Green Bonds and Sustainable Agriculture in Brazil

Justine Leigh-Bell: Founded in 2010, the Climate Bonds Initiative works to mobilize the $100 trillion bond market for climate change solutions. Justine Leigh-Bell joins us to describe the extraordinary growth of the sector. The initiative has identified a $160 billion opportunity for Brazil to transition to sustainable agriculture. Join us to learn more.

Recorded November 2, 2020

References:

Report – Unlocking Brazil’s Green Investment Potential

WATCH:

  • Justine Leigh-Bell — Climate Bonds Initiative
  • Moderator
  • Charlotte — Acumen
  • Matt Lurie — Milken Institute
  • Holt Thrasher
  • Juliana — former head of the Amazon Fund

Moderator:

And welcome everybody to the umpteenth call of the Amazon Investor Coalition. This is a weekly call series dedicated to advancing forest-friendly economic development across the Amazon region. It is a gathering place of investors and philanthropists and governments and NGOs and allies. And this week we’re going to be featuring How do you say it? Virgilio? Help me out with this, Charlotte.

Charlotte:

Yes, that’s right. Virgilio.

Moderator:

From Acumen Latin America and Justine Leigh-Bell from the Climate Bonds Initiative. And in order to root us in the South American experience, be great to begin with Virgilio if he’s on. If he’s not, then I think we can go ahead and begin with Justine. Virgilio, are you there?

Charlotte:

He is not on yet, but I’m happy to I can kick us off with sort of the Acumen context and then he can jump into the Acumen Latin America context or we can reverse the order, either way.

Moderator:

Okay, I think it’ll be easier if we reverse the order. Sounds good. The these calls are recorded and then made available in a future context as a podcast series. So a change in voice changes the editing process. So Justine, you’re up. Yay! So I have been watching Justine’s presentation for our TEDx Amazon Investor Coalition and so I feel as though I already know her, although she and I are connecting for the first time here. It’s great to meet you. So Justine, tell us a little bit about your life before the Climate Bonds Initiative came on the scene.

Who are you? Where are you based?

Justine Leigh-Bell:

Well, I’m actually based in London. If you can hear from the accent, spent some time in the US. As we all wait anxiously for where we end up this week, but yeah, I prior to Climate Bonds Initiative and getting that company up and running, I was God, where do I start? I started off as a genetic engineer and was very much focused on ecology, evolutionary biology that turned into a short stint of looking at the genetic side of evolutionary biology before then turning my attention very much on climate finance, climate change I was something that was becoming the forefront of discussion and I felt like this was the area that I needed to urgently pay attention to as many of us on the call probably also have climate change at the back of their mind or not the forefront of their mind, but essentially I switched my concentration into economics and policy with a focus in climate finance that turned into me advising a number of development finance institution including World Bank, doing some consultancy for IFC and then advising the Indian government on natural capital accounting for 3 years and then following this I then began with CBI, basically and here we are.

Moderator:

Before telling us about the CBI, the Climate Bonds Initiative, tell us for a moment, what is a green bond?

Justine Leigh-Bell:

So, a green bond is like any other bond. It’s a debt instrument that is tied to assets and projects where the issuer of that debt could be a company, could be a government, anyone who can issue debt that’s owns the assets will issue a bond that will attract investors to invest in those assets over a period of time. And when it comes to green bonds, it is very much around projects and assets that will deliver on a positive environmental objective. That’s number one. And two is also there’s transparency and disclosure around how the money is being used to ensure that investors’ money is actually being invested in those projects.

So, very two very clear distinctions in comparison to a regular bond where there is not the need to disclose such information and could be financing anything. A green bond finances 100% eligible projects and assets that deliver on a positive environmental objective and comes with transparency and disclosure on how the moneys are being managed and used.

Moderator:

Nice. Tell us what is the Climate Bonds Initiative, Climate Bonds Initiative, and where did it come from? What’s the story of its creation?

