The Amazon Opportunity for Pharmacological and Biomimetic Entrepreneurship

Dr. Maritta Koch-Weser: The Amazon Third Way Initiative wants the forest to benefit from the next industrial revolution, the one based on knowledge and data instead of extraction. As a hotbed of biodiversity, the Amazon is holding secrets that can lead to major breakthroughs in pharmaceutical and biomimetic entrepreneurship. These innovations can help ensure the forest is worth more alive and standing than cut and burned. Dr. Maritta Koch-Weser joins us to share the story.

Recorded August 10, 2020

WATCH:

  • Dr. Maritta Koch-Weser — Amazonia 4.0
  • Diego Saez Gil — Pachama
  • Jonah — moderator
  • Amy — Cadasta Foundation
  • Natalie
  • Lars — Norway
  • Other unidentified participants

Unidentified participant:

Here.

Jonah:

Hey Marita.

Maritta Koch-Weser:

Sorry, I can’t see the screen with all of you. So, I will dial in again. Just a sec.

Jonah:

Okay, no worries. And I’m going to just go ahead and create some context for people. Hi everybody. Welcome to the I think it’s the seventh installment of our weekly call series of Amazon office hours, a project of the global governance philanthropy network and the Amazon Investor Coalition. This week we’re going to be hearing from a couple of people. One is Marita who’s about to dial back in. She’s going to be talking to us about Amazonia 4.0. And do we have our other caller on the phone yet? I think he’s going to join us later.

I think we’re going to be hearing from Diego from Pachama. Marita, do you want me to begin to share your slides?

Maritta Koch-Weser:

Hang on because I Well, if I could see them then that would be perfect. Let’s try. Okay, hold on. You know what I did that the that the screen picture was the pictures of all of you suddenly disappeared, which is not a good feeling. That’s why I’m trying. Yeah, now I can see it. Yeah. Okay, that’s fine.

Jonah:

Okay, great. So just to create some context for this call so the global governance philanthropy network is a daughter organization or a sister organization I should say of Nexus it’s a philanthropic education platform for ocean climate refugee funders of transnational issues to come together and explore governance solutions to global problems. The Amazon and Amazon conservation has become a top priority because climate is a top priority and it’s probably the highest leverage climate mitigation investment opportunity. These calls are recorded and made available to other people in the network and are in the process of being edited for a podcast series that will be used to educate investors and philanthropists and others around the world about how to support sustainable Amazon and especially forest friendly economic development in the region.

So I’ve got this slide here, Marita, if you’re ready to go.

Maritta Koch-Weser:

Yeah, I’m ready to go. I’m just wondering on my screen it just shows the bottom part of the slide. Maybe there’s some way to get it centered on the screen.

Jonah:

Maybe. Do you do you see it on my screen now?

Maritta Koch-Weser:

Yeah, I see it on your screen. Okay. Okay. And I think if your screen is okay, then I’m okay. So I will talk to you about the Amazonia 4 what we call the Amazonia 4.0 project. The team is sort of linked to the Institute of Advanced Studies at São Paulo University at Amazonia 4.0 is the sort of operational program of what Carlos Nobre, who leads it, calls the Amazonia third way initiative. The third way in terms of what has been tried in the past in the Amazon on the one hand conservation and indigenous reserves almost 50% of the Brazilian Amazon are theoretically reserved.

It’s not being observed during this government but legally that’s the situation. And in the other half so to speak a lot of it is still public land. We see the terrible devastation again in the last years deforestation had gone down at some point but now over recent years it’s been accelerated and again in 2020 up for agroforestry agropecuária, cattle-raising purposes. Of course there’s in addition to that mining and number of unsustainable activities if you will. So the third way is to say well couldn’t this fabulous ecosystem be used for economic purposes socioeconomic purposes and maintained at the same time.

So, how do we turn the Amazon forest into something that is competitive with production modes that depend on deforestation? Let’s go to the next slide. Yeah. So, we have a number of strategic objectives. They’re not modest at all because we really feel that you know some part of the region one should not generalize too much but the southeastern parts of Amazonia are reaching getting very close to what is called a tipping point. Nature will not disappear. It will change. And instead of fabulous biodiverse forest, we would see in future savannah and of course indirect impacts on global climate and everything that you’ve heard about.

