Investing in New Market Opportunities in the Amazon: Perspectives of a Local Amazonian Retailer

Denis Minev: Today we learn about one man’s journey to advance Amazon-region eco-entrepreneurship. Denis Minev is an Amazonian business leader, investor, and philanthropist. As President of Bemol, one of the region’s largest chains of retail stores, Denis advocates for conservation through a kind of economic development that mobilizes new entrepreneurs, reduces bureaucracy, and pioneers technological innovation.

Recorded November 30, 2020

WATCH:

  • Jonah (moderator)
  • Denis Minev
  • Jody Weiss
  • Keith Agoada
  • Peter (XPRIZE Rainforest)
  • Margarita
  • Colleen
  • Marita
  • John (MXV Ventures)
  • Unidentified participants

Unidentified participant:

From S. Paulo University, the Amazonia 4.0 program.

Jonah:

Keith and Jody, you guys want to introduce yourselves?

Jody Weiss:

Sure. Jody Weiss with True.net, speaking to you from Chicago, Illinois.

Keith Agoada:

Keith Agoada from Producers Market, currently in Los Angeles, California.

Jonah:

And Peter or anyone else?

Peter (XPRIZE Rainforest):

Yep, just hopping on. Peter Wulhan from XPRIZE Rainforest. Actually currently in Manauss.

Jonah:

All right, great. And Juliana from Aina, do you want to just say hi real quick?

Unidentified participant:

I know Juliana.

Jonah:

Okay, great.

Unidentified participant:

Hello. Good to see you.

Jonah:

Great. Okay. So, I’m going to go ahead and set the stage and then we’ll start. I’ve already started the recording. So, hey everybody. This is Jonah Whitamper from the Amazon Investor Coalition and the Global Governance Philanthropy Network and Nexus. It’s a long list. This is the weekly phone call. We call it the Amazon office hours. Each week we hear from a different investor or innovator or government and we’re interested in advancing forest-friendly economic development across the region. These calls are recorded and are edited and in the future will be made available as a podcast series to educate people around the world about how to help Amazon cause Amazon conservation cause.

And our scope is all countries of the Amazon, not just Brazil, although Brazil gets a lot of attention. I’m going to put everyone on mute and then ask Denis to bring himself off. And I’m also going to mute those who are incoming. So, hold on one sec everybody. Okay. So Denis is has a storied career helping out with Amazon and many different levels through his family business but also through helping to build the partnership platform for the Amazon and the Amazon museum and fun Amazonia Susantav which would be the Amazon Sustainability Foundation and lots more.

I have lots of questions for him, but he also has a presentation and the good news is we have a whole a whole hour with him. So go ahead and prepare your questions everybody. This is a very unique experience. Denis is in some ways an ambassador for the Amazon region. Connecting with and influencing governments and celebrities and investors and philanthropies from all over the world who want to help. So Denis, without much more I hand the floor over to you. Share with tell us what you got.

Denis Minev:

Well, thank you Jonah. So, so I’m going to try to do a brief presentation and then just try to get into a debate. Let me share my screen. Just one second. Can you see my screen?

Jonah / Denis Minev — brief screen check:

Yes. Okay.

Denis Minev:

So, I think well, just a brief introduction. I think I’m well positioned to speak from a few different standpoints. I served for a term as a secretary for planning and economic development in the state of Amazon, which is one of nine states in the Amazon, but it’s the largest. This was a period during which economic development grew tremendously and deforestation fell by more than 60%. Also I’ve been engaged as Jonah mentioned in a few NOS’s dealing mostly either with conservation, poverty or entrepreneurship. And my family has been in business in the Amazon.

Our business has existed for 78 years and we’ve been we’ve done either our company or family members have been engaged in all sorts of economic activity in the region. From exporting rosewood oil to Brazil nuts to jute to all sorts of things. Now our businesses we have two main businesses. One is a retail store which I’m the CEO. We focus in the western Amazon AI Hondon and Harima. And here a big caveat is that most of what I’m going to tell you refers to the western Amazon. The west the Amazon is very large.

And it’s very difficult to be knowledgeable of the region as a whole. So I focus my experience in this side of the Amazon. It’s about half of the Amazon and it contains Amazonas in Hora which are very well preserved states and Rondônia which is the most deforested state in the Amazon. Now because Rondônia is not so large it doesn’t get as much focus as par or Matugos for example but it is the most deforested one. Now I also always focus on talking about the Amazon from four perspectives. From the environmental perspective, it’s of course very important.

And from the global standpoint, that’s what people see. But if you approach this problem just as an environmental problem, I believe you’re not going to be able to solve much. So you have to understand that the region has to become economically viable, socially just and politically balanced as well. And these are things that were have been talked about by a lot of people regionally. And I point out one specific person which is professor Samuel Benimo. He happens to be my grandfather as well. He passed away already, but he’s a thinker that has been the discussing the environment and the economy of the Amazon for about 70 years.

So it’s well it’s important to try to understand where we’re coming from. Now I like to point out you know 2004 to 2012 are generally considered to be a great period environmentally for the Amazon. It was a period when deforestation went down quite significantly. Just as an example 2004 was a year when we had two and a half times the deforestation that we have today. And by 2012 2004 we had 25,000 square kilometers of deforestation. 2012 we had less than 5,000. So the reduction was about 80%. Now different people read what happened during that period in different ways.

