Uniting the Right and Left for Land Tenure Reform

Alexandre Mansur: An estimated 90% of Amazon deforestation is illegal. People occupy land, raise cattle and lobby for land titles. A new campaign called “Be Legal with the Amazon” reduces the incentive by pushing for the regularization of “undesignated” lands. The campaign united both environmentalists and the agricultural industry to support the cause. That’s a big deal. Alexandre Mansur joins us to tell the story.

Recorded August 31, 2020

WATCH:

  • Alexandre Mansur
  • Unidentified speakers

Unidentified speaker:

Alexandrine Masur works with the be cool or be legal with the Amazon. In Portuguese, the word legal and cool are the same. Um it’s particularly interesting to me for a couple of reasons. One, because it gets at the real heart of the land rights struggle, which is about um uh titling and legal documentation of lands. Uh and it’s something that has been embraced by uh the sort of the conservationists and the business pro-business community. Um Alexandrine, the floor is yours. Thank you, Shauna. Oh, I’m just going to interrupt you 1 second. I’m going to post also the link. People have been asking me about what is the strategy for presentation at the UN 75 Global Governance Forum.

Uh I’m going to post a link here about our four-part strategy. Anyone has uh questions about it, please feel free to email me directly. Uh Alexandrine, please the floor is yours. Sorry. I’ll be brief cuz maybe we we can have a chat about it later. Uh well, I’m the director of an agency called Muito Queremos. Uh Muito Queremos is focusing on uh creating innovative solutions to make change happen on the way you want on the environmental field. We use different tools like we created uh the first uh fair for the first business fair for uh climate change companies. And we created the first union of former ministers of finance uh known as Comunitas do Brasil to raise the awareness of the low-carbon economy on high level uh political uh economy uh and uh um high-level economic policy in Brazil.

Well, this we launched this campaign Citzens for Legal Amazonia a year ago. And it explores an opportunity to change to to reduce deforestation certain kind of deforestation. Uh, you can see deforestation in the Amazon having different drivers depending on where it happens. 40% of deforestation in the Amazon happens on public land. The main drive is illegal appropriation of public land known as land grabbing. Uh, this is a low-hanging fruit for those who want to reduce deforestation in the Amazon because the deforestation caused by land grabbing is something understood by the whole society as not wanted. So, you can have a agreement among business sector, among policy makers that is something that we don’t want to continue.

So, we organized this campaign uh, with the support of the agribusiness associations and industry associations and environmental organizations to raise the concern and and raise the the the pressure over the the the policy makers and the authorities to fight land grabbing in Brazil. Uh, we propose uh objective measures to go ahead with the fight on land grabbing like uh empowering the public prosecution agency here in Brazil or give more power to the federal police who can investigate uh the the gangs that operate uh appropriating public land and and and cutting the forest there. Uh And our we have two main objectives. One of them is to uh to communicate to the population that the the vast majority of Amazon land is publicly owned and the the forestations is byproduct of a process of land grabbing which means that all citizens are being uh uh they are losing something that belongs to them.

And having this uh this constantly in their minds, they could pressure the authorities to fight this. Uh on the other side we are we are we are raising the the this debate with the uh the justice and the the the authorities responsible for enforcing the law uh offering to them that it’s a good way out, it’s a good response to the pressure of from the population to enforce the the the fight against land grabbing. Uh We have done uh several actions like uh public campaigns and we we have produced some videos supporting the the actions against the the criminals. We are producing a good material explaining how it happens and who who loses with that, how this is related to common crime, to violence in the region, which is the most violent in Brazil.

Uh and we are planning a second phase of the campaign which includes the creation of an index of deforestation on public land and uh events organized with some special sectors like the justice sector and the productive sector. Uh I don’t know if you feel any would like to add something. Glad you want to say something? To add something? Uh only one thing that I would like to to add is that uh this next uh phase we want to to turn the the website into a a kind of a hub of information, you know, so everybody can find information of about land grabbing and this for deforestation.