So the objective here is to really go for something that is disruptive 180 degree turnaround of Amazonian economy and making its biological and its huge water assets into principal driver for the economy. This of course requires a lot of innovation and product development. So what we’re looking for is to see science substituting for the chainsaw, adding value to standing forests and flowing rivers instead of taking them down. And all of this with a clear priority on first of all benefiting local population. 50% of Amazonians still live below the internationally defined poverty lines.

And the assumption is that as long as these people are not better off in terms of basic sanitation, income, health, energy access, communication access. You can’t have high hopes for stopping deforestation or in fact going to zero deforestation as many of us say. So the Amazonia 4.0 program u schematic as these things are has a five transformative components and we think of this as a package. If you did one thing or another from this list in the end in a few years then you would not see the desired results. One really needs to think holistically about all of these measures to.

Unidentified participant:

Excuse me. We’re not seeing any new slides. Could Jonah or you maybe change the slides? We are still on slide one.

Maritta Koch-Weser:

Oh, I’m I’m sorry. That Jonah would have to move it because he put it on the screen. I moved it on my screen.

Jonah:

I moved it on my screen too. Not sure what the issue is.

Maritta Koch-Weser:

But still your screen shows I can also see it on the side the first slide. So maybe you try to switch to the second.

Jonah:

Let’s see. No. Did that change it?

Maritta Koch-Weser:

Yes, it did. Yes, this is the second slide. So maybe you show that in big so people if they haven’t seen it before the five the three strategic objectives and then you would be now on the slide which I’m on number three page three not page four yet okay can you all see page three it has a number at the bottom on the right hand side I.

Unidentified participant:

Yes.

Maritta Koch-Weser:

Yes. Okay. So, of our of our five programmatic components which really make one joint project two are already underway. One is actually great fun mobile labs that can go local to even sequence DNA and improve the whole value chain take the sort of value added small industrial etc processes to the local level and these labs can be mounted and dismounted and taken to different parts to different communities Right now they’re working mainly on cupuaçu and açaí. But at Harvard a biologist who is part of our team is also working on a lab that’s basically just into genomics.

So it’s it’s it’s very exciting development. So we have the Amazon Creative Labs as we call them, the first ones underway. And last year the world’s first rainforest business school was founded. With the assumption that if you don’t have a place where the business community, the broader interested community can learn about the famous biodiversity, the products, the small industries which already exists, the markets which exist, the legislation which exists, this sector would not grow. So now there’s the rainforest business school which is located at the Amazon state university where they call it the rainforest social business school to express that the beneficiaries should be mainly social businesses in the region, a bit inspired by Muhammad Yunus.

But of course this is to become a system in which more universities participate also building rainforest business programs. In parallel in this COVID year, we are building a website Rainforest Business School online a knowledge highway for bioeconomy development where we put a lot of the case knowledge and the studies that is in a sense on the table today but not brought together in such a strategic operationally oriented way anywhere. So that’s what is already underway and then we think there should be bigger systemic additions as well. One is in science if you would imagine that you had a wellfunded with the best and brightest people MIT for the Amazon basin to catch up on all the research and product development that hasn’t been done in the last decades.

This could be fantastic and really bring about the turnaround which today with increasing you know markets for Amazonian perfumes and shampoos we’re not reaching. There has to be much more basic science and development work. So we want an MIT Amazon Institute of Technology. We want an Amazon to see a Amazon bioeconomy authority, a governmental authority because there needs to be governance. Bio products are complicated matter. It requires specialists to watch over them. It requires legal experts to watch over them. And it requires market experts to help grow that market. And the fifth and last component is as ever if you had maybe for the whole Amazon basin not just for Brazil a funding a financing facility whether it’s through the inter American development bank or the world bank or national programs public private partnerships then you would have a machine which could turn the sort of new products into really businesses, industries and market development.

So we think that these things all need to go together. So that’s in a nutshell Amazonia 4.0 for you and then I made of course a slide u where we look for funding as I speak today Jonah if you could move to page four now I don’t want to make this too long but certainly our project now has much more echo in Brazil the work is growing you know large banks want sustainable Amazonian program. The business community seeks for alternatives to deforestation and certainly we first and above all need to strengthen our essential project management.