Justine Leigh-Bell:

So, Climate Bonds Initiative is a global nonprofit based in London, but has operations all over the world. We are a team of about 70 plus now, started in 2009. The founder, Sean Kidney, at the time was advising pension funds in Australia, and it was very clear that if we were really going to address climate change and the exposure of climate risks, full stop and being able to really push the needle on climate change, we needed to know how to move our pensions money to address the urgency. So, CBI was really built on the premise that we need to be able to mobilize institutional capital, our sovereign wealth and pension funds, insurance industries, to investing in the next decades ahead with climate change solutions.

And the organization was really built to be an advocacy towards that and provide investors with the visibility on where those investments are. Across the investment pipelines in every major sector of the global economy, on where those key economic sectors, what are the investments to transition them over the next decades ahead, a rapid transition to a low carbon and climate resilient economy. And so, the investors are the key stakeholders, but it is very much about getting governments to act. So, CBI is there to provide the standards frameworks and the green definitional work to provide guidance to the market on what we mean by green, underpinned by the latest climate science, and ensuring that we are on a road to Paris alignment across all of our investments.

But, it is also the policy side where it is about being able to support the public sector institutions on understanding what role they need to play in helping to set down the foundations to foster market growth. And of course also for the issuers themselves and the investors all understanding what needs to be done. So we have market intelligence, we have a policy side to us, we have the standards component and of course we have our regional teams where Brazil of course is one of our most successful regional teams to date including China, ASEAN and India.

Moderator:

Nice. Let’s zoom in on Brazil and the Amazon for a second. Can you tell us about the Brazil green finance initiative that you guys have been developing?

Justine Leigh-Bell:

Yeah, so in 2016 CBI was quite new to the scene in Brazil. But it was very evident that Brazil had huge potential. Of course I’m sure Brazil hears that a lot of its potential and really being able to realize that but really there was no other place that had such an opportunity for leading the way on green finance like Brazil and recognizing that potential CBI started to invest a lot of its time to mobilize the market and of course always when entering a new market it is about understanding the state of play where are the strengths, where are the weaknesses and of course where you start.

Knowing that Brazil’s natural resource base is some of the last remaining in that we have in the world really. Amazon of course is the obvious case in point. So how do we leverage this green finance movement in a way to help protect not just the Amazon itself, of course, but also just building out a more sustainable future for the country. But of course, we are starting at ground zero at the time, and there wasn’t really a good sense or understanding of sustainable finance or green bonds for that matter, as one would expect in not just the that time limiting itself to Brazil.

This was still a very new market, continues to be a new market, but it was about mobilizing the appropriate actors, that be government, that be the domestic investor base, that be the key industries, including those in the agribusiness, but also in the energy sector, and infrastructure as well. And so, it was a chance to bring all of those different actors into one place, and so the Brazil green finance initiative was officially launched in September of 2016, where months prior had been a lot of engagement of myself and my team in identifying the appropriate people to bring into that initiative, and it crossed over investors, industry players, and what we call the intermediaries, which are the market infrastructure folks, the ones that are, you know, putting in place whether it be regulatory bodies, or whether it be stock exchange, these are the sort of in-betweens, and even the banks themselves.

Including BNDES, of course. And it was very successful, continues to be actually something that is now very much investor led. It has most of the major pension funds and asset managers in Brazil, where the dynamic of what we’ve created is a place that we give to investors to learn about what is the opportunities in Brazil. What is take what’s happening within different industries and how different industry players, companies within these sectors are embracing the sustainability agenda and have potential investments for them to invest. So we invite different companies that are coming from the agri businesses, the energy sector, infrastructure side of things, bring them to the table, and meet with the investors to discuss on both sides what investors are learning and looking for in terms of how they can start to address their ESG mandates and their sustainability agendas while also at the same time issuers are teaching them what they’ve got.

So it’s a knowledge dissemination exchange interaction that we have provided. And it over the years has been very successful. I think we have the BGFI has also partnered itself with the City of London under the economic and financial dialogue between Brazil and the UK. We have that same year of 2016 the BGFI along with a number of different companies and including BNDES came to London where we held a almost a quasi type investor roadshow for Brazil which was promoting the low carbon economy agenda for the country and being able to showcase that in London to London’s financial community including some of the largest investors in Europe who invest in Brazil.