I’ll give you my reading. And my reading has two main culprits. So one, it is true that there was a significant political and financial effort in Brazil to contain deforestation. We improved monitoring and policing overall. Impi which is the national institute for space research became capable of monitoring the Amazon and the fires through satellites. This improved quite dramatically during that period. Ibama which is the environmental regulation agency. They also they hired a lot of people during those years and became much more present in the region as well as the federal police.

The federal police increased its contingent in the Amazon quite significantly during that period in part to contain drug smuggling but also significantly to reduce deforestation. That was one factor and in my view if you ask most environmentalists those fact that will is the main factor of what happened during that period. Now I tend to disagree with that assertion. I do recognize that it’s important but I would say that there was a second more important factor happening which it which was the commodity super cycle. Now the commodity super cycle affected the Amazon in three different ways.

First municipalities earned a lot more money. Fiscal policy in Brazil is such that the small municipalities all around the country most of their budget comes from the national income tax. So Brazilians during that period got a lot wealthier, paid a lot more income tax and that made municipalities a lot wealthier including those in the middle of the Amazon. So basically, you know, S. Paulo became wealthier and the income taxes from people in S. Paulo improved the finances of small municipalities in the Amazon. Also the federal government and this was the period you may remember that Marina Silva was minister for the environment the federal government made transfers to the municipalities specifically for them to establish the secretariats for the environment.

So small municipalities which did not have secretariats for the environment before 2004 I can tell you the state of Amazonas in 2004 only the city of manos out of 62 municipalities had any institution dealing with the environment by 2012 most of them did u and because the municipalities got so much money they were able to employ a lot of people Now what happened in these small municipalities in you know in some corner of the Amazon prior to 2004 the economy worked much like this that there was a city center which was small and relatively poor and people lived in the surrounding areas in the rural areas producing manio and in some instances doing a little bit of cattle breeding or u do doing logging.

And this was a very poor economy that worked between the city and the rural areas because the municipalities got so wealthy. They hired a lot more people and by hiring a lot of people they changed the geography of these cities. The cities emptied out in the rural areas and most of the people came to the city center and this is you know Amazonas has 62 municipalities the western Amazon has 150 I’ve been traveling o over this period to most of them our business take us to many of these places and this happened all across the region the rural areas got depopulated and the city centers got bigger and bigger and people were working for the government.

Now also there were a lot of transfer payments directly to people aside from the municipalities. There was the bosia which grew tremendously during that period. There was the siguru de fzu siguru de fzu is a payment to fishermen so that they don’t fish during the reproduction of the reproduction period of fish and yahur which is a retirement for people who worked in rural areas once they reach 65 years old. All of that was established during those years or expended dramatically. So that made it that so that people became a lot wealthier during those years.

Lastly, those activities that generally either have nothing to do with the forest or have to do with already deforested areas did very well. You know, people who had cleared land by then earned a lot of money with soy. You know, the prices went up. Cattle as well. The state of Par in particular did really well with mining and the city of Manaus did really well because of the free trade zone. So Manaus was not producing commodities of course but it was selling to the rest of Brazil which was getting much wealthier because of commodities.

So the commodity super cycle had a tremendous impact on the region. A and people got wealthier, businessmen got wealthier, you know, those that had soy cattle or mining and the municipalities got wealthier, everybody’s happy. And then you introduce the concept of environmentalism and the redu reduction of deforestation into very fertile land into a situation where people are doing well and are open to it. What did not work well? Well, that there used to be in the Amazon a lot of activities that depended on standing forests. During that period, Ibama, for example, hired a lot of new people.

And these people are very I’ll say in general, good-hearted people, but they made it they made those institutions much tougher to deal with for businessmen who were dealing with the forest. And so everything improved except for one thing, what we call bioeconomy or whatever you want to call it, the activities of the standing forest. And I point here a few businesses that used to be large in the state of Amazon, sorry, in the western Amazon and now either disappeared or are much smaller. One of them that we used to be the exporters is Poaza.

Palhaza is an essence that was part of Chanel number five was the main essence in Chanel number five. Well, what happened during that period in 2011? Ibama de declared a moratorum on exports of rosewood oil palaza to in order to re-evaluate the sustainability of production. Well, we had a client. Chanel was our client, our business’s client. And Chanel asked us, “S so when are you gonna send us more POA and we said we don’t know, you know, this is a moratorium. We don’t know how long it lasts.” And what they basically did and everybody else that consumed palhaza back then is they took palhaza out of the formula linol because it’s it can be substituted with a synthetic oil that is very similar.

Now the noses the French noses that choose their fragrances they say you know the original one is better than the synthetic but given that you have you don’t have the synthetic one u the you don’t have the natural one the synthetic one will do. So in that case for example the size of the market collapsed after one year without being able to supply the market and we decided to abandon that business. You know another business that used to be large in the state of Amazon was aquarium fish. There used to be exporters of aquarium fish.

The largest exporter in the world used to be in Manaus and he ended up dropping his business and now he’s an investor in the free trade zone in industry and he abandoned because it became much harder in terms of dealing with bureaucracies and the risks. He eventually got arrested. He spent a month in prison and the charges were eventually dropped and none were raised. Of course, to every story, there’s two sides, but I’m just giving examples. In most businesses, the good and the not so good or the medium businessmen disappeared during that period.

Now, we come to 2013 to 2020. What happened? Well, first the commodity super cycle ends and with that the abundance of cash in the federal government and in all levels of government. So monitoring policing it just you know it faced scarce resources. Initially it was not an ideological thing. You know Obama got less resources, police got less resources just like everybody else in the government education and health and whatever else more recently there is a certain discussion in ideological discussion that is impacting let’s say additionally monitoring and policing. Now what else happened?

