Investing in Amazonian Forestry
Amrita Vatsal: Founded in the mid 2000s, EFM invests in companies that address the climate crisis and social inequality. Setting up shop in South America just 1 year ago, they are developing a pipeline of projects to sequester carbon, advance sustainable land use, and create alternative livelihoods. Amrita Vatsal joins us to share the story and discuss Colombia’s carbon tax. Thought priced at just $5/ton, the system finances a local market for emissions reduction. Though some forest projects rely on the market for profitability, some agroforestry projects do not. Join us to learn the story.
Recorded November 9, 2020
WATCH:
Participants
- Amrita Vatsal — EFM
- Jonah — moderator
- Lars
- Holt
- Marcelo Salazar
- Amalia
- Other unidentified participants
Transcript
Jonah:
So, Amrita Vatsal, welcome to the weekly call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. Tell us a little bit about you and EFM.
Amrita Vatsal:
Hi, Jonah. Can you hear me? Okay.
Jonah:
Yeah.
Amrita Vatsal:
I’m gonna just take my headset off. So glad to be here with you and thank you for this invitation to be on this call. I don’t know many of you so I hope that we will soon become friends and thank you for sharing all this good work. It’s very inspirational. So for background my name is Amrita. I’m a managing director with EFM. By day by night. I’m a mother to an 18-month-old and by heart I’m a optimist who is passionate about investing in natural climate solutions as a way to solve the climate crisis.
I’ve been at EFM for almost 10 years now working on creating and structuring and investing forestland investment funds and now leading our advisory work on natural climate investing. For me I guess I got into this work about 15 to 16 years ago. I lived in Southeast Asia. And you know experienced the forest fires from Indonesia on an annual basis. I was really inspired to learn more about that and spent four months in Indonesia and central Kalimantan working on what is now the largest carbon project forest carbon project in the world.
And that for me was really a pivotal moment in understanding the power of markets and investors in solving environmental and social challenges. And so I have pivoted from that moment and spent the rest of my career working on conservation finance. I came to the US in 2008. Got an MBA and a master of science and natural resources from the University of Michigan and have been working on real asset investments at EFM ever since.
Jonah:
Nice.
Amrita Vatsal:
That’s a little background about me. Do you want me to tell you a little bit about EFM as well, Jonah?
Jonah:
Yeah. And since this is a recorded podcast, I like to set thing questions up so that it, you know, when we edit it, there’s a this comfortable back and forth. So as if this wasn’t scripted, Amrita, tell us about EFM. What’s the story of the creation of the company?
Amrita Vatsal:
Absolutely, Jonah. So our mission at EFM is to accelerate the in investment into natural climate solutions that have the potential to combat the climate crisis and social inequity within the next decade. To do this, we invest alongside with investors, both public and private partners, philanthropy as well as quasi government partners to identify, structure and deploy capital that is seeking appropriate financial returns but also social and environmental impact. We currently focus on North and South America but our scope is global. In the US. To date, we have invested in over 100,000 acres.
It’s about 50,000 hectares, I guess, for those of you who don’t understand acres. And we have transitioned most of that land or in the process of transitioning that land to climate smart forestry and transitioning it to long-term local ownership. In the process, we’re creating new state parks. We’re adding to tribal reservations. We’re adding to public lands to community forests and helping communities own their own drinking watersheds. We’ve structured our work through hybrid structures. So we’re very good and flexible about using private capital alongside the muchneeded philanthropic capital and tax and public capital as well.
In South America we’ve I want to confess we’re learning and so I’m here to learn as much as I am to share. We just started investing in South America a year ago. And in the country we are essentially developing a pipeline of projects that can that can achieve carbon removals at scale can really influence land use and land management outcomes but at the same time are creating alternative livelihoods for communities. So we invest in projects in companies as well as in funds. The company EFM is about 15 years old. We were co-founded by our current CEO [name unclear] and Spencer [surname unclear], whom some of you might have heard of.
He’s a legend in the conservation world and co-founded conservation international. And really you know in summary I would say that at EFM we operate on the premise that you can make money while also doing good. And in fact by doing so you experience better investment outcomes and that is the idea that drives us collectively as an organization.
