It gives us power and leverage and often delays buys time.
So that was my comment. My question is in as you look in the coming year at the different cases that are coming up, what are some of the two or three important cases for us to be really getting behind and building a collaboration on that you see that Aayita is leading? You know, I also just want you probably know the UA case made it to the American court on human rights. So, we have that important case that you were helped you were a part of in back in 1998. But anyway, what are the two or three cases we should really keep our eyes on?
And I know we don’t have a lot of time, but I’d love to hear it. Thank you so much.
Astrid Puentes:
Right. And I speak a lot. So, one, I absolutely support what you said at the beginning at Tossa, and I want to mention a couple of things, including and so thinking about the three cases. The UA case at the court is definitely one that we should look at and see how we can support with stretching the resources that we have. And in that case, reflects a lot of the cases that we work. The fact that there is a case that was brought at the interamerican commission internationally open the possibility for the communities to have meetings with high positions from the Colombian governments.
They’re not here like literally they’re not heard. I mean I have one of the other cases that we have is in Peru Laoa which is not about the Amazon but it’s about public health and a smelter that has been operating for hund almost 100 years. It has been more than 10 years at the commission and it hasn’t been decided because it’s too complicated and it’s a lot of political situations. And one of the women that we represent, they systematically were denied to receive copies of their medical history at the hospital.
And just because I was with them without speaking a word, they were given copies of their medical history. It’s it’s insane the inequalities and the discrimination that we have. I think that fracking and the fact that fracking today is suspended in Colombia has a judicial suspension is key. Not only because it’s I mean maybe not directly linked with the Amazon, but we are what we’re dealing here is key decisions that we have to stop things to advance. There are a couple of cases on the Amazon, one in Peru at the constitutional tribunal about kids that sue, it’s a climate litigation, kids that sue the Peruvian government so that they have their rights protected.
And stopping coal. I think that is also key. I mean, there a lot of things, the Warani cases, and I’m just brainstorming, but the Warani cases in Ecuador, I think are key. Making sure that we don’t forget about the Shingu and Bonte. I mean, it’s huge work that we, a few of us here are also involved and people today just forget about that and the dam is still there. We have the bellison that is a mind. So making sure that those things that are happening we continue using those examples as why we have to make things differently.
We are facing the recovery with the pandemic and the governments are increasing investments in everything that has to go away. So we really have to this year as you mentioned is key to put light on what is working and what needs to be getting attention. And that is why like the work that you we do in the US and Europe definitely supports the work that is done in Latin America.
Jonah:
Astri, I want to thank you on behalf of all the other people participating in the call and on behalf of the Amazon for all of your extraordinary work. Thank you for educating us. Thank you for enrolling us. Now at the top of the tower hour, we go to what I call water cooler time or office hours where there isn’t a set agenda and people are welcome to introduce themselves and sort of ask each other questions in an unstructured way. I see that you post your email. Everybody, I encourage you to follow up with Astrid as much as you would like and thank you so much for joining us.
Any last words?
Astrid Puentes:
Thank you. It’s great to see you. It’s great to see a lot of friends and colleagues here in our boxes and so hopefully that we will continue be in touch and thank you also for your work. We’re all in this together.
Jonah:
Great. Okay, follow up. The floor belongs to anybody.
Unidentified participant:
Hi everyone. Thank you.
Jonah:
Most people will probably get off the call, but usually a couple takers.
Unidentified participant:
I just I’m just so you know I’m just remembering the important work we’ve done on Bellanche and I do think you’re right that issue really it needs like almost a refresh because there were some legal decisions recently. Yeah. That those I mean we’ve we won dozens of legal actions and then we lost the next one. So but right now it seems like there’s some momentum. It feels like maybe a blog post or an op-ed or something in that could really be circulated would be really great idea.
Astrid Puentes:
Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. And I mean we’re happy to continue talking and if I mean it’s not the same as you know if it’s a national newspaper or the New York Times or No. So all of those connections help us a lot to spread the word really.
Unidentified participant:
That’s right.
Jonah:
Great. I have one question. Astrid that we just didn’t have time to get into. Could you.
Astrid Puentes:
I know it was a lot of the time go.
