Designing an Agroforestry Financial Product for the Amazon
Panel discussion with Ethan Steinberg of Propagate Ventures, Mark Chasan of Transformative Capital, Daniel Sabara of Beraca, Walter Vergara of Initiative 20×20, Amanda Ravenhill of Regenerosity, and Others: Amazon reforestation is essential for ecosystem integrity. Community-led agroforestry can make the process profitable and scalable. How can we design Green Bonds and other financial products to protect vulnerable areas, replace monocultures with polycultures, restore biodiversity, empower traditional communities, and create wealth? Join Propagate Ventures co-founder Ethan Steinberg, regenerative economy evangelist Mark Chasan, and others to discuss the possibilities for the Amazon.
Recorded November 16, 2020
WATCH:
Participants
- Jonah (moderator)
- Ethan Steinberg
- Walter Vergara
- Mark Chasan
- Daniel Sabara
- Erica
- Keith Agoada
- Amanda Ravenhill
- Margarita Mora
- John Bruno
- Christina
- Alex (GIZ)
- Stan
- Other unidentified participants
Transcript
Jonah:
Hello everybody. Welcome to what may be the 20th call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. Again, this is a weekly call that is recorded and will later be made available as a podcast series. This is an initiative of the global governance philanthropy network and nexus two organizations I created previously and this is also a partnership platform of the UN75 global governance forum. Today we are talking about as we talk about every week advancing forest friendly economic development across the Amazon region but we’re also talking about Amazon reforestation everything that means the invitation was quite an ambitious one talking about not only halting deforestation but reforesting the Amazon region with commercially viable opportunities.
I want to tell a little bit about the pathway to get here. So Luis Fernando Lorena who some of you may know from Kite Inveos has one of the private equity success stories coming out of the Amazon. And he is at a place in his investing and development now where he is advocating for no longer just halting deforestation but advancing reforestation so that we can bring ecolog ecological balance back to the region. Along the way I also met Walter Verada and Initiative 20 by 20 and learned about 2.5 billion dollars in pledges coming to the Latin America region to help with reforestation and aforestation and ecosystem restoration.
And then a couple weeks ago I spoke with Ethan Steinberg and his propagate ventures which wants to make a bankable asset out of agroforestry. And also a couple weeks ago we had Justine from the climate bonds initiative talk about the growth of green bonds from a $50 billion industry 10 years ago to almost a trillion dollar industry today. So, we seem to have a perfect storm for reforesting the whole region. It can be profitable. It can be good for the environment. And, I’ve asked around, no one that I’ve spoken to knows of a reforestation bond yet.
So, it seems like we may have an opportunity to design one. And a couple weeks ago, I had a phone call with Thomas Lingard, who is the chief sustainability director for Unilever. And we spoke about Unilever possibly putting out a bond to buy sustainable produce from the Amazon, maybe in the format of a corporate bond. And if that’s the case and we can secure a long-term purchase contract, that’s enough to securitize a bond. So, how can we do this? It’s a very exciting moment, very exciting opportunity. And let’s begin this journey by hearing Ethan give us a five minute sort of review of his wandering into the space of agroforestry and trying to make a bankable asset out of it and then we’ll transition to a couple more of those sharing.
The majority of this phone call is going to be a crowdsourcing conversation. We’re the people coming on deck to put this bond together. Ethan.
Ethan Steinberg:
Thanks, Jonah. Appreciate it. It’s nice to see some friendly faces and meet some new ones. So, howdy everyone. Ethan Steinberg. I’m the CEO at Propagate Ventures. We are an analytics and project development platform for agroforestry. In short, what that means is we make it easier for investors to fund low-risk agroforestry projects in the United States. Agroforestry being the integration of fruit, nut and timber trees in row with an existing agricultural operation. So maybe a different way to approach it is we think a lot bringing think a lot about bringing the forest to the field.
Now my journey how we sort of landed across all of it and why we started propagate a couple years ago was through food. So the health of like food is thy medicine approach. I’m diabetic. One of my co-founders looked at food through healthcare and another looked at it for athletic reasons. Actually he was an Olympic hopeful. And so good food meant we were either healthy or performing well from an athletics perspective. And the question we landed on as a team was why is it that the health of the food that we’re demanding there isn’t an equivalent ask for the health of the landscapes where our food comes from.
Now regenerative agriculture kind of becoming a little bit more mainstream over that period of time. We sort of stepped back and looked at that landscape of how regenerative agriculture was developing and essentially asked the question why are why are trees not more commonly discussed as compared to things like cover cropping or rotational grazing? And simply to say all different solutions for different ecosystems and they all hold a an important part globally in terms of where they fit in. So that we can develop a holistic solution set for climate change. Now fast forward a little bit.
We’re operating in nine states across the US with multiple agroforestry projects about 23 projects that we work with. That you know I was speaking with Jonah the other the other week and thinking a lot about the applicability of agroforestry either silvo pasture systems or alleycropping systems for some of the direct challenges that are being faced in Brazil and elsewhere in that region of the world and how some of our learnings in terms of what we look at on the economics front costs revenues yield projections labor assumptions questions for the either establishment of or transition to an agroforestry system, how that might be made applicable to help develop a financial instrument that a an institutional investor would feel very comfortable with.
On one part that’s transparency in terms of the business and financial risks associated from an investment perspective as well as ensuring that our farmers have this is probably the more important part ensuring that our farmers have the resources they need to confidently manage a system to ensure that operations and maintenance are as successful as possible so an investment meets the criteria that we are aiming for I’ll stop there. Happy to answer questions. I truly appreciate getting the opportunity to talk about agroforestry with y’all.
Jonah:
Ethan, give us a one minute on the technology that you’ve been building, the data gathering behind it.
