Investing in Deforestation-Free Commodities
Brett Mallen: The government of Norway invested $100 million dollars in the “&Green Fund” to de-risk the investments of others and mobilize up to $2 billion in additional sustainability financing. Managed by Sail Ventures, the Fund aims to protect 5 million hectares of land while improving the lives of 1 million smallholder farmers, including many in the Amazon. Brett Mallen joins us to tell the story.
Recorded October 19, 2020
WATCH:
Participants
- Jonah Wittkamper
- Brett
- Isabella
- Matt
- Amalia
- Unidentified participant
Transcript
Jonah Wittkamper:
Okay. Brett also coming in from the Netherlands. Today is Netherlands night. Brett, tell us about yourself and Cell Ventures and the and Green Fund.
Brett:
Thanks very much, Jonah, and thanks. Yeah, thanks for the invite to join you guys. It’s so far a great discussion. Fernando, we’ll definitely be in touch. I didn’t want to overstate the Dutchness with the jersey. I just suddenly realized that it’s way too orange for the jurisdiction from which your two speakers come this evening. My apologies. To give you to give you some context, my background is private equity. I’m from South Africa. I then moved into looking after a number of portfolios that invested in the whole of Africa, not just private equity.
And then was pivoting my career towards having higher impact with the investments that we were making. And we’re approached by the guy the guys at SAIL Ventures and asked to join them. So, I’m a year old in this business, a year and 10 days old in this business. And it’s been a fantastic ride so far. Our sort of our flagship fund is the &Green Fund. And that’s really what I want to talk to you guys about today, particularly, you know, with respect to how it’s investing in Latin America and, you know, even more particularly in the Amazon area.
Jonah, if I may, can I share my presentation to sort of give some structure? I won’t speak strictly to it.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Microsoft, go for it.
Brett:
It will just help the conversation a little. Can you guys see that? Yeah. Okay, let’s do that.
Brett:
Okay, so very sort of gives you an idea of what I want to chat about. Let’s move quickly through it. Who we are. So, SAIL Ventures was set up in 2017. IDH, the sustainable initiative, our founder, Johnny Braum and Nicki really the Norwegian international climate and forestry fund. They all got together and they were looking at a way of catalyzing further investment as well as being able to you know pivot or transition the way in which capital was approaching agriculture in the in the tropical rainforest areas. As well as changing the behavior of the of the participants in that ecosystem.
So we really you know sort of see ourselves as quite complimentary in fact to what you’re looking to achieve with respect to the Amazon investor coalition and certainly complimentary to the work that Fernando is doing with reach etc. So we see ourselves very much as part of the part of the cog part of the ecosystem. We’ve got a fantastic group of human beings that work here really spreading the entire spectrum of skills. So it’s from a bunch of investment people that have really integrated quite nicely with a bunch of very high you know environmental and social impact as well as environmental and social compliance governance you know and very strong sort of operations you know we’re a fund and we’re looking after other people’s money.
Key I guess to what we’re up to is also where we are. So the head office is in the Netherlands but we have a very strong investment directorship spread across the globe. We have a investment director in based in Singapore looking after Southeast Asia and then we have two investment directors in Sa Paulo looking after Latin America. Okay so let’s let’s go to the why. We’ve really set ourselves three targets three big targets I guess for the an F fund and these were these were set very collaboratively which I loved when I joined was it wasn’t sort of imposed by the money and it wasn’t dreamt up by the fund manager.
That was really sort of co-created with everyone involved including the NOS’s that sort of you know we partner very strongly with. So the first one is to get to two billion catalyzed. So we’re looking to raise maybe to the question you asked Fernando earlier. We’re looking to raise $400 million as a first step in our progress. And with that to catalyze two billion dollars alongside along or with us and alongside us into the areas that we’re investing and into the sectors and the jurisdictions. We’re also looking to protect conserve and restore 5 million hectares.
So you know the restoration I guess is really the reing you know that’s exactly where we’re looking at degraded land. We’re looking at land that’s been cultivated and you know how we can possibly intensify the use of that land and conserve forest. And then we’re also looking to benefit through what we call our sort of social inclusion agenda, benefit 500,000 households to varying degrees. So, it’s not just small holders. Maybe I should just state up front, we don’t invest directly into small holders, but we very much see them as part of the ecosystem that we support.
And I’ll talk you through a couple of initiatives whereby, you know, we insist upon, you know, their outcomes and their yields and their opportunities improving. At a very high level, we’re absolutely convinced, in fact, we’re starting to prove it with the with the case studies that or the investments we’ve already made that we believe that you can dlink deforestation from agricultural commodity production in the rainforests. And what we’ve been saying more recently is we’re looking at this as a transition. So it’s transition capital from extractive exploitive behaviors through sustainable behaviors and into regenerative behavior.