Municipalities got impoverished and so they had to fire a lot of people. Starting in 2015, most municipalities started firing people and we are still in that u I will call for certain municipalities a depression. You know, we’ve never recovered since 2015 the number of employees, the number of people working, transfer payments, bosur, they’ve been reviewed, they’ve been limited, they’ve been cut in certain situations, siguru deu, for example, wasn’t paid for two years and then it got back to being paid. So economic conditions in the region have deteriorated significantly for municipalities, for the people and for businessmen.

Of course, the businessmen who used to be in non-forestry activities are facing lower commodity prices. So soy isn’t as profitable. It’s still profitable, but isn’t as profitable as it used to be. Same thing with cattle breeding. Same thing with mining. The Manaus Free Trade Zone which at its peak had about 130 or 140,000 employees. This was 2008. Today it has less than half. Today has a little bit over 60,000 employees. So the impact of this economic depression has been tremendous all across the society. But this starts in 2015. This is not a recent phenomenon at least not from local standpoint.

And the thing is those activities that the old activities that used to be done in the region that dealt with standing forests they stopped working in 2004 to 2012 and they never came back. There was a continued burial ground managed forestry there used to be managed forestry in the state of Amazonas now there’s only one large company there used to be four or five fish farming is growing in some places but many of the of the large projects went bankrupt during this period and so we face today a very difficult situation in that the economy of the region has no basis.

So, so I’ll I’ll present here to you two maps of Brazil. Now, you know where the Amazon is. Take a look to the left. Red is poor. Red is Africa level poor. The state of Amazonas and much of the Amazon is all red. Where is it not red? Generally it’s not as red in places that have a significant level of deforestation. Unfortunately that happens to be the case today and we have not found a reasonable economic model to work across the region. Now look to the map on the right. The map on the right there is this kind of orange or maybe skin color that covers most of the Amazon.

If you look at the label that is administration that is public administration. Basically everybody who is in the let’s say the skin color areas is sustained by the federal government which basically means it’s the people are paid by Brazilian southeast to stay there and let’s say not do nothing not do anything significant. So the economic basis of the region disappeared over the last one or two decades and now the economy is just an economy of money being transferred from Brazil to the Amazon in order to sustain a minimum level of living conditions.

Now I’ll pass and this is my last slide. I if you if you can read Portuguese you can see this note of indignation. It’s a it’s a shame. Okay. This is a business group from the state of par being let’s say resistant to outsiders pushing for reduced deforestation. But unfortunately this reflects pretty well the opinion of I’d say all business communities across the Amazon. Every most businessmen I know are of course you have to you know you have to have a little bit of empathy. Everybody has been in an economic depression since 2015.

So no, nobody has at this point the patient the patience to deal with the environment when there have been economic depressions and we’ve seen most businesses fail during this period. Now if you also look to the right you’ll see PSL is the current government. This was in the second round of voting in 2018. How did Brazil vote? There were four states in Brazil that gave more than 70% of the vote to Bonado in the second round. Three of them were in the Amazon. Three of them, Hondon, and Hora. Three states in the Western Amazon.

And so the reason why I frequently point this out is that people tend to think that Boson is the aggressor of something happening in the Amazon. It’s not so simple. The Amazon voted massively for Bosonaru. Bosonaru is quite significantly quite popular in the region. It is the region of Brazil where he is the most popular even though everything you see him doing towards the environment is true. So it’s what I try to point out with this talk and with these slides is that the situation is much more complex than just dealing with increased deforestation.

Increased deforestation is happening indeed. And I’m going to stop my presentation here. And we well, I extended a little bit more than I planned to. Oh, I see Lja here. Hello. And well, just wanted to open and have a longer conversation with you guys. Just but just as a last as a last message I’d like to point that you know the Amazon is in a very difficult social and economic situation since 2015 and I think if you don’t take that into account if you don’t understand what has been happening I it’s going to be very difficult to approach deforestation in the region as a whole.

Jonah:

Great. Thank you so much, Denis. We’re going to move into questions. I’m going to start off with one. In a previous conversation that you and I had, I remember you telling me about a conversation you had with a foreigner, a very significant investor in the Amazon region. And they were asking, “Well, well, how can we help?” And you said, “No, it’s not necessarily the money, it’s the talent. It’s, you know, instead of I don’t remember which country it was, instead of just Norwegian money, bring the Norwegians.” could you could you elaborate on that a little bit?

Denis Minev:

Sure. And it’s good that Marita is here. Marita has been working on the rainforest business school which is I think the type of initiative that is very significant and that we should do. Now just relating when Norway was deciding to do the Fund Mason and this was 2007 there were a lot of Norwegians circulating in the region the ambassador was in Manaus and they were asking a lot of people how can we help my answer to them which of course they didn’t follow was that okay you know if you want to spend a billion I think the best way to do it would be to get that billion and send it in the form of Norwegians.

Send us the best Norwegians. Choose the best doctors and best PhDs and whoever you have and send them here to spend five years. I think the impact would have been tremendous. I think many of them would have stayed here and married and you know had a life here and you know they would have been able to make connections because of their experience in Norway and what they see here and make the type of connections that were just unable to do because of lack of experience. So I think the development of human capital no people have developed in the world without the development of human capital also no people have development without significant levels of entrepreneurship.