Ethan Steinberg:
Yeah, of course. And maybe Jonah, there’s an opportunity for me to show a little bit. I can share my screen and walk everyone through it as well if that would be helpful. But in short, we’re looking at using GIS technology. We’re doing a series of economic analysis that looks at effectively what are the capex and opex requirements at the farm gate to deliver an agroforestry system that has to be met with the holistic context of the of the farmer themselves. So this is basically their long-term goals their management philosophy how they approach the sort of labor force needs on their farm as well as the biogeophysical climate how much how much rain there is things like that.
Those components all come together and helps us identify the costs for establishment or transition. How that’s going to affect cash flow the labor needs what the access to markets are for various crops. All that gets compiled and creates a really clear and compelling case for the investment requirements and the return.
Jonah:
Great. So a given land owner wants to take on agroforestry wants a loan. The risks involved are will he have access to market? Does he know what to plant? Can he hire the right people? The technology solution that provides help with all of those things will significantly reduce the risk which is why we may be able to create a bankable asset, a financial product out of that. But how big is the demand in the region? How big is this current ecosystem of reeforesters? Ethan, I am going to Walter now. Hey Walter, tell us in a quick nutshell, what is initiative 20 by 20?
Walter Vergara:
Oh, thank you. Jonah, very interesting and we should have a 101 afterwards. This is a coalition of 23 impact investors investing in Latin American agroforestry, civil pastures, straight reforestation, grassland restoration and lowcarbon agriculture. There are 195 projects already ongoing. You can check a lot of this information in initiative 20 times20.org. The 23 impact investors have different business models. They are most of them are based in Europe and there are a few in Latin America. I’m very proud to say that Kite Investimensus Fernando is there is one of the partners and we are very proud of what they have been achieving.
20 by 20 is also working on scale up investments. So we provide the resources required to move a successful business model has been tested on 10,000 hectares try to ramp it up to 100,000 hectares or 200,000 hectares. It’s a heavy lifting but it can be done. The initiative also has a political dialogue ongoing with the ministers in most countries or pro provincial ministers in the case of Brazil. And we have also where we have been sponsoring a number of analytical studies. One that will be of interest to EAN is the economic argument for land restoration where we look at why should a private investor be interested in agroforestry or pastures and what would the state the nation get out of it and as I said welcome to check additional details on initiative 20 times.org work.
Jonah:
Great. Thank you. Now I’d like to call in Jamie Cashman. Jamie works with the Development Finance Corporation, which is an evolutionary step beyond the overseas private investment corporation. It was created as a better process for helping the US government to do impact investing overseas. Used to be that we could only do lending. Now we can do equity. Jamie, can you tell us a little bit about the DFC? Are you there, Jamie? Oh, I think you might not be there. Okay. Well, I’ll tell you about the DFC. So the Development Finance corporation works a lot in collaboration with US A.
They now have a policy that allows them to have a $60 billion exposure ceiling which means that they can guarantee loans all over the world up to $60 billion and I’ve started a conversation with them about possibly guaranteeing a loan for an Amazon reforestation bond and the doors open for these conversations to tart to start and the changing winds in American politics will help that. Rumor has it that Joe Biden may actually be the next president. And that news has gotten a lot of investors from the United States and Brazil excited about the idea of designing new Amazon sustain sustainability financial products and the US government may be able to provide a loan guarantee of some of them which again reduces risk and will invite a lot many more financial partners to come to the table.
Jamie, if you’re there, feel free to add on. Okay, next I’d like to invite Mark to introduce himself. Mark just of transformative capital. Mark has a fair amount of experience working on bonds. Say hi, Mark.
Mark Chasan:
Hello everyone. Really grateful to be here. Excited about what you put together, Joan, and I really appreciate the invitation to collaborate with all of you in hopefully transforming the world with capital, which is what I’m about in my journey. And to nutshell it I’ve been involved in law finance entrepreneurship and what I found is that the two most influential impacts on humankind have been the environment in which we live from which beliefs behaviors and culture arises and once culture is adopted then it perpetuates those beliefs and behaviors. So if we really want to look at one of the big leverage points it’s how do we change the environments in which we live so that we can form new beliefs and behaviors and culture.
The second is entrepreneurship and innovation largely brought to us through entrepreneurs and inventors. You know the inventions and the new businesses that have been created throughout history have changed the course of history and humankind’s beliefs and behaviors again. So using those two acupuncture points transformative capital utilizes capital expertise and strategy law, finance and international entrepreneurship to really make big changes from the small from the micro to the macro rather than the macro to the micro. You know, I sometimes feel when I look out at what is happening in our world and trying to make changes at the UN level or the political level, it seems like it moves at such a glacial pace and we just don’t have that time.
So, how can we use money and capital and create those investment models? Because, let’s face it, money and love have been the big motivators throughout history. And yet money unfortunately has seemingly become the largest motivator now. So how can we make it attractive to do ecosocial investments and what we’re seeing with ESG and the $30 trillion that has flown into it largely is while I applaud the efforts lipstick on many of the same old pigs and how can we really focus our efforts to be putting money into core regenerative projects that actually have substantial returns for investors so that we and attract that trillion, multiple trillions of dollars into what I would call core regenerative enterprises and projects or reps.
Taking a page out of a company that I helped stand up clean fund which is one of the largest pace finance or property assist clean energy bond finance companies in the US. We create there was a criteria that was created that says that we can use tax assessments for example in order to support lower cost and more secure financing for energy efficiency and renewable energy as a public benefit. So taking that same model and developing a criteria for regenerative enterprises and projects that actually directly achieve the SDG goals. I believe that we can bring in financing for those projects with the guarantees of say the World Bank and DFC and get those AAA rated bonds that provide the security and also provide potentially higher interest rates than general bonds, general corporate or municipal or government bonds.
