Ecosystem Service Measurements, Credits and Bank Carbon Offsets
Alex Simiema: For the past 14 years, Alex Simiema has worked to build a new Brazilian business that measures carbon stocks and water flows. Today, his company, Brasil Mata Viva, partners with the government of the Brazilian state of Amapá to publish certified ecosystem service credits for landowners to sell and pay for conservation. To date, several of Brazil’s largest banks have purchased the credits as carbon offsets. Join us to meet Alex and learn about his journey.
Recorded August 3, 2020
WATCH:
Participants
- Alex Simiema — main presenter, identified in episodes.csv; addressed as Alex in the discussion.
- Daniel — introduced by first name before his question.
- Unidentified moderator and other participants.
Transcript
Alex Simiema:
Thank you. I would just like to compliment the last speaker. Natalie, your presentation was great. Your project is very interesting. And maybe we have some points of contact that we could also help somehow because we are also doing field work in the Amazon and maybe joining forces could be an option. Great. So, I’m going to start sharing my screen now. Here. Let me just can you all see my screen? Yeah. Okay, good. It’s just a short presentation that I tried to introduce the main, the key points on what we on what we do.
Basically, we started our work in about 14 years ago. That’s roughly the time that I also joined as an activist, actually. I have been working for about half of my life as an activist in this group. So we bring together different civil society actors, government, business owners, farmers, in order to understand what was the kind of pressure that would that brought the forest to the ground, because what we understood from all those families that live in the area, some of them are actually of big landowners. And we were trying to figure out what was the main factor that led to the destruction of the forest because it is not like anybody—I mean, anybody in their right mind—thinks that destroying forest is a fun activity.
Actually, we identified that the main issue here is the economic pressure that is exerted on the farmers. From one side, they have to compete in a position of disadvantage in comparison to European farmers, American, Chinese farmers because subsidies in our country are not [insubstantial or absent; wording unclear] [end of subsidy description unclear]. There’s a difference that we understand that with the agreements that Brazil has signed over the years in Rio ’92, even the Paris Agreement, the Kyoto Protocol, there is a pressure that is created in private lands. When you have a law that requires farmers in the Amazon, for instance to preserve up to 80% of their land.
In any other economic activity, that would be deemed unfeasible. ” But that’s what happened with the farmers. So and here we’re not talking about just permanent preservation areas that are already foreseen in the law in Brazil surrounding the rivers, riverheads, springs. We’re not talking about land coverage, a productive land that would be otherwise productive. Those two factors were combined to put the farmers in a situation that was hard for them to escape. So they were there because there were public policies established in the ’70s and the ’80s by both the military dictatorship and the democratic government that brought those people from southern regions, from the central regions, brought them there with the promise of land so that they can produce because Brazil was expanding our, for that matter, our agricultural belt into the Amazon and generated this problem because now those people are living there and then you have all the problems that arise also with the indigenous populations such as the National Park of Xingu.
So, what the way that we that we saw is we can take a down-to-earth approach to the situation and understand what happens in the land that causes the destruction of the forest. Then, we started working as you have here in the region that was formerly known I reckon that there are many Brazilians in this. If you remember the news in the mid-2000s, that region was actually known as the fire belt and it’s the southern border of the Xingu National Park and in northern Mato Grosso and southern Pará. We established I think I have the map here.
Over here. We established these four nuclei. This first our first one is Xingu, which is right here. All of our nuclei, just so you can understand, they are named after the major bodies of water that they are helping preserve. Except for the case of Amapá because Amapá adopted that as a state policy. So, and then we took that opportunity to develop a more direct way to relieve this economic pressure that they were suffering by generating an asset that would combine all the opportunity costs that came from selling hardwood, soybeans, cattle raising and reverting that.
So, forest should be at least as valuable as that. We know that the true value of the forest is much higher than all of those activities. However, it’s hard to assess that when you’re not thinking in purely [valuation terminology unclear] terms or even the production of water, the hydric flow around the world that the Amazon—as in the article that Jonah wrote and sent me the link that you have brilliantly put it—because the Amazon is actually important to the entire world when it comes to the hydric balance of the world.
Moderator:
Alex, you have five minutes.
Alex Simiema:
Okay. It’s going to be very quick after this. Then we have this financial instrument which is called the Sustainability Credit Unit, that is tradeable and traceable to the to the year and the very area. We have precision of meters when it comes to this, where it was generated and by which farmer in which context or if it is in public land, as in the case of Amapá as well, you have the direct payment to the to the farmer or the or the society that lives in that area. The singularity of the UCS comes from the fact that it is an asset that allows for direct investment in key sectors such as infrastructure, forest preservation itself, and improvement of technologies that are used for agriculture.