So I think you know it’s good that Marita is here. She’s been working on one of the what I what I tend to think is one of the most important initiatives we have going on. Great. Thank you for that. I have a feeling we’re going to hear from Marita in a moment. But first let’s go ahead and start off with a first question. It was already posted in.

Jonah:

The in the chat. Margarita,.

Margarita:

Hi Denis and hi everyone. Denis, thanks so much for sharing the this information. It was really great hearing from you. And the question that I had was thinking a bit about the pe is that the best way of analyzing the region. I was looking at the map that you share particularly some of the red areas in Amazonas and Are and I was looking that for example they include areas that are indigenous lands most of them actually are indigenous lands where you have even people living in involuntary isolation. So they have stated that they don’t want to be part of this economic system, right?

And yeah, I am curious on how you are balancing those two things because on one side you have the economic pressure and definitely people do have needs, economic needs, right? On the other side, you know, as they have economic needs, they are also fighting against gold miners that are polluting their rivers or fighting them against invaders that are reducing the amount of fish or of meat that they can have and that has been part of their sustainance over time. So, yeah, I was curious to know on your thoughts on this.

Denis Minev:

Of course, your question is very good and very difficult to answer. I will say this there’s 25 million people in the western in the Amazon in the Brazilian Amazon. H in terms of indigenous people at least the countings I’ve seen it’s something like around 200,000 people and the indigenous topic is a very complex topic to deal with. I’m not going to be able to approach it quickly. You know, some tribes want to live isolated, some tribes want a lot of development. So, I think you have to deal almost individually at the tribe level.

What do they want and try to adapt an answer to them? But, you know, even though it is an important topic, there are still 25 million people or let’s say 24.8 that are not indigenous people and that need to figure out economic alternatives. You know there is the what has been happening is the cities have been impovering have been in an impovering process. You know we are retailers and we extend credit. So we see people getting poorer and not being able to pay their bills. There has to be an alternative.

I and you know it I’m going to be I’m not going to be able to tell you okay in this case you should do this or in that this case you should do that. You have to look almost case by case and figure it out. Now I recognize and I’m sympathetic to the indigenous topic. I had to deal with it when I was in the government. It’s a very difficult topic because I don’t think you can address it in 20 minutes quickly like this. Now ju just one more thing. You mentioned gold mining in particular.

To me most activities we can find a way to do them productively, sustainably and reasonably within the Amazon. Perhaps the only exception is gold mining because gold mining is just too complex and there’s too much criminality involved in it. There’s the smuggling of mercury which leaves a terrible process behind. There is prostitution and smuggling and so in terms of gold mining that is one of the very few cases where I say that is that is more of a police matter than a social or any or economic matter. You know, gold mining does not benefit the region economically in any significant form.

And it’s very conducive to criminal activity. Now, other activities I would be more skeptical to make blanket statements.

Jonah:

Colleen, please introduce yourself and ask your question.

Colleen:

Hi, Denis. My name is Colleen Scan Lions. I’m with the governor’s climate and forest task force and I asked a question in the chat asking you to kind of put back on your hat as a secretary within a government and I would actually ask a second part. You’re now a business owner and you really brought up the fact that a lot of the leaders in the Amazon, the economic leaders, the private sector leaders are very against policies that are saying you need to reduce deforestation. So I would ask you to kind of put on a secretary hat for a second and then put back on your business leader hat for a second and tell us how we can engage with these two really important forces.

Secretaries are, you know, they have jurisdiction over an entire state or province and we know that a lot of their funding has been cut right now due to COVID. And then there’s also the business challenge you brought up. So, I’m just kind of asking you to kind of straddle these two roles that you have.

Denis Minev:

Are you first of all, I’m very proud of having participated in the origins of GCF. GCF was established I think in 2008. Arnold Schwarzenegger was the big governor. We went to Los Angeles for a few events with him. And I think it’s you know you’re not going to find one solution to big problems. You’re going to find many solutions and people pushing in many directions. So I think the subnational level is just another layer that needs to be looking for solutions while the big national layers also should be doing it.

But of course you know Brazil back then we you know we used to complain back then that the George W. Bush administration was very difficult to deal with. You know, little did we know that things could get much worse. So hey, I see mate there. Hello mate. And now what I point to generally is that people should have a level of empathy. I think Americans committed a mistake when they did not understand the appeal that Donald Trump had to a very significant number of people who are not necessarily bad people.

So you know I circulate a lot in the region and I hear a ton of people supporting the president. I hear a ton of people supporting the minister for the environment which I am quite sure all of you consider you know a terrible person. I will tell you he to most businessmen in the Amazon but even not businessmen to some politicians in the region he is not seen that way. And so as long as you don’t understand why these people think this way and you know what drives them and what motivates them.

I think you know one thing that is very different today from 2005 to 2020 is that everybody here is tired of a very deep economic depression that started in 2015 co actually in the Amazon economically wasn’t so bad because the transfer payments from the federal government were very high and that helped sustain people significantly you know the death toll was horrible especially in man but I think if you don’t get empathy between the two sides and I think there is very little every time I say that Boson is very popular and that Hikad Sales is very popular it comes as a surprise I’ll tell you in my view Bosson will win the election in 2022 in the Amazon by a very large margin.

Now, we are not that many people, so that may not make a big difference in Brazil, but regionally it seems very likely to me that he will win. Understanding each other I think would be the first step for us to move forward.

Colleen:

Thank you, Denis.