And so I believe that there is a compelling argument to be made for capital to start flowing into these regenerative enterprises and projects. And one of the core areas is how do we reforest and engage in agroforestry in order to provide the compelling returns. Also in a world where interest rates are at an all-time low on bonds, we have to be careful that as interest rates increase, the bonds will actually become devalued. So, how can we look at bond structures that have floating interest rates and or use the diversity of equity and other such things as royalties and product sales.
So I really feel like one of the things to explore is an innovative diversified bond that utilizes the guarantees of various governments and IGOS so that actually more money will flow into bonds and those bonds can have a higher interest rate to investors while lowering the interest rate to transitioning and developing countries.
Jonah:
Excellent. Thank you Mark. As I steward a network of investors into this territory of designing new financial products, I look for adviserss with experience who can tell me what a bond indenture is and what to include and not include. And Mark has been one of those recent voices I found along the way who has the experience. But we also need the experience on the ground. Who are the commercially viable companies that are already doing reforestation projects? Hey, I see that we have Erica and Daniel from Beraca on the phone. Can you guys introduce us to Beraca for a moment and tell us a little bit about your reforestation experience?
Daniel Sabara:
Sure. Thank you Jonah. Good to be here. Me and Erica, we work for a company named Beraca. I see some familiar faces here. It’s good to be here and see you all. We are based in Brazil and we use agroforestry systems usually with a diverse different kinds of groups here in Brazil mostly in the in the Amazon rainforest where people live in the forestated areas and so the agroforestry system is a very interesting model that we have used in many different projects. And one of the key factors of that model is related to the guarantee of demand for the products that will be used to reestablish a healthy system in a consortion of different species.
So that the producer can benefit from the diversity of income of additional income coming from the reforestation methodology since the beginning. So the consortion is very technical in a way that you need to better define what the species that will interact with each other since the beginning of the reforestration reforestation process until you get into a moment in the in the project where you have more closed and primarily forest species in a in a more mature way in a more mature moment. So we have used that successfully in projects mostly related to customers that are willing to invest on these kind of projects mostly for groups that have interaction with family agriculture not only with what we call wild harvesting.
So they use both u wild resources from nature as well as shorter terms agriculture. Erica if you’d like to add something.
Erica:
Hi everybody. I’m not going to add Danielle. You explained very detailed and I had already introduced myself to people I know. So just want to say hi again.
Jonah:
Great. Thanks for that. I’ve also invited a couple of other people to join the call who were not announced in the email invitation previously. They also play a key role. Hey Keith, could you tell us a little bit about producers market? You’re on mute.
Keith Agoada:
Yeah, sorry about that. Hey everyone, thank you Jonah and really amazing call. Love the topics here. In short, you know, we have a market linkage platform where we’re connecting agricultural producers to markets and working with the data and content to have it travel across value chains to consumers. Specifically to the Amazon. We were engaged with the representative of the Surinam president’s office who’s stayed on the new administration and looking at a large piece of land that a local operator wants to develop into agroforestry systems. So we’re using this as an opportunity and working with the subnational climate fund which is has been empowered by the green climate fund now to look at an innovative model of scalable food production for the Caribbean region based upon forestry crops and sustainability.
So, we’re really focused on the market connectivity side and bringing in buyers to help give greater confidence to funding and financing of these types of sustainable procurement and sustainable forestry initiatives. So, thanks for having me and excited to keep learning here.
Jonah:
Great. Thanks so much for joining us, Keith. And Amanda, could you tell us a little bit about Regenerosity and the Buckminster Fuller Institute?
Amanda Ravenhill:
Yeah, happy to. Hi, everyone. I’m Amanda Joy, executive director at Buckminster Fuller Institute. We ran a challenge program for a decade identifying regenerative projects around the world and have recently partnered up with Lush Cosmetics and the UN DP Quater Prize two other kind of regenerative prizes to create a larger pool of over 700 projects around the world that we’re helping resource and focusing first on regenerative agriculture primarily in India, East Africa and the Amazon. Thanks to the investors and philanthropists who have come to the table. And yeah, the idea is to fund these projects but also be part of the larger decolonizing wealth movement of breaking down the power dynamic that often exists between projects and funders and really recognizing that everyone is a wealthier just of different forms of capital.
And yeah, another piece of it is bringing kind of that wealth of regenerative intelligence from the projects through up through u different philanthropic networks. We have a team of philanthropists and funders that we work with and yeah trying to kind of like bring the regenerative principles throughout the whole community so that we can all achieve the sustainable development goals and beyond in the most regenerative way possible. And we have an event on Thursday we’d love to have you all at which is around monitoring and evaluation and verification for regenerative projects in a way that kind of sacks as many functions as possible.
So we’ll have open team and regen network and some others there. I’ll put the link in the chat. Great to be here.
Jonah:
Great. Thanks Amanda. I was pasting lots of links into the waiting room that had nobody in it and I only just realized that and I have repasted everything to the to the main chat room which is why you guys got all of those big dump of links all at the same time. So, guys, we’ve got a network. We’ve got an active group of people invested. We’ve got entrepreneurs. We’ve got government regulators. We’ve got financial experts. We’ve got access to people who want to securitize loans. We got access people are interested in offering long-term purchase contracts to securityize loans and bonds and things like that.
So the question the next question is okay well what we can do together who’s going to take leadership what are the unmet needs? What are the unanswered questions? And so I posted a bunch of questions which we can now talk about as a group. I just want to note is there a chance that someone from the climate bonds initiative is on that I haven’t seen yet. Okay. They’ve been presenting on a couple of calls and there was some indication they may join this one. So okay. So before I get into this question like who are the target investors and who is the bond issuer?
Does anybody have broad questions about this proposal suggested so far? Any questions for any of the previous folks who’ve introduced themselves? A teacher of mine once said that if you present something to a group and ask for questions and no one asks me questions means no one understood anything. So, feel free to ask a question and if there are none, I’ll move on, but I’ll recognize that there’s something missing in my presentation.