And we have developed a robust technological environment to trade those assets that allows for international investors, volunteers, activists to actually acquire them and support those projects on the ground. And also the reason why I live in Portugal today is because I we are expanding this to different realities because the UCS is able to be generated in other in other environments as well, understanding the local challenges. The thing is in Amapá, the state adopted the adopted it as a as a statewide policy. We attracted the attention from banks like Itaú and Santander because they understood that was an opportunity to also offset their environmental impact and make it into a net positive impact.
We have our own platform. We register that in blockchain, and we allow institutions of that size to actually pass that on to their supply chain or their clients in order to relieve the economic pressure in different fronts on at scale, because we believe that local and regional problems should be addressed at regional and local level. And the global issue, which is protecting the Amazon, can also be addressed in a global way. So, I’ll just go quickly over this so that I don’t I don’t go over my time. This is how you can purchase the UCS on our website.
You can calculate your ecological footprint. You can see how where the money is going. We are audited by Here. We are audited by Ernst & Young. Let me just move with this one here. Yes. We have partnered with UNESP, Ernst & Young. We chose the legal system of London because it is the most robust legal system in the world when it comes to this so that we can we can show to the international community that the work that we are developing is causing actual change over the past decade or so.
For my last slide, this is what we do. We transform non-ecosystemic services into ecosystemic services. That meaning any activity is not inherently bad as long as it is inserted into a logic of protection, of conservation, that activity can cause a good positive net impact on society, on economy, and on the environment. And thank you for the time.
Moderator:
Great. Could you tell us a little bit about the work that is going on with the European Union in the advance of ecosystem service payments there?
Alex Simiema:
Yes, sure. We founded BMP Portugal, which is—the BMP itself in Brazil is not a company. It is an initiative. But the company here we chose to call it BMP Portugal so that the Portuguese and the European parties could understand better what we are proposing. The European Commission has some directives recently that are going in the direction of the ecosystem services being even if they are delivered and if they are realized in other parts of the of the world, they are also good to be used in a European environment because before it was not so clear from a from a legal standpoint here in Europe whether projects in Brazil, in India, in South Africa, Congo, they could be used by companies to offset their activities because once again, regional challenges, regional responses.
However, now we have the legal basis to do this global integration. So our work here, we work closely with this association formed by two Portuguese social leaders here. Which is called Portugal Mata Viva. And here we are going to apply our methodology to actually help combat the problem they call desertification, but it’s not the original sense of the word. It’s the fact that people are abandoning the interior of Portugal to move to Lisbon, to Porto, and to Algarve, the southern part of the country. Or even to move abroad. And that leaves the interior abandoned, causing fires or just to plant eucalyptus.
So they saw that we have the expertise for this. So this is how we are kickstarting our actions here in Europe.
Moderator:
Great. Thanks so much. In contrast to traditional carbon markets, this is possibly a market for ecosystem service payments. Very exciting. Any questions?
Unidentified participant:
I had one. Alex, this is amazing. And thank you Natalie, before that. I actually had a comment question for Natalie or reflection. But Alex, are you working in other countries in South America as well? Or was it just Brazil? I thought I only heard you focusing on Brazil, but you said you were open to looking at other areas. Do you know where? We work in Ecuador and Peru, so that’s why I’m asking.
Alex Simiema:
Oh, nice. I know that Peru is a great country to start doing this. Unfortunately, we haven’t actually started working in other South American countries yet, but we have been invited by Suriname to develop work there. Let me just go back to the map, and then you’ll be able to understand why. We have been working since 2006 to establish these first four, and those are all linked to the civil society and the community of producers themselves. Amapá is also in white because Amapá took the spearhead as becoming the first government to fully implement.
And here you have in yellow the nuclei that are also of the civil society. But we chose to fully close the cycle, from sale, establishment of the nuclei, investing in infrastructure, payment for the farmers. I wish I had more time, so I but I can refer all the documents to everyone in the conversation. Our system of payment is divided in three parts. First is directly to the farmer, the [ordinal unclear] is to their association so they can invest in health, infrastructure, roads, and packaging facilities for the produce. The third one is for science and for the structure that helps guarantee that this all stays in place.
Universities, Ernst & Young, all the parties. We finished it right before the pandemic. Unfortunately, we had a pandemic come around. We finished the online environment, the electronic environment that allows for all the payments to be distributed in the most transparent way possible. And now we are able to go to Peru, to go in South America, we have such a rich biodiversity to generate the UCSs that we can look into Colombia, Peru, Uruguay, Argentina. We could move South America to a central position in the discussion of environment conservation because well, we are one of the probably even the best conserved and preserved continent on Earth.
Europe got rid of its forests a long time ago. What they have now is what they call forests here, Portugal, Sweden, Austria. It’s actually more bound to an idea of like forests that are grown for commercial profit. The idea of native forest is something that makes a lot of sense for us, Central Africa, South America, Australia, perhaps, India. ” We have the natural resources still preserved.