Jonah:
It was it was great though. Could you tell me a little bit about how you guys also I want to catch it on record because the call is still being recorded. About how you guys consult with local governments or NGOs on h on international instruments like how to change your strategy in response to the climate agreement or how to become a candidate for the green climate fund.
Astrid Puentes:
So that’s that’s a key thing Jer one of the things that we have seen is that a lot of times and that’s why I always continue to mention like this toolkits because sometimes when we talk with governments and authorities they don’t know that there is ex the Ramsar treaty to protect this wetland or that there is this obligation they’re just so isolated and sometimes people don’t even know that This can be useful also when we talk about governments. Governments have a lot of people authorities and so then we see the environmentalist minister fighting with the finance minister and so we consult we ask what is needed and we try as much as possible to understand what is happening and I think that’s one of the key things about AIDA or other colleagues that we are based in the region so we understand not only the things that are on top of the table but like on between the lines and the political threats that can move things forward in a different direction.
And in a lot of ways and it h it’s happening now with Mexico for example or even with Colombia that when a country is being inconsistent nationally but they have internationally experiences or leadership about how environmentalist they are. Then we use that to show the inconsistencies and how if we don’t advance if they don’t advance something then they will be violating international law and just sometimes by mentioning that they don’t like that and they don’t like to be seen like that. The other thing that happen is that with the US or European funding they will be risking some of that funding.
Hopefully the US and Europe will be more consistent with the no human rights etc. They’re not but sometimes we have that leverage as well. I don’t even talk about that but in Colombia we work a lot for years against the US policy to spray cocka fields with Roundup. And so what we didn’t advance nationally with the government, we could with key spokes or people in the Senate and Congress in the US that will include requirements or conditions for the endorsement of two billion dollars to Colombia. And so it’s it’s a combination and we I mean we were the people sending the information as I the legal and environment environmental and scientific information the key people at Congress were based in the US in Washington.
So, so it’s a really a combination and to a key element there is to understand the issues correctly and to see who is influence who do we have to convince who is putting the money who is making the final decision to see like what kinds of leverage will be more useful. There are a lot of re situations and a is still here and happens a lot with Brazil that a lot of situations when we do work but we are nowhere to be found because it’s better that international organizations are not seen but there are others that it’s better it helps more because they the government this is a positive leverage that they see no so it’s really a dance a lot Jonah and to really make sure that you understand because sometimes s which happened also with Makri and the fires in Brazil.
He wanted to say that he was supportive and then Bolson was accusing France to be imperialistic and tell them what to do which is exactly the scenario that we don’t want. So it really makes difference to be consulting and having the feet in the ground so that we can strategically and positively use international law or other tools anyway.
Jonah:
Atosa, you’re the reason I know about Astri, but you told Yeah, you told but you told me back in 2017 when we were putting on Nexus and I just had in my notes and.
Unidentified participant:
Oh, cool.
Jonah:
Yeah.
Atossa:
Yeah. Well, Astre, I’m I’m excited to brainstorm with you on the UA case going both the UA case and the Banani case that have been going on for UA case for 20 years and the Wani case for since 2003 are both going to the court, American court on human rights this year. So those are.
Astrid Puentes:
Oh, I didn’t know about the Wani.
Atossa:
Yeah, they’re both going to the court this year. And so we really need to pow-wow on, you know, with you and Sahil and, you know, groups in Ecuador and Earth Rights, like all the legal groups. We should really pow-wow and figure out how to make the most out of those moments. Those are really.
Astrid Puentes:
Right. Right. And I Yeah. Because we need the court to implement, that’s why also I mentioned the advisory opinion. We need the court to incorporate those decisions to cases and to talk about climate. And they’re very the commission is very shy. They say a lot of thing or some things in reports but not in cases. And what makes government advance is decisions on cases because if not we’re just going to have standards without being implemented. So yes, we definitely have to continue brainstorming. We should coordinate a call next like in January or something like I’m sure that we’re all top for this year.
But yes,.
Atossa:
Wordful. But thank you so much, Estri. Lots of love. Jonah, thank you for your continued leadership. I’m going to jump on in on another call, but I really.
Astrid Puentes:
Yeah, Jonah, thank you very much for putting us together. And I was so excited to see a lot of friends, including Atosa and Amalia and David and I remember others in this call.
Jonah:
My great pleasure. Thanks so much for joining. Absolutely. Okay.