Margarita Mora:
I do have a question. Hello everyone. Here is Margarita Mora from Materero. I thank you very much to everyone for the presentations and for sharing with us the plans. I did have a question for Keith and his work the work that producers market are like doing in Surinam. I was really triggered not triggered in the bad way but I was really curious that’s the right word about Surinam per se because I know that it is challenging that markets work differently. So I was curious on how you were thinking about this kind of approach in a country like Zorina.
Jonah:
Thank you.
Unidentified participant:
Yeah.
Keith Agoada:
Yeah. Thank you. Well, it all starts with the local operators and their connectivity to the communities within those regions. And we’re looking at 10 to 15 target crops that can reach commercial export levels. And given the lack of logistics at times, we’re looking at how we can add value to crops to put them into a non-p perishable format. So looking at you know 10 to 15 crops that the local operator would be growing and based upon those crops what would the yields be to reach market and what would be the processing requirements to put them into a commercial format to reach the potential offtakers.
And so we’re collecting a lot of information around both the growing practices the yields and offtake both from this project as well as others in the community that have access to raw materials but don’t have a market per se. And then understanding what the processing needs and requirements are to reach that commercial scale and the certification requirements while building in the market partnerships from the ground up as well as the financial and government support in order to you know fund and facilitate. And it’s seen as a climate change mitigation project as well as a climate change adaptation project due to the shift of looking at these open fields that maybe border the Amazon that have been already deforested from decades ago or more recently and how these can be put back into production as a biomimicry of sorts of like a cultivated landscape for forestry.
That you know uses no till and regenerative practices. So and hopefully I’m not boring you guys but to take a step further you know looking at how do you have cash flows in the first 12 months through root crops while the first tier of canopy grows and the first harvest come from tree crops. This model is going to be built a lot around fruit trees coconut nut crops and timber crops and the first year crops you know sacha inchi ginger turmeric and other you know shorter term cash crops. So hope hopefully that gives a little bit of a window into what we’re looking at and it’s going to require a lot of operational planning and making sure that the yields are large enough to get to commercial scale and that the processing facilities diversified and able to handle these types of outputs to reach market efficiently.
Jonah:
Great. So I can dive into a group of questions. I think I should let in a couple others. Other questions that people might have. Go ahead, John Bruno.
John Bruno:
Thanks, Jonah. I just want to ask Amanda mentioned about equitable finance and of course we know that on this call a lot of what goes on will be invisible to the people on the ground and I’m interested to see you know we’re just an NGO and not in any of those groups you mentioned but I spent a long time on Wall Street and I understand a lot of what you’re talking about. This is truly revolutionary and if done right will be amazing. You we were involved in I was asked for my opinion when Portugal was developing its you know green visa program and I can see the possibilities here but what I’m asking is since a lot of this will be done invisibly to the communities to the to the communities on the ground who will be affected how can we ensure this is a big question but I think it’s important how can we ensure that not the upstream large corporate partners that I keep hearing being mentioned in all of this.
But how will the communities directly benefit from how will we ensure I should say that the communities directly benefit from these initiatives?
Jonah:
You know, that’s a good question. I’d love other people to respond to that who have local agroforestry experience. I’ll just share one thing. I did some research to figure out how much money per Acre Amazon farmland is worth. And I found this one extraordinary article which I am amazed I had not yet seen. It gives a couple of numbers but it makes a very important point that is more than that. Here’s the article. The conversation.com is a media site for where scientists produce articles. Very interesting. So by their calculations an eastern para a cattle rancher can earn $250 per year per Acre whereas a soy farmer can get about a thousand a year per Acre and if you’re producing rice and beans and [amount unclear] for manioc per Acre.
Yet most of the agriculture in the region is cattle even though it’s not the most profitable. The article goes on to say that money isn’t the stumbling block to sustainability in the region and halting deforestation. It says that tradition and culture and relationships and people’s search for happiness which is you know less about money and more about relationships with other people. They say that it is the stumbling block to changing the winds in the region so to speak to be more sustainable. So getting at your question h how can we ensure local people are included or what is the impact going to be to local people I’m learning in this journey that you’re right it’s not about economics it’s about local dynamics all politics is local as they say in the United States would other people like to respond to John’s question.
Unidentified participant:
Yes Jonah I think it’s a Very good pertinent question. Part of the answer is that u there is a subset of investors that have those considerations in mind when investments are made and that’s they are called impact investors and that’s why it is very important when you assemble an alliance of investment in restoration in agroforestry and pastas to count with the right partners. If you look at my screen here, these are the criteria for one 123. It’s one of it’s an impact investor base in Frankfurt in Germany. And you see there the commitments before they made a dispersement 100% social insurance and access to health care, education and training.
No gap between salaries for women and men. Recycling water and so forth so forth. So just to indicate that the key to this and I agree with your comment the key is to have the right people the right partners investment partners associated to any platform. Of course you will always find a lot of money. Money is not the problem like Jonah said but the right money to reach the social environmental impacts as well as financial is a determining criteria.
Jonah:
Would anyone else like to reply to Kevin go ahead and hear from Erica and then Mark or whoever was speaking before.
Erica:
May I? Yes. I just wanted to highlight also that when we talk about u in Brazil we talk a lot about the traditionality on plantations and some kinds of cultivation. So I believe this is I didn’t read the material that you sent but I believe this is very connected too because most of the things that we have is based on family agriculture but most of the products that are the commodities that make actually make our GDP grow is very connected to just a few companies and what we do in terms of the agroforestry for restoration cultivation is to have different species.