And there’s some exciting there’s lots of operators in this space and some fantastic tech that’s come out as well that you know really leads us to believe that we can use a couple of sort of stars and create some blueprints for structures and technology that is that is rep replicable across different sectors. This really gives you a sort of high level as to the you know the genesis which was the five paths that were that were identified. And by the way, all of this is available on the and green.fund website.
So I won’t spend too much time on this. Please go in there and if you have any questions, I’ll give you guys my email at the end. Happy to have a conversation and to get your thoughts on all of these. But the idea here is to create a stronger ecosystem for the money, for the operators on the ground, for the regulators. And there we see it actually quite sort of synonymous with you know what I was reading up with respect to the coalition and its intentions. You know we also believe that the regulator and the public policy need some support.
Those regulators who are bold enough to you know to take the steps to change the regulation and then also to implement and to you know we believe boldly maybe it’s the wrong word but monitor and make sure that there’s enforcement around their regulations. They need as much support as possible and we’d like to support them in their green policies because we do believe that it’s you know it is better for the entire landscape in which we operate. Yes so you can get an idea as to where we’re invested. We maybe if I can just pause here we’ll we’ll come to it in a second but if I can pause here around how we look at different jurisdictions.
So we have a jurisdiction eligibility a set of jurisdiction eligibility criteria. Our JEC’s and we won’t invest in a jurisdiction unless it passes our jurisdiction eligibility criteria assessment. And those are the different regions that have made it through that first that first test. The reason we do that is because of that last path I just mentioned. Now we really want guys to or juris jurisdictions or regulators to get to get their policies right so we can support them by coming in with capital as well as all of the IP that we’ve been developing.
So Brazil, Madagros and Para are the two approved states and then Colombia, Ecuador and Peru. As well as in terms of different sectors, the beef and livestock soy and forestry are sort of our focus areas. In that region, palm is a big focus for us in Southeast Asia. The SGS, I mean we hit a lot of SGS, which is which is fantastic and particularly exciting for us. Let’s get to the who does it. I’ve mentioned who we are. We work in very strong partnerships with different participants in the ecosystem. You know, lots of different stakeholders.
Nick Fee I mentioned are invested. So they really were the anchor. Then Unilver jumped on board as well as Jeff. The great news around Jeff is Jeff gave us a smaller sort of first investment and we’re actually already in a conversation with them for the following investments. So, you know, obviously when we first set out, it was it was very new. It was bold. And no one really knew how well we would do. We now have three assets that sort of prove that we’re actually able to deliver on the mandate.
Those assets have already, you know, two of them are extremely new. The older one, we’re starting to see some traction and starting to see the adjustments in the practices of the borrower towards more sustainable towards more sustainable outcomes. Yeah, so it’s good relationship with Jeff. Jeff actually came to us through UNIEP the first time around. And we’re able to access Jeff again through the WWF. So we work with all of these different partners in various different degrees of formality or informality. But yeah, certainly strong relationships with all of them. This is the these are the criteria.
Again, they’re available on the website. And happy to talk through those with you if you have any questions on them. But this is more for the regulators and the governments in areas. This is our investment process. There’s no real need to hover on this for too long. It’s extremely thorough and at all different points we work very closely with whoever we can by way of other interested stakeholders. This is the part that I think is really interesting. And you know please I come from a private equity background so I may find other things interesting as I’m learning and growing into this space certainly over the last year.
But these are these are these are our real focuses. So we absolutely have a landscape approach to our funding. We target three different sets of environmental return and two sets of social inclusion objectives. The forest conserved is exactly as we discussed earlier. So that’s on concession and off concession. We’re looking where wherever there still is natural forest to protect it as strictly as we can and to encourage everyone who participates in the landscape to do so as well. So that’s you know the communities that we work with or that our borrowers work with.
There’s also the regeneration intensification. So that’s where we’re looking at integration of different types of crops and particularly crop and livestock is a type of integration certainly that Fernando alluded to earlier something that we’re looking at. In fact our first Brazilian investments really goes and speaks to that thesis and then restored forest. So where there is degraded land where there is cultivated land that isn’t being used or not is isn’t productive, you know, being able to look at getting it restored to natural forest as quickly as possible. Then we have the different households that are benefiting.