You can go to this website and find everything you need, you know, to um to understand it and to to know more about it. So, that’s also about the next phase. Uh great. Um Thanks. I would Are you guys done? Yes. Okay, great. Uh does anybody have uh questions? I have one question. Um it is particularly challenging to mobilize government money or private sector money to take on campaigns that address legality illegality. So, it seems to be the space for philanthropy. Uh I’m I’m curious uh what philanthropic support do you guys have so far? How do you guys How’s your campaign funded to date? It’s a good question.

Uh the campaign started funded by Instituto Clima e Sociedade and we had a good response from the private sector, from the organizations, uh from the associations of agribusiness because they are being targeted as responsible for illegal deforestation and they use this campaign as a way to say, “No, it’s not us. The the ones responsible for the destruction are the criminals, not the the the companies.” Uh but they don’t want to put their own money on the campaign uh in spite of using it and in spite of using the campaign to to to to to clean to clean their faces. They did they at least so far ha- has not uh uh venture their own money to support the company.

Uh now we have a small uh support from No Peace Without Justice and that’s all that we have. We have a uh uh a participation uh from the leaders from those organizations, these agribusiness and company organizations. They have they have voiceful. They they They are speakers of from the campaign. They So, they dedicate time uh arguing uh for the the campaign and for the measures that you want to to be taken. Uh but uh specifically the monitors for the campaign we don’t have from them. Uh does anybody else have another question for the B Legal with the Amazon team? I would be interested what Greenpeace is thinking to get into the group because this is very very taxing issue.

Yeah, I mean I have a lot of questions uh and and sort of uh I mean I I have I personally um have a lot of concerns about this actually just being a I a bit of a greenwashing exercise. I mean some of the members of the JBS they are um you know, there’s they’re well-documented having ties to um or having supply chains contaminated with illegalities. Um there was that recent um report from Hiporter Brasil that was uh um you know, connected to the um um the uh uh the the actual transportation of um the uh uh of of uh indirect suppliers of um uh JBS uh to with ties to illegal deforestation.

So, I mean I think um you know, that I I I understand what the theory of change here is um as you know, it’s really it’s very critical to um you know, have to have some sort of carrot or to actually you know, like we do want to split up the uh It makes sense that the part of the private sector that doesn’t want to be associated with the current agenda is is separate. I think that the um I I you know I I’m I’m curious. My question is is like is this a um How much How much of these people who are involved with this are they outspoken about the um the land grabbing bill the the and the all the other um uh political attacks?

You know, you have the Are Are these same um associations in the same effort being as vocal um about what’s happening with FUNAI right now? Like that’s that’s my That’s my main question. So, I think like it does it does make sense as a theory of change. I just, you know, I’m curiously is are the Is the private sector um forces that are part of the Are they as um vocal on these other changes that do impact legality and whether or not um illegalities are are continuing growing? It’s a good question. Uh first, let me clarify. Um we work in partnership with Greenpeace in several actions.

Uh I myself I’m chairman of the board of Greenpeace in Brazil. And uh the campaign we we are aware that this campaign uh goes until uh a given point. And and only until a certain point. The objective is to raise awareness of land grabbing and to explain the process of land grabbing and how this process is responsible for 40% of deforestation. So, largest share of deforestation. And how we have uh tools uh to fight this and to end this kind of green crime. And having done that, having shown that, we expect to to raise the pressure to to fight this. And in this process, we have the support of those uh associations of agribusiness and companies.

If we go to a a phase where we have to point to the criminals themselves and denounce the names of who are associated with that, then we we don’t we don’t have their support. So, we use the campaign to to go into a certain point, and from this point beyond, we have to use other tools, other campaigns, other reforms. Like we have created we ourselves have have created another campaign last year to from the beginning of this year to fight another project to to but this is another story. So, we know that we are a piece on the the the the puzzle. They are part of the process.