So they can have like a calendar. So during the entire year they have different species to work and different species to sell. So it creates an environment of entrepreneurship for these people to take care of their land and it’s very complex for them. So we are always looking for other partners to join us in terms of having other activities not only purchasing the seeds that Beraca does. And also for us in case of Beraca purchasing raw material because from this community we know that we are just complementing or just adding one part of their income through the seeds.
But it’s very important for them to be able to manage many species at many species in the same area. So the thing entrepreneurship here is very important as well.
Jonah:
Great. Let’s hear from Mark and then Christina if you’d like to speak about the document you posted.
Mark Chasan:
So there’s a an old saying in farming. Maybe not that old, but it’s don’t grow basil, grow pesto. And so one of the things that Keith mentioned is how do you stabilize and process products into value added products so that the farmers are not selling crops. However, many of the farmers in developing countries don’t have resources to which crops go the best, which crops are going to yield the best cash. There’s there’s no sense of sharing of equipment or co-ops. And so one of the things that I think is a huge entrepreneurial andor NGO opportunity is to really build cooperatives of local farmers that have then access to data to equipment and to a collective bargaining arrangement where they can get higher cash values.
The other thing is then to look at vertical integration of everything in the supply chain so that more products move directly from the farm to the consumer rather than through multiple middlemen using fossil fuel logistics and everything else. And how can we also then being that this is the topic of how do we maintain forests and prevent them from being deforested for largely agriculture and ranching using regenerative agriculture and training local farmers in regenerative agriculture where they’re able to plant more trees to engage in that permaculture mix of agroforestry and various crops.
That not only yield cash but also build soil. More than anything, what we have to do is build healthy soil so that the roots of plants then take carbon out of the atmosphere and put it back in the soil where it belongs. And all of this, if done right, can be highly profitable. In fact, a company that’s a client of mine, Black Sheep, has about 200 acres in Costa Rica, and they’re vertically integrated agroforestry and super food company. They have their own brand called Rewild. But then black sheep as an entity also helps to create farms and to share ownership of farms with the farmers while creating a greater vertically integrated supply chain as well as take many of the products off the farm and stabilize them through a centralized processing facility.
So that the farms can in fact generate much more income and a much greater slice of the of the supply chain pie. And so I think those are many of the ways where entrepreneurs and investors can in fact provide for much greater adoption of agroforestry as well as investment into agroforestry.
Jonah:
Christina, thank you Mark.
Christina:
Hi everyone. Yeah, I just wanted to draw your attention to this paper that was published a couple months ago here at the it was presented at the Wilson Center in DC but in so it’s headed up by Andrew Waldron who’s a professor at Cambridge University and the paper was written by over a hundred researchers. It’s super interesting because it, you know, breaks down a lot of these sort of ideas that the expansion of conservation area to 30% of the earth’s surface by 2030 might have a negative impact on the economy of the countries that are protecting these areas and so forth.
And so this paper presents the exact opposite. And so they analyzed the global economic implications of this 30% protected area target and it looks you know very different looks it’s actually positive and for indigenous people in particular it’s very attractive sadly, I’ve spoken to Andrew Waldron because I was wondering whether they had a Spanish version of this because I think that just getting this paper out in Latin America would be super interesting and of course they don’t have funding to translate the paper into Spanish. So if there are any in investors out there who would be interested in translating this paper, I’m sure Andrew Waldron would be very happy to entertain that idea.
I honestly I’ve been pushing this all over Venezuela, Colombia, but it’s in English. So anyway, I just thought that it might be relevant to some of you out there.
Jonah:
Great. There are a couple of more links and statements in the chat area. I encourage people to look at those. We’re going to leave the chat room open so that people can go into it. I’m just going to include a couple more. One is this landmark report by the climate bonds initiative about the $163 billion opportunity to help Brazil transition to sustainable agriculture. And then this is a list put out by the food and agricultural organization under the UN framework about viable commercially viable Amazon species. There are a lot of them.
This can help those agroforestry entrepreneurs move forward. So as we get into the future of this group that’s on this call it’s seldom that a call like this will have a you know a major policy impact. The best things that happen when people lose use learn some new resources take new ideas back to the table build some original relationships. Creating a network a team collaborating towards a shared goal that is a good outcome for a call like this. So I’m going to begin posting a couple questions about building the network to answer some of these unanswered questions.
I but first I’m going to give the floor to Alex Rose from GIZ.
Alex (GIZ):
Yes. Hi Jonah. This is Alex from GIS. I just wanted to mention one thing to everybody. GZ and partner the nature conservancy in Mondlay is investing in the in the southeast of para in selix dingu and tukuma and agroforestry projects based on kakau and some other species but maybe we should go a little bit deeper into this in this discussion today. I’ve heard many people talk about agroforestry. Just to give you an idea, at least in Brazil, agroforestry is mainly done by family farming and family farming according to the rules and guidelines in Brazil means it’s just a family and basically one more assistant.
So the capacity of the farms is they can basically only handle one or two hectares. So the little farms or the family farms have like 50 or 80 hectares but it’s one or two hectares only on which agroforestry is done. The other hectors are basically regular cultivation or cattle ranching. And the second issue or the challenge is the local market for the additional crops. Like if it’s Cocoa, it’s fine. There’s a stable market, but the additional products there’s still a big challenge to sell them. And I think John talked about, no, Mark talked about the Costa Rica project.
I just wanted to remind you that for example, in the Brazilian Amazon, it’s more expensive to bring the product from the Amazon to S. Paulo than a product from Costa Rica to Miami or to the US. So there’s still high logistical cost. So agroforestry is maybe a part of a solution but cannot really be the entire solution for restoation for reforestation of degraded areas. So maybe not all can be seen with an investor loop in terms of return on investment or bond. So maybe a mixed finance is a is an feasible solution like using the Amazon fund or other mechanisms mixed with some yeah impact investor funding because it’s very hard for these family farmers or regular farmers to attend to the criteria to comply with the criteria of an investment impact investor or some other kind of investors.