At this stage we look for funding for the Amazon creative labs. We look for funding for instance to endow an international chair and to develop more Harvard case study type studies on bioeconomy experiences. We need help for our website. To build a knowledge highway for bioeconomy development in Amazonia requires a permanent team of two really smart persons for continuous website enrichment and outreach. And then of course for the still inexistent u three elements we need support for feasibility studies for the MIT for the bioeconomy authority and for the Amazon bioeconomy fund on all of these we have small papers it’s but we now of course need to go many levels deeper for the MIT also If you knew any billionaires who are looking for one big thing they want to do in their lifetime, an endowment for a central sort of backbone of science in the Amazon would be fantastic.

So, the MIT is a is a very special case and a special opportunity. So to sum it up, rainforest bioeconomy is the high road towards zero deforestation. Something that is more needed than ever. And I would be glad to hear comments or to hear from you. On this last slide, I also put my I don’t know whether you can see it. It’s not in u in Jonah’s slides. My email [Email address unclear in captions]. Thank you.

Jonah:

Can you put your email address in the chat?

Maritta Koch-Weser:

Yeah, I will I will try it. I can I can now find the.

Jonah:

I’ll put it in if you can’t. Does anybody have any questions for Marita?

Amy:

Hi, this is Amy from Cadasta Foundation. I just popped in just a few minutes late so I apologize for that but what I did hear was very interesting and I appreciated that presentation. You know you talked about markets the science the technology the you know creating some entities that can provide leadership in this space. One of my questions has to do with how you’ve been thinking about or considering in this in these five transformative initiatives. The idea of protecting first of all engaging communities community inputs, community leaders, the producers, suppliers at the community level.

How have you been thinking about that in terms of rights, in terms of, you know, both land and resource rights as well as just.

Maritta Koch-Weser:

Maybe Amy, you were not there when I mentioned, of course, all of this very much in passing and I’d be happy to send you detailed material. When I mention the element of Amazon creative labs, the creativity about this is that they go to the community level and they help them basically with DNA sequencing with register registering their property rights and with improving the product. You know, you can there’s so many machines that you can put from drying to packaging to labeling to it to echolabeling u whatever it takes to take all of that to the community level rather than out of the communities.

And so the whole thing is designed for and with the rural producer communities in mind unless there’s more aggregate value so to speak at the local level. These people are never going to earn enough with bioeconomy because they export as it is now. They export raw products. They’re not even sure whether the trader will come by and pick it up. And when the trader finally comes before your produce rots, you sell it for a very small price. So all of that has to change. Another element beyond the Amazon creative labs is for instance in the state of Amazonas with whom we work very closely now the idea of creating a rainforest stock market so to speak a market so that people over the internet and the telephone could pre-sell their production and they would pre-sell it in a much more sophisticated marketing system, you know, sorted according to quality and so on and so forth, which would be good also for many of the industries.

The industries often cannot develop beyond small scale because it they get an unreliable supply unreliable in quantity, timing and quality. So there’s work also on you know through the value chain so to speak to improve the process. But again having in mind for instance that the producer needs to be paid on the day his product is delivered and not at some future state. So there’s there are many more filigr components but this is the general orientation.

Jonah:

Natalie has a question.

Natalie:

Yeah, thank you so much Marita. It was great to hear you and to know better what your plan the plans are. I would like to understand a little bit more about the authority or the agency that you mentioned. Is that something that you are planning for Brazil or for the whole of the Amazon? And is this something like public that you’re willing to co-design with any government at the subnational or national levels? Anyway, would love to hear more about that. Thank you.

Maritta Koch-Weser:

Well, the idea is of course that governance is a national thing, right? So the question is in this case for the Brazilian Amazon but of course the other countries the Peru and Ecuador and Colombia could equally use specialized capabilities in their governance system. This is a very new sector. So you have a ministry of agriculture but you don’t have even an agency for bioeconomy. Now you know all of these all of these products need to be registered. There are huge issues with intellectual property rights. Export import needs to be very clear also for investors.

There’s also just a lot of knowledge as to who does what where. So the idea is this would be on the one hand a government agency in charge of assuring legal lawful informed process. But at the same time another branch of it could be fostering the development of this business sector. You know what are incentives? What are possible partnerships? How to build up maybe in the Brazil case a very different new industry in the in the Manaus free trade zone and so on. So, so really a governmental roof for u reaching or assuring the law and compliance including environmental and indigenous protection because that’s the basis of the bioeconomy.