And it was a quite a successful run for us. The BGFI meets quarterly in through the year. Again, where we invite other investors from around the world to speak at our BGFI meetings with our investors. And of course at the same time later in the meetings, we bring in different companies to engage. And all of this is very much more around, like I said, the intent is to create awareness and understanding of what the potential is. To use it as a chance to educate. But also at the same time, hopefully move towards a connection between investors and the companies in future deals.

Moderator:

Great. One more question for me and then we already have a couple from the network. Last thing, can you tell us about the new report you guys have put out unlocking Brazil’s green investment potential? You spoke about it in the TEDx video. I’ve pasted it here. What is it? Where How is it going to help Brazil transition to sustainable agriculture and what’s the size of the investment opportunity?

Justine Leigh-Bell:

So I think that one of the things that Brazil is actually quite advanced in its regulatory regime. And it’s, you know, probably one of the toughest regulatory regimes arguably in the region and in the world when it comes to its land use. The challenge it has is of course compliance. And you know, to also speak openly in current administration, the support for keeping much of that stringency in place. But there continues to be what I would still consider very tough regulations. But what has been missing to an extent is the financial incentive to the compliance of those regulations.

That’s one. Two is the sustainable agriculture production activities, although minimal in scale in comparison to what they need to be, remain to be to the to degree invisible. And there’s not been a demand enough of a demand to actually get the shift from producers fast enough to favoring and in prioritizing sustainable agriculture production to business as usual. So, what we’re trying to achieve here is while we’re educating the market, while we are ensuring that it’s understood what the rules of the games are, especially when issuing any sort of green bonds or green CRAs, credit receivables in the agribusiness, etc., that it’s very clear about, you know, what should be financed and what are sustainable agri activities, but it’s also identifying what is currently happening now across different subsectors of the agribusinesses that we can begin to create visibility for, get a sense of the size of the market and the potential of it going forward in the decades ahead.

And that’s essentially what the Brazil in investment roadmap for sustainable agriculture is about. It is there to be a sort of a tool for visibility of the potential. And the scale is in the magnitude of billions of the opportunity at hand. And that’s anywhere from, you know, biofuels being one of the largest pieces at hand, but sustainable soy production across agriculture and sustainable livestock production, etc. And it just goes through each of those areas of agribusiness and lays out that if certain conditions and parameters are met, then this is the areas that green investors, some of the biggest institutional investors on the global stage would be looking for and wanting to buy.

The idea is that if we can financially incentivize, as I said, compliance to regulatory legislation in Brazil, and potentially sourcing cheaper capital, we will see a shift much faster. And this is what we need to be encouraging. So, our role really is to work with the Ministry of Agriculture, the staff internally, but also the producer side, and of course finally the investors, so that we bring all of that together to hopefully create a market that can scale up.

Moderator:

Great. Hey Matt, you’re next on deck. Will you please introduce yourself and bring us your question?

Matt Lurie:

Hi. I’m Matt Lurie. I work for the Milken Institute Center for Strategic Philanthropy and really appreciate your remarks so far. I actually my question centers around green bonds, ESG. They’re something that I’ve noticed and then there was a recent Climate Policy Initiative report, which I dropped the link in to the chat box, that essentially is saying that a lot of what investors are looking for or what projects that are available for them to invest in have to do with more traditional climate, energy, transportation, infrastructure, which is all which is amazing.

That’s great. And I’m sort of looking around the corner wondering how can we build out some of the more landscape level conservation challenges. How do we move that field forward in a similar way, you know, related to green bonds, ESG, that sort of thing?