That’s just some food for thought and some problems we are facing by investing into agroforestry in PA. Thanks.
Jonah:
So, Alex, I have a follow-up question for you. There are literally dozens of non-timber forest products that can be produced, some of which have more demand than others and others for which demand can be manufactured with lots of extra marketing and things like that. Something that you know the you know the commercial markets can help get behind. I understand that transport is an issue, refrigeration during transport technology is an issue. Of those dozens of others potentially commercial commercially viable products besides cocoa which are the most which have the highest opportunity market wise?
Do you have an appreciation?
Alex (GIZ):
I cannot really answer that. It depends really on the region. If there’s a city nearby, if the farmer is selling product to national procurement like school feeding programs, it’s usually the short circuit crops that help him survive like banana and mandio. But usually when you talk about agroforestry, I believe there are people in this call who understand more than me from agroforestry. But you have to go through the death through the death valley first of all you have to learn as a farmer how to how to build your agroforestry system.
For this you need you need technical assistance which is very rare or expensive or like an international project has to pay for it because the farmers cannot allow it. So first you have to set up your system then you have to go through the death valley which is usually three four or five years before you get some kind of return. So the best solution I’ve seen is investing in these short circles like bananas mio something you can you can sell on a local fair just for cash.
Jonah:
Do any of those who have u Amazonbased reforestation experience want to add some more in response to that question?
Erica:
I totally agree with Alexander and because for us it’s similar. So we understand that we cannot simply say a few species that are the most interesting because it’s really depends on the region and on the challenges and obviously on the tradition of that group. You know if they know the species we cannot simply introduce something that they it’s not on the dayto-day to work with. And also one of the things that we need to be careful just adding again with what he said is just that restorations cannot be restoration with agroforestry cannot be the only answer because in the long run we will be stimulating 10 15 species only instead of stimulating the biodiversity you know.
So this is something that we need to understand the situation the territory and work with what the territory is cap is already has its proper naturistics you know we need to work with that.
Jonah:
During the preparation process for this call I learned that some genetic work was done on soy to make soy temperature resistant and therefore viable to grow in the Amazon region and now it dominates the region. It’s the crop that’s producing $1,000 an Acre. It seems to me that work can be done on market development and many other things transport to help agroforestry products become more commercially viable and therefore scalable. Even if it is just 15 species, if you have 15 species in a poly culture, that brings back that restores biodiversity in a very significant way that soy monocultures do not permit.
So what is the frontier here? It seems to me that there must be an opportunity to scale agroforestry to compete with cattle and soy to be to have greater appeal than just small holder farmers. What are the stumbling blocks? What are the research hurdles that need to be overcome or the access to market hurdles that need to be overcome?
Unidentified participant:
I would just like to add to Erica’s comments and Alex I agree that it’s a it’s a complex system and it has to be turnkey to each region and occasion let’s say but I think that it’s important that we consider also the demand of the energy markets so for instance we have a specific legislation regarding biodiesel. So for most biodiesel producers in Brazil to sell to the energy agency the fuel that will go into buses and other transportation. They need to guarantee that part of that oil that is being transformed into biodeiesel is coming from family agriculture.
So these kind of initiatives I think they help and we I think we should also think about the advocacy of the responsibility of advocacy into the different governments to also to rely on and to increase the need of these large volumes products coming from family agriculture and wild harvesting. There is a jet fuel project going on as well globally to increase the use of biojet fuel. Let’s say that’s a global initiatives rel initiative related to transportation. So concerning very high volumes of product and there is no offer of products or of projects related to that.
So if we consider that we have a extremely large extremely large areas that need to be reforested and we have dem the demand for products that would come from these areas. I think it’s it’s just a matter of doing the connections and talking to the right people and making that scalable.
Jonah:
Great. We only have a couple minutes left. Feel free to share.
Unidentified participant:
Yeah. Yeah. Jonah, I was going to just briefly add in to one of the great obstacles is that there’s so many crops that are just not well known to markets that the large commercializers who reach consumers have narrowed and narrowed the scope of what’s marketable. Yet there’s so many crops coming that can be grown in the Amazon or come out of the Amazon that ought to have a major market and in the superfood space in the you know meat replacement vegan space and so there’s there’s crops like that can also be grown around tropical areas around the world and some examples like peach palm or pigsby and garlic vine and chaya and katuk and of course heart of palm.
You know these are crops that most consumers in the US have never heard of but it takes a huge effort to bring them to market to bring awareness. So I think there could be also an effort around taking crops that either exist in Amazon or could be grown there and commercialized and building market for it. In addition to the what was mentioned around you know yuka and plantain and bananas but going into these specialty ones I could have a very high value.
Jonah:
Great so we’re at the top of the hour this is the moment where most of the people will get off the call and you’re welcome to thank you to all of our speakers for joining us but I also call this the water cooler moment because this is where we move into unstructured conversation some connections can be made and lots other good things like that. Encourage people to share their LinkedIn ids, their email addresses, their websites in the chat area. I’m going to offer a concluding sentence about my own learning process.
So I it certainly seems like a dream that there could be a solution to scale across Amazon region and maybe there is but there’s a lot of complexity and a lot of learning and a lot of innovation that needs to happen to make it possible. And some of the presenters on this call have some of those Ethan and Propagate Ventures designing technology and new financial product for the American market. Maybe there is some applicability for Brazil and other Amazon regions. I’m in the process of learning a great deal. I’m sharing it transparently with all of you in the process, which is a little bit of a vulnerable thing to do, but I think that’s why this works.
We all learn together. And I also learned that I have a lot more to read, but it seems as though I’m surrounded by the people with the answers. So, thank you all for joining this call. It’s extraordinary. I can’t believe you all came. And, now is water cooler time. This is where you guys can shamelessly self-promote events or introduce yourselves or ask pending questions. Let me say bye if you leave.