So that’s those are the communities around the farms I guess or the operations. It’s not necessarily always farmers by the way. Will invest right up and down the supply chain provided that there’s an influence back upstream towards you know where the where the operations meet the forest. So there’s different households benefiting. You know, we’ve already seen a couple of initiatives where there’s improved opportunities for them to make better income, more sustainable income. Lots of training that happens in the communities and then, you know, particularly around COVID was an interesting example for us.
You know, our borrowers were very active in getting out into their communities and doing as much education as possible or as far as far abroad race as they could. And then small holders benefiting is obviously with respect to supply chains. And you I’ll give you an example of that in a second. So this kind of all of our IP almost pats itself into this. The money that we provide comes with a bunch of terms and conditions that we very actively manage together with our partners. You know, we call them our clients, our borrowers, our partners really.
And we work with them to make sure that we can roll out the action plans that we all agree on together. We are completely transparent in that regard. Everything goes up on the website. And the clients know that and that’s very much sort of, you know, one of the tools, one of the one of the tools of an green is that there’s a public commitment to an NDP. There’s a public commitment to an environmental and social action plan and there’s a public commitment to one of these landscape protection plans. Which is great and you know to varying degrees it’s quite a good filter.
I think the prospective borrowers that are not so keen on that, you know, don’t really continue in conversation with us. But those that do really get committed to this and we see, you know, we see them taking steps and getting off to a flying start once them once the contracts are signed and we get going in partnership with them. So then where are we active? I’ve given you the different jurisdictions. I’ve given you the different sectors. What I thought we could do is really take a look at a few case studies.
I’m not going to spend too much time on our first two transactions. They’re in Indonesia, but just maybe if we can pause here for sort of a second on each and just give you the broader thesis because they are absolutely replicable in the jurisdictions in Latin America or in the Amazon. The first one is rural tama. There we you know it was a large enough check. It was about $24 million. We catalyzed in up to another $90 million. And in fact, they’re even looking at a second raise now of another $200 million.
So, we, you know, using the fact that we’re that we’re involved and using the pract involved, using the practices that we’ve introduced to look at raising, you know, green bonds. This one’s quite an interesting one in that we’ve created a very strong buffer. There’s a natur the nature reserve that you can see there. There’s a wildlife wild wildlife conservation area. There’s two WWF regions that of all sort of scattered around the concession with quite a bit of pressure coming through from the communities down to the south southwest and it creates a very natural buffer.
You know, we’re our borrowers put a bunch of ranges that patrol up and down really making sure that the forest that’s that is in existence in all those reserves is protected. And obviously there’s a, you know, there’s some serious biodiversity up there and there’s some really strong ecosystems and lots of sort of protected and rare species. So that’s RLU. Maybe just to mention the actual you know where the lender the company is owned as a JV by Michelon and Burito which is a local big operator in Indonesia. DSMG is listed.
Maybe this goes to Jonah you asked me to mention you know scale and how scalable this is you know this is a listed company it’s a big listed company but what’s important here is the scale of the promise that they’ve been making very publicly and their commitments so they are looking to push upstream a zero deforestation policy that’s obviously easier on the estates that they own of course then it sort of becomes slightly more difficult where they have you know sort of contracted suppliers and then it gets even more difficult as we look at the co-ops and various agents.
Yet through training through a number of different initiatives that have they’ve already started rolling out even during our negotiations they started putting some of the initiatives that we had recommended in place. So they’re they’re off to a flying start and we’ve already started seeing some behavioral changes. Maybe just also to mention you know we’re extremely long-term investors. You know, we’re happy to put in 15 year debt and make an average of 10 years. So, we’re looking to measure ourselves at the end of those peri well, you know, towards the end of those periods, not within a month or within a year.
We know this takes a hell of a long time to redirect and change the behavior. So, we’re looking to have a holistic change but over a longer period and we will work, you know, we have a very strong team on the ground. We have a very strong team here at the head office that works with borrowers to make sure that we can roll that out. And then our third transaction which is which is in Brazil. So this is the ronador transaction which we love. You know these guys were extremely entrepreneurial, very innovative, took a very similar Fernando to the type of work that you were doing that you are doing.
They had a pilot in a small section of the farm that they started integrating soy and cattle. And then approached us about a year back, a little bit more to look at being able to get some financing so they could actually roll that out over all of all of their operations. So it’s, you know, it’s a big chunk of land. 60,000 hectares is what is what we’re looking to intensify, I guess, so that we’ll be able to sorry resto intensify. So we’ll be able to take pressure off about another 72,000 hectares of forest that they actually have under the forest code permission to cut down.