Jonah:
Nice. Can you tell us about your five R framework?
Amrita Vatsal:
Sure. So for those of you who haven’t heard it which is probably all of you the five R framework is how we talk about climate smart forestry. You know, the word sustainable forestry means so many things to so many different people and in the US context it is riddled by a whole range of different kinds of environmental standards from FSC to SFI and really we’ve lo we’ve got lost in all of that sort of the core principles of what is sustainable forestry and so as a forest management company as an operator with 15 years of experience, we’ve distilled our approach into what we call the five Rs.
And so the five Rs are essentially rotation, which means we extend the average age of harvest of on our properties. So instead of harvesting our trees at, you know, 35 years, which is what is common in the US West, we wait till close to 50 to 60 years. In addition, retention. So when we harvest, we’re not harvesting 100% of the trees, which believe it or not, state law allows you to harvest up to, you know, 120 acres within and leave leaving behind only one to two trees per Acre. So we’re left with large clear cuts in the US in the west and our approach is to increase retention on the landscape.
So we’re leaving behind between 30 to 70% of the trees. We’re trying to create complex matrix ecosystems with different ages, different species. And that’s a core R. The next R is reserves. So we’re also implementing u reserves across our landscapes to protect biodiversity to protect riparian buffers. And that goes way above vol sort of compliance standards. Restoration is our fourth R. EFM does a lot of we buy a lot of industrially managed land. So, this is land that has been managed as plantations primarily with single species. I mean, they’re still native species, but they’re usually managed to one or two species like Douglas fir or spruce and hemlock.
And, they’re managed towards the same age class. And so our goal is to restore not only ecosystem functioning by planting native species, but we do a lot of restoration on water for protecting land for fish, water for fish and land for animals. We do a lot of fence building exclusion of cattle and do a lot of manual restoration and infrastructure restoration. And finally, our fifth R is relationships because we know that land is about people and you cannot manage land without working with communities around you. And so really investing in relationships and partners that really benefit from the long-term well management of our lands.
Jonah:
Awesome. Can you tell us a little bit about the genesis of your interest in the Amazon region and a little bit about how you guys have sourced deals to look for investment opportunities?
Amrita Vatsal:
Yeah, absolutely. You know, so I think we sort of fell into this about a year ago, but really it wasn’t without a lot of interest amongst our management team and members. We’ve we’re you know from Latin American countries have spent a lot of time there we have experience on our team in the country but we just had not had a mechanism within EFM to really express that interest and about a year ago we met an investor who’s very interested in investing in natural climate solutions and they decided they wanted to work with us because they liked our approach to thinking about investing in real assets and you know asked us to start helping them invest their resources into natural climate solutions and so that’s really how we began you know our scope is North and South America and now we’ve started really like I said building a pipeline of investable opportunities hopefully for you know for this investor but hopefully for others as well and how we do that good old-fashioned beating on doors talking to people attending Monday afternoon conferences and webinars.
There’s not a this is probably one of the few sort of investor coalitions I’m aware of that are focused on a region. So that’s really wonderful. But outside of that, you know, we get a lot of pipeline and deal flow from international sort of impact investing coalitions and groups and investors that identify as impact investors.
Jonah:
Great. Could you name a couple of those coalitions just so other investors can know what you guys are involved in?
Amrita Vatsal:
Yeah. So, in the US, the impact investing industry is sort of coordinated by the GIIN, the Global Impact Investing Network. And they are a group of institutional investors sort of co you know, sort of really working across the industry to define what is impact investing and helping the industry grow. Individual investors. There’s a network called Toniic. GIIN and Toniic — it looks like people were having some fun while they were creating this. So, Toniic is a is meant more for high netw worth individuals investing on investing in, you know, businesses that create impact.
Jonah:
Sorry, I was on mute busy trying to copy and paste links. So, I want to go to Colombia for a moment. Can you tell us a little bit about what’s special about the carbon market in Colombia? And secondly, when it comes to Amazon startups, do you have a an appreciation of how many of them depend on carbon markets and red credits to achieve profitability?