Justine Leigh-Bell:

Thanks, Matt. I think that’s a really good point, and it is important to highlight that much of what we have seen in the green bonds market globally is it tied very much to the energy sector. A lot to do with this is because even though the market is now hovering under a little bit of a trillion now, after operating since 2008, and let’s be frank, it really didn’t even get attention until 2014 when we rose to 40 billion from 3 billion in 2012 to roughly about 40 billion by the time we got to 2014 is when it started to get market attention.

And now it’s sitting a little bit at 950 billion. So, we expect to hit a trillion by the new year. And you know, bonds are and the reason why it’s tapping the institutional space is because investors at this level do not like risk. In fact, this is our pensions. They’ve got to make decisions that, you know, are not high-risk on our retirements. And so, bonds are a perfect tool for this because they tend to be very low-risk. And also, it’s important to receive a return. So, why investors are so attracted to green bonds is because actually, they’re not taking a sacrifice for going green here.

This is not a market that’s been built on sentiment. It’s been a market that is helping to address ESG risk across their portfolios, and is and is and is ticking that box particularly on the environmental side. And so, it’s it’s it’s it’s it’s a scenario where the you know renewable energy space is a tried and tested operational assets. It delivers on a return. So, you know, same risk reward profile to a regular bond and a green bond. They’re taking the green bond because essentially the green is like an extra bonus feature to their bond.

We have to think about it like that. So, in energy over the last decades we’ve been building out wind farms, solar farms, and all of these things are now becoming eligible for debt financing. Okay? Bonds are not a project financing tool. They are not there to build things from new at scratch that have not you know, been operational. So, that’s something that’s really important to mention. And when we get into other areas beyond energy and transport and even water for that matter, the land use space, and I don’t have to tell anyone on this call because you are the experts in this field, land use is very complicated.

Complex environment. And you know, what is the portfolio mix that is scalable and attractive enough to an investor so that they can have confidence that there will be a return. We’re getting there. The a lot of this is about, you know, identifying where those investments are, what those investments look like, and what as a producer they need to do to be able to meet the requirements that investors will be looking for. And I mean things around the reporting and disclosure element of what’s being invested in.

Moderator:

Great. Holt, you’re on deck. Please introduce yourself and your question.

Holt Thrasher:

Hi Jonah. Hi everyone. I’m Holt Thrasher with [company name unclear]. We’re a venture investor in land use data analytics technologies. And so I’m doing Justin, thank you for the comments. Very helpful. I you know, I raised this point cuz we started looking about four years ago and saw the BHP Billiton green bond in Africa that they’re Kenya that came out and kind of watched it for about 2 years as the interest payments kept coming up and people had the option of either taking credits or taking offset credits or taking cash.

But most of them took cash, which I thought was kind of disappointing having the whole effort to get the structure there. And I was just curious if that’s been have been repeat efforts to try and put a system like that together cuz it seemed like a very natural fit for deforestation pledges around either agricultural lending or something like that could be done in Brazil or other places.

Justine Leigh-Bell:

Thanks Holt. I have to say unfortunately we haven’t seen a lot of those what I would consider innovative products in this space. There was actually another one that came out of Kenya that was an IFC bond tied to REDD+ credits. Similar type of approach where in fact actually I think we’re talking about the same deal to be honest with you. I think that was Yeah, it was an offset scheme. There’s been a couple of few more, but they’re far and few between, right? What we have seen emerging interestingly enough is what’s being called a sustainability-linked bonds and loans.

And essentially what that is an issuer, I’ll just give an easy one, energy company, will issue a bond and essentially it’s saying, “Look, we’ll we’ll use the proceeds on whatever we need to use, but our commitment is these investments will contribute to us achieving a 25% emissions reduction by 2025 or something like they set like a threshold milestone to achieve. And if they don’t achieve it, then the interest rate will go up. So it’s almost like they’re setting they’re they’re committing to a potential penalization. And this is very new. This has just emerged this year and of course, there’s a few criticisms about the credibility, and that’s just natural when it comes to these new products.

We have to keep an eye on them and keep pushing for rigor. But that’s one area, but I think it’s important to note that what hasn’t really come out of this market is, you know, it’s not predicated on the carbon credits. It’s really under the financial performance of the assets. And so it’s it’s rare that it’s being used as sort of a credit carbon credit component. But having said that, there are a few examples.