And on the other hand reaching into the market and helping this new market and line of production grow.

Jonah:

Other questions? I have a question. The National Institute for Amazon Research, INPA, is that group doing some things that are relevant? Have has there been.

Maritta Koch-Weser:

Very they’re very relevant Jonah but I think somebody said the other day they must have six million or something budget per year. I mean Embrapa, the agricultural research institute, is extremely competent but they are very underfunded and of course you have a number of different outfits which are not coordinated if you will with this ambition to really build a new economy. This is not the vocation of INPA or originally they have a lot of research in fact they’ve also registered if I’m not mistaken many patents and then are sitting on them because nobody comes or even knows about them.

So you need some a mightier machine to compete with the current you know uneconomic processes to express it politely. I mean what is happening in the Amazon in these last years is really quite shameful. So these are all very good institutes and you know I think I’m even saying on my on my slide there we need a more powerful central machine like an MIT because the MIT goes from basic research to product development. It’s an R&D setup. But we also need to support much more strongly and immediately if you will the existing science infrastructure.

There are very good people there. There’s a proud history but it’s just not enough to do this buildup of a completely different economy. I think estimates are that between 15 and 20% in Brazil of Amazonian species may be known. 80% is I mean sometimes I wish that some of the money that gets invested on Mars would get invested on this continent size ecosystem which we only know in small part.

Jonah:

I have one last question and maybe anyone else might have a question. So I’m familiar with the story of Princeton University developing a Brazil program and bringing thought leaders together and philanthropists and I heard about their Amazonian leaprogging event. Has there been any conversation with them or any other North American universities about developing a tight research relationship?

Maritta Koch-Weser:

Well Carlos Nobre who leads the Amazonia 4.0 program participated but this is quite a few months ago in Princeton and in a sense I’m I’m quite sure that he did not yet at that point present the idea of an Amazonian MIT because we needed to develop the concepts further. He’s now in the process of really writing the terms of reference for the feasibility studies. So in the near-term future it would be excellent to resume these kinds of discussions.

Jonah:

Great. Did anybody else have another question for Marita?

Maritta Koch-Weser:

And if not please put my because today I’m I’m a bit hamstrung. I don’t know how to get onto the main page of our meeting. I see each of you only in a in a small corner and I have no place to put a chat. So, if you could put my email for everybody and of course make the presentation available if anyone’s.

Lars:

Great I could just insert one question Marita it’s Lars from Norway. I know you have been thinking about the rainforest business school for quite a while and I’m happy to see that something is now going on. Could you say a bit more about that’s actually a fully developed course that people are joining or you have sufficient resources for actually taking that element forward because.

Maritta Koch-Weser:

We don’t have sufficient resources but we but we have enough to for a start. So we have a joint project with USP where I’m located. And the University of Amazon state we have a bit of money. So we’ve started up the work the content work for the for the knowledge highway website that’s associated and we are preparing a first course on a number of product chains cacao cupuaçu, [product name unclear], açaí, which is Amazon creative labs which also serve as field campus for the rainforest business school And for next year the University of Amazonas is planning a first full course the 400hour course not just a specialization course.

So we’re now preparing and in very good shape for first specialization course with the money we have. But we then want to go to a general course and we want to build up over the next four to five years a real M’s program and for that we are still looking for support and as I said in the beginning we don’t emphasize just one element or another but you know the rainforest business school is key unless more people who work in banks, more people who work in business also outside Amazonia but could use and build on Amazonian products have a place to systematically learn about it through specialization courses, executive courses or if they are young MBA students doing a full masters in rainforest business, we will not see greater results.

We will stay at the u you know sukus and jelly making level and that’s a shame.

Jonah:

Okay, one last question and then we’re going to move to our next presentation. It was from Natalie. She wants to know if MIT is involved in some way. Did you hear that?

Maritta Koch-Weser:

I couldn’t hear it.

Jonah:

Natalie, are you there? Do you want to ask your question?