Amrita Vatsal:
Yeah, absolutely. So Colombia is a very interesting landscape at the moment. And we you know we’re we were really heartened to learn more about their carbon market or their efforts to start reducing their fossil fuel intensity of their economy. So the government has voluntarily applied a carbon tax on their fossil fuel sector and this was a couple of years ago now and it’s been priced essentially at around $5 per ton which is a low price but it’s still you know a really good start. And so that policy is essentially a cap and tax.
So not only are they taxing the main fossil fuel producing sectors, but they’re also trying to reduce the emissions over time. So that’s an important aspect as well. The second you know what that does is it really creates a market for an internal local market for projects that are trying to reduce carbon emissions. And it but it doesn’t prohibit those projects from also accessing external international markets. To your question about the I guess reliance on carbon by projects. I mean I think that in our experience you know we have seen projects that are we’re and I should caveat we’re looking primarily at land use and land management related investments in projects.
So it’s very heavily driven by how much carbon reductions are achieved and that’s really the scope of the investor and quite often we find that accessing carbon markets and you know international voluntary markets are really driving a lot of the return profile. However, we have seen many interesting opportunities especially when it comes to agroforestry where you know you have a combination of an agricultural product that is supporting investment returns and the reforestation strategy and combined with a conservation strategy is driving a portion of the outcomes and so those are I think very interesting from our perspective.
Jonah:
Great. Can you tell us a little bit about some of your invest? As much as you can.
Amrita Vatsal:
Yeah, I mean, I guess we can’t give you any specific names. I’m happy to talk to any of you that want to learn more offline, but I can give you a sense of, you know, the kinds of firms we’ve invested in. And to be like I said, in full disclosure, we’ve we’ve made, you know, less than a handful of investments. So very much in the learning phase but rapidly hoping to scale that over the next two years. So we have money left and hoping to deploy them. But I’d say that in general we’ve made investments in alongside project carbon project developers that are seeking to invest in avoided deforestation strategies and REDD+ strategies in Colombia.
We’ve also invested or we’ve you know close to making investments in agroforestry project developers across Latin America across different countries including Peru, Colombia maybe Brazil as well. And so that’s a really you know those are promising. Those strategies involve cocoa and coffee. And then also I think for those of you that are in the you know nonprofit business or in the business of buying or conserving land we’ve we are very actively sourcing and are working on projects where we act as a bridge by bridge owner. So helping nonprofits acquire land and by acting as a bridge entity to hold the to hold land for an interim period of time, you know, say five to 15 years maybe and using carbon revenues as a way to help finance that bridge ownership.
So those are some of the kinds of the strategies we’re working on.
Jonah:
Great. And then one more question for me and then we can open it up to the group. So I had mentioned to you through email that I have seen some investors that want a real measure of avoided deforestation and carbon sequestration in their investments and investing in things like fish farming you know have a relationship with that. If you divert incomes away from deforestation and into fish farming or other things that are less deforestation intensive, you end up reducing it. But it’s it’s can be hard to measure that causal relationship.
And so when it comes to developing your investment strategy and you have a mandate to get numbers or to demonstrate causality, how can you how can you deal with that? Lack of numbers, you know, it’s it’s hard to wrap an investment strategy around. What approach have you guys taken or what have you seen?
Amrita Vatsal:
Yeah, I mean, we tend to take a very conservative approach to that to date. So we’re essentially only working within the construct of method carbon methodologies that have already been validated and verified by scientific third parties and auditors. So you know there are in the voluntary carbon market sector there are standards like Verra and Verra has a number of methodologies that actually attempt to quantify this exact question. So what happens when you invest when you grow trees for agroforestry in an area? Does it lead to lower deforestation in that region?
And you know that is a question that requires careful analysis and thought. And so there are there are methodologies that have been designed to answer that question. And so we kind of know we focus on as an investor where we are trying to monetize the carbon asset. And so we are not you know we’re take we’re taking a very conservative approach towards investing in those projects where that causality has been defined or can be defined and validated by an external party. So I think you know it’s important if you are investing in something that is new I don’t know much about fish farming but it but say that is a strategy you would you know you’re trying to prove does actually result in reduced deforestation then I would think that if you were seeking investors for that project that you would want to make sure you have a methodology that meets ISO standards has a you know meets an international framework and then can also to be validated and verified by a technical third party and I think those are the kinds of projects that will result in more capital and scale and investment over time.