Jonah:

Great. Would other people like to ask questions?

Unidentified participant:

Hi Jonah, this is speaking. Sorry, I’m with my camera off because of my connection. I’d like to address a question to my friend Denis.

Jonah:

Go for it.

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. Well, first of all, Denis, it’s a pleasure again to hear you talking about the Amazon. I always say if I have a chance of choosing only one person to talk about the Amazon, I would choose you for sure. But that’s a long history. Denis, I’d like to have your opinion about your perspective about the short shortterm perspective for the Amazon considering the high prices of soybean and cattle. I just came back from the Amazon two days ago. I spent three weeks there in Al Floresta and I was absolutely shocked.

It’s it’s amazing. How dynamic is the economy in that region in Mato Gro state? I live there during six years and I go every year there, but I’ve never seen a situation like that. It’s absolutely amazing how powerful is the economy in that region. And it fits with our analysis about Bolson because Bolsonar is like a hero there, you know. And so a lot of companies building new processing structures there and the land price is skyrocketing. It’s amazing. It became like a crazy a crazy place. You if you want to buy a piece of land, it’s very difficult and the price is very high.

So, what’s your vision about this short-term situation in the Amazon?

Denis Minev:

Okay. So, I’m not very experienced in the state of Mato Grosso in particular. It’s a it’s a very large state and there’s a lot of things going on there. It soy is doing really well right now and I can point in places in the western Amazon when it where it the same process is going on. One is in the state of Hora and another one is in Amazon in deforested areas. You know this is part of to me the problem. Who is doing well in the Amazon? The only ones that are doing well are the ones that have already significantly deforested areas.

You know, we have the great slogan that you know the forest should be worth more standing than lying down. But unfortunately that is not true to the person standing in the ground. It is true if you include externalities for the world but that’s not the case. I tend to think that you know soy will continue to grow in Brazil at a very significant pace. Hima where I was recently u a lot of people are moving from down south. Now fortunately this is Hora is much of a it has savas mostly.

It’s not it’s not tropical forest much of the state and the areas that are being occupied for soy are usually savannah areas that were unproductive previously but don’t have as much biodiversity or environmental impacts but I agree with you now this happens in the western Amazon in very few municipalities. What’s what’s useful to understand of the western Amazon is that first it’s not a very well-connected area. So one municipality that is 100 kilometers away from the next you don’t go from one to the other in an hour. Usually there are no roads.

So the economies are like islands little microcosms. In places where soy works, for example, in Rondônia, there are some municipalities where soy works. Arimis or Villenna for example, there are some where soy does not work like Jarana the soil is too rocky. They plant coffee there or do cattle breeding. Now as islands certain islands have been doing really well. But the islands in Amazonas for example where you know deforestation the state of Amazonas if you add everything up reaches about 3%. In Rondônia it reaches almost 30%. So Hondon is doing really well.

Amazonas where it’s 3% we have not found a productive model to use the forest. That’s why I tend to think it’s so important that we figure out what to do with the standing forest. We have to find economic models that work with the standing forest. Otherwise, you know, it’s not even a fair game. The economy pushes in one direction, you know, the whole world can push in the other direction. It’s going to be a difficult fight.

Jonah:

On that note, Marita, would you like to tell us a little bit about the Rainforest Business School and have you guys gotten some new newsworthy investments that you can talk about publicly? You’re on mute.

Marita:

All right. Thank you. Well, always so good to listen to Denis. Denis I have two questions. The first one is where we are making progress modestly but we’re going in that direction human resources development. So the rainforest business school is just offering places for its first course up to 800 students and the criterion is that there must be entrepreneurs already or people who have an entrepreneurship idea and they must be from the very Amazon region. So this is great. In 18 months we’ll probably have a crop of very good business plans and business improvement plans and in parallel of course there’s under the program in which I participate Amazonia 4.0 Oh, there is the drive for more science, heavyhanded cutting edge science MIT type thing for the Amazon.

So that is moving. But my first question to you is unless we also find coales around building a project for a standing forest. And of course we also talk about the waters a bioeconomy investment fund you know you will have all these business plans and you won’t have an automatic place a special bank in a sense a special fund to go to and it can be public it can be private it can be national it can be all of the above but I do think that just driving human resources development and science really needs that other leg because without money we’re not going anywhere.

So that’s question number one. Question number two is more general. Reading this note which you showed on your slide of indignation about the people who sit in on airplanes and they look out the window and then they have an opinion about the Amazon and you know through business or political relations impose it on the area. So that’s what we don’t want. But what we do want is a vision such as yours. Not just backwards, what brought us to where we are today, but forward. So my second question to you is 20 years from now, where could we be?

What’s what’s the direction you want to point us in? Thank you.

Denis Minev:

All right. Difficult questions. But on the first question, I think there are things developing and I think one of the purposes of Jonah is to try to figure out how to set up these funds and move in that direction. I’m working on a few different efforts in that direction as well. So there is the Pepe we’re establishing a fund and I’m an investor as well. We’re hoping to gain some capacity to invest soon impact hub which I was talking about a little bit earlier. We’re also going to establish a fund in that case mostly for urban investments.

But you know I think if we develop the cities we’ll we’ll take off the pressure and improve living conditions will have its impact. So I think it’s hard because you have a little bit of a chicken and egg problem. Okay. So there’s no funding. So there’s no startups. You know I act as an as an angel investor here in the region. I’ve made about 10 different investments. Most of them have not worked out well. The ones that have worked have mostly to do with it. Which is good but that doesn’t touch the forest.