Unidentified participant:
I’d like to maybe ask Mark or someone else who is dealing with large numbers and large investments in the sense that what are the preconditions for being willing to invest? Do investors need do they have to own the property? What are the tenure preconditions? Is it at all imaginable that the 25% of the Brazilian Amazon that is indigenous territories would be of interest to investors or is it totally irrelevant for that type of approach?
Mark Chasan:
Well I would say that if we look at the roughly $30 trillion that is currently invested as assets under management for ESG. When you look at the Apple green bond that paid basically was a zero coupon bond paying.3% yield. You know there is a definite demand for green bonds and for investments that are going to help you know the climate change issues are going to help the environment are going to help developing countries to become more economically sustainable and empowered. So we are seeing a lot of money going into that.
One of the problems I’ve seen in the social impact space is it’s almost like martyrdom of oh I invest for long periods of time at high risk and get low returns. Aren’t I great? And unfortunately most of the money flowing into social impact in the past has been very small amounts. You know, I’ve seen billion dollar, you know, billionaires make $5,000 investments and everybody’s like, “Oh, that’s so cool.” So, how do we get how do we get that billionaire to put in a hundred million into investments? And largely it comes down to riskreward.
Are we finding investments that actually meet the criteria of various investors? So, if we’re looking at long-term bonds with countries or governments, corporations that have fairly bad credit ratings, they’re going to have to pay more for the their capital. So if we were to take criteras that actually defined agroforestry, regenerative investments, clean energy, clean water, water recycling, biomimetic materials, waste upcycling as a few examples as those criteria. And we were able to get the guarantees that enhanced credit we could actually lower cost of capital to get more of these projects off the ground to get more money flowing into the pockets of entrepreneurs.
So largely it’s how do we how do we adjust risk one and how do we look at returns rather than just economic returns but also regenerative or environmental or social returns and actually find an objective way to measure that and add that on to the economic returns as a number so that these investments become more compelling and those large companies around the globe that have made some commitment to SGS and sustainability can actually in some objective way validate their investments into these types of enterprises and projects so that we actually can see widespread adoption.
And I think that’s been the problem is orchestrating things that will efficiently match capital and what they’re looking for with projects. And so that’s one of the areas that I’m working on diligently is to create a matching platform that utilizes algorithmic filtering and AI to effectively match capital. There’s also a lot of areas that quite frankly people aren’t considering. How do you how do you do inventory or receivables financing? How can we get royalties as a as a topline gross licensing fee and distribution potentially so that investors don’t have to wait a long time for that risky occurrence of an IPO or an M&A that may never happen.
How do we look at bonds and create float floating interest bonds in a low interest market so that bond investors will invest in bonds knowing that they’re not going to lose their shirt as interest rates climb. So there’s there’s lots of ways of sewing together multistakeholder engagement between IGOS, NOS’s, private public partnerships in ways that make the bonds and equity investments compelling.
Participant — Mentor Capital Network:
Hey everybody. Oh what do you know? I even unmuted myself. So Mark agree My name is [name unclear]. I am with the Mentor Capital Network. Jonah has invited me into this. We work with startup social entrepreneurs all over the globe including a number who are working in places where outside investors are never going to buy the land because the folks who own it have had really bad experiences with folks who look like me coming in and offering to buy their land in a in a contract that they long no longer which is why I’m a huge fan of royalties or any sort of payment out of cash flow.
This but how do you guarantee this? The earlier part of your conversation you were talking about how do we put numbers on all this? That’s the holy grail of impact investing. How do you make people actually think for the long term despite what everybody says they don’t actually do it? And political stability is in my experience unfortunately a big answer to that which has not been true in either the US or Brazil recently. And you know, if there were laws saying we will, you know, companies that do X and provide for the environment will gain these benefits because we recognize the societal benefits, that’s great.
But there are a few countries where those laws come into play, but not too many. And I would love to hear I am not I’m sort of I know a little bit about a lot of things. So I’m not deep into the Amazon but I’m into the impact investing space globally. If anyone has any sense of where in the Amazon region there are stable political entities that are offering benefits to companies where the government is thinking in the long term that investors could be tempted into. I would love to know about that.
That’s we’ve done some interesting work in Mexico but I don’t know Latin America at all. Or rather to the death of the people on this call. Anyways,.
Unidentified participant:
Across many industries, there is it depends on the industry. Across many industries, there is political stability in Brazil. There are products coming out of the Amazon and successful companies that you know win the favor of the political right and the political left. And that provide a return on investment. Some of it might only be you know small scale some of it is large scale. So that the answer changes depending on the question of scale.
Mark Chasan:
Also there’s ways that you can bring private capital to a country. Generally if you go to a country especially a developing country with your hand out and say I’ve got a great idea why don’t you fund me? They’re going to say, “Yeah, I get in the back of that mileong line.” however, if you say, “I can bring capital. I can lower the cost of capital to you if you issue a bond and if we can get AAA or double A rated bonds and then for example, let’s say that I have a regenerative community development project that I want to do in the Amazon region that will focus on regenerative agriculture and agroforestry.
And it’s a $50 million project. And let’s say that Brazil needs a waste to energy treatment plant for $100 million. I can go to my investors and say we’re raising a hundred million for $50 million project. And everybody goes, “Whoa, why?” Well, because it’s a it’s a World Bank guaranteed AAA rated bond. At the end of 10 years, your principal will be guaranteed. Now I take that bond at say 6 and a half% interest whereas Brazil might be paying 13% interest for that bond. I go to Brazil and I say to the government, you’re going to make sure that there’s no corruption involved in this.