You know, it’s a part of the portion they can cut down, but that they will that they won’t as a result of the fact that we’ll rather intensify the land that’s already being cultivated and you know, looking at different there’s a lot of technology. Needed some clever people out there, clever people on our team, clever consultants that we’re working with and the farmers themselves with respect to integrating soy and cattle. I mean, you would all know this better than I would. You know, a soy farmer is very different to a cowboy and obviously there’s a lot of change management that they’ve done over the last couple of years to really integrate not just on the ground biology of it, but actually the practices and the people running it.
So that’s been a good experience for us so far. It’s a it’s a very new transaction. But we’ve been working with them. You know, it’s new because we signed in July, but we’ve been working with them for over a year now. Maybe just to talk to Pipeline. Unfortunately, I can’t really speak there a couple of listed companies that we’re talking to, so obviously I can’t really speak about those. But just ready to say that, you know, we’ve looked at over 80 projects. 50 of those are in Latin America. So that’s across Ecuador, Peru, Colombia, and the large chunk of them are in Brazil.
And those are all Amazon. Some of them might be Sorado. But really mostly Amazon focused. That’s where we have get the biggest of bang for our buck. Yeah, I mean there’s nothing really to add there. Maybe it’s quite interesting to sort of see where you know what the different participants look like with respect to who we’re looking to finance. And you can see, I mean, it’s predominantly Brazil, predominantly producers. So, it’s obviously better for us to get sort of further up the stream and not go to processes, but actually get, you know, on the ground to the farmer and the producer.
And then what I wanted to also discuss is you sorry just also in this is we’re able we already have another $185 million worth of pipeline that’s sort of ripe. It’s come through our processes. It’s made it through all those different steps that are in the previous slide. And J I’m also happy to share these slides with you that’ll be useful. But we really sort of really moved through the process quite nicely already. That’s about 185 million. So we’re looking to bet be so well beyond $200 million worth placed you know within the next year from now.
Which gives you an idea of the scale. We have eight minutes till the top hour.
Jonah Wittkamper:
So I just encourage you to finish and so we have time for questions.
Brett:
Yeah sure I can zip through this. For this and again happy to share the slides just looking at where it hasn’t worked you know which borrowers we weren’t able to really move forward with this gives you a couple of ideas one the obvious one you know not in the jurisdictions and those are the jurisdictions there some of them the sector not necessarily global sector but just the sector in the region we were looking at which too small wrong type of borrowers that goes to the DNA of the borrower as well as just to where they are in their own business cycle just didn’t work.
Borrowed to small similar comments. Sometimes just a low commitment. There’s some high standards that we’re asking and we publish them, you know, so we’re very transparent and where that meets with low ambitions doesn’t quite work. And then importantly where there’s just no additionality. You know, well behaved borrowers who are fully compliant, who’ve got excellent practices doesn’t really give us room to show additionality with the capital that we provide. The one we don’t like using as an excuse is where the landscape is extremely complex. But sometimes it just you know if we can’t wrap our minds around the complexity of the landscape together with our borrower it just you know the risks the risks become too big for us.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. Is that out? Are you ready for questions?
Brett:
Yeah sure. Let me let me Great. Isabella feel free to go ahead and ask your question. You might have to come off of mute.
Isabella:
Hi. Thank you for the presentation. I just wanted to ask if you do any work with multilateral banks.
Brett:
Yes, absolutely. You know, we’ve looked at I can’t remember the exact detail. Yes, we do. I can’t remember the exact details now of where we have but certainly in Latin America our two our two investment directors in Latin America are both actually ex x ex x ex x ex x ex x ex x ex x ex x ex x ex x ex robble bank with very strong relationships into the multilateral banks and happy to put you in touch with them if you’d like as well.
Isabella:
Great. Yes, please. Thank you. Sure. I’ve got a question as other people prepare theirs. What kind So private investors what is the dollar ticket item? So do you entertain partners who are coming in at the $5 million level? Can you go as low as the $10 million level? What’s your relationship with the retail investor markets?
Brett:
Yes, absolutely. I mean we would take $5 million from retail. We’re you know we very much see it as part of our responsibility to catalyze, right? We want investors to find a home for their money that can drive the objectives that we’re looking to drive here. On the commercial end we are we are talking you know we have we have taken two from an investor before. The you know we don’t really have a structure now that can handle 100 investors. But the type of structure we’re looking at which is a blended finance structure looks at helping on the risk adjusted returns.
So in other words, we can bring in a retail investor and we can really, you know, prop up their risk adjusted returns because there’s a massive sort of, you know, wall of grant and redeemable grant money that helps to adjust the risks. So yeah, we can take in I would say five is about the right level for us for a retail investor, but we obviously looking for higher for bigger checks than that.