Natalie:

Yeah. Marita because you mentioned several times the MIT and I know that they have created specific like centers for India for instance. I was just wondering if you have considered partnering formally with the MIT also because [Question trails off.].

Maritta Koch-Weser:

At MIT there are already faculty who are acutely interested and in this sort of feasibility and startup phase contributing with thought and suggestions. So yes, we are working with MIT and I should have said also that for Carlos Nobre ITA, the [institute name unclear in captions] advancement that was founded in Brazil in the 1950s is a great example. Apparently that institute gave rise to the aerospace industry of Brazil which today is number three or four in the world. So there was this concerted effort and a sort of solid center of competence research and development which brought about a real industry that you know makes for Brazil’s place in the world market today.

So that’s a bit what I believe he has in mind when he when he makes this suggestion.

Jonah:

Thank you Marita. Next we have Diego from Pachama. Diego please tell us your story.

Maritta Koch-Weser:

No I will try to get the picture here. Yeah. Okay.

Diego Saez Gil:

Thank you Janna. Thank you Marita. Hi everyone. Thank you so much for the invitation. My name is Diego Saez Gil. I am the co-founder of a technology startup based in California that is focused on harnessing the latest on remote sensing and artificial intelligence technologies to improve the carbon markets that can be a great source of funding for conservation and restoration of forest in the Amazon and worldwide. And that today unfortunately are sometimes locked by a lot of barriers to entry to organizations that want to benefit from this market. So I’m going to share a quick presentation that hopefully can illustrate a little bit better our work and then happy to answer any questions.

Let me see I’ll share my screen here. Yes. Do you guys see my screen?

Unidentified participant:

Yes.

Diego Saez Gil:

Yeah. Okay. Yeah. So the name of the company is Pachama and we are harnessing technology with a mission of restoring nature to solve climate change. We are building really two things. In one side we are building a set of tools that will allow for fast affordable and reliable verification of carbon on forest. And to do that we use a combination of machine learning, satellite images, drone and lidar data that we process on a on a data platform. And then secondly, we’re building an open platform to connect directly sellers and buyers that are interested in supporting forest carbon projects.

And by making this connection direct online, we hope that we’re going to make the life easier of those on the field working on this type of projects.

Jonah:

Diego, can you close and reopen the presentation? Disapp.

Diego Saez Gil:

Yeah. Okay, great. Yeah, so as I was saying, we have this these two pillars. In one side, making it affordable and easy to certify and verify carbon projects. In the other side, making easy for projects to connect with funders. Why Forest? I don’t have to tell you guys. But why a marketplace? Well, you might have seen all these announcements by large corporations including Microsoft, Amazon, Shell, Delta that want to achieve carbon neutrality and there’s a lot and lots of talks around carbon naturebased carbon solutions and yet the amount of funding that we’re seeing going to this type of projects is not there yet.

And one of the things that we realize is that this is the way that the market looks like today. If you are a land owner, a nonprofit organization, an indigenous community that want to participate in this market, you have to go through a lot of these intermediary players that help you certify and then get connected to the final carbon buyer. And what we’re hoping to help build is something like this in which a project can come directly to us. We help them fasttrack through certification and obtain credible carbon credits and then connect them directly to the corporate buyers that are seeking to support these projects.

And the technology that we use is allows us to have three different models that are key to be able to validate a carbon project. We talk about a historical model that looks at satellite imagery since 1984. We use Landsat data and we can with that using algorithms determine what is the baseline of business as usual on a given region and then project that into the future determining what is the likelihood of a given area to be deforested. The second is a verification model that allows us to know how much carbon is there sequestered today on a given forest.

To do that, we combine lidar data that we have of different parts of the Amazon rainforest. We combine that with national forest inventories and with satellite imagery. And then our algorithms can make a prediction that falls within minus plus 10% error of how much carbon is there on the forest. And then finally, we’re building a monitoring model that allows us to detect disturbances in almost real time. We detect canopy cover change using sentinel radar data and also high-definition satellite imagery coming from planet. So the way that this these new techniques of artificial intelligence work is that you’re basically teaching an algorithm to correlate that a given shape on lidar correlates with a certain amount of carbon storage coming from field plots that we obtain and then that correlates with a certain color combination on multispectral imagery.