I mean, I’m I’m hopeful that people like Joan and you guys will be able to set up funds to get this moving, you know, and you know, if you can get 800 entrepreneurs with business plans, I think you know, I think I think people like Marina Kus who is here she can get the funds to get them all started. And but second in 20 years I like to point out that the Amazon gets into these cycles. First cycle was when Shik Mendes was murdered in the 80s. You know there was a large outro all across the world but apparently we didn’t solve much.

So that 15 years later, which was basically when Marina Silva was minister for the environment, there was another outro, you know, back then people were talking about the Amazon all the time as well. And again, I think we missed that opportunity as well to build a reasonable economy in the region. I am very hopeful, you know, and now 15 years later, 15 years later, here we are. I don’t know what to call it. Maybe the Boson cycle. But I’m hopeful that in 15 years we’re not talking about this again. Now I see a few different directions.

There are some cases that just break my heart. You know, Lena is here and Lena Luis Fernand Lena broke my heart with his fish farming project. It was the most incredible fish farming project I’ve seen anywhere in the Amazon. And it’s it’s just horrible news that it didn’t work out. But most large projects like his and I also like to point out Amata which got the concession in Rondônia, the largest forestry concession that we’ve ever had in the Amazon. That also didn’t work out. These are projects that should have worked out that eventually if we have any hope of doing well must work out you know entrepreneurs like Lena like Hobu they have to work out if they don’t then you get into a problem which a biologist from IMPa when I explained to him this process he said oh you know this is the economy is like a biological system you adapt those that are most adapt adaptable survive.

And what you’re describing is that the businessmen who are most adaptable in the Amazon are not the good businessmen. They’re the ones who bribe. They’re the ones who are able to smuggle and only they have survived. And I tend to think that, you know, part of this is true. We have self- selected for bad business practices. And that’s a problem that has to be reverted. Now I’m hopeful that in 20 years we will have been able to do that and you know fish farming managed forestry and one thing in particular you know replanting the Amazon in whatever kind of fashion agroforestry systems or whatever I think it’s time that we start talking not just of containing re deforestation but also let’s say releasing entrepreneurial spirit to replant plant the Amazon in a profitable way.

I think that would be the best way because to that there is no opposition to that, you know, you’re going to create jobs, you’re going to make people richer and you’re going to have a great impact on the environment. I tend to look for the opportunities where you won’t have opposition. You know, if you try to fight with cattle breeding, cattle breeding to me is a very specific segment, very difficult to deal with. I’ve talked to Jotabasi a couple times and u they have a really hard problem in their hands.

But not only them because about half of the butchering capacity in the region is not in the hands of the global players. Is in the hand of local small players mostly you know guys who don’t care or just you know you know small businessmen medium-sized in some cases so I’m hopeful that we find these good segments that we’re able to select good businessmen for the next cycle and that we’re able to find let’s say an institutional arrangement that allows people like Lena like Albertovak to prosper and to become examples that we can point to.

Jonah:

We have time for maybe one more question. John, please introduce yourself and share your question.

John (MXV Ventures):

Yeah. Hi John Mesner from MXV Ventures in Oakland, California. It’s great to meet you Denis and see everybody on this call. So this should be a quick and fun one to wrap up here. Do you see any technology gaps that are holding back attempts to stop and reverse deforestation? You know, we’re a venture investment firm and work with a lot of technology startups. So, very interested to get your perspective on a room for innovation there.

Denis Minev:

I tend to think there’s significant room for innovation. You know, this last week, somebody presented me this, Amazon capwalk, fiber that, they say could become, something significant. We don’t know and we don’t have the knowledge or the time or the capacity to develop many of these things that I think people from the outside are. Now even the general ju just the existing supply chains I’ll give you an example of fish farming in the state of Amazonus when I served in the government which was 2007 2008 wi with mate here and fish farming was its productivity was around 7 to eight tons per hectare as I understand today what fish farmers here around Manaus say is that now they can produce about 10 to 11 tons per hectare that’s quite significant improvement in productivity but there’s still a lot more in my view to deliver from what the people from Impa say you know it should be feasible to reach 20 tons if you improve the if you select better species if you feed them right if you use a little bit of technology if you have vaccines, different things like that.

I think to that there is a tremendous room for improvement also in managed forestry. My understanding is that there are very few types of wood that we know how to use commercially and you know oils, essences. We used to be exporters of anoba, copaiba, kumaru and all sorts of different forest products that people don’t really know well how to use. In some cases people say there’s medicinal uses but nobody really knows this well and hasn’t developed you know technologically like you should in order to understand it deeply. So I think there’s a significant room for technology in the region but it has to be people who understand you know who understand I mean the market as well as the science.

What we have a lot here is people who say oh I found the cure for cancer. Okay come on you know no you didn’t. Somebody who has a notion of the market and I’ll tell I’ll be the first one to tell you I have no idea in medicine I’m not able to judge what people say I imagine in every segment you know there is kind of specific knowledge that u that you need to have it and we don’t have it and I think in many cases the people who have that knowledge haven’t spent time in the Amazon trying to see what there is and understand what the potential could.

Jonah:

Great. I think this points to a great future potential call of the of this group. So we’re at the top of the hour. This is the moment where we transition from a formal presentation to water cooler conversation. You know, no holds barred. Anybody can say anything, post anything. Part of the group is going to leave us. A small group will probably stay. Denis, I don’t know if you’re able to stay or if you need to go. Thank you much for joining us. Thank you everybody for joining the call and now is the free-for-all.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you.