Holt Thrasher:

Okay. Thank you.

Moderator:

Great. And last question, Juliana. Please introduce yourself and your question.

Juliana:

Hi everyone. Hi Justine, it’s a pleasure to see you. Juliana from Yes, now in sabbatical at my grad to my graduate studies, former Amazon fund head of department. So my question is relates a little bit to what you mentioned quickly and it’s specifically related to my country, Brazil. So as we know, the forest legislation in Brazil is pretty dense and actually very broad and strong. So this is a good part. And beyond this umbrella, we have the forest code and the rural registry system and all that would come from the legislation.

The other good point is the our NDC, that is a lot land use based, meaning that we had we had we have strong commitments in reducing deforestation, but also restoring degraded land. So I Of course, the political moment is very sensitive, as we all know, but I don’t know going back a little bit of what Matt mentioned about what we’ve been seeing in the green bonds market, that is a very energy oriented as far as the last issues. What have you be What have you seen and what have you construct been building with the Brazilian government?

I watched webinar that you participated with the minister of agriculture, with the central bank president, and I knew you were trying to build something in that direction or build this consciousness. It also including the pressure from investors all over the world of seeking a clean production chain in the in the agriculture and agribusiness sector. So, I don’t know I would like to explore a little bit of your pick your brain in this what you’ve been seeing in this direction that is really maybe what can bring us to a new path for deforestation reduction, in my opinion.

Justine Leigh-Bell:

Thanks. Good to see you again. Well, look, let me first start by saying that what is encouraging after working with three Brazilian governments now, that despite the challenging leadership that Brazil is currently under, there are a few inside the government that are really championing the green finance agenda. And there are probably different drivers for that, right? Nonetheless, people that are in powerful positions to make decisions, are very much attracted to what this green finance agenda could be for Brazil. The most recent engagements have been with the Ministry of Agriculture, Infrastructure, and the Central Bank.

With the Central Bank, you know, if we look at essentially the financing for the industry: 70–75% is through bank lending and dominated by Banco do Brasil. And the government and you know, the national banks, they know that this is not something that can last forever. And there will be a need to tap private capital to help support the industries in agri-businesses in long run. And so understanding that there is a potential for bringing in new sources of capital, there has become this desire to figure out how. So our role has been to provide the internal capacity on understanding what sustainable finance is, how to apply the different taxonomies that are developing, what this would mean for Brazil, what kind of resources are there, what kind of credit lines should the banking sectors be preferencing, how can they strengthen existing credit lines like the ABC program and so on.

Really being able to figure out again how they get themselves attracting international capital for providing sustainable investments. And within the agri ministry, it seems at this stage the team is doing a lot of market research for them. So we’re currently after we did the investment road map, the next immediate activity was to do an investor survey both looking internationally and domestically on what investors expect out of an opportunity of sustainable agriculture investments in Brazil. So that they can understand as a ministry what they should what kind of policies they need to be putting in place to help foster that.

There’s also been our push for considering green CRA credit receivables in the agribusiness, which serves as a sort of like a securitization. You know, thinking about beyond the big players like the Bunges and the Cargills of the world and the Syngentas, you know, if we look at media even large to medium-size producers with very poor credit or not as enough investments for scale to attract investors single-handedly, you know, the CRA model allows for potentially bundling a number producers together as a de-risking opportunity that can attract green capital if it’s all putting in place the right investments.

So these are some of the things that we’re exploring in the ministry. Those are the things that we’re exploring. So there’s a lot going on, Juliana, and I’d love you know, be happy to take it offline to expand a little bit more cuz it doesn’t even do it justice to the level of activities. I appreciate, Jonah, that Timing is of essence here, so I appreciate you letting me kind of elaborate a bit on that.

Moderator:

Great. Thank you. Thank you so much for your time. Daniel Brindis also has a question which he has put into the chat. Justin, thank you so much for sharing.