Jonah Wittkamper:
You mentioned the 195 million number. What fraction of that is for the Amazon?
Brett:
Give me a second. At least half, I would say. At least half. Yeah, in fact, 100 about $100 million of that.
Jonah Wittkamper:
And what kind of return and what kind of time horizon is expected for that?
Brett:
That’s a great question. I mean, you mean from the underlying assets? Yeah. Yeah. So we because of the blended finance nature of our capital base it obviously reduces our cost of capital which is a great benefit for us because it means that we can lend at you know slight slightly better rates and over longer periods and there’s some flexibility that we can introduce I mean we would we would like to make a 6% return across the board. Certain borrowers are borrowing from us at higher rates over longer periods and for riskier projects.
Others are borrowing from us at less than that but at about 6%. On average.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Great. I have a few sillative questions to keep coming. So everyone else please interrupt me before I use up all the oxygen in the room. One question is have you guys been involved in designing green bonds that can attend to these interests?
Brett:
Yeah, none that we’ve launched yet. However, in two of the transactions that we are busy working on. Not that they will be the first part of the transaction, just to be clear, that it will be a normal bilateral loan will be the first part, but we’ve already started working on a green bond with those borrowers. So it’s let’s get the end green money invested and once the money’s invested and we can start showing to and then we’ll look at raising a green bond with them but we’ve already started working on structuring and we’ve commenced those conversations in two on two occasions.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Does anyone else have any other questions? Go for it.
Matt:
Thanks. This is Matt from Milk Institute. That was really good. My question is on the I liked the I really like the phrase the zero deforestation policy and then you said a lot of you know in certain cases it was easy to meet in others it was it was it’s harder to meet for different reasons. Would you and do you consider working with people who where it’s harder to meet that z that exact zero percentage but maybe there can be mitigation elsewhere you know to restore a force somewhere else. Is mitigation a part of the equation in a big way?
Brett:
Matt, yeah, it’s a great question. I mean, so would we tolerate deforestation on one of our concessions after our money’s gone in? Highly unlikely. However, what we acknowledge is that it’s a long-term game, right? They may they may we had a you know we’re sort of marking every single tree from the sky with satellites and we had a couple of trees disappear and we obviously then had a you know an immediate investigation as to well what happened there and these were natural trees. And it was just some guy just got given his instructions for the morning drove his tractor and knocked four these you know really beautiful trees over.
So we accept that there could be slippage. We’re saddened by it and we certainly, you know, it’s not something that we would that we would tolerate or that we would say, look, you know, knock those five trees down over there, replant over there. We’re looking to do both and we believe we can. I think the point is though, we’re not looking for perfection from day one. You know, we recognize that it’s far more important to get going. One of our concerns is that there’s so much good money out there that’s not getting involved because it really from day one wants to, you know, have perfect practices.
We know it’s not. We know we know it’s a it’s a tricky landscape out there and we just want to get going and start driving towards the right be ahead. So we see it as a transition.
Jonah Wittkamper:
Amalia, feel free to go ahead and ask your question. I think you’re on mute.
Amalia:
Yes, actually I was I’m sorry I was using was in double screen and I intended just to listen but I was very curious about your honor project because we’ve I’ve was the Shavante village and in that region was the first one I’ve ever visited in my life in 88 and they’re very close and I know they have a lot of problems with the poisons in the rivers and so I was just wondering if it’s anywhere close to the fudas marches if you know that and if there is possibility of relationship because we’d be glad to help with that.
I think that would be such a really interesting possibility.
Brett:
Happy to I don’t know the exact details. Sorry I don’t have the map in front of me. I don’t know. I don’t know how close it is, but very happy to have a discussion with you. If it is close and if there is a way to work together, we’re excited.
Amalia:
They’re ready. They’re exactly at the wrong door mountain range. All right. Great. Thank you. So we’ve reached the top of the hour. I’m going to leave the room open so people can get things from chat. And now is sort of unstructured time for anybody who wants to stick around. Thank you so much Fernando and Brett for your presentations. Just amazing.
Unidentified participant:
My pleasure. Thank you very much for the opportunity. Thank you. Thank you for the opportunity. And if anybody who wants to.
Brett:
Reach out, just send me an email. Happy to connect.
Jonah Wittkamper:
And Brett, if you could put your email address in the chat room. That’d be great.
Brett:
Yeah, I’ll do that right now. Thank you very much, everybody. Thanks for your time. Thank you. Thank you. Cheers.