Each one here will play a useful role in the process. Great, thank you. Does Does anybody else have another question? Yeah, if you’re asking, you might be on mute. Feel free to post it. Uh for those of you who are new to these calls, I sent out emails to a number of Nexus members last week and educating them about these calls, inviting them to join. There was a good response. I expect these calls will be um more popular moving forward, um populated by a number of people in the Nexus community who are relatively new to these issues. Um I have just now posted a link to an article that I wrote in April that I’ve been updating since that uh mentions a lot of these groups in English and provides background research.

Provides links. Does anybody else have any other questions for me or the B Legal with the Amazon team or the larger UN 75 strategy? I’ll just go for it. Can I can I can I add something to that? To answer Daniel. Last year we have a a movement to where one of the the main forces fighting against land grabbing in Brazil is a task force from the public prosecution agency. And there was a movement, a political movement, wanting to disband this group of prosecutors. Of public prosecutors. And we with our campaign we were able to mobilize support from the the the federal executives and from the the the region from even from the private sector in general to keep the group working.

And we had a victory when they supported the the the extension of the the the task force. So this is the kind of of of of victories that we can have and that can keep the the the fight on land grabbing going on even having a a political environment that it will be completely hostile to that. Great. Thank you. Any any more comments or questions? Uh I have one for Renata. Renata, what support or access or questions do you have for those who are working at the global or trying to work at the global level on Amazon conservation issues? Silvia Gabrielle from UN Decade on Ecosystem Restoration, would you mind introducing yourself real quick and telling this group about the campaign that you guys are doing?

Thanks. Renata Good afternoon or or good evening to everybody. My name is Gabriel Labate. I am from the UN Red program. We also work on the UN Decade on Ecosystem Restoration. And in last in our last call I presented an initiative. It is still in the early stages. We we call it the one green gigaton challenge. And it is about securing enough investments for forest habitat conservation and restoration. Not only in the Amazon but in tropical forest worldwide. And this is intended to be a partnership between private sector and public sector. We we are in conversations with a number of companies that have expressed strong interest in participating.

Some of them have already confirmed. And we expect to launch this formally by the UN Environment Assembly in February 2021. Thanks, uh, Jona. Over to you. Great. Um, one reason to involve these global actors in what seems like a regional challenge is because the, as probably all of you know, the UN the Amazon is implicated in being maybe the circle of the global water cycle and probably the highest leverage climate mitigation investment strategy. And it’s something you can make money off off of, etc. Um, and one call that I had with Gabriel and colleagues, he mentioned that one reason why it’s difficult to combat illegal logging in the Amazon is because China buys so much illegal wood, even if you get the rest of the world to stop buying it and to demand uh, credential certification mechanism for wood.

If China still continues to buy it, it’s um, the problem still persists. So, this is a global problem. Uh, there are a lot of strategies that I can get into to describe what we want to do at a global level. A lot of it is laid out, um, either in that article that I posted or in the PDF that I posted, which is the larger UN75 strategy. Many of the people in this call, um, are contributors to this sort of behemoth of ideas. Uh, the timeline is going to be uh, some announcements on uh, uh, September 16th, 17th, and 18th. On the 18th, we’re going to have a uh, a 90-minute session where we present many of the details to the world.

We’re going to be a full couple of phone calls later this week, uh, dedicated to partnership. Um, so if any of you read that larger UN75 strategy and are interested in having your name, uh, join several others as a sort of a coalition of groups pushing for this agenda. I welcome the opportunity. I’ll just sort of line up one to give everything. So, Matt works with Milken, has a center for strategic and philanthropic, but also a series of events as one of the world’s preeminent in, uh, investor education platforms. And if they could create a partnership with the UN Decade on Ecosystem Restoration, it’s good for reforestation for the rest of the world, not just the Amazon.