Jonah:
Great. Okay, I want to open it up to everybody. Questions for Amrita? Not all at once. Feel free to go ahead and fall into your questions. Go for it, Loris.
Lars:
It’s fascinating the five R approach when it comes to the northern forests. I was fascinated by your expose and at the same time in a sense the contrast between what Varcel was talking about for the Amazon sort of the Amazon is sort of anti- capitalistic in the sense that it’s so diverse so each I mean each resource is sort of small in number so the sort of approach to 50 species or sort of the multitude of approach and I understand your company to deal with timber basically and the carbon related to the timber.
Could you say something about the challenges you meet when you sort of are sort of transplanting a very sound northern strategy to the complexity of the Amazon?
Amrita Vatsal:
Absolutely. And you know, we’re certainly not suggesting that we take this five approach that we have in the in the US West. It’s really a Pacific Northwest, Western US strategy. And it you know, and it needs to be adapted for sure to any forestry strategy in Latin America. So, you know, I think that firstly, we’re not just focused on carbon. So it is a strategy where we are investing in natural forests and so you know within the natural forest context in the region in the west you don’t have as much diversity of species as you do in the Amazon.
So from that perspective we’re actually lucky the northeast in the US you have a lot more species diversity and so you end up with forest management techniques that are that are closer to sustainable techniques anyway and you rely on individual tree selection and you rely on sort of silvicultural strategies that are that are more likely to be sustainable as opposed to in the Northwest we have you know predominantly a clear-cut replant kind of strategy. And so we because you only have, you know, five species and if all five of them are commercially valuable, the most efficient way is to go in and take them all out at the same time.
So of course that strategy makes sense in the, you know, in the western US. And so we don’t we’re trying to make create value from not just the you know growing trees to longer rotations putting more carbon on the landscape but we’re also monetizing the conservation water and recreational values. And so we’re we have tools in the conservation finance markets in the US to pay us for ecosystem services around species conservation around water protection around avoided development and those tools don’t all exist in the Latin American context. So I want to acknowledge that and that you know we would need to develop new strategies and very creative solutions that will allow us to monetize you know things outside of carbon and allow us to implement light touch approaches to silviculture while still being able to monetize you know water protection biodiversity and other ways of doing that in your context.
Lars:
Thank you.
Unidentified participant:
Have you been in like in the Amazon or Colombia? Excuse me. How long have you been in the Amazon? I mean, how long have you been in the south?
Amrita Vatsal:
Just about a year.
Unidentified participant:
Okay. Very recent. Okay.
Amrita Vatsal:
That’s very recent.
Jonah:
We have a question from Hol.
Holt:
Thanks, Jonah. Thanks, Amrita. It’s very helpful and really pleasure to hear your about your work. Just following up on Lars’s point is how do you have a standardized approach or a way of thinking yet about how you can measure biodiversity and ecosystem health and some of the investment activity you’ve made to date? It looks like it’s mostly around the upper Pacific Northwest and then trying to transfer that into the Amazon basin. I know a lot of people are struggling with that issue. I was curious where your thoughts are.
Amrita Vatsal:
Absolutely. I think you know even so much in our US context we hadn’t made much progress on this until the last 10 years and so it has taken an investment by the Packard Foundation along with an industry group like the GIIN, to invest in what is called land conservation metrics and so they have integrated land conservation impact reporting metrics into the standard impact reporting framework called Iris and I’m sorry if all the jargon we I will send you links after this call. But there are third party standards around reporting for biodiversity conservation land stewardship etc that have been put together by the conser led by the conservation community in the US.
And I and I think that you know a similar effort is probably warranted in you know in your in the Latin American context as well. I mean I think you can take some of the principles and the frameworks but then use some of the more international bodies that have worked to prioritize you know bio biodiversity and species etc and use the work of research that has happened in you know in South America to inform those metrics. But we have we have not found any sort of regional regionally specific metrics. Most of the metrics that we have seen tend to be pretty high level and so you can you can say you know how much carbon have you removed.