Denis Minev:

I can stay for another 20 minutes. No problem if you want to talk.

Jonah:

I got plenty of questions and I’m sure others do too. Peter, you can go ahead.

Peter (XPRIZE Rainforest):

I have a quick question. Yeah, just to build off of John’s last question about technological advancements. Right now with XPRIZE Rainforest, were holding a 5year $10 million competition to innovate new technologies to survey and monitor tropical rainforests.

Unidentified participant:

How is that going?

Peter (XPRIZE Rainforest):

It’s going great. Our registration is still open until March. So, it’s a it’s a multi-year program and, it’d also be great to I’ll be here in Manauss for a couple weeks. It’d be great to connect, but I’m curious to hear your thoughts on that type of, technological innovation as well. And one thing that we’ve been discussing is also that aspect of bringing new technologies for monitoring biodiversity and rainforest to market. And just the challenges of bridging that gap.

Denis Minev:

Well, I’m a big fan of the XPRIZE and when I found out that you guys were coming to the Amazon, I thought that was wonderful. And I’m part of the board of the three banks, Pradesh, Kante, and set up. And I was able to congratulate the guys because I from what I hear they were the ones who funded the X-P prize for the Amazon. I think you know it’s great. There’s not going to be one single solution. You know we’re going to have to try different things and shoot at different targets.

I think you guys are shooting at a great target. I’m not sure how it’s going to be useful, but I sense it’s going to be how you know it’s up to entrepreneurs to figure it out and find paths.

Peter (XPRIZE Rainforest):

Yeah, I think I think the solutions to it are going to be extremely diverse. It’s very difficult to predict, but I’ll look forward to chatting with you and keeping in touch throughout the process. Yeah,.

Jonah:

Denis, I have a question for you. Could you share with us a little bit about what you know of Mahogany Horima?

Denis Minev:

Mahogany Horima is a an entrepreneur in Hora. I tend to hunt entrepreneurs all across the Amazon and figure out who’s doing interesting things. And mahogany harima is one that I found is doing pretty interesting work in harima. Now they’re planting exotic species. It’s it’s African mahogany. But and they’re planting in the fields. You know, Harima has fields like I mentioned before. But now they’re starting to mix mahogany with agroforestry projects. So that they’re planting mahogany, they’re planting some fruit trees like bananas and whatever else and they’re trying to reestablish an Amazonian type biodiversity this in the forested areas so that let’s say within five or 10 years they’re able to cut the mahogany and make this a very productive reestablished ecosystem.

I think it’s a it’s a worthwhile attempt to do something different and reestablish ecosystems. I think to me, you know, I’m tired of arguing about how cattle breeding is affecting and that’s such a poor discussion and poor outcome, you know. The old model for the Amazon is you cut let’s say you deforest one hector and you sell the wood. When you sell the wood you get a little bit of working capital. So with that working capital, you buy one head of cattle. And you put it there and you plant some whatever you want to plant there.

And then at the end of a year, that head of cattle has gotten a bit fatter and you sell it. And this is subsistence living. Nobody’s going to get wealthy off of this. And there’s going to be tremendous destruction. We need to figure out different things. So, Mahogany Harim is one case where we’re trying something different that they’re they’re they’re actually shooting really high. They want to be really wealthy. They think they’re going to be able to sell this mahogany for tremendous prices in 5 to 10 years. That’s great. You know, release the capital the capitalist spirit upon the Amazon and you know, let us develop and find these models that of course have to respect the environment but also have to make us wealthy.

Jonah:

Nice. I have other questions. I realize I might be interrupting someone else. Does it anyone else have a question? So my next question Denis is about the investments that you’ve made that didn’t work out. It sounds like ease of doing business or the difficulty of doing business is one of the biggest obstacles. Are there particular legislative changes or a whole raft of them that you’d like to recommend? If I was to go do some advocacy in Brasília to make it easier to operate a business in the Amazon region, what talking points would you give me?

Denis Minev:

I’ll give you two examples. My suggestion is generally aggressively rejected by environmentalists. Okay, so just give you that caveat. I’ll give you two examples. One is the forest code. The forest code says that any river that is wider than 600 meters, the first 500 meters on each side has to be protected area. And I think that makes sense in the Parani River in southern Brazil. But in the Amazon, it does not. In the Amazon, everybody occupies that first 500 meters and all economic activity happens in those first 500 meters. I would encourage any of you to travel in the Amazon and see.

Nobody goes 500 meters inland. It does not make sense. It’s just not how the region is occupied. So a forest code that u you know tries to make one law for the whole of Brazil is a very difficult thing and I tend to think it’s an impossible thing. A second example is you know the general guidelines for managed forestry are federal and they are basically regulated at the state level but there are federal guidelines. You know that’s another case where you know manage forestry works well for monoculture for cellulosis or for paper and pulp but not in the Amazon where the diversity is immense and you can’t follow the same rules it would be too difficult.

So my suggestion which again no environmentalist has ever agreed with me is that we need a federalist system. We need a system in which the state of Amazonus is more capable of establishing its own laws. I do recognize that would represent a certain level of risk for the environment. But the alternative which is what we have now which is the federal government establishes many laws that have to be valid for the whole country. It has zero chance of working and it just pushes us down this path of poverty and environmental degradation.