So, this is why these global actors are participating in these calls. Does anybody have any clarifying questions or questions for the other presenters? And please don’t be so nice that you, I think that someone else is going to ask first. Just put it out there. I’m going to start calling on people. Um, some of the new Nexus members who are joining us, I’m wondering if you might have particular questions or might like to just share your own personal quest. Miranda, would you like to introduce yourself? You don’t have to. Jonah, while nobody speaking, here’s a question for you. You started this 11 uh, you know, you said this is 11th week, I think you said.

You had an expectation for what you were trying to do and why you were doing this. How has that changed and what are you finding now and learning and what do you want to get out of it? Uh, if you were thinking in the next 2 months, let’s say, or next month and then by the end of the year. Uh, the The thing I set out to do is learn uh what are the highest leverage investment strategies. I honestly think that uh this work of be legal with the Amazon may be one of the best bets in terms of small investments that can mobilize a lot more uh resources and a lot of other activities to fall into to space.

Regularizing the story of land tenure in Brazil um can create wealth for so many and can uh bring organized crime under control. Um your question was, “What am I hoping for? What has the progress been?” Part of it is just learning what it What are the key opportunities for intervention? Uh another part of it is I just realized how interconnected the problem is. I I I’m now taking steps to mobilize Nexus China in service of this challenge that comes from selling illegal wood. Nexus has a very significant connections in the area as does the World Economic Forum and Milken and others who have been involved in these series of phone calls.

Um so the global interconnectedness of it um and also how much fragmentation there is. There probably the most known donor coalitions and regranters on the Amazon are the Biodiversity Funders Group uh which is called Funders of the Amazon Basin, which is a relatively non-public group. They don’t put out reports. The Climate and Land Use Alliance, which is six of the largest Amazon funders. It’s mostly dedicated to those who are spending very large amounts of money. Um uh and and then there’s the there are groups in Brazil. Um Sinagoga’s has a program. I There There’s a uh of of six or seven philanthropies that are is studying ways to work with each other on interventions in the Amazon.

It’s mostly Brazilian, but there’s some funders who participate as well. I I just realized that many of the actors in in the space haven’t been talking with each other. Um there doesn’t exist a a public-facing global Amazon philanthropy group that wants to build a large membership. Um so this our activism may turn into that. It may be something that brings together industry through impact investors and connects them with philanthropy. So um I set out to learn. I see gaps and this coalition that we’re developing may be the vehicle to fill in those gaps. Hi Johanna, this is Sarah Wanen, a Nexus member. Hey. To to add to that, I’m sorry, I’m driving, but I did want to know how much Nexus Latin America is involved because there’s sometimes a tendency for all of us over here to think we know what’s best, but um and I I certainly know that the two speakers are are from the region.

I’m just wondering how much engagement um from the Nexus LatAm group has been involved. So So for those of you don’t know, and I and I’m realizing now we’re a couple of minutes over. Um so I’ll I’ll be quick and then we’ll end the call. Uh so uh Nexus Latin America has had four summits and there’s a fifth one coming up in a couple of months. Um and there’s going to be a lot of activity on Amazon and I have been having phone calls and communication with that team and have been recommending speakers to them. So the two are integrated. Uh the the strategy of strategy of one informs the other.

Um It is true that I’ve been leading this and I’m a North American guy. And there is some question about if we’re mak- making such important decisions uh how are we going to be representative? Um and that’s something that I haven’t dealt with yet. I I should deal with that if if what if all of this activity and noise making leads to the creation of a new institution. So, uh so good questions and there there’s some un- answeredness and unanswerable so far. Thank you. Well, we all need bridges. We do. Agreed. Okay, everybody. Uh there’s a lot here. Thanks so much for your time. I’m going to go ahead and leave the room and the chat room open for a while in case people want to copy those links.

Uh thank you so much for joining us and you’ll be hearing from me through email and follow up. Uh and if anybody is new to the call um and hasn’t been in direct contact with me, please feel free to give me your email address so that I can include you in future call invitations. Thank you. Thank you.

Unidentified speaker:

Bye. Thanks, Joanna.