Moderator:
Great. I have another question. Part of the controversy surrounding the REDD+ mechanism for compensation forest owners is who gets the money. If the money for local conservation comes in the wrong way, it can upset local dynamics. How do you guys ensure that the money is going to the indigenous people or the land owners or the conservation as opposed to someone who’s just done some fancy footwork and gotten legal rights to something?
Alex Simiema:
Yeah. That is actually a great question because that was the exact reason why we even joined this market. The system that we have that we have put together is of public access, is registered in blockchain, and brings together all the documents from the landowner. Not only from the perspective of monitoring the activities because that’s also important to show to the people that they’re investing or donating to the right people. But also the fact that I’m so sorry, there’s just a little noise in the background. Our platform allows for a for anyone anywhere to read the QR codes that accompany our certification that is put in products, that is put on in the case of like law firms, they receive the actual certificate.
And by reading that QR code, you see how much that farmer and his association have received from the sale of this total [credit description unclear]. Each credit that we sell, that we put out into the market is uniquely identifiable by its tracking number. Since we measure every year, that’s where we are different from REDD+, for instance because REDD+ has this commitment with the future for like 25 years, or [phrase incomplete]. That is just not our system. Our system is every year we generate vintages, to use an analogy with wine production, or to think even soybeans.
Every year, you have new contracts, and they are identified. With us, every single credit generated, and all the credits generated in one hectare of land, they have a specific number that is linked to a specific farmer, that is linked to a specific scientific organization, and anyone who buys the credits is able to see every year where the money went, and where the money was used, which is also another difference that we have: we track to the very end where the money went. If it was spent on a truck, or if it was spent to restore forest, we know, and we show that to our investors and our public.
Moderator:
Great. Daniel has a question.
Unidentified participant — brief transition:
Yeah. So, I’m just going to put this here. Because I know I’m running out of time.
Daniel:
Okay, can I ask a quick question? ”] terrific. Thanks, Alex. Really awesome to get this overview, and really impressive work. I specifically love, you know, it sounds like you’ve you’ve really managed to develop a super transparent system when it comes to financial flows. My question is more around the monitoring, reporting, and verification around the underlying ecosystem assets. I’m curious, do you issue the ecosystem credits just in accordance with forest cover, or are you how are you taking into account ranges in condition and quality?
Alex Simiema:
Okay, just to make sure I understood your question. Your question is whether we only look into forest, or into other types of biomes as well?
Daniel:
No, just from a forest standpoint, you know, so when we’re thinking about valuing forests, how are you differentiating among forests in order to make sure that the ecosystem credits are actually issuing value to forests that are you know in accordance with things other than forest cover? Because we know forest cover is an incomplete proxy for you know a lot of the benefits that we really want to prioritize safeguarding.
Alex Simiema:
Yes, I didn’t include this here in the presentation but here we can we can have a quick a quick understanding. From the beginning, we started using the [methodology name unclear], the one that’s approved by the UN because we understood that actually most of the natural wealth that the Amazon’s able to provide wouldn’t be above the ground. And actually I come from a region of Brazil—I don’t know how well everyone here is acquainted with Brazilian geography. I come from the Cerrado region which is in Goiás. And there the case is even more expressive because we have what is called the upside down forests because the traditional methodologies that were used here in Europe or in other parts of the world only would go 30 cm into the soil.
And since you have the upside down forests in Cerrado actually most of the carbon is stored one and two meters underground. We take that into consideration. We adapted parts of the [methodology name unclear] methodology, and we work with UNESP. This is where UNESP is really handy here. We work with a school called [school acronym unclear], which is the agricultural studies faculty. Sorry, for a moment I lost the word. We have two professors been working with us from the beginning Professor [name unclear] and Professor [name unclear]. They are the ones that said that we need to look into the stockpile of carbon in the decomposing materials of the Amazon which allows for the Amazon to grow and to be so rich and diverse because contrary to popular belief and I think you’re acquainted with that from what you said the soil in the Amazon is actually poor.
It’s actually sandy. So you need that stockpile layer for the forest to grow and we are assessing that. We are using except for the methodologies that we developed we are using globally accepted methodologies through UNESCO and now here in Portugal we are also working with the Polytechnic Institute of Coimbra. And that all is verified by Ernst & Young from one side of the generation of the credits and but Ernst & Young is also on the side of the sales of the credits. We are we are establishing that side as well.
It’s fully auditable. We bring the scientists, the master’s-level and doctoral-level students from UNESCO and from their sister universities to the region so that we are always at the state-of-the-art technology when it comes to measuring carbon not just stock carbon on the tree, but also on the ground.
Moderator:
Great. I thank you so much, Alex. It’ll be great [ending incomplete in the source].