But I recognize it’s not a diff it’s not a simple problem. In some cases we need to ease legislation. In some case we need to ease regulation. But it’s controversial and I’ll be the first to admit it.

Jonah:

Is there a think tank or a publication or research report that lists many of these obstacles?

Denis Minev:

You know, I like the work that Institutes has been doing lately in Brazil. They looked at managed forestry the specific laws because I you know I’m not a lawyer and I’m not in the business of managed forestry so I don’t know the specifics I think they went through the very specific issues one by one in managed forestry to figure out why it’s not working we need to do that you know at a at a business level you know it has to be sustainable not only for an environmental point of view, but from an economic as well, I think they’re doing good work and should be supported.

Unidentified participant:

Can I come in on this, Denis?

Denis Minev / Unidentified participant — boundary unclear:

Sure. For the rainforest social business school in Manaus. We are as one part of the methodology now wanting to write up and we’re already getting a little bit of support case studies a little bit like the Harvard Business School case studies but maybe less ambitious and not to make a business out of selling them but it’ll be very important to get the right list of businesses those that are successful or have been and especially those that failed for some reason that was not foreseen and so I hope I can approach you for some of your ideas which should be you know what should be on the list of the case studies.

Denis Minev:

Okay it’ll be my pleasure.

Unidentified participant:

Okay thank you.

Jonah:

Denis do you mind if I share your email in the chat I saw it in your presentation great any other questions Great. Okay. I continue to have questions, but I think maybe it’s better suited through for through email. I’ll I’ll go for it. One previous call we had Denis was around the idea that we can develop an agroforestry bond. We looked up the numbers. One Acre of cattle generates about $250 per year on average in west eastern para I think it is. Soy generates $1,000 per year per hectare, but horiculture can generate $3,300 per year, but a lot of those products won’t survive the transport out of the region.

So it’s limited by, you know, local economic interests. But surely there are plenty of other kinds of agroforestry products that can be dried and can make the trip out. I’m wondering if you have seen anybody experimenting or proposing sort of leading the charge on really scaling agroforestry to out compete cattle.

Denis Minev:

There’s a few cases of agroforestry from my understanding that have worked pretty well. One is the well-known a bit old case of Tomasu. Tomasu is a Japanese colony in the state of par and it’s a cooperative that u is very well known because you know that they’re very productive. They produce like 30 different products and they’re very innovative and from my understanding that’s a good case to look at u in the state of Amazon ED has tried to do an interesting agroforestry project in Apoi Apoui is one of the most deforested municipalities in Amazon and the one with high still high deforestation indices and there they tried to do it with coffee.

So they planted coffee amid the rows of other trees and tried to figure out a model. These are the two cases that I’ve been following u and I’ve visited and to me look interesting. There’s another one also in Rondônia. I think it’s called Heekka. I think I have the link. I can send it to you that I visited about 10 years ago and I found it to be pretty interesting and you know the type of thing like I if the Amazon is ever successful in achieving high productivity with conservation that’s kind of what it would look like.

So we have I think a few examples that would work. Now there are imperfect examples. There is some deforestation connected. The biodiversity is not perfect. Once you do agroforestry, it’s not the same. But it’s close and I think you know better than the alternatives we have.

Jonah:

Great. I’ll make sure to check those out. Okay. Anyone else? Just thank you. This was very interesting.

Unidentified participant:

Agreed. Thank you so much for your time, Denis.

Denis Minev:

Let me I’m just going to put here the.

Jonah:

Great.

Denis Minev:

The link to the project in Rondônia, which I always found very interesting. Oops, sorry. Okay, there it is. Protoc I visited that and you know these what I what I found is that like in much of the Amazon you have very many you have many or I’d say most well-meaning people that want to figure out good alternatives. But in this case, it seemed to me that they found something a bit more special than usual. So I’d visit these guys and take a look.

Jonah:

Nice. And do you know people at Tomazu?

Denis Minev:

I know the main researcher in Embrapa Oriental. His name is Alfredo. Alfredo Kingo. He is he’s he’s the I think the best researcher in Imbra oriental and he has a great vision to how to restore the Amazon and what to do in order to fight deforestation with reforestation. So he would be one person that I definitely talk to and Marita Alfredo would be a great person to help set up the business cases. He.

Jonah:

Okay.

Denis Minev:

He follows this and he knows every single example. You know I can list a few. I would bet that he can list them all.

Jonah:

Fabulous. I’ll follow up with you and also I think I don’t have Alfredo’s email so you will help me right.

Denis Minev:

You know he I don’t know if he uses email he’s a bit of an old schooler but I can try to find.

Jonah:

All right thank you.

Denis Minev:

You know another person interesting to talk to Marita is a de I don’t know if you know him. He used to be the mayor of Paragominas. Paraguin is a good example of a municipality that was very deforested and then became a green example. Now that’s at least from what I know that’s not really an aggroforestry case. It’s more of a of a wellont controlled cattle breeding and soy and whatever else but he at least in my view he is the best mayor I have ever met in the Amazon and I think you know if we had a hundred mayors like him that would be pretty amazing Okay,.

Unidentified participants — closing remarks:

Great. Very helpful. I’m gonna try to look up these people, too. Great. Well, this has been great. Thank you so much, Denis. And I can’t wait for more. Great. Thank you, guys. Thank you. Good to see you, Marita. And I’ll be in touch. I’ll be here. All right. I’ll be in touch. Thank you. Bye. Bye. Thanks. Bye. Bye, everyone. Thanks for your time.