And with that we come out with these carbon stocks maps that then are surprisingly good at making carbon estimations. So with that we’re what we’re doing is we’re going to existing projects REDD+ projects that already have gone through certification or reforestation projects that have gone through the gold standard or you know a Verra VCS certification and then we draw this these charts of how the project has effectively kept the biomass standing compared to the region or for reforestation projects we show how the biomass is going up as a result of the efforts.

And we identified some great projects that are effectively stopping deforestation on the Amazon and beyond. Some restoration projects that we also are studying in South America. This these two happen to be in Uruguay and Panama, but we’re also seeing some restoration projects in the Amazon. And then this data is input into this marketplace platform that we use to display these projects and to make it very easy for funders and buyers of carbon credits to select the project. Eventually we want to use these technologies to help originate new projects. What we’re doing today is we’re going and connecting existing projects with existing buyers.

Really the hope that we have is that we can use this technology to help originate new forest carbon projects and bring them to mass buyer markets. We’re a small team but strong engineering and science background. Everyone is super passionate about protecting and restoring the forest and we were able to get backing from some of the best investors in Silicon Valley. The founder of Uber, the first investors on Airbnb and Twitter. And then the last round was led by Breakthrough Energy Ventures which is Bill Gates firm focused on climate change. These are some of the customers we’re working with today already working with Microsoft, Shopify, SoftBank and so forth.

So yes, I’ll stop there. Again our mission is to put these technologies that Silicon Valley has developed at the service of protecting and restoring the Amazon and you know hope hoping that these tools can really drive a new significant funding for this type of projects. In the process as we as.

Jonah:

The questions come forward, I’d like to ask Diego if you could upload your presentation to a Google Drive and paste a link to it so that people can download it.

Diego Saez Gil:

Sure. I can I can I can I can I can do that after call.

Jonah:

Great. Does anybody have any questions for Diego?

Unidentified participant:

Yeah. May I? Diego, how do you go about land ownership? Do you include public lands? Do you include just private uhly controlled lands? And what is the timeline? I mean u you know for instance when you have reforestation how recently has something been deforested? These are all technical definitions. I’m just interested I’m I’m sure you’ve thought about it how you go about it.

Diego Saez Gil:

Yeah, as I said today what we’re doing is we are going to projects that already have gone through certification with VCS gold standard and beyond and they have done the validation of land ownership. Some of these projects are coalitions of several institutions including indigenous communities, nonprofits and sometimes even states you know like we have a project in Jari, Pará in Brazil that is a state level project. We have other projects in Peru that are.

Unidentified participant:

This is the old Orsa and Lutick project or Ji I saw you Ji on your.

Diego Saez Gil:

Jari, Pará. Yes. Yeah. We have a project in Peru in Madre de Dios that is a coalition of a lot of small Brazil nuts you know farmers or people that live off the forest and in which you know they definitely have stopped deforestation by coming al together. So land ownership is not validated by us but by these certification bodies. Okay. In the future if we do help come up with a new methodology for the issuance of carbon credits we’ll have to come up with a way to validate land ownership and we think that with more and more open data that should be that should be possible.

In terms of duration generally these projects the VCS protocols require 100year commitment of permanence of the project. Whereas other protocols are shorter generally 100 years is a time frame of commitment.

Unidentified participant:

Okay, thank you.

Jonah:

Other questions?

Unidentified participant:

So Diego, this is MVR. So wow, that looks amazing that you’re doing this. Is your So what I still didn’t understand like what stage you’re in. I see that you’re doing you know smaller scale projects. So does that mean that you know Microsoft is then buying the carbon credits from these particular areas and then funding?

Diego Saez Gil:

Yes. Correct. So what we did is we devel we developed these tools to measure and monitor. We went to existing projects. We performed analysis of the claims of these projects and we put uploaded all this data into a report and into a data platform and then we went to companies such as Microsoft and said hey you made a commitment to buy to become carbon neutral that means that you’re going to be purchasing carbon credits here we can source you really high quality forest carbon projects and we going to provide you with data to support those claims that is the stage we’re in right so first stage of the first turn of the of the flywheel we like to say.

The second turn of the flywheel is okay now we have buyers and we have data we can go and help originate new projects.

Unidentified participant:

Okay. So are they buying it and.

Diego Saez Gil:

They are buying carbon credits, yes.