You can focus on how many species your forests impact. You can report on the amount of land or per hectare that you have conserved etc. But they don’t get down to specific you know specific regional impact.
Holt:
Thank you.
Jonah:
Great. Thank you everybody. We are now at the top of the hour. There is a lot of excitement in the air. This is the moment where we break and some people leave and the rest of us gather around the water cooler and talk. So some conversations are leftover questions for Amrita. The impact of the American election on the Amazon, which I’m certainly eager to talk about. And then this bombshell of this Excel file that’s been released that Amalia has posted. And other questions for Marcelo. So, thank you for joining us everybody.
You’re certainly welcome to go, but if you want to hang out around the water cooler, I’m here and I have a feeling some others will hang out too. Thank you, presenters.
Unidentified participant:
Thank you very much Jonah for the invitation.
Jonah:
Would anyone like to kick it off with questions or assertions?
Unidentified participant:
I have a question. I want to learn more about this group’s opinion or perspective on the impact of the election on the Amazon.
Jonah:
I can tell you a couple things that I’ve heard. I’ve heard some peop So, Bolsonaro used to be able to do a lot of things in the Amazon with impunity because, you know, his North American ally Trump would back him up. And I’ve heard some people say that argument is no longer valid. And so, as a result, some people are calling for him to change his environmental minister. This is something I just heard today. I could say a lot more other people Lars, what are your analysis?
Lars:
You are the one to tell. You are in the middle of everything, but it’s such a huge relief. And I think it’s a beginning of turning the tide. But I’m sure [politician name unclear] is quite depressed right now. But he’s also I mean he’s a focused guy. I don’t know if he will kick out [minister name unclear]. He’s stubborn so like Trump. So I don’t think maybe reason works. What do you think? I mean, I’m sure there were we got messages from the Amazon, people sort of partying when the results came out.
So, people in our camp were extremely happy in the Amazon. But you’re there in the middle. Tell me.
Marcelo Salazar:
Yeah. So, we are still partying and get some medicines for hung over. Now, we will start doing analysis. But I’ve heard the same about [minister name unclear]. I’ve heard he will be moved to another place in the government maybe but not outside of the government like we are happy because of signs of Biden during the debates Biden announced a fund for the Amazon. And this is good I think. United States back in the climate agreement, Paris climate agreement. It’s very nice and I think [politician name unclear] and Bolsonaro need to show something right now in let’s see, but I don’t have many analysis yet.
Jonah:
Amalia, do you want to share a little bit about wi with us more about the report that you’re talking about?
Amalia:
We don’t know a lot now. We h we just heard this morning. We saw the Excel there’s a big text and some people an analyzing the content and I know that there’s a group of NGOs that are writing a response right now criticizing. So the you know the text that I sent [name unclear] from ISA. There’s a lot of people of course the reaction was immediate there’s there’s a lot of problems with that kind of state so even in the constitution everybody is allowed to question the government to monitor and so anyway so there probably will be a response along this time.
But we have been hearing lately about certain actions like the information, you know, the official information system of the government sending undercover agents to the COP 25. And I guess it just came out recently. And so they were undercover. They pretended to be part of the delegation. They were monitoring who was there, what they were saying. So there’s a lot of lot of this stuff going on. But going back to the election in the US, everybody here thinks that at least because know the crazy narrative over there won’t happen anymore that over here the you know our guy will have to tame his narrative as well.
So anyway I guess this is hopeful in that in that sense. We’re not sure what else will happen. We have heard rumors already that maybe [minister name unclear] will be removed. They will have to adjust if they want to keep a relationship with the US. So, it’s a big deal. Although, I know it’s being played down right now. It’s a real big deal. So, I it’s early to say, but I’ll keep you posted, I guess, if anybody has anything.
Amrita Vatsal:
Hey, Jonah, I’m gonna sign off. I unfortunately have to leave, but it’s so nice to meet some of you, and I hope to be able to talk to you again soon.
Jonah:
Thanks so much for joining us. Marcel, you said something you were on.
Marcelo Salazar:
I just said it’s really nice to meet Amrita.