You’re going to give me fasttracking of all the permits I need. You’re going to give me tax credits for the investment. You’re going to give me employment training credits. You’re going to wave repatriation fees. You’re going to wave import and export tariffs. And they would say most likely yes and you’re going to get incremental tax revenues. You’re going to get all these wonderful things. Now what happens is the waste to energy treatment plant can be funded by incremental tax credits by tipping fees by energy fees whatever you know there’s there’s actually revenues flowing to fund the bond and to pay that bond.
So the World Bank feels pretty good that the company that the country is going to meet its obligations. From a standpoint of what I do with that hundred million bond, now I take it to a bank, put it in a lockbox account at three and a half, four% and it’s paid off and completely liquidated with advertised payments in 10 years. So now I have my $50 million to do the regenerative community development project. We got a hundred million waste energy treatment plant. So for that hundred million, we actually got $150 million worth of regenerative projects.
My project’s much more safe as a result of that because I’m actually working with the government and they’re giving me protection because I brought in a hundred million at half of what it would cost normally to get that $100 million for their plan. So those are the kinds of financial structures that I believe we can put in place that will make a lot of sense to investors on the one hand and on the other hand will really help local economies to grow and to get their needs met.
Jonah:
Great. This question, this conversation could can continue to mature. I just want to open up for some others. Go ahead.
Stan:
Can I jump in? Just listening to all this bond talk. You know, we’re working a lot on tokenization and we have a tokenization platform, but it’d be really interesting to see if there’s a way that we could tokenize a bond. One of the new things that’s starting to happen because of there’s a municipal crisis brewing in the United States, well, probably actually all the way around the world, but because of the pandemic, a lot of state and local governments are on their way to going broke or, you know, they’re they’re having huge tax volatility for their income.
And so there’s a big very quiet behind the scenes thing happening now where they’re looking at how to change and adapt like bond issuance structures and the ways that new technologies blockchain and tokenization could be used to issue new types of bonds. And so you know this conversation has got me thinking. It’s very interesting learning about especially Mark what you were just talking about whether or not we could potentially issue a digital bond you know parallel to the traditional markets because the cost of issuing a bond in the regular financial markets is very large and that’s one of the major obstacles to doing this but the ability for us to issue like an Amazon bond or some other kind of you know funding bond through the blockchain that is more of a grassroots concept u might be a solution that you guys want to think about.
It has its own regulatory hurdles and its own web of challenges but net it might be like a nice parallel or an introductory way of being able to get this kind of Amazon bond out into the market at a lower cost. So just some food for thought.
Jonah:
Nice. So I think that the destination of this conversation is going to be a lot of smaller conversations. I think that there’s a lot of opportunity here. I think that tying the bond issuance to some sort of a blockchain strategy holds a lot of promise. Maybe we’ll pursue both ideas simultaneously. These it seems to me that there are a couple of just moving forward pending questions. Alex suggested that Alex from GIZ suggested that the big stumbling block is infrastructure transport of viable produce outside the Amazon. And another stumbling block that others talked about is those products that are not soy and cattle meeting demand outside Amazon.
Both of those seem solvable to me and I’m going to try to source answers to them. My guess is that solutions already exist and Alex or others simply don’t know about them yet. So I’ll I think most people on this call are involved in the private LinkedIn chat room. So as I move forward learn on some of this I’ll post some of my questions there and we will probably dedicate future calls of the Amazon Investor Coalition to this continuing conversation.
Unidentified participant:
Could you put that link into the chat? I don’t I’m not in that LinkedIn group.
Jonah:
Oh yeah, sure.
Mark Chasan:
And Stan, I’m happy to talk to you about the crypto preservation of forests as well as agroforestry. I’m sending you a note as well.
Stan:
Yeah, great. We have we actually have a token that we launched last year which Jonah knows about called Ultra Reserve where we’re we’ve been basically doing tokenized assets around forest reserves. We have a project in Ghana and they’re doing some stuff in the Amazon. Very small scale right now, but you know, happy to talk to you about it and see where there might be opportunities to help out.
Mark Chasan:
Yeah. I mean, we could even create a stable coin that’s value is tied to growing timber and you know that at some point in time will be harvested sustainably and there thereby you have stability and also guaranteed growth in the coin itself.
Stan:
Yeah, we’ve looked at that. You know, we run Ven, which was the first digital currency, and it’s like a diversified stable coin with carbon as part of the backing. We’ve looked at timber. You know, for me, like I tend to be a bit of a dreamer purist in the sense that I would love to see rewing of these locations because the impact on biod diversity is so large. And you know, when you’re harvesting the timber and depending on how it’s being done, you know, it could either be part of the problem or part of the solution.
But yeah, I mean there’s definitely like I think a number of different financial mechanisms that could be done and they could all kind of interact with each other and even trade against each other. I mean, I tend to really advocate for the idea of like, you know, o ocean preservation zones that could be funded through a token, reforestation that could be funded through a token for reing. And I think that there’s enough demand in the market for those sorts of things where people could you know you could price in the benefits.
But theoretically you could even like price in like oxygen generation like you know the fact that the trees in a forest perform an oxygen function and put a value on that and see if you could you know start to put that into the market somewhat theoretically. But clearly like you know an asset back stable coin for forestry that’s harvested that’s going to have long-term long-term benefits for the buyers.
Jonah:
Nice. Okay, we’ll continue to pass this information along. I encourage everyone to share your emails and your LinkedIns and your websites below and unless there are any other questions maybe you can wrap. Go ahead.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you, Jonah, for putting this together. Much appreciated.
Jonah:
My pleasure. Thanks so much for joining us.
Stan:
Thank you, Jonah.
Jonah:
You bet, Stan.
Unidentified participant:
Jonah, thank you so much. This has been great. Appreciate it.
Jonah:
Likewise. I’m gonna stop recording in case you understand. Mark, thank you so much. And if you want to stay on, you are welcome.