Unidentified participant:

And then are they does that money then go to the indigenous people and the.

Diego Saez Gil:

So generally there are project developers on the field you know like for example I was mentioning this project Jari, Pará that is led and developed by an organization called Biofílica there’s the project in Peru that I mentioned is led by an organization called [organization name unclear] so These are the organizations they set the price and we are just you know sort of like a connector of between the two. We take a commission and that is our business model that help support ourself. But yeah the money goes to the project and then each project has a different cost structure.

Sometimes the avoidance of deforestation efforts mean patrolling the border. O at times means developing infrastructure for the local communities to continue harvesting sustainably the Brazil nuts and so forth.

Unidentified participant:

Wow. Cool. Yeah. I have a question. What opportunities do you see for collaborating with philanthropists?

Diego Saez Gil:

Yes. I mean we think that many of the future projects that will emerge that need to emerge sometimes need a prefunding to get started right you know there is there’s a lag of time between the moment that you start the project and you can start selling and creating an income out of selling carbon credits. So for that period of funding sometimes philanthropy and other sources of alternative funding are essential for these projects to get started. For projects that are about restoration and that means going and planting trees creating nurseries there’s a lag of a couple of years because for the trees to grow and to start generating carbon credits sometimes it’s a couple of years.

So there’s a big role on philanthropy to play backing the nonprofit organizations that are on the field going to be starting these projects.

Unidentified participant:

So Diego when you say pre-funding like what kind of what amounts are you looking at?

Diego Saez Gil:

It ranges you know to give you an example there is one organization called IPAM in Brazil that is doing a pilot project right now in Mato Grosso that is you know trying to bring a lot of farmers together to start with a project. I recently facilitated an introduction to a philanthropist in California that donated $50,000. They were incredibly grateful for that grant because it was it was what they needed to get started. But it ranges on the on depending on the ambition of the project.

Unidentified participant:

What opportunity is there to tie into compliance carbon markets?

Diego Saez Gil:

Yeah, I mean we will see a lot more compliance markets coming along. California has a compliance market, the California cap and trade and they la end of last year they approved tropical forest as you know as a valid credits as part of this market. Still not fully implemented but that means that companies in California, energy companies in California that need to comply with regulations buying this type of certificates can purchase certificates coming from Brazil, Peru, Colombia. So that is there is a great opportunity. I think at the same we will see in Europe, Canada and many other compliance markets.

Unidentified participant:

Do you are you guys positioned to tie into the carbon credits that are going to be coming out of the airline alliances next year?

Diego Saez Gil:

Yeah, we are keeping a close eye into the into the CORSIA market as it’s called. And they selected this the certification bodies as valid you know the ones that we’re working with VCS gold standard American Carbon registry climate action reserve and yes our intention is to help accelerate the origination of new projects which today takes a lot of time and a lot of money.

Unidentified participant:

Can I ask do you see a possibility Diego to have different categories? I mean you are just talking about that’s difficult enough about carbon but then look at one of the programs that Sebastião Salgado the photographer is involved in and it goes after reforestation in [unclear watershed description], areas where if you if you do this in 2,000 places along the Rio Doce which is one of Brazil’s major rivers then you would have a big river flowing again in 10 20 years so where you where you stack up different types of ecosystem restoration benefits do you see a chance to offer such products.

Diego Saez Gil:

Yeah I mean definitely we are seeing that all these companies that are interested in supporting these type of projects care beyond carbon on about other co- benefits as they’re calling this in this world. You know including biodiversity community impacts and of course you know plantations of native species as opposed to you know tree planting tree plantations you know and there are ways in which remote sensing can serve to measure biodiversity indexes. For now our algorithms can detect between species groups. But in the future there are other markers of biodiversity that we hope to be able to include in our reports so that yes project with higher biodiversity get higher benefits and probably higher prices.

Unidentified participant:

Thank you.

Jonah:

Any more questions for Diego?

Unidentified participant:

Diego I have a question for you. How what made you get started in this? I’m assuming that you’re the founder of tthis company.