Jonah:
Great. I’ll make sure to share emails. I have one more thing about the election. So on Friday before the election, someone working with the National Agricultural Council, I guess [organization name unclear], something like that. Spoke to me. So it’s not a representative of the organization, but like a political consultant to them. And they were seeking my help to have an audience with some European investors because there’s been so much pressure from Europe to ensure that commodities are deforestation free and there isn’t much dialogue and she was interested in conflict resolution as her approach she was interested in some direct contact between European investors and Brazilian agro business people and one person told me later last week that the trans the shift in the election will probably bring a number of American investors into the European camp.
So that not just Europeans pressuring Brazil to be Brazilian agriculture and commodities to be deforestation free but maybe the there’ll be increasingly large numbers of American investors asking for the same. On December 7th, we’re gonna have a phone call about American Investments in the Amazon, and we’re going to have USAID and probably someone from the Development Finance Corporation on the line. And I’m going to try to get someone from the incoming and Biden administration as well.
Unidentified participant:
I just wanted to make a brief comment about u the letter that Amalia is talking about in the sense that given the large sort of large number of military personnel in the present government. This is sort of like a 30 40 year old paranoia of the Brazilian military in the sense that they for some strange reasons and as a as a result a very consistent we can say fake news and fake messages over the years. They believe that any NGO and any foreigner has no real interest in the Amazon as a biodiversity, climate, indigenous people area.
They are only after the gold and the uranium and the etc. And it must be the at least the 15th or 20th attempt to control NGOs. So in the sense I think it will I mean the constitution is strong enough to fight it back but it’s it’s it’s hopeless because you have these eternal battles over the same thing over the same issues over and over and over again and of course coming from with the influence of the secret service and so on in Brazil of course they see both Brazilian NGOs indigenous organizations and foreign and NGOs as a kind of enemy.
So, it’s sort of hopeless. And they want to control them 100% as I say. But I doubt that they will succeed.
Unidentified participant:
Oh, the difference I’m sorry, but the difference is the military is in government again.
Unidentified participant:
I know.
Unidentified participant:
This is the real difference right now. I you know, we’re going to push back. Of course, you know, there is a constitution, but I don’t think it’s it’s not the same it’s not the same situation as we have had along the years where the military really kind of stayed in their place because there was no space that they are in government right now. So, it’s not exactly the same. Let’s hope what now what which has increased violence tremendously although it was all always violence so we’re not saying this is the only reason but everything is you know it’s getting worse for sure right now so yeah I and it’s yeah so anyway I don’t think you should undermine that’s all I’m saying but we’re going to push back what whichever way we can.
[Sentence trails off.].
Jonah:
I have a question for all of you which is I became aware of an inter agency council that Trump created just in the past month about reforestation. I found a web page on it. You know the World Economic Forum and Mark Benioff from the CEO of Salesforce announced this trillion trees campaign and this was sort of the White House’s response to that. Had the Trump administration continue, this would be, you know, one group that I would seek relationship with to get involved in these calls just to learn what the Trump government is doing about reforestation as it relates to the Amazon.
Besides US aid and the US forest service and the development finance corporation, are there other moving parts in the American government that you guys think that we should appeal to learn from when it comes to the future of Amazon?
Unidentified participant:
I guess the State Department, the embassies in each of the Brazilian, each of the Amazonian countries.
Unidentified participant:
Jonah, now that the EPA has been gutted, I don’t think they have an international mandate, but have you guys done any work with the EPA or talk talking to them about coordinated environmental strategy?
Jonah:
No, good question. Yeah, I don’t know. I clearly they would pay attention to climate things within US domestic borders which has an international context but I don’t see the EPA juris jurisdiction for South America if there isn’t.
Unidentified participant:
No they definitely don’t have jurisdiction outside US but I wonder if they would if they must have some kind of international strategy.
Unidentified participant:
The US for forest service does a lot I don’t know too many details but I found several reports about it.
Jonah:
Okay, these are larger questions. These phone calls are always so exciting. Does anyone else have anything else to talk about before we go?
Unidentified participants:
That’s it. Thank you very much, Jonah. Thanks so much for joining us. Thank you. Thanks a lot, guys. All right, take care. Thanks everybody.