Diego Saez Gil:

Yeah, I am. And you know, I’m originally from Argentina. I grew up in the north in Tucumán surrounded by the Yungas forest. And I saw in my lifetime, you know, that forest, you know, being lost to agriculture, to soy and lemon and cattle ranching. And then I came to the US to start my career. I worked for 10 years in tech building companies. Nothing to do with this. But then at some point I actually went back did a trip to my with my brothers. We crossed from North Argentina to Bolivia and to Peru and it was a super inspiring trip but also I saw the deforestation firsthand.

So couldn’t do anything else other than you know dedicating my efforts to try to revert this. So came back to California, settled here in Silicon Valley and you know partner up with a friend who is a machine learning engineer and decided to start this company.

Unidentified participant:

Oh thanks. Do you maybe last question do you have some sort of routine customers who always come back to you or is it very much a one-off business?

Diego Saez Gil:

Yeah, good question. We are trying to make it more a type of subscription service. With some customers we managed to do that like for example one of our customers is Shopify which is this e-commerce platform and with them we came up with a quarterly subscription in which every quarter they make an estimation of their carbon footprint and the carbon footprint of their partners and they make a new purchase. So you know that way they keep coming back and funding becomes more you know consistent or predictable and yes hopefully.

Unidentified participant:

Because that would become more strategic in a sense also from a company viewpoint if their offsets would not be a windmill in China and you know a bit of a forest over in Peru. But yeah, but if they would after a decade say, “Wow, we really made a difference in this particular corner of the earth.”.

Diego Saez Gil:

Yes. Correct. Well, that’s why we think the role of transparency and you know, all the satellite imagery and maps are so important because then it’s not just a piece of paper, we bought a carbon credit is we’re supporting the forest and if we don’t if we stop supporting it, it might be [unclear], right? So, so it becomes kind of like a relationship with the investment you made.

Jonah:

Okay. Very interesting. Diego, if you could post your email address.

Diego Saez Gil:

Yes, please. My email is [address incomplete in captions] and the website’s pachama.com and then you can find me on LinkedIn as well.

Jonah:

Great. Okay. So, in the couple minutes we have left, does anybody have any announcements or questions or ideas for the future of our group?

Unidentified participant:

Well, I think I mentioned of course he’s more of an advocate, but Sebastião Salgado because I think would be interesting to have him talk about his Instituto Terra. Sebastião today says that it costs in retrospect [Amount unclear: captions say 26,000], I believe dollars to rebuild a hectare of tropical rainforest. He’s done it and he can make the accounts and I think that’s a big argument for project like Diego and so many others that we are discussing in this round. So there are some interesting data to share and maybe some inspiration too.

Unidentified participant:

Great. Also, I think it’d be great to get either Atossa or Bill Twist speaking about the Sacred Headwaters project which is from Peru and Ecuador. It cross it spans Peru and Ecuador. It’s about 70 million plus acres of land that they’re trying to go for global protection because it’s the it’s called the Sacred Headwaters. It’s the beginning of the headwaters of the Amazon and it’s one of the most biodiverse regions on the entire planet. So, maybe there could be opportunities for collaboration given, you know, Diego’s company’s background and Marita what you’re doing with this educational aspect.

Jonah:

Great idea. Diego, in the one minute we have left, I’ll leave the room the room open. If you could post the link to your slides for people to download and if you post it here, also be included in the archive.

Diego Saez Gil:

Yes. Let me see. May maybe I can send it via email afterwards. That’ll be would that be easier?

Unidentified participant:

Sure. If you I’d love to get it. Yeah. Yeah.

Jonah:

Yeah. And I and I can just post it in here. Okay, great. Okay, everybody, we’ve reached the top of the hour. Thanks so much for your time and we look forward to seeing many of you next week. There are a lot of people on vacation at this time and will be next week. So, our audience is a little bit smaller. But there’s a lot coming down the pipe. I’ve got lots of news to share.

Unidentified participant:

Compliments. It’s nice you bring this together. Yeah.

Jonah:

I have one interesting website to share for any of you who do not know it. TED is going to be making a big splash on climate issues. I’m going to share their website here and it’s it’s it’s a it’s kind of under wraps still. It’s not yet linked from their main website, but I’m starting conversations with them as well about collaboration on Amazon. Okay, everybody.

Unidentified participants:

Thanks so much. Thanks, Jonah. Bye, everyone. Bye. Bye. Bye, everyone. Bye. Bye.